genetic progression and clonal relationship of recurrent ... · tic and neoplastic lesions from...

7
Advances in Brief Genetic Progression and Clonal Relationship of Recurrent Premalignant Head and Neck Lesions Joseph Califano, William H. Westra, Glenn Meininger, Russel Corio, Wayne M. Koch, and David Sidransky 1 Departments of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery [J. C., W. H. W., G. M., W. K., D. S.] and Pathology [W. H. W., R. C.], Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, Maryland 21204 Abstract We constructed a preliminary genetic progression model for head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSC) based on the frequency of genetic alterations in preneoplas- tic and neoplastic lesions from single biopsy specimens. To firmly establish the temporal order of established genetic events in HNSC, we sampled serial biopsies from five pa- tients with recurrent premalignant lesions at a single ana- tomic site over a period of time (1 month to 144 months). These lesions were examined by microsatellite analysis of the minimal regions of loss on the 10 most frequently lost chro- mosomal arms in HNSC. Each set of serial biopsies from all five patients demonstrated LOH (loss of heterozygosity) of identical alleles at multiple loci with identical boundaries between areas of LOH and retention of heterozygosity, in- dicating a common clonal origin for each set. Three patients demonstrated genetic progression (new regions of LOH) over time correlating with histopathological progression, one patient demonstrated lack of genetic progression asso- ciated with unchanged histopathological morphology, and one patient demonstrated histopathological progression without detection of a corresponding genetic progression event. For one of these patients with a laryngeal tumor, at least four separate steps in progression to malignancy could be determined, accompanied by spatial expansion of an increasingly altered clonal population from the ipsilateral to the contralateral side, ultimately resulting in a malignancy. Microsatellite-based genetic analysis of recurrent premalig- nant lesions indicates that these lesions arise from a common clonal progenitor, followed by outgrowth of clonal popula- tions associated with progressive genetic alterations and phenotypic progression to malignancy. Introduction It is now generally accepted that most sporadic solid tu- mors arise from a multistep process of accumulated genetic alterations. A colorectal cancer model for the initiation and progession of malignancy has become a paradigm for other human solid tumors.(1) Like colorectal cancer, HNSC 2 is thought to progress through a series of well-defined clinical and histopathological stages. Recently, we described a preliminary genetic progression model for HNSC (2). This model is based on genetic alterations present in premalignant head and neck lesions and genetic progression found in adjacent, clonally re- lated, but histopathologically distinct, areas within biopsy spec- imens. These studies have demonstrated that genetic progression of HNSC correlates with histopathological phenotype among a series of patients and between adjacent histopathologically dis- tinct areas in a single patient. However, demonstration of ge- netic progression over time has not been reported in HNSC. PCR based microsatellite marker analysis enables a deter- mination of specific genetic changes that occur in lesions with diverse histopathology. This study correlates genetic changes and histopathological progression within recurrent premalignant and malignant head and neck lesions in individual patients. These results help to further establish the temporal order of genetic events in HNSC progression and provide insight into the underlying genetic changes and biological behavior that accom- pany clinical phenotypic progression. Materials and Methods Subject Selection Criteria. Subjects were selected on the basis of review of diagnoses of archival biopsy specimens from the Johns Hopkins Hospital Department of Pathology and review of the Johns Hopkins Head and Neck Tumor Registry. To be included, sequential biopsy specimens with a diagnosis of dysplasia or carcinoma in situ from the upper aerodigestive tract, with adequate tissue for analysis, were required. Selection of Loci for Microsatellite Analysis. Ten chro- mosomal arms were chosen for this analysis on the basis of the following criteria: (a) they identify a minimal area of loss at a putative tumor suppressor gene locus; (b) they identify a proto- oncogene amplicon detectable by microsatellite analysis; or (c) they have displayed a substantial proportion of LOH (.40%) in invasive lesions by allelotype analysis. The 9p21 chromosomal band contains the p16 (MTS1) gene, a cyclin/cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor involved in cell cycle regulation and corre- sponds to an area of genetic loss common to many solid tu- mors.(3, 4) At this time, this locus constitutes the region with the most frequent LOH in HNSC, and the p16 protein is not ex- pressed in .80% of HNSC.(5, 6) The chromosomal band 11q13 includes the bcl-1/int-2 locus, an amplicon carrying the proto- oncogene cyclin D 1 , one of the few proto-oncogenes implicated in HNSC (7). LOH in this region actually represents allelic imbalance via amplification of cyclin D 1 , as confirmed by studies using fluorescence in situ hybridization (8). The tumor Received 12/15/98; revised 2/11/99; accepted 2/12/99. The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked advertisement in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact. 1 To whom requests for reprints should be addressed, at Division of Head and Neck Cancer Research, Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Room 818, Ross Research Building, 720 Rutland Avenue, Baltimore, MD 21205. 2 The abbreviations used are: HNSC, head and neck squamous cell carcinoma; LOH, loss of heterozygosity; TVC, true vocal cord. 347 Vol. 6, 347–352, February 2000 Clinical Cancer Research Research. on February 11, 2021. © 2000 American Association for Cancer clincancerres.aacrjournals.org Downloaded from

