ffr: pitfalls · aminian a et al. cci 2015 bl ffr eng. ffr diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 slight reduction...

48
9 th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015 FFR: pitfalls Emanuele Barbato Cardiovascular Centre Aalst, Belgium Federico II University Naples, Italy

Upload: others

Post on 02-Oct-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

FFR: pitfalls

Emanuele Barbato

Cardiovascular Centre Aalst, Belgium

Federico II University Naples, Italy

Page 2: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Pitfalls can be related to.... Preparation

• Calibration

• Equalization

Measurement

• Drifting

• Hyperaemia

• Wedging

• Whipping

Tracing interpretation

• Cursor position

Page 3: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Pitfalls can be related to.... Preparation

• Calibration

• Equalization

Measurement

• Drifting

• Hyperaemia

• Wedging

• Whipping

Tracing interpretation

• Cursor position

Page 4: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Calibration

Page 5: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

‘teaching’ the system, what is zero pressure

Page 6: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Setting in the cathlab

Page 7: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

• Aortic pressure is measured by the fluid filled

guiding catheter

• Its value is a relative pressure, compared to

the reference, measured at the transducer

• Height of the transducer has a measurable

impact on the value

Calibration: Position of the Transducer

Page 8: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Pressure TOO LOW

Pressure TOO HIGH

Pressure OK

Calibration: Position of the Transducer

Page 9: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Calibration: PressureWire

Page 10: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Calibration: PressureWire

• Fill the tube of the wire with saline

Page 11: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Page 12: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Calibration: PressureWire

• Fill the tube of the wire with saline

• Wait a minute to have the system stabilized

• Perform calibration afterwards

Page 13: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Page 14: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Page 15: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Equalization

Page 16: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

‘teaching’ the two systems, to speak the same language

Page 17: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Pa Pd =

Equalization

Page 18: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

After equalization DO NOT CHANGE YOUR SETTING

Page 19: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Pitfalls can be related to.... Preparation

• Calibration

• Equalization

Measurement

• Drifting

• Hyperaemia

• Wedging

• Whipping

Tracing interpretation

• Cursor position

Page 20: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Pitfalls can be related to.... Preparation

• Calibration

• Equalization

Measurement

• Drifting

• Hyperaemia

• Wedging

• Whipping

Tracing interpretation

• Cursor position

Page 21: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Drifting

Page 22: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

When the two systems forget to speak the

same language ...

Page 23: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Pa Pd ≠

Post-measurement check

= Drift!!!

Page 24: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Drift Same morphology

Paralell shifting

Dicrotic notch well visible

True Gradient Different morphology

Dicrotic notch not visible

Drift vs Gradient ??

Page 25: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Hyperaemia

Page 26: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

No hyperaemia …? … no FFR!

Page 27: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Wedging

Page 28: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Aortic pressure is inaccurately measured...

Page 29: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

4 mm 2.4 mm 36 %

8F

4 mm 2.1 mm 27 %

7F

4 mm 1.8 mm 20 %

6F

Induced area stenosis

Size of the guiding catheter

Page 30: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

3 mm 2.4 mm 64 %

8F

3 mm 2.1 mm 49 %

7F

3 mm 1.8 mm 36 %

6F

Size of the guiding catheter Induced

area stenosis

Page 31: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Wedging guiding catheter

Page 32: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Disengaged guiding catheter

Page 33: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Wedging guiding catheter

FALSE 0.88 TRUE FFR 0.66

Page 34: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Functional wedging of guiding catheter

Aminian A et al. CCI 2015

BL FFR eng. FFR diseng.

1.00

0.80

0.50

Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the

threshold resulted into transition of 0.80 in 30% of the cases

Page 35: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Whipping

Page 36: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Whipping

Page 37: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Pitfalls can be related to.... Preparation

• Calibration

• Equalization

Measurement

• Drifting

• Hyperaemia

• Wedging

• Whipping

Tracing interpretation

• Cursor position

Page 38: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Pitfalls can be related to.... Preparation

• Calibration

• Equalization

Measurement

• Drifting

• Hyperaemia

• Wedging

• Whipping

Tracing interpretation

• Cursor position

Page 39: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Position the cursor to the lowest value where indeed FFR was measured

Page 40: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Position the cursor to the lowest value where indeed FFR was measured

Page 41: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Fractional flow reserve measurement

Induce proper maximal hyperaemia

Reading the pressure tracings appropriately

Obtain accurate measurements

Page 42: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Thank you for your attention!

Credit for the slides to Dr. Gabor Toth and Nico Pijls

Page 43: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Fractional flow reserve measurement

Accurate distal coronary pressure (Pd)

Accurate aortic pressure (Pa)

Maximal hyperaemia

FFR

X X

X X

Page 44: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Drift vs Gradient ??

• Curves are identical in shape

• Curves are shifted paralell

• Dicrotic notch is well visible on both

Page 45: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Page 46: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Insufficient hyperaemia

Underestimation of

the gradient

Overestimation of

the FFR

Underestimation of

disease

Page 47: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Pressure TOO LOW

Pressure TOO HIGH

Pressure OK

Calibration: Position of the Transducer

Page 48: FFR: pitfalls · Aminian A et al. CCI 2015 BL FFR eng. FFR diseng. 1.00 0.80 0.50 Slight reduction in hyperemic Pd/Pa at disengangement that with values close to the threshold resulted

9th Coronary Physiology in the CathLab Course, Nice 2015

Setting in the cathlab