globalization in denmark

Upload: beckie-kuria

Post on 04-Apr-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    1/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 1

    Executive summary

    In Denmark, globalization has resulted to the redundancy of the national

    boundaries for the economic transactions. The views regarding the effects of the globalization

    are diverse. According to some arguments, global competition is presented as a force which

    reduces the spending and intervention of the state. The forces include policies that are

    market-friendly and the state of the modern welfare. Garrett and Lange (1991, p.23).

    Some argue that both social and political globalization impacts are dependent on the

    institutions within the State. Hirst (1999, p. 69). Most literature material perceives growth of

    globalization as empirical due to the various specific trajectories in the national welfare and

    their dependence on path. Esping-Andersen (1996, p.45).

    The economic globalization usually constrains the policies in vulnerable

    nations. The review of the economic policies in fiscal spending, taxation and industrial

    policies are sometimes can be easily manoeuvred. Weiss (2002). According to her,

    globalization is does not constrain the policies but the domestic within the domestic

    institutions. Denmark has a declining economy in social democracy due to the higher tax

    imposition, the spending regime, and the strong policies in the labour market, the high

    equality in income and equality in the distribution of the wealth. Danish industrial structure is

    believed to be lagging, vulnerable and very pre-Fordist, particularly when compared to the

    Scandinavian neighbours Mjoset (1987, p.67).

    However, a recent model review indicates that despite of the problems

    associated with globalization, Denmark maintains high aspirations in social democracy and

    welfare. Nielsen (2001, p.46). Studies indicate that there have been intensive efforts in

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    2/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 2

    defending of the fiscal policies and the welfare aspirations of the state.Benner (2000, p.49).

    Some studies have given more attention on the strengths related with the arrangements in

    Denmark in mediating between the interest groups and the stakeholders and Small and

    Medium sized Enterprises (SMEs) in Denmark.Amin & Thomas (1998, p.32). The

    continuous adoption of the societal cohesion context enhances flexibility and cooperation.

    Lundvall (2002, p.57). The Danish Miracle successful characteristics are a reflection of the

    small size. Nielsen (2003, p.80). Though considered a Coordinated Market Economy,

    Denmark has in the recent past developed a more hybrid market economy by decentralizing

    collective learning and decision making, and increasing the exposure of actors to market

    forces.

    Due to this change, Denmark continues to pose a paradox for the varieties of

    capitalism literature and continues to raise serious concerns about one of the variety of

    capitalisms most important logical tenets. This report is on the globalization impacts on the

    political economy in Denmark.

    In the first part of the report, the specific features of the Danish economy are

    outlined and the various challenges that characterizes globalization. The second part consists

    of the discussion on the globalization impacts on the economic policies, the industrial

    structure and on the welfare state. The conclusion contains a critical evaluation of the

    effectiveness of the response by Denmark and the political repercussions resulting from the

    response are demonstrated.

    LITERATURE REVIEW

    The political economy in Denmark is characterized by social democracy Glyn (1995, p.25),

    the Scandinavian model Jespersen (1999, p.54), and its welfare state regime Esping-Andersen

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    3/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 3

    (1990, p.76). Muller- Armack likens it to the social market economy. Muller-Armack (1956,

    p.38). The social democracy in Denmark in areas of elected government and political core

    capitalism reform objectives are meant to reduce unemployment, income inequality and

    improve the generous social services. Denmark is universalistic in nature on welfare state

    aspirations and it resonates with the classical description of the social market economy by

    Muller-Armack. This is usually based on the market competition which enhances growth and

    productivity, facilitates the intervention of the state in income redistribution, and it ensures

    fairness in markets so as to achieve the social objectives.

    Generally, research shows that these terms are true only up to a certain extent.

    In Denmark, the dominance of the social democracy is uncontested as compared to other

    Scandinavian countries. Some of the key aspects that have been neglected include the policies

    on full employment. According to Katzenstein (1985, p.65), the democratic corporatism

    provides a better description that distinctively characterizes Danish political economy. It

    involves capturing the adaptation practices on the world market changes, and this is based on

    consensual political culture. These economies are usually small and should adapt to the

    changes. The interest group meditation is crucial in adaptation and compensation process.

    Studies reveal that Danish economy relies greatly on bargaining and negotiation. In

    negotiated economy, many institutions and other inter-institutional networks will engage

    problem solving debates and make negotiations which result to conflict resolution. The

    interpretation framework is based on relatively homogeneous population and on rough power

    symmetry in the capital-labour relations.