Upload: others

Post on 03-Oct-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Genetic Progression and Clonal Relationship of Recurrent ... · tic and neoplastic lesions from single biopsy specimens. To firmly establish the temporal order of established genetic

Advances in Brief

Genetic Progression and Clonal Relationship of RecurrentPremalignant Head and Neck Lesions

Joseph Califano, William H. Westra,Glenn Meininger, Russel Corio, Wayne M. Koch,and David Sidransky1

Departments of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery [J. C.,W. H. W., G. M., W. K., D. S.] and Pathology [W. H. W., R. C.],Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, Maryland 21204

AbstractWe constructed a preliminary genetic progression

model for head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSC)based on the frequency of genetic alterations in preneoplas-tic and neoplastic lesions from single biopsy specimens. Tofirmly establish the temporal order of established geneticevents in HNSC, we sampled serial biopsies from five pa-tients with recurrent premalignant lesions at a single ana-tomic site over a period of time (1 month to 144 months).These lesions were examined by microsatellite analysis of theminimal regions of loss on the 10 most frequently lost chro-mosomal arms in HNSC. Each set of serial biopsies from allfive patients demonstrated LOH (loss of heterozygosity) ofidentical alleles at multiple loci with identical boundariesbetween areas of LOH and retention of heterozygosity, in-dicating a common clonal origin for each set. Three patientsdemonstrated genetic progression (new regions of LOH)over time correlating with histopathological progression,one patient demonstrated lack of genetic progression asso-ciated with unchanged histopathological morphology, andone patient demonstrated histopathological progressionwithout detection of a corresponding genetic progressionevent. For one of these patients with a laryngeal tumor, atleast four separate steps in progression to malignancy couldbe determined, accompanied by spatial expansion of anincreasingly altered clonal population from the ipsilateral tothe contralateral side, ultimately resulting in a malignancy.Microsatellite-based genetic analysis of recurrent premalig-nant lesions indicates that these lesions arise from a commonclonal progenitor, followed by outgrowth of clonal popula-tions associated with progressive genetic alterations andphenotypic progression to malignancy.

IntroductionIt is now generally accepted that most sporadic solid tu-

mors arise from a multistep process of accumulated geneticalterations. A colorectal cancer model for the initiation andprogession of malignancy has become a paradigm for otherhuman solid tumors.(1) Like colorectal cancer, HNSC2 isthought to progress through a series of well-defined clinical andhistopathological stages. Recently, we described a preliminarygenetic progression model for HNSC (2). This model is basedon genetic alterations present in premalignant head and necklesions and genetic progression found in adjacent, clonally re-lated, but histopathologically distinct, areas within biopsy spec-imens. These studies have demonstrated that genetic progressionof HNSC correlates with histopathological phenotype among aseries of patients and between adjacent histopathologically dis-tinct areas in a single patient. However, demonstration of ge-netic progression over time has not been reported in HNSC.

PCR based microsatellite marker analysis enables a deter-mination of specific genetic changes that occur in lesions withdiverse histopathology. This study correlates genetic changesand histopathological progression within recurrent premalignantand malignant head and neck lesions in individual patients.These results help to further establish the temporal order ofgenetic events in HNSC progression and provide insight into theunderlying genetic changes and biological behavior that accom-pany clinical phenotypic progression.

