house of commons committee of public accounts · less competition in the pricing of the equity for...
TRANSCRIPT
HC 158 Published on 15 May 2007
by authority of the House of Commons London: The Stationery Office Limited
£0.00
House of Commons
Committee of Public Accounts
Update on PFI debt refinancing and the PFI equity market
Twenty-fifth Report of Session 2006–07
Report, together with formal minutes, oral and written evidence
Ordered by The House of Commons to be printed 30 April 2007
The Committee of Public Accounts
The Committee of Public Accounts is appointed by the House of Commons to examine “the accounts showing the appropriation of the sums granted by Parliament to meet the public expenditure, and of such other accounts laid before Parliament as the committee may think fit” (Standing Order No 148).
Current membership
Mr Richard Bacon MP (Conservative, South Norfolk) Annette Brooke MP (Liberal Democrat, Mid Dorset and Poole North) Greg Clark MP (Conservative, Tunbridge Wells) Rt Hon David Curry MP (Conservative, Skipton and Ripon) Mr Ian Davidson MP (Labour, Glasgow South West) Mr Philip Dunne MP (Conservative, Ludlow) Helen Goodman MP (Labour, Bishop Auckland) Mr John Healey MP (Labour, Wentworth) Mr Sadiq Khan MP (Labour, Tooting) Mr Edward Leigh MP (Conservative, Gainsborough) (Chairman) Mr Austin Mitchell MP (Labour, Great Grimsby) Dr John Pugh MP (Liberal Democrat, Southport) Rt Hon Don Touhig MP (Labour, Islwyn) Rt Hon Alan Williams MP (Labour, Swansea West) Mr Iain Wright MP (Labour, Hartlepool) Derek Wyatt MP (Labour, Sittingbourne and Sheppey) The following were also Members of the Committee during the period of the inquiry: Sarah McCarthy-Fry MP (Labour, Portsmouth North) Kitty Ussher MP (Labour, Burnley)
Powers
Powers of the Committee of Public Accounts are set out in House of Commons Standing Orders, principally in SO No 148. These are available on the Internet via www.parliament.uk.
Publications
The Reports and evidence of the Committee are published by The Stationery Office by Order of the House. All publications of the Committee (including press notices) are on the Internet at http://www.parliament.uk/pac. A list of Reports of the Committee in the present Session is at the back of this volume.
Committee staff
The current staff of the Committee is Mark Etherton (Clerk), Philip Jones (Committee Assistant), Emma Sawyer (Committee Assistant), Anna Browning (Secretary), and Alex Paterson (Media Officer).
Contacts
All correspondence should be addressed to the Clerk, Committee of Public Accounts, House of Commons, 7 Millbank, London SW1P 3JA. The telephone number for general enquiries is 020 7219 5708; the Committee’s email address is [email protected].
1
Contents
Report Page
Summary 3
Conclusions and recommendations 5
1 PFI debt refinancing experience 7
2 The operation of the PFI equity market 11
3 The availability of financial information about PFI projects 13 The ability of public bodies to provide financial information 13 The availability of central information 13
Formal Minutes 15
Witnesses 16
List of written evidence 16
List of Reports from the Committee of Public Accounts Session 2006–07 17
3
Summary
Privately financed government projects are generally financed through a mixture of debt finance (in the form of either bank or bond finance) and equity finance (where investors have shares in the project company which has been awarded the government contract). It is a normal feature of long term projects that there may be refinancing in the form of changes to the debt or equity finance during the life of the project. This is because there is normally greater risk at the construction phase which, once completed, enables better financing terms to be obtained. Also, the maturing PFI market has meant that early PFI projects can now access better financing terms than those available when the contracts were let.
In 2002 the government introduced arrangements for the private sector to share PFI debt refinancing gains with the public sector. In 2003, the Office of Government Commerce, which then had responsibility for PFI policy, told the Committee that it expected the public sector to receive £175–£200 million from the voluntary sharing arrangements on early PFI deals, but up to December 2006 the government had secured the right to gains of only £93 million. Some of these early refinancings which had taken place had generated very high rates of return to the private sector investors and additional risks to the public sector in the form of higher termination liabilities and extended contract periods.
In the PFI equity market there is a developing secondary market which enables investors to acquire shares in PFI projects which are already in progress and some investors are building up portfolios of PFI investments. There is no requirement for the gains on selling shares in PFI projects to be shared with the government.
On the basis of a report by the Comptroller and Auditor General,1 the Committee took evidence from the Treasury on PFI debt refinancing experience, the operation of the PFI equity market and the availability of financial information about PFI projects.
1 C&AG’s Report, Update on PFI debt refinancing and the PFI equity market, HC (2005–06) 1040
5
Conclusions and recommendations
1. Most of the negotiating of refinancing deals is undertaken by the public sector at a local level where officials often lack commercial awareness. Some of the locally negotiated refinancings have produced very high investor returns and increased risks for the public sector such as higher termination liabilities and longer contract periods. All staff undertaking refinancing negotiations should undergo suitable training to equip them for this role.
2. The Treasury’s refinancing taskforce is a small team whose role is mainly advisory. To ensure its experience is brought to bear on refinancing negotiations the Treasury should approve the final terms of any refinancing involving sub
3. stantial gains to investors.
4. To date, proceeds for government from refinancing under the voluntary code amount to only £93 million. This amount is well below the indication provided by the Office of Government Commerce at the PAC hearing in 2003 that proceeds would be in the order of £175–200 million. The shortfall may be a reflection of some investors opting to defer refinancing in favour of realising gains through selling their shares in the secondary equity markets.
5. Proceeds from refinancing would also be affected if gain-sharing was a disincentive to smaller refinancings. There may therefore be a case for a more flexible sharing arrangement. Should there be any revision of the voluntary code a sliding scale of gain-sharing could be introduced which would help stimulate investors to undertake smaller value refinancings.
6. The Department of Health currently advises NHS Trusts to take refinancing gains over time. Taking the gains upfront would minimise any future risk to the public sector and is therefore preferable. The Treasury should ask the Department of Health to require NHS Trusts to take refinancing gains as an immediate lump sum unless there are convincing value for money grounds for an alternative basis.
7. The Treasury view that the public interest is not affected by sales of PFI equity is only credible if there is an efficient equity market in which investor returns can be left to find their own level as the equity is being provided on the best possible terms. The Treasury needs to demonstrate that the efficiency of the market is not prejudiced by factors such as lack of liquidity, market dominance, political risk or lack of transparency.
8. There has been growth in new investors in the PFI market mainly through the establishment of secondary market funds. It is reasonable to expect this expansion in the volume of equity available for PFI projects to produce a lower cost of equity for new deals. The Treasury should be tracking the market to assess whether pricing is improving.
6
9. The PFI equity market has shown signs of consolidation in recent years. If shares become too narrowly held these investors may be able to dominate the market with less competition in the pricing of the equity for new deals. The Treasury should have a strategy for managing these risks if they arise.
10. Transparency of information is one of the essentials to market efficiency. The Treasury should complete its database of PFI information, and use it to increase the range and quality of summarised data about PFI deals. For example, the Treasury should publish annual updates on the number and value of PFI investments held by the main PFI investors.
11. Public bodies surveyed by the National Audit Office were unable to promptly provide financial information about their PFI projects. They need to be more aware of their contractual rights to obtain financial information about their projects. Such data should include the current returns being achieved by investors, and project companies should be asked to provide annual updates of their financial models setting out the investors’ returns.
7
1 PFI debt refinancing experience 1. In 2002, following pressure from this Committee, the government introduced arrangements for the private sector to share debt refinancing gains with the public sector. On early PFI deals there is now a code which expects the private sector to voluntarily share 30% of refinancing gains with the public sector. PFI deals signed after July 2002 incorporate a 50:50 sharing arrangement.2
2. Prior to 2002 the Treasury had outlined in guidance the advantages and disadvantages of departments seeking shares of debt refinancing gains. It had left it to departments to consider in terms of value for money whether to include gain sharing arrangements. Most early PFI contracts did not include such arrangements. Whilst introducing them earlier would have given individual projects greater certainty over the sharing of refinancing gains, the Treasury was influenced by market considerations such as the possible risk that sharing arrangements might affect the private sector’s interest in bidding for the early PFI contracts.3
3. Although the Treasury provides guidance and is responsible for monitoring the refinancing of PFI deals it leaves the commercial negotiations on the detailed terms of the gain sharing to local project teams. Some of the locally negotiated debt refinancings, whilst providing the public sector with the 30% share in accordance with the refinancing code, have allowed the equity investors to achieve very large increases in their returns from the project (Figure 1).4
Figure 1 : Projects with high investor returns following refinancing
Investor rate of return prior to refinancing
Investor rate of return after refinancing
Multiple increase in investor returns on refinancing
Debden Park School 15.5% 71.3% 4.60
Norfolk & Norwich Hospital
16.0% 60.0% 3.75
Bromley Hospital 27.1% 70.5% 2.60
Darent Valley Hospital 23.0% 56.0% 2.44
Note : These four projects had the highest rate of increase in their investors internal rate of return (IRR) on refinancing from the projects surveyed in the C&AG’s report.
Source : C&AG’s report Appendix 9.
4. The Treasury acknowledges these examples of very high investor returns following refinancing but argues that they are balanced by the fact that investors have lost money on some projects. The Treasury also argues that the focus should be on whether value for
2 C&AG’s Report, para 1.1
3 Qq 27, 115, 135, 137–146; Ev 16
4 C&AG’s Report, Figure 12, page 21; Appendix 9; Qq 31–45
8
money is being achieved for the public sector from these deals, pointing to their having generally delivered the right projects for the public sector with a much better record than previous conventional procurement. The examples of high investor returns within a few years of contracts being awarded, combined with added risks for the public sector would, however, suggest that value for money is not being optimised.5
5. Returns to early participants in the PFI debt market reflected the uncertain risk they were taking on. The very high investor returns on these early debt refinancings have, however, been further enhanced in situations where the public sector accepted, as part of the refinancings, increased risks in the form of higher termination liabilities or extended contract periods. The acceptance of additional risks reflected a lack of commercial awareness by public sector officials at the local level. Although the projects may have been delivered, the full effect of the refinancing will only be capable of being assessed at a later stage in contract periods which will run for 30 or more years.6
6. The Treasury has a Refinancing Taskforce to advise project teams on refinancing issues which is, however, a limited resource comprising two people. There is no requirement for local officials to seek Treasury approval for the terms of a refinancing deal. The Treasury policy of leaving it to departments to achieve value for money from refinancing failed to prevent situations where investors increased their refinancing gains by passing added risks to the public sector.7
7. The Office of Government Commerce told us in 2003 that it expected the public sector would receive refinancing gains of £175–200 million from the voluntary sharing arrangements on early deals. When we took evidence from the Treasury in December 2006 the government had only secured the right to receive £93 million (Figure 2, overleaf), of which £60 million had arisen from three hospital refinancings where there had been high investor returns and significant increased risks for the public sector.8
5 Qq 1–3, 97–100
6 C&AG’s Report, paras 2.6–2.12; Qq 83, 108
7 Qq 30–40, 42, 55, 64
8 Committee of Public Accounts, Twenty-second Report of Session 2002–03, PFI refinancing update, HC 203; Qq 24–28, 126–129
9
Figure 2 : The government’s share of refinancings from the voluntary code for early PFI deals
Project Net present value of total refinancing gains £m
% shared with public sector
Public sector share £m
Early PFI hospital refinancings involving high investor returns and significant increased risks for the public sector :
Norfolk & Norwich hospital 115.5 29% 33.9
Bromley hospital 45.3 31% 14.2
Darent Valley hospital 33.4 194.2
35% 31%
11.7 59.8
Other refinancings of early deals:
Swindon Hospital 42.2 44% (Note 1) 18.3
Other projects 61.9 23% (Note 2) 14.4
Totals 298.3 31% 92.5 (Note 3)
Notes:
1) In addition to the 30% voluntary code sharing on the original project debt the authority secured a further 14% of the total refinancing gain relating to gains on additional debt being used to carry out further work.
2) The average gain secured of 23% on these projects was less than the usual voluntary share of 30% as three projects did not share gains (C&AG’s Report, paras 1.29–1.33) and in some further projects the code permitted the private sector to share less than 30% as, prior to the refinancing, the investors had been earning less than their target return.
3) The £92.5 million includes refinancings, where the government received the right to £21.0 million, which were completed after the publication of the C&AG’s report in April 2006 when the total gains for the public sector had been £71.5 million.
8. The Treasury attributed the shortfall in gains secured for the public sector to the OGC 2003 prediction being an uncertain estimate that had turned out not to be correct in respect of refinancing experience to date. The Treasury did not believe that the increasing trend for investors to sell shares in PFI projects had caused a reduction in refinancing activity. But with just four hospital refinancings accounting for most of what the public sector has received (Figure 2), other refinancings may have been deferred as investors can receive part of the value relating to a project’s refinancing potential when they sell their shares. The amount that the public sector has received has also been limited because the voluntary code gives it a fixed 30% share even where the investors have earned very high returns with increased risks for the public sector.9
9 C&AG’s Report, para 1.4; Qq 20–28, 77–82, 117, 123–129, 136
10
9. The Treasury has allowed local projects the freedom to decide whether they will take their share of refinancing gains as a lump sum, over the life of the contract period or in the form of services provided by the project company. The Department of Health has required NHS Trusts to take their share of refinancing benefits over time so that the benefit is received evenly over the life of the contract. The private sector, however, will wish to take the gains from refinancing immediately to reduce their risks from investing in the project. The Department of Health acknowledged during our previous examination of the Norfolk and Norwich PFI Hospital refinancing that if a private sector consortium fails financially, a Trust would not be certain of receiving its share of the refinancing gains, whereas there would have been certainty if it had taken the gains as cash at the time of the refinancing.
11
2 The operation of the PFI equity market 10. The provision of equity finance enables projects to be financed where there are risks which the providers of debt finance are unwilling to bear. As a result, the providers of equity finance should bear the risk of losing some or all of their investment if the project does not go well and should expect to earn more than the returns to the providers of debt finance if the project is successful.
11. As the PFI market has matured it has become quite common for the initial investors in PFI projects to sell their investments, either to one of the initial investors or to new investors in the emerging PFI secondary equity market (Figure 3). The Treasury has always anticipated that some PFI investors would only invest for the short term and that they would make profits if the projects were performing. For example, the contractor Carillion had sold some of its PFI investments which had cost £24 million for proceeds of £46 million. The Treasury acknowledges that the early PFI deals gave investors the potential to make these types of gains but the deals had been priced on terms available at the time reflecting the risks of a new market.10
Figure 3: Incidence of PFI share sales
Number of projects
%
Within one year of contract letting 1
One to two years after contract letting 2
Two to three years after contract letting 4
More than three years after contract letting 25
32 40
Share sales have not occurred 48
Total The National Audit Office asked all 123 PFI projects which it had surveyed for the purposes of the C&AG’s Report whether there had been a share sale. 80 projects responded to this question.
80 100
Source: C&AG’s Report, Figure 15, page 29
12. Unlike debt refinancing where the Treasury requires investor gains to be shared with the public sector the Treasury does not require investors' gains on selling equity in PFI projects to be shared with the projects. They take the view that, whereas a debt refinancing affects the public sector’s rights and interests as a purchaser, a change in the equity ownership of the project is a transaction outside the project which does not affect the public sector’s interests if the PFI equity market is operating efficiently. As equity investors take the risk of incurring losses on their investments, they might also seek higher equity
10 C&AG’s Report, paras 3.1-3.3; Qq 102–104, 109–122
12
prices in new PFI contracts to compensate if they were required to share equity gains. An alternative would be for the government to take an equity stake in PFI projects to enable it to share in the equity profits, but this would also expose it to the financial risks of the project failing.
13. The achievement of value for money in a long-term market depends, to a large extent, on competition and improved terms as the market matures. The large investor returns which arose on some early PFI deals showed that there was the potential for improving the pricing of deals. Better prices are available on current deals, although the introduction of new sources of capital through the PFI secondary market funds creates the possibility of further reducing the cost of equity finance through increased competition between investors for new PFI contracts.11
14. There is, however, a potential risk that, if the current trend for some large contractors and secondary market funds to build up portfolios of PFI investments continues, then some investors may come to dominate the market. Other parties might then be discouraged from entering into bidding competitions for new contracts and, without publicly funded projects to act as a benchmark, it would become difficult to demonstrate that value for money was being achieved. The Treasury acknowledges that reduced competition would be a concern, but believes that the market remains competitive between around ten large contractors and secondary market funds.12
15. Where an equity investor is involved with a portfolio of PFI projects there may be the opportunity for further benefits from greater operating efficiencies. There is the potential for such efficiencies to benefit the pricing of both current and future deals. Investors, however, will not all have the same approach to managing PFI projects. Some investors may place greater emphasis on earning short term gains which might not be consistent with sharing benefits with the public sector. The public sector cannot determine who the investors should be, so it is important that the public sector understands how the aims of their PFI investors may impact on the projects.13
11 Qq 66, 114
12 C&AG’s Report, para 3.9; Qq 47–54
13 C&AG’s Report, para 3.9; Qq 106–107, 165–168
13
3 The availability of financial information about PFI projects 16. Public sector project teams need information relating to the financing arrangements and the costs of their PFI projects in order to understand the economics of the project and to equip them to handle effectively negotiations on refinancing and other issues. At present there are significant limitations in:
• the ability of public bodies with PFI projects to provide basic financial information about their projects; and
• the availability of central information summarising aspects of PFI financing across all PFI contracts.
The ability of public bodies to provide financial information
17. All authorities normally receive information about the financing arrangements of their PFI project companies, including the investors’ expected returns from the project, when the companies bid for the contract and when they seek the authorities’ approval for a refinancing. In addition, the Treasury’s standard PFI contract now allows public bodies to ask for information which the project company has made available to its lenders, as well as information which will assist the monitoring of service performance. Neither the public bodies concerned, nor the Treasury ask for information about what the investors are earning. Yet information on how much PFI investors are earning is relevant to monitoring the cost-effectiveness of the projects.14
18. Despite the fact that the private sector normally discloses information about investor returns to enable the sharing of refinancing gains to be computed, public bodies in 16 out of 36 projects failed to respond with appropriate information when, on our behalf, the National Audit Office asked them to show the extent to which the returns to investors had changed following the refinancing of their projects. We have asked for the outstanding information to be collected by the National Audit Office.15
The availability of central information
19. The Treasury agrees that it should produce an annual summary of the trends in PFI financing costs and that, to provide transparency and a better understanding of the dynamics of PFI equity investment, further information is required on the full range of costs and benefits which investors experience from participating in the PFI market. A complete picture of investor benefits from investing in PFI deals would depend, however, on greater disclosure by investors of the proceeds from the sale of PFI investments, which
14 C&AG’s Report, para 3.13; Qq 59–66
15 C&AG’s Report, para 3.14, Appendix 9; Ev 48; Qq 4–19, 43
14
currently is not disclosed to authorities because it is a contract between two private sector parties.16
20. A listing of all PFI contracts is available on the Treasury’s website, and other project information is held in a database which Partnerships UK, on behalf of the Treasury, launched in 2005. The database includes available information on the financing of the projects and the extent of refinancing activity, although at the time of the Comptroller and Auditor General’s report in April 2006 considerable further work was needed to make aspects of this information accurate and comprehensive. The Treasury is seeking to improve the information on the database. It has now brought the database up to date for deals which have closed in the last three or four years, but it needs completing for earlier deals. Financial information on the database can help departments assess the value for money of new proposals. For example the Treasury told us that the cost of debt finance in recent PFI hospital deals has been 0.7% above government gilt rates.17
21. The Treasury also collects data on the PFI contract price which the public sector is committed to paying in future years. The government’s aggregate forward commitments under PFI deals are then disclosed in the Treasury’s pre-Budget report. The Treasury’s current information, based on returns from departments of PFI contracts that have been let, shows that the aggregate of these PFI commitments for the years 2006 to 2032 inclusive is £155 billion. The Treasury will be providing information on the proportion of these commitments which is accounted for on the government’s balance sheet as part of its next biannual update of PFI data which it expects to be available around March 2007.18
16 C&AG’s Report, paras 5, 6, page 9 and para 3.16; Q 66
17 C&AG’s Report, para 3.15; Qq 56–58;
18 Qq 67–69; 147–159; Ev 16
15
Formal Minutes
Monday 30 April 2007
Mr Edward Leigh, in the Chair
Mr David Curry Mr Sadiq Khan Dr John Pugh
Mr Alan Williams Mr Iain Wright Derek Wyatt
Draft Report
Draft Report (Update on PFI debt refinancing and the PFI equity market), proposed by the Chairman, brought up and read.
Ordered, That the draft Report be read a second time, paragraph by paragraph.
Paragraphs 1 to 21 read and agreed to.
Conclusions and recommendations read and agreed to.
Summary read and agreed to.
Resolved, That the Report be the Twenty-fifth Report of the Committee to the House.
Ordered, That the Chairman make the Report to the House.
Ordered, That embargoed copies of the Report be made available, in accordance with the provisions of Standing Order No. 134.
[Adjourned until Wednesday 9 May at 3.30 pm.
16
Witnesses
Monday 22 December 2006
Mr John Kingman, Managing Director, Public Services & Growth Directorate, and Mr Richard Abadie, Head, PFI Policy Team, Her Majesty’s Treasury. Ev 1
List of written evidence
1 HM Treasury Ev 16
2 National Audit Office Ev 19
17
List of Reports from the Committee of Public Accounts Session 2006–07 First Report Tsunami: Provision of support for humanitarian
assistance HC 25 (Cm 7018)
Second Report Improving literacy and numeracy in schools (Northern Ireland)
HC 108 (Cm 7035)
Third Report Collections Management in the National Museums and Galleries of Northern Ireland
HC 109 (Cm 7035)
Fourth Report Gas distribution networks: Ofgem’s role in their sale, restructuring and future regulation
HC 110 (Cm 7019)
Fifth Report Postcomm and the quality of mail services HC 111 (Cm 7018) Sixth Report Gaining and retaining a job: the Department for Work
and Pensions support for disabled people HC 112 (Cm 7019)
Seventh Report Department for Work and Pensions: Using leaflets to communicate with the public about services and entitlements
HC 133 (Cm 7020)
Eighth Report Tackling Child Obesity—First Steps HC 157 (Cm 7020)Ninth Report The Paddington Health Campus Scheme HC 244 (Cm 7076)Tenth Report Fines Collection HC 245 (Cm 7020)Eleventh Report Supporting Small Business HC 262 (Cm 7076)Twelfth Report Excess Votes 2005–06 HC 346 Thirteenth Report Smarter Food Procurement in the Public Sector HC 357 Fourteenth Report Ministry of Defence: Delivering digital tactical
communications through the Bowman CIP Programme HC 358
Fifteenth Report The termination of the PFI contract for the National Physical Laboratory
HC 359
Sixteenth Report The Provision of Out-of-Hours Care in England HC 360 Seventeenth Report Financial Management of the NHS HC 361 Eighteenth Report DFID: Working with Non-Governmental and other Civil
Society Organisations to promote development HC 64
Nineteenth Report A Foot on the Ladder: Low Cost Home Ownership Assistance
HC 134
Twentieth Report Department of Health: The National Programme for IT in the NHS
HC 390
Twenty-first Report Progress in Combat Identification HC 486 Twenty-second Report Tax credits HC 487 Twenty-third Report The office accommodation of the Department for
Culture, Media and Sport and its sponsored bodies HC 488
Twenty-fourth Report Owfat: Meeting the demand for water HC 286 Twenty-fifth Report Update on PFI debt refinancing and the PFI equity
market HC 158
The reference number of the Treasury Minute to each Report is printed in brackets after the HC printing number
3639101001 Page Type [SO] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 1
Oral evidence
Taken before the Committee of Public Accounts
on Monday 11 December 2006
Members present:
Mr Alan Williams, in the Chair
Mr Richard Bacon Mr Sadiq KhanMr Philip Dunne Mr Austin MitchellHelen Goodman Mr Don Touhig
Sir John Bourn KCB, Comptroller and Auditor General, gave evidence.Ms Paula Diggle, Treasury OYcer of Accounts, HM Treasury, was in attendance.
REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL
UPDATE ON PFI DEBT REFINANCING AND THE PFI EQUITY MARKET (HC 1040)
Witnesses: Mr John Kingman, Managing Director, Public Services & Growth Directorate and Mr RichardAbadie, Head, PFI Policy Team, Her Majesty’s Treasury, gave evidence.
Q1 Chairman: Today, we are considering theComptroller and Auditor General’s Report, Updateon PFI debt refinancing and the PFI equity market.We have two guests here today: Mr John Kingmanand Mr Richard Abadie. Welcome back, gentlemen.May we start with you, Mr Kingman, and look atfigure 12 on page 21? The middle panel shows somestartling figures. Starting at the bottom of the middlethree with Norfolk and Norwich: total refinancinggain £116 million, pre-refinancing internal rate 16%.After refinancing it had increased fourfold to 60%.Bromley hospital: total refinancing gain £45 million,pre-refinancing 27%, post-refinancing 71%, athreefold increase. For Debden, the sums aresmaller, but the percentages are every bit asdramatic. Debden school: £1 million totalrefinancing gain, 16% internal pre-refinancing rateand 71%, four and a half times that, post-refinancing. How on earth could the Treasury allowsuch obscene profit figures to arise?Mr Kingman: Mr Chairman, thank you. There hasobviously been a great deal of discussion over theyears on this very subject. We think that, with theassistance of the work that the NAO has done andthe hearings that the PAC has held over the years, wehave got to a place where we are able to secure a fairand sensible share of the gains from refinancing forthe taxpayer. The background, which is important,is that our concern at the Treasury is value formoney; it is getting capital projects built better andcheaper and delivered to time and budget, and thereis clear evidence that the PFI programme has donethat. It is true that there have been projects where ithas been possible for contractors to make significantsums; equally, it is true that there have been projectswhere contractors have lost significant sums. Ourconcern is with getting the projects delivered on timeand to budget.
Q2 Chairman: But it is surely diYcult to reconcilefourfold increases in the percentage rate of returnwith any concept of value for money.
Mr Kingman: Our view would be that the key tests ofvalue for money are whether we are getting the rightprojects and whether we are getting them on theright terms, and there is clear evidence that PFI isdoing that much better than conventional forms ofprocurement have done. Yes, as I say, people havemade significant sums on particular projects. Wethink that it is right we have been able to secure a fairshare of the gains for the taxpayer, and I pay tributeto the work that the NAO and the PAC have doneover the years, which has helped us in that.
Q3 Chairman: Those tail figures—71%, 71% and60%—do not cause you any embarrassment or anyfeeling that they are diYcult to reconcile with valuefor money?Mr Kingman: I do not think that they cause as muchembarrassment as they would if the projects werevery expensive or very delayed. Looking back overthe work that the NAO has done, the fact is that,under conventional forms of procurement,something like three quarters of projects weredelivered over budget and three quarters weredelayed. The record of PFI has been dramaticallybetter.
Q4 Chairman: Bearing in mind that the figures Igave are from those who deigned to provideinformation, what do you think about the 16 of the36 projects that the NAO approached—virtuallyhalf the projects—which provided no information atall or hardly any? Are you not worried that theymight be even more grotesquely inexplicable?Mr Abadie: Since 1999, all projects through ourstandard contract have an obligation, if asked by theNAO to reply, to provide the information requested.The fact that they have not replied—I am not awarewhy they have not replied—
3639101001 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 2 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
HM Treasury
Q5 Chairman: Are you not concerned that they didnot reply? Are you not concerned that you do notknow why they did not reply? I should have thoughtthat it was your job to find out.Mr Kingman: We certainly believe that we needbetter information than we currently have on someof these situations; I entirely agree with that point,and the recommendations in the Report are veryhelpful.
Q6 Chairman: So you have written to each of the 16and told them that you want a reply from them?Mr Abadie: No, we have not.
Q7 Chairman: Why not?Mr Abadie: The survey was done by the NAO. Wehave a broader process of—
Q8 Chairman: But you knew that you were going tobe asked questions here and you must have guessedthat virtually every Member of the Committee, giventhe opportunity, would want to ask the samequestion—I just happened to be first. The fact thatvirtually half the projects did not reply suggests thatthey just may have had something to hide. If I hadbeen in your position, I would have wanted to comehere equipped to answer. Do you not feel that youshould have done more to find out?Mr Abadie: We have a wider process of trying toaccess and receive information from all the projects,not just those 16. It is that process that we arefocussed on.
Q9 Chairman: Do you even know which the 16were?Mr Abadie: Again, I do not know at the moment.
Q10 Chairman: You do not know whether youknow?Mr Abadie: I do not know which the 16 projects are.
Q11 Chairman: You are not even that curious? Youare not curious to find out who did not reply?Mr Abadie: Again, we are looking for informationfrom all the projects. It may be on a detailed list.
Q12 Chairman: Why did you not ask the NAO whodid not reply?Mr Abadie: The NAO followed up with thoseprojects subsequently, after the initial survey. Wetold the NAO in—
Q13 Chairman: I am terrible at remembering titles,but are you not supposed to be the head of a PFIpolicy team?Mr Abadie: I am.
Q14 Chairman: And yet you have not even shownmarginal curiosity at the fact that half the peoplequestioned did not deign to provide the informationor a reason for not providing the information. Andyou did not even ask the Comptroller and AuditorGeneral who they might be. Is that a fact?
Mr Abadie: I would like to clarify that. Wesupported the NAO in trying to gather the data inthe first place. As part of its inquiry into all theprojects that had undertaken refinancing, we agreedthat Treasury could be mentioned in the letter. So itis not a case that we were not involved in the datagathering at all; we were part of the process ofgathering that data in the first instance.
Q15 Chairman: Sir John, you made repeatedattempts to get that information?Sir John Bourn: Yes.
Q16 Chairman: And they just ignored you, despitethe fact that they had been told that they might becalled before this Committee? We might considerthat.Sir John Bourn: Yes.
Q17 Chairman: Can you let us have a list of thenames?Sir John Bourn: Certainly.
Q18 Chairman: Can you let us have a list of theprojects and the value of them? Can you tell each ofthem that we are considering the possibility ofcalling them before us unless we get the informationthat we have asked for, or a good explanation of whyit is not available? Will you do that?1
Sir John Bourn: Yes.
Q19 Chairman: Mr Abadie, in your oversight role inrelation to PFI across the spectrum, will you alsomake sure that same message goes forward?Mr Abadie: Yes. 2
Q20 The Chairman: Well, that is helpful, thankyou—belated but helpful. Now, what about this newtechnique of selling shares? Instead of refinancing,shares in the project are being sold. How far is thata device to deprive the public of the share that theymight get under the existing refinancingarrangements? Does it have that eVect even if it wasnot intended to?Mr Kingman: Maybe I could try to answer that. I donot think that it is correct to see equity transactionsas an alternative to PFI refinancing. The evidencethat we have and the evidence in the Report is thatprojects where there have been changes in equityholdings have been more likely to be refinanced thanothers. We believe that refinancings and equity salesare diVerent kinds of transactions. Perhaps I can tryto explain why. A refinancing takes place within aproject. It changes the contractual basis and theterms of trade between the public sector purchaserand the provider in the private sector. We think thatit is absolutely right that major value for moneyissues can arise there, and that is why it is right to goafter a share of the gains.
1 Ev2 Note by witness: The request, for projects identified as
providing incomplete or no initial responses, to providecomplete data has gone out from the NAO. The NAO’sletter rightly emphasised that their request had full Treasuryendorsement.
3639101001 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 3
HM Treasury
Q21 Chairman: This change is made not with theconsent of the public sector, but between one privatesector seller and a private sector buyer. So thechange has not been agreed and it is not consensualbetween the customer and the provider; it has beenchanged by the provider—we assume, because it isadvantageous to the provider. By definition, onewould have thought that that means it isdisadvantageous to the buyer in a range in thepublic sector.Mr Kingman: It is absolutely correct that a change inthe equity holdings in the project is outside a project,and that is precisely why we see it as diVerent froma refinancing. It does not change the public sector’srights; it does not change the relationship between usand the provider; it is a change in the ownership ofthe provider.
Q22 Chairman: Hold on. You say it does notchange our rights, but it changes what we have ourrights to, does it not? If they are selling shares insteadof refinancing, they are extracting gain without thepublic sector sharing in that gain. It is a device.Mr Kingman: I do not believe that it is a device; Ithink it is a diVerent kind of transaction from arefinancing.
Q23 Chairman: Yes, it is conniving at getting moremoney for the private sector.Mr Kingman: I do not think that that is correct, andI point to the evidence in the Report. The projectswhere there have been changes in equity holdingshave been more likely to be refinanced, with gainsaccruing to the public sector, than those that havenot.
Q24 Chairman: When the OYce of GovernmentCommerce gave us evidence, it indicated that it wasanticipating that the voluntary share under theprocess would amount to £175 million to £200million. To date, at the time of the Report, it hadamounted to only £93 million. Why the massiveshortfall, just 50% of what was expected? Can youassure me that it is totally unrelated to what we havebeen talking about, namely the switch to sellingshares?Mr Kingman: I believe that it is unrelated. WhenPeter Gershon gave you that estimate, he gave it ingood faith, but I think that it was always clear thatthere was a great deal of uncertainty about whatwould be likely. We have never seen the estimate thatPeter gave as a target and it would be quite wrong forus to target any particular level of gain, becauseour issue—
Q25 Chairman: But it was the best estimate on theinformation at the time?Mr Kingman: Correct.
Q26 Chairman: So what changed for the estimate tobe literally 100% out? They only got half of whatthey thought they would get.Mr Kingman: I am not sure that I can point toanything specific that has changed. It was simply abest estimate that has turned out not to be correct.
The private sector is already very highly incentivisedto go after refinancings. We do not want to be in aposition where the public sector is pushingrefinancing levels to meet some number, because itseems to us that the most important test is valuefor money.
Q27 Chairman: Well, you should be pushing.Remember how we got here. When I first startedtabling questions, we had had one report onrefinancing. I tabled questions to every Department,and as a result, I discovered that hardly any of themwere even trying to get refinancing. Thatinformation was handed to the Comptroller andAuditor General, who then showed that only 15%of Departments were getting refinancing. Theconsequence was a deal of 30%, which eventuallyrose to 50% as a result of pressure from thisCommittee. We must push. If we do not, it seemsthat you will not.Mr. Kingman: We think that you were right to pushon that. We have pushed also. We push public sectorproviders to get that share of the gains, and theReport’s evidence is that it has been successful.What we do not push is refinancing for refinancing’ssake. The Report warns rightly that—
Q28 Chairman: Why not?Mr Kingman: Because refinancing can be very badvalue for money, particularly if it involves anincrease in termination liabilities. As the Reportsays, you can imagine that a situation in whichpublic sector providers themselves pushed forrefinancing for aVordability reasons might result inbad deals for the public sector. Seen from where wesit, the fact that there is a little more caution aboutrefinancing for refinancing’s sake, as the Reportacknowledges, is an entirely good thing from a valuefor money point of view.
Q29 Mr Touhig: Mr Abadie—an unusual name.Are you related, by any chance, to Paul Abadie, the19th Century French architect?Mr Abadie: No.
Q30 Mr Touhig: Well, that is a relief all around,because after one of his jobs he became known as“Abadie the wrecker”. Tell me, must the Treasuryapprove every proposal to refinance a PFI project?Mr Abadie: The answer is no.
Q31 Mr Touhig: Why?Mr Abadie: From a policy point of view, we haveestablished the framework in which refinancingstake place. The decision about what is or is not valuefor money, as the case may be, is the responsibilityof the accounting oYcer of the Department orauthority concerned.
Q32 Mr Touhig: Does anybody in the Treasuryhave a particular interest in protecting the public’sinterest in these matters?Mr Abadie: Yes, most definitely. Within theTreasury, we have established the refinancingtaskforce. We fund a couple of people to act—
3639101001 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 4 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
HM Treasury
Q33 Mr Touhig: Is there any one person?Mr Abadie: Two people.
Q34 Mr Touhig: There are two people responsiblefor looking to the public interest in any refinancingproject?Mr Abadie: That is quite correct.
Q35 Mr Touhig: The Chairman alluded in hiscomments to the killing that was made on therefinancing of the Norfolk and Norwich hospitalPFI. You do not have to approve each PFIrefinancing, but you do have two people to look ateach project. In what detail do they do so ?Mr Abadie: The mandate of the refinancingtaskforce has changed a little over time, but it isprincipally a supporting body. Authorities that wantto use the refinancing taskforce are entitled to do so.It sits in an advisory capacity, advising on goodpractice. At the time of the Norfolk and Norwichand the Bromley hospitals, and probably DebdenPark school as well, the refinancing taskforce mighthave been involved and concluded that policy wascomplied with.
Q36 Mr Touhig: But the Treasury has an overviewof all that?Mr Abadie: Yes.
Q37 Mr Touhig: You are a pushover then, really,are you not?Mr Kingman: My reading of the NAO’s Report isnot that we have a situation in which there are a largenumber of public sector purchasers which are notfollowing the code, or not driving it through, so asto secure the gains. Were that the case, we wouldwant to be more hands-on than we are. Actually, wehave a good dialogue with the key purchasingDepartments, and I think that the evidence of theReport is that the code is being followed.
Q38 Mr Touhig: You have good dialogue to letpurchasers make a good deal of extra money at thepublic’s expense. Barclays and Innisfree made largegains on the Darent Valley and the Norfolk andNorwich hospital projects. Who at the Treasurymakes sure that after a refinancing takes place, wecontinue to get value for money and that the projectsare well managed in the public interest?Mr Kingman: That is the responsibility of theDepartments that purchase the projects.
Q39 Mr Touhig: So you do not have much of a role,do you?Mr Kingman: We have a clear role in policy, and wehad a very important role in instituting, negotiatingand establishing the code successfully, such that thegains are realised.
Q40 Mr Touhig: You do not seem to want to policeit—you are quite arm’s length in all of this.Mr Kingman: I do not see the Report painting apicture of a code that is not being policed.
Q41 Mr Touhig: The Report points out, on page 31,that equity investors and debt providers haveconsiderable opportunities to generate benefits fromrefinancing PFI projects. Do you agree with that?Mr Kingman: Yes, I do agree. That was particularlythe case with earlier projects. In relation to those,and following the discussions at numerous PAChearings and the work of the NAO, our aim has beento extract a fair share of the gains in accordance withthe code negotiated with the private sector.
Q42 Mr Touhig: But you do not have to approveeach project. Do investors have to advise you of anyimprovement in value, and do they share with thepublic the financial benefits from a refinancingproject?Mr Abadie: Yes, they do. Once a refinancing iscompleted, or even before it is completed, therefinancing taskforce would be made aware of it andprovide support where necessary. I shall add animportant point to what John said: from our pointof view, there are very few cases in which the codehas not been complied with. Even when you see thelevels of return to which you referred, the code isnevertheless complied with. The Government havereceived their 30% share under the code as wasvoluntarily negotiated with the private sector. Inthat sense, it is not a failure of the code that theprivate sector is getting a 70 or 71% return. That isa separate issue.
Q43 Mr Touhig: The Chairman pointed outexamples at the beginning of the sitting describingthe very considerable refinancing gains that accrued:£1 million was the smallest; £116 million the largest.People must think that the Treasury is a pretty softtouch. In your earlier response to the Chairman, youcould not tell us why we could not get responsesfrom some of the companies involved.Mr Kingman: I do not accept that we are a softtouch. The success has been in negotiating thevoluntary code—it is worth remembering that theGovernment had precisely no legal entitlement toany of the gains—and the NAO’s Report concludedthat it was a successful negotiation.
Q44 Chairman: You may say that the fact that therewas no legal entitlement was a fault in the draftingof the scheme in the first place.Mr Kingman: Perhaps.
