FragileParadise:HealthImpactsof

ClimateChangeinPacificIslandCountries

by

DrLachlanMcIverMBBSMPH&TMJCC(Anaes)FACRRMFACTM

Athesissubmittedforthedegreeof

DoctorofPhilosophy

ofTheAustralianNationalUniversity

July2016

ii

iii

Declaration

Thecontentsofthisthesisaretheresultoforiginalresearchandhavenotbeensubmittedto

anyotheruniversityorinstitution.

ThemajorityoftheworkdescribedhereinwasundertakenwhileIwasonassignmentwith

theWorldHealthOrganization(WHO)SouthPacificoffice,basedinSuva,Fijifrom2011to

2013.IacceptedthisassignmentontheunderstandingthatIwouldcarryoutadoctoral

programmeofresearchworkcoupledtotheoperationalresponsibilitiesrequiredofmeby

WHO.MyresearchworkwasthussupportedbyWHOandtheANUoverthefouryearsthat

followedthecommencementofmyassignmentin2011.

MyrolewasinitiallyastheWHOClimateChangeandHealthTechnicalOfficerand

subsequentlytheproject’sleadtechnicaladvisor.Assuch,Iwastheprincipalinvestigator

fortheregionalresearchprojectinvestigatingthehealthimpactsofclimatechangeinPacific

islandcountriesandcompilingevidence-basedadaptationstrategiestominimisetheserisks

tohealth.Thisinvolvedcoordinationofalloftheresearchandoperationalaspectsofthe

workattheregionallevel.AtthecountrylevelIledalltheresearchactivities,including

design,datacollection,analysisandimplementation,workingalongsidethenational“focal

point”ineachinstanceforallaspectsoftheprojectresearchwork,carriedoutin

collaborationwiththeWHOconsultantsengagedforeachgroupofcountries.

IhadthesupportofTheAustralianNationalUniversity,WHOandtheMinistryofHealth(or

equivalent)ineachPacificislandcountrytoleadthisresearchprojectandincorporatethe

resultantpublicationsintothisthesis.Thissupportisreflectedinthelettersofpermission

providedbythecountriesandthelettersofsupportprovidedbyalloftheco-authorsofthe

papersincludedinthethesis(seebelow).

Inadditiontothepublishedpaperscontainedwithinthisthesis,Iwasalsotheleadauthor

foreachcountry’sNationalClimateChangeandHealthActionPlan(orequivalent)-withthe

exceptionofSamoa,whoseworkisnotincludedinthisthesis-andforthefinalproject

technicalreportpublishedbyWHOinlate2015.Thelatterdocument,entitledHuman

HealthandClimateChangeinPacificIslandCountries,summarisesthefindingsofthe

vulnerabilityassessmentandadaptationplanningprocessforeachcountryandprovidesa

iv

seriesofrecommendationsfromWHOtoassistcountriesinimplementingeffective

adaptationmeasures.TheWHOreportaddressesprimarilythepolicyandimplementation

aspectsofadaptation,whiletheresearchpapersinthisthesisprovidethevitaladditional

technicalperspectiveontheprocess,findingsandoutcomesoftheproject.

SeveralofthepapersincludedinthisthesisbuiltonthefindingsoftheWHO-supported

project,butresultedfromsubsequentresearchthatIledfollowingthecompletionofmy

assignmentwithWHO.

Allofthosewhomadesubstantivecontributionstotheprojectoutputsandpublished

papershavebeengratefullyandrespectfullymentioned,eitherinthefollowing

Acknowledgementssectionand/orinthepapersthemselves.Theorderofauthorshipfor

eachpublicationaccordswiththeguidelinesprovidedbytheInternationalCommitteeof

MedicalJournalEditors(ICMJE).

Ihadtheunanimoussupportofmycollaboratorsinco-authoring-andinmostcaseslead-

authoring-thepeer-reviewedpublicationsincludedinthisthesis,givenmyroleasprincipal

investigatorforalloftherelevantresearchactivitiesineachoftheprojectcountries(except

Samoa).Iconductedtheneedsandcapacityassessments,consultedwiththerelevant

stakeholders,designedthemethodology,collectedthedata,conductedorcollaboratedon

theanalyses,draftedthemanuscriptsandcoordinatedthedisseminationofthekeyfindings.

Iwasinvolvedwithallofthetechnicalandanalyticalaspectsoftheresearch.Inthefew

instanceswhereco-investigatorswithparticularexpertiseinspecificanalyticaltechniques

wererequiredtotaketheleadonvariousaspectsofthedataanalysis,thisprocesswas

consistentlycollaborativeanddependentuponmycontributions.

AsummaryofmycontributiontoeachpaperisincludedinTable1below.Thisstatement

hasbeenreviewedandendorsedbyalloftheco-authorsofpapersincludedinthisthesis.

Theirsignedconfirmationsareavailableuponrequest.

v

Table1.Contributionofdoctoralcandidate(DrLachlanMcIver)tothekeycomponentsof

eachpublicationincludedasdiscretechapterinthesis

Chapternumber

Titleofpaper Journal Status Authors(inorder)

Candidate’scontribution

4 HealthimpactsofclimatechangeinPacificislandcountries:aregionalassessmentofvulnerabilitiesandadaptationpriorities

EnvironmentalHealthPerspectives

Published McIverL,KimR,WoodwardA,HalesS,SpickettJ,KatscherianD,HashizumeM,HondaY,KimH,IddingsS,NaickerJ,BambrickH,McMichaelA&EbiK

-Leadinvestigatorforregionalproject-Collaboratedonvulnerabilityassessmentandadaptationplanningworkinallcountries-Leddraftingoffinalprojectoutputformostcountries-Ledauthorshipofpaper

5 AssessmentofClimate-sensitiveInfectiousDiseasesintheFederatedStatesofMicronesia

TropicalMedicineandHealth

Published McIverL,HashizumeM,KimH,HondaY,PretrickM,IddingsS&PavlinB

-Collecteddataandcollaboratedonanalysis-Guidedstakeholderconsultations,vulnerabilityassessmentandadaptationplanningprocesses-Ledauthorshipofprojectoutputandpublishedpaper

6 HealthImpactsofClimateChangeinVanuatu:AnAssessmentandAdaptationActionPlan

GlobalJournalofHealthSciences

Published SpickettJ,KatscherianD&McIverL

-Collaboratedonstakeholderconsultation,vulnerabilityassessmentandadaptationplanningprocesses-Co-authoredprojectoutputandpublishedpaper

7 AssessmentoftheHealthImpactsofClimateChangeinKiribati

InternationalJournalofEnvironmentalResearchandPublicHealth

Published McIverL,WoodwardA,DaviesS,TibweT&IddingsS

-Collaboratedonstakeholderconsultation,vulnerabilityassessmentandadaptationplanningprocesses-Collecteddataandconductedpreliminaryanalysis-Ledauthorshipofprojectoutputandpublishedpaper

8 ClimateChangeandHealthinFiji:EnvironmentalEpidemiologyofInfectiousDiseasesandPotentialforClimate-BasedEarlyWarningSystems

FijiJournalofPublicHealth

Published McIverL,NaickerJ,HalesS,SinghS&DawainavesiA

-Collecteddata-Sharedanalyticalworkload(quantitativeepidemiologicalandgeographicinformationsystemanalysis)-Ledauthorshipofprojecttechnicaloutputsandpublishedpaper

9 EarlyWarningSystemsforClimate-SensitiveInfectiousDiseasesinFiji:LessonsLearnedandNextSteps

FijiJournalofPublicHealth

Published McIverL,HalesS,DearK&KimR

-Shareddevelopmentanddesignofpaper-Collecteddataforanalysis-Interpretedresults-Ledauthorshipofpaper

10 ClimateChange,OvercrowdingandNon-Communicable

AnnalsoftheAustralasianCollegeof

Published McIverL,VineyK,HarleyD,HannaE&KieneneT

-Shareddevelopmentanddesignofpaper-Compileddata

vi

Diseases:the“TripleWhammy”ofTuberculosisTransmissionRiskinPacificAtollCountries

TropicalMedicine

-Developedmechanisticmodel-Ledauthorshipofpaper

11 A“HealthyIslands”FrameworkforClimateChangeinthePacific

HealthPromotionInternational

Published McIverL,BowenK,HannaE&IddingsS

-Leddevelopmentanddesignofpaper-Adaptedhealthpromotionmodel-Ledauthorshipofpaper

Signed:

LachlanMcIver

July2015

vii

Acknowledgements

IwritethesewordsinPortVila,Vanuatu,inearlyMay2015,surroundedbytheevidenceof

theimpactofTropicalCyclonePam.Thedevastationcausedbythistropicalstorm–the

mostsevereinthePacificregioninlivingmemory–includedthedestructionoftensof

thousandsofhomesandthedisplacementofoverhalfofVanuatu’spopulation.

AfterspendingmostofthelastfiveyearsinthePacific,Iconsiderthisbeautifulpartofthe

world–theBlueContinent,asit’sbecomeknown–tobemyhome.However,thebeautyof

theregion,includingitsspectacularislandgeographyandculture,isassociatedwith

significantfragility.

Vanuatuisoneofthemostdisaster-pronecountriesintheworldand,asasmallisland

developingstate,itisoneofthemostvulnerableintheworldtotheimpactsofclimate

change.Thisthesiscontainssomeofthemostdetailedandup-to-dateinformationavailable

regardingtheclimatechangeandhealthvulnerabilitiesofPacificislandcountries,including

Vanuatu,andsuggestssomesuitablehealthsystemsadaptationandresilience-building

strategies.Whatthisthesiscannotadequatelydescribe,however,isthehumanimpactof

thechangesthathavebeenhavewroughtuponourplanetaryecosystem.

AtleastelevenpeopleareknowntohavediedfromdirecttraumacausedbyCyclonePam.

Agreaternumberoffatalitieswasanticipated;itistestamenttothetimelyinterventionsof

governmentagenciesandnon-governmentorganisations,andthewisdom,ingenuityand

sheerresilienceofni-Vanuatucommunities,thatthedeathtollwasnotmuchhigher.Health

facilitiesalloverthecountrywereinundatedforweekswithcasesofrespiratoryand

diarrhoealdiseases.Woundinfectionsarenowbeingseenintheclinicsandemergency

departments,astheinjuriessustainedfromthedisasterandrecoveryeffortfester,andthe

countryhasjustseenitsfirstreportedcaseofZikavirus(amosquito-bornedisease

previouslyunknowninVanuatu)amidstanepidemicofdenguefever.

Allofthesemanifestationsofill-health–andmanyothershiddenfromview,suchasthe

psychologicaltraumasufferedbysomany–maybelinkedtothecyclone.Thiscyclone,in

turn,mustbeinterpretedfromalong-term,macroscopicperspective,whichseesthereturn

periodforextremeweathereventsdiminishing(suchthathydrometeorologicaldisasterslike

viii

thisarebecomingmorefrequent),astheforcesdrivinganthropogenicclimatechange

continue,unabated.

Myconcernabouttheseandotherhealthhazardsposedbyclimatechangeandclimate-

relateddisasterswasakeymotivationformetoembarkonthisjourney;whathasinspired

mesincearethepeopleIhaveencounteredalongtheway.

