gma tro

7/21/2019 gma tro

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gma-tro 1/4

Republic of the Philippines

Supreme Court Manila

EN BANC

GLORIA MACAPAGAL-ARROYO,

Petitioner,

-versus- G.R. No. 199034

Hon. LEILA M. DE LIMA, in her

capacity as Secretary of the Department of

Justice and RICARDO A. DAVID, JR., inhis capacity as Commissioner of the Bureau

of Immiration,

Respondents!

"-----------------------------------------------"

JOSE MIGUEL T. ARROYO,Petitioner,

-versus- G.R. No. 19904

Hon. LEILA M. DE LIMA, in her TEMPORARY RESTRAINING

capacity as Secretary, Department of ORDER

Justice, RICARDO V. PARAS III, in

his capacity as Chief State Counsel,

Department of Justice and RICARDO A.

DAVID, JR., in his capacity as

Commissioner, Bureau of Immiration,

Respondents!

"-----------------------------------------------"

#$% Hon. LEILA M. DE LIMA

Secretary

RICARDO V. PARAS III

Chief State Counsel Department of

Justice &D$J' Padre (aura St!,

)rmita, Manila

RICARDO A. DAVID, JR.

Commissioner

Bureau of Immiration &B$I'* nd (loor B$I Buildin

Maallanes Drive, Intramuros, Manila

7/21/2019 gma tro


+!R! os! ../01 2 ../13 ovember 4, */

+R))#I+S%

56)R)7S, the Supreme Court, on ovember 4, */, adopted a resolution in

the above-entitled cases, to 8it%

G.R. No. 199034 &+loria Macapaal-7rroyo vs! 6on! 9eila M! De 9ima,

in her capacity as Secretary of the Department of Justice and Ricardo 7! David,

Jr!, in his capacity as Commissioner of the Bureau of Immiration' and G.R. No.

19904 &Jose Miuel #! 7rroyo vs! 6on! 9eila M! de 9ima, in her capacity as

Secretary, Department of Justice, Ricardo :! Paras III, in his capacity as Chief

State Counsel, Department of Justice and Ricardo 7! David, Jr!, in his capacity as

Commissioner, Bureau of Immiration'!- 7ctin on the Special Civil 7ctions forCertiorari and Prohibition 8ith Prayer for the Issuance of a #emporary Restrainin $rder and;or 5rit of Preliminary In<unction, and mindful of the

underlyin issues in the cases - the riht to life &8hich is the hihest riht under

the Constitution' and its supportin rihts, includin the riht to travel - the

Court Resolved to

&a' CONSOLIDATE the above-entitled

cases=

&b' RE!UIRE the respondents to

COMMENT on the consolidated petitions NOT LATER THAN NOVEMBER 1", #011$

&c' ISSUE a TEMPORARY RESTRAINING

ORDER in the consolidated

petitions, en<oinin the respondents from enforcin or

implementin D$J Department Circular o! 1 and 5atchlist $rder os! 7SM--*0> dated 7uust ., */,

*/-1** dated September 3, */ and */-4>0 dated

$ctober *>, */, sub<ect to the follo8in conditions%

&i' #he petitioners shall post a

cash bond of #8o Million Pesos&P*,///,///!//' payable to this Court

8ithin five &4' days from notice hereof!

(ailure to post the bond 8ithin theaforesaid period 8ill result in the

automatic liftin of the temporary

restrainin order=

&ii' #he petitioners shall

appoint a leal representative common

to both of them 8ho 8ill receive

subpoena, orders and other lealprocesses on their behalf durin theirabsence! #he petitioners shall submit

the name of the leal representative,

also 8ithin five &4' days from notice

hereof= and

&iii' If there is a Philippine embassy orconsulate in the place 8here they 8ill be travelin,

the petitioners shall inform said embassy or

consulate by personal appearance or by phone of

their 8hereabouts at all times= and

&d' SET the consolidated cases for ORAL

Temporary Restraining Order - * -

7/21/2019 gma tro


+!R! os! ../01 2 ../13 ovember 4, */

ARGUMENTS on ovember **, */, #uesday, at *%// p!m! at

the e8 Session 6all, e8 Supreme Court Buildin, Padre (aura,)rmita, Manila!

