golspie high schoolghsbusinessstudies.weebly.com/uploads/6/5/7/4/6574145/8_decision... · swot...
TRANSCRIPT
Decision Making 15 September 2015 2
Learners should be aware of:
strategic, tactical and operational decisions
the role of a manager in making decisions
SWOT analysis and its use as a decision making tool
factors which affect quality decisions
Types of decisions:
Strategic Tactical Operational
Long term decisions (5-10
years)
Medium term (6 months –
5 years)
Short term
Shaping the main
objectives of the
organisation – they don’t
go into great detail about
how these decisions will be
achieved
Are taken to help achieve
strategic decisions –
contain the details of how
a strategic decision will be
achieved
Day-to-day/Routine
decisions
Taken by directors/senior
managers
Made by senior and
middle managers/heads of
department
Made by all staff including
lower level managers, eg
to order supplies
Carry high levels of
financial risk – very difficult
and expensive to reverse
Carry less financial risk
than strategic decisions –
can be reversed but this is
time-consuming and
expensive
Low financial risk decision
– can be reversed easily
and with little or no cost
To expand into a foreign
country
To diversify into new
products
To merge with another
company
To increase market share
by 5%
Cut costs by finding
cheaper suppliers,
minimising overtime or
find ways to cut wages
Widen product range
Increase production by
building new premises
• Seek opportunities to sell
goods or services in
locations where they don’t
already
• Offer internet shopping
• Target new market
segments
• Training staff in new
products available
• Decisions on staff working
hours for next week
Decision Making 15 September 2015 3
The role of a manager in making decisions
Organisations must make decisions to achieve objectives and to improve their
performance. These decisions are made by managers who have the authority to
make them. Decision making involves choosing the best option from a range of
options. Managers have various functions to carry out when making decisions.
Decision Making 15 September 2015 4
Henri Fayol, a management theorist, identified what he called the functions of
management:
Plan Looking ahead, seeing potential opportunities or problems and devising
solutions, setting targets, and setting aims and strategies.
Organise Arranging the resources of the organisation to be there when people
need them and acquiring additional resources if required.
Commands This involves the issuing of instructions, motivating staff and displaying
leadership.
Co-ordinates Making sure everyone is working towards the same goals, that all the
work being done fits together, and people are not duplicating work or
working against each other.
Controls Looks at what is being done, checks it against what was expected, and
makes any necessary adjustments. This is the monitoring and evaluating
role of management. Modern managers are likely also to include:
Delegates Gives subordinates the authority to carry out tasks. This helps with
motivation and reduces the manager's workload. The overall
responsibility will still lie with the manager who delegated the authority.
Motivates Rather than simply telling workers to work harder, which is not likely to
be successful, you encourage them by helping to them enjoy their tasks
through team-working, participation in decision making, and by giving
them some powers.
People who are in management positions have a very important role to perform in
the organisation and will have been selected based on the skills and qualities that
they have. Managers must be able to work well with other people, review and
assess different situations and, where necessary, make decisions to ensure the
organisation meets its objectives.
Impact of managers
When employees are motivated and perform well, a great deal of this can be
attributed to positive relationships with managers/supervisors. Successful managers:
communicate effectively with staff
give appropriate guidance and encouragement
arrange necessary training and development
encourage employee participation in decision making.
Decision Making 15 September 2015 5
SWOT analysis and its use as a decision making
tool
SWOT Analysis is a simple yet effective tool for helping to develop alternative
strategies. It is a systematic and disciplined approach which assists organisations to
predict and plan for the future rather than sit back and wait to react to changing
circumstances.
SWOT is short for:
STRENGTHS
What is the organisation doing well?
WEAKNESSES
What is the organisation not doing so
well?
OPPORTUNITIES
Where are there opportunities for the
organisation to improve its
performance and profitability?
THREATS
What factors are outwith the
organisation’s control that may impact
upon its activities?
