functional assessment after peripheral nerve injury · extensor postural, latência do reflexo...
TRANSCRIPT
2012
Technical University of Lisbon
Faculty of Human Kinetics
Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury
- Kinematic Model of the Hindlimb of the Rat
Thesis submitted in the fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor in
Motricidade Humana, speciality of Fisioterapia
SANDRA CRISTINA FERNANDES AMADO
Advisor: Doutor António Prieto Veloso
Co-advisor: Doutora Ana Colette Pereira de Castro Osório Maurício
Jury
President: Reitor da Universidade Técnica de Lisboa
Vogals:
Doutor António José de Almeida Ferreira, Professor Catedrático da Faculdade de Veterinária da Universidade Técnica de Lisboa; Doutor António Prieto Veloso, Professor Catedrático da Faculdade de Motricidade Humana da Universidade Técnica de Lisboa; Doutora Ana Colette Pereira de Castro Osório Maurício, Professora Associada com Agregação do Instituto de Ciências Biomédicas Abel Salazar da Universidade do Porto; Doutora Maria Margarida Marques Rebelo Espanha, Professora Associada da Faculdade de Motricidade Humana da Universidade Técnica de Lisboa; Doutor Artur Severo Proença Varejão, Professor Auxiliar com Agregação da Escola de Ciências Agrárias e Veterinárias da Universidade de Trás-os-Montes e Alto Douro; Doutor Paulo Alexandre Silva Armada da Silva, Professor Auxiliar da Faculdade de Motricidade Humana da Universidade Técnica de Lisboa
The following parts of this thesis have been published or submitted for publication:
(1) Amado S, Simões MJ, Armada da Silva PAS, Luís AL, Shirosaki Y, Lopes MA,
et al. Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting
nerve regeneration in an axonotmesis rat model. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2008
Nov ;29(33):4409-19.
(2) Amado S, Rodrigues JM, Luís AL, Armada-da-Silva P a S, Vieira M, Gartner
A, et al. Effects of collagen membranes enriched with in vitro-differentiated
N1E-115 cells on rat sciatic nerve regeneration after end-to-end repair.
[Internet]. Journal of neuroengineering and rehabilitation. 2010 Jan; 7:7.
(3) Amado S, Armada-da-Silva P, João F, Mauricio AC, Luis AL, Simões MJ, et al.
The sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb joints kinematics analysis in
assessing function in rats after sciatic nerve crush. Behavioural brain research.
2011 (submitted);
(4) S Amado, AL Luis, S Raimondo, M Fornaro, MG Giacobini-Robecchi, S
Geuna, F João, AP Veloso, AC Maurício , PAS Armada-da-Silva. 2012
Neuroscience (submitted)
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
(4) A Gärtner, AC Maurício, T Pereira, PAS Armada-da-Silva, S Amado, AP
Veloso, AL Luís, ASP Varejão, S Geuna (2011). Cellular systems and
biomaterials for nerve regeneration in neurotmesis injuries. In Biomaterials /
Book 3. Editor Prof. Rosario Pignatello. InTech (ISBN 979-953-307-295-0).
(5) João, F., Amado, S., Veloso, A., Armada-da-silva, P., & Maurício, Ana C.
(2010). Anatomical reference frame versus planar analysis: implications for
the kinematics of the rat hindlimb during locomotion. Reviews in the
neurosciences, 21(6), 469.
(6) Simões, M. J., Amado, S., Gärtner, A., Armada-Da-Silva, P. a S., Raimondo,
S., Vieira, M., et al. (2010). Use of chitosan scaffolds for repairing rat sciatic
nerve defects. Italian journal of anatomy and embryology = Archivio italiano di
anatomia ed embriologia, 115(3), 190-210.
ORAL PRESENTATIONS
(7) Armada-da-Silva P, Amado S, Borges M, Simões MJ, João F,
Maurício AC, et al. Nerve Decompression Does Not Improve
Sciatic Function in Chronic Constriction Injury in the Rat. In: 2nd
International Fascia Research Congress. Amsterdam: 2009.
Functional assessment after peripheral nerve injury: Kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
vi
(8) Amado S, Veloso A, Armada-da-Silva P, João F, Simões MJ,
Vieira M, et al. Biomechanical and Morphological Approach to
Assess Recovery After Peripheral Nerve Injury in Animal Model.
In: 2nd International Fascia Research Congress. Amsterdam:
2009.
(9) Amado S, Veloso AP, Armada-da-silva P, João F, Luís AL,
Geuna S, et al. Análise biomecâanica da recuperação funcional
na reparação de lesõoes do nervo periférico num modelo
animal. In: 3º Congresso Nacional de Biomecânica da
Sociedade Portuguesa de Biomecânica. Bragança: 2009.
(10) João F, Amado S, Veloso A, Armada-da-Silva P, Mauricio A.
Segmental Kinematic Analysis using a tridimensional
reconstruction of rat hindlimb: comparison between 2D and 3D
joint angles. In: ISB 2010.
vii
Contents
CONTENTS VII
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS IX
SUMMARY XI
RESUMO XII
CHAPTER1–INTRODUCTIONANDMAINOBJECTIVES 1
CHAPTER2–METHODOLOGICALCONSIDERATIONS 19
CHAPTER3‐USEOFHYBRIDCHITOSANMEMBRANESANDN1E‐115CELLSFOR
PROMOTINGNERVEREGENERATIONINANAXONOTMESISRATMODEL 39
CHAPTER4‐EFFECTSOFCOLLAGENMEMBRANESENRICHEDWITHINVITRO‐
DIFFERENTIATEDN1E‐115CELLSONRATSCIATICNERVEREGENERATIONAFTER
END‐TO‐ENDREPAIR 77
CHAPTER5‐THESENSITIVITYOFTWO‐DIMENSIONALHINDLIMBJOINTS
KINEMATICSANALYSISINASSESSINGFUNCTIONINRATSAFTERSCIATICNERVE
CRUSH 105
CHAPTER6‐THEEFFECTOFACTIVEANDPASSIVEEXERCISEINNERVE
REGENERATIONANDFUNCTIONALRECOVERYAFTERSCIATICNERVECRUSHIN
THERAT 135
CHAPTER7‐GENERALDISCUSSIONANDCONCLUSIONS 165
Functional assessment after peripheral nerve injury: Kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
viii
ix
Acknowledgements
Institutional support and partnership was crucial for the successful development of
scientific work. The experimental work was possible to be performed at the Instituto
Nacional Ricardo Jorge and Faculdade de Medicina Veterinaria de Lisboa. I would
like to gratefully acknowledge the valuable support by Doutor José Manuel Correia
Costa, from Laboratório de Parasitologia, Instituto Nacional de Saúde Dr. Ricardo
Jorge (INSRJ), Porto, Portugal and by Doutora Belmira Carrapiço, from Faculdade
de Medicina Veterinária de Lisboa.
I would like to thanks to the Universidade Técnica de Lisboa (UTL) rector, the
president of scientific committee and the president of Faculdade de Motricidade
Humana, also of Instituto Ciências Biomédicas Abel Salazar – Universidade do
Porto, ICETA-CECA, and Escola Superior de Saúde de Leiria - Instituto Politécnico
de Leiria.
I wish to express my sincere appreciation and gratitude to all of those who have
made this thesis possible. In particular I would like to thank:
Professor António Prieto Veloso, my supervisor, and the head of Neuromechanics
Research Group, for your never-ending patience and generous giving of your time
and skills. I am very grateful for you guiding me through this work.
Professor Ana Colette de Castro Osório Maurício, my co-supervisor, for your
enthusiastic support, your door always being open, for you being a great human. I
have learnt a lot from you. Special thanks also to Henrique…
Professor Paulo Armada-da-Silva, my co-author, for your generous giving of
feedback and input during the work with the research projects.
Professor Ana Lúcia Luís, my co-author, for her microsurgery skills and for all
fruitful discussions and advices regarding science and life in general. Thank you also
to her family, Fernando and Rita.
Professor Jorge Rodrigues, my co-author, for his microsurgery skills and for being
a great example of Human Professional.
Professor Stefano Geuna and his team, my co-authors, for his stereological
techniques that stimulated my interest about nerve morphology.
Professor José Domingues and Ascenção Lopes, my co-authors, for the great
opportunity to work at experimental level with biomaterials, regenerative medicine
and tissue engineering.
Functional assessment after peripheral nerve injury: Kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
x
Maria João Simões, Márcia Vieira, my co-authors, for the patience during the hours
spent at the lab performing the videos.
Filipa João, my co-author, for the enthusiastic interest about rats in silica…!
My former research colleagues at the Neuromechanics group: Professors Filomena
Carnide, Filomena Vieira and Carlos Andrade. Maria Machado (Didi), Vera
Moniz-Pereira, Filipa João, Liliana, Silvia Cabral, Ricardo Matias, Wangdoo Kim
thank you for all the great time we have spent together in the lab and of course
during all of our parties.
Professor Carlos Ferreira, thank you for the “Master thesis” format.
Professor Hugo Gamboa and Neuza Nunes for encouraging the study of pattern
recognition.
To all my patients that understood the need felt to initiate a different way to answer
their questions…. Thank you.
For students and my colleagues at Escola Superior de Saúde de Leiria, a special
thanks to: Ana Roque, José Vital, Luís Eva Ferreira, Sílvia Jorge, Dulce Gomes e
Sónia Pós de Mina, Susana Custódio, Sílvia Gonzaga, Filipa Soares.
My friends and family for the time not spent with them… My parents and sister for
always being there and supporting me in every aspects of life. For your never-ending
encouragement to fully explore my curiosity. My gratitude and my admiration see no
limitations.
To Francisco, for the unconditional love, and Claudio that supported the day-by-day
basis.
My research has been supported by Fundação para a Ciência e Tecnologia (FCT)
from Ministério da Ciência e Ensino Superior (MCES), Portugal, through the financed
grant SFRH/BD/30971/2006 and research project PTDC/CTM/64220/2006. Part of
the work was also supported by PRIN and FIRB grants from the Italian MIUR
(Ministero dell’Istruzione, dell’Università e della Ricerca), by the Regione Piemonte
(Programma di Ricerca Sanitaria Finalizzata)
xi
Summary
Gait analysis is increasingly used on research methodology to assess dynamics
aspects of functional recovery after peripheral nerve injury in the rat model, which
ultimately is the goal of treatment and rehabilitation. In this thesis we studied nerve
regeneration using techniques of molecular and cellular biology. Functional recovery
was evaluated using the sciatic functional index (SFI), the static sciatic index (SSI),
the extensor postural thrust (EPT), the withdrawal reflex latency (WRL) and hindlimb
kinematics. Nerve fiber regeneration was assessed by quantitative stereological
analysis and electron microscopy. From our results, hybrid chitosan membranes after
sciatic nerve crush, either alone or enriched with N1E-115 neural cells, may
represent an effective approach for the improvement of the clinical outcome in
patients receiving peripheral nerve surgery. Collagen membrane, with or without
neural cell enrichment, did not lead to any significant improvement in most of
functional and stereological predictors of nerve regeneration that we have assessed,
with the exception of EPT. Extending the kinematic analysis during walking to the hip
joint improved sensitivity of this functional test. For motor rehabilitation, either active
or passive exercises positively affect sciatic nerve regeneration after a crush injury,
possibly mediated by a direct mechanical effect onto the regenerating nerve.
Keywords: functional assessment, rat, joint kinematics, neurorehabilitation,
peripheral nerve, biomaterials.
Functional assessment after peripheral nerve injury: Kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
xii
Resumo
A crescente utilização da análise da marcha após lesão do nervo periférico no
modelo do rato relaciona-se com a necessidade de avaliar aspectos dinâmicos da
recuperação funcional. Na presente tese estudámos a regeneração do nervo com
utilização de técnicas moleculares e celulares. A recuperação funcional foi avaliada
com uso de Índice de funcionalidade do ciático, índice estático do ciático, reflexo
extensor postural, latência do reflexo flexor e cinemática do membro posterior. A
regeneração da fibra nervosa foi avaliada com técnicas estereológicas e microscopia
electrónica. Dos nossos resultados concluímos que as membranas híbridas de
quitosano após lesão de esmagamento do nervo ciático, com ou sem
enriquecimento de células neurais N1E-115, podem representar uma abordagem
efetiva para a melhoria dos resultados clínicos dos pacientes sujeitos a cirurgia do
nervo periférico. As membranas de colageneo, com ou sem enriquecimento de
células neurais, não repercutiram nenhuma melhoria significativa nos parâmetros
preditores funcionais e estereologicos de regeneração do nervo. Verificámos que a
inclusão da articulação da coxo-femoral na analise cinemática de marcha aumentou
a sensibilidade deste teste funcional. Para a reabilitação motora, quer o exercício
ativo quer passivo influenciou a regeneração do nervo após esmagamento,
possivelmente devido a um efeito mecânico na regeneração do nervo periférico.
Palavras-chave: avaliação funcional, rato, cinemática, neuroreabilitação, nervo
periférico, biomateriais
Chapter 1 – Introduction and Main Objectives
2 Functional Assessement After Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
1 Introduction and main objectives
This thesis was focused on the study of functional recovery after biological therapeutic
strategies for repair of peripheral nerve axonotmesis and neurotmesis injuries with
experimental model of the rat. The available background regarding peripheral nerve
repair suggests that: 1) Biomaterials are important for peripheral nerve repair after
injury with promising functional results; 2) Functional recovery is the golden standard to
ascertained efficacy of interventions and results transposition from in vivo experiments;
3) the description of functional movement of the ankle i.e. ankle kinematics during
stance phase is an accurate method for functional assessment. So, the aims of this
thesis were: 1) to evaluate functional recovery after a moderate i.e axonotemesis and
severe i.e neurotemesis sciatic nerve injury and verify if various types of biomaterials,
would affect functional recovery and the morphology of nerve fibers, with emphases on
evaluation of kinematic analysis of the rat ankle; 2) to improve kinematic model for
assessment of functional recovery after sciatic nerve crush injury; 3) to verify if
therapeutic exercise would induce changes on kinematics of gait and nerve
morphology.
After peripheral nerve injury, its inner capability of repair is a remarkable reality.
Previously, our research group reported in vitro results that highlighted the relevance of
Ca2+ (1; 2) and results leads to a significant research to know which biological element
might contribute to synergistically optimize effects of microsurgical techniques and
improve morphological and functional recovery (3-5). Neurotrophic factors have been
the target of intensive research - their role in nerve regeneration and the way they
influence neural development, survival, outgrowth, and branching (6). Among
neurotrophic factors, neurotrophins have been heavily investigated in nerve
regeneration studies. They include the nerve growth factor (NGF), brain-derived
neurotrophic factor (BDNF), neurotrophin-3 (NT-3), and neurotrophin-4/5 (NT-4/5) (7).
Neurotrophic factors promote a variety of neural responses, including survival and
outgrowth of the motor and sensory nerve fibers, and spinal cord regeneration (8).
However, in vivo responses to neurotrophic factors can vary due to the method of their
delivering. Therefore, the development and use of controlled delivery devices are
required for the study of complex systems.
A multidisciplinary team, including Veterinaries, Engineers, Medical doctors like
neurologists and surgeons, through Experimental Surgery has a crucial role in the
development of biomaterials associated to these cellular systems, and in testing the
surgical techniques that involve their application, always considering animal welfare
Introduction and Main Objectives 3
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
and the most appropriate animal model. Rodents, particularly the rat and the mouse,
have become the most frequently utilized animal models for the study of peripheral
nerve regeneration because of the widespread availability of these animals as well as
the distribution of their nerve trunks which is similar to humans (9). Although other
nerve trunks, especially in the rat forelimb, are getting more and more used for
experimental research (10; 11), the rat sciatic nerve is still the far more employed
experimental model as it provides a nerve trunk with adequate length and space at the
mid-thigh for surgical manipulation and/or introduction of grafts or guides (9). Although
sciatic nerve injuries themselves are rare in humans, this experimental model provides
a very realistic testing bench for lesions involving plurifascicular mixed nerves with
axons of different size and type competing to reach and reinnervate distal targets (9).
Common types of experimentally induced injuries include focal crush or freeze injury
that causes axonal interruption but preserves the connective sheaths (axonotmesis),
complete transection disrupting the whole nerve trunk (neurotmesis) and resection of a
nerve segment inducing a gap of certain length. Several biomaterials developed by our
research group (including PLGA with a novel proportion 90:10 of the two polymers,
poly(L-lactide):poly(glycolide), hybrid chitosan and collagen) or available already in the
market like Neurolac® (made of poly-ε-caprolactone) have been tested associated to
cellular systems to promote nerve regeneration after axonotmesis and neurotmesis
injuries in the sciatic nerve experimental model. The cellular systems that have been
studied in this context include an immortalized neural cell line N1E-115.
One primary cause of poor recovery after long-term denervation is a profound
reduction in the number of axons that successfully regenerate through the deteriorating
intramuscular nerve sheaths. Muscle force capacity is further compromised by the
incomplete recovery of muscle fibres from denervation atrophy. Progressive muscle
atrophy and changes in muscle fibres composition are consequences of peripheral
nervous system injury that interrupts communication between skeletal muscle and
neurons. After peripheral nerve injury, alterations of gait pattern are the most relevant
observation (5; 12). Functional recovery stills the main limitation to achieve results
translation, and the understanding of such limitation is greatly dependent also on
research methods and on therapeutic strategies. Choosing the correct functional assay
in the rat model for peripheral nerve injury (13) and spinal cord injury (14) is a question
of intensive research interest as an experimental model. After peripheral nerve injury
there are neural and mechanical disturbances and the amount of sensory endings that
exist is one of the major limitations to study the functional meaning of recovery and
thus, the biomechanical model has been increasingly used. For most recently
published studies, functional tests consider analysis of voluntary movement and reflex
4 Functional Assessement After Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
activity. Gait function represents the integration of motor and sensory function and
several gait parameters were considered with significant relationship for functional
evaluation of experimental rat model, only during the last decade it has been studied
with biomechanics research methods. Previously, we have highlighted the importance
of both functional and morphological methods in this model (5) already reported by
Varejão et al. (15), which make possible to have different levels of complexity to study
the peripheral nerve repair process. In experimental laboratory animal model it is a
great advance to measure observable functional gains, until now impossible to obtain
since they were considered subjective behavioral measurements.
Locomotion, from a mechanical point of view, is characterized by a repetitious
sequence of limb motion to move the body forward while maintaining the stance
balance. There are three basic approaches to analyze gait (16): 1) subdividing the
cycle according to the variations in reciprocal floor contact by the two feet; 2) using the
time and distance qualities of the stride; 3) identifying the functional significance of the
events within the gait cycle and designate these intervals as the functional phases of
gait. According to the variations in reciprocal floor contact by the two feet, as the body
moves forward, one limb serves as mobile source of support while the other limb
advances itself to a new support site. Stance phase designates the entire period during
which the foot is on the ground and begins with initial contact (IC). Swing phase is the
phase of the normal gait cycle during which the foot is off the ground. The swing phase
follows the stance phase and is divided into the initial swing, the midswing, and the
terminal swing stages.
Analysis of the free walking pattern of the rat is the method mostly used for
assessment of motor function through motion analysis. Although locomotor activity in
an open field is a stable behavioural test and may be used as an index of the
behavioural-physiological coping style of an individual rat (Basso, Beatie and
Bresnahan (BBB) Locomotor Rating Scale) (17), the information obtained is qualitative,
range from 0 to 21 and distinguish between locomotor features such as flaccid
paralysis, isolated hind-limb joint movements, weight-supported plantar stepping,
coordination, and details of locomotion (eg, toe clearance, paw position) (18).
Specifically for peripheral nerve injury, it was developed a method to measure a
combination of motor and sensory recovery: Sciatic Functional Index (SFI) (19). They
calculated an index of the functional condition of rat sciatic nerve (SFI) that consists on
expressing as a percentage the difference between the measurements of injured hind
paw parameters and the intact contralateral hind paw parameters obtained from
footprints. The main objective of these methods was to extrapolate the nerve function
Introduction and Main Objectives 5
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
recovery considering its action on innervated muscles. After sciatic nerve injury,
footprints reveal differences between the normal and experimental print length with the
last one being the largest. Although SFI is a quantitative method, it is dependent on
the pressure exerted by the foot on the floor, and it is restricted to a point in time, which
limits the information obtained. Automutilation, inversion or eversion deformations often
limit the functional assessment with the use of SFI (20), despite this limitation it is a
widely used parameter because of its reliability (21). Bervar (2000) described an
alternative video analysis of static footprint video analysis (SSI) to assess functional
loss following injury to the rat sciatic nerve, during animal standing or periodic rest on a
flat transparent surface used motion analysis with the utilization of video analysis. SSI
static sciatic index was developed based on the premise that the recovery of muscle
tone after nerve injury is a constituent part of integral nerve and muscle functional
recovery and forces acting on the body i.e. body weight and postural muscle tone
during standing influenced footprint parameters (22). The main difference between SFI
and SSI was that the distance between the tip of the third toe and the posterior margin
of the sole discoloured area (PLF), defined as the print length parameter, was not
considered. The authors considered this parameter the most difficult part of the video
analysis and it was subject to observer’s misinterpretation and unwilling measuring
errors with excessive variability and poor correlation between static video method and
dynamic ink track method. They found better reproducibility, high accuracy, more
precise quantification of the degree of functional loss and there are few non-
measurable footprints with SSI.
Walking pattern is the result of several signs that contributes to the performance of
movement (23). Understanding adaptive changes in motor activity associated with
functional recovery following muscle denervation can be achieved with biomechanical
research methods. In biomechanics, movement is studied in order to understand the
underlying mechanisms involved in the movement or in the acquisition and regulation
of skill. Biomechanics involves mechanical measurements used in conjunction with
biological interpretations (24). Mechanicaly, motion production also depends on the
geometry of bones and muscles, which reflects the moment pattern of motion.
The development of scientific methods of monitoring locomotion is based on
computational and mathematical principles. Biomechanics is based on Newton´s
equation of motion. There are some assumptions about Biomechanics to simplify the
complex musculoskeletal system and eliminate the necessity of quantifying the
changes in mass distribution caused by tissue deformation and movement of bodily
fluids: body segments behave as rigid bodies during movements, and in addition,
segmental mass distribution is similar among members of a particular population (23).
6 Functional Assessement After Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Over the last years, the number of parameters used for ankle joint motion analysis has
been increasing, most likely reflecting advances in computer-based video and motion
analysis. In a first use of ankle joint kinematics in peripheral nerve research, Santos et
al. (25) proposed a 2D geometrical model of the joint using two intersecting lines
joining the knee and ankle and the fifth metatarsal head to the ankle. They
demonstrated an increase in joint angle during the swing phase after a crush injury of
the peroneal nerve. After this early study, Lin et al. (26) examined the angular changes
of the ankle joint during the rat walk after sciatic nerve transection and autografting
using a single parameter: the joint angle at mid-stance. Changes in this angle were
reported as being sensitive to assess functional impairment after sciatic nerve injury
after several months of the sciatic transection, when compared to non-injured controls.
More recently, Varejão et al. (27) contributed significantly to improve ankle joint
kinematic analysis in the rat sciatic nerve model by proposing a more thorough
analysis of ankle motion during the stance phase that takes into account well-defined
time events. These authors measured the angle of the ankle joint at initial (toe) contact
(IC), opposite toe-off (around 20% of the duration of stance phase), heel raise (around
40% of the duration of stance phase), and at toe-off (TO) (27; 28). Using these
measurements, the authors could demonstrate the presence of functional deficit
beyond 8 weeks after sciatic nerve crush, in clear contrast to SFI measures. By this
time of recovery after sciatic crush, SFI measures usually show complete recovery (5;
15).
More recently, the use of digital 2D video analysis of ankle motion in rat peripheral
nerve models also includes the swing phase of walking (29). Also using 2D video
analysis and dedicated software for motion analysis, our group reported recently
measures of both angle and angular velocity of the ankle joint during the stance phase
(5). Angular velocity data were calculated in an attempt to raise the precision of ankle
motion analysis and to increase its power in detecting subtle differences in functional
recovery when testing alternative treatments after sciatic crush (27; 28). We reasoned
that functional deficits during walking in rat nerve models may be masked by the high
redundancy and adaptability of the motor apparatus in response to sensorimotor
alterations (5; 15). From a biomechanical perspective, joint rotational velocity has a
more direct relationship with the forces actuating onto the hindlimb segments and
therefore velocity measures may be better indicators of dysfunction caused by nerve
injury. Moreover, ankle position data is sometimes difficult to interpret, for example in
those cases where ankle joint angle remains unaffected in the weeks immediately after
Introduction and Main Objectives 7
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
sciatic nerve crush (27; 28). This shows that measures of ankle joint angle taken at
snapshots during walking may lack sensitivity to assess functional impairment.
Increasing the number of measures may not improve the precision of functional
evaluation. In fact, including more kinematic variables in walking analysis may
otherwise raise uncertainty in interpreting data. For example, Varejão et al. (15) report
that ankle angles at TO were similar before and after 4 weeks of sciatic crush, whereas
ankle angles were clearly affected post-injury at other time points during the stance
phase. Similar inconsistency in kinematic measurements of ankle joint motion in rats
after sciatic crush injury has been also reported by us (30). This latter study was
designed in order to prolong the observation up to 12 weeks. A full functional recovery
was predicted by SFI/SSI, Extensor Postural Trust (EPT) and Withdrawal Reflex
Latency (WRL) but not by all ankle kinematics parameters. Moreover, only two
morphological parameters (myelin thickness/axon diameter ratio and fiber/axon
diameter ratio) returned to normal values. Although these results may reflect
phenomena related to nerve regeneration and end-organ reinnervation, such as motor
axons misdirection (34), they also suggest that kinematic parameters display distinct
ability to demonstrate functional alterations after peripheral nerve injury.
Damage to any portion of the reflex arc, including the sciatic nerve can result in loss or
slowing of the reflex response. Reflex activity refers to the neural activity in which a
particular stimulus, by exciting an afferent nerve, produces a stereotyped, immediate
response of muscle. Considering motor control, it is related with sensory feedback
control. Marshal Hall was the first neurologist who has introduced the term reflex into
biology in the 19th century. He thought of the muscle as reflecting a stimulus as a wall
reflects a ball thrown against it. Reflex was defined as the automatic response of a
muscle or several muscles to a stimulus that excites an afferent nerve. The anatomical
pathway used in a reflex is called the reflex arc and it consists of an afferent nerve, one
or more interneurons within the central nervous system and an efferent nerve. Reflexes
are considered unlearned, rapid, predictable motor responses to a stimulus, and occur
over a highly specific neural pathway called reflex arc. Thalhammer and collaborators,
(36), originally proposed the Extensor Postural Trust (EPT) as a part of the evaluation
of motor function in the rat after sciatic nerve injury. It is classified as a postural reflex
reaction. For this test, the entire body of the rat, excepting the hindlimbs, was wrapped
and supporting the animal by the thorax and lowering the affected hindlimb towards the
platform of a digital balance, elicits the EPT. As the animal is lowered to the platform, it
extends the hindlimb, anticipating the contact made by the distal metatarsus and digits.
The force applied to the platform balance was recorded. Sensory function is usually
8 Functional Assessement After Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
assessed with the nociceptive withdrawal reflex (WRL), also called the flexion reflex.
The flexor, or withdrawal, reflex is initiated by a painful stimulus and causes automatic
withdrawal of the endangered body part from the stimulus. It was adapted from the
hotplate test as described by Masters and collaborators in 1993 (35) and involves a
protective response to withdraw the site from the stimulus when cutaneous receptors
(Group III and IV afferents) sense a noxious stimulus. It is a polysynaptic reflex that is
induced by noxious stimulation of the limb and its latency, amplitude, and duration
depends on stimulus intensity (28). Although WRL reflex was originally termed flexion-
withdrawal reflex (37), it has since been shown to involve other muscles besides
flexors (38). The WRL can be variable because it depends on which afferents are
activated by the stimulus and is transmitted over polysynaptic pathways, which means
that the input signal can be modified along its path.
Quantification of the number of myelinated fibers in peripheral nerve is one of the main
indicators of success of peripheral nerve repair. Number, density and diameter of the
nervous fibers are the main variables considered. However, sampling scheme is crucial
to avoid systematic errors of estimation (39) due to, for instance, anisotropy of the
nervous fibres along the nerve and consequent tendency of grouping fibers related with
their diameter (40). The golden standard is the designed-based sampling also
recognized as systematic random sampling scheme. Previously, we have reported that
12 weeks after injury, regenerated nerves have higher mean density and total number
of myelinated axons as lower mean fiber diameter and myelin thickness. Fiber density
and number in crushed nerves is still significantly higher than normal nerves while size
is still significantly lower (5). It has been hypothesized that one explanation could be
the occurrence of a sprouting of more than one growth cone from each severed axon
leading to the presence of an abundance of small regenerating axons that cross the
lesion site and grow to innervate the end organs (46). The primary function of
peripheral nerves is communication. Thus, electrical and/or chemical messages are
passed from neuron to neuron or from neuron to target organ. Curiously, early work on
impulse conduction along peripheral fibers by Erlanger and Gasser (for which they
shared the Nobel Prize in 1942) demonstrated remarkable relationships between the
conduction velocity of the axons and the type of information that was conveyed. In
what concerns nerve morphology, peripheral nerves demonstrate a wide variety of
axonal types, from myelinated axons of 20 microns in diameter, to very fine
nonmyelinated axons as small as 0.2 microns in diameter. Significant correlation and
internal consistency between electrophysiological and morphological parameters (i.e.
conduction velocity and fiber diameter) make available information and guidelines for
Introduction and Main Objectives 9
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
parameter selection based upon the specific question being investigated (36). The
largest motor fibers (13-20 um, conducting at velocities of 80 -120 m/s) innervate the
extrafusal fibers of the skeletal muscles, and smaller motor fibers (5-8 um, conducting
at 4-24 m/s) innervate intrafusal muscle fibers. The largest sensory fibers (13-20 µm)
innervate muscle spindles and Golgi tendon organs (both conveying unconscious
proprioceptive information), the next largest (6-12 µm) convey information from
mechanoreceptors in the skin, and the smallest myelinated fibers 1 – 5 µm) convey
information from free nerve endings in the skin, as well as pain, and cold receptors.
Non myelinated peripheral C fibers (0.2 – 1.5 µm) carry information about pain and
warmth.
In our fist study (chapter 3) functional recovery was assessed after different therapeutic
strategies to improve sciatic nerve repair after axonotemesis injury. The experimental
model based on the induction of a crush injury (axonotmesis) in the rat sciatic nerve
provides a very realistic testing bench for lesions involving plurifascicular mixed nerves
with axons of different size and type competing to reach and re-innervate distal targets
(35). This type of injury is thus appropriate to investigate the cellular and molecular
mechanisms of peripheral nerve regeneration, to assess the role of different factors in
the regeneration process (36) and to perform preliminary in vivo testing of biomaterials
that will be useful in tube-guide fabrication for more serious injuries of the peripheral
nerve, such as neurotmesis. Reflex activity, gait function, motion analysis during gait
and nerve morphology were assessed with EPT and WRL, SFI, ankle kinematics and
nerve histomorphometry respectively. Motion pattern of ankle joint was studied
performing 2-D biomechanical analysis (sagital plan) during stance phase of gait. It
was carried out applying a two-segment model of the ankle joint. It was characterized
with four time events: Initial Contact, Opposite Toe-Off, Hell Rise, and Toe-Off as
described above. We brought together two of the more promising recent trends in
nerve regeneration research: 1) local enwrapping of the lesion site of axonotmesis by
means of hybrid chitosan membranes; 2) application of a cell delivery system to
improve local secretion of neurotrophic factors. First, type I, II and III chitosan
membranes were screened by an in vitro assay, in terms of physical, mechanical and
cytocompatibility properties. Then, membranes were evaluated in vivo to assess their
biocompatibility and their effects on nerve fiber regeneration and nerve recovery in a
standardized rat sciatic nerve crush injury model (37). Among the various substances
proposed for the fashioning of nerve conduits, chitosan attracted particular attention
because of its biocompatibility, biodegradability, low toxicity, low cost, enhancement of
wound-healing and antibacterial effects (38). In addition, the potential application of
10 Functional Assessement After Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
chitosan in nerve regeneration has been demonstrated both in vitro and in vivo (39).
Chitosan is a partially deacetylated polymer of acetyl glucosamine obtained after the
alkaline deacetylation of chitin (40).
In our second study (chapter 4) different therapeutic strategies were developed to
improve sciatic nerve repair after a different, more severe lesion i.e. neurotmesis with
and without gap. The aim of this study was to verify if rat sciatic nerve regeneration
after end-to-end reconstruction can be improved by seeding in vitro differentiated N1E-
115 neural cells on a type III equine collagen membrane and enwrap the membrane
around the lesion site. Reflex activity, gait function, motion analysis during gait and
nerve morphology were assessed with EPT and WRL, SSI, ankle kinematics and nerve
morphometry respectively. 2-D biomechanical analysis (sagital plan) was carried out
applying a two-segment model of the ankle joint. As in the previous study, we only
considered the stance phase.
In chapter 5, it is described a third group of experiments, that established different
levels of functional dysfunction by evaluating sciatic-crushed rats: 1) in the denervation
phase (one week after injury), 2) in the reinnervated phase: 12 weeks after injury, and
3) sham-operated controls. We considered the entire gait cycle i.e. stance and swing
phases, which were characterized with four time events: Initial Contact, Midstance,
Toe-Off and Midswing. Peak values of joint angle and angular velocity were studied in
both phases: stance and swing. Additionally, all hindlimb joints were studied: ankle,
knee and hip, allowing the study of 2-D motion analysis (sagital plan) and interjoint
coordination. Gait was also characterized in terms of spatiotemporal parameters (gait
velocity, step length, swing and stance phase duration), which allowed having insights
about its mechanical characteristics. An important statistical question was raised with
this study: Increasing the number of ankle motion measures is also not statistically
desirable, particularly if these carries redundancy and lowers sensitivity. Studies in
animal models of peripheral nerve injury are usually constrained by low number of
subjects according to international welfare laws. When kinematic measures are applied
to determine changes at behavioural level, less than 10 animals per group are
commonly used (41-45). Therefore the decision of which kinematic variables should be
used to assess functional recovery in peripheral nerve research should be based on an
evaluation of their sensitivity to detect functional changes of different levels of severity.
A proper selection of kinematic variables would give researchers a tool to monitor
functional recovery after nerve injury and to detect long term functional changes
caused by incomplete recovery or adaptive changes in motor patterns. We performed a
Introduction and Main Objectives 11
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
discriminant analysis of the kinematic parameters to verify if 2D joint motion analysis is
highly sensitive and specific to identify functional deficits caused by acute sciatic crush
in the rat. The sensitivity and specificity of a given set or battery of tests may be
evaluated using discriminant analysis. This statistical technique builds a predictive
model to detect membership based on a set of independent variables. This technique
may be applied to evaluate the sensitivity and specificity of a set of testing variables
since it measures the ability of these tests in classifying elements in a specific group.
While assessing sensitivity, discriminant analysis also determines the relative
importance of the independent variables in classifying observations and to discard
variables with little importance in-group segregation. These applications of discriminant
analysis will help to select which of the potentially large number of variables related to
segmental motions during walking will be most important in assessing functional
recovery after a peripheral nerve injury in the rat. Therefore, this study evaluates the
sensitivity and specificity of ankle joint motion kinematic measures in detecting motion
abnormalities as a result of sciatic nerve crush by employing discriminant analysis.
Different levels of functional dysfunction in this study were established by evaluating
sciatic-crushed rats: 1) in the denervation phase (one week after injury), 2) in the
reinnervated phase: 12 weeks after injury, and 3) sham-operated controls.
Our fourth study (chapter 6) aimed to verify if active and passive exercise would elicit
changes in functional recovery after sciatic nerve crush detected by hindlimb
kinematics and nerve morphology. Progressive muscle atrophy and changes in muscle
fibres composition are consequences of peripheral nervous system injury that
interrupts communication between skeletal muscle and neurons. Many strategies have
been used to maintain the muscle activity during the time of reinnervation (46).
Exercise is an important activity in the management of neuromuscular disease. It might
improve return of sensorymotor function. Exercise performed after peripheral nerve
injury acts on muscle properties (histochemical muscle fiber alteration, contractile
properties, enzyme activities, and muscle weight) and nerve properties (axonal
regrowth and myelinization of axons). Most investigations have frequently used the
motorized treadmill in in vivo studies since it offers a controlled and convenient strategy
for testing and training. Twelve weeks after crush injury without exercise protocol,
functional recovery is not full and nerve morphology remains significant different in
control and injured animals as well as ankle joint motion during walk (47). Although
many studies have studied the effects of exercise in functional recovery, biomechanical
evaluation was not considered. Previous studies (48) suggested that functional
reinnervation of hindlimb muscles begins 2 or 3 weeks post sciatic nerve crush in rats
12 Functional Assessement After Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
and that overwork of muscle before this period can be harmful (41-45), but the reason
for the negative effect of exercise is still unknown. Therefore, in our study we
performed four groups of animals: two groups of animals started an exercise training
protocol 2 weeks after injury (week 2). Groups (1) sciatic-crushed rats that performed
treadmill walking; (2) sciatic-crushed rats that performed passive muscle stretch (3)
sham-operated controls and (4) sciatic-crushed controls. The exercise groups ended
the program at week-12 post injury. Each rat received 2 weeks of training before
surgery. All rats were subjected to walk/run with no incline at a treadmill speed of 10
m/min continuously, 30 min/day, for 5 days/week during 10 consecutive weeks.
Training was performed on a specially constructed treadmill for rodents developed in
our laboratory with a 10-lane motor-driven conveyer belt with adjustable speed and
inclination. Biomechanical analysis of rat walk was performed every 2 weeks on a
purpose-developed walkway integrating two miniature force plates and a motion
capture system with four high-speed Oqus cameras (Qualysis Systems).
Introduction and Main Objectives 13
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
REFERENCES
1. Rodrigues JM, Luís AL, Lobato JV, Pinto MV, Faustino A, Hussain NS, et al.
Intracellular Ca2+ concentration in the N1E-115 neuronal cell line and its use for
peripheric nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Acta médica portuguesa. 2005
;18(5):323-8.
2. Rodrigues JM, Luís AL, Lobato JV, Pinto MV, Lopes MA, Freitas M, et al.
Determination of the intracellular Ca2+ concentration in the N1E-115 neuronal
cell line in perspective of its use for peripheric nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Bio-
medical materials and engineering. 2005 Jan ;15(6):455-65.
3. Luis A, Amado S, Geuna S, Rodrigues J, Simoes M, Santos JD, et al. Long-term
functional and morphological assessment of a standardized rat sciatic nerve
crush injury with a non-serrated clamp [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience
methods. 2007 ;16392–104.
4. Luis AL, Rodrigues JM, Amado S, Veloso AP, Armada-Da-silva PAS, Raimondo
S, et al. PLGA 90/10 and caprolactone biodegradable nerve guides for the
reconstruction of the rat sciatic nerve [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2007 ;27(2):125–
137.
5. Luís AL, Amado S, Geuna S, Rodrigues JM, Simões MJ, Santos JD, et al. Long-
term functional and morphological assessment of a standardized rat sciatic
nerve crush injury with a non-serrated clamp. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience
methods. 2007 Jun ;163(1):92-104.
6. Schmidt CE, Leach JB. Neural tissue engineering: strategies for repair and
regeneration. [Internet]. Annual review of biomedical engineering. 2003 Jan
;5293-347.
7. Lundborg G, Dahlin L, Danielsen N, Zhao Q. Trophism, tropism, and specificity
in nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Journal of reconstructive microsurgery. 1994
Sep ;10(5):345-54.
8. Frykman GK, McMillan PJ, Yegge S. A review of experimental methods
measuring peripheral nerve regeneration in animals. [Internet]. The Orthopedic
clinics of North America. 1988 Jan ;19(1):209-19.
9. Mackinnon SE, Hudson AR, Hunter DA. Histologic assessment of nerve
regeneration in the rat. [Internet]. Plastic and reconstructive surgery. 1985 Mar
;75(3):384-8.
10. Sinis N, Schaller H-E, Becker ST, Lanaras T, Schulte-Eversum C, Müller H-W,
et al. Cross-chest median nerve transfer: a new model for the evaluation of
14 Functional Assessement After Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
nerve regeneration across a 40 mm gap in the rat. [Internet]. Journal of
neuroscience methods. 2006 Sep 30;156(1-2):166-72.
11. Papalia I, Tos P, Scevola A, Raimondo S, Geuna S. The ulnar test: a method for
the quantitative functional assessment of posttraumatic ulnar nerve recovery in
the rat. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience methods. 2006 Jun 30;154(1-2):198-
203.
12. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Geuna S, Patrício J a, Azevedo HR, Ferreira AJ, et
al. Functional assessment of sciatic nerve recovery: biodegradable poly (DLLA-
epsilon-CL) nerve guide filled with fresh skeletal muscle. [Internet].
Microsurgery. 2003 Jan ;23(4):346-53.
13. Nichols CM, Myckatyn TM, Rickman SR, Fox IK, Hadlock T, Mackinnon SE.
Choosing the correct functional assay: a comprehensive assessment of
functional tests in the rat. [Internet]. Behavioural brain research. 2005 Sep
;163(2):143-58.
14. Sedý J, Urdzíková L, Jendelová P, Syková E. Methods for behavioral testing of
spinal cord injured rats. [Internet]. Neuroscience and biobehavioral reviews.
2008 Jan ;32(3):550-80.
15. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Melo-Pinto P, Raimondo S,
et al. Functional and morphological assessment of a standardized rat sciatic
nerve crush injury with a non-serrated clamp. [Internet]. Journal of neurotrauma.
2004 Nov ;21(11):1652-70.
16. Perry J. Gait analysis: Normal and Pathological Function. SLACK Incorporated;
1992.
17. Basso DM, Beattie MS, Bresnahan JC. A sensitive and reliable locomotor rating
scale for open field testing in rats. [Internet]. Journal of neurotrauma. 1995 Feb
;12(1):1-21.
18. Basso DM. Experimental Spinal Cord Injury : Implications of Basic Science
Research for Human Spinal Cord Injury. 2000 ;80(8):808 - 817.
19. Medinaceli L de, Freed WJ, Wyatt RJ. An index of the functional condition of rat
sciatic nerve based on measurements made from walking tracks. [Internet].
Experimental neurology. 1982 Sep ;77(3):634-43.
20. Yu P, Matloub HS, Sanger JR, Narini P. Gait analysis in rats with peripheral
nerve injury. [Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 2001 Feb ;24(2):231-9.
21. Meek MF, Den Dunnen WF, Schakenraad JM, Robinson PH. Long-term
evaluation of functional nerve recovery after reconstruction with a thin-walled
biodegradable poly (DL-lactide-epsilon-caprolactone) nerve guide, using walking
Introduction and Main Objectives 15
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
track analysis and electrostimulation tests. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 1999 Jan
;19(5):247-53.
22. Bervar M. Video analysis of standing--an alternative footprint analysis to assess
functional loss following injury to the rat sciatic nerve. [Internet]. Journal of
neuroscience methods. 2000 Oct ;102(2):109-16.
23. Robertson GM, Hamill J, Caldwell G, Kamen G, Whittlesey S. Research
Methods in Biomechanics [Internet]. Human Kinetics Publishers; 2004.
24. Higgins S. Movement as an emergent form: Its structural limits [Internet]. Human
Movement Science. 1985 Jun ;4(2):119-148.
