feminist leadership for social transformation · feminist leadership for social transformation:...

42
" #$ %&’()*+) #)*(’,)() %-+.()& /00.-’)*12 #3’(4’56 718’5’0* 9.:1815*0 )54 ;&6)5’<)*’.50 /=>? @/00.-’)*’.5 A.& =.815B0 C’6+*0 ’5 ?1:1(.D815*E 7.& FCG/ H F&1)*’56 C10.3&-10 A.& G8D.,1&815* ’5 /-*’.5 9)$ IJ"J ! Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud

Upload: vonga

Post on 27-Aug-2018

229 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! "!

!

!

!

#$!%&'()*+)!#)*(',)()!

%-+.()&!/00.-')*12!#3'(4'56!718'5'0*!9.:1815*0!)54!;&6)5'<)*'.50!

/=>?!@/00.-')*'.5!A.&!=.815B0!C'6+*0!'5!?1:1(.D815*E!

!

7.&!FCG/!H!F&1)*'56!C10.3&-10!A.&!G8D.,1&815*!'5!/-*'.5!

9)$!IJ"J!

!

!"

!

!

!

!

Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud

Page 2: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! I!

"#$%&'()*+),)%-./!

!

>!)8!:1&$!6&)*1A3(!A.&!*+1!1K*150':1!A114L)-M!&1-1':14!.5!*+1!A'&0*!4&)A*!.A!*+'0!D)D1&!A&.8!

*+1!D)&*'-'D)5*0!.A!*+1!811*'56!.5!N#3'(4'56!718'5'0*!O1)41&0+'D!H!O..M'56!#)-M2!O..M'56!

7.&,)&4P2!.&6)5'<14!L$!FCG/!'5!F)D1!Q.,52!%.3*+!/A&'-)2!'5!R.:18L1&!IJJS2!:'<TU!F+)&(.**1!

#35-+2!R3&63(!?V)5)1:)2!>&115!?3L1(2!9)(('M)!?3**2!#'0'!/41(1$1W7)$18'2!%30)5)!7&'142!

9'-+1(!7&'148)52!C)M+11!X.$)(2!Y1(15!Z'82![1)51**1!Z(..0*1&8)52!7&)5-10!Z35&13*+1&2!

[.)55)!Z1&&2!9)'*&'!9.&)&V'2!%)530+M)!934)(')&2!%+)('5'!R)*)&)V2!G:)!R)3-M+.AA2!)54!Q)5')!

\&'5-'D1T!!!

F)&.('51!G)&(1!.A!FCG/]0!R1,!^.&M!.AA'-1!&101)&-+14!)54!D&.:'414!'5:)(3)L(1!'5D3*0!*.!*+1!

01-.54!4&)A*!.A!*+1!4.-3815*!A&.8!8)*1&')(0!):)'()L(1!.5($!'5!+)&4!-.D'10!'5!*+1!)&-+':10!.A!

*+1!F15*1&!A.&!=.815]0!X(.L)(!O1)41&0+'D!)*!C3*61&0!_5':1&0'*$2!)54!0'5-1&1!*+)5M0!*.!

F+)&(.**1!#35-+!A.&!A)-'('*)*'56!*+'0!)54!0+)&'56!0.!6151&.30($!*+1!.&)(!+'0*.&$!.A!*+1!1)&('10*!

01)&-+10!A.&!81)5'56!'5!*+1!'41)!.A!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'DT!

>!.,1!)!6&1)*!41L*!*.!\&)8)4)!915.52!9'-+1(!7&'148)52!F)&.('51!G)&(1!)54!%T!`'5'*)!A.&!

*+1'&!-)&'562!(.:'562!)54!-&'*'-)(!&1)4'56!.A!L.*+!4&)A*02!)54!A.&!'50'6+*0!*+)*!+):1!15&'-+14!'*!

15.&8.30($T!

9.0*!.A!)((2!>!A11(!D&.A.354!6&)*'*341!*.!FCG/2!)54!10D1-')(($!*.!X11*)5V)('!9'0&)2!A.&!D30+'56!

)54!03DD.&*'56!81!*.!8)M1!*+'0!+)DD152!)54!*.!X11*)5V)(']0!:'0'.5!)54!A.&10'6+*!'5!M5.,'56!

+.,!83-+!*+'0!,)0!511414a!!

!

%&'()*+)!#)*(',)()!

#)56)(.&12![3($!IJ"J

Page 3: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! b!

0&1)'&1*!

%'5-1!'*0!'5-1D*'.52!FCG/!+)0!A.-3014!.5!L3'(4'56!(1)41&0+'D!-)D)-'*$2!)54!D)&*'-3()&($!.A!

$.3561&!,.8152!*.!Nc!)001&*!*+1'&!&'6+*0!L$!-.5*'53)(($!1:)(3)*'56!&1(1:)5*!1KD1&'15-102!

d310*'.5'56!*+1'&!&.(10!'5!0.-'1*$2!-+)((156'56!D.,1&!0*&3-*3&102!)54!1AA1-*':1($!-)*)($<'56!

D.0'*':1!0.-')(!-+)561cP!='*+'5!*+'02!FCG/]0!D)&*'-3()&!6.)(!+)0!L115!*.!A.0*1&!03-+!

(1)41&0+'D!'5!*+1!A'1(40!.A!01K3)('*$2!01K3)(!&'6+*0!)54!,.815]0!+38)5!&'6+*02!,+'-+!'0!*+1!

'5*1&01-*'.5!)*!,+'-+!,1!,.&MT!!

Q+'0!-.5-1D*!D)D1&!'0!D)&*!.A!)!L&.)41&!D&.-100!()35-+14!L$!FCG/!*.!)5)($<1!)54!1:)(3)*1!

*+1!'8D)-*!.A!'*0!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!0*&)*16'102!)54!*.!1KD(.&1!+.,!*.!0*&156*+15!

*+101T!Q+1!8)'5!6.)(!.A!*+'0!1KD(.&)*'.5!,)0!5.*!81&1($!*.!-&1)*1!51,!*+1.&$!H!)(*+.36+!

*+)*!'0!:)(3)L(1!)0!,1((!H!L3*!*.!)4:)5-1!.3&!8'00'.5!.A!L&'46'56!*+1.&$!)54!D&)-*'-1!*.!L3'(4!

A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!A.&!*&)50A.&8)*':1!0.-')(!V30*'-1T!!

FCG/]0!,.&M!.:1&!*+1!D)0*!01:15!$1)&0!+)0!-.50'0*15*($!*&'14!*.!'5A.&8!D&)-*'-1!,'*+!*+1!L10*!

):)'()L(1!)5)($0'0!)54!*+1.&$!'5!*+1!A'1(40!.A!61541&2!+38)5!&'6+*02!)54!01K3)('*$2!)54!*.!

L3'(4!*+1.&$!A&.8!*+1!M5.,(1461!)54!'50'6+*0!6)'514!*+&.36+!D&)-*'-1T!!NF(1)&'56!*+1!

-.5-1D*3)(!)54!0*&)*16'-!-(.34!.5!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'DP!'0!)!A3&*+1&!1KD&100'.5!.A!*+'0!

-.88'*815*T!!>*!+)0!181&614!.3*!.A!,+)*!,1!&1)('<14!,)0!)!8)V.&!6)D!'5!.3&!M5.,(1461!

L)01!)L.3*!,+)*!0.&*0!.A!A&)81,.&M02!81*+.4.(.6'10!)54!-3&&'-3()!+):1!1:.(:14!'5!*+'0!

4.8)'52!)54!8.&1!'8D.&*)5*($2!)L.3*!*+1!1AA1-*':15100!.A!-3&&15*!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!

'5*1&:15*'.50!*.!L3'(4!'5-(30':12!&'6+*0W)AA'&8'562!)54!61541&WV30*!0.-')(!-+)561!(1)41&0+'DT!!

Q+'0!-.5-1D*!D)D1&!'0!D)&*!.A!)!()&61&!D&.-100!*+)*!011M0!*.!A'((!*+'0!6)D2!)54!*.!4.-3815*!

L.*+!*+1!0*&156*+0!)54!03--10010!.A!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!0.!A)&2!)0!,1((!)0!*+1!

)8L'63'*'102!4'(188)0!)54!0'(15-10!)L.3*!'*0!('8'*0!)54!0+.&*-.8'560!W!,+)*!)&1!*+1$!R;Q!

4.'56e!=1!A1(*!*+1&1!,)0!)!5114!A.&!-&'*'-)(!)5)($0'0!.A!,+1*+1&!.3&!-3&&15*!8.41(0!.A!

(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!H!)54!D)&*'-3()&($!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!H!)&1!'5!A)-*!

1d3'DD'56!,.815!*.!(1)4!4'AA1&15*($2!*.!*&)50A.&8!*+1!)&-+'*1-*3&1!.A!D.,1&!,'*+'5!*+1'&!

.,5!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!8.:1815*02!)0!,1((!)0!*+1!D.,1&!0*&3-*3&10!'5!*+1!,.&(4!.3*0'41!*+)*!

-.5*'531!*.!8)&6'5)('<1!)54!.DD&100!,.815!)54!415$!*+1'&!+38)5!&'6+*0T!!!

Q.,)&40!*+'0!1542!FCG/!-.88'00'.514!A18'5'0*!0-+.()&W)-*':'0*!%&'()*+)!#)*(',)()!*.!+1(D!30!

410'65!)54!.:1&011!)!0*34$!*+)*!-.3(4!)50,1&!0.81!.A!*+101!d310*'.502!)54!*.!L&'56!.*+1&0!

'5*1&10*14!'5!,.815]0!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!'5*.!*+1!D&.-100!.A!143-)*'56!.3&01(:10!)54!

