global auto executive survey 2010
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
1/44
Automotive
KPMGs Global Auto ExecutiveSurvey 2010Industry Concerns and Expectations to 2014
kpmg internAtionAl
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
2/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
Contents
Chapter Page
1 Survey methodology 2
2 Executive summary 3
3 Introduction 4
4 The growth prospect 6Executive view: volume automaker Europe 8Overcapacity is now critical 9Emerging markets are becoming overbuilt 11
5 The perormance angle 12Executive view: mid-size automaker US 14No easy cost savings expected 15Capital costs to remain high 17
M&A set to grow 18Debt and technology needs will drive M&A 20
6 Product innovation and consumer change 22Fuel eciency and environment top o consumer concerns 24Low-cost producers to win most market share 26Hybrid technology rated clear leader 28Executive view: large Tier 1 supplier US 30R&D will win most investment 31
7 Investing in new markets 34Executive view: diversied supplier emerging market 36BRIC sales orecasts continue to grow 37Smaller emerging markets to gain 40
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
3/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
Foreword
1Foreword
Dieter BeckerGlobal Chair, Automotive
KPMG ELLP
KPMGs Global Auto Executive Survey
2010 was conducted at the end o a historic
year or the auto business. The intensity o
the crisis that enguled the entire industry
can hardly be underestimated.
Last year we surveyed an industry that
had been plunged, very suddenly, into
total uncertainty. As one o the large
automakers interviewed as part o thisyears report said, a year ago we were
in the middle o nowhere anything
was possible.
This crisis was in part a consequence
o success. Auto products are better
than they have ever been: with todays
high levels o reliability and longevity,
many customers can deer the purchase
o a new vehicle. So when condence
collapsed on a global scale at the end
o 2008, that is exactly what customers
did. Sales plummeted in almost everymarket, while nancial conditions became
intolerable even or companies with
moderate levels o indebtedness. The
destruction o large segments o the
worlds auto industry and other
industries too became a real possibility.
As our survey records, the industry is
already on the way out o that period
o crisis. Condence is higher, while
growth and new investment are back
on the agenda.
But more striking is the record o autoindustry caution that the survey depicts.
We have come a long way, respondent
companies are saying, but we have a lot
urther to go. In particular, we note that
many companies are saying that
overcapacity is still at very high levels
respondents believe it is signicantly
higher than last year, despite a year o
closures and bankruptcies and the
consequence is that much o the
expected restructuring o the industry
may still lie in the uture.
And there are huge technology challenges
to be met. Last year companies told
us that uel eciency and emissions
improvements were top o their agenda.
This year they are still top o their agenda.
Meanwhile, companies ace the challenge
o nancing the cycle o innovation and
let us not orget that we are still in the
middle o a rapid innovation cycle whileconsumers eel they are poorer than
beore, and less inclined to spend. That,
say our respondents, means that companies
are likely to have to compete on technology
and on cost. That is a tall order.
Meeting that challenge inevitably means
more change more change in the structure
and in the practices o the auto industry.
I anything is clear rom what respondents
are saying to us today, it is that change has
only just begun.
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
4/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.ational or any other member rm vis--v is third parties,
Vehicle manuacturer
Tier 1 supplier
Tier 2 supplier
KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Intern
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
2 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
Chapter 1: Survey methodology
CEO/President/Chairman
C-level Executive
Business Unit Head/Functional Head
Business Unit Function Management/
Leadership Team
Business Unit Functional Manager
4%
3%
47%
6%
40%
38.50%
50.00%
11.50%
Survey participantsby job title
Survey participantsby company type
KPMGs Global Auto ExecutiveSurvey 2010 is the 11th consecutiveannual survey o senior global autoexecutives carried out by KPMGInternational. This year the survey ismore extensive than in previousyears: 200 respondents rom 24countries took part in the survey
between mid-September and earlyNovember 2009, includingcompanies in the Americas, AsiaPacic, Europe, Arica and theMiddle East. All survey questionsrelate to the coming ve-yearperiod, extending to 2014, unlessspecically stated otherwise.
Each year we ask executives to describe
themselves and their companies. In earlier
surveys automakers and suppliers describing
themselves as Tier 1, Tier 2 and Tier 3
companies participated. However, the
increasing diculty o nding a large
sample o Tier 3 suppliers that are o
sucient size to participate in the survey
(with revenues in excess o US$100 million)
meant that in last years survey no respondentschose to describe themselves as Tier 3
suppliers, and results rom Tier 2 and Tier 3
suppliers in data rom earlier years were
grouped together. In the current survey
KPMG restricted the survey to Tier 1 and
Tier 2 suppliers. In almost all cases this
permits direct year-on-year comparisons
o results rom Tier 1 and Tier 2 suppliers
in only one case (noted in the text),
comparative data rom 2007 includes
some results rom Tier 3 suppliers.
In last years survey a number o questions
were restricted to regional companies.
In the present survey all companies were
oered the opportunity to respond to all
questions, irrespective o the region in
which the company was headquartered.
The result is a greatly expanded sample
base throughout the current survey.
Some questions elicited no response romsome respondents; thereore total results
may be less than 100 percent.
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
5/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
3Executive Summary
Chapter 2: Executive Summary
Key resultsExpectations o emerging market
perormance and auto investment
accumulation have strengthened
considerably.
Overcapacity is still seen to be very high
over the ve-year period in the Americas,
Europe and Japan; M&A activity is
expected to be strong.
The long-term investment ocus remains
on new products and new technologies,
especially uel eciency.
The growth prospectAll emerging economy regions are
expected to contribute growth: not only
Asia excluding Japan, but also Eastern
Europe and Russia.
Growth expectations or Western Europe
are low, and lower still or both Japan andNorth America.
The industry still believes that overcapacity
in the established manuacturing triad
North America, Europe and Japan
remains very high.
Companies also have strong concerns
over the emergence o automotive
overcapacity in the BRICs. Concern is
highest in Russia but companies also
believe that the automotive industry
in Brazil will be overbuilt in the near to
medium term, and that China and India
will also have signicant overcapacity
not much later.
The perormance angleProtability expectations have allen.
Respondents believe best perormers will
be companies able to leverage the whole
o the supply chain, with higher prots
expected o automakers, and the lowest
expectation or Tier 3 suppliers.
Companies expect nancial conditions
to improve, but only moderately, withconditions better or consumers than
or companies.
Expectations or M&A have risen, marginally,
rom an already high level in the preceding
year, with the exception o the dealer
business, where ater a year o closure
and rationalization companies now see
M&A alling back.
Companies expect to nd ewer cost-saving
opportunities in existing businesses.
Product innovation andconsumer changeNew products and new technologies have
moved higher in the ranking o concerns
rom an already high leading position.
Fuel eciency and the environmental
prole o products continue to be
considered by companies the most
signicant consumer buying issues.