Therearemanyindividualswhodeservetobeacknowledgedashavingassistedand

supportedmeinmyriad,profoundwaysoverthelastfewyears.Theyinclude,ofcourse,the

brilliantgroupofacademicsupervisorswhoprovidedtheguidanceandgoodhumourthat

wasthebedrockonwhichIwasabletobuild:LizHanna,theindefatigableandeternally

optimisticChairofmypanel;SimonHales,whomIhavetreasuredasamentorsincemy

arrivalinthePacific;DaveHarley,whohasbeenanever-patientandpragmaticsourceof

advice;andKeithDear,withoutwhosetechnicalandanalyticalexpertisemyexperience,and

theseresults,wouldhavesuffered.Whatbeganasaprofessionalrelationshipwiththese

fourcollaboratorsisnowafirmfriendship,forwhichIammostappreciative.

Imustgivespecialthankstotwopeopleinparticular,whotookachanceonmeandgaveme

theopportunitytopursuemyprofessionalinterestsandpassionforresearch.SteveIddings,

theformerTeamLeaderforEnvironmentalHealthandEmergencyHumanitarianActionat

theWHOSouthPacificoffice,createdtheassignmentforwhichIapplied,acceptedmefor

thepositionandsupportedmyresearchagenda.Hetrustedmyjudgementandallowedme

theautonomytoroamaroundtheregion,carryingoutthisimportantwork.Stevealso

taughtmemorethanIcouldhaveevercaredtoknowabouttheactionsandinteractionsof

WHOanditspartnersinthePacific,aswellasaboutthetechnicalandmanagerialaspectsof

environmentalhealthpracticeanddisastermanagement.Thisknowledgehassinceserved

meextremelywell,notleastwhenIfound,tomyastonishment,thatIwasrequiredtoactin

Steve’scapacityforseveralmonthsfollowinghisdeparture.Iwillbeeternallygratefulto

Steveforopeningupthisworldtomeandshowingsuchfaithinmyabilities.

TheotherpersontowhomIoweadeepdebtofgratitude,fromtheearlieststepsofmy

journey,isTonyMcMichael.TonywasgraciousenoughtolistentomyideaswhenIfirst

approachedhimaboutmyWHOassignmentandthepossibilityofaPhD.Hewasthen

generousenoughtojoinmysupervisorpanelandprovidedinvaluableguidance(or,asLizso

ix

whimsicallyreferstoit“sprinkledhisfairydust”)asthejourneyprogressed.IbelieveIam

oneofthelaststudents–perhapsthefinal–thatTonytookunderhiswing,andIam

privilegedtohavebenefittedfromhiswisdomrightupuntilthedaysbeforehepassedaway

latelastyear.IamextremelyproudtohaveTonyasaposthumousco-authoronthemost

importantofthepapersinthisthesis(Chapter5),andthecorrespondingWHOreport

entitled“HumanHealthandClimateChangeinPacificIslandCountries”,bothofwhichare

tobepublishedthisyear.AtextbookchapterwhichattemptstosummariseTony’s

contributiontothisfieldofwork,anditsrelevanceinthePacific,hasbeenincludedasan

annextothisthesis.

Iamalsoverygratefultothefriendswhosupportedme–infact,“putupwithme”,would

bemoreaccurate–throughoutthisjourney,andwithwhomI’mverymuchlookingforward

togettingreacquainted.SpecialthanksmustgotoSimonRice,KathrynBowenandNaomi

Godden,whohavebeenconsistentsourcesofencouragement,adviceandfellowthesis-

sufferersympathysincethebeginning,andwithwhomIhopetocollaborateontheas-yet

inadequatelyaddressedissuesofclimatechangeanditseffectsonmentalhealth,women’s

health,socialjusticeandhealthsystemsindevelopingcountries.

Mymother,Mary-Jane,andmysister,Kirsty,havebeenunfailingsourcesoflovingsupport

overtheseoftendifficultyears.IthankthembothwithalltheloveIpossess.Myfather,Ian

McIver,whopassedawayseventeenyearsagowould,Iamcertain,beimmenselyproudof

thisachievement.

Finally,IdedicatethisworktothePacificIslandersInowcountamongmyfamilyand

friends.Ihopethisadditiontoourcollectiveknowledgeenablestheinformingofpolicy,

empowermentofcommunitiesandavoidanceofthemostseriousthreatsthatclimate

changeposestothehealthandwell-beingofourPacificpeople.

x

Abstract

Pacificislandcountriesareamongthemostvulnerableintheworldtotheimpactsofclimate

change,includingthemanyandvariedeffectsonhumanhealth.Thevastmajorityofthese

healthimpactsareexpectedtobenegativeandtheburdenofclimatechange-attributable

ill-healthwillbemaldistributed,withthegreatestsufferinglikelytobeexperiencedbythe

poor.

Theobjectivesoftheresearchdescribedinthisthesiswere:

a) Tocriticallyappraisevariousmethodsofassessingclimatechangeandhealth

vulnerabilitiesinPacificislandcountries;

b) Toestablishthekeyclimate-sensitivehealthrisksineachcountry;and

c) Todevelopanevidencebaseforhealthsystemsadaptationtoclimatechangeinthe

Pacificregion.

Thirteencountriesparticipatedinthisregionalclimatechangeandhealthvulnerability

assessmentandadaptationplanningprojectbetween2011and2013:CookIslands,

FederatedStatesofMicronesia,Fiji,Kiribati,MarshallIslands,Nauru,Niue,Palau,Samoa,

SolomonIslands,Tonga,TuvaluandVanuatu.Thisproject,supportedbytheWorldHealth

OrganizationSouthPacificoffice,employedarangeofquantitativeandqualitative

techniquesintheassessmentandstratificationofclimatechangeandhealthrisksforeach

countryandthedevelopmentofregionalandcountry-specificadaptationstrategies.

Thethesispresentstheresultsoftheseanalysesanddescribesindetailthepredominant

riskstohealthposedbyclimatechangeinthePacific.Theseinclude:injuriesandtrauma;

compromisedsafetyandsecurityofwaterandfood(leadingtomalnutritionand

gastrointestinalinfections);vector-bornediseases;heat-relatedillnesses;zoonoses;

respiratoryailments;psychologicalandemotionalill-health;increasingmorbidityand

mortalityfromnon-communicablediseases;populationpressures;andincreasedstrainand

pressureonhealthsystemsinthesesmallislanddevelopingstates.

Correspondingly,theadaptationthemescommonacrosstheregionrelatetoimprovingthe

safetyandsecurityoffoodsuppliesandwater,sanitationandhygienefacilities;enhancing

xi

infectiousdiseasesurveillanceandresponsecapabilities;buildingresiliencewithinhealth

systemsandofhealthinfrastructure;andincreasingtheaccuracyandefficiencyof

communicationandcollaborationbetweenthehealthsectorandotheragencies.

Theresultsoftheseassessmentshavebeencompiledintonationalclimatechangeand

healthadaptationplansforeachcountry,andsynthesisedinaWorldHealthOrganization

reportpublishedinlate2015.

Thethesissummarisesthemaincategoriesofadaptationstrategiesplannedaroundthe

regionandthehealthsystemsandpolicylandscapewithinwhichadaptationistakingplace.

Indoingso,thethesiscombinesoverviewsofthevulnerabilitiesandadaptationplansfroma

regionalperspective,alongwithexamplesofspecificcountries,includingFederatedStates

ofMicronesia,Fiji,KiribatiandVanuatu.

Theoverallaimofthisworkistoenhancetheabilityofindividuals,communitiesandhealth

systemsintheregiontowithstandthepressuresandhazardsposedbyclimatechange,by

providingabodyofscientificevidenceandabasisforsoundpoliciesaimedatprotectingthe

healthofPacificIslandpeople.Itisclearthatthiswillnecessarilyinvolvesubstantialsupport

fromwealthiercountries–themessagesareincreasinglyclear;theaudienceisglobal;and

thetimingisurgent.

xii

TableofContents

Chapter1. Introduction 1

Chapter2. Background 9

Chapter3. ResearchDesign 21

Chapter4. Paper1:HealthimpactsofClimateChangeinPacificIslandCountries: 29

ARegionalAssessmentofVulnerabilitiesandAdaptationPriorities

Chapter5. Paper2:AssessmentofClimate-sensitiveInfectiousDiseasesinthe 63

FederatedStatesofMicronesia

Chapter6. Paper3:HealthImpactsofClimateChangeinVanuatu:AnAssessment 77

andAdaptationActionPlan

Chapter7. Paper4:AssessmentoftheHealthImpactsofClimateChangeinKiribati 91

Chapter8. Paper5:ClimateChangeandHealthinFiji:EnvironmentalEpidemiology 111

ofInfectiousDiseasesandPotentialforClimate-BasedEarlyWarning

Systems

Chapter9.Paper6:EarlyWarningSystemsforClimate-SensitiveInfectiousDiseases 121

inFiji:LessonsLearnedandNextSteps

Chapter10.Paper7:ClimateChange,OvercrowdingandNon-Communicable 133

Diseases:the“TripleWhammy”ofTuberculosisTransmissionRiskin

PacificAtollCountries

Chapter11. Paper8:A“HealthyIslands”FrameworkforClimateChangeinthePacific 139

Chapter12.Discussion 150

Chapter13. Conclusions 167

Annex1. FragileParadise–HealthandClimateChangeintheSouthPacific 171

AtributetoTonyMcMichael’scontributiontoclimatechangeandhealth

1ChapterOne

ChapterOne

Introduction

2 ChapterOne

1.1IntroductiontothePacific

ThePacificregionishometoseveralmillionpeople,inhabitingtensofthousandsofislands

sharedbetweenmorethantwentycountriesandterritoriesthattogetherconstitutetheso-

calledBlueContinent(Map1.1).

Map1.1.Pacificislandcountriesandterritories(showingExclusiveEconomicZones,orEEZs).

Source:CartoGIS,CollegeofAsiaandthePacific,TheAustralianNationalUniversity

Infewotherplacesintheworldaretheeffectsofclimatechangeasvisibleortangibleasthe

Pacific.Theleadersoftheregionknowthis,andareamongthemostoutspokenonthe

globalstageonissuessuchasclimatechangemitigationanddisasterriskreduction-related

risksinoneofthemostdisaster-proneandclimatechange-susceptibleregionsofthe

world.1,2

InthePacific,climatechangeisnotanenvironmentalissue.Norisitonlyanissueaffecting

health.Rather,itrepresentsbothanexistentialthreatandanoverarchingimpedimentto

developmentandthebettermentofthelivesofPacificIslandpeople.3

3ChapterOne

AsVanuatu’sPresidentBaldwinLonsdalestated,incisivelyandemotionally,regardingthe

impactandimplicationsofCyclonePaminMarch2015:“It’sasetbackforthegovernment

andthepeopleofVanuatu…allthisdevelopmenthasbeenwipedout.Climatechangeis

contributingtothedisastersinVanuatu…thehazardsofglobalwarmingaffectourpeoplein

differentways,anditisacatastrophethatimpingesonourrights…andoursurvivalintothe

future”1.Theimperativetoaddressthis“catastrophe”byresearchingtheimpactsofclimate

changeonhumanpopulationhealthinthePacificisthekeypremiseofthisthesis.

