formative assessment in classroom practice
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
1/29
Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
Submitted by
May Phoo Mon
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
2/29
Content
1. Introduction
1.1. The place of English in Myanmar
2. The objective of teaching writing and how teachers are teaching and how it is
assessed
3. How can I modify the current teaching strategy of writing skills
4. What is formative assessment?
4.1. Is there any formative assessment in class?
4.2. How it is different from current assessment system?
5. How formative assessment can be used in teaching writing?
5.1. The useful principles/ characteristics for teaching writing and why?
5.2. Some teaching strategies that teacher can use for teaching writing
6. Is there any constraint that will encounter and how to overcome?
7. Conclusion
8. Reference
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
3/29
1. Introduction
1.1. The place of English in Myanmar
In Myanmar, the place of English can be safely addressed as a foreign language, as almost
everyone, who is learning English, never uses that language in their daily life and what is our
official and mother tongue for everyone in Myanmar is Burmese (Myanmar). Moreover, in
Myanmar, English is taught for different purposes: some language school, especially private
language schools focus communication, while some schools, especially government basic
education schools, teach English for academic purposes, for instance, to be able to handle
long written assignments and to comprehend long and complex reading texts, which will
encounter in their academic life. We can infer how the English is being taught by looking
the main objectives of the current high school syllabus as an example:
1.
To build up and enrich vocabulary of the learners
2. To train learners to do as much independent reading as possible
3. To expose learners to a variety of contemporary English writing
4. To help learners assimilate the grammar, lexis, syntax and idiom of the English
language
5. To help learners develop their reading and writing skills in English.
So, it can be safely assumed that the basic education in Myanmar focuses on the
development of reading and writing skills in English, in other words, the main aim of basic
education would be the linguistics competence, not communicative competence. In this
paper, I am going to cover how to teach writing in high school and how can I apply the
formative assessment to give rise more effective teaching and learning. Thus, the next
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
4/29
section of this paper will cover how teachers are teaching writing in high schools and how
students are being assessed, and the outcomes of this teaching strategies and assessments.
2. How teachers are teaching writing skill and how it is assessed in high school
Needless to say, as the objective teaching English of government basic education schools is
to be able to comprehend the complex texts and long writing assignments which our
students may encounter in their higher education (for example, university and college), the
majority of lessons is spent by teaching reading comprehension, rules and structures of
sentences and vocabulary. However, what surprisingly found out is that very small part of
lesson is covered by teaching extensive writing: essays and letters. In others words, in high-
schools, the English-language classes consist of 5 periods per weeks and each period is 45
minutes. However, teachers just spend only 45 minutes on teaching writing per week, which
is one period. Moreover, what also found out is that most of writing is essays and letters,
which intend students to develop how the texts are constructed for social exchanges and
displaying knowledge or information (Marilyn Lewis, 2009, Pg5).
Additionally, in English-language teaching classes, the way that language teachers teach
writing skills, including grammar, essays and letters, is totally explicit and the contexts are
very artificial and not real-life. That is to say, the students are taught the new structures,
which are usually isolated sentences and lacking context, essays or letters by giving the
samples by the teachers, and then, teachers explain these new languages in mother tongue
and word-by-word translation (use especially when they teach essays and letters). After
that, the next stage of teaching is that teachers give them grammar exercises; for instance,
filling the gap with the correct forms, connecting sentences in the correct ways, unjumble
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
5/29
sentences, rewrite sentences, etc., which are isolated sentences and lacking context, and
ask them to write the parallel essays and letters as samples at home or sometimes in class.
Furthermore, unfortunately, it is a shame to say that the majority of teacher in Myanmar
focus on the product of writing, what are the form of good writing? , rather than on the
how is good writing performed? (Donovan, 1980 , X). The writing tasks done by students
are assessed by certain criteria, such as content, organization, vocabulary use, grammatical
use and mechanical considerations, for instance spelling and punctuation (H. Douglas
Brown, 2007) without any explanation of the mistakes that students made and suggestion
for improvement. Thus, teachers teach writing skills according to the way it is evaluat ed,
where the emphasis is on grammar and mechanic rather than the content (Pavlik, 1986).
Therefore, as students are not being provided any comments and feedbacks from teachers,
they have no idea about what they are lacking and what they need to learn more in order to
improve their weakness. On the top of that, it seems to me that the current teaching
strategy for writing skills is not as productive as the syll abus writers expectations.
Accordingly, in next session, I will cover how current teaching strategies for writing skills
could be modified if I taught according to the syllabus of high school.
