frequently asked questions about psers’ investments · what are psers’ investment objectives?...
TRANSCRIPT
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC SCHOOL EMPLOYEES’ RETIREMENT SYSTEM
Frequently Asked Questions About PSERS’ Investments
Updated: August 2016
Table of Contents
1
What are PSERS’ Investment Objectives?
PSERS Investments are a Profit Center
How Does PSERS Achieve its Return Objectives?
PSERS’ Success Blending Passive and Active Strategies
How Does PSERS Evaluate its Investment Manager Fees?
Why Does PSERS Invest in Hedge Funds, Private Equity and Private Real Estate?
Has PSERS Achieved its Investment Objectives?
How Have PSERS’ Investments Benefitted the Commonwealth?
2
RETURN: to meet or exceed the actuarial rate (currently 7.25%) over the long-term. RISK: to minimize the risk of losses through diversification. CONSTRAINTS:
To maintain adequate liquidity to meet required benefit payments; and To act solely in the interests of the members of the System and for the
exclusive benefit of the System’s members, and their beneficiaries.
What are PSERS’ Investment Objectives?
3
RETURN OBJECTIVE: The overall return objective is to realize a return sufficient
to achieve funding adequacy on an inflation-adjusted basis. The System has a return objective of meeting or exceeding the actuarial rate (currently 7.25%) over the long-term. In addition, the Board has the following broad objectives: The assets of the System shall be invested to maximize the returns for the
level of risk taken; and, The System shall strive to achieve a return that exceeds PSERS’ Policy
Index.
What are PSERS’ Investment Objectives?
4
RISK OBJECTIVES:
The assets of the System shall be diversified to minimize the risk of losses within any one asset class, investment type, industry or sector exposure, maturity date, or geographic location. Failure to do so could seriously impair the System’s ability to achieve its funding and long-term investment goals and objectives; and,
The System’s assets shall invested so that the probability of investment losses (as measured by the Policy Index) in excess of 15% in any one year is no greater than 2.5% (or two standard deviations below the expected return).
What are PSERS’ Investment Objectives?
5
CONSTRAINTS:
Downside Risk, or the risk of loss of capital The Commonwealth and school districts already face significant fiscal
challenges. Large investment losses could result in even larger requirement for
employer contributions. Risk-averse investment strategies that limit the probability of losses are
most appropriate in this environment. Liquidity Risk PSERS currently pays out over $6 billion in member benefits annually. Member benefit payments exceeded employee and employer
contributions by over $3.1 billion in FY 2008, and have modestly shrunk to $2.6 billion for FY 2015.
Maintaining adequate short term liquidity is an expense to the taxpayer because it limits PSERS’ ability to achieve long term return objectives.
What are PSERS’ Investment Objectives?
6
CONSTRAINTS (con’t)
Fiduciary Standard: Commonwealth law requires PSERS’ investments to be made solely for the benefit of the members.
Prudent Person Standard: Commonwealth law requires PSERS’ Board exercise “that degree of judgment, skill and care under the circumstances then prevailing which persons of prudence, discretion and intelligence who are familiar with such matters exercise in the management of their own affairs…”.
What are PSERS’ Investment Objectives?
Table of Contents
7
What are PSERS’ Investment Objectives?
How Does PSERS Achieve its Return Objectives?
PSERS’ Success Blending Passive and Active Strategies
How Does PSERS Evaluate its Investment Manager Fees? PSERS Investments are a Profit Center Why Does PSERS Invest in Hedge Funds, Private Equity and Private Real Estate?
Has PSERS Achieved its Investments Objectives?
How Have PSERS’ Investments Benefitted the Commonwealth?
8
ASSET ALLOCATION POLICY
The mix of stocks, bonds, and other classes of investment assets targeted by the fund.
The Asset Allocation Policy is typically responsible for 80% to 90% of investment performance.
MANAGER SELECTION AND ALLOCATION TILTS
Mix of Active/Passive and other investment strategies within and between asset classes.
Typically responsible for about 10% to 20% of investment performance.
How Does PSERS Achieve its Return Objectives?
