fragility of the world’s dream...are, in part, somatic and psychological manifestations of the...
TRANSCRIPT
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
1
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
The story keepers of the Eranos Foundation tell us that the name “Eranos”
was inspired by Rudolf Otto and, shortly thereafter, Eranos was incarnated through
the work of Olga Forebe-Kapteyn (www.eranosfoundation.org). If we think of Otto's
main contribution to depth psychology as naming the numinous, then we can
imagine Eranos as a feast where each guest brings a numinous dish as contribution.
Such contributions are not a recapitulation of others’ ideas or a rehash of what any
of us has been said before, but rather a way of giving voice to what is presently
numinous as it makes itself known through dream, waking vision, synchronicity,
and more. My intent is to offer a numinous dish to this great feast, one that is
moving through my experience and is in relation to the theme of our undertaking,
the fragility in the contemporary world. What I bring is a depth psychological-
archetypal reflection on how the terrible consequences of ecological devastation
manifest in the dreams and behavior of our children.
From my point of view, the fragility in the contemporary world is rooted
most fundamentally in our continuing denial of the pathos active in the anima mundi,
the soul of the world, as expressed through the images of the world’s dream. When
the world’s dream, the imaginal world behind the world or what Henri Corbin called
the mundus imaginalis (1988, p. xi) goes unattended, we live in peril. In a time when
extinction of life as we know it is a real possibility and the screams of the dying echo
across the land, the compensatory defenses of narcissism, deflation, and over-
consumption keep us disconnected from the world’s dream and the threat of
ecological devastation.
We are now being asked to find new ways of responding to environmental
peril. We must look beyond a person-centered perspective, and listen to the figures
that are alive and active in the world’s dream. The world’s dream consists of images
that do not come exclusively from within us, but also originate in the world itself,
out there. In other words, it is not just people who are dreaming. The creatures,
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
2
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
landscapes and things of the world are also dreaming and their interiority, their
plight in the world, comprise the content of the world’s dream.
Our first step in listening to the world’s dream is to differentiate between the
suffering out there and the suffering in here, inside of our subjective experience. We
as humans can no longer imagine the pain we experience each day and night as ours
alone. The angst we feel involves something other than our personal life
circumstances. Our bad moods are more than a response of a relationship gone
wrong. Our anxiety is more than the result of childhood disorder. Personal suffering
is, in part, the result of the anguish located in the creatures and things of the
world—out there, in their subjectivity. We experience their torment in our bodily
afflictions, high-risk behaviors, disturbances of mind, and our soul’s despair. Their
distress becomes our misery as well as our illness. Experiencing our afflictions and
dream images as originating in the world is an indigenous perspective that offers
great value in a time of fragility. Native peoples know that everything is dreaming.
When a river becomes polluted and fish disappear, the people of the land feel both
an empty stomach and a loss of life force. Their dreaming becomes disturbed.
Through the world’s dream we gain access to the intelligence alive in nature’s
psyche.
In the modern world, who would notice these interconnections? Fish never
seem to disappear. They are caught thousands of miles away, flash frozen and
preserved for years to make them available for consumption at any time in any
place. Stomachs stay full and we feel no loss. Thus, there is no personal pain and
little relationship to the circle of life. People are not overtly distressed by what
remains unseen. It is only the last-remaining schools of fish, hunted down and
processed in high tech, ocean-based factories that experience the pain of their
extinction. Their grief is part of the world’s dream. It is the plight of the fish—or the
struggle of a forest drenched in acid rain, or the deadly bleaching of coral reefs as
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
3
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
ocean temperatures perilously rise, or the demolition of the heart of a small town to
make way for redevelopment—it is all this that appears as agitated images in
dreams. These are the figures that sound the alarm. It is their sorrow and torment
that, in many ways, condition what we feel and how we behave.
Taken one step further, when a species or an eco-system dies, the questions
become, how will it be remembered? How will the knowledge of what is no longer
be passed on? The answers are found in the interrelated realms of the world’s
dream, where their presence, intelligence, and voices are eternal, and forever
pleading with us to hear the urgency of the call, which brings us back to the theme:
tending to the fragility of today’s world. A generative response is possible if only we
have the ears to listen, the eyes to see, and the courage to respond.