    The negotiated economy in Denmark is based on self-organization principles,

    egalitarianism, consensus and compromise approaches. Capital formation, labour, and well

    established government was not experienced in Denmark due to the presence of strong

    countervailing forces. The centralized corporatist model was mainly impossible due to the

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    4/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 4

    nature of the state: it was highly decentralized. However, the availability of the pluralistic and

    localized reform process enhanced the acceptance of the co-determination principles and

    division of responsibilities. Basically, the industrial structure in Denmark is mostly

    dominated by the SMEs and the economy specializes in low value added, and the strong

    international competition. Research show that the development in food and pharmaceutical

    industries has not been Cleary defined. Maskell (1998, p.41). Denmark dependent highly on

    the SMEs with the basic low-tech and medium-tech fields, hence the growth in the

    international markets is limited. The domination by social democrats in Denmark was

    significant, and conservative government election between 1982 and 1993 was not successful

    in legacy changing of economic governance and social democratic politics. In 2001, there

    was formation of a coalition between the social democrats and the social liberals.

    However, there should be no overestimation of the discretionary power by the

    national Danish governments. Centre parties have been in the forefront in providing the

    coalition votes necessary for governance leading to the emergence of strong consensual

    policies despite of the governing partys political spectrum. The consensus history in

    Denmark has since 2002 been very uncertain. For once after fifty years, now Denmark has a

    majority in the right-wing government which is independent of centre partys moderating

    influence. The hybridization thus incorporates both the Liberal Market Economies (LME)

    and Coordinated Market Economies (CME) characteristics and being a CME, Denmark has

    elements typically found in LMEs that has been incorporated into its structure in ways that

    have enhanced its socioeconomic performance. This has been clearly demonstrated by

    institutions governing vocational training and skills formation, labour markets and industrial

    policy.

    In studying labour markets, Denmark clearly exhibited traits associated with

    CMEs by having almost 80% of all workers unionized and were covered by the collective

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    5/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 5

    bargaining agreements (CBAs) reached through corporatist institutions. On the other hand,

    employees in the private sector had rather limited levels of employment protection thus

    employers had an upper hand depending on the market signals, to hire and fire workers. In

    addition, decentralization of bargaining regarding job training, work scheduling, especially to

    the level of individual firms, represented a move in the direction of LMEs. Thus, Denmarks

    overall level of employment protection changed from that of pure CMEs to move closer to

    pure LMEs.

    Historically, Denmark is highlighted as one of the easiest in business

    conducting. At the initial stages, Denmark had already been integrated internationally. The

    Danish firms used to operate subsidiaries and affiliates abroad. Various latent internal and

    external forces challenged the success. Until 1970, Denmark was a homogenous country after

    which the influx of the working immigrants affected its economy. With the shifting of the

    demographics, Danes started questioning the beneficiaries of the taxes and payments from

    social security. Danes believed that their transition from the close knit community threatened

    their democratic values and exposed them to the diverse society. The concern by the Danes

    was on the sustenance of their welfare.

    In 2008, Denmark entered into a recession. According to Lars Lkke Rasmusse,

    Denmark was supposed to strike a balance between the globalization and social welfare of the

    state. There was an active subsidization in alternative energy innovation by Denmark after the

    economic recession in 1970. According to Paul Krugman, the shifts in relative demand in

    labour; both skilled and unskilled, leading to unemployment and tensions in welfare state

    policies.

    According to Peter Katzenstein, the economic downswings in the world markets

    contributed greatly to the adjustment of policies so as to sustain globalization. Some

    economists argue the enhancement of the adaptability by the welfare states in traditional

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    6/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 6

    unemployment. The present day Denmark reflects independence and a considerable decline

    in the geographical size. Denmark transformed from a superpower under the Northern Europe

    to a prosperous nation. The Vikings used techniques that were very advanced when they were

    building ship. Vikings were feared since they were used for warfare and in looting throughout

    the whole period. Both the 16th and 17th centuries saw the stability in the economy.

    Influence of globalization on policies and decision making processes in Denmark

    Globalization can be perceived as techniques used in intensifying the worldwide

    interconnections of the economic activities. According Appelt & Weiss (2001, p. 15),

    globalization is ideally a discursive process that is based on neo-liberalism, evidenced by the

    neo-liberal discourse in competition, the comparative advantages, and the investment friendly

    environments.