9
Asset Allocation Considerations:
PSERS’ investment time horizon; Capital market assumptions (e.g., expected return, risk, correlations); Return targets; Demographics of plan participants and beneficiaries, and actuarial analysis; Cash flow requirements; PSERS’ funded status; The Commonwealth’s and School Districts’ financial strength; and The Board’s willingness and ability to take on risk.
PSERS’ asset allocation plan is designed to meet the unique needs of a defined benefit system that is currently underfunded and had been receiving employer contributions below the actuarial required contribution for over 10 years.
How Does PSERS Achieve its Return Objectives?
10
Manager Selection Criteria:
Have a unique insight or process; Have the ability to add consistent excess returns above passive
alternatives, net of fees; Process is sustainable and timeless; Have adequate capacity to execute the strategy; Add diversification to our existing investment structure; Do not exhibit style drift; and Exhibit a high level of ethical behavior.
How Does PSERS Achieve its Return Objectives?
11
Passive and active strategies each play important roles
How Does PSERS Achieve its Return Objectives?
Passive Strategies Active Strategies
Investment Goal Endeavor to achieve the return of the targeted market over extended periods
Endeavor to exceed the return of the targeted market over extended periods
Costs Generally lower (less management need)
Generally higher (more management required)
Investment Risks Generally exhibit volatility similar to the index replicated
Varies greatly depending on strategy details
Availability in Public Markets
Nearly all public markets; effectiveness is usually good in deep, developed markets but less effective in smaller and emerging markets
All public markets; effectiveness often struggles in deep, developed markets but is often more effective in smaller and emerging markets
Availability in Private Markets Rarely available in private markets Well-developed market for institutional investors
Table of Contents
12
What are PSERS’ Investment Objectives?
PSERS Investments are a Profit Center
How Does PSERS Achieve its Return Objectives? PSERS’ Success Blending Passive and Active Strategies How Does PSERS Evaluate its Investment Manager Fees?
Why Does PSERS Invest in Hedge Funds, Private Equity and Private Real Estate?
Has PSERS Achieved its Investments Objectives? How Have PSERS’ Investments Benefitted the Commonwealth?
13
When passive strategies are appropriate, PSERS’ staff have outperformed
outsourced alternatives.
PSERS’ Success Blending Passive and Active Strategies
Comparison of Net of Fees Performance of Vanguard S&P 500 Index
versus PSERS S&P 500 Index For Years Ending December 31, 2015
Vanguard S&P 500
PSERS S&P 500 PSERS Outperformance
1 Year 1.25% 1.43% 0.18% 5 Year 12.40% 12.65% 0.25% 10 Year 7.18% 7.61% 0.43%
14
PSERS has better returns than passive alternatives, even with fees and expenses
taken into account, at lower levels of risk.
PSERS’ Success Blending Passive and Active Strategies
1 3 5 10
PSERS -1.80% 5.08% 6.15% 5.01%Policy Benchmark -2.49% 3.24% 4.14% 3.72%
Value Added as Percentage over Pure Index 0.69% 1.84% 2.01% 1.29%Value Added in $ Billions over Pure Index $0.32 $0.86 $0.94 $0.60
1 3 5 10PSERS -0.31 1.02 1.2 0.42
-0.45 0.71 0.83 0.32
PSERS 5.54% 4.95% 5.08% 10.39%5.37% 4.63% 4.97% 9.15%
Comparison of Net of Fee Annualized Performance of PSERS Total Fund versus Policy Benchmark For Years Ending December 31, 2015
Performance
Sharpe RatioPolicy Benchmark
Standard DeviationPolicy Benchmark
Table of Contents
15
What are PSERS’ Investment Objectives?
PSERS Investments are a Profit Center
How Does PSERS Achieve its Return Objectives?
PSERS’ Success Blending Passive and Active Strategies How Does PSERS Evaluate its Investment Manager Fees?
Why Does PSERS Invest in Hedge Funds, Private Equity and Private Real Estate?
Has PSERS Achieved its Investment Objectives? How Have PSERS’ Investments Benefitted the Commonwealth?