Chairman: So do not use that to bounce back at theCommittee.
Q45 Mr Touhig: You may not have any legalentitlement—I understand that—but you are givingpeople a licence to print money.Mr Kingman: All I can say is that we negotiated acode, and that that negotiation was regarded assuccessful. The key thing now is whether the code isa reality and whether it is working. I believe that theevidence of the Report is that it is.
3639101001 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 5
HM Treasury
Q46 Mr Touhig: I am not clear whether you areinterested in processes or outcomes. Why do youallow Departments to opt to take their benefits overa period of time? Why do you not say “Take the cashnow”—a bird in the hand and all that?Mr Kingman: Because some Departments prefer totake benefits in other forms. There are legitimatereasons for taking the benefits in one form ratherthan another. I do not think that hard, rigidTreasury rules on everything would be justified inthis case.
Q47 Mr Touhig: Why break the habit of a lifetime?We have hard, rigid Treasury rules on every damnthing. Why do you think that certain investors arebuilding up large portfolios of PFI projects? Is itbecause they are public spirited?Mr Abadie: They have been building up thoseportfolios since the beginning of PFI. It is quitenormal practice. Most of the equity funds that arenamed in the Report were set up in the mid to late1990s with a view to building up those assets.
Q48 Mr Touhig: Is it a good thing?Mr Abadie: From the point of view of eYciency, webelieve so. I shall not name specific funds, but somehave collective insurance arrangements, and thebenefits are passed on to the individual projects.
Q49 Mr Touhig: Is not there a danger that increasedownership of PFI shares by a few large investors willin fact allow those investors to control the marketand reduce competition? Is the Treasury againstcompetition these days?Mr Abadie: Most definitely not. It is a question ofthe appropriate number of investors. There are fiveor six fairly substantial equity funds in the marketand there are four or five very large contractors thathave equity portfolios as well. There is a high degreeof competition between the eight and 10 fairly largeinvestors, so lack of competition does not overlyconcern us.
Q50 Mr Touhig: The Treasury is not overlyconcerned. That is definitive?Mr Abadie: Correct.
Q51 Mr Touhig: The Treasury is not concerned thata small number of very large companies is gettingcontrol of major PFI projects?Mr Kingman: We would be very concerned if therewere a sense that there was less competition in themarket, but we believe that there is healthycompetition in the market.
Q52 Mr Touhig: Thirty or forty years ago, localauthorities set up their own direct labourorganisations to build and maintain property—schools and the rest of it—because cabals of majorcompanies were being set up to bid for the workand control access to it. Have you thought ofestablishing a publicly owned and financed companythat would be a benchmark and that would providesome competition for the organisations in themarket?
Mr Kingman: Not as such, but let me return tothe general record of PFI. Compared with publicsector procurement it has been markedly moresuccessful—PFI investment projects have beencompleted on time in almost 90% of cases, whereasthree quarters of publicly financed projects overran.
Q53 Mr Touhig: Thinking out of the box, that one,was it?Mr Kingman: I think that PFI was about thinkingout of the box.
Q54 Mr Touhig: No, I mean my suggestion ofsetting up your own publicly financed company tocompete and set a benchmark. That is a tried andtested practice in local government. It has workedvery successfully and has delivered value for money.Mr Kingman: I could not claim to have studied theidea in detail, because we have not studied it indetail.Mr Touhig: If you decide to take it on, recognise thatyou heard it here first. I think that my time is up.Thank you.
Q55 Mr Philip Dunne: I remind the Committee ofmy declaration in the Register of Members’Interests. I am the director of a small fundmanagement firm that has invested particularlyenthusiastically in PFI refinancings and otherprojects, so I understand the economic attractionsfor the investor. You referred, I think, to the factthat the Treasury has two members of staV whoadvise on individual projects as they arise. Howmany are involved in monitoring the existing PFIschemes?Mr Abadie: Within the Treasury, or acrossGovernment?Mr Dunne: Within the Treasury.Mr Abadie: Within the Treasury, we have a team ofsomething between 10 and 12 people. There are acouple of people from the private sector, such asmyself, and there are two senior civil servants in theteam. We are supported on a contract basis byPartnerships UK, which provides us with additionaldepth and resource if we need it.Mr Kingman: To give a sense of the scale, that is aslarge a team as we have shadowing the entireDepartment of Health.
Q56 Mr Dunne: Presumably you require fullfinancial information on each project that qualifiesfor PFI, from any Department.Mr Abadie: We have a process whereby we obtaininformation on a semi-annual basis. Thatinformation can include the value of deals that wereclosed in the year and also the forwardcommitment—the unitary charge commitmentgoing forward. When a deal is closed there is also aprocess of data collation on the transaction, afterwhich the data are stored on a database held byPartnerships UK.
Q57 Mr Dunne: Does that mean that, if I were toask you for financial information on a specificproject, you could provide that?
3639101001 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 6 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
HM Treasury
Mr Abadie: The database needs updating—particularly for older projects—but it is very muchup to date for transactions that have taken placeover the last three to four years.
Q58 Mr Dunne: I ask that question because when Iasked, in a parliamentary question, for a full list ofall PFI projects by Department, I was told that thatinformation was not available.Mr Abadie: That is surprising. We have a full list onthe Treasury website of every single signedtransaction. That is readily accessible.
Q59 Mr Dunne: Does it provide information onrates of return to investors at diVerent stages of theproject?Mr Abadie: No. On the website we have a list of allthe signed deals, and information on when they weresigned and by whom—by which Department—thename of the project and its capital value. The ratesof return, to the extent that we have that data, areincluded in the Partnerships UK database, which isavailable to the public sector.
Q60 Mr Dunne: Do you not require disclosure ofrates of return as part of the contract?Mr Abadie: No. Under the standard contract that weput out, authorities are entitled to ask for thatinformation and any information about thecontractor. Whether they ask for that data is up tothem. One of the helpful recommendations made bythe NAO in the Report is that we should be moresystematic in that respect and request that data.
Q61 Mr Dunne: I agree. It makes it very diYcult foryou to do your job and monitor the cost-eVectiveness of these projects if you do not knowwhat returns third parties are getting, does it not?Mr Abadie: There are various ways of looking atthat. The nature of the contract we enter into withthe private sector is eVectively for a fixed price. Whatwe are looking for over the period of the contract iscertainty of delivery of the services.
Q62 Mr Dunne: But, in order to make thejudgments that you have made that this is bettervalue for money than previous procurementpolicies, you must be able to establish how muchmoney third parties are making out of thesecontracts.Mr Abadie: If I may, I think that the yardstick bywhich we judge value for money is not how muchprofit people are making—people may makesignificant profits and they may make losses—butwhether we are getting better projects purchased atless cost and delivered to time. That is what we meanby value for money.
Q63 Mr Dunne: But as far as these refinancings areconcerned—they are generally at the stage after theconstruction risk has been taken out of a project,and I recognise that construction risk is one thingand that operating a financial risk thereafter is acompletely separate sort of risk—the Treasury
should have a good grip on the returns being madeby the industry. From what you have told me, youdo not have that at present.Mr Abadie: That is correct. We do not requestfrom the projects on a periodic basis what thecontractor—the PFI company—is making in termsof ongoing equity returns. That is a diVerent matter,though, from assessing whether a refinancing isvalue for money for the public sector. The trade-oVthere from a public sector point of view is theamount of money that we are getting under the gainshare. We always get 30% or thereabouts, so it is theamount of money that we get relative to the increasein termination liabilities and the probability of thoseoccurring. That is the value for money assessmentthat takes place under refinancing.
Q64 Mr Dunne: I accept that a great deal of goodwork was done by this Committee before I joined itin encouraging the private sector to share some ofthese gains, but unless you can assess the quantumof the gains, you are in a weak negotiating positionin order to extract maximum value for money.Mr Abadie: The NAO points out in the Report thatit and we are not aware of any transactions where theprivate sector has not told us that it has done arefinancing. Therefore, we are aware of all therefinancings that have taken place. Everyrefinancing has to be signed oV by an AccountingOYcer’s value for money for his or her Department.So, coming back to the value for money equation,every refinancing transaction that has taken placethat we are aware of—and we are aware of all ofthem—has been deemed to be value for moneysomewhere in that process. I do not know if thatanswers your direct question.
Q65 Mr Dunne: It sounds as though you are makingthat assumption without the full set of data on whichto base it.Mr Abadie: Again, I can only refer back to theReport, which says that we are aware of every singlerefinancing that has taken place. We are not awareof any refinancings that have not been advised tobe—
Q66 Mr Dunne: I am seeking to be on your side herebecause I think that this is ultimately likely to reducethe cost to the Government. In theory, the moresources of secondary market capital there are toinvest in PFI projects, the lower the economic cost tothe public purse, so this is a good thing to develop. Ifind it inconceivable, however, that you can sit hereand tell us that you recognise that there is a datashortage and you do not plan to do anything aboutit by changing the terms of the contract.Mr Abadie: I am not saying that we are not going tochange the contract. I think I said that we agree withthe NAO recommendation about collecting furtherdata. We have a process under way with theintention of doing just that, but I emphasise that thatin itself does not impair value for money on the backof a refinancing. That is a separate exercise and aseparate decision.
3639101001 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 7
HM Treasury
Q67 Mr Dunne: Mr Kingman, does the Treasury orthe diVerent Departments underwrite any of the PFIprojects to any degree? Is there any comeback on theGovernment through these contracts?Mr Abadie: I am happy to answer that. Under ourstandard contract, there is no guarantee in thatsense. If a project is terminated, for whateverreason—public sector default, private sector defaultor because we want to do so voluntarily—there isa compensation regime that diVers in diVerentcircumstances. It does not contemplate a guaranteeon underwriting—if I understand the question—butthere may be individual projects when an authoritydecides to go counter to the standard contract and,for reasons unique to its project, may seek to providesome form of underpin or guarantee of either thedebt or the equity in that transaction. We are awareof a couple of those.
Q68 Mr Dunne: Those have been done by localauthorities or by agencies.Mr Abadie: No, there are some central Governmentones. On the London Underground, the debt wasunderwritten to an extent. On Skynet 5, which is aMinistry of Defence satellite project, somethingsimilar was also done. They are not local authorityprojects.
Q69 Mr Dunne: Are those accounted for in adiVerent way from those where there are noGovernment guarantees?Mr Abadie: The accounting may or may not beimpacted by the guarantee, depending on the level ofrisk transfer. That is independently assessed underthe extant accounting rules by the auditors and, ifnecessary, the National Audit OYce. It depends onthe balance of risk.
Q70 Mr Dunne: For each individual project, doesthe Treasury do an assessment of the anticipatedborrowing cost that the project can sustain?Mr Abadie: It is assessed in the round, together withall the other costs. We do not specifically assessborrowing capacity for the project. It is part of thevalue-for-money analysis and when the businesscase has come forward, either to the Department or,if large enough, to the Treasury to sign oV on, weassess the value for money in totality, not just of theborrowing costs.
Q71 Mr Dunne: What credit rating do you apply?Mr Abadie: For a bond project when the project isaccessing the capital markets for those projects, themonoline guarantors require the project to be aninvestment-grade project, which is then creditenhanced by a rating agency. Bank projectsnormally border on investment grade, either slightlyhigher or slightly lower.
Q72 Mr Dunne: Just for my benefit, does investmentgrade mean triple B or greater?Mr Abadie: Triple B minus, or greater. That iscorrect.
Q73 Mr Dunne: What credit rating do theGovernment borrow at?Mr Abadie: Triple A.
Q74 Mr Dunne: Who makes the spread betweenthose two rates? Does it accrue as a return to thefunders, or to the equity share in the PFI scheme?Sorry, does it accrue to the investor in the underlyinginstrument when there is bank borrowing or bonds,or does it accrue to the equity owner of the PFIproject?Mr Abadie: The diVerence between the cost ofGovernment borrowing and the cost of the project,where it is the average cost of capital, accrues to theprivate sector. It is at the heart of the value-for-money analysis that occurs. What you really dothere is to trade oV the cost of finance against therisks that John referred to earlier: the risk ofconstruction being transferred, the risk of operationand the like. If it is deemed that the finance cost—thepremium paid for the private finance—is in excess ofthe risks, as we determine them, that are beingtransferred to the private sector, the project undercurrent guidance should not go forward because it isnot value for money.Mr Kingman: It is worth adding that we require allprojects to undergo a comparison against preciselysuch a public sector comparison.
Q75 Mr Dunne: On average, what is the percentagediVerence in the funding cost for a project that isbeing financed through a PFI vehicle and aGovernment-funded project?Mr Abadie: It depends on the source of funding. Acouple of hospitals have closed during the past yearand from a price point of view, the overall interestcost was about 70 basis points higher than prevailingGovernment gilt rates.
Q76 Mr Dunne: 6%.Mr Abadie: 70 basis points—0.7%.
Q77 Helen Goodman: I would like to begin byasking you about the way in which the code isoperating. If you turn to page 23, it says, “The Codeis voluntary and the private sector has stated thatany changes could damage their commitment to it”.Do you agree with that?Mr Kingman: When the voluntary code wasnegotiated, one of the conditions that was requiredby the private sector was that the code would not berevisited. I think that the private sector had aconcern that the Government would, in a sense, seekto salami slice it. A judgment had to be reachedabout whether to agree to that condition—
Q78 Helen Goodman: But do you not think that thisis a case of “They would say that, wouldn’t they?”?Mr Kingman: Well yes, that is true in anynegotiation. We took a judgment that, since theprivate sector had been very clear about the issuefrom the beginning, we were much better oV with thegains that we had accrued under the code than withnot having the deal.
3639101001 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 8 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
HM Treasury
Q79 Helen Goodman: Somewhere else, theReport—I cannot find the page now—said thatsome refinancings had not gone ahead because thePFIs were too small and the amount of managementtime involved would make them too expensive. Whydid you not have a new code for new PFIs or asliding scale in the old voluntary code?Mr Kingman: I am not certain that I know whetheranyone thought about that at the time. In a sense, wehave two codes: we have a backward-looking codefor—
Q80 Helen Goodman: But they are not related to thesize of the PFI; they are just related to the timing.Would not a sliding scale be a way of overcoming thedisincentive to refinance at one extreme and the verylarge returns accruing to the private sector at theother extreme?Mr Kingman: Possibly. We are where we are with thecode, in the sense that it was negotiated and it is notsomething that can, or should, easily be reopened.
Q81 Helen Goodman: Can I ask you to look at box10 on page 18? It says—this is an NAO point, andI want to know whether you agree—“In our view itwould seem more appropriate in such cases wherethe post refinancing IRR is significantly above thebase case IRR for the full amount of the gain to beshared.” Are you saying that you do not agree withthat point?Mr Abadie: We definitely can see the attraction ofchanging the arrangements, because that wouldclearly give more money to the public sector.However, as John suggested, part of the deal that westruck with the private sector to get it voluntarily tooVer up the 30% was that the code would not bechanged. We stand behind that commitment, andthat is what that sentence is eVectively referring to.
Q82 Helen Goodman: In eVect, you are admittingthat you did not get as good a deal as you might havedone and the public sector is not getting the sharesthat it might have got, but that, having done thedeal, you do not want to go back on you word?Mr Kingman: In a sense, it is always the case in anynegotiation of this kind that one could imaginebetter outcomes. We believe that the code has beensuccessful, and I note that the NAO, in its ownanalysis of the code, describes it as a goodnegotiating achievement. In the discussion that thentook place in this Committee, the OGC wascongratulated by at least one Member of theCommittee, who noted that we did not have much inthe way of negotiating power, which was a faircomment.
Q83 Helen Goodman: I would like to turn to theissue of changing liabilities for the public sectorfollowing a refinancing. Is it not really the case thatit is too soon to tell whether the refinancings oVer thepublic sector value for money?Mr Kingman: Yes, it is too soon to tell in a numberof respects. Many of these are long contracts, and asthe Report quite fairly says, we will need to see howthey work through. If we are in a situation where
liabilities are a big issue, we will need to look at thatdown the track. We are, as you know, cautious in theTreasury about public sector bodies agreeing tohigher termination liabilities. We think that thatconstrains their negotiating freedom, and theyshould think very hard indeed about agreeing tothem.
Q84 Helen Goodman: When you look at this issue,what account do you take of the changing patternsin service delivery?Mr Kingman: Whenever a public sector body entersinto a PFI contract for a school, hospital or prison, itneeds to think very hard about whether it needs thatschool, hospital or prison. When it enters intocommitments with a PFI contractor, it needs to beclear that those are the right commitments to enterinto. Of course, that is true under public sectorprocurement as well: if you are going to build ahospital, you need to think very hard about whetheryou are going to need it.
Q85 Helen Goodman: Yes. This point is made inparagraph 2.14. Hospital provision is an area whereit seems likely to happen. I know that from my ownconstituency. A PFI hospital was opened there fouryears ago, but already the medical practice ischanging and there are proposals on the table toclose wards. Obviously, if you close wards, you arenot getting the money in to pay the PFI charges.Despite that, paragraph 2.5 says:, “Most publicsector departments have chosen to take the gain as alump sum with the exception of the Department ofHealth which has advised NHS trusts to take theirrefinancing gains over time.” Why is that? In the onearea where delivery is changing fast, you areallowing people to behave like that.Mr Kingman: As I said earlier, there are legitimatereasons why a Department may choose to take thesein diVerent form. I do not know whether Richard—
Q86 Helen Goodman: Yes, but what are they? Thatis my question.Mr Abadie: It is probably a question best asked ofthe Department of Health. I shall try to answer as ithas told me in the past: the Department of Healthfeels that its share of the refinancing gain isbest amortised over the forward commitments.You referred to 30 years of commitments; theDepartment of Health’s policy tends to be to rebatethe unitary charge evenly over the life of thecontract, rather than taking the cash up front.
Q87 Helen Goodman: I understand that, and I amasking you, “Why?” Further, I want to knowwhether in allowing the Department of Health tobehave like this, you have talked to your colleagueswho deal with controlling spending on the healthside.Mr Abadie: I cannot answer the latter question.Again, the decision to approve or not approve arefinancing is for the Department and the trustconcerned. As I mentioned to another Member, it isnot a decision that is taken by the Treasury. We do
3639101001 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 9
HM Treasury
not approve the refinancing, so I doubt that ourspending teams would have been involved in thatdecision making process.
Q88 Helen Goodman: Okay, but could I suggestthat you ask the Department to reconsider this in thelight of changing patterns of service provision,please?Mr Abadie: We will do that.
Q89 Helen Goodman: Thank you. I would like toturn to the question of what is happening in theequity market. The Report says that you haveexcluded equity sales from gain sharing, because youare assuming that they are subject to taxation. Doyou think that that is a realistic assumption?Mr Kingman: That is not the main reason why we seethem as rightly excluded from the code. As I said atthe outset, we see equity transactions as verydiVerent from a PFI refinancing. The latter takesplace within the project and it is an importantchange that aVects our rights and interests as apurchaser. A change in the equity ownership of theproject is diVerent: it is outside the project, it doesnot aVect our rights and it happens in any form ofpublic procurement. Companies that sell—
Q90 Helen Goodman: You are saying that it isanalogous to the operation of the gilts market really?Mr Kingman: Well, it would not be the closestanalogy in my mind. The closest analogy would be ifthe Government were to sign a property lease, asthat is very similar to a PFI project. If theGovernment were to lease a property, you wouldexpect us to drive a hard bargain on the lease and todrive a hard bargain if somebody wanted to changethe lease; however, you would not expect us to try tosecure rights over the freehold, which is theequivalent of the equity stake.
Q91 Helen Goodman: Are you saying that you didnot take the decision because you thought that thepublic sector would get its share of the returnsthrough taxation? Are you going back on what youhave obviously agreed with the NAO in writingthis Report?Mr Kingman: Could you point me to the relevantparagraph?Helen Goodman: Sorry, it is page 30, paragraph 3.6.Mr Kingman: The Report quite rightly names arange of reasons. The reason that I am trying todescribe is probably the first bullet point on that list.The tax issue is the third bullet point.
Q92 Helen Goodman: It was highlighted, so Ithought that it was a major consideration.Mr Kingman: I certainly would not describe it as theprincipal reason.
Q93 Helen Goodman: Would you be concerned atall if things were sold on the equity markets orvehicles were set up overseas that were not subject toUK taxation?
Mr Kingman: There are principles aroundtransactions involving oVshore tax havens, forexample. I know that they have come up before theCommittee in relation to the Mapeley transaction.In general, the Treasury always likes to get a shareof tax out of anything that we can, but we are not inthe business of requiring any form of UK publicsector procurement to be done solely through UK-based vehicles, because that would be illegal underEU law.
Q94 Helen Goodman: I can understand that, but itseems that you are opening up a massive loophole.Mr Williams pointed out that whereas you had ashare in debt refinancing, you do not have the samelevel of control here. The situation is even worse ifthings are sold on to overseas vehicles.Mr Kingman: As I said, legally, it simply would notbe possible for the British Government to restrictany form of procurement to UK-based bodies.
Q95 Helen Goodman: Do you have any estimate ofhow many equity holdings are in the hands ofcompanies registered overseas?Mr Kingman: No, I do not. As you know, theTreasury is very restricted in what information it hasaccess to in relation to the aVairs of individualtaxpayers or taxpaying companies.
Q96 Helen Goodman: So at the moment, we do notknow the potential loss or gain?Mr Kingman: Correct.
Q97 Mr Khan: Mr Kingman, isn’t the PAC being abit unfair to you by moving the goalposts? Thereason behind PFIs, as I understand it, is to harnessprivate sector management expertise in the deliveryof public services and not to have a detrimentalimpact on public borrowing. PFIs are doing sosuccessfully. You would say that one could use twocriteria to assess how wonderfully successful boththe PFI projects and refinancing have been: first,projects are finishing well on time—I think that youused a figure of 90%—and secondly, most areunder budget.Mr Kingman: I would agree that that is the principalway that we judge the success of the policy, but Ithink that the work done with the NAO and the PACover time has been—
Q98 Mr Khan: You have already sucked up to me.That is fine—the PAC is wonderful—but we arebeing slightly unfair. We are moving the goalposts.Mr Kingman: I do not think that it is for me to makethat comment.
Q99 Mr Khan: Some would argue—it is not quite athird fiscal rule—that we have a third PAC rule. Asyou said, the first two rules are to be on time andunder budget. The third rule that we have imposedon you is to share the proceeds of refinancing withthe taxpayer.Mr Kingman: I think that it is right when refinancinghas taken place that we should seek to secure a gooddeal for the taxpayer from it.
3639101001 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 10 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
HM Treasury
Q100 Mr Khan: Right. You accept the moving ofthe goalposts, so that we now require you to sharethe proceeds of refinancing with the taxpayer. Doyou accept that that is a noble and right thing to do?Mr Kingman: I do not know that I myself woulddescribe it as moving the goalposts, but—
Q101 Mr Khan: You are happy with it. Fine. Doyou think that it is moving the goalposts if we saythat you should share the proceeds of equity with thetaxpayer?Mr Kingman: I think that that would be a verydiVerent thing, yes, for the reasons that I have given.Equity transactions are a diVerent variety oftransaction, which does not aVect the public sector’srights in the same way.
Q102 Mr Khan: Let us come to that in a second.What is quite clear is that investors, whether they arein refinancing or on the equity side of things, aremaking huge sums of money from PFI projects. Doyou accept that?Mr Kingman: There have been some projects whereinvestors have made significant sums of money, andother projects where a great deal of money hasbeen lost.
Q103 Mr Khan: Could that mean that the originaldeals were not priced properly at the outset?Mr Kingman: It might mean, with the benefit ofhindsight, that they could have been priced better,but they were priced on the terms available at thetime. The real test should be whether they were gooddeals. Were the projects good, were they deliveredon time and so on?
Q104 Mr Khan: Right. In those examples wherethey may have been priced a bit too generously, doyou accept that people in the equity markets havemade huge sums of money because of it?Mr Kingman: I accept that there is the potential formoney to be made in PFI, either from projects orfrom selling on the projects at a profit or a loss. Thatcan happen in any market.
Q105 Mr Khan: So why not agree to move thegoalposts in the equity situation, as you have agreedto do vis-a-vis refinancing?Mr Kingman: Because it is a diVerent variety oftransaction. For reasons that I have attempted togive, one aVects and changes the public sector’sinterest and exposes the public sector to liabilities,and we need to consider that and get a benefit out ofit; the other does not.
Q106 Mr Khan: Do you accept that there aresimilarities with, for example, the impact thatsecondary investors may have on the management ofPFI projects?Mr Abadie: It may impact. In one of my earlierresponses, I referred to potential eYciencies that theportfolio investors may bring to bear on the projects,which may have an impact.
Q107 Mr Khan: That is a positive impact?Mr Abadie: A positive impact, yes, but I want toclarify and add to what John has said. Who theinvestor is does not aVect the underlying contracts—Government contracts with a special purposecompany. That is who we contract with; we do notcontract directly with investors, so if the investorschange, the underlying contract does not change.
Q108 Mr Khan: Sure. So let us be clear: yourposition is that the Committee’s obsession withmaking sure that the taxpayer is not dealt withunfairly is unnecessary, because projects arefinishing on time, or perhaps ahead of time, andunder budget? Is that fair?Mr Abadie: It clearly does not stop there: theobjective of PFI goes beyond just the build phase; itgoes right through the life of the contract.
Q109 Mr Khan: Do you have idea of the financialrewards that those who invest in the equities marketare making in share sales and stuV?Mr Abadie: We do.
Q110 Mr Khan: You do? What sort of sums are wetalking about?Mr Abadie: I can quote publicly availableinformation, which is easily available on the publicwebsites of some plcs. Carillion, which is one of theinvestors, probably owns about 20 PFI projects. Itsold some of its investments quite recently tosecondary market investors, and the proceeds that itreceived were about £46 million. The cost of theinvestment that it reported was about £24 million.
Q111 Mr Khan: Over what period is that?Mr Abadie: It is a portfolio, so the individual assetsin that underlying—
Q112 Mr Khan: What period are we talking about?Mr Abadie: Again, it depends on the underlyingassets.
Q113 Mr Khan: We are not talking 30 years, are we?Mr Abadie: No, clearly not. It is worth adding thatwhen investors enter these projects in the beginning,they do not expect to own the assets for 30 years. IfI look back over policy, going back 10 years to thedays of the private finance panels, that was quiteopenly spoken about.
Q114 Mr Khan: That is what concerns me. I am nota PFI expert, unlike many others of the Committee,but I read somewhere in the Report that that thereason why we should not feel that we have beenripped oV as taxpayers in relation to refinancing isthat terms and conditions have improved as theadvantages of reduced risk trickle down as a resultof the more mature PFI market. Yes?Mr Abadie: Yes.
Q115 Mr Khan: And so taxpayers are appeasedbecause that is the reason why huge profits are beingmade. Because we were inept and did not negotiate a
3639101001 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 11
HM Treasury
gain supplement, we have had a voluntary code andhave got 30%, if we are lucky, and 50% after 2002.Yes?Mr Abadie: Correct.
Q116 Mr Khan: I am unclear, however, about thejustification that you are giving for yet further profitsbeing made by the equity markets. How can youexplain this double profit that is now being made bythe equity markets? You have explained therefinancing profits, and we have alleviated some ofthe pain that taxpayers are feeling as a result of beingshort-changed in the original negotiation, but howdo you explain the second tranche of profits beingmade by equity?Mr Kingman: I just want to make a generalobservation before Richard comments. The fact—
Q117 Mr Khan: Mr Kingman, I only have 10minutes, and seven minutes are up, so please dealfirst with my specific question, and then you canmake your general point in the Chairman’s time.Mr Abadie: When the investors went into theseprojects initially—Mr Khan: I am sorry, but I really cannot hear you.Mr Abadie: Sorry, it must be my voice—I am losingmy voice here. When the investors went into theseprojects initially, they had certain expectations ofwhat type of returns they could possibly make on theback of their investments. Those would haveincluded an assumption about the amount that theycould make out of refinancing, which is clearly asource of revenue, and, as an ancillary, what theycould potentially make by selling on theirinvestments. Those things are not mutuallyexclusive.
Q118 Mr Khan: So they foresaw, when they firstnegotiated these deals, that they would make twotranches of profit: first during refinancing and thenby selling shares?Mr Abadie: If the asset was performing. As Johnsaid, some people have lost all their money—
Q119 Mr Khan: But, Mr Abadie, if they couldforesee that, why could not we foresee it and write itinto the contract to ensure that we would get theproceeds of the refinancing or of the equity? I do notunderstand.Mr Kingman: It depends entirely on whether theproject is successful. If it is successful it is possible tomake money, but if it is unsuccessful it is possible tolose money.
Q120 Mr Khan: I am not asking you to takeproceeds from those who lose money; I am askingwhy we could not get a better deal for when hugeprofits are made.Mr Kingman: If you are suggesting that we shouldtake equity stakes in PFI projects, I think that thatwould be a very big step for the Government to take.We would essentially be saying, “Not only do wewant to buy a prison or hospital, we also we want totake a stake in the commercial success or otherwise
of that venture.” I think that the PAC would be thefirst to challenge us on the value for money ofdoing that.
Q121 Mr Khan: You are saying that one of theincentives that private investors have is the hugeprofits that they may make—obviously some willnot be successful—on two things: refinancing andselling shares?Mr Kingman: They can make money in a number offorms, yes.
Q122 Mr Khan: So why are you not saying moreloudly and clearly, “Look, PAC, calm down. Youguys have got your knickers in a twist aboutsomething that we always expected to happen.”?Mr Kingman: I am not sure that it is for us to tell thePAC to calm down or otherwise—
Q123 Mr Khan: Let me tell you why. I am surprisedby the timidity of your answers to the Chairman’sassertions of negligence/incompetence and of yourfailure to negotiate proper proceeds to the taxpayerand your reliance on the voluntary code. The codeclearly is not working, is it?Mr Kingman: On the contrary, the evidence issupportive. The NAO says that the code is generallyworking.
Q124 Mr Khan: What was the prediction? Howmuch money should we have got by now from thevoluntary code?Mr Kingman: I do not understand your question:how much money should we have got? 30% is whatwe should have got and 30% is what we have got.
Q125 Mr Khan: There is no shortage in the figures?Mr Kingman: No.
Q126 Mr Khan: I thought that there was a £93million figure versus £200 million.Mr Kingman: That was an estimate.
Q127 Mr Khan: Oh, it was an estimate. So it isokay?Mr Kingman: It was not a target.Mr Khan: Oh, I beg your pardon.Mr Kingman: I think it would be quite wrong for itto be a target.
Q128 Mr Khan: Mr Kingman, have you read theReport?Mr Kingman: Yes.
Q129 Mr Khan: I think that my time is almost up. Icannot see either targets or estimates defined in theglossary at the back of the Report. I hope that for thenext report you will talk to the NAO and make surethat I can understand the diVerence between anestimate and a target. When I see an estimate forthose sorts of savings and they are not made, I amquite disappointed by it. I am paraphrasing, but youare saying, “Look, it wasn’t a target, so it’s okay.”
3639101001 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 12 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
HM Treasury
Mr Kingman: I am saying that it was an estimategiven in good faith of what Peter Gershon predictedwould be the outcome. However, it was clear at thattime that there were enormous uncertainties and hewas clear about that.
Q130 Mr Khan: May I ask you about the oVshoretax shelters that we are told in paragraph 3.6 someof these companies use to avoid paying tax whenthey sell their PFI shares? Should we be concernedabout that?Mr Kingman: I am not sure that that is whatparagraph 3.6 says.
Q131 Mr Khan: Should we be concerned about theoVshore tax shelters?Mr Kingman: I am not sure whether—
Q132 Mr Khan: Are investors taking advantage ofthem?Mr Kingman: I do not know. As I said earlier, thereare very tight constraints on what the Treasury canknow about the aVairs of individual taxpayers.
Q133 Mr Khan: One way in which we can reap someof the proceeds of the sale of shares is byrevenue—yes?Mr Kingman: Tax revenue, yes.
Q134 Mr Khan: Are you surprised that I amextremely surprised that you have no idea whethersome of these investors are using tax shelters toreduce the amount of tax they pay?Mr Kingman: I do not know whether to be surprisedthat you are surprised. What I am saying is that thereare very tight constraints on what the Treasury canknow about the aVairs of individual taxpayers.Mr Khan: I am afraid that my time is up.
Q135 Chairman: Would you be surprised to knowthat when I started asking for shares andrefinancing, the Treasury told me that it wouldfrighten away investors? Is not that what you aresaying about this second proposition from theComptroller and Auditor General?Mr Kingman: All I can say, Chairman, is that Ibelieve that these are diVerent kinds of things andthat it would be a very big step to move into thatspace.
Q136 Mr Bacon: I shall start with the NAOquestion, if I may. Sir John, thanks to Mr Williams,in the first instance, we have been looking at PFIrefinancings for some time now. I follow on from MrKhan’s question about paragraph 3.6, which saysthat equity sales from selling shares would“potentially” be subject to taxation, thus implyingthat they might not be. Is what you are suggesting inthe Report roughly this: now that there is avoluntary code and now that companies whorefinance are subject to that voluntary code and willshare their refinancing gains 70:30 with thetaxpayer—the public sector—there is an extraincentive, which may not previously have existed,for companies, in order to get all the gain, rather
than to have to share some of it with the publicsector, to leave the uncrystallised refinancing gaininside the project and sell the equity in the project tosomebody else, and in so doing, sell it through a tax-eYcient vehicle overseas so that they can keep,eVectively, all the gain? If you like, there is anincentive to shift away from initial refinancingstowards equity sales. Is that what you are basicallysaying?Sir John Bourn: Certainly that might be a possibilityand what a company might seek to do, but if youtake, as it were, the gain by selling shares, you takeit from somebody else rather than from the taxpayer.Somebody else then, in a sense, is financing yourgain, and having bought the shares, he will hope tomake some gain or create some advantage,otherwise he would not do it. On the question oftaxation arrangements, it applies to commercialarrangements generally. Companies, in whateverline of business, will think about their taxationposition and try to arrange to be taxed in onejurisdiction or another in accordance with theestimates that they make about the advantage tothem—whether it is a PFI proposition or a generalcommercial proposition.
Q137 Mr Bacon: Mr Kingman, I think you werequoting a Member of the Committee, although I amnot sure whom, when you said: “We didn’t havemuch in the way of negotiating power.” Will you saywhy you or the authorities concerned did not?Mr Kingman: Simply because we had no contractualrights to any of the gains.
Q138 Mr Bacon: That is what I thought. Elsewhere,you said that there was no entitlement to any ofthese gains.Mr Kingman: Yes, correct.
Q139 Mr Bacon: But elsewhere you said that theprivate sector was already very highly incentivised togo after those gains, and earlier you said, “We thinkit is correct that major value for money issues canarise.” If the private sector is already highlyincentivised to go after the gains and we think itcorrect that major value for money issues can arise,why were not provisions included initially in thecontracts to ensure that there was a right to a shareof the refinancing gain?Mr Kingman: Clearly, it would have been better ifthey had.
Q140 Mr Bacon: Why were they not?Mr Kingman: I am afraid that I am not in a positionto answer.
Q141 Mr Bacon: Can I tell you the answer? It isbecause the Treasury forbade it, is it not? TheTreasury issued guidance forbidding the inclusion ofrefinancing clauses, did it not?Mr Kingman: I am afraid that I do not know whetherthe answer is yes or no.
3639101001 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 13
HM Treasury
Mr Bacon: Mr Abadie?Mr Abadie: I understand that to be correct.
Q142 Mr Bacon: Could you send us a copy of thatguidance please?Mr Abadie: We will do so.
Q143 Mr Bacon: You are aware, are you not, thatthe Department of Health, acting as I understand iton Treasury guidance, forbade the Norfolk andNorwich hospital from including a refinancingclause in its contract, although it would very muchliked to have done so? I know that because it is onthe borders of my constituency and the ChiefExecutive and the Finance Director told me thatthey would have loved to have had a refinancingclause at the outset, but they could not, could they?Mr Abadie: I am not aware of that particular point,but I understand your point about the wider policy.
Q144 Mr Bacon: They could not do it because theywere forbidden from doing it by the Department ofHealth and the Treasury. Is not that the case?Mr Abadie: I do not know the answer to Norfolkand Norwich.
Q145 Mr Bacon: But generally speaking, it iscorrect that Treasury guidance prohibited theinclusion of refinancing clauses early on?Mr Abadie: That is correct. The position of theTreasury at the time was that to encourage entrantsinto the market—both debt and equity—we wouldnot include refinancing or gain-share clauses in that,as was customary on similar programmes.
Q146 Mr Bacon: I would just like to get a copy ofthe guidance; it would be very helpful to get itpublished in our Report.3 You mentioned earlierthat you have collected a lot of information,although the information on the older projects ismore out of date, and that one must look in a coupleof diVerent places—on the Partnerships UK websiteand, I think, on the Treasury’s own website. Howmany PFI projects are there all together?Mr Abadie: There are just over 750 projects. I wantto clarify something that you said, however: the dataare all available on the Partnerships UK website topublic authorities; we have a slimmed-down versionof that on our public website.
Q147 Mr Bacon: Of those 750, how many are on-balance-sheet projects and how many are oV-balance-sheet projects?Mr Abadie: I am not sure of the numbers. There is adetailed reconciliation and we can provide it to theCommittee, if you would like. It depends on theconstruction stage of the project. If a project is underconstruction it scores against the public sectorbalance sheet when it starts operations. Even thoughthere are 750 signed deals, one cannot just make acut as to which are on and which are oV, because itdepends on the stage in the construction period.
3 http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/documents/public–private–partberships/ppp–guidance–index.cfm
Q148 Mr Bacon: Two particular pieces ofinformation interest me. First, out of the 750 deals,what is the current situation—which are on andwhich are oV balance sheet? Secondly, how much byvalue is on and oV balance sheet? Can you providethat information?4
Mr Abadie: We can.
Q149 Mr Bacon: What is the total value of the 750deals at the moment?Mr Abadie: Just over approximately £50 billion.The reason I am slightly cautious is that onebig transaction—the Committee has consideredit previously—is that relating to LondonUnderground. That counts for £16 billion to £17billion of the total. However, the way the transactionworks means that there is approximately £1 billion ayear of asset spending over 15 years, which is howthat number arises.
Q150 Mr Bacon: Okay. It would be helpful if youcould send us a detailed note containing a list withthe number of projects, details of those that are onbalance sheet and those that are oV balance sheet,and the value of those that are on and oV balancesheet.5 When you said £50 billion, what did youmean? Did you mean the net present value or thecumulative value of the annual unitary payments,or what?Mr Abadie: No. That number is the capital value ofthe projects, which means diVerent things todiVerent people. In eVect it is the initial build cost.
Q151 Mr Bacon: Right. So let us take an examplethat is close to home: the first Treasury building—Exchequer partnership No 1. Do you know theinitial build cost of that?Mr Abadie: Approximately £140 million.
Q152 Mr Bacon: No, that was the value of the bond.The construction cost was £118 million. So whenyou mention the £50 billion, you mean a number foreach project that is analogous to the comparison of£140 million and £118 million in the case of theTreasury project.Mr Abadie: No, when I refer to the £50 billion Imean the capitalised cost over the constructionperiod, which includes interest during construction,inflation and a couple of other things.
Q153 Mr Bacon: I would like you to send us anothernote. Taking the Exchequer partnership number 1example again, the annual unitary payment is£14,037,000, is it not?Mr Abadie: I do not know.
