georgian pingbacks: mapping attribution networks in a 19th-century newspaper corpus 

17
GEORGIAN PINGBACKS MAPPING ATTRIBUTION NETWORKS IN A 19TH CENTURY NEWSPAPER CORPUS HTTP://TINYURL.COM/MHBEALSESSHC2016 M. H. BEALS ORCID: 0000-0002-2907-3313 LOUGHBOROUGH UNIVERSITY @MHBEALS

Upload: m-h-beals

Post on 12-Apr-2017

267 views

Category:

Education


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

GEORGIAN PINGBACKSMAPPING ATTRIBUTION NETWORKS IN A 19TH CENTURY NEWSPAPER CORPUS

HTTP://TINYURL.COM/MHBEALSESSHC2016

M. H. BEALSORCID: 0000-0002-2907-3313LOUGHBOROUGH UNIVERSITY

@MHBEALS

Page 2: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

SCISSORS-AND-PASTE JOURNALISM

A longstanding practice wherein one newspaper reprints, in part of in whole, content from another newspaper, with or without attribution, as part of an explicit or implied reciprocity agreement.

Page 3: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

PLAGIARISM OR DISTRIBUTION

Lou Bloomfield, Copyfind (version 4.1.4). Windows. Charlottesville, Va., 2016.

Page 4: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

PLAGIARISM OR DISTRIBUTION

Undirected Network of Newspaper Reprints, 1818-1819. Gephi Consortium, Gephi (version 0.9.1 ). Windows. 2016.

Page 5: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

PLAGIARISM OR DISTRIBUTION

M. H. Beals and John Wood, Reprint Mapper  (version 0.0.4). Windows. Loughborough, UK, 2016.

while (Data >> PM >> OL >> OR >> A_Year >> A_Month >> A_Day >> A_Newspaper >> UI_A >> B_Year >> B_Month >> B_Day >> B_Newspaper >> UI_B)

{++NumLines;if (A_Newspaper == B_Newspaper){}else if (OR <= OR_Tolerance && OL <= OL_Tolerance && OR + OL <=

PM_Tolerance){}else if (A_Year > B_Year){

if (A_Year - B_Year == 1){

int A_Days = MonthToDays(A_Month, IsLeap(A_Year)) + A_Day;

bool bIsLeapYear = IsLeap(B_Year);int B_Days = MonthToDays(B_Month,

bIsLeapYear) + B_Day;if (bIsLeapYear)

B_Days = 366 - B_Days;else

B_Days = 365 - B_Days;if (A_Days + B_Days <=

MaxDaysBetween){

{Comparisons.push_back(Comp);

Comparisons[i].PM = PM;

Comparisons[i].OL = OL;

Comparisons[i].OR = OR;

Comparisons[i].bIsOriginal = false;Comparisons[i].A.UI =

UI_A;

Comparisons[i].A.Newspaper = A_Newspaper;Comparisons[i].A.Year

= A_Year;

Comparisons[i].A.Month = A_Month;Comparisons[i].A.Day =

A_Day;Comparisons[i].B.UI =

UI_B;

Comparisons[i].B.Newspaper = B_Newspaper;Comparisons[i].B.Year =

B_Year;

Comparisons[i].B.Month = B_Month;Comparisons[i].B.Day =

B_Day;++i;bUI_A_Done = false;bUI_B_Done = false;for (unsigned int it = 0;

it != size(UniqueArticle); ++it){

if (UniqueArticle[it].UID == UI_A)

bUI_A_Done = true;if

(UniqueArticle[it].UID == UI_B)

bUI_B_Done = true;}

Page 6: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

PLAGIARISM OR DISTRIBUTION

Page 7: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

UNAUTHORISED AND UNATTRIBUTED TEXTS

Directed Network of Newspaper Reprints, 1818-1819. Gephi Consortium, Gephi (version 0.9.1 ). Windows. 2016.

Page 8: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

IDENTIFYING ATTRIBUTION

Page 9: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

GEORGIAN PINGBACKS PROJECT

Particular thanks to the following undergraduate students at Loughborough University: Will Dickinson, Alice Gilbert, Ollie Luhrs, Alex Mackinder, Pooja Makwana, Matthew McCulloch, Jonny Ord, Emily Stanyard and Rebecca

Thompson.

Page 10: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

GEORGIAN PINGBACKS PROJECT

Page 11: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

GEORGIAN PINGBACKS PROJECT

Page 12: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

GEORGIAN PINGBACKS PROJECT

Page 13: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

PRELIMINARY RESULTS

The Ipswich Journal of 1820. David Huynh, Open Refine (version 2.6-beta.1 ). 2015.

Page 14: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

PRELIMINARY RESULTS

Ipswich; 36

London; 27

Calais; 3

Cambridge; 3

Hanover; 3

Barking; 2

Dublin; 2Eye; 2

Wisbech; 2Woodbridge; 2

Barking Hall; 1Bayonne; 1 Burking Hall; 1 Colchester; 1 Norwich; 1 Seme; 1 Smithfield Market; 1 Southwark; 1 Thoroughfare; 1

Page 15: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

PRELIMINARY RESULTSForeign Office; 1

Hampshire Telegraph; 3

London Gazette; 5

Newry Telegraph; 1

The Bury Post; 1

Page 16: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

THE ETHICS OF REPRINTING

The Sydney Gazette, 2 January 1819, p. 2

Page 17: Georgian Pingbacks: Mapping Attribution Networks in a 19th-Century Newspaper Corpus 

WOULD YOU LIKE TO KNOW MORE?These Slides

http://tinyurl.com/mhbealsesshc2016

Georgian Pingbacks Project: http://www.scissorsandpaste.net/Georgian_Pingbacks

Scissors and Paste Projecthttp://www.github.com/mhbeals/scissorsandpaste

M. H. [email protected] @mhbeals∙