    The Economic Policy

    Globalization reduced significantly the repertoire and the efficiency of the

    national economic policies. Mostly, the instruments used in traditional macroeconomic

    disappeared and effectiveness of other instruments adversely declined. The global capital

    markets hindered the effective control of the money supply and the interest rates. This

    undermined the effectiveness for the national monetary policy. Moreover, at national level,

    the exchange rate management became vulnerable to the speculative capital movements. As a

    result, the economic policy makers aim at accommodating expectations by the big investors

    internationally, in their consideration of the most appropriate measures in the economic

    policy. This has proved more imperative than the domestic political considerations.

    The perception of European Union as the supranational body limits the plans by

    the EU countries in using the instruments in macroeconomic policy. The Keynesian demand

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    7/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 7

    management effectiveness has reduced due to spill over demand effects of the expansion

    across the borders. Some industrial policy instruments have been ineffective in transfer

    production and undermine the efforts towards the support of the "national champions".

    The Global Trade

    The Free trade free capital availability improves the international competition

    and as well as inducing pressures on OECD member countries in pursuing the industrial

    restructuring measures. Cow-cost producers competition based on the modern technologies

    in production has been very vital. New market economies affect the restructuring processes.

    The effects competitive ventures are grave and the individual nation states should cautiously

    reallocate the resources thus shifting the international markets conditions. The pressure

    towards industrial upgrade in Denmark is especially high due to the low and medium tech

    specialization.

    The Social Policies

    Domestic socio-economic adjustment encompasses shifting of the resources

    from shrinking sectors to expanding sector. As a result, there is greater need to compensate so

    as to alleviate adjustment process. The compensation capacities appear to be declining. The

    curtailed efficiency and the autonomy in the management of the macroeconomic policy have

    undermined the nation state policies on full employment.

    This was considered as first most line of the defence from poverty in

    Keynesian model of welfare state. Mishra (1999, p.48). Secondly, the effectiveness in the

    social support defence has drastically reduced due to the decline in effectiveness of taxation

    of the increased mobility of the tax base national governments. Moreover, globalization is

    believed to undermine the extent to which the political basis can chip in and facilitate the

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    8/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 8

    funding of the welfare state.

    Usually, it is said that employers demand the reduction in taxes and

    contribution in social security. They argue that these two impedes their competitiveness

    globally. On the other hand, the political forces will resist the tax cuts and weaken the decline

    in social contributions. Some other barriers arise due to the integration of the EU monetary

    union and common market. The increased barriers are as a result of the unavailability of

    common integration of social policy. These lead to downward spiralling in social standards

    even as the nation counters the competition in the international market.

    The Ideological Change

    Despite of the factual effects of globalization, there are also the indirect effects

    that involve the change in the strategic arena as well as the payoffs from various actions. The

    reorientation in political perspectives as well as changes in the shared mental models follows.

    The ideological forces play a key role in apparent convergence of the political and the social

    agendas in the commitment towards the price stability, privatization, low deficits and

    taxation, and expenditure cuts measures in welfare and social support. In the non-liberal

    discourse, the Danish socio-economic development is affected when the factual pressures are

    limited. The consequences are real, particularly if those involved believe in globalization.

    Ganssmann (2001, p.48).

    Some other impacts of globalization include the decline in the wages due to the

    increase in the international competitions. Lack of skilled labour exposed the high-cost

    countries to severe competitive pressures. Furthermore, globalization is believed to reinforce

    the disintegration of the pre-existing bargains. The Danish "negotiated economy" context on

    future survival of the institutions that have been established raises contentions. Kjaer &

    Pedersen (200l,p.45). The rate of unemployment is higher than average among the low-

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    9/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 9

    skilled workers. However, efforts were made towards the prevention of their social and

    economic marginalization. This was done through income support supplement in 1990s and it

    was done through a special program on democratic workforce.

    Response of Denmark

    The globalization pressures affected the Danish government capacity in

    promotion of the national prosperity through the macroeconomic policy. In 1984, Denmark

    made remarkable efforts in de-regulation of the credit and liberalization of the capital

    movements. After this period, Denmark has not been able to regulate and manipulate credit,

    though the effects of these two instruments are minimal.

    Denmark declined EURO currency and did not join European Monetary Union

    (EMU). Despite of this, its exchange rates and other monetary policies are linked to EU,

    which is based on EMU membership. Their interest rates were higher than from other

    members of the union. The influence of Denmark on decision-making processes in European

    Central Bank is limited, and is prone to speculative attacks. As a result, Denmark relies on

    policies that are more prudent policies than in cases where it could be part of EMU.