Q154 Mr Bacon: That is indexed each year, so it hasprobably increased slightly since I obtained theinformation by way of a parliamentary question. Itis about £14 million per year. If you multiply £14million by the number of years of the contract, whichfrom memory is 35, one gets £838 million. Can yousend us a note with the same sum for each project,
4 Ev 15–175 Ev 15–17
3639101001 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 14 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
HM Treasury
so that we can get the total amount of payments—inother words, the annual unitary charges multipliedby the total number of years, for all the projects?Mr Abadie: We can do that.
Q155 Mr Bacon: It would be a lot higher than £50billion, would it not?Mr Abadie: Definitely. It is publicly availablealready.
Q156 Mr Bacon: Yes, but it would be nice to have itin one place.Mr Abadie: It is in one place. It is in the Pre-Budget Report.
Q157 Mr Bacon: I would quite like it in our Report.When you send the note on the 750 projects, couldyou attach a column with those figures—the capitalcost, and the cost in terms of the annual unitarycharge multiplied by the number of years?6
Mr Abadie: We can do that by year. As I said, it ispublicly available information.
Q158 Mr Bacon: Yes, but I would like you to sendit to us, if you could.Mr Kingman: We will want to be sure that anythingwe send is meaningful in today’s money.
Q159 Mr Bacon: I am interested in the cash. If youwant to put in extra stuV too, please do. You maywant to explain why certain information would notby itself be meaningful, as you put it, but I shouldlike the raw number—how much cash is going outthe door—the “COTD”, if you like. Mr Abadie, youwork for PricewaterhouseCoopers, do you not?Mr Abadie: I do.
Q160 Mr Bacon: How long have you been secondedto the Treasury?Mr Abadie: I have been in the Treasury since thebeginning of November 2004.
Q161 Mr Bacon: So you have been there just twoyears. How much longer are you expecting to stay?Mr Abadie: John?Mr Kingman: Richard will shortly be leaving us andreturning to PricewaterhouseCoopers. I should saythat, from our point of view, having someone withhis expertise is vital in ensuring that we can run aprofessional policy operation.
Q162 Mr Bacon: Your job is head of PFI policy.Mr Abadie: That is correct.
Q163 Mr Bacon: It strikes me as interesting that theTreasury, for something so important, had to gooutside on a temporary, seconded basis to findsomeone to drive such a significant policy.Mr Kingman: I would not see that as a sort of secondbest. On the contrary, I would see it as a much betterarrangement from our point of view. This is a verytechnical area, and I think the Committee would bethe first to tell us that we do not want to be
6 Ev 15–17
hoodwinked by the private sector. I think it isabsolutely essential that we have in the Treasury, aswe had for a number of years in a number ofRichard’s predecessors, senior people from theprivate sector to help us with developments.
Q164 Mr Bacon: I am running out of time, but Iwould just like to ask you a question about thesecondary market. You drew a distinction betweenrefinancing on one hand, which you called animportant change, and changes in the ownership ofthe equity on the other, which you said did not aVectyour rights. Plainly, if you sell a company with aseries of rights, those rights are then held by the newowner. Are you saying, therefore, that you have nointerest in who the owners of these companies are?Mr Kingman: No, I am not saying that. I am sayingthat for us to have good grounds and for it to besensible value for money, clawing back gains needsto be in relation to some change in our contractualposition and our rights as a purchaser.
Q165 Mr Bacon: But you have no control over howfrequently these companies are bought and sold,do you?Mr Kingman: No.
Q166 Mr Bacon: Yet, as we know from the highlydeveloped capital market for companies, who ownsa company can be a hugely significant fact in termsof how well it performs. When companies merge andare taken over, sometimes they do very well as aresult, and sometimes they do very poorly as a directresult of the change of ownership, so ownership hasa big potential impact on the delivery of service, doesit not?Mr Kingman: I am not sure that we would see PFI asdiVerent from any other form of procurement. If webuy computers from IBM, that does not give usrights over who owns IBM.
Q167 Mr Bacon: Yes, but buying a service andbuying a computer are not the same thing. Buyingmanagement services, buying intellectual servicesand buying commodities are not the same. You arenot trying to suggest that buying a series of services,which is essentially what PFI is about, is like buyinga commodity, are you?Mr Kingman: No, but I think the same principleswould apply for anyone we were buying servicesfrom. If we buy services from a large consulting firm,we have no rights over who owns the consulting firm.
Q168 Mr Bacon: No. So you are quite content thatthe secondary market should develop and grow andthat there should be large portfolios of PFIcompanies oVering services to schools and hospitals,and that you will not necessarily know who theunderlying owners are.Mr Kingman: It may well be sensible for the publicsector purchasers to know who their investors are.We clearly need to have a good picture in theTreasury of what the market is like and what thebroad position is like, but, yes, we are content withthe situation you described.
3639101001 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 15
HM Treasury
Mr Bacon: Thank you.
Q169 Chairman: You have been calling the tune asfar as the other Departments are concerned in termsof the approach to PFI, yet the Treasury is singularlyreluctant to send witnesses to Select Committees,other than to the Treasury Committee. Do you thinkit is right that when you have a cross-Governmentrole, the Treasury is rather reticent about appearingto defend its position? For example, there werecomplaints in relation to the hearings on the tubeprojects.Mr Kingman: I am afraid that I am not sure that Iam an authority on our position on representationsat other hearings.
Q170 Chairman: What has come over today is thatthe Treasury calls the tune. The others are allowedto play to the hymn sheet—that is a rough analogy—but essentially you are the people who state theground rules. Yet when Select Committees wantevidence of the thinking behind the ground rules, itis sometimes diYcult for them to get the Treasury toprovide witnesses to individual departmental SelectCommittees. Can you at least concede that thatpresents certain diYculties?Mr Kingman: I am afraid that I am simply not awareof the position in relation to other Committees.
Q171 Chairman: Okay.Mr Abadie, at some stage in the near future, you
are going to return to the private sector, and Inoted the warmth of the reception by yourcolleague, who is reluctant to see you go. If youwere about to leave, what would you advise us to
do diVerently from what we are doing now? Isuspect that this will lead to you leaving rathermore suddenly.Mr Abadie: Or not going back to the private sector,as the case may be. In overseeing Treasury policy,pretty much all our forward-looking policy agendawas captured in a March Treasury policydocument, published alongside the Budget, entitledStrengthening Long-Term Partnerships. Thatdocument describes chapter and verse our forward-looking policy agenda. Although that might havebeen a hypothetical question, that documentencapsulates what the Treasury will be looking atin the future, beyond me and John. We mention inthe document a couple of areas—I do not know ifthe Committee wants to go through them—that wehave decided to look at more closely. Since thatdocument in March, we have published a couple ofguidance notes on value for money, benchmarkingand market testing. We are looking at design in PFIand, as I said, the document covers many areassuch as reform of the procurement process.
Q172 Chairman: Has the NAO had theopportunity to consider the implications, perhapson the work of this Committee, of the Marchdocument? Would anything in it changesubstantially the way in which the Committee looksat PFI cases? It does not matter if you cannot givean immediate answer. You can write if you wish.Sir John Bourn: Certainly.Chairman: Gentlemen, you will gather that therehas been a degree of gentle scepticism throughoutthis hearing, which I suspect will be reflected in theReport, but thank you very much for trying toreply openly.
3639101002 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 16 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Supplementary memorandum submitted by HM Treasury
Questions 148, 150 & 150 (Mr Richard Bacon)
As noted during the PAC hearing, the Treasury is updating data on all PFI projects. This exercise iscarried out by the Treasury biannually in line with publication of data in the Pre-Budget and BudgetReports. Data on accounting treatment, unitary charges and capital value for individual projects should,subject to departmental verification, become available by around March. The Treasury will provide thePAC with this information when it is available. Because of restrictions arising from commercialconfidentiality, the information provided will be all that is available for publication. The table belowprovides a disaggregation of the capital value of projects, as well as the sum of unitary charges, bydepartment based on the Treasury’s most recent estimates.
— The capital value data is available publicly on the HMT PPP website: http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/documents/public private partnerships/ppp pfi stats.cfm
— The table on unitary charges provides the latest update on data published in the Budget Reportand Pre-Budget Report on a yearly aggregate basis.
PFCI signed projects list, total capital value by Department
Department Total Capital Value(£bn)
DCLG 1.4DCMS 0.23DEFRA 0.94DfES 4.57DfT 22.13Health 8.67LCD 0.37Chancellor’s Departments 0.82Home OYce 1.22MoD 5.99Devolved Administrations 6.22Other Departments* 1.96Total 54.55
* Other departments are CO, DTI, DWP, FCO.
Note, the PFI signed deals list records capital values not the debt amount likely to arise therefrom. Forthose projects judged to be on-balance sheet, the debt only scores when the asset completes construction.For example, London Underground Limited (LUL) is shown on the signed deals list to have a capital valueof £17 billion, however this is only spent and comes onto the public sector’s balance sheet over a 15 yearperiod.
3639101002 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 17
DE
PA
RT
ME
NT
EST
IMA
TE
DU
NIT
AR
YE
STIM
AT
ED
UN
ITA
RY
EST
IMA
TE
DU
NIT
AR
YE
STIM
AT
ED
UN
ITA
RY
EST
IMA
TE
DU
NIT
AR
YE
STIM
AT
ED
UN
ITA
RY
EST
IMA
TE
DU
NIT
AR
YE
STIM
AT
ED
UN
ITA
RY
EST
IMA
TE
DU
NIT
AR
YE
STIM
AT
ED
UN
ITA
RY
EST
IMA
TE
DU
NIT
AR
YE
STIM
AT
ED
UN
ITA
RY
EST
IMA
TE
DU
NIT
AR
YC
HA
RG
EP
AY
ME
NT
2006
-07
CH
AR
GE
PA
YM
EN
T20
07-0
8C
HA
RG
EP
AY
ME
NT
2008
-09
CH
AR
GE
PA
YM
EN
T20
09-1
0C
HA
RG
EP
AY
ME
NT
2010
-11
CH
AR
GE
PA
YM
EN
T20
11-1
2C
HA
RG
EP
AY
ME
NT
2012
-13
CH
AR
GE
PA
YM
EN
T20
13-1
4C
HA
RG
EP
AY
ME
NT
2014
-15
CH
AR
GE
PA
YM
EN
T20
15-1
6C
HA
RG
EP
AY
ME
NT
2016
-17
CH
AR
GE
PA
YM
EN
T20
17-1
8C
HA
RG
EP
AY
ME
NT
2018
-19
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)D
CL
G11
713
213
713
113
013
013
213
513
613
913
914
214
4D
CM
S12
1920
2020
2021
2121
2122
2222
DE
FR
A18
220
622
123
324
526
227
728
529
329
330
231
132
0D
fES
326
391
409
409
405
406
406
408
412
419
423
430
434
DfT
1874
1967
2042
2237
2384
2517
2535
2562
2541
2530
2495
1807
520
Hea
lth
621
731
885
1001
1073
1099
1127
1251
1283
1315
1347
1381
1416
LC
D96
2728
2929
3031
3132
3334
3535
Cha
ncel
lor’
sD
epar
tmen
ts37
236
336
737
337
938
638
738
939
333
934
835
636
5H
ome
OY
ce49
050
549
849
750
743
442
939
339
540
541
442
443
3M
OD
1150
1191
1247
1235
1252
1151
1138
1158
1156
1176
1140
926
929
Dev
olve
dA
dmin
istr
atio
ns59
365
172
676
380
377
378
379
180
783
284
085
886
8O
ther
Dep
artm
ents
*72
671
171
273
074
968
670
372
073
875
677
478
00
DE
PA
RT
ME
NT
EST
IMA
TE
DU
NIT
AR
YE
STIM
AT
ED
UN
ITA
RY
EST
IMA
TE
DU
NIT
AR
YE
STIM
AT
ED
UN
ITA
RY
EST
IMA
TE
DU
NIT
AR
YE
STIM
AT
ED
UN
ITA
RY
EST
IMA
TE
DU
NIT
AR
YE
STIM
AT
ED
UN
ITA
RY
EST
IMA
TE
DU
NIT
AR
YE
STIM
AT
ED
UN
ITA
RY
EST
IMA
TE
DU
NIT
AR
YE
STIM
AT
ED
UN
ITA
RY
EST
IMA
TE
DU
NIT
AR
YC
HA
RG
EP
AY
ME
NT
2019
-20
CH
AR
GE
PA
YM
EN
T20
20-2
1C
HA
RG
EP
AY
ME
NT
2021
-22
CH
AR
GE
PA
YM
EN
T20
22-2
3C
HA
RG
EP
AY
ME
NT
2023
-24
CH
AR
GE
PA
YM
EN
T20
24-2
5C
HA
RG
EP
AY
ME
NT
2025
-26
CH
AR
GE
PA
YM
EN
T20
26-2
7C
HA
RG
EP
AY
ME
NT
2027
-28
CH
AR
GE
PA
YM
EN
T20
28-2
9C
HA
RG
EP
AY
ME
NT
2029
-30
CH
AR
GE
PA
YM
EN
T20
30-3
1C
HA
RG
EP
AY
ME
NT
2031
-32
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)D
CL
G14
412
811
913
091
9293
8783
7972
6955
DC
MS
2223
2323
2424
2425
2524
2321
16D
EF
RA
329
339
348
358
339
271
219
224
204
7143
4444
DfE
S43
844
344
845
144
043
241
940
138
635
933
430
225
8D
fT51
854
848
249
049
253
653
337
125
820
814
912
011
3H
ealt
h14
5114
8715
2415
6216
0116
4116
8216
9117
3317
7617
8618
3117
71L
CD
3637
3839
4041
4233
2929
13C
hanc
ello
r’s
Dep
artm
ents
375
384
108
107
9998
8081
7976
7067
69H
ome
OY
ce43
444
345
435
335
933
330
724
724
817
698
782
MO
D95
290
590
489
490
284
687
084
784
378
369
061
659
0D
evol
ved
Adm
inis
trat
ions
876
887
877
874
882
880
860
821
777
731
658
525
433
Oth
erD
epar
tmen
ts*
00
00
00
00
00
00
0
3639101004 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 18 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Question 150 (Mr Richard Bacon): Data on individual PFI projects covering: unitary charge payments, totalcapital values and balance sheet treatment
The data is current, having been updated for the Budget. We will be updating the HM Treasury onlinesigned deals list to reflect this data. It has been produced as part of an extensive reconciliation exercise thathas been conducted to establish the current operational portfolio of PFI projects. The data has been sourceddirectly from returns from over 20 diVerent public sector bodies, many of which have in turn compiled theirreturns from a much greater number of public sector organisations. As such it has been a detailed andresource intensive-exercise covering more than 500 projects that have been signed over 15 years.
Differences Between PAC Return and Signed Deals List
The current signed deals list on the Treasury website is an historical record of all PFI projects that havesigned. It has been added to over time as new deals have signed. However, this is the first time an overallreconciliation exercise has been conducted for these figures to establish the current operational portfolio ofPFI projects. This will allow us to revise and update the signed deal list, since:
— some projects have concluded or been terminated;
— some projects have contractual structures that means they are no longer classed as PFI; and
— some projects have been contractually merged.
In addition there are some new projects which have been signed since the last signed deals list waspublished in December 2006.
Non-provision of Data
Data on unitary charge payments for Scottish PFI projects has not been provided at the request of theScottish Executive. The Scottish Executive has stated to us that the PAC’s responsibilities do not coverScottish PFI/PPP and they believe it is not appropriate for them to provide unitary charge data.
Transport for London have asked that, due to the commercially sensitive nature of a number of theirongoing negotiations, unitary charge payments are not released into the public domain.
Smaller Projects
There are also two projects for where unitary charge payments have not been provided to the Treasuryby Departments. For clarity, these projects are marked on the attached data return. We are still seeking toobtain this data and will update the PAC with progress on this final reconciliation shortly.
Indexation
For 24 projects, Departments have not indexed the unitary charge payments with an inflation assumption.In these cases we have factored in a generic indexation approach, indexing 40% of the unitary charge(an assumption designed to cover the proportion of the project cost aVected by inflation) at 2.75%(RPI at the inflation target level ie equivalent to 2% CPI). This is consistent with the terms we would expectto be used in projects across all sectors of the PFI market. For clarity, these projects are marked on attacheddata return. Again, we are seeking to track the exact indexations for these projects with Departments andwill update the PAC on this shortly.
3639101004 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 19
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
Tot
alch
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
geca
pita
lB
alan
cepa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tva
lue
shee
t19
92–9
319
93–9
419
94–9
519
95–9
619
96–9
719
97–9
819
98–9
919
99–0
020
00–0
120
01–0
220
02–0
320
03–0
420
04–0
520
05–0
6D
epar
tmen
tC
omm
issi
onin
gbo
dyP
roje
ctna
me
(£m
illio
ns)
trea
tmen
t(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)
Hea
lth
Dar
tfor
dan
dG
rave
sham
Hos
pita
lNH
ST
rust
94.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
—11
.03
20.2
820
.47
19.0
619
.54
20.0
2H
ealt
hN
orth
Cum
bria
Acu
teH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
66.7
0O
V—
——
——
——
—12
.40
12.7
113
.03
13.3
513
.69
14.7
7H
ealt
hB
ucki
ngha
msh
ire
Hos
pita
lsN
HS
Tru
st45
.10
On
——
——
——
——
10.0
410
.29
10.5
510
.81
11.0
811
.36
Hea
lth
Nor
folk
and
Nor
wic
hH
ealt
hC
are
NH
ST
rust
158.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
27.0
938
.70
39.6
740
.66
41.6
8H
ealt
hC
ount
yD
urha
m&
Dar
lingt
onA
cute
Hos
pita
lsN
HS
61.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
11.8
012
.26
12.5
612
.88
13.2
0T
rust
Hea
lth
Sout
hM
anch
este
rU
nive
rsit
yH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
66.7
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
7.64
18.9
919
.46
19.9
521
.70
Hea
lth
Que
enE
lizab
eth
Hos
pita
lNH
ST
rust
96.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
—18
.19
18.6
519
.11
19.5
920
.08
20.5
8H
ealt
hC
alde
rdal
ean
dH
udde
rsfie
ldN
HS
Tru
st64
.60
OV
——
——
——
——
—16
.64
17.0
617
.49
17.9
218
.37
Hea
lth
Bro
mle
yH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
117.
90O
n—
——
——
——
——
—5.
8018
.69
19.1
519
.63
Hea
lth
Que
enM
ary’
sH
ospi
talS
idcu
pN
HS
Tru
st15
.00
On
——
——
——
——
1.80
1.85
1.89
1.94
1.99
2.04
Hea
lth
Bar
net
and
Cha
seF
arm
Hos
pita
lsN
HS
Tru
st54
.30
On
——
——
——
——
—19
.69
20.1
819
.86
19.7
615
.08
Hea
lth
Wor
cest
ersh
ire
Acu
teH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
86.6
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
17.8
418
.28
18.7
422
.28
22.8
4H
ealt
hH
eref
ord
Hos
pita
lsN
HS
Tru
st64
.10
OV
——
——
——
——
—10
.56
10.8
211
.09
11.3
711
.65
Hea
lth
Not
ting
ham
Uni
vers
ity
Hos
pita
lsN
HS
Tru
st16
.60
OV
——
——
——
——
2.61
2.67
2.74
2.81
2.88
2.95
Hea
lth
Cou
nty
Dur
ham
&D
arlin
gton
Acu
teH
ospi
tals
NH
S48
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
6.45
8.60
8.82
9.04
Tru
stH
ealt
hSu
ssex
Par
tner
ship
NH
ST
rust
22.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
—3.
443.
533.
623.
713.
803.
89H
ealt
hSo
uth
Tee
sA
cute
Hos
pita
lNH
ST
rust
121.
90O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
26.1
726
.82
27.4
9H
ealt
hSw
indo
n&
Mar
lbor
ough
NH
ST
rust
100.
20O
V—
——
——
——
——
—4.
4918
.12
18.5
719
.04
Hea
lth
Kin
g’s
Col
lege
Hos
pita
lNH
ST
rust
75.5
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
—12
.26
17.5
018
.37
18.3
8H
ealt
hN
orth
StaV
ords
hire
Com
bine
dH
ealt
hcar
eN
HS
Tru
st28
.07
OV
——
——
——
——
—3.
483.
563.
653.
743.
84H
ealt
hL
eeds
Men
talH
ealt
hT
each
ing
NH
ST
rust
47.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
—8.
268.
478.
688.
90H
ealt
hSt
Geo
rge’
sH
ealt
hcar
eN
HS
Tru
st46
.10
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—7.
337.
637.
82H
ealt
hO
xlea
sN
HS
Tru
st10
.80
On
——
——
——
——
—1.
011.
031.
061.
091.
50H
ealt
hU
nive
rsit
yC
olle
geL
ondo
nH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
422.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
40.0
0H
ealt
hN
orth
Eas
tL
ondo
nM
enta
lHea
lth
NH
ST
rust
10.8
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
1.15
1.18
1.21
1.24
1.27
Hea
lth
Bir
min
gham
&So
lihul
lMen
talH
ealt
hN
HS
Tru
st18
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
5.77
5.19
6.07
6.22
Hea
lth
Eas
tL
ondo
n&
the
Cit
yM
enta
lHea
lth
NH
ST
rust
14.5
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
—1.
511.
481.
511.
55H
ealt
hC
ornw
allH
ealt
hcar
eN
HS
Tru
st10
.20
OV
——
——
——
——
——
2.46
2.53
2.59
2.65
Hea
lth
Nor
thum
bria
Hea
lth
Car
eN
HS
Tru
st17
.82
OV
——
——
——
——
——
0.16
1.32
1.35
1.39
Hea
lth
Lut
onan
dD
unst
able
Hos
pita
lNH
ST
rust
14.7
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
—0.
801.
371.
401.
25H
ealt
hH
ulla
ndE
ast
Yor
kshi
reH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
22.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
—0.
502.
002.
052.
10H
ealt
hW
est
Mid
dles
exU
nive
rsit
yH
ospi
talN
HS
Tru
st60
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—9.
7010
.50
10.7
6H
ealt
hN
orth
umbr
iaH
ealt
hC
are
NH
ST
rust
55.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
2.22
3.80
3.89
Hea
lth
Dud
ley
Gro
upof
Hos
pita
lsN
HS
Tru
st13
7.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—18
.18
Hea
lth
Ber
kshi
reH
ealt
hcar
eN
HS
Tru
st29
.70
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—4.
214.
314.
42
3639101004 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 20 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
2006
–07
2007
–08
2008
–09
2009
–10
2010
–11
2011
–12
2012
–13
2013
–14
2014
–15
2015
–16
2016
–17
2017
–18
2018
–19
2019
–20
2020
–21
2021
–22
2022
–23
2023
–24
2024
–25
2025
–26
2026
–27
2027
–28
2028
–29
2029
–30
2030
–31
2031
–32
2032
–33
2033
–34
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
20.5
221
.04
21.5
622
.10
22.6
523
.22
23.8
024
.40
25.0
125
.63
26.2
726
.93
27.6
028
.29
29.0
029
.72
30.4
731
.23
32.0
132
.81
——
——
——
——
15.1
415
.52
15.9
116
.31
16.7
117
.13
17.5
618
.00
18.4
518
.91
19.3
819
.87
20.3
620
.87
21.3
921
.93
22.4
823
.04
23.6
224
.21
24.8
125
.43
26.0
726
.72
27.3
9—
——
11.6
411
.94
12.2
312
.54
12.8
513
.17
13.5
013
.84
14.1
914
.54
14.9
115
.28
15.6
616
.05
16.4
516
.86
17.2
917
.72
18.1
618
.62
19.0
819
.56
20.0
520
.55
21.0
6—
——
42.7
243
.79
44.8
846
.00
47.1
548
.33
49.5
450
.78
52.0
553
.35
54.6
856
.05
57.4
558
.89
60.3
661
.87
63.4
265
.00
66.6
368
.29
70.0
071
.75
73.5
475
.38
77.2
779
.20
——
13.5
313
.87
14.2
214
.57
14.9
415
.31
15.6
916
.08
16.4
916
.90
17.3
217
.75
18.2
018
.65
19.1
219
.60
20.0
920
.59
21.1
021
.63
22.1
722
.73
23.2
923
.88
24.4
725
.08
——
22.2
422
.80
23.3
723
.95
24.5
525
.16
25.7
926
.44
27.1
027
.77
28.4
729
.18
29.9
130
.66
31.4
232
.21
33.0
133
.84
34.6
935
.55
36.4
437
.35
38.2
939
.24
40.2
341
.23
——
21.1
021
.62
22.1
722
.72
23.2
923
.87
24.4
725
.08
25.7
026
.35
27.0
127
.68
28.3
729
.08
29.8
130
.55
31.3
232
.10
32.9
033
.73
34.5
735
.43
36.3
237
.23
38.1
6—
——
18.8
319
.30
19.7
820
.28
20.7
821
.30
21.8
422
.38
22.9
423
.51
24.1
024
.71
25.3
225
.96
26.6
027
.27
27.9
528
.65
29.3
730
.10
30.8
531
.62
32.4
233
.23
34.0
634
.91
——
20.1
220
.63
21.1
421
.67
22.2
122
.77
23.3
423
.92
24.5
225
.13
25.7
626
.40
27.0
627
.74
28.4
329
.15
29.8
730
.62
31.3
932
.17
32.9
833
.80
34.6
435
.51
36.4
037
.31
——
2.09
2.14
2.19
2.25
2.30
2.36
2.42
2.48
2.54
2.61
2.67
2.74
2.81
2.88
2.95
3.02
3.10
3.18
3.26
3.34
3.42
3.51
3.59
3.68
3.78
——
—15
.45
15.8
416
.23
16.6
417
.06
17.4
817
.92
18.3
718
.83
19.3
019
.78
20.2
720
.78
21.3
021
.83
22.3
822
.94
23.5
124
.10
24.7
025
.32
25.9
526
.60
27.2
727
.95
28.6
5—
—23
.41
23.9
924
.59
25.2
125
.84
26.4
827
.15
27.8
228
.52
29.2
329
.96
30.7
131
.48
32.2
733
.07
33.9
034
.75
35.6
236
.51
37.4
238
.36
39.3
240
.30
41.3
142
.34
43.4
0—
—11
.95
12.2
412
.55
12.8
613
.19
13.5
213
.85
14.2
014
.55
14.9
215
.29
15.6
716
.07
16.4
716
.88
17.3
017
.73
18.1
818
.63
19.1
019
.57
20.0
620
.56
21.0
821
.61
22.1
5—
—3.
023.
103.
183.
263.
343.
423.
513.
593.
683.
783.
873.
974.
074.
174.
274.
384.
494.
604.
724.
834.
965.
085.
215.
345.
47—
——
9.26
9.49
9.73
9.97
10.2
210
.48
10.7
411
.01
11.2
811
.57
11.8
612
.15
12.4
612
.77
13.0
913
.41
13.7
514
.09
14.4
414
.81
15.1
815
.56
15.9
416
.34
16.7
517
.17
17.6
0—
3.99
4.09
4.19
4.30
4.41
4.52
4.63
4.74
4.86
4.99
5.11
5.24
5.37
5.50
5.64
5.78
5.93
6.07
6.23
6.38
6.54
6.70
6.87
7.04
7.22
——
—28
.18
28.8
929
.61
30.3
531
.11
31.8
932
.68
33.5
034
.34
35.2
036
.08
36.9
837
.90
38.8
539
.82
40.8
241
.84
42.8
843
.95
45.0
546
.18
47.3
348
.52
49.7
350
.97
52.2
553
.55
54.8
919
.51
20.0
020
.50
21.0
121
.54
22.0
822
.63
23.2
023
.78
24.3
724
.98
25.6
026
.24
26.9
027
.57
28.2
628
.97
29.6
930
.44
31.2
031
.98
32.7
833
.60
——
——
—18
.35
18.8
119
.28
19.7
620
.25
20.7
621
.28
21.8
122
.36
22.9
223
.49
24.0
824
.68
25.3
025
.93
26.5
827
.24
27.9
228
.62
29.3
330
.07
30.8
231
.59
32.3
833
.19
34.0
234
.87
—3.
934.
034.
134.
244.
344.
454.
564.
674.
794.
915.
035.
165.
295.
425.
565.
705.
845.
986.
136.
296.
446.
616.
776.
947.
117.
29—
—9.
129.
359.
589.
8210
.06
10.3
210
.57
10.8
411
.11
11.3
911
.67
11.9
612
.26
12.5
712
.88
13.2
013
.53
13.8
714
.22
14.5
814
.94
15.3
115
.70
16.0
916
.49
16.9
017
.33
—7.
828.
028.
228.
428.
638.
859.
079.
309.
539.
7710
.01
10.2
610
.52
10.7
811
.05
11.3
311
.61
11.9
012
.20
12.5
012
.81
13.1
313
.46
13.8
014
.14
14.5
014
.86
15.2
31.
531.
571.
611.
651.
691.
731.
781.
821.
871.
921.
962.
012.
062.
112.
172.
222.
282.
332.
392.
452.
512.
582.
642.
712.
772.
84—
—41
.00
42.0
343
.08
44.1
545
.26
46.3
947
.55
48.7
449
.95
51.2
052
.48
53.8
055
.14
56.5
257
.93
59.3
860
.86
62.3
963
.95
65.5
467
.18
68.8
670
.58
72.3
574
.16
76.0
177
.91
79.8
61.
301.
341.
371.
401.
441.
471.
511.
551.
591.
631.
671.
711.
751.
801.
841.
891.
931.
982.
032.
082.
142.
192.
242.
302.
362.
42—
—6.
376.
536.
706.
867.
047.
217.
397.
587.
777.
968.
168.
368.
578.
799.
019.
239.
469.
709.
9410
.19
10.4
510
.71
10.9
711
.25
11.5
311
.82
12.1
1—
1.59
1.63
1.67
1.71
1.75
1.80
1.84
1.89
1.94
1.99
2.03
2.09
2.14
2.19
2.25
2.30
2.36
2.42
2.48
2.54
2.60
2.67
2.74
2.80
2.87
2.95
3.02
—2.
722.
792.
862.
933.
003.
083.
163.
233.
313.
403.
483.
573.
663.
753.
843.
944.
044.
144.
244.
354.
464.
574.
684.
804.
925.
045.
17—
1.88
1.93
1.98
2.03
2.08
2.13
2.18
2.24
2.29
2.35
2.41
2.47
2.53
2.59
2.66
2.73
2.79
2.86
2.94
3.01
3.08
3.16
3.24
3.32
3.40
3.49
3.58
—1.
281.
311.
351.
381.
411.
451.
491.
521.
561.
601.
641.
681.
721.
771.
811.
861.
901.
952.
002.
052.
102.
152.
212.
262.
322.
382.
43—
2.15
2.21
2.26
2.32
2.38
2.44
2.50
2.56
2.62
2.69
2.76
2.83
2.90
2.97
3.04
3.12
3.20
3.28
3.36
3.44
3.53
3.62
3.71
3.80
3.90
3.99
4.09
—11
.03
11.3
111
.59
11.8
812
.18
12.4
812
.79
13.1
113
.44
13.7
814
.12
14.4
714
.84
15.2
115
.59
15.9
816
.38
16.7
917
.21
17.6
418
.08
18.5
318
.99
19.4
719
.95
20.4
520
.96
21.4
93.
996.
636.
796.
967.
147.
317.
507.
687.
888.
078.
288.
488.
698.
919.
139.
369.
609.
8410
.08
10.3
410
.59
10.8
611
.13
11.4
111
.69
11.9
912
.29
12.5
918
.18
18.6
319
.10
19.5
820
.07
20.5
721
.08
21.6
122
.15
22.7
023
.27
23.8
524
.45
25.0
625
.69
26.3
326
.99
27.6
628
.35
29.0
629
.79
30.5
331
.29
32.0
832
.88
33.7
034
.54
35.4
14.
534.
644.
764.
885.
005.
125.
255.
385.
525.
665.
805.
946.
096.
246.
406.
566.
726.
897.
067.
247.
427.
617.
807.
998.
198.
408.
618.
82
3639101004 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 21
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
Tot
alch
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
geca
pita
lB
alan
cepa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tva
lue
shee
t19
92–9
319
93–9
419
94–9
519
95–9
619
96–9
719
97–9
819
98–9
919
99–0
020
00–0
120
01–0
220
02–0
320
03–0
420
04–0
520
05–0
6D
epar
tmen
tC
omm
issi
onin
gbo
dyP
roje
ctna
me
(£m
illio
ns)
trea
tmen
t(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)
Hea
lth
Eas
t&
Nor
thH
ertf
ords
hire
PC
T14
.75
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—1.
871.
941.
99H
ealt
hSu
rrey
PC
T29
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—3.
003.
083.
15H
ealt
hT
heR
oyal
Wol
verh
ampt
onH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
12.8
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
0.14
3.11
3.18
Hea
lth
NuY
eld
Ort
hopa
edic
NH
ST
rust
37.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hG
louc
este
rshi
reH
ospi
tals
NH
SF
ound
atio
nT
rust
32.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—3.
303.
31H
ealt
hC
ount
yD
urha
m&
Dar
lingt
onA
cute
Hos
pita
lsN
HS
10.4
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
892.
12T
rust
Hea
lth
Dev
onP
CT
10.4
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—1.
451.
48H
ealt
hW
est
Ber
kshi
reP
CT
18.8
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—3.
173.
25H
ealt
hL
eeds
Tea
chin
gH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
14.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
651.
72H
ealt
hT
heW
hitt
ingt
onN
HS
Tru
st31
.90
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hea
lth
Uni
vers
ity
Hos
pita
lsC
oven
try
&W
arw
icks
hire
NH
S37
8.90
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Tru
stH
ealt
hB
rent
PC
T21
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
84H
ealt
hSa
ndw
ell&
Wes
tB
irm
ingh
amH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
26.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
3.15
Hea
lth
Cou
nty
Dur
ham
&D
arlin
gton
Pri
orit
ySe
rvic
esN
HS
15.7
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
500.
76T
rust
Hea
lth
Eas
tL
anca
shir
eH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
109.
60O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hD
onca
ster
&So
uth
Hum
ber
Hea
lthc
are
NH
ST
rust
12.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.64
Hea
lth
Der
byH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
312.
20O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hE
ast
Lan
cash
ire
Hos
pita
lsN
HS
Tru
st30
.10
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
61H
ealt
hN
orth
Wes
tL
ondo
nH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
69.3
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
3.53
Hea
lth
Oxf
ord
Rad
cliV
eH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
134.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
h”B
arki
ng,H
aver
ing
&R
edbr
idge
NH
ST
rust
”23
8.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hea
lth
New
ham
Hea
lthc
are
NH
ST
rust
52.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hL
eeds
Tea
chin
gH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
265.
20O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hA
von
&W
este
rnW
iltsh
ire
MH
NH
ST
rust
83.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hSa
lisbu
ryH
ealt
hC
are
NH
ST
rust
24.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.41
Hea
lth
Kir
klee
sP
CT
25.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.06
Hea
lth
Wan
dsw
orth
PC
T75
.40
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
h”N
orth
umbe
rlan
d,T
yne
&W
ear
NH
ST
rust
”31
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
42H
ealt
hB
ucki
ngha
msh
ire
Hos
pita
lsN
HS
Tru
st46
.60
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hea
lth
Bri
ghto
n&
Suss
exU
nive
rsit
yH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
36.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hL
ewis
ham
Hos
pita
lNH
ST
rust
51.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hC
ambr
idge
Uni
vers
ity
Hos
pita
lsN
HS
Fou
ndat
ion
76.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—T
rust
Hea
lth
Ham
pshi
reP
CT
36.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hK
ings
ton
Hos
pita
lNH
ST
rust
27.6
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hSh
eYel
dT
each
ing
Hos
pita
lsN
HS
Fou
ndat
ion
Tru
st30
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hea
lth
Cen
tral
Man
ches
ter
&M
anch
este
rC
hild
ren’
s42
0.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Uni
vers
ity
Hos
pita
lsN
HS
Tru
stH
ealt
hN
otti
ngha
msh
ire
Hea
lthc
are
NH
ST
rust
18.7
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hN
orth
ampt
onsh
ireT
each
ing
PC
T28
.20
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hea
lth
New
cast
leup
onT
yne
Hos
pita
ls29
8.60
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hea
lth
Sher
woo
dF
ores
tH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
296.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hN
orth
gate
&P
rudh
oe—
Neu
roD
isab
ility
Cen
tre
24.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—
3639101004 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 22 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
2006
–07
2007
–08
2008
–09
2009
–10
2010
–11
2011
–12
2012
–13
2013
–14
2014
–15
2015
–16
2016
–17
2017
–18
2018
–19
2019
–20
2020
–21
2021
–22
2022
–23
2023
–24
2024
–25
2025
–26
2026
–27
2027
–28
2028
–29
2029
–30
2030
–31
2031
–32
2032
–33
2033
–34
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
2.04
2.09
2.14
2.20
2.25
2.31
2.37
2.43
2.49
2.55
2.61
2.68
2.74
2.81
2.88
2.95
3.03
3.10
3.18
3.26
3.34
3.43
3.51
3.60
3.69
3.78
3.88
3.97
3.23
3.31
3.39
3.48
3.57
3.66
3.75
3.84
3.94
4.03
4.14
4.24
4.34
4.45
4.56
4.68
4.80
4.92
5.04
5.16
5.29
5.43
5.56
5.70
5.84
5.99
6.14
6.29
3.26
3.34
3.43
3.51
3.60
3.69
3.78
3.88
3.98
4.07
4.18
4.28
4.39
4.50
4.61
4.73
4.84
4.96
5.09
5.22
5.35
5.48
5.62
5.76
5.90
6.05
6.20
6.36
4.36
4.47
4.58
4.69
4.81
4.93
5.05
5.18
5.31
5.44
5.58
5.72
5.86
6.01
6.16
6.31
6.47
6.63
6.80
6.97
7.14
7.32
7.50
7.69
7.88
8.08
8.28
8.49
3.40
3.48
3.57
3.66
3.75
3.84
3.94
4.04
4.14
4.24
4.35
4.46
4.57
4.68
4.80
4.92
5.04
5.17
5.30
5.43
5.56
5.70
5.85
5.99
6.14
6.30
6.45
6.61
2.18
2.23
2.29
2.34
2.40
2.46
2.52
2.59
2.65
2.72
2.79
2.86
2.93
3.00
3.08
3.15
3.23
3.31
3.40
3.48
3.57
3.66
3.75
3.84
3.94
4.04
4.14
4.24
1.52
1.56
1.60
1.64
1.68
1.72
1.76
1.81
1.85
1.90
1.95
2.00
2.05
2.10
2.15
2.20
2.26
2.32
2.37
2.43
2.49
2.56
2.62
2.69
2.75
2.82
2.89
2.96
3.33
3.41
3.50
3.58
3.67
3.76
3.86
3.95
4.05
4.16
4.26
4.37
4.47
4.59
4.70
4.82
4.94
5.06
5.19
5.32
5.45
5.59
5.73
5.87
6.02
6.17
6.32
6.48
1.76
1.80
1.85
1.90
1.94
1.99
2.04
2.09
2.14
2.20
2.25
2.31
2.37
2.43
2.49
2.55
2.61
2.68
2.74
2.81
2.88
2.96
3.03
3.11
3.18
3.26
3.34
3.43
0.16
3.78
3.88
3.97
4.07
4.17
4.28
4.39
4.50
4.61
4.72
4.84
4.96
5.09
5.21
5.34
5.48
5.61
5.76
5.90
6.05
6.20
6.35
6.51
6.67
6.84
7.01
7.19
53.9
355
.27
56.6
658
.07
59.5
261
.01
62.5
464
.10
65.7
067
.35
69.0
370
.76
72.5
274
.34
76.2
078
.10
80.0
582
.05
84.1
186
.21
88.3
690
.57
92.8
495
.16
97.5
499
.98
102.
