hearst park and pool and idaho avenue trail … · the organic act of 1871 incorporated washington...
TRANSCRIPT
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
1
HEARST PARK AND POOL/IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL
PHASE IB ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE SURVEY MANAGEMENT SUMMARY
Submitted to:
Dr. Ruth Trocolli
DC Historic Preservation Office
1100 4th Street SW
Suite 650-E
Washington, D.C. 20024
By:
Emily L. Swain, MAA
Stantec Consulting Services Inc.
6110 Frost Place
Laurel, Maryland 20707
23 September 2016
Under contract to EHT Traceries, Inc., Stantec Consulting Services Inc. (Stantec) conducted a
Phase IB archaeological site survey within the proposed Hearst Park and Pool and Idaho Avenue
Trail Limits of Disturbance (LOD) in northwest Washington, D.C. (Figure 1). The archaeological
site survey was conducted in accordance with the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards and
Guidelines for Archeology and Historic Preservation, and the DC Preservation League’s
Guidelines for Archaeological Investigations in the District of Columbia (DC Preservation
League 1998; Federal Register 1983). All investigations were based on DGS RFP DCAM-15-AE-
0146 and the Idaho Avenue ROW RFP issued by Cox Graae + Spack Architects on June 23,
2016. The archaeological site survey included six (6) tasks: review of background research;
elevation change analysis; archaeological field investigations; artifact analysis and site form
preparation; preparation of draft and final versions of a management summary and a Phase IB
technical report for submittal to EHT Traceries and the District of Columbia Historic
Preservation Office (DC HPO) for review and comment; and artifact/ document curation.
The DC HPO site files indicate that a Phase IA reconnaissance archaeological survey and
subsequent Phase II evaluation survey were conducted on the Hearst Park and Pool property by
Engineering-Science, Inc. (Artemel et al. 1984; Crowell et al. 1986); however, the studies were
insufficient to determine if archaeological resources are present. A single archaeological site has
been identified within 500 feet of the Hearst Park and Pool property. The Sidwell Friends School
site (51NW123) was identified during the National Register of Historic Places nomination
process but has not been evaluated for archaeological potential. No archaeological investigations
have been conducted nor have any archaeological sites been identified within the Idaho Avenue
Trail LOD.
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
2
Figure 1. Location of Hearst Park and Idaho Avenue Trail (north at top of figure) (Google 2016).
Proposed Undertaking
The District of Columbia Department of General Services (DGS) is providing design-build
services for the Department of Parks and Recreation at the Hearst Park property in northwest
Washington, D.C. (Figure 1). The proposed project includes the renovation or replacement of
athletic fields, construction of a new pool and pool house, construction of new tennis courts,
stormwater management (including remediation of site drainage and runoff issues),
improvements to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act, landscaping, fencing, site
furnishing, amenities, signage, and hardscaping (Figure 2). Maximal depth of excavation is
anticipated to be 10 feet below grade for the pool and detention structure, while the pool house
foundation, storm sewer, and other utilities will be 3 feet below surface. All other excavations
will be 1.5 feet or less below grade. The DGS team is currently conducting a feasibility study and
no site plans have been developed that locate the proposed amenities.
In conjunction with the park and pool renovation project, DGS will improve the existing trail
within the trail footprint and extend the trail to connect with the park entrance steps (Figure 3).
The trail improvements will consist of a limited portion of the LOD as depicted in Figure 3.
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
3
Figure 2. Hearst Park Existing Site Plan with proposed improvements noted. (Map provided by Cox Graae +
Spack Architects)
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
4
Figure 3. Idaho Avenue Trail and Hearst Park and Pool LODs. (Map provided by Cox Graae + Spack
Architects)
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
5
Historical Overview (Kendra Parzen, EHT Traceries)
Hearst Recreation Center is located at 37th Street and Quebec Street NW (Figure 1). It occupies
an irregularly shaped parcel bounded to the south by Quebec Street, to the west by 37th Street,
to the north by Hearst Elementary School, and to the east by Idaho Avenue, a trail, and a
residential neighborhood. The parcel is located within Square 1905, Lots 802 and 008.
The earliest known European ownership of the Hearst Recreation Center parcel dates to 1713,
when it became part of a tract in Montgomery County, Maryland, patented by Thomas Addison
and James Stoddert (Busey 1898, 170). Born in Maryland in 1679, Thomas Addison was a
member of the Privy Council of Maryland from 1711 until his death in 1727. He was also a
Colonel of the Prince George’s County Militia (Bowie 1947:32). James Stoddert was born in
Scotland in 1666 and emigrated circa 1675. He became the Surveyor-General for the colony of
Maryland. He died in 1726 (Early Colonial Settlers of Southern Maryland and Virginia’s
Northern Neck Colonies 2016). In 1790, the Residence Act established the capital district, and
the Hearst Recreation Center parcel became part of Washington County.
