h igh -f idelity dna h ybridization using p rogrammable m olecular dna d evices nikhil...

33
HIGH-FIDELITY DNA HYBRIDIZATION USING PROGRAMMABLE MOLECULAR DNA DEVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

Upload: ethelbert-fowler

Post on 18-Dec-2015

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

HIGH-FIDELITY DNA HYBRIDIZATION USING PROGRAMMABLE MOLECULAR DNA DEVICES

Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

Page 2: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

FIDELITY OF HYBRIDIZATION

Perfect hybridization

Mismatched hybridization

Difference in energy between red strand hybridization and green strand hybridization is

small

Page 3: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

FIDELITY OF HYBRIDIZATION

Hybridization fidelity depends on length Errors in hybridization

Noise: Strands with sequence similar to the target

Page 4: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

DRAWBACKS OF LOW FIDELITY: SELF-ASSEMBLY

Page 5: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

DRAWBACKS OF LOW FIDELITY: SELF-ASSEMBLY

Page 6: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

DRAWBACKS OF LOW FIDELITY: DNA MICROARRAYS

From: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:NA_hybrid.svg

Page 7: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

EXACT HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION

Solution: ensemble of distinct sequences Target sequence s

Problem statement: Completely hybridize allcopies of s and don’t hybridize any other sequence

Multiple strands may bind to s and cooperatively hybridize it

Page 8: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

EXACT HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION

Solution: ensemble of distinct sequences Target sequence s

Problem statement: Completely hybridize all copies of s and don’t hybridize any other

sequence Multiple strands may bind to s and

cooperatively hybridize it Completion of hybridization should be

detectable Example: by fluoroscence

Page 9: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

APPROXIMATE HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION

Hybridization Error At most b bases may mismatch: b-hybridized

Success probability probability of b-hybridization at least p

Problem statement: b-hybridize each copy of s with probability at least p and no other sequence is b-hybridized with probability greater than 1-p

p ≈ 95% and b ≈ 1/10th of length of s

Page 10: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

ASSUMPTIONS

Short sequences have high fidelity of hybridization

Subsequences sequestered in short hairpins are unreactive

Strand displacement occurs whenever possible and proceeds to completion

Page 11: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

APPROXIMATE HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION

Page 12: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

NOTATION

Letters represent sequences Example: ci

Sequences concatenate ci = ai bi

Written from 5’ to 3’ Sequences differing only in the subscript are

concatenations of subsequences differing only in the subscript ci = ai+1 bi implies ci+1 = ai+2 bi+1

Bar indicates reverse complement ci = bi ai is the reverse complement of ci = ai bi

Page 13: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION: 1ST PROTOCOL

Page 14: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION: 1ST PROTOCOL

Page 15: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION: 1ST PROTOCOL

Page 16: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION: 1ST PROTOCOL

Page 17: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION: 1ST PROTOCOL

Page 18: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION: 1ST PROTOCOL

Page 19: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

1ST PROTOCOL: POTENTIAL SOURCE OF ERROR

Page 20: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

1ST PROTOCOL: POTENTIAL SOURCE OF ERROR

Page 21: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

1ST PROTOCOL: POTENTIAL SOURCE OF ERROR

Page 22: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION: 2ND PROTOCOL

Page 23: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION: 2ND PROTOCOL

Page 24: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION: 2ND PROTOCOL

Page 25: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION: 2ND PROTOCOL

Page 26: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION: 2ND PROTOCOL

Page 27: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

HIGH-FIDELITY HYBRIDIZATION: 2ND PROTOCOL

Page 28: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

FAVORABLE PROPERTIES OF THE PROTOCOLS

Autonomous Fluorophore based detection

Page 29: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

SIMULATION OF FINITE AUTOMATA

Finite automata: Mathematical constructs that define languages

Limited computational power Memoryless

Page 30: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

SIMULATION OF FINITE AUTOMATA

Target strand encodes input to automata Checker sequences perform state transitions

Green sequence performs δ(y,0) = z

Page 31: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

SIMULATION OF FINITE AUTOMATA

Incorrect checker sequence may attach Further attachment is blocked as second hairpin

doesn’t open At each step, probability of correct

attachment ≥ 0.5 Probability of successful completion ≥ 1/2 n

where n=size of i/p Can process multiple inputs in parallel Number of checker sequences ≤ Twice

number of edges in the transition diagram of the automata

Page 32: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

PROTOCOL KINETICS

Page 33: H IGH -F IDELITY DNA H YBRIDIZATION USING P ROGRAMMABLE M OLECULAR DNA D EVICES Nikhil Gopalkrishnan, Harish Chandran & John Reif

FUTURE WORK

Experimental verification for a simple case with just two checker sequences

Computer simulation to predict reaction kinetics