0+)&'56!.3&!1KD1&'15-10!)54!M5.,(1461T!!Q+1!D&.-100!'5-(3410!!

! /5)($0'0!.A!*+1!1K'0*'56!('*1&)*3&1!.5!(1)41&0+'D!)54!L3'(4'56!)5!)5)($*'-)(!!

A&)81,.&M!.5!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!A.&!0.-')(!*&)50A.&8)*'.5!H!.A!,+'-+!D&.-100!*+'0!

D)D1&!'0!*+1!D&.43-*f!!!

! /!6(.L)(!811*'56!.A!,.815]0!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!.&6)5'<)*'.50!*.!4'0-300!*+1!

A&)81,.&M!)54!.3&!:)&'.30!)DD&.)-+102!*+1'&!0*&156*+0!)54!('8'*)*'.502!+1(4!'5!F)D1!

Q.,52!%.3*+!/A&'-)2!A&.8!R.:18L1&!"IW"b2!IJJSf!)54!

! >A!&10.3&-10!-)5!L1!8.L'('<142!)!01*!.A!-)01!0*34'10!.A!*+1!-3&&'-3()!)54!A&)81,.&M0!

.A!*+.01!156)614!'5!,.815]0!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*2!)!-.8D)&)*':1!)5)($0'0!.A!.3&!

)DD&.)-+10f!)54!D.00'L($2!*..(M'*0!A.&!410'65'56!A3*3&1!1AA.&*0!)54!0D1-'A'-!

8.5'*.&'56!)54!1:)(3)*'.5!A&)81,.&M0!A.&!)00100'56!*+1!'8D)-*!.A!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!'5'*')*':10T!

=1!4.!5.*!011!*+'0!-.5-1D*!D)D1&!)0!*+1!A'5)(!,.&4!.5!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!H!'*!'0!)!,.&M!'5!

D&.6&1002!)5!)**18D*!*.!5)'(!4.,5!)54!0*&3-*3&1!.3&!)DD&.)-+!*.!)!-&'*'-)(!L3*!)8.&D+.30!

Page 4: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! g!

-.8D.515*!.A!.3&!8.:1815*0!)54!.&6)5'<)*'.50T!!;3&!+.D1!'0!*+)*!*+1!)5)($*'-)(!A&)81,.&M!

)54!'41)0!)&*'-3()*14!+1&1!,'((!6151&)*1!51,!(1:1(0!.A!*+'5M'56!)54!)-*'.5!*+)*!,'((!

0*&156*+15!)54!0+)&D15!.3&!-.((1-*':1!D&)K'0!.5!*&)50A.&8)*':1!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'DT!

!

+223456478!,89:4!

);2<=38>2!*8:2<3?:@!#1)"!

%2A!*27B8@!C=7D!EFGF!

!

H53:?I=<38?5/!

;:1&!*+1!D)0*!A'A*$!$1)&0!.A!41:1(.D815*!+'0*.&$2!)!01&'10!.A!)L0*&)-*!5.*'.50!)54!-.5-1D*0!

+):1!15*1&14!*+1!41:1(.D815*!(1K'-.5!)54!*+1!:.-)L3()&$!.A!)-*':'0*0T!!9)5$!.A!*+18!

L1-)81!,'41($!3014!L3<<W,.&40!)54!8)5*&)0!(.56!L1A.&1!*+1$!,1&1!41A'514!.&!

41-.50*&3-*14!H!*)M1!A.&!1K)8D(12!-.5-1D*0!('M1!ND)&*'-'D)*'.5P2!!N18D.,1&815*P2!N-':'(!

0.-'1*$P2!N8.:1815*P2!.&!N&'6+*0WL)014!)DD&.)-+TP!>5!*+1!,.&(4!.A!A18'5'082!,.815]0!&'6+*0!

)54!61541&!1d3)('*$2!*1&80!('M1!N('L1&)*'.5P2!N)3*.5.8$P2!N,.815]0!18D.,1&815*P2!)54!

N61541&!8)'50*&1)8'56P!L1-)81!,'410D&1)4T!Q+1!-.5-1D*!.A!#$%&'&()"*$+,$-(.&/2!+)0!)(0.!

L115!,'41($!4'0-300142!410-&'L14!)54!)5)($<14T!!#3*!*+1!()0*!*+'&*$!$1)&0!.A!A18'5'0*!

1KD1&'815*0!,'*+!L3'(4'56!)(*1&5)*':1!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!A.&80!)54!(1)41&0+'D!D&)-*'-10!51140!*.!

L1!'5*1&&.6)*14!)54!*+1.&'<142!D)&*'-3()&($!'5!('6+*!.A!*+1!A)&!411D1&!3541&0*)54'56!.A!D.,1&!

)54!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!L1+):'.&!*+)*!+)0!181&614!43&'56!*+'0!*'81T!!

Q+'0!*)0M!)003810!3&615-$!6':15!*+1!,'410D&1)4!301!.A!*1&80!('M1!(1)41&0+'D!)54!(1)41&02!

D)&*'-3()&($!'5!*+1!-.5*1K*!.A!0.-')(!V30*'-1!)54!,.815]0!18D.,1&815*f!L3*!1:15!8.&1!

L1-)301!15*'&1!D&.6&)80!.A!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*2!.&!(1)41&0+'D!L3'(4'562!+):1!L115!

A&)814!)54!()35-+14!,'*+.3*!)41d3)*1($!)5)($<'56!*+1!D)0*!41-)410!.A!1KD1&'15-1!)54!

0*&366(1!'5!-&1)*'56!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!D&)-*'-102!.&!&1WA&)8'56!.3&!-.5-1D*0!,'*+!*+1!

)4:)5-10!8)41!'5!A'1(40!('M1!D.,1&!)5)($0'0!)54!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!*+1.&$T!!\1&+)D0!*+'0!'0!

L1-)301!(1)41&0+'D!'0!.51!.A!*+.01!'41)0!*+)*!'0!-.50'41&14!01(AW1:'415*2!)54!+)&4($!'5!5114!

.A!1KD()5)*'.5!.&!41-.50*&3-*'.5!H!.&!D1&+)D0!L1-)301!'*!'0!.51!.A!*+.01!+)&4W*.W41A'51!

D+15.815)!*+)*!'0!-(1)&10*!,+15!'*!'0!)L015*a!!;&!L1-)301!NTTT(1)41&0+'D!'0!('M1!*+1!

/L.8'5)L(1!%5.,8)52!,+.01!A..*D&'5*0!)&1!1:1&$,+1&1!L3*!,+.!'0!5.,+1&1!*.!L1!0115TP"!

Q+'0!D)D1&!'0!*+1&1A.&1!)5!)**18D*!*.!D3((!*.61*+1&!1K'0*'56!41A'5'*'.50!)54!-.5-1D*0!)&.354!

(1)41&0+'D2!:'1,!*+101!*+&.36+!)!A18'5'0*!(1502!D()-1!*+18!'5!*+1!-.5*1K*!.A!0.-')(!V30*'-1!

)54!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D2!)54!*+15!)**18D*!*.!)&*'-3()*1!)!51,!)54!8.&1!&'6.&.30!-.5-1D*3)(!

A&)81,.&M!A.&!#$%&'&()"*$+,$-(.&/T!Y.D1A3(($2!*+'0!,'((!+1(D!A18'5'0*!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!

-)D)-'*$!L3'(41&02!)0!,1((!)0!4.5.&0!'5*1&10*14!'5!)4:)5-'56!1AA1-*':1!(1)41&0+'D!L$!)54!A.&!

,.815!@03-+!)0!A.354)*'.50!)54!,.815]0!A3540E2!*.!(..M!8.&1!-&'*'-)(($!)*!.3&!-3&&15*!

(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!)DD&.)-+102!)54!0*&156*+15!.3&!D&)-*'-1!'5!*+'0!:'*)(!)&15)T!

'BD!I?29!3B89!J4332:K!

?.10!-.5-1D*3)(!-()&'*$!)L.3*!(1)41&0+'D!H!10D1-')(($!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!W!&1)(($!8)**1&e!!>A!

,1!)((!M5.,!,+)*!'*!'02!03&1($!41A'5'*'.50!)&1!)!8)**1&!.A!018)5*'-0e!!;5!*+1!-.5*&)&$2!*+1&1!'0!

)!:1&$!'8D.&*)5*!&1)0.5!*.!*&$!*.!N5)'(!*+1!V1(($!*.!*+1!,)((PU!'A!,1!-)5]*!41A'51!)54!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1 =)&&15!#155'0!h!#3&*!R)5302!!"#$"%&'()*%#*"+,"&(-.%(/#0,1+(23#%+"2!R1,!^.&M2!Y)&D1&!F.(('502!"iij2!\T"i

Page 5: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! k!

41-.50*&3-*!(1)41&0+'D2!10D1-')(($!*+1!M'54!.A!A18'5'0*!0.-')(!V30*'-1!(1)41&0+'D!,1!)&1!*)(M'56!

)L.3*2!*+15!,1!+):1!5.!,)$!.A!)00100'56!*+1!:)(31!.&!1AA'-)-$!.A!*+1!(1)41&0+'D!

41:1(.D815*!'5*1&:15*'.50!'5!,+'-+!,1!)&1!156)614T!!/0!0.-')(!V30*'-1!.&6)5'<)*'.502!

,.815]0!.&6)5'<)*'.502!-)D)-'*$WL3'(4'56!.&6)5'<)*'.502!)54!4.5.&0!H!,1!+):1!)((!'5:10*14!

15.&8.30!151&6$2!+38)5!&10.3&-102!-&1)*':'*$!)54!8.51$!'5!L3'(4'56!(1)41&0+'D!A.&!0.-')(!