In 1817, Joseph Nourse purchased 130 acres of the former Addison/Stoddert patent that
included the future Hearst Park. Nourse, an English emigre who arrived in Virginia in 1769,
served in the Revolutionary Army before becoming Register of the Treasury in 1789. From 1803
to 1813, he resided at Dumbarton Oaks in Georgetown before moving to the country near the
current site of Washington Cathedral, where he established his Mt. Alban estate. He purchased
the property containing the Hearst Recreation Center as a wedding present for his son, Charles
J. Nourse (U.S. Department of the Interior [US DOI] 1972:3). Charles was an army careerist and
eventually rose to become an Adjutant General (Pequet du Bellet 1907:110). Between 1817 and
1827, the Nourse family constructed a house on the property called the Highlands. Today known
as Zartman House, it currently serves as an administrative building for the Sidwell Friends
school, located west across 37th Street from Hearst Recreation Center (US DOI, 1972:1–3). The
Nourse estates were two of many large plantations located in Washington County in the early
1800s, many of which relied on slave labor (DC HPO 2013:7).
Charles J. Nourse and his wife Rebecca had eleven children, four boys and seven girls. One son,
Israel Pemberton Nourse, died in the Civil War fighting for the Confederacy (Pequet du Bellay
1907:110). A daughter, Phoebe, died unmarried at age eighteen, leaving a bequest to erect a
church for the Episcopal parish of St. Albans (Evening Star [ES], 8 December 1929:101). Her
sisters Mary, Rosa, and Rebecca continued to be active supporters of that church throughout
their lives (ES 7, September 1912:8). Charles Nourse passed away in 1851, leaving the Highlands
to a son and two unmarried daughters, James Burn, Mary, and Rosa Nourse (ES, 16 January
1903:14). The 1861 Topographical Map of the District of Columbia shows the property to be
under the ownership of Mary and Rosa Nourse, the two elder siblings (Boschke 1861) (Figure 4).
The Organic Act of 1871 incorporated Washington County, Washington City, and Georgetown
into one entity, the District of Columbia. Around the same time, the Nourse siblings added a
stone cottage to the back acreage of their estate on the land that would become Hearst Park. The
cottage was allegedly built for an unknown “colored couple” (Artemel et al. 1984:76).
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
6
Figure 4. 1861 Topographical Map of the District of Columbia by Albert Boschke. Accessed at the Library of
Congress, Washington, DC. Approximate Hearst Park boundary in red (north at upper left corner).
Maps by B.D. Carpenter and G.W. Hopkins indicate that between 1881 and 1887, the Nourses
sold a large portion of the estate (Carpenter 1881; Hopkins 1887) (Figures 5 and 6). The
southern portion of the land that would become Hearst Recreation Center became the property
of R.H. Goldborough while the Nourses retained the land that contains the northern portion of
the park. Goldborough immediately began planning to develop the area as a subdivision, which
was named Richmond Park (Washington Post [WP], 18 May 1887:2). This transaction was in
keeping with area trends. Throughout the later nineteenth century, large estates in the former
Washington County were divided and sold, land speculation increased, and several subdivisions
were created (DC HPO 2013:10).
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
7
Figure 5. 1881 Map of the Real Estate in the County of Washington, D.C. Outside the Cities of. Washington
and Georgetown from actual surveys by B.D. Carpenter. Accessed at the Library of Congress, Washington,
D.C. Approximate Hearst Park boundary in red (north at top of page).
By 1907, Richmond Park was managed by Easly & Hill, a real estate brokerage. The Washington
Post reported that the available land was divided into 270 individual lots and that the brokers
were introducing paved streets and sidewalks, with sewer lines soon to follow (WP, 7 July
1907:FRE4). By 1910, the same newspaper reported that subdivision owner Northwest
Washington Improvement Company had spent $150,000 on these improvements. William F.
Matteson served as the real estate operator for the subdivision and oversaw these changes (WP,
24 April 1910:R1). No further improvements were made to the remaining Nourse estate at this
time with the exception of a small structure that first appears on the 1907 Baist’s Real Estate
Atlas of Surveys of Washington, District of Columbia to the west of the current park (Baist
1907) (Figure 7).
Rosa Nourse died in 1903, Mary Nourse in 1908, and James Burn Nourse in 1917 (Find a Grave
Index 2009). In 1920, Admiral and Mrs. Grayson purchased the Nourse property and took up
residence in the Highlands (US DOI 1972:3). The Graysons appear on the 1925 Baist map as the
property owners (Figure 8). Admiral Grayson was personal physician to President Woodrow
Wilson and served as chairman of the Red Cross, while Mrs. Grayson was active in the city’s
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
8
Figure 6. 1887 Map of the District of Columbia from official records and actual surveys by G.M. Hopkins.
Library of Congress, Washington, D.C. Approximate Hearst Park boundary in red (north at top of page).
social and charitable scenes (WP, 28 February 1940:1). The 1931 Baist map shows a wood-frame
building on the southern portion of the Grayson estate that would become Hearst Park. By 1937,
this building had already been demolished along with the ca. 1907 structure (Figures 9 and 10).
Despite increased interest in the residential development of the area, a 1927 Sanborn map that
was revised in 1960 indicates that no structures were erected on the Richmond Park lots within
the future park land (Figure 11).