Strengths and weaknesses are concerned with the organisation and its current
position; opportunities and threats are concerned with the external environment and
the impact it may have on the future of the organisation. An organisation wants to
build on its strengths, improve its weaknesses, take advantage of opportunities and
minimise the impact of threats.
SWOT analysis should not be seen as a one off exercise. It should be part of the
continuing process of evaluating how the organisation is doing now and what it
should be doing in the future.
Decision Making 15 September 2015 6
STRENGTHS
The following questions should be
considered:
What advantages do you have?
What do you do well?
What relevant resources do you have
access to?
What do other people see as your
strengths?
Examples:
exceptional customer goodwill
brand loyalty
efficient technical staff
adequate financial resources
enthusiastic sales force
Strengths are the foundations on which
continued success can be built.
WEAKNESSES
These must be honestly investigated and
faced. They are negative influences on
success and growth and remedies need to
be sought to overcome them:
What could you improve?
What do you do badly?
What should you avoid?
Examples:
obsolete machinery
no provision for senior management
succession
inadequate research and development
resulting in lack of new products to
succeed present production lines
If finance is a strength then the above
problems could be sorted out. However,
if finance is also a weakness then it would
first have to be sorted out as a priority.
OPPORTUNITIES
When an opportunity does arise it is
important that it is taken up:
Where are the good opportunities facing
you?
What are the interesting trends you are
aware of?
Examples:
a new market opening up which can be
filled from already existing resources
Management must always be able to take
opportunities which coincide with the
main objectives of the firm.
THREATS
These need to be recognised and dealt
with:
What obstacles do you face?
What is your competition doing?
Are the required specifications for your
job, products or services changing?
Is changing technology threatening your
position?
Do you have bad debt or cash-fow
weaknesses?
Examples:
changing technology
economic and political uncertainty
loss of existing client group
price competition
To discover the opportunities and threats faced by the organisation a PESTEC analysis
can be done.
Decision Making 15 September 2015 7
Drawing conclusions from SWOT analysis
The purpose of SWOT analysis is to help make decisions. These involve mainly what
needs to be done now and what is likely to happen in the future. The conclusions will
be the basis for the future of the organisation so it is important that the SWOT is
correctly interpreted.
The strengths will identify areas where the business is doing well at this present time,
and where possibilities for the future exist. For example, having new products in the
development stages ready for launch will provide a very good platform for the
business to progress.
The weaknesses will highlight the areas where attention needs to be paid now in
order to ensure survival. For example, having a high level of borrowing will make the
business vulnerable to changes in the economy. As part of the strategic plan steps
should be taken to reduce borrowing.
Opportunities have to be carefully measured to make sure that the business makes the
best of them. These opportunities could come about from any of the factors
mentioned in the PEST analysis. To take advantage of these opportunities the business
must include them in their strategic planning.
As with opportunities, threats come from the political, economic, socio-cultural,
technological, and competitive forces. It is necessary for the business to take action to
deal with these threats to ensure survival.
The SWOT analysis should not be thought of as a one-off process. Evaluation of the
conclusions drawn should take place to ensure that decisions were pertinent. Carrying
out another SWOT analysis will allow the business to see if their conclusions were
correct.
Decision Making 15 September 2015 8
Decision Making Models
There is a number of tried and trusted ways of helping managers come to generate
new ideas, to co-operate and finally to arrive at what is hoped to be the best
decisions.
SWOT Analysis
As discussed above.
Brainstorming
Brainstorming is when a group meet to try to come up with as many alternative
solutions as possible in a short period of time.
Each member of the group comes up with as many ideas as they can, no matter how
extreme they might appear.
All the ideas are written down as they are suggested.
Once every one has finished, the group work their way through each of the ideas in
turn discussing the possibilities contained in each to identify feasible solutions. This
way they can often come up with the most creative ideas because it encourages every
one to participate in an informal setting without the members of the group feeling
that they are in some way being judged.
Benchmarking
This involves comparing what you do with what the very best organisations do. You
could for example look at what the market leader does and then try to copy them. In
this case the market leader is the 'benchmark' or ideal standard that you want to
achieve. Benchmarking is used widely in operations to ensure quality. However, it is
equally valid as a method to aid decision making in any of the organisation's
functional areas.
