fire safety of road vehicles status and trends

Fire Safety of Road VehiclesStatus and Trends

Fire safety road vehicles Japan, September 2014

Presentation given at TokyoSeptember 2014

Fire Safety of Road Vehicles

Flammability requirements for automotive worldwide very low (MVSS 302). No major regulatory changes foreseen

Trends automotive: Compact systems with more plastics, electromobility requires higher fire safety for cabling, electrical/electronic parts, batteries

Battery fires may be an issue. Requirements for large batteries in electric vehicles developed by Underwriters Laboratories as UL Subject 2580

Consequences: higher fire safety requirements (UL94 V0 or 5V for electrical parts and batteries) in automotive


Fire Safety of Buses

Busses EU very low fire safety (MVSS 302 + vertical curtain + drip tests)

A series of bus fire catastrophes in Europe (Germany, Nordic countries), USA, China and India has sensitized public opinion to improve fire safety

Studies made on fire safety of materials and components meeting new European railway requirements show that bus fires can be avoided or dramatically reduced

Medium term adjustment of fire safety in buses to stringent European railway requirements under discussion


Bus fires statistical review Norway/Sweden

1.0 - 1.5 % of buses in Norway and Sweden are involved in a fire incident every year

Largest risk of severe fire starting in engine compartment


Bus fire Hannover, Germany, November 2008

A German tour bus caught fire on a German highway killing 20 people

Fire broke out in the bathroom of the bus due to electrical malfunction

When the door was opened, flames shot out and quickly engulfed the bus

The fire propagated so quickly because the materials’ fire safety level was too low


• Also ISO 3795, DIN 75200• Car interior• Bunsen burner 38 mm flame• Horizontal flame propagation max. 100 mm/min or less

What are the fire safety tests for buses used in Europe?

International Flammability Test for Road Vehicles to FMVSS 302


EU Flammability Tests for Buses to EU Directive 95/28/EC

• Interior materials Horizontal to ISO 3795 • Curtains Vertical to ISO 6940

• Ceiling Drip test to NF P 92-505

Bus fire safety India, September 2014Fire safety road vehicles Japan, September 2014

Fire safety of buses

New developments

Following several catastrophic bus fires, the current fire safety requirements are perceived as too low

This is evidenced by a Swedish study (SP) on fire safety in buses

As a consequence, on international level, UNECE initiated a revision of the regulation No. 118, Burning behaviour of materials in buses

Sweden and Norway proposed more stringent tests for buses; they are already used for European high speed railways and internationally for ships (IMO FTP Code)


Fire safety of buses

Fire safety in buses2006 Study made and published by

SP Technical Research Institute of Swedenon behalf of the Swedish Road Administration and

The Norwegian Public Roads Administration


Background and objectives SP study

Most public transport applications, except buses, have high fire safety requirements that give a satisfactory level of safety

Test methods to evaluate ignition, fire spread, smoke and toxic gases have been developed within ISO and are already used for high speed trains in Europe and internationally for passenger ships (IMO)

The study objective is to show that established test methods for ships and trains are suitable for improving the fire safety levels of materials and components used in buses


Conclusions SP Study

The existing fire safety requirements do not guarantee a satisfactory fire safety level on buses

Reason: test method and criteria (FMVSS 302) do not properly discriminate between

materials with high or low fire safety performance Consequence: fire safety performance of the interior materials and furnishings of certain

bus types may be unacceptably low

An acceptable fire safety level can be reached when using the ISO tests for flame spread of surface linings and floorings, as well as the smoke and toxic gas production tests


World Forum for Harmonization of Vehicle Regulations

United Nations Economic and Social CouncilECONOMIC COMMISSION FOR EUROPE

INLAND TRANSPORT COMMITTEEWorld Forum for Harmonization of Vehicle Regulations

Working Party on General Safety ProvisionsECE/TRANS/WP.29/GRSG/Geneva


Amendment of Regulation No. 118

Proposal Norway and Sweden from the SP study

Lateral flame spread to ISO 5658-2 on transport products in vertical configuration(also used for ships according to IMO FTP-Code)

The following materials shall undergo the test :(a) Ceiling lining materials(b) Side and rear walls, including separation walls, lining materials(c) Thermal and/or acoustic function materials(d) Interior lining of luggage-racks, heating and ventilation pipes materials

Test result satisfactory if average value of CFE* > 20 kW/m2




Smoke generation and toxicity to ISO 5659-2of smoke gases from a burning material(also used for ships according to IMO FTP-Code)

The following materials shall undergo the test:(a) Ceiling lining materials(b) Side and rear walls, including separation walls, lining materials(c) Thermal and/or acoustic function materials(d) Interior lining of luggage-racks, heating and ventilation pipes materials(e) Interior lining of the floor materials

Result for smoke opacity satisfactory if the average value of the maximum smoke density (Dm) for materials (a) to (d) < 200 and < 500 for material (e)

(c) Materials for interior lining of floors tested at 25 kW/m2, + pilot flame(b) All other materials at 50 kW/m2, no pilot flame




Lateral flame spread (floorings) to ISO 9239-1on transport products in horizontal configuration

Test result satisfactory, if average value of CHF > 4.5 kW/m2 (CHF = critical heat flux)




Test to determine the fire behaviour of seats(Annex C to EN 45545-2Fire protection of railway vehicles)

The complete seats shall undergo the test. Result satisfactory if MARHE < 50 kW.(MAHRE = Maximum Average Rate of Heat Emission)


Flammability test for wire and cable in buses

Newly introduced into ECE R 118

ISO 6722:2006 Road vehicles - 60 V and 600 V single-core cables - Dimensions, test methods and requirements

Paragraph 12: Resistance to flame propagation



Conclusions

With the 01 series of amendments (date of entry into force 9 December 2010) the test to determine the capability of materials to repel fuel or lubricant and tests for electric cables were added. It becomes mandatory on 9th of December 2012 for new bus types and component types and on 9th of December 2015 for first registrations.

With the 02 series of amendments (date of entry into force 26 July 2012) the requirements for material installed in a vertical position with regard to the vertical burning rate were extended and the possibility to use the tests of the railway standard was introduced. These requirements become mandatory on 26th of July 2016 for new component types, 26th of July 2017 for new vehicle types and on 26th of July 2020 for first registrations.


School buses in the USA

Basically, MVSS 302 is required for all school buses

In many US States higher fire safety requirements are prescribed for school buses

In Nevada for instance, as of January 2016 any new school bus must meet additional requirements to either:

- ASTM E1537 Fire Testing of Upholstered Furniture (propane burner and heat release measurement by oxygen consumption) ; or - The School Bus Seat Upholstery Fire Block Test - In the engine compartment UL 94 V0 has to be met for molded parts, HF-1 for foams and VTM-0 for thin films

Some states also use the vertical Bunsen burner test to FAR-25-853B used for aircraft interior materials


Fire safety in buses

Conclusions and outlook

Following catastrophic fires, the fire safety in buses is perceived as currently being too low

The amendment of the UNECE Regulation 118 has set higher fire safety levels in buses; this is a step in the right direction

In the USA, some states have higher fire safety requirements for seating in school buses

Basically more efforts must be made for further improving the fire safety levels of buses’ interiors (tests on seating)


fire safety of road vehicles status and trends

Documents