In 1931, the eastern portion of the Grayson estate became the site of a new elementary school
and park in combination with the unimproved Richmond Park lots to the south. The school and
park were named for Phoebe Hearst of California, in honor of her efforts to establish free
kindergartens (ES, 14 November 1931: A7). The Phoebe A. Hearst Elementary School opened in
September 1932 and received 250 students in its first year of operation (ES, 18 September
1932:B1).
In 1935, Hearst Park was included in a plan for public works expenditures for recreational
facilities proposed by Sibyl Baker, D.C. Director of Recreation. It was one of forty sites around
the city that she wanted to improve (ES, 29 March 1935: B1). In the same year, architects of the
National Park Service repurposed the c. 1870 stone cottage as a recreation center. They added a
full-width rear porch to bring the building more in line with other recreation centers of the
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
9
Figure 7. 1907 Baist’s Real Estate Atlas of Surveys of Washington, District of Columbia by G.W. Baist (Vol. 3,
Plate 28). Accessed at the Library of Congress, Washington, D.C. Approximate Hearst Park boundary in red.
Figure 8. 1925 Baist’s Real Estate Atlas of Surveys of Washington, District of Columbia by G.W. Baist (Vol. 3,
Plate 28). Accessed at the Martin Luther King Jr. Memorial Library, Washington, D.C. Approximate Hearst
Park boundary in red (north at top of page).
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
10
Figure 9. 1931 Baist’s Real Estate Atlas of Surveys of Washington, District of Columbia by G.W. Baist (Vol. 3,
Plate 28). Accessed at the Martin Luther King Jr. Memorial Library, Washington, D.C. Approximate Hearst
Park boundary in red (north at top of page).
1930s, which were commonly Colonial Revival in style (Claypool et al. 2014:8–9). Further
improvements to the playground were made in 1936, though their exact nature is not known,
and they are not indicated on the 1937 Baist map (ES, 6 May 1936:B1) (Figure 10). In 1943,
Federal Works Agency funds paid for the installation of the amphitheater playfield and tennis
courts present today. The funds were provided under the Lanham Act to provide increased
recreational facilities to the expanding wartime population in the District (ES, 18 July 1943:A2)
(Figure 12).
Elevation Change Analysis
A GIS-based elevation change (also known as cut and fill) analysis was conducted using ArcGIS
to determine the extent of the landscape modification that occurred over time within the study
area. As a topographic baseline, the elevation change analysis used the U.S. Coast and Geodetic
Survey (USCGS) 1888 Topographic Map of Washington and Vicinity (Sheets 32 and 42) (U.S.
National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration, Office of Coast Survey 2016). The map
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
11
Figure 10. 1937 Baist’s Real Estate Atlas of Surveys of Washington, District of Columbia by G.W. Baist (Vol. 3,
Plate 28). Accessed at the Martin Luther King Jr. Memorial Library, Washington, D.C. Approximate Hearst
Park boundary in red (north at top of page).
was then georeferenced to the base map of Washington, D.C. (District of Columbia GIS 2016).
The 1888 map was converted to a three-dimensional elevation model by redrawing the 5-ft
contour lines and transforming them into a TIN (triangulated irregular networks) and then into
a raster (a grid of cells or pixels that contain data such as elevation). A vertical datum shift of 2.2
feet was subtracted from the historical map elevations as recommended by Katz et al. (2012) to
account for changes in datum elevation between the 1888 and modern maps.
A modern elevation layer (10-ft contours taken from the 2008 contour map) for Washington,
D.C., was obtained from DC GIS Open Data (District of Columbia GIS 2016). The modern
contour lines were similarly transformed into a TIN and then a raster. Once both historical and
modern data sets were created, ArcGIS algebraic formulae calculated the topographical changes
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
12
Figure 11. 1927 Insurance Maps of Washington, D.C. (Vol. 7, Sheet 701) with 1960 edits by the Sanborn Map
Company. Accessed at the Library of Congress, Washington, D.C. Approximate Hearst Park boundary in red.
to the landscape between 1888 and 2008. A final raster layer demonstrates those differences
with a specific color gradient to distinguish cut areas from fill areas. The USCGS 1888 map was
also used to identify structures that once stood within the boundaries of the study area.
The results of the elevation change analysis of the Hearst Park and adjacent Idaho Avenue Trail
LODs are depicted in Figure 13. This figure illustrates areas of filling as shaded in red and areas
of cutting as shaded in green. Areas of yellow have witnessed little change in elevation.
Most areas within the LODs have undergone major changes in elevation since 1888. The areas
throughout the middle of the park (shaded in red), indicate infilling of a tributary of Rock Creek
to create a level land surface. The deepest infilled areas are in the north central and southwest
portions of the property and range in thickness from 5 to 16 feet. Along the western and
southeastern boundary are areas of elevation decrease (cutting, shaded in green) of as much as
15 feet. Areas of little elevation change (shaded in yellow) abut areas of cut and fill.
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
13
Figure 12. 1943 Evening Star article on improvements at Hearst Playground (18 July: A2).
