National Irrigation Administration (NIA) The Republic of the Philippines

PREPARATORY SURVEY ON

MALITUBOG-MARIDAGAO IRRIGATION PROJECT

(PHASE II) IN

THE REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES

FINAL REPORT (APPENDIXES)

September 2018

Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA) Sanyu Consultants Inc. (SCI) 1R

JR(先) 18-066

i

CONTENTS

APPENDIXES

I. IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENT .....................................................................I-1 II. METEOROLOGY AND HYDROLOGY .................................................................... II-1 III. AGRICULTURE .......................................................................................................... III-1 IV. IRRIGATION AND DRAINAGE ................................................................................ IV-1 V. ROAD AND BRIDGE .................................................................................................... V-1 VI. FLOOD SIMULATION ................................................................................................ VI-1 VII. ENVIRONMENT ........................................................................................................ VII-1 VIII. INDIGENOUS PEOPLE AND OTHER SOCIAL ISSUES ....................................VIII-1 IX. COST ESTIMATION ................................................................................................... IX-1 X. PROJECT EVALUATION ............................................................................................ X-1 XI. SATELLITE IMAGE ANALYSIS ............................................................................... XI-1 XII. A CATCH-UP PLAN ON HELP FOR CATUBIG AGRICULTURAL ADVANCEMENT PROJECT (HCCAP) .................................................................. XII-1 XIII. TOR AND PERSON-MONTH FOR LOAN CONSULTANT ................................XIII-1

APPENDIX-I

IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENT

APPENDIX I: IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENT OF THE PROJECT

TABLE OF CONTENTS

I.1 JICA Team Members and Counterparts Personnel ............................................................... I-1 I.1.1 JICA Team Members ................................................................................................ I-1 I.1.2 Counterpart Personnel .............................................................................................. I-1

I.2 Person-Month Input for the Survey ...................................................................................... I-2 I.3 Minutes of Meetings Concluded in the Process of the Project ............................................. I-3

Philippines MMIP II

JICA I-1 NIA

APPENDIX I. IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENT

I.1 JICA Team Members and Counterpart Personnel

I.1.1 JICA Team Members

Team Leader/ Irrigation Planning Kosei HASHIGUCHI Irrigation Designing Kosuke HIROTA Agriculture/ Farming Harunobu YOSHINO/Ai NAGINO Institutional Development Hiroko YASHIKI Civil/ Road Design Yoji SAWADA Meteorology/ Hydrology Takayuki OISHI Cost Estimation/ Procurement Yoji SAWADA Economic and Financial Evaluation Ryo INOUE Environmental Consideration Rie KITAO Social Consideration Hiroko YASHIKI Satellite Image Analysis (A) Izumi KATO Satellite Image Analysis (B) Taketo EGUCHI Inundation Analysis (A) Toru NAKAGAWA Inundation Analysis (B) Hajime KITA

I.1.2 Counterpart Personnel

(1) Central Office, National Irrigation Administration (NIA) Mr. Ricardo R. Visaya Administrator Mr. Czar M. Sulaik Deputy Admin for Eng. And Operations Ms. Felipa E. Mascariñas Manager, CMD - Engr. Dept. Ms. Alma S. Villaluna Senior Engineer A, CMD Ms. Andrea P. Pagtulingan Engineer A, CMD Ms. Alfonso delos Reyes Technical Assistant A, CMD Mr. Reynaldo B. Villanera DM PPD- Engineering Dept. Ms. Kit A. Maglangit Senior Exec. Assistant, Office of Senior Deputy Administrator Mr. Josias R. Pacolon DSD, Consultant, DSD Mr. Ernesto G. Collado Technical Assistant A Ms. Lydia S. Esguerra Department Manager Ms. Alma S. Villaluna Senior Engineer A Ms. Andrea Pagtulingan Engineer A Mr. Reynaldo B. Villanera Project Planning Division Manager Mr. Hanziel Nonilon de Guzman Supervising Engineer A

(2) Ministry of Finance Ms. Megan Barte Economist

(3) MMIP Project Management Office (PMO) under NIA Region XII Mr. Reynaldo M. Sarigumba Manager, Engr. Division Mr. Abedin L. Hadjisalik Head Construction Mr. Ali S. Satol RM/APM

(4) NIA Cotabato Irrigation Management Office under NIA Region XII Mr. Saldi P. Serafino Acting Division Manager, CIMO Mr. Saleh P. Kabunto Provincial Engineer A, NIA – MRIS

MMIP II Philippines

NIA I-2 JICA

I.2 Person-Month Input for the Survey

Per

son-

mon

th: P

repa

rato

ry S

urve

y on

Mal

itubo

g-M

arid

agao

Irrig

atio

n P

roej

ct (P

hase

2)

45

67

89

1011

121

23

45

67

89

10In

Phi

lippi

nes

In J

apan

Tot

al

Team

Lea

der/

Irrig

atio

n Pl

anni

ngK

osei

HA

SHIG

UC

HI

SCI

(6)

(60)

(23)

(21)

(7)

3.90

3.90

Irrig

atio

n D

esig

ning

Kos

uke

HIR

OTA

SCI

(56)

(38)

(7)

3.37

3.37

Har

unob

u Y

OSH

INO

SCI*

(45)

1.50

1.50

Ai N

AG

INO

SCI

(30)

1.00

1.00

Inst

itutio

nal D

evel

opm

ent

Hiro

ko Y

ASH

IKI

SCI

(30)

1.00

1.00

Civ

il/ R

oad

Des

ign

Yoj

i SA

WA

DA

SCI

(49)

1.63

1.63

Met

eoro

logy

/ Hyd

rolo

gyTa

kayu

ki O

ISH

ISC

I(4

7)(2

4)2.

