gps based gamma survey for decommissioning …...gps gamma survey data method for gathering soil...

8
GPS based gamma survey for decommissioning NORM sites E. Ruedig, PhD, CHP T. Alecksen M. Schierman, CHP 24 September 2019 ERG

Upload: others

Post on 31-Jan-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: GPS based gamma survey for decommissioning …...GPS gamma survey data Method for gathering soil concentration data for gamma emitting NORM over large areas Critical assumption: a

GPS based gamma survey for decommissioning NORM sitesE. Ruedig, PhD, CHP

T. Alecksen

M. Schierman, CHP

24 September 2019

ERG

Page 2: GPS based gamma survey for decommissioning …...GPS gamma survey data Method for gathering soil concentration data for gamma emitting NORM over large areas Critical assumption: a

True distribution of

soil contaminationInvestigation grid

+ =OR

ERG Note: figure after Lively, J. The Art and Power of Data Imaging. ICEM2013.

Page 3: GPS based gamma survey for decommissioning …...GPS gamma survey data Method for gathering soil concentration data for gamma emitting NORM over large areas Critical assumption: a

GPS gamma survey data➢ Method for gathering soil concentration data for gamma emitting NORM over large areas

Critical assumption: a stable correlation between soil concentrations and gamma count rate

➢ Cost effective compared to traditional soil sampling

➢Survey parameters can be optimized based upon study goals: obtain more quantitative survey data, with a commensurate response on survey cost, or perform a survey that is less quantitative in nature (scoping only – high uncertainties).

➢ Sensitive to all gamma-emitting radionuclides, including NORM, so the set of nuclides that contribute to ambient gamma must be understood at some phase of the project.

ERG

Page 4: GPS based gamma survey for decommissioning …...GPS gamma survey data Method for gathering soil concentration data for gamma emitting NORM over large areas Critical assumption: a

Overview –Ambrosia Lake West Facility

ERGAverage Ra-226 Concentration (Bq g-1)

Colorado

New Mexico

Me

an

Un

sh

ield

ed

Ga

mm

a C

ou

nt

Ra

te (

cts

s-1

)

p < 0.001

Adj R2 = 0.24

Grey bands represent the 95 prediction limits

Page 5: GPS based gamma survey for decommissioning …...GPS gamma survey data Method for gathering soil concentration data for gamma emitting NORM over large areas Critical assumption: a

Improving gamma survey data quality

Physical parameters:

• Scan more slowly

• Position the detector closer to the ground

• Survey tighter transects

• Use a shield

Detector parameters

• Use newer, digital electronics

• Avoid algorithmic processing of data

Environmental parameters

• Control for ambient radon

• To the detector, radon in the ground is the same as radon in the air!

Grey bands = 8am to 5pmERG

Date

Co

nc

en

trati

on

of

Rad

on

-22

2

(No

rma

liz

ed

)G

am

ma C

ou

nt

Rate

(N

orm

ali

ze

d)

Page 6: GPS based gamma survey for decommissioning …...GPS gamma survey data Method for gathering soil concentration data for gamma emitting NORM over large areas Critical assumption: a

Results: radium-226/gamma correlation

p < 1E-7

Adj R2 = 0.63

ERG

Mean Ra-226 Concentration (Bq g-1)Mean Ra-226 Concentration (Bq g-1)

p = 0.117

Adj R2 = 0.053

Me

an

Sh

ield

ed

Ga

mm

a C

ou

nt

Ra

te

(cts

s-1

)

Me

an

Un

sh

ield

ed

Ga

mm

a C

ou

nt

Ra

te (

cts

s-1

)

Grey bands represent the 95 prediction limitsGrey bands represent the 95 prediction limits2019 Survey2016 Survey

Page 7: GPS based gamma survey for decommissioning …...GPS gamma survey data Method for gathering soil concentration data for gamma emitting NORM over large areas Critical assumption: a

ERG

2019 Survey 2016 Survey

Note: histograms are log/log plots.Note: color bins in both figures generated using 10 geometric intervals with the same color ramp.

65m 65m

LOG - Normalized gamma count rate

LO

G -

No

rma

lize

d n

um

be

r o

f o

cc

urr

en

ce

s

(Grey) 2019 Survey

(Outlines) 2016 Survey

Page 8: GPS based gamma survey for decommissioning …...GPS gamma survey data Method for gathering soil concentration data for gamma emitting NORM over large areas Critical assumption: a

The authors wish to gratefully acknowledge:

BHP, for funding this work, and especially BHP’s site staff:Kent Applegate, Theresa Ballaine,

Michaella Gorospe, and Sandra Ross

Our field crew:Tom Bottomly, Jake Halstead,

Patrick Hendrickson, Sam Paterniti

Acknowledgements

ER

G