Most of the eastern portion of Figure 13, corresponding to the Idaho Avenue Trail LOD, has
witnessed less significant modifications. Nearly the entire area is denoted as having an elevation
change between 5 feet of increase to 5 feet of elevation decrease. These values are well within the
range of error for the historical map used in this analysis. The results could indicate that little to
no elevation change has taken place in the Idaho Avenue Trail LOD since the late nineteenth
century.
Archaeological Field Investigations
Based on the results of the elevation change analysis, it appears that much of the middle section
of the Hearst Park and Pool LOD has been extensively filled. This is the location of a former
tributary of Rock Creek which has since been diverted into the sewer system. The creek bed was
subsequently filled and leveled for the athletic field. The western portion of the Hearst Park and
Pool LOD within the tree line appears to have been cut by as much as 15 feet. Additional areas
that show less extensive cutting are around the tennis courts and in the southeastern portion of
the Hearst Park and Pool LOD. In contrast, the elevation change analysis indicates that
significantly less elevation change has taken place in the Idaho Avenue LOD. Most areas within
the LOD are within the range of error for the historical map used in the analysis, indicating that
little to no elevation change has occurred in the area since the late nineteenth century.
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
14
Figure 13. Results of Hearst Park and Pool and Idaho Avenue Trail LODs elevation change analysis
comparing the 1888 and modern topographic maps. Note: Red shades indicate fill, green shades indicate
cut, and yellow shades indicate minor change. The + symbol denotes a spot elevation, also presented in
feet.
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
15
Based on the potential for the presence of Native American archaeological resources within both
LODs, contrasted with the likelihood of significant impacts by land levelling in the Hearst Park
and Pool property, initial field investigations took the form of hand-auger excavations to
determine whether any intact A-horizon soils remained within the LODs. Hand augers
specifically targeted areas where 10 feet or less elevation decrease has occurred. In areas where
hand-auger excavations indicated potentially intact soils were present or where the auger
encountered cobbles and was inconclusive, limited shovel testing was used to determine the
extent of the intact soils. Where possible, the hand augers and shovel test pits (STPs) were
excavated below any fill present and into culturally sterile subsoil. Excavated soils were screened
through ¼-inch (6.35-mm) hardware cloth to ensure uniform recovery of cultural materials. All
hand augers and STPs were backfilled following documentation on standardized recording
forms. Documentation also included narrative notes, photographs, and a plan map depicting
hand-auger and STP locations.
As a baseline for the excavations, the soils documented in Smith (1976) were reviewed for the
project area. Smith maps the entirety of the Hearst Park and Pool LOD and the southern and
western portion of the Idaho Avenue Trail LOD as within the Udorthents complex. Udorthents
consist of areas that have been altered during grading for roads, railroads, housing
developments, recreational areas, and similar uses. Areas of cutting and filling often occur
together, with cutting generally exposing sandy soils that are mainly the underlying material
from areas of Galestown, Sassafras, Rumford, and Woodstown soils. Fill soils are typically the
materials removed from cutting and are generally sandy.
The remaining portion of the Idaho Avenue Trail LOD is within the Glenelg-Urban complex
(Smith 1976). This complex is mainly in areas which have been graded, cut, filled, or otherwise
disturbed during urbanization. Glenelg soils typically have two A-horizon strata that extend to
23 cm below surface and consist of dark brown loam which transitions to yellowish brown. Two
B-horizon soils follow, comprised of strong brown silt loam and yellowish red silty clay loam
mottled with yellowish brown clay. Combined, these two strata extend from 23 cm to 71 cm
below surface. Finally, the C horizon is variegated yellowish red, yellowish brown, and red loam
that is highly micaceous. The results of the hand-auger and STP survey are discussed below.
Hearst Park and Pool Hand Augers and Shovel Test Pits
Initially, nine hand augers were excavated within the Hearst Park and Pool LOD (Figure 14).
Subsequently, ten STPs were excavated near four hand augers that had potentially intact soils or
were inconclusive in the initial hand auger survey. The LOD consists of a soccer field, tennis
court, wooded areas along the west and southern boundary, and manicured lawn with specimen
trees around the recreation center and the walk between the lower field and Phoebe Hearst
Elementary School (Figure 15). The soccer field sits at the base of a high terrace to the north and
west, while the tennis court sits on a lower terrace between the street and the field.
Six hand-auger tests (Augers 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 12) were placed within the soccer field or directly
adjacent to it (Figure 14). Several of these augers (1, 3, 5, and 12) did not encounter subsoil
deposits due to rock refusals. Fill deposits ranged from one stratum extending to 30 cm below
surface to ten strata extending to 119 cm below surface (Figure 16). The initial stratum was
landscape fill consisting of dark yellowish brown (10YR4/4) sandy loam that ranged in thickness
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
16
Figure 14. Location of auger tests and STPs within the Hearst Park and Pool and Idaho Avenue Trail LODs.
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
17
Figure 15. Hearst Park and Pool LOD, athletic field and tennis court (top, view to south) and recreation
center (bottom, view to northeast).