3. How can I modify the current teaching strategy of writing skills?
It is very true to say that most of high schools are rarely teaching how to write essays and
letters. To put it in another way, they are given samples essays and letters, and then,
teacher explain these in word-by-word translation, without explaining anything about the
format, and asks them to write similar essays and letters at home, rather than encouraging
them to go beyond the idea and format of samples essays and letters. Moreover, the
teacher usually evaluates students writing according grammatical use, vocabulary use ,
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
6/29
spelling and punctuation. Hence, what is happening is that when such kinds of students sit
for Matriculation Examination, they usually encounter the problem of time-managing. In
Matriculation Examination, the candidates write a guided composition, an essay and a
letter, which are unseen topics. Here, what makes students difficult to manage time is that
as they have never gone beyond the ideas and format of samples, they are severely
hindered by mental block (H. Douglas Brown , 2007, Pg.392), which is inability to come out
any new ideas and continue a train of thoughts. Therefore, by considering the outcome of
current teaching strategies, I come up with an alternative way of teaching: the combination
of process and product writing. Actually, as teachers teach English through structural
approach, almost all students are quite competence in language forms. So much so that,
what is missing is the process writing: brainstorming, drafting, and editing, redrafting and
final writing.
4. The learning objectives of teaching writing
I assume that it would be worthy to admit that, currently, I am not teaching high school
level and not even at government schools, but, actually, I was working for a private summer
school. However, if I had a chance to teach high school English course, I would like to set
following objectives for learning writing:
1. Student must be aware about the format of good writing (product) and how to
perform (process).
2. Student must be able to write accurately as well as fluently.
3. Students must be able to see their own mistakes and correct them.
4. Students must be able to produce their own relevant ideas and evaluate these ideas
in relation to the purpose, topic and audience.
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
7/29
5. Students must be able to use formal and informal (register) according to the
audience.
5. What is formative assessment?
There should not be any doubt that, traditionally, summative assessments, which are
usually held at the end of the learning period or a semester, are the only way to get the
information about students mastery, understanding, and competency in a particular
subject. However, by and large, it is a fact that the summative assessments actually can only
provide the information of our students learning to a limited extent. To make this clear,
what happening in many country, including Myanmar, is that summative assessment, such
as nationwide matriculation examinations, gives rise the spot question and teaching to the
test, that is to say, teacher teach students only what is necessary for passing exams(
Assessment reform Group, the role of teachers in the assessment of learning). Apart from
these, there are another obvious negative impact of summative assessment on students
learning styles and performance during the exam. This means that as summative
assessments are usually appear at long interval and they assess the whole things that were
taught during that interval (for instance, during a semester), almost everyone students find
this assessment is stressful. Besides that, some students just study or practice the past exam
papers or even some of them, which cram for that exam. Therefore, needless to say, such
drawbacks of the summative assessment cannot give the correct figure of students
achievement in learning.
In contrast, formative assessment appears before, during, and after instruction (Laura
Greenstein, What teachers really know about formative assessment, Pg. 2). Moreover, while
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
8/29
summative assessment is very teacher-centered, the formative assessments is student
focused, that is to say, the formative assessment is the process of measuring how well
students receive the information, how well they understand it, and how they can apply it.
(Laura Greenstein, What Teacher Really Know about Formative Assessment, Pg.16).
Additionally, Thomas A. Angelo and K. Patricia Cross claimed in Classroom Assessment
Techniques that the classroom assessments provide teachers with the evidence to make
useful feedback on what, how much, and how well their students are learning.
Moreover, it is very true to say that formative assessments give the reliable evidence of
individual students progress as well as their weak ness, then, teacher can give effective
feedback and suggestion for improvement individually, as well as immediately. So much so
that, there should not be any doubt to claim that the formative assessment is based on a
belief: No student is left behind. Besides that, the formative assessment gives non -
threatening comment and feedback, rather than public announcement of grades, scores and
ranks which can cause low achieving students anxious and stressful which can demotivate
them in their learning. Thus, Rick Stiggins (2005) addressed formative assessment as
scaffolding which assists students, even low -achieving students, to reach the goals (Rick
Stiggins, From Formative Assessment to Assessment For Learning). Therefore, without a doubt, it is
true to say that the formative assessment has powerful impact on the learning and it is labeled as
Assessment for Learning (AFL).