1.2BackgroundtoclimatechangeandhealthinthePacific

AssessmentoftheclimatechangevulnerabilitiesofPacificislandcountries(PICs)

commencedintheearly1990s,withthecompilationandsubmissionofInitialNational

CommunicationstotheUnitedNationsFrameworkConventiononClimateChange(UNFCCC)

and,fortheleast-developedcountries(LDCs)intheregion,preparationofNational

AdaptationProgrammesofAction(NAPAs).Atthistime,theinternationalpublichealth

community,ledbytheWorldHealthOrganization(WHO)wasstillinthepreliminarystages

ofconductingresearchandprovidingguidancetocountries–largelybasedoninformed

speculation–onassessinghealthvulnerabilitiesandproposingadaptationstrategiesto

managethesethreatstohealth.4Thus,thehealthsector’scontributionstotheseearly

assessmentsandadaptationplanswererelativelylight,andlackinginstrongevidenceto

supportthedetailscontainedtherein.5

Thelate2000ssawasignificantscale-upofpoliticalcommitmentandfinancialandtechnical

supportforPICstoaddressclimatechangevulnerabilities,includingimpactsonhuman

health.ThekeypolicyinstrumentsforthisataregionallevelwereWHO’sRegional

FrameworkforActiontoProtectHumanHealthfromEffectsofClimateChangeintheAsia-

PacificRegion6andthePacificHealthMinisters’MadangCommitment,7whichcommittedall

countriesintheregiontoactiononclimatechangeandhealth,withparticularemphasison

vulnerabilityassessmentandadaptationplanning.

Thesewerethemuch-neededcatalystsfortheinitiationofthisfocused,evidence-based,

policy-orientedclimatechangeandhealthresearchinPacificregion.

1http://www.weather.com/storms/hurricane/news/cyclone-pam-vanuatu-climate-change

4 ChapterOne

WithguidancefromWHOandfundingfromgovernments(notablyJapanandtheRepublicof

Korea)andinternationaldonoragencies(principally,theGlobalEnvironmentFacility–GEF),

aregionalclimatechangeandhealthprojectcommencedinthePacificin2010.Thisproject,

whichformsthefoundationofthisthesis,wasconductedviadifferentprocessesineach

country;theendresultforalmostallcountriesinvolvedwasthecompilationofaNational

ClimateChangeandHealthActionPlan(NCCHAP),oranequivalentthereof.Theprocesses

andoutcomesofthisworkaredescribedinthisthesis,inadditiontothecorresponding

WHOreport(seebelow).

1.3Aimsandscope

Theresearchpresentedinthisthesisformedthefoundationoftheclimatechangeand

healthvulnerabilityassessmentsandadaptationplanningprocessesinthirteenPacificisland

countries(PICs):CookIslands,FederatedStatesofMicronesia(FSM),Fiji,Kiribati,Marshall

Islands,Nauru,Niue,Palau,Samoa,SolomonIslands,Tonga,TuvaluandVanuatu.

Theoverallobjectivesofthisresearchandrelatedprojectworkwere:

- toassessthevulnerabilitiesofPacificislandcountriestothelikelyhealthimpactsof

climatechange;

- toprioritiseeachcountry’sclimate-sensitivehealthrisksaccordingtoperceived

likelihoodandimpact;and

- toplanadaptationstrategiestominimisesuchthreatstohealth.

Asuiteofresearchactivitieswasundertakentomeettheseobjectives,whichalignwiththe

themesoftheresearch.TheresearchquestionsandmethodsareelaboratedinChapter3.

Itshouldbenotedthatalloftheresearchworkcontainedinthisthesis,includingthe

publications,isinadditiontothereportsroutinelycompiledbyWHOfortheregionalproject

onhealthvulnerabilityandadaptationassessments.Inotherwords,thisthesisprovides

invaluableaddedvalueintheresearchandacademicdomainswhichgoessubstantially

beyondtheoperationalworkconductedaspartoftheunderlyingWHOprojecttowhichthis

researchwaslinked.

5ChapterOne

Intermsofthegeographicscopeoftheproject,itisacknowledgedthatnotallPICscouldbe

included,forvariousreasons.PapuaNewGuinea,forexample,hadalreadyundertakena

healthvulnerabilityandadaptationassessmentin2010.TheFrenchterritories,including

FrenchPolynesia,NewCaledoniaandWallisandFutuna,hadseparatesupportforrelated

workfromtheSecretariatforthePacificCommunity.Othersmallterritoriessuchas

Tokelau,CommonwealthoftheNorthernMarianaIslandsandPitcairnIsland,affiliatedwith

NewZealand,theUSAandUKrespectively,areyettoreceivededicatedsupportforhealth

adaptation,butmustnotbeoverlookedasthisworkcontinues.

1.4Thesisstructure

Thisthesisiscomposedofaseriesofpublishedworksthataddressthethreekeythemes

above.Thejournalpapersandtextbookchaptersincludedconstitutethemost

comprehensiveoverviewofclimatechangeandhealthinthePacificregiontodate.

ThesewerecomplementedbyaWHOreportentitledHumanHealthandClimateChangein

PacificIslandCountries,publishedinlate2015,ofwhichIamleadauthor.

Thethesisalsocontainssectionsonmethods,discussionpointsandconclusionsthatlinkthe

publishedpaperstogetherintoacoherentbodyofwork.

Theoutlineofthethesisisasfollows:

ChapterTwogivesanoverviewofclimatechangeandhealththeory,withafocusonthe

workofWHOandtheIntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange(IPCC)indetermining

globalandregionalhealthvulnerabilitiesandproposingmethodsforcarryingoutsuch

assessments.

ChapterThreedescribesthemethodsemployedinthisresearchandcomparesthe

approachestakenindifferentcountriesinvolvedinthisproject.

ChapterFourprovidesanoverviewoftheprocesses,outcomesandimplicationsofthe

WHO-supportedclimatechangeandhealthprojectsconductedinthePacificbetween2011

and2015.Thispapersetsthesceneforthecountry-specificpapersthatfollow.

6 ChapterOne

InChaptersFive,SixandSeven,threepapersarepresentedwhichdescribethedistinct

approachesemployedintheclimatechangeandhealthvulnerabilityassessmentand

adaptationplanningprocessesinthreedifferentPacificislandcountries–FSM,Vanuatuand

Kiribati.

ChaptersEightandNinefocusonFiji,withlinkedpaperspublishedtwoyearsapart–bothin

theFijiJournalofPublicHealth–describingthedisease-orientedapproachtovulnerability

andadaptationinthatcountry,whichwasoneofseventoparticipateinaWHO-led,GEF-

fundedglobalclimatechangeandhealthpilotproject.

ThepaperinChapterTenilluminatesanunprecedentedconvergenceofhealthrisksinthe

Pacific,asclimatechangehasthepotentialtoactinsynergywithnon-communicable

diseases(particularlydiabetes)toincreasetheriskofcommunicablediseasessuchas

tuberculosis–adiseasenothithertoconsideredintheliteraturetobe“climate-sensitive”.

ChapterElevenprovidesaregional,historicalperspectiveonhealthsystemsgovernanceasit

appliestoclimatechangeadaptation.Thispaperplaceshealthadaptationinthecontextof

the“HealthyIslands”vision–theoverarchingpolicyframeworkforhealthsystemsinthe

Pacific.

ChaptersTwelveandThirteenconcludethethesiswithdiscussionoftheresearchfindings,

synthesisoftheimplicationsandrecommendationsarisingfromtheworkcontainedtherein.

Annex1isachapterpublishedinatextbookdedicatedtoTonyMcMichael,oneofthe

leadersofthefieldofclimatechangeandhealthresearch,andoneofthesupervisorsofmy

PhDuntilhisdeathin2013.ThispublicationdescribessomeofTony’soutstanding

contributionstothefieldofclimatechangeandhealthandplaceshispioneeringworkinthe

contextofthePacificregionalproject.

Allpapersincludedinthisthesiswerepreparedduringtheperiodofdoctoralcandidature,

andarereproducedwiththepermissionoftheco-authorsandrespectivepublishing

companies.

7ChapterOne

References

1 MahanyMJ,KeimME.ChallengesandStrategiesforClimateChangeAdaptationAmongPacificIslandNations.DisasterMedPublicHealthPrep2011;publishedonlineJune30,2011:1–9.

2 FieldC,BarrosV,StockerT,QinD.ManagingtheRisksofExtremeEventsandDisasterstoAdvanceClimateChangeAdaptation.Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,2012DOI:10.1017/CBO9781139177245.

3 WoodwardA,HalesS,LitidamuN,PhillipsD,MartinJ.Protectinghumanhealthinachangingworld:theroleofsocialandeconomicdevelopment.BullWorldHealthOrgan2000;78:1148–55.

4 WorldMeteorologicalOrganizationandtheUnitedNationsEnvironmentProgram1988.Developingpoliciesforrespondingtoclimaticchange–asummaryofthediscussionsandrecommendationsoftheworkshopsheldinVillach(28September–2October1987)andBellagio(9–13October1987)undertheauspicesoftheBeijerInstitute,Stockholm,Sweden(WMO/TD–225,April1988).

5 McIverL,HannaE.FragileParadise-HealthandClimateChangeintheSouthPacific.In:HealthofPeople,PlacesandPlanet.Butler,Dixon&Capon(eds);ANUe-press2015:337–50.

6 WorldHealthOrganization,WesternPacificRegionalOffice.RegionalFrameworkforActiontoProtectHumanHealthfromEffectsofClimateChangeintheAsia-PacificRegion.WHO2007;1-3.Manila,Philippines.

7 WorldHealthOrganizationandSecretariatforthePacificCommunity.MadangCommitment.2009.WHO,Geneva,Switzerland.

8 ChapterOne

9ChapterTwo

ChapterTwo

Background

10 ChapterTwo

2.1Climatechange–aglobalperspective

Sincethelatenineteenthcentury,ithadbeenrecognisedthattheEarth’saverageambient

temperaturewasincreasing,anditwassuspectedthatthiswascloselycorrelatedwith

atmosphericcarbondioxideconcentrations.1Thetwokeyfeaturesthatdistinguishedthis

modernperiodofwarmingfromearlierplanetaryclimatecyclesweretherateof

temperatureriseandtheidentificationofasuddenaccelerationaroundthetimeofthe

IndustrialRevolution,whichhascontinuedoverthelastcentury(Figure2.1).

Figure2.1Historicalglobalatmosphericcarbondioxideconcentrations(top)andambienttemperatures(bottom).Source:ReproducedwithpermissionfromGRID-Arendal(http://www.grida.no/graphicslib/detail/historical-trends-in-carbon-dioxide-concentrations-and-temperature-on-a-geological-and-recent-time-scale_a210)

11ChapterTwo

Thecombinationofcarbondioxideandotherheat-trapping(“greenhouse”)gasesinthe

atmosphere,suchasmethane,hasmultiple,complexeffectsonhydro-meteorological

systems.Theseeffectsmanifestasdetectablevariationsinweather(short-term)and

climate(long-term),whicharecollectivelyknownas“climatechange”andare

acknowledgedtobetheconsequenceofhumanactivity(i.e.anthropogenic)–hencethe

introductionoftheterm“anthropocene”todescribethemodernera.2,3

TheIPCC,initsFifthAssessmentReport(2013),documentsthemaincategoriesofclimate-

relatedphenomenaforwhichchangeshavebeenrecordedsincemodernmeasurements

began(approximatelymid-twentiethcentury),alongwithanassessmentofthecontribution

ofhumanactivitytothesechanges,andthelikelihoodoffurtherchangesoverthecourseof

thetwenty-firstcentury.ThesefindingsaresummarisedinTable2.1below.