    The severity of the speculative attacks suffered by Denmark was not as serious

    as it was in Britain and Sweden. By 1982, the Denmarks exchange rate was linked fully to

    Germans Mark then to EURO. The Danish governments were strongly committed to the

    fixed rate in boosting the employment through budget deficits and devaluations of the

    currency.

    The rate of unemployment was very high in Denmark than it was in the other

    countries. The regime of the economic policy acted as a surrender to the capitalism and

    departure from the definitions of the Scandinavian model. Globalization has resulted to a

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    10/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 10

    significant reduction in Keynesian demand management. Not all autonomy was lost, recent

    developments depict macroeconomic policy scope which support employment. Between 1993

    and 1994, the democratic government revived the stagnant economy using different policies

    that relied on existing manoeuvring room based on fixed exchange rate during the

    international growth regime. Combination of these measures with innovative arrangements

    on paid leave, a declining level in unemployment resulted in Denmark. Loftager & Madsen

    (1997, p.36). The labour market supply played key roles towards the success and it was clear

    that the demand management could be effective even in employment policies on condition

    that they be conducted on criteria of anti-inflationary and fixed exchange rate regime.

    Sources depict that apart from macroeconomic policies being limited in achieving the

    economic growth, they contribute to unemployment and they are usually irrelevant.

    Efforts are made towards improving of quality in production sector especially in

    technology, knowledge skills and the social skills. The formulation of policies in industry,

    labour market, education and in training facilitated the improvement of the economic

    performance. The Schumpeterianism; new regime replaced the Keynesianism, and this was

    characterized by the supply side measures substituting the demand side measure which has

    boosted competitiveness and restructuring Jessop (2000, p.58). The adoption of these

    structural policies by Denmark took place earlier and in 1980s, some major technological

    policies were initiated which acted as guidelines in the economic policies. Nielsen (1991,

    p.71).

    There was an introduction of structural monitoring system by the government in

    1997 meant to enhance the structural competitiveness. It also reduced structural

    unemployment. As a result, new polices emerged in industrial and labour market sectors.

    The traditional macroeconomic policies were greatly undermined by the increased pressures

    from globalization. The management of the aggregate demand is still limited despite of the

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    11/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 11

    institution constrain from the deficit limit that was imposed by EU Stability. The effects on

    smaller countries lie Denmark were minimal. The smallness and openness restricted the

    autonomy. The growth in structural policies in Denmark has been remarkable and its progress

    in economic policy is commendable.

    GLOBAL TRADE

    The global industrial reorganization facilitated specialization that contributed to

    structural changes between and within industrial trade economies. Held et al (1999, p.186).

    Denmark showed such a trend in its economy, where this Danish economy did not suffer

    from the high competitions of the low-wage countries. In 2000, the 88% of its proceedings

    were obtained from trade with other OECD countries, while about 68% was from the EU.

    Trade with industrialized economies from Asia (NIEs) constituted 1.4% and 3.8% from the

    CEE countries.

    Increase in the trade between Denmark and NIEs was negligible in the last

    decade while that with the CEE grew gradually from 1.4% to 3.8%. The trade between

    Denmark to CEE was characterized by Danish exports increasing significantly than the

    imports (Rasmussen and Andersen 2002). Despite of the occurrence of specialization pattern,

    competition was still heightened in the low-cost countries.

    Denmark can be classified as one of the countries with the highest level of

    specialization. The Danish exports were highest in food products and less of pharmaceuticals

    and furniture. Various challenges ere experienced in pharmaceuticals, biomedical electronics

    and wireless communication. The industrial structure in Denmark was dominated by

    international level sectors that were characterized by low research, growth and wages. This

    weakened the already low specialization degree of the high-tech products. Despite of these

    challenges, the maintenance and improvement of relative positions in Denmark was a success

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    12/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 12

    and it was measured in GDP per capita. Flexibility and adaptability in the use of resources

    enhanced the diffusion of new technologies in both the low tech and the medium tech

    industries. This period saw advanced production equipment and improved manufacturing

    methods in foodstuffs, in furniture and in clothing. This contributed significantly to the

    expertise in design and marketing. Lundvall (2002, p.98). The assets in experience-based

    knowledge in the traditional industries are limited to R&D, but social interaction on the

    organizations boundaries, on the departments and in the management levels dominated. The

    system is capable of supporting the interaction between education and labour market. The

    structural reforms were aimed at facilitating capabilities and flexibility in labour markets.