25. Santos PM, Williams SL, Thomas SS. Neuromuscular evaluation using rat gait
analysis. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience methods. 1995 ;61(1-2):79-84.
26. Lin FM, Pan YC, Hom C, Sabbahi M, Shenaq S. Ankle stance angle: a functional
index for the evaluation of sciatic nerve recovery after complete transection.
[Internet]. Journal of reconstructive microsurgery. 1996 Apr ;12(3):173-7.
27. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Gabriel RC, Filipe VM, et al.
Motion of the foot and ankle during the stance phase in rats. [Internet]. Muscle &
nerve. 2002 Nov ;26(5):630-5.
28. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Filipe VM, Gabriel RC, et al.
Ankle kinematics to evaluate functional recovery in crushed rat sciatic nerve
[Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 2003 ;27(6):706–714.
29. Ruiter GC de, Spinner RJ, Alaid AO, Koch AJ, Wang H, Malessy MJ a, et al.
Two-dimensional digital video ankle motion analysis for assessment of function
in the rat sciatic nerve model. [Internet]. Journal of the peripheral nervous
system : JPNS. 2007 Sep ;12(3):216-22.
30. Luís AL, Rodrigues JM, Geuna S, Amado S, Simões MJ, Fregnan F, et al.
Neural cell transplantation effects on sciatic nerve regeneration after a
standardized crush injury in the rat. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2008 Jan
;28(6):458-70.
31. Luís AL, Rodrigues JM, Geuna S, Amado S, Shirosaki Y, Lee JM, et al. Use of
PLGA 90:10 scaffolds enriched with in vitro-differentiated neural cells for
repairing rat sciatic nerve defects. [Internet]. Tissue engineering. Part A. 2008
Jun ;14(6):979-93.
32. Canu M-H, Garnier C. A 3D analysis of fore- and hindlimb motion during
overground and ladder walking: comparison of control and unloaded rats.
[Internet]. Experimental neurology. 2009 Jul ;218(1):98-108.
16 Functional Assessement After Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
33. Canu M-H, Garnier C, Lepoutre F-X, Falempin M. A 3D analysis of hindlimb
motion during treadmill locomotion in rats after a 14-day episode of simulated
microgravity. [Internet]. Behavioural brain research. 2005 Feb ;157(2):309-21.
34. Ruiter GCW de, Malessy MJ a, Alaid AO, Spinner RJ, Engelstad JK, Sorenson
EJ, et al. Misdirection of regenerating motor axons after nerve injury and repair
in the rat sciatic nerve model. [Internet]. Experimental neurology. 2008 Jun
;211(2):339-50.
35. Masters DB, Berde CB, Dutta SK, Griggs CT, Hu D, Kupsky W, et al. Prolonged
regional nerve blockade by controlled release of local anesthetic from a
biodegradable polymer matrix. [Internet]. Anesthesiology. 1993 Aug ;79(2):340-
6.
36. Thalhammer JG, Vladimirova M, Bershadsky B, Strichartz GR. Neurologic
Evaluation of the Rat during Sciatic Nerve Block with Lidocaine [Internet].
Anesthesiology. 1995 Apr ;82(4):1013-1025.
37. Sherrington CS. Flexion-reflex of the limb, crossed extension-reflex, and reflex
stepping and standing. [Internet]. The Journal of physiology. 1910 Apr ;40(1-
2):28-121.
38. Schouenborg J, Holmberg H, Weng HR. Functional organization of the
nociceptive withdrawal reflexes. II. Changes of excitability and receptive fields
after spinalization in the rat. [Internet]. Experimental brain research.
Experimentelle Hirnforschung. Expérimentation cérébrale. 1992 Jan ;90(3):469-
78.
39. Geuna S, Gigo-Benato D, Rodrigues A de C. On sampling and sampling errors
in histomorphometry of peripheral nerve fibers. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2004
Jan ;24(1):72-6.
40. Torch S, Usson Y, Saxod R. Automated morphometric study of human
peripheral nerves by image analysis. [Internet]. Pathology, research and
practice. 1989 Nov ;185(5):567-71.
41. Yuan Y, Zhang P, Yang Y, Wang X, Gu X. The interaction of Schwann cells with
chitosan membranes and fibers in vitro. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2004 Aug
;25(18):4273-8.
42. Wang W, Itoh S, Matsuda A, Ichinose S, Shinomiya K, Hata Y, et al. Influences
of mechanical properties and permeability on chitosan nano/microfiber mesh
tubes as a scaffold for nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Journal of biomedical
materials research. Part A. 2008 Feb ;84(2):557-66.
Introduction and Main Objectives 17
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
43. Chandy T, Sharma CP. Chitosan--as a biomaterial. [Internet]. Biomaterials,
artificial cells, and artificial organs. 1990 Jan ;18(1):1-24.
44. Shirosaki Y, Tsuru K, Hayakawa S, Osaka A, Lopes MA, Santos JD, et al. In
vitro cytocompatibility of MG63 cells on chitosan-organosiloxane hybrid
membranes. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2005 Feb ;26(5):485-93.
45. Yamaguchi I, Itoh S, Suzuki M, Osaka A, Tanaka J. The chitosan prepared from
crab tendons: II. The chitosan/apatite composites and their application to nerve
regeneration. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2003 Aug ;24(19):3285-92.
46. Mackinnon SE, Dellon AL, OʼBrien JP. Changes in nerve fiber numbers distal to
a nerve repair in the rat sciatic nerve model. [Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 1991
Nov ;14(11):1116-22.
47. Dellon AL, Mackinnon SE. Selection of the appropriate parameter to measure
neural regeneration. [Internet]. Annals of plastic surgery. 1989 Sep ;23(3):197-
202.
48. Marqueste T, Alliez J-R, Alluin O, Jammes Y, Decherchi P. Neuromuscular
rehabilitation by treadmill running or electrical stimulation after peripheral nerve
injury and repair. [Internet]. Journal of applied physiology (Bethesda, Md. :
1985). 2004 May ;96(5):1988-95.
49. Senel S, McClure SJ. Potential applications of chitosan in veterinary medicine.
[Internet]. Advanced drug delivery reviews. 2004 Jun ;56(10):1467-80.
Chapter 2 – Methodological considerations
20 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
1 Animals
During this chapter we will describe the methods used for the following chapters.
Experiments were performed in rats (Wistar or Sprague-Dawley) weighing 250-300g
(Charles River Laboratories, Barcelona, Spain). Animals were housed for 2 weeks
before entering the experiment and experimental groups were defined with six or eight
animals each depending on the study. Two animals were housed per cage (Makrolon
type 4, Tecniplast, VA, Italy), in a temperature and humidity controlled room with 12-
12h light / dark cycles, and were allowed normal cage activities under standard
laboratory conditions. The animals were fed with standard chow and water ad libitum.
Adequate measures were taken to minimize pain and discomfort taking into account
human endpoints for animal suffering and distress. Moreover, after surgical intervention
cage environment was enriched for all animals with the goal of minimize stress.
All procedures were performed with the approval of the Veterinary Authorities of
Portugal in accordance with the European Communities Council Directive of November
1986 (86/609/EEC).
Handling
The handling was performed to familiarize animals with the experimenter, with the
environment in which the studies would be performed, and with the manipulations
involved in the neurologic evaluation. This familiarization minimizes the stress-
response during the experimental period. The experimental animals were observed for
exploratory activity, and the latency of grooming was everyday monitored.
Chapter 2 – Methodological considerations 21
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
2 Microsurgical procedures
Our experimental work, concerning the in vivo testing of neurotmesis and axonotmesis
injury and regeneration, was based on the use of Sasco Sprague-Dawley rat sciatic
nerve. Usually, the surgeries are performed under an M-650 operating microscope
(Leica Microsystems, Wetzlar, Germany). Under deep anaesthesia (ketamine 9 mg/100
g; xylazine 1.25 mg/100 g, atropine 0.025 mg/100 body weight, intramuscular), the right
sciatic nerve is exposed through a skin incision extending from the greater trochanter
to the distal mid-half followed by a muscle splitting incision. After nerve mobilisation, a
transection injury is performed (neurotmesis) using straight microsurgical scissors. The
nerve must be injured at a level as low as possible, in general, immediately above the
terminal nerve ramification. For neurotmesis without gap, the nerve is reconstructed
with an end-to-end suture, with two epineural sutures using de 7/0 monofilament nylon.
For axonotmesis we used a standardized clamping procedure that was described in
details in previous works (1-4). After nerve mobilisation, a non-serrated clamp (Institute
of Industrial Electronic and Material Sciences, University of Technology, Vienna,
Austria) exerting a constant force of 54 N, was used for a period of 30 seconds to
create a 3-mm-long crush injury, 10 mm above the bifurcation into tibial and common
peroneal nerves (4; 5). The starting diameter of the sciatic nerve was about 1 mm,
flattening during the crush to 2 mm, giving a final pressure of p9 MPa. The nerves
were kept moist with 37ºC sterile saline solution throughout the surgical intervention.
Finally the skin and subcutaneous tissues are closed with a simple-interrupted suture
of a non-absorbable filament (Synthofil®, Ethicon). An antibiotic (enrofloxacin, Alsir®
2.5 %, 5 mg / kg b.w., subcutaneously) is always administered to prevent any
infections. To prevent autotomy a deterrent substance must be applied to rats’ right
foot (6; 7). All procedures must be performed with the approval of the Veterinary
Authorities of Portugal in accordance with the European Communities Council Directive
of November 1986 (86/609/EEC).
22 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
3 Methods for Functional Assessment of
Reinnervation
Biomechanical model - Kinematic analysis
The first step to perform a biomechanical analysis of body motion is the definition of a
mechanical rigid body model that is an idealized form of simplification the structural
differences of bones and represents a system. The definition of the numbers of body
segments is dependent on the movement that we want to analyze. To study ankle joint
movement during locomotion, we defined two rigid bodies: foot and shank.
Considering the computational setting used, to be possible to detect an object/body
moving, it must recognize the body that moves within a recognized and well-defined
area. Therefore, we have to define the 1) segments of the body we want to evaluate; 2)
the reference system;
Motion analysis software provides time-dependent quantitative data, which can be
obtained from stick figures or from volumetric models representing the animal body.
Digital video images record
Animals walked on a Perspex track with length, width and height of respectively 120,
12, and 15 cm (Figure 1). In order to ensure locomotion in a straight direction, the width
of the apparatus was adjusted to the size of the rats during the experiments, and a
darkened cage was connected at the end of the corridor to attract the animals. The
rats’ gait was video recorded at a rate of 100 Hz images per second (JVC GR-
DVL9800, New Jersey, USA). The camera was positioned at the track half-length
where gait velocity was steady, and 1 m distant from the track obtaining a visualization
field of 14 cm wide. Reference system was defined with four points to perform the area:
0.03m x0.015m.
Only walking trials with stance phases lasting between 150 and 400 ms were
considered for analysis, since this corresponds to the normal walking velocity of the rat
(20–60 cm/s) (8; 9).
Digital video images analysis - Two-dimensional joint kinematic analysis
The video images were stored in a computer hard disk for latter analysis using an
appropriate software APAS® (Ariel Performance Analysis System, Ariel Dynamics, San
Diego, USA). Image data were trimmed using APAS-Trimmer: five frames before Initial
contact of the fingers on the floor and five after Toe Off. Data were digitized manually
Chapter 2 – Methodological considerations 23
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
(APAS-Digitize and -Transform) to perform image representation and filtered with low
pass digital filter at 6 Hz (APAS filter) to determine coordinates for skin landmarks; and
to obtain kinematic parameters of angular displacement and velocity of joint using DLT
(Direct linear transformation) by Abdel-Aziz and Karara (1971). 2-D biomechanical
analysis (sagital plan) was carried out applying a two-segment model of the ankle joint,
adopted from the model firstly developed by Varejão and co-workers (9). Skin
landmarks were tattooed at 3 points: the proximal edge of the tibia, the lateral
malleolus and, the fifth metatarsal head (Figure 2). The definition of the segments foot
and shank was performed manually with digitalization of these points after selecting the
total frames that fulfilled the stance phase (Figure 3). The rats’ ankle angle was
determined using the scalar product between a vector representing the foot and a
vector representing the lower leg. Four complete walking cycles were analysed per rat.
With this model, positive and negative values of position of the ankle joint indicate
dorsiflexion and plantarflexion, respectively. For each stance phase the following time
points were identified (Figure 4): initial contact (IC), opposite toe-off (OT), heel-rise
(HR) and toe-off (TO) (10; 11), and were time normalized for 100% of the stance
phase. The normalized temporal parameters were averaged over all recorded trials.
Angular ankle’s velocity was also determined (negative values correspond to
dorsiflexion).
Figure 1- Track where animals walked, (Perspex 120cm length, 12cm width, and 15cm height)
24 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Figure 2 - Skin landmarks were tattooed at 3 points: the proximal edge of the tibia, the lateral
malleolus and, the fifth metatarsal head
Figure 3 - Video image of the stance phase of rats locomotion
Motion capture - Optoelectronic system
With technical advances in computer science and the continuous development of
mathematical models, biomechanical modeling has improved. Optoelectronic system of
infrared cameras (Oqus-300, Qualisys, Sweden) operating at a frame rate of 200Hz
tracks the motion of small reflective markers placed on the hindlimb using two infra-red
video cameras and has been used to quantify locomotor motion. To obtain three-
dimensional co-ordinate data for a marker, two cameras must record the marker
IC OT HR TOFigure 4 - Time points during stance phase: initial contact (IC), opposite toe-off (OT), heel-rise (HR)
and toe-off (TO)
Chapter 2 – Methodological considerations 25
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
position in space. Image-processing software identified the marker locations in each
two-dimensional infra-red camera image to compute its three-dimensional location
relative to a calibration plate that was positioned in the data collection corridor. Two
additional cameras can be used to ensure that data from at least two cameras is
always recorded. Prior to recording movements, the cameras must be calibrated by
way of an object with an array of markers whose positions in space are certified to a
known accuracy. Motion capture (MOCAP) allows the assessment of the instantaneous
positions of markers located on the surface of the skin and, thus, a kinematics analysis
of movement. Passive marker based systems use markers coated with a retroreflective
material to reflect light back that is generated near the cameras lens. The camera’s
threshold can be adjusted so only the bright reflective markers will be sampled. We
used an optoelectronic system of six infrared cameras (Oqus-300, Qualisys, Sweden)
operating at a frame rate of 200Hz was used to record the motion of right hindlimb
during the gait cycle. A new corridor was conceptualized and constructed with force
platform system with four load cells (two for vertical force component and two for
anterior-posterior force component) (Figure 5). Animals walked on a Perspex track with
length, width and height of respectively 120, 12 and 15cm. Two darkened cages were
connected at the extremities of the corridor to facilitate walking.
Figure 5 - Set-up of cameras and corridor for motion capture using optoelectronic system
After shaving, seven reflective markers with 2mm diameter were attached to the right
hindlimb at bony prominences (Figure 6): 1) tip of fourth finger, 2) head of fifth
metatarsal, 3) lateral malleolus, 4) lateral knee joint, 5) trochanter major, 6) anterior
superior iliac spine, and 7) ischial tuberosity. The same operator placed all markers
and the rat was maintained static in a similar position to the walking position with the
aim of minimizing the error introduced by the mobility of skin in relation to the bony
references. All rats previously performed two or three conditioning trials to be
familiarized with the corridor. Initial trials are often rejected because rats stop or rise on
26 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
their hindlimbs to explore the track. Sometimes another rat was placed inside the cage
to encourage the trial rat to walk along the track toward it. Cameras were positioned to
minimize light reflection artifacts and to allow recording 4-5 consecutive walking cycles,
defined as the time between two consecutive initial ground contacts (IC) of the right
fourth finger. The motion capture space was calibrated regularly using a fixed set of
markers and a wand of known length (20 cm) moved across the recorded field.
Calibration was accepted when the standard deviation of wand’s length measure was
below 0.4 mm.
Figure 6 - Reflective markers with 2mm diameter were attached to the right hindlimb at bony
prominences: (1) tip of fourth finger, (2) head of fifth metatarsal, (3) lateral malleolus, (4) lateral
knee joint, (5) trochanter major, (6) anterior superior iliac spine, and (7) ischial tuberosity and three
non-colinear markers.
Motion analysis - Two-dimensional joint kinematic analysis
In chapters 5 and 6, the kinematic analysis was performed with Visual3D software.
An absolute reference system (ARS), direction of lab co-ordinate, was defined: a right-
handed orthogonal triad <X, Y, Z> fixed in the track ground. Each of the axes is defined
as: +X axis pointing rightward, +Y axis pointing anteriorly and +Z axis pointing upward.
Additionally, a segmental reference system (SRS) is defined. This system uses
Cartesian coordinates fixed to the rigid body and also has clear anatomical meanings
such as proximal-distal, lateral-medial and anterior-posterior.
A gait cycle was defined as the time interval between two consecutive IC of the right
fifth metatarsal. The definition of a static position as a reference frame to define the
position of the segments was conventionally at TO event (Figure 7). Time events (IC
and TO) were detected manually during a first trial by analysing coordinate data from
head of fifth metatarsal marker. IC was defined when the data values became constant,
and TO when data values increased, with visual inspection of the movement. The axis
considered for analysis was that of the direction of locomotion. After the definition of
the event on the first cycle, it was applied a target pattern recognition for others trials of
the same group.
Chapter 2 – Methodological considerations 27
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
Six walking cycles were analyzed for each animal. Temporal parameters were
normalized to the total duration of the gait cycle. A spline interpolation (performing a
least-squares fit of a 3rd order polynomial to 10 points) and a 2nd order Butterworth
lowpass filter (cut-off frequency of 6Hz, determined by analysis of the difference
residuals between filtered and non-filtered data (12) were applied to the original marker
coordinates data. Joint angle and joint angular velocity were calculated by dot product
and first derivative of joint angle, respectively, between adjacent segments: shank and
foot for ankle joint; shank and thigh for the knee joint; thigh and pelvis for the hip joint.
Figure 7 - Reference frame to define the position of the segments, conventionally at TO event.
Sciatic Functional Index (SFI) and Static Sciatic Index (SSI)
For SFI, animals were tested in a confined walkway measuring 42-cm-long and 8.2-cm-
wide, with a dark shelter at the end. A white paper was placed on the floor of the rat
walking corridor. The hindpaws of the rats were pressed down onto a finger paint-
soaked sponge, and they were then allowed to walk down the corridor leaving its hind
footprints on the paper (Figure 8). Often, several walks were required to obtain clear
print marks of both feet. Prior to any surgical procedure, all rats were trained to walk in
the corridor, and a baseline walking track was recorded. Subsequently, walking tracks
were recorded every week until the week-8 postoperatively and then on weeks 10 and
12 or on weeks 16 and 20 for axonotmesis and neurotemesis injury, respectively.
28 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Several measurements were taken from the footprints (Figure 9): (I) distance from the
heel to the third toe, the print length (PL); (II) distance from the first to the fifth toe, the
toe spread (TS); and (III) distance from the second to the fourth toe, the intermediary
toe spread (ITS). For both dynamic (SFI) and static assessment (SSI), all
measurements were taken from the experimental (E) and normal (N) sides. Prints for
measurements were chosen at the time of walking based on clarity and completeness
at a point when the rat was walking briskly. The mean distances of three
measurements were used to calculate the following factors (dynamic and static):
Toe spread factor (TSF) = (ETS – NTS)/NTS
Intermediate toe spread factor (ITSF) = (EITS – NITS)/NITS
Print length factor (PLF) = (EPL – NPL)/NPL
Where the capital letters E and N indicate injured (experimental) and non-injured side
(normal), respectively.
SFI was calculated as described by (14) according to the Equation 1:
SFI = -38.3 (EPL – NPL)/NPL + 109.5(ETS-NTS)/NTS + 13.3(EIT-NIT)/NIT – 8.8 = (-
38.3 x PLF) + (109.5 x TSF) + (13.3 x ITSF) – 8.8
Equation 1 - SFI
Static footprints were obtained at least during four occasional rest periods. For the
sciatic static index (SSI) only the parameters TS and ITS, were measured (15)
(Equation 2).
SSI = [(108.44 x TSF) + (31.85 x ITSF)] - 5.49
Equation 2 – SSI
Figure 8 - Paint-soaked sponge and corridor where rats leave its hind footprints on the paper
(13).
Chapter 2 – Methodological considerations 29
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
Figure 9 - Measurements from the footprints: (PL) distance from the heel to the third toe, the print
length; (TS) distance from the first to the fifth toe, the toe spread; and (ITS) distance from the
second to the fourth toe, the intermediary toe spread (13).
For both SFI and SSI, an index score of 0 is considered normal and an index of -100
indicates total impairment. When no footprints were measurable, the index score of -
100 was given (11). Reproducible walking tracks could be measured from all rats. In
each walking track three footprints were analysed by a single observer, and the
average of the measurements was used in SFI calculations.
Extensor Postural Thrust (EPT) - Motor reflex function
The Extensor Postural Trust was originally proposed by Thalhammer and collaborators,
(17) as a part of the neurological recovery evaluation in the rat after sciatic nerve injury.
For EPT test, the entire body of the rat, except the hindlimbs, was wrapped in a
surgical towel and supported by the thorax (Figure 10). The affected hindlimb was then
lowered towards the platform of a digital balance (model PLS 510-3, Kern & Sohn
GmbH, Kern, Germany) to elicit the EPT. As the animal was lowered over the platform,
it extended the hindlimb, anticipating the contact made by the distal metatarsus and
digits. The force in grams applied to the digital platform balance was recorded (digital
scale range 0-500 g). The reduction in this force, representing reduced extensor
muscle tone, was considered a deficit of motor function. The same procedure was
applied to the contra-lateral, unaffected limb. The affected and normal limbs were
tested 3 times, with an interval of 2 minutes between consecutive tests, and the three
values were averaged to obtain a final result. The normal (unaffected limb) EPT
(NEPT) and experimental EPT (EEPT) values were incorporated into an equation
Equation (11) to derive the percentage of functional deficit, as described in the
literature by (16):
% Motor deficit = [(NEPT – EEPT)/NEPT] x 100
Equation (11) - EPT
Normal(N) Experimental(E)
30 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Figure 10 - Extensor Postural Thrust (13)
Withdrawal Reflex Latency - Nociception
The rat was wrapped in a surgical towel above its waist and then positioned to stand
with the affected hindpaw on a hotplate at 56ºC (Figure 12) (model 35-D; IITC Life
Science Instruments, Woodland Hill, CA). WRL is defined as the time elapsed from the
onset of hotplate contact to withdrawal of the hindpaw (Figure 11) and measured with a
stopwatch. Normal rats withdraw their paws from the hotplate within 4 seconds or less
(18). The affected limbs were tested three times, with an interval of 2 minutes between
consecutive tests to prevent sensitization, and the three latency times were averaged
to obtain a final result (19; 20). The cut off time for heat stimulation was set at 12
seconds to avoid skin damage to the foot (3; 21).
Figure 11 – WRL test (13).
Chapter 2 – Methodological considerations 31
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
Figure 12 - Hotplate for WRL test (13)
32 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
4 Morphological Evaluation
Design-based quantitative morphology and electron microscopy
After the follow-up time, rats were anaesthetised and a 10-mm-long segment of the
sciatic nerve that included the injured portion was collected, fixed, and prepared for
morphological analysis and histomorphometry of myelinated nerve fibers. A 10-mm
segment of uninjured sciatic nerve was also withdrawn from the control animals.
Immediately after collecting the nerve, rats were euthanized through an intracardiac
injection of 5% sodium pentobarbital (Eutasil®). Sciatic nerve samples were immersed
immediately in a fixation solution, containing 2.5% purified glutaraldehyde and 0.5%
saccarose in 0.1M Sorensen phosphate buffer for 6-8 hours. Specimens were then
washed in a solution containing 1.5% saccarose in 0.1M Sorensen phosphate buffer,
post-fixed in 2% osmium tetroxide, dehydrated and embedded in Glauerts' embedding
mixture of resins consisting in equal parts of Araldite M and the Araldite Härter, HY 964
(Merck, Darmstad, Germany), to which was added 1-2% of the accelerator 964, DY
064 (Merck, Darmstad, Germany). The plasticizer dibutyl phthalate was added in a
quantity of 0.5% (19; 20). Series of 2-µm thick semi-thin transverse sections were cut
using a Leica Ultracut UCT ultramicrotome (Leica Microsystems, Wetzlar, Germany)
and stained by Toluidine blue for 2-3 minutes for high resolution light microscopy
examination. In each nerve, histomorphometry was conducted using a DM4000B
microscope equipped with a DFC320 digital camera and an IM50 image manager
system (Leica Microsystems, Wetzlar, Germany). This system reproduced microscopic
images (obtained through a 100x oil-immersion objective) on the computer monitor at a
magnification adjusted by a digital zoom. The final magnification was 6600x enabling
accurate identification and morphometry analysis of myelinated nerve fibers. One semi-
thin section from each nerve was randomly selected and used for the morpho-
quantitative analysis. The total cross-sectional area of the nerve was measured and
sampling fields were then randomly selected using a protocol previously described (3;
21). Briefly, cross-sectional area of the nerve is divided into various equal geometric
fields (usually >15) and then each of these are divided into smaller fields. The first
sampling field is randomly selected and then the selection of the next fields was
defined through a systematic “jump” process. Possible "edge effects" (i.e. counting a
fibre more than once, especially for larger fibres that appear in more than one sampling
field) were compensated by employing a two-dimensional dissector procedure, which is
based on sampling the "tops" of fibers (22). Briefly, considering a two-dimensional
observational field where direction (North/South) is defined and the North top of each
Chapter 2 – Methodological considerations 33
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
fiber is marked. The top of each fiber represents the point of the shape of the fibre that
first intersects the observational field, and since it appears only once, therefore it will be
counted only once.
Mean fiber density was calculated by dividing the total number of nerve fibers within the
sampling field by its area (N/mm2). Total fibers number (N) was then estimated by
multiplying the mean fiber density by the total cross-sectional area of the whole nerve
cross section assuming a uniform distribution of nerve fibers across the entire section.
Fiber and axon area were measured and the circle-fitting diameter of fiber (D) and axon
(d) were calculated. These data were used to calculate myelin thickness [(D-d)/2],
myelin thickness/axon diameter ratio [(D-d)/2d], and fiber/axon diameter ratio (D/d).
The precision of the histomorphometry methods was evaluated by calculating the
coefficient of error (CE). Regarding quantitative estimates of fiber number, the CE(n)
was obtained as follows (23; 24):
'
1)(
QnCE
Equation 4 - quantitative estimates of fiber number
Where Q' is the number of counted fibers in all dissectors.
For size estimates, the coefficient of error was estimated as follows (22):
Mean
SEMzCE )(
Equation 5 - coefficient of error
Where SEM = standard error of the mean.
The sampling scheme was designed in order to keep the CE below 0.10, which
assures enough accuracy for neuromorphological studies (23; 24).
Transmission electron microscopy
The immunohistochemical technique is based on the use of antibodies that bind
specifically to certain cell antigen and thus became visible by fluorescence microscopy
or confocal laser. For this it is necessary to use certain fluorophores or fluorescent
probes to detect the antigen-antibody complexes. This technique allowed detection of
the axon regeneration and possible migration of Schwann cells within the guide tubes
or in biomaterials during the regeneration of peripheral nerve (26). By
immunhistochemistry, the antibodies used are anti-NF-200kd (antiprotein 200kd
neurofilament) and anti-GFAP (anti-glial protein). The first antibody will allow for tracing
of regenerating axons and the second, the possible migration of Schwann cells within
the guide tubes (27). Nowadays there are a number of antigens available, antigen-
antibody affinity, antibody types and methods of assessment and detection. However, it
34 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
is necessary that the method is assessed for each particular situation. For optical
microscopy, is usually used staining hematoxylin-eosin (28).
For transmission electron microscopy, ultra-thin sections were cut by means of the
same ultramicrotome and stained with saturated aqueous solution of uranyl acetate
and lead citrate. Ultra-thin sections were analyzed using a JEM-1010 transmission
electron microscope (JEOL, Tokyo, Japan) equipped with a Mega-View-III digital
camera and a Soft-Imaging-System (SIS, Münster, Germany) for the computerized
acquisition of the images.
Scanning electron microscope analysis
The surface morphology of the chitosan membranes was observed under a scanning
electron microscope (SEM; JEOL JSM 6301F) equipped with x-ray energy dispersive
spectroscopy (EDX) microanalysis capability (Voyager XRMA System, Noran
Instruments).
Cell culture, intracellular calcium concentration ([Ca2+]i) measurements and cell
adherence assays
N1E-115 cell line is a clone of cells derived from mouse neuroblastoma C-1300 [58]
and retains numerous biochemical, physiological, and morphological properties of
differentiated neuronal cells in culture [59]. N1E-115 neuronal cells were cultured in
poly-l-lisine coated Petri dishes (around 2 x 106 cells) on 2 x 2 cm chitosan fragments
(chitosan type I, type II and type III) at 37ºC, 5% CO2 in a humidified atmosphere
(Nuaire). Maintenance medium was 89.8% Dulbecco’s Modified Eagle’s Medium
(DMEM) supplemented with glutamine (GlutaMAX; Gibco), 10% fetal bovine serum
(FBS, Sigma), and 0.1% penicillin/streptomycin (100000 U/ml penicillin, 10 mg/ml
streptomycin; Sigma) and with 0.1% β-amphoterrycin (250 μg/ml, Sigma). The culture
medium was changed every 48 hours and the cells were observed daily in an inverted
microscope. Before surgery, once N1E-115 cell culture reached approximately 80%
confluence, cells were supplied with differentiation medium containing DMSO. The
differentiation medium was composed by 95.8% Dulbecco’s Modified Eagle’s Medium
(DMEM) supplemented with glutamine (GlutaMAX; Gibco), 2.5% FBS, 0.1%
penicillin/streptomycin (100000 U/ml penicillin, 10 mg/ml streptomycin; Sigma), 0.1% β-
amphoterrycin (250 μg/ml, Sigma), and 1.5% DMSO (Sigma). Cell culture viability was
assessed by measuring intracellular free calcium concentration ([Ca2+]i). The [Ca2+]i
Chapter 2 – Methodological considerations 35
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
was measured in Fura-2-AM-loaded cells, through dual wavelength spectrofluorometry
as previously described (22; 26). [Ca2+]i was determined in N1E-115 cell culture before
differentiation and 24, 48 and 72 hours after the onset of DMSO-induced differentiation,
in order to determine the best period of neural differentiation, before the [Ca2+]I rise and
the initiation of the apoptosis process.
36 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
REFERENCES
1. Luís AL, Amado S, Geuna S, Rodrigues JM, Simões MJ, Santos JD, et al. Long-
term functional and morphological assessment of a standardized rat sciatic
nerve crush injury with a non-serrated clamp. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience
methods. 2007 Jun ;163(1):92-104.
2. Luis AL, Rodrigues JM, Amado S, Veloso AP, Armada-Da-silva PAS, Raimondo
S, et al. PLGA 90/10 and caprolactone biodegradable nerve guides for the
reconstruction of the rat sciatic nerve [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2007 ;27(2):125–
137.
3. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Fornaro M, Geuna S, Giacobini-Robecchi
MG. Morphology of nerve fiber regeneration along a biodegradable poly (DLLA-
epsilon-CL) nerve guide filled with fresh skeletal muscle. [Internet]. Microsurgery.
2003 Jan ;23(4):338-45.
4. Varejão AS, Melo-Pinto P, Meek MF, Filipe VM, Bulas-Cruz J. Methods for the
experimental functional assessment of rat sciatic nerve regeneration. [Internet].
Neurological research. 2004 Mar ;26(2):186-94.
5. Beer GM, Steurer J, Meyer VE. Standardizing nerve crushes with a non-serrated
clamp. [Internet]. Journal of reconstructive microsurgery. 2001 Oct ;17(7):531-4.
6. Sporel-Ozakat RE, Edwards PM, Hepgul KT, Savas A, Gispen WH. A simple
method for reducing autotomy in rats after peripheral nerve lesions. [Internet].
Journal of neuroscience methods. 1991 Feb ;36(2-3):263-5.
7. Kerns JM, Braverman B, Mathew A, Lucchinetti C, Ivankovich AD. A comparison
of cryoprobe and crush lesions in the rat sciatic nerve. [Internet]. Pain. 1991 Oct
;47(1):31-9.
8. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Patricio JA, Bulas-Cruz J, Gabriel RC, Melo-Pinto P,
et al. Functional assessment of peripheral nerve recovery in the rat: gait
kinematics [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2001 ;21(8):383–388.
9. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Filipe VM, Gabriel RC, et al.
Ankle kinematics to evaluate functional recovery in crushed rat sciatic nerve
[Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 2003 ;27(6):706–714.
10. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Gabriel RC, Filipe VM, et al.
Motion of the foot and ankle during the stance phase in rats. [Internet]. Muscle &
nerve. 2002 Nov ;26(5):630-5.
11. Dijkstra JR, Meek MF, Robinson PH, Gramsbergen A. Methods to evaluate
functional nerve recovery in adult rats: walking track analysis, video analysis and
Chapter 2 – Methodological considerations 37
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
the withdrawal reflex. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience methods. 2000 Mar
;96(2):89-96.
12. Winter DA. Biomechanics and Motor Control of Human Movement [Internet].
Wiley; 2004.
13. Luis AL. Reparação de lesões do nervo periférico. 2008 Doctoral Thesis;
ICBAS-UP.
14. Bain JR, Mackinnon SE, Hunter DA. Functional evaluation of complete sciatic,
peroneal, and posterior tibial nerve lesions in the rat. [Internet]. Plastic and
reconstructive surgery. 1989 Jan ;83(1):129-38.
15. Bervar M. Video analysis of standing--an alternative footprint analysis to assess
functional loss following injury to the rat sciatic nerve. [Internet]. Journal of
neuroscience methods. 2000 Oct ;102(2):109-16.
16. Koka R, Hadlock TA. Quantification of functional recovery following rat sciatic
nerve transection. [Internet]. Experimental neurology. 2001 Mar ;168(1):192-5.
17. Thalhammer JG, Vladimirova M, Bershadsky B, Strichartz GR. Neurologic
Evaluation of the Rat during Sciatic Nerve Block with Lidocaine [Internet].
Anesthesiology. 1995 Apr ;82(4):1013-1025.
18. Hu D, Hu R, Berde CB. Neurologic evaluation of infant and adult rats before and
after sciatic nerve blockade. [Internet]. Anesthesiology. 1997 Apr ;86(4):957-65.
19. Shir Y, Campbell JN, Raja SN, Seltzer Z. The correlation between dietary soy
phytoestrogens and neuropathic pain behavior in rats after partial denervation.
[Internet]. Anesthesia and analgesia. 2002 Feb ;94(2):421-6.
20. Campbell JN. Nerve lesions and the generation of pain. [Internet]. Muscle &
nerve. 2001 Oct ;24(10):1261-73.
21. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Geuna S, Patrício J a, Azevedo HR, Ferreira AJ, et al.
Functional assessment of sciatic nerve recovery: biodegradable poly (DLLA-
epsilon-CL) nerve guide filled with fresh skeletal muscle. [Internet]. Microsurgery.
2003 Jan ;23(4):346-53.
22. Geuna S, Tos P, Battiston B, Guglielmone R. Verification of the two-dimensional
disector, a method for the unbiased estimation of density and number of
myelinated nerve fibers in peripheral nerves. [Internet]. Annals of anatomy =
Anatomischer Anzeiger : official organ of the Anatomische Gesellschaft. 2000
Jan ;182(1):23-34.
23. Geuna S, Gigo-Benato D, Rodrigues A de C. On sampling and sampling errors
in histomorphometry of peripheral nerve fibers. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2004
Jan ;24(1):72-6.
38 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
24. Schmitz C. Variation of fractionator estimates and its prediction. [Internet].
Anatomy and embryology. 1998 Nov ;198(5):371-97.
25. Di Scipio F, Raimondo S, Tos P, Geuna S. A simple protocol for paraffin-
embedded myelin sheath staining with osmium tetroxide for light microscope
observation. [Internet]. Microscopy research and technique. 2008 Jul ;71(7):497-
502.
26. Geuna S, Tos P, Guglielmone R, Battiston B, Giacobini-Robecchi MG.
Methodological issues in size estimation of myelinated nerve fibers in peripheral
nerves. [Internet]. Anatomy and embryology. 2001 Jul ;204(1):1-10.
27. Raimondo S, Fornaro M, Di Scipio F, Ronchi G, Giacobini-Robecchi MG, Geuna
S. Chapter 5: Methods and protocols in peripheral nerve regeneration
experimental research: part II-morphological techniques. [Internet]. International
review of neurobiology. 2009 Jan ;8781-103.
28. Luís AL, Rodrigues JM, Geuna S, Amado S, Simões MJ, Fregnan F, et al.
Neural cell transplantation effects on sciatic nerve regeneration after a
standardized crush injury in the rat. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2008 Jan
;28(6):458-70.
Chapter 3 - Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and
N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model
Amado S, Simões MJ, Armada da Silva PAS, Luís AL, Shirosaki Y, Lopes MA, et al.
Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve
regeneration in an axonotmesis rat model. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2008 Nov;
29(33):4409-19 DOI: 10.1016/j.biomaterials.2008.07.043.
40 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
1 Introduction
Peripheral nerve injuries are a frequent pathology in today’s society (1). Despite recent
progress in peripheral nerve trauma management, recovery of functional parameters is
usually far from normal, even for the most skilled surgeons, and thus much attention is
being paid to nerve regeneration research (2; 3).
The experimental model based on the induction of a crush injury (axonotmesis) in the
rat sciatic nerve provides a very realistic testing bench for lesions involving
plurifascicular mixed nerves with axons of different size and type competing to reach
and re-innervate distal targets (4; 5). After a lesion of axonotmesis, the distal nerve
fragment undergoes a process named Wallerian degeneration, which leads to the
degradation of axons and myelin sheaths and creates a favourable environment for
nerve regeneration (6-9). Both macrophages and Schwann cells are locally recruited to
eliminate axonal and myelin fragments. While distal stump degenerates, the proximal
stump initiates the regeneration process - the axonal ends elongate in order to reach
the distal stump and Schwann cells differentiate and multiply, being responsible for the
ensheathing and myelination of the newly sprouted axons (6; 7; 9-12). This type of
injury is thus appropriate to investigate the cellular and molecular mechanisms of
peripheral nerve regeneration, to assess the role of different factors in the regeneration
process (13) and to perform preliminary in vivo testing of biomaterials that will be useful
in tube-guide fabrication for more serious injuries of the peripheral nerve, such as
neurotmesis.
Autologous nerve grafting is the gold standard to reconstruct a large defect in a
peripheral nerve, but with some important disadvantages, such as availability of the
donor site and complications related to its sacrifice, inadequate recovery of function
and aberrant regeneration (14-21). Nowadays, the use of entubulation has attempted
to overcome these problems. A cylinder-shaped tube is placed between the nerve
ends, not only allowing orientation of growing nerve fibres, but also enabling the
incorporation of substances, either molecules or cells, that enhance nerve regeneration
(16; 21; 22). Among the various materials than can be used in the composition of the
tube guides, biodegradable substances offer two important advantages: one surgical
step is saved, as they avoid the need to be removed as required for autologus tissue
transplantation and it is possible to modulate the time of degradation according to the
axonal regeneration time diminishing inflammation on the lesion site. Thus, a major
challenge in tissue engineering is to create adequate scaffolds that are capable of
replace the autografts techniques. As far as peripheral nerve regeneration is
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 41
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
concerned, a wide range of substances have been developed to meet this purpose (16;
21; 25; 26).
There are many properties required for desirable nerve guided conduit. They include
permeability that prevents fibrous scar tissue invasion but allow nutrient and oxygen
supply, revascularization to improve nutrient and oxygen supply, mechanical strengths
to maintain a stable support structure for the nerve regeneration, immunological
inertness with surrounding tissues, biodegradability to prevent chronic inflammatory
response and pain by nerve compression, easy regulation of conduit diameter and wall
thickness, and surgical amenability (26). The degradation rate of these biomaterials
should be related to the axonal regeneration time. Among the various substances
proposed for the fashioning of nerve conduits, chitosan has recently attracted particular
attention because of its biocompatibility, biodegradability, low toxicity, low cost,
enhancement of wound-healing and antibacterial effects(27). In addition, the potential
usefulness of chitosan in nerve regeneration have been demonstrated both in vitro and
in vivo (28-34). Chitosan is a partially deacetylated polymer of acetyl glucosamine
obtained after the alkaline deacetylation of chitin (35). Chitosan matrices have been
shown to have low mechanical strength under physiological conditions and to be
unable to maintain a predefined shape for transplantation, which has limited their use
as nerve guidance conduits in clinical applications. The improvement of their
mechanical properties can be achieved by modifying chitosan with a silane agent. γ-
glycidoxypropyltrimethoxysilane (GPTMS) is one of the silane-coupling agents, which
has epoxy and methoxysilane groups. The epoxy group reacts with the amino groups
of chitosan molecules, while the methoxysilane groups are hydrolyzed and form silanol
groups, and the silanol groups are subjected to the construction of a siloxane network
due to the condensation. Thus, the mechanical strength of chitosan can be improved
by the crosslinking between chitosan and GPTMS and siloxane network. Chitosan and
chitosan-based materials have been proven to promote adhesion, survival, and neurite
outgrowth of neural cells (36; 37).
Together with scaffolds, neurotrophic factors have also been the target of intensive
research - their role in nerve regeneration and the way they influence neural
development, survival, outgrowth, and branching (20). Among neurotrophic factors,
neurotrophins have been heavily investigated in nerve regeneration studies. They
include the nerve growth factor (NGF), brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF),
neurotrophin-3 (NT-3), and neurotrophin-4/5 (NT-4/5)(38). Neurotrophic factors
promote a variety of neural responses, including survival and outgrowth of the motor
and sensory nerve fibers, and spinal cord regeneration (22; 39). However, in vivo
42 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
responses to neurotrophic factors can vary due to the method of their delivering.
Therefore, the development and use of controlled delivery devices are required for the
study of complex systems. N1E-115 cell line that undergoes neuronal differentiation in
response to either dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO), adenosine 3’5’-cyclic monophosphate
(cAMP) or serum withdrawal is an important cellular system to locally produce and
deliver neurotrophic factors (40; 41).
Based on this premises, the aim of the study was to bring together two of the more
promising recent trends in nerve regeneration research: 1) local enwrapping of the
lesion site of axonotmesis by means of hybrid chitosan membranes; 2) application of a
cell delivery system to improve local secretion of neurotrophic factors.
First, types I, II and III chitosan membranes were screened by an in vitro assay. Then,
membranes were evaluated in vivo to assess their biocompatibility and their effects on
nerve fiber regeneration and nerve recovery in a standardized rat sciatic nerve crush
injury model (42; 43).
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 43
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
2 Materials and methods
2.1 Preparation of chitosan membranes
Chitosan (high molecular weight, Aldrich®, USA) was dissolved in 0.25M acetic acid
aqueous solution to a concentration of 2% (w/v). To obtain type II and type III
membranes, GPTMS (Aldrich®, USA) was also added to the chitosan solution and
stirred at room temperature for 1h. The solutions for type I and II chitosan membranes
were then poured into polypropylene containers with cover, and aged at 60°C for 2
days. The drying process for type III chitosan membrane was significantly different: the
solutions were frozen for 24h at -20°C and then transferred to the freeze-dryer, where
they were left 12h to complete dryness. The chitosan membranes (type I, II and III)
were soaked in 0.25N sodium hydroxide aqueous solution to neutralize remaining
acetic acid, washed well with distilled water, and dried again at 60°C for 2 days (type I
and II) or freeze dried (type III). All membranes were sterilized with ethylene oxide gas,
considered by some authors the most suitable method of sterilization for chitosan
membranes (44). Prior to their use in vivo, membranes were kept during 1 week at
room temperature in order to clear any ethylene oxide gas remnants.