Table2.1Globalclimatechangephenomena.Source:AdaptedfromIPCC,20134

Phenomenonanddirectionoftrend Assessmentofhumancontributiontoobservedchanges

Likelihoodoffurtherchangesthiscentury

Warmerand/orfewercolddaysandnightsovermostlandareas

Verylikely

Virtuallycertain

Warmerand/ormorefrequenthotdaysandnightsovermostlandareas

Verylikely

Virtuallycertain

Increasedfrequencyand/ordurationofheatwavesovermostlandareas

Likely Verylikely

Heavyprecipitationevents-increaseinthefrequency,intensity,and/oramountofheavyprecipitation

Mediumconfidence Verylikely

Increasedincidenceand/ormagnitudeofextremehighsealevel

Likely Verylikely

Increasesinintensityand/ordurationofdrought

Lowconfidence Likely

Increasesinintensetropicalcycloneactivity Lowconfidence Morelikelythannot

12 ChapterTwo

2.2ClimatechangeinthePacific

InthePacific,aregionaltechnicalcollaborationbetweentheCommonwealthScientific

IndustrialandResearchOrganisation,AustralianBureauofMeteorologyandmeteorology

departmentsfromoveradozenPICs,knownasthePacificClimateChangeScienceand

AdaptationProgram(PCCSP),publishedaseriesofscientificreportsin2011providing

detailedclimatechangeobservationandprojectioninformationforallcountriesinthe

region.ThemajorclimatechangephenomenapredictedforthePacificregionthroughthe

workofPCCSParesummarisedinTable2.2.

Table2.2Pacificclimatechangephenomena.Source:AdaptedfromPCCSP,20115

Climatechangephenomenon ExpectedchangeinPacificregion

Increasingairtemperature Increasebyupto1°Cby2030and3°Cby2090,withlargeincreasesinincidenceofheatwavesandextremelyhotdaysandnights

Increasingsea-surfacetemperature

Increaseacrossregion,maximalincentralequatorialPacific

Alteredrainfallpatterns Increaseintotalannualrainfall,heavyrainfalldaysandfrequencyandseverityofextremerainfallevents(withfloodingpotential)

Humidity Littleoverallchangeduetoincreaseinbothproductionofwatervapourandpotentialatmosphericwatervapour-holdingcapacity

Evapotranspiration Increaseinseveralareaswithpotentialforresultingincreasedaridity

Sea-levelrise 0.55-1.0mincreaseby2100

Oceanacidification Increaseacrossregion

Theeffectsofsea-levelrise,particularlyincombinationwithincreasedstormsurges,in

termsoftheimmediatephysicalhazardsandthelossoflandandlivelihoodsthatentails,are

visible,tangibleandliterallylife-threateningrealitiesforPacificislandcommunities.Climate

changeposesanexistentialthreatfortheatollcountriesofKiribati,MarshallIslandsand

Tuvalu,wherethevastmajorityofthepopulationliveinovercrowdedconditionslessthan

twometresabovesealevel.Tuvalu’sformerPrimeMinister,BikenibeuPaeniuhasreflected

that“…inmygrandchildren’slifetime,maybeevenearlier,theymaynothaveanationtolive

in…Soonerorlater,Tuvaluwilleventuallybesubmergedunderwater”1.

1Interviewfor“NewFlagsFlying–PacificLeadership”series,RadioNewZealand,2011.

13ChapterTwo

2.3Impact,riskandvulnerability

Inexploringandattemptingtoexplainthehumandimensionsoftheconsequencesof

climatechange,termsthatareusedintheliteratureincludeimpact,riskandvulnerability.

TheIPCCdefinitionsofthesetermsareprovidedhere,6asthesenseinwhichtheywillbe

appliedinthisthesis.Indoingso,itisacknowledgedthatmanyalternativedefinitionsof

vulnerabilitymakeexplicitrecognitionofothercontributingfactors,particularlythoseinthe

socio-economicanddevelopmentdomains,whicharealsolinkedtohealth.Nevertheless,

forclarityandcoherence,theIPCCdefinitionwillbethedefinitionreferencedinthisthesis.

Impact:Aneffectonnaturalandhumansystems;inparticular,effectsonlives,livelihoods,

healthstatus,ecosystems,economic,socialandculturalassets,servicesandinfrastructure

duetotheinteractionofclimatechangesorhazardousclimateevents.

Risk:Thepotentialforconsequenceswheresomethingofhumanvalue(includinghumans

themselves)isatstakeandwheretheoutcomeisuncertain.

Vulnerability:Thepropensityorpredispositiontobeadverselyaffected;thisencompassesa

varietyofconceptsincludingsensitivityorsusceptibilitytoharmandlackofcapacitytocope

andadapt.

Thesedistinctbutrelatedtermsoverlapwithotherconceptssuchexposureandhazard,as

depictedinFigure2.2.

Figure2.2Theintersectingconceptsofhazard,exposure,vulnerability,riskandimpactSource:IPCC,20147

14 ChapterTwo

2.4Healthimpactsofclimatechange

Theimpactsofclimatechangeonhumanhealthrangefromtheimmediateandobviousto

theinsidiousandobscure.Aparadigmusedbymany,includingtheIPCC,toconsiderand

explaintheseeffects,istodescribethemintermsoftheirmechanismanddirectnessof

action,forexample:direct,indirectanddiffuse;orprimary,secondaryandtertiary(see

Table2.2).8–10

Table2.2Climatechangeandhealthexposure-impactpathways

Impactcategory Examplesofimpactpathwaysandconsequences

Primary Direct biological consequences of heat waves (e.g. cardio-respiratory arrests);traumaticinjuriesanddeathsfromextremeweathereventssuchascyclones

Secondary Changes inbiophysicallyandecologicallybasedprocessesandsystems,particularlyfoodyields,waterflowsandtherangeandbehaviorsofvectorssuchasmosquitoes,causingincreasesindiseasessuchasmalaria,denguefeveranddiarrhoealdisease

Tertiary Lossoflandandlivelihoods,populationdisplacementandconflictleadingtomentalhealthdisordersandsocialdysfunction.

Theseeffectsmaybemoderatedbyeffortstominimiseexposure,vulnerabilityandrisk,

whichinthecontextofclimatechangeareknownasadaptations.6,11

Throughoutthefirstdecadeofthiscentury,asincreasedattentionwaspaidtotherisks

posedbyclimatechangeonhealthandtheevidencebasisexpanded,12–16thelistofdiseases

andcategoriesofill-healthconsideredsensitivetoclimatechangegrewsteadily.WHO

developedmodelsforestimatingclimatechange-attributableburdensofdiseases,17and

includedclimatechangeinitsquantitativeassessmentsoftheglobalcausesofillnessand

death.18,19Thelatestofthese,publishedin2014,projectsthattheannualexcessmortality

duetoclimatechangearoundtheyear2030willbeapproximately250000deaths,taking

intoaccountonlytheburdenofadditionalheat-relatedillness,diarrhoealdisease,malaria

andmalnutrition.19

TheIPCChasdescribedwhatitseesasthemaincategoriesofclimate-sensitivehealthrisks,

andprovidedlevelsofconfidencewithwhichtheseburdensofdiseasearepredictedto

increaseduetoclimatechange.TheseeffectsandpredictionsaresummarisedinTable2.3.

15ChapterTwo

Table2.3Summaryoftheanticipatedglobalhealthimpactsofclimatechange,withconfidencelevels.Source:AdaptedfromIPCC,201410Healthimpact Confidencerating

Greaterriskofinjury,diseaseanddeathduetoheatwavesandextremeweathereventssuchasfires,floodsandtropicalstorms

Veryhigh

Increasedrisksoffood-andwater-bornediseases Veryhigh

Increasedriskofunder-nutrition(resultingfromdiminishedfoodproductioninpoorregions)

High

Increasedriskofvector-bornediseases

Medium

Modestimprovementsincold-relatedmorbidityandmortality Low

2.5ClimatechangeandhealthinthePacificregion

TheliteratureonclimatechangeandhealthinthePacificpriorto2010is,broadlyspeaking,

limitedtothatinferredfromtheworkoftheIPCCandotherstudiesrelatedtosmallisland

states;20,21hypothesisedbasedontheclimatechangeresearchconductedinthePacific(but

notspecifictohealth);22–24includedinhealthvulnerabilityassessmentsforthewiderAsia-

Pacific25andOceania26regions;orextrapolatedfromcountry-specificstudies,suchasthe

preliminaryassessmentinSamoa.27

Thesmallnumberofnotablepublicationsfromthisperiodthatspecificallyaddressedhealth

andclimatechangeinPacificislandcountries28–30werebasedandinformedspeculation,

withoutrecoursetoin-countryresearch,ashadbeenthecasefortheearlyworkonclimate

changeandhealthonaglobalscaleinthe1990s.31Thesepublicationswerethuslargely

restrictedtogeneralities,suchaspointingoutthepotentialriskstoPacificcommunitiesof

increasingfood-,water-andvector-bornediseases;extremeweatherevents;and

malnutrition,withoutlinkingthesewithempiricaldataorprovidingestimatesoffuture

climatechange-attributableburdensofdisease.However,despitetheirlimitations,these

earlyreportslaidthefoundationforsubsequenthealthvulnerabilityassessments,andmade

cleartheneedforstronggovernancemechanismstoenableeffectiveadaptation.28

16 ChapterTwo

2.6Rationaleforthisresearch

By2010,withtheaforementionedregionalclimatechangeandhealthmandatesin

place,32,33therewasconsensusregardingtheurgentneedtocarryoutnationalclimate

changeandhealthvulnerabilityassessmentsandplanadaptationstrategiesforallcountries

inthePacificregion.WithWHOhavingledtheestablishmentofgeneralprinciplesand

evidence-basedguidelinesfortheseprocesses,34,35thisprojectcommencedinlate2010,

withthefollowingoverarchingobjective:“Tostrengthencountry-levelcapacitieswith

respecttoresearchandpolicy-makingrelevanttoclimatechangeandhealth,bysupporting

vulnerabilityassessments,datacollectionandanalysis,andpreparationofdraftnational

actionplansforclimatechangeandhealthinPacificislandcountries”.

Theworkpresentedinthisthesisrepresentstheresearchthatwaswoventhroughthis

regionalproject,providingtheevidencebasisforthefindingsandadaptationplansforeach

countryandtheregionasawhole.