Chinese and Indian brands remain in the
top three places in terms o expectation o
market share gain, but conviction is slightly
lower than last year. Two signicant
winners o market share competition are
seen as Hyundai/Kia and VW.
Companies in all three global regions cite
exactly the same three vehicle types as top
market share gainers (hybrids, other
alternative-uel vehicles and low-cost
introduction cars).
Alternative propulsion technologies are
the key technological ocus or companies.
Electric power ranks only just behind
hybrid power developments and battery
and uel-cell approaches are ascribed
almost equal priority.
Companies say they will direct most
investment capital to technology and
new model development. New plantbuilding is accorded very low priority.
New marketsCompanies are nearly unanimous in
expecting emerging markets to build most
automotive capacity and to provide the
most growth in automotive revenues.
The majority o companies surveyed say
they intend to increase their investments
in the BRICs.
Expectations or both domestic and
export Chinese sales have increased.
The consensus view o companies on
sales growth in Brazil, India and Russia
is also strong, although Russian export
potential is not rated so highly.
Beyond the BRICs companies expect
strong demand growth and auto
investment in South East Asia and
in Eastern Europe.
Top-rated individual destinations or
auto investment beyond the BRICs
are Ukraine, Thailand and Mexico.
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
6/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
4 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
Chapter 3: Introduction
Last years KPMG Global Auto Executive
Survey reported on an industry alling into
crisis. Sales were collapsing, growth
expectations were swinging rom positive
to negative, investment schedules were
being torn up, and or more than one large
company, bankruptcy loomed.
This year, we report on an industry that
has conronted the crisis, and has justbegun to emerge into a landscape o
greater stability. In many ways the crisis
was much worse than the gloomiest
predictions. Bankruptcy became a reality
or a number o large automakers, as
demand ell urther and aster than
expected, and as the ability o indebted
businesses to nance themselves simply
evaporated.
Yet the worst was avoided. Exceptional
government intervention helped to shield
the industry rom the worst o the all in
demand, and allowed some companies
to begin to rebuild themselves behind the
wall o temporary bankruptcy. Above all,
the sudden loss o condence in demand
and growth in the big emerging economies
was counteracted by an equally sudden
resurgence, as it became clear thatemerging world growth was much more
resilient than pessimists eared. The
stabilization and subsequent recovery o
asset prices against a background o less
volatile energy costs helped immeasurably.
But we are let with a world that has
changed: a deep restructuring o the
automotive industry has begun, and
continues. One dimension o this has
been a signicant transer o automotive
technology to the emerging world.
Existing producers with lower costs have
seen their businesses strengthened.
And with a global market that has clearly
shrunk, many established producers arehaving to conront the act that competition
or sales is likely to be much, much
tougher in the next ew years than any
time in the last two decades.
As one European automaker interviewed
or this report commented: this last year
has made us conront reality.
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
7/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
8/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
6 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
Chapter 4: The growth prospect
The current survey shows that the gradual
reorientation o growth expectations away
rom the mature economies and toward
Asia and other signicant emerging
economies has passed a tipping point.
Although previous surveys show that
companies have consistently been
orecasting a decline in the growth trend
or some years, the great majority o
companies now locate all their signicantgrowth expectations or the next ve
years in the emerging world.
All emerging economy regions are
expected to contribute growth: not only
Asia (excluding Japan), but also Eastern
Europe and Russia. The balance o
expectations or Western Europe is now
even between companies expecting
some decline and companies expecting
some improvement (most expect little
change), but the balance is negative or
both Japan and North America: morecompanies now expect decline in those
regions than expect improvement.
On a regional basis, pessimism on
revenues in the Americas is strongest
in European and Asian companies.
Companies in the Americas are slightly
more positive both regarding their own
region, and on growth prospects in Asia.
76.00%
15.50%
6.00%17.50%
42.00%
36.00%
47.00%
28.00%
23.50% 24.00%
50.00%
24.50%
20.00%
52.50%
19.00%27.00%
47.00%
19.00%
Asia
(exclu
dingJa
pan)
Cent
ral&
Sou
thAme
rica
Easte
rnEur
ope&Rus
sia
Wes
tern
Eur
ope
Midd
leEa
st&
Afri
ca
Japa
n Nor
thAm
erica
21.50%
44.50%
31.50%
What are your orecasts or auto industry revenuesin the ollowing regions and countries?
Growth expectations largely geared to Asia
Eastern Europe shows second biggest increase
Biggest declines seen in North America and Japan
Increase Stable Decline
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
9/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.
North America Western Europe Japan Eastern Europe &Russia
Asia (excludingJapan)
Central & SouthAmerica
Middle East &Arica
Americas Europe, Middle East and Arica (EMEA) Asia Pacic (ASPAC)
KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
7The growth prospect
46.67%
41.66%
18.34%
26.67%
30.00%
18.34%
45.16%
27.42%
17.74%
29.03%
19.36%
48.71%
38.46%
23.08%
19.23%
16.66%
27.42%
74.20%
86.67%
14.11%
69.23%
What are your orecasts or auto industry revenues in the ollowing regions and countries?*
Companies in the Americas most optimistic on emerging economy growth
Japan rated lowest growth market by EMEA companies
Broad regional consensus on high Eastern European and Asian growth
* Percentage o companiesexpecting improvements
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
10/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
8 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
Executive view: volume automaker Europe
This Europe-headquartered globalautomaker with signicantmanuacturing and sales in allregions o the world says that morethan ever the key to success isproduct excellence.
My condence level has increased
signicantly in the last 12 months. A year
ago we were in the middle o nowhere
not just in the auto industry; it applied to all
businesses. Nobody knew what the next
24 months would bring. Anything was
possible. But now we have some clarity.
Consumer demand has recovered better
than we expected a year ago. It is stillgoing to take a long time to recover ully,
but the important thing is that recovery
is predictable.
I share the general aith in demand rom
the emerging markets. From the consumer
point o view these markets are simply
better placed than the US or Europe or
Japan. In the past these economies were
highly dependent on oreign direct
investment or their growth, but now they
are generating their own trade surpluses,
they have growth that is not investment-dependent, and some o them are still
beneting rom very low interest rates.
So the emerging market economies will
be airly positive over the next one to two
years. The question is, what does this
mean or autos? Weve seen a huge
increase in demand over 2009, but or the
near uture I am more doubtul about auto
demand. I dont expect a collapse, but
incentives like we have seen in China and
Brazil cannot continue orever.
As or the global picture, I think the next
ve years are going to see the industry
challenged to compete both on technology
and on cost. In technology we have a huge
challenge ahead o us, especially in CO2
reduction where expectations are enormous.
And on the cost ront there is no reason to
expect our mature-economy consumers
to become very much wealthier over the
next ew years, so there is also going to bea strong ocus on aordability.
The last year has shown us that the
winners in tough situations are always
the companies with strong products at
aordable cost. I you have weak products
you are going to suer even with a good
cost situation. That is irrespective
o segment or market
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
11/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.
