how civil society sees the vpa process

13
How does civil society see the VPA process? Iola Leal FLEGT Training course for EC delegations Brussels, 16-18 November 2009 The campaigning NGO for greater environmental and social justice, with a focus on forests and forest peoples rights in the policies and practices of the EU

Upload: retchid

Post on 24-May-2015

439 views

Category:

Technology


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: How Civil Society Sees The Vpa Process

How does civil society see the VPA process?

Iola LealFLEGT Training course for EC delegations

Brussels, 16-18 November 2009

The campaigning NGO for greater environmental and social justice, with a focus on forests and forest peoples rights in the policies and practices of the EU

Page 2: How Civil Society Sees The Vpa Process

Bad forest governance is the result of a variety of complex issues.

Any process aiming to successfully reform governance must address

these complexities.

‘The process’ is THE KEY to success

Page 3: How Civil Society Sees The Vpa Process

What are we NOT REALLY interested in?

FLEGT - Law enforcementLaws more often than not:•Fail to recognise the rights of local communities•Benefit industrial logging•Do little to promote rural development•Are overlapping and/or contradictory •Regulate industrial operations but miss the codes regulating environmental issues and social benefits•And a long etcetera.

 We don’t want to enforce laws that are socially unjust and environmentally unsound

FLEGT – Trade

A carrot, but not an aim! 

For civil society FLEGT is about

LE T

 

F G

Page 4: How Civil Society Sees The Vpa Process

Some governance challenges...

1.Improving the regulatory framework (so that policies are not unclear or unjust government)

2.Clarifying land ownership and access rights for local communities

3.Ensuring the effective participation of civil society in policy-making and implementation

4.Strengthening the enforcement capacity

5.Fighting corruption and organised crime

Page 5: How Civil Society Sees The Vpa Process

Illegal logging is not a cause, but a symptom of other problems.

To address illegal logging,the real causes need to be

addressed

Page 6: How Civil Society Sees The Vpa Process

The process is as important as the outcome

[and arguably more]

Page 7: How Civil Society Sees The Vpa Process

• Governance problems ought to be raised (It has to address FLEGT objectives!)

• The final outcome needs to be accepted by all stakeholders (legitimacy and workability)

How do we measure a good FLEGT process?

Page 8: How Civil Society Sees The Vpa Process

1.All stakeholders must be included and effort should be made to ensure that the voices of the weakest stakeholders are being heard. NGOs are just as much stakeholders as timber industry and their effective involvement during the negotiations and the implementation of the VPA is essential. Role of delegations:•Ensure that there is political space for civil society to bring up their issues (if needed: create that space!)

What makes a good process?

Page 9: How Civil Society Sees The Vpa Process

1. All stakeholders must be included

2. Trust building is essential... And it takes time!

As people build trust in each other, several false starts and turn arounds are expected both between and within different stakeholder groups.

 Role of delegations:• Know the interests of the different actors well• Ensure that ‘legitimate’ (national) actors are represented

NOTE - Wise political navigation is recommended!

What makes a good process?

Page 10: How Civil Society Sees The Vpa Process

1. All stakeholders must be included

2. Trust building is essential... And it takes time!

3. To be meaningfully involved in discussions stakeholders must be prepared.

The pace of negotiations needs to reflect this need.  

Role of delegations (and all of us):• Allow for time needed by stakeholders to prepare• Ensure that there is close coordination between the

different actors and initiatives• Support strategies and thinking to build that capacity

What makes a good process?

Again: Time!

Page 11: How Civil Society Sees The Vpa Process

1. All stakeholders must be included

2. Trust building is essential... And it takes time!

3. To be meaningfully involved in discussions stakeholders must be prepared

4. Forestry sector reform (and of its laws) is required

A VPA process that will not address the failures of existing forest governance systems will fail

 

Role of delegations:• (Whenever relevant) support stakeholders to challenge

established systems

What makes a good process?

Page 12: How Civil Society Sees The Vpa Process

Some tips on what works and what doesn’t

• Negotiations must include social and environmental NGOs chosen via self selection process

• Land rights issues are the most sensitive but also the most key

• Negotiations led by the timber trade do not work

• Independent facilitators need to be accepted by all stakeholders

• Strategies for building the capacity of one stakeholder group must be developed together with the stakeholders concerned

• Not engaging stakeholders in defining the modalities of their involvement in the process tends to lead to misunderstandings, frustrations and conflict

Not following the above ends up delaying the pace of negotiations and implementation

Page 13: How Civil Society Sees The Vpa Process

26 Rue d’Edimbourg • Brussels

B-1050 • Belgium

The campaigning NGO for greater environmental and social justice, with a focus on forests and forest peoples rights in the policies and practices of the EU

www.fern.org

m +32 (0)496 20 55 00e [email protected]

Thank you