4810
5.04
2.91
2.98
3.06
3.13
3.21
3.29
3.37
3.46
3.54
3.63
3.72
3.82
3.91
4.01
4.11
4.21
4.32
4.42
4.54
4.65
4.76
4.88
5.01
5.13
5.26
5.39
5.53
5.66
3.23
3.31
3.40
3.48
3.57
3.66
3.75
3.84
3.94
4.04
4.14
4.24
4.35
4.46
4.57
4.68
4.80
4.92
5.04
5.17
5.30
5.43
5.57
5.70
5.85
5.99
6.14
6.30
0.77
0.79
0.81
0.83
0.86
0.88
0.90
0.92
0.94
0.97
0.99
1.02
1.04
1.07
1.09
1.12
1.15
1.18
1.21
1.24
1.27
1.30
1.33
1.37
1.40
1.44
1.47
1.51
8.45
11.2
711
.55
11.8
412
.13
12.4
412
.75
13.0
713
.39
13.7
314
.07
14.4
214
.78
15.1
515
.53
15.9
216
.32
16.7
317
.14
17.5
718
.01
18.4
618
.92
19.4
019
.88
20.3
820
.89
21.4
11.
791.
841.
881.
931.
982.
032.
082.
132.
182.
242.
302.
352.
412.
472.
532.
602.
662.
732.
802.
872.
943.
013.
093.
163.
243.
323.
413.
49—
—35
.66
38.9
039
.87
40.8
741
.89
42.9
444
.01
45.1
146
.24
47.4
048
.58
49.8
051
.04
52.3
253
.62
54.9
656
.34
57.7
559
.19
60.6
762
.19
63.7
465
.34
66.9
768
.64
70.3
63.
133.
213.
293.
373.
463.
553.
633.
733.
823.
914.
014.
114.
214.
324.
434.
544.
654.
774.
895.
015.
145.
265.
405.
535.
675.
815.
966.
107.
057.
237.
417.
597.
787.
988.
188.
388.
598.
809.
029.
259.
489.
729.
9610
.21
10.4
710
.73
11.0
011
.27
11.5
511
.84
12.1
412
.44
12.7
513
.07
13.4
013
.73
—17
.84
19.4
619
.95
20.4
520
.96
21.4
822
.02
22.5
723
.13
23.7
124
.30
24.9
125
.53
26.1
726
.83
27.5
028
.18
28.8
929
.61
30.3
531
.11
31.8
932
.68
33.5
034
.34
35.2
036
.08
13.1
731
.60
32.3
933
.20
34.0
334
.88
35.7
536
.64
37.5
638
.50
39.4
640
.45
41.4
642
.49
43.5
644
.65
45.7
646
.91
48.0
849
.28
50.5
151
.78
53.0
754
.40
55.7
657
.15
58.5
860
.04
11.2
111
.49
11.7
712
.07
12.3
712
.68
12.9
913
.32
13.6
513
.99
14.3
414
.70
15.0
715
.45
15.8
316
.23
16.6
317
.05
17.4
817
.91
18.3
618
.82
19.2
919
.77
20.2
720
.77
21.2
921
.83
——
13.3
320
.00
20.5
021
.01
21.5
422
.08
22.6
323
.19
23.7
724
.37
24.9
825
.60
26.2
426
.90
27.5
728
.26
28.9
729
.69
30.4
331
.19
31.9
732
.77
33.5
934
.43
35.2
936
.17
6.26
6.42
6.58
6.74
6.91
7.08
7.26
7.44
7.63
7.82
8.01
8.21
8.42
8.63
8.84
9.06
9.29
9.52
9.76
10.0
110
.26
10.5
110
.78
11.0
411
.32
11.6
011
.89
12.1
92.
482.
542.
602.
672.
732.
802.
872.
943.
023.
093.
173.
253.
333.
413.
503.
593.
683.
773.
863.
964.
064.
164.
264.
374.
484.
594.
714.
822.
122.
172.
222.
282.
342.
392.
452.
522.
582.
642.
712.
782.
852.
922.
993.
063.
143.
223.
303.
383.
473.
553.
643.
733.
833.
924.
024.
1210
.20
10.4
610
.72
10.9
811
.26
11.5
411
.83
12.1
212
.43
12.7
413
.06
13.3
813
.72
14.0
614
.41
14.7
715
.14
15.5
215
.91
16.3
116
.71
17.1
317
.56
18.0
018
.45
18.9
119
.38
19.8
75.
005.
135.
255.
385.
525.
665.
805.
946.
096.
246.
406.
566.
726.
897.
067.
247.
427.
617.
807.
998.
198.
408.
618.
829.
049.
279.
509.
748.
5510
.26
10.5
210
.78
11.0
511
.33
11.6
111
.90
12.2
012
.50
12.8
113
.13
13.4
613
.80
14.1
414
.50
14.8
615
.23
15.6
116
.00
16.4
016
.81
17.2
317
.66
18.1
018
.56
19.0
219
.50
—4.
104.
204.
304.
414.
524.
644.
754.
874.
995.
125.
245.
385.
515.
655.
795.
936.
086.
236.
396.
556.
716.
887.
057.
237.
417.
607.
792.
895.
775.
926.
076.
226.
376.
536.
696.
867.
037.
217.
397.
577.
767.
968.
168.
368.
578.
789.
009.
239.
469.
709.
9410
.19
10.4
410
.70
10.9
70.
136.
356.
516.
676.
847.
017.
197.
377.
557.
747.
938.
138.
338.
548.
758.
979.
209.
439.
669.
9110
.15
10.4
110
.67
10.9
311
.21
11.4
911
.77
12.0
71.
924.
604.
714.
834.
955.
085.
205.
335.
475.
605.
745.
896.
036.
186.
346.
506.
666.
837.
007.
177.
357.
537.
727.
928.
118.
328.
528.
747.
237.
898.
098.
298.
508.
718.
939.
159.
389.
629.
8610
.10
10.3
610
.61
10.8
811
.15
11.4
311
.72
12.0
112
.31
12.6
212
.93
13.2
613
.59
13.9
314
.28
14.6
315
.00
1.07
2.56
2.62
2.69
2.75
2.82
2.89
2.97
3.04
3.12
3.19
3.27
3.36
3.44
3.53
3.61
3.70
3.80
3.89
3.99
4.09
4.19
4.30
4.40
4.51
4.63
4.74
4.86
——
29.5
949
.32
50.5
551
.81
53.1
154
.44
55.8
057
.19
58.6
260
.09
61.5
963
.13
64.7
166
.33
67.9
969
.68
71.4
373
.21
75.0
476
.92
78.8
480
.81
82.8
384
.90
87.0
389
.20
0.37
2.24
2.30
2.36
2.42
2.48
2.54
2.60
2.67
2.73
2.80
2.87
2.94
3.02
3.09
3.17
3.25
3.33
3.41
3.50
3.59
3.68
3.77
3.86
3.96
4.06
4.16
4.26
—0.
642.
132.
182.
242.
292.
352.
412.
472.
532.
602.
662.
732.
792.
862.
943.
013.
083.
163.
243.
323.
413.
493.
583.
673.
763.
853.
95—
24.6
325
.24
25.8
726
.52
27.1
827
.86
28.5
629
.27
30.0
030
.75
31.5
232
.31
33.1
233
.95
34.7
935
.66
36.5
637
.47
38.4
139
.37
40.3
541
.36
42.3
943
.45
44.5
445
.65
46.7
9—
——
33.2
034
.03
34.8
835
.75
36.6
537
.56
38.5
039
.46
40.4
541
.46
42.5
043
.56
44.6
545
.77
46.9
148
.08
49.2
950
.52
51.7
853
.08
54.4
055
.76
57.1
658
.59
60.0
5—
0.25
1.49
1.52
1.56
1.60
1.64
1.68
1.72
1.77
1.81
1.86
1.90
1.95
2.00
2.05
2.10
2.15
2.21
2.26
2.32
2.38
2.43
2.50
2.56
2.62
2.69
2.75
3639101004 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 23
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
Tot
alch
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
geca
pita
lB
alan
cepa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tva
lue
shee
t19
92–9
319
93–9
419
94–9
519
95–9
619
96–9
719
97–9
819
98–9
919
99–0
020
00–0
120
01–0
220
02–0
320
03–0
420
04–0
520
05–0
6D
epar
tmen
tC
omm
issi
onin
gbo
dyP
roje
ctna
me
(£m
illio
ns)
trea
tmen
t(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)
Hea
lth
Oxf
ord
Rad
cliV
eH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
129.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hP
orts
mou
thH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
193.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hSh
rops
hire
Cou
ncil
Soci
alC
are
Sche
me*
22.4
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hH
ulla
ndE
ast
Yor
kshi
reH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
67.2
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hIp
swic
hH
ospi
talN
HS
Tru
st36
.10
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hea
lth
Bar
ts&
the
Lon
don
NH
ST
rust
1,00
0.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hea
lth
StH
elen
s&
Kno
wsl
eyH
ospi
tals
NH
ST
rust
338.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ealt
hU
nive
rsit
yH
ospi
talB
irm
ingh
amN
HS
Tru
st62
7.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hea
lth
Sout
hW
est
Ess
exT
each
ing
PC
T30
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hea
lth
Lon
don
Bor
ough
ofE
alin
gE
alin
gC
are
Alli
ance
27.1
7O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
3.60
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtD
VL
AE
stat
esT
rans
form
atio
n25
.30
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
—9.
80D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Hig
hway
sA
genc
yD
artf
ord
Cro
ssin
g18
0.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtH
ighw
ays
Age
ncy
Seve
rnC
ross
ing
331.
00O
n—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Hig
hway
sA
genc
yM
6T
oll
485.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Hig
hway
sA
genc
yA
1(M
)12
8.00
On
——
——
—6.
6420
.12
22.0
426
.95
27.2
428
.29
28.1
228
.58
26.8
2D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Hig
hway
sA
genc
yA
1D
toD
Yor
kshi
re24
5.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
176.
3514
.70
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtH
ighw
ays
Age
ncy
A19
29.0
0O
n—
——
—0.
211.
2218
.69
25.2
027
.95
28.4
222
.18
24.9
021
.84
24.3
6D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Hig
hway
sA
genc
yA
30/3
575
.00
On
——
——
5.40
11.6
912
.09
12.2
315
.74
29.3
930
.74
32.2
228
.10
28.7
5D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Hig
hway
sA
genc
yA
5021
.00
On
——
——
1.12
2.26
9.25
11.2
011
.71
12.3
712
.85
13.6
614
.38
15.2
4D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Hig
hway
sA
genc
yA
699.
00O
n—
——
—4.
287.
778.
558.
999.
089.
439.
5810
.57
10.7
711
.11
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtH
ighw
ays
Age
ncy
A24
973
.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtH
ighw
ays
Age
ncy
A41
7/41
949
.00
On
——
——
——
13.1
316
.52
18.6
119
.45
20.2
019
.96
19.6
819
.05
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtH
ighw
ays
Age
ncy
M1/
A1
214.
00O
n—
——
——
—7.
5258
.63
57.7
454
.86
52.7
252
.17
55.3
955
.96
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtH
ighw
ays
Age
ncy
M40
65.0
0O
n—
——
——
21.9
319
.83
21.3
725
.05
25.4
625
.74
25.8
922
.30
22.8
0D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Hig
hway
sA
genc
yN
RT
S23
7.30
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtH
ighw
ays
Age
ncy
Tra
Yc
Con
trol
Cen
tres
85.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
—8.
3716
.10
8.10
16.5
0D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
VO
SAM
OT
Com
pute
risa
tion
29.6
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
29.0
0D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Tra
nspo
rtfo
rL
ondo
nB
rtis
hT
rans
port
Pol
ice
13.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
0.55
1.13
1.01
1.64
2.55
2.69
2.91
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtT
rans
port
for
Lon
don
Con
nect
475.
16O
V—
——
——
——
6.22
19.9
837
.45
54.1
461
.16
84.3
343
.31
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtT
rans
port
for
Lon
don
Pow
er13
3.00
OV
——
——
——
26.2
043
.41
63.5
663
.04
62.6
354
.39
53.6
144
.78
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtT
rans
port
for
Lon
don
Pre
stig
e16
1.15
OV
——
——
——
7.99
37.2
349
.11
51.0
458
.50
72.0
779
.50
77.5
3D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Tra
nspo
rtfo
rL
ondo
nP
PP
JNP
5,52
6.40
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtT
rans
port
for
Lon
don
PP
PSS
L6,
687.
00O
n—
——
——
——
——
——
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Tra
nspo
rtfo
rL
ondo
nP
PP
BC
V5,
381.
00O
n—
——
——
——
——
——
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Tra
nspo
rtfo
rL
ondo
nC
royd
onT
ram
link
80.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Tra
nspo
rtfo
rL
ondo
nD
LR
Lew
isha
m14
2.00
On
——
——
——
——
22.9
422
.85
25.2
326
.82
27.7
928
.40
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtT
rans
port
for
Lon
don
DL
RC
ity
Air
port
147.
00O
n—
——
——
——
——
——
——
3.28
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtT
rans
port
for
Lon
don
DL
RW
oolw
ick
Ext
ensi
on17
7.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtT
rans
port
for
Lon
don
A13
229.
04O
V—
——
——
——
—4.
758.
084.
979.
3317
.88
14.2
0D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Not
ting
ham
Cit
y&
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
Not
ting
ham
Exp
ress
Tra
nsit
172.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
1.24
19.5
119
.91
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtD
onca
ster
PT
ED
onca
ster
Inte
rcha
nge
205.
81O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Ess
exC
ount
yC
ounc
ilA
130
90.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Por
tsm
outh
Cit
yC
ounc
ilP
orts
mou
thH
ighw
ayM
aint
enan
ce12
1.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtL
ondo
nB
orou
ghof
Bar
net
Stre
etL
ight
ing
27.7
7O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Lon
don
Bor
ough
ofB
rent
Stre
etL
ight
ing
9.40
OV
——
——
——
0.57
1.86
2.81
2.88
2.95
2.96
——
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtL
ondo
nB
orou
ghof
Eal
ing
Stre
etL
ight
ing
31.9
2O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Lon
don
Bor
ough
ofE
nfiel
dSt
reet
Lig
htin
g23
.70
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtL
ondo
nB
orou
ghof
Islin
gton
Stre
etL
ight
ing
12.1
7O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
0.98
1.35
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Lon
don
Bor
ough
ofL
ambe
thSt
reet
Lig
htin
g17
.22
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
39D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Dor
set
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
Stre
etL
ight
ing
31.6
3O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Lee
dsC
ity
Cou
ncil
Stre
etL
ight
ing
94.6
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Man
ches
ter
Cit
yC
ounc
ilSt
reet
Lig
htin
g34
.10
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
4.47
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
New
cast
le&
Nor
thT
ynes
ide
Stre
etL
ight
ing
44.4
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—5.
91—
3639101004 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 24 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
2006
–07
2007
–08
2008
–09
2009
–10
2010
–11
2011
–12
2012
–13
2013
–14
2014
–15
2015
–16
2016
–17
2017
–18
2018
–19
2019
–20
2020
–21
2021
–22
2022
–23
2023
–24
2024
–25
2025
–26
2026
–27
2027
–28
2028
–29
2029
–30
2030
–31
2031
–32
2032
–33
2033
–34
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
——
15.7
216
.11
16.5
116
.93
17.3
517
.78
18.2
318
.68
19.1
519
.63
20.1
220
.62
21.1
421
.67
22.2
122
.77
23.3
323
.92
24.5
225
.13
25.7
626
.40
27.0
627
.74
28.4
329
.14
——
—32
.87
33.6
934
.53
35.3
936
.28
37.1
838
.11
39.0
740
.04
41.0
542
.07
43.1
244
.20
45.3
146
.44
47.6
048
.79
50.0
151
.26
52.5
453
.85
55.2
056
.58
58.0
059
.45
2.17
2.82
2.86
2.90
2.93
2.97
3.10
3.05
3.09
3.14
3.18
3.23
3.27
3.32
3.37
3.42
3.47
3.53
3.58
3.64
3.70
3.76
3.82
3.89
3.95
4.02
4.09
4.16
——
4.05
4.15
4.25
4.36
4.47
4.58
4.70
4.81
4.93
5.06
5.18
5.31
5.45
5.58
5.72
5.86
6.01
6.16
6.32
6.47
6.63
6.80
6.97
7.14
7.32
7.51
—2.
902.
973.
053.
123.
203.
283.
363.
453.
533.
623.
713.
813.
904.
004.
104.
204.
314.
414.
524.
644.
754.
874.
995.
125.
255.
385.
51—
——
——
—96
.40
98.8
110
1.28
103.
8110
6.41
109.
0711
1.79
114.
5911
7.45
120.
3912
3.40
126.
4912
9.65
132.
8913
6.21
139.
6214
3.11
146.
6815
0.35
154.
1115
7.96
——
30.0
030
.75
31.5
232
.31
33.1
133
.94
34.7
935
.66
36.5
537
.47
38.4
039
.36
40.3
541
.36
42.3
943
.45
44.5
445
.65
46.7
947
.96
49.1
650
.39
51.6
552
.94
54.2
655
.62
——
——
47.0
048
.18
49.3
850
.61
51.8
853
.18
54.5
155
.87
57.2
658
.70
60.1
661
.67
63.2
164
.79
66.4
168
.07
69.7
771
.52
73.3
075
.14
77.0
178
.94
80.9
182
.94
——
3.26
3.34
3.43
3.51
3.60
3.69
3.78
3.88
3.98
4.07
4.18
4.28
4.39
4.50
4.61
4.73
4.84
4.96
5.09
5.22
5.35
5.48
5.62
5.76
5.90
6.05
3.83
4.17
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
10.7
212
.77
14.3
614
.79
15.2
415
.69
16.1
716
.65
17.1
517
.66
18.1
918
.74
19.3
019
.88
20.4
821
.09
21.7
222
.38
23.0
5—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
36.0
036
.00
38.0
037
.00
40.0
040
.66
42.9
140
.77
43.0
342
.16
44.1
446
.78
49.2
748
.10
50.6
547
.07
49.4
852
.02
54.6
957
.49
——
——
——
——
26.7
827
.47
28.1
928
.92
29.6
730
.44
31.2
432
.05
32.8
833
.74
34.6
135
.51
36.4
437
.38
38.3
539
.35
40.3
841
.42
42.5
043
.61
44.7
445
.90
47.1
048
.32
49.5
850
.87
21.8
824
.84
25.6
929
.48
31.5
136
.78
35.5
228
.33
20.4
517
.62
31.7
938
.73
14.0
99.
6861
.77
26.7
231
.76
23.8
454
.25
57.6
425
.79
——
——
——
—29
.08
29.4
029
.62
30.0
030
.19
30.4
530
.69
9.70
10.0
110
.32
10.6
110
.80
11.2
211
.55
11.8
612
.23
11.2
212
.93
13.2
513
.63
14.0
6—
——
——
——
12.4
212
.64
12.8
413
.05
13.2
613
.47
4.57
4.68
4.80
4.91
5.01
5.12
5.23
5.34
5.46
5.58
5.70
5.82
5.95
6.08
——
——
——
——
9.50
9.62
9.75
9.87
10.0
010
.13
10.2
510
.38
10.5
110
.05
10.7
810
.92
11.0
611
.20
11.3
411
.48
11.6
311
.78
11.9
512
.08
——
——
——
——
5.41
10.7
410
.80
10.9
111
.00
11.1
111
.18
11.2
911
.40
11.5
111
.57
11.7
011
.81
11.6
611
.96
12.1
512
.27
12.4
112
.50
12.6
512
.78
12.6
411
.51
13.2
913
.52
13.6
3—
—21
.96
22.1
523
.30
22.1
223
.15
24.2
323
.43
24.3
125
.17
26.6
623
.70
24.1
823
.97
24.7
925
.64
19.1
019
.74
20.3
821
.04
21.7
2—
——
——
——
—56
.47
57.4
358
.48
59.5
163
.32
67.2
768
.56
69.8
834
.56
35.2
836
.02
34.4
535
.18
35.9
325
.46
27.0
327
.62
28.2
328
.85
29.4
9—
——
——
——
—28
.10
29.0
530
.10
31.2
532
.49
33.8
635
.36
37.0
238
.84
40.8
242
.93
45.3
147
.74
50.3
853
.26
56.3
959
.48
63.4
567
.08
70.9
456
.33
——
——
——
——
29.9
856
.40
57.4
758
.58
59.7
160
.87
62.0
763
.30
61.8
7—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—20
.09
20.3
220
.54
20.7
821
.02
9.18
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
28.0
026
.20
26.0
025
.30
22.0
018
.20
15.2
0—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
3.29
3.48
3.56
3.68
3.71
3.61
3.67
3.74
3.77
3.82
3.99
4.05
3.84
3.86
3.95
3.93
0.57
——
——
——
——
——
—87
.80
101.
0412
4.31
86.8
287
.89
88.9
990
.10
91.0
592
.31
94.1
795
.31
73.6
254
.40
35.2
8—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—45
.24
44.3
744
.41
44.3
347
.22
48.5
448
.34
50.3
149
.84
52.9
857
.97
63.7
267
.42
69.0
667
.35
56.8
449
.51
47.2
247
.02
47.9
949
.24
49.6
019
.05
——
——
—96
.54
99.4
599
.34
99.8
910
0.90
102.
5010
3.66
86.1
775
.73
35.6
6—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—29
.41
29.9
731
.24
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—14
.23
14.6
115
.02
15.3
715
.76
16.1
416
.52
16.9
417
.39
17.8
618
.28
18.6
719
.14
19.6
820
.20
20.6
821
.16
21.6
722
.25
22.8
223
.39
24.0
224
.54
25.1
125
.78
26.5
121
.53
1.18
——
1.87
21.0
721
.61
21.7
222
.35
22.9
723
.79
24.5
125
.95
25.0
423
.25
21.1
819
.03
18.7
919
.14
19.4
520
.62
21.3
821
.86
21.6
523
.01
24.7
825
.18
24.0
422
.70
22.3
515
.85
16.2
516
.56
17.0
317
.45
17.8
918
.29
18.7
019
.26
22.2
322
.91
23.4
823
.97
24.6
525
.27
24.8
519
.22
27.1
027
.21
28.4
828
.79
29.6
830
.24
27.3
62.
38—
——
20.3
720
.78
21.1
921
.62
22.0
522
.49
22.9
423
.40
23.8
724
.34
24.8
325
.33
25.8
326
.35
26.8
827
.42
27.9
628
.52
28.7
322
.34
18.3
514
.76
14.3
614
.36
4.10
——
—2.
662.
622.
692.
762.
832.
902.
972.
652.
682.
712.
752.
682.
722.
752.
792.
832.
872.
912.
953.
003.
043.
093.
133.
183.
233.
283.
393.
319.
579.
9110
.24
10.5
910
.96
11.3
411
.72
12.8
614
.55
12.9
713
.40
13.8
514
.30
14.7
920
.16
15.7
616
.79
16.8
017
.31
11.4
311
.58
12.8
2—
——
——
—12
.14
14.4
316
.45
18.2
019
.76
20.6
321
.06
21.5
221
.97
22.4
022
.87
23.3
923
.88
24.3
624
.88
25.4
425
.99
26.5
227
.09
27.7
128
.32
28.9
029
.53
30.2
230
.76
——
—2.
202.
993.
443.
954.
534.
394.
304.
304.
304.
304.
304.
304.
304.
304.
304.
304.
304.
304.
304.
304.
304.
304.
304.
304.
300.
70—
—3.
273.
353.
433.
513.
603.
693.
783.
883.
984.
094.
204.
312.
63—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
2.88
3.22
3.56
3.91
4.17
4.28
4.34
4.40
4.60
4.52
4.58
4.64
4.71
4.77
4.83
4.90
4.97
5.04
5.11
5.18
5.24
5.32
5.39
5.47
1.83
——
—1.
972.
683.
093.
554.
083.
953.
873.
873.
873.
873.
873.
873.
873.
873.
873.
873.
873.
873.
873.
873.
873.
873.
873.
873.
870.
63—
—1.
802.
062.
202.
202.
252.
272.
302.
332.
352.
382.
412.
432.
462.
492.
522.
552.
582.
612.
642.
672.
702.
73—
——
——
—1.
291.
972.
492.
782.
592.
602.
632.
662.
692.
722.
752.
782.
822.
852.
892.
922.
963.
003.
043.
083.
123.
163.
213.
251.
95—
——
—4.
684.
744.
814.
874.
935.
005.
075.
135.
205.
275.
345.
415.
495.
565.
635.
715.
795.
865.
946.
026.
106.
186.
266.
356.
43—
—4.
356.
888.
219.
7511
.34
12.4
312
.61
12.7
812
.95
13.1
313
.31
13.5
013
.68
13.8
714
.06
14.2
514
.45
14.6
514
.85
15.0
515
.26
15.4
715
.68
15.9
016
.12
4.09
——
5.00
6.00
7.00
8.00
8.00
8.00
8.00
8.00
8.00
8.00
8.00
8.00
9.00
9.00
9.00
9.00
9.00
9.00
9.00
9.00
9.00
10.0
010
.00
——
——
—8.
258.
398.
548.
698.
859.
009.
159.
319.
489.
649.
819.
9810
.16
10.3
410
.52
10.7
010
.89
11.0
811
.27
11.4
711
.67
11.8
712
.08
——
——
—
3639101004 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 25
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
Tot
alch
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
geca
pita
lB
alan
cepa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tva
lue
shee
t19
92–9
319
93–9
419
94–9
519
95–9
619
96–9
719
97–9
819
98–9
919
99–0
020
00–0
120
01–0
220
02–0
320
03–0
420
04–0
520
05–0
6D
epar
tmen
tC
omm
issi
onin
gbo
dyP
roje
ctna
me
(£m
illio
ns)
trea
tmen
t(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tra
nspo
rtSo
uth
Tyn
esid
eM
BC
Stre
etL
ight
ing
31.5
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
StaV
ords
hire
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
Stre
etL
ight
ing
31.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
6.59
7.02
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Stok
eM
BC
Stre
etL
ight
ing
22.6
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
1.60
3.20
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Sund
erla
ndM
BC
Stre
etL
ight
ing
28.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
1.33
2.74
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Wak
efiel
dM
BC
Stre
etL
ight
ing
16.2
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
0.33
2.29
—D
epar
tmen
tfo
rT
rans
port
Wal
sall
MB
CSt
reet
Lig
htin
g18
.60
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—1.
682.
47—
MO
DA
rmy
Fou
ndat
ion
Col
lege
(AF
C)
65.1
9O
V—
——
——
——
—6.
458.
9413
.43
15.9
716
.41
16.8
1M
OD
AST
UT
EC
lass
Tra
inin
gSe
rvic
e(A
CT
S)72
.78
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
MO
DA
ttac
kH
elic
opte
rsT
rain
ing—
Apa
che
232.
25O
V—
——
——
——
—18
.71
22.2
136
.27
45.7
144
.83
46.7
2Si
mul
ator
Tra
inin
gM
OD
Bri
stol
,Bat
han
dP
orts
mou
thF
amily
78.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
8.40
9.63
6.82
8.62
8.46
Mar
ried
Qua
rter
sM
OD
Cve
hicl
es11
4.44
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—8.
49M
OD
Cen
tral
Scot
land
Fam
ilyQ
uart
ers
(HQ
)24
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
—3.
323.
323.
31M
OD
Col
ches
ter
539.
37O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
1.50
23.8
127
.40
MO
DD
efen
ceA
nim
alC
entr
e(D
AC
)11
.23
On
——
——
——
——
—0.
653.
553.
613.
863.
71M
OD
Def
ence
Sixt
hF
orm
Col
lege
(DSF
C)
50.5
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
6.47
MO
DD
evon
port
Supp
ort
Serv
ices
—A
RM
AD
A44
.51
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
4.94
10.3
8M
OD
Fie
ldE
lect
rica
lPow
erSu
pplie
s(F
EP
S)73
.41
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
10.2
710
.38
MO
DN
RT
AF
ire
Fig
htin
gT
rain
ing
Uni
ts21
.80
OV
——
——
——
——
—6.
636.
796.
967.
137.
31(F
FT
U)
MO
DH
awk
Sim
ulat
or20
.20
OV
——
——
——
0.02
1.35
3.27
3.33
3.61
3.82
3.24
3.10
MO
DH
eavy
Equ
ipm
ent
Tra
nspo
rter
s(H
ET
)65
.02
On
——
——
——
——
——
28.8
029
.52
30.2
625
.97
MO
DJo
int
Serv
ices
Com
man
dan
dSt
aVC
olle
ge93
.00
On
——
——
——
——
—26
.58
27.2
828
.07
29.9
229
.94
MO
DM
ain
Bui
ldin
gR
efur
bish
men
t43
8.96
On
——
——
——
——
20.8
728
.98
29.5
036
.99
49.8
073
.92
MO
DM
ediu
mSu
ppor
tH
elic
opte
rA
ircr
ew11
4.00
OV
——
——
——
—0.
5917
.92
21.5
824
.17
24.2
424
.41
21.5
5T
rain
ing
Fac
ility
(MSH
AT
F)
MO
DM
OD
-wid
eW
ater
and
Was
teW
ater
Pro
ject
153.
94O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
10.0
130
.54
31.0
7(A
quat
rine
)—P
acka
geA
MO
DM
OD
-wid
eW
ater
and
Was
tew
ater
(Pro
ject
48.6
5O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
3511
.70
Aqu
atri
ne)—
Pac
kage
BM
OD
MO
D-w
ide
Wat
eran
dW
aste
wat
er(P
roje
ct17
4.25
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.18
32.2
6A
quat
rine
)—P
acka
geC
MO
DN
orth
woo
dH
eadq
uart
ers
161.
52O
n—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—M
OD
Por
tsm
outh
Hou
sing
227
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
MO
DA
llenb
y/C
onna
ught
1,25
7.05
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
MO
DR
AF
Cos
ford
and
Shaw
bury
Fam
ily15
.00
OV
——
——
——
—1.
882.
072.
102.
022.
031.
872.
06Q
uart
ers
MO
DR
AF
Los
siem
outh
Fam
ilyQ
uart
ers
33.5
0O
n—
——
——
——
1.52
3.93
3.94
3.94
3.98
4.10
4.49
MO
DSt
rate
gic
Seal
ift
(Ro-
Ro
Fer
ries
)19
5.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
28.8
029
.52
30.2
625
.97
MO
DSk
ynet
51,
079.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
30.9
040
.78
—M
OD
Tor
nado
GR
4Si
mul
ator
54.1
6O
V—
——
——
——
——
—4.
418.
459.
099.
33M
OD
Tri
Serv
ice
Mat
eria
lsH
andl
ing
Serv
ice
35.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
—7.
007.
007.
007.
007.
007.
00M
OD
Nav
alC
omm
unic
atio
ns58
.49
On
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
367.
067.
15M
OD
Wat
tish
amM
arri
edQ
uart
ers
13.0
4O
V—
——
——
——
——
21.5
82.
203.
473.
713.
67
3639101004 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 26 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
2006
–07
2007
–08
2008
–09
2009
–10
2010
–11
2011
–12
2012
–13
2013
–14
2014
–15
2015
–16
2016
–17
2017
–18
2018
–19
2019
–20
2020
–21
2021
–22
2022
–23
2023
–24
2024
–25
2025
–26
2026
–27
2027
–28
2028
–29
2029
–30
2030
–31
2031
–32
2032
–33
2033
–34
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
2.22
2.49
2.83
3.21
3.61
3.81
3.86
3.91
3.96
4.01
4.06
4.11
4.16
4.22
4.27
4.32
4.38
4.43
4.49
4.55
4.60
4.66
4.72
4.78
4.43
——
—6.
607.
007.
227.
367.
517.
667.
817.
978.
138.
308.
468.
648.
818.
999.
179.
369.
559.
749.
9410
.14
10.3
410
.55
8.58
——
——
—3.
393.
463.
543.
603.
673.
753.
823.
893.
974.
054.
134.
214.
294.
374.
464.
554.
634.
724.
824.
915.
005.
102.
16—
——
——
5.78
6.13
6.22
6.30
6.39
6.47
6.56
6.65
6.73
6.82
6.91
7.00
7.10
7.19
7.28
7.38
7.48
7.57
7.76
7.77
7.88
0.66
——
——
——
2.81
3.26
3.72
3.97
4.03
4.09
4.15
4.21
4.28
4.34
4.41
4.47
4.54
4.61
4.68
4.75
4.82
4.89
4.96
5.04
5.11
5.19
5.71
——
——
—3.
263.
313.
363.
413.
463.
523.
573.
633.
683.
743.
763.
853.
913.
974.
044.
104.
164.
224.
294.
354.
424.
493.
73—
——
——
17.2
217
.65
18.0
918
.54
19.0
019
.47
19.9
920
.52
21.0
721
.63
22.2
122
.81
23.4
224
.06
24.7
125
.38
26.0
726
.78
27.5
128
.27
29.0
429
.84
30.6
631
.51
——
——
1.07
9.07
10.9
511
.83
12.4
413
.52
13.7
914
.07
14.3
514
.64
14.9
315
.23
15.5
415
.85
16.1
716
.49
16.8
217
.16
17.5
117
.86
18.2
218
.59
18.9
619
.34
19.7
316
.20
12.5
212
.77
46.9
947
.62
48.2
748
.44
45.8
243
.53
44.0
844
.62
29.9
619
.19
19.3
4—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
8.92
8.96
9.01
9.05
9.10
9.14
9.10
9.05
9.00
8.95
8.90
8.85
8.79
8.73
8.68
8.62
8.56
8.50
8.45
8.39
8.32
8.26
4.13
——
——
—41
.76
42.8
243
.66
44.5
245
.39
46.2
847
.19
48.1
249
.07
50.0
351
.01
52.0
253
.04
54.0
855
.14
9.22
——
——
——
——
——
——
3.36
3.38
3.40
3.42
3.44
3.46
3.47
3.49
3.51
3.53
3.55
3.57
3.59
3.61
3.63
3.64
3.66
3.68
3.70
——
——
——
——
—33
.21
50.6
152
.35
61.5
664
.69
65.4
469
.07
70.4
373
.45
73.9
477
.28
77.0
780
.50
82.4
685
.63
84.8
688
.88
88.1
091
.34
90.0
798
.88
99.1
310
0.01
103.
8410
3.12
105.
8810
7.57
111.
473.
813.
944.
014.
094.
174.
254.
344.
424.
514.
604.
704.
794.
894.
995.
095.
205.
305.
415.
536.
30—
——
——
——
—11
.28
11.4
711
.67
11.7
611
.90
12.1
312
.24
12.3
812
.63
12.5
912
.63
12.8
813
.13
13.3
913
.65
13.9
214
.19
14.4
714
.75
15.0
415
.33
15.6
415
.94
16.2
616
.57
16.9
017
.23
7.28
10.8
511
.52
18.9
319
.24
19.5
619
.89
20.2
320
.58
20.9
321
.30
21.6
722
.05
22.4
422
.85
23.2
623
.68
24.1
124
.56
25.0
125
.48
25.9
526
.44
26.9
5—
——
——
10.1
210
.86
11.1
311
.41
11.7
011
.99
12.2
912
.60
12.9
113
.23
13.5
613
.90
14.2
514
.61
14.9
715
.35
2.62
——
——
——
——
——
—7.
507.
687.
878.
078.
278.
488.
698.
919.
139.
369.
599.
8310
.08
6.63
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
3.52
3.56
3.61
3.65
1.72
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—13
.07
13.3
713
.79
14.2
814
.77
15.1
815
.78
15.4
215
.96
16.5
617
.10
18.0
018
.48
18.9
819
.50
20.0
420
.60
8.39
——
——
——
——
——
16.8
211
.25
16.4
810
.94
16.1
210
.61
15.7
910
.25
16.0
210
.19
16.6
910
.31
17.1
610
.67
17.6
710
.99
18.0
211
.52
18.2
711
.70
18.4
511
.60
18.5
511
.55
18.5
311
.59
18.5
011
.63
75.7
776
.45
77.7
979
.26
79.7
280
.67
82.3
882
.91
95.3
595
.88
99.8
010
0.88
101.
4110
0.89
104.
3010
5.40
107.
0910
6.69
107.
3173
.57
76.8
247
.53
50.9
550
.67
48.4
4—
——
20.1
420
.98
19.7
420
.02
19.6
118
.47
14.7
711
.75
11.9
912
.25
12.5
26.
33—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—31
.77
32.4
833
.21
33.9
634
.72
35.5
036
.30
37.1
237
.96
38.8
139
.68
40.5
841
.50
42.4
243
.38
44.3
545
.35
46.3
747
.41
48.4
849
.57
50.6
934
.55
——
——
—11
.67
11.9
612
.23
12.5
112
.79
13.0
813
.37
13.6
713
.98
14.3
014
.62
14.9
515
.28
15.6
315
.98
16.3
416
.71
17.0
817
.47
17.8
618
.26
18.6
719
.10
17.8
2—
——
—32
.26
32.9
933
.73
34.4
935
.27
36.0
636
.87
37.7
038
.55
39.4
240
.30
41.2
142
.14
43.0
944
.06
45.0
546
.06
47.1
048
.16
49.2
450
.35
51.4
852
.64
53.8
2—
——
—9.
6521
.00
24.0
028
.00
35.0
041
.12
42.6
143
.30
44.0
044
.72
45.4
646
.22
47.0
047
.79
48.6
149
.44
50.3
051
.18
52.0
853
.00
53.9
554
.92
55.9
156
.93
57.9
839
.02
——
—2.
862.
862.
892.
912.
942.
962.
983.
013.
033.
063.
093.
113.
143.
153.
163.
183.
193.
203.
223.
233.
233.
263.
273.
283.
303.
32—
134.
8322
7.18
268.
2731
4.37
349.
6738
1.92
334.
8032
2.03
328.
6833
1.44
325.
2132
6.01
332.
1033
8.31
344.
6735
1.17
357.
8036
4.57
371.
4737
8.47
385.
4839
2.88
400.
2540
7.73
415.
3342
3.01
430.
7643
8.59
2.20
2.16
2.18
2.20
2.18
2.16
2.13
2.11
2.09
2.06
2.04
2.01
1.99
1.96
1.94
1.91
1.88
1.85
1.82
——
——
——
——
—4.
564.
534.
534.
544.
554.
574.
574.
584.
594.
614.
614.
58—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—25
.17
25.6
025
.96
27.0
125
.84
26.9
422
.97
25.0
523
.74
24.0
824
.39
26.6
025
.18
25.8
026
.03
28.4
026
.94
27.5
021
.13
——
——
——
——
—14
1.62
205.
6222
2.13
222.
8622
3.93
225.
4422
6.68
228.
5823
0.67
233.
5723
9.00
223.
85—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—10
.39
10.6
710
.86
11.0
311
.21
11.3
811
.57
11.7
511
.95
12.1
512
.35
12.5
612
.78
13.0
010
.06
——
——
——
——
——
——
—8.
448.
819.
249.
499.
73—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
7.24
7.34
7.44
11.3
710
.09
10.1
98.
248.
308.
368.
428.
488.
538.
608.
658.
718.
779.
139.
199.
259.
309.
359.
129.
209.
276.
94—
——
3.77
3.87
3.97
4.06
4.17
4.26
4.33
4.41
4.49
4.57
4.66
4.75
4.83
4.95
5.01
5.10
5.19
5.28
5.38
5.47
5.57
5.71
——
——
——
3639101004 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 27
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
Tot
alch
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
geca
pita
lB
alan
cepa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tva
lue
shee
t19
92–9
319
93–9
419
94–9
519
95–9
619
96–9
719
97–9
819
98–9
919
99–0
020
00–0
120
01–0
220
02–0
320
03–0
420
04–0
520
05–0
6D
epar
tmen
tC
omm
issi
onin
gbo
dyP
roje
ctna
me
(£m
illio
ns)
trea
tmen
t(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)
MO
DC
omm
erci
alSa
telli
teC
omm
unic
atio
n2.