Scanning electron microscope analysis
The surface morphology of the chitosan membranes was observed under a scanning
electron microscope (SEM; JEOL JSM 6301F) equipped with x-ray energy dispersive
spectroscopy (EDX) microanalysis capability (Voyager XRMA System, Noran
Instruments).
Cell culture, intracellular calcium concentration ([Ca2+]i) measurements and cell
adherence assays
N1E-115 is a clone of cells derived from mouse neuroblastoma C-1300 (45) and
retains numerous biochemical, physiological, and morphological properties of
differentiated neuronal cells in culture (46). N1E-115 neuronal cells were cultured in
poly-l-lisine coated Petri dishes (around 2 x 106 cells) on 2 x 2 cm chitosan fragments
(chitosan type I, type II and type III) at 37ºC, 5% CO2 in a humidified atmosphere
(Nuaire). Maintenance medium was 89.8% Dulbecco’s Modified Eagle’s Medium
(DMEM) supplemented with glutamine (GlutaMAX; Gibco), 10% fetal bovine serum
(FBS, Sigma), 0.1% penicillin/streptomycin (100000 U/ml penicillin, 10 mg/ml
44 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
streptomycin; Sigma) and with 0.1% β-amphoterrycin (250 μg/ml, Sigma). The culture
medium was changed every 48 hours and the cells were observed daily in an inverted
microscope. Before surgery, once N1E-115 cell culture reached approximately 80%
confluence, cells were supplied with differentiation medium containing DMSO. The
differentiation medium was composed by 95.8% Dulbecco’s Modified Eagle’s Medium
(DMEM) supplemented with glutamine (GlutaMAX; Gibco), 2.5% FBS, 0.1%
penicillin/streptomycin (100000 U/ml penicillin, 10 mg/ml streptomycin; Sigma), 0.1% β-
amphoterrycin (250 μg/ml, Sigma), and 1.5% DMSO (Sigma). Cell culture viability was
assessed by measuring intracellular free calcium concentration ([Ca2+]i). The [Ca2+]i
was measured in Fura-2-AM-loaded cells, through dual wavelength spectrofluorometry
as previously described (24). [Ca2+]i was determined in N1E-115 cell culture before
differentiation and 48 hours after the onset of DMSO-induced differentiation.
In vivo assays
All procedures were performed with the approval of the Veterinary Authorities of
Portugal in accordance with the European Communities Council Directive of November
1986 (86/609/EEC).
Figure 13 - The picture shows the dorsal incisions made on the dorsal
area of the four Wistar rats, to test the biocompatibility of the chitosan
membranes: 1 (left cranial incision), type I chitosan membrane; 2 (mid-
right incision), type II chitosan membrane; 3 (left caudal incision), type III
chitosan membrane
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 45
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
Biocompatibility assay
Prior to their use on crushed sciatic nerves, the three types of chitosan membranes
were tested in vivo to assess their biocompatibility: 4 adult female Wistar rats were
used. On each one, under general anaesthesia, 3 longitudinal dorsal incisions, 3 cm-
long, were made and 2 x 2 cm fragments were implanted (Figure 13). Animals were
sacrificed on weeks one, two, four and eight. The membrane remnants were collected
together with skin and subcutaneous tissues and were fixed in a 10% formaldehyde
solution for later histological analysis. Throughout the 8-week follow-up time, all
animals remained healthy, and none developed local or systemic signs of infection
and/or inflammation.
Nerve regeneration assay
In vivo nerve regeneration assay was carried out in types II and III chitosan
membranes only because of the higher elasticity which proved to facilitate surgery. A
total of 36 adult female Wistar rats (Charles River Laboratories, Barcelona, Spain)
weighing approximately 250g at the start of the experiment were used. The animals
were divided by six experimental groups of six animals each. Animals were housed two
animals per cage (Makrolon type 4, Tecniplast, VA, Italy), in a temperature and
humidity controlled room with 12-12h light / dark cycles, and were allowed normal cage
activities under standard laboratory conditions. The animals were fed with standard
chow and water ad libitum. Adequate measures were taken to minimize pain and
discomfort taking into account human endpoints for animal suffering and distress.
Animals were housed for 2 weeks before entering the experiment. All procedures were
performed with the approval from the Veterinary Authorities of Portugal, and in
accordance with the European Communities Council Directive of 24 November 1986
(86/609/EEC). The experimental groups were set according to treatment after nerve
sciatic crush injury. Therefore, in one group the animals recovered from the sciatic
crush injury without any other intervention (Crush). In other two groups, the crushed
sciatic nerve was encircled by a type II chitosan membrane either alone (ChitosanII) or
covered with a monolayer of N1E-115 cells, differentiated in vitro (ChitosanIICell). In
the remaining two groups, type III chitosan was used alone (ChitosanIII) or covered by
N1E-115 cells (ChitosanIIICell). Finally, an additional group of unoperated animals was
used as control for nerve histological analysis. The standardized crush injury was
carried out with the animals placed prone under sterile conditions and the skin from the
46 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
clipped lateral right thigh scrubbed in a routine fashion with antiseptic solution. Under
deep anaesthesia [ketamine (Imalgene 1000®) 9 mg/100 g; xylazine (Rompun®), 1.25
mg/100 g, atropine 0.025 mg/100 g body weight, IP], the right sciatic nerve was
exposed unilaterally through a skin incision extending from the greater trochanter to the
mid-thigh followed by a muscle splitting incision. After nerve mobilisation, a non-
serrated clamp (Institute of Industrial Electronic and Material Sciences, University of
Technology, Vienna, Austria) exerting a constant force of 54 N, was used for a period
of 30 seconds to create a 3-mm-long crush injury, 10 mm above the bifurcation into
tibial and common peroneal nerves (16; 20). The starting diameter of the sciatic nerve
was about 1 mm, flattening during the crush to 2 mm, giving a final pressure of p9
MPa. The nerves were kept moist with 37ºC sterile saline solution throughout the
surgical intervention. Muscle and skin were then closed with 4/0 resorbable sutures.
The surgical procedure was performed with the aid of an M-650 operating microscope
(Leica Microsystems, Wetzlar, Germany). To prevent autotomy, a deterrent substance
was applied to rats’ right foot (21; 25). The animals were intensively examined for signs
of autotomy and contracture and none presented severe wounds (absence of a part of
the foot or severe infection) or contractures during the study.
2.2 Functional Assessment of Reinnervation
Motor performance and nociceptive function
All animals were tested preoperatively (week 0), and every week until week 8 and then
every two weeks until the end of the 12-week follow-up time. Animals were gently
handled, and tested in a quiet environment to minimize stress levels. Motor
performance and nociceptive function were evaluated by measuring extensor postural
thrust (EPT) and withdrawal reflex latency (WRL), respectively. For EPT test, the entire
body of the rat, except the hindlimbs, was wrapped in a surgical towel and supported
by the thorax. The affected hindlimb was then lowered towards the platform of a digital
balance (model PLS 510-3, Kern & Sohn GmbH, Kern, Germany) to elicit the EPT. As
the animal was lowered over the platform, it extended the hindlimb, anticipating the
contact made by the distal metatarsus and digits. The force in grams applied to the
digital platform balance was recorded (digital scale range 0-500 g). The same
procedure was applied to the contra-lateral, unaffected limb. The affected and normal
limbs were tested 3 times, with an interval of 2 minutes between consecutive tests, and
the three values were averaged to obtain a final result. The normal (unaffected limb)
EPT (NEPT) and experimental EPT (EEPT) values were incorporated into an equation
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 47
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
Equation 3) to derive the percentage of functional deficit, as described in the literature
(27):
% Motor deficit = [(NEPT – EEPT)/NEPT] x 100
Equation 3 – EPT formula
The nociceptive withdrawal reflex (WRL) was adapted from the hotplate test as
described by Masters et al. (47). The rat was wrapped in a surgical towel above its
waist and then positioned to stand with the affected hindpaw on a hotplate at 56ºC
(model 35-D; IITC Life Science Instruments, Woodland Hill, CA). WRL is defined as the
time elapsed from the onset of hotplate contact to withdrawal of the hindpaw and
measured with a stopwatch. Normal rats withdraw their paws from the hotplate within 4
seconds or less (28). The affected limbs were tested three times, with an interval of 2
minutes between consecutive tests to prevent sensitization, and the three latency times
were averaged to obtain a final result (22). The cut off time for heat stimulation was set
at 12 seconds to avoid skin damage to the foot (28).
Sciatic Functional Index (SFI) and Static Sciatic Index (SSI)
For SFI, animals were tested in a confined walkway measuring 42-cm-long and 8.2-cm-
wide, with a dark shelter at the end. A white paper was placed on the floor of the rat
walking corridor. The hindpaws of the rats were pressed down onto a finger paint-
soaked sponge, and they were then allowed to walk down the corridor leaving its hind
footprints on the paper. Often, several walks were required to obtain clear print marks
of both feet. Prior to any surgical procedure, all rats were trained to walk in the corridor,
and a baseline walking track was recorded. Subsequently, walking tracks were
recorded every week until the week-8 postoperatively and then on weeks 10 and 12.
Several measurements were taken from the footprints: (I) distance from the heel to the
third toe, the print length (PL); (II) distance from the first to the fifth toe, the toe spread
(TS); and (III) distance from the second to the fourth toe, the intermediary toe spread
(ITS). For both dynamic (SFI) and static assessment (SSI), all measurements were
taken from the experimental (E) and normal (N) sides. Prints for measurements were
chosen at the time of walking based on clarity and completeness at a point when the
rat was walking briskly. The mean distances of three measurements were used to
calculate the following factors (dynamic and static):
Toe spread factor (TSF) = (ETS – NTS)/NTS
Intermediate toe spread factor (ITSF) = (EITS – NITS)/NITS
Print length factor (PLF) = (EPL – NPL)/NPL
48 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Where the capital letters E and N indicate injured (experimental) and non-injured side
(normal), respectively.
SFI was calculated as described by Bain et al. (30) according to the following equation
Equation 4):
SFI = -38.3 (EPL – NPL)/NPL + 109.5(ETS-NTS)/NTS + 13.3(EIT-NIT)/NIT – 8.8 = (-
38.3 x PLF) + (109.5 x TSF) + (13.3 x ITSF) – 8.8
Equation 4- SFI formula
Static footprints were obtained at least during four occasional rest periods. For the
sciatic static index (SSI) only the parameters TS and ITS, were measured (31):
SSI = [(108.44 x TSF) + (31.85 x ITSF)] - 5.49
Equation 5 –SSI formula
For both SFI and SSI, an index score of 0 is considered normal and an index of -100
indicates total impairment. When no footprints were measurable, the index score of -
100 was given (32). Reproducible walking tracks could be measured from all rats. In
each walking track three footprints were analysed by a single observer, and the
average of the measurements was used in SFI calculations.
Kinematic analysis
Ankle kinematics and stance duration analysis were carried out prior to nerve injury
and on weeks one, four, eight and twelve of recovery. Animals walked on a perspex
track with length, width and height of respectively 120, 12, and 15 cm. In order to
ensure locomotion in a straight direction, the width of the apparatus was adjusted to the
size of the rats during the experiments, and a darkened cage was connected at the end
of the corridor to attract the animals. The rats’ gait was video recorded at a rate of 100
Hz images per second (JVC GR-DVL9800, New Jersey, USA). The camera was
positioned at the track half length where gait velocity was steady, and 1 m distant from
the track obtaining a visualization field of 14 cm wide. Only walking trials with stance
phases lasting between 150 and 400 ms were considered for analysis, since this
corresponds to the normal walking velocity of the rat (20–60 cm/s) (33; 34; 48). The
video images were stored in a computer hard disk for latter analysis using an
appropriate software APAS® (Ariel Performance Analysis System, Ariel Dynamics, San
Diego, USA). 2-D biomechanical analysis (sagittal plan) was carried out applying a two-
segment model of the ankle joint, adopted from the model firstly developed by Varejão
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 49
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
et al. (48). Skin landmarks were tattooed at 3 points: the proximal edge of the tibia, the
lateral malleolus and, the fifth metatarsal head. The rats’ ankle angle was determined
using the scalar product between a vector representing the foot and a vector
representing the lower leg. Four complete walking cycles were analysed per rat. With
this model, positive and negative values of position of the ankle joint indicate
dorsiflexion and plantarflexion, respectively. For each stance phase the following time
points were identified: initial contact (IC), opposite toe-off (OT), heel-rise (HR) and toe-
off (TO) (34; 48), and were time normalized for 100% of the stance phase. The
normalized temporal parameters were averaged over all recorded trials. Angular
ankle’s velocity was also determined (negative values correspond to dorsiflexion).
2.3 Design-based quantitative morphology and electron
microscopy
After the 12-week follow-up time, rats were anaesthetised and a 10-mm-long segment
of the sciatic nerve that included the injured portion was collected, fixed, and prepared
for morphological analysis and histomorphometry of myelinated nerve fibers. A 10-mm
segment of uninjured sciatic nerve was also withdrawn from the 6 control animals.
Immediately after collecting the nerve, rats were euthanized through an intracardiac
injection of 5% sodium pentobarbital (Eutasil®). Sciatic nerve samples were immersed
immediately in a fixation solution, containing 2.5% purified glutaraldehyde and 0.5%
saccarose in 0.1M Sorensen phosphate buffer for 6-8 hours. Specimens were then
washed in a solution containing 1.5% saccarose in 0.1M Sorensen phosphate buffer,
post-fixed in 2% osmium tetroxide, dehydrated and embedded in Glauerts' embedding
mixture of resins consisting in equal parts of Araldite M and the Araldite Härter, HY 964
(Merck, Darmstad, Germany), to which was added 1-2% of the accelerator 964, DY
064 (Merck, Darmstad, Germany). The plasticizer dibutyl phthalate was added in a
quantity of 0.5% [75]. Series of 2-µm thick semi-thin transverse sections were cut using
a Leica Ultracut UCT ultramicrotome (Leica Microsystems, Wetzlar, Germany) and
stained by Toluidine blue for 2-3 minutes for high resolution light microscopy
examination. In each nerve, histomorphometry was conducted using a DM4000B
microscope equipped with a DFC320 digital camera and an IM50 image manager
system (Leica Microsystems, Wetzlar, Germany). This system reproduced microscopic
images (obtained through a 100x oil-immersion objective) on the computer monitor at a
magnification adjusted by a digital zoom. The final magnification was 6600x enabling
50 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
accurate identification and morphometry analysis of myelinated nerve fibers. One semi-
thin section from each nerve was randomly selected and used for the morpho-
quantitative analysis. The total cross-sectional area of the nerve was measured and
sampling fields were then randomly selected using a protocol previously described
(37). Possible "edge effects" were compensated by employing a two-dimensional
dissector procedure which is based on sampling the "tops" of fibers (37). Mean fiber
density was calculated by dividing the total number of nerve fibers within the sampling
field by its area (N/mm2). Total fibers number (N) was then estimated by multiplying the
mean fiber density by the total cross-sectional area of the whole nerve cross section
assuming a uniform distribution of nerve fibers across the entire section. Fiber and
axon area were measured and the circle-fitting diameter of fiber (D) and axon (d) were
calculated. These data were used to calculate myelin thickness [(D-d)/2], myelin
thickness/axon diameter ratio [(D-d)/2d], and fiber/axon diameter ratio (D/d). The
precision of the histomorphometry methods was evaluated by calculating the coefficient
of error (CE). Regarding quantitative estimates of fiber number, the CE(n) was
obtained as follows in Equation 6 (37):
'
1)(
QnCE
Equation 6 - quantitative estimates of fiber number
Where Q' is the number of counted fibers in all dissectors.
For size estimates, the coefficient of error was estimated as follows in Equation 7 (36):
Mean
SEMzCE )(
Equation 7 - coefficient of error
Where SEM = standard error of the mean.
The sampling scheme was designed in order to keep the CE below 0.10, which
assures enough accuracy for neuromorphological studies (49).
For transmission electron microscopy, ultra-thin sections were cut by means of the
same ultramicrotome and stained with saturated aqueous solution of uranyl acetate
and lead citrate. Ultra-thin sections were analyzed using a JEM-1010 transmission
electron microscope (JEOL, Tokyo, Japan) equipped with a Mega-View-III digital
camera and a Soft-Imaging-System (SIS, Münster, Germany) for the computerized
acquisition of the images.
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 51
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
3 Statistics
Two-way mixed factorial ANOVA was used to test for the effect of time (within subjects
effect) and group (between subjects effect). Sphericity was evaluated by the Mauchly’s
test and when this assumption was not satisfied, the degrees of freedom were
corrected by using the more conservative Greenhouse-Geiser’s epsilon. Differences
between pre-surgery results and those obtained throughout the 12-week recovery
period were systematically assessed by applying planned contrasts (General Linear
Model, simple contrasts). The effect of the chitosan membrane alone or associated to
N1E-115 differentiated cells was then evaluated through two way mixed factorial
ANOVA. For histomorphometry, statistical comparisons of quantitative data were
subjected to one-way ANOVA test. MANOVA analysis was employed to assess
differences in functional recovery between the experimental groups. Statistical
significance was established as p<0.05. All statistical procedures were performed by
using the statistical package SPSS (version 14.0, SPSS, Inc) except histomorphometry
data that was analysed using the software “Statistica per discipline bio-mediche”
(McGraw-Hill, Milan, Italy). All data in this study is presented as mean standard error
of the mean (SEM).
52 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
4 Results
4.1 In vitro results and SEM analysis of chitosan membranes
Results obtained from epifluorescence technique are referred to measurements from
non-differentiated N1E-115 cells and after 48h of differentiation in the presence of 1.5%
DMSO. The mean value of [Ca2+]i in non-differentiated N1E-115 cells (N = number of
cells submitted to [Ca2+]i measurement) was 39.9 ± 3.4 nM (N = 15), 35.9 ± 3.2 nM (N =
15) and 40.2 ± 2.9 nM (N = 15), for cultures over chitosan membranes, type I,II and III,
respectively. Values of [Ca2+]i for N1E-115 cells after 48h of differentiation in the
presence of 1.5% DMSO were 42.9 ± 5.1 nM (N = 15), 44.3 ± 4.8 nM (N = 15) and 41.6
± 4.3 nM (N = 15), for cultures over chitosan membranes, type I,II and III, respectively.
All these values are not statistically different for p<0.05, and correspond to [Ca2+]i from
cells that did not begin the apoptosis process besides the evident neural differentiation.
According to this fact, it is reasonable to conclude that chitosan membranes, previously
presented as type I, II and III, were a viable substrate for N1E-115 neuronal cell line
adhesion, multiplication and differentiation.
Figure 14 shows the SEM microstructure of type II Figure 14A) and type III (Figure
14B) chitosan membranes, respectively. The drying techniques employed to prepare
the membranes were freeze-drying (type III) and the conventional thermal drying (type I
and type II), which led to extremely dissimilar microstructural and mechanical
properties. In this study, the chitosan membranes type III have about 110 µm pores
and about 90% of porosity.
Figure 14 - Scanning electron microscopy microstructure of chitosan membranes. (A) Type II chitosan
membrane. (B) Type III chitosan membrane, showing a more porous microstructure, when compared to Type
II chitosan membrane
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 53
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
4.2 In vivo biocompatibility results
Despite the same composition, type II and type III membranes presented a distinct
behavior: the latter elicited an exuberant cellular infiltrate composed in a large extent by
multinucleated giant cells and some mast cells, whereas type II chitosan elicited a mild
fibrous capsule and a discrete inflammatory reaction. Type III chitosan membranes
underwent a completely different aging process, the so called freeze drying. This
lyophilisation procedure resulted in highly porous membranes: after freezing and
lyophilisation, the spaces formerly occupied by the solvent were left emptied so these
porous membranes presented a superior surface/volume ratio, when compared to the
type I and type II chitosan membranes. As surface/volume ratio increases, there is a
higher contact surface with the host’s immune system, which could explain the
resulting exuberant cellular component. In fact, this study demonstrated that the three
chitosan membranes tested in vitro and in vivo were biocompatible and therefore an
important scaffold for the reconstruction of peripheral nerve, after axonotmesis or
neurotmesis injury, associated or not to neurotrophic factors cellular producing
systems. Types II and III chitosan membranes showed higher elasticity in comparison
to type I chitosan membrane, a feature which would facilitate the surgical manipulation.
Therefore, we decided to carry out in vivo testing with chitosan types II and III only.
4.3 Functional Assessment of Reinnervation
Immediately after the acute compression injury, the crushed areas of all sciatic nerves
were flattened but nerve continuity was preserved. Complete flaccid paralysis of the
operative foot was observed following crush injury. All rats survived, with no wound
infection or automutilation.
Withdrawal reflex latency (WRL)
The results obtained, performing Withdrawal Reflex Latency (WRL) test to evaluate the
nociceptive function are shown in Figure 15. Two way ANOVA shows that the WRL
were significantly affected after the sciatic nerve crush [F(10,250)=82,884; p<0,000].
Contrast analysis indicates that the WRL values were affected up to week 8. Beyond
this time point, WRL values, the experimental groups pooled together, were similar to
those preoperatively. A significant effect of group was found for WRL data
[F(4,25)=12,018; p<0,000], and post hoc analysis showed that differences were
significant between ChitosanII group from one side and ChitosanIICell, ChitosanIII and
54 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
ChitosanIIICell groups on the other side (p<0,05). These results are suggestive of a
slower rate of recovery in WRL with the use of type II chitosan.
Figure 15 - WRL results
Motor Deficit (EPT)
The EPT values obtained during the healing period of 12 weeks are represented in
Figure 16. EPT values were significantly affected by the crush injury [F(10,250)=1497,366;
p<0,000] and contrast analysis shows that at week 12, EPT had still not recovered to
baseline values. There were significant differences in EPT values between the
experimental groups [F(4,25)=12,018; p<0,000] and post hoc analysis shows that the
EPT values from the Crush group were significantly different from those of the
ChitosanIICell and ChitosanIIICell (p<0,05), suggesting a negative effect of the N1E
115-differentiated cells on motor recovery after sciatic crush injury.
Figure 16 - EPT results
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 55
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
Sciatic functional index (SFI) and Static Sciatic Index (SSI)
SFI and SSI results are depicted in Figure 17 and Figure 18, respectively. Two way
ANOVA shows that SFI values changed significantly after the crush injury
[F(10,250)=488,931; p<0,000]. Contrast analysis shows that SFI values were different
from baseline until week 7 of recovery. A significant effect of group was observed for
SFI values [F(4,25)=144,125; p=0,01] with post hoc analysis indicating that values from
ChitosanIICell group were different from those of the ChitosanII and ChitosanIII groups.
Two way ANOVA analysis on SSI data was similar to that of the just reported SFI
results. However, post hoc analysis shows that SSI results from the ChitosanIIICell
group were different from those of the Crush, ChitosanII and ChitosanIICell groups.
Figure 17 - SFI results
56 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Figure 18 - SSI results
Ankle joint Kinematics
Video recordings of the rats’ gait were undertaken at week 0 (pre-operatively) and at
post-surgery at weeks 0, 2, 4, 8 and 12, so the amount of time points for statistical
analysis was reduced to only five (see Methods). Figure 19 and Figure 20 represent
the values of ankle joint angle and the values of ankle joint velocity at IC, OT, HR and
TO, respectively, obtained by kinematic analysis during the healing period of 12 weeks.
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 57
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
Figure 19 - Curves representing ankle joint angle in the sagittal plane during the stance phase of
walking. Note the absence of plantarflexion at push off in all sciatic crushed groups at week 2
post-injury. The normal ankle motion pattern is progressively regained during the 12-weeks
recovery period. The mean of each group is plotted: (solid line) Control Group; () Axonotmesis
Group (Crush); (dashed line) Axonotmesis involved with chitosan II membrane (ChitosanII); ()
Axonotmesis involved with chitosan III membrane (ChitosanIII); (x) Axonotemesis involved with
chitosan type II membrane covered with the cellular system (ChitosanIICell); () Axonotemesis
involved with chitosan type III membrane covered with the cellular system (ChitosanIIICell).
58 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Initial Contact (IC)
The ankle joint angle at IC changed significantly after the sciatic crush [F(4, 100)=28,705;
p<0,000]. Such changes were transient and by week 4 ankle joint angle at IC was
indistinguishable from baseline, as indicated by contrast analysis. Two way ANOVA
revealed group differences [F(4,25)=10,671; p<0,000] and post hoc analysis shows that
ChitosanII group was different from all the other four groups.
Opposite toe off (OT)
Ankle joint angle at OT was significantly affected after the crush injury [F(4,100)=13,464;
p<0,000] but by week 4 of recovery joint position at this point of stance had recovered
to normal values. Two way ANOVA revealed a significant group effect [F(4,25)=4,150;
p=0,01] and post hoc analysis showed that ankle joint angles at OT in the ChitosanII
group throughout the study were significantly different from Crush and ChitosanIII
groups (Figure 19).
Ankle joint velocity at OT was significantly affected after the crush injury [F(4,100)=8,582;
p<0,000] and returned to preoperative values at week 4 (p<0,05). There were
significant differences between the groups for ankle joint velocity at OT [F(4,25)=3,164;
p<0,031] with post hoc analysis showing significant differences between ChitosanII and
ChitosanIICell groups (p<0,05) (Figure 20).
Heel Raise (HR)
Ankle joint angle at HR was significantly altered after the sciatic nerve injury
[F(4,100)=34,151; p<0,000] until week 12 (p<0,05). A significant effect of group was found
for this variable [F(4,25)=3,456; p<0,022]. Post hoc tests found significant differences in
ankle joint angle at HR between ChitosanII and the Crush and ChitosanIIICell groups
(Figure 19).
Instantaneous ankle’s joint velocity at HR was significantly affected after axonotmesis
[F(4,100)=42,384; p<0,000] with contrast analysis showing that differences in ankle’s joint
velocity were significantly different from normal values until week 4 of recovery. A
significant effect of group was registered [F(4,25)=3,766; p<0,016], and post hoc tests
showed significant differences between ChitosanII and ChistosanIICell groups (Figure
20).
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 59
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
Figure 20 - Curves represent ankle joint angular velocity in the sagittal plane during the stance
phase of walking. Note the loss of the normal ankle joint angular velocity biphasic response in all
sciatic crushed groups at week 2 post-injury. The normal ankle velocity pattern is progressively
regained during the 12-weeks recovery period. The mean of each group is plotted: (solid line)
Control Group; ()Axonotmesis Group (Crush); (dashed line) Axonotmesis involved with chitosan
II membrane (ChitosanII); () Axonotmesis involved with chitosan III membrane (ChitosanIII); (x)
Axonotemesis involved with chitosan type II membrane covered with the cellular system
(ChitosanIICell); ()Axonotemesis involved with chitosan type III membrane covered with the
cellular system (ChitosanIIICell).
60 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Toe off (TO)
Ankle joint angle at TO was significantly altered after the sciatic nerve injury
[F(4,100)=181,588; p<0,000]. Contrast analysis showed that at week 12 ankle’s joint
angle mean value at TO was similar to that registered before the sciatic nerve injury. A
significant effect of group was found for this variable [F(4,25)=3,409; p<0,023]. Post hoc
tests found significant differences in ankle’s joint angle at TO between ChitosanII and
ChitosanIIICell groups (Figure 19). Ankle’s joint velocity at TO was significantly affected
after the crush injury [F(4,100)=103,331; p<0,000] with contrast analysis showing that
ankle’s joint velocity did not recovered completely within the 12-weeks follow up time. A
significant effect of group was registered [F(4,25)=9,689; p<0,000], and post hoc tests
showed significant differences between ChitosanIICell, from one hand and Crush,
ChitosanIII and ChistosanIIICell groups, on the other hand (Figure 20).
MANOVA analysis was employed to further compare the results of the walk kinematic
analysis of the experimental groups, using values of week 12 only. A significant effect
of the experimental group was observed (Pillai’s Trace 3,709; p<0,000). Multivariate
contrast analysis (K matrix) showed that ChitosanIII was the group differing from Crush
group in a less number of variables. This indicates that at the end of the recovery
period animals in ChitosanIII group presented a degree of functional recovery similar to
that registered in the Crush group.
4.4 Morphological and histomorphometrical analysis
Figure 21 shows the histological appearance of control normal sciatic nerve cross
sections (Figure 21A) in comparison to cross sections of the regenerated nerve fibers
with and without cell delivery (Figure 21B-F). As expected, regenerated nerve fibers in
all five experimental groups were organized in microfascicles and were smaller than
control nerve fibers. In the two experimental groups in which cell delivery was carried
out (Figure 21B,D,F), the presence of unusual cell profiles, interpretable as the
transplanted cells, were detectable at the periphery of the nerves. This was seldom
observed in inner parts of the nerve (Figure 21F) suggesting that only few transplanted
cells colonized the inner nerve interstice.
Electron microscopy confirms that a good regeneration pattern of both unmyelinated
and myelinated nerve fibers occurred in all experimental groups, irrespectively of the
enrichment with neural stem cells (Figure 23A,B and Figure 24A,B). The border zone of
the nerve still shows the presence of some chitosan debris integrated with the collagen
fibers of the epineurium (Figure 23C,D). Moreover, in the two experimental groups in
which cell delivery was carried out (Figure 24), it was possible to find some of
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 61
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
transplanted cells localized in the border zone of the regenerated nerve (Figure
24C,D).
Results of the design-based morphoquantitative analysis of regenerated myelinated
nerve fibers permitted to quantitatively compare the different experimental groups. As
expected, fiber density was significantly (p<0.05) higher in all experimental groups in
comparison to control sciatic nerves, while mean axon and fiber diameter and myelin
thickness were significantly (p<0.05) lower.
62 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
As regards the number of regenerated myelinated nerve fibers, this parameter was
found to be significantly higher (p<0.05) in comparison to controls in four out of the five
experimental groups only; in fact, ChitosanIII group showed a number of fibers not
significantly (p<0.05) different in comparison to normal control nerves.
Figure 21 - High resolution photomicrographs of nerve fibers from control and regenerated rat sciatic
nerves. (A) Control group; (B) Crush group; (C) ChitosanII group; (D) ChitosanIICell group; (E) ChitosanIII
group. (F) ChitosanIIICell group. Original magnification: 1000x
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 63
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
The peculiarity of the experimental group characterized by type III chitosan membrane
enwrapment, was also confirmed by statistical analysis of inter-group variability among
experimental groups which demonstrated that ChitosanIII group has a significantly
(p<0.05) higher mean fiber and axon diameter and myelin thickness in comparison with
all other experimental crush groups.
Figure 22 - High resolution photomicrographs comparing ChitosanIII (A, C, E) and
ChitosanIIICell (B, D, F) groups. The presence of transplanted cells is clearly identifiable at
the periphery of the nerve (D) and, seldom, also in the inner nerve areas (F). Original
magnification: A, B: = 200x; C-F=1000x
64 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Figure 23 - Electron microscopy regenerated nerve fibers in ChitosanIII experimental group.
In panels A and B, the ultrastructural appearance of unmyelinated (A) and myelinated (B)
nerve fibers can be appreciated. In panels C and D, the presence of chitosan debris mingled
with epineurial connective tissue can be still detected. Original magnification: A = 40,000x; B
= 30,000x; C = 50,000x; D = 150,000x.
A B
C D
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 65
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
Figure 24 - Electron microscopy regenerated nerve fibers in ChitosanIIICell experimental group. In panels A
and B, the ultrastructural appearance of unmyelinated (A) and myelinated (B) nerve fibers can be
appreciated. In panels C and D, the presence of elongated transplanted cells mingled with chitosan debris
and epineurial connective tissue can be still detected. Original magnification: A = 40,000x; B = 25,000x; C =
10,000x; D = 15,000x.
66 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
5 Discussion
To find out effective strategies for promoting peripheral nerve regeneration is a
challenging issue in Regenerative Medicine (1-3; 19; 38; 50-52). The study of new
materials for promoting nerve regeneration is usually carried out in axonotmesis nerve
lesion models (20). Although nerve fibers always regenerate after experimental
axonotmesis, there are considerable differences in the extent and rate of recovery
between studies which probably reflect the different techniques used to induce the
injury (20; 21; 38). To cope with this limitation, in this study we used a standardized
clamping procedure that was described in details in previous works (20; 21; 49; 53), for
investigating the effects of enwrapping the axonotmesis site with type II and type III
chitosan membranes. In two experimental groups, chitosan membranes were covered
with in vitro differentiated N1E-115 cells before implanting them in vivo. In neuronal
cells the regulation of the intracellular free calcium concentration [Ca2+]i plays an
important role in physiological processes such as growth and differentiation, controlling
important cell functions like the release of neurotransmitters and the membrane’s
excitability. The mechanisms that control [Ca2+]i are of crucial importance for normal
homeostasis, and its deregulation has been associated to cellular changes and even
cell death, when [Ca2+]i reaches values above 105 nM (42). The measurements of
[Ca2+]i of the N1E-115 cells in vitro differentiated by the addition of DMSO indicated
that these cells did not begin the apoptosis process although the evident neural
differentiation supporting the hypothesis that chitosan membranes type I, II and III,
were a viable substrate for N1E-115 neuronal cell line adhesion, multiplication and
differentiation. The in vivo biocompatibility studies also corroborated that the three
types of chitosan membranes were biocompatible and therefore an important scaffold
for the reconstruction of peripheral nerve, after axonotmesis or neurotmesis injury,
associated or not to cellular systems producing neurotrophic factors. The higher
elasticity observed in type II and III chitosan membranes, when compared to type I, that
facilitates surgery, induced us to carry out the in vivo testing on the rat sciatic nerve
regeneration, with these GPTMS hybrid membranes only, abandoning type I
membranes. As a matter of fact, the GPTMS hybrid membranes provide a suitable
scaffolding environment for neural tissue engineering, making this material a potential
candidate for scaffolds in neural tissue engineering.
The in vivo study on crushed rat sciatic nerve experimental model showed that
morphological predictors of nerve regeneration (number of fibers, axon and fiber size
and myelin thickness) were significantly improved in ChitosanIII group in comparison to
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 67
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
all other experimental crush groups, thus suggesting that type III chitosan is a suitable
biomaterial to be used in reconstructive peripheral nerve surgery. Functional
assessment partially supported the morphometric results since results of the WRL,
EPT, SFI and SSI tests suggest that chitosan type II and the N1E-115 cells have a
reduced degree of functional recovery which is in line with results of histomorphometric
analysis.
Results of both morphological and functional predictors of nerve regeneration also
showed that enrichment of chitosan membranes with N1E-115 neural cells did not have
any positive effect on nerve regeneration in comparison to crush controls and, in case
of type III chitosan membrane, the presence of transplanted cells seemed to prevent
the positive effect of the membrane wrapping alone on nerve regeneration. These
results are in agreement with previous investigation that showed that N1E-115 cell
population does not have significant effect in promoting axon regeneration and, when
N1E-115 cells were cultured inside a PLGA scaffold used to bridge a nerve defect, they
can even exert negative effects on nerve fiber regeneration (21; 53). Thus N1E-115
cells did not prove to be a potential candidate therapeutic agent for treatment of nerve
injury and their utilization is just limited to research purposes, mainly as a basic
scientific step in the investigation of the potentiality for nerve regeneration promotion of
cell transplantation delivery systems that permit that transplanted cells are able to
secrete neurotrophic factors in the site of injury without being directly in contact with
regenerating axons.
Chitosan type II and chitosan type III were developed as a hybrid of chitosan by the
addition of GPTMS. Wettability of material surfaces is one of the key factors for protein
adsorption, cell attachment and migration (39). The addition of GPTMS improves the
wettability of chitosan surfaces (41), and therefore chitosan type II and chitosan type III
are expected to be more hydrophilic than the original chitosan (41). Chitosan type III
was developed to be more porous, with a larger surface to volume ratio but preserving
mechanical strength and the ability to adapt to different shapes. Significant differences
in water uptake between commonly used chitosan and our hybrid chitosan type III were
previously reported due to the difference in the ability of the matrix to hold water (13).
In fact, hybrid chitosan-based membranes may retain about two times as much
biological liquid fluid as chitosan (13). A synergetic effect of a more favourable porous
microstructure and physicochemical properties (more wettable and higher water uptake
level) of chitosan type III compared to chitosan type II, and the presence of silica ions
may be responsible for the good results obtained in this study for the former in the
nerve regeneration process.
68 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
The observation that significant improvement of axonal regeneration was obtained in
crushed sciatic nerves surrounded by chitosan type III membranes alone suggests that
this material may not just work as a simple mechanical scaffold but instead may work
as an inducer of nerve regeneration. The regenerative property of chitosan type III
might be explained by the action on Schwann cell proliferation and axon elongation and
myelination (9; 13). Yet, the expression of established myelin genes such as PMP22,
PO and MBP (40) may be influenced by the presence of silica ions which exert an
effect on several glycoprotein expression (13; 43).
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 69
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
6 Conclusions
Enwrapment of the site of a nerve crush lesion with a chitosan type III membrane
significantly improves nerve regeneration in the rat, whereas enrichment of chitosan
membranes with N1E-115 neural cells does have positive effects. Whereas translation
of animal studies to patients should always be dealt with caution, the results obtained
in this experimental study open interesting perspectives for the clinical employment of
hybrid chitosan membranes in peripheral nerve reconstruction.
70 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
REFERENCES
1. Schlosshauer B, Dreesmann L, Schaller H-E, Sinis N. Synthetic nerve guide
implants in humans: a comprehensive survey. [Internet]. Neurosurgery. 2006
Oct;59(4):740-7; discussion 747-8.
2. Samii M, Carvalho GA, Nikkhah G, Penkert G. Surgical reconstruction of the
musculocutaneous nerve in traumatic brachial plexus injuries. [Internet]. Journal
of neurosurgery. 1997 Dec;87(6):881-6.[
3. Höke A. Mechanisms of Disease: what factors limit the success of peripheral
nerve regeneration in humans? [Internet]. Nature clinical practice. Neurology.
2006 Aug;2(8):448-54.
4. Lee JM, Tos P, Raimondo S, Fornaro M, Papalia I, Geuna S, et al. Lack of
topographic specificity in nerve fiber regeneration of rat forelimb mixed nerves.
[Internet]. Neuroscience. 2007 Feb;144(3):985-90. 1
5. Tos P, Battiston B, Nicolino S, Raimondo S, Fornaro M, Lee JM, et al.
Comparison of fresh and predegenerated muscle-vein-combined guides for the
repair of rat median nerve. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2007 Jan;27(1):48-55.
6. Chen G, Ushida T, Tateishi T. Preparation of poly(L-lactic acid) and poly(DL-
lactic-co-glycolic acid) foams by use of ice microparticulates. [Internet].
Biomaterials. 2001 Sep;22(18):2563-7.
7. Chandy T, Sharma CP. Chitosan--as a biomaterial. [Internet]. Biomaterials,
artificial cells, and artificial organs. 1990 Jan;18(1):1-24.
8. Yamaguchi I, Itoh S, Suzuki M, Osaka A, Tanaka J. The chitosan prepared from
crab tendons: II. The chitosan/apatite composites and their application to nerve
regeneration. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2003 Aug;24(19):3285-92.
9. Yuan Y, Zhang P, Yang Y, Wang X, Gu X. The interaction of Schwann cells with
chitosan membranes and fibers in vitro. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2004
Aug;25(18):4273-8.
10. Ishikawa N, Suzuki Y, Ohta M, Cho H, Suzuki S, Dezawa M, et al. Peripheral
nerve regeneration through the space formed by a chitosan gel sponge.
[Internet]. Journal of biomedical materials research. Part A. 2007 Oct
;83(1):3340.
11. Wang W, Itoh S, Matsuda A, Ichinose S, Shinomiya K, Hata Y, et al. Influences
of mechanical properties and permeability on chitosan nano/microfiber mesh
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 71
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
tubes as a scaffold for nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Journal of biomechanical
materials research. Part A. 2008;84(2):557-66.
12. Senel S, McClure SJ. Potential applications of chitosan in veterinary medicine.
[Internet]. Advanced drug delivery reviews. 2004 Jun;56(10):1467-80.
13. Shirosaki Y, Tsuru K, Hayakawa S, Osaka A, Lopes MA, Santos JD, et al. In
vitro cytocompatibility of MG63 cells on chitosan-organosiloxane hybrid
membranes. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2005 Feb;26(5):485-93.
14. Amano T, Richelson E, Nirenberg M. Neurotransmitter synthesis by
neuroblastoma clones (neuroblast differentiation-cell culture-choline
acetyltransferase-acetylcholinesterase-tyrosine hydroxylase-axons-dendrites).
[Internet]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States
of America. 1972 Jan;69(1):258-63.
15. Marreco PR, Luz Moreira P da, Genari SC, Moraes AM. Effects of different
sterilization methods on the morphology, mechanical properties, and cytotoxicity
of chitosan membranes used as wound dressings. [Internet]. Journal of
biomedical materials research. Part B, Applied biomaterials. 2004
Nov;71(2):268-77. 9
16. Beer GM, Steurer J, Meyer VE. Standardizing nerve crushes with a non-serrated
clamp. [Internet]. Journal of reconstructive microsurgery. 2001 Oct;17(7):531-4.
17. Kimhi Y, Palfrey C, Spector I, Barak Y, Littauer UZ. Maturation of neuroblastoma
cells in the presence of dimethylsulfoxide. [Internet]. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 1976 Feb;73(2):462-6.
18. Schmidt CE, Leach JB. Neural tissue engineering: strategies for repair and
regeneration. [Internet]. Annual review of biomedical engineering. 2003
Jan;5293-347.
19. Lundborg G, Dahlin L, Danielsen N, Zhao Q. Trophism, tropism, and specificity
in nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Journal of reconstructive microsurgery. 1994
Sep;10(5):345-54.
20. Varejão AS, Melo-Pinto P, Meek MF, Filipe VM, Bulas-Cruz J. Methods for the
experimental functional assessment of rat sciatic nerve regeneration. [Internet].
Neurological research. 2004 Mar;26(2):186-94.
21. Luís AL, Amado S, Geuna S, Rodrigues JM, Simões MJ, Santos JD, et al. Long-
term functional and morphological assessment of a standardized rat sciatic
72 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
nerve crush injury with a non-serrated clamp. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience
methods. 2007 Jun;163(1):92-104.
22. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Melo-Pinto P, Raimondo S,
et al. Functional and morphological assessment of a standardized rat sciatic
nerve crush injury with a non-serrated clamp. [Internet]. Journal of neurotrauma.
2004 Nov;21(11):1652-70.
23. Tuttle JB, Richelson E. Phenytoin action on the excitable membrane of mouse
neuroblastoma. [Internet]. The Journal of pharmacology and experimental
therapeutics. 1979 Dec;211(3):632-7.
24. Fisher SK, Domask LM, Roland RM. Muscarinic receptor regulation of
cytoplasmic Ca2+ concentrations in human SK-N-SH neuroblastoma cells: Ca2+
requirements for phospholipase C activation. [Internet]. Molecular pharmacology.