Theresearchcomponentsoftheproject,ledbytheauthorasadoctoralprogrammeof

work,thussoughttoaddressthefollowingcriticalgapsinknowledgeregardingclimate

changeandhealthinthePacificthatexistedpriortocommencementoftheprojectandthe

author’srelatedPhD:

• Comparativeanalysisoftheoptimalmethodsofassessinghealthvulnerabilityand

adaptationstrategiesintheseverelyresource-constrainedenvironmentsinPacific

islandcountries;

• IdentificationoftheriskstohealthposedbyclimatechangeforindividualPacific

islandcountriesandtheregionasawhole,asdeterminedbyquantitativeand

qualitativevulnerabilityassessmenttechniques;and

• Establishmentofprioritiesforhealthsystemsadaptationstoprotecthumanhealth

fromclimatechangeintheregion.

17ChapterTwo

References

1 ArrheniusS.OntheInfluenceofCarbonicAcidintheAirupontheTemperatureoftheGround.PhilosMagJSci1896;5:237–76.

2 SteffenW,GrinevaldJ,CrutzenP,McNeillJ.TheAnthropocene:conceptualandhistoricalperspectives.PhilosTransAMathPhysEngSci2011;369:842–67.

3 McMichaela.J.PopulationhealthintheAnthropocene:Gains,lossesandemergingtrends.AnthrRev2014;1:44–56.

4 IPCC,2013:SummaryforPolicymakers.In:ClimateChange2013:ThePhysicalScienceBasis.ContributionofWorkingGroupItotheFifthAssessmentReportoftheIntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange[Stocker,TFetal(eds.)].CambridgeUniversityPress,Cambridge,UnitedKingdomandNewYork,NY,USA.

5 AustralianBureauofMeteorologyandCommonwealthScientificandIndustrialResearchOrganisation(CSIRO)(2011).ClimatechangeinthePacific:Scientificassessmentandnewresearch.Volume1:RegionalOverview.Melbourne,Australia.

6 AllwoodJ.M.,V.Bosetti,N.K.Dubash,L.Gómez-Echeverri,andC.vonStechow,2014:Glossary.In:ClimateChange2014:MitigationofClimateChange.ContributionofWorkingGroupIIItotheFifthAssessmentReportoftheIntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange[Edenhofer,O,etal(eds.)].CambridgeUniversityPress,Cambridge,UnitedKingdomandNewYork,NY,USA.

7 IPCC,2014:Summaryforpolicymakers.In:ClimateChange2014:Impacts,Adaptation,andVulnerability.PartA:GlobalandSectoralAspects.ContributionofWorkingGroupIItotheFifthAssessmentReportoftheIntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange[Field,CB,etal(eds.)].CambridgeUniversityPress,Cambridge,UnitedKingdomandNewYork,NY,USA,pp.1-32.

8 McMichaelAJ,LindgrenE.Climatechange:presentandfutureriskstohealth,andnecessaryresponses.JInternMed2011;270:401–13.

9 ButlerCD,HarleyD.Primary,secondaryandtertiaryeffectsofeco-climaticchange:themedicalresponse.PostgradMedJ2010;86:230–4.

10 Smith,K.R.,A.Woodward,D.Campbell-Lendrum,D.D.Chadee,Y.Honda,Q.Liu,J.M.Olwoch,B.Revich,andR.Sauerborn,2014:Humanhealth:impacts,adaptation,andco-benefits.In:ClimateChange2014:Impacts,Adaptation,andVulnerability.PartA:GlobalandSectoralAspects.ContributionofWorkingGroupIItotheFifthAssessmentReportoftheIntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange[Field,CB,etal(eds.)].CambridgeUniversityPress,Cambridge,UnitedKingdomandNewYork,NY,USA,pp.709-754.

11 ChalabiZ,KovatsS.Toolsfordevelopingadaptationpolicytoprotecthumanhealth.MitigAdaptStrategGlobChang2014;19:309–30.

12 McMichaelAJ,WoodruffRE,HalesS.Climatechangeandhumanhealth:presentandfuturerisks.Lancet2006;367:859–69.

18 ChapterTwo

13 HainesA,KovatsRS,Campbell-LendrumD,CorvalanC.Climatechangeandhumanhealth:Impacts,vulnerabilityandpublichealth.Lancet2006;367:2101–9.

14 WeissR,McMichaelA.Socialandenvironmentalriskfactorsintheemergenceofinfectiousdiseases.NatMed2004;10:S70–6.

15 GithekoaK,LindsaySW,ConfalonieriUE,PatzJa.Climatechangeandvector-bornediseases:aregionalanalysis.BullWorldHealthOrgan2000;78:1136–47.

16 WorldHealthOrganization.Climatechangeandhumanhealth–risksandresponses.WHO,2004;Geneva,Switzerland.

17 Campbell-LendrumD,WoodruffR.ComparativeRiskAssessmentoftheBurdenofDiseasefromClimateChange.EnvironHealthPerspect2006;114:1935–41.

18 PatzJ.,GibbsHK,FoleyJ.,RogersJV.,SmithKR.ClimateChangeandGlobalHealth:QuantifyingaGrowingEthicalCrisis.Ecohealth2007;4:397–405.

19 WorldHealthOrganization.Quantitativeriskassessmentoftheeffectsofclimatechangeonselectedcausesofdeath,2030sand2050s.WHO,2014;Geneva,Switzerland.

20 EbiKL,LewisND,CorvalanC,LuciaS.ClimateVariabilityandChangeandTheirPotentialHealthEffectsinSmallIslandStates :InformationforAdaptationPlanningintheHealthSector.EnvironHealthPerspect2006;114:1957–63.

21 Nurse,L.A.,R.F.McLean,J.Agard,etal,2014:Smallislands.In:ClimateChange2014:Impacts,Adaptation,andVulnerability.PartB:RegionalAspects.ContributionofWorkingGroupIItotheFifthAssessmentReportoftheIntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange[Barros,VR,etal,(eds.)].CambridgeUniversityPress,Cambridge,UnitedKingdomandNewYork,NY,USA,pp.1613-1654.

22 MimuraN.VulnerabilityofislandcountriesintheSouthPacifictosealevelriseandclimatechange.ClimRes1999;12:137–43.

23 BarnettJ,CampbellJ.ClimateChangeandSmallIslandStates:Power,Knowledge,andtheSouthPacific.Earthscan,2010.

24 PacificIslandsFrameworkforActiononClimateChange,ClimateVariabilityandSeaLevelRise2000-2004.2006;1–10.

25 WoodwardA,HalesS,WeinsteinP.ClimatechangeandhumanhealthintheAsiaPacificregion:whowillbemostvulnerable?ClimRes1998;11:31–8.

26 McMichaelA,WoodrufR,WhettonP,etal.HumanhealthandclimatechangeinOceania:ariskassessment.CommonwealthofAustralia,2002;Canberra,Australia.

27 LindsayG,PercivalT,WoodwardA.Fromtyphoidtotsunamis:Samoanchildreninachangingworld.IntPubHealthJ2010;2(4):447-458.

28 LovellSA.HealthgovernanceandtheimpactofclimatechangeonPacificsmallislanddevelopingstates.IHDPUpdat2011;:50–5.

19ChapterTwo

29 WoodwardA,HalesS,LitidamuN,PhillipsD,MartinJ.Protectinghumanhealthinachangingworld:theroleofsocialandeconomicdevelopment.BullWorldHealthOrgan2000;78:1148–55.

30 RussellL.Poverty,climatechangeandhealthinPacificislandcountries:Issuestoconsiderindiscussion,debateandpolicydevelopment.CenterforAutraliaandNewZealandStudies,GeorgetownUniversity,2011;WashingtonD.C.,USA.

31 WorldMeteorologicalOrganisation,WorldHealthOrganizationandtheUnitedNationsDevelopmentProgramme.ClimateandHumanHealth.WMO,1996;Geneva,Switzerland.

32 WorldHealthOrganization,WesternPacificRegionalOffice.RegionalFrameworkforActiontoProtectHumanHealthfromEffectsofClimateChangeintheAsia-PacificRegion.WHO,2007;1–4.

33 WorldHealthOrganizationandSecretariatforthePacificCommunity.MadangCommitment.2009;Manila,Philippines.

34 KovatsR,EbiK,MenneB.Methodsofassessinghumanhealthvulnerabilityandpublichealthadaptationtoclimatechange.WHO,2003;Copenhagen,Denmark.

35 EbiKL,KovatsRS,MenneB.AnApproachforAssessingHumanHealthVulnerabilityandPublicHealthInterventionstoAdapttoClimateChange.EnvironHealthPerspect2006;114(12):1930–1934.

20 ChapterTwo

21ChapterThree

ChapterThreeResearchDesign

22 ChapterThree

3.1KeyresearchquestionsThekeyresearchquestionsforthisPhDwereasfollows:

1. Whatmethodsmaybeusedtoassessclimatechangeandhealthvulnerabilitiesin

thePacific,andhowdothesemethodscompareintermsoftheirfocus,feasibility,

usefulnessandrelevancetoPacificislandcountries?

2. WhatarethemostsignificantriskstohealthposedbyclimatechangeinthePacific

region?

3. Whatarethemainopportunitiesandchallengesintermsofimplementingeffective

climatechangeandhealthadaptationstrategiesinPacificislandcountries?

Thesekeyquestions–necessarilybroadinscope–wereaddressedbytheauthoroverthe

durationoftheclimatechangeandhealthprojectconductedbyWHOinthePacificviaa

three-phaseprocessinvolvingcollectionofdata,assessmentofvulnerabilitiesandplanning

ofadaptationstrategiestominimisethehealthimpactsofclimatechangeintheregion.

• Thefirstphaseinvolvedinceptionworkshops,whichbroughttogethercountry

representativesandconsultantteamstoreviewthecurrentstateofknowledgeon

climatechangeandhealth,anddiscussvulnerabilitiesandapproachestoadaptation

relevanttoeachcountry.

• Duringthesecondphase,theinternationalsupportteamsvisitedeachofthecountries

forfurtherstakeholderconsultations,examinationandanalysisoftheavailablelocal

dataonclimateandclimate-sensitivediseases,andprioritisationofclimate-sensitive

healthrisks.Stakeholdersinthisprocessincludedgovernmentandnongovernment

agencies,communityrepresentativesandtheprivatesector.

• Inthefinalphase,duringreturnvisitstoeachcountry,WHOteamsassistedthecountry

teamsindraftingnationalclimatechangeandhealthactionplansthatreflectedkey

vulnerabilitiesandadaptationprioritieswithrespecttothecountry-specifichealth

impactsofclimatechange.

Theresearchmethodsinvolvedineachofthesethreephasesareelaboratedinturnbelow.

23ChapterThree

3.2Assessingvulnerability

TheprocessrecommendedbyWHOtoassesshealthvulnerabilitiestoclimatechangeiswell

articulatedintheliterature,1,2andisgenerallyconsideredtoinvolvethefollowingsteps:

- determiningthescopeoftheassessment;

- describingthecurrentdistributionandburdenofclimate-sensitivediseases;

- identifyinganddescribingcurrentstrategies,policiesandmeasuresthatreducethe

burdenofclimate-sensitivediseases;

- reviewingthehealthimplicationsofthepotentialimpactofclimatechangeand

variabilityonother(non-health)sectors;

- estimatingthefuturepotentialhealthimpactusingscenariosoffutureclimate

change,populationgrowthandotherfactors,anddescribingtherelated

uncertainty;and

- assemblingtheresultsanddraftingascientificassessmentreport.