Yes No
Dont know
88.00%
3.00%9.00%
2.84%
37.50%35.80%
13.64%
10.22%
1-10% 11-20% 21-30% 31-40% Morethan 40%
KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
9The growth prospect
Overcapacity is now critical
For several years KPMGs Global
Executive Auto Survey has asked
companies about their perceptions o
overcapacity: the extent to which the
manuacturing capacity o the industry is
overbuilt is a key determinant o protability
now and the likely path o restructuring
through mergers, acquisitions and
divestments in the coming ve years.
In the current survey these questionswere expanded to provide an insight
into industry perceptions o regional
overcapacity. (It is worth noting that
these questions on overcapacity relate
to long-term capacity: companies were
asked to rate levels o overcapacity over
a whole business cycle, and not just
overcapacity in relation to the current
years market).
The result is one o the most striking in
the survey. Ater a year o unprecedented
change in the structure o the auto
industry, one in which automakers
including the large US manuacturers
and suppliers closed capacity around
the world, the industry still believes
that overcapacity in the established
manuacturing triad North America,
Europe and Japan remains very high.
Companies see more overcapacity in
North America than in other regions,
but in all cases the majority sees
signicant overcapacity.
Those companies that do see overcapacity,
are more likely to rate the level o
overcapacity higher in North America than
elsewhere, with a consensus o around
25 percent overcapacity, although a
signicant minority see higher levels
one in ten companies thinks overcapacity
in North America is more than 40 percent,
or example.
Is there automotive overcapacityin North America today? How much?
North America seen as most overbuilt
Perceptions o 20 percent plus
overcapacity have risen strongly
year-on-year
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
12/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a S ational.wiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG Intern
Yes No
Dont know
KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
10 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
Yes No
Dont know
80.50%
6.50%
13.00%
18.01%
37.27%
30.43%
9.32%
4.97%
1-10% 11-20% 21-30% 31-40% Morethan 40%
Is there automotive overcapacity
in Western Europe today? How much?
75.00%
8.50%16.50%
17.33%
8.67%
6.67%
35.33%
32.00%
1-10% 11-20% 21-30% 31-40% Morethan 40%
Is there automotive overcapacityin Japan today? How much?
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
13/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.ember rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
23.24%
2.88%
1.92%
30.99%
33.10%
5.63%
7.04%
Chi
na
24.04%
43.27%
27.88%
India
13.64%
30.68%
43.18%
6.82%
5.68%
Brazil
22.62%
28.57%
29.76%
7.14%
11.9%
Rus
sia
Now 1-2 years 3-5 years
6-10 years >10 years
KPMG International provides no client services. No m
nor does KPMG International have any such authority
11The growth prospect
Emerging markets are becoming overbuilt
Given the high level o expectation o
revenue growth in the BRICs and the
high level o expressed intentions to build
investment in those economies, the act
that companies also have strong concerns
over the emergence o automotive
overcapacity in the BRICs is striking.
Companies believe that the automotive
industries in both Russia and Brazil will beoverbuilt in the near to medium term,
and that China will also have signicant
overcapacity not much later. Concern over
near-term capacities is highest in Russia,
where almost 12 percent o companies
think that overcapacity is already emerging
and 19 percent believe it will emerge
within two years.
However, it is worth noting that it is not
irrational or companies to plan investment
in locations where they believe overcapacity
is emerging: more ecient manuacturerscan always utilize ully their own investments
and make prots in an overbuilt economy.
When do you expect overcapacity in the BRICsto become a serious issue?
Overcapacity not conned to triad
Russia seen as most overbuilt in the short run
Brazil seen as most overbuilt in ve year orecast
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
14/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.s. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
39.50%
33.00%
27.50%
22.50%
36.50%
40.50% 44.50%
36.00%
18.50%
14.50%
38.50%
31.50%
22.00%
34.50%
40.00%
40.50%
42.50%
19.50%
Automakers Tier 3suppliers
Financialservices
DealersTier 2suppliers
Tier 1suppliers
Increase Stable Decline
KPMG International provides no client service
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
12 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
Chapter 5: The perormance angle
Who will best be able to make prots
against this background o alling revenue
expectations? Industry expectations o
protability by company type over the next
ve years are strikingly negative especially
when companies are asked about the
protability o their own type o company.
Overall, it is unsurprising that in an era
expected to be highly competitive
companies believe that higher prots will
accrue to companies better able to leverage
the whole o the supply chain, with higher
prots expected o automakers, and the
lowest expectation or Tier 3 suppliers.
On a regional basis, protability corresponds
roughly to revenue expectations, with the
best outlook in ASPAC.
How proftable do you think the global automaking, supplierand dealer industries will be over the next fve years?
Financial services seen as most protable
Tier 3 suppliers expected to show lower protability
Protability expected to decrease along value chain
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
15/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
13The perormance angle
30.0
0%
30.64
%
30.00
%
23.0
7%
27.4
2%
23.3
4%
17.9
5%
25.8
1%
21.6
7%
10.2
6%
22.5
8%
13.3
3%
8.9
7%
51.6
1%
46.6
7%
25.6
4%
32
.26%
20.0
0%
8.9
7%
Automakers Tier 1 suppliers Tier 2 suppliers Tier 3 suppliers Financial services Dealers
Americas Europe, Middle East and Arica (EMEA) Asia Pacic (ASPAC)
How proftable do you think the global automaking, supplierand dealer industries will be over the next fve years?*
EMEA protability expectations lowest
Across the whole value chain ASPAC expectations highest
* Percentage o companiesexpecting improvements
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
16/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
Executive view: mid-size automaker US
This subsidiary o a Japanese-owned global manuacturer remainsextremely cautious about long-termsales and prot prospects.
Over the last year my condence level
has not improved much. Unavorable
undamentals in the market have been with
us or some time now, but i anything it is
getting harder or people to sustain their
spending. No, Im not much more condent.
We have cut capacity. Perhaps not as much
as we should have done. I it werent or
our contract with the United Auto Workerswe would have done a lot more. We have
changed the product mix as well the old big
SUV products, or example, are just not
viable any more. Our competitive oers now
are in compact and crossover vehicles.
When we started developing small SUVs
people thought we were crazy but now we
are developing crossovers that are even
smaller, and people understand what we are
doing. These are the cars people want.
The government assistance scheme in the
US certainly had an impact, although ocourse it was not as great as we might have
hoped. Whether a company benets rom a
cash assistance program like that depends a
lot on the level o inventory it holds. We gave
up on the strategy o holding high inventory
and waiting or a miracle a long time ago
but when cash-or-clunkers came in, we
just didnt have the inventory. The Koreans
on the other hand do hold very high
inventories, so they had a home run.