Apart from that, these assessments are the helpful device for professional development of teachers
as the results of these assessments provide the attention to adapt the way of instruction to give rise
the effective teaching and learning in the classroom , as well as to meet the students needs. Laura
Greenstein claimed:
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
9/29
Formative assessment allows both teachers and students to measure learning by inches, ounces,
and degrees. The results can inform teachers and student decisions about what to do next on an
hour-to-hour, day-to-day, or month-to- month basis.
Additionally, Black and William (1998, Pg.139-148) addressed the formative assessments as all
activities that teachers and students undertake to get information that can be used diagnostically to
alter teaching and learning
In addition to these facts, in my opinion, formative assessment is one of the ways to develop learner
autonomy as it is a kind of teaching strategies which is based on the view : Sell a man a fish, he eats
for a day, teach a man how to fish, he eats for the rest of his life . To make it more clear, as all
students are clear about what they have to learn, why they have to learn, where they are and how
they can make further achievements and what the criteria of achievements that they have to look
for, all students have motivation, confidence and skills to assess their own learning and the level of
understanding and take next steps in their learning. Moreover, it can be safely said that learners
know how to make the further progress and how to make effective learning by following the
feedback and the suggestion from the teacher, which are the skills that are useful for their life-long
learning.
5.1. Is there any formative assessment in class?
Without a doubt, even though teacher gives exercises and homework, she just marks and return to
students. She corrects every mistake she sees, for instance grammatical and vocabulary uses,
without any comment and remedial suggestion/ teaching for these mistakes. The worst is that most
students rarely review the marked exercises and homework until the exam is drawing near. So, it can
be safely said that there is no formative assessment in class in high schools.
5.2. How it is different from current assessment system?
Currently, students are being assessed their writing skills through grade sand marks, which
cannot show reliable figure of their weakness and progress. That is to say, there should raise
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
10/29
questions regarding to current grading and marking system: how students can interpret
grades if their progress and weakness? How students can know how much progress they
make if they get a particular grades and mark? How can grading systems reveal any gap
between what students learnt and what teachers have taught? If there is gap, is there any
remedial teaching to bridge the gap?
I do believe that only formative assessment can answer these questions because one of the
characteristics of formative assessment is that it focuses on the comment and feedback on
the works of students, instead of abstract grades and marks. Moreover, from feedback and
suggestion from the teachers, students will know what they need to learn more. Not only
that, on looking the works of students, teacher can know which part of the lesson is not so
eff ective and needs remedial teaching and how she can adjust the instruction in order to
gap these bridge. accordingly, it makes me assume that what is missing in current assessing
strategies is that the comment, feedback, suggestion for improvement from teachers and
how the weakness of students can be bridged, and, if we add on these factors to current
assessing strategies of students learning, I think that it would be very fruitful.
6. How formative can be in teaching writing and why?
In my opinion, it makes me convinced that formative assessment is useful to teach both
product and process writing. This is because formative assessment can foster learner
autonomy and make students to handle their own mistakes, through self- and peer-
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
11/29
assessment activities. Moreover, as teacher keep giving feedback and comment about
students work, formative assessment can booster students progress quickly.
In my opinion, I think that following six principles/ characteristics are useful for teaching
writing:
1. Formative assessment should be the central of classroom practice.
In my opinion, I understand that formative assessment is on-going process, which can
take place before, during and after the instruction in order to check student understands
about the subject matter. By and large, since it can be addressed as activities and tasks
that can measure students learning, which means gauge where students are on the way
to the goal. Black and William (1998, Pg.139-148) addressed the formative assessments
as al l activities that teachers and students undertake to get information that can be
used diagnostically to alter teaching and learning. Moreover, Laura Greenstein claimed:
Formative assessment allows both teachers and students to measure learning by
inches, ounces, and degrees. The results can inform teachers and student decisions
about what to do next on an hour-to-hour, day-to-day, or month-to- month basis.
Therefore, I think that formative assessment is very useful tool for teaching process
writing. By applying the formative assessment, teacher can do any scaffolding reaction,
such as reconstructing the activities and tasks, and altering the way she instructs, to
students at the every stage of approaching to the good writing. Moreover, as the main
focus of this paper is about the process writing, formative assessment play major
assessment for every classroom activities of writing class. What is found out is that
formative assessment can be used in every stage of process writing: brainstorming,
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
12/29
planning, drafting and final writing. At every stage, teacher can evaluate and give useful
so as to build confidence in our students and see how to improve their writing.