*&)50A.&8)*'.5T!!Y.,!4.!,1!M5.,!,+1*+1&!.3&!8.41(0!)&1!L3'(4'56!*+1!M'540!.A!(1)41&0!,1!

51142!)54!+.,!4.!,1!81)03&1!*+1'&!'8D)-*e!!Y.,!4.!,1!M5.,!,+)*!-&'*'-)(!L3*!+'4415!

)0D1-*0!.A!(1)41&0+'D!.3&!)DD&.)-+10!)&1!5.*!)44&100'562!)54!+15-1!A)'('56!*.!L3'(4!*+1!:1&$!

)(*1&5)*':1!(1)41&0+'D!*+)*!'0!*+1'&!6.)(e!/54!8.0*!'8D.&*)5*!.A!)((2!+.,!4.!,1!'5*16&)*1!)54!

)4:)5-1!.3&!)DD&.)-+10!L$!+)&:10*'56!*+1!(1)&5'56!A&.8!*+1!()0*!41-)410!.A!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'D!1KD1&'15-1!'5!L.*+!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!8.:1815*0!)&.354!*+1!,.&(4e!!R.51!.A!

*+101!6.)(0!-)5!L1!1AA1-*':1($!)-+'1:14!,'*+.3*!-(1)&'56!*+1!-.5-1D*3)(!-(.34!H!,'*+.3*!

-.5-1D*3)('<'56!*+1!*+1.&$!)54!D&)-*'-1!.A!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!8.&1!-(1)&($T!

!

/5.*+1&!'8D1&)*':1!A.&!-&1)*'56!8.&1!-()&'*$!'0!*+)*!(1)41&0+'D!'0!)!4"#1&2!5.*!)5!154T!!=1!

L3'(4!(1)41&0+'D!-)D)-'*$!)54!0M'((0!-.%!0.81*+'562!*.($.!0.81*+'56!.&!53#1+"!0.81*+'562!

)54!5.*!L1-)301!(1)41&0+'D!'0!)!D&.43-*!.&!01&:'-1!A.&!-.5038D*'.5T!!Q+'0!'0!10D1-')(($!*&31!'5!

0.-')(!V30*'-1!-.5*1K*0T!!='*+.3*!3541&0*)54'56!-(1)&($!*+1!-.5-1D*!)54!D&)-*'-1!.A!

(1)41&0+'D!A.&!A18'5'0*!0.-')(!*&)50A.&8)*'.52!)54!+.,!*+1!*,.!)&1!&1()*14!*.!.51!)5.*+1&2!

,1!)&1!,)(M'56!4.,5!)!L('54!)((1$T!!=.&012!,1!)&1!8)M'56!)0038D*'.50!)L.3*!*+1!('5M0!

L1*,115!*+1!*,.!*+)*!8)$!.&!8)$!5.*!L1!:)('4T!

!

>541142!)!-&'*'-)(!)5)($0'0!.A!*+1!8)*1&')(!.5!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!'5!*+1!0.-')(!V30*'-1!

-.5*1K*!'0!&'A1!,'*+!)0038D*'.502!*+.36+!A1,!.A!*+101!)&1!1KD('-'*T!!7.&!1K)8D(12!*+1&1!'0!)!

3L'd3'*.30!)0038D*'.5!*+)*!0*&.562!-.+1&15*!(1)41&0+'D!H!)54!0*&.562!-.8D1*15*!'54':'43)(!

(1)41&0!W!,'((!'51:'*)L($!0*&156*+15!)54!15+)5-1!*+1!'8D)-*!.A!0.-')(!-+)561!.&6)5'<)*'.502!

'5*1&:15*'.502!)54!8.:1815*0T!!#3*!*+1&1!'0!4.-3815*14!1:'415-1!.A!0.-')(!8.:1815*0!

,'*+!+'6+($!4'0D1&014!)54!5.5W'54':'43)('0*'-!(1)41&0+'D!*+)*!+):1!)-+'1:14!&18)&M)L(1!

&103(*0!H!*+1!\'d31*1&.0!)54!\'d31*1&)0!.A!/&615*'5)2!A.&!1K)8D(12!.&!*+1!-)8D)'65!*.!L)5!

()548'510T!!%.!D1&+)D0!0*&.56!(1)41&0+'D!'0!)!301A3(!L3*!'503AA'-'15*!-.54'*'.5!A.&!1AA1-*':1!

-+)561T!!!

!

7'5)(($2!,1!5114!6&1)*1&!-()&'*$!)54!)!8.&1!)5)($*'-)(!)DD&.)-+!*.!(1)41&0+'D!'5!.&41&!*.!

4'0*'563'0+!L1*,115!*+1!4'AA1&15*!A.&802!8.41(02!)54!0*$(10!.A!(1)41&0+'D2!*+1!4':1&01!

D3&D.010!*.!,+'-+!'*!'0!)DD('142!)54!*+1!'41.(.6'-)(!A&)81,.&M0!*+)*!'5A.&8!'*0!D&)-*'-1T!!Q+'0!

'0!,+1&1!,1!8.:1!L1$.54!*+1!410-&'D*':1!W!(..M'56!81&1($!)*!,+)*!(1)41&0+'D!,&!W!*.,)&40!

*+1!5.&8)*':12!,+'-+!'0!-.5-1&514!,'*+!,+)*!6..4!(1)41&0+'D!0+.3(4!L1T!!Q+'0!'0!-&'*'-)(!'5!

*+1!-.5*1K*!.A!-"4,1,&*!(1)41&0+'D2!0'5-1!.3&!-.5-1&5!'0!5.*!81&1($!,'*+!-)D)-'*)*'56!8.&1!

,.815!*.!D()$!(1)41&0+'D!&.(102!L3*!*.!(1)4!4'AA1&15*($2!,'*+!A18'5'0*!:)(310!)54!'41.(.6$2!

)54!*.!)4:)5-1!*+1!)6154)!.A!A18'5'0*!0.-')(!*&)50A.&8)*'.5!'5!)!,)$!*+)*!.*+1&!A.&80!.A!

(1)41&0+'D!4.!5.*!)54!-)55.*T!!%3-+!-()&'*$!,.3(4!)(0.!15)L(1!30!*.!L3'(4!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!

-)D)-'*$!'5!5.5WA18'5'0*!,.815!)54!815a!

!

%.!A.&!)((!*+101!&1)0.502!'*!'0!*'81!,1!-.5A&.5*14!*+1!)8L'63'*$!)54!)*!(1)0*!)**18D*!*.!

41-.50*&3-*!,+)*!(1)41&0+'D!8'6+*!81)5!*.!*+.01!.A!30!-.88'**14!*.!A18'5'0*!0.-')(!

*&)50A.&8)*'.5T!

!

%48785L!3B2!C277D!3?!3B2!'477/!*2M8585L!"N93:4<3!HI249!

!

?1A'5'56!)54!35D)-M'56!)L0*&)-*!'41)0!'0!)!-+)((15612!L3*!5.*!'8D.00'L(1T!!;:1&!*+1!D)0*!*,.!

41-)4102!6&1)*!0*&'410!+):1!L115!8)41!'5!41-.50*&3-*'56!)!538L1&!.A!)L0*&)-*!L3*!:'*)(!

Page 6: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! l!

0.-')(!&1)('*'102!)54!'5!A'54'56!,)$0!.A!81)03&'56!*+18T!!\1&+)D0!*+1!8.0*!+'0*.&'-!,)0!*+1!

-.5-1D*!.A!N+38)5!41:1(.D815*P2!D'.511&14!L$!*+1!()*1!9)+L3L!3(!Y3d!)*!*+1!_R?\2!)0!

D)&*!.A!+'0!0*&366(1!*.!-.35*1&!*+1!+'6+($!1-.5.8'0*'-!)DD&.)-+10!*.!41:1(.D815*!)4:)5-14!

L$!*+1!#&1**.5!=..40!'50*'*3*'.50T!!Q+1!Y38)5!?1:1(.D815*!>541K!@.&!Y?>E2!A.&!)((!'*0!

0+.&*-.8'5602!L1-)81!)!,'41($!)--1D*14!D&.K$!A.&!*+1!(1:1(!.A!4'0D)&'*$!m!1d3'*$!'5!)!0.-'1*$T!!

>*!+)0!6&.,5!*.!L1!.51!.A!*+1!8.0*!D.,1&A3(!)4:.-)-$!*..(0!'5!*+1!,.&(42!)54!1:'415-1!*+)*!

-&1)*'56!)5!)--100'L(1!)54!4$5)8'-!L3*!5.*!&,467,&*,5(81)03&1!.A!)5!)L0*&)-*'.5!('M1!+38)5!

41:1(.D815*!'0!:1&$!301A3(!'5!*+1!N&1)(P!,.&(4T!!

!

/(.56!0'8'()&!('5102!-&1)*':1!&101)&-+1&0!)54!)-*':'0*0!+):1!41:1(.D14!A&)81,.&M0!A.&!

)00100'56!03-+!-.8D(1K!)54!)L0*&)-*!D+15.815)!)0!,.&(4!:)(310!@*+1!=.&(4!`)(310!

%3&:1$IE2!-.&&3D*'.5!@Q&)50D)&15-$!>5*1&5)*'.5)(]0!F.&&3D*'.5!\1&-1D*'.5!>541K

bE2!)54!

418.-&)-$!@7&114.8!Y.301]0!?18.-&)-$!03&:1$0!)54!*+1!\.('*$!D&.V1-*!01&'10gET!!/((!*+101!

4'AA1&15*!81*+.4.(.6'10!+):1!)**18D*14!*.!-)D*3&1!0.-')(!)54!D.('*'-)(!D+15.815)!*+&.36+!

-.5-&1*1!'54'-)*.&02!0'5-1!*+1$!&1:1)(!*+1!'5+1&15*!-+)((15610!'5:.(:14!'5!81)03&'56!)54!