When the cash assistance scheme ended,
sales plummeted. There just isnt the natural
demand in the market. So it is going to be
a very dicult 12 months, at least. But we
are going to have to grow our way out o it.
Government cant go on making sales or us.
Growth is the challenge, and that means
investment is the challenge. When you look
at the return on a dollar o investment in Chinaor in India, and you look at the return in the
US, the US does not look attractive. So the
uture is going to be all about operating more
eciently. We just cannot aord to waste
money on anything inecient.
The winners rom what has happened in
2009 will be primarily the Korean companies.
They have the lowest cost o production in
the US. That means they can prot in this
very weak market. But Japanese companies
also have low costs lower than the
domestic US makers, even ater all therestructuring. The Japanese also have the
culture, the camaraderie and the dedication
on the actory foor. I the domestic US
automakers cannot reproduce that, they
will never prosper.
14 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
17/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member frms o the KPMG network o independent frms are afliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member frm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member frm vis--vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member frm. All rights reserved.
62.0
0% 6
7.0
0%
57.0
0%
61.0
0%
59.0
0%
65.0
0%
55.0
0%
43.0
0%
43.0
0%
47.0
0%
50.0
0%
46.0
0%
27.0
0%
29.0
0%
46.0
0%
21.5
0%
28.0
0%
46.0
0%
48.0
0%
58.0
0%
x
38.0
0%
x x
23.5
0%
x x
30.5
0%
x x
Productmaterialsinnovation
Health careWagecosts/directlabor
Salarycosts
Taxefciency
Marketingand sales
Supplychainmanagement
Overheadcostreduction
Computermodeling
Low-costcountrysourcing
2009 2008 2007 X No data or 2008 X No data or 2007
154/Beyond crisis: challenges and opportunities 15The perormance angle
No easy cost savings expected
Falling expectations o both revenues and
proftability over the next fve years imply
a continued intense concern with cost-saving
opportunities. Yet in the current survey the
overall picture is that company expectations
o fnding cost-saving opportunities have
allen somewhat: in particular, there is less
expectation o fnding savings through
overhead cost-reduction and supply chain
innovation, and more interest inimplementing advanced IT in design.
There is a low expectation o fnding
savings through cutting wage costs
(the opportunity or making savings in
white-collar salaries is higher this years
survey is the frst in which companies
have been asked to distinguish between
wage and salary savings opportunities).
On a regional basis (results not shown
in chart) ASPAC companies are more
likely to view new design technologies as a
cost-saving opportunity. Companies in the
Americas are clearly more concerned thanother regions about salary costs and see
this as a cost opportunity, while European
companies continue to ocus more on
low-cost country sourcing.
* Percentage o companies seeingcost-saving opportunities by year
What are the cost-saving opportunities or auto manuacturers and suppliers?*
Cost ocus shits away rom restructuring
Increasing number o companies believe supply chains are ully optimized
Computer modelling rated sharply higher
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
18/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -vis third parties,
24.6
7%
25.0
0%
43.4
8%
31.1
7%
29.0
0% 3
4.7
8%
68.8
3%
54.0
0%
65.2
1%
66.2
4%
60.0
0%
56.5
2%
51.0
0%
47.8
3%
62.3
4%
7.0
9%
18.1
9% 2
3.0
0%
48.0
5%
45.0
0%
52.1
7%
26.0
0%
17.3
9%2
2.0
8%
51.9
5%
47.0
0%
39.
13%
42.8
6%
33.0
0%
43.4
8%
Supplychainmanagement
HealthcareComputermodeling
Overheadcostreductions
Productmaterialsinnovations
Marketingand sales
Low costcountrysourcing
Wage costs/direct labor
Salary costsTaxefciency
OEMs Tier 1 suppliers Tier 2 suppliers
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
16 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
* Percentage o companies seeingcost-saving opportunities
What are the cost-saving opportunities or auto manuacturers and suppliers?*
OEMs see higher cost saving opportunities
Materials innovation, computer modeling and low-cost sourcing top opportunities or OEMs
Tier 2 suppliers most likely to cut labor costs
Wage and benets cost opportunities rated low by most companies
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
19/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
ority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
Americas Europe, Middle East and Arica (EMEA) Asia Pacic (ASPAC)
KPMG International provides no client services.
nor does KPMG International have any such auth
17The perormance angle
Capital costs to remain high
The sudden contraction in late 2008 in the
availability o capital or consumers and
companies, and the increase in borrowing
costs which remain high despite low policy
interest rates, have been key components
o the auto business crisis o the last year.
In the current survey, companies were
asked or the rst time how they expected
nancial conditions or consumers and
companies to evolve.
The chart shows company expectations
o improvement. They expect the
improvement to be less apparent in
corporate nancing than in consumer
nancing, and European companies are
most pessimistic about an early return
to easy nance.
31.67%
25.64%
30.65%
33.34%
14.10%
33.87%
25.00%
32.06%
37.10%
51.67%
34.62%
41.94%
Cost o capital Availability o capital Cost o consumer credit Availability oconsumer credit
How do you expect fnancial conditionsto evolve in the next 12 months?*
Companies expecting nancial improvement outnumber
those expecting decline
EMEA companies most pessimistic on corporate nancing
* Percentage o companiesexpecting improvement
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
20/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member frms o the KPMG network o independent frms are afliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member frm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member frm vis- -vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member frm. All rights reserved.
72.0
0%
71.0
0%
52.0
0%
60.0
0%
73.0
0%
65.0
0%
51.0
0%
x
43.0
0%
70.5
0%
56.0
0%
52.0
0%
48.5
0%
47
.00%
73.5
0%
Automakers Tier 1 suppliers Tier 2 suppliers Tier 3 suppliers Dealers
2009 2008 2007 X No data or 2007
18 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
M&A set to grow
Perceptions o a continued high level o M&A is also expected in growth markets
overcapacity in the ace o a diminished as well as in stagnant markets: companies
consumer market imply continuing merger believe that the rate o M&A will not only
and acquisition activity. The results in the be high in the Americas and Europe, but
current survey show that expectations or also in Eastern Europe and in Asia.
M&A have risen, marginally, rom an Companies appear to be telling us that
already high level in the preceding year M&A may be driven by high growth as
although interestingly the one exception to well as by overcapacity in the mature
that rising expectation is in the dealer economies. Expectations or Japan are
business, where ater a year o closure lower, but still highly signifcant givenand rationalization companies now see the historically low rate o M&A activity
M&A alling back. in Japan.
How will M&A in these types o companies developover the next fve years?*
Expectations o OEM M&A growth stay
at last years high levels
Increasing expectation o M&A growth
or Tier 2 and Tier 3 suppliers
Only dealer M&A set to all back
* Percentage o companiesexpecting increase
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
21/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.