I feel compelled to advocate on behalf of the world’s dream for two primary
reasons. First, for the planet to survive in a way that supports life, as we know it, we
as a species need help from another source. Second, as our planetary environment
becomes increasingly toxic, I am concerned about the psychological and physical
health of the human race, particularly of our youth. Advocating on behalf of the
world’s dream pushed itself on me. And, as is often the case, when that kind of push
happens, it begins with a broken heart—and so it was with me. So, I start with a
story of heartbreak.
This last year I was asked to be with a group of emotionally troubled
students, ages 16 to 18, from a number of American high schools. All were taking
advanced placement courses in environmental studies and history. These are bright
kids: top tier, university bound, studying with the best teachers the school system
has to offer. In their Environmental Science courses, they discovered a frightening
consensus among members of the scientific community: the environmental damage
to the planet due to global warming is irreversible and, unless something
unprecedented happens, the end of life on the planet is only 20 to 40 years away.
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
4
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
Is it any wonder that these kids felt alienated, cut off, and hopeless? They
sank into a despondent state. They began asking, What difference does any of this
make? A few had actually dropped out of school, creating considerable personal and
parental distress. A number of others were suffering significant psychological
symptoms and more severe psychiatric disorders. Many engaged in high-risk
behavior. Or they became very isolated, spending entire days jacked up on Red Bull
mixed with vodka, relating only to the artificial world of violent and disembodied
video games such as World of WarCraft™. Of course, many of these high school
students were experiencing the kind of existential crisis appropriate at this age,
though perhaps more acutely than others. Some were still in the potent heroic mode
that accompanies adolescence: Hey, leave it to us, we can change the world! This
particular group of students was swinging back and forth sharply between
despondency and potency, and their behavior had reached an acute level, including
suddenly dropping out of school, not coming home for days at a time, drug addiction,
and deep depression. The severity of their behavior is why I was asked to help.
When I was with these kids, my spirits dropped and my heart hurt, because
of the extent of their pain and also because the simple truth is that this generation,
these kids, will inherit the horrible environmental mess. This heartbreak led me to
ask: How can dreamwork, particularly the consideration of the world’s dream, be
helpful to these kids? What if we try to put ourselves in their shoes and absorb the
information they were learning in their environmental science classes? It is not
difficult to do; we all know something of the crises these kids are facing because it is
in the headlines virtually every day, and is the subject of the powerful film The 11th
Hour, produced by Leonardo DiCaprio in 2007. Here is a brief sample of some of the
facts related in the documentary:
Stephen Hawking, the Lucasian Professor of Mathematics at Cambridge
University, warns that Earth will very soon become like her sister planet Venus.
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
5
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
Temperatures will become so high on Earth that the raining of sulfuric acid will
create conditions that the human race and all living beings will not survive. Recent
research shows that the earth has warmed up so much, that even if we were to cap
carbon dioxide emissions at the level that they are at now, 20% of the ice in the
Arctic will melt, and most likely in few decades the arctic will be Ice Free, creating
catastrophic consequences. According to Bill Mickibben, founder of Stepitup07.org,
the UN estimates that there will be 150 million refugees because of climate change
by the middle of this century. Wallace J. Nichols, Senior Scientist, The Ocean
conservancy; and Sylvia Earle, Oceanographer, Explorer-in-Residence, National
Geographic Society agree that our oceans are in crisis. Humans are extracting too
much—removing billions of creatures every year—and, in return, putting too many
pollutions back in. They estimate that 90% of the bigger fish are no longer present.
Many species of the ocean, as well as the land, are disappearing daily, never to be
found alive on earth again. Omar Freilla, Director of the Green Worker Cooperatives,
says that in virtually every elementary school, when kids are asked how many have
asthma, at least 30% of the hands go up, and in many classrooms the number is as
high as 50% or even 60%. Kids look around and see every other friend on an inhaler.