1989 Feb;35(2):195-204.
25. Sporel-Ozakat RE, Edwards PM, Hepgul KT, Savas A, Gispen WH. A simple
method for reducing autotomy in rats after peripheral nerve lesions. [Internet].
Journal of neuroscience methods. 1991 Feb;36(2-3):263-5.
26. Luís AL, Rodrigues JM, Geuna S, Amado S, Simões MJ, Fregnan F, et al.
Neural cell transplantation effects on sciatic nerve regeneration after a
standardized crush injury in the rat. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2008 Jan;28(6):458-
70.[cited 2011 Mar 15]
27. Koka R, Hadlock TA. Quantification of functional recovery following rat sciatic
nerve transection. [Internet]. Experimental neurology. 2001 Mar;168(1):192-
5.[cited 2010 Dec 7]
28. Hu D, Hu R, Berde CB. Neurologic evaluation of infant and adult rats before and
after sciatic nerve blockade. [Internet]. Anesthesiology. 1997 Apr;86(4):957-65.
29. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Geuna S, Patrício J a, Azevedo HR, Ferreira AJ, et al.
Functional assessment of sciatic nerve recovery: biodegradable poly (DLLA-
epsilon-CL) nerve guide filled with fresh skeletal muscle. [Internet]. Microsurgery.
2003 Jan;23(4):346-53.
30. Bain JR, Mackinnon SE, Hunter DA. Functional evaluation of complete sciatic,
peroneal, and posterior tibial nerve lesions in the rat. [Internet]. Plastic and
reconstructive surgery. 1989 Jan;83(1):129-38.
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 73
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
31. Bervar M. Video analysis of standing--an alternative footprint analysis to assess
functional loss following injury to the rat sciatic nerve. [Internet]. Journal of
neuroscience methods. 2000 Oct;102(2):109-16.
32. Dijkstra JR, Meek MF, Robinson PH, Gramsbergen A. Methods to evaluate
functional nerve recovery in adult rats: walking track analysis, video analysis and
the withdrawal reflex. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience methods. 2000
Mar;96(2):89-96.
33. Clarke KA, Parker AJ. A quantitative study of normal locomotion in the rat.
[Internet]. Physiology & behavior. 1986 Jan;38(3):345-51.[
34. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Gabriel RC, Filipe VM, et al.
Motion of the foot and ankle during the stance phase in rats. [Internet]. Muscle &
nerve. 2002 Nov;26(5):630-5.
35. Di Scipio F, Raimondo S, Tos P, Geuna S. A simple protocol for paraffin-
embedded myelin sheath staining with osmium tetroxide for light microscope
observation. [Internet]. Microscopy research and technique. 2008 Jul;71(7):497-
502.
36. Schmitz C. Variation of fractionator estimates and its prediction. [Internet].
Anatomy and embryology. 1998 Nov;198(5):371-97.
37. Geuna S, Gigo-Benato D, Rodrigues A de C. On sampling and sampling errors
in histomorphometry of peripheral nerve fibers. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2004
Jan;24(1):72-6.
38. Mackinnon SE, Dellon AL, OʼBrien JP. Changes in nerve fiber numbers distal to
a nerve repair in the rat sciatic nerve model. [Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 1991
Nov;14(11):1116-22.
39. Hench L. Biomaterials: An Interfacial Approach (Biophysics and bioengineering
series) [Internet]. Academic Pr; 1982.
40. Kuhn G, Lie A, Wilms S, Müller HW. Coexpression of PMP22 gene with MBP
and P0 during de novo myelination and nerve repair. [Internet]. Glia. 1993
Aug;8(4):256-64.
41. Tateishi T, Chen G, Ushida T. Biodegradable porous scaffolds for tissue
engineering [Internet]. Journal of Artificial Organs. 2002 Jun;5(2):77-83.
74 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
42. Trump BF, Berezesky IK. Calcium-mediated cell injury and cell death. [Internet].
The FASEB journal: official publication of the Federation of American Societies
for Experimental Biology. 1995 Feb;9(2):219-28.
43. Pietak AM, Reid JW, Stott MJ, Sayer M. Silicon substitution in the calcium
phosphate bioceramics. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2007 Oct ;28(28):4023-32.
44. Wenling C, Duohui J, Jiamou L, Yandao G, Nanming Z, Xiufang Z. Effects of the
degree of deacetylation on the physicochemical properties and Schwann cell
affinity of chitosan films. [Internet]. Journal of biomaterials applications. 2005
Oct;20(2):157-77.
45. Rodrigues JM, Luís AL, Lobato JV, Pinto MV, Faustino A, Hussain NS, et al.
Intracellular Ca2+ concentration in the N1E-115 neuronal cell line and its use for
peripheric nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Acta médica portuguesa.
2005;18(5):323-8.
46. Rodrigues JM, Luís AL, Lobato JV, Pinto MV, Lopes MA, Freitas M, et al.
Determination of the intracellular Ca2+ concentration in the N1E-115 neuronal
cell line in perspective of its use for peripheric nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Bio-
medical materials and engineering. 2005 Jan;15(6):455-65.
47. Masters DB, Berde CB, Dutta SK, Griggs CT, Hu D, Kupsky W, et al. Prolonged
regional nerve blockade by controlled release of local anesthetic from a
biodegradable polymer matrix. [Internet]. Anesthesiology. 1993 Aug;79(2):340-6.
48. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Filipe VM, Gabriel RC, et al.
Ankle kinematics to evaluate functional recovery in crushed rat sciatic nerve
[Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 2003;27(6):706–714. l
49. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Fornaro M, Geuna S, Giacobini-Robecchi
MG. Morphology of nerve fiber regeneration along a biodegradable poly (DLLA-
epsilon-CL) nerve guide filled with fresh skeletal muscle. [Internet]. Microsurgery.
2003 Jan;23(4):338-45.
50. Geuna S, Papalia I, Tos P. End-to-side (terminolateral) nerve regeneration: a
challenge for neuroscientists coming from an intriguing nerve repair concept.
[Internet]. Brain research reviews. 2006 Sep;52(2):381-8.
51. Battiston B, Geuna S, Ferrero M, Tos P. Nerve repair by means of tubulization:
literature review and personal clinical experience comparing biological and
synthetic conduits for sensory nerve repair. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2005
Jan;25(4):258-67.
Chapter 3 – Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve regeneration in an
axonotmesis rat model 75
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
52. Meek MF, Robinson PH, Stokroos I, Blaauw EH, Kors G, Dunnen WF den.
Electronmicroscopical evaluation of short-term nerve regeneration through a
thin-walled biodegradable poly(DLLA-epsilon-CL) nerve guide filled with modified
denatured muscle tissue. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2001 May;22(10):1177-85.
53. Luis AL, Rodrigues JM, Amado S, Veloso AP, Armada-Da-silva PAS, Raimondo
S, et al. PLGA 90/10 and caprolactone biodegradable nerve guides for the
reconstruction of the rat sciatic nerve [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2007;27(2):125–
137.
76 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Chapter 4 - Effects of Collagen Membranes Enriched
with in Vitro-Differentiated N1E-115 Cells on Rat Sciatic
Nerve Regeneration after End-to-End Repair
Amado S, Rodrigues JM, Luís AL, Armada-da-Silva P a S, Vieira M, Gartner A, et al.
Effects of collagen membranes enriched with in vitro-differentiated N1E-115 cells on rat
sciatic nerve regeneration after end-to-end repair. [Internet]. Journal of
neuroengineering and rehabilitation. 2010 Jan;7:7.
78 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
5 Introduction
Nerve regeneration is a complex biological phenomenon. In the peripheral nervous
system, nerves can spontaneously regenerate without any treatment if nerve continuity
is maintained (axonotmesis) whereas more severe type of injuries must be surgically
treated by direct end-to-end surgical reconnection of the damaged nerve ends (1-3).
Unfortunately, the functional outcomes of nerve repair are in many cases unsatisfactory
(4-10) thus calling for research in order to reveal more effective strategies for improving
nerve regeneration. However, recent advances in neuroscience, cell culture, genetic
techniques, and biomaterials provide optimism for new treatments for nerve injuries (1;
9-20).
The use of materials of natural origin has several advantages in tissue engineering.
Natural materials are more likely to be biocompatible than artificial materials. Also, they
are less toxic and provide a good support to cell adhesion and migration due to the
presence of a variety of surface molecules. Drawbacks of natural materials include
potential difficulties in their isolation and controlled scale-up (6-10). In addition to the
use of intact natural tissues, a great deal of research has focused on the use of purified
natural extracellular matrix (ECM) molecules, which can be modified to serve as
appropriate scaffolding (16). ECM molecules, such as laminin, fibronectin and collagen
have also been shown to play a significant role in axonal development and
regeneration (8; 21; 22). For example, silicone tubes filled with laminin, fibronectin, and
collagen led to a better regeneration over a 10 mm rat sciatic nerve gap compared to
empty silicone controls (14). Collagen filaments have also been used to guide
regenerating axons across 20–30 mm defects in rats (23-26). Further studies have
shown that oriented fibers of collagen within gels, aligned using magnetic fields,
provide an improved template for neurite extension compared to randomly oriented
collagen fibers (22; 27). Finally, rates of regeneration comparable to those using a
nerve autograft have been achieved using collagen tubes containing a porous
collagen-glycosaminoglycan matrix (28-30). Nerve regeneration requires a complex
interplay between cells, ECM, and growth factors. The local presence of growth factors
plays an important role in controlling survival, migration, proliferation, and differentiation
of the various cell types involved in nerve regeneration (8-10; 31). Therefore, therapies
with relevant growth factors received increasing attention in recent years although
growth factor therapy is a difficult task because of the high biological activity (in pico- to
nanomolar range), pleiotrophic effects (acting on a variety of targets), and short
Chapter 4 - Effects of Collagen Membranes Enriched with in Vitro-Differentiated N1E-115 Cells on Rat Sciatic
Nerve Regeneration after End-to-End Repair 79
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
biological half-life (few minutes to hours) (32). Thus, growth factors should be
administered locally to achieve an adequate therapeutic effect with little adverse
reactions and the short biological half-life of growth factors demands for a delivery
system that slowly releases locally the molecules over a prolonged period of time.
Employment of biodegradable membranes enriched with a cellular system producing
neurotrophic factors has been suggested to be a rational approach for improving nerve
regeneration after neurotmesis (16).
The aim of this study was thus to verify if rat sciatic nerve regeneration after end-to-end
reconstruction can be improved by seeding in vitro differentiated N1E-115 neural cells
on a type III equine collagen membrane and enwrap the membrane around the lesion
site. The N1E-115 cell line has been established from a mouse neuroblastoma (33)
and have already been used with conflicting results as a cellular system to locally
produce and deliver neurotrophic factors (6-10). In vitro, the N1E-115 cells undergo
neuronal differentiation in response to dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO), adenosine 3’, 5’-
cyclic monophosphate (cAMP), or serum withdrawal (4-10). Upon induction of
differentiation, proliferation of N1E-115 cells ceases, extensive neurite outgrowth is
observed and the membranes become highly excitable (4-10). The interval period of 48
hours of differentiation was previously determined by measurement of the intracellular
calcium concentration (Ca2+i). At this time point, the N1E-115 cells present already
the morphological characteristics of neuronal cells but cell death due to increased
Ca2+i is not yet occurring as described elsewhere (4-10).
80 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
6 Methods
6.1 Cell culture
The N1E-115 cells, clones of cells derived from the mouse neuroblastoma C-130035
retain numerous biochemical, physiological, and morphological properties of neuronal
cells in culture (4-10). N1E-115 neuronal cells were cultured in Petri dishes (around 2 x
106 cells) over collagen type III membranes (Gentafleece®, Resorba Wundversorgung
GmbH + Co. KG, Baxter AG) at 37ºC, 5% CO2 in a humidified atmosphere with 90%
Dulbecco’s Modified Eagle’s Medium (DMEM; Gibco) supplemented with 10% fetal
bovine serum (FBS, Gibco), 100 U/ml penicillin, and 100 µg/ml streptomycin (Gibco).
The culture medium was changed every 48 hours and the Petri dishes were observed
daily. The cells were passed or were supplied with differentiating medium containing
1.5% of DMSO once they reached approximately 80% confluence, mostly 48 hours
after plating (and before the rats’ surgery). The differentiating medium was composed
of 96% DMEM supplemented with 2.5 % of FBS, 100 U/ml penicillin, 100 µg/ml
streptomycin and 1.5% of DMSO (6-10).
6.2 Surgical procedure
Adult male Sasco Sprague Dawley rats (Charles River Laboratories, Barcelona, Spain)
weighing 300-350 g, were randomly divided in 3 groups of 6 or 7 animals each. All
animals were housed in a temperature and humidity controlled room with 12-12 hours
light / dark cycles, two animals per cage (Makrolon type 4, Tecniplast, VA, Italy), and
were allowed normal cage activities under standard laboratory conditions. The animals
were fed with standard chow and water ad libitum. Adequate measures were taken to
minimize pain and discomfort taking in account human endpoints for animal suffering
and distress. Animals were housed for two weeks before entering the experiment. For
surgery, rats were placed prone under sterile conditions and the skin from the clipped
lateral right thigh scrubbed in a routine fashion with antiseptic solution. The surgeries
were performed under an M-650 operating microscope (Leica Microsystems, Wetzlar,
Germany). Under deep anaesthesia (ketamine 90 mg/Kg; xylazine 12.5 mg/Kg,
atropine 0.25 mg/Kg i.m.), the right sciatic nerve was exposed through a skin incision
extending from the greater trochanter to the mid-thigh distally followed by a muscle
splitting incision. After nerve mobilisation, a transection injury was performed
(neurotmesis) immediately above the terminal nerve ramification using straight
Chapter 4 - Effects of Collagen Membranes Enriched with in Vitro-Differentiated N1E-115 Cells on Rat Sciatic
Nerve Regeneration after End-to-End Repair 81
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
microsurgical scissors. Rats were then randomly assigned to three experimental
groups. In one group (End-to-End), immediate cooptation with 7/0 monofilament nylon
epineurial sutures of the 2 transected nerve endings was performed, in a second group
(End-to-EndMemb) nerve transection was reconstructed by end-to-end suture, like in
the first group, and then enveloped by a membrane of equine collagen type III. In a
third group (End-to-EndMembCell) animals received the same treatment as the
previous group but with equine collagen type III membranes covered with neural cells
differentiated in vitro. Sciatic nerves from the contralateral site were left intact in all
groups and served as controls. To prevent autotomy, a deterrent substance was
applied to rats’ right foot (34; 35). The animals were intensively examined for signs of
autotomy and contracture during the postoperative and none presented severe
wounds, infections or contractures. All procedures were performed with the approval of
the Veterinary Authorities of Portugal in accordance with the European Communities
Council Directive of November 1986 (86/609/EEC).
6.3 Functional assessment
Evaluation of motor performance (EPT) and nociceptive function (WRL)
Motor performance and nociceptive function were evaluated by measuring extensor
postural thrust (EPT) and withdrawal reflex latency (WRL), respectively. The animals
were tested pre-operatively (week-0), at weeks 1, 2, and every two weeks thereafter
until week-20. The animals were gently handled, and tested in a quiet environment to
minimize stress levels. The EPT was originally proposed by Thalhammer and
collaborators, in 1995 (36) as a part of the neurological recovery evaluation in the rat
after sciatic nerve injury. For this test, the entire body of the rat, excepting the hind-
limbs, was wrapped in a surgical towel. Supporting the animal by the thorax and
lowering the affected hind-limb towards the platform of a digital balance, elicits the
EPT. As the animal is lowered to the platform, it extends the hind-limb, anticipating the
contact made by the distal metatarsus and digits. The force in grams (g) applied to the
digital platform balance (model TM 560; Gibertini, Milan, Italy) was recorded. The same
procedure was applied to the contralateral, unaffected limb. Each EPT test was
repeated 3 times and the average result was considered. The normal (unaffected limb)
EPT (NEPT) and experimental EPT (EEPT) values were incorporated into an equation
(Equation 8) to derive the functional deficit (varying between 0 and 1), as described by
Koka and Hadlock, in 2001 (37).
82 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Motor Deficit = (NEPT – EEPT) / NEPT
Equation 8 EPT formula
To assess the nociceptive withdrawal reflex (WRL), the hotplate test was modified as
described by Masters and collaborators (38). The rat was wrapped in a surgical towel
above its waist and then positioned to stand with the affected hind paw on a hot plate
at 56ºC (model 35-D, IITC Life Science Instruments, Woodland Hill, CA). WRL is
defined as the time elapsed from the onset of hotplate contact to withdrawal of the hind
paw and measured with a stopwatch. Normal rats withdraw their paws from the
hotplate within 4.3 s or less (39). The affected limbs were tested 3 times, with an
interval of 2 min between consecutive tests to prevent sensitization, and the three
latencies were averaged to obtain a final result (40; 41). If there was no paw withdrawal
after 12 s, the heat stimulus was removed to prevent tissue damage, and the animal
was assigned the maximal WRL of 12 s (42).
Kinematic Analysis
Ankle kinematics during the stance phase of the rat walk was recorded prior nerve
injury (week-0), at week-2 and every 4 weeks during the 20-week follow-up time.
Animals walked on a Perspex track with length, width and height of respectively 120,
12, and 15 cm. In order to ensure locomotion in a straight direction, the width of the
apparatus was adjusted to the size of the rats during the experiments, and a darkened
cage was placed at the end of the corridor to attract the animals. The rats gait was
video recorded at a rate of 100 images per second (JVC GR-DVL9800, New Jersey,
USA). The camera was positioned perpendicular to the mid-point of the corridor length
at a 1-m distance thus obtaining a visualization field of 14-cm wide. Only walking trials
with stance phases lasting between 150 and 400 ms were considered for analysis,
since this corresponds to the normal walking velocity of the rat (20–60 cm/s) (42-44).
The video images were stored in a computer hard disk for latter analysis using an
appropriate software APAS® (Ariel Performance Analysis System, Ariel Dynamics, San
Diego, USA). 2-D biomechanical analysis (sagittal plan) was carried out applying a two-
segment model of the ankle joint, adopted from the model firstly developed by Varejão
and collaborators (8; 42-44). Skin landmarks were tattooed at points in the proximal
edge of the tibia, in the lateral malleolus and, in the fifth metatarsal head. The rats’
ankle angle was determined using the scalar product between a vector representing
the foot and a vector representing the lower leg. With this model, positive and negative
values of position of the ankle joint indicate dorsiflexion and plantarflexion, respectively.
For each stance phase the following time points were identified: initial contact (IC),
Chapter 4 - Effects of Collagen Membranes Enriched with in Vitro-Differentiated N1E-115 Cells on Rat Sciatic
Nerve Regeneration after End-to-End Repair 83
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
opposite toe-off (OT), heel-rise (HR) and toe-off (TO) (8; 42-44), and were time
normalized for 100% of the stance phase. The normalized temporal parameters were
averaged over all recorded trials. Angular velocity of the ankle joint was also
determined where negative values correspond to dorsiflexion. Four steps were
analysed for each animal (8).
Histological and Stereological analysis
A 10-mm-long segment of the sciatic nerve distal to the site of lesion was removed,
fixed, and prepared for quantitative morphometry of myelinated nerve fibers. A 10-mm
segment of uninjured sciatic nerve was also withdrawn from control animals (N=6). The
harvested nerve segments were immersed immediately in a fixation solution containing
2.5% purified glutaraldehyde and 0.5% saccarose in 0.1M Sorensen phosphate buffer
for 6-8 hours. Specimens were processed for resin embedding as described in details
elsewhere (45; 46). Series of 2-µm thick semi-thin transverse sections were cut using a
Leica Ultracut UCT ultramicrotome (Leica Microsystems, Wetzlar, Germany) and
stained by Toluidine blue for stereological analysis of regenerated nerve fibers. The
slides were observed with a DM4000B microscope equipped with a DFC320 digital
camera and an IM50 image manager system (Leica Microsystems, Wetzlar, Germany).
One semi-thin section from each nerve was randomly selected and used for the
morpho-quantitative analysis. The total cross-sectional area of the nerve was
measured and sampling fields were then randomly selected using a protocol previously
described (46-48). Bias arising from the "edge effect" was coped with the employment
of a two-dimensional disector procedure which is based on sampling the "tops" of fibers
(49; 50). Mean fiber density in each disector was then calculated by dividing the
number of nerve fibers counted by the disector’s area (N/mm2). Finally, total fiber
number (N) in the nerve was estimated by multiplying the mean fiber density by the
total cross-sectional area of the whole nerve. Two-dimensional disector probes were
also used for the unbiased selection of a representative sample of myelinated nerve
fibers for estimating circle-fitting diameter and myelin thickness. Precision and
accuracy of the estimates were evaluated by calculating the coefficient of variation
(CV=SD/mean) and coefficient of error (CE=SEM/mean) (46-48).
84 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
7 Statistical analysis
Two-way mixed factorial ANOVA was used to test for the effect of time in the End-to-
End group (within subjects effect; 12 time points) and experimental groups (between
subjects effect, 3 groups). The sphericity assumption was evaluated by the Mauchly’s
test and when this test could not be computed or when sphericity assumption was
violated, adjustment of the degrees of freedom was done with the Greenhouse-
Geiser’s epsilon. When time main effect was significant (within subjects factor), simple
planned contrasts (General Linear Model, simple contrasts) were used to compare
pooled data across the three experimental groups along the recovery with data at
week-0. When a significant main effect of treatment existed (between subjects factor),
pairwise comparisions were carried out using the Tukey’s HSD test. At week-0,
kinematic data was recorded only from the End-to-End group so the main effect of time
was evaluated only in this group. Evaluation of the main effect of treatment on ankle
motion variables used only data after nerve injury. In this case, and when appropriate,
pairwise comparisons were made using the Tukey’s HSD test. Statistical comparisons
of stereological morpho-quantitative data on nerve fibers were accomplished with one-
way ANOVA test. Statistical significance was established as p<0.05. All statistical
procedures were performed by using the statistical package SPSS (version 14.0,
SPSS, Inc) except stereological data that were analysed using the software “Statistica
per discipline bio-mediche” (McGraw-Hill, Milan, Italy). All data in this study is
presented as mean ± standard error of the mean (SEM).
Chapter 4 - Effects of Collagen Membranes Enriched with in Vitro-Differentiated N1E-115 Cells on Rat Sciatic
Nerve Regeneration after End-to-End Repair 85
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
8 Results
8.1 Motor deficit and Nociception function
Motor deficit (EPT)
Before sciatic injury, EPT was similar in both hindlimbs in all experimental groups
(Figure 25). In the first week after sciatic nerve transection, near total EPT loss was
observed in the operated hindlimb, leading to a motor deficit ranging between 83 to
90%. The EPT response steadily improved during recovery but at week-20 the EPT
values of the injured side were still significantly lower compared to values at week-0
(p<0.05). A significant main effect for treatment was found [F(2,17) = 14.202; p=0.000],
with pairwise comparisons showing significantly better recovery of the EPT response in
the End-to-EndMembCell group when compared to the other two experimental groups
(p<0.05). At week-20, motor deficit decreased to 27% in the End-to-EndMembCell and
to 34% and 42% in the End-to-End and End-to-EndMemb groups, respectively (Figure
25).
EPT
0
20
40
60
80
100
0 1 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
W eek
Motor Deficit (%)
End-to-End End-to-EndMem b EndtoENdMem bCell
* #
Figure 25 - Weekly values of the percentage of motor deficit obtained by the Extensor
Postural Thrust (EPT) test. * Significantly different from week-0 all groups pooled together (p
< 0.05). # Group End-to-EndMembCell significantly different from the other groups (p < 0.05).
Results are presented as mean and standard error of the mean (SEM).
86 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Nociception function (WRL)
In the week after sciatic transection, all the animals presented a severe loss of sensory
and nociception function acutely after sciatic nerve transection and the WRL test has to
be interrupted at the 12 s-cutoff time (Figure 26). During the following weeks there was
recovery in paw nociception which was more clearly seen between weeks 6 and 8
post-surgery. At week-6, half of the animals still had no withdrawal response to the
noxious thermal stimulus in the operated side, which is in contrast with week-8, when
all animals presented a consistent, although delayed, response. Despite such
improvement in WRL response, contrast analysis showed persistence of sensory deficit
in all groups by the end of the 20-weeks recovery time (p<0.05). No differences
between the groups was observed in the level of WRL impairment after the sciatic
nerve transection [F(2,17) = 1.563; p=0.238].
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
0 1 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
End-to-End End-to_EndMemb End-to_EndMembCell
* * * *
Figure 26 - Weekly values of the withdrawal reflex latency test. At week-1 all animals failed in responding to
the noxious thermal stimulus within the 12 sec cut-off time. No differences between the percentages of
motor deficit obtained by the Extensor Postural Thrust (EPT) test. * Significantly different from week-0 all
groups pooled together (p < 0.05). Results are presented as mean and standard error of the mean (SEM).
Chapter 4 - Effects of Collagen Membranes Enriched with in Vitro-Differentiated N1E-115 Cells on Rat Sciatic
Nerve Regeneration after End-to-End Repair 87
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
Kinematics Analysis
Figure 27 and Figure 28 display the mean plots, respectively for ankle joint angle and
ankle joint velocity during the stance phase of the rat walk. Comparisons to the normal
ankle motion can only be draw for the End-to-End group for reasons explained in the
Methods section. In the weeks following sciatic nerve transection, ankle joint motion
became severely abnormal, particularly throughout the second half of stance
corresponding to the push-off sub-phase. In clear contrast to the normal pattern of
ankle movement, at week-2 post-injury animals were unable to extend this joint and
dorsiflexion continued increasing during the entire stance, which is explained by the
paralysis of plantarflexor muscles. The pattern of the ankle joint motion seemed to
have improved only slightly during recovery. Contrast analysis was performed for each
of the kinematic parameters (Table 1 and Table 2) with somewhat different results. For
OT velocity and HR angle no differences existed before and after sciatic nerve
transection, whereas for OT angle differences from pre-injury values were significant
only at weeks 2 and 16 of recovery (p<0.05). The angle at IC showed a unique pattern
of changes, being unaffected at week-2 post-injury and altered from normal in the
following weeks of recovery. Probably the most consistent results are those of HR
velocity, TO angle and TO velocity. These parameters were affected immediately after
the nerve injury and remained abnormal along the entire 20-weeks recovery period
(p<0.05). The effect of the different tissue engineering strategies was assessed
comparing the kinematic data of the experimental groups only during the recovery
period (see Methods). Statistical analysis demonstrated that the collagen membrane
and the cells had no or little effect on ankle motion pattern recovery. Generally, no
differences in the kinematic parameters were found between the groups. Exceptions
were IC velocity in the End-to-EndMembCell group, which was different from the other
two groups (p<0.05), and OT angle in the End-to-EndMemb group that was also
different from the other two groups (p<0.05).
88 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Figure 27- Kinematics plots in the sagittal plane for the angular position (°) of the ankle as it moves
through the stance phase, during the healing period of 20 weeks. The mean of each group is plotted
Chapter 4 - Effects of Collagen Membranes Enriched with in Vitro-Differentiated N1E-115 Cells on Rat Sciatic
Nerve Regeneration after End-to-End Repair 89
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
Figure 28 - Kinematics plots in the sagittal plane for the angular velocity (°/s) of the ankle as it moves
through the stance phase, during the healing period of 20 weeks. The mean of each group is plotted.
90 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Table 1- Ankle kinematics and stance duration analysis were carried out prior to nerve injury (week-
0), at week-2, and every 4 weeks during the 20-week follow-up period.
Values of the ankle angular position (°) at initial contact (IC); opposite toe-off (OT); heel-rise (HR);
toe-off (TO) of the stance phase. Results are presented as mean and standard error of the mean
(SEM). N corresponds to the number of rats within the experimental group.
Chapter 4 - Effects of Collagen Membranes Enriched with in Vitro-Differentiated N1E-115 Cells on Rat Sciatic
Nerve Regeneration after End-to-End Repair 91
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
Table 2- Ankle kinematics and stance duration analysis were carried out prior to nerve injury (wek-
0), at week-2, and every 4 weeks during the 20-week follow-up period.
Values of the ankle angular velocity (°/sec) at initial contact (IC); opposite toe-off (OT); heel-rise
(HR); toe-off (TO) of the stance phase. Results are presented as mean and standard error of the
mean (SEM). N corresponds to the number of rats within the experimental group.
92 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
8.2 Histological and Stereological Analysis
Table 3- Stereological quantitative assessment density, total
number, diameter and myelin thickness of regenerated sciatic
nerve fibers at week-20 after neurotmesis. Values are presented as
mean ± SEM.
Chapter 4 - Effects of Collagen Membranes Enriched with in Vitro-Differentiated N1E-115 Cells on Rat Sciatic
Nerve Regeneration after End-to-End Repair 93
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
Figure 29 shows representative light micrographs of the regenerated sciatic nerves of
the three groups (Figure 29A-C) and control sciatic normal nerves (Figure 29D). As
expected, regeneration of axons was organized in many smaller fascicles in
comparison to controls. The results of the stereological analysis of myelinated nerve
fibers are reported in Table 3. Statistical analysis by ANOVA test revealed no
significant (p>0.05) difference regarding any of the morphological parameters
investigated in the regenerated axons from the three experimental groups. On the other
hand, comparison between regenerated and control nerves showed, as expected, the
presence of a significantly (p<0.05) higher density and total number of myelinated
axons in experimental groups accompanied by a significantly (p<0.05) lower fiber
diameter.
Figure 29 - Representative high resolution photomicrographs of nerve fibers form regenerated (A-C)
and normal (D) rat sciatic nerves. A: End-to-End. B:End-to-EndMemb. C:End-to-EndMembCell.
Magnification = × 1,500.
94 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
9 DISCUSSION
Transected peripheral nerves can regenerate provided that a connection is available
between the proximal and distal severed stumps and, when no substance loss
occurred; surgical treatment consists in direct end-to-end suturing of the nerve ends (2;
3). However, in spite of the progress of microsurgical nerve repair, the outcome of
nerve reconstruction is still far from being optimal (51). Since during regeneration
axons require neurotrophic support, they could benefit from the presence of a growth
factors delivery cell system capable of responding to stimuli of the local environment
during axonal regeneration.
In the present study, we aimed at investigating the effects of enwrapping the site of
end-to-end rat sciatic nerve repair with equine type III collagen nerve membranes
either alone or enriched with N1E-115 pre-differentiated into neural cells in the
presence of 1.5% of DMSO. The rationale for the utilization of the N1E-115 cells was to
take advantages of the properties of these cells as a neural-like cellular source of
neurotrophic factors (6-10).
Results showed that enwrapment with a collagen membrane, with or without neural cell
enrichment, did not lead to any significant improvement in most of functional and
stereological predictors of nerve regeneration that we have assessed. The only
exception was represented by motor deficit recovery which was significantly improved
after lesion site enwrapment with membrane enriched with neural cells pre-
differentiated from N1E-115 cell line.
Natural tissues possess several advantages when compared to synthetic materials,
when use to reconstruct peripheral nerves after injury. Natural materials are more likely
to be biocompatible than artificial materials, are less toxic, and provide a support
structure to promote cell adhesion and migration. Drawbacks, on the other hand,
include potential difficulties with isolation and controlled scale-up. In addition to intact
acellular tissues, a great deal of research has focused on the use of purified natural
ECM proteins and glycosaminoglycans, which can be modified to serve as appropriate
scaffolding. ECM molecules, such as laminin, collagen, and fibronectin, have been
shown to play a significant role in axonal development and repair in the body (24; 52).
There are a number of examples in which the ECM proteins laminin, fibronectin, and
collagen have been used for nerve repair applications (21; 23-25; 52-56). For example,
silicone tubes filled with laminin, fibronectin, and collagen show improved regeneration
over a 10 mm rat sciatic nerve gap compared to empty silicone controls (14). Collagen
Chapter 4 - Effects of Collagen Membranes Enriched with in Vitro-Differentiated N1E-115 Cells on Rat Sciatic
Nerve Regeneration after End-to-End Repair 95
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
filaments have also been used to guide regenerating axons across 20–30 mm defects
in rats (25; 26; 57). Further studies have shown that oriented fibers of collagen within
gels, aligned using magnetic fields, provide an improved template for neurite extension
compared to randomly oriented collagen fibers (22; 27). Rates of regeneration after
neurotmesis comparable to those using a nerve autograft have been achieved using
collagen tubes containing a porous collagen-glycosaminoglycan matrix (29; 30).
Results of this study contribute to the lively debate about the employment of cell
transplantation for improving post-traumatic nerve regeneration (58; 59). Actually, a
great enthusiasm among researchers and especially the public opinion has risen over
the last years about cell-based therapies in Regenerative Medicine (60-62) and there
seems to be widespread conviction that this type of therapy is not only effective but
also very safe in comparison to other pharmacological or surgical therapeutic
approaches. By contrast, recent studies showed that cell-based therapy might be
ineffective for improving nerve regeneration [66-69], and results of the present study
are in line with these observations. Recently, it has even been shown that N1E-115 cell
transplantation can also have negative results by hindering the nerve regeneration
process after tubulisation repair (17). Of course, the choice of the cell type to be used
for transplantation is very important for the therapeutic success and use of another cell
type could have led to better results, especially when the cellular system of choice is
derived from autologous or heterologous stem cells1 (17-20; 58; 63). Moreover, the
construction of more appropriate tube-guides with integrated growth factor delivery
systems and/or cellular components could improve the effectiveness of nerve tissue
engineering. In fact, single-molded tube guides may not give sufficient control over both
the mechanical properties and the delivery of bioactive agents. More complex devices
will be needed, such as multilayered tube guides where growth factors are entrapped in
polymer layers with varying physicochemical properties or tissue engineered tube
guides containing viable stem cells (17-20; 58; 63). The combination of two or more
growth factors will likely exert a synergistic effect on nerve regeneration, especially
when the growth factors belong to different families and act via different mechanisms.
Combinations of growth factors can be expected to enhance further nerve
regeneration, particularly when each of them is delivered at individually tailored kinetics
(16-20; 58; 63). The determination and control of suitable delivery kinetics for each of
several growth factors will constitute a major hurdle both technically and biologically
with the biological hurdle lying in the compliance with the naturally occurring cross talk
between growth factors and cells. A solution to this problem may be the use of
96 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
autologous stem cells because they can synthesize several growth factors and
differentiate into Schwann cells which are critical for very long gaps (16-20; 58; 63).
Previous work already published by other research groups, point out a very interesting
source of stem cells for nerve regeneration of peripheral nerve and spinal cord. They
developed hair follicle pluripotent stem cells (hfPS) and have shown that these cells
can differentiate to neurons, glial cells in vitro, and other cell types, and can promote
nerve and spinal cord regeneration in vivo. These cells are located above the hair
follicle bulge (hfPS cell area) and are nestin and CD34 positive, and keratin 15
negative (64-67). The mouse hfPS cells were implanted into the gap region of the
severed sciatic and tibial nerve of mice. These cells, after 6-8 weeks,
transdifferentiated largely into Schwann cells. Also, blood vessels formed a network
around the joined sciatic and tibial nerve. Function of the rejoined sciatic and tibial
nerve was confirmed by contraction of the gastrocnemius muscle upon electrical
stimulation and by walking track analysis (64-66). hfPS cells can promote axonal
growth and functional recovery after peripheral nerve injury, offering an important
opportunity for future clinical application. These hfPS cells, in contrast to Embrionic
stem cells, N1E-115 cells after in vitro differentiation and induced pluripotent stem
cells, do not require any genetic manipulation, are readily accessible from any patient,
and lack the ethical issues, do not form tumors.
Chapter 4 - Effects of Collagen Membranes Enriched with in Vitro-Differentiated N1E-115 Cells on Rat Sciatic
Nerve Regeneration after End-to-End Repair 97
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
References
1. Lundborg G. Alternatives to autologous nerve grafts. [Internet]. Handchirurgie,
Mikrochirurgie, plastische Chirurgie. 2004 Feb ;36(1):1-7.
2. Matsuyama T, Mackay M, Midha R. Peripheral nerve repair and grafting
techniques: a review [Internet]. Neurologia medico-chirurgica. 2000 ;40(4):187–
199.
3. Siemionow M, Brzezicki G. Chapter 8: Current techniques and concepts in
peripheral nerve repair. [Internet]. International review of neurobiology. 2009 Jan
;87141-72.
4. Kimhi Y, Palfrey C, Spector I, Barak Y, Littauer UZ. Maturation of neuroblastoma
cells in the presence of dimethylsulfoxide. [Internet]. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 1976 Feb ;73(2):462-6.
5. Prasad KN, Kentroti S, Edwards-Prasad J, Vernadakis A, Imam M, Carvalho E,
et al. Modification of the expression of adenosine 3ʼ,5'-cyclic monophosphate-
induced differentiated functions in neuroblastoma cells by beta-carotene and D-
alpha-tocopheryl succinate. [Internet]. Journal of the American College of
Nutrition. 1994 Jun ;13(3):298-303.
6. Rodrigues JM, Luís AL, Lobato JV, Pinto MV, Faustino A, Hussain NS, et al.
Intracellular Ca2+ concentration in the N1E-115 neuronal cell line and its use for
peripheric nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Acta médica portuguesa. 2005
;18(5):323-8.
7. Rodrigues JM, Luís AL, Lobato JV, Pinto MV, Lopes MA, Freitas M, et al.
Determination of the intracellular Ca2+ concentration in the N1E-115 neuronal
cell line in perspective of its use for peripheric nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Bio-
medical materials and engineering. 2005 Jan ;15(6):455-65.
8. Luís AL, Amado S, Geuna S, Rodrigues JM, Simões MJ, Santos JD, et al. Long-
term functional and morphological assessment of a standardized rat sciatic
nerve crush injury with a non-serrated clamp. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience
methods. 2007 Jun ;163(1):92-104.
9. Luís AL, Rodrigues JM, Geuna S, Amado S, Simões MJ, Fregnan F, et al.
Neural cell transplantation effects on sciatic nerve regeneration after a
standardized crush injury in the rat. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2008 Jan
;28(6):458-70.
98 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
10. Amado S, Simões MJ, Armada da Silva PAS, Luís AL, Shirosaki Y, Lopes MA,
et al. Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve
regeneration in an axonotmesis rat model. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2008 Nov
;29(33):4409-19.
11. Doolabh VB, Hertl MC, Mackinnon SE. The role of conduits in nerve repair: a
review. [Internet]. Reviews in the neurosciences. 7(1):47-84.
12. Jensen JN, Tung THH, Mackinnon SE, Brenner MJ, Hunter DA. Use of anti-
CD40 ligand monoclonal antibody as antirejection therapy in a murine peripheral
nerve allograft model. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2004 Jan ;24(4):309-15.
13. Geuna S, Papalia I, Tos P. End-to-side (terminolateral) nerve regeneration: a
challenge for neuroscientists coming from an intriguing nerve repair concept.
[Internet]. Brain research reviews. 2006 Sep ;52(2):381-8.
14. Chen YS, Hsieh CL, Tsai CC, Chen TH, Cheng WC, Hu CL, et al. Peripheral
nerve regeneration using silicone rubber chambers filled with collagen, laminin
and fibronectin. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2000 Aug ;21(15):1541-7.
15. Dunnen WF den, Robinson PH, Wessel R van, Pennings AJ, Leeuwen MB van,
Schakenraad JM. Long-term evaluation of degradation and foreign-body reaction
of subcutaneously implanted poly(DL-lactide-epsilon-caprolactone). [Internet].
Journal of biomedical materials research. 1997 Sep ;36(3):337-46.
16. Schmidt CE, Leach JB. Neural tissue engineering: strategies for repair and
regeneration. [Internet]. Annual review of biomedical engineering. 2003 Jan
;5293-347.
17. Luís AL, Rodrigues JM, Geuna S, Amado S, Shirosaki Y, Lee JM, et al. Use of
PLGA 90:10 scaffolds enriched with in vitro-differentiated neural cells for
repairing rat sciatic nerve defects. [Internet]. Tissue engineering. Part A. 2008
Jun ;14(6):979-93.
18. Battiston B, Raimondo S, Tos P, Gaidano V, Audisio C, Scevola A, et al.
Chapter 11: Tissue engineering of peripheral nerves [Internet]. Elsevier; 2009.
19. Zacchigna S, Giacca M. Chapter 20: Gene therapy perspectives for nerve repair.
[Internet]. International review of neurobiology. 2009 Jan ;87381-92.
20. Karagoz H, Ulkur E, Uygur F, Senol MG, Yapar M, Turan P, et al. Comparison of
regeneration results of prefabricated nerve graft, autogenous nerve graft, and
vein graft in repair of nerve defects. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2009 Jan
;29(2):138-43.
Chapter 4 - Effects of Collagen Membranes Enriched with in Vitro-Differentiated N1E-115 Cells on Rat Sciatic
Nerve Regeneration after End-to-End Repair 99
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
21. Kauppila T, Jyväsjärvi E, Huopaniemi T, Hujanen E, Liesi P. A laminin graft
replaces neurorrhaphy in the restorative surgery of the rat sciatic nerve.
[Internet]. Experimental neurology. 1993 Oct ;123(2):181-91.
22. Ceballos D, Navarro X, Dubey N, Wendelschafer-Crabb G, Kennedy WR,
Tranquillo RT. Magnetically aligned collagen gel filling a collagen nerve guide
improves peripheral nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Experimental neurology.
1999 Aug ;158(2):290-300.
23. Toba T, Nakamura T, Lynn AK, Matsumoto K, Fukuda S, Yoshitani M, et al.
Evaluation of peripheral nerve regeneration across an 80-mm gap using a
polyglycolic acid (PGA)--collagen nerve conduit filled with laminin-soaked
collagen sponge in dogs. [Internet]. The International journal of artificial organs.
2002 Mar ;25(3):230-7.
24. Grimpe B, Silver J. The extracellular matrix in axon regeneration. [Internet].
Progress in brain research. 2002 Jan ;137333-49.
25. Yoshii S, Oka M. Peripheral nerve regeneration along collagen filaments.
[Internet]. Brain research. 2001 Jan ;888(1):158-162.
26. Itoh S, Takakuda K, Kawabata S, Aso Y, Kasai K, Itoh H, et al. Evaluation of
cross-linking procedures of collagen tubes used in peripheral nerve repair.
[Internet]. Biomaterials. 2002 Dec ;23(23):4475-81.
27. Dubey N, Letourneau PC, Tranquillo RT. Guided neurite elongation and
schwann cell invasion into magnetically aligned collagen in simulated peripheral
nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Experimental neurology. 1999 Aug ;158(2):338-
50.
28. Archibald SJ, Shefner J, Krarup C, Madison RD. Monkey median nerve repaired
by nerve graft or collagen nerve guide tube. [Internet]. The Journal of
neuroscience : the official journal of the Society for Neuroscience. 1995 May
;15(5 Pt 2):4109-23.
29. Chamberlain LJ, Yannas IV, Hsu HP, Strichartz G, Spector M. Collagen-GAG
substrate enhances the quality of nerve regeneration through collagen tubes up
to level of autograft. [Internet]. Experimental neurology. 1998 Dec ;154(2):315-
29.
30. Chamberlain LJ, Yannas IV, Hsu HP, Strichartz GR, Spector M. Near-terminus
axonal structure and function following rat sciatic nerve regeneration through a
collagen-GAG matrix in a ten-millimeter gap. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience
research. 2000 Jun ;60(5):666-77.