372.

37

Cos

t Est

imat

ion/

Pro

cure

men

tY

oji S

AW

AD

ASC

I(4

9)1.

631.

63

Econ

omic

and

Fin

anci

al E

valu

atio

nR

yo IN

OU

ESC

I(7

5)(2

1)3.

203.

20

Envi

ronm

enta

l Con

sider

atio

nR

ie K

ITA

OSC

I(3

7)(4

9)2.

872.

87

Soci

al C

onsid

erat

ion

Hiro

ko Y

ASH

IKI

SCI

(28)

(14)

(14)

1.87

1.87

Sate

llite

Imag

e A

naly

sis (A

)Iz

umi K

ATO

SCI

(30)

1.00

1.00

Sate

llite

Imag

e A

naly

sis (B

)Ta

keto

EG

UC

HI

SCI

(30)

1.00

1.00

Inun

datio

n A

naly

sis (A

)To

ru N

AK

AG

AW

ASC

I(2

6)0.

870.

87

Inun

datio

n A

naly

sis (B

)H

ajim

e K

ITA

SCI

(26)

0.87

0.87

Sub

Tota

l28

.07

28.0

7

Team

Lea

der/

Irrig

atio

n Pl

anni

ngK

osei

HA

SHIG

UC

HI

SCI

(8)

0.40

0.40

Irrig

atio

n D

esig

nK

osuk

e H

IRO

TASC

I(4

)(1

2)0.

800.

80

Met

eoro

logy

/ Hyd

rolo

gyTa

kayu

ki O

ISH

ISC

I(1

9)0.

950.

95

Cos

t Est

imat

ion/

Pro

cure

men

tY

oji S

AW

AD

ASC

I0.

000.

00

Econ

omic

and

Fin

anci

al E

valu

atio

nR

yo IN

OU

ESC

I(4

)0.

200.

20

Sate

llite

Imag

e A

naly

sis (A

)Iz

umi K

ATO

SCI

(14)

(10)

1.20

1.20

Sate

llite

Imag

e A

naly

sis (B

)Ta

keto

EG

UC

HI

SCI

(14)

(24)

1.90

1.90

Inun

datio

n A

naly

sis (A

)To

ru N

AK

AG

AW

ASC

I(1

6)(2

0)(2

0)(8

)(1

0)(1

0)4.

204.

20

Inun

datio

n A

naly

sis (B

)H

ajim

e K

ITA

SCI

(11)

(20)

(14)

2.25

2.25

Sub

Tota

l11

.90

11.9

0

Tota

l28

.07

11.9

039

.97

Legend　

　　

　　

　　

In P

hilip

pine

sSC

I：Sa

nyu

Con

sulta

nts

Inc.

, JA

PAN

SCI*

: Rei

nfor

cem

ent (

TASK

Co.

, Ltd

)

　　

　　

　 　

In J

apan

IcR：

Ince

ptio

n R

epor

t　　

ITR：

Inte

rim R

epor

t　　

DFR

：D

raft

Fina

l Rep

ort　

　FR

：Fi

nal R

epor

t

Exp

ertis

eN

ame

Firm

2017

Pers

on-M

onth

Mai

n A

ctiv

ities

Con

firm

atio

n of

Exi

stin

g C

ondi

tion,

Prel

imin

ary

Des

ign

Nat

iona

l Con

dtio

ns (

Inun

datio

n an

alys

is, G

eote

chnc

al C

ondi

tion)

, Pro

ject

Out

linin

g, E

valu

atio

n of

Pro

ject

Effe

cts,

Env

iron

. Soc

ial C

onsi

dera

tions

etc

.

2018

Agr

icul

ture

/ Far

min

g

In Philippines In Japan

Rep

ort

△Ic

R▲ IT

R▲ DFR

▲IT

R (2

)

2111

411

242

1811

2411

2111

2411

211

△国内事前準備

▲ FR

Philippines MMIP II

JICA I-3 NIA

I.3 Minutes of Meetings Concluded in the Process of the Project

No. Title Page 1 Minute of Meeting on Inception Report I-4 2 Minute of Meeting on Interim Report I-8

MMIP II Philippines

NIA I-4 JICA

Philippines MMIP II

JICA I-5 NIA

MMIP II Philippines

NIA I-6 JICA

Philippines MMIP II

JICA I-7 NIA

MMIP II Philippines

NIA I-8 JICA

Philippines MMIP II

JICA I-9 NIA

MMIP II Philippines

NIA I-10 JICA

Philippines MMIP II

JICA I-11 NIA

MMIP II Philippines

NIA I-12 JICA