how a behavioral scientist can work productively with an hci researcher?
DESCRIPTION
Presentation given at SBM 2013TRANSCRIPT
How do I find and work productively with a computer scientist (person)?
Panel #10
Thanks to Caroline Richardson & Paul Resnick for their contribution to these slides!
Take home message
Design choices impact interventions
HCI researchers study this
COLLABORATION = WIN!
Distinct Roles
Behavioral Medicine
HCI Computer Science
Practitioner (Staff)
Study Coordinator, Data analyst
Designer, Evaluator
Software developer, system administrator
Researcher (Investigator)
SBM Attendees!
HCI Researcher Computer Scientist
Abstracted conceptual model
System Features/Behavior Change Techniques
Psychological States/Theoretical Constructs
System usage
Health-impacting behavior
Health outcomes
1
2
3
4
5
Focus for behavioral medicine
System Features/Behavior Change Techniques
Psychological States/Theoretical Constructs
System usage
Health-impacting behavior
Health outcomes
1
2
3
4
5
Focus for HCI
System Features/Behavior Change Techniques
Psychological States/Theoretical Constructs
System usage
Health-impacting behavior
Health outcomes
1
2
3
4
5
Theory/ Previous Research
Qualitative Interviews
Intervention Creation
Observation
Theory
Sketching/ Prototyping
Data mining
“Intervention” Development
HCI Behavioral Science
EMERGING: MOST/SMART/N-of-1
Efficacy Trial
Effectiveness Trial
Seco
nd
ary
Data
An
aly
sis
“Intervention” Evaluation
HCI Behavioral Science
Usability & Design Reaction Studies
Qualitative Field Studies
Behavioral Field Studies
A/B Testing “in the wild”
Pilot Study
Discussion
"despite our best efforts, forums, message boards, and chat rooms are rarely used in Internet interventions“
Bennett and Glasgow
Bennett GG, Glasgow RE. The delivery of public health interventions via the Internet: actualizing their potential. Annu Rev Public Health 2009 Apr 29;30:273-292.
Same study, different questions
HCI
What are the critical design decisions that will drive adults with or at risk for cardiovascular disease who are enrolled in an online walking program to participation in an online community
Behavioral Science
Among Adults with or at risk for cardiovascular disease, does adding a well designed Online community to an internet Mediated Walking Program increase adherence and step counts.
Stepping Up to Health
AutomatedInternet MediatedTailoredPedometersGoal SettingFeedback
Staff Seeding and Feeding
Introductions
Competitions for posting
Reply to all posts in < 24 hours
Asking questions
Online Community
Time to Drop out
13% more users engaged at 4 months hazard ratio = 0.4795% CI = 0.25-0.90, P = .022
Original Paper
Adding an Online Community to an Internet-Mediated Walking Program. Part 2: Strategies for Encouraging Community Participation.
Paul J. Resnick, PhD; Adrienne W. Janney, MSI; Lorraine R. Buis, PhD, Caroline R. Richardson, MD
http://www.jmir.org/2010/4/e72/
http://www.jmir.org/2010/4/e71/
For more information:
wish2013workshop.wordpress.co
m
Take home message
Design choices impact interventions
HCI researchers study this
COLLABORATION = WIN!
Comparison
HCI Emphasis
Design and creation of usable and useful artifacts
Publications Conferences
What’s funded Novel lines of inquiry,
particularly creation of “new” systems and processes.
Behavioral Science Emphasis
Development and evaluation of health interventions
Publications Journals
What’s funded Evaluation of
interventions, particularly those that have already been “vetted”
How might HCI help behavioral science?
Development of systems people want to use
Help reduce likelihood of Type III Error
Theoretical fidelity of intervention components
Opportunities for “big data” & A/B testing
Hekler, E.B., Klasnja, P. Froehlich, J. & Buman, M. (2013, May). Mind the theoretical gap: Interpreting, using, and developing behavioral theory in HCI research. ACM-CHI Conference. Paris, France.