2. Formative assessment focus on how students learn.
No doubt, formative assessments should focus on how students learn, instead of what
students learn. Moreover, it cannot be denied that formative assessment is a
component of learning process. That is to say, formative assessment sometimes acts as
diagnostics tests, which can show the problematic part of lesson which students might
experience. Another thing is that teacher can use the results of these tests to redesign
the activities and tasks in order to diagnose these problematic areas and facilitate
students learning process. Not only that, what I und erstand is that formative
assessment can give obvious figure of what students learning, whether their learning
can meet the essential criteria to achieve the learning goals and what they need to do
to achieve these goals. Therefore, it is true to say that formative assessment can be
addressed as Assessment for Learning.
What is more, formative assessment can be classroom activities. That means that
formative assessment caters the information about student weakness and progress,
teacher can plan future lesson, that is, as she get the information about what students
dont know and what they need to know, she can construct the future classroom
activities and tasks in order to bridge that gaps. That is very true especially in process
writing class. In process writing class, the main focus of teacher is not on what is
students final production, but on how students process to get that production and
judging whether that process can give good outcome. I think that assessing what
student learnt is the main focus of summative assessment, which usually appears at the
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
13/29
end of instruction and gauges students abilities by grades and scores, which ca nnot
interpret their abilities, and it cannot be applied in the process writing class.
3. Teacher should share learning objectives with students.
This characteristic of formative assessment is very true to for the teaching writing, especially
at the initiative stage of transforming from the traditional way of teaching product writing
to process and product writing, because students may be confused why certain new task
they have to do, which is different from tasks that they usually do, and without this
awareness, students may baffles whether the new teaching strategies/ approach will be
useful to get high grade in exam. Another reason is that teacher should, of course, convey
what he/she want students to learn as knowing what they must try to achieve and want to
achieve can have obvious effective impact on students learning. It cannot be denied that
students will be demotivated as there are no concrete goals for doing certain task. That is to
say, even though they are asked to do homework, composition and grammar exercises, they
have no idea why they have to do these things, and what are the benefits of doing these
tasks. Therefore there should be any doubt that if students are given information about the
goals of tasks that they will have to do, they will come to realize what they need to do so as
to achieve that goal.
In order to make students to understand the goals of the course, one thing teacher can do is
explain them verbally, for instance, tell them after this course, the students can write essays
and letters in English creatively, they can come up with their own ideas, rather depending
on the teachers and samples ideas. Or, another way what teacher can do is that he/she can
give the sheets with learning objectives. However, one important things teacher should do
after sharing the goals for students learning is that c hecking the understanding of the
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
14/29
meaning of learning goals. Susan M. Brookhart (2209, Pg.27) suggested teachers not to ask
direct and very explicit question to check students understanding, for instance, Do you
understand? If we ask students this question so as to check their understanding, it is logical
to assume that students will response Yes, we understand. For that reason, we must help
them to see what they dont understand by using certain strategies. One of these strategies
would be asking them to find out at least two questions about the learning goals after they
read the handouts or listening to teacher. Another thing that teacher can evaluate students
understanding is that teacher asks students to describe the learning goals as much as they
can without referring to the handouts after reading it.
4. Teacher also should help students to clear and recognize about the criteria or
standard that teacher is looking for.
In my opinion, I think that this characteristic is very appropriate when teacher approach the
combination of product and process writing. That is to say, teacher can explain what good
writing is, perhaps the criteria of good writing and how to process the good writing. That is,
in traditional class, whenever teacher teaches writing essays and letters, she just gives the
samples and explains in translation. In my opinion, I think that, rather just giving the
samples and explain them in word-by- word translation, teacher should ask students to read
the samples and find out the characteristics of a good writing in groups. Apart from this,
what else teacher can do is that she can give two sample, one which is good, perfect and
the other is work of previous students, and then, ask them to compare these two works and
ask them to give comments on both. Sometimes students can also be asked to find out any
further improvement for the samples. Then, teacher can evaluate the characteristics that
students found out and can give the comment or fill any missing characteristics. Or, another
thing what teacher can do is that teacher can explain what criteria that students need in
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
15/29
order to achieve good writing. That is to say, teacher can explain what she is expecting in
essay writing homework, for instance, such as own creative idea, grammar, and vocabulary,
before she asks students to do.
The reason behind this characteristic is that as students are given the knowledge about
the criteria of good writing, they become aware how can they write or approach to these
good writing, which can be helpful to achieve better grade in matriculation examination.
Not only that, it would be helpful for the students to evaluate their own writing as they are
provided the criteria of good work, which is also teacher is expecting from students
production.