100 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
31. Fu Y. Contributing Factors to Poor Functional Nerve Repair : Prolonged
Denervation Recovery after Delayed. 1995 ;15(May):3886-3895.
32. Tria MA, Fusco M, Vantini G, Mariot R. Pharmacokinetics of nerve growth factor
(NGF) following different routes of administration to adult rats. [Internet].
Experimental neurology. 1994 Jun ;127(2):178-83.
33. Amano T, Richelson E, Nirenberg M. Neurotransmitter synthesis by
neuroblastoma clones (neuroblast differentiation-cell culture-choline
acetyltransferase-acetylcholinesterase-tyrosine hydroxylase-axons-dendrites).
[Internet]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States
of America. 1972 Jan ;69(1):258-63.
34. Kerns JM, Braverman B, Mathew A, Lucchinetti C, Ivankovich AD. A comparison
of cryoprobe and crush lesions in the rat sciatic nerve. [Internet]. Pain. 1991 Oct
;47(1):31-9.
35. Sporel-Ozakat RE, Edwards PM, Hepgul KT, Savas A, Gispen WH. A simple
method for reducing autotomy in rats after peripheral nerve lesions. [Internet].
Journal of neuroscience methods. 1991 Feb ;36(2-3):263-5.
36. Thalhammer JG, Vladimirova M, Bershadsky B, Strichartz GR. Neurologic
Evaluation of the Rat during Sciatic Nerve Block with Lidocaine [Internet].
Anesthesiology. 1995 Apr ;82(4):1013-1025.
37. Koka R, Hadlock TA. Quantification of functional recovery following rat sciatic
nerve transection. [Internet]. Experimental neurology. 2001 Mar ;168(1):192-5.
38. Masters DB, Berde CB, Dutta SK, Griggs CT, Hu D, Kupsky W, et al. Prolonged
regional nerve blockade by controlled release of local anesthetic from a
biodegradable polymer matrix. [Internet]. Anesthesiology. 1993 Aug ;79(2):340-
6.
39. Hu D, Hu R, Berde CB. Neurologic evaluation of infant and adult rats before and
after sciatic nerve blockade. [Internet]. Anesthesiology. 1997 Apr ;86(4):957-65.
40. Campbell JN. Nerve lesions and the generation of pain. [Internet]. Muscle &
nerve. 2001 Oct ;24(10):1261-73.
41. Shir Y, Campbell JN, Raja SN, Seltzer Z. The correlation between dietary soy
phytoestrogens and neuropathic pain behavior in rats after partial denervation.
[Internet]. Anesthesia and analgesia. 2002 Feb ;94(2):421-6.
42. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Filipe VM, Gabriel RC, et al.
Ankle kinematics to evaluate functional recovery in crushed rat sciatic nerve
[Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 2003 ;27(6):706–714.
Chapter 4 - Effects of Collagen Membranes Enriched with in Vitro-Differentiated N1E-115 Cells on Rat Sciatic
Nerve Regeneration after End-to-End Repair 101
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
43. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Geuna S, Patrício J a, Azevedo HR, Ferreira AJ, et al.
Functional assessment of sciatic nerve recovery: biodegradable poly (DLLA-
epsilon-CL) nerve guide filled with fresh skeletal muscle. [Internet]. Microsurgery.
2003 Jan ;23(4):346-53.
44. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Gabriel RC, Filipe VM, et al.
Motion of the foot and ankle during the stance phase in rats. [Internet]. Muscle &
nerve. 2002 Nov ;26(5):630-5.
45. Di Scipio F, Raimondo S, Tos P, Geuna S. A simple protocol for paraffin-
embedded myelin sheath staining with osmium tetroxide for light microscope
observation. [Internet]. Microscopy research and technique. 2008 Jul ;71(7):497-
502.
46. Raimondo S, Fornaro M, Di Scipio F, Ronchi G, Giacobini-Robecchi MG, Geuna
S. Chapter 5: Methods and protocols in peripheral nerve regeneration
experimental research: part II-morphological techniques. [Internet]. International
review of neurobiology. 2009 Jan ;8781-103.
47. Geuna S, Tos P, Battiston B, Guglielmone R. Verification of the two-dimensional
disector, a method for the unbiased estimation of density and number of
myelinated nerve fibers in peripheral nerves. [Internet]. Annals of anatomy. 2000
Jan ;182(1):23-34.
48. Geuna S, Tos P, Guglielmone R, Battiston B, Giacobini-Robecchi MG.
Methodological issues in size estimation of myelinated nerve fibers in peripheral
nerves. [Internet]. Anatomy and embryology. 2001 Jul ;204(1):1-10.
49. Geuna S, Gigo-Benato D, Rodrigues A de C. On sampling and sampling errors
in histomorphometry of peripheral nerve fibers. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2004
Jan ;24(1):72-6.
50. Geuna S. The revolution of counting "tops": two decades of the disector principle
in morphological research. [Internet]. Microscopy research and technique. 2005
Apr ;66(5):270-4.
51. Gordon T, Sulaiman O, Boyd JG. Experimental strategies to promote functional
recovery after peripheral nerve injuries. [Internet]. Journal of the peripheral
nervous system : JPNS. 2003 Dec ;8(4):236-50.
52. Rutishauser U. Adhesion molecules of the nervous system. [Internet]. Current
opinion in neurobiology. 1993 Oct ;3(5):709-15.
53. Luis AL, Rodrigues JM, Amado S, Veloso AP, Armada-Da-silva PAS, Raimondo
S, et al. PLGA 90/10 and caprolactone biodegradable nerve guides for the
102 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
reconstruction of the rat sciatic nerve [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2007 ;27(2):125–
137.
54. Tong XJ, Hirai K, Shimada H, Mizutani Y, Izumi T, Toda N, et al. Sciatic nerve
regeneration navigated by laminin-fibronectin double coated biodegradable
collagen grafts in rats. [Internet]. Brain research. 1994 Nov ;663(1):155-62.
55. Whitworth IH, Brown RA, Doré C, Green CJ, Terenghi G. Orientated mats of
fibronectin as a conduit material for use in peripheral nerve repair. [Internet].
Journal of hand surgery (Edinburgh, Scotland). 1995 Aug ;20(4):429-36.
56. Ahmed Z, Brown RA. Adhesion, alignment, and migration of cultured Schwann
cells on ultrathin fibronectin fibres. [Internet]. Cell motility and the cytoskeleton.
1999 Jan ;42(4):331-43.
57. Yoshii S, Oka M, Shima M, Taniguchi A, Akagi M. 30 mm regeneration of rat
sciatic nerve along collagen filaments. [Internet]. Brain research. 2002 Sep
;949(1-2):202-8.
58. Terenghi G, Wiberg M, Kingham PJ. Chapter 21: Use of stem cells for improving
nerve regeneration. [Internet]. International review of neurobiology. 2009 Jan
;87393-403.
59. Lundborg G. Enhancing posttraumatic nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Journal of
the peripheral nervous system : JPNS. 2002 Oct ;7(3):139-40.[cited 2011 Mar
31] Available from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12365560
60. Tohill M, Terenghi G. Stem-cell plasticity and therapy for injuries of the
peripheral nervous system. [Internet]. Biotechnology and applied biochemistry.
2004 Aug ;40(Pt 1):17-24.
61. Pfister LA, Papaloïzos M, Merkle HP, Gander B. Nerve conduits and growth
factor delivery in peripheral nerve repair. [Internet]. Journal of the peripheral
nervous system : JPNS. 2007 Jul ;12(2):65-82.
62. Chalfoun CT, Wirth GA, Evans GRD. Tissue engineered nerve constructs: where
do we stand? [Internet]. Journal of cellular and molecular medicine. 10(2):309-
17.
63. Dahlin L, Johansson F, Lindwall C, Kanje M. Chapter 28: Future perspective in
peripheral nerve reconstruction. [Internet]. Elsevier; 2009. [cited 2010 Nov 22]
Available from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19682657
64. Amoh Y, Kanoh M, Niiyama S, Hamada Y, Kawahara K, Sato Y, et al. Human
hair follicle pluripotent stem (hfPS) cells promote regeneration of peripheral-
nerve injury: an advantageous alternative to ES and iPS cells. [Internet]. Journal
of cellular biochemistry. 2009 Aug ;107(5):1016-20.
Chapter 4 - Effects of Collagen Membranes Enriched with in Vitro-Differentiated N1E-115 Cells on Rat Sciatic
Nerve Regeneration after End-to-End Repair 103
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
65. Amoh Y, Li L, Campillo R, Kawahara K, Katsuoka K, Penman S, et al. Implanted
hair follicle stem cells form Schwann cells that support repair of severed
peripheral nerves. [Internet]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
of the United States of America. 2005 Dec ;102(49):17734-8.
66. Amoh Y, Li L, Katsuoka K, Penman S, Hoffman RM. Multipotent nestin-positive,
keratin-negative hair-follicle bulge stem cells can form neurons. [Internet].
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of
America. 2005 May ;102(15):5530-4.
67. Li L, Mignone J, Yang M, Matic M, Penman S, Enikolopov G, et al. Nestin
expression in hair follicle sheath progenitor cells. [Internet]. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 2003 Aug
;100(17):9958-61.
Chapter 5 - The sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb
joints kinematics analysis in assessing function in rats
after sciatic nerve crush
Amado S, Armada-da-Silva P, João F, Mauricio AC, Luis AL, Simões MJ, et al. The
sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb joints kinematics analysis in assessing function
in rats after sciatic nerve crush. Behavioural brain research. 2011; submitted.
106 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
1 Introduction
Injury of peripheral nerves is generally followed by abnormal nerve regeneration,
axonal misrouting, and incorrect reinnervation of the target organs (1; 2). Intense
investigation exists trying to develop new nerve treatments and neurorehabilitation
strategies, including alternative surgical techniques (3; 4), the use of biomaterial and
cellular systems (5-7), nerve electrical stimulation (8) and different modalities of
exercise (9; 10).
The evaluation of the effectiveness of peripheral nerve treating strategies, however,
requires accurate assessment of functional recovery, since the latter is the major goal
of peripheral nerve treatment and the most important outcome when translating
experimental treatment approaches to humans. Notwithstanding, functional
assessment in animal models of peripheral nerve injury is a challenging task. The rat
sciatic nerve is a widely used model of peripheral nerve injury. In this case, computer-
assisted biomechanical analysis of joint motion during walking using video recordings
and focusing on ankle joint motion as been shown to be a valid and reliable method to
evaluate functional recovery and the reestablishment of proper reinnervation (11-13).
When compared to other functional tests, in particular the standard sciatic functional
index test, analysis of ankle motion pattern during walking in sciatic-injured rats
demonstrates higher sensitivity to motion deficits and shows better relationship with the
degree of nerve regeneration (13). Also, recent studies demonstrate that measures of
two-dimensional (2D) ankle joint motion during rat walking present good day-to-day
and inter-observer reliabilities and are capable of identifying animals carrying injuries to
the sciatic, tibial or common peroneal nerves (14).
Joint kinematics during a given movement, such as walking, is usually represented by
a trajectory in an angle versus time space. Specific kinematic parameters are then
extracted from such trajectories considering particular events that can be
unambiguously defined (12; 14; 15). This can result in a varied number of variables that
may be used to measure changes in the normal pattern of joint motion. In the case of
experimental injury to the sciatic nerve of the rat, authors have focused on the ankle
joint kinematics during walking, based on the fact this nerve innervates the muscles
crossing this joint (11; 12; 14-16). Some studies limited their walking analyses only to
the stance phase, based on the argument that muscles are particularly active during
the stance phase in order to support the load of body weight and to generate the power
needed to accelerate the body forwardly (5; 11; 12; 17). However, more recent studies
have choose to analyze ankle motion during both the stance and swing phases of
Chapter 5 - The sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb joints kinematics analysis in assessing function in rats after
sciatic nerve crush 107
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
walking (14; 18), thus raising the ability to unveil motion deficits of the ankle joint after
sciatic nerve injury since this nerve supplies both dorsiflexor and plantarflexor muscles.
Also, 2D video analysis of ankle joint motion in the two walking phases is important to
distinguish between injuries to the sciatic, tibial or common peroneal nerves (18).
In previous studies we also conducted video recordings of the rat walk in the sagittal
plane pre and post sciatic crush injury, measured ankle joint angles at given time points
during the stance phase and calculated the angular velocities at these instants of time
(5; 11). The angular velocity of the ankle joint motion was used as an attempt to
improve the accuracy of ankle kinematic analysis to detect walking dysfunction. In fact,
there are cases where results of ankle joint angles are difficult to interpret, raising
concerns about their validity as a functional assessment. For example in our previous
study (11), we reported in sciatic nerve-crushed rats unchanged ankle angle at the
instant of opposite toe off in the early paralytic stage (two weeks post-injury) and
altered ankle angle at this time point thereafter and until the end of the twelve weeks
follow-up time. Inconsistent results were found also for other ankle kinematics
parameters in this study (11), as well as in other studies (14; 19). These suggest that
not all ankle kinematic parameters are sensitive to severe functional deficit caused by
complete sciatic nerve denervation and therefore are not a valid functional test.
Importantly, the use of inaccurate kinematic parameters blurs the results and may
become an obstacle to draw sound conclusions.
Sciatic nerve crush is also likely to affect the kinematics of hindlimb joints other than
the ankle joint. Motion changes at the hip and knee joints might accompany ankle joint
dysfunction during walking either to compensate for the abnormal movement of the
ankle joint or else due to higher-level reorganization of the whole hindlimb action in
response to long-lasting motor and proprioceptive deficits of the muscles supplied by
the sciatic nerve (20). Therefore, it is possible that screening hip and knee motion will
enhance the sensitivity and specificity of kinematic analysis of walking in the rat sciatic
nerve model. To our knowledge a walking analysis that includes a description of the
hip, knee and ankle joint kinematics after sciatic nerve injury has never been
performed.
The sensitivity (i.e. the true positive rate) and specificity (i.e. the true negative rate) are
two key properties of diagnostic and screening tests. These test properties can be
evaluated using linear discriminant analysis particularly if we are talking of multivariate
tests that combine several parameters (21). Discriminant analysis simply addresses
classification or discrimination in which objects or patterns are classified into one of
several distinct populations using a predictive model developed on a set of
108 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
independent variables (22). The number of subjects that are correctly classified by the
discriminant model provides a measure of the sensitivity of the set of testing variables
used in its building. Conversely, the number of subjects misclassified is a measure of
the specificity of the test variables. Additionally, discriminant analysis gives information
about the relative importance of each of the independent variables in their classification
role, yielding a sound basis for discarding variables with little contribution in separating
the groups. Therefore, discriminant analysis may be used to identify which are the best
walking joint kinematic parameters to assess functional recovery after sciatic nerve
injury in the rat.
In this study we conduct a detailed 2D biomechanical analysis of the hip, knee and
ankle joints in the rat and employed linear discriminant analysis to assess the
sensitivity and specificity of a large set of spatiotemporal and joint kinematic variables
as a test of movement dysfunction after sciatic nerve injury. Sciatic nerve-crushed rats
in the denervated (one week post injury) and in the reinnervated (twelve weeks post
injury) phases were used as they may serve as a model of animals with severe and
minor walking deficits, respectively. Sham-operated controls were used as the normal
walking group.
Chapter 5 - The sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb joints kinematics analysis in assessing function in rats after
sciatic nerve crush 109
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
2 Methods and Materials
Twenty four male Sprague-Dawley rats (Harlan Laboratories, Udine, Italy) were
randomly assigned to one of three groups. A crush injury to the right sciatic nerve was
induced in animals in two of the groups, while animals of the third group underwent a
sham surgery (Sham). Walking tests were performed one week after sciatic nerve
injury, corresponding to a period of complete denervation and paralysis of sciatic-
innervated muscles (DEN group) (23), and twelve weeks after either sciatic nerve crush
(REINN group) or sham surgery (Sham group). After twelve weeks from a sciatic nerve
crush, muscle reinnervation has occurred and functional recovery based on the
standard sciatic functional index is complete (11; 24; 25). As a result of the longer
follow up time, mean (±SD) weight was higher in the REINN (454.1±15.8 g) and Sham
(435.5±17.6) groups, compared to the DEN group (351±5.1 g). All procedures were
performed with the approval of the Veterinary Authorities of Portugal in accordance
with the European Communities Council Directive of November 1986 (86/609/EEC).
The sciatic crush injury procedure was described in detail elsewhere (11). Briefly,
under deep anaesthesia (ketamine 9 mg/100 g; xylazine 1.25 mg/100 g, i.p.), the right
sciatic nerve was exposed by skin incision and by splitting the fascia and muscles
overlying the nerve. The right sciatic nerve was crushed in the gluteal region, well
before its trifurcation point, by applying pressure for 30 s using a non-serrated clamp
(25; 26). The muscle, fascia, and skin were closed with 4/0 resorbable sutures. To
prevent autotomy, a deterrent substance was applied to the rats’ right hindleg and foot
[(27; 28). The animals were intensively examined for signs of autotomy and contracture
and none of the animals presented severe wounds (absence of a part of the foot or
severe infection) or contractures during the study. In sham-operated animals, skin and
muscle incisions were performed and the sciatic nerve exposed and mobilized, but no
injury was induced to this nerve. All animals were left to recover in their cages with no
other measures taken that could enhance nerve regeneration and/or functional
recovery.
2.1 Kinematic analysis
An optoelectronic system of six infrared cameras (Oqus-300, Qualisys, Sweden)
operating at a frame rate of 200Hz was used to record the motion of the right hindlimb.
After shaving, seven reflective markers with 2mm diameter were attached to the skin of
the right hindlimb at the following bony prominences: (1) tip of fourth finger, (2) head of
110 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
fifth metatarsal, (3) lateral malleolus, (4) lateral knee joint, (5) trochanter major, (6)
anterior superior iliac spine, and (7) ischial tuberosity. All markers were placed by the
same person. Animals walked on a Perspex track with length, width and height of
respectively 120, 12 and 15cm with two darkened cages placed at both ends of the
corridor to attract the animals and facilitate walking. Before data collection, all animals
performed two or three conditioning trials to be familiarized with the corridor. Cameras
were positioned to minimize light reflection artifacts and to allow recording 4 to 5
consecutive walking cycles, defined as the time between two consecutive initial ground
contacts (IC) of the right fourth finger. The motion capture space was calibrated
regularly using a fixed set of markers and a wand of known length (20 cm) moved
across the recorded field. Calibration was accepted when the standard deviation of the
wand’s length measures was below 0.4 mm. Planar motion in the sagittal plane of the
hip, knee and ankle joint was calculated with Visual 3D software (C-Motion, Inc,
Germantown, USA) by a computational procedure implementing the dot product
between the skeletal segments articulated by these joints. Joint velocity was also
calculated using the first derivative of joint angle motion. The trajectory of the reflective
markers was smoothed using a Butterworth low-pass filter with a 6 Hz cut-off. Data
were obtained by averaging six walking cycles. Each walking cycle was time
normalized by interpolation using the longest trial. Our angles convention was: 1)
decreasing hip angle value – hip flexion; 2) decreasing knee angle value – knee
flexion; 3) positive ankle angle value – dorsiflexion. Positive angular velocity indicates
increasing angle values. This also applies to the ankle joint: positive angular velocity
signifies increasing dorsiflexion. Joint angle and angular velocity values were
measured at the instants of initial ground contact (IC), defined as the time point where
horizontal velocity of the toe reflective marker becomes zero, midstance (MSt), the
point of fifty per cent duration of the stance phase, toe-off (TO), defined as the instant
the horizontal velocity of the toe’s reflective marker increases from zero, and midswing
(MSw), defined as the point of fifty per cent duration of the swing phase. Additional
kinematics parameters recorded included peak angles and angular velocities during
both phases of the walking cycle.
Spatiotemporal parameters, including walking velocity, walking cycle duration, stride
length, stance duration, and swing duration, were directly given by Visual 3D software
based on horizontal displacement of the reflective markers.
Interjoint coordination shape patterns were studied by using cyclograms or else
designated angle-angle plots. The angle-angle plots included those of hip-knee, knee-
ankle and hip-ankle. Cyclograms perimeters were measured using the euclidean
distance between each two consecutive points.
Chapter 5 - The sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb joints kinematics analysis in assessing function in rats after
sciatic nerve crush 111
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
3 Statistical analysis and modelling
Univariate ANOVA was used to test for differences between the groups. Further
pairwise comparisons were performed using the Tukey’s HSD test.
Linear disciriminant analysis was used to predict walking function and to classify
animals after sciatic nerve crush and controls. Four models were tested utilizing
spatiotemporal data and joint kinematics data of the hip, knee and ankle joints,
separately. For each subset all parameters were employed, meaning using both joint
angle and angular velocity in the cases of joint kinematics. Peak angles and angular
velocities were excluded from this analysis. The stepwise method was selected to input
the criterion variables with the Wilk’s Lambda choose as the method for inclusion or
rejection of the predictive variables. The leave-one-method was implemented for
further model cross-validation. This method is particularly useful when using small
samples and when a training sub-sample is not available for unbiased model
development. This method operates by having each subject classified by a discriminant
model constructed on the basis of data pertaining to the remaining subjects. Data are
presented as mean and standard deviation (SD). Statistical analysis was performed
using SPSS software package (version 17, SPSS Inc). Statistical significance was
accepted at p<0.05.
112 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
4 Results
4.1 Spatiotemporal parameters
Spatiotemporal data are presented in Table 4. The DEN group had a lower walking
velocity and a shorter stride length compared to the Sham group (p=0.005 and
p=0.007, for walking velocity and stride length, respectively) but not to the REINN
group (p=0.058 and p=0.145, for walking velocity and stride length, respectively). The
walking cycle time was longer in the DEN group, again only compared to the Sham
group (p=0.046, Sham group; p=0.131, REINN group). The DEN group also showed a
significantly longer swing duration, compared to both REINN (p=0.000) and Sham
(p=0.000) groups. No differences in spatiotemporal measures were observed between
the REINN and the Sham groups.
Table 4 - Mean values for spatiotemporal data for each experimental group; eight animals per
group
Groups Walking velocity
(ms-1)
Cycle duration
(s)
Stride length (m) Stance time (s) Swing time (s)
DEN 0.161±0.029b 0.852±0.057b 0.133±0.003b 0.238±0.030 0.175±0.009a
REINN 0.210±0.016 0.730±0.035 0.148±0.006 0.258±0.010 0.123±0.002
Sham 0.231±0.014 0.697±0.030 0.160±0.005 0.248±0.015 0.125±0.002
aSignificantly different from REINN and Sham; p<0.05;
bSignificantly different from Sham only; p<0.05
Chapter 5 - The sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb joints kinematics analysis in assessing function in rats after
sciatic nerve crush 113
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
4.2 Joint kinematics
Plots of mean ankle, hip and knee joint angle and angular velocity are shown in Figure
30 with the parameter measures reported in Table 5, Table 6 and Table 7
The ankle was the most affected joint after sciatic nerve injury. During the stance
phase, the most evident ankle motion change is the higher overall dorsiflexion angle in
Figure 30 - Mean trajectories for hip (upper graphs), knee (middle graphs) and ankle (lower
graphs) joint angle (left hand graphs) and angular velocity (right hand graphs) during the rat’s
walking cycle. Full lines correspond to the stance phase and dashed lines correspond to the
swing phase of the walking cycle. In the hip joint angle, increased extension during the stance
phase is visible in the DEN group (single line) as well as the increased flexion in the REINN
group (triple line). Also evident, the deep altered ankle kinematics in both stance and swing
phases in the DEN group and similar trajectories of ankle angle and angular velocity between
the REINN and Sham groups. All groups n=8.
114 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
the DEN group. In this group, ankle motion is also severely affected across the swing
phase, and the characteristic movement of fast dorsiflexion followed by plantarflexion
that can be seen in REINN and Sham groups is absent in the DEN group. Accordingly,
changes in ankle angular velocity in the DEN group occur mostly during the swing
phase and not during the stance phase. In both REINN and Sham groups, ankle’s
maximal dorsiflexion and plantarflexion angular velocities are recorded during the
swing phase, that obviously correspond to a large range of movement of the ankle
performed in a short time interval. In the DEN group, these two peak angular velocities
are no longer observed and in replace of a large amplitude movement, the ankle
performs a slow and small amplitude plantarflexion movement along the entire swing
phase. This ankle motion pattern is consistent with total paralysis of the hindleg
muscles and loss of contractile force of both the dorsiflexor and plantarflexor muscles
caused by complete injury of the motoneuron axons in the sciatic nerve.
Reflecting the deep ankle kinematics changes in the DEN group, ANOVA reveals
significant differences between the groups for all ankle kinematics parameters,
excepting ankle’s angular velocity at MSw (p=0.192, Table 5). Pairwise tests showed
significant differences in ankle angles and angular velocities between the DEN group
and both REINN and Sham groups, excepting for ankle angle at MSw, where the
differences were significant only between DEN and Sham groups (11.4±11.3º and
28.1±13.9º, for DEN and Sham groups, respectively, p<0.05). Peak dorsiflexion angle
during the stance phase was increased in the DEN group comparing with the other two
groups (47.42±7.82º, 3.60±14.19º, 4.53±15.19º, DEN, REINN, Sham groups,
respectively; both pairwise comparisons, p=0.000). No clear peak plantarflexion angle
could be identified in animals of the DEN group, either in the stance or in the swing
phase. Ankle peak angles and angular velocities during the swing phase in REINN and
Sham groups were similar (Table 5).
Hip joint motion was also affected by sciatic nerve crush (Figure 30 and Table 6). Hip
joint excursion during walking was considerably increased in the DEN group. This
increased range of motion was due to a larger hip extension during the stance phase
while hip flexion during the swing phase remained relatively unaffected (Figure 30).
Accordingly, hip angular velocity was also higher in the DEN group, than in the REINN
and Sham groups (Figure 30). In the DEN group, hip angle at IC, TO, and MSt were
significantly different compared to the Sham group (p<0.05). Hip joint angle and
angular velocity at MSt were different between the REINN and Sham groups (p=0.046
and p=0.034 for hip angle and velocity, respectively). Hip’s peak extension angle
occurred at around TO and therefore it was not computed. In the swing phase, a
distinct hip flexion peak angle could be noticed only in the DEN group. However, its
Chapter 5 - The sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb joints kinematics analysis in assessing function in rats after
sciatic nerve crush 115
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
value was similar to maximum hip flexion angle in the other groups for the same
walking phase (Figure 30). Hip peak flexion and extension velocities were increased in
DEN group compared to both REINN and Sham groups.
The changes in knee joint motion with denervation (DEN group) were less pronounced
than those registered in ankle and hip joints (Figure 30). The most evident knee angle
change in the denervated group is increased knee angle extension, particularly during
the stance phase (Table 7). The increased knee extension in the DEN group is likely a
compensation for the augmented ankle dorsiflexion and a strategy to maintain the
whole limb length. Knee angle changes were also noticed in the REINN group. This
group showed increased knee flexion at TO (50.29±15.09º), compared to both Sham
(72.50±11.26º, p=0.037) and DEN (79.40±13.55º, p=0.001) groups. Also, peak knee
flexion angle during the swing phase was increased in REINN group, compared to the
DEN group (p=0.047). This reflected a global increase in knee flexion throughout the
entire walking cycle in the REINN group compared to knee motion in sham-control
animals (Figure 30). No differences in knee angle at IC and MSw were found between
the groups. Knee angular velocity in the DEN group was different from either the Sham
or REINN groups at MSt, TO, and MSw. No differences in knee angular velocity were
found between REINN and Sham groups. Knee peak flexion velocity during the swing
phase was similar in all groups.
Table 5 - Mean values for ankle joint angle and angular velocity for each experimental group; eight animals per group
Ankle joint
Groups IC MSt
Peak value
extension
(plantarflexion)
Peak value flexion
(dorsiflexion) TO
Peak value
extension
(plantarflexion)
Peak value
flexion
(dorsiflexion)
MSw
Ang
le (
º)
DEN -0.6±
12.9a
46.2±
8.4a
-0.81±
13.26
47.42±
7.82a
17.1±
9.4a
-5.31±
12.65b
17.50±
9.57
11.4±
11.3b
REINN -20.1±
12.5
4.2±
14.1
-22.45±
13.08
3.60±
14.19
-14.6±
13.6
-20.86±
12.69
22.63±
14.89
23.1±
15.1
Sham -16.4±
9.6
4.7±
15.1
-18.55±
11.15
4.53±
15.19
-17.0±
11.0
-17.34±
9.97
28.66±
14.49
29.1±
13.9
Vel
ocity
(º/
s)
DEN 321.8±
145.8a
200.3±
91.6a
573.93±
64.71
-447.97±
100.00
-361.4±
237.8a
42.13±
122.98
-407.78±
156.76
-228.0±
256.1
REINN -313.4±
100.7
1.4±
56.2
386.26±
43.01
-297.82±
49.87
431.4±
113.6
846.71±
100.51
-912.5±
140.87
-402.3±
91.2
Sham -280.9±
127.4
-52.2±
81.8
359.45±
87.23
-359.57±
68.31
486.8±
104.1
1025.51±
198.15
-967.05±
189.79
-383.1±
220.6 a Significantly different from REINN and Sham; p < 0.05; b Significantly different from Sham only; p < 0.05
Table 6 - Mean values for hip joint angle and angular velocity for each experimental group; eight animals per group
Hip joint
Groups IC MSt Peak value
extension
Peak value
flexion TO
Peak value
extension
Peak value
flexion MSw
Ang
le (
º)
DEN 90.51
14.84b
112.50
8.70b
116.58
11.07
91.25
14.46a
109.42
13.51b
104.45
14.30b
74.77
15.54
75.38
15.71
REINN 65.44
10.20
74.76
13.11b
77.27
14.38
65.30
10.04
71.06
14.41
74.90
15.53
63.30
10.84
63.94
11.47
Sham 76.42
10.15
89.01
11.16
98.50
14.40
76.44
10.19
93.40
14.80
97.42
15.48
74.38
9.79
77.26
10.80
Vel
ocity
(º/
s)
DEN 294.67
85.80a
125.43
83.40
116.70
86.56
-372.18
168.03
-347.56
116.73a
302.19
82.24a
-471.49
155.71a
-138.63
86.07
REINN 62.52
32.64
73.92
48.24b
109.15
34.03
-70.02
68.37
-155.40
49.02
71.27
26.05
-164.38
64.76
-30.01
78.72
Sham 71.42
29.92
157.03
44.71
163.95
32.73
-89.67
82.09
-236.47
55.28
86.56
18.40
-299.45
62.17
-144.23
107.46
aSignificantly different from REINN and Sham; p < 0.05; bSignificantly different from Sham only; p < 0.05
Table 7 - Mean values for knee joint angle and angular velocity for each experimental group; eight animals per group
Knee joint
Groups IC MSt Peak value
extension
Peak value
flexion TO
Peak value
extension
Peak value
flexion MSw
Ang
le (
º)
DEN 121.08
14.46
105.33
16.04a
123.34
14.88
77.33
7.83
79.40
13.55
120.07
14.91
62.24
14.10b
72.13
17.87
REINN 105.54
14.30
69.66
13.70
105.92
14.71
56.29
15.09c
50.70
13.34c
105.73
14.11
46.62
11.92
64.75
12.20
Sham 119.69
11.78
80.06
7.41
120.11
11.90
72.50
11.26
68.25
12.65
119.78
11.86
59.86
10.39
76.72
10.27
Vel
ocity
(º/
s)
DEN 26.49
69.29
-161.26
84.53a
-40.14
64.96
-270.98
44.66
-621.61
137.42a
959.80
189.25
-452.17
144.97
872.07
230.25a
REINN 9.01
82.35
-255.12
28.54
-125.40
77.40
-390.89
56.54
-265.91
65.89
1101.70
105.38
-237.73
66.86
1073.30
101.82
Sham -58.44
54.69
-213.98
69.05
17.96
112.34
-447.77
84.79
-363.16
87.63
1173.84
139.00
-339.01
110.13
1100.27
173.29
a Significantly different from REINN and Sham; p < 0.05; b Significantly different from REINN only; p < 0.05 c significantly different from DEN and
Sham; p < 0.05
Chapter 5 - The sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb joints kinematics analysis in assessing function in rats after
sciatic nerve crush 119
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
4.3 CYCLOGRAMS
The cyclograms in Figure 31 display the interjoint coordination for hip-knee, hip-ankle
and knee-ankle during the rat walking cycle. Our cyclograms of Sham group are
comparable to thoe observed in non-injured rats during level walking (29).
In line with hip motion changes, hip-knee plot in the DEN group displays wider
perimeter when compared to the REINN group (p=0.000). This increased perimeter
results from enlarged hip joint range of motion during walking in DEN group that is
approximately twice this joint’s range of motion in the other groups. Aside the higher
perimeter, the hip-knee plot also reveals interjoint coordination changes in the DEN
group. The stance-to-swing transition in sham controls (Sham group) is characterized
by reversal of hip motion from extension to flexion with the knee keeping its flexion
position during the early part of the swing phase. In contrast, hip flexion in the DEN
group initiates with the rat’s foot still in ground contact and fulfils approximately half of
its flexion range of motion before the foot leaves the ground (swing initiation). Similarly,
hip extension in the DEN group starts well in the swing phase, with the foot still off-
ground and the knee at its maximal extension angle. Hip-knee plot perimeter is similar
in REINN and Sham groups as well as the shape of the angle-angle contour. However,
in the REINN group the hip-knee loop is markedly shifted to the left, reflecting the fact
that the hip joint is operating at a more flexed position.
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
120 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury: Kinematic Model of the Hindlimb of the rat
The cyclogram for the hip-ankle displays a horizontal eight-shaped pattern, present
also in the DEN group. In the REINN and Sham groups, the ankle joint at IC joint
reaches maximal plantarflexion and the hip has initiated extension. The DEN group,
however, shows altered changes in hip-ankle pattern at this time point, with the ankle
Figure 31 Ankle-knee, knee-hip and ankle-hip loops during the walking cycle for DEN (single line),
REINN (triple line) and Sham (double line) groups. Full lines correspond to the stance phase and
dashed lines to the swing phase. The start of the walking was taken as the initial paw ground
contact and is marked by a full circle. The end of the swing phase is signed with an arrowhead.
Chapter 5 - The sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb joints kinematics analysis in assessing function in rats after
sciatic nerve crush 121
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
moving already to dorsiflexion and with the hip having completed a significant amount
of its extension range of motion. Again, the major distinction between REINN and
Sham groups is higher hip flexion in the REINN group that is accompanied by slightly
increased ankle plantarflexion. During the stance phase, the range of ankle dorsiflexion
in the DEN group is increased when compared to both REINN and Sham groups, as
described when presenting individual joint kinematics. The hip-ankle loop pertaining to
the DEN group demonstrates that ankle plantarflexion during the stance phase is
associated with hip flexion. This suggests that flexion of the hip joint is a strategy that
enables foot clearance at the end of stance in sciatic-denervated animals, and
compensates the lack of contractile force by plantarflexor muscles.
In the REINN and Sham groups, TO coincide with maximal ankle plantarflexion
whereas the knee is maximally flexed at this walking event (see knee-ankle plot, Fig.
2). In these groups, ankle performs a fast dorsiflexion movement during the first half of
the swing phase while the knee maintains static its flexion angle. Ankle plantarflexion
and knee extension occur during the second half of the swing phase, reaching maximal
extension just before IC. In the DEN group, the major change in knee-ankle
coordination occurs during the swing phase and is characterized by active knee flexion
early during the swing phase, most likely to help raise the paralysed foot off the ground.
The perimeters of ankle-knee cyclograms were similar in all groups. Knee-hip
cyclogram perimeter shows differences between DEN and REINN groups. Hip-ankle
cyclogram perimeter is significantly different in DEN group compared to the REINN and
SHAM groups (p= 0.001 and p=0.000 respectively).
4.4 Discriminant analysis
Four different discriminant models were built: one model based on spatiotemporal data
and three other models based on the kinematic data of hip, knee and ankle joints. Peak
angle and angular velocity values were not considered for model development. All
models correctly classified DEN group animals, excepting the model constructed on the
basis of spatiotemporal data that assigned one of animal of the DEN group into the
REINN group. Models based on kinematics of the hip, knee and ankle joints showed
full sensitivity to identify the animals of the DEN group. Also, none of the animals of
REINN and Sham groups was wrongly classified into the DEN group by any of the
models. Therefore, the kinematics of the hip, knee or ankle all provide maximal
specificity for detecting walking changes in the early phase after sciatic crush injury.
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
122 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury: Kinematic Model of the Hindlimb of the rat
However, the several discriminant models revealed significantly less ability to identify
animals of the REINN and Sham groups. In REINN group, the rate of correct
assignments, i.e. sensitivity, lowered to 50% when using spatiotemporal data.
Surprisingly, the best models to distinguish between animals of the REINN and Sham
groups were those based on hip and knee kinematics. Assuming sensitivity as the
ability to identify animals of the REINN group, both hip and knee kinematics models
reach a sensitivity of 87.5% (7 out of 8 animals correctly classified), remaining
unchanged with cross-validation. However, the hip kinematics-based model displayed
better specificity, misclassifying just two animals of the Sham group before cross-
validation, and three after cross-validation. In contrast, the discriminant model based
upon the ankle joint kinematics performed poorly, correctly classifying just five animals
(62.5%) of the REINN group. The least sensitive model in finding the sciatic-
reinnervated animals was that employing spatiotemparal data. The hip kinematic
parameters selected by the stepwise method of linear disciminant model building were
hip angle at TO and MSw and hip angular velocity at IC and MSw.
Chapter 5 - The sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb joints kinematics analysis in assessing function in rats after
sciatic nerve crush 123
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
5 Discussion
The assessment of joint kinematics during walking can be useful to evaluate functional
recovery after hindlimb peripheral nerve injury in the rat only if its sensitivity and
specificity are acceptable. Here, we tested a large set of spatiotemporal and joint
kinematics parameters describing rats’ walking function, taking for the first time into
account data from the hip, knee and ankle joints. We showed that the large majority of
spatiotemporal and joint parameters are affected early post sciatic nerve crush injury.
Moreover, we demonstrated the ability of joint kinematics to highlight minor walking
changes after long term recovery from sciatic crush injury. However, the kinematics
changes during walking twelve weeks after sciatic nerve crush were noticed in the hip
and knee joints, while ankle joint kinematics had recovered its normal pattern. In line
with joint kinematics data, discriminant analysis clearly demonstrated that walking
measures, either pertaining spatiotemporal features or hindlimb joint kinematics
measures, accurately recognize sciatic-denervated animals and distinguishes them
from sciatic-reinnervated animals and sham controls. Only the models employing hip
and knee kinematics demonstrated good accuracy when distinguishing animals that
had recovered from sciatic crush from sham controls.
5.1 Spatiotemporal and joint kinematics in sciatic-denervated
and reinnervated animals
Different factors affect the accuracy and variability of hindlimb joint kinematics during
the rat walking, including two- versus three-dimensional analysis (30), the use of
anatomical- versus reference-based system (29), skin slippage and the difficulty in
tracking bony references (31), over ground versus treadmill walking (32),
familiarization, walking velocity and the size and weight of animals (14). However,
despite the various sources of variation ankle joint kinematics during walking in the rat
displays good day-to-day and inter-observer reliabilities when assessed by 2D video
recordings (14). In our study, we adopted a very careful experimental design in order to
avoid many of the above mentioned sources of potential bias and to reach accurate
measures of hindlimb joint kinematics during walking in rats with different degrees of
deficits and in control animals. In this sense, we used a motion capture system with
high frame rate and notable tracking precision, thus avoiding data aliasing and spatial
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
124 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury: Kinematic Model of the Hindlimb of the rat
imprecision. Great care was also taken in placing the reflective markers, and this task
was always carried out by the same person that followed a strict procedure. In addition,
the number of animals in each group was relatively large, the age and weight of sham-
operated and REINN animals were similar, and all animals were familiarized with
walking in the corridor prior to data collection. Therefore, our data can be viewed as a
reference for sagittal hip, knee and ankle kinematics in rats after sciatic nerve crush.
In the first week post sciatic nerve crush, and in the rat, the regenerating axons are
elongating in direction of the target organs but the end plates of the target muscles
remain denervated (23), which produces paralysis of denervated muscles of the
hindleg and foot and severe walking deficits. However, the animals are still capable of
locomotion by adopting an abnormal walking pattern that affects either the
spatiotemporal features of gait, the joint kinematics, and that is recognizable by simple
observation. In the DEN group, we observed slower walking speed and shortened
stride length. Also in this group, the stride duration was increased mainly caused by a
longer swing phase, while the stance phase duration seemed not to be affected. In
contrast, the gait spatiotemporal characteristics in the REINN group were similar to
those of the Sham group, indicating total recover of these gait parameters in twelve
weeks post sciatic crush, which is in line with previous reports (33). In fact, the
recovery of the spatial and temporal features of gait to pre-injury levels takes around
four weeks in cases of sciatic nerve crush in the rat (33). The mean walking speed in
our study varied from around 16 cm/s, in the DEN group, to 23 cm/s in sham controls,
with intermediate velocity of 21 cm/s in the REINN group. Walking velocity in rats
varies in a wide range and velocities between 20 to 50 cm/s are considered low (34).
This signifies that our reported velocities are at the lower limit of normal rat walking
velocity, even in our sham-controls. However, we were very careful selecting the
walking cycles for analysis and only those from uninterrupted sequences of three to
five walking steps were chosen, discarding steps with arrests or accompanied by
evident exploratory behaviours like sniffing.
Ankle joint showed the largest motion changes during walking early post sciatic injury,
comparing to the hip and knee joints. This is corroborated by several previous studies
using comparable sciatic injuries (5; 14; 25). Most of these studies have focused on the
stance phase of walking and they generally report increased ankle dorsiflexion in the
weeks immediately after the nerve injury (5; 7; 11; 12; 16; 17). Varejao et al. (19), using
computerized high-speed (225 images per second) video system, show increased
ankle dorsiflexion (90º angle between leg and foot corresponds to neutral ankle
position) during the entire stance phase when animals are assessed one week after
Chapter 5 - The sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb joints kinematics analysis in assessing function in rats after
sciatic nerve crush 125
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
sciatic nerve axonotmesis. Moreover, the degree of ankle dorsiflexion rises from the
point of initial contact to near the end of the stance phase. Although we employed a
photogrammetric system, our results are in total agreement with this latter study
(Figure 30). However, ankle motion changes in the DEN group during the swing phase
were also substantial. This is not a unique observation and decreased ankle
dorsiflexion angle at midswing, defined as the instant where the swinging leg crosses
the contralateral hindlimb, has already been reported after sciatic nerve crush (14; 18).
Our data confirms such decreased dorsiflexion at MSw plus decreased plantarflexion
angle in the late swing phase, which is compatible with lack of contractile ability by the
dorsiflexor and plantarflexor muscles supplied by the peroneal and tibial branches of
the sciatic nerve, respectively. Moreover, looking at both ankle angle and angular
velocity trajectories (Figure 30) it emerges that it is in the swing phase that ankle
motion pattern in the DEN group most deviates from the REINN group and the Sham
group. However, since we are not comparing the whole trajectories but simply testing
differences in certain kinematic parameters drawn from these trajectories at specific
time points, we found similar ankle angular velocity at MSw between all groups. This
apparently paradoxical finding is enlightening and shows how is critical the choice of
the individual kinematics parameters and exemplifies the chance of finding unaffected
parameters in animals presenting severe walking deficits (11).
