high incidence of recurrence and hematologic events following liver transplantation for...

6
High incidence of recurrence and hematologic events following liver transplantation for Budd–Chiari syndrome Budd–Chiari syndrome (BCS) is characterized by hepatic venous outflow obstruction involving the hepatic vein, inferior vena cava (IVC) or both. The presentation of BCS may be acute or chronic, typically associated with signs and symptoms of portal hypertension (1). Hepatic congestion result- ing from outflow obstruction leads to hepatic necrosis and ischemic injury, with progressive centrilobular fibrosis and eventual cirrhosis (1). Most cases of BCS in the Western hemisphere are associated with underlying myeloproliferative dis- ease (MPD) or other hematologic disorders with inherent thrombogenic propensity (1–5). Treatment of BCS consists of medical and surgical interven- tions (1–3). Medical management includes treating the underlying hematologic disorder, anticoagula- tion and the use of diuretics for control of ascites (1, 5, 6). Percutaneous balloon angioplasty, stenting and thrombolytic therapy may be beneficial in selected cases with acute presentation (1, 7, 8). Porto-systemic shunting converts the portal vein into an outflow tract for the liver, thus relieving hepatic congestion and necrosis (2, 9). Recently, transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt Cruz E, Ascher NL, Roberts JP, Bass NM, Yao FY. High incidence of recurrence and hematologic events following liver transplantation for Budd–Chiari syndrome. Clin Transplant 2005: 19: 501–506. ª Blackwell Munksgaard, 2005 Abstract: Background: Most cases of Budd–Chiari syndrome (BCS) in Western countries are related to underlying hematologic diseases with inherent thrombogenic propensity. We evaluated the long-term outcome, risks for recurrent disease, and other hematologic complications following orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) for BCS. Methods: Clinical data from 11 consecutive patients with BCS who underwent OLT were retrospectively reviewed. Four patients had a prior transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt and one had a surgical shunt procedure. All patients were started on intravenous heparin within the first 24 h following OLT. All except one patient who had protein C deficiency were maintained on long-term oral anticoagulation. Results: The Kaplan–Meier survival rates at 1, 5 and 10 yr were 81, 65 and 65%, respectively. Three patients developed BCS recurrence, inclu- ding two who died as a consequence of rapid graft failure within days after OLT. Three patients developed other thrombotic events, including splenic vein thrombosis associated with gastric variceal hemorrhage requiring splenectomy, portal vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism. Four patients experienced severe bleeding complications within 7 d after OLT requiring exploratory laparotomy. One patient died after transfor- mation of polycythemia vera to acute myelogenous leukemia at 2.1 yr after OLT. Conclusion: We observed a high incidence of recurrent BCS and compli- cations related to the underlying hematologic disorder or anticoagulation after OLT for BCS. The present series also included the first two cases of rapid recurrence of BCS and graft failure within days after OLT. Elizabeth Cruz a , Nancy L Ascher b , John P Roberts b , Nathan M Bass a and Francis Y Yao a,b a Division of Gastroenterology, Department of Medicine, and b Division of Transplantation, Department of Surgery, University of California, San Francisco, CA, USA Key words: bleeding complications – Budd–Chiari syndrome – orthotopic liver transplantation – recurrence – thrombosis Corresponding author: Francis Y. Yao, M.D., Division of Gastroenterology, Department of Medicine, University of California, San Francisco, Box 0538, 513 Parnassus Avenue, Room S-357, San Francisco, CA 94143-0538, USA. Tel.: +1 415 514 0332; fax: +1 415 476 0659; e-mail: [email protected] Accepted for publication 17 March 2005 Clin Transplant 2005: 19: 501–506 DOI: 10.1111/j.1399-0012.2005.00374.x Copyright ª Blackwell Munksgaard 2005 501

Upload: elizabeth-cruz

Post on 15-Jul-2016

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: High incidence of recurrence and hematologic events following liver transplantation for Budd–Chiari syndrome

High incidence of recurrence andhematologic events following livertransplantation for Budd–Chiari syndrome