59.00%
30.50%
8.50%
8.00%
57.00%
30.00%
25.50%
60.00%
7.00%
7.00%
28.00%
64.00%
35.00%
55.00%
6.50%5.00%
30.50%
62.00%
64.50%
28.00%
5.50%
Asia
(exclu
dingJap
an)
Cent
ral&
Sou
thAm
erica
Easte
rnEur
ope&
Rus
sia
Wes
tern
Europ
e
Midd
leEa
st&
Africa
Japa
nNo
rthAm
erica
Increase Stay the same Decline
KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
How will M&A in these regions develop over the next fve years?
High expectations o Eastern European and Asian M&A
Less than one in ten companies expect M&A to decline anywhere
19The perormance angle
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
22/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -vis third parties,
82.00% 83.00%
95.00%
54.50%
74.00%
67.00%
47.00%
53.00%
65.00%
30.00%
33.00%
55.00%
83.00%85.00%
75.00%
89.00%
73.00%
55.00%
80.00%
84.00%
x
Access to newmarkets andcustomers
Access to newtechnologies andproducts
Debt and risk obankruptcy
Raw materials andcost pressures
Labor costpressures
Pension andhealth costpressures
Potential orproduct synergies
2009 2008 2007 X No data or 2007
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
20 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
Debt and technology needs will drive M&A
Companies believe that a rising rate o
M&A will be driven partly by crisis actors,
and partly by the long-term imperative o
nding and developing new technology
solutions or a changing market (the
continued high stress that companies
place upon new technology development
is explored urther in chapter 6 o
this survey). So both debt and new
technologies rise in companies ratings
o the drivers o M&A, while access to
raw materials is seen as less important
against a background o alling raw material
prices during 2009. Pension and labor
costs all urther rom an already low
position in companies ratings o
M&A drivers.
What will drive M&A over the next fve years?
Indebtedness now seen as top driver o M&A
All cost pressures now seen as less signicant
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
23/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
ity to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
Access to newtechnologies
Access to newmarkets
Raw materialscost pressure
Product synergies
Americas Europe, Middle East and Arica (EMEA) Asia Pacic (ASPAC)
KPMG International provides no client services. No
nor does KPMG International have any such author
21The perormance angle
90.00%88.46%
72.58%
95.00%
83.33%
67.74%
51.67%
47.44%
66.13%
83.33%
87.18%
77.42%
* The our largest regionaldisparities shown
What will drive M&A over the next fve years roma regional perspective?*
Americas and EMEA level o global consensus
on M&A drivers is high
Americas companies more concerned with market access
ASPAC more concerned with raw materials cost pressure
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
24/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member frms o the KPMG network o independent frms are afliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member frm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member frm vis- -vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member frm. All rights reserved.
22 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
When asked about their long-range Cost reduction has moved slightly lower But there are dierences ASPAC
priorities, automotive companies have while environmental concerns continue companies are markedly more concerned
consistently told KPMGs Global Auto to rise higher on the corporate agenda. than others with managing labor, and
Executive Survey that their highest-ranking Managing labor relations remains a low markedly more concerned with product
concerns are with new technology and new priority. quality (the proportion o ASPAC
products. That remained the case in the companies rating it very important
current survey: both new products and new Regional results show very similar as against moderately important is
technologies have moved higher in the patterns, suggesting as in earlier surveys high). ASPAC companies are also more
ranking o concerns rom an already high that the broad shape o priorities remains concerned with pricing, while companies
leading position in last years survey. the same in all regions o the world: auto in the Americas and in Europe preer tocompanies tend to take a global view. prioritize total aordability.
Chapter 6: Product innovation and consumer change
81.0
0%
79.0
0%8
4.5
0%
85.0
0%
82.0
0%
83.0
0%
80.5
0%
85.0
0%
86.0
0%
63.0
0%
64.0
0%
72.0
0%
65.0
0%
62.0
0%
90.0
0% 9
6.0
0%
x
64.0
0%
72.0
0%
49.50%
49.50%
59.0
0%
74.5
0%
69.0
0%
Developingnew products
Developing newtechnologies
Reducingcosts
Meetingenvironmentaldemands
Pricing andsales incentives
Improvingproduct quality
Improving totalaffordability
Managing laborrelations
* Percentage o companies rating
issues as important
How important today are the following issues to the global auto industry?*
Companies are shiting ocus rom quality improvement to new products
Total aordability and pricing seen as less important than innovation
2009 2008 2007 X No data or 2007
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
25/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
Extremely Somewhat
EMEA
Americas
ASPA
CEM
EA
Americas
ASPA
C
EMEA
Americas
ASPA
C
EMEA
America
s
ASPA
C
28.33%
15.00%
26.92%
10.26%
30.65%
25.81%
45.00%
28.33%
39.74%
24.36%
43.55%
11.29%
26.67%
30.00%
33.33%
32.05%
38.71%
30.65%
36.67%
28.33%
30.77%
17.95%
32.26%
43.55%
Managing laborrelations
Improving totalaordability
Pricing and salesincentives
Improving productquality
KPMG International provides no client services. No
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
23Product innovation and consumer change
* The our largest regionaldisparities shown
How important today are the ollowingissues to the global auto industry?*
Asian companies least concerned with total aordability,
most concerned with quality
EMEA companies give low rating to quality improvement
Aordability a leading issue or companies in the Americas
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
26/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member frms o the KPMG network o independent frms are afliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member frm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member frm vis- -vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member frm. All rights reserved.
24 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
Fuel efciency and environment top o consumer concerns
In qualitative interviews which accompanied In the current survey uel efciency and the inclined to rate consumer preerences as
the preparation o the current survey, environmental profle o products continue very important than are companies in
companies repeatedly stated that they to be considered by companies the most other regions. The relatively low priority
believe that adaptation to changing signifcant consumer buying issues. But ascribed to telematics is consistent with
consumer demand will be an important on a regional basis it is clear that consumer results last year globally, telematics
key to survival in the coming fve years. concerns are believed to dier: the high received the highest number o not
The survey questions on drivers o rating accorded to saety is due to ASPAC important scores. Overall, the efciency
consumer buying give an insight into companies citing this issue and on o vehicles is believed to dominate
just how companies will do that. all issues ASPAC companies are more consumer concerns.
