healthcare trends and opportunities
TRANSCRIPT
Healthcare Trends & OpportunitiesPwC India Analysis
Dr. Rana Mehta
Partner, Healthcare
PwC India
1
Specially prepared for TiE Leapfrog in association with
Health lies at the heart of economic, political, social and environmental prosperity : it matters to society
2
Source: 1. World Health Organization, WHO Global Health Expenditure Atlas, (2012); 2. Stewart WF, Ricci JA, Chee E, Morganstein D. Lost productive work time costs from
health conditions in the United States: results from the American productivity audit. J Occup Environ Med. 2003;45(12):1234-1246.; 3. Jamison D.T. et.al Global health 2035: A
world converging within a generation (2013);
Reductions in mortality account for 11% of recent
growth in low and middleincome countries3
4 of the 8 UN Millennium Development Goals (MDG) are
healthcare related. Health is expected to be at the heart of the new set of goals, the
Sustainable Development Goals,when launched in September 2015
Productivity losses related to personal and family health problems cost US employers $1,685 per employee per year, or $225.8 billion annually2
Health represents 12.4% of GDP in OECD countries. In the
US it is close to 18%1
The World Health Organization in its constitution defines health as “a
state of complete and physical, mental and social well-being and
not merely the absence of disease or infirmity”
Significant economic returns and social benefits derive from investingin health
Health and health equity are integral to public policies of all sectors
Health remains a major political issue in the developed and developing countries as evidenced by elections in Brazil, India, Japan, US, Turkey
and UK.
Yet rising costs and access to care pose big challenges
3
People that still lack access to healthcare worldwide
Amount OECD and BRIC nations are expected to spend on healthcare infrastructure and services over the next decade
1B $70TSource: 1. Chan M. WHO Director-General Remarks to Global Vaccine and Immunization Research Forum. March 2014 ; 2. 2040 health expenditure projections from “The
Financial Sustainability of Health Systems”, World Economic Forum and GDP data from the OECD (2013), PwC 2010-2020 spending projections
The collision of trends is impacting expenditure on health around the world
4
North America• Spending to increase by 4.9%
annually in 2014-18 • US healthcare spending, already the
highest in the world, is likely to reach 17.9 % of GDP by 2018
• Canada is expected to see growth of 4.5% annually over the same period, reaching 11.6% of GDP
• Shift to value from volume care • New wellness players emerging
South America• Spending expected to rise by 4.6% annually
over 2014-18 as Gov’ts try to improve public health systems
• In Mexico the rise will be an annual 8.2% given the commitment to a universal social service in the next 5 years
• In Brazil rising disposable incomes will continue to drive rising healthcare expenditure, with health expected to reach 9.1% of GDP by 2018 (lifestyle diseases on the increase)
• Argentina to experience growth in medical tourism
• Access to care remains a big issue across the region
Middle East & Africa• Population growth and efforts to expand
access to care will see strong growth • The average increase is expected to be 8.7%
over the 2014-18 period • Substantial growth in chronic disease• Regional medical tourism• Whole health system reforms, with a need
for “leapfrog” ideas and solutions
Western Europe• The continued need to reduce fiscal
deficits means healthcare spending is expected to rise just 2.4% annually over 2014-18
• Greece, Italy and Spain will have the tightest budgets whilst the UK, Germany and Sweden will see the strongest growth
• Proportion of population over 65 will be 20% by 2018
• EU Directive on cross-border care• Telemedicine for chronic patients• Regional medical tourism
Asia Pacific• The rollout of public health care reform
programmes combined with growing consumer wealth will boost health expenditure by an average of 8.1% in 2014-18
• Emergence of private provider sector• The strongest growth, at 15.2% per year,
will be in India with China following at 12.5% per year
• Proportion of population over 65 will be 28% by 2018
• Access, quality and training issues
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit; Kennedy Consulting Research Advisory estimates
Disruptive Trends
5
Disruptive trends are revolutionising the health industry today
These trends are impacting the delivery and financing of care…
…resulting in:
6
Technological advances
Shift in global economic power
Demographic shifts & social change
GlobalisationThe empowered consumer
The emergence of new business models
New entrants expanding and
reshaping the health system
A rebalance of the public and private
sectors in the financing and delivery
of care A greater focus to reward for outcomes instead of volume of
activity
A trend from inpatient care to
outpatient services
The healthcare sector industralising
Ageing populations are increasing the demand for healthcare
Source: UN Population Division, World Population Prospects (2012)
7
1 billionexpected increase in the world’s population by 2025
300 millionof that increase is predicted to come from those aged 65 or more
Developing countries are experiencing a rising middle class, leading to lifestyle changes…
8
Source: Brookings Institute (2010)
Nearly 65% of
the global population will be middle class by 2030
…promoting a sedentary lifestyle that’s contributing to the rise in obesity and chronic disease
9
Chronic diseases are expected to increase to 57% by 2020.