Our data shows complete recovery of the normal ankle kinematics during walking in
twelve weeks after the sciatic crush. This agrees with prior studies with comparable
sciatic nerve injury, showing total recovery of ankle motion during walking in 2 to 6
weeks, depending on the particular angle parameter (5; 11; 14; 18). Notwithstanding
the fast recovery in ankle joint kinematics, we and other authors have reported subtle
and persisting ankle joint motion changes, emerging later in the recovery period (11;
12; 14). However, the exact meaning of these ankle motion changes is unclear. They
might indicate abnormal reinnervation of target organs and axon misrouting, causing
diskynesis that manifests only in later stages of recovery (18; 35); but the hypothesis
that in the sciatic crush model they simply reflect the effect of the various sources of
variation affecting the precision of these measures is also a strong possibility,
particularly taking into account their inconsistency in repeated measures taken at
regular intervals (11; 18).
A major contribution of this study is the reported changes in hip and knee kinematics
during walking affecting sciatic-injured rats. This improves our knowledge about the
extent of the walking deficits caused by sciatic injury but is particularly relevant since
altered patterns of hip and knee motion were encountered not just in the DEN group
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
126 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury: Kinematic Model of the Hindlimb of the rat
but also in the REINN group. In the DEN group, hip and knee motion changes were
expected as a mean to overcome the dysfunction at the ankle and foot and for allowing
locomotion. Higher level tasks required for walking include foot clearance from the
ground and the ability to protract and retract the whole limb during the swing and
stance phases, respectively (36). The ankle joint actively contributes to these tasks
either by joint rotation, particularly important in the swing phase, or by providing joint
stability through contraction of the muscles actuating this joint, which is required for
load bearing control during the stance phase. We observed increased hip and knee
extension angle in the DEN group during the stance phase. This change in normal hip
and knee action are most likely a strategy that compensates the inability of the ankle to
perform active plantarflexion. The higher hip range of motion in the DEN group is likely
a mean to replace the ankle joint in its functions of both push off and paw forward
displacement during the stance and swing phases, respectively. The hindlimb
protraction seems to be assisted also by trunk flexion, which is indicated by a visible
rounded posture of the rat’s torso. However, the contribution of the trunk to locomotion
and to the displacement of the affected hindlimb was not objectively measured. In turn,
increased knee extension during the stance phase maintains limb length in the
absence of ankle plantarflexion (Table 6).
Our data suggests that the hip plays a very important role in keeping limb function
during locomotion. In each phase of the walking cycle, the hip undergoes a steady
flexion or extension motion. This steady motion is lost in denervated animals. In the
DEN group, hip flexion starts before toe off in the stance phase, whereas hip extension
begins with the paw still off ground during the swing phase. This changed pattern of hip
motion probably emerges as a solution to move the paralytic hindleg using mechanical
energy transfer from the hip up to the foot. In the REINN group, the range of motion of
the hip joint during walking is similar to sham controls but the joint operates in
increased flexion, as demonstrated by the leftward shift of the loop in both the knee-hip
and ankle-hip plots of the REINN group (Figure 31). This change in hip motion was
unsuspected and could not be detected by simple observation. The reasons explaining
such altered hip motion in the REINN group cannot be resolved by our study. However,
one simple hypothesis would consider the increased hip flexion as an after effect of the
coordination pattern developed at early stages of severe deficit. As we saw,
denervated animals rely on trunk and hip flexion to propel the affected limb and this
facilitation of flexion may not be resolved even after recovery of the normal ankle joint
motion. Other possibility looks at the hip motion changes as an adaptive strategy
implemented at whole limb level to adjust for deficits at the ankle that cannot be
Chapter 5 - The sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb joints kinematics analysis in assessing function in rats after
sciatic nerve crush 127
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
disclosed by biomechanical analysis of this individual joint. In the cat, triceps surae and
gastrocnemius self-reinnervation are at the origin of motion deficits that surpasses the
ankle joint motion and affect the kinematics of the other limb joints (36). Apparently,
there are mechanisms that adjust individual joint kinematics in a step-by-step basis to
keep a relatively invariant whole limb orientation and length across the walking cycle
(36). Though, it is possible that hip motion changes during walking in our reinnervated
rats reflect the action of mechanisms that maintain a stable locomotor function in the
presence of long-lasting or permanent deficits in force generation ability or
proprioceptive feedback of the reinnervated muscles (1; 20). Probably more stringent
walking tasks, such as up-hill or downhill walking, are needed to unveil the ankle joint
motion deficits in the long term after sciatic nerve crush in the rat (20).
5.2 Discriminant analysis
Several tests based in walking analysis have played an extremely useful role in
assessing functional recovery in peripheral nerve research. To assess the efficacy of
novel peripheral nerve treatments we require functional test that are very accurate
since alternative nerve treatments will most likely be characterized by moderate or
small effect size (5; 37). The development of valid and accurate tests for unbiased
assessment of functional recovery in the rat is a challenging task considering the
difficulty in standardising the testing conditions and the constraint imposed by reduced
number of subjects in the experimental groups. Ankle joint kinematics during walking is
envisaged as a reliable and accurate test to assess function recovery but we should
underline that its testing properties have been evaluated using gross functional deficits
and contrasting groups of animals with deficits with large differences in magnitude (15;
16; 24). Here, we directly addressed this limitation by comparing sham controls with
animals that had recovered from sciatic crush injury for twelve weeks, a recovery time
that is enough to re-establish the normal values in many functional tests (38; 39).
Corroborating the data from several of the measured parameters, our discriminant
analysis confirmed the sensitivity of ankle kinematics during walking to highlight
functional deficits in sciatic-denervated animals. This level of sensitivity, however, is
shared by the discriminant models developed on the basis of hip and knee kinematics
as well as on spatiotemporal measures of the rat walking. This means that test
sensitivity is not a critical point when testing animals with deficits of great magnitude
caused by peripheral nerve injury, and researchers are comfortable choosing from a
rather large set of tests to evaluate functional deficits (7; 19; 25; 32; 33; 39; 40). The
critical issue is, therefore, how can we measures small differences in functional
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
128 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury: Kinematic Model of the Hindlimb of the rat
recovery that might indicate enhanced nerve regeneration, better re-establishment of
end organ reinnervation or changes at the integrative neural circuits at spinal or
supraspinal levels using behavioural tests. To date, we were unable to find evidence in
the literature that current tests employed to assess functional recovery after sciatic
nerve injury demonstrate such potential, particularly considering commonly employed
static tests (33). In an attempt to help solving this drawback, we explored the potential
of discriminant analysis. This statistical method is a powerful and popular classifier
technique and has been previously applied to extract predicting features from complex
movement patterns (41). Surprisingly, the discriminant models that employed hip and
knee joints parameters showed a very good sensitivity in distinguishing between
animals of the REINN and Sham groups. In fact, both hip- and knee-based discriminant
models identified correctly seven out of eight animals belonging to the REINN group.
This is a good sensitivity level and largely surpassed the sensitivity of the models
based on spatiotemporal or ankle joint parameters. Of note, the level of agreement
reached by the hip- and knee-based discriminant models was robust and did not
diminished with cross-validation.
Many of the variables selected by the discriminant analysis stepwise procedure regard
joints’ angular velocity. In the case of hip-based discriminant model, the predictor
variables selected included hip angular velocities at IC and MSw plus hip angles at TO
and MSw. Unlike joint angles, angular velocity is affected by gait speed and this might
be a limitation in using angular velocity data when animals walk freely along the
corridor. Although we could not find significant differences in group means for
spatiotemporal data between the REINN and DEN groups, we found significant
correlations between walking velocity and some of the angular velocity parameters
when considering only data from these two groups (data not shown). It is possible then
that differences between groups in angular velocity data reflect our particular
experimental setup and self-paced locomotion. However, our discriminant model using
spatiotemporal data consistently showed poorer performance when compared with
models using joint kinematics data. Further studies may want to look whether our
results are reproduced in more constrained walking conditions, such as using a
motorized treadmill.
Chapter 5 - The sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb joints kinematics analysis in assessing function in rats after
sciatic nerve crush 129
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
6 Conclusions
Hip, knee and ankle joint kinematics during walking are all deeply affected following
sciatic nerve crush in the rat. After twelve weeks, animals recover the normal pattern of
ankle joint motion but kinematics changes affecting the hip and knee joints subsist. The
discriminant models using kinematics data of the ankle, knee and hip joints reveal
maximal sensitivity and specificity to identify the denervated rats against reinnervated
and control counterparts. However, poor classification performance characterized most
of the discriminant models when addressing reinnervated and control animals. From all
tested spatiotemporal and joint kinematics variables, those describing hip joint motion
revealed higher ability to highlight minor walking deficits in the reinnervated animals.
We conclude that hip and knee kinematics analysis improves the sensitivity of rat
walking test and its potential to single out subtle functional changes in the long term
after sciatic injury, which may be essential to prove the advantage of new treatment
approaches.
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
130 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury: Kinematic Model of the Hindlimb of the rat
References
1. English AW, Chen Y, Carp JS, Wolpaw JR, Chen XY. Recovery of
electromyographic activity after transection and surgical repair of the rat sciatic
nerve. [Internet]. Journal of neurophysiology. 2007 Feb;97(2):1127-34.
2. Brushart TM. Preferential reinnervation of motor nerves by regenerating motor
axons. [Internet]. The Journal of neuroscience : the official journal of the Society
for Neuroscience. 1988 Mar;8(3):1026-31.
3. Geuna S, Papalia I, Tos P. End-to-side (terminolateral) nerve regeneration: a
challenge for neuroscientists coming from an intriguing nerve repair concept.
[Internet]. Brain research reviews. 2006 Sep;52(2):381-8.
4. Battiston B, Raimondo S, Tos P, Gaidano V, Audisio C, Scevola A, et al.
Chapter 11: Tissue engineering of peripheral nerves [Internet]. Elsevier; 2009. 0
5. Amado S, Simões MJ, Armada da Silva PAS, Luís AL, Shirosaki Y, Lopes MA,
et al. Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve
regeneration in an axonotmesis rat model. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2008
Nov;29(33):4409-19.
6. Luis AL, Rodrigues JM, Amado S, Veloso AP, Armada-Da-silva PAS, Raimondo
S, et al. PLGA 90/10 and caprolactone biodegradable nerve guides for the
reconstruction of the rat sciatic nerve [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2007;27(2):125–
137.
7. Luís AL, Rodrigues JM, Geuna S, Amado S, Simões MJ, Fregnan F, et al.
Neural cell transplantation effects on sciatic nerve regeneration after a
standardized crush injury in the rat. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2008 Jan;28(6):458-
70.
8. Brushart TM, Jari R, Verge V, Rohde C, Gordon T. Electrical stimulation restores
the specificity of sensory axon regeneration. [Internet]. Experimental neurology.
2005 Jul;194(1):221-9.
9. English AW, Cucoranu D, Mulligan A, Sabatier M. Treadmill training enhances
axon regeneration in injured mouse peripheral nerves without increased loss of
topographic specificity. [Internet]. The Journal of comparative neurology. 2009
Nov ;517(2):245-55.
10. Angelov DN, Ceynowa M, Guntinas-Lichius O, Streppel M, Grosheva M,
Kiryakova SI, et al. Mechanical stimulation of paralyzed vibrissal muscles
following facial nerve injury in adult rat promotes full recovery of whisking.
[Internet]. Neurobiology of disease. 2007 Apr ;26(1):229-42.
Chapter 5 - The sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb joints kinematics analysis in assessing function in rats after
sciatic nerve crush 131
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
11. Luís AL, Amado S, Geuna S, Rodrigues JM, Simões MJ, Santos JD, et al. Long-
term functional and morphological assessment of a standardized rat sciatic
nerve crush injury with a non-serrated clamp. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience
methods. 2007 Jun ;163(1):92-104.
12. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Gabriel RC, Filipe VM, et al.
Motion of the foot and ankle during the stance phase in rats. [Internet]. Muscle &
nerve. 2002 Nov;26(5):630-5.
13. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Melo-Pinto P, Raimondo S,
et al. Functional and morphological assessment of a standardized rat sciatic
nerve crush injury with a non-serrated clamp. [Internet]. Journal of neurotrauma.
2004 Nov;21(11):1652-70.
14. Ruiter GC de, Spinner RJ, Alaid AO, Koch AJ, Wang H, Malessy MJ a, et al.
Two-dimensional digital video ankle motion analysis for assessment of function
in the rat sciatic nerve model. [Internet]. Journal of the peripheral nervous
system : JPNS. 2007 Sep;12(3):216-22.
15. Santos PM, Williams SL, Thomas SS. Neuromuscular evaluation using rat gait
analysis. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience methods. 1995 ;61(1-2):79-84.
16. Lin FM, Pan YC, Hom C, Sabbahi M, Shenaq S. Ankle stance angle: a functional
index for the evaluation of sciatic nerve recovery after complete transection.
[Internet]. Journal of reconstructive microsurgery. 1996 Apr ;12(3):173-7.
17. Amado S, Rodrigues JM, Luís AL, Armada-da-Silva P a S, Vieira M, Gartner A,
et al. Effects of collagen membranes enriched with in vitro-differentiated N1E-
115 cells on rat sciatic nerve regeneration after end-to-end repair. [Internet].
Journal of neuroengineering and rehabilitation. 2010 Jan;77.
18. Ruiter GCW de, Malessy MJ a, Alaid AO, Spinner RJ, Engelstad JK, Sorenson
EJ, et al. Misdirection of regenerating motor axons after nerve injury and repair
in the rat sciatic nerve model. [Internet]. Experimental neurology. 2008
Jun;211(2):339-50.
19. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Filipe VM, Gabriel RC, et al.
Ankle kinematics to evaluate functional recovery in crushed rat sciatic nerve
[Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 2003;27(6):706–714.
20. Maas H, Prilutsky BI, Nichols TR, Gregor RJ. The effects of self-reinnervation of
cat medial and lateral gastrocnemius muscles on hindlimb kinematics in slope
walking. [Internet]. Experimental brain research. 2007 Aug;181(2):377-93.
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
132 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury: Kinematic Model of the Hindlimb of the rat
21. Sefton JM, Hicks-Little CA, Hubbard TJ, Clemens MG, Yengo CM, Koceja DM,
et al. Sensorimotor function as a predictor of chronic ankle instability. [Internet].
Clinical biomechanics (Bristol, Avon). 2009 Jun;24(5):451-8.
22. Press SJ, Wilson S. Choosing Between Logistic Regression and Discriminant
Analysis [Internet]. 2007 Nov ;
23. Jaweed MM, Herbison GJ, Ditunno JF. Denervation and reinnervation of fast
and slow muscles. A histochemical study in rats. [Internet]. The journal of
histochemistry and cytochemistry : official journal of the Histochemistry Society.
1975 Nov ;23(11):808-27.
24. Medinaceli L de, Freed WJ, Wyatt RJ. An index of the functional condition of rat
sciatic nerve based on measurements made from walking tracks. [Internet].
Experimental neurology. 1982 Sep ;77(3):634-43.
25. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Patricio JA, Bulas-Cruz J, Gabriel RC, Melo-Pinto P,
et al. Functional assessment of peripheral nerve recovery in the rat: gait
kinematics [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2001 ;21(8):383–388.
26. Beer GM, Steurer J, Meyer VE. Standardizing nerve crushes with a non-serrated
clamp. [Internet]. Journal of reconstructive microsurgery. 2001 Oct ;17(7):531-4.
27. Sporel-Ozakat RE, Edwards PM, Hepgul KT, Savas A, Gispen WH. A simple
method for reducing autotomy in rats after peripheral nerve lesions. [Internet].
Journal of neuroscience methods. 1991 Feb ;36(2-3):263-5.
28. Kerns JM, Braverman B, Mathew A, Lucchinetti C, Ivankovich AD. A comparison
of cryoprobe and crush lesions in the rat sciatic nerve. [Internet]. Pain. 1991 Oct
;47(1):31-9.
29. João F, Amado S, Veloso A, Armada-da-silva P, Maurício AC. Anatomical
Reference Frame versus Planar Analysis : Implications for the Kinematics of the
Rat Hindlimb during Locomotion. Reviews in the Neurosciences. 2010 ;485469-
485.
30. Couto P a, Filipe VM, Magalhães LG, Pereira JE, Costa LM, Melo-Pinto P, et al.
A comparison of two-dimensional and three-dimensional techniques for the
determination of hindlimb kinematics during treadmill locomotion in rats following
spinal cord injury. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience methods. 2008 Aug
;173(2):193-200.
31. Filipe VM, Pereira JE, Costa LM, Maurício AC, Couto P a, Melo-Pinto P, et al.
Effect of skin movement on the analysis of hindlimb kinematics during treadmill
locomotion in rats. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience methods. 2006 May
;153(1):55-61.
Chapter 5 - The sensitivity of two-dimensional hindlimb joints kinematics analysis in assessing function in rats after
sciatic nerve crush 133
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
32. Pereira JE, Cabrita AM, Filipe VM, Bulas-Cruz J, Couto P a, Melo-Pinto P, et al.
A comparison analysis of hindlimb kinematics during overground and treadmill
locomotion in rats. [Internet]. Behavioural brain research. 2006 Sep ;172(2):212-
8.
33. Bozkurt A, Deumens R, Scheffel J, OʼDey DM, Weis J, Joosten EA, et al.
CatWalk gait analysis in assessment of functional recovery after sciatic nerve
injury. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience methods. 2008 Aug ;173(1):91-8.
34. Koopmans GC, Deumens R, Brook G, Gerver J, Honig WMM, Hamers FPT, et
al. Strain and locomotor speed affect over-ground locomotion in intact rats.
[Internet]. Physiology & behavior. 2007 Dec ;92(5):993-1001.
35. Ijkema-Paassen J, Meek MF, Gramsbergen A. Reinnervation of muscles after
transection of the sciatic nerve in adult rats. [Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 2002 Jun
;25(6):891-7.
36. Chang Y-H, Auyang AG, Scholz JP, Nichols TR. Whole limb kinematics are
preferentially conserved over individual joint kinematics after peripheral nerve
injury. [Internet]. The Journal of experimental biology. 2009 Nov ;212(Pt
21):3511-21.
37. Yao L, Ruiter GCW de, Wang H, Knight AM, Spinner RJ, Yaszemski MJ, et al.
Controlling dispersion of axonal regeneration using a multichannel collagen
nerve conduit. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2010 Aug ;31(22):5789-97.
38. Bodine-Fowler SC, Meyer RS, Moskovitz A, Abrams R, Botte MJ. Inaccurate
projection of rat soleus motoneurons: a comparison of nerve repair techniques.
[Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 1997 Jan ;20(1):29-37.
39. Hare GM, Evans PJ, Mackinnon SE, Best TJ, Bain JR, Szalai JP, et al. Walking
track analysis: a long-term assessment of peripheral nerve recovery. [Internet].
Plastic and reconstructive surgery. 1992 Feb ;89(2):251-8.
40. Varejão a S, Meek MF, Ferreira a J, Patrício J a, Cabrita a M. Functional
evaluation of peripheral nerve regeneration in the rat: walking track analysis.
[Internet]. Journal of neuroscience methods. 2001 Jul ;108(1):1-9.
41. Cavalheiro GL, Almeida MFS, Pereira AA, Andrade AO. Study of age-related
changes in postural control during quiet standing through linear discriminant
analysis. [Internet]. Biomedical engineering online. 2009 Jan ;835.
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
134 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury: Kinematic Model of the Hindlimb of the rat
Chapter 6 - The effect of active and passive exercise in
nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic
nerve crush in the rat
S Amado, AL Luis, S Raimondo, M Fornaro, MG Giacobini-Robecchi, S Geuna, F
João, AP Veloso, AC Maurício , PAS Armada-da-Silva (2012). Neuroscience
(submitted)
136 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
1. Abstract
For the first time the effects of exercise after peripheral nerve injury was assessed with
quantitative method of kinematic analysis. There is growing evidence that both active
and passive exercise improve peripheral nerve regeneration and functional recovery.
With the aim of contributing to this mounting evidence, we investigated the effect of
treadmill walking exercise and the effect of passive mobilization of the entire hindlimb
in the sciatic morphology and functional recovery after a sciatic crush injury in the rat.
The injured animals were separated in a treadmill exercise group (EXa), passive
mobilization group (EXp) and a group without any further treatment intervention
(Crush). A sham-operated control group was also included (Sham). Active exercise
consisted on 30 minutes daily of treadmill walking at a speed of 10 m/min, while
passive mobilization consisted on 3 minutes repetitive triple flexion and triple extension
(i.e. simultaneous flexion or extension of the hip, knee and ankle joints) with slight
stretching at the two movement extremes. The two types of exercise slightly improved
nerve morphology at 12-weeks survival time, reducing the total number of regenerated
myelinated fibers to values similar to intact nerves. This effect of exercise on nerve
regeneration seems to operate through different mechanisms dependent on whether
the exercise is active or passive, since nerve fibers density was significantly increased
in the Exp group, in contrast to the sciatic-injured groups. Functional recovery was
assessed using gait variable and hindlimb joint kinematics during level self-paced
walking. At the end of the 12-weeks survival time spatiotemporal gait variables were
similar in all groups. Similarly, ankle kinematics recovered the normal motion pattern in
all groups. In contrast, hip and knee kinematics in the Crush group were still abnormal
at the end of the survival time, while these joints in both exercise groups displayed a
pattern of motion during walking that was indistinct from that of the sham control
animals. It is concluded that either active or passive exercise positively affect sciatic
nerve regeneration after a crush injury. We suggest that the positive role of passive
exercise results from a general stimulus induced by the movement and possibly
mediated by a direct mechanical effect onto the regenerating nerve.
Chapter 6 – The effect of active and passive exercise on nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic
crush injury 137
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
2 Introduction
Peripheral nerve injuries cause motor, sensory and autonomic dysfunction in the
denervated territory. After injury and repair, the injured axons grow from the proximal
nerve stump in direction to the target organs. However, and irrespective of the good
ability of peripheral nerves to regenerate, the degree of reinnervation and of functional
recovery after peripheral nerve injury is typically disappointing (1). Dysfunction after
peripheral nerve injury and repair is manifold. In the rat sciatic nerve crush model,
several studies show increased number of nerve fibers as well as decreased nerve
fibers’ diameter and decreased myelin thickness in regenerated nerves (2-4). The
increase in the number of nerve fibers distally to the injured site results from multiple
branching of the severed axons (5-7). The many collaterals branching from single
proximal axon often disperse and lead to inappropriate reinnervation, including
reinnervation of multiple muscle groups possibly with antagonistic function (8). A
second wave of axonal sprouting occurs when regenerating axons reach the target
muscle. In this case, axon terminal splits in several small sprouts that course through
bridges formed by extensive Schwann cells processes. In this way, multiple fine axonal
branches spread to re-innervate multiple end-plates. The poly-neuronal innervation
caused by increased density of sibling collaterals reaching the denervated muscle
groups and by terminal axon sprouting, disturbs force generation control and
contributes to poor functional recovery (8). Sciatic nerve injury also affects sensitive
function. Deafferentiation causes adaptive changes at the dorsal root ganglion and the
dorsal horn of the spinal cord, disrupting the normal processing of afferent inflow and
spinal reflexes integration (9). At a higher level, remapping of central controlling neural
circuitry may occur in order to cope with muscle paralysis and to maintain motor
function. All these changes contribute to dyskinesia, dysreflexia and hyperalgesia that
typically develop after peripheral nerve transaction and that severely compromise
functional recovery.
The poor functional outcome after peripheral nerve repair and its clinical relevance
have raised the interest in the development of rehabilitation strategies to enhance
nerve regeneration and improve functional recovery. Physical exercise is one of such
rehabilitation strategies and has been the focus of intense research recently. Many
different types of exercise have been tested, including active (3; 10-14) and passive
exercise (15; 16). Treadmill walking is a common procedure to stimulate the
denervated territories and the regenerating axons in rodents. This type of exercise
138 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
uses a natural pattern of locomotion and its intensity can be easily adjusted, turning
treadmill walking a very useful exercise model. Studies in mice show that active
treadmill walking at both mild and high intensity increases the rate of axonal elongation
after nerve transection (12) as well as it leads to a higher intensity in axonal collateral
branching but without accompanying increase in incorrect reinnervation (17). The latter
effect contrasts to that of electrical nerve stimulation delivered at the time of nerve
repair that has been shown to increase collateral axonal branching at the lesion site but
also causing excessive axonal misrouting (18). Positive effect of treadmill walking is
also reported for adult rats (16). In these animals, daily treadmill walking produced an
increase in the number of myelinated nerve fibers in transected and end-to-end
repaired sciatic nerves and enhanced muscle reinnervation, demonstrated by
increased M-wave amplitude in the gastrocnemius, soleus and plantaris muscles of the
affected hindlimb (16). In this study, active walking exercise also resulted in improved
spinal reflex activity and in a decrease in H-reflex facilitation that is manifested after
peripheral nerve injury and non-exercised animals (9; 16).
The positive effect of exercise stimulus on nerve regeneration and in the extent and
precision of target organs reinnervation seems to apply also to passive exercise.
Increased mechanical stimulation of the vibrissal muscles and whisker muscle pad of
rats restored the normal vibrissae function after transection and direct coaptation of the
facial nerve (15). Here, manual stimulation had no effect on the degree of axonal
collateral branching, which occurs in a large extent after facial nerve injury in rats, but
instead reduced the amount of motor end-plate polyinnervation (15). This positive
effect of manual mobilization of the denervated facial nerve territory seems to rely on
intact sensory function conveyed by uninjured trigeminal nerve sensory endings (19). In
the rat sciatic nerve model, passive exercise has also been shown to positively affect
nerve regeneration and muscle reinnervation, demonstrating that the beneficial effect
of passive mobilization after peripheral nerve injury also applies to lesions of mixed
nerve trunks and is not strictly dependent on normal sensory input (16).
By causing muscle paralysis, denervation is associated with reduced movement of the
affected limbs and mechanical unloading of muscles and other soft tissues. The lack of
normal movement pattern of the joints and surrounding tissues leads to the
development of tissue contractures and joint ankylosis in severe cases. These
conditions may be prevented by passive exercise, joint mobilization and gentle muscle
stretching. By helping maintain the normal muscle structure and joint mobility, this type
of exercise may contribute to functional recovery.
In this study we tested for the effect of brief manual mobilization of the hindlimb joints
and muscles on nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic nerve crush in
Chapter 6 – The effect of active and passive exercise on nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic
crush injury 139
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
the rat, and compared to the effect of active treadmill walking and to non-treated
conditions. Our manual mobilization technique involved moving the hip, knee and ankle
joints through their full range of motion thus applying a slight stretching to the muscles
crossing these joints as well as to the other soft tissues.
140 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
3 Methods
A total of 32 adult Sprague-Dawley male rats were randomly separated in the following
groups: (1) sciatic crush plus treadmill-walking (EXa), (2) sciatic crush plus passive
exercise (EXp), (3) sciatic crush (Crush) and (4) sham-operated control (Sham). Our
procedure to cause sciatic nerve crush has been detailed elsewhere. Briefly, we
utilized a non-serrated clamp (Institute of Industrial Electronic and Material Sciences,
University of Technology, Vienna, Austria), that exerts a constant force of 54 N onto the
nerve. The pressure was applied for duration of 30 seconds, generating a 3mm-long
crush of the sciatic nerve and complete axonotmesis. The right sciatic nerve was
crushed 1 cm above the bifurcation into tibial and common fibular nerves. This
procedure was demonstrated to cause complete axonotmesis of the sciatic nerve (4;
20-22).
Animals in the EXa group exercised for 30 min on a 10-lane motorized treadmill at a
constant speed of 10 m/min with zero incline. The exercise was performed 5 days a
week starting at week 2 post-injury and maintained until week 12 post sciatic nerve
crush (Figure 32). At least two weeks before sciatic crush injury, animals in the EXa
were acclimated to treadmill walking during five to ten minutes daily for one week.
Twelve days after the surgery, rats were again tested to ascertain their ability to walk
on the treadmill. All animals initiated the walking training protocol at day fourteen after
sciatic nerve crush.
Figure 32 - image of rats on the treadmill after sciatic nerve injury.
Passive exercise consisted on manual mobilization of the entire right hindlimb. The
passive mobilization of the hindlimb included movement of the hip, knee and ankle
joints in concert, and alternating flexion and extension of the joints. During extension, a
slight stretching was applied at the end of the movement amplitude. The passive
Chapter 6 – The effect of active and passive exercise on nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic
crush injury 141
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
exercise sessions took approximately three minutes and were undertaken with animals
fully awake with the head and upper torso covered with a scarf to help keep the
animals relaxed. The animals tolerated the passive exercise sessions without signs of
pain or discomfort. The exercise was performed 5 days a week and along the same
recovery period as the EXa group.
Animals of the Crush and Sham groups remained in their cages during the 12-weeks
recovery period with no other intervention. All animals were socially housed within a
single room. Dry food and water were provided ad libitum. All procedures were
performed with the approval of the Veterinary Authorities of Portugal in accordance
with the European Communities Council Directive of November 1986 (86/609/EEC).
3.1 Kinematic analysis
Gait analysis was performed before training protocol (one week post-injury) and at
weeks 4, 8 and 12 post-injury. This analysis used an optoelectronic system of six
infrared cameras (Oqus-300, Qualisys, Sweden) operating at a frame rate of 200Hz to
record the motion of the right hindlimb during the rat level gait. After skin shaving,
seven reflective markers with 2 mm diameter were attached to the right hindlimb at
bony prominences: (1) tip of fourth finger, (2) head of fifth metatarsal, (3) lateral
malleolus, (4) lateral knee joint, (5) trochanter major, (6) anterior superior iliac spine,
and (7) ischial tuberosity. The retroreflective markers were in all instances placed by
the same operator using the marked skin as a guide. Animals walked on a Perspex
track with length, width and height of respectively 120, 12 and 15 cm. Two darkened
cages were placed at the extremities of the corridor as a mean to facilitate the animals
to cross the walking corridor. All rats previously performed two or three conditioning
trials to be familiarized with the corridor. Cameras were positioned to minimize light
reflection artifacts and to allow recording 4-5 consecutive walking cycles, defined as
the time between two consecutive initial ground contacts (IC) of the right fourth finger.
The motion capture space was calibrated regularly using a fixed set of markers and a
wand of known length (20 cm) moved across the recorded field. Calibration was
accepted when the standard deviation of wand’s length measure was below 0.4 mm.
Planar motion in the sagittal plane of the hip, knee and ankle joint was calculated with
Visual 3D software (C-Motion, Inc, Germantown, USA) by a computational procedure
implementing the dot product between the skeletal segments articulated by these
joints. Joint velocity was also calculated using the first derivative of joint angle motion.
The trajectory of the reflective markers was smoothed using a Butterworth low-pass
filter with a 6 Hz cut-off. Data for each animal at each recording session consisted on
142 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
an average of six walking cycles. Each walking cycle was time normalized by
interpolation using spline fitting. Our angles convention was: 1) decreasing hip angle
value – hip flexion; 2) decreasing knee angle value – knee flexion; 3) positive ankle
angle value – dorsiflexion. Positive angular velocity indicates increasing angle values
(i.e. hip and knee extension). This also applies to the ankle joint where a positive
angular velocity means increase dorsiflexion angle. Joint angle and angular velocity
values were measured at the instants of initial ground contact (IC), defined as the time
point where horizontal velocity of the toe reflective marker becomes zero, midstance
(MSt), the point of fifty per cent duration of the stance phase, toe-off (TO), defined as
the instant the horizontal velocity of the toe’s reflective marker increases from zero, and
midswing (MSw), defined as the point of fifty per cent duration of the swing phase.
Additional kinematics parameters recorded included peak angles and angular velocities
during both phases of the walking cycle.
Spatiotemporal parameters, including walking velocity, walking cycle duration, stride
length, stance duration, and swing duration, were directly obtain from kinematic model
developed under Visual 3D software based on horizontal displacement of the reflective
markers.
3.2 Design-based quantitative nerve morphology
At the end of the 12-weeks follow-up time, rats were anaesthetised and a 10-mm-long
segment of the sciatic nerve that included the injured portion was collected, fixed, and
prepared for morphological analysis and histomorphometry of myelinated nerve fibers.
A 10-mm segment of uninjured sciatic nerve was also withdrawn from the 8 control
animals. Immediately after collecting the nerve, rats were euthanized through an
intracardiac injection of 5% sodium pentobarbital (Eutasil®). Sciatic nerve samples were
immersed immediately in a fixation solution, containing 2.5% purified glutaraldehyde
and 0.5% saccarose in 0.1M Sorensen phosphate buffer for 6-8 hours. Specimens
were then washed in 0.1M Sorensen phosphate buffer (1.5% saccarose), post-fixed in
1% osmium tetroxide, dehydrated and embedded in Glauerts’ embedding mixture of
resins (23). Series of semi-thin transverse sections (2-µm thick) were then cut starting
from the distal nerve stump and stained by Toluidine blue for high resolution light
microscopy examination and design-based stereology (24). Systematic random
sampling and 2-D disector were adopted (25-27). The following predictors of nerve
regeneration were assessed: mean fiber density (D), total fibers number (N); circle-
fitting diameter of fiber (D) and axon (d), and the g-ratio (d/D). The sampling scheme
was designed in order to keep the coefficient of error (CE) below 0.10, a level which
assures enough accuracy for neuromorphological studies (28).
Chapter 6 – The effect of active and passive exercise on nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic
crush injury 143
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
4 Statistical analysis
Differences between groups for each of the variables were tested by univariate ANOVA
and the post hoc Tukey’s HSD test. Significance was accepted at p<0.05. Data are
presented as mean and standard deviation (SD). Statistical analysis was performed
using SPSS software package (version 17, SPSS Inc).
144 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
5 Results
During surgery, the sciatic nerve crushed resulted in visible crush of nerve but without
interrupting its continuity. Muscle paralysis of the operated foot was observed following
crush injury. All rats survived, with no wound infection or automutilation.
1.1 Gait spatiotemporal data
All animals could walk with steady pace in the corridor during the testing sessions
carried out in the recovery period. As a consequence of sciatic nerve injury and sham
surgery, most gait spatiotemporal features changed along the recovery time. During the
12-weeks recovery, stride length increased [F(3,84) = 17.239, p = 0.000] either in sciatic-
injured groups and Sham group [non-significant main effect of group; F(2,28) = 2.688, p =
0.066], while gait cycle time diminished [F(3,84) =19.794,p=0.000] again in all groups.
The shortened gait cycle duration was associated with decreased swing phase duration
[F(3,84) = 27.133 , p = 0.000], while that of the stance phase showed no changes in any
of the groups at any joint in time. A trend for the rise of gait speed rise with time of
recovery was noticed (p=0.054). At week 1 post-injury, gait speed ranged from
0.161±0.038 m.s-1 in EXp group to 0.116±0.028 m.s-1 in Crush group. By week twelve,
mean gait speed varied from 0.239±0.052 m.s-1 in EXa group to 0.210±0.047 m.s-1 in
Crush group (Table 8).
Table 8 - Walking velocity and cycle time data if the right hindlimb in sciatic-crushed animals and
sham-operated controls; n=8 in each group
Group
Gait velocity
(m/s)
stride lenght
(m)
cycle
duration (s)
stance duration
(s)
swing
duration (s)
W01 W12 W01 W12 W01 W12 W01 W12 W01 W12
EXa
0.15
0.04
0.24
0.05
0.14
0.01
0.17
0.01
0.92
0.16
0.73
0.17
0.23
0.05
0.20
0.03
0.20
0.05
0.13
0.01
EXp
0.16
0.03
0.23
0.09
0.13
0.01
0.16
0.02
0.85
0.16
0.76
0.20
0.24
0.09
0.25
0.06
0.17
0.03
0.13
0.01
Crush
0.12
0.03
0.21
0.05
0.13
0.01
0.15
0.02
1.11
0.27
0.73
0.10
0.28
0.04
0.26
0.03
0.19
0.03
0.12
0.01
Sham
0.15
0.03
0.23
0.04
0.14
0.01
0.16
0.01
0.96
0.13
0.70
0.09
0.28
0.08
0.25
0.04
0.17
0.01
0.13
0.01
Chapter 6 – The effect of active and passive exercise on nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic
crush injury 145
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
1.2 Hindlimb joint kimematics
Ankle kinematics
Sciatic nerve crush causes paralysis of the hindleg and foot muscles. Therefore, we
start by presenting ankle joint kinematics data followed by that of the hip and knee
joints.
Ankle kinematics was most affected at week 1 post sciatic nerve injury (Figure 33).
Exaggerated dorsiflexion during the whole stance phase characterizes movement
about this joint in sciatic-injured animals, with differences to sham-operated controls
being most evident at midstance and toe-off time points. Clear changes in ankle
angular velocity were also induced by sciatic injury. Ankle angular velocity at week 1
post injury shifted from negative to positive values in sciatic-injured animals either at
initial paw contact and midstance, contrasting to the negative values of sham controls.
Conversely, at toe-off time point (Table 10), ankle angular velocity was negative in
sciatic nerve-injured animals and positive in Sham group. Ankle kinematics at midswing
(Table 12) was less affected by sciatic nerve crush. At week 1, sciatic crushed animals
demonstrated a decreased ability to perform ankle dorsiflexion at midswing, compared
to animals in the Sham group, but ankle angular velocity was similar in all groups. A
good recovery of the normal pattern of ankle kinematics during walking occurred during
the 12 weeks of follow up, and no consistent differences in the extent of this recovery
were observed due to treatment modality (Figure 34).
146 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Figure 33 - Mean trajectories for hip (upper graphs), knee (middle graphs) and ankle (lower graphs)
joint angle (left hand graphs) and angular velocity (right hand graphs) during the rat’s walking
cycle. Full lines correspond to the stance phase and dashed lines correspond to the swing phase
of the walking cycle: crush group (red line); EXa (black line); EXp (blue line); Sham Group (green
line). All groups n=8
Chapter 6 – The effect of active and passive exercise on nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic
crush injury 147
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
Figure 34 - Mean trajectories for hip (upper graphs), knee (middle graphs) and ankle (lower graphs)
joint angle (left hand graphs) and angular velocity (right hand graphs) during the rat’s walking
cycle. Full lines correspond to the stance phase and dashed lines correspond to the swing phase
of the walking cycle: crush group (red line); EXa (black line); EXp (blue line); Sham Group (green
line). All groups n=8.
148 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Hip kinematics
Hip kinematics during walking was also affected as a consequence of sciatic nerve
crush. Significant differences between groups in hip kinematics were acutely observed
after sciatic denervation being these differences were still noticeable at the end of the
12-weeks recovery. In the week immediately after surgery, changes in normal hip joint
motion during walking were noticed only in angular velocity values. At this point in time,
sciatic injured animals walk with increased hip angular velocity either at initial toe
contact (i.e. swing-to-stance transition) and toe off (i.e. stance-to-swing transition),
compared to Sham group animals. Despite such changes in hip angular velocity, no
significant alterations in hip position at the relevant phases of gait were recorded in
sciatic denervated animals. Sciatic nerve reinnervation led to the recovery of the
normal hip motion pattern during walking in exercised animals (i.e. EXa and EXp
groups) but differences between Crush and Sham groups emerged. In fact, all
kinematic parameters obtained from the stance phase were significantly different in
Crush group, compared to Sham control at the 12-weeks time point. The changes were
characterized by more acute hip angles at the entire stance phase and significantly
lower hip angular velocity in Crush group.
Knee kinematics
Sciatic denervation was also accompanied by compensatory changes in knee joint
kinematics as a mean to enable successful walking. Early after sciatic nerve crush,
changes in knee kinematics occurred mainly during the stance phase. At the instant of
paw touch down, knee angle shows similar values in all groups but its angular velocity
was distinctly higher in sciatic-injured animals. At midstance (Table 11), and at week 1
post injury, sciatic denervated animals display a more extended knee, when compared
to the sham operated animals. This can be reasonably interpreted as a compensatory
response to the more plantigrade pattern of walking resulting from paralysis of the
muscle crossing the ankle joint thus avoiding excessive shortening of the overall limb
length. At this particular instant of the step cycle, knee joint velocity was not affected by
the sciatic nerve injury. Conversely, at the stance-to-swing transition knee angular
velocity in the sciatic-injured animals is greatly augmented compared to Sham group,
meaning fast knee flexion motion in the former animals. A recovery of the normal knee
pattern of motion during walking occurred in the weeks after sciatic nerve crush. This
recovery was, however, enhanced by both walking exercise and manual mobilization.
At week 12 post injury, and when compared to Sham group, animals in Crush group
walked with exaggerated knee flexion at the instants of initial toe ground contact and
toe off.
Chapter 6 – The effect of active and passive exercise on nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic
crush injury 149
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
Table 9 - Values of hindlimb joints joint angle and angular velocity at initial contact (IC)
Joint Group Angle (º) Velocity (º/s)
week01 week12 week01 week12
Ankle
EXa -6.64.4 -13.32.9 446.2123.4 -67.2114.6
EXp -0.64.6 -22.73.5 321.8145.8 -243.0165.0
Crush 1.04.2 -20.14.4 365.4122.8 -313.4100.7
Sham -11.74.8 -16.43.4 57.2100.8 -280.9127.4
Knee
EXa 117.1 18.42 116.17.3 -59.899.5 -153.491.5
EXp 121.114.5 118.29.6 26.569.3 -46.9134.3
Crush 115.015.6 105.514.3 23.767.2 9.082.3
Sham 104.915.8 119.711.8 -214.3106.4 -58.454.7
Hip
EXa 89.111.3 78.311.4 201.938.4 75.636.5
EXp 90.514.8 72.67.0 294.785.8 70.330.4
Crush 83.214.6 65.410.2 218.394.7 62.532.6
Sham 83.69.4 76.410.1 109.552.5 71.429.9
Table 10 - Values of hindlimb joints angle and angular velocity at toe-off (TO)
Joint Group Angle (º) Velocity (º/s)
week01 week12 week01 week12
Ankle
EXa 12.0914.32 -19.259.92 -367.97254.35 320.36109.10
EXp 17.099.43 -15.009.44 -361.44237.79 363.65146.06
Crush 23.6311.57 -14.5913.62 -447.27212.76 431.40113.60
Sham -17.899.48# -17.0311.00 74.36187.84 486.84104.15
Knee
EXa 72.3012.80 66.2910.31 -563.86183.40 -281.7283.49
EXp 79.4013.55 63.8212.44 -621.61137.42 -325.0269.60
Crush 65.5015.47 50.7013.34 -557.37108.77 -265.9165.89
Sham 67.0416.21 68.2512.65 -205.83102.05 -363.1687.63
Hip
EXa 103.328.86 93.0219.35 -336.71167.08 -173.1889.81
EXp 109.4213.51 85.079.72 -347.56116.73 -208.1267.99
Crush 93.8219.59 71.0614.41 -367.31138.26 -155.4049.02
Sham 97.4216.27 93.4014.80 -155.1076.60 -236.4755.28
150 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Table 11 - Values of hindlimb joints angle and angular velocity at midstance (MSt)
Joint
Group
MSt angle (º) MSt velocity (º/s)
week01 week12 week01 week12
Ankle EXa 42.1010.54 11.6512.28 175.98119.89+ -134.3584.06
EXp 46.228.43 6.9912.28 200.3291.63- 23.1685.33
Crush 48.0412.96 4.2414.12 163.38118.21- 1.4356.25
Sham 13.6113.19 4.7315.17 -58.6361.23 -52.1981.85
Knee EXa 94.0515.01 75.156.85 -137.3676.77 -224.3660.35
EXp 105.3316.04 80.4214.86 -161.2684.53 -247.4135.48
Crush 91.0910.28 69.6613.70 -142.4981.28 -255.1228.54
Sham 68.3115.44 80.067.41 -121.7943.65 -213.9869.05
Hip EXa 106.2110.76 89.8016.38 109.0773.71 137.1894.40
EXp 112.508.70 84.307.20 125.4383.40 124.8944.64
Crush 99.0117.72 74.7613.11 115.2167.04 73.9248.24
Sham 93.3811.15 89.0111.16 95.1970.18 157.0344.71
Table 12 - Values of hindlimb joints angle and angular velocity at midswing (MSw)
Joint
Groups
MSw Angle (º) MSw velocity (º/s)
week01 week12 week01 week12
Ankle EXa 4.5410.39 27.3812.18 -274.44310.80 -276.94129.49
EXp 11.4011.32 22.066.99 -227.98256.05 -422.19133.67
Crush 16.0911.00 23.0915.11 -313.59292.90 -402.2891.21
Sham 35.4111.38 29.0613.91 -282.91263.38 -383.13220.56
Knee EXa 71.1819.46 73.745.71 860.40333.73 1035.40145.63
EXp 72.1317.87 74.7912.39 872.07230.25 1099.1594.48
Crush 61.8814.04 64.7512.20 976.08249.34 1073.30101.82
Sham 65.9614.70 76.7210.27 844.78165.17 1100.27173.29
Hip EXa 71.259.53 78.3812.15 109.07100.53 137.1896.65
EXp 75.3815.71 71.897.19 125.4386.07 124.8975.40
Crush 63.6913.66 63.9411.47 115.21140.41 73.9278.72
Sham 80.6311.15 77.2610.80 95.1983.82 157.03107.46
Chapter 6 – The effect of active and passive exercise on nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic
crush injury 151
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
1.3 Nerve stereology
Figure 35 - Representative micrographs toluidine blue stained semithin sections from EXa (A), Exp
(B), Ctrl (C) and Sham (D) groups. The presence smaller myelinated nerve fibers can be
appreciated in all axonotmesis groups (A-C) in comparison to controls (D). Morphometrical
changes have been quantified by stereology and results are reported in table 6. Original
magnification = 1,000x.