PESTEC Analysis
To discover the opportunities and threats faced by the organisation a PESTEC analysis
can be done, as discussed in the last unit (Exernal Factors).
Benefits of using DM Models
No rash or hasty decisions are made, as time is taken to go through the decision
making process
Better quality decisions are made, as decisions are based on gathered relevant
information
Opportunity to explore alternatives
May enhance innovation, motivation and responsiveness by allowing employees
to be involved in the decision making process.
Decision Making 15 September 2015 9
Constraints of using DM Models
• Time consuming, may slow the decision making process
• Limited information available
• Problems of generating and choosing between alternative solutions
• Internal constraints: finance, policy, staff attitudes or resistance
• External constraints: legislation, competitors, lack of technology
• Stifles creativity
Factors which affect quality decisions
Factors affecting quality decisions
There are many factors that will affect the quality of a decision:
• The ability and skill of the manager - if the manager has not had proper training
or not skilled enough to make decisions then a poor decision may be made.
• The appropriate use of decision making models - if the SWOT analysis has been
misunderstood the decisions taken as a result will bot benefit the business.
• The quality of the information used to make the decision - if out-of-date or based
information is used the outcome will be flawed.
• The level of risk taken - the more high risk the better the information must be.
• The managers own interests - are the managers more interested in Management
by Objectives or business growth?
• Motivation of staff to properly implement the decision
• The finance available to implement the decision.
• The time available to make the decision.
Internal problems that can exist when managers try to make effective decisions:
Finance may be restricted which might mean the organisation cannot afford to
implement the best decision.
Staff may not agree with the decision and resist the change making it less effective.
The organisation may have policies in place that are restrictive and the decisions
may need to be altered to suit policies.
The decision may be constrained by the lack of technology and mean that new
technology needs to be purchased or decisions shelved.
Managers may not have the appropriate skills or initiative to make the best
decisions and may be unable to cope with complex decisions or situations, may fail
to consult or be indecisive resulting in a poor decision being made
The quality of information may not be good enough
Managers may be wary of taking decision with certain levels of risk willing
Decision Making 15 September 2015 10
Evaluation of Decisions
An important part of decision making is finding out how well your decision making
worked. This is called evaluation.
• Were the objectives of the decision met?
• What happened that was not expected?
If things did not go to plan then some changes may be needed. All decisions may not
be successful for a number of reasons. They could be due to internal factors such as
poor employee relations, or external factors such as changes in the economy. It is
important that managers evaluate their decisions and make adjustments if necessary.
Quality decision making depends on checking at all stages, so any necessary changes
can be made and the organisation can best meet its objectives.
Assessing the effectiveness of a decision:
• Evaluate the decision with their staff to gain their views on the change and if it
has been successful
• Issue questionnaires to customers to evaluate their response
• Have sales increased? If sales have increased then it could be assumed the decision
was successful
• Have profits risen?
• Has the situation improved?
• Has absenteeism reduced amongst staff?
• Has staff morale improved?
Decision Making 15 September 2015 11
Past Paper Questions
Question 1
(Source: 2012 SQA Section 1 Question 1)
Identify the problems faced by Peter Scott & Co. You should use the following
headings. (Please identify problems only, solutions will not be credited.)
• Marketing
• Finance
• Operations
• External Factors 10
Question 2
(Source: 2012 SQA Section 1 Question 4)
Describe the 3 main types of decision that an organisation could make. 3
Question 3
(Source: 2011 SQA Section 2 Question 1)
(a) Distinguish between a strategic decision and a tactical decision. 3
(c) Describe the role of a manager in staff appraisal. 5
Question 4
(Source: 2011 SQA Section 2 Question 1e)
(i) Explain the effects that 3 political factors could have on an organisation. (A
different effect should be explained each time.) 3
(ii) Describe 4 external factors (other than political) that could have an impact
on an organisation. 4
Question 5
(Source: 2011 SQA Section 2 Question 4b)
Explain internal problems that can exist when managers try to make effective decisions. 5
Question 6
(Source: 2010 SQA Section 1 Question 4)
Describe the factors that would result in a quality decision being made. 4
Decision Making 15 September 2015 12
Question 7
(Source: 2010 SQA Section 1 Question 6)
Explain the reasons why some organisations produce a mission statement. 3
Question 8
(Source: 2010 SQA Section 2 Question 5a)
(i) A manager decides to grant a worker’s request to have a week’s holiday.