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
18
Figure 16. Representative Hearst Park and Pool LOD hand-auger profiles.
from 13 cm to 30 cm below surface. Additional fill deposits of varying colors and textures but
generally with a sandy component followed the initial stratum. Lenses of coal ash were
encountered in Auger 1, which was likely located near where the former tributary once flowed.
Two hand augers near the soccer field did encounter subsoil deposits. In Auger 2, which
exhibited seven strata, a possible buried A horizon was encountered beneath several distinct fill
deposits (Figure 16). The initial four strata were fill deposit soils and included dark yellowish
brown (10YR4/4) sandy loam landscape fill over strong brown (7.5YR5/8) sandy clay, followed
by dark yellowish brown (10YR4/4) sandy clay loam, then yellowish brown (10YR5/8) sandy
clay mottled by pale yellow (2.5Y8/3) sandy clay. Combined, these four strata extended to 45 cm
below surface. Beneath these was dark yellowish brown (10YR4/4) sandy loam that ranged from
45 cm to 60 cm below surface. This stratum was initially interpreted as a buried A horizon.
Underlying this was two strata of B/C-horizon soils, light gray (2.5Y7/2) silt which transitioned
to strong brown (7.5YR5/6) silt. Further testing was conducted around this hand auger test and
is discussed further below.
Unlike the other augers around the soccer field, Auger 4 exhibited shallow fill deposits over
truncated B/C-horizon soils (Figure 17). The initial stratum was comprised of yellowish brown
(10YR5/6) sandy loam extending to 15 cm below surface. This was followed by brownish yellow
(10YR6/8) silt mottled with pale yellow (5Y8/2) silt.
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
19
Figure 17. Additional Hearst Park and Pool LOD representative hand-auger profiles.
Two hand augers (Augers 6 and 7) were excavated near the recreation center and playground
(Figure 14). Both augers had similar stratigraphy consisting of two or three fill strata over B-
horizon soils (Figure 17). Auger 6 was located east of the playground and showed evidence of the
recent renovation in the area. Four strata were present, including an initial stratum that
consisted of yellowish brown (10YR5/4) sandy clay fill over a buried landscape-fill stratum
comprised of very dark grayish brown (10YR3/2) sandy loam. Beneath this was variegated sandy
loam fill. Combined, these three fill strata extended to 60 cm below surface and overlay strong
brown (7.5YR5/6) silty clay B-horizon soils. Auger 7 was placed to the south of the recreation
center. Two fill strata, brown (10YR4/3) silt loam landscape fill over yellowish brown (10YR4/6)
sandy clay, extended to 50 cm below surface. Beneath the fill strata were B-horizon soils
consisting of strong brown (7.5YR5/8) silty clay.
Auger 11 was located east of the tennis courts on the south terrace (Figure 14). Three strata were
evidenced, including two fill strata over possible B-horizon soils (Figure 17). The two strata
consisted of dark yellowish brown (10YR4/4) sandy loam landscape fill over variegated sand fill.
Combined, they extended to 25 cm below surface. Stratum III consisted of light yellowish brown
(10YR6/4) sand with 40 percent gravel that was initially classified as fill soils because bottle
glass was recovered from it; however, the STP excavated near this auger located similar soils at
43 cm below surface that have been classified as B-horizon soils.
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
20
STPs 1–3 and 7–10 were placed in the area around Auger 2 where a possible intact surface was
identified at 45 cm below surface (Figure 14). STPs 1–3 were grouped within 2–3 m of the initial
auger while STPs 7–10 were placed at 5-m intervals in cardinal directions from STP 1 (Figure 14,
insert). The buried surface was encountered again in all seven STPs and was determined to be a
modern landscape surface buried during a rehabilitation project for the athletic field. The STPs
exhibited between four and five strata (Figure 18). The initial stratum consisted of brown
(10YR4/3) sandy loam landscape fill with some mottling of yellowish brown (10YR5/8) or dark
yellowish brown (10YR4/6). Following the initial stratum in some STPs was an additional fill
stratum of dark yellowish brown (10YR4/6) sandy clay mottled with brown (10YR4/3).
Combined, the fill strata had a thickness of between 11 cm and 38 cm. The interface between the
fill and the stratum below generally contained angular cobbles likely added to assist with
drainage. Beneath the fill deposit(s) was a layer of dark brown (10YR3/3) or brown (10YR4/3)
sandy loam which had a thickness of between 9 cm and 16 cm. No artifacts were recovered from
this stratum apart from a fragment of a Chinese porcelain saucer found in STP 7. This stratum
has been interpreted as a layer of modern landscape fill buried during a renovation project. At
least one additional stratum of fill deposits was present beneath this buried surface. These
deposits were often mottled and had a variety of colors and textures, many with a fine-grained
component. Like the fill deposits at the surface, these also contained angular cobbles, many of
which were medium or large in size. Subsoil was reached in STP 1–3 at between 48 cm and 54
cm below surface. It consisted of yellow (10YR8/6 or 7/6) sand. STPs 7–10 encountered large
rock refusals and did not reach subsoil deposits. Both the upper and lower fill deposits
contained a mix of nineteenth- and twentieth-century artifacts, including modern bottle glass,
window glass, wire nails, machine-cut nails, brick, coal, and slag.