16
Integrated with asset allocation & investment manager selection processes. PSERS’ contracts require lowest fees offered (“Most Favored Nation”). Business Case: For the fees to be paid, how likely is it that the investments will be
profitable?
How Does PSERS Evaluate its Investment Manager Fees?
Table of Contents
17
What are PSERS’ Investment Objectives?
PSERS Investments are a Profit Center
How Does PSERS Achieve its Return Objectives?
PSERS’ Success Blending Passive and Active Strategies How Does PSERS Evaluate its Investment Manager Fees?
Why Does PSERS Invest in Hedge Funds, Private Equity and Private Real Estate?
Has PSERS Achieved its Investment Objectives? How Have PSERS’ Investments Benefitted the Commonwealth?
18
The success of PSERS’ investment activities should be evaluated as any business
by asking:
ARE PSERS’ INVESTMENTS PROFITABLE TO THE COMMONWEALTH?
PSERS Investments are a Profit Center
19
Fees are actual total investment expenses, and include investment management fees, service provider fees (e.g., custodian), consultant fees, and overhead (personnel, technology, etc.)
PSERS Investments are a Profit Center
Fiscal Year Ended June 30
Actual Investment Return above Policy Benchmark Return,
Before Fees("REVENUES")
Fees("COSTS")
Actual Investment Return above Policy
Benchmark Return, After Fees
("PROFIT")2015 $ 952 $ 455 $ 497 2014 $ 2,001 $ 482 $ 1,519 2013 $ 1,801 $ 558 $ 1,243 2012 $ 1,381 $ 481 $ 900 2011 $ 2,088 $ 515 $ 1,573 2010 $ 2,276 $ 522 $ 1,754 2009 $ (2,653) $ 478 $ (3,131)2008 $ (219) $ 399 $ (618)2007 $ 2,674 $ 314 $ 2,360 2006 $ 1,846 $ 211 $ 1,635
$ 12,148 $ 4,415 $ 7,733
Dollar amounts in millions.
20
Over the last 10 fiscal years, PSERS earned $12.1 billion OVER indexed market
returns, incurred $4.4 billion in investment expenses, and earned a profit of $7.7 billion.
PSERS Investments are a Profit Center
2006 - 2015 Total
Actual Investment Return above Policy Benchmark, Before Fees ("REVENUES")
$ 12,148
Fees ("COSTS") $ 4,415
Actual Investment Return above Policy Benchmark, After Fees ("PROFIT")
$ 7,733
Dollar amounts in millions.
Table of Contents
21
What are PSERS’ Investment Objectives?
PSERS Investments are a Profit Center
How Does PSERS Achieve its Return Objectives?
PSERS’ Success Blending Passive and Active Strategies How Does PSERS Evaluate its Investment Manager Fees?
Why Does PSERS Invest in Hedge Funds, Private Equity and Private Real Estate?
Has PSERS Achieved its Investment Objectives? How Have PSERS’ Investments Benefitted the Commonwealth?
22
Hedge Funds, Private Equity, and Private Real Estate are expensive asset classes:
In isolation, fees paid to managers in these asset classes are higher than fees paid in other asset classes.
Reasons why fees are higher can include: Larger management teams. Greater infrastructure needs. Limited capacity (not scalable like an index).
– Supply vs. demand leads to higher costs. Unique strategies are difficult to replicate. Intellectual capabilities. Proprietary insights.
Why Does PSERS Invest in Hedge Funds, Private Equity, and Private Real Estate?
23
To generate returns that are uncorrelated to equity, fixed income, and commodity
markets: Improves diversification, reduces investment risks. Proprietary strategies take advantage of market inefficiencies. Access to top-quartile investment managers to implement these strategies.
Why Does PSERS Invest in Hedge Funds?
24
Attractive excess returns can be achieved over public equity:
Market inefficiencies in private markets. Illiquidity premium expected for committing capital for periods in excess of 5
years. Access to top-quartile managers and excellent consulting relationships to
exploit these inefficiencies. Greater diversification using both public and private equities reduces
investment risks.
