fracture analysis and mapping of the cretaceous boquillas ...• fracture analysis of the boquillas...
TRANSCRIPT
-
FractureanalysisandmappingoftheCretaceousBoquillasFormation,BlackGapWildlife
ManagementArea,BrewsterCounty,TXWilliams,J.W.,Alsleben,H.,andEnderlin,M.B.
SchoolofGeology,Energy,andtheEnvironment,TexasChristianUniversity,FortWorth,TX76129
• StratigraphicunitsalongwithprominenttopographicfeatureslocatednearHeathCanyonmayrePlectthestressesoftwomajordeformationalepisodes:Laramide-related
shorteningandBasinandRangeextension.ShorteningstressesduringtheLaramideOrogenyproducedtheSierradelCarmenMountains,thehighpeakswithinalongthe
westernborderoBlackGapWMA.Thelocationofthestudyareamaybeanorth-easternextensionofthismountainrange.BasinandRangeextensionalstressesgenerated
high-anglenormalfaultsandhalf-grabenstructureswhichjuxtaposeSantaElenaLimestoneagainsttheyoungerBudaLimestoneandBoquillasFormation.Thesefaultsare
consistentwithBasinandRange-relatedhigh-anglenormalfaultswithinBigBendNationalPark.Additionally,asaresultofthisfaulting,stratigraphicunitswithinthearea
aretilted~10-15°tothesouthwest.
• FractureanalysisoftheBoquillasFormationwithinHeathCanyonrevealsaconjugatesetoffractures.Set1hasanaveragestrike/dipof223°/63°.Set2hasanaverage
strikeanddipof53°/75°.Paleostressdirectionsmaybeinferredasroughlynortheast/southwestbasedontheaveragestrikeofthesefracturesetswhichisconsistentwith
thepaleostressdirectionsassociatedwithLaramidedeformation.
• PreviousstudiesshowalinearrelationshipbetweenmodeIfracturespacingandbedthickness.Datainthisstudyshowanon-lineartrendbetweenthesetwovariables
whichsuggeststhattheBoquillasFormationfracturesdifferentlythantheformationsanalyzedinpreviousstudies,thefracturesseeninthisstudyarenotmodeIfractures,
orthattheclassiPicationoflayeringforthisstudywasincorrect.
• Lithologymayplayaroleintheverticalpersistenceoffractures.XRFanalysisallowsthecarbonaterocklayersoftheBoquillasFormationtobeclassiPiedintoeithercalcite
dominantlimestonesorcalcite-claydominantmarls.Thesetwochemicallydistinctrockstypesexhibitdifferingrockstrengthvalues.Limestonelayersgenerallyhavehigher
strengthvaluesthanmarllayers,afunctionofhighercalciteandlowerclaycontent.Duetothestrength,limestonesbehaveinamorebrittlemannerthanmarlsallowing
fracturestopropagatemorereadily.
• Thoughpreviousstudiessuggestthenatureofbed-to-bedtransitions,gradationalorabrupt,affecttheverticalpersistenceoffractures.dataproducedinthisstudyshow
littledifferenceinthefrequencyofthrough-goingfractureswhenthelayerinterfaceisgradualorabruptwithinlimestone-to-marltransitions.However,whentheinterface
iscomposedofthinashbeds,thereisamarkeddecreaseinthefrequencyofthrough-goingfractures.
Abstract Data
Background
Analysis
Conclusions
Figure3:BrükerTracerIII-Venergy-dispersivex-rayPluorescence(ED-XRF)spectrometer(ImagefromBruker
2015).
Figure1:EquotipBambino2micro-reboundhammermetalhardnesstester(ImagefromProceq).