As the world becomes more toxic, the loss of breath, the most frightening of physical
afflictions, is here now, a waking dream.
From the point of view of the world’s dream we are living in a nightmare.
These environmental facts create images of catastrophe, territorial threat, and
impending apocalypse that produce grief and helplessness. Our kids are particularly
vulnerable to these horrific images, which visit their dreams and impact the way
they are imagining their future. Their anxiety, depression, and disease syndromes
are, in part, somatic and psychological manifestations of the fragile world’s agitated
dream making its presence known to the most vulnerable among us, our young.
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
6
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
While their rational minds scramble to maintain denial, they know the natural
balance needed for a sustainable future has broken down.
Let me share one teenager’s dream that I listened to just months ago. This
came from a 17-year-old boy, a high achieving student, from Santa Barbara,
California.
In the dream I see the Earth. It is the size of a giant head. I notice that it is MY head—I am the Earth. My hands are outstretched, and I see that I hold all of the world’s populations in the palms of my hands. A huge energy moves through me. I realize that I need to stay very still; if I even move a finger, just a little bit, hundreds or thousands of people will fall off and die. I use all the strength that I have not to move a muscle, not even a little bit. I stay as still as I possibly can. I must sacrifice my personal life and stay paralyzed so nobody else will fall off and get hurt. Wow. I think, this is much bigger then I am. I realize I don’t have a choice but to remain paralyzed. I must keep my balance to save the people. The only thing to do, the best thing to do, is to dedicate the rest of my life to staying completely still. I have no other choice. End of dream.
His outstretched hands, holding all the world’s people, is an embodied image
of life in the balance. It is the world’s dream telling its plight in the images of this
boy’s dream and asking for help. So what do we do? How do we support this young
man? How do we help him move out of paralysis and increasingly self-destructive
behaviors to a quality of generativity? He hauntingly illustrates the point made by
pediatrician and human rights activist Dr. Helen Caldicott in a 2005 speech. It is as if
the death of our planet is being grieved in the dreams of our children.
Of course, some of what is pictured in the young man’s dream may be an
expression of his personal condition. He may be suffering from personal anxiety, or
isolation, or an inflated feeling of power or powerlessness. He may be experiencing
the pressure of holding too much at the moment. These considerations and more
would need to be explored. If we surmise that the world’s fragility is expressing
itself through dream images hosted by this young man and his peers, it creates both
disabling afflictions and as yet unrealized opportunities. For this teenage boy, to
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
7
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
learn that what he is holding in his hands is the pain of the world, and not entirely
his personal struggle, is liberating and healthy. He understands that it is not his
pathology alone. In addition, the dream offers the knowledge needed for his
development. Imagine, for a moment, the earth image “the size of a giant head” as a
seed. When nurtured, it comes to life and releases the potency of new growth. The
dream offers access to a planetary life force that can support inspiration rather than
desperation.
This young man most likely was born with this capacity to connect to the
world soul, a gift, as the old stories say, from the ancient earth guardians given upon
his birth. Sourced in the psyche of nature, this seed image can be imagined, and once
upon a time was imagined, as this young man’s true character; his fate, a calling, his
daimon—his authentic power. This kind of connection, this power, is important to
today’s world. Authentic power is an innate potency rooted most essentially in the
world’s dream. It is a subtle power informed by intuition, curiosity, and imagination;
a seed power that originates in a planetary consciousness. Authentic power, when
cultivated, releases this boy from the isolation and paralysis of the civilized world—
a world readying itself for its inevitable destruction—and connects him to a broader
web of life. For this teenage boy, at a time of fragility in the world, authentic power
offers something more precious than rubies and gold. It offers a way of being placed,
a sense of deep belonging, and a ground to stand on.
I will speak of more ways of tending to the world’s dream soon but first, a
word of caution. Make no mistake: listening to the voices of the planet as expressed
in dream images is not, and will not, be easy. Hearing the world speak on behalf of
itself is difficult. From the start these voices are muted by three dominating forces:
the media, business, and grief. The first force is modern media, blanketing human
experience with an ever-accelerating totality of information and visual stimulation.