5. Teacher should provide opportunity to involve peer- and self-assessment.
There are a lot of advantages of equipping students with the opportunity to involve peer-
and self- assessment. The most obvious one is that these opportunities can give rise to
learner-autonomy. This is because these opportunities can assist for students to identify
next steps in their learning and to be able to come up with new skills, knowledge and
understanding. Furthermore, Marilyn Lewis (2009, Pg.52,53) points out a fact that peer
assessment have effective impact on both low- achieving and high-achieving students. She
claims that for asking them to check the work of their peers, they are provided with a good
sample at a level slightly above their own and they can aware of further different ways of
composing by using the vocabulary and grammar structures that have been taught". For
higher achieving students, they will become aware of how certain writing work can improve
and what kind of mistakes can be made frequently and how can be avoided, when they sit
for exam. So it can be safely said that such peer-assessment can develop the ability to carry
out self-assessment, and, needless to say, this can lead to learner autonomy.
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
16/29
This principle of formative assessment is obviously helpful in teaching process writing,
especially at brainstorming, editing, and final writing. Moreover, writing is a thinking process
and it must need audience who is going to read the work, so that, I think peer-assessment is
a way of providing audience. In brainstorming stage, in group, teacher can ask them put
forward any ideas relevant to the given topic. Then, she can ask them to decide what to
include and what to reject, or ask them to give comment on ideas about whether it is
relevant or not. In editing and final writing stage, teacher can ask students to read the works
of their peer and then ask them to evaluate their work depending on the criteria that
teacher is expecting. Here, there needs one things that teacher must do is that explanation
of the criteria that students must consider when they evaluate their peers work. One thing
teacher can do is providing checklist. Kroll (1991, pg. 259) presented some questions that
will be useful when students are asked to do peer-assessment:
1. What is the main purpose of this paper?
2. What have you found particularly effective in the paper?
3. Do you think the writer has followed through on what paper is set out to do?
4. Find at least three places in the essay where you can think of questions that have not
answered by the writer. Write those questions in the margin as areas for the writer
to answer in the next draft.
Moreover, here is another example of checklist (teaching writing Skills)
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
17/29
Peer Editing Checklist
Directions: Read your friends composition, answer the following questions, and tell
your friend about it.
1. Is the composition interesting?
YES NO
*If interesting, underline the words or sentences that make it interesting.
*If not interesting, tell your friend how he/ she can make it more interesting.
2. Are the ideas in the composition clear to you?
YES NO
*If the answer is no, tell your friend why they are not clear.
3. Are the paragraphs in the right order?
YES NO
*If they are not, tell your friend how he/she can arrange them.
4. Did you find any mistakes, such as grammar, spelling, etc. in the composition?
YES NO
*If you did, tell your friend what the mistakes are.
5. Which words do you especially like?
6. Are there any words which you dont like? What are they? Why dont you like
them?
7. Whats the best part of the composition? How can your friend make it even better?
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
18/29
Moreover, for self- assessment, Andrea H. Peaflorida (2002) suggests three useful
questions for self-assessment:
1. What I am writing about?
2. Is the main idea of my work clear?
3. Do I have details (e.g., examples and illustrations) to support my main idea?
So, it cannot be denied that these peer and self-assessment are useful to improve learner
autonomy and they can equip students with the ability to see their own weakness and
progress as well as how to make progress.
6. Teacher should provide feedbacks and advices which make students to see what
they need to do/learn in order to achieve the goals
Needless to say, feedbacks and advice from teacher is the most important component of
formative assessment. It cannot be denied that feedbacks from teacher can help students
understand where they are now and what to do next, and also, they can bridge the gap
between what students know and what they need to know. Moreover, in my opinion, I feel
that it would be more effective if feedbacks are accompanied with suggestions for
improvement. However, what Assessment Reform Group (2002) insist that the feedback
should be constructive and sensitive, that is say, the feedbacks can hav e emotional impact
on students, which can make either motivated or demotivated. Anyway, I think that
feedback must give students confidence to go one step further than their current level and
focus on the work of the students, not personal. When teacher gives feedback, she can
pinpoint the strength of the students and how to grow it bigger, and, for weakness, she can
give suggestion and guide the way to improve them.
