(gauteng division, pretoria) pretoria this 15th day of … · 2020-05-21 · (gauteng division,...
TRANSCRIPT
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
(GAUTENG DIVISION, PRETORIA)
PRETORIA THIS 15TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2018
THURSDAY
CRIMINAL TRIALS
IN COURT GA AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RABIE
IN COURT GB AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RAULINGA
IN COURT GC AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKHOBA AJ IN COURT GD AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LETSOALO AJ IN COURT AT 10:00
Page 2 of 21
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MUNZHELELE AJ
URGENT COURT IN COURT 4F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JW LOUW IN COURT 8F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HAUPT AJ
CRIMINAL APPEALS
IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TOLMAY BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MNCUBE AJ
Date : 15 November 2018 (Thursday)
Before the Honourable Judge : Tolmay Before the Honourable Judge : Mncube
Name of Advocate for the State: Molatudi No. Case no. Name of appellant Jail/Bail
1. A282/17 L M Kekae jail
2. A266/17 M Lavhelani jail
3. A309/17 N S Shongwe jail
4 A325/17 J M Mongale jail
CIVIL APPEALS
Page 3 of 21
IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAQWA BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE GWALA AJ THURSDAY
15 NOVEMBER 2018
RULE 50 (4)
VRESTHENA (PTY) LIMITED VS LEZMIN 2417 CC A155/18
VALENCIA KEITUMETSE MARUMOLE VS LEBOGANG ISIAH MARUMOLE A127/18
7
ADMISSIONS
IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TOLMAY BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MNUBE AJ
1. T. O MASHEGO ADV 48400/18
2. G. M MAMABOLO ADV 42552/18
3. R. DE LEEUW ADV 69953/18
4. V. E RAMAKOABA-MALOPE ATT 69969/18
5. S. NDEVU ATT 60071/18
6. S. NDEVU ATT 69971/18
7. T. MOTSAATHEBE ATT 78585/18
Page 4 of 21
IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAQWA BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE GWALA AJ
8. D. MOKOENA ATT 51325/18
9. K. B KEKANA ADV 66872/18
10. F.STERM ADV 67691/18
11. A. VAHED ATT 52404/18
12. N. DADABHAI ATT 69982/18
13. C. ERNST ATT 52426/18
14. M OOSTHUIZEN NOT 59978/18
REVIEW JUDGEMENT
IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TOLMAY
1. The State vs Zacharia Moatshe A411/18
UNOPPOSED MOTIONS
IN COURT 2A AT 10:00
Page 5 of 21
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KUBUSHI IN COURT 2B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TUCHTEN IN COURT 8E AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KHUMALO
OPPOSED MOTIONS
IN COURT 4D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FABRICIUS IN COURT 8A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE WINDELL IN COURT 8B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SENYATSI AJ IN COURT 8D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SHANGISA AJ IN COURT8G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOSOPA AJ
JUDGMENTS
IN COURT GC AT 08:30
Page 6 of 21
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE LETSOALO AJ
Mampe K.L. v Road Accident Fund – Case No.95837/2016
IN COURT 8F AT 10:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HAUPT (AJ) obo NEUKIRCHER (AJ)
WILLEM JOHANNES CLAASE VS SILVERLAKES HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION NPC
14068/18