Theprocessesoutlinedaboveareintendedtobeplacedwithinthebroaderhealthpolicy

landscape,andincludefeedbackloopsthatinformadaptationplanningandenable

evaluation.TheselinksaredepictedinFigure3.3.

Figure3..3Overviewoftheclimatechangeandhealthvulnerabilityassessmentprocess.Source:BasedonKovatseta,20031

24 ChapterThree

AdetailedcomparisonbetweentheWHOvulnerabilityassessmentandadaptationplanning

frameworkandtheprocessimplementedinthePacificregionalprojectisprovidedinthe

followingchapter.

WHOhasalsoprovidedguidanceonthestatisticaltechniquesthatmaybeusedtoestimate

theburdensofill-healthattributabletoclimatechangeinpresentandfutureperiods.3,4This

requirescompleteandreliablebaselinedata,andcorrelationofdiseaseburdens(e.g.

incidence)withclimaticfactors(e.g.temperatureorrainfall).Thesestatisticalassociations

arethenextrapolatedforwardintimebasedonrobustclimateprojectiondata.Initsideal

form,thisprocessalsoenablesanestimationofthemorbidityandmortalitythatmaybe

avoidedundervariousscenarios,suchasmitigation(i.e.thearrestingofclimatechangeata

particularpointintime).

Figure3.4showstheprocessbywhichsuchestimatesmaybemadeiftheabovementioned

datarequirementsaremet.

Figure3.4Estimatingattributableandavoidableriskofdiseaseburden(s)duetoclimatechange(GHG:greenhousegases;ppmv:partspermillionbyvolume;T:time)Source:Campbell-Lendrumetal,20063

25ChapterThree

InthePacificislandcountriesincludedinthisproject,thehighlyvariable(andoftenpoor)

availability,reliabilityandcompletenessofdatatypicallyprohibitedthesophisticated

attributionandprojectionmodelingdescribedintheWHOguidelines.Examplesofthe

compromisedqualityofdiseasedataincludedincompleterecords;lackofconfirmatory

diagnostics–andthusrelianceoncase-basedsurveillance;andlikelymisclassifications(e.g.

theinabilitytodistinguishbetweencausesofacutefebrileillnessessuchasdenguefever

andleptospirosis,particularlyinthesettingofdisastersandoutbreaks).Thequalityof

climatedataacrosstheregionwasoftenofahigherstandard(intermsofitsreliabilityand

completeness),butrarelycoveredtimeperiodslongenoughtoenablethedetectionof

statisticallysignificantassociationswithvariationsindiseasetrends.

Somecountries–notablyFSM,MarshallIslands,PalauandFiji–strovetousethebest

availabledatatoconstructclimate-diseaseexposure-responsemodels,andincludedthese

statisticalanalysesintheirvulnerabilityassessments.Thetechniquesemployedtomodel

climate-diseaseassociationsincludedtimeseriesanalyses,Poissonregressionand

distributedlagnon-linearmodeling,alongwithspatialanalysisfordetectionof“hotspots”,

allofwhichhavestrongprecedentsintheliteraturefortheiruseinthiscontext.5–8

ExamplesofsuchquantitativemodelsareprovidedforFSMandFijiinthisthesis.

InotherPacificislandcountries,amorequalitativeapproachwastakentothevulnerability

assessmentprocess.Specifically,amodifiedversionoftheEnvironmentalHealthImpact

Assessment(EHIA)framework,adaptedforuseintheclimatechangecontext9andpiloted

successfullyinAustralia,10wasemployedinthevulnerabilityassessmentsforSolomon

Islands,VanuatuandNauru.Thishighlyiterativeandconsultativeapproach,which

considersvariousaspectsofvulnerabilityfromacrosssocietyandpolicyareas,was

particularlyusefulinthePacificislandcountrycontext,11giventhefrequentabsenceof

sufficientlyrobustdataavailableforquantitativeanalysis.Thestepsinvolvedinthis

modifiedEHIAapproach,asitwascarriedoutinVanuatu,aredescribedinChapterSix.

TheapproachtakenineachPacificislandcountrywasdeterminedbytheavailabilityof

relevantdataandthepreferenceofthenationalteam,aswellastheanalyticalmethods

consideredmostappropriateforeachcountry’scontext.Thesearepresentedindetailin

thefollowingchapters.

26 ChapterThree

3.3Prioritisingrisk

AcriticalfeatureofthevulnerabilityassessmentsconductedinthePacific–aselsewhere–

wastheconsiderationoftherangeofplausiblehazardsposedbyclimatechangeonhealth

andthestratificationoftheseaccordingtothelevelofriskrepresented.Levelsofriskwere

determinedasafunctionofeachhazard’slikelihoodandconsequence(thelattermay,in

thiscontext,beconsideredsynonymouswith“impact”),asitwasperceivedtopertainto

eachcountry.Thisapproachhasitshistoricalrootsinriskassessmenttheory,12andhasfor

decadesbeenappliedtopolicydevelopmentinthefieldsofenvironment,13health14and,

morerecently,climatechangeandhealth.15

TheriskstratificationprocessisfurtherelaboratedinChapterFourandexamplesofcountry-

specificoutcomesarepresentedinChapterFive(forFSM)andChapterSix(Vanuatu).

3.4Planningadaptation

Adaptation strategies for each PIC were planned according to the outcomes of the

respectivevulnerabilityassessmentandriskstratificationprocesses–seeChapterFour.

SomeofthekeycharacteristicsofclimatechangeandhealthworkinthePacificmentioned

above–forexample,thevariationsininter-countrymethodologiesandinconsistenciesin

dataavailability–meantthattheadaptationplanningprocessgenerallyfavoureda“no/low

regrets”approach.Inpractice,thismeantthatthenationalplansforhealthadaptation

aimedtoincreasethecapacityofthehealthsystem,andsocietymorebroadly,tomanage

climateriskswithaviewtoreducingclimatechangeandhealthvulnerabilitieswhile

increasingtheopportunitiesforsustainabledevelopment.16

Thus,Pacificislandcountriesfollowedahighlypragmaticapproachtoadaptationthat

soughttostrengthenhealthsystemsresilienceandcapacitytomeetcontemporary

challenges,aswellasthelonger-termhazardsposedbyclimatechange.Thisisconsistent

withtheapproachrecommendedforweakhealthsystems,suchasthoseinthesmallisland

developingstatesofthePacific.17Themainadvantagesofthisapproacharediscussedin

moredetailinChapterEleven,andsomecriticallimitationsexploredinChapterTwelve.

27ChapterThree

References

1 KovatsR,EbiK,MenneB.Methodsofassessinghumanhealthvulnerabilityandpublichealthadaptationtoclimatechange.PanAmHealth2003.http://researchonline.lshtm.ac.uk/14942/(accessedNov7,2012).

2 EbiKL,KovatsRS,MenneB.AnApproachforAssessingHumanHealthVulnerabilityandPublicHealthInterventionstoAdapttoClimateChange.EnvironHealthPerspect2006;114:1930–4.

3 Campbell-LendrumD,WoodruffR.ComparativeRiskAssessmentoftheBurdenofDiseasefromClimateChange.EnvironHealthPerspect2006;114:1935–41.

4 KovatsRS,Campbell-LendrumD,MatthiesF.Climatechangeandhumanhealth:estimatingavoidabledeathsanddisease.RiskAnal2005;25:1409–18.

5 BhaskaranK,GasparriniA,HajatS,SmeethL,ArmstrongB.Timeseriesregressionstudiesinenvironmentalepidemiology.IntJEpidemiol2013;42:1187–95.

6 HashizumeM,ArmstrongB,HajatS,etal.TheEffectofRainfallontheIncidenceofCholerainBangladesh.Epidemiology2008;19:103–10.

7 GasparriniA,LeoneM.Attributableriskfromdistributedlagmodels.BMCMedResMethodol2014;14:55.

8 LoverA,BuchyP,RachlineA,etal.Spatialepidemiologyandclimaticpredictorsofpaediatricdengueinfectionscapturedviasentinelsitesurveillance,PhnomPenhCambodia2011-2012.BMCPublicHealth2014;14:658.

9 BrownH,SpickettJ,KatscherianD.Ahealthimpactassessmentframeworkforassessingvulnerabilityandadaptationplanningforclimatechange.IntJEnvironResPublicHealth2014;11:12896–914.

10 SpickettJT,BrownHL,KatscherianD.AdaptationstrategiesforhealthimpactsofclimatechangeinWesternAustralia:ApplicationofaHealthImpactAssessmentframework.EnvironImpactAssessRev2011;31:297–300.

11 SpickettJT,KatscherianD.HealthImpactsofClimateChangeintheSolomonIslands:AnAssessmentandAdaptationActionPlan.GlobJHealthSci2014;6:261–73.

12 WilsonR,CrouchEa.Riskassessmentandcomparisons:anintroduction.Science1987;236:267–70.

13 RussellM,GruberM.Riskassessmentinenvironmentalpolicy-making.Science1987;236:286–90.

14 LaveLB.Healthandsafetyriskanalyses:informationforbetterdecisions.Science1987;236:291–5.

28 ChapterThree

15 BrownH,SpickettJ.HealthConsequenceScalesforUseinHealthImpactAssessmentsofClimateChange.IntJEnvironResPublicHealth2014;11:9607–20.

16 HeltbergR,SiegelPB,JorgensenSL.Addressinghumanvulnerabilitytoclimatechange:Towarda‘no-regrets’approach.GlobEnvironChange2009;19:89–99.

17 WardekkerJA,deJongA,vanBreeL,TurkenburgWC,vanderSluijsJP.Healthrisksofclimatechange:Anassessmentofuncertaintiesanditsimplicationsforadaptationpolicies.EnvironHealth2012;11:67.

29ChapterFour

ChapterFour

Paper1:HealthimpactsofclimatechangeinPacific

islandcountries:aregionalassessmentofvulnerabilities

andadapationpriorities

30 ChapterFour

Prelude

ThischaptersummarisesthePacificregionalclimatechangeandhealthprojectintermsof

itsprocesses,outcomesandimplications.Thefocusisonthemethodsandresultsofthe

vulnerabilityassessmentscarriedoutacrosstheregion,linkedwiththepriorityadaptation

strategiesplannedinPacificislandcountries.

Itisthemostup-to-dateandcomprehensivesynthesisofknowledgeregardingclimate

changeandhealthinthePacific,andcomplementstheforthcomingWHOreportentitled

“HumanHealthandClimateChangeinPacificIslandCountries”,compiledbythesame

authors,publishedinlate2015.

Thispaperreferencestheotherpublishedworksincludedinthisthesis,thusincorporating

thecountry-specificcomponentsoftheregionalproject,andalsodescribesthecommon

themestohaveemergedfromthevulnerabilityassessmentsandadaptationplanning

processesthroughouttheregion.

Thecandidate’sestimatedproportionalcontributionstothispaperwereasfollows:

Researchdesign: 70%

Analysisandinterpretation: 80%

Authorshipofpaper: 90%

ThispaperisreproducedwiththepermissionoftheNationalInstituteofEnvironmental

HealthSciences(USA),publishersofEnvironmentalHealthPerspectives.