Budd–Chiari syndrome (BCS) is characterized byhepatic venous outflow obstruction involving thehepatic vein, inferior vena cava (IVC) or both. Thepresentation of BCS may be acute or chronic,typically associated with signs and symptoms ofportal hypertension (1). Hepatic congestion result-ing from outflow obstruction leads to hepaticnecrosis and ischemic injury, with progressivecentrilobular fibrosis and eventual cirrhosis (1).Most cases of BCS in the Western hemisphere areassociated with underlying myeloproliferative dis-ease (MPD) or other hematologic disorders with

inherent thrombogenic propensity (1–5). Treatmentof BCS consists of medical and surgical interven-tions (1–3). Medical management includes treatingthe underlying hematologic disorder, anticoagula-tion and the use of diuretics for control of ascites(1, 5, 6). Percutaneous balloon angioplasty, stentingand thrombolytic therapy may be beneficial inselected cases with acute presentation (1, 7, 8).Porto-systemic shunting converts the portal veininto an outflow tract for the liver, thus relievinghepatic congestion and necrosis (2, 9). Recently,transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt

Cruz E, Ascher NL, Roberts JP, Bass NM, Yao FY. High incidence ofrecurrence and hematologic events following liver transplantation forBudd–Chiari syndrome.Clin Transplant 2005: 19: 501–506. ª Blackwell Munksgaard, 2005

Abstract: Background: Most cases of Budd–Chiari syndrome (BCS) inWestern countries are related to underlying hematologic diseases withinherent thrombogenic propensity. We evaluated the long-term outcome,risks for recurrent disease, and other hematologic complications followingorthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) for BCS.Methods: Clinical data from 11 consecutive patients with BCS whounderwent OLT were retrospectively reviewed. Four patients had a priortransjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt and one had a surgical shuntprocedure. All patients were started on intravenous heparin within the first24 h following OLT. All except one patient who had protein C deficiencywere maintained on long-term oral anticoagulation.Results: The Kaplan–Meier survival rates at 1, 5 and 10 yr were 81, 65and 65%, respectively. Three patients developed BCS recurrence, inclu-ding two who died as a consequence of rapid graft failure within daysafter OLT. Three patients developed other thrombotic events, includingsplenic vein thrombosis associated with gastric variceal hemorrhagerequiring splenectomy, portal vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism.Four patients experienced severe bleeding complications within 7 d afterOLT requiring exploratory laparotomy. One patient died after transfor-mation of polycythemia vera to acute myelogenous leukemia at 2.1 yrafter OLT.Conclusion: We observed a high incidence of recurrent BCS and compli-cations related to the underlying hematologic disorder or anticoagulationafter OLT for BCS. The present series also included the first two cases ofrapid recurrence of BCS and graft failure within days after OLT.

Elizabeth Cruza, Nancy L Ascherb,John P Robertsb, Nathan M Bassa

and Francis Y Yaoa,b

a Division of Gastroenterology, Department of

Medicine, and b Division of Transplantation,

Department of Surgery, University of California,

San Francisco, CA, USA

Key words: bleeding complications –

Budd–Chiari syndrome – orthotopic liver

transplantation – recurrence – thrombosis

Corresponding author: Francis Y. Yao, M.D.,

Division of Gastroenterology, Department of

Medicine, University of California, San Francisco,

Box 0538, 513 Parnassus Avenue, Room S-357,

San Francisco, CA 94143-0538, USA.