Figure 35 shows representative images of myelinated nerve fibers from nerves
belonging to the four experimental groups included in this study. The results of the
stereological analysis of myelinated nerve fibers are reported in Table 13. Overall,
regenerated sciatic nerves present increased number and density of myelinated nerve
fibers in comparison to intact nerves. The regenerated nerve fibers are also
characterized by smaller diameter and lower myelin sheet thickness. Slight effects of
exercise were observed in the morphology of the regenerated sciatic nerves. When
compared to the Sham group, the increase in total number of myelinated fibers was
only significant for the Crush group (p<0.05), suggesting that both types of exercise
prevented an excessive increase in regenerating axonal collaterals. Despite this
apparently positive effect of active and passive exercise, nerve density was increased
in EXp group only, when compared to Sham control group (p<0.05). Other
morphological features characterizing the myelinated nerve fibers, i.e. diameter of
152 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
nerve fiber (D) and axon (d) and the g-ratio (D/d), were all significantly different in
regenerated sciatic nerves, compared to the intact nerves.
Table 13 - stereological analysis of myelinated nerve fibers
Group Density of
myelinated nerve
fibers (N/mm2)
Total number of
myelinated nerve
fibers (N)
d - axonal
diameter (µm)
D - nerve fiber
diameter (µm)
d/D
(g-ratio)
EXa 14786 ± 4186 9255 ± 1618 3.90 ± 0.32 5.37 ± 0.41 0.72 ± 0.02
EXp 18146 ± 4691 8974 ± 1918 3.85 ± 0.37 5.35 ± 0.44 0.71 ± 0.03
Crush 16701 ± 4251 10473 ± 1487 3.72 ± 0.31 5.22 ± 0.42 0.71 ± 0.04
Sham 11680 ± 1282 6883 ± 1222 5.35 ± 0.35 8.22 ± 0.38 0.65 ± 0.04
Chapter 6 – The effect of active and passive exercise on nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic
crush injury 153
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
6 Discussion
In this study we evaluated the role of two different methods of exercise on sciatic nerve
regeneration and functional recovery after a sciatic nerve crush lesion. The two
exercise modes consisted on treadmill exercise walking and passive mobilization of the
affected hindlimb. The effect of both exercise programs was evaluated in contrast to a
non-exercise group of sciatic nerve crushed animals and sham operated controls. The
results showed marginal effects of both active and passive exercise on functional
recovery, assessed by hindlimb joint kinematics during level walking. Although the
impact of exercise on functional recovery was relatively modest it was nonetheless
accompanied by improved nerve morphology, particularly by preventing excessive
increase in total number of myelinated fibers in regenerated sciatic nerves.
Physical exercise has received much interest recently due to its potential effect in
enhancing nerve regeneration and reinnervation in different models of peripheral nerve
pathology (11; 13; 15-17; 29; 30). The results of the majority of these studies point to a
small to moderate positive effect of the active exercise stimulus in nerve regeneration
after sciatic injury and repair in rodents either when used alone (16; 17; 31) or in
combination with nerve electrical stimulation (13), as well as in the degree of
reinnervation and extent of functional recovery (12; 13; 16; 31).
To date, the exact mechanisms explaining the beneficial effect of active exercise on
nerve regenerations are still not completely elucidated; although several mechanisms
have been alluded. After sciatic nerve transection and repair, walking exercise has
been shown to increase the number of myelinated nerve fibers distal to injury site (13;
16), as well as to enhance the rate of axonal elongation in the common fibular nerve of
mice (12). After being cut, elongating axons are well known to divide profusely in a
variable number of collaterals that, afterwards, may either travel in parallel along the
same nerve or take a divergent route through alternative nerve pathway leading to
inappropriate reinnervation. Increased axonal branching, although important in the
sense that it contributes with more regenerating nerve fibers to reinnervation, has a
downside consequence if accompanied by aberrant reinnervation of target organs.
Studies in mice demonstrate that nerve regeneration is considerably enhanced by
electrical stimulation applied to the proximal nerve stump for a brief period of time just
prior to nerve repair, as well as by distal nerve stump treatment with chondroitinase
ABC, an enzyme that removes the axonal growth-inhibiting glycosaminoglycans from
chondroitin sulfate proteoglycans (18). This conclusion is driven by the use of different
retrograde fluorescent tracers applied to the tibial and common fibular branches of the
154 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
sciatic nerve and consequent enumeration of labeled motoneurons at the anterior horn
of the spinal cord (18). However, the increased number of labeled motoneurons was
most pronounced two weeks after sciatic transection, lowering to almost control levels
at four weeks survival time. Importantly, the enhanced nerve regeneration, noticed two
weeks after the sciatic nerve injury, was manifested with clear loss of the normal spinal
topographical organization of tibial and common fibular motoneurons, consequent to
elongating axon collaterals entering erroneous ending nerves, which in turn might
compromise function (18). Comparable increase in the number of labeled motoneurons
of the sciatic motor nucleus also occurred at 2-week and 4-week after sciatic nerve
transection and repair when animals performed either mild-intensity continuous or high-
intensity intermittent treadmill exercise during the two recovery periods of time, with
more robust effect with the more intense treadmill exercise protocol (17). Treadmill
exercise, however, not just enhanced nerve regeneration but importantly had such
effect without simultaneously raising inappropriate target reinnervation. In addition,
treadmill exercise seems to exert a sustained nerve regeneration enhancing effect, with
the number of tibial nerve labeled motoneurons in exercised animals increasing from
week-2 to week-4 after sciatic nerve transection and repair whereas this number
remained unchanged between these two recovery times in animals that had nerve
regeneration accelerated by treatment with electrical stimulation and chondroitinase
ABC (17; 18).
Active treadmill exercise was also shown to improve nerve regeneration in the rat after
sciatic transection and direct repair (13; 16). Morphological evaluation at the level of
the tibial nerve reveals increased number of regenerated myelinated fibers in the active
exercise group, compared to the non-exercise, control group (16). Detailed
morphometry of regenerated sciatic crushed nerve in the rat again supports a positive
role of treadmill endurance exercise in nerve regeneration (31). In this latter study,
treadmill exercise started two weeks after the sciatic nerve injury and was maintained
throughout the next five weeks, with animals of the endurance exercise group walking
at 50% of their maximal exercise capacity determined pre-operatively, corresponding to
a mean walking velocity of around 9 m/min, thus comparable to that we used in the
present study. When compared to untrained control animals, the endurance-trained
group depicted better nerve regeneration, demonstrated by greater myelin thickness,
higher area fraction of myelinated nerve fibers and less of that of endoneurial
connective tissue in regenerated sciatic nerves (31).
A major aim of the present study was to test for the effect of brief passive manual
mobilization of the affected hindlimb on sciatic nerve regeneration and functional
recovery. Our data of the sciatic nerve morphology collected distally to injury site again
Chapter 6 – The effect of active and passive exercise on nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic
crush injury 155
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
showed signs of better regeneration as a result of passive hindlimb mobilization and
gentle stretching. As for the EXa group, and when excluding outliers from statistical
testing, mean total number of myelinated fibers in the EXp group was indistinct from
that of the Sham group. To some extent , this agrees with other studies investigating
the effect of passive exercise on sciatic nerve regeneration after transection injury and
direct cooptation (16). Udina et al. (16) tested the effect of passive bicycling in the rat
on sciatic regeneration and noticed improved sciatic regeneration to a similar degree to
that registered for active treadmill exercise. It is difficult to interpret, and thus it
deserves further research, the discrepancy between the results of this authors who
revealed an increase in the number of myelinated axons and our results, which
evidenced the opposite.
In the case of the facial nerve, manual mobilization of the whisker pad reduced muscle
fibers poly-innervation two months after nerve transection and repair. In this case,
however, the passive exercise showed no effect on the degree of regenerating nerve
fibers misdirection (15). Thus, our results of a seemingly positive role of manual
mobilization on sciatic nerve regeneration add to those of the latter studies, and
reinforce the notion that passive exercise is an effective strategy to stimulate nerve
regeneration.
Despite the importance of nerve regeneration, a successful nerve treatment is much
dictated by the degree of reinnervation and of functional recovery. Here, we conducted
gait analysis to track functional recovery and assessed motion changes at the hip, knee
and ankle joints during voluntary level walking. Several motion changes occurred that
can be attributed to the sciatic nerve injury and that affected all recorded joints. In the
weeks following the sciatic nerve crush and before initiating either active or passive
exercise, relevant changes in hip and knee kinematics were noticed, particularly during
the stance phase. Higher hip joint velocity and overall increase in knee extension
characterized walking of sciatic-injured animals acutely post injury. This profound
reorganization of the role played by each individual joint reveals most likely a strategy
to overcome dysfunction at the level of ankle joint and to permit walking. Similar to
other studies (2; 32; 33), twelve weeks after sciatic injury ankle kinematics was recover
in all sciatic-injured groups, taking into account either the ankle angle and the ankle
angular velocity during both the stance and swing phases. Complete recovery of the
normal ankle kinematics during level walking in a walkway is a common observation
after a sciatic nerve crush, however some studies report few kinematic changes
appearing late during recovery suggesting that walking is altered after this type of injury
(32; 33). Also, it should be kept in mind that the morphology of regenerated crushed
156 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
sciatic nerves are clearly distinct from intact nerves, which suggest that complete
functional recovery is unlikely to occur on these animals. However, and in contrast to
ankle joint kinematics, hip and knee joint kinematics in the Crush group clearly deviated
to that of the Sham group. Such changes in the normal hip and knee kinematics during
walking were not noticed in both the EXa and EXp groups. We interpret these results
as a demonstration that the hindlimb motion pattern during level walking is not fully
reestablished after sciatic crush injury and those compensatory changes at the hip and
knee joint kinematics emerges that masks disability at the ankle joint. The mechanisms
guiding these changes cannot be discerned by our data, but studies have shown
altered pattern of electromyographical activity of the muscles crossing the ankle joint
after sciatic nerve transection that are best explained by changes at spinal neural
output (34). A possibility is that hip and knee motion pattern changes result from
altered proprioceptive feedback originating from muscles crossing the ankle joint and
other hindleg afferents (35; 36). A simpler explanation, and probably one that better
adjusts to our results, is that hip and knee kinematic changes reflect past
compensatory changes that are not corrected even if their purpose is not justified
anymore. In fact, the stimulus of active and passive exercise corrected hip and knee
motion changes during level walking in our exercised animals.
This study was not designed to investigate the mechanisms by which active or passive
exercise improves nerve regeneration and functional recovery. The mechanisms are
potentially many and might operate at several levels and at distinct organs, including
the spinal cord (19; 37), the regenerating nerve (Sabatier, Redmon et al. 2008) and the
reinnervated muscles (15; 38). The enhancing effect of active exercise on nerve
regeneration and reinnervation probably expresses the maintenance of an adequate
degree of stimulation onto the affected motor groups at the spinal cord level. This
stimulus might come either from the descending pathways that are active when
animals attempt to walk, even if due to denervation the movement itself does not
happen, or from afferent pathways originating from non-denervated hindlimb territories
but projecting onto the sciatic motoneuron pools (15; 39). It is known from cultured
retinal ganglion cells that neuronal outgrowth does not occur spontaneously and is
dependent on soluble neurotrophic factors and neuronal electrical activity (40). It is
likely that both active and passive exercise originate bursts of electrical activity at the
neuronal soma in the spinal cord that then travel along the severed axons and
stimulate axonal outgrowth.
The positive effect of passive exercise on nerve regeneration and functional recovery is
probably less anticipated, compared to active exercise. Previous studies used a
passive exercise stimulus that was designed to closely resemble natural active
Chapter 6 – The effect of active and passive exercise on nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic
crush injury 157
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
movements and behaviors. For instance, passive bicycling used by Udina et al. (16)
emulated the range of motion of hindlimb joints observed during walking in the rat.
Similarly, the manual strokes of the whisker pad implemented by Angelov et al. (15)
took into consideration the normal sweep exploratory motions of the vibrissae in these
animals. Our manual passive mobilization of the hindlimb was not planned to mimic
any specific task but otherwise to move the hip, knee and ankle joints through most of
their movement amplitude and to cause a mild stretch of the muscles crossing the
ankle joint. This protocol is in line with rehabilitation techniques aiming to maintain the
joint amplitude and prevent muscle shortening and contracture. However, the stimulus
caused by this rather unspecific passive motion proves also to have a positive effect on
the regenerating nerve morphology and in overall hindlimb motion pattern during
walking. Such apparent positive direct effect on nerve regeneration might result from
increased afferent input due to the movement stimulus (19; 37). Another possibility is
that our passive movement induced rhythmic mechanical load onto the regenerating
nerve inducing local cellular and molecular responses that enhance nerve regeneration
(41).
Lastly, some limitations of our study must be addressed. Our active walking exercise
might be envisaged as a mild-intensity endurance exercise, consisting of daily sessions
of 30 minutes continuous level walking at a 10 m/min speed. This exercising protocol
was initiated two weeks after sciatic nerve crush, when injured axons start
reinnervating the target muscles. However, there is evidence that the nerve
regeneration enhancing effect of exercise might be dose-dependent, being endurance
high-intensity, intermittent physical exercise capable of inducing higher effect than mild-
intensity (17). Also, some protocols use treadmill exercise of one-to two-hours duration
(13; 16; 31). It is then possible that our slight positive effect of active exercise on nerve
regeneration and functional recovery is the reflection of a relatively low exercise
stimulus. Also, our walking conditions used to test functional recovery might not
challenge the walking animals to a degree sufficient to uncover the disability associated
to faulty reinnervation or changes at spinal neural output (42).
In summary, active continuous walking exercise and passive mobilization of whole
hindlimb had a positive effect on the morphology of regenerating crushed sciatic nerves
and improved overall hindlimb kinematics during the rat gait. These results are in line
with growing evidence that not just active exercise but passive exercise as well are
suitable strategies to help nerve regeneration after injury and, most important, to aid in
function restoration. Moreover, the positive effect of passive exercise after sciatic nerve
injury does not require a strict task-specific movement and might alternatively result
158 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
from a general action of movement stimulation, including a direct mechanical effect on
the nerve and muscles. Clearly, further studies are needed for in vivo investigation of
the mechanism responsible for the effect of passive exercise.
Chapter 6 – The effect of active and passive exercise on nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic
crush injury 159
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
References
1. Raimondo S, Fornaro M, Tos P, Battiston B, Giacobini-Robecchi MG, Geuna S.
Perspectives in regeneration and tissue engineering of peripheral nerves.
[Internet]. Annals of anatomy = Anatomischer Anzeiger : official organ of the
Anatomische Gesellschaft. 2011 Mar 12;
2. Amado S, Simões MJ, Armada da Silva PAS, Luís AL, Shirosaki Y, Lopes MA,
et al. Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve
regeneration in an axonotmesis rat model. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2008 Nov
;29(33):4409-19.
3. Malysz T, Ilha J, Nascimento PSD, Angelis KD, Schaan BD, Achaval M.
Beneficial effects of treadmill training in experimental diabetic nerve regeneration
[Internet]. Clinics. 2010 ;65(12):1329-1337.
4. Varejão AS, Melo-Pinto P, Meek MF, Filipe VM, Bulas-Cruz J. Methods for the
experimental functional assessment of rat sciatic nerve regeneration. [Internet].
Neurological research. 2004 Mar ;26(2):186-94.
5. Bodine-Fowler SC, Meyer RS, Moskovitz A, Abrams R, Botte MJ. Inaccurate
projection of rat soleus motoneurons: a comparison of nerve repair techniques.
[Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 1997 Jan ;20(1):29-37.[
6. Brushart TM. Preferential reinnervation of motor nerves by regenerating motor
axons. [Internet]. The Journal of neuroscience : the official journal of the Society
for Neuroscience. 1988 Mar ;8(3):1026-31.
7. Ruiter GCW de, Malessy MJ a, Alaid AO, Spinner RJ, Engelstad JK, Sorenson
EJ, et al. Misdirection of regenerating motor axons after nerve injury and repair
in the rat sciatic nerve model. [Internet]. Experimental neurology. 2008 Jun
;211(2):339-50.
8. Bernstein JJ, Guth L. Nonselectivity in establishment of neuromuscular
connections following nerve regeneration in the rat. [Internet]. Experimental
neurology. 1961 Sep ;4262-75.
9. Valero-Cabré A, Navarro X. H reflex restitution and facilitation after different
types of peripheral nerve injury and repair. [Internet]. Brain research. 2001 Nov
23;919(2):302-12.
10. Meeteren NL van, Brakkee JH, Helders PJ, Gispen WH. The effect of exercise
training on functional recovery after sciatic nerve crush in the rat. [Internet].
Journal of the peripheral nervous system : JPNS. 1998 Jan ;3(4):277-82.
160 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
11. Marqueste T, Alliez J-R, Alluin O, Jammes Y, Decherchi P. Neuromuscular
rehabilitation by treadmill running or electrical stimulation after peripheral nerve
injury and repair. [Internet]. Journal of applied physiology (Bethesda, Md. :
1985). 2004 May ;96(5):1988-95.
12. Sabatier MJ, Redmon N, Schwartz G, English AW. Treadmill training promotes
axon regeneration in injured peripheral nerves [Internet]. Experimental
neurology. 2008 ;211(2):489–493.
13. Asensio-Pinilla E, Udina E, Jaramillo J, Navarro X. Electrical stimulation
combined with exercise increase axonal regeneration after peripheral nerve
injury. [Internet]. Experimental neurology. 2009 Sep ;219(1):258-65.
14. English AW, Cucoranu D, Mulligan A, Sabatier M. Treadmill training enhances
axon regeneration in injured mouse peripheral nerves without increased loss of
topographic specificity. [Internet]. The Journal of comparative neurology. 2009
Nov ;517(2):245-55.
15. Angelov DN, Ceynowa M, Guntinas-Lichius O, Streppel M, Grosheva M,
Kiryakova SI, et al. Mechanical stimulation of paralyzed vibrissal muscles
following facial nerve injury in adult rat promotes full recovery of whisking.
[Internet]. Neurobiology of disease. 2007 Apr ;26(1):229-42.
16. Udina E, Puigdemasa A, Navarro X. Passive and active exercise improve
regeneration and muscle reinnervation after peripheral nerve injury in the rat.
[Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 2011 Feb ;1-10.
17. English AW, Cucoranu D, Mulligan A, Sabatier M. Treadmill training enhances
axon regeneration in injured mouse peripheral nerves without increased loss of
topographic specificity. [Internet]. The Journal of comparative neurology. 2009
Nov ;517(2):245-55.
18. English AW. Enhancing axon regeneration in peripheral nerves also increases
functionally inappropriate reinnervation of targets. [Internet]. The Journal of
comparative neurology. 2005 Oct ;490(4):427-41.
19. Pavlov SP, Grosheva M, Streppel M, Guntinas-Lichius O, Irintchev A, Skouras
E, et al. Manually-stimulated recovery of motor function after facial nerve injury
requires intact sensory input. [Internet]. Experimental neurology. 2008 May
;211(1):292-300.
20. Beer GM, Steurer J, Meyer VE. Standardizing nerve crushes with a non-serrated
clamp. [Internet]. Journal of reconstructive microsurgery. 2001 Oct ;17(7):531-4.
21. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Melo-Pinto P, Raimondo S,
et al. Functional and morphological assessment of a standardized rat sciatic
Chapter 6 – The effect of active and passive exercise on nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic
crush injury 161
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
nerve crush injury with a non-serrated clamp. [Internet]. Journal of neurotrauma.
2004 Nov ;21(11):1652-70.
22. Luís AL, Amado S, Geuna S, Rodrigues JM, Simões MJ, Santos JD, et al. Long-
term functional and morphological assessment of a standardized rat sciatic
nerve crush injury with a non-serrated clamp. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience
methods. 2007 Jun ;163(1):92-104.
23. Di Scipio F, Raimondo S, Tos P, Geuna S. A simple protocol for paraffin-
embedded myelin sheath staining with osmium tetroxide for light microscope
observation. [Internet]. Microscopy research and technique. 2008 Jul ;71(7):497-
502.
24. Raimondo S, Fornaro M, Di Scipio F, Ronchi G, Giacobini-Robecchi MG, Geuna
S. Chapter 5: Methods and protocols in peripheral nerve regeneration
experimental research: part II-morphological techniques. [Internet]. International
review of neurobiology. 2009 Jan ;8781-103.[
25. Geuna S, Gigo-Benato D, Rodrigues A de C. On sampling and sampling errors
in histomorphometry of peripheral nerve fibers. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2004
Jan ;24(1):72-6.
26. Geuna S, Tos P, Battiston B, Guglielmone R. Verification of the two-dimensional
disector, a method for the unbiased estimation of density and number of
myelinated nerve fibers in peripheral nerves. [Internet]. Annals of anatomy =
Anatomischer Anzeiger : official organ of the Anatomische Gesellschaft. 2000
Jan ;182(1):23-34.
27. Geuna S. The revolution of counting “tops”: two decades of the disector principle
in morphological research. [Internet]. Microscopy research and technique. 2005
Apr ;66(5):270-4.
28. Pakkenberg B, Gundersen HJ. Neocortical neuron number in humans: effect of
sex and age. [Internet]. The Journal of comparative neurology. 1997 Jul
28;384(2):312-20.
29. Nascimento PS do, Malysz T, Ilha J, Araujo RT, Hermel EES, Kalil-Gaspar PI, et
al. Treadmill training increases the size of A cells from the L5 dorsal root ganglia
in diabetic rats. [Internet]. Histology and histopathology. 2010 Jun ;25(6):719-32.
30. Malysz T, Ilha J, Nascimento PS do, Angelis KD, Schaan BD, Achaval M.
Beneficial effects of treadmill training in experimental diabetic nerve
regeneration. [Internet]. Clinics (São Paulo, Brazil). 2010 Jan ;65(12):1329-37.
31. Ilha J, Araujo RT, Malysz T, Hermel EES, Rigon P, Xavier LL, et al. Endurance
and resistance exercise training programs elicit specific effects on sciatic nerve
162 Functional Assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - kinematic model of the hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
regeneration after experimental traumatic lesion in rats. [Internet].
Neurorehabilitation and neural repair. 2008 ;22(4):355-66.
32. Luis AL, Rodrigues JM, Lobato JV, Lopes MA, Amado S, Veloso AP, et al.
Evaluation of two biodegradable nerve guides for the reconstruction of the rat
sciatic nerve. [Internet]. Bio-medical materials and engineering. 2007 Jan
;17(1):39-52.
33. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Filipe VM, Gabriel RC, et al.
Ankle kinematics to evaluate functional recovery in crushed rat sciatic nerve
[Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 2003 ;27(6):706–714.
34. Sabatier MJ, To BN, Nicolini J, English AW. Effect of slope and sciatic nerve
injury on ankle muscle recruitment and hindlimb kinematics during walking in the
rat. [Internet]. The Journal of experimental biology. 2011 Mar 15;214(Pt 6):1007-
16.
35. Maas H, Prilutsky BI, Nichols TR, Gregor RJ. The effects of self-reinnervation of
cat medial and lateral gastrocnemius muscles on hindlimb kinematics in slope
walking. [Internet]. Experimental brain research. Experimentelle Hirnforschung.
Expérimentation cérébrale. 2007 Aug ;181(2):377-93.
36. Chang C-J. The effect of pulse-released nerve growth factor from genipin-
crosslinked gelatin in schwann cell-seeded polycaprolactone conduits on large-
gap peripheral nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Tissue engineering. Part A. 2009
Mar ;15(3):547-57.
37. Chen Y, Wang Y, Chen L, Sun C, English AW, Wolpaw JR, et al. H-reflex up-
conditioning encourages recovery of EMG activity and H-reflexes after sciatic
nerve transection and repair in rats. [Internet]. The Journal of neuroscience : the
official journal of the Society for Neuroscience. 2010 Dec 1;30(48):16128-36.
38. Cebasek V, Kubínová L, Janácek J, Ribaric S, Erzen I. Adaptation of muscle
fibre types and capillary network to acute denervation and shortlasting
reinnervation. [Internet]. Cell and tissue research. 2007 Nov ;330(2):279-89.
39. Udina E, Voda J, Gold BG, Navarro X. Comparative dose-dependence study of
FK506 on transected mouse sciatic nerve repaired by allograft or xenograft.
[Internet]. Journal of the peripheral nervous system : JPNS. 2003 Sep ;8(3):145-
54.
40. Goldberg JL, Espinosa JS, Xu Y, Davidson N, Kovacs GTA, Barres BA. Retinal
ganglion cells do not extend axons by default: promotion by neurotrophic
signaling and electrical activity. [Internet]. Neuron. 2002 Feb 28;33(5):689-702.
41. Heidemann SR, Buxbaum RE. Mechanical tension as a regulator of axonal
development. [Internet]. Neurotoxicology. 1994 Jan ;15(1):95-107.
Chapter 6 – The effect of active and passive exercise on nerve regeneration and functional recovery after sciatic
crush injury 163
Sandra Cristina Fernandes Amado
42. Sabatier MJ, To BN, Nicolini J, English AW. Effect of axon misdirection on
recovery of electromyographic activity and kinematics after peripheral nerve
injury. [Internet]. Cells, tissues, organs. 2011 Jan ;193(5):298-309.
164 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury: Kinematic Model of the Hindlimb of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Chapter 7 - General discussion and conclusions
166 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - Hindlimb Kinematic Model of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
1 General discussion
The main objective of this thesis was to investigate functional recovery of rats’ hindlimb
after therapeutic strategies for peripheral nerve repair in axonotmesis and neurotmesis
injuries. The results obtained in the experimental studies included in this thesis allowed
to verify functional and morphological differences between different therapeutic
strategies, when using tissue engineering and cellular therapies based on new
biomaterials. Chitosan (Chapter 3) and collagen (Chapter 4) associated to a cellular
system capable of neurotrophic factors production are the different therapeutic
strategies. Exercise-based neurorehabilitation was also studied in chapter 6.
The relevance of rat model in this thesis is related with the possibility to isolate several
levels of complexity to understand biological systems and develop cellular systems to
promote nervous tissue regeneration. It was possible to evaluate functional recovery in
vivo after therapeutic intervention for peripheral nerve repair during a follow-up period
with morphological evaluation of the nerve at the end of the experiment. Our
experimental model was the sciatic nerve, and we have verified that the possibility of
peripheral nerve repair is a promising reality. Peripheral nerve regeneration can be
studied in a number of different experimental models based on the use of nerves from
both forelimb and hindlimb (1-3). The experimental animal model of choice for many
researchers remains the rat sciatic nerve. It provides an inexpensive source of
mammalian nervous tissue of identical genetic stock that it is easy to work with and
well studied (4) and shows a similar capacity for regeneration in rats and sub-humans
primates (5). The rat sciatic nerve is a widely used model for the evaluation of motor as
well as sensory nerve function at the same time (3).
Our studies of sciatic nerve regeneration include a post-surgery follow-up period of 20
weeks after neurotmesis and 12 weeks after axonotmesis based on the assumption
that, by the end of this time, functional and morphological recovery are complete (6-9).
Although both morphological and functional data have been used to assess neural
regeneration after induced neurotmesis and axonotmesis injuries, the correlation
between these two types of assessment is usually poor (10-12). Classical and newly
developed methods of assessing nerve recovery, including histomorphometry,
retrograde transport of horseradish peroxidase and retrograde fluorescent labelling (13;
14) do not necessarily predict the reestablishment of motor and sensory functions (10;
15-17). Although such techniques are useful in studying the nerve regeneration
process, they generally fail in assessing functional recovery (10). In this sense,
Chapter 7- General discussion and conclusions 167
Sandra Crisitina Fernanades Amado
research on peripheral nerve injury needs to combine both functional and
morphological assessment. The use of biomechanical techniques and rat’s gait
kinematic evaluation is a progress in documenting functional recovery (17). Indeed, the
use of biomechanical parameters has given valuable insight into the effects of the
sciatic denervation/reinnervation, and thus represents an integration of the neural
control acting on the ankle and foot muscles (17-20).
After peripheral nerve injury, acute changes were particularly evident during push off
phase during stance, reflected in increased dorsiflexion at Toe Off (TO). With time,
there was a somewhat limited recovery towards normality during stance phase with
less pronounced dorsiflexion at TO, suggesting that extensor muscles regained the
ability to partially perform the push off action.
In sciatic-crushed (i.e. axonotmesis) animals, functional recovery is fast and by week 6
to 8 most of the kinematic parameters show values similar to those post-surgery.
However, some of the parameters remain altered even after a 12-weeks recovery
period which contrasts to other functional test that recover within 8 weeks following
sciatic crush injury (8).
After axonotmesis injury, hybrid chitosan membranes were used for peripheral nerve
regeneration. Chitosan has recently attracted particular attention because of its
biocompatibility, biodegradability, low toxicity, low cost, enhancement of wound-healing
and antibacterial effects. Its potential usefulness in nerve regeneration have been
demonstrated both in vitro and in vivo (7; 22). Chitosan is a partially deacetylated
polymer of acetyl glucosamine obtained after the alkaline deacetylation of chitin (23).
Chitosan matrices have been shown to have low mechanical strength under
physiological conditions and to be unable to maintain a predefined shape for
transplantation, which has limited their use as nerve guidance conduits in clinical
applications. The improvement of their mechanical properties can be achieved by
modifying chitosan with a silane agent. γ-glycidoxypropyltrimethoxysilane (GPTMS) is
one of the silane-coupling agents, which has epoxy and methoxysilane groups. The
epoxy group reacts with the amino groups of chitosan molecules, while the
methoxysilane groups are hydrolyzed and form silanol groups, and the silanol groups
are subjected to the construction of a siloxane network due to the condensation. Thus,
the mechanical strength of chitosan can be improved by the crosslinking between
chitosan and GPTMS and siloxane network. Chitosan and chitosan-based materials
168 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - Hindlimb Kinematic Model of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
have been proven to promote adhesion, survival, and neuritis outgrowth of neural cells
(7).
The normal pattern of ankle motion during stance characterized by initial dorsiflexion
followed by plantarflexion (push off action) was lost and dorsiflexion continues up to the
end of the stance phase caused by inability of the leg muscles to generate
plantarflexion moment (21). The ankle joint angle at Initial Contact changed
significantly after the sciatic crush. Such changes were transient and by week4 ankle
joint angle at Initial Contact was indistinguishable from baseline. Ankle joint angle at
Opposite Toe-off was significantly affected after the crush injury but by week 4 of
recovery joint position at this point of stance had recovered to normal values. At Heel
Rise ankle joint angle was significantly altered after the sciatic nerve injury until week
12. Ankle joint angle at Toe-Off was significantly altered after the sciatic nerve injury. At
week 12 ankle’s joint angle mean value at Toe-Off was similar to the one registered
before the sciatic nerve injury.
Group differences were observed, being the values at Initial Contact in the ChitosanII
group different from all the other four groups. Ankle joint angular position at Opposite
Toe in the ChitosanII group, throughout the study, were significantly different from
Crush and ChitosanIII groups. At Heel Rise, it was possible to verify differences
between ChitosanII and the Crush and ChitosanIIICell groups. Ankle’s joint angle at
Toe-Off was different between ChitosanII and ChitosanIIICell groups.
Ankle angular velocity at Opposite Toe was significantly affected after the crush injury
and returned to preoperative values at week 4. Instantaneous ankle’s joint velocity at
Heel Rise was significantly affected after axonotmesis with differences from normal
values until week 4 of recovery. Ankle’s joint velocity at Toe-Off was significantly
affected after the crush injury and did not recover completely within the 12-weeks
follow up time.
There were significant differences between the groups for ankle joint velocity at
Opposite Toe with significant differences between ChitosanII and ChitosanIICell
groups. Differences between ChitosanII and ChistosanIICell groups were registered at
Heel Rise. At Toe-Off, differences between ChitosanIICell, from one hand and Crush,
ChitosanIII and ChistosanIIICell groups, on the other were found. At week12, results of
the gait kinematic analysis of the experimental groups revealed that the group using
Chapter 7- General discussion and conclusions 169
Sandra Crisitina Fernanades Amado
ChitosanIII group differs from Crush group in a smaller number of variables. This
indicates that at the end of the recovery period animals in ChitosanIII group presented
a degree of functional recovery similar to that registered in the Crush group.
Sciatic functional index (SFI) and Static Sciatic Index (SSI) results showed that SFI
values changed significantly after the crush injury. SFI values were different from
baseline until week 7 of recovery.
The effect of group was observed for SFI values indicating that values from
ChitosanIICell group were different from those of the ChitosanII and ChitosanIII groups.
Analysis on SSI data was similar to the reported SFI results. However, SSI results from
the ChitosanIIICell group were different from those of the Crush, ChitosanII and
ChitosanIICell groups.
The Extensor Postural Trust (EPT) values obtained during the healing period of 12
weeks were significantly affected by the crush injury and at week 12, EPT had still not
recovered to baseline values.
There were significant differences in EPT values between the experimental groups
analysis shows that the EPT values from the Crush group were significantly different
from those of the ChitosanIICell and ChitosanIIICell, suggesting a negative effect of the
N1E 115-differentiated cells on motor recovery after sciatic crush injury.
Withdrawal Reflex Latency (WRL) assessed nociceptive function and it was affected up
to week 8. Beyond this time point, WRL values, the experimental groups pooled
together, were similar to those preoperatively.
The effect of group was found for WRL data and analysis showed that differences were
significant between ChitosanII group from one side and ChitosanIICell, ChitosanIII and
ChitosanIIICell groups on the other side. These results are suggestive of a slower rate
of recovery in WRL with the use of type II chitosan.
Functional assessment partially supported the histomorphometric results since results
of the WRL, EPT, SFI and SSI tests suggest that chitosan type II and the N1E-115
cells have a reduced degree of functional recovery which is in line with results of
histomorphometric analysis. Histological appearance of control normal sciatic nerve
cross sections in comparison to cross sections of the regenerated nerve fibers in all
five experimental groups were organized in microfascicles and were smaller than
control nerve fibers. In the two experimental groups in which cell delivery was carried
170 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - Hindlimb Kinematic Model of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
out, the presence of unusual cell profiles, interpretable as the transplanted cells, was
detectable at the periphery of the nerves. This was seldom observed in inner parts of
the nerve suggesting that only few transplanted cells colonized the inner nerve
interstice. Electron microscopy confirms that a good regeneration pattern of both
unmyelinated and myelinated nerve fibers occurred in all experimental groups,
irrespectively of the enrichment with neural stem cells. The border zone of the nerve
still shows the presence of some chitosan debris integrated with the collagen fibers of
the epineurium. Moreover, in the two experimental groups in which cell delivery was
carried out, it was possible to find some of transplanted cells localized in the border
zone of the regenerated nerve. Results of the design-based morphoquantitative
analysis of regenerated myelinated nerve fibers permitted to quantitatively compare the
different experimental groups. As expected, fiber density was significantly higher in all
experimental groups in comparison to control sciatic nerves, while mean axon and fiber
diameter and myelin thickness were significantly lower. On what regards the number of
regenerated myelinated nerve fibers, was found to be significantly higher in comparison
to controls in four out of the five experimental groups only; in fact, ChitosanIII group
showed a number of fibers not significantly different in comparison to normal control
nerves. The peculiarity of the experimental group, characterized by type III chitosan
membrane enwrapment, was also confirmed by statistical analysis of inter-group
variability among experimental groups which demonstrated that ChitosanIII group
presented a significantly higher mean fiber and axon diameter and myelin thickness in
comparison with all other experimental crush groups.
We also studied the effects on nerve regeneration when using collagen membranes
after neurotmesis without gap (end-to-end microsurgical technique) associated with in
vitro differentiated cellular system (chapter 3). After 20 weeks animals were sacrificed
and the repaired sciatic nerves were processed for histological and stereological
analysis. SFI was not possible to perform because of automutilation of the fingers after
sciatic nerve injury.
In the weeks following sciatic nerve transection, ankle joint motion became severely
abnormal, particularly throughout the second half of stance corresponding to the push-
off sub-phase. In clear contrast to the normal pattern of ankle movement, at week-2
post-injury animals were unable to extend this joint and dorsiflexion continued
increasing during the entire stance. This result could be associated to the paralysis of
plantarflexor muscles. The pattern of the ankle joint motion seemed to have improved
only slightly during recovery. For OT velocity and HR angle no differences were found
Chapter 7- General discussion and conclusions 171
Sandra Crisitina Fernanades Amado
before and after sciatic nerve transection, whereas for OT angle differences from pre-
injury values were significant only at weeks 2 and 16 of recovery. The angle at IC
showed a unique pattern of changes, being unaffected at week-2 post-injury and
altered from normal in the following weeks of recovery. Probably the most consistent
results are those of HR velocity, TO angle and TO velocity. These parameters were
affected immediately after the nerve injury and remained abnormal along the entire 20-
weeks recovery period.
Generally, no differences in the kinematic parameters were found between the groups.
Exceptions were IC velocity in the End-to-EndMembCell group, which was different
from the other two groups, and OT angle in the End-to-EndMemb group that was also
different from the other two groups.
Reflex activity also revealed relevant information concerning functional recovery. The
EPT response steadily improved during recovery but at week-20 the EPT values of the
injured side were still significantly lower compared to values at week-0.
A significant main effect for treatment was found, with better recovery of the EPT
response in the End-to-EndMembCell group when compared to the other two
experimental groups: at week-20, motor deficit decreased to 27% in the End-to-
EndMembCell and to 34% and 42% in the End-to-End and End-to-EndMemb groups,
respectively.
During the following weeks after injury there was recovery in paw nociception, which
was more clearly seen between weeks 6 and 8 post-surgery. At week-6, half of the
animals still had no withdrawal response to the noxious thermal stimulus in the
operated side, which is in contrast with week-8, when all animals presented a
consistent, although delayed, response. Despite such improvement in WRL response,
persistence of sensory deficit in all groups by the end of the 20-weeks recovery time
was reported. No difference between the groups was observed in the level of WRL
impairment after the sciatic nerve neurotmesis.
After neurotmesis, regeneration of axons was organized in many smaller fascicles in
comparison to controls. No significant difference regarding any of the morphological
parameters investigated in the regenerated axons from the three experimental groups.
On the other hand, comparison between regenerated and control nerves showed, as
expected, the presence of a significantly higher density and total number of myelinated
172 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - Hindlimb Kinematic Model of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
axons in experimental groups accompanied by a significantly lower fiber diameter.
Results showed that enwrapment of the rapair site with a collagen membrane, with or
without neural cell enrichment, did not lead to any significant improvement in most of
functional and stereological predictors of nerve regeneration. The exception was EPT
which recovered significantly better after neural cell enriched membrane employment.
Results of this study revealed that this particular type of nerve tissue engineering
approach has very limited effects on nerve regeneration after sciatic end-to-end nerve
reconstruction in the rat.
We have concluded that the sciatic nerve regeneration after neurotmesis and end-to-
end suture can be improved by in vitro differentiated N1E-115 neural cells seeded on a
type III equine collagen membrane, enwrapped around the injury site. The N1E-115
cell line has been established from a mouse neuroblastoma (24) and have already
been used, with conflicting results due to its neoplasic origin, as a cellular system to
locally produce and deliver neurotrophic factors (25). In vitro, the N1E-115 cells
undergo neuronal differentiation in response to dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO), adenosine
3’, 5’- cyclic monophosphate (cAMP), or serum withdrawal (24). Upon induction of
differentiation, proliferation of N1E-115 cells ceases, extensive neurite outgrowth is
observed and the membranes become highly excitable (8; 9; 26-30). The interval
period of 48 hours of differentiation was previously determined by measurement of the
intracellular calcium concentration (Ca2+i). Notice that at this time, the N1E-115 cells
present, already, the morphological characteristics of neuronal cells, nevertheless cell
death due to increased Ca2+i is not yet occurring as described elsewhere (8; 9; 26;
29-36).
Neurotrophic factors play an important role in nerve regeneration after injury or disease
and it is conceivable that if neurotrophic factors are applied in the close vicinity of the
injured nerve their healing potency is optimized. In spite of these assumptions and
contrary to our initial hypothesis, the N1E-115 cells did not facilitate either nerve
regeneration or functional recovery and, as far as morphometrical parameters are
concerned, results showed that the presence of this cellular system reduced the
number and size of the regenerated fibers. These results suggest that this type of
nerve guides can partially impair nerve regeneration, at least from a morphological
point of view (8; 9; 26; 29-36). The impaired axonal regeneration seems to be the result
of N1E-115 cells surrounding and invading the regenerating nerve, since numerous of
these cells where seen colonizing the nerve and might have deprived regenerated
nerve fibers blood supply (8; 9; 26-30). The use of N1E-115 cells did not promote nerve
Chapter 7- General discussion and conclusions 173
Sandra Crisitina Fernanades Amado
healing and their use might even derange the nerve regenerating process. Whereas
the effects on nerve regeneration were negative, an interesting result of this study was
the demonstration that the cell delivery system that we have used was effecting in
enabling long-term colonization of the regenerated nerve by transplanted neural cells.
