fisp technical committee meeting november 8, 2011 timothy d. straub, p.e., ph.d.,

17
FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy D. Straub, P.E., Ph.D., Marian Domanski, and a many others. LISST-SL Experience and Testing Results in Illinois

Upload: indra

Post on 06-Feb-2016

27 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

LISST-SL Experience and Testing Results in Illinois. FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy D. Straub, P.E., Ph.D., Marian Domanski , and a many others. Typical Boat Setup. Typical Bridge Setup. Experience Summary. 1,194 Files on LISST-SL Topside Controller Box - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

FISP Technical Committee Meeting

November 8, 2011Timothy D. Straub, P.E., Ph.D.,

Marian Domanski, and a many others.

LISST-SL Experience and Testing Results in Illinois

Page 2: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

Typical Boat Setup

Page 3: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

Typical Bridge Setup

Page 4: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

Experience Summary• 1,194 Files on LISST-SL Topside Controller Box

-Solution: MATLAB programs to view and process

Point Sample Example

Page 5: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

Experience SummarySingle Vertical Sample Example

Page 6: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

Experience Summary Cont.

• 13 IL-WSC datasets – Over 160 samples at 11 sites

• Concentration– 18 – 2,170 mg/L (from physical samples analyzed at lab)

• Velocity– 1.1 – 7.6 ft/s

• Depth– 2 – 30 ft

Page 7: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

Example Data at Kickapoo Bloomington

Page 8: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

Physical Sample and Laboratory Analysis Inventory

LISST-SL Testing:

~170 samples

~100 Sand/Fine Split

~60 Full Particle Size

17 Pycnometer

5 Loss of Ignition

Labs Used:

Kentucky Lab (Pipette/VA)

CVO Lab (SediGraph/Sieve, Pycnometer, Digital Imaging)

Page 9: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

Pycnometer Testing

     Density

Statistic (g/ml)Minimum 2.56Maximum 2.72Average 2.64Samples Used 17

Page 10: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

Concentration Results

  Laboratory (Mass) LISST-SL (Volumetric)1  Concentration  Percent  Concentration Percent   (Mass Conc)  finer than (Vol Conc) finer than

Statistic  (mg/L)  0.0625 mm  (ml/L)  0.0625 mmMinimum 18 68 17 48Maximum 2170 100 1994 100Average 557 92 448 90Samples Used 163 102 163 163

1 Volumetric concentration in this table is not adjusted for unmeasured fraction (percent of physical sample mass less than 2 microns and greater than 381 microns). The unmeasured fraction ranged from 32 to 65 percent for 25 samples analyzed.

Page 11: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

Concentration Results

Page 12: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

Concentration Results

Page 13: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

Comparison of particle-size distributions for three sites with a broad range of percent finer than 0.0625 mm and unmeasured LISST-SL fraction.

Page 14: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

Deployment Experiences

• Pitot Tube

• Tail Fin Configuration

Page 15: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

• Good range of testing

• Volumetric Concentration Issues– Software Revisions?– Percent finer than 2 microns?

• Overall good LISST-SL performance

Summary

Page 16: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,
Page 17: FISP Technical Committee Meeting November 8, 2011 Timothy  D. Straub,  P.E., Ph.D.,

Laser In-Situ Scattering and Transmissometry (LISST) Stream Lined (SL)

• Background/Clean Water Checks– Before and after testing at a site– Instrument should be left in the water for 35

minutes prior to background checks and testing• Single Vertical Samples

– “a”, “b”, and optional “c” samples– Transit rate of the LISST-SL < 1 ft per 5 seconds

• Point Samples– “a”, “b”, and optional “c” samples– At least at 0.6 depth, and 0.2, 0.4, and/or 0.8 as

conditions allow

LISST-SL Testing Guidelines