Tel.: +1 415 514 0332; fax: +1 415 476 0659;

e-mail: [email protected]

Accepted for publication 17 March 2005

Clin Transplant 2005: 19: 501–506 DOI: 10.1111/j.1399-0012.2005.00374.xCopyright ª Blackwell Munksgaard 2005

501

Page 2: High incidence of recurrence and hematologic events following liver transplantation for Budd–Chiari syndrome

(TIPS) has also been shown to be an effectivealternative therapy among patients with BCSrefractory to medical therapy (10, 11).BCS accounts for about 1% of all indications for

orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) in theUnited States (12) and in Europe (13). The usualcriteria for OLT for patients with BCS includefulminant disease presentation, advanced fibrosisor cirrhosis by liver biopsy and deterioration ofliver function despite medical or surgical interven-tions (1–3). While satisfactory patient survivalfollowing OLT for BCS has been reported (13–21), information on the risks for recurrent BCS andother hematologic complications after OLT is stilllimited.In the present study, we reviewed the results of

OLT in 11 consecutive patients with BCS andcompared the outcome with other published data.We focussed on hematologic complications follow-ing OLT, including recurrent BCS, otherthrombotic events, bleeding associated with anti-coagulation and hematologic malignancies.

Patients and methods

Among 1162 adult patients over the age of 18 yrwho underwent OLT at the University of Califor-nia San Francisco between January 1988 andJanuary 2002, 11 patients (1%) had BCS as theprimary indication for OLT. Clinical data of these

patients were collected retrospectively from acomputerized database and by review of theirmedical charts.

The individual baseline clinical characteristicsare presented in Table 1. To summarize, there werenine females and two males with a median age of48 yr (range 27–62 yr). Polycythemia vera (PCV)was the most common underlying hematologicdisorder, found in six patients (55%). One patienthad protein C deficiency. The type of MPD couldnot be specified in two patients. The remaining twopatients had no known underlying hematologicdiagnosis. Three of the patients with PCV also hada history of oral contraceptive use.

The interval from the diagnosis of BCS to theday of OLT ranged from 1 month to 18 yr. Sixpatients were on chronic oral anticoagulation for3–156 months prior to OLT. Anticoagulation wasdiscontinued after 14 yr for patient no. 5 followingan episode of upper gastrointestinal bleeding at1 yr prior to OLT. Four other patients were not onoral anticoagulation prior to OLT because of acutepresentation of BCS within 4 weeks before OLT intwo patients and for unknown reasons in the othertwo patients.

All 11 patients had ascites requiring diuretictherapy at the time of OLT. Five patients had ahistory of hepatic encephalopathy treated withneomycin or lactulose or both. Pertinent laborat-ory data within 24 h prior to OLT were recorded.

Table 1. Baseline characteristics for the 11 patients in the present cohort who underwent liver transplantation

PatientGender(M/F)

Age(years)

Hematologicdiagnosis

Duration ofBCS diagnosisbefore OLT(months)

Anticoagulationbefore OLT(time before OLT)

Other treatments(time before OLT) HE

Bilirubin(mg/dL) INR

Creatinine(mg/dL)

1 F 27 PCV 24 Warfarin (15 months) SSPCS (26 months),hydroxyurea, phlebotomy

Yes 1.5 1.4 1.4

2 F 54 Protein Cdeficiency

48 Warfarin (39 months) TIPS (11 months) No 2.3 1.3 1.3

3 F 52 PCV 2 Warfarin (2 months) TIPS (9 d) No 15.9 1.9 0.64 F 56 PCV 1 Intraveneous heparin No 8.1 2.6 2.55 F 47 PCV 216 Warfarin for 14 yr

before stopped1 yr before OLT

Phlebotomy (7 yr) No 1.8 1.5 1.1

6 F 58 PCV 18 Warfarin(18 months)

Hydroxyurea (5 yr) No 7.0 3.6 1.5

7 M 29 MPDa 8 TIPS Yes 3.6 1.3 1.98 F 55 MPDa 1 Intraveneous

heparin (1 month)Peritoneovenous shunt Yes 1.7 1.1 3.9

9 M 62 Unknown 6 Failed TIPS attempt No 1.2 1.7 1.710 F 54 PCV 2 TIPS (2 months),

hydroxyurea (9 yr)Yes 4.9 1.5 0.9

11 F 50 Unknown 48 Warfarin (4 yr) Yes 1.2 1.2 0.8

BCS, Budd–Chiari syndrome; OLT, orthotopic liver transplantation; HE, hepatic encephalopathy; INR, international normalized ratio for prothrombin time; PCV, polycyt-hemia vera; SSPCS, side-to-side portal caval shunt; TIPS, transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt; MPD, myeloproliferative disorder.a The type of myeloproliferative disorder could not be further specified in two patients (patient nos 7 and 8).