#he Court further Resolved to NOTE the

&a' :ery ?rent Manifestation and Motion dated

ovember ., */ filed by the $ffice of the Solicitor +eneral &$S+'

for respondents 6on! 9eila M! De 9ima, in her official capacity as

Secretary of the Department of Justice and Ricardo 7! David, Jr!,in his capacity as Commissioner of the Bureau of Immiration in

+!R! o! ../01=

&b' Manifestation and Motion dated ovember /,*/ filed by the $S+ for respondents 6on! 9eila M! De 9ima and

Ricardo 7! David, Jr! in +!R! o! ../01=

&c' Supplemental Petition dated ovember 0, */

filed by counsel for petitioner in +!R! o!

../01=

&d' Comment;$pposition &on;to the :ery ?rent

Manifestation and Motion dated ovember ., */' dated

ovember 1, */ filed by counsel for petitioner in +!R! o!

../01=

&e' :ery ?rent Manifestation and Motion dated

ovember ., */ filed by the $S+ for respondents 6on! 9eila M!

de 9ima, in her capacity as Secretary of the Department of Justice,

Ricardo :! Paras III, in his capacity as Chief State Counsel and

Ricardo 7! David, Jr!, in his capacity as Commissioner of the

Bureau of Immiration in +!R! o! ../13= and

&f' ?rent Manifestation filed by counsel for petitioner

in +!R! o! ../13!

#he temporary restrainin order shall be immediately e@ecutory! Justices

7ntonio #! Carpio and Bienvenido 9! Reyes have reserved the riht to submit their

dissentin opinions! 9eonardo-De Castro, J!, on official business! Del Castillo, J!, on

official leave! &adv43 2 4>'

$5, #6)R)($R), effective immediately and continuin until further orders

from this Court, Aou, Respondents, your aents, representatives, or persons actin in

your place or stead, are hereby ENJOINED from enforcin or implementin D$J

Department Circular o! 1 and 5atchlist $rder os! 7SM--*0> dated 7uust ., */,

*/1** dated September 3, */ and */-4>0 dated $ctober *>, */!

+I:) by the Supreme Court of the Philippines, this 4 th day of ovember */!

ENRI!UETA E. VIDAL

Cler of Court

By%

%ELIPA B. ANAMA


7/21/2019 gma tro


+!R! os! ../01 2 ../13 ovember 4, */

Deputy Cler of Court )n Banc

Copy furnished:

Attys. ESTELITO P. MENDOZA, IV D. PATD! "nd O##ICE O# T$E SOLICITO% &ENE%AL

$ACINT$ E. %A#AEL '() A*orso+o St., Le"spi Vi++"e

L"- Offie of Este+ito P. Mendo/" 0 Assoi"tes M"1"ti City

Counse+ for Petitioner in &.%. No. '223()

)th #+oor Dyn"4ision 5ui+din

'36 %"d" St., Le"spi Vi++"e

M"1"ti City

Attys. ANACLETO M. DIAZ, MA%IA %OSA%IO Z. DEL

%OSA%IO, C$%ISTIAN 5. DIAZ "nd ANALENE V.

5ALISON&

L"- #ir* of Di"/ De+ %os"rio 0 Assoi"tes Co7

ounse+ for Petitioner in &.%. No. '223() 8th

#+oor P"di++" 5+d.

#. Orti"s, 9r. %o"d for*er+y E*er"+d A4enue; Orti"s

Center, P"si City

Attys. #E%DINAND S. TOPACIO "nd 9OSELITO O.

LOMAN&AA

Top"io L"- Offie

Counse+ for Petitioner in &.%. No. '223)8 Suite'3< S1y-"y T-in To-ers $. 9"4ier Street,

Orti"s Center P"si City


gma tro

Documents