Identify and justify this type of decision. 2
(ii) Describe 2 other types of decisions and give an example of each. 4
Question 9
(Source: 2009 SQA Section 1 Question 7)
(a) Describe how a manager could assess the effectiveness of a decision. 4
(b) Explain the factors that could affect the quality of a decision made by a
manager. 4
Question 10
(Source: 2009 SQA Section 2e)
Justify why strategic decisions are made by senior managers. 3
Question 11
(Source: 2008 SQA Section 1 Question 4)
Lees’ Board of Directors has identified growth as a strategic objective.
(a) Explain internal factors which could be taken into account prior to an
organisation setting strategic objectives. 4
(b) Describe 3 tactical decisions that could lead to growth. 3
Question 12
(Source: 2007 SQA Section 1 Question 4b)
The local council are trying to attract tourists to Oban with worldwide marketing of the
area. They will need to consider many external factors that could influence the industry.
Describe external factors that could influence the effectiveness of a marketing campaign. 6
Decision Making 15 September 2015 13
Question 13
(Source: 2007 SQA Section 2 Question 2bi)
Public sector organisations are owned and controlled by Central Government.
Describe 2 strategic objectives of a public sector organisation. 2
Question 14
(Source: 2007 SQA Section 2 Question 4a)
Describe internal constraints that can make decision making difficult. 6
Question 15
(Source: 2006 SQA Section 2 Question 3aii)
(ii) Describe, using examples, the 3 types of decisions taken by organisations in
order to achieve their objectives. 6
Decision Making 15 September 2015 14
Manager’s role in decision making
Management styles
Management style also has a major impact on the success of a business and the
motivation of its employees.
Definition Advantages Disadvantages
Autho
ritaria
n/auto
cratic
Manager controls all
of the decisions based
on his/her own ideas
and judgments with
no or little input from
others
The manager closely
controls the
employees.
This style of
management is suited
to the military
services.
Decisions can be made
quickly, eg in a crisis
Manager maintains
overall control
Change is
implemented quickly
Lack of two-way
communication is
demotivating
Employees cannot use
their initiative
Increase in staff
turnover and
absenteeism
Creates a ‘them and
us’ culture
‘Whatever a manager does, he does through making decisions. These decisions may be a matter of routine. Indeed he may not even realise he is making them. Or they may affect the future existence of the enterprise and require years of systematic analysis. But management is always a decision-making process.’
Peter F Drucker, The Practice of Management
Decision Making 15 September 2015 15
Definition Advantages Disadvantages D
em
ocratic
Manager will consult
with lower-level
managers and/or
employees when
making decisions or
will delegate the
authority to make
decisions
Employees feel
empowered, which is
motivating
Better quality decisions
are made as there is
input from more than
one person
Increase in creativity
Lower staff turnover
and absenteeism
Increased productivity
as employees have
ownership
Can take longer to
reach a decision
Management control
is reduced
Risk that employees
will not have
adequate knowledge
or expertise to made
effective decisions
Time taken for
consultation could
result in deadlines not
being met
Lais
sez-fair
e
Managers have a
‘hands-off’ approach
and allow employees
to make decisions,
although the manager
will provide the
resources needed to
make decisions
This style of
management leads to
the lowest
productivity and
would not be suitable
to most workplaces,
except those where
creativity is important,
for example designers
If employees are
highly skilled and
capable of working on
their own this style of
leadership can be
motivational
Employees will feel
empowered knowing
that they can still
consult with managers
for advice when
making decisions
Employees may lack
the knowledge and
experience to make
good-quality decisions
Employees may be
unable to meet
deadlines and solve
problems without
guidance and direction
from their manager
Risk that deadlines
will be missed as staff
have more freedom
Decision Making 15 September 2015 16
Corporate Culture
The style of management will also contribute towards the corporate culture.