Cruz et al.

502

Page 3: High incidence of recurrence and hematologic events following liver transplantation for Budd–Chiari syndrome

The bilirubin level ranged from 1.5 to 8.1 mg/dLwith a median of 2.3 mg/dL. The serum creatinineranged from 0.9 to 2.5 mg/dL with a median of1.4 mg/dL. The last set of values for the interna-tional normalized ratio for prothrombin time(INR) before OLT was presented in Table 1.

Four patients underwent TIPS between 9 d and11 months prior to OLT. This procedure wascomplicated by severe intra-abdominal bleedingwith rapid deterioration of liver function in patientno. 3, resulting in OLT 9 d after the procedure.Patient no. 9 had attempted TIPS that failed fortechnical reasons. Patient no. 1 had a side-to-sideportocaval shunt performed at 26 months prior toOLT. Patient no. 8 had a peritoneovenous shuntplaced for control of ascites (Table 1).

Results

The outcome of the individual patient is summar-ized in Table 2. All 11 patients were started onintravenous heparin within the first 24 h afterOLT. The single patient with protein C deficiencywas not maintained on long-term anticoagulationas OLT would cure this disorder. The other eightpatients who survived the initial hospitalization forOLT were maintained on chronic warfarin

therapy. Six patients were also placed on hydroxy-urea and aspirin after OLT.

Patient and graft survival

The Kaplan–Meier survival rates at 1, 5 and 10 yrwere 81, 65 and 65%, respectively. The respectivegraft survival rates were identical to patient survi-val. The median follow-up was 4.7 yr amongsurvivors with a range of 0.3–11 yr. Nine of 11patients survived the initial hospitalization forOLT. The two early deaths were both because ofrecurrent BCS. The first patient (patient no. 3,Table 2) was found to have extensive thrombosisinvolving the hepatic veins, portal vein and IVC onDoppler ultrasound examination performed withinthe first 24 h after OLT. She experienced severegraft failure and died 2 d after OLT. Patient no. 4developed early recurrent BCS and underwent liverre-transplantation 4 d after primary OLT. Pathol-ogy of the first liver graft revealed extensive intra-hepatic thrombi consistent with rapid recurrence ofBCS. This patient developed multi-organ failureand died 16 d after the second OLT. At autopsy, alarge organizing thrombus was found in the IVC,associated with extensive central venous necrosis inthe liver. Patient no. 5 died at 27 months after OLT

Table 2. Summary of outcome after liver transplantation for the 11 patients in the present cohort

PatientThrombotic event(time after OLT)

Treatment forthrombotic eventin addition toanticoagulation

Bleeding event(time after OLT)

Treatment forbleeding event(time after OLT) Outcome

1 Splenic vein thrombosiswith gastric varicealbleeding at 7 and 9 d

Splenectomy at 11 d Splenic vein thrombosiswith gastric varicealbleeding at 7 and 9 d

Alive at 23 months

2 Intra-abdominalbleeding on day 3

Exploratorylaparotomy

Alive at 94 months

3 Recurrent BCS(within 1 d)

Died 3 d after OLTfrom graft failure

4 Recurrent BCS(within 2 d)

Re-OLT at 4 d after OLT Died 16 d afterre-OLT from multi-organ failure andrecurrent BCS of thesecond graft

5 Pulmonary embolism(intraoperative)

Intra-abdominal bleedingon day 6 from hepaticartery anastomosis

Exploratorylaparotomy

AML at 24 monthsDied at 27 months

6 Portal vein thrombosis(2 months)

Thrombolytic therapywith urokinase

Intra-abdominalbleeding on day 2

Exploratorylaparotomy

Alive at 3 months

7 Intra-abdominalbleeding on day 3

Exploratorylaparotomy

Alive at 9 months

8 Alive at 132 months9 Alive at 100 months

10 Alive at 100 months11 Recurrent BCS

(26 months)Placement of TIPS Alive at 29 months

OLT, orthotopic liver transplantation; BCS, Budd–Chiari syndrome; re-OLT, liver re-transplantation; TIPS, transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt.