Materials and MethodsSubject Selection Criteria. Subjects were selected on

the basis of review of diagnoses of archival biopsy specimensfrom the Johns Hopkins Hospital Department of Pathology andreview of the Johns Hopkins Head and Neck Tumor Registry.To be included, sequential biopsy specimens with a diagnosis ofdysplasia or carcinomain situ from the upper aerodigestivetract, with adequate tissue for analysis, were required.

Selection of Loci for Microsatellite Analysis. Ten chro-mosomal arms were chosen for this analysis on the basis of thefollowing criteria: (a) they identify a minimal area of loss at aputative tumor suppressor gene locus; (b) they identify a proto-oncogene amplicon detectable by microsatellite analysis; or (c)they have displayed a substantial proportion of LOH (.40%) ininvasive lesions by allelotype analysis. The 9p21 chromosomalband contains thep16 (MTS1) gene, a cyclin/cyclin-dependentkinase inhibitor involved in cell cycle regulation and corre-sponds to an area of genetic loss common to many solid tu-mors.(3, 4) At this time, this locus constitutes the region with themost frequent LOH in HNSC, and the p16 protein is not ex-pressed in.80% of HNSC.(5, 6) The chromosomal band 11q13includes thebcl-1/int-2 locus, an amplicon carrying the proto-oncogenecyclin D1, one of the few proto-oncogenes implicatedin HNSC (7). LOH in this region actually represents allelicimbalance via amplification ofcyclin D1, as confirmed bystudies using fluorescencein situ hybridization (8). The tumor

Received 12/15/98; revised 2/11/99; accepted 2/12/99.The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by thepayment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby markedadvertisementin accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely toindicate this fact.1 To whom requests for reprints should be addressed, at Division ofHead and Neck Cancer Research, Department of Otolaryngology-Headand Neck Surgery, Room 818, Ross Research Building, 720 RutlandAvenue, Baltimore, MD 21205.2 The abbreviations used are: HNSC, head and neck squamous cellcarcinoma; LOH, loss of heterozygosity; TVC, true vocal cord.

347Vol. 6, 347–352, February 2000 Clinical Cancer Research

Research. on February 11, 2021. © 2000 American Association for Cancerclincancerres.aacrjournals.org Downloaded from

Page 2: Genetic Progression and Clonal Relationship of Recurrent ... · tic and neoplastic lesions from single biopsy specimens. To firmly establish the temporal order of established genetic

suppressor genep53 is commonly mutated in HNSC (9). Thep53 gene is found on chromosomal arm 17p13, which alsocorresponds to an area of frequent LOH in HNSC (5). Chromo-somal arm 3p has been shown to contain at least three putativeHNSCC tumor suppressor loci (10, 11). Chromosomal band

13q21 contains an area with frequent LOH near theRb locusthat is now thought to include a second, novel tumor suppressorgene locus (12). Chromosomes 6p and 8 contain loci thought tocontain putative tumor suppressor genes that have not beenprecisely mapped and are as yet unidentified but are included

Fig. 1 Allelograms of biopsy specimens from patients 1–4. Parta for patient 1 indicates biopsy of dysplastic lesion with negative histopathologicalmargins, and rebiopsy 1 year later (b) showed dysplastic epithelium. Identical boundaries between loss and retention are shown on chromosomal arm3p. Loss of identical alleles for loci demonstrating LOH were found and are shown. Patient 2 received an initial biopsy of carcinomain situ (a),demonstrating margins free of dysplastic epithelium. Subsequent biopsy 1 month later (b) showed epithelial dysplasia. Note identical pattern of allelicloss at three loci with identical boundaries between loss and retention on chromosomal arms 3p and 11q13 but additional loss at two loci (17p13 and13q21) in the earlier, higher grade lesion. Patient 3 also demonstrated an identical pattern of allelic loss at one locus, 9p21, with identical boundariesbetween loss and retention but additional loss at two loci (17p13 and 13 q21) in the earlier, higher grade lesion biopsied 1 year earlier. Patient 4 showsa matching pattern of LOH at five loci with an identical breakpoint at chromosomal arm 9p. Two additional loci, located at 8q and 13q21, displayadditional LOH in the biopsy taken 1 month later, indicating that additional genetic alterations have been acquired. Allelograms from patient 5 areprovided, with detailed explanation in the text.h, noninformative;o, retention;k, loss of top allele;q, loss of bottom allele;CIS, carcinomain situ;Dys, dysplasia.