The adrenaline rush of the next sensational story propagates and perpetuates an
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
8
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
addiction to screen time—and thus a limited attention span. The rhythms of the
natural world, the voices of the world’s dream, give way to the over 700 channels of
hyperkinetic overload. The second force stifling the world’s dream is the religion of
our times—business, as defined by the ideas of western capitalism. Business has
become the fundamental force of human society, dominating our thinking and
behavior, and defeating everything in its path. For good and for bad, the business of
doing business has become omnipresent. The mergers, the start-ups, the family
business, the takeovers, the ponzi schemes, bank scandals, debt ceiling, and
mortgage bundling are the obsessions of our time. Business is the waking dream of
contemporary civilization, pushing aside the organicity of the world’s dream and
her capital. The third and perhaps most powerful force limiting our access to the
intelligence of the world’s dream is grief. To listen to the voice of the world is to
hear the suffering of the dying. In modern culture we have little tolerance or
patience for death. Few authentic rituals of death are left to us. We have, for the
most part, forgotten how to grieve. We push death away at all costs. Tending to the
figures of the world’s dream means listening to the suffering of the terminally ill. It
is a task many of us avoid.
Because of the dominance of the media, the obsession of business, and the
intolerance of grief, the divinities of nature who are located in the world’s dream—
the oceans, the deserts, the magna at the earth’s core, and the powers of storm and
rain—are now marginalized as mere symptoms of climate change. Yes, they blast
forth in the headlines for a moment, briefly capturing psychic awareness in times of
natural disaster. But they are quickly forgotten, repressed in the solar light of
daytime media and its preoccupation with sex scandals and the fixation on the ticker
tape of numbers of a manic-depressive stock market. For instance, even in times of
environmental calamity such as Hurricane Irene that landed on the northeast coast
of America in August 2011, we deny or forget. When New York City officials took the
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
9
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
unprecedented step of ordering nearly half a million people to evacuate, when
airlines cancelled thousands of flights, when severe flooding caused billions of
dollars of property damage, and when dozens of people lost their lives; even then,
the voice of the planet went unheard. Watching CNN on the morning of August 28th, I
was astounded to hear one Philadelphia resident admit “I slept through the whole
thing.” “It’s nothing. It’s exaggerated,” asserted a citizen from Boston. An anchor on
CNN said, “a bunch of people in New York have already said to me this morning, you
know, ‘What was the big deal all about?’” And then from North Carolina, perhaps
one of the areas hardest hit, comes this from an old timer, “this was the non-event of
the century. Let’s just move on.” Yet, despite our denial, our bravado, our avoidance,
the old pagan nature Gods do erupt. They have not been altogether subdued by the
dominating forces of the media and the economy. Their voices scream through the
dreams of humans, particularly, as we have seen, though the dreams of our children,
people most permeable to their plea.
To continue our work of tending to the world’s dream, we must first take a
moment to once again recognize the multidimensional nature of dreams. Dreams
originate from a variety of sources and each implicates the other. The events of the
day influence the personal, which in turn connects to the cultural, all of which is
impacted by the world. Like a circle, dreams go around and around; sometimes in
one direction, other times just the opposite. Experiencing dream images, in some
ways, is like looking through a kaleidoscope. Depending upon how one looks
through the lens, it is possible to see the many different levels of figures and motifs
interacting in a dream. From this perspective, the modes of perception, ways of
seeing are as important as what one sees. Let’s take another example, an image that
is familiar to all of us.