-.5-&1*'<'56!)L0*&)-*!'41)0!*+)*!)&1!1KD1&'15-14!)54!0115!'5!&1)('*$T!

!

7'5)(($2!)!D(1*+.&)!.A!A18'5'0*!&101)&-+1&0!)54!'55.:)*':1!*+'5M1&0!+):1!A.&!41-)410!

41:1(.D14!A&)81,.&M0!)54!'54'-)*.&0!A.&!*&)50()*'56!*+1!&1)('*$!.A!61541&!4'0-&'8'5)*'.5!

'5*.!8)5)61)L(1!)54!-.8D1(('56!4)*)!)54!)00100815*!*..(0!H!1T6T!,1!+):1!A&)81,.&M0!A.&!

)00100'56!*+1!0*)*30!.A!,.8152!:'.(15-1!)6)'50*!,.8152!)54!61541&!4'0D)&'*'10T!!%3&1($!

D'55'56!4.,5!*+1!-.5-1D*!.A!(1)41&0+'D!A.&!A18'5'0*!0.-')(!*&)50A.&8)*'.5!'0!1d3)(($!A1)0'L(1a!

!

/!0*34$!.A!)((!*+101!4'AA1&15*!A&)81,.&M0!)54!81)03&1815*!*..(0!&1:1)(!*+)*!61**'56!*.!6&'D0!

,'*+!)L0*&)-*!'41)0!'5:.(:10!)**18D*'56!*.!A'K2!,'*+!)0!83-+!-()&'*$!)54!D&1-'0'.5!)0!D.00'L(12!

)*!(1)0*!A.3&!M1$!4'8150'.50U!!

!

"T 'B43!89!83K!?1A'5'56!*+1!-.5-1D*!)0!-(1)&($!)0!,1!-)5f!

IT 'B43O9!85!83K!_5D)-M'56!*+1!-.&1!-.8D.515*0!.A!*+1!D+15.815.5f!!

bT 'B2:2!89!83K!O.-)*'56!*+1!0'*10!,+1&1!*+1!D+15.815.5!.--3&0f!)54!

gT 'B43!I?29!83!7??P!78P2K!/5)($<'56!*+1!M1$!-+)&)-*1&'0*'-0!.A!*+1!D+15.815.5!'5!

D&)-*'-1T!

!

Q+'0!4.-3815*!,'((!)44&100!*+1!A'&0*!A.3&!d310*'.502!0.!*+)*!'*0!301&0!H!(1)41&0+'D!

D&)-*'*'.51&0!)54!(1)41&0+'D!-)D)-'*$!L3'(41&0!'5!4'AA1&15*!(.-)*'.502!0.-'.WD.('*'-)(!-.5*1K*02!

*+18)*'-!)&1)02!)54!(1:1(0!.A!156)61815*!H!-)5!)50,1&!*+1!A'A*+T!!=1!+.D1!*+1!-.5-1D*3)(!

A&)81,.&M!,1!D&1015*!+1&1!,'((!+1(D!$.3!*.!(..M!)*!+.,!(1)41&0+'D!,.&M0!'5!$.3&!-.5*1K*0!

)54!3541&0*)54!,+)*!-+)5610!5114!*.!L1!8)41!*.!8)M1!'*!,.&M!)0!'*!0+.3(4a!!

!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!2 %11!,,,T,.&(4:)(31003&:1$T.&6

3 %11!,,,T*&)50D)&15-$T.&6

4 %11!,,,TA&114.8+.301T.&6!)54!,,,T0$0*18'-D1)-1T.&6mD.('*$mD.('*$gT+*8!!

Page 7: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! j!

!

!

HQ 'B43!89!83K!*2M8585L!724I2:9B8R!

!

89/3"%"(#%":(#74.&*(#&(4#1;($"-,1,*,.1&(.-(7"#$"%&3,6(#&(*3"%"(#%"(6"%&.1&(<3.(3#="(

#**"46*"$(*.($"-,1"(*3"(5.15"6*>8?(

(

8@7<#;&A(,*(&""4&A(*3"(5.15"6*(.-(7"#$"%&3,6("7B$"&(B&(.%(*B%1&(B6(,1(#1.*3"%(-.%4(*.(

*#B1*(B&(#+#,1(<,*3(,*&(&7,66"%,1"&&(#1$(5.467"C,*;>().(<"(3#="(,1="1*"$(#1("1$7"&&(

6%.7,-"%#*,.1(.-(*"%4&(*.($"#7(<,*3(,*(>(>(>(#1$(&*,77(*3"(5.15"6*(,&(1.*(&B--,5,"1*7;(

$"-,1"$>8D(

!

Q+101!)&1!35):.'4)L(1!*&3'080T!!/A*1&!0'A*'56!*+&.36+!('*1&)(($!+354&140!.A!41A'5'*'.502!>!A.354!

*+)*!*+1$!A)((!'5*.!*,.!-)*16.&'10U!41A'5'*'.50!.A!7"#$"%E&2!,+'-+!8)'5($!A.-30!.5!*+1!

)**&'L3*10!)54!D&)-*'-10!.A!1AA1-*':1!(1)41&02!)54!41A'5'*'.50!.A!7"#$"%&3,62!)0!)!D&.-100!)54!

D&)-*'-1T!!Q+101!41A'5'*'.50!-.81!()&61($!A&.8!*+1!8)5)61815*!)54!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!

41:1(.D815*!A'1(40T!!>!)(0.!A.354!*+)*!'5!*+1!&1-15*!D)0*2!*+1!NA18'5'51!0*$(1!.A!(1)41&0+'DP!

+)0!L1-.81!D.D3()&!'5!*+1!-.&D.&)*1!,.&(42!)0!()&61&!538L1&0!.A!,.815!15*1&14!

-.8D)5'10!)54!L16)5!*.!418.50*&)*1!*+)*!*+1$!-.3(4!D&.43-1!&103(*0!)54!D&.A'*0!*+&.36+!

4'AA1&15*!81)50!A&.8!*+1!*10*.0*1&.51W4&':15!8)(1!0*$(1!*+1!NL.$0P!+)4!3014!

@-.8D1*'*':151002!)66&100'.52!1*-TET!!/54!,+'(1!0.81!.A!*+101!10015*')('<1!,.815!)54!0118!

*.!L3'(4!.5!61541&W0*1&1.*$D10!)L.3*!,.815]0!,)$0!.A!,.&M'56!)54!41)('56!,'*+!.*+1&02!

*+1$!4.!&1-.65'<1!'54'&1-*($!*+)*!61541&!-.50*&3-*'.5!D&.-10010!&103(*!'5!,.815!516.*')*'56!

'5*1&WD1&0.5)(!)54!-.((1-*':1!D&.-10010!4'AA1&15*($2!)54!D.00'L($!8.&1!1AA1-*':1($T!

!

/DD154'K!@'E!D&.:'410!)!01(1-*'.5!.A!8)'50*&1)8!41A'5'*'.50!.A!(1)41&02!)54!0.81!D&.:.-)*':1!

)54!'5*1&10*'56!41A'5'*'.50!.A!(1)41&0+'Df!*+1$!+1(D!*.!61*!30!*+'5M'56!)L.3*!*+1!-.5*15*!)54!

-+)&)-*1&'0*'-0!.A!(1)41&0!)54!(1)41&0+'D!8.&1!6151&)(($2!)54!)L.3*!+.,!*+101!4':1&61!.&!

-.5:1&61!,'*+!A18'5'0*!41A'5'*'.50T!C1:'1,'56!*+101!41A'5'*'.502!>*!'0!0*&'M'56!*+)*!*+1!:)0*!

8)V.&'*$!)&1!.A!R.&*+1&5m=10*1&5!.&'6'52!L)&&'56!*+1!.510!A&.8!F+'5101!D+'(.0.D+1&!O).!

Q012!)54!*+)*!*+1$!)&1!.:1&,+1(8'56($!8)(1T!9.0*!&1-15*!0-+.()&0+'D!.5!(1)41&0+'D!)54!

(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!)(0.!-.810!.3*!.A!*+1!8)5)61815*!0-+..(0!)54!8)5)61815*!

&101)&-+2!)54!+15-1!*1540!*.!A.-30!.5!*+1!)--.8D('0+815*!.A!-.&D.&)*1!6.)(0!)54!*+1!

1AA1-*':1!8)5)61815*!.A!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!0$0*180T!!Q+1!41A'5'*'.50!.A!!NA18'5'51!

(1)41&0+'DP!&1-.65'<1!*+)*!,.815!L&'56!4'AA1&15*!d3)('*'10!*.!(1)41&0+'D2!,'*+!)!6&1)*1&!

)**15*'.5!*.!-.(()L.&)*'.52!-..D1&)*'.52!-.((1-*':1!41-'0'.5W8)M'562!)54!)L.:1!)((2!

&1()*'.50+'DWL3'(4'56T!!#3*!*+101!-.81!+)<)&4.30($!-(.01!*.!10015*')('<'56!,.815!@)54!

)K'.8)*'-)(($2!815!*..aE!)54!D()$'56!'5*.!(.56W0*)54'56!61541&!0*1&1.*$D102!1:15!'A!

35'5*15*'.5)(($T!Q+101!41A'5'*'.50!)(0.!&1:1)(!0.81!-.88.5!*+&1)402!:'<TU!

! Q+1!'54':'43)(!)0!(1)41&2!)54!*+1!(1)41&!)0!@303)(($E!)!8)5!

! Q+1!(1)41&!)0!+1&.2!)54!(1)41&0+'D!)0!+1&.'08!

! Q+1!(1)41&!)0!41-'0'.5W8)M1&!