50.00%
72.00%70.00%
75.00%
84.00%
96.00%
80.50%
71.00%
93.50%
Fuel efciency Environmentalriendliness
Saety innovation
* Percentage o companies rating issues as
important (the top three issues shown)
How important are these product issues to consumerpurchase decisions over the next fve years?*
Fuel efciency top concern over last three years
Companies think consumer concerns on
environment continue to rise
2009 2008 2007
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
27/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
58.9
8%
67.7
5%
56.6
7%
70.0
0%
65.3
9%
79.0
3%
76.6
7%
80.7
7%
83.8
7%
50.0
0%
44.8
7%
74.1
9%
95.0
0%
92.3
1%
93.5
5%
45.0
0%
35.9
0%
50.0
0%
40.0
0%
33.3
3%
56.4
5%
Saety innovation Vehicle stylingTelematics/personal assistanceservices
Enhanced vehicleliespan
Fuel efciencyErgonomicsand comort
Environmentalriendliness
Americas Europe, Middle East and Arica (EMEA) Asia Pacic (ASPAC)
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
25Product innovation and consumer change
* Percentage o companies ratingissues as important
How important are these product issues to consumer purchase decisions over the next fve years?*
Asian companies now rate styling, comort and saety signicantly higher than others
Asian companies also most likely to rate environment as top consumer concern
Fuel eciency or all regions most important
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
28/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
Chi
nese
brand
s
5.00%
13.00%
78.50%
Hyu
ndai/Kia
10.50%
13.00%
73.50%
Indian
brand
s
9.50%
14.50%
72.50%
Toyo
ta
11.00%
30.50%
57.00%
Fiat
25.00%
32.50%
40.50%
Renault
/Niss
an
15.00%
49.00%
34.50%
BMW
11.50%
56.50%
30.50%
Ford
26.00%
44.00%
29.00%
Mercedes
15.00%
57.00%
26.50%
Russianbrands
35.00%
38.00%
20.50%
Peugeot/Citroen
27.50%
53.50%
17.50%
Subaru/Fuji
31.50%
45.50%
16.00%
Mitsubishi
42.50%
37.50%
16.00%
GeneralMotors
68.00%
17.50%
13.00%
Chrysler
72.50%
18.00%
7.50%
Honda
10.00%
51.50%
36.50%
Volkswagen
6.50%
22.50%
70.00%
Increase Stay the same Decrease
26 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
Low-cost producers to win most market share
Company expectations o market
share gain and loss have changed in
signicant ways. Chinese and Indian
brands remain in the top three places in
terms o expectation o market share
gain, but conviction is slightly lower
than in last years survey. Both Toyota
and Honda are expected to win market
share at a lower rate than in previous
years, and there has been a all inexpectation or Russian brands. Overall
we note that the top six rated companies
have either very strong cost or product
advantages, or both.
Two signicant winners emerge
in year-on-year comparisons:
Hyundai/Kia is one a result that may
refect the success o Korean automakers
in proting rom government sales
subsidies during 2009 and VW is the
second. Market share gain expectations
or the big three US makers remain low
and Chrysler has allen urther, although
Fiat, now the key actor in Chryslersimmediate uture, is rated higher in terms
o market share prospects than in the
previous year.
Both Mercedes and BMW are also seen
as better placed to win market share, both
companies having deed expectations o
a collapse o premium vehicle sales.
How will market share by company change in the next fve years?
Low cost makers in top three places
Toyota and Honda all in ratings or rst time in three years
VW seen as strongest European OEM, Ford as strongest US OEM
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
29/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
8.33%
AmericasBest Worst
EMEABest Worst
ASPACBest Worst
Increase Stay the same Decrease
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
Expectations o the perormance o sales
by vehicle type show a remarkable degree
o consensus: companies in all three
global regions cite exactly the same three
vehicle types as top perormers (hybrids,
other alternative uel vehicles and low-cost
introduction cars). Expectations o declining
sales perormance are perhaps not
surprisingly ocused on larger and more
inecient vehicles, although it is notablethat companies in the Americas do not cite
luxury vehicles in their bottom three.
Hyb
ridfuelveh
icle
s
Oth
eralte
rnativ
efu
elvehicle
s
Low
-costi
ntrod
uctio
ncars
91.94%
4.84%
3.23%1.61%
17.74%
79.03% 80.65%
14.52%
3.23%
Luxu
ryvehicles
Smallp
icku
ps
Largepick
ups
32.26% 32.26% 24.19%
27.42%
48.39%
SUVs
Luxu
ryveh
icles
Larg
epi
ckups
62.82%
12.82%
24.36%
30.77%
44.87%
35.90%60.00%
19. 23% 19. 23%
Hybr
idfu
elveh
icles
Oth
eralte
rnativefu
elveh
icles
Low
-cos
tintrod
uctio
nca
rs
7.69%
91.03%
1.28% 1.28%
16.67%
82.05%
5.13%
12.82%
80.77%
SUVs
Min
ivans
Larg
epi
ckups
23.33%
68.33% 60. 00%
23.33%
16.67%16.75%
38.33%
45.00%
Hybr
idfu
elveh
icles
Oth
eralte
rnativefu
elveh
icles
Low
-cos
tintrod
uctio
nca
rs
95.00%
88.33%
10.00%
1.67%3.33%
10.00%
85.00%
5.00%
22.58%
29.03%
37.10%45.16%
* Regional best and worst perormers
How will sales by vehicle type change in the next fve years?*
Hybrids, alternative uel and low cost vehicles lead in all regions
Inecient vehicles to lose most sales
27Product innovation and consumer change
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
30/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
63.3
4%
61.5
4%
64.5
2%
68.3
4%
67.9
5%
67.7
4%
41.6
6%
20.5
1%
40.3
3% 4
6.6
7%
34.6
2%
46.7
8%
20.0
0%
34.6
1%
61.2
9%
85.0
0%
85.9
0%
82.2
6%
23.0
7%
41.9
4%
18.3
4%
Fuel-cell electricpower
Battery electricpower
Ethanol Biodiesel LPG/LNG Hybrid uelsystems
Solar power
Americas Europe, Middle East and Arica (EMEA) Asia Pacic (ASPAC)
28 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
Hybrid technology rated clear leader
The primary importance that companies
ascribe to vehicle eciency and the
urther development o alternative
propulsion technologies is already
apparent rom earlier questions in the
current survey, as well as rom the
growing emphasis on these developments
in year-on-year responses despite
relatively low sales (see next page).
Electric power ranks only just behindhybrid power developments in the current
survey responses, and battery and
uel-cell approaches are ascribed almost
equal priority. Regional views o other
alternatives are clearly infuenced by
regional issues, particularly the extent o
installed uel inrastructure; accordingly,
ethanol is rated low priority by EMEA
companies, while LPG is considered
considerably less important in the
Americas than elsewhere.
*Percentage o companies ratingtechnologies as important
How important are these alternative uel technologies over the next fve years?*
Strong global consensus on importance o hybrids and electric technologies
ASPAC companies rate solar power much higher than other regions
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
31/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
1.5 million Dont know
2.5 million Dont know
1.28%
6.67%
10.00%
13.33%
55.00%
11.50%
7.69%
7.69%
39.74%
17.95%
25.64%
16.13%
1.61%
38.71%
24.19%
19.35%
Americas EMEA ASPAC
37.10%
1.61%
19.34%
17.74%
24.19%1.67%10.00%
43.33%
28.33%
16.67%
10.26%
8.97%
38.46%
12.82%
29.49%
Americas EMEA ASPAC
*2008 sales approximately 780,000
How many hybrid vehicles will be sold in 2010?*
*2008 sales approximately 1.5 million
How many alternative uel vehicles (not including hybrids) will be sold in 2010?*
29Product innovation and consumer change
. .