The remaining three STPs were placed near augers that were inconclusive. STP 4 was excavated
near Auger 3 where several additional augers were started but encountered large cobbles within
the first 20 cm below surface. As in Auger 3, STP 4 consisted of three strata of fill deposits. The
initial stratum was strong brown (7.5YR4/6) sandy loam landscape fill, followed by brown
(10YR4/3) sandy loam and yellowish brown (10YR5/6) sandy loam. Intact subsoil was not
encountered in STP 4 because of a rock refusal at 52 cm below surface. No artifacts were
recovered from this STP. STP 5 was placed near Auger 11 and encountered fill deposits over B-
horizon soils (Figure 9). The initial stratum of dark yellowish brown (10YR4/4) sandy loam
landscape fill overlay yellowish brown (10YR5/4) sand fill mottled with yellowish brown
(10YR5/8) that contained large brick fragments, coal, slag, and window, vessel, and bottle glass.
Bottle glass included colorless glass with embossed letters, while the vessel glass included a
tumbler fragment. Combined, the fill deposits extended to 43 cm below surface. Beneath the fill
stratum was B horizon soils consisting of brownish yellow (10YR6/6) sand. STP 6 was excavated
near Auger 12 and four strata were present, including three fill strata over B-horizon soils. An
initial stratum of strong brown (7.5YR4/4) sandy loam landscape fill was followed by brownish
yellow (10YR6/6) sandy loam fill, which overlaid brownish yellow (10YR6/6) sandy loam
mottled with yellow (10YR8/6) sandy loam. Combined, the three fill strata extended to a depth
of 36 cm below surface. The B-horizon soils encountered in Stratum IV consisted of brownish
yellow (10YR6/8) sandy clay. Artifacts were recovered from the initial fill stratum only and
include soda bottle glass and whiteware fragments.
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
21
Figure 18. Representative Hearst Park and Pool LOD STP profiles.
Idaho Avenue Trail Hand Augers
Three hand augers (Augers 8, 9, and 10) were excavated within the Idaho Avenue Trail LOD
(Figure 14). The LOD consists of a wooded and partially graveled trail that connects to a nearby
neighborhood and to Hearst Park, a patch of manicured lawn at the southern extent, and a
narrow, heavily eroded path through a wooded area between the two (Figure 19). The trail sits
on a small terrace below the level of the athletic field.
Located adjacent the graveled portion of the trail, Auger 8 uncovered dark brown (10YR3/3)
sandy loam A-horizon soils extending to 12 cm below surface over truncated B-horizon soils of
strong brown (7.5YR5/8) sand followed by yellowish red (5YR4/6) sand (Figure 11). Auger 9,
located south of Auger 8, evidenced two strata over truncated B-horizon soils (Figure 11). The
initial stratum was dark brown (10YR3/3) sandy loam to 16 cm below surface. Beneath the A-
horizon soils was mixed strong brown (7.5YR4/6) and yellowish red (5YR4/6) sandy clay fill
which ranged from 16 cm to 28 cm below surface. Beneath this was strong brown (7.5YR4/6)
sandy clay B-horizon soils. The last auger, Auger 10, was placed within the southern manicured
area of the LOD. Four strata were present, including three fill strata over truncated B-horizon
soils (Figure 20). The three fill strata consisted of dark yellowish brown (10YR4/4) sandy loam
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
22
Figure 19. Idaho Avenue Trail, graveled segment (view to south).
landscape fill, followed by strong brown (7.5YR4/6) sand which transitioned to brown
(10YR4/3) sand. Combined, these three strata extended to 46 cm below surface. Beneath these
strata were truncated B-horizon soils consisting of reddish yellow (7.5YR6/6) loamy sand.
Conclusions and Recommendations
An elevation change analysis suggests that the northwest and southeast portions of the Hearst
Park and Pool LOD have been cut, in some locations by 10 feet or more, while varying amounts
of fill, in some areas over 15 feet, have covered the middle portion where the old tributary of
Rock Creek once flowed. Within the Idaho Avenue Trail LOD, the analysis suggests that the
northern and southern portions have been cut, while the middle portion has been filled.
Subsequently, in late August and early September 2016, Stantec conducted a Phase IB
archaeological survey of areas within the Hearst Park and Pool and Idaho Avenue Trail LODs
where elevation change analysis indicated less than 10 feet of fill deposits are present. The
survey consisted of the excavation of 9 hand-auger tests and 10 STPs within the Hearst Park and
Pool LOD and 3 hand-auger tests within the Idaho Avenue Trail LOD. Buried modern landscape
deposits were found in an auger on the east side of the soccer field and in the STPs excavated
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
23
Figure 20. Idaho Avenue Trail hand auger profiles.
around adjacent to the original auger test. It was determined that this surface was buried in the
recent past during a renovation project. Additional fill deposits over B/C-horizon soils were
found beneath this surface. The hand augers within the Idaho Avenue Trail LOD contained
significantly less fill deposits over B/C-horizon soils. The cutting and filling is likely related to
the use of the trail as a road until shortly after the creation of the park.