! Q+1!(1)41&!)0!18L.4'815*!.A!-+)&)-*1&!)54!'5*16&'*$!

! Q+1!(1)41&!)0!D&.:'41&!.A!:'0'.52!8'00'.52!6.)(0!)54!0*&)*16$!A.&!*+1!15*1&D&'012!)54!

8.*':)*'56!.*+1&0!*.!0+)&1!*+.01!6.)(0!

! Q+1!-)D)-'*$!*.!'5A(315-12!'50D'&1!)54!8.*':)*1!.*+1&02!4'&1-*'56!.*+1&0]!L1+):'.&!

)54!)-*'.50!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!5 C)(D+!9T!%*.64'((2!F#1$G..0(.-(!"#$"%&3,6(H(@()B%=";(.-(/3".%;(#1$(I"&"#%532!R1,!^.&M2!7&11!\&1002!"ijg2!\T!

Iki!6 =)&&15!#155'02!8)5)61815*!63&32!"iki

Page 8: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! S!

F&1)*'56!)!-.8D.0'*1!.A!*+101!-.&1!'41)0!,.3(4!$'1(4!)!41A'5'*'.5!.A!(1)41&0+'D!)(.56!*+101!

('510U!

0+"($)"1#"+2)&1'("+',"/-12$(($(3"/$-#1-%$,"45"&',&6&,7+*("1#"2.+-+2)$-3"8'19*$,:$3"+',"

&')$:-&)53"9.1".+6$").$"2+/+2&)5")1"2-$+)$"+"6&(&1'"#1-"2.+':$3"&'(/&-$"+',"%1)&6+)$"1).$-("

)1"(.+-$").+)"6&(&1'3",$6$*1/"&,$+(3"+',"()-+)$:&$(").+)",&-$2)"+',"$'+4*$"1).$-(")1"91-8"

)19+-,(").+)"2.+':$3"+',"%+8$"2-&)&2+*",$2&(&1'(").+)"$'(7-$").$"+2.&$6$%$')"1#").$":1+*!"""

Q+1!.L:'.30!()-35)!'5!*+'0!41A'5'*'.5!'0!*+1!)L015-1!.A!)5$!D.('*'-02!-.5*1K*2!.&!:'0'.5!)L.3*!

*+1!5)*3&1!.A!*+1!N-+)561P!*+)*!(1)41&0+'D!011M0!*.!L&'562!)0!*+.36+!*+1!6B%6.&"!.A!

(1)41&0+'D!4.10!5.*!)(*1&!'*0!1#*B%"T!Q+'0!'0!*+1!6)D!*+)*!0.-'.(.6'0*![)810!`T!?.,5*.5!A'((14!

,+15!+1!)&*'-3()*14!*+1!-.5-1D*!.A!)-+'(#1-%+)&1'+*"*$+,$-(.&/;2!)!0*$(1!.A!(1)41&0+'D!

N,+1&1!.51!.&!8.&1!D1&0.50!156)61!,'*+!.*+1&0!'5!03-+!)!,)$!*+)*!(1)41&0!)54!A.((.,1&0!

&)'01!.51!)5.*+1&!*.!+'6+1&!(1:1(0!.A!8.*':)*'.5!)54!8.&)('*$TP![)810!9)-X&16.&!#3&502!)!

D.('*'-)(!0-'15*'0*2!0-+.()&!.A!D.('*'-)(!(1)41&0+'D!)54!/81&'-)5!D&10'415*')(!L'.6&)D+1&2!

A3&*+1&!41:1(.D14!?.,5*.5]0!,.&MS2!)54!*+1'&!'41)0!+)4!-.50'41&)L(1!&10.5)5-1!,'*+!

181&6'56!*+'5M'56!.5!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'DT!!!

!

#3&50!-.5*&)0*14!?.,5*.5]0!-.5-1D*!.A!*&)50A.&8)*'.5)(!(1)41&0+'D!,'*+!)-+'(+2)&1'+*"

*$+,$-(.&/2!,+'-+!)--1D*0!*+1!6.)(02!-3(*3&1!)54!0*&3-*3&1!.A!*+1!1K'0*'56!.&6)5'<)*'.5!.&!

15*1&D&'012!)54!'0!10015*')(($!L)014!.5!-.5:15*'.5)(!8.*':)*'.52!&1,)&42!D35'0+815*2!)54!

-.8D(')5-1f!-+)561!'0!)-+'1:14!'5-&1815*)(($2!)54!*+1!8.*':)*.&0!)&1!"C*%,1&,5T!>5!-.5*&)0*2!

<=-+'(#1-%&':"*$+,$-(.&/!!!"1227-("9.$'"1'$"1-"%1-$"/$-(1'("$':+:$"9&)."1).$-("&'"(72."+"

9+5").+)"*$+,$-("+',"#1**19$-("-+&($"1'$"+'1).$-")1".&:.$-"*$6$*("1#"%1)&6+)&1'"+',"

%1-+*&)5!"=.$&-"/7-/1($(3"9.&2."%&:.)".+6$"()+-)$,"17)"+("($/+-+)$"47)"-$*+)$,3"+("&'").$"

2+($"1#")-+'(+2)&1'+*"*$+,$-(.&/3"4$21%$"#7($,!">19$-"4+($("+-$"*&'8$,"'1)"+("

217')$-9$&:.)("47)"+("%7)7+*"(7//1-)"#1-"21%%1'"/7-/1($!"0!!)-+'(#1-%&':"*$+,$-(.&/"

7*)&%+)$*5"4$21%$("%1-+*"&'").+)"&)"-+&($(").$"*$6$*"1#".7%+'"21',72)"+',"$).&2+*"

+(/&-+)&1'"1#"41)."*$+,$-"+',"*$,3"+',").7("&)".+("+")-+'(#1-%&':"$##$2)"1'"41).!<i!!!

!

=+'(1!A18'5'0*0!,.3(4!d310*'.5!*+1!301!.A!*1&80!('M1!8.&)(!)54!8.&)('*$2!*+101!)4:)5-10!'5!

*+'5M'56!.5!(1)41&0+'D!8.41(0!+1(D!30!&1-.65'<1!+.,2!41D154'56!.5!-3(*3&)(!-.5*1K*!)54!

+'0*.&$2!4.8'5)5*!8.41(0!)54!D&)-*'-10!.A!(1)41&0+'D!)&1!411D($!18L14414!,'*+'5!302!1:15!

'A!,1!)&1!A18'5'0*!,.815!H!)54!815!W!011M'56!*.!-+)561!.3&!.,5!D&)-*'-1T!;51!&1-15*!)54!

301A3(!)5)($0'0!.A!+.,!61541&2!A18'5'082!)54!(1)41&0+'D!-.81!*.61*+1&!)54!)AA1-*!.51!

)5.*+1&!)(0.!+1(D0!30!D()-1!*+101!:)&'.30!41A'5'*'.50!'5!)!A18'5'0*!D1&0D1-*':1T!!>5!*+1!:.(381!

N=.815!)54!O1)41&0+'D2P"J!#1&5'-1!O.**]0!'5*&.43-*'.5!.AA1&0!30!*+&11!'50'6+*0!)L.3*!

D&1:)'('56!)DD&.)-+10!*.!(1)41&0+'D!)54!,.815""U!

! Q+)*!8)'50*&1)8!&101)&-+!)54!*+1.&'<)*'.5!.5($!156)610!,'*+!*+1!n-"4,1,1"]H!5.*!

-"4,1,&*(W!0*$(1!.A!(1)41&0+'Df!

! G:15!,.&M0!$"=.*"$(*.(<.4"1J&(7"#$"%&3,6!4.!5.*!)44&100!.&!4'0-300!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'Df!)54!

! Q+1!#**%,GB*"&(.-(-"4,1,1"(7"#$"%&3,6(&*;7"&(#%"(#77(<,*3,1(*3"(#55"6*"$(+"1$"%"$(

%.7"&(.-(<.4"12!'T1T2!53&*3&'562!-)&'562!0150'*':12!-..D1&)*':12!-.503(*)*':12!'5-(30':12!

1*-T!1*-T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!7 [)810!`'-*.&!?.,5*.52!I"G"7(!"#$"%&3,6'(2.44,*4"1*(#1$(23#%,&4#(,1(*3"(I"=.7B*,.1#%;(K%.5"&&A!#)0'560*.M12!

9)-8'(()5!\3L('0+'56!F.8D)5$2!"ijb!S![)810!9)-X&16.&!#3&502!O1)41&0+'D2!R1,!^.&M2!Y)&D1&!F.(('502!"ijS!

9 [)810!9)-X&16.&!#3&502!"ijS2!.DT-'*T2!DTIJ!"J![1)5!O)3!F+'52!#1&5'-1!GT!O.**!)54![)5'-1!%)5-+1<WY3-(10!@G40E2!=.815!)54!O1)41&0+'DU!Q&)50A.&8'56!`'0'.50!

)54!?':1&01!`.'-102!#()-M,1((!\3L('0+'562!IJJj!""!#1&5'-1!O.**2!,G,$T2!DTIg!W!Ij!

Page 9: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! i!

O.**!)001&*0!*+)*!'*!'0!-&'*'-)(!*.!8)M1!)!4'0*'5-*'.5!L1*,115!A18'5'51!)54!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D2!

0'5-1!*+1!A.&81&!4.10!5.*!156)61!,'*+!61541&!D.,1&!)54!,.815]0!()-M!.A!)--100!*.!A.&8)(!

D.0'*'.50!.A!)3*+.&'*$T!!%+1!D&.D.010!:1&$!0150'L($!*+)*!L.*+!*+1!*1&80!NA18'5'08P!)54!