Corporate culture is the beliefs and behaviours which managers and employees adopt
to enable the business to achieve its aims. Usually it is not specifically defined but
develops organically over time and become the unwritten rules and values of the
business.
The culture will be reflected in every aspect of the business, for example dress codes,
layout and décor of premises, symbols/logos, terms and conditions of employment,
employee incentives, eg employee of the month, and customer service.
The advantages of a strong corporate culture are:
employees feel part of the business
increased staff motivation
improved employee loyalty
increased productivity
improved employee relationships.
These advantages can reduce absenteeism and
staff turnover, and will help the company in terms
of customer loyalty and recruitment.
Decision Making 15 September 2015 17
As we discussed earlier, external influences can be grouped under the headings:
Political, Economic, Socio-cultural, Technological, Environmental, Competitive.
Looking at these areas is also known as PEST analysis which organisations often carry
out in conjunction with the SWOT analysis, as it allows for a better view of the
business environment.
Political
The major source of potential threats or opportunities politically is when the
government decides to introduce new laws, or alter taxation rates. For example,
increases in the taxation on petrol are a threat to car sales, so manufacturers produce
cars with more fuel-efficient engines. The introduction of the minimum wage was seen
as a major threat to many small businesses. However, this did not result in the large-
scale unemployment that was predicted.
Economic
How the economy is performing has a major influence on the level of success of a
business. Those organisations which are very dependant on borrowing will find their
costs rising and falling with the interest rate, and so therefore will their profits. This
makes businesses less likely to borrow money for major projects when rates are high.
Interest rate also affect consumer spending. When rates are low consumers are much
more likely to borrow and spend money. This in turn creates more sales for business.
However, it is also true that when rates are high they will borrow and spend less,
decreasing the level of sales.
The exchange rate affects the prices of imported and exported goods. When the
pound is valued highly against other currencies the price of our imports becomes
cheaper. However, our exports then become much dearer for other countries making
them less attractive and reducing sales levels.
Also, during a recession people have less money to spend on luxury goods, so
manufacturers will produce cheaper alternatives until the economy comes out of
recession.
Socio-cultural
Organisations have to take account of changes in the tastes, lifestyles and attitudes of
consumers. Tastes in fashions change from season to season and from year to year, so
clothing manufactures have to ensure that their latest products meet the consumer
tastes. More women are working than ever before, and this has had two effects.
Firstly, women themselves have a far greater influence on what is bought within the
household.
Decision Making 15 September 2015 18
Secondly, the lifestyles of working women were changed meaning less time to spend
on shopping and preparing food, looking after children, and daily household chores.
This led to the growth in a wide variety of family convenience foods and fast food
outlets, a growth in childcare facilities and nurseries, and a growth in small house
cleaning companies and ironing services.
Consumers are far more aware of social issues such as third world poverty, health
issues, and environmental concerns. Organisations have adapted their products, their
image, and their processes to take account of consumers concerns. For example, most
supermarkets will carry a range of organic produce, a range of fair trade goods, label
the contents of their products and offer recycling facilities.
Technological
The introduction of new technologies forces change on organisations. Mass
production techniques allow capital intensive automated processes which are more
efficient than labour intensive production. Producing 'Hi-tech' consumer goods such as
computers uses very sophisticated robotics. As new developments in computer
components are introduced, this requires new automated machinery. Firms have to
keep up to date to survive. As these new computers are introduced to some
businesses, other businesses will then need to update their systems.
Environmental
Environmental factors are not usually controllable by organisations. The weather is an
example that may have an impact of business. Localised flooding or rail delays due to
snow can delay or halt the production process as businesses fail to receive stock. 24
hour news cycles and Internet stories have made consumer much more aware of
environmental issues. Protest groups such as Green Peace attract much more coverage
than in the past.