Why Does PSERS Invest in Private Equity?
25
PSERS Private Equity investments have outperformed publicly traded stocks, net of
all investment management fees
Why Does PSERS Invest in Private Equity?
$7.79
$2.08
$0
$2
$4
$6
$8
$10
$12
1998
Dec
1999
Jun
1999
Dec
2000
Jun
2000
Dec
2001
Jun
2001
Dec
2002
Jun
2002
Dec
2003
Jun
2003
Dec
2004
Jun
2004
Dec
2005
Jun
2005
Dec
2006
Jun
2006
Dec
2007
Jun
2007
Dec
2008
Jun
2008
Dec
2009
Jun
2009
Dec
2010
Jun
2010
Dec
2011
Jun
2011
Dec
2012
Jun
2012
Dec
2013
Jun
2013
Dec
2014
Jun
2014
Dec
2015
Jun
PSERS Private Equity through September 2015 Actual NAV versus if Invested in VITSX
($ amounts in billions)
PSERS Private Equity Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund (VITSX)
Table of Contents
26
What are PSERS’ Investment Objectives?
PSERS Investments are a Profit Center
How Does PSERS Achieve its Return Objectives? PSERS’ Success Blending Passive and Active Strategies
How Does PSERS Evaluate its Investment Manager Fees?
Why Does PSERS Invest in Hedge Funds, Private Equity and Private Real Estate?
Has PSERS Achieved its Investment Objectives?
How Have PSERS’ Investments Benefitted the Commonwealth?
27
Has PSERS Achieved its Investment Objectives?
PSERS has better returns than its targeted policy benchmark, even when all fees and expenses are taken into account:
1 3 5 10PSERS -1.80% 5.08% 6.15% 5.01%
-2.49% 3.24% 4.14% 3.72%0.69% 1.84% 2.01% 1.29%
Annualized Net of Fee Performance for Years Ending December 31, 2015
Policy BenchmarkValue-added %
Table of Contents
28
What are PSERS’ Investment Objectives?
PSERS Investments are a Profit Center
How Does PSERS Achieve its Return Objectives? PSERS’ Success Blending Passive and Active Strategies
How Does PSERS Evaluate its Investment Manager Fees?
Why Does PSERS Invest in Hedge Funds, Private Equity and Private Real Estate?
Has PSERS Achieved its Investment Objectives?
How Have PSERS’ Investments Benefitted the Commonwealth?
29
Pennsylvania-based investment managers or partnerships were managing 34.7% of
PSERS’ assets, or $16.2 billion, as of December 31, 2015. This includes portfolios managed by staff and 39 Pennsylvania-based investment
managers or partnerships.
How Have PSERS’ Investments Benefitted the Commonwealth?
30
How Have PSERS’ Investments Benefitted the Commonwealth?
Asset Class
Total PA Market Value (PSERS'
Portion)
Total PA Market Value (Total
Invested)# of People Employed Payroll
U.S. Equities $ 175.7 $ 175.7 * *Fixed Income $ 61.5 $ 61.5 * *Private Real Estate $ 79.8 $ 2,327.4 290 $ 6.8 Private Markets:
Venture Capital $ 121.4 $ 408.9 3,419 $ 77.9 Private Equity $ 1,073.1 $ 13,512.5 22,492 $ 535.7 Private Debt $ 201.7 $ 1,689.7 8,426 $ 207.6
Total $ 1,713.2 $ 18,176.0 34,627 $ 828.0
Summary of Investments in Pennsylvania as of December 31, 2015($'s in millions)
*Statistics for publicly traded companies not included due to the difficulty in obtaining the information.
31
More Investment Earnings = Lower Employer Contributions from both School
Districts and the Commonwealth. Investments in PA Businesses = PA Employment + PA Corporate and Real Estate
Tax Revenue.
How Have PSERS’ Investments Benefitted the Commonwealth?
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC SCHOOL EMPLOYEES’ RETIREMENT SYSTEM
Frequently Asked Questions About PSERS’ Investments
Updated: August 2016