.
, ,
. . .
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
32/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
Executive view: large Tier 1 supplier US
This large US supplier believes thatthe industry has made progressin 2009, but that more needs tobe done.
I am a little bit more optimistic than I was a
year ago, but there are a lot o uncertainties.
The US is only going to sell around 10 million
cars this year. Whether the recovery weve
seen during the second hal o the year
is sustainable in 2010 is uncertain:
the economy has not bottomed yet, and
unemployment is still rising. Elsewhere,
China is still growing, although that bubblemay burst. India still has huge potential,
although whether consumers have the
money to buy cars in volume we dont yet
know. And Europe I think may have a more
dicult time next year than this, once the
ending o the government incentive
schemes hits home. But South America
will grow, and especially Brazil will grow.
My sense is that in the US people still do
not understand how things are changing.
The automakers are very busy developing
smaller cars, but whether they are goingto sell them to the US consumer is another
matter: the mindset is not there, not yet.
We are working with a number o
companies on electric cars, hybrid-cars
and super-economical vehicles. I think the
pure electric car as a mass-market product
is ten years away at least. For now, plug-in
hybrids have more potential. But in both
cases the economics o the vehicles are
unavorable. For example, we are working
on a small electric vehicle, but it will still
have to cost around $40,000 thats an
expensive car. Even with hybrids, i youdo the math then they dont really make
sense. People dont buy them or economic
reasons, because as things stand you will
never get your money back in uel savings.
It is hard to see that as a mass market
proposition.
Overall the industry still needs to cut
capacity. It is much easier to cut capacity
in the US than it is in Europe, and that is
one reason why the big three have all cut
capacity in the US. That is something they
still have to do in Europe. The carmakers
will all need to continue moving European
production to the East to cut costs, and
they will need to cut their production in
Western Europe because there just wontbe the sales or those plants.
I think the biggest winner over the last
year has been General Motors. And it has
a pretty good model line-up now. As or
the others, Ford has had to borrow money
and that has damaged their nances.
Chrysler still has to be turned around, and
its an open question whether Fiat can
achieve that. I think European makers will
suer unless they can nd more ways to
cut costs. Even Toyota has seen a all in
US market share or the rst time. Almosteveryone has suered in some way.
For the US the question is all about demand.
The potential or selling 16 or 17 million
cars a year is there the demographics
are there. The only question is, will people
have the money to buy those cars? I dont
know the answer to that.
30 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
33/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.
25.97%
85.71%
93.51%
55.84%
45.00%
93.00% 93.00%
49.00%
53.00%
44.16%
New plants New models/products
Newtechnologies
Marketing andadvertising
Logistics/distribution
2009 2008
KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
31Product innovation and consumer change
R&D will win most investment
When companies were asked where they
would direct investment capital, while new
technology and new model development
remained top priorities, companies also
said they would spend more on marketing
but less on logistics and much less on
new plants. The pattern o investment
intentions or suppliers remains the same
as in last years survey, but or suppliers
too the reduction in expectation o newplant building is striking. Tier 2 suppliers
are expected to show a higher propensity
to invest, refecting the concern o many
Tier 2 suppliers (supported by the results
on protability earlier in this survey) that
they need to invest to raise protability.
The responses on dealer investment
represent the views o manuacturers on
dealer businesses (dealers themselves
were not participants in the survey).
Companies believed that ASPAC dealerswill have a higher propensity to invest,
and believed that domestic and cross-
border dealer expansion will be muted,
especially in the Americas and in EMEA.
We also note companies expectation o
signicant IT and training investment in
the dealer industry; this reinorces results
rom KPMGs study o the global dealer
industry published in early 2009, which
ound that dealers themselves believe
that the industry suers rom an IT and
training decit.
* Positive responses rommanuacturers only
Do you expect manuacturers to increase their investmentover the next two years?*
Investment growth expectations o OEMs all slightly
year-on-year
Expectations o investment growth in innovation
remain high
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
34/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -vis third parties,
59.00%
93.00%93.00%
57.00%
88.00%91.00%
62.00%
59.00%
70.00%
64.00%
30.43%
95.65%100.00%
89.00% 91.00%
82.61%
64.00%
47.83%
44.00%
32.00%
Tier
2supplie
r
Tier
1supplie
r
Tier
2supplie
r
Tier
1supplie
r
Tier
2supplie
r
Tier
1supplie
r
Tier
2supplie
r
Tier
1supplie
r
Tier
2supplie
r
Tier
1supplie
r
Tier
2supplie
r
Tier
1supplie
r
Tier
2supplie
r
Tier
1supplie
r
Tier
2supplie
r
Tier
1supplie
r
Tier
2supplie
r
Tier
1supplie
r
Tier
2supplie
r
Tier
1supplie
r
New plants New models/products
Newtechnologies
Marketing andadvertising
Logistics/distribution
2009 2008
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
32 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
* Positive responses rom suppliers only. 2008 results includesome responses rom Tier 3 suppliers
Do you expect suppliers to increase their investment over the next two years?*
Supplier expectations o innovation investment have grown
Investment growth in new plants to all by almost hal
Tier 2 suppliers expect to increase investments in marketing and advertising
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
35/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
Americas
America
s
31.67%
66.67%
60.00%
38.33%
EMEA EM
EA
38.46%
53.85%
35.90%
51.28%
47.44%
46.15%
ASPA
CASPA
C
Americas
EMEA
ASPA
CAm
erica
s
EMEA
ASPA
C
43.55%
46.77%
72.58%
22.58%
77.42%
25.00%
Domestic expansionand acquisitions
Cross-border expansionand acquisitions
IT systems andcommunication
HR training
Yes
33Product innovation and consumer change
* Results rom manuacturers and suppliers
Do you expect dealers to increase their investment over the next two years?*
ASPAC companies see HR decit as signicant dealer issue
All regions expect dealers to improve IT
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
36/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative G International.. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMy authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -v
6.50%
3.00%
10.00%
1.00%
73.50%
2.50%2.50%
1.00%
North America (US & Canada)
Western Europe
Japan
Eastern Europe and Russia
Asia (excluding Japan)
Central & South America
Middle East & Arica
Dont know
Over the next fve years whichregion o the world or country doyou think will build the mostmanuacturing capacity?
KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has an is third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
34 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
Chapter 7: Investing in new markets
Companies are nearly unanimous in
expecting emerging markets to build most
automotive capacity and to provide the
most growth in automotive revenues. The
majority o companies say they intend to
increase their investments in the BRICs
(Brazil, Russia, India and China).