The archaeological investigations undertaken at Hearst Park and the Idaho Avenue Trail suggest
that park development resulted in the removal of all upper soil horizons, including those
horizons potentially containing archaeological deposits. Fill was subsequently placed over the
graded areas. While an intact surface was found beneath initial fill deposits, the presence of
additional fill deposits beneath it suggest that it is a former landscape surface that was buried
during a renovation project for the athletic field. No additional intact deposits were located
beneath this modern buried surface. As such, no additional archeological investigations are
recommended within either LOD. No artifacts were recovered from non-fill contexts. Stantec
will consult with DC HPO as to whether any of the items recovered from fill deposits will be
retained. All artifacts retained and all pertinent project documentation will be curated with DC
HPO upon completion of the final report.
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
24
References Cited
ArcGIS.com
2016 Washington, DC. Electronic document, http://www.arcgis.com/home/item.html?id=
e229d715f7ca4fa980308549fb288165, accessed 14 June 2016.
Artemel, Janice G., Jeffrey Parker, and Elizabeth Crowell
1984 Preliminary Archeological Survey, 23 Recreation Facilities, Washington, D.C.
Engineering-Science, Inc., Washington, D.C. Submitted to the District of Columbia
Department of Recreation. Report on file (No. 136), District of Columbia State Historic
Preservation Office.
Baist, G.W.
1907 Baist’s Real Estate Atlas of Surveys of Washington, District of Columbia. Vol. 3. G.W.
Baist, Philadelphia. Accessed at the Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.
1925 Baist’s Real Estate Atlas of Surveys of Washington, District of Columbia. Vol. 3. G.W.
Baist, Philadelphia. Accessed at the Martin Luther King Jr. Memorial Library,
Washington, D.C.
1931 Baist’s Real Estate Atlas of Surveys of Washington, District of Columbia. Vol. 3. G.W.
Baist, Philadelphia. Accessed at the Martin Luther King Jr. Memorial Library,
Washington, D.C.
1937 Baist’s Real Estate Atlas of Surveys of Washington, District of Columbia. Vol. 3. G. W.
Baist, Philadelphia. Accessed at the Martin Luther King Jr. Memorial Library,
Washington, D.C.
Boschke, A.
1861 Topographical Map of the District of Columbia Surveyed in the Years 1856 ‘57 ‘58 &
‘59. D. McClelland, Blanchard & Mohun, Washington, D.C. Physical copy accessed at
the Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.
Bowie, Effie Gwynn
1947 Across the Years in Prince George’s County. Garrett and Massie, Richmond, Virginia.
Busey, Samuel Clagett
1898 Pictures of the City of Washington in the Past. W. Ballantyne & Sons, Washington,
D.C.
Carpenter, B.D.
1881 Map of the Real Estate in the County of Washington, D.C. Outside the Cities of
Washington and Georgetown from actual surveys. Accessed at the Library of Congress,
Washington, D.C.
Claypool, Julia, Edna Johnson, and Jess Neubelt
2014 District of Columbia Parks and Recreation Master Plan Historic Preservation
Review. History Matters, Washington, D.C.
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
25
Crowell, Elizabeth A., Janice G. Artemel, and J.N. Leith Smith
1986 D.C. Department of Recreation Project, Eight Recreation Areas, Phase II.
Engineering-Science, Inc., Washington, D.C. Submitted to the District of Columbia
Department of Recreation. Report on file (No. 134), District of Columbia State Historic
Preservation Office.
District of Columbia Historic Preservation Office
2013 Rural Remnants of Washington County: An Architectural Survey of Washington’s
Historic Farms and Estates. District of Columbia Historic Preservation Office,
Washington, D.C.
District of Columbia GIS
2016 District of Columbia Open Data. Electronic document, http://opendata.dc.gov/,
accessed 15 June 2016.
DC Preservation League
1998 Guidelines for Archaeological Investigations in the District of Columbia. Electronic
document, http://planning.dc.gov/sites/default/files/dc/sites/op/publication/
attachments/DCArchaeologyGuidelines1998.pdf, accessed 6 July 2015.
Early Colonial Settlers of Southern Maryland and Virginia’s Northern Neck Colonies
2016 James Stoddert. Electronic document, http://www.colonial-settlers-md-
va.us/getperson.php?personID=I001517&tree=tree1, accessed 21 September 2016.
Evening Star (ES) [Washington, D.C.]
1903 “Tribute to the Dead." 16 January: 14. Washington, D.C. Electronic document,
http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/, accessed 21 September 2016.
1912 “Guild Hall at Mt. St. Alban to Be Completed Shortly.” 7 September:Part 2, Page 8.
Washington, D.C. Electronic document, http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/, accessed
21 September 2016.
1929 “New Book Commemorates St. Albans 75 Years.” 8 December: 101. Washington, D.C. Electronic document, http://infoweb.newsbank.com.dclibrary.idm.oclc.org/iw-search/we/HistArchive/?p_product=EANX-NB&p_theme=ahnp_nb&p_nbid=H61Q55GLMTQ3NDQ4Mzk1NS42NDExNzk6MToxNToxMzIuMTc0LjI1NC4xNDU&p_action=doc&s_lastnonissuequeryname=11&d_viewref=search&p_queryname=11&p_docnum=2045&toc=true&p_docref=v2:13D5DA85AE05A305@EANX-NB-148B8D49108D5919@2425954-148A76410211374A@98, accessed 14 September 2016.