16°
08°
06°
02°
09°
07°23°
21°
13°
19°
26°
10°
26°
10°
06° 05°
05°
04°
01°
01°
04°
06°
10°
03°07°
03°06°
07°
10°
12°
14°
04°
08°
01°
05°
01°
05°
08°
03°05°
04°
06°
14°
09°
07°11°
03°
25°
07°
05°08°
15°09°
12°
09°
07°
09°
17°
06°
05°
12°
11°
22°27°
13°
04°
01°
07°
09°
Sources: Esri, HERE, DeLorme, Intermap, increment P Corp., GEBCO, USGS, FAO,NPS, NRCAN, GeoBase, IGN, Kadaster NL, Ordnance Survey, Esri Japan, METI, EsriChina (Hong Kong), swisstopo, MapmyIndia, © OpenStreetMap contributors, and theGIS User Community
704000.000000
704000.000000
705000.000000
705000.000000
706000.000000
706000.000000
707000.000000
707000.000000
708000.000000
708000.000000
709000.000000
709000.000000
3264100.
0000
00
3264100.
0000
00
3265000.
0000
00
3265000.
0000
00
3265900.
0000
00
3265900.
0000
00
3266800.
0000
00
3266800.
0000
00
3267700.
0000
00
3267700.
0000
00
±
LegendLinestype
Contact³ Fault
³ ³ Fault Inferred
Kse
Kbu
Kb
Qg
Qal0 0.45 0.9 1.35 1.80.225
km
A
A’
TheEagleFordShaleinsouthTexasisoneofthemostproliPicunconventionalhydrocarbonplaysintheworld(Breyer,2016).).
In2015,naturalgasandoilfromthisPieldhitpeakproductionnumbersat5,539MMcf(millioncubicfeet)and1,118,648Bbl
(barrels)perday,respectively(TexasRRC,2016).InSeptemberof2016,theEagleFordShaleproduced1,027,000Bblperday,
approximately23%ofunconventionaloilproducedintheUnitedStatesforthatmonth(EIA,2016).Inorderforthislow-
permeabilityformationtoproduce,companiesareusinghydraulicfracturing,astimulationtreatmentusedinlow-permeabilityrock
wherebyPluidsarepumpedathighpressuresintoreservoirs,causingnewfracturestoopenand/orthereactivationofexisting
fractures(Schlumberger,2016).
Theaimofthisstudyistoidentifyanygeomechanicalandgeochemicalpropertiesthatoptimizefractureconnectivitywithinthe
BoquillasFormation,theWestTexasEagleFordShaleequivalent.TheBoquillasFormationiscomposedofalternatingbedsof
calcareousshale,marlandlimestone,rocktypesdePinedbytheircalcite,clay,andsilicacontent.
Herewepresentageologicmapcompletedat1:6000scaleoftheareainandaroundHeathCanyonaswellasdatatakenfrom
fouroutcropstationswithinHeathCanyon.Mappingwascompletedtounderstandlocaldeformation.Fracturespacing,frequency,
andverticalpersistencemeasurementsweretakeninthePieldaswellasrockstrengthandhardnessmeasurements.Rockstrength
wasmeasuredusingtheEquotipBambino2(Fig.1)androckhardnesswasdeterminedusingapointloadpenetrometer(dimpler)
(Fig.2).Energy-dispersivex-rayPluorescence(ED-XRF)datadeterminedthebulkelementalcompositionofthematerialandsemi-
quantitativelyassesschemicalvariationsthroughouttheoutcrop.ED-XRFanalyseswerecompletedusingaBrukerTracerIII-V
spectrometer(Fig.3).ED-XRFandstrength/hardnessdatafromthisstudysuggeststhatfracturefrequencyandlengthareaffected
bytheclayandcalciumcarbonatecontent,and,byinference,thestrengthoftherock.
Figure2:Pointloadpenetrometer(dimpler)modeofoperation(top)andgraphshowingthe
relationshipbetween“tick”marksandunconPined
compressivestrength.
Figure8:(left)Geologicmap
(1:6000)ofthe
areainand
aroundHeath
Canyon,Black
GapWildlife
Management
Area.
BlackGapWildlifeManagementArea(WMA)encompassesapproximately
103,000acres(160mi2)(414km2)withintheTrans-Pecosregionofwest
Texas(Fig.1).TheTrans-PecosisboundedbythePecosRivertotheeast,the
thirty-secondparalleltothenorth,andbytheRioGrandeRivertothesouth
andwest.ThewildlifemanagementareaiseastofBigBendNationalPark.