Competitive
Probably the biggest concern for most businesses is (rightly or wrongly) the actions of
their competitors. Businesses look at how their product competes in terms of what it
can do, what it looks like, what price it is or what offers are being made and what
after sales service is available.
Decision Making 15 September 2015 19
Summary Questions
TRUE FALSE
1 To maximise sales in the next 5 years is an example of a tactical
decision.
2 To merge with a competitor is an example of a tactical decision.
3 Arranging work rotas is an example of an operational decision.
4 Strengths and weaknesses are external to the business.
5 The Role of the manager is to plan, organise and communicate.
6 Brainstorming is a suitable aid to decision making.
7 Conducting an appraisal is the managers job.
Complete the sentences using one from the following types of decision making:
A(a) tactical A(a) strategic An(an) operational
Q8: ____________________ decision is made by middle managers whereas
____________________ decision can be made by anyone in the organisation normally
lower level managers.
Q9: ____________________ decision is made daily or short term whereas
____________________ decision is a medium term decision.
Q10: ____________________ decision carries a medium amount of financial risk but
____________________ decision carries virtually no financial risk.
Q11: ____________________ decision is made to help the smooth running on a daily
basis whereas ____________________ decision is made to help implement the strategic
objectives.
Q12: A business deciding to extend weekend opening hours is an example of
____________________ decision making.
Decision Making 15 September 2015 20
Q13: Use following meanings to match with internal constraints that make the
decision making difficult.
• Meaning implementing decisions may be difficult.
• Meaning the organisation cannot afford to implement the decision.
• Meaning that new technology needs to be purchased or decisions shelved.
• Meaning a recruitment drive may be necessary.
• Meaning a staff training programme may be necessary.
• Meaning a simpler solution may need to be found.
Managers may be unable to cope with
complex decisions.
Staff skills may make the decision difficult
to implement.
Finance may be restricted.
The decision may be constrained by the
lack of technology.
Staffing levels may be too low for the
suggested solution to be used.
Staff may be resistant to change.
TRUE FALSE
14 SWOT analysis is an example of structured decision making.
15 PEST analysis involves looking at the external factors that
influence the organisation.
16 SWOT analysis is not often used by organisations as it results
in poor decisions.
17 SWOT analysis stands for strengths, weaknesses, opportunities
and threats.
18 The use of PEST and SWOT analysis always guarantees that
the right decision will be made.
19 Opportunities and Threats are external to the organisation.
20 Strengths and Weaknesses are external to the organisation.
Decision Making 15 September 2015 21
Here’s a couple of links that I thought you might find useful for use with Business Management pupils – useful for SWOT analysis. http://www.slideshare.net/khamarudheent/starbucks-coffee-32533485?qid=54b7529e-6cd8-4b43-9c82-2f6853785645&v=default&b=&from_search=1
What does a Manager do? A manager makes decisions – i.e. decides what to do when given a choice. He/she also: Plans (looks ahead and sets aims and strategies) Organises (ensures resources are in the right place at the right time) Commands (tells others what their responsibilities are) Coordinates (ensures resources are used to achieve overall aims) Controls (measures, evaluates and corrects work relative to plans) Delegates (gives responsibility for actions/decisions to others) Motivates (encourages others to work effectively). What Qualities or Skills make a “Good” Manager? Communication skills Leadership skills Good judgement Initiative Organisational skills Motivation and motivational skills Planning skills Innovation Personal energy Interpersonal skills Maturity Numeracy skills Adaptability Stress-handling Assertiveness.