In addition to these facts, teacher can give feedback and suggestions for improvement orally
or even in the writing. However, teacher should give the feedback as immediately as
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
19/29
possible , contrast students works with the criteria of good work, which has been explained
as learning goals (Susan M. Brookhart, 2009, Pg. 43) . She also points out that teacher must
use the words that students can understand and also the words must be explicit. Murray
(1885, Pg.156) also present some useful feedback and comment which can bring about the
stimulation and encouragement to students improvement:
1. What do you plan to work on next?
2. I like the way you wove the quote into the text. Are there other things that could
be woven in the same way?
3. Where do you think you can get off the track?
4. And you said you have no voice. Tell me how you made this draft so different.
Moreover, he also point out the some sample comments and feedback that teacher should
avoid:
1. This is no good!
2. Wow! You can write.
3. Didnt you learn anything about writing?
4. Ive never seen such a bad paper before.
5. I dont know what I can teach someone who wrote like you.
Additionally, Marilyn Lewis (2002, Pg. 72) suggest some useful sentence starters for teacher
to make suggestion:
1. How about.?
2. Try to ..
3. Id suggest.
4. Look at page for
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
20/29
Moreover, without any doubt, every teacher thinks that, in applying formative
assessment, their responsibility is just giving feedback, comment, and teaching some
mistakes that majority of students make again, and, they think that their students may
review the marked essays, feedback and suggestions, that they gave. Actually, if they
think in that way, it would be a big mistake. To my personal experience, this is such a
common thing that most of students rarely revise their works unless the exam is
drawing near. It would be correct to say that only good and motivated students will
revise the marked essays, teachers feedback and comment. What can do in order to
handle this problem is making both teacher and students to involve in reviewing and
reflecting result of formative assessment. For instance, many teacher argue that they
have no enough time to do face-to- face discussion about progress of students progress
as they a r e given limited time to finish teaching the content of syllabus. However, I think
that it would be worthy for both teachers and students if teacher give some times for
conferencing (H. Douglas Brown, 2007, Pg. 477). Moreover, Marilyn Lewis claimed in
teaching writing:
During conferencing, teacher will usually read a draft of the writing and make comment
like these:
Suggest an improvement (e.g. better word)
Ask a question (e.g. How did you decide to put that idea last?
Point to further help ( e.g. Show a page in the text book)
All in all, it is very true to say that feedback and suggestions for improvements are one of
the most important component parts of formative assessment. Moreover, whenever
teacher gives feedback and suggestions, these things must be constructive and sensitive,
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
21/29
which means that they must reflect students work and guide student progress and
weakness, as well as ways to improve them.
7. Teacher should build confidence that every students can achieved
There should not be any doubt to say that students will be motivated if they feel as their
teachers are interested in their learning progress and invest their time in figuring out what
they need to adjust their teaching styles in order to bridge students weakness. As well, as
students are clear about the objective of the learning to achieve and way to arrive those
objectives, as they know whether they are on the right track to achieve them by following
the feedback and suggestions from teacher, all of them, even low-achieving students, have
confidence about their achievement.
What is more, as my concerning is on the writing skills, what I found out is that most
students have no confidence to write as they are suffering from mental block and fear
about making mistakes. In order for such kind of students to overcome from these suffering,
in my view, teachers must encourage them, of course. One thing what teacher can do in
order to overcome mental block, teacher can ask them to write down any idea or words
related to given topic as much as they can within 10 minutes, for instance. Another thing
she can do is that introducing portfolio, which is the collection of all students works,
including drafts, plans of essays and any ideas come out from them. First, student may think
this is a collection of trash as they cannot see how useful it is; so, teacher can explain how
helpful it is and encourage them to collect their works in portfolio. Then, the one thing
teacher must do is to ask them to submit their portfolio once a week, for instance, and give
comments, such as whic h ideas do you think is useful or relevant to put in your essays?
How can you arrange these ideas in your essays? In addition to that fact, as the students
have a good knowledge of how to process good writing and how to handle mistakes, they
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
22/29
have confidence to handle any unseen question of writing skill in matriculation examination.
So it is very true to say that the second or foreign language learning would be fruitful, as the
learners are motivated and confident to apply all the language they have learnt. Thus,
without a doubt, in order to have effective teaching foreign language, teacher must foster
students with motivation and confidence.
8. Formative assessment involves both teacher and students in reviewing and reflecting
on assessment information.