BlackGapWMAisapartoftheChihuahuadesertbiomeandisunderthe
managementofTexasParksandWildlife.
TheTrans-PecosregionofTexashasexperiencedmultiplemajor
deformationalepisodesincluding:(1)LatePaleozoicshorteningassociated
withtheOuachitaorogeny,(2)CretaceoustoTertiaryLaramideshortening
andtranspressionaldeformation,and(3)TertiaryBasinandRangeextension
(MuehlbergerandDickerson,1989;Maxwelletal.,1967;St.John,1966)(Fig.
5).TheTrans-Pecosalsoexperiencedwidespreadmagmatismfromthe
MesozoicthroughtheCenozoicrelatedtotheLaramideorogenyandBasin
andRangeextension(Turneret.al.,2011).
TherockunitswithinBlackGapWMAareCretaceousoryounger.The
LateCretaceousmarinerocksweredepositedoncarbonateplatforms
northeastoftheChihuahuaTrough,whichformedduringlateTriassicrifting
associatedwiththeopeningoftheGulfofMexico(Fig.6).Thisriftbasinwas
locatedeast-northeastofasubductionrelatedmagmaticarc,whichwasthe
sourceforLateCretaceousclasticsedimentsintheTrans-Pecos(Lehmanand
Busbey,2007).The
carbonateplatforms
thatdevelopedinthe
EarlyCretaceouswere
thesiteofdeposition
fortheSantaElena
Limestone,theBuda
Limestone,andthe
BoquillasFormation,
whicharethe
dominantunitsinthe
studyarea(Fig.7).
Asidefrombeing
widespreadinthe
studyarea,rocksthat
make-uptheCoahuila
Platformunderliethe
majorityoftheTrans-
Pecosregion(Lehman
andBusbey,2007).
Figure7:StratigraphicColumnoftheBigBendarea(ModiPiedfromTiedemann,2010).
Figure5:MajortectonicepisodeswithinTrans-PecosTexas(fromMuehlbergerandDickinson,1989).
A
B
C
D
Figure10A-D:Outcropstations1-4(A-Drespectively)photosandlinedrawings
withassociateddatatablesbelow(photos
donothavetheresolutiontoincludeall
fracturesinlinedrawings).
Figure11A-D:Stereonetdataofbeddingplanesforoutcropstations1-4(A-D
respectively).
Figure12A-D:Stereonetdataoffracturesforoutcropstations1-4(A-D
respectively).
Figure13A&B:XRFdataforallbedswithineachoutcropstation(A).The
averagecalicite-quartz-claycontentof
eachsample.(LS=limestone)(B).
A
B
Breyer,J.A.2016,Introduction,inAAPGMemoir110:TheEagleFordShale:ArenaissanceinU.S.oilproduction,pp.259-283.
Brüker2015,Tracerseriesoverview.Accessed:April6,2015.https://www.bruker.com/products/x-ray-diffraction-and-elemental-analysis/handheld-xrf/tracer-iii/overview.html
Lehman,T.M.,andBusbey,A.B.,2007,SocietyofVertebratePaleontologyFall2007BigBendFieldTripGuidebook,Austin,SocietyofVertebratePaleontology.
Muehlberger,W.R.,andDickerson,P.W.1989,StructureandstratigraphyofTrans-PecosTexas:ElPasotoGuadalupeMountainsandBigBendGuidebook,20-29July.Washington,D.C.:AmericanGeophysicalUnion.
Maxwell,R.A.,Lonsdale,J.T.,Hazzard,R.T.andWilson,J.A.1967,GeologyofBigBendNationalPark,BrewsterCounty,Texas.UniversityofTexasatAustin,BureauofEconomicGeology,TexasUniv.Pub.6711.
