future proofing fodder quality analysis for australia · 5.4 performance of australian laboratories...

93
Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia

Upload: others

Post on 10-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia

Page 2: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer
Page 3: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer
Page 4: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Table of Contents

Executive summary

1. Background

2. Purpose of this report

3. Activities undertaken in preparing this report

4. Use of fodder quality analysis services in Australia

4.1. Stage of maturity of the Australian fodder testing market

4.2 Extent to which Australian customers’ needs and wants are being met

4.3 New entrants and their possible impact

5. Inter-laboratory proficiency testing

5.1 Introduction

5.2 NFTA Certification Testing Program (USA)

5.3 AFIA Ring Test program

5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date

5.5 Conclusions

5.6 Path forward

6. Provision of NIR-based fodder testing services

6.1. Introduction

6.2. Provision of NIR-based fodder testing by Australian laboratories to date

6.3. NIR networks – an alternative for provision of NIR-based fodder testing

6.4. Path forward

7. Provision of more sophisticated nutritional parameters (CNCPS)

7.1. Introduction

7.2. Path forward

8. Additional strategies to help future proof fodder quality analysis in Australia

8.1 Industry-agreed sampling methods and equipment

8.2 More user-friendly laboratory request forms

8.3 Easier to interpret laboratory reports

8.4 Paper-less system for processing samples (mobile apps)

9. Summary of options

9.1 Inter-laboratory proficiency testing

9.2 Provision of NIR-based fodder testing

9.3 Provision of more sophisticated nutritional parameters (CNCPS)

10. Process for assessing options and committing to action

10.1 Inter-laboratory proficiency testing

10.2 Provision of NIR-based fodder testing services

10.3 Provision of more sophisticated nutritional parameters (CNCPS)

11. Acknowledgements

12. Appendices

13. Glossary ...

Page 5: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Executive summary

• • •

Page 6: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer
Page 7: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• • • • • •

Page 8: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• • •

Page 9: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

1. Background

Page 10: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• • • •

• • • •

Page 11: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer
Page 12: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

2. Purpose of this report

3. Activities undertaken in preparing this report

Page 13: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

Page 14: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

4. Use of fodder quality analysis services in Australia

4.1. Stage of maturity of the Australian fodder testing market

• • • • • • • •

Page 15: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• •

Page 16: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

4.2 Extent to which Australian customers’ needs and wants are being met

• • •

Page 17: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

o

o

Page 18: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

o

4.3 New entrants and their possible impact

Page 19: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• •

Page 20: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

5. Inter-laboratory proficiency testing

5.1 Introduction

• •

Page 21: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• •

• • •

• o o

• •

Page 22: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

5.2 NFTA Certification Testing Program (USA)

Page 23: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer
Page 24: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer
Page 25: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• • • • • •

5.3 AFIA Ring Test program

Page 26: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• • • • •

• •

Page 27: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

Page 28: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

o

o o

Page 29: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer
Page 30: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date

5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer expectations

• •

• •

• •

Page 31: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

5.4.2 Against a set of performance ratings

• • • •

Page 32: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Page 33: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

5.4.3 Over six consecutive rounds

Page 34: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

5.5 Conclusions

Page 35: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

o o o

• o o

Page 36: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• •

Page 37: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

5.6 Path forward

5.6.1 Key considerations

Page 38: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• o

o

o

• o o

o

o o

Page 39: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

5.6.2 Options

• •

• •

Page 40: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Page 41: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• •

Page 42: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• •

• • • •

Page 43: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Page 44: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

o o

o o

Page 45: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• •

Page 46: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• •

Page 47: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

6. Provision of NIR-based fodder testing services

6.1. Introduction

Page 48: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• • •

• •

• • •

Page 49: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

6.2. Provision of NIR-based fodder testing by Australian laboratories to date

• •

• •

Page 50: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

6.3. NIR networks – an alternative for provision of NIR-based fodder testing

• •

• •

• •

Page 51: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• • • • • • •

Page 52: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer
Page 53: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

6.4. Path forward

6.4.1. Key considerations

• • •

• • • •

• •

• •

o o o

Page 54: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• • • • • •

6.4.2. Options

Page 55: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Page 56: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Page 57: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Page 58: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Page 59: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Page 60: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer
Page 61: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

7. Provision of more sophisticated nutritional parameters (CNCPS)

7.1. Introduction

Page 62: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Page 63: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

7.2. Path forward

7.2.1. Key considerations

• • •

• o o o o o o o o o

Page 64: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• o o o o o o o o o o o o o

Page 65: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• •

7.2.2. Options

Page 66: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer
Page 67: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• • •

Page 68: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

8. Additional strategies to help future proof fodder quality analysis in Australia

8.1 Industry-agreed sampling methods and equipment

• • • • • • •

8.2 More user-friendly laboratory request forms

8.3 Easier to interpret laboratory reports

Page 69: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Page 70: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

8.4 Paper-less system for processing samples (mobile apps)

• • •

Page 71: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

9. Summary of options 9.1 Inter-laboratory proficiency testing

9.2 Provision of NIR-based fodder testing

Page 72: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

9.3 Provision of more sophisticated nutritional parameters (CNCPS)

Page 73: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

10. Process for assessing options and committing to action

10.1 Inter-laboratory proficiency testing

Page 74: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

10.2 Provision of NIR-based fodder testing services

Page 75: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

10.3 Provision of more sophisticated nutritional parameters (CNCPS)

Page 76: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

11. Acknowledgements

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

Page 77: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

12. Appendices

Page 78: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Appendix A

Notes from visits to two large US forage laboratories

Page 79: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• • •

Page 80: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• • • • • • •

Page 81: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer
Page 82: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Appendix B

Notes on two overseas NIR calibration networks

• • •

Page 83: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• •

• • •

• •

• • • • • •

Page 84: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

o o o o o o o o o o

Page 85: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• •

• o o o

o

Page 86: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• •

Page 87: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

• •

Page 88: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

13. Glossary

Page 89: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer
Page 90: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer
Page 91: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer
Page 92: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer
Page 93: Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia · 5.4 Performance of Australian laboratories in AFIA Ring Test to date 5.4.1 Versus what’s technically possible and customer

Phone: 02 6271 4100

Fax: 02 6271 4199

Postal Address: PO Box 4776, Kingston ACT 2604

Street Address: Level 2, 15 National Circuit, Barton ACT 2600

www.rirdc.gov.au

Future proofing fodder quality analysis for Australia

Pub. No. 14/076 Project No. PRJ-008975

This independent report was commissioned by RIRDC to:

• conduct a world-class assessment of means to meet the current and future needs of the Australian fodder industry for consistent, accurate, efficient and cost-effective fodder quality analysis services, and

• provide options for industry which might help to future proof Australian fodder quality analysis.