Liver transplant for Budd–Chiari syndrome

503

Page 4: High incidence of recurrence and hematologic events following liver transplantation for Budd–Chiari syndrome

following transformation of PCV to acute myelo-genous leukemia at 24 months after OLT.

Thrombotic complications

In addition to the two early deaths because ofrecurrent BCS, four other patients had thromboticevents following OLT (Table 2). Patient no. 1 wasfound to have splenic vein thrombosis presentingwith gastric variceal bleeding at 7 and 9 d respect-ively, after OLT, requiring splenectomy at 11 dafter OLT. Patient no. 5 experienced pulmonaryembolism intra-operatively but recovered withoutsequelae. Patient no. 6 developed portal veinthrombosis two months after OLT despite beingon oral anticoagulation with therapeutic INRlevels. This patient was given thrombolytic therapywith urokinase and was subsequently maintainedon low molecular weight heparin subcutaneously.Patient no. 11 developed recurrent BCS at26 months after OLT associated with sub-thera-peutic INR levels and non-compliance. Thispatient did well after a TIPS procedure.

Bleeding complications associated with anticoagulation

Not including patient no. 1 who had splenic veinthrombosis presenting with gastric variceal bleed-ing, four other patients had major intra-abdominalhemorrhage within the first 7 d after OLT requi-ring exploratory laparotomy for control of bleed-ing (Table 2). All patients had uneventful recoveryfrom these bleeding episodes and were subse-quently maintained on anticoagulation therapy.

Discussion

We presented our single-center experience withOLT for BCS in 11 patients and reviewed the datafrom eight series published since 1990 (14–21),which are summarized in Table 3. The 65%actuarial patient survival rates at 5 and 10 yr afterOLT in the present study were similar to thatreported in most other published series, althoughSrinivasan et. al. (20) reported an exceptional 5 yrsurvival rate of 95% (Table 3). For patients withBCS because of antithrombin III, protein S orprotein C deficiency, OLT also cures the inbornerror of metabolism and eliminates the associatedthrombogenic propensity. Other patients with BCSand MPD such as PCV continue to be at risk forthrombosis after OLT and require long-term anti-coagulation. The incidence of recurrent BCSfollowing OLT ranged from 0% to about 10% inthese studies (14–21). Including information fromisolated case reports (22, 23), recurrence of BCS

was diagnosed between 5 months and 7 yr afterOLT and was most often because of sub-therapeu-tic anticoagulation (14, 18, 21). Jamieson et al. (15)reported a patient who received no anticoagulationafter OLT and developed recurrent BCS at 28 dafter OLT. In addition to recurrent BCS, somepostoperative thrombotic events, including pul-monary embolism, portal vein thrombosis andhepatic artery thrombosis, have culminated indeath or graft loss (14, 15, 18–21) (Table 3). Earlyadministration of anticoagulation therapy toreduce the risk for thrombosis in these patientsneeds to be carefully balanced against bleedingcomplications associated with anticoagulationespecially in the early postoperative period. Melearet al. (21) reported a low incidence of thromboticevents with no major bleeding complications afterOLT for BCS using anti-platelet agents includinghydroxyurea and aspirin without warfarin in themajority of their patients with MPD.