50O
V—
——
——
——
——
2.00
2.00
2.00
2.00
—Se
rvic
e—IN
MA
RSA
TM
OD
Def
ence
Fix
edT
elec
omm
unic
atio
nsSe
rvic
e70
.00
OV
——
——
—23
.43
88.6
912
3.27
148.
9217
2.33
150.
3817
2.22
159.
31—
(DF
TS)
MO
DD
efen
ceH
ousi
ngE
xecu
tive
—In
form
atio
n11
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—7.
658.
35—
Syst
ems
(DO
MIS
)M
OD
Ele
ctro
nic
Mes
sagi
ngSy
stem
(Arm
ymai
l)33
.00
OV
——
——
——
2.26
2.26
2.26
2.26
2.26
2.26
2.11
—M
OD
Haz
ardo
usSt
ores
Info
rmat
ion
Syst
em1.
00O
V—
——
—0.
230.
230.
230.
230.
200.
200.
200.
200.
20—
(HSI
S)M
OD
Lyn
xA
ircr
ewT
rain
ing
15.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
3.80
3.80
3.80
3.80
—M
OD
Mar
ine
supp
ort
toR
ange
&A
ircr
ew11
.85
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—5.
755.
78—
Serv
ices
MO
DM
ater
ialH
andl
ing
Equ
ipm
ent
(MH
E)—
12.3
1O
V—
——
——
——
——
—3.
476.
456.
45—
(Fol
low
on)
MO
DR
AF
Fyl
ingd
ales
(Pow
er)
8.02
On
——
——
——
——
3.49
3.63
4.36
3.97
3.75
—M
OD
RA
FL
yneh
amSe
wer
age
4.00
OV
——
——
——
——
—0.
500.
510.
510.
52—
MO
DR
AF
Mai
l12
.00
OV
——
——
—1.
462.
262.
262.
262.
262.
262.
262.
11—
MO
DR
AF
Sent
ryE
3DA
ircr
ew5.
50O
V—
——
——
——
—0.
310.
791.
341.
371.
40—
MO
DT
AF
MIS
(IT
)41
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—19
.20
22.3
7—
MO
DT
idw
orth
Wat
er&
Sew
erag
e(T
ham
es5.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
0.69
0.70
—W
ater
)M
OD
Tri
Serv
ice
Whi
teF
leet
40.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
54.0
054
.00
—M
OD
Yeo
vilt
onF
amily
Qua
rter
s8.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
0.96
1.00
—D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
QE
IIC
onfe
renc
eC
entr
eC
ater
ing
3.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tB
olto
nM
BC
Com
mun
ity
Lea
rnin
gR
esou
rce
Cen
tre
&10
.14
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
651.
32P
rim
ary
Scho
olD
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
Cam
brid
gesh
ire
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
Com
mun
ity
ICT
Net
wor
k11
.94
OV
——
——
——
——
——
0.51
2.76
3.37
3.46
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tC
opel
and
Bor
ough
Cou
ncil
New
Cou
ncil
OY
ces
8.12
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.62
1.37
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tK
ent
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
Stra
tegi
cIC
T7.
47O
V—
——
——
—0.
703.
103.
173.
213.
243.
283.
323.
42D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
LB
Cro
ydon
Cus
tom
erF
ocus
ICT
27.7
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
4.41
11.8
815
.90
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tL
BH
ackn
eyT
echn
olog
y&
Lea
rnin
gC
entr
e14
.40
OV
——
——
——
——
—0.
043.
253.
343.
423.
59D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
LB
Islin
gton
Dep
otse
rvic
es23
.37
OV
——
——
——
10.3
510
.88
11.0
911
.38
11.5
011
.78
12.0
80.
40D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
LB
Lam
beth
LIF
TJo
int
Serv
ice
Cen
tre
4.21
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tL
eice
ster
Cit
yC
ounc
ilL
IFT
Join
tSe
rice
Cen
tre
2.10
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
New
cast
le-u
pon-
Tyn
eC
ity
Cou
ncil
LIF
TJo
int
Serv
ice
Cen
tres
2.56
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
27D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
New
cast
le-u
pon-
Tyn
eC
ity
Cou
ncil
LIF
TJo
int
Serv
ice
Cen
tre
5.30
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tN
orfo
lkC
ount
yC
ounc
ilSa
ltba
rns
1.34
OV
——
——
——
——
0.20
0.20
0.21
0.21
0.21
0.21
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tN
orth
Tyn
esid
eB
orou
ghC
ounc
ilL
IFT
Join
tSe
rvic
eC
entr
es7.
95O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
Nor
thW
iltsh
ire
Dis
tric
tC
ounc
ilC
ounc
ilO
Yce
Acc
omm
odat
ion
7.60
OV
——
——
——
——
—0.
501.
501.
531.
551.
57D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
Nor
wic
hC
ity
Cou
ncil
Nor
wic
hC
onne
ctIC
T12
.60
OV
——
——
——
—1.
601.
641.
651.
671.
691.
711.
73D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
Not
ting
ham
Cit
yC
ounc
ilL
IFT
Join
tSe
rvic
eC
entr
es3.
54O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.24
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tR
edca
r&
Cle
vela
ndB
orou
ghC
ounc
ilO
Yce
Acc
omm
odat
ion
13.7
2O
V—
——
——
——
——
—1.
321.
601.
651.
70
3639101004 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 28 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
2006
–07
2007
–08
2008
–09
2009
–10
2010
–11
2011
–12
2012
–13
2013
–14
2014
–15
2015
–16
2016
–17
2017
–18
2018
–19
2019
–20
2020
–21
2021
–22
2022
–23
2023
–24
2024
–25
2025
–26
2026
–27
2027
–28
2028
–29
2029
–30
2030
–31
2031
–32
2032
–33
2033
–34
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
143.
6235
.91
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
7.63
7.63
7.63
7.63
7.63
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—1.
96—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.20
0.20
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
3.80
3.80
3.80
3.80
3.80
3.80
3.80
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—5.
645.
455.
195.
184.
954.
90—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—6.
456.
616.
776.
94—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
492.
522.
552.
582.
842.
642.
672.
702.
732.
992.
792.
822.
852.
883.
152.
95—
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
520.
530.
540.
540.
550.
560.
560.
570.
580.
580.
590.
600.
610.
620.
630.
630.
640.
65—
——
——
——
——
—1.
96—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.47
1.50
1.53
1.57
1.60
1.64
1.67
1.71
1.75
1.78
1.82
1.86
1.91
1.95
1.99
2.03
2.08
2.13
2.17
1.67
——
——
——
——
23.1
07.
83—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
730.
740.
750.
760.
780.
790.
800.
820.
830.
840.
860.
87—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—54
.00
54.0
054
.00
54.0
05.
00—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.08
1.12
1.13
1.14
1.15
1.17
1.18
1.19
1.20
1.21
1.22
1.24
1.25
1.26
1.27
1.29
1.30
1.31
1.33
1.34
1.35
1.37
1.38
1.39
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.38
1.41
1.44
1.47
1.51
1.54
1.57
1.61
1.64
1.68
1.72
1.75
1.79
1.83
1.87
1.91
1.96
2.00
2.04
2.09
2.13
2.18
1.02
——
——
—3.
513.
563.
613.
672.
79—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.35
1.38
1.41
1.43
1.46
1.49
1.52
1.55
1.58
1.61
1.64
1.67
1.70
1.73
1.77
1.80
1.84
1.87
1.91
1.95
1.20
1.98
2.02
2.06
0.97
——
—3.
463.
503.
553.
59—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—15
.77
15.7
015
.70
3.96
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
3.68
3.77
3.87
3.97
4.06
4.17
4.27
4.38
4.49
4.60
4.71
4.83
4.95
5.08
5.20
5.33
5.47
5.60
5.74
5.89
6.03
6.18
6.34
6.50
6.57
——
—0.
400.
410.
410.
420.
420.
43—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
170.
240.
240.
250.
250.
250.
250.
260.
260.
260.
270.
270.
270.
280.
280.
290.
290.
290.
300.
300.
310.
310.
320.
320.
330.
05—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.41
0.40
0.42
0.43
0.44
0.45
0.46
0.47
0.49
0.50
0.51
0.52
0.54
0.55
0.56
0.58
0.59
0.61
0.62
0.64
0.65
0.67
0.69
0.70
——
——
—0.
070.
290.
300.
310.
310.
320.
330.
340.
350.
350.
360.
370.
380.
390.
400.
410.
420.
430.
440.
450.
460.
480.
490.
500.
510.
39—
0.22
0.22
0.22
0.22
0.23
0.23
0.23
0.24
0.24
0.24
0.25
0.25
0.25
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.16
1.08
1.10
1.13
1.16
1.19
1.22
1.25
1.28
1.31
1.35
1.38
1.41
1.45
1.49
1.52
1.56
1.60
1.64
1.68
1.72
1.77
1.81
1.86
1.90
0.98
—1.
591.
611.
631.
651.
671.
691.
711.
731.
751.
781.
801.
831.
851.
881.
901.
931.
961.
992.
022.
052.
08—
——
——
——
1.76
1.78
1.80
1.82
1.85
1.87
1.90
1.92
1.95
1.98
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.25
0.25
0.26
0.27
0.27
0.28
0.29
0.29
0.30
0.31
0.32
0.32
0.33
0.34
0.35
0.36
0.37
0.38
0.38
0.39
0.40
0.41
0.42
0.44
0.33
——
—1.
741.
801.
851.
911.
962.
022.
082.
152.
212.
282.
342.
412.
492.
562.
642.
722.
802.
882.
973.
063.
150.
54—
——
——
—
3639101004 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 29
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
Tot
alch
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
geca
pita
lB
alan
cepa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tva
lue
shee
t19
92–9
319
93–9
419
94–9
519
95–9
619
96–9
719
97–9
819
98–9
919
99–0
020
00–0
120
01–0
220
02–0
320
03–0
420
04–0
520
05–0
6D
epar
tmen
tC
omm
issi
onin
gbo
dyP
roje
ctna
me
(£m
illio
ns)
trea
tmen
t(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tSh
eYel
dC
ity
Cou
ncil
Hea
rtof
the
Cit
yO
Yce
s17
.24
OV
——
——
——
——
—3.
473.
613.
753.
864.
06D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
Stok
e-on
-Tre
ntC
ity
Cou
ncil
Ben
tile
eD
istr
ict
Join
tSe
rvic
eC
entr
e13
.68
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
17D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
Tra
Vor
dM
etro
polit
anB
orou
ghC
ounc
ilC
ivic
Cen
tre
OY
ceA
ccom
mod
atio
n16
.40
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
501.
101.
14D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
Avo
nSo
mer
set
&G
louc
este
rshr
eF
ire
&R
escu
eF
ire
Tra
inin
gF
acili
ty16
.90
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
102.
102.
20A
utho
riti
esD
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
Cor
nwal
lCou
nty
Cou
ncil
Cor
nwal
lFir
eSt
atio
ns12
.26
OV
——
——
——
——
—0.
711.
271.
511.
421.
57D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
Gre
ater
Man
ches
ter
Cou
nty
Fir
eSe
rvic
eSt
retf
ord
Div
isio
nalH
eadq
uart
ers
and
Fir
e4.
79O
V—
——
——
——
0.57
0.63
0.64
0.64
0.65
0.66
0.67
Stat
ion
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tL
anca
shir
eF
ire
and
Res
cue
Serv
ice
Div
isio
nalH
Qan
dtw
ofir
est
atio
ns5.
56O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
0.55
0.58
0.59
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tL
ondo
nF
ire
&E
mer
genc
yP
lan
Fir
eV
ehic
les
&E
quip
men
t45
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
1.40
11.1
011
.30
11.7
012
.00
12.7
0D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
Nor
thY
orks
hire
Fir
ean
dR
escu
eSe
rvic
eF
ire
Tra
inin
gF
acili
tyan
dF
ire
Stat
ion
6.36
OV
——
——
——
——
——
0.77
0.77
0.87
0.91
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tT
yne
and
Wea
rF
ire
and
Civ
ilD
efen
ceA
utho
rity
New
HQ
and
com
mun
ity
fire
stat
ions
29.1
4O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
823.
58D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
LB
Cam
den
Cha
lcot
sE
stat
e66
.40
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tC
oven
try
Cit
yC
ounc
ilN
ewH
omes
for
Old
PF
ISc
hem
e21
.80
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tD
erby
Cit
yC
ounc
ilSo
cial
Hou
sing
9.91
OV
——
——
——
——
—0.
720.
220.
350.
360.
37D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
LB
Islin
gton
Stre
etP
rope
rtie
sII
151.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
LB
Islin
gton
Stre
etP
rope
rtie
sI
89.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
6.05
6.09
6.39
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tL
BH
amm
ersm
ith
&F
ulha
mF
utur
eSe
rvic
esfo
rO
lder
Peo
ple
2.33
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.01
0.01
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tL
BT
ower
Ham
lets
Bar
kant
ine
Ene
rgy
1.60
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tL
BN
ewha
mC
anni
ngT
own
41.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
944.
57D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
Rea
ding
Bor
ough
Cou
ncil
Nor
thW
hitl
ey30
.70
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
4.22
6.00
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tL
eeds
Cit
yC
ounc
ilSw
arcl
iVe
113.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
3.02
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tM
anch
este
rC
ity
Cou
ncil
Man
ches
ter
Dom
esti
cE
nerg
ySe
rvic
es2.
82O
V—
——
——
——
0.04
0.48
0.47
0.47
0.49
0.50
0.50
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tM
anch
este
rC
ity
Cou
ncil
Ard
wic
kH
RA
PF
I30
.80
OV
——
——
——
——
——
0.00
1.91
2.24
2.37
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tN
ED
erby
shir
eD
istr
ict
Cou
ncil
Hol
mw
ood
Pro
ject
1.75
OV
——
——
——
0.00
0.04
0.05
0.05
0.05
0.05
0.05
0.05
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tSa
ndw
ellM
BC
Haw
thor
nF
ield
s61
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
07D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
Selb
yD
istr
ict
Cou
ncil
”Sel
by,S
herb
urn
and
Tad
cast
erP
FI”
16.3
2O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
000.
02D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
War
ring
ton
Bor
ough
Cou
ncil
Ans
onan
dB
lenh
eim
Clo
se25
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.01
0.05
Dep
t.fo
rC
omm
unit
esan
dL
ocal
Gov
tO
ldha
mP
FI
2Sh
elte
red
Hou
sing
Pro
ject
148.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
ept.
for
Com
mun
ites
and
Loc
alG
ovt
Cro
ydon
New
for
Old
7.64
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veSt
irlin
gC
ounc
ilB
alfr
on16
.20
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veE
ast
Ren
frew
shir
eC
ounc
ilE
ast
Ren
frew
shir
eSc
hool
sP
PP
113
.30
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veC
ity
ofG
lasg
owC
ounc
ilG
lasg
owSc
hool
s20
5.80
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veF
alki
rkC
ounc
ilF
alki
rkSc
hool
sP
PP
170
.10
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veF
ife
Cou
ncil
Fif
eSc
hool
sP
PP
180
.70
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veH
ighl
and
Cou
ncil
Hig
hlan
dSc
hool
sP
PP
117
.70
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veW
est
Lot
hian
Cou
ncil
Wes
tL
othi
anSc
hool
sP
PP
127
.80
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
3639101004 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 30 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
2006
–07
2007
–08
2008
–09
2009
–10
2010
–11
2011
–12
2012
–13
2013
–14
2014
–15
2015
–16
2016
–17
2017
–18
2018
–19
2019
–20
2020
–21
2021
–22
2022
–23
2023
–24
2024
–25
2025
–26
2026
–27
2027
–28
2028
–29
2029
–30
2030
–31
2031
–32
2032
–33
2033
–34
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
4.25
4.38
4.51
4.65
4.79
4.93
5.08
5.23
5.39
5.55
5.72
5.89
6.07
6.25
6.44
6.63
6.83
7.03
7.24
7.46
7.68
7.91
8.15
8.40
7.29
——
—1.
991.
991.
981.
971.
961.
991.
992.
001.
931.
901.
932.
022.
071.
991.
921.
992.
182.
392.
152.
011.
831.
911.
861.
881.
72—
——
1.15
1.16
1.18
1.19
1.21
1.22
1.24
1.25
1.27
1.29
1.30
1.32
1.34
1.36
1.38
1.40
1.42
1.44
1.46
1.50
0.60
0.77
——
——
——
2.20
2.30
2.30
2.40
2.50
2.50
2.60
2.60
2.70
2.80
2.80
2.90
3.00
3.00
3.00
3.20
3.20
3.30
3.40
3.50
3.60
——
——
——
—1.
591.
611.
631.
661.
681.
701.
731.
751.
781.
811.
831.
861.
891.
921.
951.
982.
012.
052.
082.
112.
15—
——
——
——
0.68
0.69
0.70
0.71
0.72
0.73
0.74
0.75
0.76
0.77
0.78
0.80
0.81
0.82
0.83
0.85
0.86
0.66
——
——
——
——
——
0.60
0.61
0.61
0.62
0.63
0.64
0.65
0.66
0.66
0.67
0.68
0.69
0.70
0.71
0.72
0.73
0.74
0.76
0.77
0.78
0.79
0.80
0.82
0.83
0.84
——
—13
.00
13.5
013
.90
14.3
014
.70
15.2
015
.60
16.1
015
.60
17.1
017
.60
18.1
018
.60
16.8
0—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
930.
960.
981.
001.
031.
051.
081.
111.
141.
161.
191.
221.
251.
281.
321.
351.
381.
421.
451.
49—
——
——
——
—3.
623.
663.
703.
743.
783.
823.
873.
913.
964.
014.
054.
104.
154.
204.
264.
314.
374.
424.
484.
544.
604.
670.
79—
——
——
6.64
7.32
8.47
9.51
9.76
9.85
9.94
10.0
310
.12
10.2
210
.31
10.4
110
.52
10.6
210
.73
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
2.30
5.69
5.86
5.86
6.03
6.21
6.40
6.59
6.80
7.00
7.22
7.44
7.67
7.91
8.16
8.42
8.69
8.96
9.25
9.55
9.86
10.1
710
.51
10.8
511
.20
11.5
72.
990.
370.
370.
380.
380.
390.
390.
390.
400.
400.
410.
420.
420.
430.
430.
440.
440.
450.
460.
460.
470.
480.
480.
490.
500.
510.
52—
—10
.40
18.9
820
.80
22.7
224
.69
26.5
527
.45
27.8
228
.19
28.5
828
.98
29.3
829
.80
30.2
330
.66
31.1
139
.79
——
——
——
——
——
—7.
738.
388.
558.
748.
848.
949.
049.
159.
269.
389.
499.
619.
749.
869.
9910
.13
10.2
710
.41
10.5
510
.70
10.8
511
.01
11.1
711
.34
11.5
111
.69
11.8
712
.05
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—5.
005.
135.
225.
315.
415.
515.
615.
725.
835.
946.
056.
176.
296.
416.
536.
666.
796.
937.
067.
207.
357.
507.
657.
817.
978.
13—
—6.
076.
136.
206.
286.
356.
426.
506.
586.
666.
756.
836.
927.
017.
117.
217.
307.
417.
517.
627.
737.
847.
968.
088.
208.
338.
468.
59—
4.47
6.86
7.21
7.52
7.88
8.00
8.12
8.25
8.38
8.51
8.65
8.79
8.93
9.08
9.23
9.38
9.54
9.70
9.87
10.0
410
.21
10.3
910
.58
10.7
710
.96
11.1
611
.36
11.5
70.
490.
500.
500.
490.
510.
510.
510.
520.
520.
520.
530.
530.
530.
540.
540.
540.
55—
——
——
——
——
——
4.41
4.38
4.39
4.44
4.48
4.53
4.55
4.60
4.64
4.70
4.72
4.77
4.82
4.88
4.92
4.96
5.01
5.08
5.12
5.17
5.23
5.30
5.34
5.40
5.46
5.54
5.59
—0.
050.
050.
050.
050.
050.
050.
06—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
5.70
6.20
6.80
7.30
7.30
7.50
7.60
7.80
7.90
8.00
8.20
8.30
8.40
8.60
8.70
8.90
9.00
9.10
9.30
9.50
9.60
9.80
9.90
5.60
5.50
——
—0.
130.
320.
450.
540.
560.
570.
580.
600.
610.
630.
650.
660.
680.
700.
710.
730.
750.
770.
790.
810.
830.
850.
870.
890.
910.
930.
960.
980.
250.
300.
400.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
390.
39—
5.63
8.01
9.69
11.4
112
.67
13.2
713
.44
13.6
113
.78
13.9
514
.13
14.3
114
.49
14.6
714
.85
15.0
415
.23
15.4
215
.61
15.8
116
.01
16.2
116
.41
16.6
216
.83
17.0
417
.25
——
0.08
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.95
0.36
0.95
0.78
0.96
0.97
0.97
0.97
0.98
0.98
0.99
0.99
0.99
1.00
1.00
1.01
1.01
1.02
1.02
1.03
1.03
1.04
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
3639101004 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 31
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
Tot
alch
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
geca
pita
lB
alan
cepa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tva
lue
shee
t19
92–9
319
93–9
419
94–9
519
95–9
619
96–9
719
97–9
819
98–9
919
99–0
020
00–0
120
01–0
220
02–0
320
03–0
420
04–0
520
05–0
6D
epar
tmen
tC
omm
issi
onin
gbo
dyP
roje
ctna
me
(£m
illio
ns)
trea
tmen
t(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veA
berd
eens
hire
Cou
ncil
Abe
rdee
nshi
reSc
hool
sP
PP
115
.50
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veE
dinb
urgh
Cou
ncil
Edi
nbur
ghSc
hool
sP
PP
!80
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veM
idlo
thia
nC
ounc
ilM
idlo
thia
nSc
hool
sP
PP
136
.40
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veE
ast
Lot
hian
Cou
ncil
Eas
tL
othi
anSc
hool
sP
PP
46.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Abe
rdee
nshi
reC
ounc
ilA
berd
eens
hire
Scho
ols
PP
P2
65.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Eas
tR
enfr
ewsh
ire
Cou
ncil
Eas
tR
enfr
ewsh
ire
Scho
ols
PP
P2
50.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Ren
frew
shir
eC
ounc
ilR
enfr
ewsh
ire
Scho
ols
110.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Nor
thL
anar
kshi
reC
ounc
ilN
orth
Lan
arks
hire
Scho
ols
148.
30O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Arg
yll&
But
eC
ounc
ilA
rgyl
l&B
ute
Scho
ols
90.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Fif
eC
ounc
ilF
ife
Scho
ols
PP
P2
Exp
andi
ngH
oriz
ons
66.7
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—N
ewC
omm
unit
ySc
hool
sSc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Eas
tA
yrsh
ire
Cou
ncil
Eas
tA
yrsh
ire
Scho
ols
74.3
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Hig
hlan
dC
ounc
ilH
ighl
and
Scho
ols
PP
P2
134.
50O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Mid
loth
ian
Cou
ncil
Mid
loth
ian
Scho
ols
PP
P2
50.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Nor
thA
yrsh
ire
Cou
ncil
Nor
thA
yrsh
ire
Par
tner
ship
sfo
rSc
hool
s83
.50
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veSo
uth
Lan
arks
hire
Cou
ncil
Sout
hL
anar
kshi
reSc
hool
s39
4.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veSt
irlin
gC
ounc
ilSt
irlin
gSc
hool
s83
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veA
ngus
Cou
ncil
Ang
usSc
hool
s45
.69
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veSo
uth
Ayr
shir
eC
ounc
ilSo
uth
Ayr
shir
eSc
hool
sP
PP
76.2
8O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Mor
ayC
ounc
ilM
oray
ITIn
tegr
ated
Edu
cati
on5.
60O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—m
anag
emen
tse
rvic
esSc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Hig
hlan
dC
ounc
ilH
ighl
and
IS/I
TSe
rvic
es13
.40
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veA
rgyl
l&B
ute
Cou
ncil
Arg
yll&
But
eW
aste
Man
agem
ent
15.6
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Dun
dee
Cit
yC
ounc
ilB
aldo
vie
43.4
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Dum
frie
s&
Gal
low
ayD
umfr
ies
&G
allo
way
Was
te25
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veA
ngus
Cou
ncil
Ang
usA
92*
53.7
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Per
th&
Kin
ross
Cou
ncil
Per
th&
Kin
ross
oYce
20.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Stra
thcl
yde
Pol
ice
Pol
ice
For
ceT
rain
ing
Cen
tre
20.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Scot
tish
Chi
ldre
nsR
epor
ter
Adm
inis
trat
ion
SCR
A—
Inte
grat
edIn
form
atio
nSy
stem
1.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veSc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
M6D
BF
O96
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veSc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
M77
(*in
clud
ing
Gla
sgow
Sout
hern
Orb
ital
)13
0.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veSc
otti
shP
riso
nSe
rvic
eK
ilmar
nock
pris
on32
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veSc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Skye
Bri
dge
(now
nolo
nger
aP
PP
)23
.60
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veH
ighl
ands
&Is
land
sA
irpo
rtL
tdIn
vern
ess
Air
port
(HIA
L)
(now
nolo
nger
a9.
50O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—P
PP
)Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Scot
tish
Wat
erH
ighl
and
32.7
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Scot
tish
Wat
erT
ay84
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veSc
otti
shW
ater
Abe
rdee
n56
.60
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veSc
otti
shW
ater
Mor
ay60
.10
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veSc
otti
shW
ater
AV
SE(A
lmon
dval
eSe
afiel
d)10
5.10
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veSc
otti
shW
ater
Lev
enm
outh
46.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Scot
tish
Wat
erD
alm
uir
32.2
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Scot
tish
Wat
erD
aldo
wie
71.3
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Scot
tish
Wat
erM
SI(M
eado
wfie
ld)
61.3
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Fur
ther
and
Hig
her
Edu
cati
onF
undi
ngC
ounc
ilSt
irlin
gC
olle
ge2.
90O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Fur
ther
and
Hig
her
Edu
cati
onF
undi
ngC
ounc
ilW
est
Lot
hian
Col
lege
15.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Fur
ther
and
Hig
her
Edu
cati
onF
undi
ngC
ounc
ilN
orth
Ayr
shir
eC
olle
ge9.
80O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SA
yrsh
ire
&A
rran
Cro
ssho
use
Mat
erni
ty20
.80
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Ayr
shir
e&
Arr
anE
ast
Ayr
shir
eC
omm
unit
yH
ospi
tal
9.10
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Ayr
shir
e&
Arr
anIr
vine
—nu
rsin
gho
me
3.80
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Ayr
shir
e&
Arr
anSa
ltco
ats
-eld
erly
care
2.50
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Dum
frie
s&
Gal
low
ayP
rovi
sion
ofM
ater
nity
&D
ayC
are
serv
ices
9.80
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Gra
mpi
anK
inca
rdin
eC
omm
unit
yH
ospi
tal
3.80
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Gre
ater
Gla
sgow
Stob
hill
Loc
alF
oren
sic
Uni
t17
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Gre
ater
Gla
sgow
Gar
tnav
elR
oyal
Hos
pita
l19
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Gre
ater
Gla
sgow
Stob
hill
&V
icto
ria
AC
AD
s17
6.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
3639101004 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 32 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
2006
–07
2007
–08
2008
–09
2009
–10
2010
–11
2011
–12
2012
–13
2013
–14
2014
–15
2015
–16
2016
–17
2017
–18
2018
–19
2019
–20
2020
–21
2021
–22
2022
–23
2023
–24
2024
–25
2025
–26
2026
–27
2027
–28
2028
–29
2029
–30
2030
–31
2031
–32
2032
–33
2033
–34
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
3639101004 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 33
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
Tot
alch
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
geca
pita
lB
alan
cepa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tva
lue
shee
t19
92–9
319
93–9
419
94–9
519
95–9
619
96–9
719
97–9
819
98–9
919
99–0
020
00–0
120
01–0
220
02–0
320
03–0
420
04–0
520
05–0
6D
epar
tmen
tC
omm
issi
onin
gbo
dyP
roje
ctna
me
(£m
illio
ns)
trea
tmen
t(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Gre
ater
Gla
sgow
Uni
vH
osp
210
bed
unit
11.6
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SG
reat
erG
lasg
owS.
Gla
sgow
Uni
Hos
HIS
0.30
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Gre
ater
Gla
sgow
Lar
kfiel
d9.
40O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SG
reat
erG
lasg
owG
lasg
owR
IC
arpa
rk9.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SG
reat
erG
lasg
owY
orkh
illH
IS3.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SG
reat
erG
lasg
owSG
H—
Ger
iatr
icm
edic
ine
11.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SG
reat
erG
lasg
owD
arnl
eyN
ursi
ngH
ome
3.50
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Gre
ater
Gla
sgow
Mea
rnsk
irk
Ger
iatr
icca
re2.
40O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SG
reat
erG
lasg
owR
uchi
llN
ursi
ngH
ome
3.30
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Gre
ater
Gla
sgow
Rut
herg
len
Nur
sing
Hom
e5.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SG
reat
erG
lasg
owSh
ettl
esto
nN
ursi
ngH
ome
3.80
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Hig
hlan
dN
ewC
raig
sH
ospi
tal
14.4
2O
n—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SH
ighl
and
Eas
ter
Ros
sP
CC
entr
e8.
83O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SH
ighl
and
Mid
Arg
yllC
omm
Hos
p17
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Lan
arks
hire
”HIS
,Lan
arks
hire
”2.
50O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SL
anar
kshi
reP
atie
ntM
anSy
stem
4.40
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Lan
arks
hire
Hai
rmyr
esH
ospi
tal
68.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SL
anar
kshi
reW
isha
wG
ener
al12
1.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Lan
arks
hire
Ston
ehou
seH
ospi
tal
3.82
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Lan
arks
hire
BU
PA
Car
eH
omes
2.10
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Lot
hian
Roy
alIn
firm
ary
ofE
dinb
urgh
206.
00O
n—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SL
othi
anT
ippe
thill
(Bat
hgat
e)7.
30O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SL
othi
anF
erry
field
Hou
se7.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SL
othi
anE
llen’
sG
len
Hou
se2.
70O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SL
othi
anF
indl
ayH
ouse
4.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Lot
hian
PA
CS
7.50
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Lot
hian
CT
&M
RI
Scan
syst
em2.
20O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
SL
othi
anE
nerg
yM
ansy
stem
3.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Lot
hian
HIS
12.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
ST
aysi
deC
arse
view
Cen
tre
10.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
NH
ST
aysi
deF
orfa
r&
Kir
riem
uir
CR
C12
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Tay
side
Uni
vers
ity
Hos
pita
ls-s
mal
lpro
ject
s12
.10
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
HS
Lot
hian
&F
orth
Val
ley
Clin
ical
Was
teD
ispo
sal
4.50
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veN
orth
ern
Tru
sts
Clin
ical
Was
teD
ispo
sal
6.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Scot
tish
Exe
cuti
veSo
uth
Ayr
shir
eC
ounc
ilSo
uth
Ayr
shir
eSc
hool
sP
PP
76.2
8O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—Sc
otti
shE
xecu
tive
Dun
dee
Cit
yC
ounc
ilD
unde
eSc
hool
s90
.11
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
DfE
SB
arki
ng&
Dag
enha
mP
FI
Pro
ject
s—G
roup
edSc
hool
s47
.30
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—3.
18D
fES
Bar
nsle
yM
BC
Bar
nsle
ySc
hool
sP
FI
47.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
fES
Bed
ford
shir
eC
ount
yC
ounc
ilM
idB
eds
Upp
erSc
hool
sP
roje
ct24
.20
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
220.
890.
92D
fES
Bex
ley
LB
Bex
lyT
hree
Scho
ols
Pro
ject
35.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
3.12
DfE
SB
irm
ingh
amC
ity
Cou
ncil
Bir
min
gham
Gro
upSc
hool
s1
40.7
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
2.42
7.07
7.44
7.67
7.88
DfE
SB
irm
ingh
amC
ity
Cou
ncil
PP
P2
71.9
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
fES
Bol
ton
MB
CC
astl
eH
illC
omm
unit
yL
earn
ing
Cen
tre
10.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
0.66
1.33
1.37
DfE
SB
rent
—JF
SSc
hool
new
scho
ol38
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
0.29
0.59
0.61
0.63
DfE
SB
righ
ton
and
Hov
eB
righ
ton
&H
ove—
four
scho
ols
24.4
9O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
3.62
3.55
3.39
DfE
SB
rist
olC
ity
Cou
ncil
Scho
ols
Pha
se1A
60.5
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
2.47
DfE
SC
alde
rdal
eG
roup
scho
ols
53.9
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—1.
736.
34D
fES
Lon
don
Bor
ough
ofC
amde
nH
aver
stoc
kSc
hool
PF
I20
.90
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
140.
801.
99D
fES
Che
shir
eC
ount
yC
ounc
ilE
llesm
ere
Por
tSc
hool
s24
.24
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
931.
621.
65D
fES
Cor
nwal
lCou
nty
Cou
ncil
Scho
ols
136
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
—2.
743.
496.
156.
827.
09D
fES
Cor
nwal
lCou
nty
Cou
ncil
”Sch
ools
””2”
48.6
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
854.
34D
fES
Cov
entr
yC
ity
Cou
ncil
Cal
udon
Cas
tle
PF
I24
.30
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.01
0.48
3639101004 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 34 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
2006
–07
2007
–08
2008
–09
2009
–10
2010
–11
2011
–12
2012
–13
2013
–14
2014
–15
2015
–16
2016
–17
2017
–18
2018
–19
2019
–20
2020
–21
2021
–22
2022
–23
2023
–24
2024
–25
2025
–26
2026
–27
2027
–28
2028
–29
2029
–30
2030
–31
2031
–32
2032
–33
2033
–34
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
5.52
5.66
5.71
5.77
5.83
5.88
5.94
6.00
6.06
6.12
6.19
6.25
6.31
6.37
6.44
6.50
6.57
6.63
6.70
6.76
6.83
6.90
6.97
7.04
4.65
——
—1.
836.
407.
117.
087.
107.
177.
197.
087.
027.
177.
247.
197.
056.
887.
047.
347.
297.
077.
067.
297.
577.
807.
807.
677.
146.
751.
67—
3.37
3.53
3.58
3.64
3.69
3.75
3.81
3.87
3.93
3.99
4.06
4.13
4.20
4.27
4.34
4.41
4.49
4.57
4.64
4.73
4.81
4.90
4.98
5.07
5.17
5.26
5.36
5.46
4.98
5.03
5.08
5.14
5.19
5.25
5.31
5.37
5.43
5.49
5.56
5.62
5.69
5.76
5.83
5.91
5.98
6.06
6.14
6.22
6.30
6.38
6.47
6.56
3.88
——
—8.
158.
368.
438.
658.
869.
089.
319.
549.
7810
.03
10.2
810
.53
10.8
011
.07
11.3
411
.63
11.9
212
.22
12.5
212
.83
13.1
513
.48
13.8
214
.17
14.5
2—
——
0.65
4.61
8.14
8.98
9.20
9.31
9.41
9.52
9.63
9.88
10.1
410
.41
10.6
810
.96
11.2
411
.53
11.8
412
.14
12.4
612
.76
12.9
113
.06
13.2
213
.39
13.5
613
.73
13.9
114
.09
1.40
1.43
1.47
1.51
1.54
1.58
1.62
1.66
1.70
1.75
1.79
1.83
1.88
1.93
1.98
2.03
2.08
2.13
2.18
2.24
2.29
2.35
1.20
——
——
—0.
670.
690.
700.
720.
740.
760.
780.
800.
820.
840.
860.
880.
900.
920.
950.
970.
9910
.19
10.4
510
.71
——
——
——
——
3.17
3.21
3.26
3.30
3.35
3.40
3.45
3.50
3.55
3.61
3.66
3.72
3.78
3.84
3.90
3.96
4.03
4.09
4.16
4.23
4.30
4.37
——
——
——
9.91
9.73
9.56
9.40
9.26
9.13
9.00
8.89
8.79
8.70
8.62
8.56
8.50
8.45
8.40
8.37
8.35
8.33
8.33
8.33
8.34
8.36
8.39
8.42
8.47
3.21
——
6.78
6.86
6.90
6.95
6.99
7.04
7.09
7.13
7.18
7.23
7.29
7.34
7.39
7.45
7.50
7.56
7.62
7.67
7.73
7.80
7.86
7.92
7.99
8.05
0.67
——
—2.
242.
252.
272.
282.
302.
322.
342.
352.
372.
392.
412.
432.
442.
462.
482.
502.
522.
542.
562.
572.
592.
612.
632.
651.
11—
——
1.67
1.68
1.71
1.73
1.76
1.78
1.81
1.83
1.86
1.89
1.91
1.94
1.97
2.00
2.02
2.05
2.08
2.11
2.14
2.17
2.20
2.24
2.27
2.30
2.33
2.37
2.40
1.01
7.59
8.09
8.23
8.04
8.06
8.58
8.63
8.75
8.26
8.47
10.1
411
.09
11.4
210
.32
10.0
911
.51
11.3
411
.08
9.66
9.50
——
——
——
——
5.92
9.30
8.23
8.33
8.43
8.53
8.32
8.10
8.20
8.31
8.42
8.53
8.64
8.76
8.88
9.01
9.13
9.26
9.39
9.53
9.67
9.03
9.16
9.30
9.44
9.59
——
2.77
3.14
3.11
3.08
3.05
3.04
3.01
2.99
2.98
2.98
2.96
2.96
2.96
2.97
2.96
2.97
2.98
3.00
3.01
3.03
3.05
3.09
3.10
3.13
3.17
3.21
3.24
3.28
3639101004 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 35
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
Tot
alch
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
geca
pita
lB
alan
cepa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tva
lue
shee
t19
92–9
319
93–9
419
94–9
519
95–9
619
96–9
719
97–9
819
98–9
919
99–0
020
00–0
120
01–0
220
02–0
320
03–0
420
04–0
520
05–0
6D
epar
tmen
tC
omm
issi
onin
gbo
dyP
roje
ctna
me
(£m
illio
ns)
trea
tmen
t(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)
DfE
SL
ondo
nB
orou
ghO
fC
royd
onA
shbu
rton
Lea
rnin
gV
illag
e24
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
DfE
SD
arlin
gton
Bor
ough
Cou
ncil
Dar
lingt
onF
ive
Scho
ols
Pro
ject
34.9
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.42
DfE
SD
erby
Cit
yD
erby
Gro
uped
Scho
ols
31.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
297.
43D
fES
Der
bysh
ire
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
Gro
uped
Scho
ols
29.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
3.59
4.14
4.15
DfE
SD
erby
shir
eC
ount
yC
ounc
ilSc
hool
sP
hase
238
.20
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
36D
fES
Dev
onC
ount
yC
ounc
ilE
xete
rG
roup
Scho
ols
PF
I10
0.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—4.
25D
fES
Dor
set
The
Sir
John
Col
fox
Scho
ol13
.90
OV
——
——
——
—1.
472.
232.
262.
302.
382.
432.
44D
fES
Dud
ley
MB
CD
udle
yG
rid
for
Lea
rnin
g(S
choo
lsIT
32.2
5O
V—
——
——
—0.
073.
955.
175.
175.
175.
335.
355.
42N
etw
ork)
DfE
SD
udle
yM
BC
Par
agon
18.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
1.66
2.21
2.33
DfE
SE
alin
g,L
BG
roup
scho
ols
33.1
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
604.