    The Danish society was characterized by the strong cohesion where the firms

    took advantage of the relatively huge stock in social capital and the mutual trust. This results

    to a reduction of costs in the firm transaction and enhances the adaptation, cooperation and

    learning among the firms. The localized learning was on the basis of shared trust acted major

    competitive assets in Denmark. Maskell et al. (1999, p.76). The degree of direct investments

    in the international level was very low. Danish Competition Authority (1999,p.180). This low

    degree in outward foreign investment reflected the small sized nature of Danish firms and the

    large multinationals in smaller numbers than in Sweden and Netherlands. The SMEs

    predominance made many foreign firms being uninterested in making any investments in

    Denmark.

    Also, the investment by foreign firms was affected by the challenges in tapping

    the competitive sources of Danish economy. The experience-based knowledge entailed the

    context tacit knowledge. Despite of the availability of such knowledge amongst the insiders,

    its transfer is usually hard. It was crucial that availability of any specialization in the high

    tech products be backed-up by codified (R&D) knowledge. In Denmark, the previous two

    decades were characterized by increase in the foreign investments. In Denmark, the FDIs

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    13/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 13

    share quadrupled as that of GDP. Danish Government (1997, p. 53).

    Contrary to Swedish firms, the Danish firms were dependent on the national

    innovation systems in technological and organization adaptation, hence they preferred voice

    to exit.

    Areas of improvement: welfare restructuring

    Despite of globalization, the social spending, which is a percentage of GDP increased

    substantially. The high expenditure by the welfare is usually incompatible with the

    globalizations economic growth. The welfare provision evidence is not systematic and it

    affects the performance of trade. Pfaller et al.(1991, p.90). The availability of strong welfare

    programs is believed to enhance high level social capita as well as creation of strong social

    support in social capital maintenance. Selle (1999, p.80). It is believed that there is no

    correlation between employment and taxation.

    The case was true for Denmark in that Denmark is highly dependent on the

    income taxes and the contributions from other employers, the availability of the security in

    modest job, and finally, the strong decentralized and collective bargaining was very strong.

    The welfare state in Denmark was described as being compatible with other competitive

    economies. The migration and integration of the European affected the Danish approach

    critically. Apart from the ideological and structural changes, the political repercussions

    constituted majority of the decisive impacts in Denmark.

    The government in Denmark sided with Britain in the opposition evidenced by

    rejection of the Maastricht treaty by the Danish electorate. As a result, Denmarks situation

    became unsustainable due to exemption from the dynamic developments within the EU. Most

    political parties and various interest groups favoured Denmark. The elites and ordinary

    nationals from Denmark split. The emergent split was because of divergence in the

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    14/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 14

    perceptions toward globalization. Elites considered globalization being an opportunity but

    other citizens considered it to be an obstacle.

    CONCLUSION

    The negotiated economy in Denmark mediated the effects of globalization

    pressures particularly in the national context. Facts on globalization influence within the

    Danish economy are minimal but there is an ideological evidence of the impacts of neo-

    liberal ideas regarding the e policy discourse. The trade regulations in EU through some

    international bodies such as WTO denote alterations and renegotiations in state sovereignty.

    Denmark was one of pioneers in enactment of the adjustments from autonomy loss before

    popularity of globalization. The transition of Denmark from a Keynesian demand to the

    Schumpeterian supply side, some challenges in globalization were solved.

    The economy of Denmark is faced by low unemployment levels, dynamism in

    industrial networks, stability in public finances and strong currency. Generally, Denmark

    does not have large companies, the high tech industries are incomprehensive and the

    influential interest group are of high tax burden.

    Remarkably, a country with well planned welfare related expenditures will have

    the equality in transition from the demand side to the supply side free of welfare

    retrenchment and without causing any discrepancies in wages. Despite of the open market

    economy in Denmark, there have been obstacles when dealing with the outsiders. The non-

    liberal ideologies by the public did not alter the social consensus in Denmark but it changed

    negotiated economy practices. Apparent split between the elites and the ordinary people

    evidenced the negative ideological impacts of the neo-liberal ideas in public discourse of

    Denmark.