Decision-Making What is meant by Decision-Making? Decision-making involves making a choice between alternatives in order to get you from where you are to where you want to be. Types of Decisions Strategic/policy (long-term decisions that establish aims) Tactical/management (short-term objectives to realise aims) Operational/administrative (day-to-day decisions to realise aims). Types of Decision-Makers
Decision Making 15 September 2015 22
Strategic – owners or senior management team Tactical – senior management or divisional directors Operational – section managers and/or workers. Higher Still
Notes Higher Business Management Notes Unit 1 – Business Enterprise Page 2 www.hsn.uk.net HSN81300
Who Needs to Know About Decisions? Owners Managers (to ensure they are carried out) Employees (to show relevance and ensure motivation) Customers (for information which may affect their buying). Mission Statements Mission statements are used to communicate decisions to many parties. They usually contain long-term strategic decisions, reflected as a broad statement of an organisation’s aims. Why is Decision-Making Important or Necessary? To address the dynamic pressures upon businesses To allow changing objectives to be realised To prevent problems arising from unaddressed pressures To allow management to fulfil their role effectively To provide a framework to direct an organisation To allow evaluation and changed performance (if required) Effective Decision-Making using the Structured Decision-Making Model Most organisations use a decision-making model to structure and organise their decisionmaking. The structure of the commonly used “PO(C)GADSCIE” model can be seen below. Identify the problem Identify the objectives Some models include identification of constraints Gather information Analyse information Devise alternatives Select one solution from the alternatives Communicate the decision Implement the decision Evaluate the effectiveness of the decision. Other Decision-Making Models
Decision Making 15 September 2015 23
Decision trees Linear programming Critical path analysis. Why is Evaluation of Decisions a Particularly Important Step in Structured Decision- Making? Evaluation of the success of a decision made can be performed through: Market research Comparison of accounts Comparison of budgets Comparison of sales figures Comparison of market share Comparison of employee turnover Comparison of absenteeism Comparison of quality standards. Higher Still
Notes Higher Business Management Notes Unit 1 – Business Enterprise Page 3 www.hsn.uk.net HSN81300
Evaluation is particularly important in effective decision-making to ensure that: The decision has had the desired effect The decision was therefore a “good” one Such good decision-making practice is identified Any decision-making problems are identified Problems are stopped and corrected Good/bad practice is used to improve other decisions. Benefits of a Structured Decision-Making Process Time is taken to ensure that no snap decisions are made Time is taken to fully assess alternative solutions Innovation is enhanced due to alternative solutions being devised The quality of information and therefore decisions will be good. Problems Associated with the Structured Decision-Making Process The length of time required for effective use may be too long. It is expensive and time-consuming to collect the information required. ICT and information “overload” There are internal and external constraints on alternatives There is a lack of creativity due to effort and cost. Aids to the structured decision-making process ICT and software SWOT analysis (to show internal and external strengths and constraints) PEST analysis
Decision Making 15 September 2015 24
Brainstorming sessions. What affects the quality of decisions made? There are many decision-making constraints that will limit the decisions that can be made, and therefore the quality of these decisions. These constraints can be classified as follows: Internal constraints Availability of resources (e.g. ICT, time, money, sources of information) Existing policies and practices The quality of internal information available and used The quantity of internal information available and used Training or expertise of the decision-makers The “human” element. External constraints The quality of external information available and used The quantity of external information available and used Government and EC legislation The behaviour of competitors The economic environment that the business is currently involved in. Reasons organisations produce a mission statement:
Could be released to the press which would help market the business and its
products
Issued to all employees allowing them to see the firm’s aims and objectives linked
to their roles as employees
Shows the organisation’s plans for the future and therefore how the customers
will be treated/affected
Will detail social responsibilities of the organisation which may attract customers
to the organisation
Could be used to attract quality staff who would agree with the information
contained in the mission statement
• Improve the image of the organisation which could increase sales
Describe the role of a manager in staff appraisal:
Plan out the timing and purpose of the appraisal interview in advance to ensure
the employee is fully aware of the purpose.
Organise a suitable venue and time.
Control the meeting to allow the employee to have an input into the appraisal.
Command − may have to tell the employee that the meeting is taking place if
they are unhappy with the appraisal and against it.
Co-ordinate the appraisal meetings before and after to ensure appropriate
feedback is given.