An image of an Ocean appears in a dream. At first, we could link it to the
circumstances of the last 24 hours visiting the ocean; wanting to be at the ocean;
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
10
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
remembering something special or hurtful that happened while at the ocean; and so
on. On another level, the dream image of Ocean may suggest something of our
personal history, our memories. For example, a deep sadness that started with
events in childhood such as an ocean of tears or an early experience of feeling
drowned. This is the perspective of developmental psychology, sometimes referred
to as realm of the personal unconscious. Looking further, on another level, the image
of Ocean may take on an archetypal significance, and be linked to a mythological
theme or a motif from literature or the arts. Here, Ocean is the place of the night sea
journey, or Ocean is womb where all life began, or this is Ocean of the great floods
and epic transformation. This is the perspective of Jungian-oriented psychologies,
and sometimes referred to as the realm of the collective unconscious.
Speaking of the Jungian perspective—Carl Jung talked about the genius of
dreams by invoking the image of a 2-million-year-old wisdom figure alive in each of
us (1977, p. 89), a figure with access to all of these dimensions who can speak with
great intelligence. This central archetypal figure speaks in the language of images.
To develop relationship with this core figure of the Self is enormously helpful,
particularly when times are hard and we are feeling a sense of loss.
To return to my point: on all of these levels there is much psychic intelligence,
well beyond our rational minds, at work. This intelligence informs our lives and
behavior. But please notice: as amazing and useful as this way of listening to dreams
is, it is still a human-centered orientation. It relates Ocean to the circumstances of
the day, our personal development, and cultural themes. All of this is helpful, no
doubt, yet all is imagined as originating from the experiences and knowledge base of
one species, human beings.
Let’s broaden it, taking another step. Beyond the wisdom of Jung’s 2-million-
year-old human body lives a 2-billion-year-old earth body, with an intelligence that
is much deeper and, in some ways, much more evolved than what originates out of
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
11
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
personal or collective human experience. Of course, in his later work Jung hints of
this when he talks of the psychoid archetype and the phenomenon of synchronicity
in a presentation he offered here at Eranos, both of which implicate the world. The
point is that below the personal and collective human experience is the dreaming of
the world, the world’s dream. We must attend to the world’s dream. The scope of
the ecological crisis demands it.
I want to continue with the Ocean as dream image, and elaborate with a true
account of what happens along the Santa Barbara coastline each year. A few months
each year several factors combine to pollute the ocean around Santa Barbara.
Glaring signs that warn people to stop and stay out of the water are posted up and
down the beach, telling us that the sea is toxic. The ocean, always dreaming, voices
its ills through its images, and these appear as images in our dreams. During those
months, many Santa Barbarans feel depressed. Even when we haven't visited the
ocean for weeks, we feel its toxicity in our own bodies. Most of us don't recognize
that our feelings of dread have nothing to do with our personal condition, but rather
with the state of an ocean in distress, making its sickness known as a disturbance in
our physical and emotional lives. When we experience the world’s dream expressing
itself through our afflictions, again, we do not deny these experiences, nor attribute
them to a bad mood or to a biological virus. Instead, we have the opportunity to
respond from the strength and resources found in our dreaming body/mind. A
dream loves to be met in the way of a dream. So what do we do? How do we keep
hope alive? How do we move out of paralysis or worse, the perpetuation and
escalation of our destructive ways? How do we develop the skills to attend to the
images of the world’s dream? This morning I will offer three ideas.
First we can cultivate another way of listening and seeing, a way of tending
not only to the despair In the world’s dream, but, also, to the beauty and the promise
alive in an animated world. Dream Tending is the methodology I offer, a
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
12
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
phenomenological practice of working as a naturalist might—befriending, in the
immediacy of experience, the images of the world’ dream—whether they are
peoples, animals, things, landscapes, or any other beings of the world. Tending to
the world’s dream requires patience, presence, and gut level curiosity. The dream
tender follows his nose, not only his mind, relying on his instinctive compass as a
navigational tool. Listening to the figures of the world’s dream is never move vivid
than when we are connected to them instinctually.
To get started, this would mean we must slow down, be patient, and get out
of the mania of everyday life. We need to take time each day to go on a walkabout as
the Australian aborigines do when following the way of the dreamtime. To learn,
then practice, how to go on a walkabout in the world, is to acquire the skills of
walking about in the landscapes of the dream. On walkabout, we walk without intent
or an agenda. We get into our instinctive curiosity and out of that list of obligations,
chores, or tasks that we are always thinking about. On walkabout, one is in the
world as if it were a dream, experiencing that animating spark that is alive in all
creatures and things. When we do this we become open to the enchantment of
places and creatures and things of the nature-made as well as of the human-made.