    The integrative democracy which involves strong participatory elements is a

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    15/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 15

    guarantee of strong relationship between elite and ordinary discourses in a negotiated

    economy. The split that occurred latest was a potentially disruptive phenomenon. Generally,

    the growing globalization in Denmark can be likened to a sinking ship from a rough sea. In

    order to prevent any wreckage, a consensus on the intended direction and collaboration

    amongst the crew should be reached through solidarity and equality. Globalization can be

    likened to a rough sea and efforts to steer the ship is from the political elite. The elites

    express their eagerness in exploiting the new opportunities but ordinary citizens will be

    worried about the costs.

    The political party support has been facilitated by the strategic positioning of

    the party in the defending side of the ordinary person from the effects of globalization. The

    opposition by the EU has reinforced the xenophobic reactions in the Danish public. As a

    result, the downgrading of the welfare benefits may be necessary in coping up with the

    asylum seekers. The threats in the welfare state and they have contributed to inactiveness in

    the defensive posture for the active initiatives. As a result, the defensive posture by the

    politicians in Denmark influences the transformations in the society.

    The activities of parties are an example of a compromise on strict measures so

    as to meet deadlines. The compromise hinders the efforts to make any remarkable progress

    by the government. Denmark, being one of the CMEs has employed tighter monetary policy,

    deficit reduction, an undervalued currency, increased debt-driven consumer demand and the

    pursuit of stable exchange rates for her success.

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    16/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 16

    REFERENCES

    Amin, A. and Thomas, D. (1998) "The Negotiated Economy: State and Civic Institutions in

    Denmark," Economy and Society 25(2): 255-281.

    Andersen, T. M. (2002) "Internationaliseringog Velfaerdssamfund", Politica 34(1): 24-37.

    Appelt, E. and Weiss, A. (eds) (2001) Globalisierung und der Angriff auf die europaischen

    Wohlfahrtsstaaten, Argument-Sonderband Neue Folge AS 279. Berlin and Hamburg.

    Benner. M. (1997) The Politics of Growth, Lund: Arkiv.

    Benner, M. and Vad, T. (2000) "Sweden and Denmark: Defending the Welfare State," in F.

    W. Scharpf and V. A. Schmidt (eds) Welfare and Work in the Open Economy:

    Volume II. Diverse Responses to Common Challenges, Oxford: Oxford University

    Press: 399-466.

    Berger, S. and Dore, R. (eds) (1996) National Diversity and Global Capitalism, Ithaca:

    Cornell University Press.

    Cox, R. (1997) "Democracy in Hard Times. Economic Globalization and the Limits to

    Liberal Democracy," in A. G. McGrew (ed.) The Transformation of Democracy?

    Globalization and Territorial Democracy, Cambridge: Polity Press: 49-72.

    Crouch, C. and Streeck, W. (eds) (1997) Political Economy of Modern Capitalism: Mapping

    Convergence and Diversity, London: Sage.

    Danish Competition Authority (Konkurrencestyrelsen) (1999) Konkurrenceredegoerelsen,

    Copenhagen: Konkurrencestyrelsen.

    Danish Government (1997) A Structural Monitoring System for Denmark, Copenhagen: The

    Danish Government.

    Deppe, F. (2001) "Vom keynesianischen Wohlfahrtsstaat zum neoliberalen

    Wettbewerbsregime," in E. Appelt and A. Weiss (eds) Globalisierung und der Angriff

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    17/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 17

    auf die europaischen Wohlfahrtsstaaten, Berlin and Hamburg: Argument-Sonderband

    Neue Folge AS 279:21-46.

    Edquist, C. and Lundvall. B.-A. (1993) "Comparing the Danish and the Swedish Systems of

    Innovation," in R. R. Nelson (ed.) National Innovation Systems: A Comparative

    Analysis, Oxford: Oxford University Press: 265-298.

    Esping-Andersen, G. (1990) The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism, Cambridge: Polity

    Press.

    Esping-Andersen, G. (ed.) (1996) Welfare States in Transition National Adaptation in Global

    Economies, London: Sage.

    Ganssmann, H. (2001) "Soziale Sicherheit und Kapitalmobilitat--Hat der Sozialstaat ein

    Standortproblem?", in E. Appelt and A. Weiss (eds) Globalisieruag und der Angriff

    auf die europaischen Wohlfahrtsstaaten, Berlin and Hamburg: Argument-Sonderband

    Neue Folge AS 279:47-66.

    Garrett, G. and Lange, P. (1991) "Political Responses to Interdependence: What's 'Left' for

    the Left?", International Organization 45(4): 539-64.

    Gill, S. (1995) "Globalization, Market Civilization, and the Disciplinary Neoliberalism,"

    Millennium 24(3): 399-423.