NA18'5'0*P!+):1!*.!L1!3541&0*..4!8.&1!-(1)&($!L1A.&1!-()&'*$!-)5!L1!)-+'1:14!.5!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'DT!%.!(1*!30!*3&5!5.,!*.!+.,!A18'5'0*0!+):1!41A'514!)54!3541&0*..4!*+1!5.*'.5!.A!

(1)41&0+'DT!!!

*2M8585L!02J85893!(24I2:9B8R!!

Q+1!01)&-+!A.&!41A'5'*'.50!.A!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!'0!8.&1!-+)((156'56!*+)5!.51!,.3(4!

'8)6'51"IT!!/0!)!A18'5'0*!()L.&!0-+.()&!&1-15*($!,&.*12!NQ+1!1K)-*!*1&8!nA18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D]!

D&.:14!*.!L1!0-)&-1!'5!*+1!('*1&)*3&1!*+)*!4'0-30010!,.815!'5!(1)41&0+'D!D.0'*'.50TP"b!!

>541142!>!A.354!*+1!&103(*0!.A!8$!1)&($!,1LWL)014!&101)&-+!1d3)(($!4'0)DD.'5*'56T!;*+1&0!

,+.!+):1!,.&M14!-.50'0*15*($!.5!351)&*+'56!41A'5'*'.502!'41)0!)54!'5A.&8)*'.5!)L.3*!

A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!A'54!*+)*!,+'(1!0.81!4)*)!1K'0*0!)L.3*!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!'5!4'AA1&15*!

4.8)'50!@'5!6&)00&..*0!6&.3D02!-.8835'*$!,.&M2!L30'5100!8)5)61815*2!)54!*1)-+'56E2!'*!

+)0!5.*!L115!A3(($!1KD(.&14!.&!41:1(.D14!)0!)!A18'5'0*!-.50*&3-*T!!

!

Q+'0!4.10!5.*!81)5!*+)*!A18'5'0*0!+):1!5.*!'5*1&&.6)*14!)54!)5)($<14!(1)41&0+'D!)0!)!

-.5-1D*!)54!D&)-*'-12!.&!*+)*!'*!+)0!5.*!.--3D'14!)5!'8D.&*)5*!D()-1!'5!A18'5'0*!41L)*10!'5!

4'AA1&15*!D)&*0!.A!*+1!,.&(4T!!;5!*+1!-.5*&)&$2!.3&!&101)&-+!&1:1)(0!*+)*!0'5-1!*+1!4),5!.A!

1)&($!8.41&5!H!.&!N%1-.54!=):1P!H!A18'5'08!'5!*+1!%1:15*'10!)54!G>6+*'102!A18'5'0*!

*+'5M1&0!)54!)-*':'0*0!)44&10014!*+1!d310*'.5!.A!(1)41&0+'D!:1&$!)-*':1($"g2"k2!L1('1:'56!*+)*!

Nc!(1)41&0+'D!'0!)!-&3-')(!8)M1!.&!L&1)M!'0031!A.&!A18'5'08TP"l!!

93-+!.A!*+1!1)&($!A18'5'0*!,.&M!.5!(1)41&0+'D!181&614!A&.8!R.&*+!/81&'-)5!A18'5'0*02!)54!

.--3&&14!,'*+'5!()&61&!4'0-300'.50!.A!D.,1&2!)54!.A!)(*1&5)*':12!5.5WD)*&')&-+)(2!5.5W

+'1&)&-+'-)(!0*&3-*3&10!)54!.&6)5'<)*'.50"jT!!%.3*+1&5!A18'5'0*0!,1&1!D1&+)D0!(100!A.-3014!

.5!(1)41&0+'D!D1&!01!)*!*+'0!*'812!L3*!1d3)(($!156)614!'5!1KD1&'815*0!,'*+!)(*1&5)*':1!

0*&3-*3&10!)54!D&.-100102!)54!,'*+!411D!)5)($010!.A!*+1!61541&14!5)*3&1!.A!D.,1&!'5!*+1!

0.-')(2!1-.5.8'-2!)54!D.('*'-)(!&1)(8T!!/54!'5!L.*+!R.&*+!)54!%.3*+2!*+1&1!,)0!,'410D&1)4!

&101)&-+!)54!)5)($0'0!.A!,.815]0!1K-(30'.5!A&.8!D.,1&!)54!)3*+.&'*$!'5!*+1!D3L('-!&1)(82!

,'*+!)--.8D)5$'56!)4:.-)-$!-)8D)'650!A.&!'5-&1)0'56!,.815]0!)--100!*.!D.('*'-)(!D.,1&2!

)54!A.&!6&1)*1&!&1D&1015*)*'.5!.A!,.815!'5!(1)41&0+'D!D.0'*'.50!'5!6.:1&5815*2!L30'51002!

)54!-':'(!0.-'1*$T!!!

!

F.501d315*($2!A18'5'0*!)DD&.)-+10!*.!)54!41A'5'*'.50!.A!(1)41&0+'D!,1&1!.A*15!'54'&1-*!

D&.43-*0!.A!*+1'&!0*&366(10!*.!1K)8'51!*+1'&!.,5!&1()*'.50+'D!*.!)54!D&)-*'-1!.A!D.,1&2!*.!

)4:)5-1!61541&!1d3)('*$!'5!D.0'*'.50!.A!D.,1&!'5!*+1!D3L('-!)54!D&':)*1!01-*.&2!)54!*.!-&1)*1!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"I!Q+1!4'(188)!,)0!-)D*3&14!L$!*+1!D()'5*':1!D(1)!.A!)!F)5)4')5!6&)43)*1!0*3415*!>!A.354!43&'56!8$!,1L!

&101)&-+U!!N>!+):1!*.!4.!)!*1&8!D)D1&!.5!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!)54!>!-)5]*!A'54!)!0'56(1!41A'5'*'.5!H!-)5!0.81.51!

+1(DeP!"b!O'0)!9'*-+1((2!N718'5'0*!O1)41&0+'D!'5!*+1!\&':)*1!%1-*.&U!%.81,+1&1!;3*!*+1&1eP2!O)L.3&!%*34'10!?1D*T2!

_5':1&0'*$!.A!=)'M)*32!R1,!o1)()542!71LTIJJg2!\TI!"g!G)&($!A18'5'0*!V.3&5)(0!('M1!p310*U!*+1!718'5'0*!p3)&*1&($2!-)&&'14!4'0-300'.50!.A!A18'5'08]0!'5*1&01-*'.5!,'*+!

(1)41&0+'D!A&.8!)0!1)&($!)0!"ijlf!*+1!,&'*'560!.A!!O.&&)'51!9)0*1&0.52!N718'5'0*!O1)41&0!F)5]*!=)(M!.5!=)*1&P!@>>!

qgr!IiWgJE2!7(.&)!F&)*1&2!NO1)41&0+'D2!X&.,*+2!)54!%D'&'*P2!@>>!qgr!lJ!H!llE2!)54![)-M'1!%*T![.)52!N=+.!=)0!

C18L&)54*]0!8.*+1&eP!@>>!qgr!lj!H!jiE!)&1!d3'*1!'5*1&10*'56!6('8D010!'5*.!1)&($!=10*1&5!A18'5'0*!*+'5M'56!.5!

(1)41&0+'D!'00310T!"k!9)&$!%T!Y)&*8)552!"iii2!Q)(M'56!O1)41&0+'DU!F.5:1&0)*'.50!,'*+!\.,1&A3(!=.8152!R1,!#&350,'-M2!C3*61&0!

_5':1&0'*$!\&100T!"l!!p310*2!/!718'5'0*!p3)&*1&($2!"ijl2!NO1)41&0+'DP2!>>!@gET!

"j!GT6T2!F+)&(.**1!#35-+!)54!#1:1&($!7'0+1&2!"ijl2!N=+)*!73*3&1!A.&!O1)41&0+'DeP2!'5!p310*U!/!718'5'0*!p3)&*1&($!>>!

@gEUIW"b!

Page 10: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! "J!

A18'5'0*!0*&3-*3&10!*+)*!,.3(4!5.*!&1D&.43-1!*+1!D)*&')&-+)(!8.41(0!*+)*!4.8'5)*14!8.0*!

0.-'1*'10!)54!-3(*3&10T!!Q+1&1!,)0!)!:1&$!:'L&)5*!01)&-+!A.&!*+1.&$!)54!D&)-*'-1!'5!)(*1&5)*':1!

,)$0!.A!30'56!)54!)DD($'56!D.,1&2!51,2!5.5W+'1&)&-+'-)(!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!A.&802!)54!*+302!

51,!,)$0!.A!(1)4'56T!!!

_5A.&*35)*1($2!83-+!.A!*+'0!1)&('1&!A18'5'0*!)5)($0'0!'0!'5:'0'L(1!*.!30!L1-)301!'*!'0!5.*!

):)'()L(1!.5('51!.&!'5!8)5)61815*!.&!0-+.()&($!0.-')(!0-'15-1!V.3&5)(0!H!'*!'0!(.-)*14!'5!*+1!

('L&)&'10!.A!35':1&0'*'10!.&!'541D15415*!,.815]0!0*34'10!-15*1&02!'5!35D3L('0+14!&1D.&*0!.A!

811*'5602!.&!'5!'54':'43)(!,.815]0!D1&0.5)(!)&-+':10!.A!*+1!41L)*10!)54!4'0-300'.50!)&.354!

*+1!03LV1-*!'5!*+1!jJ0!)54!SJ0T!!Q+1!A.((.,'56!41A'5'*'.502!*+1&1A.&12!+):1!L115!-3((14!A&.8!

L.*+!.5('51!)54!.AA('51!0.3&-1!8)*1&')(2!0D)55'56!)*!(1)0*!*+'&*$!$1)&0!.A!A18'5'0*!*+'5M'56!