Proceq.EquotipBambino2ProceqMetalHardnesTesters.LastmodiPiedOctober17,2016.AccessedOctober17,2016.http://www.proceq.com/jp/nondestructivetestequipment/metal-testing/hardness-testing/equotip-
bambino-2.html
RailroadCommissionofTexas(TexasRRC)2016,EagleFordShaleinformation.LastmodiPied:April5.AccessedApril13,2016.http://www.rrc.state.tx.us/oil-gas/major-oil-gas-formations/eagle-ford-shale/
St.John,B.1966,GeologyofBlackGapArea,BrewserCounty,Texas.geologicalquadranglemapGQ-0030BureauofEconomicGeology,vol.18,UniversityofTexasatAustin(1966)geologicmapscale:1:62,500
Tiedemann,N.S.2010,ThesequencestratigraphyoftheCommanchean-GulPianinterval,BigBendNationalPark,WestTexas.[Master’sthesis]BallStateUniversity.
Turner,K.J.,Berry,M.E.,Page,W.R.,Lehman,T.M.,Bohannon,R.G.,Scott,R.B.,Miggins,D.P.,Budahn,J.R.,Cooper,R.W.,andDrenth,B.J.,2011,GeologicmapofBigBendNationalPark,Texas:USDepartmentoftheInterior,US
GeologicalSurvey.
U.S.EnergyInformationAdministration(EIA)2016,Drillingproductivityreport.LastmodiPiedSeptember12.AccessedOctober25,2016http://www.eia.go/petroleum/drilling/archive/2016/09
References
Figure14A,B,&C:Cross-plotsofUCS(psi)(bambinoinblue&dimplerinred)vsXRFdataforallbedswithineachoutcropstation.
UCSvs.calcite(%Ca)showsapositivecorrelation(A).UCSvs.quartz
(%Si)showsnotrend(B),whereasUCSvsclay(%Al)showsa
negativecorrelation(C).
A
B
C
Figure9:(right)Locationofthe
fouroutcrop
stationswithin
HeathCanyon.
Figure 16: Stereonet displaying the orientation of both sets of fractures with inferred paleostress directions.
• Highanglenormalfaultsassociatedwith
TertiaryBasinandRangeextensionare
responsibleforthepresentdaytopography
withinthemappingarea.Thedeformation
associatedwithBasinandRangeextension
causedthetiltingofgeologicunitsaswellas
forminghalf-grabenstructuresalonghigh-
anglenormalfaultswhichjuxtaposeolder
andyoungerrocks(Fig.15A&B).
• Fracturesaremorelikelytobethrough-
goinginlayersofmorecompetentrock.
Conversely,fracturesweremorelikelyto
terminatewithinoratthecontactofabedin
thickerlesscompetentrock(Figure10A-D).
• Ingeneral,fractureswithineachoutcropcan
bedividedinto2sets:Set1averagestrike/
dipis223°/63°.Set2averagestrike/dipis
53°/55°(Figs.XA-D).Maximumpaleostress
directionscanbeinferredbasedonthis
conjugateset,roughlyNE/SWinthiscase
(Fig.16)
• RocksoftheBoquillasFormationtendtobe
morecalcareouswithcertainlayers
containinghigherclayandquartzcontent.
Overall,theBoquillasFormationatthis
locationismoreclay-poorthantheaverage
EagleFordShalecomposition(Figure13A&
B)
• Cross-plotsofXRFvs.UCSsuggestthat
strengthoftherockincreasesascalcite
contentincreaseandclaycontentdecreases.
Additionally,thedimplermethodshoweda
strongercorrelationwithelementaldata
thantheBambino.TheBambinorequiresa
relativelysmoothsurfacetotake
measurementsonwhilethedimplerdoes
not.Thiscouldbeonereasonforthe
differenceinUCSvalues(14A,B,&C).
B
A
Figure 15 A & B: Geologic map draped over a digital elevation model of Heath Canyon and the surrounding area. View looking south-southwest (A) and a view looking west-southwest (B).
ChihuahuaTrough
CoahuilaPlatform
Figure6:PaleogeographicreconstructionoftheNorthAmericancontinentduringthedepositionoftheBoquillasFormation(93.2Ma).Theblackovalsoutlinethe
approximatelocationoftheChihuahuaTrough(left)andthecarbonateplatformon
whichsedimentsweredepositedduringthistime(modiPiedfromBlakey,2017).
N
14miles(22km)
Figure4:LocationsoftheTransPecosregionofTexas(right,blackpolygon)andBlackGapWildlifeManagementArea(left,redpolygon).