Reference:McIverL,KimR,WoodwardA,HalesS,SpickettJ,KatscherianD,HashizumeM,

HondaY,KimH,IddingsS,NaickerJ,BambrickH,McMichaelA,EbiK.Healthimpactsof

climatechangeinPacificislandcountries.EnvironmentalHealthPerspectives2015(doi:

http://dx.doi.org/10.1289/ehp.1509756).

ENVIRONMENTALHEALTH PERSPECTIVES

Note to readers with disabilities: EHP will provide a 508-conformant version of this article upon final publication. If you require a 508-conformant version before then, please contact ehp508@niehs.nih.gov. Our staff will work with you to assess and meet your accessibility needs within 3 working days.

http://www.ehponline.org

ehpHealth Impacts of Climate Change in Pacific Island

Countries: A Regional Assessment of Vulnerabilities and Adaptation Priorities

Lachlan McIver, Rokho Kim, Alistair Woodward, Simon Hales, Jeffery Spickett, Dianne Katscherian, Masahiro Hashizume, Yasushi Honda, Ho Kim, Steven Iddings, Jyotishma Naicker, Hilary Bambrick, Anthony J. McMichael, and Kristie L. Ebi

http://dx.doi.org/10.1289/ehp.1509756

Received: 24 January 2015Accepted: 30 November 2015

Advance Publication: 8 December 2015

http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/accessibility/mailto:ehp508%40niehs.nih.gov?subject=http://dx.doi.org/10.1289/ehp.1509756

Environ Health Perspect DOI: 10.1289/ehp.1509756 Advance Publication: Not Copyedited

1

Health Impacts of Climate Change in Pacific Island Countries:

A Regional Assessment of Vulnerabilities and Adaptation

Priorities

Lachlan McIver,1,2 Rokho Kim,2 Alistair Woodward,3 Simon Hales,4 Jeffery Spickett,5

Dianne Katscherian,5 Masahiro Hashizume,6 Yasushi Honda,7 Ho Kim,8 Steven Iddings,2

Jyotishma Naicker,2 Hilary Bambrick,9 Anthony J. McMichael1*, and Kristie L. Ebi 10

1National Centre for Epidemiology and Population Health, Australian National University,

Canberra, Australia; 2World Health Organization, Western Pacific Regional Office, Division

of Pacific Technical Support, Suva, Fiji; 3School of Public Health, University of Auckland,

Auckland, New Zealand; 4Department of Public Health, University of Otago, Wellington,

New Zealand; 5World Health Organization Collaborating Centre for Environmental Health

Impact Assessment, Curtin University, Perth, Australia; 6Institute of Tropical Medicine,

Nagasaki University, Nagasaki, Japan; 7Faculty of Health and Sport Science, University of

Tsukuba, Tsukuba, Japan; 8Graduate School of Public Health, Seoul National University,

Seoul, Republic of Korea; 9Centre for Health Research, School of Medicine, University of

Western Sydney, Sydney, Australia; 10School of Public Health, University of Washington,

Seattle, USA. *Professor Tony McMichael passed away in 2014.

Address correspondence to Lachlan McIver, National Centre for Epidemiology and

Population Health, Australian National University, Canberra, A.C.T., 2601. Telephone: +61 3

9421 6754. E-mail: lachlan.mciver@gmail.com

Running title: Health and climate change in the Pacific region

Environ Health Perspect DOI: 10.1289/ehp.1509756 Advance Publication: Not Copyedited

2

Acknowledgments: This paper is the result of a collaborative project between the World

Health Organization Division of Pacific Technical Support and the ministries and

departments of health in thirteen Pacific island countries. While it is not possible to mention

all of the project’s collaborators, the authors would like to give special thanks to Yvonne

Underhill-Sem, Moses Pretrick, Seren Davies, Tebikau Tibwe, Russell Edwards, Manila

Nosa, Vili Nosa, Maireng Sengebau, Victoria Faasili, Bobby Patterson, Jimmy Hilly, Malakai

Ofanoa, Malakai Ake, Nese Ituaso-Conway, Teuila Percival, Brian Phillips, Shirley Laban,

Pakoa Rarua and the late Godfrey Waidubu. The authors would also like to add a special

acknowledgement to their co-author, colleague and friend, Anthony (Tony) McMichael – a

pioneer and leader in the field of global public health – who passed away during the

preparation of this final manuscript. The work conducted throughout the course of this

project was made possible by funding from the governments of the Republic of Korea and

Japan.

Competing financial interests: The authors declare they have no actual or potential

competing financial interests.

Environ Health Perspect DOI: 10.1289/ehp.1509756 Advance Publication: Not Copyedited

3

Abstract

Background: Between 2010 and 2012, the World Health Organization Division of Pacific

Technical Support led a regional climate change and health vulnerability assessment and

adaptation planning project, in collaboration with health sector partners, in thirteen Pacific

island countries - Cook Islands, Federated States of Micronesia, Fiji, Kiribati, Marshall

Islands, Nauru, Niue, Palau, Samoa, Solomon Islands, Tonga, Tuvalu and Vanuatu.

Objective: To assess the vulnerabilities of Pacific island countries to the health impacts of

climate change and plan adaptation strategies to minimize such threats to health.

Methods: This assessment involved a combination of quantitative and qualitative techniques.

The former included descriptive epidemiology, time series analyses, Poisson regression and

spatial modeling of climate and climate-sensitive disease data, in the few instances where this

was possible; the latter included wide stakeholder consultations, iterative consensus-building

and expert opinion. Vulnerabilities were ranked using a “likelihood versus impact” matrix,

and adaptation strategies prioritized and planned accordingly.

Results: The highest priority climate-sensitive health risks in Pacific island countries include

trauma from extreme weather events; heat-related illnesses; compromised safety and security

of water and food; vector-borne diseases; zoonoses; respiratory illnesses; psychosocial ill-

health; non-communicable diseases; population pressures and health system deficiencies.

Adaptation strategies relating to these climate change and health risks can be clustered

according to categories common to many countries in the Pacific region.

Conclusion: Pacific island countries are among the most vulnerable in the world to the health

impacts of climate change. This vulnerability is a function of their unique geographic,

demographic and socioeconomic characteristics, combined with their exposure to changing

weather patterns associated with climate change, the health risks entailed, and the limited

capacity of the countries to manage and adapt in the face of such risks.

Environ Health Perspect DOI: 10.1289/ehp.1509756 Advance Publication: Not Copyedited

4

Introduction

Climate change is widely acknowledged as one of the most serious global threats to future

human population health and international development (Costello et al. 2009; Stephenson et

al. 2013; Woodward et al. 2014). The Fifth Assessment Report (AR5) from the

Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) affirms that recent decades have seen

warming air and ocean temperatures; altered precipitation patterns; changes in the frequency

and intensity of some extreme events such as droughts, floods and storms; and rising sea

levels (Field et al. 2014). The AR5 also asserts with greater confidence that recent warming

is largely attributable to human activity than reported by the assessment published in 2007

(Parry et al. 2007). Further, there is increasing certainty these trends will continue or, in

some cases, accelerate (Field et al. 2014).

A changing climate has significant and diverse impacts on human health (McMichael and

Lindgren 2011; Woodward et al. 2014). The pathways by which climate change affects

health vary according to their modes of action and include primary or direct effects (e.g.

injuries and deaths caused by extreme weather events such as cyclones); secondary or

indirect effects (e.g. the increasing geographic range of, and population exposed to, vectors

that spread disease); and tertiary, diffuse and/or delayed effects (e.g. disruptions to health and

social services) (Butler and Harley 2010; McMichael 2013).

Pacific island countries (PICs) are among those most vulnerable to the health impacts of a

changing climate (Hanna and McIver 2014; Woodward et al. 2000). This vulnerability is a

function of their exposure to changing weather patterns associated with climate change, the

health risks entailed, and the limited capacity of the countries to manage and adapt in the face

of such risks. The climate change phenomena occurring in the Pacific pose a suite of health

hazards to the island communities across the region. A conceptualization of the pathways by

Environ Health Perspect DOI: 10.1289/ehp.1509756 Advance Publication: Not Copyedited

5

which climate change will affect health in the Pacific and the major anticipated impacts

throughout the region is shown in Figure 1.

In PICs, this vulnerability reflects the unique geographic, demographic and socio-economic

characteristics of small island developing states (SIDS) (Table 1) which, combined with their

contemporary burden of ill-health and relatively low health systems capacity, give credence

to their epithet of “canaries in the coalmine” of climate change and health (Hanna and McIver

2014).

Recognizing the risks to health posed by climate change, the WHO Regional Offices for the

Western Pacific and South-East Asia issued a joint Regional Framework for Action to Protect

Human Health from the Effects of Climate Change in the Asia-Pacific Region (WHO 2007).

This Framework committed all countries in the region to increasing awareness of climate

change and health; strengthening the capacity of health systems to protect against climate-

related health risks and reduce greenhouse gas emissions in the health sector; and ensuring

that health concerns were addressed in climate action in other sectors. Specific actions

mandated in the Framework included supporting formalized climate change and health

vulnerability assessments, and leading the health sector’s contribution to national adaptation

planning processes in the region.

Subsequently, the health ministers of PICs strengthened their commitments to action on

climate change at their biennial meeting in Madang, Papua New Guinea, in 2009. The

Madang Commitment included further recommendations related to vulnerability assessments

and adaptation planning, framing these within the Healthy Islands vision for health systems

development in the Pacific (Galea et al. 2000; WHO 2009).

Environ Health Perspect DOI: 10.1289/ehp.1509756 Advance Publication: Not Copyedited

6

This paper describes the process and outcomes of climate change and health vulnerability

assessments in thirteen SIDS in the Pacific region: Cook Islands, Federated States of

Micronesia, Fiji, Kiribati, Marshall Islands, Nauru, Niue, Palau, Samoa, Solomon Islands,

Tonga, Tuvalu and Vanuatu (see map in Figure 2).

The paper reports how these assessments link with adaptation planning; highlights some of

the unique challenges facing PICs in the context of climate change; and summarizes the

corresponding recommendations arising from the regional project. This paper is aimed at a

general scientific audience, and is a synthesis of the key technical findings and policy

implications of the forthcoming WHO report entitled Human Health and Climate Change in

Pacific Island Countries (McIver et al. 2015a).

Methods

Between 2010 and 2012, the WHO Division of Pacific Technical Support, with support from

the Western Pacific Regional Office (WPRO) and funding from the governments of Republic

of Korea and Japan, led a regional climate change and health vulnerability and adaptation

project involving eleven PICs: Cook Islands, Federated States of Micronesia (FSM), Kiribati,

Marshall Islands, Nauru, Niue, Palau, Solomon Islands, Tonga, Tuvalu and Vanuatu. This

project was implemented in three phases, with the eleven countries divided into three groups

on broadly geographic lines, and a team of expert climate change and health consultants

guiding and assisting each group. These eleven countries form the majority of independent

or autonomous states in the Pacific region, along with Fiji and Samoa, which carried out

related projects (see below). Papua New Guinea has been involved in a separate climate

change and health project, along with other countries in the Western Pacific region, so was

not included; the French territories of New Caledonia, French Polynesia and Wallis and

Futuna were excluded for similar reasons.