O companies with existing investments in
the BRICs, most say they will increase thevalue o those investments (the number o
companies with existing investments that
say they have no plans to change their level
o investment is negligible). Those results
refect companies revenue expectations:
the strongest expectations are or revenues
rom China although a very small minority
o companies envisage revenue decline in
China. In India many more companies see
moderate growth than see strong growth,
although no companies at all envisage
revenue alls. Moderate rather than strong
growth is also the majority expectation or
Brazil. Russia is the outlier while morethan hal o all investors have expectations
o moderate or strong growth, a signicant
minority now anticipate a all in revenues
over ve years.
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
37/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.
Strong improvement Moderate improvement
Neutral/stable Moderate decline
Dont know
Rus
sia
Brazil
India
Chi
na
2.38%
15.48%
41.67%
25.00%
15.48%
3.41%1.14%
53.41%
29.55%
12.50%
29.81%
53.85%
16.35%
2.82%
42.25%
46.48%
7.75%
0.70%
KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis--vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
35Investing in new markets
0.50%
2.00%
Rus
sia
Chi
na
India
Brazil
58.50%
26.00%
43.00%
35.00%
2.00%
Increase Decrease
Do you plan to increase ordecrease your investmentin the BRICs?
Existing BRIC investors will increase
exposure
Reduction o investment negligible
What are your revenue orecasts or theBRICs?
India and China seen as biggest growth markets
Signicant minority see Russian decline
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
38/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
Executive view: diversied supplier emerging market
This India-ocused supplier, parto a group with sales o over hala billion US dollars and over 6,000employees, says that automotivedemand in emerging markets isset to grow at breakneck speed.
I am almost 100 percent more condent
than I was at this time last year, and I am
especially condent about the Indian market.
The crisis certainly had a very negative
eect on many o our customers. We saw
the worst eects in the commercial
vehicle market. Vehicle usage was down,
demand or new vehicles was down, and
it was very dicult or companies tonance new purchases. Private passenger
car demand held up better: personal
nances were more resilient than
company nances.
We have cut output, but we did that by
reducing stang, a cut o somewhere
between 20-30 percent. We have not
closed any acilities. And in the last
quarter o 2009 we stopped cutting
manpower. It is quite likely that by the end
o the rst quarter o 2010 all those job
cuts will be reversed.
We have also cut costs by reducing the
number o processes we outsource,
things like powder coating and machining.
Our strategy has been to increase the
amount o value we add in-house.
As we go into 2010 I can see a lot o M&A
opportunities. Many companies outside
o Asia are not in good shape, and we may
be able to buy them cheaply. The limiting
actor is nancing: banks have cut lending,
and we will have to rely on internal sources
o capital.
We would look or market share and or
technology. In commercial vehicles, orexample, we have the market share, but
we are concerned that we dont have
uture technology. For passenger cars
we need market share.
For the next ve years our biggest
challenges are going to be dealing with
a growing market. We have two or three
main competitors in India, and we need
to maintain market share as the market
grows. A key will be winning business
rom the worlds main OEMs as they
invest more in India.
36 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
39/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member frms o the KPMG network o independent frms are afliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member frm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member frm vis--vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member frm. All rights reserved.
37Investing in new markets
BRIC sales orecasts continue to grow
In previous editions o this survey,
companies were asked to give specifc
orecasts o domestic unit sales growth
ranges and export sales in China in fve
years time: the current survey extended
these questions to all o the BRIC markets.
Expectations or both domestic and export
Chinese sales have increased. There has
been an increase in expectation or the higherranges o domestic sales to be achieved by
2014, except in the extreme high range o
18 million plus: we believe this indicates both
a growth in optimism on and knowledge o
the Chinese market on the part o companies.
The proportion o companies expecting
export sales to pass one million within fve
years has also increased dramatically..
71.10%
28.90%
82.00%
18.00%
2009 2008
42.25%
10.56%
1.41%
20.42%
13.38%
9.15%
30.00%
10.00% 10.00%
20.00%
10.00%
20.00%
18 million16-18 million14-16 million12-14 mill ion10-12 million
*2008 sales approximately 9.4 million cars and commercial vehicles
What do you estimate will be the annual volume o unit sales in China by 2014?*
2009 2008
When will China sell a signifcant number (1 million+ a year)o cars in other markets?
Expectations o Chinese exports improve ater alling last year
Within 5 years Beyond 5 years
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
40/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
9.09%
36.36%
47.73%
4.55%
25.96%
11.54%
47.12%
15.38%
3-4 million 4-5 million
5-6 million >6 million2-3 million 3-4 million
4-5 million >5 million
*2008 sales approximately 3.2 million cars and commercial vehicles*2008 sales approximately 2.3 million cars and commercial vehicles
What do you estimate will be the annualvolume o unit sales in India in 2014?*
What do you estimate will be the annualvolume o unit sales in Brazil in 2014?*
38 KPMG Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
The consensus views o companies on
sales in Brazil, India and Russia are also
strikingly strong. Expectations o sales
volumes in India are equivalent to a
consensus that growth o 17 percent will
be achieved annually. The consensus is or
growth o around 30 percent over ve
years in Brazil, and o around 40 percent
over ve years in Russia (although it should
be noted that a signicant minority thinkRussian sales will be fat or even all).
It should also be noted that investment
intentions noted elsewhere in this
survey or India in particular do not seem
commensurate with sales expectations,
suggesting that companies may be
expecting to sell in India a signicant
proportion o vehicles manuactured
elsewhere.
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
41/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member frms o the KPMG network o independent frms are afliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member frm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member frm vis--vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member frm. All rights reserved.
39Investing in new markets
42.86%
7.14%
32.14%
15.47%
2-3 million 3-4 million
4-5 million >5 millionWithin 5 years Beyond 5 years
India
47.12%
52.88%
Brazil
54.55%
45.45%
Russia
63.10%
36.90%
*2008 sales approximately 2.8 million cars and commercial vehicles
What do you estimate will be the annualvolume o unit sales in Russia in 2014?*
When will Brazil, Russia and Indiasell a signifcant number (1 million +a year) o cars in other markets?
Expectations or the achievement o
export sales o over one million rank in
order India, Brazil and Russia. Over 50
percent o companies think that level will
be achieved by India within fve years, and
over 45 percent o companies think it will
be achieved by Brazil within the fve-year
horizon. However companies do not
believe that Russia is in that league:
almost two thirds o companies believe
Russia will not sell more than one million
cars outside its borders within fve years.
-
8/9/2019 Global Auto Executive Survey 2010
42/44
2010 KPMG International. KPMG International is a Swiss cooperative. Member rms o the KPMG network o independent rms are aliated with KPMG International.KPMG International provides no client services. No member rm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG International or any other member rm vis- -vis third parties,
nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member rm. All rights reserved.
Eastern Europe including Ukraine Central and South America including Mexico Middle East including North Arica
Arica excluding North Arica Southeast Asia
35.00%
23.33%
6.67%
35.00%
39.74%
41.03%
10.26%
6.41%
22.58%