348 Genetic Progression of Recurrent Head and Neck Lesions

Research. on February 11, 2021. © 2000 American Association for Cancerclincancerres.aacrjournals.org Downloaded from

Page 3: Genetic Progression and Clonal Relationship of Recurrent ... · tic and neoplastic lesions from single biopsy specimens. To firmly establish the temporal order of established genetic

because these chromosomal arms are lost in a high percentage ofpreinvasive and invasive lesions (2, 5). Microsatellite markersincluded in this study are:D3S1067, D3S1284, D3S1038,D3S1007 (chromosomal arm 3p),D6S265, TCTE, D6S105(chromosomal arm 6p),D8S261, D8S262, D8S257, D8S167,D8S273(chromosomal arm 8),IFN-a, D9S736, D9S171(chro-mosomal arm 9p21),D11S873, INT-2, PYGM(chromosomalarm 11q13),D13S170, D13S133(chromosomal arm 13q21),TP-53,andCHRNB-1(chromosomal arm 17p13).

Tissue and DNA Extraction. Tissue was obtained fromarchival, paraffin-embedded blocks from the Johns HopkinsHospital Department of Pathology or from freshly frozen tissue,obtained with consent from Johns Hopkins Hospital patients.Representative sections from tissue used for DNA extractionwere stained with H&E, and the diagnosis was confirmed foreach lesion by a pathologist (W. H. W.). Freshly frozen tissuefrom a biopsy specimen was meticulously dissected on a cryo-stat to ensure that the specimen contained at least 75% epithelialcells from the mucosal lesion. Areas of homogeneous his-topathological appearance were dissected separately if morethan one distinct area of histopathological alteration existed. Acontrol section was stained before microdissection and aftereach interval of 12 sections to ensure an adequate proportion ofepithelial cells from the mucosal lesion of interest. Approxi-mately 12–35 12-mm sections, depending on the adequacy of thespecimen, were then collected and placed in 1% SDS/proteinaseK (0.5 mg/ml) at 58°C for 24 h. Paraffin-embedded tissue fromdirected mucosal biopsies was sectioned into 25 14-mm sec-tions. Each individual section was placed on a glass slide andindividually microdissected using a dissecting microscope toobtain.75% epithelial cells. The samples were placed in xy-lene overnight to remove the paraffin, pelleted in 70% ethanol,dried, and incubated in SDS/proteinase K at 58°C for 72 h.

Fig. 2 Cartoons representing genetic changes present in epithelial bi-opsies fromR (right) and L (left) TVCs. A, initial biopsies wereperformed in year 1 and demonstrate LOH of 17p13 and 13q21 on theL TVC but only loss of 17p13 on the R TVC.B, biopsies in year 2 showadditional LOH on chromosomal arms 3p, 8, and 9p21 on the L TVC butno change on the R TVC.C, by year 4, the neoplastic clone on the LTVC has spread to the R TVC, showing the same genetic changes foundin the invasive cancer diagnosed in year 12.

Fig. 3 Autoradiograph of microsatellite markerD13S133. N, lympho-cyte DNA. The autoradiograph demonstrates loss of the top allele in thebiopsy specimen from the left TVC in year 1 (L1) but retention of thetop allele in the biopsy from the right TVC in the same year (R1).Identical LOH on both sides in year 4 (L4andR4) is seen, as is seen inthe tumor specimen from year 12 (T12).

349Clinical Cancer Research

Research. on February 11, 2021. © 2000 American Association for Cancerclincancerres.aacrjournals.org Downloaded from

Page 4: Genetic Progression and Clonal Relationship of Recurrent ... · tic and neoplastic lesions from single biopsy specimens. To firmly establish the temporal order of established genetic

Digested tissue from both sources was then subjected to phenol-chloroform extraction and ethanol precipitation as describedpreviously (12). Normal control DNA was obtained either by:(a) venipuncture and isolation of lymphocyte DNA as describedpreviously (12); (b) microdissection of nonepithelial normaltissue in the previously mentioned archival, paraffin-embeddedbiopsy specimens; or if necessary, (c) isolation of DNA fromnonepithelial, paraffin-embedded tissue from archival paraffinblocks other than the biopsy specimen blocks in the mannerdescribed above.