Compared to prior studies, there are severalunusual aspects of our findings. First, early recur-rence of BCS within hours to days after OLTleading to rapid graft failure was observed in twopatients and confirmed by histopathology of theliver graft. One of the two patients died withoutre-OLT, whereas the other patient suffered fromrecurrent BCS again in the second liver graft anddied eventually of multi-organ failure. To ourknowledge, these are the first two reported casesthat clearly demonstrated rapid recurrence of BCSwithin days after OLT and led to rapid graft losseven when anticoagulation was initiated within24 h after OLT. Some investigators recommendedanticoagulation to be commenced within 6 h afterOLT (21), despite substantial bleeding risk duringthe early postoperative period. Second, the overallincidence of all types of thrombotic events in ourseries (55%) appears to be significantly higher thanother reports (Table 3), although the small samplesize may be a source of bias. We also observed ahigh incidence of serious postoperative bleedingrequiring surgical intervention. Only three of 11patients in our series were completely free ofhematologic complications after OLT. However,these complications were not the focus of some ofthe published series. Consequently, their trueincidence could have been underestimated in thesestudies.

One patient in our series died after transforma-tion from PCV to acute myelogenous leukemia at2 yr after OLT. This patient was diagnosed withPCV at 7 yr and BCS at 18 yr, prior to OLT.Srinivasan et al. (20) also described a patient withPCV who developed acute leukemia 8 yr afterOLT. It has been suggested that patients with PCV

Cruz et al.

504

Page 5: High incidence of recurrence and hematologic events following liver transplantation for Budd–Chiari syndrome

Tab

le3.

Sum

mar

yof

clin

ical

dat

afr

omp

ublis

hed

serie

sof

liver

tran

spla

ntat

ion

for

Bud

d–C

hiar

isyn

dro

me

Aut

hor,

Yea

r(R

efer

ence

)N

umb

erof

pat

ient

s

Act

uaria

lpat

ient

surv

ival

(%)

Rec

urre

ntB

CS

,n

(%),

trea

tmen

tan

dou

tcom

eO

ther

thro

mb

otic

even

ts,

n(%

)B

leed

ing

even

ts,

n(%

)O

ther

even

ts1-

yr5-

yr10

-yr

Hal

ffet

al.

(14)

2369

45N

R2

(9)

–D

ied

at15

and

34m

onth

s,re

spec

tivel

y,w

ithou

tre

-OLT

3(1

3)–

PE

(Int

ra-o

per

ativ

ean

dd

ied

),H

AT

(5m

onth

s)an

dH

AT

(re-

OLT

at4

d)

NR

Jam

ieso

net

al.

(15)

2869

50N

R2

(7)

–D

ied

at28

d(r

ecei

ved

noan

ticoa

gul

atio

n)an

d11

yr

5(1

8)–

PV

Tin

four

(tw

od

ied

),H

AT

inon

e(d

ied

)

3(1

1)–

Die

dp

eri-

oper

ativ

ely

unre

late

dto

anti-

coag

ulat

ion

Lym

pho

ma

at5

yrin

one

pat

ient

Sha

ked

etal

.(1

6)14

8676

(3yr

)N

R0

(0)

NR

NR

Kno

opet

al.

(17)

888

NR

NR

1(1

3)–

Re-

OLT

at2

yr1

(13)

–H

AT

with

PV

T(r

e-O

LTat

1yr

)2

(25)

–P

osto

per

ativ

ein

tra-

abd

omin

alb

leed

and

GI

ble

edin

gR

ing

eet

al.

(18)

4369

6969

0(0

)6

(14)

–H

AT

intw

o(r

e-O

LTin

bot

h),

PV

Tin

thre

e(o

ned

ied

at19

d,

two

had

varic

eal

ble

edin

g),

cere

bra

lthr

omb

osis

inon

e(d

ied

at16

d)

Nin

ep

atie

nts

(21)

with

early

pos

top

erat

ive

ble

edin

g(d

etai

lsno

tp

rovi

ded

)

Hem

min

get

al.

(19)

782

67N

R0

(0)

1(1

4)–

HA

Tw

ithP

VT

at2

wee

ks(r

e-O

LT)

NR

Srin

iasa

net

al.