Environ Health Perspect DOI: 10.1289/ehp.1509756 Advance Publication: Not Copyedited

7

In the first phase, sub-regional inception meetings were held in Auckland, New Zealand (for

the group that included Cook Islands, Kiribati, Niue, Tonga and Tuvalu); Honiara, Solomon

Islands (for Nauru, Solomon Islands and Vanuatu); and Pohnpei, FSM (for FSM, Marshall

Islands and Palau). During these meetings, the science of climate change and health was

reviewed, along with the relevant work hitherto conducted in each country, and plans were

laid for the in-country vulnerability assessment and adaptation planning phases of the project.

The second phase involved a mixed-methods approach to ascertain each country’s climate-

sensitive health risks, based on a combination of review and analysis of climate and health

data; stakeholder consultations; and an assessment of the potential impacts of a changing

climate across different aspects of society. Where possible, epidemiological analysis was

carried out on the available data on historical climate variables and climate-sensitive diseases

(e.g. diarrhoeal disease, dengue fever and leptospirosis). This was only possible in some

countries, where the data was adequate (in terms of quality and quantity) and the technical

support was available. The sophistication of the modeling undertaken ranged from simple

reviews of disease burdens and weather patterns in Kiribati (McIver et al. 2014) to Poisson

regression models in FSM (McIver et al. 2015b) and similar techniques, combined with

spatial modeling, for multiple climate-sensitive diseases in Fiji (McIver et al. 2012). The

results of these country-specific analyses have not been included in this paper, which instead

provides a more general, regional overview.

In the final phase, each country’s climate change and health vulnerabilities were assessed via

a “likelihood-versus-consequence” matrix. This tool was used to rank climate-sensitive

health priorities, rationalize resources, and focus the activities of the health sector on the most

urgent adaptation activities. Its use was based on precedents in Australia (Brown et al. 2014)

and growing evidence of its utility in this context in Pacific island countries such as Vanuatu

Environ Health Perspect DOI: 10.1289/ehp.1509756 Advance Publication: Not Copyedited

8

(Spickett and Katscherian 2014; Spickett et al. 2013). In the use of this matrix, each climate-

sensitive health risk was considered in terms of the likelihood of the burden of disease

increasing with climate change (over a twenty year time-frame), a range of climate change

projections (as localized as possible), and the impact of such an increased health burden

occurring (considering the resilience or coping capacity of the community and health sector

to manage such consequences).

Each Pacific island country differed in terms of their willingness and perceived capacity to

manage their respective highest-priority climate-sensitive health risks. Some elected to

include most or all of these hazards in their adaptation plans; others chose to concentrate on

the few health impacts deemed to represent the greatest threat, according to the

abovementioned matrix. Thus, the climate-sensitive health risks presented in the Results

below should be considered a synthesis of each country’s respective priorities, rather than a

true cross-country comparison of risks.

Following the prioritization of these climate change-related health vulnerabilities, relevant

adaptation strategies were planned accordingly. Adaptation measures were categorised as

follows: legislative and regulatory; public education and communication; surveillance and

monitoring; ecosystem intervention; infrastructure development; technological and

engineering responses; medical intervention; and research.

Each adaptation measure was prioritised for each PIC according to its local relevance, the

current capacity of the health system, the inclusion of vulnerable groups, the manner in which

adaptations could be implemented, and the identification of sectors that would be involved in

the development and implementation of the adaptation strategies. The country teams – which

were typically, but not exclusively, led by the Ministry of Health or its equivalent, in

collaboration with other government departments, civil society organisations and major

Environ Health Perspect DOI: 10.1289/ehp.1509756 Advance Publication: Not Copyedited

9

private sector stakeholders - chose the factors that would be included, and decided upon their

relative weighting.

These vulnerabilities and the responses required from the health sector were incorporated into

National Climate Change and Health Action Plans (NCCHAPs), or an equivalent thereof.

These domestic policy documents are in various stages of finalisation and implementation

across the Pacific island countries participating in this regional project.

The vulnerability assessment and adaptation planning process was slightly different for

Samoa. An initial workshop on health aspects of vulnerability and adaptation to climate

change was conducted in Apia in 2010, as part of a national project entitled “Integrating

Climate Change Risks in the Agriculture and Health Sectors in Samoa”. Building on this

work, in 2013, a climate change and health adaptation strategy and action plan was developed

for Samoa.

The approach was different again for Fiji, which since 2010 has been taking part in a global

climate change and health adaptation pilot project, led by WHO with support from the United

Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and funding from the Global Environment

Facility (GEF - https://www.thegef.org/). In Fiji’s Piloting Climate Change Adaptation to

Protect Human Health project, a small number of priority climate-sensitive diseases were

selected as the focus for the vulnerability assessment, research, capacity-building, community

education and adaptation elements of the project (McIver et al. 2012).

The process outlined above broadly followed the guidelines laid out by WHO on

vulnerability assessment and adaptation planning (Kovats et al. 2003; WHO 2013a). Table 2

compares the WHO theoretical framework with the actual steps implemented in the

abovementioned PICs.

Environ Health Perspect DOI: 10.1289/ehp.1509756 Advance Publication: Not Copyedited

10

In each of the thirteen PICs, efforts were made to include mechanisms for monitoring and

evaluation and iterative information management – for example, the incorporation of updated

data on climate and climate-sensitive diseases – into each NCCHAP (Ebi 2014).

Results

Table 3 summarizes the climate-sensitive health risks prioritised in each country’s

vulnerability assessment. These risks are subdivided into three categories: direct, indirect

and diffuse effects, in accordance with the international nomenclature (McMichael and

Lindgren 2011; McMichael et al. 2013). Examples of direct effects include the traumatic

injuries and deaths that occur during hydro-meteorological disasters, and the detrimental

physiological consequences of heatwaves. Indirect effects occur through disruption of

ecological systems; examples include increased pathogen loads in food and water in hotter

and/or more humid conditions, and the altered geographic ranges and biting habits of

mosquitoes that spread diseases such as malaria and dengue fever. Diffuse effects relate to

societal dysfunction, of which disrupted health services, population displacement and

potential conflict over climate-related resources are key examples (Kjellstrom and

McMichael 2013).

This was not compiled as – nor was it intended to be – a comprehensive list, describing every

conceivable climate change-attributable risk to health; only those risks regarded by the

country teams as most important at the present time are included in this summary table. This

table is also not intended to serve as a tool for comparison, as while all countries used a

similar process of prioritising climate change and health vulnerabilities, each country differed

in terms of the number of these hazards they felt it appropriate to address in their respective

adaptation plans. Thus, the absence of an entry in a row for a particular country in Table 3

should not be necessarily be interpreted to mean that the country did not perceive that

Environ Health Perspect DOI: 10.1289/ehp.1509756 Advance Publication: Not Copyedited

11

climate-sensitive health risk to be a problem; rather that this was not among the most

immediate priorities for that country at that time.

Table 3 displays some common themes in terms of climate-sensitive health risks across the

Pacific. Climate change-attributable impacts on extreme weather events and diseases related

to food, water and vectors are prominent concerns throughout the region. Specific diseases

such as dengue fever, malaria, diarrhoeal illness, leptospirosis, typhoid fever, respiratory

infections, obstructive airways disease and malnutrition are generally considered to be highly

climate-sensitive (Woodward et al. 2014). There is thus a clear and relatively urgent need for

these and other hazards (such as the health effects of heat and extreme weather events) to be

considered in the context of climate change in the Pacific, and anticipated accordingly

(Haines et al. 2014).

However, there are some climate-related health risks that are of concern in the Pacific to an

extent not documented elsewhere in the world – notably non-communicable diseases

(NCDs), disorders of mental/psychosocial health and ciguatera (Mannava et al. 2013; WHO

2013b). The potential for climate change to amplify the drivers of NCD risk in the Pacific is

considered in more detail below.

In addition, there are other important aspects of health vulnerability in the region that are

unique to, or at least uniquely highly prioritized in, a small number of Pacific island

countries. These include high fertility rates and overcrowding in atoll nations such as

Kiribati which, combined with limited land area, low elevation and the threat posed by rising

seas, may lead to forced relocation – which brings with it a particular suite of health

complications (McMichael et al. 2012; Berry et al. 2010).

Environ Health Perspect DOI: 10.1289/ehp.1509756 Advance Publication: Not Copyedited

12

Women and children are expected to experience a disproportionate burden of climate change

and health impacts in the Pacific (Lawler 2011) and elsewhere, particularly in the developing

world (Field et al. 2014).

With respect to adaptation, a number of strategies have been proposed and are being

implemented across the Pacific region. While some adaptation measures are country-specific

(for example, developing legislation around cultural practices such as kava-drinking to

protect against water-borne diseases, or experimenting with drought- and salt-resistant taro

and cassava crops), the majority may be grouped under broad categories aligned with the

abovementioned vulnerabilities. These include:

• Ensuring health and safety considerations are incorporated into adaptation activities

across sectors (“Health in All Policies” approach);

• Improving the safety and security of food and water;

• Improving sanitation and hygiene facilities;

• Increased resourcing for health emergency risk management;

• Climate-proofing key health and safety infrastructure;

• Enhanced surveillance targeting climate-sensitive diseases and their risk sources

• Applied environmental epidemiological research focusing on climate-sensitive

diseases; and

• New and improved communication pathways between the health sector, meteorology

services and other stakeholders, including trialling and evaluating climate-based early

warning systems.

Environ Health Perspect DOI: 10.1289/ehp.1509756 Advance Publication: Not Copyedited

13

Discussion

The climate change and health vulnerability assessment and adaptation planning project in

the Pacific is similar in some respects to the corresponding work being carried out in other

regions (Brooks and Adger 2003; Confalonieri et al. 2009; Wolf et al. 2014). However, there

are some significant differences in terms of the process, findings and implications that

distinguish climate change and health issues in PICs from other countries of the world.

In terms of process, the precise methods by which the assessments were performed and

adaptations planned varied from country to country. These included highly focused, largely

quantitative assessments in the Marshall Islands and FSM, as distinct from a more

deliberative, qualitative process employed in Nauru, Solomon Islands and Vanuatu, where a

modified environmental health impact assessment approach was employed (Spickett and

Katscherian 2014; Spickett et al. 2013). In Kiribati, a mixed-methods, ‘middle way’

approach proved effective in combining a review and analysis of the available data with a

pragmatic process of inter-agency collaboration and stakeholder engagement, which has

contributed to Kiribati’s NCCHAP being among the first to undergo government ratification

and implementation (McIver et al. 2014).

With respect to outcomes, the issue of NCDs, in particular, was of unprecedented prominence

in the Pacific in the face of climate change. With PICs already experiencing the highest rates

of NCDs in the world (Mannava et al. 2013), the potential for climate change to act as an

additional driver of NCD risk is considerable and of significant concern.

While the literature on climate change and NCDs is relatively scant, and has hitherto focused

primarily on the implications of heat on individuals with pre-existing NCDs (Friel et al. 2011;

Kjellstrom and McMichael 2013; Kovats and Hajat 2008; Shubair et al. 2013), in the Pacific

region there is a very real concern that climate change may act as an additional risk factor for

Environ Health Perspect DOI: 10.1289/ehp.1509756 Advance Publication: Not Copyedited

14

NCDs. It is likely that the Pacific region is – or will be – the first to experience the

consequences of the interaction between climate