IN COURT 2D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TLHAPI CASE NO. 46074/18
LEBASHE INVESTMENTS GROUP (PTY) LTD & 5 OTHERS
AND
UNITED DREMOCRATIC MOVEMENT + 1
IN COURT GA AT 9:30
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RABIE
M SOULET vs MEC FOR COMMUNITY SAFETY,
GAUTENG A718/16
Page 7 of 21
IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE
LEAVE TO APPEALS IN COURT 8A AT 9:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE STRIJDOM AJ A E SWANEPOEL EA VS C PRO CONSTRUCTION(PTY)LTD AND 9 OTHERS CASE NO: 63054/2015
IN COURT 2A AT 09H30 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TUCHTEN
GLOBAL STRAKE SECURITY CC
VS
MAHLATSI SECURITY SERVICES CC
CASE NO: 59134/15
IN COURT 8E AT 08:45 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KHUMALO Petrus J van Staden Vs Thabiso R Ramphalile
Page 8 of 21
IN COURT C - PALACE OF JUSTICE AT 09:30
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE MADAM JUSTICE JANSE VAN NIEUWENHUIZEN
CASE NUMBER: 97406/2016
Philip Riekert v Granite Slab Sales (Pty) Ltd and five others and Firstrand Bank Limited and three other intervening parties
IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE
PART HEARD MATTERS IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE
Page 9 of 21
IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE
SPECIAL CIVIL TRIALS IN COURT B AT 10:00 PALACE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE DAVIS IN COURT 6E AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE COLLIS IN COURT A AT 10:00 PALACE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOLOPA IN COURT 6D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TEFFO
3RD COURT MOTIONS IN COURT 6C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE DE VOS IN COURT 6G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MALI
Page 10 of 21
CIVIL TRIALS THAT STOOD DOWN IN COURT 8E AT 9:30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RAULINGA A DJ P A B M CEBEKHULU VS RAF 8198/15 B K MKANSI VS RAF 74498/15 C LEE ANN VAN ROOYEN VS RAF 8187/18 D C DE JAGER VS RAF 32506/14 E P MAPONYA VS RAF 79761/17 F N P MABELE VS RAF 10217/17 G M G MALELE VS RAF 88969/15 H S M THOLANE VS RAF 22137/18 I M C THIPE VS RAF 23800/15 J E MSIMANGO VS RAF 47464/15 K Z HLULANE VS RAF 8367/18
Page 11 of 21
L S H MATYEKA VS RAF 68324./16 M M MANTOA VS RAF 69477/14 N S T MIYA VS RAF 68720/17 O O L FUTA VS RAF 31409/17 P M E MGHEMBU VS RAF 36165/14 Q S K MAGALE VS RAF 11695/15 R P J DUBE VS RAF 62321/14 S T S ZWANE VS RAF 8035/16
CIVIL TRIALS ALOCATIONS IN COURT 8E AT 9:30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RAULINGA A DJ P AA J RAMBALLY VS RAF P/P/ 17/08 48069/16
BB A LINDEQUE VS RAF P/P/30/10 86071/16
CC B M MLAMBO VS RAF P/P/41928 41928/17
DD N E MAHLANGU VS RAF P/P/21/08/18 95252/15
EE GOVENDER H S VS RAF PP 17/8/18 15244/16
CIVIL TRIALS IN COURT 8E AT 9:30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RAULINGA A DJ P
PRETORIA THIS DAY OF 15 NOVEMBER 2017
Page 12 of 21
CIVIL TRIALS
1 MS MASEMULA obo T MOTSHWENI VS RAF MERITS
42505/16 42506/16
2 T MASUKA VS RAF MERITS 83330/16
3 SJ CALITZ JG RAF MERITS 19778/14
4 AM VAB EEDEN VS RAF MERITS 62926/12
5 FJ DE BRUYN VS RAF MERITS 30311/17
6 M THEYSSE VS RAF CERT 24053/17
7 MAHLAULE M VS RAF NO FILE 78297/14 NP
8 TK GUMEDE VS RAF MERITS 13028/17
9 SL MOOKETSI VS RAF MERITS 17338/17
10 QASHA MM VS RAF NO FILE 95305/15
11 LE NOVELA VS RAF MERITS 84208/16
12 JP MASHINII VS RAF MERITS 78871/15