10D
fES
Eal
ing,
LB
Gro
upsc
hool
s61
.80
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
DfE
SE
ast
Rid
ing
ofY
orks
hire
Bri
dlin
gton
Scho
ols
26.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
3.51
3.89
3.95
DfE
SE
ast
Suss
exC
CG
roup
scho
ols
19.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
—0.
092.
033.
413.
533.
643.
74D
fES
Enfi
eld
LB
Hig
hlan
dsSc
hool
21.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
—1.
322.
502.
532.
552.
582.
65D
fES
Enfi
eld
LB
Join
tSc
hool
sP
FI
(wit
hL
BN
ewha
m)
37.7
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
0.67
2.15
3.75
DfE
SE
ssex
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
Deb
den
Par
kH
igh
Scho
ol12
.03
OV
——
——
——
——
1.86
1.90
1.95
2.00
2.05
2.10
DfE
SE
ssex
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
Cla
cton
Seco
ndar
ySc
hool
s35
.70
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
742.
044.
98D
fES
Gat
eshe
adC
ounc
ilG
ates
head
Scho
ols
PF
IP
roje
ct64
.20
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
DfE
SH
arin
gey
Gro
uped
seco
ndar
ysc
hool
spr
ojec
t40
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—8.
55D
fES
Har
row
Spec
ialS
choo
lsP
FI
70.1
4O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
0.76
0.53
1.49
DfE
SH
eref
ords
hire
Cou
ncil
Whi
tecr
oss
Scho
olP
FI
20.7
9O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
fES
LB
Hill
ingd
onB
arnh
illSc
hool
63.3
0O
V—
——
——
——
0.95
1.79
2.04
2.13
2.30
2.25
2.99
DfE
SK
ent
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
Swan
scom
beP
FI
12.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
—0.
882.
142.
132.
20D
fES
Ken
tC
ount
yC
ounc
il6
Gro
uped
scho
ols
PF
I92
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
DfE
SK
ings
ton
upon
Hul
lCit
yC
ounc
ilV
icto
ria
Doc
kP
rim
ary
Scho
ol3.
90O
V—
——
——
—0.
320.
310.
430.
420.
61D
fES
Kir
klee
sM
CK
irkl
ees
Gro
uped
Scho
ols
PP
P58
.70
OV
——
——
——
——
——
3.65
7.33
9.15
9.59
DfE
SK
irkl
ees
MC
Spec
ialS
choo
lsP
PP
23.5
6O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
fES
Lon
don
Bor
ough
ofL
ambe
thL
illia
nB
aylis
Scho
ol—
PF
ISc
hem
e13
.10
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.53
2.13
DfE
SL
ondo
nB
orou
ghof
Lam
beth
Lam
beth
Con
nect
edL
earn
ing
proj
ect
(IC
T7.
07O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.06
inSc
hool
s)D
fES
Lan
cash
ire
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
Fle
etw
ood
Hig
hSc
hool
PF
ISc
hem
e13
.40
OV
——
——
——
——
——
0.90
1.57
1.58
1.59
DfE
SL
eeds
Cit
yC
ounc
ilC
ardi
nalH
eena
nH
igh
Scho
ol8.
70O
V—
——
——
——
——
0.41
0.72
0.73
0.76
0.78
DfE
SL
eeds
Cit
yC
ounc
ilL
eeds
1(7
)Sc
hool
s38
.30
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
235.
045.
77D
fES
Lee
dsC
ity
Cou
ncil
Lee
ds2
(10)
Pri
mar
ySc
hool
s35
.70
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
00D
fES
Lee
dsC
ity
Cou
ncil
Lee
ds3
&4
Seco
ndar
yan
dP
ost
1697
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
DfE
SL
ewis
ham
Lew
isha
m—
Cat
erin
gP
FI
Pro
ject
4.30
OV
——
——
——
—5.
44—
—5.
45—
5.42
—D
fES
LO
ND
ON
BO
RO
UG
HO
FL
EW
ISH
AM
GR
OU
PE
DSC
HO
OL
S54
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
MO
DE
RN
ISA
TIO
NP
RO
JEC
TD
fES
Lin
coln
shir
eC
ount
yC
ounc
il)E
stim
ated
byL
A)
Lin
coln
shir
eSc
hool
sG
roup
edP
FI
Sche
me
12.8
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
—0.
652.
162.
662.
90D
fES
Liv
erpo
olL
iver
pool
—Sp
eke/
Gar
ston
Lif
elon
g20
.40
OV
——
——
——
——
——
1.81
—3.
453.
50L
earn
ing
Cen
tre
DfE
SL
iver
pool
Cit
yC
ounc
ilG
roup
Scho
ols
74.7
4O
V—
——
——
——
——
1.88
5.15
9.60
11.5
111
.80
DfE
SM
anch
este
rC
ity
Cou
ncil
Tem
ple
Pri
mar
ySc
hool
3.00
OV
——
——
——
——
—0.
320.
460.
470.
480.
53D
fES
Man
ches
ter
Cit
yC
ounc
ilW
righ
tR
obin
son
Spor
tsC
olle
ge35
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
DfE
SM
erto
nL
BC
Mer
ton
Gro
uped
Scho
ols
PF
IP
roje
ct56
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
576.
168.
47D
fES
New
cast
leC
ity
Cou
ncil
New
cast
leSc
hool
sP
FI
1P
roje
ct42
.80
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
505.
306.
10D
fES
New
ham
LB
Gro
upsc
hool
s59
.30
OV
——
——
——
——
——
2.40
3.00
3.10
4.00
3639101004 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 36 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
2006
–07
2007
–08
2008
–09
2009
–10
2010
–11
2011
–12
2012
–13
2013
–14
2014
–15
2015
–16
2016
–17
2017
–18
2018
–19
2019
–20
2020
–21
2021
–22
2022
–23
2023
–24
2024
–25
2025
–26
2026
–27
2027
–28
2028
–29
2029
–30
2030
–31
2031
–32
2032
–33
2033
–34
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
2.21
2.24
2.26
2.29
2.31
2.34
2.37
2.39
2.42
2.45
2.48
2.51
2.55
2.58
2.61
2.65
2.68
2.72
2.76
2.79
2.83
2.87
2.91
2.95
3.00
3.04
3.09
3.13
4.75
4.68
4.61
4.54
4.49
4.43
4.38
4.34
4.30
4.27
4.24
4.22
4.20
4.19
4.18
4.17
4.17
4.18
4.18
4.19
4.21
4.23
4.25
4.28
2.50
——
—5.
505.
385.
285.
205.
115.
044.
974.
904.
854.
804.
754.
714.
674.
644.
624.
604.
584.
574.
574.
574.
574.
584.
594.
614.
633.
49—
—4.
204.
234.
274.
314.
344.
384.
424.
464.
504.
544.
584.
624.
664.
704.
744.
784.
824.
864.
914.
954.
995.
045.
080.
43—
——
—4.
474.
514.
554.
594.
634.
674.
714.
754.
794.
834.
874.
924.
965.
005.
055.
095.
145.
185.
235.
275.
325.
365.
415.
465.
514.
63—
—10
.27
12.8
512
.85
12.8
412
.98
12.8
812
.82
12.8
612
.79
12.7
012
.77
12.7
312
.59
12.6
712
.65
12.4
912
.45
12.2
912
.23
12.3
012
.13
11.8
911
.74
11.9
011
.89
11.5
311
.17
4.60
2.50
2.41
2.44
2.47
2.51
2.54
2.57
2.61
2.64
2.68
2.72
2.76
2.80
2.84
2.88
2.92
2.97
3.01
3.06
3.11
3.16
3.21
3.26
0.83
——
——
5.49
5.58
4.41
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
382.
422.
472.
522.
572.
632.
682.
742.
792.
852.
912.
973.
033.
093.
163.
223.
293.
363.
433.
503.
573.
653.
723.
803.
880.
33—
—4.
154.
264.
344.
404.
504.
604.
704.
804.
905.
005.
105.
205.
305.
505.
605.
705.
805.
906.
106.
206.
306.
506.
606.
806.
90—
——
0.70
6.60
8.50
8.60
8.70
8.80
8.90
9.10
9.20
9.30
9.50
9.60
9.70
9.90
10.1
010
.20
10.4
010
.50
10.7
010
.90
11.1
011
.30
11.5
011
.70
11.9
0—
——
3.99
4.04
4.08
4.13
4.18
4.23
4.28
4.34
4.39
4.45
4.51
4.57
4.63
4.69
4.75
4.82
4.88
4.95
5.02
5.09
5.17
5.24
0.41
——
——
—3.
894.
014.
094.
174.
264.
354.
444.
534.
624.
724.
824.
925.
025.
135.
245.
355.
465.
575.
691.
94—
——
——
——
—2.
682.
722.
762.
792.
832.
882.
922.
963.
013.
053.
103.
153.
203.
253.
313.
363.
423.
483.
541.
80—
——
——
——
—4.
364.
574.
624.
674.
724.
784.
834.
894.
955.
015.
075.
145.
205.
275.
345.
415.
495.
565.
645.
725.
805.
895.
974.
46—
——
—2.
152.
212.
262.
322.
372.
432.
492.
562.
622.
692.
752.
822.
892.
973.
043.
123.
193.
273.
36—
——
——
——
——
5.33
5.36
5.38
5.41
5.43
5.46
5.48
5.51
5.53
5.56
5.59
5.62
5.64
5.67
5.70
5.73
5.75
5.78
5.81
5.84
5.86
5.89
5.92
5.95
6.03
6.14
6.25
6.37
—4.
556.
857.
397.
477.
537.
597.
657.
727.
787.
857.
927.
998.
078.
148.
228.
308.
388.
468.
558.
638.
728.
818.
919.
009.
109.
205.
298.
658.
748.
848.
959.
059.
169.
279.
389.
509.
629.
749.
869.
9910
.12
10.2
510
.39
10.5
310
.68
10.8
35.
49—
——
——
——
—2.
122.
142.
162.
182.
212.
232.
252.
282.
312.
332.
362.
392.
412.
442.
472.
502.
542.
572.
602.
632.
672.
702.
742.
782.
822.
852.
891.
472.
102.
612.
632.
662.
692.
722.
742.
772.
802.
832.
872.
902.
932.
973.
003.
043.
073.
113.
153.
193.
233.
273.
313.
363.
400.
57—
—3.
123.
173.
243.
303.
363.
433.
493.
563.
633.
713.
783.
863.
944.
024.
104.
194.
282.
18—
——
——
——
——
—2.
222.
252.
252.
252.
252.
252.
252.
252.
252.
252.
252.
252.
252.
252.
252.
252.
252.
252.
252.
252.
251.
13—
——
——
—1.
328.
4610
.88
11.0
011
.12
11.2
511
.38
11.5
111
.65
11.7
911
.94
12.0
812
.24
12.3
912
.56
12.7
212
.89
13.0
713
.25
13.4
313
.62
13.8
214
.02
14.2
214
.43
14.6
514
.87
15.1
00.
530.
560.
590.
530.
520.
500.
490.
470.
460.
440.
430.
420.
400.
390.
380.
370.
360.
350.
340.
33—
——
——
——
—9.
8310
.05
10.1
810
.31
10.4
510
.59
10.7
310
.88
11.0
311
.18
11.3
411
.50
11.6
711
.84
12.0
112
.19
12.3
712
.56
12.7
512
.95
13.1
513
.36
13.5
713
.79
14.0
214
.24
14.4
86.
031.
692.
902.
882.
862.
842.
822.
802.
792.
772.
762.
752.
742.
742.
732.
732.
732.
732.
732.
732.
742.
752.
752.
772.
782.
791.
15—
—2.
162.
132.
182.
232.
292.
342.
372.
392.
402.
412.
422.
442.
492.
562.
642.
712.
742.
752.
762.
762.
722.
041.
401.
43—
——
—2.
082.
102.
122.
132.
152.
172.
190.
74—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—1.
571.
581.
591.
571.
581.
621.
641.
661.
681.
701.
721.
741.
761.
781.
801.
831.
851.
871.
901.
931.
951.
982.
012.
040.
67—
—0.
800.
820.
840.
860.
880.
900.
930.
950.
971.
001.
031.
051.
081.
111.
141.
171.
211.
241.
281.
310.
45—
——
——
——
5.85
5.92
6.00
6.08
6.16
6.24
6.32
6.41
6.50
6.59
6.68
6.78
6.88
6.98
7.08
7.19
7.30
7.41
7.52
7.64
7.76
7.88
8.01
8.14
8.27
2.80
——
3.01
4.90
4.95
5.00
5.05
5.10
5.15
5.20
5.26
5.32
5.38
5.44
5.50
5.56
5.62
5.69
5.76
5.83
5.90
5.97
6.05
6.12
6.20
6.28
6.37
6.45
2.18
——
4.79
11.4
413
.89
13.9
914
.11
14.2
214
.33
14.4
514
.58
14.7
014
.83
14.9
615
.09
15.2
315
.37
15.5
215
.67
15.8
215
.98
16.1
416
.30
16.4
716
.64
16.8
217
.00
17.1
817
.37
5.64
—5.
995.
87—
6.27
—6.
937.
107.
287.
46—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.71
3.75
6.52
6.54
6.61
6.69
6.78
6.86
6.94
7.02
7.10
7.19
7.28
7.37
7.47
7.56
7.66
7.76
7.87
7.97
8.08
8.19
8.31
8.43
8.55
8.67
8.80
8.93
3.05
3.09
3.13
3.17
3.21
3.26
3.30
3.35
3.40
3.45
3.50
3.55
3.61
3.67
3.73
3.79
3.86
3.92
3.99
4.07
4.14
4.22
4.30
4.38
4.47
4.56
1.94
—3.
573.
61—
3.64
3.72
3.79
3.83
3.88
3.92
3.97
4.02
4.07
4.12
4.17
4.22
4.28
4.33
4.39
4.45
4.51
4.57
4.63
4.70
4.76
2.01
——
—11
.74
11.8
711
.70
11.5
411
.39
11.2
611
.18
11.0
310
.93
10.8
410
.76
10.6
910
.64
10.5
910
.55
10.5
310
.51
10.5
010
.50
10.5
110
.53
10.5
610
.59
10.6
410
.69
4.57
——
0.54
0.21
0.21
0.22
0.22
0.23
0.23
0.24
0.25
0.25
0.26
0.27
0.27
0.28
0.29
0.29
0.30
0.31
0.32
0.32
——
——
——
——
—2.
914.
034.
074.
134.
194.
244.
284.
334.
374.
424.
474.
524.
574.
634.
684.
744.
794.
854.
914.
985.
045.
105.
175.
245.
310.
33—
7.66
7.32
7.41
7.49
7.60
7.78
7.91
8.04
8.16
8.31
8.43
8.77
9.03
9.40
9.66
9.94
10.0
410
.08
10.4
49.
9910
.55
11.6
112
.30
2.82
——
——
6.80
6.90
7.00
7.10
7.20
7.40
7.60
7.90
8.00
8.10
8.00
8.00
7.90
7.80
7.70
7.60
7.50
7.50
7.30
6.80
5.80
5.00
5.30
——
——
—3.
103.
133.
173.
213.
243.
283.
323.
363.
403.
443.
493.
533.
583.
623.
673.
723.
773.
83—
——
——
——
——
—
3639101004 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 37
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
Tot
alch
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
geca
pita
lB
alan
cepa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tva
lue
shee
t19
92–9
319
93–9
419
94–9
519
95–9
619
96–9
719
97–9
819
98–9
919
99–0
020
00–0
120
01–0
220
02–0
320
03–0
420
04–0
520
05–0
6D
epar
tmen
tC
omm
issi
onin
gbo
dyP
roje
ctna
me
(£m
illio
ns)
trea
tmen
t(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)
DF
ES
New
ham
LB
Join
tSc
hool
sP
FI
(wit
hE
nfiel
d)50
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
2.20
0.80
DfE
SN
orfo
lkC
ount
yC
ounc
ilN
orw
ich
Are
aSc
hool
sP
FI
42.8
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
fES
Nor
thT
ynes
ide
Cou
ncil
Scho
ols
for
the
Fut
ure
PF
IP
roje
ct26
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
472.
623.
68D
fES
Nor
thY
orks
hire
CC
Nor
thY
orks
hire
Scho
ols
PF
IP
roje
ct7.
20O
V—
——
——
——
——
—1.
141.
081.
151.
16D
fES
Nor
tham
pton
shir
eW
oold
ale
Cen
tre
23.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—1.
482.
90D
fES
Nor
tham
pton
shir
eN
orth
ampt
onSc
hool
sR
evie
w19
1.20
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—3.
36D
fES
Not
ting
ham
shir
eC
CE
ast
Lea
kesc
hool
s16
.50
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—1.
332.
002.
02D
fES
Not
ting
ham
shir
eC
CB
asse
tlaw
scho
ols
112.
10O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.56
DfE
SO
ldha
mM
etro
polit
anB
orou
ghC
ounc
ilO
ldha
mSe
cond
ary
Scho
ols
Pro
ject
58.2
1O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
fES
Pet
erbo
roug
hC
ity
Cou
ncil
Pet
erbo
roug
hSe
cond
ary
Scho
ols
Sche
me
71.4
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
fES
Por
tsm
outh
(Est
imat
edU
Cpa
ymen
tsfr
omL
A)
Milt
oncr
oss
Scho
ol12
.40
OV
——
——
——
——
1.24
1.92
1.97
2.01
2.03
2.04
DfE
SR
edbr
idge
Red
brid
ge—
Oak
sP
ark
Scho
ol20
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
—0.
141.
582.
302.
362.
77D
fES
Red
car
&C
leve
land
Bor
ough
Cou
ncil
Gro
uped
Scho
ols
PF
IP
roje
ct48
.90
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
DfE
SL
ondo
nB
orou
ghof
Ric
hmon
dup
onT
ham
esL
ondo
nB
orou
ghof
Ric
hmon
dup
on23
.80
OV
——
——
——
——
——
0.34
1.55
2.36
2.62
Tha
mes
—P
rim
ary
Scho
ols
PF
ID
fES
Roc
hdal
eR
ochd
ale
Aim
ing
Hig
h44
.67
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
DfE
SR
othe
rham
MB
CG
roup
edSc
hool
sP
FI
97.3
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
463.
90D
fES
Salf
ord
Cit
yC
ounc
ilSa
lfor
dSE
NSc
hool
sP
roje
ct17
.64
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.17
2.25
DfE
SSa
lfor
dC
ity
Cou
ncil
Salf
ord
Hig
hSc
hool
sP
roje
ct37
.88
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
DfE
SSa
ndw
ellM
BC
Sand
wel
lSch
ools
21.1
2O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
582.
24D
fES
SheY
eld
Cit
yC
ounc
ilSc
hool
sP
FI
Pha
seI
47.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
4.56
7.10
7.18
7.26
7.31
DfE
SSh
eYel
dC
ity
Cou
ncil
Scho
ols
PF
IP
hase
226
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—3.
41D
fES
SheY
eld
Cit
yC
ounc
ilSc
hool
sP
FI
Pha
se3
52.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
fES
Slou
ghB
CSl
ough
Gro
uped
Scho
ols
PF
IC
ontr
act
44.9
4O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
fES
Sout
hT
ynes
ide
Bol
don
Scho
ol17
.75
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
DfE
SSo
utha
mpt
onC
ity
Cou
ncil
Scho
ols
PF
I42
.65
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—3.
745.
155.
22D
fES
StaV
ords
hire
LE
AT
wo
scho
ols
13.7
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
1.76
2.19
2.26
2.21
2.18
DfE
SSt
ockt
on-o
n-T
ees
Bro
ugh
Cou
ncil
Tw
osc
hool
sw
Ingl
eby
Bar
wic
k10
.70
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
881.
561.
62D
fES
Stok
e-on
-Tre
ntSt
oke
Scho
ols
PF
I98
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
2.97
8.46
8.85
9.98
11.2
012
.78
DfE
SSu
nder
land
Cit
yC
ounc
ilSa
ndhi
llSc
hool
17.6
6O
V—
——
——
——
——
—1.
182.
282.
242.
47D
fES
Swin
don
Nor
thSw
indo
nP
FI
proj
ect
62.8
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.38
DfE
ST
ames
ide
MB
CH
atte
rsle
ySc
hool
sP
FI
Pro
ject
16.8
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
—0.
822.
632.
632.
66D
fES
Bor
ough
ofT
elfo
rd&
Wre
kin
Had
ley
Lea
rnin
g&
Jigs
awP
roje
ct70
.01
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
DfE
ST
orba
yC
ounc
ilT
wo
scho
olre
build
14.4
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
0.81
1.56
1.64
1.69
1.74
DfE
ST
ower
Ham
lets
LB
Gro
upsc
hool
s91
.68
OV
——
——
——
——
——
4.53
7.17
8.97
9.85
DfE
ST
ower
Ham
lets
LB
Mul
berr
ySc
hool
22.4
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
—0.
470.
571.
311.
94D
fES
Wal
sall
MB
CSt
Tho
mas
Mor
e8.
20O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
1.70
1.85
1.87
DfE
SW
alth
amF
ores
tG
roup
Scho
ols
PF
I53
.60
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.94
3.35
DfE
SL
ondo
nB
orou
ghof
Wal
tham
For
est
Lam
mas
Scho
ol18
.50
OV
——
——
——
——
—1.
381.
392.
422.
312.
58D
fES
Wes
tSu
ssex
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
Cra
wle
ySc
hool
s59
.28
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.15
4.70
DfE
SW
iltsh
ire
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
3N
orth
Wilt
shir
eSe
cond
ary
Scho
ols
26.8
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
1.75
4.30
4.35
4.41
4.47
DfE
SW
irra
lMB
CW
irra
lSch
ools
’PF
I58
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
0.40
2.95
7.75
8.09
DfE
SW
orce
ster
shir
eC
ount
yC
ounc
ilB
rom
sgro
veSc
hool
sP
FI
64.4
1O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
fES
Cit
yof
Yor
kC
ounc
ilY
ork
Scho
ols
PF
I16
.54
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—3.
55D
fES
Lan
cash
ire
BSF
Wav
e114
7.90
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
DfE
SB
rist
olB
SFW
ave1
95.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
fES
Bra
dfor
dB
SFW
ave1
71.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—
3639101004 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 38 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
2006
–07
2007
–08
2008
–09
2009
–10
2010
–11
2011
–12
2012
–13
2013
–14
2014
–15
2015
–16
2016
–17
2017
–18
2018
–19
2019
–20
2020
–21
2021
–22
2022
–23
2023
–24
2024
–25
2025
–26
2026
–27
2027
–28
2028
–29
2029
–30
2030
–31
2031
–32
2032
–33
2033
–34
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
3.90
3.94
3.99
4.03
4.08
4.13
4.18
4.23
4.28
4.33
4.39
4.44
4.50
4.56
4.62
4.68
4.75
4.81
4.88
4.95
5.02
5.10
——
——
——
0.13
1.15
4.77
5.51
5.57
5.63
5.68
5.74
5.80
5.86
5.93
5.99
6.06
6.13
6.20
6.27
6.34
6.42
6.49
6.57
6.65
6.74
6.82
6.91
7.00
7.09
2.39
—3.
903.
933.
963.
994.
034.
064.
094.
134.
164.
204.
244.
284.
314.
354.
404.
444.
484.
524.
574.
614.
664.
714.
764.
814.
864.
91—
—1.
171.
171.
181.
191.
201.
211.
211.
221.
231.
241.
251.
261.
271.
271.
281.
291.
301.
311.
321.
331.
34—
——
——
——
2.81
3.03
3.21
3.24
3.38
3.49
3.52
3.56
3.61
3.65
3.69
3.74
3.78
3.83
3.87
3.92
3.97
4.02
4.08
4.13
4.19
4.24
4.30
1.81
——
——
13.4
716
.12
21.9
623
.42
23.6
623
.92
24.1
824
.45
24.7
225
.00
25.2
925
.58
25.8
926
.20
26.5
126
.84
27.1
727
.51
27.8
728
.22
28.5
928
.97
29.3
629
.75
30.1
630
.58
31.0
031
.44
2.04
2.09
2.08
2.10
2.13
2.15
2.18
2.20
2.23
2.25
2.28
2.31
2.34
2.37
2.40
2.43
2.46
2.49
2.53
2.56
2.60
0.88
——
——
——
2.07
12.5
016
.71
16.7
116
.71
16.7
116
.71
16.7
116
.71
16.7
116
.71
16.7
116
.71
16.7
116
.71
16.7
116
.71
16.7
116
.71
16.7
116
.71
16.7
116
.71
16.7
116
.71
16.7
14.
16—
—0.
927.
257.
317.
377.
447.
507.
577.
647.
717.
787.
857.
938.
008.
088.
168.
258.
338.
428.
518.
608.
698.
798.
898.
999.
097.
67—
2.84
10.9
37.
387.
537.
667.
737.
817.
887.
968.
048.
128.
218.
308.
388.
488.
578.
678.
768.
868.
979.
079.
189.
299.
419.
529.
649.
779.
892.
052.
072.
082.
092.
112.
122.
142.
152.
162.
182.
192.
212.
222.
242.
262.
272.
292.
302.
32—
——
——
——
——
2.69
2.75
2.82
2.89
2.96
3.03
3.11
3.19
3.26
3.35
3.43
3.52
3.60
3.69
3.79
3.88
3.98
4.08
4.18
4.28
4.39
4.50
4.61
4.73
4.85
4.97
5.09
—3.
847.
707.
747.
787.
837.
877.
927.
968.
018.
068.
118.
168.
218.
268.
328.
378.
438.
488.
548.
608.
668.
728.
788.
848.
908.
979.
03—
2.85
2.90
2.94
2.99
3.04
3.09
2.98
3.03
3.08
3.13
3.18
3.24
3.29
3.35
3.41
3.46
3.52
3.59
3.65
3.71
3.78
3.84
3.91
3.98
4.05
4.13
0.76
—0.
384.
297.
007.
107.
217.
327.
447.
567.
687.
807.
938.
078.
208.
348.
498.
648.
798.
959.
119.
289.
459.
639.
8110
.00
10.1
99.
813.
99—
9.58
12.2
012
.35
12.2
912
.44
12.6
012
.76
12.9
313
.10
13.2
813
.46
13.6
413
.83
14.0
314
.22
14.4
314
.64
14.8
515
.07
15.3
015
.53
15.7
616
.00
16.2
516
.51
16.7
717
.04
17.3
12.
752.
702.
662.
622.
582.
542.
512.
482.
452.
432.
412.
392.
382.
362.
352.
342.
342.
342.
342.
342.
342.
352.
362.
37—
——
——
—3.
035.
245.
305.
365.
415.
475.
535.
605.
665.
735.
805.
875.
946.
016.
086.
166.
246.
326.
406.
496.
576.
666.
756.
856.
942.
372.
292.
432.
452.
472.
502.
522.
552.
582.
602.
632.
662.
692.
722.
752.
782.
812.
842.
872.
912.
942.
983.
023.
051.
80—
——
—7.
397.
487.
567.
657.
737.
827.
918.
008.
098.
188.
278.
368.
468.
558.
658.
748.
848.
949.
049.
145.
33—
——
——
——
3.50
3.54
3.59
3.63
3.68
3.73
3.78
3.83
3.89
3.94
4.00
4.05
4.11
4.17
4.23
4.30
4.36
4.43
4.49
4.56
4.64
4.71
4.78
4.86
1.90
——
—2.
346.
746.
806.
876.
947.
017.
087.
157.
237.
307.
387.
467.
557.
637.
727.
817.
908.
008.
098.
198.
298.
408.
508.
618.
722.
90—
—2.
144.
466.
026.
076.
126.
176.
226.
276.
326.
376.
436.
486.
546.
606.
666.
726.
786.
846.
916.
977.
047.
117.
187.
257.
327.
397.
477.
540.
962.
332.
352.
362.
382.
402.
422.
442.
462.
482.
512.
532.
552.
582.
602.
632.
652.
682.
702.
722.
762.
792.
822.
852.
881.
70—
—5.
445.
475.
545.
625.
695.
775.
855.
946.
026.
116.
216.
306.
406.
506.
606.
716.
826.
947.
067.
187.
307.
437.
567.
707.
843.
29—
—2.
052.
001.
951.
901.
861.
821.
781.
741.
711.
671.
641.
611.
581.
551.
531.
501.
481.
461.
441.
429.
60—
——
——
——
1.70
1.75
1.79
1.84
1.88
1.93
1.98
2.03
2.08
2.13
2.18
2.24
2.29
2.35
2.41
2.47
2.53
2.59
2.66
2.73
2.79
2.86
1.22
——
——
—14
.47
12.4
113
.09
13.6
113
.88
14.3
015
.30
16.7
118
.26
20.8
519
.63
21.7
920
.96
21.2
021
.48
19.5
217
.90
17.1
517
.08
6.89
——
——
——
——
2.39
2.44
2.49
2.53
2.58
2.63
2.68
2.73
2.78
2.83
2.89
2.95
3.00
3.06
3.12
3.19
3.25
3.31
3.38
3.45
3.52
1.73
——
——
——
3.93
12.6
313
.98
14.3
314
.69
15.0
615
.43
15.8
216
.21
16.6
217
.03
17.4
617
.90
18.3
418
.80
19.2
719
.75
20.2
520
.75
21.2
721
.81
22.3
522
.91
23.4
824
.07
24.6
76.
32—
2.69
2.75
2.78
2.81
2.85
2.88
2.91
2.95
2.99
3.02
3.06
3.10
3.14
3.18
3.22
3.26
3.31
3.35
3.40
3.44
3.49
3.54
3.59
3.64
3.70
3.75
——
3.38
9.10
9.20
9.30
9.39
9.38
9.14
9.23
9.33
9.42
9.52
9.61
9.70
9.80
9.89
9.99
10.0
810
.18
10.2
710
.37
10.4
610
.56
10.6
510
.61
10.3
010
.39
10.4
810
.57
1.77
1.82
1.86
1.91
1.96
2.00
2.05
2.11
2.16
2.21
2.27
2.32
2.38
2.44
2.50
2.57
2.63
2.70
2.76
2.83
2.90
1.74
——
——
——
11.5
912
.32
12.4
912
.64
12.7
912
.94
13.0
913
.24
13.3
913
.54
13.6
913
.84
13.9
914
.14
14.2
914
.44
14.5
914
.74
14.8
815
.03
15.1
87.
65—
——
——
—2.
372.
022.
032.
062.
082.
102.
132.
152.
182.
202.
232.
252.
282.
302.
332.
352.
382.
412.
432.
462.
492.
522.
55—
——
——
1.89
1.92
1.94
1.96
1.98
2.01
2.03
2.06
2.08
2.11
2.14
2.17
2.20
2.22
2.26
2.29
2.32
2.35
2.39
2.42
2.46
2.49
——
——
——
8.60
8.84
8.68
8.56
8.43
8.30
8.19
8.09
8.00
7.94
7.83
7.76
7.69
7.64
7.59
7.54
7.51
7.48
7.46
7.45
7.44
7.44
7.44
7.45
7.47
7.50
7.53
7.56
2.66
2.66
2.63
2.78
2.68
2.48
2.44
2.60
2.75
2.80
2.80
2.80
2.80
2.77
2.79
2.83
2.86
2.90
2.94
3.11
3.28
3.20
2.62
2.17
0.91
——
—6.
216.
176.
106.
045.
985.
915.
865.
805.
745.
695.
635.
585.
535.
485.
435.
395.
345.
305.
255.
215.
175.
135.
095.
055.
014.
984.
944.
904.
544.
604.
664.
724.
784.
844.
914.
975.
045.
115.
185.
255.
325.
405.
485.
565.
645.
725.
815.
895.
986.
086.
176.
276.
376.
10—
—8.
729.
159.
379.
619.
8510
.09
10.3
510
.61
10.8
711
.14
11.4
211
.71
12.0
012
.30
12.6
112
.92
13.2
513
.58
13.9
214
.26
14.6
214
.99
15.3
615
.74
16.1
45.
51—
——
3.65
8.13
8.20
8.26
8.33
8.39
8.46
8.53
8.59
8.66
8.73
8.80
8.87
8.94
9.01
9.09
9.16
9.23
9.31
9.38
9.46
9.53
9.61
9.69
9.77
9.84
9.92
2.29
2.27
2.24
2.22
2.19
2.18
2.16
2.15
2.13
2.12
2.12
2.11
2.11
2.11
2.11
2.11
2.12
2.13
2.14
2.15
2.16
2.18
2.20
2.22
2.24
2.26
2.29
2.31
——
8.00
8.08
8.16
8.25
8.33
8.42
8.51
8.60
8.70
8.80
8.90
9.00
9.10
9.21
9.32
9.43
9.55
9.67
9.79
9.92
10.0
410
.17
10.3
110
.45
10.5
910
.73
——
13.0
013
.13
13.2
613
.40
13.5
413
.68
13.8
313
.98
14.1
414
.29
14.4
614
.62
14.7
914
.97
15.1
515
.33
15.5
215
.71
15.9
116
.11
16.3
216
.53
16.7
516
.98
17.2
117
.44
——
9.00
10.1
210
.23
10.3
510
.48
10.6
010
.73
10.8
711
.00
11.1
411
.29
11.4
411
.59
11.7
411
.90
12.0
612
.23
12.4
012
.57
12.7
512
.94
13.1
313
.32
13.5
213
.72
13.9
3
3639101004 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 39
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
Tot
alch
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
geca
pita
lB
alan
cepa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tva
lue
shee
t19
92–9
319
93–9
419
94–9
519
95–9
619
96–9
719
97–9
819
98–9
919
99–0
020
00–0
120
01–0
220
02–0
320
03–0
420
04–0
520
05–0
6D
epar
tmen
tC
omm
issi
onin
gbo
dyP
roje
ctna
me
(£m
illio
ns)
trea
tmen
t(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)
OF
MD
FM
NI
DE
CA
LE
lect
roni
cL
ibra
ries
for
Nor
ther
nIr
elan
d10
.20
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
400.
290.
33O
FM
DF
MN
ID
EC
AL
/SE
EL
BL
isbu
rnC
ity
Lib
rary
3.66
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
34O
FM
DF
MN
IH
omefi
rst
Com
mun
ity
HSS
Tru
stC
ontr
act
ener
gyse
rvic
es0.
20O
V—
—0.
250.
250.
250.
250.
25—
——
——
——
OF
MD
FM
NI
Roy
alG
roup
ofH
ospi
tals
HSS
Tru
stC
arP
arki
ng(2
0ye
ars)
2.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
OF
MD
FM
NI
Bel
fast
Cit
yH
ospi
talH
SST
rust
New
rena
ldia
ysis
faci
titi
es.(
Star
t01
.11.
98.
3.30
OV
——
——
——
0.54
1.39
1.49
1.49
1.64
1.54
1.64
1.70
Fin
ish
01.1
1.20
13.C
ontr
act
Gra
ham
Gam
bro)
OF
MD
FM
NI
Cra
igav
onA
rea
Hos
pita
lsH
SST
rust
Con
trac
ten
ergy
serv
ices
0.50
OV
——
—0.
500.
500.
500.
500.
50—
——
——
—O
FM
DF
MN
IU
nite
dH
ospi
tals
HSS
Tru
stN
ewre
nald
ialy
sis
faci
litie
s.C
ontr
act—
2.70
OV
——
——
——
——
0.62
0.62
0.87
0.90
0.91
0.92
Bax
ter
Hea
lthc
are
OF
MD
FM
NI
Bel
fast
Cit
yH
ospi
talH
SST
rust
”Can
cer
cent
re(e
quip
men
t,m
aint
enan
ce42
.21
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—1.
07an
dco
nsum
able
s)”
OF
MD
FM
NI
Alt
nage
lvin
Hos
pita
lHSS
Tru
stSe
rvic
esC
entr
e(N
ewpa
thol
ogy
phar
mac
y15
.20
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
&ch
angi
ngro
oms)
OF
MD
FM
NI
Roy
alG
roup
ofH
ospi
tals
HSS
Tru
stM
anag
edE
quip
men
tSe
rvic
e(M
ES)
/AT
ICS
98.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—O
FM
DF
MN
ID
epar
tmen
tfo
rR
egio
nalD
evel
opm
ent
Roa
dsSe
rvic
eD
BF
O—
Pac
kage
111
8.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
OF
MD
FM
NI
Dri
ver
&V
ehic
leT
esti
ngA
genc
yR
epla
cem
ent
ofV
ehic
leT
est
Equ
ipm
ent
and
24.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
—0.
011.
401.
402.
903.
303.
30re
late
dse
rvic
esO
FM
DF
MN
ID
epar
tmen
tof
Edu
cati
onfo
rN
IC
lass
room
2000
smal
lpri
mar
ies
—O
V—
——
——
——
——
2.49
5.97
7.11
6.95
4.73
OF
MD
FM
NI
Dep
artm
ent
ofE
duca
tion
for
NI
Cla
ssro
om20
00m
ediu
m/la
rge
prim
arie
s—
OV
——
——
——
——
——
5.23
10.7
010
.27
7.63
OF
MD
FM
NI
Dep
artm
ent
ofE
duca
tion
for
NI
Cla
ssro
om20
00po
st-p
rim
ary
&sp
ecia
l—
OV
——
——
——
——
——
1.60
7.05
14.0
414
.72
OF
MD
FM
NI
Dep
artm
ent
ofE
duca
tion
for
NI
Cla
ssro
om20
00w
ide
area
netw
ork
—O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
3.29
15.6
216
.31
OF
MD
FM
NI
Dep
artm
ent
ofE
duca
tion
for
NI
Ref
resh
ofth
epr
imar
yse
rvic
e—
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
OF
MD
FM
NI
Dep
artm
ent
ofE
duca
tion
for
NI
Dru
mgl
ass
Hig
hSc
hool
6.50
OV
——
——
——
——
0.60
1.03
1.03
1.04
1.05
1.06
OF
MD
FM
NI
Dep
artm
ent
ofE
duca
tion
for
NI
StG
enev
ieve
’sH
igh
Scho
ol11
.50
OV
——
——
——
——
—0.
402.
402.
502.
512.
55O
FM
DF
MN
ID
epar
tmen
tof
Edu
cati
onfo
rN
IW
ellin
gton
/Bal
mor
al17
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
—0.
200.
800.
800.
880.
88O
FM
DF
MN
ID
epar
tmen
tof
Edu
cati
onfo
rN
IB
ango
rA
cade
my
&Si
xth
For
mC
olle
ge/
31.7
0O
n—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—N
endr
umH
igh
Scho
olO
FM
DF
MN
ID
epar
tmen
tof
Edu
cati
onfo
rN
IH
oly
Cro
ssC
olle
ge31
.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
OF
MD
FM
NI
Soci
alSe
curi
tyA
genc
ySS
ASt
rate
gic
Par
tner
ship
Con
trac
tw
ith
26.5
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
—3.
475.
994.
704.
00E
DS
OF
MD
FM
NI
Bel
fast
Inst
itut
eof
Fur
ther
and
Hig
her
Edu
cati
onB
elfa
stIn
stit
ue—
Mill
field
20.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
—1.
292.
372.
602.
64(M
illfie
ld)
OF
MD
FM
NI
Nor
thW
est
Inst
itut
eof
Fur
ther
and
Hig
her
Edu
cati
onN
orth
Wes
tIn
stit
ute—
Nor
thla
ndB
uild
ing
10.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
—0.
091.
291.
221.
321.
141.