And 60% of this burden will occur in emerging markets
57%
Emerging markets
Source: World Health Organization (2005)
Demographic shifts and societal changes are burdening existing health systems
10
Source: World Health Organization (2013)
Projected shortage of healthcare workers
2013
2035
7.2 million 12.9 million
Health worker retirements and demand for care are contributing to a shortage of skilled labour
2030
Shifts in economic power are leading to financial pressures and new markets
11
Source: PwC World in 2050 Projections (2013)
We predict that seven of the world’s 12 biggest economies in 2030 will come from emerging markets, the ‘E7’
Competition from different geographies and stakeholders are contributing to new health economies
12
As part of its strategy to develop the digital opportunity in the mHealth market, Telefonica Digital, part of telco Telefonica, acquired AxisMed, a chronic care management provider based in Brazil.
South Korea’s largest mobile telecom carrier bought a 49% stake in China’s X’ian Tianlong Science and Technology Co, a producer of medical diagnosis equipment
Walgreens bought 45% of shares in Alliance Boots with plans to acquire the rest to create a “global pharmacy-led health and wellbeing enterprise”
Telefonica
AxisMed
SK telecom
Tianlong
Walgreens
Alliance Boots
Source: telecoms.com. “Telefonica eyes e-health opportunity with Brazilian acquisition”, (4 February 2013); SK Telecom; New York Times, “Walgreen to take stake in Alliance Boots for
$6.7 billion”, 12 June 2012
Technology is becoming a driver of change and a solution, creating greater efficiency & value
13
Social Volume Value
2000 2010 2020
Mobile
Analog
Analytics
Cloud
Places Spaces
General Individual
Digital
Institutional ConsumerAgent
New value propositions
New care delivery models
More customised solutions
Greater portability, security, access
More freedom, transparency, choice
Technological advances are also creating new care delivery models – and consumers are responding
14
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit, “Emerging mHealth: Paths for growth “ (2012)
49% expect mHealth to change how they manage their overall health
59%say mHealth has changed how they seek information on health issues
Patients are becoming empowered and engaged consumers, taking greater accountability for their care
15
36.7%
Have at-home
chemotherapy
Get an MRI at a retail clinic or pharmacy
34.4%
Percent of respondents answering “Very likely” and “Somewhat likely” to consider these alternatives:
Have a wound or pressure
sore treated at a clinic in a
retail store or pharmacy
49.1%
Have stitches or staples removed at a
retail clinic or pharmacy
48.3%
Have a pacemaker
or defibrillator
checked wirelessly
by a physician
42.6%
43.6%Have an electrocardiogram at
home using a device attached
to your phone, with results
wirelessly sent to your
physician
Source: HRI US consumer survey (2013 and 2011)
Consumers are leveraging new technology to self-manage their care
16
52% make
healthcare substantially
more convenient
for me
46% substantially reduce my healthcare
costs
48% improve the quality of
healthcare I receive
In the next three years, patients agree mHealth applications/services will: 59%
of patients say that mHealth services have replaced some visits to doctors or nurses
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit, “Emerging mHealth: Paths for growth” (2012)
Globalisation is allowing for greater collaboration, resulting in new care delivery models
17
Example:
Europe
EU Directive 2011/24/EU allows:
• European Union patients to access treatment in another EU country and be reimbursed for it
• Cooperation between EU health systems
Impact on healthcare
18
New business models are emerging
19
Excellence from strength
through execution
Unleashing potential
Driven by client issues
Developmental in all we do
Consumer insight
Value proposition• Customer
experience• Product + service• Brand value
Business model innovation
Value network• Value
network/ecosystem• Revenue & margin
model
Target customer• Buyers & involved
non-buyers• Marketing methods
Source: Making Innovation Work, Davila Epstein, Shelton: Wharton School Publishing (2006)
Patient influence and empowerment are influencing business models and the delivery of services
20
Convenient
Reliable
TransparentAffordable
Seamless
High quality
The principles of a consumer-oriented system
Source: PwC Health Research Institute “Money matters: Billing and payment for a New Health Economy” (2015)
Patient engagement will become increasingly important as financial performance is tied to clinical outcomes