13 N FETU VS RAF MERITS 87355/16
14 WB MATHIBELA VS RAF MERITS 59575/16
15 LE MMAKO VS RAF MERITS 8624/17
Page 13 of 21
16 M MOTHUSI obo K VS RAF REMOVED 8618/17
17 MA MABASO VS RAF MERITS 32994/17
18 NJ NTSHANGASE VS RAF MERITS 87753/14
19 LA WELLINGTON VA RAF MERITS 45420/15
20 W V MGXOBANE VS RAF 14011/14
21 L SEHLARE VS RAF MERITS 28328/17
22 SA ZWANE VS RAF MERITS 62429/16
23 A H MAREDI VS RAF NO FILE 83313/17
24 B P DLAMINI VS RAF NO FILE 9630/15
25 MK POTGIETER VS RAF MERITS 67096/16
26 B JACOBS VS RAF MERITS 21427/17
27 CT MAJADUBODU VS RAG MERITS 21993/12
28 P ERASMUS VS
TRANSNET SOC+1 OTHER CIVIL NO FILE 30211/16
29 NE GOABONNA VS RAF MERITS 93305/16
30 MA MOLOI VS RAF MERITS 89492/15
31 PP ZONDI VS RAF MERITS NO FILE 97213/16
32 CIV HATTING VA RAF MERITS NO FILE 47876/14
Page 14 of 21
33 ZM TSHABALALA VS RAF MERITS 38194/17
34 S KRUGER VS RAF MERITS 53400/14
35 P SITHOLE VS RAF MERITS 62367/11
36 P SELEPE VS RAF MERITS 94060/16
37 A NKOMO VS RAF CERTIFICATE 29667/16
38 Tm letsoalo VS RAF CERTIFICATE 52091/16
39 GT MARULE VS RAF MERITS 9062/17
40 NJ MOKOENA VS RAF MERITS 71334/14
41 WG MOGASWE VS RAF MERITS 85220/16
42 D PHIRI VS RAF CERTIFICATE 70645/16
43 MG EROBE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 66125/16
44 RD GELDENHUIS VS RAF CERTIFICATE 68662/14
45 HT MARAKALALA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 77723/14
46 PP MMARA VS RAF CERTIFICATE NO FILE 65790/13
47 BS PHETO VA RAF CERTIFICATE 47678/14
48 NBS NDABA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 71074/11
49 KM MANGENDA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 73697/13
Page 15 of 21
50 MT MAHLOKWANE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 64941/13
51 S DLAMINI VS RAF CERTIFICATE NO FILE 25783/16
52 LN MASHININI VS RAF CERTIFICATE 12354/16
53 DN SCHOEMAN VS RAF CERTIFICATE 59268/16
54 KC CHABALALA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 2363/14
55 MA CHEPHE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 67636/12
56 DG DUVENHAGE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 53872/14
57 MS MOLEFE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 70456/14
58 SA SIBIYA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 27005/16
59 SA TWALA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 34746/13
60 MM MOTSIE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 79529/16
61 BN MAZIBUKO VS RAF CERTIFICATE 8355/16
62 KML MALATLOU VS RAF CERTIFICATE 78742/15
63 H SIBIYA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 1200/16
64 KS SLATER VS RAF CERTIFICATE 1283/16
65 R MANUHWA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 66976/16
66 MR MATHOBELA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 94608/16
Page 16 of 21
67 MA ASCROFT VS RAF CERTIFICATE 16918/14
68 NP SWANA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 50180/13
69 ND NGOBENI VS RAF CERTIFICATE 15994/16
70 SW MAHLANGU VS RAF CERTIFICATE 48282/16
71 K BHIMJEE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 62936/15
72 NM MOKETLA obo VS RAF CERTIFICATE 66198/14
73 J SHABANGU obo MINOR VS RAF CERTIFICATE 28812/16
74 N SUNTBOOI VS RAF CERTIFICATE 75559/13
75 MD MOHLALANYANE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 52088/16
76 M J NZIMA VS` RAF 85088/16
77 M N SHIBA VS RAF 75379/13
78 SV CHOMA VS RAF 59983/14
79 B C GROENEWALD VS RAF MERITS 67798/17
80 RAMERAFI O D VS RAF 51819/16
81 DD MHLAMBI VS PRASA CIVIL 38454/16
82 J J G TOLMAY VS