34O
FM
DF
MN
IO
mag
hC
olle
geof
Fur
ther
and
Hig
her
Edu
cati
onO
mag
hC
olle
ge16
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
OF
MD
FM
NI
Eas
tT
yron
eC
olle
geof
Fur
ther
and
Hig
her
Edu
cati
onE
ast
Tyr
one
Col
lege
—D
unga
nnon
16.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—O
FM
DF
MN
ID
epar
tmen
tfo
rE
mpl
oym
ent
and
Lea
rnin
gD
EL
CIS
(IT
Pro
ject
)—
N/A
——
——
——
——
4.00
4.00
5.00
6.00
6.00
5.51
OF
MD
FM
NI
INV
EST
NI
INV
EST
NI
HE
AD
QU
AR
TE
RS
25.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
2.10
AC
CO
MM
ON
DA
TIO
NO
FM
DF
MN
IW
ater
Serv
ice
Kin
nega
rP
FI
12.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
1.47
2.05
2.59
1.84
1.93
OF
MD
FM
NI
Wat
erSe
rvic
eA
lpha
Pro
ject
110.
00O
n—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—O
FM
DF
MN
IL
and
Reg
istr
yN
orth
ern
Irel
and
LA
ND
WE
B—
OV
——
——
——
—0.
151.
662.
394.
296.
497.
387.
44H
ome
OY
ceH
ome
OY
ceH
ome
OY
ceH
Q(2
Mar
sham
Stre
et)
375.
63O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—3.
5538
.36
3639101004 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 40 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
2006
–07
2007
–08
2008
–09
2009
–10
2010
–11
2011
–12
2012
–13
2013
–14
2014
–15
2015
–16
2016
–17
2017
–18
2018
–19
2019
–20
2020
–21
2021
–22
2022
–23
2023
–24
2024
–25
2025
–26
2026
–27
2027
–28
2028
–29
2029
–30
2030
–31
2031
–32
2032
–33
2033
–34
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
0.33
0.34
0.35
0.36
0.37
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
350.
360.
370.
380.
380.
390.
400.
410.
420.
430.
440.
450.
460.
470.
480.
500.
510.
520.
530.
550.
560.
570.
590.
60—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—1.
731.
761.
801.
831.
861.
891.
12—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.93
0.94
0.95
0.96
0.98
0.99
1.00
0.54
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
4.33
4.37
4.41
4.46
4.50
4.55
4.59
4.64
4.69
4.73
4.78
4.83
4.88
4.93
4.97
5.02
5.07
5.13
5.18
5.23
5.28
5.33
5.39
5.44
4.12
——
—0.
311.
701.
741.
781.
811.
851.
901.
941.
982.
022.
072.
112.
162.
212.
262.
312.
362.
412.
462.
522.
572.
632.
682.
742.
802.
87—
—3.
397.
027.
267.
527.
788.
058.
338.
638.
939.
249.
569.
9010
.25
10.6
010
.98
——
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
102.
304.
209.
2013
.40
13.8
014
.10
14.5
014
.80
16.0
016
.00
16.0
016
.00
16.0
018
.10
18.1
018
.10
18.1
018
.10
20.4
020
.40
20.4
020
.40
20.4
023
.10
23.1
023
.10
23.1
03.
403.
503.
603.
603.
703.
803.
803.
904.
004.
104.
204.
20—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—1.
300.
36—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
100.
57—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—15
.72
15.6
815
.87
15.6
415
.80
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—17
.51
17.2
817
.18
16.5
916
.39
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—5.
777.
978.
098.
128.
15—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.06
1.08
1.10
1.11
1.13
1.15
1.16
1.18
1.20
1.22
1.23
1.25
1.27
1.29
1.31
1.33
1.35
1.37
1.39
1.41
——
——
——
——
2.58
2.62
2.66
2.70
2.74
2.78
2.82
2.87
2.91
2.95
3.00
3.04
3.09
3.13
3.18
3.23
3.28
3.33
3.38
3.43
3.48
——
——
——
—0.
890.
910.
920.
930.
950.
960.
980.
991.
011.
021.
041.
051.
071.
081.
101.
121.
131.
151.
171.
191.
20—
——
——
——
——
4.29
4.35
4.42
4.48
4.55
4.62
4.69
4.76
4.83
4.90
4.98
5.05
5.13
5.20
5.28
5.36
5.44
5.52
5.60
5.69
5.77
5.86
5.95
6.04
6.13
6.22
——
3.85
4.09
4.13
4.19
4.25
4.32
4.38
4.45
4.51
4.58
4.65
4.72
4.79
4.86
4.94
5.01
5.09
5.16
5.24
5.32
5.40
5.48
5.56
5.64
5.73
—1.
952.
002.
082.
171.
87—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
2.65
2.72
2.78
2.85
2.92
3.00
3.07
3.15
3.23
3.31
3.39
3.48
3.56
3.65
3.74
3.84
3.93
4.03
4.13
4.24
4.34
1.60
——
——
——
1.36
1.40
1.43
1.47
1.50
1.54
1.58
1.62
1.66
1.70
1.75
1.79
1.83
1.88
1.93
1.97
2.02
2.07
2.13
2.01
——
——
——
——
2.81
2.88
2.95
3.02
3.10
3.18
3.26
3.34
3.42
3.51
3.59
3.68
3.78
3.87
3.97
4.07
4.17
4.27
4.38
4.49
4.60
4.72
4.83
4.95
5.08
5.21
5.34
5.47
1.81
1.85
1.90
1.95
1.99
2.04
2.09
2.15
2.20
2.26
2.31
2.37
2.43
2.49
2.55
2.62
2.68
2.75
2.82
2.89
2.96
3.03
3.11
3.19
3.27
3.35
3.43
3.52
5.82
5.99
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
4.70
4.81
4.92
5.03
5.14
5.26
5.38
5.50
5.63
5.75
5.89
6.02
6.16
6.30
6.44
6.59
6.75
6.90
7.06
7.22
7.39
7.56
7.74
7.92
——
——
2.40
2.43
2.45
2.48
2.51
2.54
2.57
2.60
2.63
2.67
2.70
2.73
2.77
2.81
2.84
2.88
2.92
2.96
3.00
——
——
——
——
——
—8.
7717
.93
18.1
618
.50
18.7
519
.04
19.3
419
.71
20.0
720
.35
20.6
420
.95
21.2
422
.48
23.6
724
.08
24.4
124
.77
27.6
828
.06
28.4
328
.91
26.5
44.
35—
—5.
005.
105.
205.
305.
405.
50—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—40
.48
40.5
042
.67
43.7
044
.76
45.8
546
.97
48.1
349
.32
50.5
451
.80
53.0
954
.43
55.8
057
.23
58.6
860
.19
61.7
463
.35
64.9
866
.67
68.4
170
.21
72.0
673
.97
——
—
3639101004 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 41
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
Tot
alch
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
geca
pita
lB
alan
cepa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tva
lue
shee
t19
92–9
319
93–9
419
94–9
519
95–9
619
96–9
719
97–9
819
98–9
919
99–0
020
00–0
120
01–0
220
02–0
320
03–0
420
04–0
520
05–0
6D
epar
tmen
tC
omm
issi
onin
gbo
dyP
roje
ctna
me
(£m
illio
ns)
trea
tmen
t(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)
Hom
eO
Yce
Nat
iona
lOV
ende
rM
anag
emen
tSe
rvic
es(N
OM
S)H
MP
Alt
cour
se68
.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hom
eO
Yce
NO
MS
HM
YO
IA
shfie
ld26
.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hom
eO
Yce
NO
MS
HM
PB
ronz
efiel
d43
.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hom
eO
Yce
NO
MS
HM
PD
oveg
ate
64.0
0O
n—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ome
OY
ceN
OM
SH
MP
For
est
Ban
k45
.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hom
eO
Yce
NO
MS
HM
PL
owdh
amG
rang
e25
.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hom
eO
Yce
NO
MS
HM
PP
arc
47.0
0O
n—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—H
ome
OY
ceN
OM
SH
MP
Pet
erbo
roug
h68
.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hom
eO
Yce
NO
MS
HM
PR
yeH
ill37
.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Hom
eO
Yce
Pri
son
Serv
ice
Qua
ntum
ITSe
rvic
es51
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
31.4
933
.95
48.3
555
.75
34.4
536
.48
Hom
eO
Yce
Pri
son
Serv
ice
HE
S1
9.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
—3.
104.
605.
00H
ome
OY
ceP
riso
nSe
rvic
eH
ES
216
.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
—4.
105.
305.
80H
ome
OY
ceId
enti
ty&
Pas
spor
tSe
rvic
eP
ASS
Pro
ject
30.0
0O
V—
——
——
—6.
009.
2015
.40
19.0
019
.80
19.8
020
.70
19.9
0H
ome
OY
ceY
outh
Just
ice
Boa
rdST
CC
ookh
amW
d14
.30
On
——
——
——
5.00
7.00
7.30
7.50
9.30
13.4
013
.80
14.2
0H
ome
OY
ceY
outh
Just
ice
Boa
rdST
CO
nley
Exp
ansi
on18
.90
On
——
——
——
—3.
805.
806.
409.
8011
.30
11.6
011
.90
Hom
eO
Yce
You
thJu
stic
eB
oard
STC
Has
sock
field
15.4
0O
n—
——
——
——
3.20
5.80
6.10
5.70
6.60
6.80
7.00
Hom
eO
Yce
You
thJu
stic
eB
oard
Milt
onK
eyne
sST
C19
.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
7.10
14.7
0H
ome
OY
ceH
ome
OY
ceIT
2000
(Sir
ius)
24.7
0O
FF
——
——
——
——
——
—81
.90
76.3
074
.00
Hom
eO
Yce
Der
bysh
ire
Pol
ice
Ilke
ston
Pol
ice
Stat
ion
3.00
OF
F—
——
——
—0.
650.
500.
500.
500.
500.
500.
500.
50H
ome
OY
ceW
iltsh
ire
Pol
ice
Air
Supp
ort
3.00
OF
F—
——
——
—0.
600.
600.
600.
600.
600.
600.
600.
60H
ome
OY
ceN
orth
umbr
iaP
olic
eM
ount
edF
acili
ties
1.50
OF
F—
——
——
—0.
260.
260.
270.
280.
290.
300.
320.
33H
ome
OY
ceT
ham
esV
alle
yP
olic
eA
bing
don
Are
aD
HQ
8.00
OF
F—
——
——
——
1.21
1.24
1.27
1.31
1.34
1.41
1.48
Hom
eO
Yce
Der
bysh
ire
Pol
ice
Div
isio
nalH
Q16
.40
OF
F—
——
——
—2.
802.
872.
943.
023.
093.
173.
333.
50H
ome
OY
ceD
orse
tP
olic
eR
egio
nalH
Q&
Cit
yP
olic
eSt
atio
ns15
.00
OF
F—
——
——
——
—2.
522.
562.
612.
652.
742.
83H
ome
OY
ceN
orfo
lkP
olic
eC
onst
abul
ary
HQ
,Ope
rati
ons
&C
omm
unic
atio
nsC
entr
e23
.00
OF
F—
——
——
——
——
1.52
5.13
5.14
5.22
5.32
Hom
eO
Yce
Cle
vela
ndP
olic
ean
dD
urha
mC
onst
abul
ary
Fir
earm
sF
acili
ty6.
00O
FF
——
——
——
——
—1.
211.
231.
251.
291.
33H
ome
OY
ceD
yfed
Pow
ysP
olic
eA
utho
rity
Am
man
ford
Pol
ice
Stat
ion
8.00
OF
F—
——
——
——
—0.
580.
590.
590.
600.
610.
62H
ome
OY
ceC
umbr
iaC
onst
abul
ary
Wor
king
ton
Pol
ice
Stat
ion
5.00
OF
F—
——
——
——
——
0.76
0.78
0.81
0.86
0.91
Hom
eO
Yce
Not
ting
ham
shir
eP
olic
eT
raY
cW
ing
and
Veh
icle
sSe
rvic
es20
.00
OF
F—
——
——
——
——
—1.
062.
562.
672.
79H
ome
OY
ceSu
ssex
Pol
ice
Aut
hori
tyC
entr
alis
edC
usto
dySu
ites
17.0
0O
FF
——
——
——
——
——
3.47
6.98
8.14
8.50
Hom
eO
Yce
Che
shir
eP
olic
eA
utho
rity
For
ceH
Q35
.00
OF
F—
——
——
——
——
——
3.20
6.50
5.65
Hom
eO
Yce
N.W
ales
Div
isio
nalH
Q15
.00
OF
F—
——
——
——
——
——
1.62
2.82
2.86
Hom
eO
Yce
Gre
ater
Man
ches
ter
Pro
pert
yR
evie
w—
Div
isio
nal/S
ubD
ivis
iona
l60
.00
OF
F—
——
——
——
——
——
0.02
7.99
8.39
HQ
&P
olic
eSt
atio
nsH
ome
OY
ceW
iltsh
ire
Pol
ice
HQ
19.6
0O
FF
——
——
——
——
——
——
2.70
2.75
Hom
eO
Yce
Glo
uces
ters
hire
Con
stab
ular
yF
orce
HQ
17.0
0O
FF
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.73
3.03
Hom
eO
Yce
Ken
tC
onst
abul
ary
Med
way
22.0
0O
FF
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.42
2.90
Hom
eO
Yce
Gw
ent
Pol
ice
Tst
rad
Myn
ach
Pol
ice
Stat
ion
6.00
OF
F—
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
411.
00H
ome
OY
ceC
hesh
ire
Pol
ice
Aut
hori
tyC
entr
alis
edC
usto
dySu
ites
17.0
0O
FF
——
——
——
——
——
——
3.68
5.68
Hom
eO
Yce
Cle
vela
ndP
olic
eR
atio
nalis
edC
usto
dy29
.00
OF
F—
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.05
Hom
eO
Yce
Ken
tC
onst
abul
ary
Nor
thK
ent
32.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
EF
RA
Env
iron
men
tA
genc
yB
road
land
Flo
odA
llevi
atio
nP
roje
ct16
8.42
OV
——
——
——
——
—1.
721.
901.
691.
521.
41D
efra
Flo
odR
isk
Man
agem
ent
Env
iron
men
tA
genc
yP
even
sey
Bay
Sea
Def
ence
s4.
65O
V—
——
——
——
—1.
101.
311.
431.
811.
871.
91D
efra
Flo
odR
isk
Man
agem
ent
Kaj
ima
Cam
brid
geL
tdP
FI
Eas
tbro
ok18
.21
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
3.24
0.94
Def
raIs
leof
Wig
htC
ount
yC
ounc
ilW
aste
15.9
0O
V—
——
——
1.51
3.55
3.75
4.03
4.36
4.69
4.93
——
Def
raK
irkl
ees
MC
Was
te44
.00
OV
——
——
—6.
307.
307.
607.
808.
008.
009.
00—
—D
efra
Her
efor
d&
Wor
cest
erC
ount
yC
ounc
ilW
aste
80.8
8O
V—
——
——
—3.
4215
.36
17.2
619
.31
21.8
827
.70
——
Def
raSo
uth
Glo
uces
ters
hire
DC
Was
te43
.19
OV
——
——
——
——
6.11
9.45
9.91
10.6
510
.87
—D
efra
Surr
eyC
ount
yC
ounc
ilQ
uest
Was
teD
ispo
salP
roje
ct10
3.00
OV
——
——
——
—5.
0419
.79
20.1
219
.59
20.9
3—
—D
efra
Lei
cest
erIn
tegr
ated
Was
teM
anag
emen
t48
.14
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
3639101004 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 42 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
2006
–07
2007
–08
2008
–09
2009
–10
2010
–11
2011
–12
2012
–13
2013
–14
2014
–15
2015
–16
2016
–17
2017
–18
2018
–19
2019
–20
2020
–21
2021
–22
2022
–23
2023
–24
2024
–25
2025
–26
2026
–27
2027
–28
2028
–29
2029
–30
2030
–31
2031
–32
2032
–33
2033
–34
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
28.8
729
.59
30.3
331
.09
31.8
632
.66
33.4
834
.31
35.1
736
.05
36.9
537
.87
38.8
239
.79
40.7
941
.81
——
——
——
——
——
——
21.0
421
.56
22.1
022
.65
23.2
223
.80
24.4
025
.01
25.6
326
.27
26.9
327
.60
28.2
929
.00
29.7
230
.47
31.2
332
.01
——
——
——
——
——
20.6
221
.14
21.6
722
.21
22.7
723
.33
23.9
224
.52
25.1
325
.76
26.4
027
.06
27.7
428
.43
29.1
429
.87
30.6
231
.38
32.1
732
.97
33.8
034
.64
35.5
1—
——
——
18.9
319
.41
19.8
920
.39
20.9
021
.42
21.9
622
.51
23.0
723
.64
24.2
424
.84
25.4
626
.10
26.7
527
.42
28.1
128
.81
29.5
330
.27
——
——
——
——
20.0
220
.52
21.0
421
.56
22.1
022
.66
23.2
223
.80
24.4
025
.01
25.6
326
.27
26.9
327
.60
28.2
929
.00
29.7
330
.47
31.2
3—
——
——
——
——
13.8
214
.17
14.5
214
.88
15.2
615
.64
16.0
316
.43
16.8
417
.26
17.6
918
.13
18.5
919
.05
19.5
320
.02
——
——
——
——
——
——
32.3
533
.16
33.9
934
.83
35.7
136
.60
37.5
138
.45
39.4
140
.40
41.4
142
.44
43.5
044
.59
45.7
146
.85
——
——
——
——
——
——
25.7
126
.35
27.0
127
.69
28.3
829
.09
29.8
230
.56
31.3
332
.11
32.9
133
.74
34.5
835
.44
36.3
337
.24
38.1
739
.12
40.1
041
.10
42.1
343
.19
44.2
6—
——
——
14.9
615
.34
15.7
216
.11
16.5
116
.93
17.3
517
.78
18.2
318
.68
19.1
519
.63
20.1
220
.62
21.1
421
.67
22.2
122
.77
23.3
323
.92
——
——
——
——
50.1
554
.31
30.5
818
.61
18.0
418
.45
4.62
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—5.
205.
405.
605.
806.
106.
306.
606.
70—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—6.
006.
306.
506.
807.
107.
407.
708.
108.
408.
809.
209.
609.
60—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
14.6
015
.00
15.4
015
.80
16.2
016
.60
17.0
0—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
12.6
013
.50
13.8
014
.10
14.4
014
.70
15.0
0—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
7.40
8.20
8.40
8.60
8.80
9.00
9.20
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—15
.10
15.5
015
.90
16.3
016
.70
17.1
017
.50
17.9
018
.30
18.7
019
.20
19.6
020
.00
20.4
020
.80
21.2
021
.60
22.0
022
.40
22.8
023
.20
23.6
0—
——
——
—75
.80
77.7
079
.70
81.7
083
.70
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
500.
500.
500.
500.
600.
500.
500.
500.
500.
500.
500.
500.
500.
510.
500.
500.
500.
500.
500.
50—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
340.
350.
370.
380.
39—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.51
1.55
1.59
1.63
1.67
1.71
1.76
1.78
1.85
1.89
1.94
1.99
2.04
2.09
2.14
2.19
2.25
2.30
2.36
2.42
2.48
——
——
——
—3.
583.
673.
773.
863.
964.
064.
164.
264.
374.
484.
594.
704.
824.
945.
065.
195.
325.
455.
595.
73—
——
——
——
—2.
882.
922.
973.
033.
083.
133.
193.
253.
303.
363.
433.
493.
553.
623.
693.
763.
833.
903.
974.
054.
134.
21—
——
——
—5.
375.
425.
475.
525.
575.
635.
685.
745.
805.
865.
925.
986.
056.
116.
186.
256.
326.
406.
476.
556.
636.
71—
——
——
—1.
351.
381.
401.
421.
451.
471.
491.
521.
541.
571.
601.
621.
651.
681.
711.
731.
761.
79—
——
——
——
——
—0.
630.
640.
640.
650.
660.
660.
670.
680.
690.
690.
700.
710.
720.
730.
730.
740.
750.
760.
770.
780.
790.
80—
——
——
—0.
940.
971.
001.
041.
071.
101.
141.
171.
211.
251.
291.
371.
411.
461.
501.
551.
60—
——
——
——
——
——
2.85
2.92
2.98
3.05
3.11
3.18
3.25
3.33
3.40
3.47
3.55
3.63
3.71
3.79
3.88
4.01
4.10
4.19
4.29
2.56
——
——
——
——
8.68
8.87
9.07
9.26
9.47
9.68
9.89
10.1
110
.34
10.5
710
.80
11.0
411
.29
11.5
511
.81
12.0
812
.35
12.6
312
.92
13.2
113
.52
13.8
3—
——
——
—5.
715.
785.
855.
925.
996.
066.
156.
226.
306.
386.
466.
566.
646.
736.
826.
917.
027.
117.
217.
327.
437.
55—
——
——
—2.
892.
912.
932.
952.
973.
003.
023.
043.
063.
093.
113.
133.
163.
183.
203.
233.
253.
283.
303.
331.
40—
——
——
——
8.60
8.81
9.03
9.25
9.48
9.71
9.95
11.2
011
.99
12.2
912
.59
12.9
013
.22
13.5
513
.88
14.2
314
.58
14.9
415
.31
15.6
916
.08
16.4
8—
——
——
—2.
772.
802.
822.
852.
872.
902.
932.
952.
983.
013.
033.
063.
093.
123.
143.
173.
203.
233.
263.
293.
323.
35—
——
——
—3.
063.
093.
123.
163.
193.
233.
263.
303.
333.
373.
403.
443.
483.
513.
553.
593.
633.
673.
713.
753.
793.
833.
873.
91—
——
—2.
932.
973.
013.
053.
093.
133.
173.
213.
253.
303.
343.
393.
443.
493.
543.
593.
643.
703.
753.
813.
873.
933.
994.
05—
——
—1.
021.
031.
041.
061.
071.
091.
101.
121.
141.
151.
171.
191.
211.
221.
241.
261.
281.
301.
321.
341.
361.
381.
411.
43—
——
—5.
795.
916.
026.
146.
266.
386.
516.
646.
776.
917.
057.
197.
347.
497.
467.
807.
968.
138.
308.
488.
668.
849.
039.
22—
——
—4.
494.
544.
594.
654.
704.
764.
824.
884.
945.
005.
065.
135.
205.
265.
335.
415.
485.
565.
635.
715.
805.
885.
976.
052.
56—
——
—0.
424.
754.
514.
284.
683.
873.
673.
493.
323.
163.
002.
862.
722.
582.
462.
342.
232.
122.
021.
921.
831.
741.
661.
581.
511.
441.
371.
381.
171.
131.
131.
111.
131.
561.
341.
341.
461.
541.
511.
571.
611.
430.
23—
——
——
——
——
——
—1.
961.
961.
961.
961.
961.
271.
131.
131.
131.
131.
131.
131.
131.
131.
131.
131.
131.
131.
130.
19—
——
——
——
—3.
733.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
153.
150.
265.
395.
555.
725.
896.
076.
256.
446.
636.
83—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
10.5
011
.00
11.5
012
.00
12.5
012
.80
13.0
013
.30
13.6
013
.90
14.2
014
.50
14.9
015
.20
15.6
015
.90
16.3
0—
——
——
——
——
——
29.6
530
.67
31.7
332
.84
34.0
035
.21
36.4
737
.62
38.4
639
.89
41.3
942
.95
44.5
946
.31
48.1
249
.87
51.3
940
.00
——
——
——
——
——
11.5
511
.92
12.2
912
.67
13.0
513
.44
13.8
414
.24
14.6
415
.05
15.4
615
.89
16.3
316
.78
17.2
517
.72
18.2
118
.72
19.2
3—
——
——
——
——
27.0
529
.66
32.4
235
.32
38.3
841
.61
43.4
045
.27
47.2
349
.29
51.4
453
.69
56.0
558
.53
61.1
263
.84
66.6
969
.67
36.4
0—
——
——
——
——
10.8
110
.91
11.1
211
.32
11.6
811
.78
12.0
812
.30
12.4
712
.72
13.2
213
.35
13.4
913
.66
13.9
714
.49
15.0
615
.23
15.4
915
.68
15.8
715
.78
1.49
——
——
—
3639101004 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 43
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
Tot
alch
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
geca
pita
lB
alan
cepa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tva
lue
shee
t19
92–9
319
93–9
419
94–9
519
95–9
619
96–9
719
97–9
819
98–9
919
99–0
020
00–0
120
01–0
220
02–0
320
03–0
420
04–0
520
05–0
6D
epar
tmen
tC
omm
issi
onin
gbo
dyP
roje
ctna
me
(£m
illio
ns)
trea
tmen
t(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)
Def
raE
ast
Lon
don
Was
teA
utho
rity
(EL
WA
)In
tegr
ated
Was
teM
anag
emen
t:P
utW
aste
130.
80O
V—
——
——
——
——
—6.
1025
.20
27.3
031
.30
init
sP
lace
Def
raE
ast
Suss
exan
dB
righ
ton
&H
ove
New
Was
teP
artn
ersh
ips—
AJo
int
144.
00O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
12.7
214
.90
18.7
5In
tegr
ated
Was
teM
anag
emen
tSe
rvic
eD
efra
Wes
tSu
ssex
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
Rec
yclin
g&
Was
teH
andl
ing
Pro
ject
—40
.13
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
8.09
9.74
Rec
laim
Wes
tSu
ssex
Def
raN
otti
ngha
msh
ire
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
Not
ting
ham
shir
eSu
stai
nabl
eW
aste
130.
20O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—So
luti
ons
Env
iron
men
t,F
ood
&R
ural
AV
airs
Cen
tral
Ber
kshi
reC
entr
alB
erks
hire
Was
teM
anag
emen
t40
.50
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Pro
ject
Env
iron
men
t,F
ood
&R
ural
AV
airs
”L
anca
shir
eW
aste
Par
tner
ship
Inte
grat
edW
aste
Man
agem
ent
Con
trac
t24
6.09
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Env
iron
men
t,F
ood
&R
ural
AV
airs
Cor
nwal
lCou
nty
Cou
ncil
Inte
grat
edW
aste
Man
agem
ent
Con
trac
t15
7.32
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Env
iron
men
t,F
ood
&R
ural
AV
airs
”N
orth
umbe
rlan
dC
ount
yC
ounc
ilN
orth
umbe
rlan
dW
aste
Man
agem
ent
PF
I90
.56
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
Pro
ject
Wal
esB
roM
orga
nnw
gN
HS
Tru
stN
eath
Por
tT
albo
tH
ospi
tal
66.0
0oV
——
——
——
——
——
5.23
11.5
511
.50
11.3
9W
ales
Car
diV
and
Val
eN
HS
Tru
stSt
Dav
id’s
Hos
pita
l13
.85
oV—
——
——
——
——
2.55
2.63
2.73
2.77
3.11
Wal
esC
arm
arth
ensh
ire
NH
STE
nerg
yM
anag
emen
t0.
30O
V—
——
—0.
090.
090.
090.
100.
110.
110.
120.
120.
120.
13W
ales
Con
wy
and
Den
bigh
shir
eN
HS
Tru
stR
enal
and
Dia
bete
sU
nit
3.40
OV
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
130.
23W
ales
Gw
ent
Hea
lthc
are
NH
ST
rust
Che
psto
wC
omm
Hos
p10
.00
oV—
——
——
——
—1.
681.
661.
741.
711.
751.
79W
ales
Gw
ent
Hea
lthc
are
NH
ST
rust
Ene
rgy
Man
agem
ent
Roy
alG
wen
t/St
4.00
oV—
——
——
——
0.13
0.52
0.53
0.53
0.55
0.57
0.58
Woo
los
Wal
esG
wen
tH
ealt
hcar
eN
HS
Tru
stD
aySu
rger
y6.
66on
——
——
——
—0.
370.
550.
580.
600.
630.
650.
69W
ales
Gw
ent
Hea
lthc
are
NH
ST
rust
Ene
rgy
Man
agem
ent
Nev
illH
all
3.30
oV—
——
——
——
——
0.10
0.42
0.42
0.45
0.44
Wal
esG
wen
tH
ealt
hcar
eN
HS
Tru
stM
onno
wC
ourt
4.00
oV—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—W
ales
Pon
typr
idd
&R
hond
daN
HS
Tru
stSt
aVR
esid
ence
s2.
50O
V—
——
——
——
0.21
0.21
0.22
0.22
0.21
0.22
0.22
Wal
esW
elsh
Ass
embl
yG
over
nmen
tO
SIR
IS(O
Yce
Infr
astr
uctu
reR
evie
wan
dN
/AoV
——
——
0.18
4.90
5.00
9.37
10.7
014
.20
16.8
014
.40
5.90
—im
plem
enta
tion
Stra
tegy
)-I
TW
ales
Wel
shA
ssem
bly
Gov
ernm
ent
A55
100.
00oV
——
——
——
——
—14
.91
15.5
415
.64
15.5
415
.50
Wal
esF
orm
erW
elsh
Dev
elop
men
tA
genc
yL
loyd
Geo
rge
Ave
nue
&C
alla
ghan
Squa
re45
.00
oV—
——
——
——
—1.
855.
135.
855.
846.
006.
19W
ales
Cer
edig
ion
CC
Ysg
olP
enw
eddi
g12
.00
oV—
——
——
——
—0.
451.
771.
801.
771.
771.
74W
ales
Pem
brok
eshi
reC
CP
embr
oke
Doc
kP
rim
ary
Scho
ol8.
00oV
——
——
——
——
—0.
701.
361.
371.
421.
43W
ales
Cae
rphi
llyC
BC
Ysg
olG
yfun
Cw
mR
hym
ni&
Lew
isB
oys
25.0
0oV
——
——
——
——
——
1.67
2.93
2.89
2.97
Wal
esN
ewpo
rtC
BC
—R
oads
(Sou
ther
nD
istr
ibut
orR
oad—
New
port
Sout
hern
Dis
trib
utor
Roa
d57
.10
oV—
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
025.
48SD
R)
Wal
esD
enbi
ghsh
ire
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
OY
ces
12.1
0oV
——
——
——
——
——
——
2.02
2.17
Wal
esC
onw
yC
BC
3Sc
hool
Bun
dle
40.7
0oV
——
——
——
——
——
——
3.70
5.83
Wal
esC
aerp
hilly
CB
CSE
WR
oad
Sche
me
34.3
0oV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—1.
38W
ales
Rho
ndda
Cyn
onT
afC
BC
Lif
elon
gL
earn
ing
Cen
tre
28.1
8oV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
24W
ales
Bri
dgen
dC
BC
Mae
steg
Com
preh
ensi
veSc
hool
20.4
1oV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
DC
MS
Lon
don
Bor
ough
ofB
rent
Will
esde
nSp
orts
Cen
tre
16.6
6O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
CM
SL
ondo
nB
orou
ghof
Lew
isha
mD
ownh
amL
ifes
tyle
sC
entr
e17
.64
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
DC
MS
Pen
wit
hD
istr
ict
Cou
ncil
Rec
reat
ion
Wes
t6.
70O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.66
DC
MS
Wol
verh
ampt
onC
ity
Cou
ncil
Nor
thE
ast
Lei
sure
Cen
tre
13.3
5O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
CM
SA
mbe
rV
alle
yB
orou
ghC
ounc
ilA
mbe
rV
alle
yQ
uest
for
Lei
sure
22.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
—D
CM
S/O
DP
MO
ldha
mM
BC
Lib
rary
&L
ifel
ong
Lea
rnin
gC
entr
e13
.50
OV
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
23D
CM
SB
reck
land
Cou
ncil
Mak
ing
Con
nect
ions
Lei
sure
Pro
ject
15.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.37
DC
MS/
OD
PM
Bou
rnem
outh
Bor
ough
Cou
ncil
New
Cen
tral
Lib
rary
and
com
mun
ity
libra
ry20
.10
OV
——
——
——
——
—0.
341.
681.
711.
741.
77IC
Tsy
stem
OD
PM
Bri
ghto
n&
Hov
eC
ity
Cou
ncil
Jubi
lee
Lib
rary
11.9
4O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
601.
89D
CM
S/O
DP
MSe
fton
Bor
ough
Cou
ncil
Cro
sby
Lei
sure
Cen
tre
6.20
OV
——
——
——
——
——
0.03
0.98
1.00
1.01
DC
MS/
OD
PM
Utt
lesf
ord
Dis
tric
tC
ounc
ilU
ttle
sfor
dSp
orts
and
Lei
sure
Cen
tre
5.80
OV
——
——
——
——
——
0.06
0.47
0.82
0.84
LC
DL
ord
Cha
ncel
lor’
sD
epar
tmen
tA
RA
MIS
39.5
0oV
——
——
—3.
0713
.54
14.4
718
.50
18.3
923
.60
30.1
031
.16
31.3
0
3639101004 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 44 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
2006
–07
2007
–08
2008
–09
2009
–10
2010
–11
2011
–12
2012
–13
2013
–14
2014
–15
2015
–16
2016
–17
2017
–18
2018
–19
2019
–20
2020
–21
2021
–22
2022
–23
2023
–24
2024
–25
2025
–26
2026
–27
2027
–28
2028
–29
2029
–30
2030
–31
2031
–32
2032
–33
2033
–34
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
34.1
043
.80
48.6
050
.90
53.2
055
.30
57.2
059
.20
60.8
060
.80
62.7
064
.40
66.2
068
.00
69.8
071
.70
73.6
075
.60
77.7
079
.70
81.9
059
.10
——
——
——
23.2
128
.68
31.6
235
.20
38.3
039
.84
41.8
443
.26
44.6
345
.85
47.1
248
.34
49.6
850
.83
52.0
953
.17
54.3
755
.53
56.7
757
.95
59.2
560
.57
——
——
——
11.8
012
.83
13.8
214
.39
15.1
615
.71
16.2
616
.81
17.6
518
.21
18.7
819
.37
19.9
820
.60
21.2
521
.91
22.6
023
.30
24.0
224
.77
25.5
426
.33
27.1
4—
——
——
12.1
015
.10
15.8
016
.50
17.0
025
.00
30.9
031
.40
31.9
032
.40
32.9
033
.40
34.0
034
.10
34.6
035
.10
35.7
036
.30
36.9
037
.40
38.1
038
.70
39.3
040
.00
40.6
041
.30
42.0
0—
7.58
13.9
817
.35
18.8
820
.09
20.3
620
.18
20.7
021
.11
21.8
022
.38
22.9
723
.59
24.2
124
.77
25.4
726
.19
26.9
327
.60
28.3
929
.25
30.0
930
.86
31.6
632
.48
13.8
5—
—0.
330.
691.
5812
.26
28.1
964
.86
66.0
267
.22
68.4
669
.74
71.0
572
.39
73.8
375
.36
76.9
578
.59
80.3
082
.07
83.9
185
.82
87.8
089
.85
91.9
994
.22
——
——
8.99
19.3
620
.73
22.2
623
.73
32.1
632
.09
32.9
234
.08
35.0
836
.36
37.6
338
.92
40.2
441
.61
43.0
044
.43
45.8
947
.40
48.9
650
.56
52.2
153
.91
55.6
557
.45
59.3
161
.22
63.1
8—
14.0
315
.09
17.8
719
.56
20.3
420
.35
20.6
821
.11
21.5
622
.08
22.6
423
.21
23.8
524
.55
25.3
226
.16
26.9
527
.86
28.7
429
.71
30.6
631
.70
32.6
833
.76
34.8
735
.99
37.1
511
.73
12.0
812
.45
12.8
213
.20
13.6
014
.01
14.4
314
.86
15.3
115
.77
16.2
416
.73
17.2
317
.75
18.2
818
.83
19.3
919
.97
20.5
721
.19
21.8
222
.48
13.5
1—
——
—3.
293.
493.
703.
924.
164.
414.
674.
955.
255.
575.
906.
256.
637.
037.
457.
908.
378.
879.
409.
9710
.57
11.2
011
.87
12.5
813
.34
14.1
4—
—0.
130.
14—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
300.
310.
320.
330.
340.
360.
370.
390.
400.
420.
440.
460.
480.
500.
520.
540.
560.
590.
610.
640.
670.
680.
700.
710.
720.
740.
75—
1.86
1.91
1.97
2.03
2.09
2.15
1.97
2.03
2.09
2.15
2.22
2.28
2.35
2.42
2.50
2.57
2.65
2.73
2.81
——
——
——
——
—0.
600.
620.
640.
660.
680.
700.
720.
740.
45—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.69
0.72
0.74
0.76
0.78
0.80
0.83
0.85
0.88
0.90
0.93
0.96
0.99
1.02
1.05
1.08
1.11
0.14
——
——
——
——
——
0.47
0.49
0.50
0.52
0.53
0.55
0.56
0.58
0.60
0.62
0.63
0.65
0.67
0.69
0.71
0.73
0.76
0.78
0.80
0.83
0.60
——
——
——
—0.
520.
530.
550.
570.
580.
600.
620.
640.
660.
680.
700.
720.
740.
760.
780.
810.
830.
860.
880.
910.
940.
970.
991.
021.
051.
09—
—0.
220.
230.
230.
240.
240.
250.
260.
260.
270.
280.
280.
290.
300.
300.
310.
320.
330.
340.
340.
350.
360.
370.
38—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
15.3
516
.48
16.8
016
.50
16.0
017
.00
18.0
017
.00
17.0
017
.00
20.0
022
.00
22.0
020
.00
18.0
020
.00
22.0
020
.00
19.0
011
.00
12.0
015
.00
8.00
1.00
——
——
6.20
6.30
6.40
6.50
6.60
6.70
6.80
6.90
7.00
7.10
7.20
7.30
7.40
7.50
7.60
7.70
7.80
7.90
8.00
8.00
——
——
——
——
1.73
1.74
1.79
1.94
2.00
1.93
1.93
2.02
2.06
2.05
2.04
2.05
2.10
2.08
1.95
1.76
1.64
1.63
1.63
1.62
1.60
1.58
1.41
1.33
0.91
——
—1.
471.
491.
501.
521.
531.
551.
571.
591.
601.
621.
641.
661.
681.
701.
721.
741.
761.
781.
811.
831.
851.
881.
901.
931.
950.
99—
—3.
163.
233.
313.
383.
463.
553.
633.
723.
813.
904.
004.
104.
204.
304.
414.
524.
644.
764.
885.
005.
135.
265.
405.
545.
695.
842.
46—
7.01
7.12
7.22
7.32
7.44
7.54
7.28
7.38
7.09
7.20
7.30
7.41
7.52
7.63
7.74
7.86
7.97
8.09
8.20
8.33
8.45
8.58
8.70
8.83
8.96
9.10
9.23
9.36
2.19
2.21
2.24
2.26
2.28
2.30
2.33
2.35
2.37
2.40
2.42
2.45
2.47
2.49
2.52
2.54
2.57
2.60
2.62
2.65
2.67
2.70
2.73
2.76
——
——
6.10
6.19
6.28
6.37
6.46
6.55
6.64
6.74
6.84
6.94
7.04
7.14
7.24
7.35
7.45
7.56
7.67
7.78
7.90
8.01
8.13
8.25
8.37
2.83
——
——
5.50
5.70
5.28
5.28
5.18
5.13
5.09
5.05
5.04
5.18
5.15
5.11
4.92
4.69
4.54
4.52
4.58
4.65
4.43
4.27
4.25
4.31
4.09
3.99
4.10
2.08
2.12
1.74
3.93
3.97
4.02
4.07
4.11
4.16
4.21
4.26
4.31
4.36
4.42
4.47
4.53
4.59
4.65
4.71
4.77
4.84
4.91
4.97
5.04
5.11
5.19
5.26
——
——
1.63
2.45
2.47
2.48
2.49
2.50
2.52
2.53
2.54
2.56
2.57
2.59
2.60
2.62
2.63
2.65
2.67
2.68
2.70
2.72
2.74
2.75
2.77
2.79
2.81
0.94
——
0.76
1.87
1.90
1.93
1.97
2.01
2.02
2.05
2.09
2.13
2.17
2.21
2.25
2.29
2.35
2.33
2.38
2.42
2.47
2.52
2.57
2.62
2.67
2.72
2.78
1.65
——
0.16
1.76
1.79
1.83
1.86
1.89
1.92
1.96
1.99
2.03
2.07
2.01
2.04
2.08
2.12
2.16
2.20
2.24
2.29
2.33
2.38
2.42
2.47
2.39
2.44
2.49
2.54
2.59
1.03
1.04
1.06
1.07
1.08
1.09
1.10
1.11
1.12
1.13
1.14
1.15
1.17
1.18
1.19
1.20
1.21
1.23
1.24
1.25
1.26
1.28
1.29
1.30
1.31
1.33
1.34
—0.