    Glyn, A. (1995) "Social Democracy and Full Employment," New Left Review 211(1): 33-55.

    Harvey, D. (1997) "Betreff Globalisierung," in S. Becker, T. Sablowski and W. Schumm

    (eds) Jenseits der Nationalokonomie? Weltwirtschaft und Nationalstaat zwischen

    Globalisierung und Regionalisierung, Berlin and Hamburg: Argument-Sonderband

    Neue Folge AS 249:28-49.

    Held, D. and McGrew, A., Goldblatt, D. and Perraton, J. (1999) Global Transformations--

    Politics, Economics and Culture, Cambridge: Polity Press.

    Hirst, P. and Thompson, G. (1999) Globalization in Question--The International Economy

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    18/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 18

    and the Possibilities of Governance, Polity Press: Cambridge.

    Jespersen, J. (1999) "Scandinavian Model," in P. A. O'Hara (ed.) Encyclopedia of Political

    Economy, London and New York: Routledge: 1005-1007.

    Jessop, B. (2000) "Restructuring the Welfare State, Re-Ordering Welfare Strategies, Re-

    Visioning the Welfare Society," in B. Greve (ed.) What Constitutes a Good Society?,

    Basingstoke: Macmillan: 13-34.

    Jessop, B. (2002) The Future of the Capitalist State, Cambridge: Polity Press. Katzenstein. P.

    (1985) Small States in World Markets, Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

    Kjaer, P. and Pedersen, O. K. (2001) "Translating Liberalization--Neoliberalism in the

    Danish Negotiated Economy," in J. L. Campbell and O. K. Pedersen (eds) The Rise of

    Neoliberalism and Institutional Analysis, Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University

    Press: 219-248.

    Loftager, J. and Madsen, P. K. (1997) "Denmark," in H. Compton (ed.) The New Politics of

    Unemployment: Radical policy initiatives in Western Europe, London and New York:

    Routledge: 123-145.

    Lundvall, B.-A. (2002) Innovation, Growth and Social Cohesion, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

    Maskell, P. (1998) "Learning in the Village Economy of Denmark--the Role of Institutions

    and Policy in Sustaining Competitiveness," in H. Braczyk, P. Cooke, and M.

    Heidenreich (eds) Regional Innovation Systems--The Role of Governance in a

    Globalized World. London: UCL Press: 190-213.

    Maskell, P. (ed.) (1999) Competitiveness, Localised Learning and Regional Development:

    Specialisation and Prosperity in Small Open Economies, Routledge: London.

    Ministry of Business and Industry (1996) Technological and Organizational Change.

    Implications for Labour Demand. Enterprise Performance and Industrial Policy. The

    OECD Jobs Strategy, Country Report Denmark, Ministry of Business and Industry,

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    19/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 19

    Copenhagen.

    Mishra, R. (1999) Globalization and the Welfare State. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

    Mjoset, L. (1987) "Nordic Economic Policies in the 1970s and 1980s," International

    Organization 41 (3): 403-56.

    Muller-Armack, A. (1989) "The Meaning of the Social Market Economy," in A. Peacock and

    H. Willgerodt (eds) Germany's Social Market Economy Origins and Evolution,

    London: Macmillan: 82-86.

    Nielsen, K. (1991) "Learning to Manage the Supply-side: Flexibility and Stability in

    Denmark," in B. Jessop (ed.) The Politics of Flexibility. Restructuring State and

    Industry in Britain, Germany and Scandinavia, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar: 282-313.

    Nielsen, K. (2000) "From Macro-economic to Structural Policy: New Trends in Economic

    and Industrial Policies in Denmark," in B. Greve (ed.) What Constitutes a Good

    Society, London: Macmillan: 77-97.

    Nielsen, K. (2001) "Discourses of Globalization and Competitiveness in the Negotiated

    Economy," in W. Eisner, A. Biesecker and K. Grenzdorffer (eds) Okonomische

    BeWertungen in gesellschaftlichen Prozessen--Markt--Macht--Diskurs, Herbolzheim:

    Centaurus: 21-52.

    Nielsen, K. (2003) "Dansk mirakel nat litenhet omvandleats till styrka, Axess," 2:22-24:

    English website version ( www.axess.se ) "Why Small is Beautiful in the Danish

    Economy".