Our way of seeing changes, our modes of perception alter. On walkabout, we follow
a different path. We activate our senses. Following our curiosity, we allow time to
touch, smell, and even sometimes taste the beauty alive in the world. We make time
each day to listen to birds singing or the wind rustling the leaves in the trees.
Sounds simple, yes? No, not really. To take the time to go on a walkabout with a
quiet mind is a challenge. But, when doing so, the world responds and shows itself
to us.
As archetypal psychologist James Hillman says, “the things of an ensouled
landscape announce themselves, ‘Look, here we are” (1982, p. 77). They regard us
beyond how we may regard them, our perspective, what we intend with them, and
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
13
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
how we dispose of them. This imaginative claim on attention bespeaks a world
ensouled. To be present to the things and the creatures in the world and in the
dream is to hear their stories, experience their beauty, and to allow their dreams to
inform our lives and our actions. So, I suggest taking 20 minutes each day to go on a
walkabout.
A second way of attending to the images of the world’s dream is to make
contact with what I have come to call the indigenous image. Listening to hundreds of
dreams of people who grew up in the Information Age, I noticed that many of their
dream images were originating not from their deep personal nature, but from the
advertising industry. When I tracked these commercial images back to their sources,
I found that they did not root back into the authentic experience of the dreamer.
They tracked back to the dreamer’s susceptibility to a sales pitch. These images are
not organic, and they do not arise from the world’s dream. They do not individuate
on their own, and so do not help us grow. They are like a genetically-engineered
plant with a terminator gene. They exist to sell a product and then simply disappear.
I call these kinds of images counterfeit images. Billions of dollars are spent on
advertising each year to sell products. Hours of TV viewing a day are common for a
person now coming into college. Our connection to a sense of our deep belonging is
no longer located in nature’s fabric. It is located in the dream of commerce, urban
life, and the multitude of information screens that surround us. The dreamscape is
fast becoming the screenscape. I was surprised to discover that the average person
can identify hundreds of corporate logos, but less than a dozen flowers or
indigenous animals in their neighborhood?
So, what do we do? Look at a dream. Begin by identifying an image that is
rooted in nature, a dream image that has qualities that are recognizable as nature-
based. Spend time with this image. Look at its particularity. How is the image
unique? For example, suppose Fox visits. How is this image of Fox different from any
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
14
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
other of Fox? What is this animal’s distinguishing features? Feel the presence of Fox.
Then feel how you are affected in turn by its presence. Another method is to simply
start with the dream setting, a place in the natural world, a cityscape, or for that
matter, someplace in outer space. The dream setting, the landscape of a dream, is
one of the most forgotten dream elements because our tendency is to orient around
the dream ego, the “I” in the dream, its feelings and actions. Yet all dreams come
with a setting, even if it is a sense of nowhere, which often offers rich access to the
world’s dream. Getting to know the landscape of a dream brings an awareness of
place, of being placed, along with a sense of belonging to something larger than our
human-centered experience. Here we can feel the pulse of the world’s dream.
The third way of tending to the world’s dream is to take dream tending to the
streets. Become what I call an “archetypal activist.” Listen to voices of the Earth’s
creatures and landscapes, some of whom are gone now, only alive as ancestral
figures in the dreamtime. When hearing their voices, like the plea of Ocean, the call
of Forest, or the voice of Fox, take it seriously, and act on their behalf. Acting this
way is out of the ordinary, and some may regard it with suspicion. I respond by
saying this: taking action on behalf of the creatures and landscapes of the world is
what it means to be a planetary citizen with an expanded consciousness.