Microsatellite Analysis. Microsatellite markers suitablefor PCR analysis were obtained from Research Genetics. Priorto amplification, 50 ng of one primer from each pair were endlabeled with [g-32P]ATP (20 MCi; Amersham) and T4 kinase(New England Biolabs) in a total volume of 50ml. PCR reac-tions were carried out in a total volume of 12.5ml containing 10ng of genomic DNA, 0.2 ng of labeled primer, and 15 ng of eachunlabeled primer. The PCR buffer included 16.6 mM ammoniumsulfate, 67 mM Tris (pH 8.8), 6.7 mM magnesium chloride, 10mM b-mercaptoethanol, 1% DMSO to which were added 1.5mM deoxynucleotide triphosphates and 1.0 unit of Taq DNApolymerase (Boehringer Mannheim). PCR amplifications ofeach primer set were performed for 30–35 cycles consisting ofdenaturation at 95°C for 30 s, annnealing at 50–60°C for 60 s,and extension at 70°C for 60 s as described (12). One-third ofthe PCR product was separated on 8% urea-formamide-polyac-rylamide gels and exposed to film from 4 to 48 h as described.For informative cases, allelic loss (or allelic imbalance in thecase of the 11q13 locus) was scored if one allele was.40%decreased in tumor DNA when compared with the same allele innormal control DNA.

ResultsFour patients underwent repeat biopsies of persistent pre-

malignant lesions at an identical anatomic site, with time inter-vals between biopsies ranging from 1 to 12 months. One patientunderwent biopsies at six separate timepoints over a 12-yearperiod. All five patients demonstrated LOH of identical allelesat multiple loci with identical boundaries between areas of lossand retention (“breakpoints”) for each set of serial biopsies,indicating a common clonal origin for each set. Fig. 1 shows anallelogram of patient 1, who was biopsied for a leukoplakiclesion in the identical location in the floor of the mouth twiceover a 1-year interval. This allelogram shows an identical pat-tern of LOH at four separate chromosomal loci and an identicalboundary between areas of loss and retention on chromosomalarm 3p. The corresponding histopathological appearance ofmoderate dysplasia did not change during this time interval.Histopathological analysis of the first biopsy demonstrated nor-mal epithelium in all margins. Therefore, these results indicatethat the recurrent lesion arose from a subclinical persistence ofthe original population. If genetic progression occurred, it wasnot detected by histopathological examination or by analysis ofLOH.

Patient 2 was rebiopsied at the ventral tongue over a1-month interval for a leukoplakic lesion with some erythropla-sia. The initial lesion was diagnosed as a carcinomain situ, butthe second biopsy demonstrated moderate dysplasia. The corre-

sponding allelogram in Fig. 1 shows an identical pattern ofallelic loss at three loci with identical boundaries between lossand retention on chromosomal arm 3p and 11q13 but additionalloss at two loci (17p13 and 13q21) in the earlier, more aggres-sive lesion. Similarly, another patient (no. 3), initially biopsiedfor carcinomain situ in a leukoplakic lesion on the left lateraltongue, was rebiopsied 1 year later for a dysplastic lesion at thesame site. Once again, both lesions showed a common loss andidentical breakpoint at 9p21 but additional loss at 17p13 and13q21 in the initial biopsy. In each case, identical loss/retentionboundaries were identified, and the same alleles (either paternalor maternal) were lost, confirming the interpretation that thelesions are derived from the same progenitor clone. It is notablethat neither lesion from this patient or from the patient shown inFig. 1 displayed any evidence of dysplastic cells in the epithelialmargins of the initial biopsy of carcinomain situ. The subse-quent biopsy showed only dysplasia in both cases, and the moremalignant appearance of the earlier lesions corresponded withchromosomal loss at two additional loci. In both of these ex-amples, there is no known mechanism by which the cells in thelater lesions may have regained previously lost chromosomalfragments. Instead, it is likely that subsequent lesions representpersistence of a more benign subclone along the progressionpathway that was not excised during the initial biopsy but onethat shared identical, early genetic events with the initiallyexcised lesion. In addition, identical patterns of LOH wereobserved at 9p21, 3p, and 17p13 in these sequential biopsyspecimens, in agreement with their role as early, importantevents in tumor progression.