)L.3*!(1)41&0+'DU!

!

*2M85838?59!?M!02J85893!(24I2:9B8R!

!"#$"%&3,6(-%.4(#(-"4,1,&*(&*#1$6.,1*(,&(,1-.%4"$(G;(*3"(6.<"%(.-(*3"(-"4,1,&*(7"1&A(<3,53(

"1#G7"&(*3"(-"4,1,&*(7"#$"%(*.(,$"1*,-;(,1LB&*,5"&(#1$(.66%"&&,.1&(#1$(,1&6,%"&(3"%(*.(-#5,7,*#*"(

*3"($"="7.64"1*(.-(4.%"(,157B&,="A(3.7,&*,5(M>(5.44B1,*,"&>(N"4,1,&*(7"#$"%&(#%"(4.*,=#*"$(

G;(-#,%1"&&A(LB&*,5"A(#1$("OB,*;(#1$(&*%,="(*.(0""6(,&&B"&(.-(+"1$"%A(%#5"A(&.5,#7(57#&&A(&"CB#7(

.%,"1*#*,.1A(#1$(#G,7,*;(#*(*3"(-.%"-%.1*(M>>(/3"("7"4"1*&(6#%*,5B7#%(*.(#(-"4,1,&*(7"#$"%&3,6(

5.1&*%B5*,.1(,157B$"(#(-.5B&(.1(G.*3(,1$,=,$B#7(.%(4,5%.P7"="7(#1$(&.5,"*#7(.%(4#5%.P7"="7(

&.5,#7(LB&*,5"(5.15"%1&A(#($"&,%"(*.(G%,1+(4#%+,1#7,Q"$(=.,5"&(*.(*3"(5"1*"%(.-(*3"(

5.1="%&#*,.1A(#1$(#(<,77,1+1"&&(*.(*#0"(%,&0&(#&(.1"(&*%,="&(*.("1#5*(#(*%#1&-.%4#*,="(#+"1$#>(

Q&)-$!#)&*.5"S!!

M>(-"4,1,&*(M>(7"#$"%&3,6(,&(M(<.4"1(#1$(<.4"1J&(.%+#1,Q#*,.1&(&3#%,1+(6.<"%A(#B*3.%,*;(

#1$($"5,&,.1P4#0,1+(,1(.B%(5.44.1(6B%&B,*(.-(&.5,#7A(7"+#7A(6.7,*,5#7A("5.1.4,5(#1$(5B7*B%#7(

"OB#7,*;>!?/=R!;5*)&'."i!

9):.5,"*;(3#&(*"1$"$(*.(4;&*,-;(7"#$"%&3,6(&0,77&(#&(&.4"3.<(G"7.1+,1+(.17;(*.(#(-"<(6".67"(

<3.(#%"(*3"1(&""1(#&(G"**"%(*3#1("="%;G.$;("7&">(RB*(,-(<"(=,"<(7"#$"%&3,6(&0,77&(#&(

&.4"*3,1+(*3#*(4#1;(6".67"(3#="(*.(=#%;,1+($"+%""&(H(&0,77&(*3#*(5#1(G"(GB,7*(B6.1A(

&B66.%*"$A(#1$("13#15"$(G"5#B&"(*3";(#%"(1""$"$(,1(*3"(<.%7$A(1.*(,1(.%$"%(*.(4#0"(.1"(

6"%&.1(&B6"%,.%(H(*3"1(<"(4,+3*(3#="(#(G"**"%(<#;(.-($"#7,1+(<,*3(7"#$"%&3,6>!F+)&(.**1!

#35-+IJ!

S"(#%"(1.*(,1*"%"&*"$M(,1(7"#$"%&3,6(-.%(7"#$"%&3,6J&(&#0">(S"(#%"(,1*"%"&*"$(,1(G%,1+,1+(

<.4"1J&(*#7"1*&(*.(G"#%A(#7.1+(<,*3(4"1J&A(,1(#$$%"&&,1+(4#L.%(&.5,#7A(6.7,*,5#7A(#1$(

"5.1.4,5(5.15"%1&>!9)&$!%T!Y)&*8)55I"!

9/:3"(OB"&*,.1(,&(1.*(<3"*3"%(<"(&3.B7$(3#="(7"#$"%&A(GB*(3.<(<"($"="7.6(#77(<.4"1(#&(

7"#$"%&M(!"#$"%&3,6(#&(#(-B15*,.1(.-(+%.<*3(,&(#7&.A(*3"1A(*3"(6%.5"&&(.-(GB,7$,1+(5.1-,$"15"A(

1.*(.17;(&.(*3#*(.*3"%&(<,77(-.77.<A(GB*(#7&.(&.(*3#*(.*3"%&(<,77(#**"46*(7"#$"%&3,6(

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!18 Q&)-$!#)&*.52!N718'5'0*!O1)41&0+'DU!#3'(4'56!R3&*3&'56!/-)418'-!F.8835'*'10P2!'5!@$=#15,1+(S.4"1J&(

!"#$"%&3,6!;5('51![.3&5)(2!`.(TI"2!7)((!IJJlT!19 ?/=R!;5*)&'.2!+**DUmm4),5T*+.*T51*mA18'5'08""T+*8(2!Q+1!718'5'0*!\&'5-'D(1!.A!O1)41&0+'D2!)--10014!

;-*.L1&!IJJS IJ!>50*'*3*1!A.&!=.815]0!O1)41&0+'DT!IJJIT!N\.,1&!A.&!=+)*e!=.815]0!O1)41&0+'DU!=+$!0+.3(4!$.3!-)&1eP2!

R)*'.5)(!?')(.631!.5!G43-)*'56!=.815!A.&!O1)41&0+'D!"2!R1,!#&350,'-M2!>50*'*3*1!A.&!=.815]0!O1)41&0+'D2!"lT!!I"!>50*'*3*1!A.&!=.815]0!O1)41&0+'DT!IJJJT!N/&1!O1)41&0!9)41!.&!#.&5e!G43-)*'56!=.815!A.&!O1)41&0+'DP2!

R)*'.5)(!?')(.631!.5!G43-)*'56!=.815!A.&!O1)41&0+'D!"2!R1,!#&350,'-M2!>50*'*3*1!A.&!=.815]0!O1)41&0+'D!2!iT!

Page 11: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! ""!

*3"4&"7="&M(,*(,&("&6"5,#77;(,46.%*#1*(*3#*(7"#$"%&3,6(G"(5.1&,$"%"$(#(-.%4(.-(&*"<#%$&3,6>(

7(.&)!F&)*1&II!

T-(;.B(<#1*(*.($.(&.4"*3,1+(G,+A(,*J&(1.*(LB&*(;.B>(U.B(3#="(*.(3#="(6".67"(<,*3(;.B(<3.(&""(

*3"(5.44.1(+.#7(.%(.GL"5*,=">((T(*3,10(*3"(4.&*(,46.%*#1*(*3,1+(,1(*#0,1+(,1,*,#*,="&(,&(*.(

4#0"(6".67"(6#%*(.-(,*(&.(*3#*(#77(.-(*3"4(<,77(-""7(*3#*(*3";(#%"(%"&6.1&,G7"M(T-(;.B(<.%0(*.(

4#0"(&.4"*3,1+(+%.<(#1$(*.(&3#%"(*3"(%"&B7*&(<,*3(.*3"%&A(*3"1(*3"(*3,1+(,1(,*&"7-(3#&(#(7,-"M((

).(T(B1$"%&*#1$(*3#*(7"#$"%&3,6(,&(%"7#*"$(*.(*3"(6.&&,G,7,*;(.-(5%"#*,1+(&.7,$(,1,*,#*,="&(*3#*(

7#&*>(U.B(5#1(+.(#<#;A(#1$(*3"(&*%B5*B%"&(.%(<3#*"="%(;.B(3#="(5%"#*"$(%"4#,1A(*3";(#%"(

*+1&1>([)-d31('51!\'*)563$Ib!

/3"%"(,&(#($,--"%"15"(G"*<""1(<.4"1J&(7"#$"%&3,6(#1$(-"4,1,&*(7"#$"%&3,6A(G"5#B&"(*3"(7#**"%(

3#&(#(6#%*,5B7#%(6.7,*,5#7(&*#1$6.,1*>(V"="%*3"7"&&A(,*(,&(,46.%*#1*(*.(,15%"#&"(*3"(1B4G"%(.-(

<.4"1(,1(7"#$"%&3,6A(6"%,.$A(%"+#%$7"&&(.-(*3",%(6.7,*,5&>(M()*B$,"&(3#="(&3.<1(*3#*(<.4"1(

*"1$(*.(7"#$(4.%"(,157B&,="7;>(/3";(3#="(G""1(6"#5"P4#0"%&(#1$(%"#53"$(#5%.&&("*31,5(7,1"&>((

!"#$"%&(#%"(G.%1(,1(6#%*A(GB*(7"#$"%&(4B&*(G"(-.&*"%"$W(4#1;(6".67"(+"*($,&5.B%#+"$(-%.4(

*%;,1+(*.(G"(7"#$"%&>(S.4"1(3#="(7"$(#(7.*A(GB*(*3",%(7"#$"%&3,6(,&(1.*(%"5.+1,Q"$>!!F+)&(.**1!

#35-+Ig!