Here is a word of caution. Don’t rush in to find an immediate solution to a
crisis situation. Though we mean well, when we act this way we tend to act
reactively and impulsively. So, the key is to change the question. Instead of asking
What can we do to fix the planet? inquire, What are the creatures and places of the
planet asking of us? Listen to their intelligence, their two-billion-year-old
knowledge. They visit every night in our dreams, making their presence known.
To conclude: Dreams come. They offer themselves to our species. Humans
are visited night after night by visitors with voices from outside the confines of our
rational, linear, analytical minds. These beings from the world’s dream beg that we
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
15
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
step away from a manic style of living and relinquish our addiction to speed. In the
fragility of today’s world our children, need more than what the civilized world can
offer; more than making the grade, technical training for career placement, and
evidence-based learning outcomes. They yearn to be touched more deeply, to feel a
sense of soul that comes to life beyond the personal and even beyond the collective
human condition. They long for an indigenous way of knowing and a sense of
elemental belonging to a home that they will inherit and inhabit. Instinctively young
people seek out social networking and technology not to necessarily further a split
from the natural world but, in fact, to forge a closer relationship to the living
embodied images of the world’s dream, a dreamscape sourced in the psyche of
nature. They want to hear the callings of the others and to become stewards of the
wellbeing of creatures and landscapes that share the planet. Our children can
cultivate an attitude of cooperation not domination, where even sustainability is no
longer adequate but instead gives way to profound regeneration.
We feel the desperation of our youth. We see their symptoms. We know the
plight of the planet. We experience the vengeance of her imbalance and the
consequences of her fragility. Now is the time to change our mode of perception, to
see in a different way, to listen with a poetic ear, to hear the voices of the others as
they make their intelligence known. Now is the time to listen to the world’s dream, a
way of being expressed by Kabir, the 15th-century Sufi-Hindu master (2004, p. 18):
Between the conscious and the unconscious, the mind has put up a swing: all earth creatures, even the supernovas, sway between these two trees, and it never winds down.
Angels, animals, humans, insects by the million, also the wheeling sun and moon; ages go by, and it goes on.
Everything is swinging: heaven, earth, water, fire, and the secret one slowly growing a body.
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
16
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
Developing this way of seeing need not take a long time. Kabir saw this poetic
vision for fifteen seconds, and it made him a servant for life.
In this essay, we started with and heard a dream of distress from a teenager
living in Santa Barbara. We know this dream. These images, in one way or another,
appear in each of our dreamtimes. Now it is up to us to do something. It is up to us
to tend to the world soul, to keep the beauty alive, and imagination open. The world
is asking this of us. Our community is asking this of us; and, so are our youth. If I
have learned but one thing over these last months, it is that the generativity we seek
starts with a new attitude, an attitude that is occasioned by the presence of the
living images of the world’s dream. These images visit each night, and each day in
dreams.
Yes, the intolerable is with us; the horrific lurks behind each headline. But
maybe this pathos, this suffering of the world soul, will connect us to our deeper
resources, the beauty and intelligence alive in the psyche of nature. We are moved to
be present to the intelligence of the dreaming psyche in all of her images. We are
being challenged into a way of being that requires another way of responding. We
can meet this challenge. In community we can do this. In communities like Eranos
we can offer to each other our best. We can support one another to make the time—
to be out of time, for a while. In community, we can, we must, help each other
remember the anima mundi, the soul of the world.
We can, as the poet Rumi says, let the beauty we love be what we do [2006, p.
36). We can do this now. Our world and our children need us now.
-
Fragility of the World’s Dream Eranos, September 2011
Stephen Aizenstat, Ph.D.
17
© Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.
References
Corbin, H. (1988). Alone with the alone. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
DiCaprio, L. (Producer), & Conners, N. & Petersen, L. (Directors). (2007). The 11th hour movie. USA: Warner Brothers.
Hillman, J. (1982). Anima Mundi: The return of the soul to the world. Spring, 71-93.
McGuire, W. & R.F.C. Hull (Eds.) (1977). CG Jung Speaking: interviews and encounters. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Rumi, J. (2006). The essential Rumi, new expanded edition, C. Barks and J. Moyne (Trans.). New York: Harper Collins