Another patient (no. 4) was rebiopsied over a 1-monthinterval for a leukoplakic lesion of the TVC, showing a match-ing pattern of loss at five loci with an identical breakpoint at 3pin lesions that were both diagnosed as dysplastic (Fig. 1).However, two loci, 8q and 13q21, displayed LOH in the secondbiopsy specimen, indicating that a subclone from a commonprogenitor cell developed additional genetic alterations and ac-quired a growth advantage, producing a persistent dysplasticlesion.

Finally, patient 5 is represented in Figs. 1 and 2. Thispatient received serial bilateral biopsies for persistent laryngealleukoplakia demonstrating dysplasia on six separate occasionsover a 12-year period, culminating in diagnosis of a left truevocal cord HNSC. At least four separate genetic progressionevents can be discerned from this examination. We noted thatidentical alleles were lost in each of the six loci of interest whenLOH occured, indicating a common clonal origin for eachlesion. We also noted that genetic alterations initially evident onbiopsies taken from the left TVC subsequently became manifeston both vocal cords.

This first biopsy specimen shows LOH on both chromo-somes 13q11 and 17p13 on the left TVC, with LOH only ofchromosome 17p13 on the right TVC. This implies that the rightTVC specimen represents a clonal proliferation earlier on theprogression pathway that may have originated on the left TVC.13q11 LOH represents a subsequent genetic event resulting infurther clonal outgrowth (Fig. 3). 17p13 loss is most likely theinitial genetic event, and 13q11 is most likely the second geneticevent. Subsequent genetic events seen in the left TVC in year 2are LOH of chromosomes 3p, 8, and 9p21. This clonal out-

350 Genetic Progression of Recurrent Head and Neck Lesions

Research. on February 11, 2021. © 2000 American Association for Cancerclincancerres.aacrjournals.org Downloaded from

Page 5: Genetic Progression and Clonal Relationship of Recurrent ... · tic and neoplastic lesions from single biopsy specimens. To firmly establish the temporal order of established genetic

growth expands to the right TVC in year 4. A likely sequence ofgenetic alteration for this tumor would therefore be 17p13 LOH,followed by 13q11 LOH, followed by 9p21, 8, and 3p LOH inan undetermined order. Again, other losses at different chromo-somal loci may have occurred during this time period but werenot detectable by our analysis.

DiscussionIn the past several years, tumor progression models have

been constructed for multiple tumor types, including HNSC, bycorrelating a particular genetic alteration with histopathologicprogression (2). The initial description of genetic progression ofsolid tumors in the context of colon cancer noted: (a) thattumors progress via the inactivation of tumor suppressor genesand activation of proto-oncogenes; (b) specific events occur in ageneralized order of progression; and (c) the temporal order ofgenetic alteration is not identical for each individual tumor, butthe accumulation of genetic events is critical for determiningtumor progression (1).

The data presented in this study reinforce the paradigm ofa genetic progression model for HNSC as presented previously.Certain genetic events (9p21 LOH, 3p LOH, and 17p13 LOH)tend to occur earlier on the progression pathway, but other,usually late-occurring events (13q11, 8), may also occur early inthe time course of progression. For all patients, the accumula-tion of genetic events was associated with histopathologicalprogression.

In addition, the last patient presented (no. 5) demon-strated that progression to malignancy occurs over a period ofyears. During this progression, a significant number of ge-netic events occur early on the progression pathway, whereasclinical expression of a malignant phenotype (symptoms orgross morphological changes) occurs later. For this patient,all detectable genetic alterations at the loci we tested weredescribed 9 years before the clinical appearance of malig-nancy. This is consistent with our previous observation thatthe incidence of genetic alteration in dysplastic, premalignantlesions is greater than half the rate of genetic alteration foundin invasive HNSC (2). When coupled with the observationthat the latency period between carcinogen exposure andappearance of malignancy may be as long as 25 years inHNSC, these data suggest that a significant amount of de-tectable genetic alteration may be present in affected mucosayears before an invasive phenotype is produced.