1931 “President Hoover Will Entertain Some Members of the Congressional Set at White House Dinner Tonight.” 14 November:A7. Washington, D.C. Electronic document, http://www.genealogybank.com/, accessed 21 September 2016.
1932 “90,000 to Enroll as Schools Begin Term Tomorrow.” 18 September:B1. Washington, D.C. Electronic document, http://infoweb.newsbank.com.dclibrary.idm.oclc.org/iw-search/we/HistArchive/HistArchive?d_viewref=doc&p_docnum=-1&p_nbid=H61Q55GLMTQ3NDQ4Mzk1NS42NDExNzk6MToxNToxMzIuMTc0LjI1NC4xNDU&f_docref=v2:13D5DA85AE05A305@EANX-NB-148C2447B7AD2272@2426969-148A23B5585CE652@0&toc=true&p_docref=v2:13D5DA85AE05A305@EANX-NB-
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
26
148C2447B7AD2272@2426969-148A23B569D08CA1@12, accessed 14 September 2016.
1935 “Miss Sibyl Baker Seeking $751,000 for Playgrounds.” 29 March: B1. Washington, D.C. Electronic document, http://search.proquest.com.dclibrary.idm.oclc.org/docview/151308996/8EA638B1A755473BPQ/1?accountid=46320, accessed 14 September 2016.
1936 “Two Plots Urged for Use as Parks.” 6 May:B1. Washington, D.C. Electronic document, http://www.genealogybank.com/, accessed 21 September 2016.
1943 “FWA Projects Help City.” 18 July:A2. Washington, D.C. Electronic document,
http://www.genealogybank.com/, accessed 21 September 2016.
Federal Register
1998 Standards and Guidelines for Archeology and Historic Preservation. Vol. 49, No. 190.
Find a Grave Index
2009 “James Burn Nourse.” Find a Grave Index. Electronic document,
http://www.findagrave.com/cgi-bin/fg.cgi?page=gr&GRid=41347484&
ref=acom, accessed July 11, 2016.
2016 Google Maps. Electronic document, https://www.google.com/maps, accessed 22 June
2016.
Hopkins, G.M.
1887 Map of the District of Columbia from official records and actual surveys. Accessed at
the Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.
Katz, Gregory, Charles LeeDecker, Patti Kuhn, and Jason Shellenhamer
2012 Archaeological Investigation and Monitoring of Construction at the United States
Coast Guard Headquarters Site, St. Elizabeths West Campus, Washington, D.C. The
Louis Berger Group, Inc., Washington, D.C. Submitted to Quinn Evans Architects.
Report on file (No. 531), District of Columbia State Historic Preservation Office.
Pecquet du Bellet, Louise
1907 Some Prominent Virginia Families. Vol. 4. J.P. Bell Company, Lynchburg, Virginia.
Sanborn Map Company
1960 Insurance Maps of Washington, D.C. Vol. 7 Sheet 701 (1927 edition with 1960 edits).
Sanborn Map Company, New York. Accessed at the Library of Congress, Washington,
D.C.
Smith, Horace
1976 Soil Survey of District of Columbia. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Soil Conservation
Service, Washington, D.C.
U.S. Department of the Interior,
1972 National Register of Historic Places, “The Highlands.” U.S. Department of the Interior,
Washington, D.C.
HEARST PARK AND POOL AND IDAHO AVENUE TRAIL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY
27
U.S. National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration, Office of Coast Survey
2016 1888 Topographic Map of Washington and Vicinity, Sheet 40. Electronic document,
http://historicalcharts.noaa.gov/historicals/preview/image/DC3140C, accessed 22
June 2016.
Washington Post (WP) [Washington, D.C.]
1887 “More Suburban Improvements.” 18 May: 2. Washington, D.C.
http://search.proquest.com.dclibrary.idm.oclc.org/docview/138107567/F4EC702490
E8488EPQ/1?accountid=46320, accessed 14 September 2016.
1907 “Richmond Park Booming.” 7 July: FRE4. Washington, D.C.
http://search.proquest.com.dclibrary.idm.oclc.org/docview/144781429/BB940587666
F43EBPQ/1?accountid=46320, accessed 14 September 2016.
1910 “Park Nearly Ready.” 24 April: R1. Washington, D.C. http://search.proquest.com.dclibrary.idm.oclc.org/docview/145005057/FEA42D2794A245F0PQ/2?accountid=46320, accessed 14 September 2016.
1940 “License Issued Here for Admiral’s Widow and N.Y. Federal Reserve President;
Marriage at St. Alban’s in ‘Near Future.’” 28 February:1. Washington, D.C.
http://search.proquest.com.dclibrary.idm.oclc.org/docview/151308996/8EA638B1A7
55473BPQ/1?accountid=46320, accessed 14 September 2016