    Nielsen, K. and Pedersen, O. K. (1991) "From the Mixed Economy to the Negotiated

    Economy: The Scandinavian Countries." in: R. M. Coughlin (ed.) Morality,

    Rationality, and Efficiency--New Perspectives on Socio-Economics, New York and

    London: M. E. Sharpe: 145-165.

    Pierson, P. (1996) Dismantling the Welfare State? Reagan, Thatcher and the Politics of

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    20/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 20

    Retrenchment, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

    Pfaller, A., Gough, I. and Therborn, G. (1991) Can the Welfare State Compete?, Basingstoke:

    Macmillan.

    Rasmussen, F. and Andersen, P. (2002) Globaliseringens oekonomiske konsekvenser for

    Danmark, Aarhus: Maktudredningen.

    Regeringen--Danish Government (1995) "Velstand og Velfaerd--en analysesammenfatning,"

    Erhvervsminsteriet, Finansministeriet, Copenhagen: Statsministeriet og

    Oekonomiministeriet.

    Regeringen--Danish Government (1997) Globalisering og Dansk Oekomnni. Copenhagen:

    Finansministriet.

    Rodrik, D. (1997) Has Globalization Gone Too Far?, Washington D.C.: Institute for

    International Economics.

    Scharpf, F. W. (1996) "Politische Optionen im erweiterten Binnenmarkt," in M. Jachtenfuchs

    and B. Kohler-Koch (eds) Europaische Integration, Opladen: Leske and Budrich: 109-

    140.

    Scharpf, F. W. (2000) "Economic Changes, Vulnerabilities, and Institutional Capabilities," in

    F. W. Scharpf and V. A. Schmidt (eds) Welfare and Work in the Open Economy--

    Volume I. From Vulnerability to Competitiveness, Oxford: Oxford University Press:

    21-124.

    Schwartz, H. (1994) "Small States in Big Trouble. State Reorganization in Australia,

    Denmark, New Zealand and Sweden in the 1980s," World Politics 46(July): 527-55.

    Selle, P. (1999) "The Transformation of the Voluntary Sector in Norway: a Decline in Social

    Capital?" in J. Van Deth, M. Maraffi, K. Newton, P. Whiteley and H. Kenman (eds)

    Social Capital and European Democracy, London and New York: Routledge.

    Streeck, W. (1999) Korporatismus in Deutschland Zwischen Nationalstaat und Europaischer

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    21/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 21

    Union, Frankfurt a.M. and New York: Campus Verlag.

    Swank, D. (2002) "Withering Welfare," Globalisation, Political Economic Institutions, and

    the Foundation of Contemporary Capitalism," in L. Weiss (ed.) States in the Global

    Economy: Bringing Domestic Institutions Back In, Cambridge: Cambridge University

    Press: 58-82.

    Torfing, J. (1999) "Workfare with Welfare," Journal of European Social Policy, 9(1): 1-31.

    Weiss, L. (2002) "Introduction. Bringing Domestic Institutions Back In,'" in L. Weiss (ed.)

    States in the Global Economy. Bringing Domestic Institutions Back hi. Cambridge:

    Cambridge University Press: 1-33.

  • 7/29/2019 Globalization in Denmark

    22/22

    CONTINUITY AND CONTEMPORARY BUSINESS IN DENMARK 22

    Klaus Nielsen (1) and Stefan Kesting (2)

    (1) Roskilde University Denmark and Birkbeck, University of London and (2) University of

    Bremen

    Klaus Nielsen is Professor in Social Science (Institutional theory) at the University of

    Roskilde, Denmark, and Senior Lecturer in Management at Birkbeck, University of London,

    UK. He has published several books including Institutions and Economic Change. New

    Perspectives on Markets, Firms and Technologies (1998) (with Bjorn Johnson) and Strategic

    Choice and Path-Dependency in Post-Socialism (1995) (with Jerzy Hausner and Bob Jessop).

    In the context of a new Book Series New Developments in Institutional Theory (Edward

    Elgar) of which he is the editor, two of his forthcoming books are Institutionalism in

    Economics and Sociology. Variety, Dialogue and Future Challenges and Social Capital, Trust

    and Institutions.

    Stefan Kesting holds a Ph.D. in economics and is working as lecturer and researcher at the

    University of Bremen, Germany. As an institutional and social economist, he has published

    articles on power and language in economics. He is author of a textbook on microeconomics

    in German Mikookonomik (Oldenbourg 2003, with A. Biesecker) and is currently writing a

    book on welfare economics.

    COPYRIGHT 2003 Routledge

    Document RVSE000020040211dz9100005