There should be any denying saying that teacher and students should review and look back
the assessment information, that is, they should revise the learning objective and consider
whether current teaching styles are helpful to achieve these objectives. One thing teacher
can do is that teacher should make continuous announcement of the students progress and
how closer they are to the objectives. Another thing teacher can do is that teacher reminds
frequently about the learning objectives and the criteria that they need to achieve these
objectives. Moreover, teacher can evaluate the result of current teaching styles and if there
is no obvious progress, she can adapt the style of teaching. What is more, in order to see the
effectiveness of her teaching and alter teaching approach, she should ask following
questions frequently:
1. What essential skills and knowledge I can try to teach?
2. How can I find out whether students care learning?
3. How can I help them learn better?
There is one reason for doing this that teacher can improve their teaching skills and gain
ability to see and understand whether their teaching is productive. As well, for students, as
their progress is frequently announced, they will be well motivated and have confidence as
they are gradually approaching to the goals. Moreover, they can measure their own
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
23/29
progress as teacher is always reminding the criteria that they need in order to achieve good
work.
7. The useful teaching strategies for assessing and facili tating students learning
In general, there are two main effective ways that teachers can use to assess and facilitate
their students learning: self- and peer- assessment, and teacher- assessment.
7.1. Self- and peer- assessment
There should not be any doubt that self- and peer- assessments are useful device that all
language teachers should exploit it as it enhance students motivation and learner -
autonomy. In teaching writing, self- and peer- assessments can be used especially in pre-
writing stage and drafting stage.
In pre- writing stage, normally, teacher just introduce brainstorming activities, such as listing
ideas and brainstorming group discussion, which are good ways to assess students
background knowledge about a particular topic. In these activities, teacher get students to
write down and/or list as many words or ideas related to that topic as they can think during
a set time. Then, what teacher can do is that give the assessment checklists or a list of
questions, which can be used in either self-assessment or peer-assessment. Following list of
questions is the useful in either self- or peer-assessments:
Read the list of words and ideas and answer.
Find out which ideas and/or words are irrelevant to the topic. If there are, why do
you think they are not relevant?
Is there any useful ideas and/ words for this topic. If, why?
Is there any ideas and/ words you want to add? If, what are they and why?
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
24/29
Moreover, in drafting stage, teachers can also apply these kinds of assessment. In this stage,
it cannot be denied that peer- assessment can provide the audience for the students, which
can have impact on the motivation to write more and better as they realize somebody will
read their work. Similar to the brainstorming activities, teacher must tell what factors they
students must focus on when they evaluate their own works and/or their peers work. The
following is the list of the questions that teachers normally use:
Read through the draft (of your friend) and answer following question.
Which part of this draft is interesting for you? Why?
Which part is not interesting for you? Why?
Is there any irrelevant sentence/ idea? What are they and why do you think in that way?
What else do you want to add?
Is there any grammar and spelling mistakes? What are they?
Can you summarize what is text is about?
All in all, I think that peer- and self- assessment can equip student with the ability to see
their learning weakness and weakness. Not only that, it is very helpful for the students who
are familiar with product writing to adjust with the teaching process writing, and it is the
most effective way to cure the suffering of mental block.
7.2. Teacher- assessment
It is very true to say that, traditionally, teacher-assessment usually happened at the end of
writing, however, in teaching process writing, teacher must intervene during the process of
writing, that is, he/she must collaborate with students at every stage of writing. The obvious
advantage of this way of assessing is that teacher can know where the students, how they
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
25/29
process to get the good product, every difficulties and weakness that students encounter on
the way of process to the good product. Moreover, it cannot be denied that teacher can
react and do remedial teaching to the students weakness and difficulties a nd can
reconstruct the activities and tasks in order to facilitate students learning. Moreover, it is
very important that teacher do need to take part collaboratively in peer- and self-
assessment. One clear example is that, while students are carrying out the brainstorming
activities and/or the peer- and self-assessment, teacher should move around the class and
spend some times in every students and/or group to listen to what they are discussing, and
how they are carrying out the tasks. By doing this, needless to say, teacher can help and give
feedback as soon as possible when students have difficulties. Moreover, this kind of teacher
feedback will become a model for the type of feedback that students give in peer-
assessment.
Moreover, teacher should spend some time for conferencing, which can give effective
feedback and advice for further progress for individual students. In conferencing, teacher
reads through the drafts, portfolio and finial writing work. Ronald E. Lapp(1985, Pg. 88)
suggested some useful question to ask students:
What did you write about in your first draft?
How would you describe the amount of change you made from your first to your
second draft
Many changes
Some changes
Few changes
Point put the way ideas changed from your first to your final draft.
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
26/29
Point out the way your organization changed from your final draft.
