halloween vs the day of the dead
DESCRIPTION
published in TheGreenGazetteTRANSCRIPT
October/November 2014 www.thegreengazette.ca Page 11
TheGreenGazette
I grew up celebrating Halloween,
and, like many other children,
never understanding the meaning
of the day. All I knew was I was
getting candy, and if I had the stamina to
walk for blocks in the cold, it could very
well mean lots of candy. �ow in those
days, we kept things rather simple: with
an old, white sheet we could be a ghost or
a mummy… with old tattered clothes we
could be a hobo… a cardboard box and
we could be a walking TV. We would
carve a pumpkin and stick a candle in it,
and use an old pillow case to collect our
loot. Simple. Profitable. And lots of fun.
But as I grew older, Halloween began
to change and so did my views on it. I did-n’t understand the concept, or the worship
of evil dead things, and I thought perhaps
the whole affair was some type of devilish
trick to entice innocent children into wick-
edness. In addition, the whole commercial-
ism of the festivity seemed to be intensify-
ing. I just could not justify spending large
amounts of hard-earned dollars on plastic
horrors… plastic spiders, plastic headless
dead things, plastic skeletons, plastic
tombstones, plastic masks, plastic cos-tumes, and the worst—plastic pumpkins—
all of which, I could probably guess were
made in China. My green personality
cringed at the thought of someone cram-
ming all that plastic into an attic every
year. And the vision of the dead plastic
beings squeezed up against a plastic
Christmas tree, a plastic baby Jesus, and a
plastic Virgin Mary sent chills down my
spine. Now that was scary. And, of course,
ironic.
In walks Hollywood, promoting horror flicks prior and during Halloween observa-
tions, with countless of slasher films and
monster mania. The most successful of the
movies to promote Halloween terror is the
American horror franchise, Halloween,
consisting of 10 slasher films, and novels
and comic books. The fictional character of
Michael Myers stalks and kills people dur-
ing the Halloween holiday. With the abun-
dance of receiving treats and the overtone
of slashers, devils, and monsters, how could the coming generation see Hallow-
een as anything other than a time of want
and fear?
Now don’t get me wrong: I was not
about to deprive my children of the Hal-
loween experience. They enjoyed the cele-
bration in the same manner I did as a child,
with home made costumes and a real
pumpkin. Begrudgingly, I went along with
it, cursing my own self for part taking in
the paganistic ritual, until I learned the true meaning of why Halloween is celebrated.
The word Halloween means “Holy
Evening.” It comes from the Scottish term,
All Hallows’ Eve. Halloween falls on the
evening before the Christian holy days of
All Saints (Nov. 1) and All Souls’ Day
(Nov. 2). These three days are collectively
referred to as Hallowtide. It was a time
meant for honoring the saints and praying
for recently departed souls. By the end of
the 12th century the church began new
traditions. The town criers would set afoot empty streets, dressed in black and ringing
bells to call upon Christians to remember
the deceased. It was also folklore that the
souls of the departed would wander the
earth during Hallowtide for one last chance
to gain vengeance on their enemies before
moving to the afterworld. However, this was not instituted until around 750 AD, in
Europe. Before then, Halloween came
from a pre-Christian Celtic festival known
as Samhain. The pagan rite was dedicated
to the harvest. It was said during Samhain
banshees and witches were known to steal
children and destroy crops, bringing terror
to the population.
And yet, it wasn’t until the 1940s that
the practice of “trick or treating” came to
North America. The tradition already ex-
isted in Scotland, Great Britain, and Ire-land during Hallows’ Eve in the form of
“souling” where children and the poor
would sing for the dead in return for
sweets or coins. The celebration in the
west, morphed into a “trick or treat”—give
me a treat or I will play a trick on you—
sacrament that brought with it a taste of
paganistic terror.
Immigration to North America may
have brought these trick or treat traditions
with them. However it is not to say that the practice of honoring the dead did not exist
prior to these settlements in the continent.
In fact, Dia de los Muertos (the Day of
the Dead), is a common holiday celebrated
in many countries across the globe that
existed in North America before European
immigration. It is similar to All Hallows’
Eve; however, it is more of a happy cele-
bration than a sad mourning. Mexico, for
instance, joyously celebrates the holiday
by remembering friends and family mem-
bers who have passed on. It is believed that the deceased loved ones are given back to
families and friends during this time—they
are sometimes even set a place at the din-
ner table and parties are thrown with a
great feast, drinking, and dancing. It is
traditional for people to build private altars
in their homes honouring the deceased.
These may include photos of the dead,
sugar skulls or similar treats, flowers, fa-
vorite foods, of the deceased, crafts, and
more. And yet, even in Mexico, Dia de los
Muertos has become a melting pot of tradi-
tional rite. Before the Spanish invasion of
1519, the Aztecs held a festival for at least
3,000 years celebrating the death of their
ancestors. They honoured the goddess of
the underworld, Mictecacihuatl, and would
celebrate for 20 days during the corn har-
vests for the entire ninth month of the Az-
tec calendar, which begins at the end of
July. The Spanish conquerors, wishing to eradicate any and all of the rituals of the
Aztec people, failed at wiping out the festi-
val all together. They succeeded, however,
in shortening the length of the celebration
and adjusted the time of celebration to
align with their own Catholic holidays of
All Saints’ Day and All Souls’ Day.
So, apart from the “scare the wits out of
people” ritual we see today in Canada and
the US, history shows the holiday is deeply
rooted in the celebration of the past lives of
our loved ones, and how we celebrate the time is a personal one. I, for one, will be
celebrating the lives of family members
that have passed, with perhaps a bowl of
candy and chocolate.
Teena Clipston is a published writer, with
100’s of articles on the internet, in news
Halloween vs The Day of the Dead
papers, and in magazines. Clipston ob-
tained her journalism diploma in 1995,
and has worked in publishing and as a
journalist for over 20 years.
By Teena ClipstonBy Teena ClipstonBy Teena ClipstonBy Teena Clipston
Canadian house ready for trick or treat—decorated with a witch,
black cat, and spiders. Photo: Sameer Vasta
Traditional Mexican ‘Day of the Dead’ altar for family member,
Playa del Carmen, Mexico. Photo: Laura Winfree