Finally, the last patient (no. 5) also afforded insight intothe nature of clonal expansion for HNSC and human cancersin general. As successive genetic alterations were acquired bya dominant clonal population in this patient, a phenotypicprogression to malignancy was seen, accompanied by a waveof clonal expansion to the contralateral TVC in the absence ofan invasive phenotype. This demonstrates that clonal, epithe-lial populations, conferred with a significant growth advan-tage, may migrate to distances of several centimeters. Sup-porting evidence for this phenomenon is also provided by: (a)studies that indicate a clonal relationship between adjacentepithelial areas of diverse histopathlogical appearance (2,13); (b) studies that indicate that a second primary HNSC isusually clonally related to the initial primary HNSC, despite

an anatomically distant site of origin (14); and (c) studies thatdemonstrate patches of normal appearing epithelia in the upperaerodigestive tract that are clonally related to regional metastases inpatients with HNSC of unknown primary origin (15).

These observations have several clinical implications.Clonal genetic alterations may precede the development ofmalignancy by a significant amount of time, at least severalyears. Clonal expansion and lateral migration of geneticallyaltered clonal populations may involve a significant portion ofthe upper aerodigestive tract mucosa before the appearance of amalignant phenotype. Taken together, these observations indi-cate that there may be a prolonged latency period during whichclonal genetic populations may be detected, but invasive pro-gression has not yet taken place.

Characterization of genetic events in premalignant lesionsmay allow definition of those lesions that may display a moreaggressive clinical behavior, perhaps warranting more aggres-sive treatment strategies. Genetic progression may thereforeprovide additional indications of clinical behavior when com-bined with histopathological appearance (16). Chemopreventivestrategies could be targeted to these early clonal cell popula-tions. Finally, these populations of clonally expanded, geneti-cally altered cells would be the ideal targets of a strategy aimedat early detection of HNSC before development of an invasivephenotype. A large clonal population of in the aerodigestivemucosa harboring early genetic changes should shed sufficientmaterial to allow detection of genetic alterations in saliva. Thishypothesis constitutes the basis of a novel approach for cancerdetection in patients with HNSC (17).

References1. Fearon, E. R., and Vogelstein, B. A genetic model for colorectaltumorigenesis. Cell,61: 759–767, 1990.2. Califano, J., van der Riet, P., Westra, W., Nawroz, H., Clayman, G.,Piantadosi, S., Corio, R., Lee, D., Greenberg, B., Koch, W., and Sidran-sky, D. Genetic progression model for head and neck cancer: implica-tions for field cancerization. Cancer Res.56: 2488–2492, 1996.3. Kamb, A., Gruis, N., Weaver-Feldhaus, J., Liu, Q., Harshman, K.,Tautigan, S. V., Stockert, E., Day, R. S., III, Johnson, B. E., andSkolnick, M. H. A cell cycle regulator potentially involved in genesis ofmany tumor types. Science, (Washington DC),264: 436–440, 1994.4. Nabori, T., Miura, K., Wu, D., Lois, A., Takahayashi, K., andCarson, D. A. Deletions of the cyclin-dependent kinase-4 inhibitor genein multiple human cancers. Nature (Lond.),368: 753–756, 1994.5. Nawroz, H., van der Riet, P., Hruban, R. H., Koch, W. M., Ruppert,J. M., and Sidransky, D. Allelotype of head and neck squamous cellcarcinoma. Cancer Res.,54: 1152–1155, 1994.6. Reed, A. L., Califano, J., Cairns, P., Westra, W. H., Jones, R. M.,Koch, W., Ahrendt, S., Eby, Y., Sewell, D., Nawroz, H., Bartek, J., andSidransky, D. High frequency of p16 (CDKN2/MTS-1/INK4A) inacti-vation in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma. Cancer Res.,56:3630–3633, 1996.7. Callender, T., El-Naffar, A. K., Lee, M., Frankenthaler, R., Luna,M. A., and Batsakis, J. G. PRAD-1 (CCND1)/cyclin D1 oncogeneamplification in primary head and neck squamous cell carcinoma.Cancer (Phila.),74: 152–158, 1994.8. Lese, C. M., Rossie, K. M., Appel, B. N., Reddy, J. K., Johnson, J.T., Myers, E. W., and Gollin, S. M. Visualization of Int2 and Hst1amplification in oral squamous cell carcinomas. Genes ChromosomesCancer,12: 288–295, 1995.9. Boyle, J. O., Hakim, J., Koch, W., van der Riet, P., Hruban, R. H.,Roa, R. A., Correo, R., Eby, Y. J., Ruppert, J. M., and Sidranski, D. The

351Clinical Cancer Research

Research. on February 11, 2021. © 2000 American Association for Cancerclincancerres.aacrjournals.org Downloaded from