Point out five changes you made in grammar, spelling or punctuation
If you were given chance to revise this graft one more time, what changes would you
make?
Moreover, in traditional way of teaching writing, teachers just mark and correct grammar
and spelling mistakes, rather than giving any feedback and suggestions. In teaching process
writing, teacher should tell which factors she is expecting, such as ideas, grammar and
vocabulary use, when she asks her students to do homework and composition tasks. For
example, if teacher wants to make students able to write without disturbing the flow of
thoughts, she should ask them to focus on idea and tell them no need to worry about the
grammar and vocabulary uses. However, the problem here is that if teacher focus too much
on the meaning and idea enrichment, what is found out is that the accuracy is plummeting.
So, this means that teacher cannot ignore these mistakes; however, how these mistakes
should be corrected is questions for teacher. One thing teacher can do is that mistakes are
not corrected explicitly. Teacher can create special correcting code, such as SP for spelling
mistakes, GR= for grammar, and underline the mistakes. Additionally, teacher should let
students to find out how to correct their mistakes, rather than correcting these mistakes
explicitly.
All in all, it cannot be denied that teacher assessment is important component of formative
assessment. Teacher should work cooperatively with students in order to give feedback and
assess students progress, and react to the students weakness as soon as possible.
Moreover, the teacher assessment must be frequent and on-going process.
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
27/29
8. Is there any constraint that will encounter and how to overcome?
Indeed, there will be some difficulties if teachers use formative assessment in their
classroom immediately. I think that teacher needs to give students to adapt in new
teaching strategies. This is because students are familiar with the traditional ways of
teaching writing skills, which is very teacher-centered, whereas formative assessment is
so learner-centered. Therefore, it cannot be denied that they need some times to
familiar with new teaching strategies. What is more, the te achers observation and
feedback during peer- and self- assessment can make students more reliant on the
teacher. So what teacher can do is that she should give feedback carefully on few major
factors. Moreover, to my experience, some students are very sensitive about comments,
so teacher needs to keep in mind that every comment should be constructive and
sensitive. What is more, teachers also need time and special training to be familiar with
formative assessment as they are also used to teach in language skills in very traditional
way and when they transform into formative ways, most teachers have difficulties,
especially when they think up ways to assess students progress, instead of just marking
and grading. Hence, what Boston, Carol (2002) claimed:
Training and professional development in the area of classroom assessment (formative
assessment) are essential in order to provide individual teachers with the time and
support necessary to make changes. Teachers need time to reflect upon their
assessment practices and benefit from observing and consulting with other teachers
about effective practice and about changes they would like to make. Moreover, it
would be challenge for some teachers as they have to come up with different strategies
to adjust teaching in order to bridge students weakness and assess students progress.
Moreover, teacher also needs to inform parents about new assessing strategies, as some
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
28/29
parents used to know their children in grades. Another big challenge is that teachers
have to assess students learning frequently. As Black and William (1998) recommended:
Frequent short tests are better than infrequent long one
New learning should be tested within about a week of first exposure.
However, teachers in Myanmar are given very limited time to teach the whole content of
syllabus, so that, they argue that they can give time for frequents short test and
conferencing.
However, in order to cope with aforementioned difficulties, I think teacher should give at
least 10 or 15 minutes to d o short test once a week so as to assess students progress as
well as weakness. Moreover, it seems to me that they should spend at least one period per
week for remedial teaching and for conferencing with their students.
9. Conclusion
To take everything that I mentioned above sections, it can safely conclude that current way
of teaching writing skills in Myanmar high schools is very traditional way as it is focus on the
product, so I think that high schools teachers should give attention teaching both product
and process of writing. Moreover, another thing is that formative assessment cannot be
necessarily addressed as formal pen and paper tests. Actually, formative assessments can be
any activities that appear in classroom. Moreover, it cannot be denied that formative
assessment is effective approach of teaching writing as it can equip students with learner
autonomy and creativity, which are essential skills to handle unseen topic in matriculation
examination. So, I think that the responsible persons should start the programs to
widespread the application of formative assessment nationwide; for instance, they can
embark the training programs for teacher to enrich their teaching skills and knowledge
-
8/12/2019 Formative Assessment in Classroom Practice
29/29
about formative assessment. I want to conclude this paper by suggesting to the syllabus
writers and responsible persons to set formative assessment as a part of syllabus and
introduce teacher development in the field of formative assessment programs and they
should also urge teachers to use formative assessment in order to bring about effective
teaching and fruitful learning in schools.
Bibliography