(20)

1995

9578

2(1

1)–

One

had

TIP

San

dsu

rgic

alsh

unt

(5m

onth

s),

one

had

re-O

LTat

7yr

2(1

1)–

HA

Tin

two,

bot

hha

dre

-OLT

7(3

7)–

Pos

top

erat

ive

intr

a-ab

dom

inal

ble

edin

gin

thre

e,G

Ib

leed

ing

inth

ree,

hem

orrh

agic

pan

crea

titis

inon

e

PC

Vto

AM

Lat

8yr

inon

ep

atie

nt

Mel

ear

etal

.(2

1)a

17N

RN

RN

R0

(0)

3(1

8)–

PV

Tin

two

(one

die

dat

124

mon

ths)

,th

rom

bos

isof

bra

chia

lar

tery

inon

ep

atie

nt

Non

e

Pre

sent

serie

s11

8165

653

(27)

–O

ned

ied

at2

d,

one

had

re-O

LTat

4d

and

die

d16

dla

ter,

one

had

TIP

Sat

2yr

3(2

7)–

PV

T(2

mon

ths

trea

ted

with

thro

mb

olys

is),

Sp

leni

cve

inth

rom

bos

is(t

reat

edw

ithsp

lene

ctom

y),

PE

(intr

a-op

erat

ive)

Six

even

tsin

five

pat

ient

s(4

5)–

Pos

top

erat

ive

intr

a-ab

dom

inal

ble

edin

gin

five,

GI

ble

edin

gin

one

(Tab

le2)

PC

Vto

AM

Lat

2yr

inon

ep

atie

nt

NR

,no

tre

por

ted

;re

-OLT

,liv

erre

-tra

nsp

lant

atio

n;P

E,

pul

mon

ary

emb

olis

m;

HA

T,he

pat

icar

tery

thro

mb

osis

;P

VT,

por

tal

vein

thro

mb

osis

;TI

PS

,tr

ansj

ugul

arin

trah

epat

icp

orto

syst

emic

shun

t;P

CV

,p

olyc

ythe

mia

vera

;A

ML,

acut

em

yelo

gen

eous

leuk

emia

;G

I,g

astr

oint

estin

al.

aTh

em

ajor

ityof

pat

ient

sin

this

stud

yre

ceiv

edan

tipla

tele

tag

ents

incl

udin

ghy

dro

xyur

eaan

das

piri

nw

ithou

tw

arfa

rinaf

ter

liver

tran

spla

ntat

ion.

Liver transplant for Budd–Chiari syndrome

505

Page 6: High incidence of recurrence and hematologic events following liver transplantation for Budd–Chiari syndrome

have a near-normal life expectancy in the first 10 yrsince the initial diagnosis. However, the risk formyelofibrosis and acute leukemia increases there-after, estimated to be 10% at 15 yr and 25% at25 yr (3). Consequently, the duration of PCV maybe an important factor in considering OLT forthese patients (1–3).In conclusion, we observed a high incidence of

disease recurrence as well as other associatedhematologic complications in patients with BCSwho underwent OLT. Our series also included thefirst two cases of rapid recurrence of BCS leadingto graft failure within days after OLT, despiteanticoagulation initiated within 24 h after OLT.Correcting the thrombogenic propensity of theunderlying hematologic disorder remains the keyto the management of these patients, althoughanticoagulation carries a substantial bleeding riskin the early postoperative period.

Acknowledgements

The work was supported in part by a grant from theNational Institute of Health to the University of California,San Francisco Liver Center (P30DK26743).

References

1. Narayanan Menon KV, Shah V, Kamath PS. TheBudd–Chiari syndrome. N Engl J Med 2004: 350: 578.

2. Klein AS, Molmenti EP. Surgical treatment of Budd–Chiari syndrome. Liver Transpl 2003: 9: 891.

3. Ganguli SC, Ramzan NN, McKusick MA, Andrews

JC, Phyliky RL, Kamath PS. Budd–Chiari syndrome inpatients with hematologic disease: a therapeutic challenge.Hepatology 1998: 27: 1157.

4. DenningerMH, Chait Y, CasadeallN. Cause of portalor hepatic venous thrombosis in adults: the role of multipleconcurrent factors. Hepatology 2000: 31: 587.