21
Health systems
Source: HRI Consumer Survey (2012)
When asked if consumers want their feedback tied to healthcare companies’ financial records, almost half said yes
Advances in technology and analytics are exciting tools for stakeholders to become more precise with treatments and predicting patient behaviour
22
0
30
60
90
Clinical informatics goal to supportorganisational strategies e.g., new
product dev't, new business models overthe next 2 years
Effectively impact patient behaviour
Formalinformaticsprogram
No formalinformaticsprogram
69%58%
17%7%
Physician benefits
Source: HRI Clinical Informatics Survey (2011)
New entrants are expanding and reshaping the health system
23
• Patient-centric health systems opens the door to new market participants
• These commercial entrants are revolutionising healthcare, introducing new products, services and delivery systems
Source: Fortune 50 (2013)
New entrants are helping democratise and decentralise the healthcare industry
24
• Apple and Google have announced health and wellness phone apps
• Facebook is exploring the creation of online “support communities” connecting users suffering from similar ailments
• Canada’s 9000 points of care aims to reduce care wait times by shifting 17 million physician visits to pharmacists
• Walmart partnered with DirectHealth.com to offer customers with agents who will help consumers navigate the health exchange
• Orange (formerly French Telecom) uses SMS technology to fight the spread of counterfeit drugs in Kenya
• Swisscom formed a partnership with a software company to help Swiss hospitals process medical and administrative records more effectively
• Nintendo recently revealed plans to redefine itself as a health-oriented entertainment company
Sources: 9000 Points of Care website 9000pointsofcare.ca; “Walmart Works with DirectHealth.com to Introduce Comprehensive Health Insurance Program” press release (6 October
2014); “Apple Unveils iOS 8, the Biggest Release Since the Launch of the App Store” press release (2 June, 2014); Dean Takahashi, “Nintendo CEO outlines plan to move into
health-related entertainment”, VentureBeat, (3 March 2014); PwC, “Bending the Cost Curve: Stellenbosch” (2011) ; “Swisscom continues to expand its healthcare business” press
release (3 September 2013); Christina Farr and Alexei Oreskovic,, “Facebook plots first steps into healthcare”, Reuters, (3 October, 2014)
New entrants regard their unique perspective as an asset to capture and dominate the fragmented sector
25
Global reach
Customer insights
Innovation
BrandrecognitionGlobal reach
Commitment to consumer needsand value
Exploit ability to attract and retain new markets
Products/services launched based on
ability to meet outcomes
Leverage existing intellectual property
Perspective
Incumbents face critical decisions about whether to compete or partner with new entrants
26
Ford and Medtronic partner to make chronic disease more manageable through mobile
health solutions
?Compete
Partners
UnitedHealth offers Health4me app, allowing users to find health facilities
in their area thus competing with other similar solutions in the marketplace
There is a rebalance of the public and private sectors in the financing and delivery of care
27
Government
New healthcare facility and/or clinical services delivered by
private partner
Private sector partner
Contract
Private sector expertise (skills) & investment (capital)
Financial compensation; transfer existing assets; policy vision
Public and private sectors are evolving to reward for better outcomes while providing economic benefits
28
University Hospital and Primary Care, Alzira, Valencia, Spain
• Includes infrastructure & clinical services for hospital and primary care clinics
• Performance is contractually demanded
• Alzira has seen 20-30% efficiency gain
• Cost per capita in the Alzira Model is 75% lower than the cost for the UK’s Regional National Health Service
Examples:
The Queen ′Mamohato Memorial Hospital, Maseru, Lesotho
• Includes infrastructure, clinical & non-clinical services for hospital & 3 clinics
• Full patient risk transferred to the private partner with performance standards safeguarded through reward & penalty clauses of clinical and non-clinical indicators
• Death rate decreased by 41%
• On target to deliver financial results
Sources: PwC, “Bending the Cost Curve: Washington, DC” (2011), IFC (2013); PwC, “Bending the Cost Curve: Stellenbosch” (2011)
Rising healthcare costs are prompting healthcare systems to reward for better outcomes, better quality, cost savings and value
29