481.
441.
461.
481.
491.
511.
531.
551.
571.
591.
601.
631.
651.
671.
691.
711.
741.
761.
781.
811.
841.
861.
891.
921.
951.
982.
01—
—2.
602.
632.
662.
692.
722.
752.
782.
822.
852.
892.
922.
963.
003.
043.
083.
123.
173.
213.
253.
303.
353.
403.
453.
503.
55—
—2.
792.
822.
852.
882.
912.
942.
973.
003.
043.
073.
103.
143.
183.
213.
253.
293.
333.
383.
423.
463.
513.
553.
603.
653.
31—
——
0.70
1.61
1.70
1.72
1.74
1.76
1.78
1.80
1.82
1.84
1.86
1.88
1.91
1.93
1.95
1.97
2.00
2.02
2.04
2.07
2.09
2.12
2.14
2.17
2.19
2.22
2.24
—1.
811.
861.
891.
921.
961.
992.
032.
072.
112.
152.
182.
222.
272.
312.
352.
392.
442.
492.
532.
582.
632.
682.
732.
782.
842.
90—
—1.
992.
032.
072.
122.
162.
212.
252.
302.
352.
412.
462.
522.
572.
632.
692.
762.
822.
892.
963.
033.
113.
183.
262.
23—
——
—1.
031.
051.
071.
081.
101.
121.
141.
161.
181.
201.
221.
241.
261.
281.
301.
331.
351.
371.
401.
421.
441.
28—
——
——
—0.
830.
870.
890.
920.
950.
960.
960.
960.
960.
970.
981.
001.
001.
031.
041.
061.
061.
121.
171.
201.
211.
241.
261.
241.
321.
181.
211.
2423
.80
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—
3639101004 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 45
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
Act
ual
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
Tot
alch
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
geca
pita
lB
alan
cepa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tpa
ymen
tva
lue
shee
t19
92–9
319
93–9
419
94–9
519
95–9
619
96–9
719
97–9
819
98–9
919
99–0
020
00–0
120
01–0
220
02–0
320
03–0
420
04–0
520
05–0
6D
epar
tmen
tC
omm
issi
onin
gbo
dyP
roje
ctna
me
(£m
illio
ns)
trea
tmen
t(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)
LC
DC
ourt
Serv
ice
Nat
iona
lPro
bate
Rec
ords
Cen
tre
11.0
0oV
——
——
——
——
—1.
251.
391.
451.
462.
05L
CD
Wor
cest
erC
ount
yC
ounc
ilH
eref
ord
and
Wor
cest
erM
agis
trat
es’C
ourt
25.0
0on
——
——
——
——
—1.
613.
664.
344.
465.
42L
CD
Eas
tR
idin
gof
Yor
kC
ount
yC
ounc
ilH
umbe
rsid
eM
agis
trat
es’C
ourt
19.0
0on
——
——
——
——
—1.
223.
193.
243.
303.
99L
CD
Man
ches
ter
Cit
yC
ounc
ilM
anch
este
rM
agis
trat
es’C
ourt
s30
.00
on—
——
——
——
——
——
—4.
845.
88L
CD
Der
bysh
ire
Cou
nty
Cou
ncil
Der
bysh
ire
Mag
istr
ates
’Cou
rts
31.0
0on
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
501.
005.
09L
CD
Cou
rtSe
rvic
eE
ast
Ang
liaC
ourt
s25
.00
on—
——
——
——
——
——
—3.
794.
97L
CD
Cou
rtSe
rvic
eSh
eYel
dF
amily
Hea
ring
Cen
tre
5.00
on—
——
——
——
——
——
—0.
731.
08L
CD
Cou
rtSe
rvic
eE
xete
rC
ombi
ned
Cou
rt15
.00
on—
——
——
——
——
——
—1.
032.
90L
CD
Lor
dC
hanc
ello
r’s
Dep
artm
ent
LO
CC
S27
.00
on—
——
——
6.44
5.92
14.3
524
.90
33.2
317
.26
32.7
59.
8438
.25
LC
DL
ord
Cha
ncel
lor’
sD
epar
tmen
tL
IBR
A38
.90
on—
——
——
——
—10
.20
23.4
058
.79
44.8
038
.21
38.1
8D
CA
Som
erse
tC
ount
yco
unci
lA
von
&So
mer
set
Mag
istr
ates
Cou
rt45
.00
on—
——
——
——
——
——
——
0.53
*inc
lude
sP
roba
tion
Serv
ice
elem
ent
DW
PW
ork
&P
ensi
ons
PR
IME
990.
00O
V—
——
——
—27
5.00
257.
0028
1.00
299.
0030
7.00
417.
0063
1.00
662.
70N
IC
ourt
Serv
ice
Nor
ther
nIr
elan
dC
ourt
Serv
ice
IS/I
TA
gree
men
t26
.40
OV
——
——
——
—0.
803.
303.
103.
203.
704.
304.
90N
IC
ourt
Serv
ice
NI
Cou
rts
Serv
ice
Lag
ansi
de28
.20
On
——
——
——
——
—4.
704.
323.
874.
024.
17F
CO
FC
OF
orei
gnan
dC
omm
onw
ealt
hO
Yce
73.9
0O
V—
——
——
——
—9.
8216
.75
26.3
129
.42
30.8
032
.40
Tel
ecom
mun
icat
ions
Net
wor
k(F
TN
)F
CO
FC
OB
erlin
Em
bass
y17
.10
On
——
——
——
——
1.93
3.70
4.13
4.98
4.77
4.52
HM
RC
Inla
ndR
even
ueSt
ockp
ort
6.00
OV
——
——
——
——
—1.
071.
071.
091.
331.
33H
MR
CIn
land
Rev
enue
StJo
hn’s
Hou
seB
ootl
e12
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
—2.
242.
242.
332.
402.
46H
MR
CIn
land
Rev
enue
Man
ches
ter
32.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
5.58
5.75
6.53
6.95
HM
RC
Inla
ndR
even
ueE
dinb
urgh
10.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
1.40
1.44
1.47
1.46
1.44
1.53
1.56
HM
RC
Inla
ndR
even
ueG
lasg
ow10
.00
OV
——
——
——
—1.
421.
461.
491.
501.
511.
571.
60H
MR
CIn
land
Rev
enue
New
cast
leE
stat
eD
evel
opm
ent
218.
00O
V—
——
——
2.05
7.38
9.66
18.5
518
.50
20.6
623
.74
27.3
931
.12
HM
RC
Inla
ndR
even
ue/C
usto
ms
&E
xcis
eST
EP
S37
0.00
OV
——
——
——
——
—18
2.44
187.
3219
0.89
197.
6220
0.93
HM
RC
GO
GG
S18
2.00
On
——
——
——
——
——
——
4.73
18.5
7D
TI
The
Coa
lAut
hori
tyG
eoph
ysic
alM
inin
gD
ata
Pro
ject
(MR
SDS)
3.53
OV
——
——
——
0.87
1.46
1.51
1.65
1.80
2.12
1.94
1.97
DT
IN
atur
alE
nvir
onm
ent
Res
earc
hC
ounc
ilA
ntar
tic
Surv
eySh
ippi
ngSe
rvic
es22
.00
On
——
——
—2.
312.
332.
362.
382.
412.
442.
472.
502.
53D
TI
Eng
inee
ring
&P
hysi
calS
cien
ces
Res
earc
hC
ounc
ilH
igh
Pow
ered
Com
puti
ngP
roje
ct18
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
5.00
9.00
10.9
06.
20D
TI
DT
IE
LG
AR
35.2
0O
V—
——
——
—0.
4016
.00
32.4
035
.20
45.1
052
.50
54.6
052
.50
Cab
inet
OY
ceC
abin
etO
Yce
(Nat
iona
lSch
oolo
fG
over
nmen
t)Su
nnin
gdal
eP
ark
Pro
pert
y18
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
4.30
4.30
4.40
4.20
Cab
inet
OY
ceG
CH
QN
ewA
ccom
mod
atio
nP
roje
ct33
0.00
On
——
——
——
——
—17
.27
17.5
536
.46
51.2
752
.70
HM
Tre
asur
yH
MT
reas
ury
GO
GG
SW
est
141.
00O
n—
——
——
——
——
—9.
9515
.44
15.7
916
.32
HM
Tre
asur
yN
atio
nalS
avin
gs&
Inve
stm
ents
Nat
iona
lSav
ings
Pro
ject
Agr
eem
ent
48.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
99.6
097
.20
94.8
079
.50
77.9
083
.60
83.4
0C
row
nP
rose
cuti
onSe
rvic
eC
row
nP
rose
cuti
onSe
rvic
eC
OM
PA
SS21
.00
OV
——
——
——
——
——
13.8
620
.78
31.3
434
.38
DW
PH
ealt
han
dSa
fety
Exe
cuti
ve(H
SE)
RE
FIT
(Ret
ende
ring
For
ITSe
rvic
es)
23.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
5.60
12.5
012
.80
13.0
013
.10
DW
PH
ealt
han
dSa
fety
Exe
cuti
ve(H
SE)
Mer
seys
ide
Hea
dqua
rter
s(R
edgr
ave
Cou
rt)
60.0
0O
V—
——
——
——
——
——
——
2.20
DW
PH
ealt
h&
Safe
tyL
abor
ator
y(H
SL)
Est
ates
Rat
iona
lisat
ion
66.2
0O
n—
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
307.
00
3639101004 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 46 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
Est
imat
edE
stim
ated
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
unit
ary
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
char
gech
arge
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
paym
ent
2006
–07
2007
–08
2008
–09
2009
–10
2010
–11
2011
–12
2012
–13
2013
–14
2014
–15
2015
–16
2016
–17
2017
–18
2018
–19
2019
–20
2020
–21
2021
–22
2022
–23
2023
–24
2024
–25
2025
–26
2026
–27
2027
–28
2028
–29
2029
–30
2030
–31
2031
–32
2032
–33
2033
–34
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
(£m
)(£
m)
2.09
2.13
2.18
2.22
2.26
2.31
2.35
2.40
2.45
2.50
2.55
2.60
2.65
2.70
2.76
2.81
2.87
2.93
2.99
3.05
0.70
——
——
——
—5.
535.
645.
755.
875.
986.
106.
236.
356.
486.
616.
746.
877.
017.
157.
297.
447.
597.
747.
908.
051.
86—
——
——
——
4.07
4.15
4.23
4.32
4.41
4.49
4.58
4.67
4.77
4.86
4.96
5.06
5.16
5.26
5.37
5.48
5.59
5.70
5.81
5.93
3.04
——
——
——
—6.
006.
126.
246.
366.
496.
626.
756.
897.
037.
177.
317.
467.
617.
767.
918.
078.
238.
408.
578.
748.
919.
099.
27—
——
——
5.19
5.30
5.40
5.51
5.62
5.73
5.85
5.96
6.08
6.20
6.33
6.46
6.58
6.72
6.85
6.99
7.13
7.27
7.42
7.56
7.71
7.87
8.03
8.19
——
——
5.07
5.17
5.27
5.38
5.49
5.60
5.71
5.82
5.94
6.06
6.18
6.30
6.43
6.56
6.69
6.82
6.96
7.10
7.24
7.39
7.53
7.68
7.84
——
——
—1.
101.
121.
151.
171.
191.
221.
241.
271.
291.
321.
341.
371.
401.
431.
451.
481.
511.
541.
571.
601.
641.
671.
70—
——
——
2.96
3.02
3.08
3.14
3.20
3.27
3.33
3.40
3.47
3.54
3.61
3.68
3.75
3.83
3.90
3.98
4.06
4.14
4.22
4.31
4.40
4.48
4.57
4.66
——
——
19.0
0—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
38.1
838
.18
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
3.40
7.50
7.65
7.80
7.96
8.12
8.28
8.45
8.62
8.79
8.96
9.14
9.33
9.51
9.70
9.90
10.0
910
.30
10.5
010
.71
10.9
311
.14
11.3
711
.59
——
——
642.
0062
5.50
624.
4064
0.00
656.
0067
2.40
689.
2070
6.40
724.
1074
2.20
760.
8077
9.80
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
6.10
6.10
6.40
4.90
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
4.25
4.33
4.41
4.50
4.59
4.68
4.74
4.87
4.96
5.06
5.17
5.27
5.38
5.50
5.61
——
——
——
——
——
——
—30
.00
24.0
024
.00
24.0
0—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—4.
394.
444.
504.
554.
614.
674.
724.
784.
844.
904.
965.
035.
095.
155.
215.
285.
345.
415.
485.
555.
615.
685.
755.
835.
905.
976.
056.
121.
331.
331.
351.
621.
621.
621.
621.
55—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—2.
532.
632.
722.
822.
933.
033.
153.
263.
383.
513.
633.
773.
914.
054.
204.
354.
514.
684.
851.
31—
——
——
——
—6.
956.
957.
958.
458.
458.
452.
82—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.59
1.62
1.65
1.69
1.72
1.76
1.80
1.29
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
1.63
1.66
1.70
1.73
1.77
1.81
1.84
1.33
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
32.4
833
.51
34.5
435
.64
36.6
237
.80
38.8
440
.10
41.2
242
.58
43.9
845
.43
46.9
448
.50
50.1
351
.81
49.8
039
.79
37.0
720
.35
21.0
117
.05
12.6
35.
37—
——
—20
4.94
206.
2821
1.20
216.
7922
1.20
228.
4523
5.96
242.
2725
1.01
260.
5026
9.14
278.
0828
7.35
296.
9430
6.87
——
——
——
——
——
——
—19
.49
19.6
520
.08
20.5
921
.10
21.6
322
.17
22.7
223
.29
23.8
724
.47
25.0
825
.71
26.3
527
.01
27.6
928
.38
29.0
929
.81
30.5
631
.32
32.1
232
.97
33.7
934
.64
35.5
036
.39
37.3
01.
952.
142.
051.
940.
98—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
2.56
2.59
2.63
2.66
2.70
2.73
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
4.50
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—43
.00
39.7
037
.00
30.4
024
.50
23.9
022
.30
22.7
0—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
—4.
404.
404.
404.
404.
504.
504.
504.
504.
504.
504.
50—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
53.9
955
.86
57.2
158
.76
58.2
759
.61
61.0
362
.71
64.4
266
.33
67.9
869
.89
71.9
474
.14
75.8
577
.96
80.7
283
.28
85.4
488
.04
90.8
793
.94
97.5
010
3.64
23.9
8—
——
16.6
817
.15
17.6
318
.12
18.6
319
.15
19.6
920
.24
20.8
021
.39
21.9
922
.60
23.2
323
.88
24.5
525
.24
25.9
526
.67
27.4
228
.19
28.9
829
.79
30.6
231
.48
32.3
633
.27
34.2
035
.16
69.0
065
.50
64.3
066
.10
65.8
064
.60
64.3
063
.10
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
35.3
436
.37
37.3
938
.46
39.5
7—
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
14.3
014
.60
15.0
015
.30
15.6
012
.60
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
——
7.90
8.10
8.30
8.50
8.70
9.00
9.20
9.50
9.70
10.0
010
.30
10.5
010
.80
11.1
011
.40
11.7
012
.00
12.4
012
.70
13.0
013
.40
13.8
014
.10
14.5
014
.90
15.3
015
.70
16.1
07.
808.
208.
408.
709.
009.
309.
509.
8010
.10
10.5
010
.80
11.1
011
.40
11.7
012
.00
12.4
012
.70
13.1
013
.40
13.8
014
.20
14.6
015
.00
15.4
015
.80
16.3
016
.70
17.2
0
3639101004 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 47
At the hearing on the Governement’s use of consultants, Mr Bacon asked a series of questions relatingto the earlier hearing on PFI refinancing. The reponse to these is as follows:
Private Finance Initiative
1. Can you say whether the number of projects that are PFI projects is commercially confidential or not?
This is public information and is available via the signed deals list on HM Treasury’s public website:http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/documents/public–private–partnerships/ppp–pfi–stats.cfm
2. Are the details of those that are on balance sheet commercially confidential?
The balance sheet treatment of PFI projects is not the determinant of whether the project’s details arecommercially confidential.
3. Is it commercially confidential whether a PFI project is on balance sheet?
This information is not commercially confidential.
4. Is the fact that a PFI project is oV balance sheet commercially confidential or not?
This information is not commercially confidential.
5. Is the total amount of cash paid for each project by the authority concerned over the life of the projectcommercially confidential?
At an aggregate level this information is not commercially confidential, however departments may diVerin their ability to provide detailed breakdowns of cash payments due to commercial confidentiality issues.
6. Is the total capital value commercially confidential?
This information is not commercially confidential.
7. Is the length of contract for each PFI project commercially confidential or not?
8. Is the inflation assumption that is used in the project commercially confidential?
9. Is the discount rate that is used in each project commercially confidential?
10. Is the net present value of each project commercially confidential?
11. Is the public sector comparator that is used for each project commercially confidential?
The Treasury does not collect this data centrally. However, it is possible that there may be commercialconfidentiality issues that relate to the information listed.
12. The website signed project list says that the total capital value of the MoD main building is £345 million.The NAO’s report says that it is £746 million. What is the basis of the figure for the total capital value that isused on the PFI signed project list?
Both figures are correct but refer to diVerent measures of value. The total capital value as covered in theTreasury’s signed deals list is defined as “the public sector procuring body’s estimate of the capital value ofthe property the private sector purchases or creates for delivering services under a PFI contract.”
The figure referenced in the NAO report Ministry of Defence: Redevelopment of MOD Main Building isnot the capital value of the project. The £746 million figure refers to the net present value of the entirecontract—eVectively a total of the unitary charges of the project. Unitary charge data not only coversprovisions for the redevelopment or construction of an asset but also provisions for factors such as inflation,other services provided and major refurbishments. As noted in the NAO report:
“In May 2000, MOD let a PFI contract with a net present value of £746 million (at 2000 pricelevels) to a consortium called Modus. The 30-year contract covered the redevelopment of MainBuilding and limited refurbishment and provision of support to other buildings needed toaccommodate staV while redevelopment is undertaken, followed by the provision of maintenanceand facilities management services at Main Building and the Old War OYce until May 2030”.
John KingmanManaging Director, Public Services and Growth DirectorateHM Treasury
3639101003 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 48 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Supplementary memorandum submitted by the National Audit OYce
PFI projects which did not supply information requested by the Committee of Public Accounts
1. Missing information on internal rate of returns (IRRs) before and after refinancing
On 11 December 2006, the Committee of Public Accounts held a hearing based on the Comptroller &Auditor General’s report, Update on PFI debt refinancing and the PFI equity market. During the hearing, theCommittee raised the issue highlighted in the C&AG’s report that 16 out of 36 projects had not providedinformationrequestedby theNAOonbehalfof theCommittee in respectof internal ratesof returnbeforeandafter the projects’ refinancing, which would show the benefits investors had derived from the refinancings.
The Committee asked for a list of the projects which had failed to provide this information and their value,and also asked the NAO to continue to seek the missing information in the aftermath of the hearing. Anupdate of the situation as at 28 February 2007 is provided in Figure 1. The National Audit OYce will beplacing this information, and any further information supplied by the projects after 28 February 2007, onits website www.nao.org.uk
Figure 1
POSITION AT 28 FEBRUARY 2007 ON PROJECTS WHICH HAD PREVIOUSLY NOTSUPPLIED IRR INFORMATION REQUESTED BY THE COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS
Information now returned (see Figure 2 below)
Value ofproject (capital Previous response provided at
Project Name value £m) publication of C&AG’s Report
1. M1—A1 Link Road (Lofthouse to Bramham) 210 No return2. A30/A35 Exeter to Bere Regis Design Build 76 No return
Finance and Operate (DBFO) contract3. A50/A564 Stoke-Derby Link DBFO contract 21 No return4. North Wiltshire District Council- Property 10 Returned incomplete information
Rationalisation
No return to date but the authority has said that it will be disclosing information
Value ofproject (capital Previous response provided at
Project Name value £m) publication of C&AG’s Report
5. Sussex Weald and Downs NHS Trust: 27 No returnGraylingwell Hospital reprovision, Chichester
6. A19 Dishforth to Tyne Tunnel DBFO contract 29 No return7. M40 Denham to Warwick 65 No return
No return but it is unlikely that the authority would have had the information since the private sector didnot share gains with the authority
Value ofproject (capital Previous response provided at
Project Name value £m) publication of C&AG’s Report
8. Second Severn Crossing 331‘ No information provided by theHighways Agency on the groundsthat, due to the nature of thetransaction (note 1), it had beenagreed there was no gain to beshared with the government and itwas not able to calculate theprivate sector gains or the IRRinformation requested
9. A69 Carlisle to Newcastle DBFO contract 9 No return10. Hillingdon—Barnhill School 27 No return
Note 1: Following a European Court of Justice ruling imposing VAT on road tolls aVecting the consortium’sability to service its debt, it was agreed the project would be refinanced with no share to the government.
3639101003 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 49
Information has been returned but it appears incorrect and is being investigated further by the NAO
Value ofproject (capital Previous response provided at
Project Name value £m) publication of C&AG’s Report
11 Colfox School 13 No return12. Central Scotland Family Quarters, 30 No return
Bannockburn
School projects where it has not been possible to obtain information from either the former investor(Jarvis) or the current investor SMIF but where the NAO would have expected the authority to have theinformation in order to check its share of the refinancing gain
Value ofproject (capital Previous response provided at
Project Name value £m) publication of C&AG’s Report
13. Cardinal Heenan (VA) School 8 No return14. Haringey Schools 63 No return15. Brent Jews Free School 9 Returned incomplete information16. Bridlington Schools 26 Returned incomplete information
Figure 2
FURTHER INFORMATION ON IRRS SUPPLIED SINCE PUBLICATION OF C&AG’S REPORT
IRR at contract IRR just before IRR just afterProject award refinancing refinancing
M1-A1 Link Road 17% 25% 33%(Lofthouse to Bramham)
North Wiltshire District Council 13% 13% Note 1property rationalisation
A30/A35 Exeter to Bere Regis DBFO 16% 17% 23%A50/A564 Stoke-Derby Link DBFO 13% 23% 27%
Note 1: This was a small early PFI scheme (capital value £10 million, share capital from Jarvis of £125,000and a refinancing gain of only £0.3 million). Despite these small numbers the project has reported an IRRafter refinancing of 662%. Whilst arithmetically correct, this is a highly unusual situation as this small valuerefinancing occurred early during construction so that subordinated debt of £1.1 million which Jarvis wasdue to lend was not drawn down and outstanding for a full year. This produced a very big eVect on the IRRwhich is very sensitive to the amount and timing of shareholder loans. Had the subordinated debt beenoutstanding for a full year the IRR after refinancing would have reduced to around 80%. For these reasonsthe IRR is not comparable to data in Figure 2 or Appendix 9 of the C&AG’s report.
In addition, the MOD Joint Services Command and StaV College has advised us that, based oninformation it has received from the private sector parties to the deal, the IRR just after refinancing shouldbe 52% and not 31% as the College had disclosed previously prior to the publication of the C&AG’s report.
2. Missing supplementary information
In addition to the main information requested by the Committee of Public Accounts on IRRs referred toabove the following projects had also not provided, when the C&AG’s report was published, at least somedetails of certain supplementary information the PAC had requested on cash flows to investors and the cashprice of the contract. The data which had been supplied was set out in Appendix 9 of the C&AG’s report.We have also continued to request this information from the projects and the progress on obtaining thisinformation is set out in Figure 3 below. The further information which these projects have supplied, orcontinue to supply, subsequent to the publication of the C&AG’s report will be placed on the National AuditOYce website www.nao.org.uk
3639101003 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 50 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
Figure 3
MISSING SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
All information has now been suppliedValue of project
Project Name (capital value £m)
1. Tube Lines Ltd—London Underground 5,4842. Norwich & Norfolk Health Care NHS Trust 2293. HM Customs & Excise—IT Infrastructure PFI 1564 Bromley NHST—New Hosp 1505 Medium Support Helicopter 1006. Altcourse (Fazakerley) Prison 887. Joint Services Command and StaV College 888 Calderdale Hospital 669. Central Scotland Family Quarters—Bannockburn 3010. DEFRA oYces, Brooklands Avenue, Cambridge 2411 Debden Park School 1512 North Wiltshire District Council—Property 10
Rationalisation
No return to date but the authority has said that it will be disclosing information
Value of projectProject Name (capital value £m)
13. Sussex Weald and Downs NHS Trust— 27Graylingwell Hospital Reprovision, Chichester
14. Dartford and Gravesham Hospital NHS Trust 122
Some information still outstandingValue of project
Project Name (capital value £m)
15. M1—A1 Link Road (Lofthouse to Bramham) 21016. A30/A35 Exeter to Bere Regis DBFO contract 7617. M40 Denham to Warwick 6518. Dovegate (Marchington) Prison 489. Lowdham Grange Prison 3220. Ashfield (Pucklechurch) Prison 3121. A19 Dishforth to Tyne Tunnel DBFO contract 2922. A50/A564 Stoke-Derby Link DBFO contract 2123. Colfox School 1324. Hassockfield 1225. A69 Carlisle to Newcastle DBFO contract 9
Information returned but not in the format requiredValue of project
Project Name (capital value £m)
26. Bridlington Schools 2627. Brent Jews Free School 9
3639101003 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 51
No return but it is unlikely that the authority would have had the informationsince the private sector did not share gains with the authority
Value of projectProject Name (capital value £m)
28 Second Severn Crossing 331
School projects where it has not been possible to obtain information from eitherthe former investor (Jarvis) or the current investor SMIF
Value of projectProject Name (capital value £m)
29. Haringey Schools 6330. Hillingdon—Barnhill School 2731. Cardinal Heenan (VA) School 8
The 31 projects referred to above include the 16 projects which, at publication of the C&AG’s report, hadalso not supplied the principal information requested by the PAC on IRRs and a further 15 projects whichhad provided the IRR information but had failed to submit at least some part of the supplementaryinformation.
Comments on the Treasury’s Publication, PFI: Strengthening long term partnerships
1. In March 2006 the Treasury published a report on PFI: strengthening long-term partnerships (“thereport”). This publication set out an update on how the Private Finance Initiative (PFI) is being used acrossgovernment together with various proposed actions by the government to support the PFI’s role indelivering better public services. On 11 December 2006, the Committee of Public Accounts took evidence onthe Comptroller and Auditor General’s report Update on PFI debt refinancing and the PFI equity market(HC1040 2005-06). The Committee asked the National Audit OYce to prepare a note considering theimplications on the work of the Committee, and the way the Committee looks at PFI cases.
2. In the report, the Treasury
— provided background on the Government’s approach to PFI;
— reported back on its research into the performance of over 100 operational projects and identifiedareas for policy development relating to operational issues;
— identified areas in which to improve PFI procurement including retention and development ofprocurement expertise and improved development of projects within the public sector beforelaunch to the market;
— identified some refinements to the use of private finance to further improve its flexibility andtransparency.
In preparing the report the Treasury consulted with the National Audit OYce (NAO) on the NAO’sexperience of the issues to be covered in the report.
A. Operational Projects
3. The research commissioned by Treasury covered more than 100 out of over 500 operational PFIprojects. The report’s results indicated that, based on the results of surveys of the end users of PFI servicessuch as doctors, patients, teachers and pupils, users are satisfied with the services provided in PFI projectswith good overall performance levels, and suYcient confidence in the contracts incentivising as intended.Public sector contract managers reported that 96% of projects were performing at least satisfactorily, andin 89% of projects, public authorities felt that services were being provided in line with the contract or better.The Treasury also found that public sector managers believed the relationships between them and theprivate sector were generally good with the parties displaying a positive and pragmatic approach to thecontract.
4. The reports on service delivery which the Treasury obtained from contract managers are in line withour examinations of PFI projects that have identified very few projects which are not delivering services inline with the contract. One such project was the contract for the National Physical Laboratory on which theCommittee has reported.
3639101003 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 52 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
5. The Treasury report proposed measures to promote operational and contractual flexibility under thePFI. It is important that these matters are addressed as the majority of the 750 PFI contracts which havebeen let are now in the operational phase. There are risks and challenges in seeking to manage operationaland contractual flexibility. The main issues are :
— PFI contract management experience is being built up in the early contracts that have beenoperational for some years. But with 750 PFI contracts let and further contracts being developed,there is a continuing need to enhance public sector skills in dealing with operational issues. As theTreasury report says, the fragmentation of the portfolio of large and complex projects across manyauthorities limits the opportunities for staV who have built up PFI experience to move from theirexisting projects to similar projects within their existing employer. Their private sectorcounterparts, however, are likely to be working for companies which can draw on a wide rangeof experienced contract management staV. Public sector staV therefore have a particular need fortraining and support in managing PFI contracts to ensure they are not at a disadvantage.
— The NAO has found that 55% of PFI contracts had been changed within a few years of contractletting.1 Dealing with change is inherent in all government activity. PFI contracts therefore needto have flexibility to deal with these changes and the terms of any changes must be capable of beingdemonstrated as being value for money.
— Given that government’s requirements will change, authorities also need to assess the mostappropriate length of contract. Long contracts bring stability in the arrangements for servicedelivery but there can be risks. For example, the Committee was critical of the Norfolk & NorwichUniversity Hospital NHS Trust’s extension of the Norfolk and Norwich Hospital contract to 2037in a situation where it could also be very expensive to the NHS Trust to terminate the contract.
6. The Treasury report’s main proposals in this regard were:
— providing additional support to project teams in the form of an operational taskforce available toadvise on operational issues;
— assessing whether there should be changes to the standard PFI contract to make variationprocedures more flexible and eYcient;
— determining sector specific caps on the length of PFI contracts.
7. All these initiatives seek to help oYcials derive the intended benefits from PFI contracts, while allowingfor requirements to change over time as the nature of public service delivery evolves.
Operational taskforce
8. In response to the growing number of operational projects and the research showing that authoritieswould benefit from the support, the Treasury formed in 2006 an operational taskforce staVed byPartnerships UK. The taskforce is available to respond to requests for advice on operational issues with aspecific helpdesk facility. The taskforce is also developing specific guidance for the public sector in issueskey to operational projects and in November 2006 published guidance on benchmarking and market testing.
9. We will be reporting on the early experience of projects with benchmarking and market testingarrangements in a report we expect to publish by mid-2007. This will provide the Committee with an earlyopportunity to consider the role that benchmarking and market testing plays in PFI projects. Departmentsand their PFI project teams are now able to draw on the new guidance and further support from theTreasury’s operational taskforce when using these processes. The Treasury consulted the NAO in preparingthe guidance and, as part of this consultation, we shared with the Treasury the results of the fieldwork whichwe had been carrying out.
10. In collaboration with OGC, the taskforce is expanding the Gateway review process to incorporateoperational reviews of PFI projects. This involves detailed discussions with both public and private sectorpartners involved in projects, with the primary aim of providing forward looking advice to project teams toimprove performance. In 2006 the taskforce ran seminars for projects in a number of locations and plansto provide other training events for PFI contract management staV.
Contract variations
11. As noted above, there is a strong likelihood that PFI projects will be subject to change. The Treasuryrecognises that PFI contracts will need to adapt to changing requirements. Its research found that 83% ofprojects reported that their contracts always or almost always accurately specify the services currentlyrequired. Whilst this leaves a minority of projects where there may be a gap between what the contractprovides and current needs, the Treasury considers the results of the research as evidence that most contractswere working well in adapting to change, and that the relevant incentives within contracts are working. Atthe same time, the Treasury recognised that if PFI contracts are to continue to adapt to changing publicsector needs during contract periods which may run for 30 or more years, it is important that the contracts
1 Managing the relationship to secure a successful partnership in PFI projects (HC375 2001–02).
3639101003 Page Type [O] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence Ev 53
are flexible to allow variations to service delivery to be made and that the terms on which these variations aremade can be demonstrated to be value for money. The Treasury will be making amendments to the standardcontract terms to improve their ability to deal with variations.
12. The NAO is collecting data on contract variations which have already been made and this will betaken into account by the Treasury in the revisions to the standard contract clauses and related guidanceon PFI contract variations. The data which the NAO is collecting will form the basis of a report for the PACon contract variations later in 2007.
Caps on the length of contract periods
13. The issue of appropriate length of contract period is a diYcult balance. Authorities need to take intoaccount their current views on the optimal period over which services should be provided, the risks that therequirements for particular services may change over time and the need to manage aVordability (where, ina PFI deal, reducing the contract period generally increases the annual charge).
14. The Treasury will now encourage departments to identify appropriate maximum contract periods fortheir diVerent types of PFI contracts and to use these in future procurements. The Treasury report notedthat contract lengths should be set with reference to value for money factors rather than aVordability—thatis to say, long contracts should not be entered into simply to reduce the annual cost to make the projectaVordable. The Treasury report says that long contracts can oVer value for money in the rightcircumstances—they can incentivise public authorities to think more strategically about the services theyprovide and the whole life costs of maintaining an asset and risk transfer. In other cases however theimportance of these factors may be reduced, by for instance relatively low capital cost elements to theproject.
The NAO will continue to assess the reasonableness of contract periods in any examinations which wecarry out of individual deals.
B. Other Proposed Measures to Ensure the Delivery of Value for Money in PFI Projects
15. In the report, the Treasury proposed to add to some areas of its PFI value for money assessmentguidance, the updated version of which was released in November 2006. The most notable aspect of theupdated guidance is that the Treasury strengthened the test for whether it is appropriate for authorities toinclude “soft services” (services not related to the building infrastructure such as catering, and cleaning) inPFI contracts.
16. The Treasury report provides guidance that departments have the option of not including softservices in a PFI project where they believe their transfer is not required for achieving the overall benefitsof improved service delivery required by the procurer. The assessment of whether soft services are to beincluded is on value for money factors demonstrating how the particular benefits of the chosen procurementroute will be realised, taking into account the particular trade-oVs involved on a case-by-case basis.
17. We agree with the Treasury analysis which shows that a detailed assessment is required to understandthe balance of advantages and disadvantages of soft service inclusion in a particular project. Based on ourexperience of the PFI and other outsourcing markets factors that appear relevant are:
— The case for including soft services in PFI contracts is that the soft service providers will then bea key part of the private sector PFI team and, in a building project, can then contribute to decisionsabout how the building should be designed and how the project should be priced to make the mosteYcient use of soft services.
— The case for excluding soft services from PFI contracts is mainly to test whether better value formoney might be achieved for these services if the services can be recompeted, say every three or fiveyears. There are, however, arrangements whereby the value of soft services can be benchmarked ormarket tested within a PFI contract, usually every five years, which allow authorities to ask for newservice contractors to be appointed if the existing contractors are unable to provide the services onterms which are value for money. If these arrangements, which are in the early stages of being usedby authorities, work eVectively then the ability of authorities to replace contractors within a longterm PFI contract should be similar to what would have arisen if the soft services had beenexcluded from the PFI contract and relet on a series of short term contracts.
18. The NAO is examining the initial experiences of using these arrangements as part of a report to bepublished in the first half of 2007 on the benchmarking and market testing of ongoing services in PFIcontracts. The forthcoming PAC hearing on this report will enable the Committee to consider further theseissues relating to testing the value for money of soft services in PFI contracts.
19. The other area where the Treasury will be adding to its guidance on the assessment of the value formoney of PFI deals includes the consequences for authorities of diVerent financial structures which biddersmay propose. The type of financing structure used (for example whether bond or bank finance is used fordebt finance) can have implications for the authority in terms of how contract variations which the authority
3639101003 Page Type [E] 03-05-07 21:36:47 Pag Table: COENEW PPSysB Unit: PAG1
Ev 54 Committee of Public Accounts: Evidence
may wish to undertake during the contract period will be funded or implications for seeking to terminatethe contract. The updated value for money guidance November 2006 outlined these issues, with furtherassistance to follow in the Treasury’s update of standard contract terms guidance.
C. Steps to Reduce PFI Procurement Times
20. The Treasury outlined in its report steps aimed at reducing procurement times and costs, withmeasures including those aimed at further improving PFI procurement skills and providing greater support,together with the identification and dissemination of best practice in PFI procurement. In particular, theTreasury report proposes:
— enhancing the capacity of departmental Private Finance Units to ensure they are appropriatelyresourced to support public sector PFI project teams;
— ensuring that public oYcials with experience of complex procurement can be retained anddeployed on projects across the public sector;
— enhancing individual and team procurement skills through formal training;
— requiring procuring authorities to do more work up-front before projects go to the market so as toreduce the risk of time delays through project plans being refined during the procurement process;
— increasing the monitoring and scrutiny of projects, changing how complex projects are approvedand putting in place a mechanisms to identify projects which develop problems during theprocurement;
— developing a best practice PFI project governance model; and
— facilitating the spread of procurement best practice.
21. We agree with the Treasury proposals aimed at reducing PFI procurement times. The NAO report,Improving the tendering process, took a further look at this area of PFI, covering evidence collected sincethe Treasury report was published in March 2006.
22. The NAO published its report, Improving the tendering process (HC149 2006–07), on 8 March2007. The NAO’s examination arose out of concerns expressed by the Committee in 2003 that the tenderingof PFI projects did not follow good practice and was not handled with suYcient skill on the part of the publicsector, with high costs and risks to value for money. In this report we found that key elements of thetendering process had not improved and in some respects had worsened. In particular, tendering times ondeals closed between April 2004 and June 2006 averaged 34 months, no better than the average for projectsthat closed between 2000 and 2003. There have been concerns raised by the private sector that PFI dealstake a long time in the procurement process. Whilst time spent understanding the risks in PFI projects beforecontracts are let has contributed to the avoidance of time and cost overruns in the subsequent delivery ofthe projects we found that many of the reasons for long tendering periods (some of which may relate equallyto conventionally procured projects) could have been avoided or mitigated by the public sector withoutrisking overall value for money.
23. Based on this further evidence the NAO report also recommended that:
— departments should agree with the Treasury appropriate target times for their sector. 18 to 24months would not be unreasonable for many projects although it may be unrealistic forparticularly complex, one-oV PFI deals. Progress should be monitored during procurement, withdepartments taking action if progress suggests target times are likely to be missed.
— in line with the Treasury proposal that projects do more work up-front, authorities should obtaincommitment from all key stakeholders at an early stage, develop better output specifications,establish the aVordability of the project before it is brought to market and again before a preferredbidder is selected, and agree the commercial basis of a deal as well as key aspects of the detaileddesign prior to selecting a preferred bidder.
— The Treasury should consider publishing information on the length of time taken to procureindividual deals to help motivate project teams to achieve shorter tendering times.
— in line with the Treasury proposal that procurement best practice should be spread, departmentsshould identify lessons from recently closed PFI deals, revising guidance and standardspecifications accordingly. They should also ensure that post-project evaluations are completedand the lessons shared. There should be a more co-ordinated and targeted approach to sharinggood practice by central advisory bodies such as the OYce of Government Commerce (OGC),Partnerships UK (PUK), the local advisory body 4Ps and the Treasury Project Review Group witha forum through which authorities can share their experiences and raise queries to complement theexisting PUK helpline.
24. The Committee will be able to consider further these issues relating to PFI procurement at theforthcoming hearing on the NAO report, Improving the PFI tendering process.
Printed in the United Kingdom by The Stationery OYce Limited5/2007 363910 19585