Whether the negative effects of using N1E-115 cells as a cellular aid to peripheral
neural tissue regeneration extends to other types of cells is not known at present and
further studies are warranted to assess the role of other cellular systems, e.g.
mesenchymal stem cells, as a foreseeable therapeutic strategy in peripheral nerve
regeneration. Our experimental results with this cellular system are also important in
the perspective of stem cell transplantation employment for improving posttraumatic
nerve regeneration with patients (8; 9; 26; 29-36). Undoubtedly, great enthusiasm has
raised among researchers and in the general public about cell-based therapies in
regenerative medicine (8; 9; 26; 29-36). There is a widespread opinion that this type of
therapy is also very safe in comparison to other pharmacological or surgical therapeutic
approaches. By contrast, recent studies showed that cell-based therapy might be
ineffective for improving nerve regeneration (8; 9; 26; 29-36) or even have negative
effects by hindering the nerve regeneration process after tubulisation repair. Whereas
the choice of the cell type to be used for transplantation is certainly very important for
the therapeutic success, our present results suggest that the paradigm that donor
tissues guide transplanted stem cells to differentiate in the direction that is useful for
the regeneration process it is not always true and the possibility that transplanted stem
cells choose another differentiation line potentially in contrast with the regenerative
process should be always taken in consideration.
From a functional point of view, it was verified that independently from the type of
sciatic nerve injury, ankle motion is severely affected in the weeks immediately after
the injury. After neurotmesis (chapter 4), automutilation, chronic foot deformities,
inversion or eversion deformations were the main methodological source of limitation
for the functional assessment with the use of others widely used behavioural tests, i.e.
Sciatic Functional Index (SFI) and Static Sciatic Index (SSI) (12; 37). Despite this
limitation SFI is a widely used parameter because of its reliability (38), but recent
studies revealed that SFI method is only reliable from the 3rd week on after a severe
lesion (39). Although SFI is a quantitative method, it only considers stance phase and
several aspects have been reported as methodological limitations since some of the
measurements (i.e. Print Length factor) are dependent on the walking velocity and
pressure exerted by the foot on the floor influenced for instance by the weight of the
174 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - Hindlimb Kinematic Model of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
animal. Performing kinematic analysis for assessment of gait as dynamic function, as it
describes the trajectory of a joint during the movement, was a good alternative.
Although kinematics are only the description of movement and only takes into
consideration joint angles, it represent a good approach to understand joint
coordination and changes in kinematics during walking could be indicative of the role of
muscles in regulating locomotor activity. Using 2D video analysis and dedicated
software for motion analysis, our group reported measures of both angle and angular
velocity of the ankle joint during the stance phase (8; 26). Angular velocity data were
calculated in an attempt to raise the precision of joint motion analysis and to increase
its power in detecting subtle differences in functional recovery when testing alternative
treatments after sciatic crush (26). We reasoned that functional deficits during walking
in rat nerve models might be masked by the high redundancy and adaptability of the
motor apparatus in response to sensorimotor alterations (12; 37).
Almost all the kinematics parameters analysed regarding ankle motion during the
whole phase of the rat walk reveals a persistent abnormal pattern. Muscles innervated
by sciatic nerve rami includes both dorsiflexors and plantarflexors and although in
previous studies we focused our kinematic analysis only in the stance phase, including
analysis of all joints also during the swing phase provided additional information.
However, a key question regarding joint motion analysis is which parameters present
enough sensitivity to evaluate function after different types of sciatic injury. We have
evaluated the sensitivity and the specificity of ankle motion analysis to detect functional
deficits in the rat sciatic model (Chapter 5). By using a set of kinematic variables
describing angle and velocity during walking, a statistical model was generated that
robustly separates animals shortly after sciatic crush from sham-operated controls and
animals after 12 weeks of recovery. Moreover, the model displayed a moderate ability
to separate between the two latter groups of animals. Therefore, 2D kinematic analysis
of joint motion is sensitive to detect motor deficit caused by sciatic nerve injury even
when functional deficits are minimized by long-term recovery.
All kinematic measures were significantly altered in the time shortly after the sciatic
crush, when compared to sham-operated and recovered animals, with the exception of
angular velocity at mid-swing, which apparently is not affected by the sciatic nerve
crush and therefore seems not to be of great utility to assess functional status in the rat
sciatic model. Moreover, the introduction of interjoint coordination was also important in
order to have insights about the behaviour of all hindlimb joints, considering the
denervated chain of muscles after injury. Sciatic nerve gives off branches to the hip
Chapter 7- General discussion and conclusions 175
Sandra Crisitina Fernanades Amado
extensors and leg flexors and continues its courses beneath the gluteus medius
muscle into the thigh, in the mid-thigh the nerve trifurcates into the peroneal, tibial and
sural branches; the peroneal nerve subsequently innervates the tibialis anterior and
extensor digitorum longus, while the tibial nerve supplies the plantar flexor, toe flexors,
and the tibialis posterior. Thus, it is expected that after sciatic nerve injury hip, knee
and ankle motion reflect functional deficits. Although kinematics is only the description
of movement and only takes into consideration joint angles, it represents a good
approach to understand joint coordination. Recent studies revealed that different joint
positions were combined to achieve functional movement during cat walking after
peripheral nerve injury (12; 37). The whole limb position and orientation were
considered a preferable parameter than joint position (38). Therefore, inter segmental
transfer of energy might also be a mechanisms of economical movement production
after muscle denervation.
Our data suggest that joint kinematics has the ability to highlight minor walking
changes after long-term recovery from sciatic crush injury. However, the kinematics
changes during walking twelve weeks after sciatic nerve crush were noticed in the hip
and knee joints, while ankle joint kinematics had recovered its normal pattern. In line
with joint kinematics data, discriminant analysis clearly demonstrated that walking
measures, either spatiotemporal features or hindlimb joint kinematics, accurately
recognize sciatic-denervated animals and distinguishes them from sciatic-reinnervated
animals and sham controls. Spatiotemporal parameters like gait velocity, stride length,
stance phase duration and swing phase duration are relevant for the study of
pathological pattern of gait after peripheral nerve injury in experimental rat model (39).
Stance phase duration measured the time hind foot was in contact with the floor. After
sciatic nerve injury, the injured limb has a smaller stance phase duration. Step length,
is accurately measured using the location of the middle metatarsal head to metatarsal
head in successive steps (8; 26) and walking speed is considered a parameter that
influences stance phase and step length after sciatic crush injury (26).
The relevance of spatiotemporal parameters is related with mechanical aspects of
locomotion and its functional relevance for performance. Considering that the basic
functions of locomotion are propulsion, stance stability, shock absorption and energy
conservation (40; 41), gravitational forces are important in walking and gait
disturbances reduces the ability to use gravity and inertia in ambulation and therefore
must resort to actual muscle work, which means that they have to spend more energy
to cover certain distance.
176 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - Hindlimb Kinematic Model of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Finally, it was possible to detect subtle differences between two types of therapeutic
exercise widely used in neurorehabilitation clinical practice. The two exercise modes
consisted on treadmill exercise walking and passive mobilization of the affected
hindlimb and their effect was evaluated in contrast to a non-exercise group of sciatic
nerve crushed animals and sham operated controls. Passive exercise consisted on
manual mobilization of the entire right hindlimb. The manual mobilization included
movement of the hip, knee and ankle joints in concert, and alternating flexion and
extension of the joints. The results demonstrate marginal effects of both active and
passive exercise on functional recovery, assessed by hindlimb joint kinematics during
level walking. Although the impact of exercise on functional recovery was relatively
modest it was nonetheless accompanied by improved nerve morphology, particularly
by preventing excessive increase in total number of myelinated fibers in regenerated
sciatic nerves.
Kinematic analysis distinguished recovery of movement pattern between groups.
Twelve weeks after injury, ankle joint was similar between groups. In contrast to ankle
joint kinematics, hip and knee joint kinematics in the Crush group clearly deviated to
that of the Sham group. Such changes in the normal hip and knee kinematics during
walking were not noticed in both the active and passive exercise groups. We interpret
these results as a demonstration that the hindlimb motion pattern during level walking
is not fully reestablished after sciatic crush injury and that compensatory change at the
hip and knee joint kinematics masking disability at the ankle joint. The mechanisms
underlying these changes cannot be discerned by our data. The stimulus caused by
this rather unspecific passive motion proves also to have a positive effect on the
regenerating nerve morphology and in overall hindlimb motion pattern during walking.
Such apparent positive direct effect on nerve regeneration might result from increased
afferent input due to the movement stimulus (38). Another possibility is that our passive
movement induced rhythmic mechanical load onto the regenerating nerve inducing
local cellular and molecular responses that enhance nerve regeneration (39)
Comparison between regenerated and non-injured nerves showed morphological
differences. Signs of better regeneration as a result of passive hindlimb mobilization
were observed. As for the active exercise group, mean total number of myelinated
fibers in the passive exercise group was indistinct from that of the Sham group.
Interpretation of these results is difficult, and thus it deserves further research, the
Chapter 7- General discussion and conclusions 177
Sandra Crisitina Fernanades Amado
discrepancy between different authors who revealed an increase in the number of
myelinated axons and our results, which evidenced the opposite. Thus, results from
exercise-based neurorehabilitation are promising. In conclusion, passive and active
joint movement causes joint kinematics and nerve morphological changes. Results of
this study suggest that mechanical load plays a role on functional recovery after
peripheral nerve repair. However, further studies are needed to understand the
functional meaning of results.
178 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - Hindlimb Kinematic Model of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
2 Future perspectives
2.1 Nerve regeneration
Enwrapment of the site of a nerve crush lesion with a chitosan type III membrane
significantly improves nerve regeneration in the rat, whereas enrichment of chitosan
membranes with N1E-115 neural cells does have positive effects. Whereas
transposition of animal studies to patients should always be dealt with caution, the
results obtained in this experimental study opened interesting perspectives for the
clinical use of hybrid chitosan membranes in peripheral nerve reconstruction.
More complex devices will be needed, such as multilayered tube guides where growth
factors are entrapped in polymer layers with varying physicochemical properties or
tissue engineered tube guides containing viable stem cells (8; 26). The combination of
two or more growth factors will likely exert a synergistic effect on nerve regeneration,
especially when the growth factors belong to different families and act via different
mechanisms. Combinations of growth factors can be expected to enhance further
nerve regeneration, particularly when each of them is delivered at individually tailored
kinetics (26). The determination and control of suitable delivery kinetics for each of
several growth factors will constitute a major hurdle both technically and biologically
with the biological hurdle lying in the compliance with the naturally occurring cross talk
between growth factors and cells. A solution to this problem may be the use of
mesenchymal autologous or heterologous stem cells because they can synthesize
several growth factors and differentiate into Schwann cells which are critical for very
long gaps (40; 41).
Tissue engineering advances promotes the development of other biomaterials to
enhance peripheral nerve regeneration. The choice of the cellular system to be applyed
is crucial for the therapeutic success. Using another cell line other than N1E-115 could
have led to better results, concerning for instance, the emerging knowledge about
autologous or heterologous mesenchymal stem cells from extra-fetal sources (38).
Moreover, the construction of more appropriate tube-guides with integrated growth
factor delivery systems and/or cellular components could improve the effectiveness of
nerve tissue engineering. In fact, single-molded tube guides may not give sufficient
control over both the mechanical properties and the delivery of bioactive agents.
Chapter 7- General discussion and conclusions 179
Sandra Crisitina Fernanades Amado
2.2 Methodological improvement of functional assay
Kinematic analysis has improved the sensitivity of functional recovery assessment after
peripheral nerve injury in experimental animals and its importance seems will increase
in the future as a result of advanced technology and improved biomechanical models.
From a biomechanical perspective, joint rotational velocity has a more direct
relationship with the forces actuating onto the hindlimb segments and therefore velocity
measures may be better indicators of dysfunction caused by nerve injury. Moreover,
ankle position data is sometimes difficult to interpret, for example in those cases where
ankle joint angle remains unaffected in the weeks immediately after sciatic nerve crush
(8; 26). This shows that measures of ankle joint angle taken at snapshots during
walking may lack sensitivity to assess functional impairment. In the near future, other
statistical methods should be considered. Individual joint kinematics either in control or
nerve-injured animals is characterized by high variability, with notable differences
between different animals and even from step to step (42). Such high level of
variability, which seems to be an intrinsic property of normal quadruped walking,
seriously affects the precision of joint kinematic measures of functional recovery after
nerve injury. Reducing this variability is a challenge for efficient use of walking analysis
to assess functional recovery. Attempts to overcome this limitation include constraining
walking velocity by using treadmill walking instead of self-paced locomotion (28; 43-
48). This, of course, is likely to reduce step-by-step variability in joint kinematics but
has the disadvantage of requiring expensive equipment and limits the possibility of
combining kinematic analysis with other data, such as ground reaction forces. Other
possibilities look at a global, limb-level movement analyses as an alternative to
individual joints kinematics (28; 43-48). Also, systematic changes in the biomechanical
and movement control constraints of the locomotor task, such as using up- and down-
slope walking might also increase the accuracy of walking analysis within the context of
peripheral nerve research (28; 43-48).
Study the influence of gait velocity on functional parameters. Yu et al (2001) (37)
showed that gait analysis method is highly sensitive and studied seven spatial and
kinematic parameters. It was also pointed out that when the spontaneous walking
speed exceeded 55 cm/s was approached the limit of walking. When the walking speed
was less than 25cm/s the rats looked nervous and overcautious. Moreover, the stance
phase and step length, accurately measured by middle metatarsal head to metatarsal
head distance, was affected by walking speed.
180 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - Hindlimb Kinematic Model of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
Bilateral hindlimb model should be constructed. Yu et al. (2001) defined the right:left
stance/swing ratio (SS); right:left step length ratio (SLR); angle of the ankle joint at
terminal stance (ATS); angle of the ankle joint at midswing (AMS); tail height; tail
deviation, and midline deviation (MID). Concerning to tail and midline deviation, they
verified that the tail of normal rats deviated towards the side where the hindlimb was at
terminal stance, and during walking the body leans towards the contralateral side when
the hindlimb is at midswing. During a gait cycle after sciatic nerve injury produces ankle
dorsiflexion deformity presumably due to the dominance of tibial nerve innervation in
the lower extremities. Based on discriminant analysis these authors concluded that
right:left stance/swing ratio, right:left step length ratio and ankle joint at terminal stance
contributed significantly to the equation developed to obtain sciatic injury score.
Methodological errors related with skin movement artefacts should be studied in
kinematic analysis with optimization methods. In fact, the main sources of error
affecting in vivo estimation of the pose of a skeletal bone with a non invasive skin
markers technique are related with skin slippage, namely soft tissue artefacts (37),
anatomical landmarks misallocation and instrumental noise (40; 41), and efforts have
been made to overcome this limitation. While the estimation of instrumental errors is
not problematic, the in vivo quantification of soft tissue artefacts and their effect on the
determination of the bone position and orientation is still an open issue. Rats have
excessive skin mobility that can generate large soft tissue artefacts therefore
increasing the kinematic and kinetics data error during motion analysis. Thus, it was
verified that using tattooing the anatomical landmarks misallocation and consequent
inter-test variability was controlled (50). Soft tissue artefacts were verified to be
problematic at the knee joint (51). The position of the knee joint is loosed by skin
coverage; (8; 26) proposed that it could be calculated by using hip and ankle joint
position and external individual measurements of femur and tibia length. (26), used
high speed X-ray video and reported that the largest error between skin and bone
derived angles occurred immediately before the paw contact, and at toe-off the error
was the smallest. It was also reported that skin-derived kinematics overestimated
angular values and the knee position was the joint most affected. The choice of skin
marker placement is a critical aspect for discussion about motion analysis, and
comparisons between studies should consider this aspect when interpreting for
instance joint angle values. Sagittal values derived from skin markers are only
approximation of the actual movements of the bones that comprises a joint of interest.
Chapter 7- General discussion and conclusions 181
Sandra Crisitina Fernanades Amado
Another problem in kinematic studies related with protocol is the accurate
determination of cycle landmarks such as Initial contact and toe-off. Ground reaction
forces will improve the accuracy of determination of stance phase events. The
introduction of optoelectronic motion capture system (Chapter 4) improved accuracy of
the kinematic model, allowing instantaneous position estimation and reducing the error
introduced by digitalization process, improving data processing. Position estimation is
performed automatically and when a marker is missing it is estimated with
mathematical algorithm considering the coordinates of the following frames. Data using
this system has surprisingly showed that unlike our previous stance phase based
results showing significant improvement in ankle joint motion after sciatic injury,
analysis of swing phase shows that the abnormal ankle motion pattern remains without
significant improvement over the entire recovery period. Using optoelectronic
technology it will be possible to introduce anthropometric characteristics. In what
concerns biomechanical model, the relative position of anatomical segments is
important to perform biomechanical modelling. Reconstruction and analysis of in vivo
skeletal system kinematics using optoelectronic stereophotogrammetric data will allows
the joint kinematic description providing segment morphology (40; 41). Anatomical 3D
analyses (42) will be possible to quantify observable functional deficits in others planes
of movement further than sagittal, like rotation of the injured paw, curvation and
inversion of the feet (37; 49).
2.3 Functional meaning
From animal models we know that neural control of locomotion operates automatically
at a basic level, without conscious perception. There is a spinal network, which
generates a detailed muscle-specific spatio-temporal pattern similar to what is
observed during walking. However, this automatic level does not operates in isolation,
the final muscle activation pattern is also influenced by sensory feedback from joint,
muscle, and skin receptors (37). During ongoing movement fundamental mechanical
variables of force, length, and velocity are monitored within muscles by Golgi tendon
organs and by muscle spindle receptors, respectively. Thus, kinematics description of
motor behaviour provides a foundation for integrating morphology and physiology with
mechanics and function (28; 43-48). Moreover, force generated by a muscle depends
on activation by nerve impulses as well as the length and velocity of the muscle. The
functional meaning of recovery after peripheral nerve injuries implies the study of motor
control since peripheral nerves enclose both sensory and motor information, which are
important to produce controlled movement. From our results, we demonstrated that
182 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - Hindlimb Kinematic Model of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
joint angular displacement and joint velocity during locomotion movement might
quantify functional recovery after peripheral nerve injury. Moreover, nociception was
the first variable achieving signs of recovery. How could these quantities be related
with neuromuscular function and have functional meaning and clinical implications?
When we analyze joint kinematics data, it should be taken into consideration that these
results are also related with neural and muscle function thus being relevant to perform
a comprehensive description of movement of individual muscle action within the joint or
the joints it crosses. Dynamics of muscle function is usually examined by indirect
assessment of muscle length change based on kinematics (51) and muscle moment
arms, or estimates of fascicle length change that must take into account in-series
elastic stretch of a tendon and a simplification of the effects of muscle architecture.
Knowledge of the more complex, but a realistic pattern of 3D movement is important for
understanding its neuromuscular control, as well as the principles of musculoskeletal
design (52) that are crucial to the production of movement. During dynamic conditions,
combining kinematic data with kinetics and electromyography would be desirable to
make a comprehensive understanding of movement patterns and its changes as well
as the study of inefficient movement after injury. The study of the relationship between
joint angular velocity and muscle moments would contribute to understand muscle
contraction and work production. Results from the last study awake us for the
relevance of mechanical load, fatigue and the influence of joint rotational velocity,
which should be explored to understand performance and make available results
translation for motor rehabilitation.
Understanding functional results after peripheral nerve injury is complex, especially
when both sensory and motor pathways are impaired. Moreover, some limitation of
WRL and EPT should be considered and the interpretation of functional results should
be made carefully. Motor reflex deficit was assessed by extensor postural test (EPT)
that is characterized by the exertion of force on the ground, in a hand-controlled
loading condition, quantified with a scale. The reduction in this force, representing
reduced extensor muscle tone, was considered a deficit of motor function. Moreover,
the muscles that has been considered for interpretation of the results was the ankle
extensors i.e. gastrocnemius and soleus muscles. Also for sensory function, some
authors considered that the influence of mecanoreceptors should be controlled for the
interpretation of the results controlling the pressure exerted on the thermal platform.
Although WRL reflex was originally named flexion-withdrawal reflex (42), it has since
been shown to involve other muscles besides flexors (52). The WRL can vary because
Chapter 7- General discussion and conclusions 183
Sandra Crisitina Fernanades Amado
it depends on which afferents are stimulated and signals transmitted over polysynaptic
pathways. This means that the input signal can be modified along its path. The
recovery of sensory function is undertaken by several afferent fibers and may not be
explained by the outgrowth of regenerating axons from the sectioned proximal sciatic
nerve stumps but also by collateral sprouts from intact fibers in the skin surrounding the
denervated zone. In fact, the recovery of sensory nerve function might be started with
the expansion of the territory of intact neighbouring fibers (28; 43-48). Regenerated
sciatic nerve began to regain function between 3 (28; 43-48) to 7 (52) weeks after
injury. The borderline between a sensory-motor response involving both sensory
ascending and descending motor pathways and a pain-based withdrawal reflex-
response is not always possible. It cannot always be sure that all responses are based
on proper temperature sensing. Reflex activity should be integrated in a dynamic
model, assessed during movement, since it might comprise an important aspect on
motor control with functional meaning for the position of the limb and movement.
Mathematical modelling is a possible solution to simplify and understand the potential
environmental effect with similar neural control and exclude neural feedback. Efforts
will be made to improve the biomechanical modelling with musculoskeletal model and
methodologies to understand the reflex mechanisms involved in the sensory and motor
recovery of function.
In summary, gait analysis is a promising method to assess functional recovery after
hindlimb nerve injury. However, in order to provide accurate measures of functional
recovery, gait analysis after hindlimb peripheral nerve injury should evolve from a
simple ankle kinematics analysis to a full 3D biomechanical description of complete
hindlimb motion, meaning analysis of hip, knee and ankle joints. Further refinements of
gait analysis in the field of peripheral nerve research using the rat model should include
the combined use of joint kinematics, ground reaction forces and electromyography
data.
Innervation regulates muscle mass and muscle phenotype (53) and peripheral nerve
injury in the rat is a widely used model to investigate nerve regeneration and can also
be employed as a model of muscle inactivity and muscle atrophy (54). Previous work of
our research team has been devoted to enhance nerve regeneration after injury,
including the use of biomaterials and cellular systems (26). By combining motor and
sensory function tests, biomechanical analysis of the rat gait and nerve morphology
assessment by unbiased stereological methods, we could demonstrate that animals
184 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - Hindlimb Kinematic Model of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
almost fully recover from sciatic nerve crush in 12 weeks (8). However, nerve
morphology remains significantly different in control and injured animals as well as
ankle joint motion during walk (8). Muscle function was not assessed in our previous
work. Aside incomplete nerve regeneration, changes in the muscles may contribute to
functional deficit after nerve injury (54-56).
Denervation induces muscle atrophy and, 25 months post denervation, muscle fibres
crossectional area of the EDL muscle diminish to only 2.5% of control animals although
their fascicular organization is maintained (57). The effect of denervation on muscle
atrophy is both activity-dependent and activity-independent since the degree of
hindlimb muscle atrophy after spinal isolation (activity-independent nerve influence) is
less when compared to the atrophy caused by removal of all nerve influences by
transecting the sciatic nerve (53). Two basic mechanisms are responsible for
denervation-induced muscle atrophy. First, there is augmented activity of the ubiquitin-
proteasome pathway and proteolysis (58). Second, there is cell death and myonuclei
apoptosis conjugated with decreased capacity of satellite cell-dependent reparative
myogenesis (54; 57). Together with atrophy, denervated/reinnervated muscles undergo
phenotypical changes and conversion between muscle fibre types (55).
The relative increase in type I or type II muscle fibres following denervation seems to
depend on the type of muscle fibres predominant in the muscle, with type II muscle
fibres (fast fibres) increasing in proportion in soleus (slow muscle) and type I muscle
fibre number increasing in gastrocnemius and tibialis anterior muscles (54). Likewise,
the degree of muscle fibre atrophy in short-term denervation (4 weeks) has been
noticed to be greater in the muscle fibre type that is more abundant in the affected
muscles (59). However, it must be stressed that for many purposes there is a lack of
detailed morphological description of denervated/reinnervated muscles since in most
cases the morphoquantitative methods employed lack accuracy and completeness.
Muscle architectural changes, and also likely remodeling of the enveloping connective
tissue (60) might contribute to altered function in denervated/reinnervated muscles.
Ideally, muscle contractile properties are evaluated in minimally dissected muscle-
nerve preparations in which muscle contractions are elicited by electrical stimulation of
the nerve (61). Using such approach, fundamental properties of hindlimb muscles of
the rat, like isometric peak force, range of active force, slack length, and passive
length-force curve can be obtained. All these parameters are potentially affected by
changes in muscle morphology secondary to denervation/reinnervation (60). Unlike the
classical view, skeletal muscles are not isolated units and their mechanical properties
are dependent on the context, meaning the mechanical load in surrounding muscles
Chapter 7- General discussion and conclusions 185
Sandra Crisitina Fernanades Amado
and connective tissue (62). The transmission of force out from the muscle fibres to the
skeleton follows both myotendinous and myofascial links (63). The latter involves load
being transmitted to synergistic and antagonistic muscles (60) and occurs through the
muscular and non-muscular connective tissues (e.g. neurovascular tracts, i.e. the
collagen fiber reinforced tissues surrounding nerves and blood vessels). Surgical
reconstruction of the peripheral nerves affects the mechanical properties of the
neurovascular tract supplying leg muscles in unknown ways as well as the architecture
of denervated muscles. In addition, altered properties of supportive connective tissue
may affect myofascial force transmission and overall function (60). In situ testing of
muscle function, keeping the connective tissue that envelops the muscle or muscle
groups undamaged, is a unique method to evaluate possible changes in myofascial
force transmission (62), and by measuring the force produced at the proximal and
distal ends of the EDL an indication of myofascial force transmission is obtained (64).
In recent years, great emphasis has been placed on kinematic analysis of the rat
locomotion [(19). Although gait analysis is an elegant and meaningful way to assess
functionality, it is limited in evaluating physiological and mechanical properties of the
affected muscles. The potential for biomechanical gait analysis to assess hindlimb
muscle function requires precise motion capture system combined with ground reaction
force data (65) and a geometrical model of the rat hindlimb musculoskeletal system
(66).
The development of biological and material therapeutic strategies to enhance
functional recovery is the major interest of several research areas such as Biology,
Engineering, and Medicine. The assessment of functional recovery is a complex
question that has many different facts to be addressed in detail. A common feature of
these problems is that they address relationships between morphological, physiological
and behavioural aspects of information processing in nervous system (“structure-
function” relationships). Movement Sciences should be considered for the
interdisciplinary approaches across established neuroscience disciplines. Moreover,
functional recovery after peripheral nerve injury assessed with dynamical model of
locomotion might represent an integrative approach to have deep knowledge about
neural activity, mechanical and structural relationship.
186 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - Hindlimb Kinematic Model of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
REFERENCES
1. Yang C-C, Shih Y-H, Ko M-H, Hsu S-Y, Cheng H, Fu Y-S. Transplantation of
human umbilical mesenchymal stem cells from Whartonʼs jelly after complete
transection of the rat spinal cord. [Internet]. PloS one. 2008 Jan ;3(10):e3336.
2. Höke A. Mechanisms of Disease: what factors limit the success of peripheral
nerve regeneration in humans? [Internet]. Nature clinical practice. Neurology.
2006 Aug ;2(8):448-54.
3. Jensen JN, Tung THH, Mackinnon SE, Brenner MJ, Hunter DA. Use of anti-
CD40 ligand monoclonal antibody as antirejection therapy in a murine peripheral
nerve allograft model. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2004 Jan ;24(4):309-15.
4. Geuna S, Raimondo S, Ronchi G, Di Scipio F, Tos P, Czaja K, et al.
International Review of Neurobiology Volume 87 [Internet]. Elsevier; 2009.
5. Hu D, Hu R, Berde CB. Neurologic evaluation of infant and adult rats before and
after sciatic nerve blockade. [Internet]. Anesthesiology. 1997 Apr ;86(4):957-65.[
6. Amado S, Rodrigues JM, Luís AL, Armada-da-Silva P a S, Vieira M, Gartner A,
et al. Effects of collagen membranes enriched with in vitro-differentiated N1E-
115 cells on rat sciatic nerve regeneration after end-to-end repair. [Internet].
Journal of neuroengineering and rehabilitation. 2010 Jan ;77.
7. Simões MJ, Amado S, Gärtner A, Armada-Da-Silva P a S, Raimondo S, Vieira
M, et al. Use of chitosan scaffolds for repairing rat sciatic nerve defects.
[Internet]. Italian journal of anatomy and embryology = Archivio italiano di
anatomia ed embriologia. 2010 Jan ;115(3):190-210.
8. Luís AL, Amado S, Geuna S, Rodrigues JM, Simões MJ, Santos JD, et al. Long-
term functional and morphological assessment of a standardized rat sciatic
nerve crush injury with a non-serrated clamp. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience
methods. 2007 Jun ;163(1):92-104.
9. Luís AL, Rodrigues JM, Geuna S, Amado S, Simões MJ, Fregnan F, et al.
Neural cell transplantation effects on sciatic nerve regeneration after a
standardized crush injury in the rat. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2008 Jan
;28(6):458-70.
10. Shen N, Zhu J. Application of sciatic functional index in nerve functional
assessment. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 1995 Jan ;16(8):552-5.
11. Kanaya F, Firrell JC, Breidenbach WC. Sciatic function index, nerve conduction
tests, muscle contraction, and axon morphometry as indicators of regeneration.
Chapter 7- General discussion and conclusions 187
Sandra Crisitina Fernanades Amado
[Internet]. Plastic and reconstructive surgery. 1996 Dec ;98(7):1264-71,
discussion 1272-4.
12. Dellon AL, Mackinnon SE. Sciatic nerve regeneration in the rat. Validity of
walking track assessment in the presence of chronic contractures. [Internet].
Microsurgery. 1989 Jan ;10(3):220-5.
13. Mackinnon SE, Dellon AL, OʼBrien JP. Changes in nerve fiber numbers distal to
a nerve repair in the rat sciatic nerve model. [Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 1991
Nov ;14(11):1116-22.
14. Mackinnon SE, Hudson AR, Hunter DA. Histologic assessment of nerve
regeneration in the rat. [Internet]. Plastic and reconstructive surgery. 1985 Mar
;75(3):384-8.
15. Almquist E, Eeg-Olofsson O. Sensory-nerve-conduction velocity and two-point
discrimmination in sutured nerves. [Internet]. The Journal of bone and joint
surgery. American volume. 1970 Jun ;52(4):791-6.
16. Medinaceli L de, Freed WJ, Wyatt RJ. An index of the functional condition of rat
sciatic nerve based on measurements made from walking tracks. [Internet].
Experimental neurology. 1982 Sep ;77(3):634-43.
17. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Filipe VM, Gabriel RC, et al.
Ankle kinematics to evaluate functional recovery in crushed rat sciatic nerve
[Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 2003 ;27(6):706–714.
18. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Patricio JA, Bulas-Cruz J, Gabriel RC, Melo-Pinto P,
et al. Functional assessment of peripheral nerve recovery in the rat: gait
kinematics [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2001 ;21(8):383–388.
19. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Gabriel RC, Filipe VM, et al.
Motion of the foot and ankle during the stance phase in rats. [Internet]. Muscle &
nerve. 2002 Nov ;26(5):630-5.
20. Varejão ASP, Cabrita AM, Meek MF, Bulas-Cruz J, Melo-Pinto P, Raimondo S,
et al. Functional and morphological assessment of a standardized rat sciatic
nerve crush injury with a non-serrated clamp. [Internet]. Journal of neurotrauma.
2004 Nov ;21(11):1652-70.
21. Luis A, Amado S, Geuna S, Rodrigues J, Simoes M, Santos JD, et al. Long-term
functional and morphological assessment of a standardized rat sciatic nerve
crush injury with a non-serrated clamp [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience
methods. 2007 ;16392–104.
22. Chandy T, Sharma CP. Chitosan--as a biomaterial. [Internet]. Biomaterials,
artificial cells, and artificial organs. 1990 Jan ;18(1):1-24.
188 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - Hindlimb Kinematic Model of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
23. Senel S, McClure SJ. Potential applications of chitosan in veterinary medicine.
[Internet]. Advanced drug delivery reviews. 2004 Jun ;56(10):1467-80.
24. Amano T, Richelson E, Nirenberg M. Neurotransmitter synthesis by
neuroblastoma clones (neuroblast differentiation-cell culture-choline
acetyltransferase-acetylcholinesterase-tyrosine hydroxylase-axons-dendrites).
[Internet]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States
of America. 1972 Jan ;69(1):258-63.
25. Shirosaki Y, Tsuru K, Hayakawa S, Osaka A, Lopes MA, Santos JD, et al. In
vitro cytocompatibility of MG63 cells on chitosan-organosiloxane hybrid
membranes. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2005 Feb ;26(5):485-93.
26. Amado S, Simões MJ, Armada da Silva PAS, Luís AL, Shirosaki Y, Lopes MA,
et al. Use of hybrid chitosan membranes and N1E-115 cells for promoting nerve
regeneration in an axonotmesis rat model. [Internet]. Biomaterials. 2008 Nov
;29(33):4409-19.
27. Luis AL, Rodrigues JM, Amado S, Veloso AP, Armada-Da-silva PAS, Raimondo
S, et al. PLGA 90/10 and caprolactone biodegradable nerve guides for the
reconstruction of the rat sciatic nerve [Internet]. Microsurgery. 2007 ;27(2):125–
137.
28. Luís AL, Rodrigues JM, Geuna S, Amado S, Shirosaki Y, Lee JM, et al. Use of
PLGA 90:10 scaffolds enriched with in vitro-differentiated neural cells for
repairing rat sciatic nerve defects. [Internet]. Tissue engineering. Part A. 2008
Jun ;14(6):979-93.
29. Rodrigues JM, Luís AL, Lobato JV, Pinto MV, Faustino A, Hussain NS, et al.
Intracellular Ca2+ concentration in the N1E-115 neuronal cell line and its use for
peripheric nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Acta médica portuguesa. 2005
;18(5):323-8.
30. Rodrigues JM, Luís AL, Lobato JV, Pinto MV, Lopes MA, Freitas M, et al.
Determination of the intracellular Ca2+ concentration in the N1E-115 neuronal
cell line in perspective of its use for peripheric nerve regeneration. [Internet]. Bio-
medical materials and engineering. 2005 Jan ;15(6):455-65.
31. Kimhi Y, Palfrey C, Spector I, Barak Y, Littauer UZ. Maturation of neuroblastoma
cells in the presence of dimethylsulfoxide. [Internet]. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 1976 Feb ;73(2):462-6.
32. Laat SW de, Saag PT van der. The plasma membrane as a regulatory site in
growth and differentiation of neuroblastoma cells. [Internet]. International review
of cytology. 1982 Jan ;741-54.
Chapter 7- General discussion and conclusions 189
Sandra Crisitina Fernanades Amado
33. Reagan LP, Ye XH, Mir R, DePalo LR, Fluharty SJ. Up-regulation of angiotensin
II receptors by in vitro differentiation of murine N1E-115 neuroblastoma cells.
[Internet]. Molecular pharmacology. 1990 Dec ;38(6):878-86.
34. Larcher JC, Basseville M, Vayssiere JL, Cordeau-Lossouarn L, Croizat B, Gros
F. Growth inhibition of N1E-115 mouse neuroblastoma cells by c-myc or N-myc
antisense oligodeoxynucleotides causes limited differentiation but is not coupled
to neurite formation. [Internet]. Biochemical and biophysical research
communications. 1992 Jun ;185(3):915-24.
35. Prasad KN. Differentiation of neuroblastoma cells: a useful model for
neurobiology and cancer. [Internet]. Biological reviews of the Cambridge
Philosophical Society. 1991 Nov ;66(4):431-51.
36. Prasad KN, Kentroti S, Edwards-Prasad J, Vernadakis A, Imam M, Carvalho E,
et al. Modification of the expression of adenosine 3ʼ,5'-cyclic monophosphate-
induced differentiated functions in neuroblastoma cells by beta-carotene and D-
alpha-tocopheryl succinate. [Internet]. Journal of the American College of
Nutrition. 1994 Jun ;13(3):298-303
37. Yu P, Matloub HS, Sanger JR, Narini P. Gait analysis in rats with peripheral
nerve injury. [Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 2001 Feb ;24(2):231-9.
38. Meek MF, Den Dunnen WF, Schakenraad JM, Robinson PH. Long-term
evaluation of functional nerve recovery after reconstruction with a thin-walled
biodegradable poly (DL-lactide-epsilon-caprolactone) nerve guide, using walking
track analysis and electrostimulation tests. [Internet]. Microsurgery. 1999 Jan
;19(5):247-53.
39. Monte-Raso VV, Barbieri CH, Mazzer N. Índice funcional do ciático nas lesões
por esmagamento do nervo ciático de ratos. Avaliação da reprodutibilidade do
método entre examinadores [Internet]. Acta Ortopédica Brasileira. 2006
;14(3):133-136.
40. Canu M-H, Garnier C, Lepoutre F-X, Falempin M. A 3D analysis of hindlimb
motion during treadmill locomotion in rats after a 14-day episode of simulated
microgravity. [Internet]. Behavioural brain research. 2005 Feb ;157(2):309-21.
41. Canu M-H, Garnier C. A 3D analysis of fore- and hindlimb motion during
overground and ladder walking: comparison of control and unloaded rats.
[Internet]. Experimental neurology. 2009 Jul ;218(1):98-108.
42. Chang Y-H, Auyang AG, Scholz JP, Nichols TR. Whole limb kinematics are
preferentially conserved over individual joint kinematics after peripheral nerve
190 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - Hindlimb Kinematic Model of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
injury. [Internet]. The Journal of experimental biology. 2009 Nov ;212(Pt
21):3511-21.
43. Lundborg G. Alternatives to autologous nerve grafts. [Internet]. Handchirurgie,
Mikrochirurgie, plastische Chirurgie : Organ der Deutschsprachigen
Arbeitsgemeinschaft für Handchirurgie : Organ der Deutschsprachigen
Arbeitsgemeinschaft für Mikrochirurgie der Peripheren Nerven und Gefässe :
Organ der Vereinigung der Deut. 2004 Feb ;36(1):1-7.
44. Schmidt CE, Leach JB. Neural tissue engineering: strategies for repair and
regeneration. [Internet]. Annual review of biomedical engineering. 2003 Jan
;5293-347.
45. Battiston B, Raimondo S, Tos P, Gaidano V, Audisio C, Scevola A, et al.
Chapter 11: Tissue engineering of peripheral nerves [Internet]. Elsevier; 2009.
46. Zacchigna S, Giacca M. Chapter 20: Gene therapy perspectives for nerve repair.
[Internet]. International review of neurobiology. 2009 Jan ;87381-92.
47. Terenghi G, Wiberg M, Kingham PJ. Chapter 21: Use of stem cells for improving
nerve regeneration. [Internet]. International review of neurobiology. 2009 Jan
;87393-403.
48. Dahlin L, Johansson F, Lindwall C, Kanje M. Chapter 28: Future perspective in
peripheral nerve reconstruction. [Internet]. Elsevier; 2009.
49. Santos PM, Williams SL, Thomas SS. Neuromuscular evaluation using rat gait
analysis. [Internet]. Journal of neuroscience methods. 1995 ;61(1-2):79-84.
50. Perry J. Gait analysis: Normal and Pathological Function. SLACK Incorporated;
1992.
51. Cavanagh P. Biomechanics of distance running [Internet]. Champaign, Illinois:
Human Kinetics Books; 1990.
52. Meek MF, Werff JFA van der, Klok F, Robinson PH, Nicolai JPA, Gramsbergen
A. Functional nerve recovery after bridging a 15 mm gap in rat sciatic nerve with
a biodegradable nerve guide. [Internet]. Scandinavian journal of plastic and
reconstructive surgery and hand surgery / Nordisk plastikkirurgisk forening [and]
Nordisk klubb for handkirurgi. 2003 Jan ;37(5):258-65.
53. Hyatt J-PK, Roy RR, Baldwin KM, Edgerton VR. Nerve activity-independent
regulation of skeletal muscle atrophy: role of MyoD and myogenin in satellite
cells and myonuclei. [Internet]. American journal of physiology. Cell physiology.
2003 Nov ;285(5):C1161-73.
Chapter 7- General discussion and conclusions 191
Sandra Crisitina Fernanades Amado
54. Ijkema-Paassen J, Meek MF, Gramsbergen A. Reinnervation of muscles after
transection of the sciatic nerve in adult rats. [Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 2002 Jun
;25(6):891-7.
55. Edgerton VR, Roy RR. How selective is the reinnervation of skeletal muscle
fibers? [Internet]. Muscle & nerve. 2002 Jun ;25(6):765-7.
56. Borisov AB, Dedkov EI, Carlson BM. Abortive myogenesis in denervated skeletal
muscle: differentiative properties of satellite cells, their migration, and block of
terminal differentiation [Internet]. Anatomy and Embryology. 2005 Mar
11;209(4):269-279.
57. Dedkov EI, Kostrominova TY, Borisov AB, Carlson BM. Reparative myogenesis
in long-term denervated skeletal muscles of adult rats results in a reduction of
the satellite cell population. [Internet]. The Anatomical record. 2001 Jun
1;263(2):139-54.
58. Bruusgaard JC, Gundersen K. In vivo time-lapse microscopy reveals no loss of
murine myonuclei during weeks of muscle atrophy. [Internet]. The Journal of
clinical investigation. 2008 Apr ;118(4):1450-7.
59. Cebasek V, Radochová B, Ribaric S, Kubínová L, Erzen I. Nerve injury affects
the capillary supply in rat slow and fast muscles differently. [Internet]. Cell and
tissue research. 2006 Mar ;323(2):305-12.[
60. Huijing P a, Jaspers RT. Adaptation of muscle size and myofascial force
transmission: a review and some new experimental results. [Internet].
Scandinavian journal of medicine & science in sports. 2005 Dec ;15(6):349-80.
61. Meijer HJM, Rijkelijkhuizen JM, Huijing PA. Effects of firing frequency on length-
dependent myofascial force transmission between antagonistic and synergistic
muscle groups. [Internet]. European journal of applied physiology. 2008 Oct
;104(3):501-13.
62. Rijkelijkhuizen JM, Baan GC, Haan a de, Ruiter CJ de, Huijing P a.
Extramuscular myofascial force transmission for in situ rat medial gastrocnemius
and plantaris muscles in progressive stages of dissection. [Internet]. The Journal
of experimental biology. 2005 Jan ;208(Pt 1):129-40.
63. Huijing P a. Muscle as a collagen fiber reinforced composite: a review of force
transmission in muscle and whole limb. [Internet]. Journal of biomechanics. 1999
Apr ;32(4):329-45.
64. Maas H, Meijer HJM, Huijing PA. Intermuscular interaction between synergists in
rat originates from both intermuscular and extramuscular myofascial force
transmission. [Internet]. Cells, tissues, organs. 2005 Jan ;181(1):38-50.
192 Functional assessment after Peripheral Nerve Injury - Hindlimb Kinematic Model of the rat
FMH – Technical University of Lisbon
65. Howard CS, Blakeney DC, Medige J, Moy OJ, Peimer C a. Functional
assessment in the rat by ground reaction forces. [Internet]. Journal of
biomechanics. 2000 Jun ;33(6):751-7.
66. Johnson WL, Jindrich DL, Roy RR, Reggie Edgerton V. A three-dimensional
model of the rat hindlimb: musculoskeletal geometry and muscle moment arms.
[Internet]. Journal of biomechanics. 2008 Jan ;41(3):610-9.