Source: Outcome Based Commissioning Alliance (OBC Alliance) formed of PwC, Wragge & Co, Cobic and Beacon, excerpt from “Beginning with the end in mind: How outcomes-based
commissioning can help unlock the potential of community services”, NHS Confederation’s Community Health Services Forum in collaboration with PwC (September 2014)
As consumers become engaged, there is a shift towards wellness and prevention
30
Source: PwC analysis (2014)
Fitness and wellness offers a lucrative market opportunity
$1.49 trilliontotal global ancillary/wellness
market size
$391B
Global nutrition
market
$236.5B
Sporting goods
and apparel
$595B
Weight loss
industry
$8.02B
Mobile
health apps
$114B
Alternative
medicine
$48B
Medical
tourism
$3.1B
Wearable
devices
$113. 4B
Natural &
organic foods
$109.5B
Supplements
$43B
Natural and
organic
personal care &
household products
$125.1B
Functional
foods
$19.4B
RPM/
Telemedicine
$78.4B
Global fitness
industry
There is a trend from inpatient care to outpatient services
3131
Primary Care Centre
Mobile platform to
connect patients to the
care network and enable
continuity of care
1
Analytics and its
dissemination with
other care settings to
make effective
decisions thus driving
higher quality care
within the network
2
home
Acu
te C
are
Research Facility Tertiary Care Centre
Standard-of-Care
Medical Learnings and
Discovery
Collaboration platform to facilitate
real-time use of patient data to
enable dynamic triaging and
learning
3
Technology via remote monitoring, telemedicine and mobile devices will help usher a move towards home care
32
Mobile system gives physicians and caregivers remote access to a patient's vital signs from anywhere within the hospital.
A device lets doctors conduct real time consultations using a revolving robot.
Patch cardiac rhythm monitor provides continuous monitoring for up to 14 days.
Sensor mat is placed under mattresses to monitor a patient's presence, sleep pattern, heart rate and breathing rate.
Sensors on the patient and throughout the home detects falls, wandering, missed medication
Analytics can give insight into patient flows and care pathways, allowing providers to deliver care that’s appropriate for the patient
33
Analytics
Personalised healthcare
Measurements/benchmarks
Clinical decision support
Well-being monitoring
There is a general move from fragmented to integrated care across the continuum
34
Extension of care
Pre
ven
tati
ve
care
Pri
ma
ry c
are
Imm
edia
te c
are
Sp
eci
alt
y v
isit
Dia
gn
ost
ics
Tre
atm
ent
an
cill
ari
es
Em
erg
ency
ca
re
Inp
ati
ent
care
Reh
ab
ca
re
Lo
ng
-ter
m c
are
Sk
ille
d n
urs
ing
Res
iden
tia
l ca
re
En
d-o
f-li
fe c
are
He
alt
hc
ar
e c
on
tin
uu
m
Healthcare providers have been concentrating here Extension of
care
Healthcare is transforming into a precision-based industry
35
PERSONALISED
An understanding of how genetic variation drives individual treatment
• Targeted therapeutics• Personal Health Records
PREDICTIVE
Ability to identify what condition a person might contract in the future and how they will respond to a given treatment, enabling tailored health strategies
• Molecular diagnostics• Genomic sequencing
PREVENTATIVE
Facilitates a proactive approach to health and medicine, shifting focus from illness to wellness
• Nutritional / Functional Foods
• Wellness programs
PARTICIPATORY
Empowers patients to make informed choices and take responsibility for their own health
• Telemedicine• Remote patient monitoring
Process driven advances, standardised procedures and the division of labour can reduce costs and improve quality
36
• Quebec Ministry of Health applies Lean management, which has meant a 50% inventory reduction in medication and bed linen1
Lower costs
• Narayana Health System has an average 1.4% mortality rate within 30 days of a coronary artery bypass graft surgery, compared to 1.9% in the US2
Improve quality
• Aravind Health Care System, an eye care provider in India, performs around 2,000 cataract procedures a year, compared to the national average of just 4003
Efficiency
Source: 1. PwC, “Bending the Cost Curve: Amsterdam” (2011), 2. Wall Street Journal “The Henry Ford of Heart Surgery” (25 November, 2009); 3. Aravind Health Care System (2013)
Emerging markets are practicing reverse innovation, introducing creative solutions to help solve pressing problems
37
Developed countries Emerging markets
Entrenched, conservative infrastructure
Lack of legacy infrastructure to impede change
Rigid regulations Fewer regulations to hinder progress
Abundant resources and many options for first-class treatment
Lack of access and fewer options drives alternative solutions