5. Zeitoun G, Escolano S, Hadengue A et al. Outcome ofBudd–Chiari syndrome: a multivariate analysis of factorsrelated to survival including surgical portosystemicshunting. Hepatology 1999: 30: 84.

6. Min AD, Atillasoy EO, Schwartz ME, Thiim M,Miller CM, Bodenheimer HC Jr. Reassessing the role ofmedical therapy in the management of hepatic veinthrombosis. Liver Transpl Surg 1997: 3: 423.

7. Frank JW, Kamath PS, Stanson AM. Budd–Chiarisyndrome: early intervention with angioplasty andthrombolytic therapy. Mayo Clin Proc 1994: 69: 877.

8. Bibao JI, Pueyo JC, Longo JM. Interventional thera-peutic techniques in Budd–Chiari syndrome. CardiovascInterv Radiol 1997: 20: 112.

9. Orloff MJ, Daily PO, Orloff SL, Girard B, Orloff

MS. A 27-year experience with surgical treatment ofBudd–Chiari syndrome. Ann Surg 2000: 232: 340.

10. Ganger DR, Klapman JB, McDonald V. Transjugularintrahepatic portosystemic shunt (TIPS) for Budd–Chiarisyndrome or portal vein thrombosis: review of indicationsand problems. Am J Gastroenterol 1999: 94: 603.

11. Perello A, Garcia-Pagan JC, Gilabert R et al. TIPS isa useful long-term derivative therapy for patients withBudd–Chiari syndrome uncontrolled by medical therapy.Hepatology 2002: 35: 132.

12. Roberts MS, Angus DC, Bryce CL, Valenta Z,Weissfeld L. Survival after liver transplantation in theUnited States: a disease-specific analysis of the UNOSdatabase. Liver Transpl 2004: 10: 886.

13. Adam R, McMaster P, O’Grady J et al. Evolution ofliver transplantation in Europe: report of the EuropeanLiver Transplant Registry. Liver Transpl 2003: 9: 1231.

14. Halff G, Todo S, Tzakis AG, Gordon RD, Starzl TE.Liver transplantation for the Budd–Chiari syndrome. AnnSurg 1990: 211: 43.

15. Jamieson NV, Williams R, Calne RY. Liver transplan-tation for Budd–Chiari syndrome. Ann Chir 1991: 45: 362.

16. Shaked A, Goldstein R, Klintmalm G, Drazan K,Husberg B, Busuttil RW. Portosystemic shunt versusorthotopic liver transplantation for the Budd–Chiarisyndrome. Surg Gynecol Obstetr 1992: 174: 453.

17. Knoop M, Lemmens H-P, Lengrehr J et al. Livertransplantation for Budd–Chiari syndrome. TransplantProc 1994: 26: 3577.

18. Ringe B, Lang H, Oldhafer KJ et al. Which is the bestsurgery for Budd–Chiari syndrome: venous decompressionor liver transplantation? A single-center experience with 50patients. Hepatology 1995: 21: 1337.

19. Hemming AW, Langer B, Greig P, Taylor BR, Adams

R, Heathcoate EJ. Treatment of Budd–Chiari syndromewith portosystemic shunt or liver transplantation. Am JSurg 1996: 171: 176.

20. Srinivasan P, Rela M, Prachalias A et al. Livertransplantation for Budd–Chiari syndrome. Transplanta-tion 2002: 73: 973.

21. Melear JM, Goldstein RM, Levy MF et al. Hemato-logic aspects of liver transplantation for Budd–Chiarisyndrome with special reference to myeloproliferatiedisorders. Transplantation 2002: 74: 1090.

22. Seltman HJ, Dekker A, Van Thiel DH, Boggs DR,Starzl TE. Budd–Chiari syndrome recurring in a trans-planted liver. Gastroenterology 1983: 84: 640.

23. Ruckert JC, Ruckert RI, Rudolf B, Muller JM.Recurrence of the Budd–Chiari syndrome after orthotopicliver transplantation. Hepatogastroenterology 1999: 46:867.

Cruz et al.

506