BONGIWE PATIENCE BALENI + OTHER 67653/11
Page 17 of 21
83 MOKOBODI J C VS RAF 70990/16
84 SR MOGALE VS NDPP CIVIL 23888/17
85 E KOEKEMOER VS MIN OF POLICE CIVIL 78686/15
86 ET DINGISWAYO VS
MIN OF POLICE +1 OTHER CIVIL 49770/16
87 INCAFORCE VS O&T DEV CIVIL 61711/12
88 DELTEC POWER VS CG NEL CIVIL 71570/14
89 SB MAKAMO VS PRASA CIVIL 29065/16
90 M THEBE VS MIN OF POLICE CIVIL NO FILE 22622/15
91A L M BOPAPE VS RAF 3864/18
91B WESANI BERNAD VS RAF CERTNO FILE 84918/16
NP
92 OP THABENG VS RAF 42631/16
93 STEEL PIPES FOR AFRICA VS
LAW STAALWERK+1OTHER CIVIL 28161/14
94 SK MAHLANGU VS
MIN OF PIOLICE +1 OTHER CIVIL 50149/12
95 SS MASHIGO VS
MIN OF POLICE +1 OTHER CIVIL 61587/12
96 RAMERAFI O D VS RAF NO FILE 51819/16
97
N J SWART VS RAF 2786/13
98 GB DLAMINI VS RAF 21703/15
Page 18 of 21
99 K M MOGALE VS RAF 53868/11
100 S M SELEKE VS RAF 43415/13
101 VAN SCHALKWYK Q VS RAF CERTNO FILE 47455/12
102 N MAMPA VS RAF CERT 32808/15
103 S MABENA VS RAF CERT 78600/14
104 S P TSELANYANE VS LOS 39570/17
105 N MCQUIRE VS RAF 25896/17
106 N I NCETYANE VS RAF 73178/16
107 E RALEOHOI VS RAF 51048/15
108 VILAKAZI J VS RAF CERT NO FILE 12416/16
109 M J MABUZA VS RAF 53346/16
110 T J MOKWALA VS RAF NO FILE 53845/12
111 Z MTHEMBU VS RAF 16082/17
112 G C LANGASIKI VS RAF 1451/17
113 F N MEKGWE VS RAF 76192/17
114 C P PRINSLOO VS RAF 95701/15
115 L D THOKA VS RAF PREFDATE 21/05/18 56315/16
116 P K MORABA VS RAF PREFDATE DJP 21/05/18 NP 44028/15
117 J MNGUNI VS RAF PREFGDATE 21/05/18NO FILE 56318/14
118 J T MATHATI VS RAF PREFDATE 21/5/18 23077/17
119 S C LEDWABA +T J LEDWABA VS RAF 14240/16 14241/16
Page 19 of 21
120 B MAGAGULA VS RAF 68541/13
121 M J MATHEYANE VS RAF CONSOLIDATED 71988/13 41447/10 122 DJP
123 K M RAMATSWANI VS RAF 2801/15
124 D J HOVES VS RAF 20162/17
125 HJ P LABUSCHAGNE VS RAF 3516/14
126 S ISLAM VS RAF MERITS 9201/16
127 P A MVALA M, K VS RAF CERT 8272/15
128 S J MOISI VS RAF 51894/14
129 M E SIGAUQUE VS RAF 27567/16
130 A MTHIMUNYE VS RAF 65495/15
131 P RAMOROKA VS RAF 38430/17
132 M T MOSEISI VS RAF 14522/15
133 N P MSANI VS RAF 26101/15
134 D J NOKERI VS RAF NO FILE 49595/17
135 Z MZANSI VS RAF 95186/15
136 JP MOTHA VS RAF 91912/16
137 I S GUMEDE VS RAF 25848/12
138 K C KGONGOANA VS RAF NO FILE 67259/14
139 A MTHIMUNYE VS RAF NO FILE 53821/12
140 M I KHUBEKA VS RAF NO FILE 39282/16
Page 20 of 21
141 L S KALAKE VS RAF 71008/16
142 CHAUKE TA VS RAF 45126/17
143 M J MATHEYANE VS RAF NO FILE 71088/13 CONSOLIDATED
144 CHAUKE T A VS RAF NO FILE 45126/17NP
145 N A MQWATHI VS RAF 67704/11
146 RS MATHIANE VS RAF 24633/14
147 M D BONANI VS RAF 63551/17
148 N E MAHLANGA VS RAF 92252/15
149 M A MOKOKA VS RAF 20706/17
150 S T MASHABA VS RAF NO FILE 83440/17NP
151 J S VILAKAZI VS RAF 52416/16
152 J T MTSHWENI VS RAF 82982/14
153 N GUMEDE VS RAF 81726/14
CIVIL COURT JUDGES IN COURT 4G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE PRINSLOO IN COURT 2D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TLHAPI IN COURT 4E AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MABUSE IN COURT 6F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE VAN DER WESTHUIZEN
Page 21 of 21
IN COURT 8C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKHUVHELE IN COURT 6A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE VAN DER SCHYFF IN COURT 4B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LUKHAIMANE IN COURT 6B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MATHUNZI AJ
COURTS AVAILABLE