Page 6: Genetic Progression and Clonal Relationship of Recurrent ... · tic and neoplastic lesions from single biopsy specimens. To firmly establish the temporal order of established genetic

incidence of p53 mutations increases with progression of head and neckcancer. Cancer Res.,53: 4477–4480, 1994.10. Wu, C. L., Sloane, P., Read, A. P., Harris, R., and Thakker, N.Deletion mapping on the short arm of chromosome 3 in squamous cellcarcinoma of the oral cavity. Cancer Res.,54: 6484–6488, 1994.11. Maestro, R., Gasparotto, D., Vuksavljevic, T., Barzan, L., Sulfaro,S., and Biocchi, M. Three discrete regions of deletion in head and neckcancers. Cancer Res.,53: 5775–5779, 1993.12. Yoo, G. H., Xu, H. J., Brennan, J. A., Westra, W., Hruban, R. H.,Koch, W., Benedict, W. F., and Sidransky, D. Infrequent inactivation ofthe retinoblastoma gene despite frequent loss of chromosome 13q inhead and neck squamous cell carcinoma. Cancer Res.,54: 4603–4606,1994.13. Rosin, M. P., Epstein, J. B., Berean, K., Durham, S., Hay, J., Cheng,X., Zeng, T., Huang, Y., and Zhang, L. The use of exfoliative cellsamples to map clonal genetic alterations in the oral epithelium ofhigh-risk patients. Cancer Res.,57: 5258–5260, 1997.

14. Bedi, G., Westra, W., Gabrielson, E., Koch, W., and Sidransky, D.Multiple head and neck tumors: evidence for clonal origin. Cancer Res.,56: 2484–2487, 1996.

15. Califano, J., Westra, W. H., Meninger, G., Reed, A., Koch, W., andSidransky, D. Molecular identification of the site of origin of unknownprimary squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck, submitted forpublication.

16. Spafford, M., Koch, W. M., Reed, A. L., Califano, J. A., Xu, L.H., Eisenberger, C. F., Yip, L., Leong, P. L., Wu, L., Liu, S. X.,Geronimo, C., Westra, W., and Sidransky, D. Detection of head andneck squamous cell carcinoma in saliva by microsatellite analysis. J.Natl., Cancer Inst., in press, 2000.17. Mao, L., El-Naggar, A. K., Papadimitrakopoulou, V., Shin, D. M.,Shin, H. C., Fan, Y., Zhou, X., Clayman, G., Lee, J. J., Hittelman, W.N., Lippman, S. M., and Hong, W. K. Phenotype and genotype ofadvanced premalignant head and neck lesions after chemopreventivetherapy. J. Natl. Cancer Inst.,90: 1545–1551, 1998.

352 Genetic Progression of Recurrent Head and Neck Lesions

Research. on February 11, 2021. © 2000 American Association for Cancerclincancerres.aacrjournals.org Downloaded from

Page 7: Genetic Progression and Clonal Relationship of Recurrent ... · tic and neoplastic lesions from single biopsy specimens. To firmly establish the temporal order of established genetic

2000;6:347-352. Clin Cancer Res   Joseph Califano, William H. Westra, Glenn Meininger, et al.   Premalignant Head and Neck LesionsGenetic Progression and Clonal Relationship of Recurrent

  Updated version

  http://clincancerres.aacrjournals.org/content/6/2/347

Access the most recent version of this article at:

   

   

  Cited articles

  http://clincancerres.aacrjournals.org/content/6/2/347.full#ref-list-1

This article cites 15 articles, 10 of which you can access for free at:

  Citing articles

  http://clincancerres.aacrjournals.org/content/6/2/347.full#related-urls

This article has been cited by 17 HighWire-hosted articles. Access the articles at:

   

  E-mail alerts related to this article or journal.Sign up to receive free email-alerts

  Subscriptions

Reprints and

  [email protected] at

To order reprints of this article or to subscribe to the journal, contact the AACR Publications

  Permissions

  Rightslink site. Click on "Request Permissions" which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center's (CCC)

.http://clincancerres.aacrjournals.org/content/6/2/347To request permission to re-use all or part of this article, use this link

Research. on February 11, 2021. © 2000 American Association for Cancerclincancerres.aacrjournals.org Downloaded from