go256: conflict in east asia

17
GO256: Conflict in East Asia Professor Walter Hatch Colby College Case #2

Upload: urania

Post on 20-Feb-2016

43 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

GO256: Conflict in East Asia. Professor Walter Hatch Colby College Case #2. “One would expect people to remember the past and imagine the future …. But what they more often do is imagine the past and remember the future.”. -- Lewis Namier. And then fight over the difference. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

GO256: Conflict in East Asia

Professor Walter HatchColby College

Case #2

Page 2: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

“One would expect people to remember the past and imagine the future …. But what they more often do is imagine the past and remember the future.”

-- Lewis Namier

Page 3: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

And then fight over the difference

Page 4: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

What is Imagined/Remembered

1895

1937

Page 5: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

The Most Contentious Memories

“Rape of Nanjing”Unit 731Comfort Women

Page 6: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

Nanjing Massacre

Page 7: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

Massacre Museum

Page 8: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

Yushukan

Page 9: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

Unit 731

Page 10: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

Has Japan shown contrition?

Depends on whom you talk to

Page 11: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

Japanese Apologies

Nakasone (1985): regret“ultranationalism”“militarism”

Hosokawa (1993): “sincere sympathy”“acts of agression”“intolerable pain and suffering”

Maruyama (1995): deep remorse“tremendous damage and suffering”

Page 12: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

Yasukuni Shrine

Page 13: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

History Textbooks

Page 14: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

Question:

Why did China decide to make this an issue in 1980s?

Page 15: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

Protests

Page 16: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

The Snub

China’s Vice-Premier Wu Yi Leaves Tokyo

Page 17: GO256: Conflict in East Asia

The Burden of History

Yasukuni Shrine