(9T1(GB,7$,1+(N"4,1,&*(!"#$"%&3,6:(T(&#<(*3"(1""$(*.(<.%0(#*(*<.(7"="7&'(-,%&*A(GB,7$,1+(

<.4"1J&(&"7-P"&*""4(,1(.%$"%(*.(&*%"1+*3"1(*3",%(7"#$"%&3,6A(#1$(&"5.1$A(+,=,1+(<.4"1(*3"(

&0,77&A(%"&.B%5"&A(#1$(#55"&&(*.($"5,&,.1(4#0,1+(<3,53(<.B7$("1#G7"(*3"4(*.(3#="(4.%"(

6.<"%(*.(4#0"(#($,--"%"15"(,1(*3",%(.<1(5.44B1,*,"&>(T1(.*3"%(<.%$&A(7"#$"%&3,6(-.%(53#1+">(

\166$!/5*&.L30Ik(

/%#1&-.%4#*,.1#7(7"#$"%&3,6(,&(7"#$"%&3,6(5.15"%1"$(<,*3(5#B&,1+(&.5,#7(53#1+"W(-"4,1,&*(

*%#1&-.%4#*,.1#7(7"#$"%&3,6(,&(5.15"%1"$(<,*3(#53,"=,1+(+"1$"%(LB&*,5">(N.%(#1;(0,1$(.-(

-"4,1,&*(*%#1&-.%4#*,.1#7(7"#$"%&3,6A(7"#$"%&(1""$(*.(B1$"%+.(#(6%.5"&&(.-(6"%&.1#7(

*%#1&-.%4#*,.1A(5.1&5,.B&1"&&P%#,&,1+A(#1$(,1*"%1#7,Q#*,.1(.-(-"4,1,&4>(!(\166$!/5*&.L30Il(

K#*%,#%53;A(%"-7"5*"$(*3%.B+3(#77(*3"(&*%B5*B%"&(#1$(,1&*,*B*,.1&(.-(.B%(<.%7$A(,&(#(&;&*"4(*3#*(

+7.%,-,"&($.4,1#*,.1A(5.1*%.7A(=,.7"15"A(5.46"*,*,="1"&&(#1$(+%""$>((T*($"3B4#1,Q"&(4"1(#&(

4B53(#&(,*($"1,"&(<.4"1(*3",%(3B4#1,*;>().(<"(1""$(7"#$"%&3,6(*3#*(<,77("C67.%"(#1$("C6.&"(

*3"&"(7,10&(#1$(53#77"1+"(6#*%,#%53;>(/3"(.17;(7"#$"%&3,6(*3#*($."&(*3,&(,&(-"4,1,&*(7"#$"%&3,6>(!(

\166$!/5*&.L30Ij(

S.%$&(7,0"(X&#5%,-,5"JA(X#7*%B,&4J($.(1.*(&"**7"(<"77(<,*3(4#1;(-"4,1,&*&(G"5#B&"(*3"&"(

OB#7,*,"&(3#="(G""1(#GB&"$(G;(&.5,"*;M(Y;(#%+B4"1*(,&(*3#*(<"(5#1(4#0"(.B%&"7="&(

6.<"%-B7(G;(5"7"G%#*,1+(.B%(="%;(.<1(&*%"1+*3&(#1$(1.*(7"**,1+(,*(G"(LB$+"$(G;(*3"(1.%4#*,="(

=#7B"&(.-(*3"(4#7"(<.%7$M(S3;(1.*(&B++"&*(*3#*(7"#$"%&(#%"(*3.&"(<3.(5#1(7"#$(

5.44B1,*,"&(*.(<"77(G",1+(#1$(6"#5"-B7(7,=,1+Z(!"#$"%&(#%"(*3.&"(<3.(4#0"(&#5%,-,5"&A(<3.(

#%"(#7*%B,&*,5(#1$(7..0(#-*"%(.*3"%&Z>>>([17"&&(<"($.(*3#*A(#1$(%#,&"(.B%(.<1(5.1&5,.B&1"&&(.-(

*3"(OB#7,*;(#1$(5.1*"1*(.-(-"4,1,&*(7"#$"%&3,6A(6B**,1+(.B%&"7="&(,1(*3"(67#5"(.-(4"1(,1(#(

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!II!7(.&)!F&)*1&T!"ijlT!O1)41&0+'D!X&.,*+!h!%D'&'*T!\B"&*'(@(N"4,1,&*(\B#%*"%7;!>>!@gEU!lJWllT!

Ib!9)&$!%T!Y)&*8)52!G4T2!N[)-d31('51!\'*)563$U!>5!F.5:1&0)*'.5!,'*+!F+)&(.**1!#35-+!)54!#)&L)&)!/T!%+)'(.&2P!>5!

Q)(M'56!O1)41&0+'DU!F.5:1&0)*'.50!,'*+!\.,1&A3(!=.8152!R1,!#&350,'-M2!C3*61&0!_5':1&0'*$!\&1002!"ljT!Ig!GK-1&D*14!A&.8!>50*'*3*1!A.&!=.815]0!O1)41&0+'D2!IJJI2!N\.,1&!A.&!=+)*e!=.815]0!O1)41&0+'DU!=+$!0+.3(4!

$.3!-)&1eP2!R)*'.5)(!?')(.631!.5!G43-)*'56!=.815!A.&!O1)41&0+'D!"2!9)$!IJJI2!R1,!#&350,'-M2!>50*'*3*1!A.&!

=.815]0!O1)41&0+'D!!Ik!\166$!/5*&.L30U!>5!F.5:1&0)*'.5!,'*+!F+)&(.**1!#35-+!)54!9)&')551!?1Z.:152!NQ)(M'56!O1)41&0+'DU!

F.5:1&0)*'.50!,'*+!\.,1&A3(!=.815P2!R1,!#&350,'-M2!C3*61&0!_5':1&0'*$!\&1002!"iii2!\T!IiWgg!Il!\166$!/5*&.L302!IJJJ2!Q&)50A.&8)*'.5)(!(1)41&0+'DU!)4:)5-'56!*+1!)6154)!A.&!61541&!V30*'-12!'5!]"1$"%(#1$(

^"="7.64"1*!S@bEU!kJWkl!Ij!\166$!/5*&.L302!IJJIT!718'5'08!)0!Q&)50A.&8)*'.5)(!\.('*'-0U!Q.,)&40!D.00'L'('*'10!A.&!)5.*+1&!,.&(4T!

?1:1(.D815*!gk@IEU!glWkIT!

nataliae
Highlight
nataliae
Highlight
Page 12: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! "I!

4#7"($%,="1(#1$($"&,+1"$(6.7,*,5#7(#1$(5B7*B%#7(&6#5"(,&(%"#77;(OB,*"(6.,1*7"&&(,-(1.*(,1=#7,$>(

?1:)M'![)'5IS!

9]:..$(7"#$"%&3,6(H(7"#$"%&3,6(*3#*(&"%="&(G.*3(<.4"1(#1$(4"1A(6..%(#1$(%,53A(#1$(*3"(

6.<"%7"&&(#1$(6.<"%-B7(H(,&(,157B&,="A(6#%*,5,6#*.%;(#1$(3.%,Q.1*#7M(7"#$"%&3,6(&3.B7$(G"(

#G.B*(5#6,*#7,Q,1+(.1(*3"(,$"#&(#1$(&0,77&(.-(#&(4#1;(,1$,=,$B#7&(#&(6.&&,G7"M(@(+..$(7"#$"%(,&(

#7&.(5.1&5,.B&(*3#*(*3"(6%.5"&&"&(H(*3"(4"#1&(G;(<3,53(&3"(5#%%,"&(.B*(3"%(.GL"5*,="&(H(#%"(

LB&*(#&(,46.%*#1*(#&(*3"(.GL"5*,="&(*3"4&"7="&>((9)+5)<!/AM+)8'2!/55!G'015L1&6!)54!Y)(1+!

`)<'&'Ii!

(/3"(6.,1*(,&(*3#*(<3"%"="%(<"(#%"(#&(<.4"1A(<3"%"="%(<"(#%"(&,*B#*"$(,1(.B%(7,="&A(<"(5#1(

#$=#15"(#(-"4,1,&*(#+"1$#(,-(<"(&*.6(*3,10,1+(#G.B*(3.<(*.(G"(7"#$"%&(#1$(*3,10(%#*3"%(

#G.B*(3.<(*.(G"($."%&A(3.<(*.(G"(#+"1*&>(X1&4)!O1&51&bJ!

T1(4.$"%1(7"#$"%&3,6(*3".%;A(*3"(7"#$"%(67#;&(9#:(&*#%(%.7"(_*#0"&(*3"(7"#$A(G"5.4"&(*3"(

3"#$`A(#77(.*3"%&(G"5.4"(G,*(67#;"%&A(&B66.%*,1+(53#%#5*"%&A(#1$("C*%#&(,1(*3"(67#;A(*3"(

*3"#*%,5&(.-(7"#$"%&3,6>(Y.$"%1(7"#$"%&3,6(,&(G;($"-,1,*,.1(3,"%#%53,5#7A(4#7"(#1$(63#77,5(

&6"5*#57">((N"4,1,&*(7"#$"%&3,6(,&(4.%"(5,%5B7#%A(G.**.4(B6(#1$(7"&&(4#7">!?):'4!9T!#.V1b"!

/.(5%"#*"(&.4"*3,1+(*3#*(%"67#5"&(#1$(&B%6#&&"&(;.BA(*3#*(3#&(#(7,-"(.-(,*&(.<1(G"5#B&"(*3"%"(

#%"(4#1;(6".67"(<3.(<,77(G"($%#<1(,1*.(,*(#1$(<3.(<,77(+,="(7"#$"%&3,6(*.(,*(#&(#(+%.B6A("="1(

/3"(6.,1*(,&(*3#*(<3"%"="%(<"(#%"(#&(<.4"1A(<3"%"="%(<"(#%"(&,*B#*"$(,1(.B%(7,="&A(<"(5#1(

#$=#15"(#(-"4,1,&*(#+"1$#(,-(<"(&*.6(*3,10,1+(#G.B*(3.<(*.(G"(7"#$"%&(#1$(*3,10(%#*3"%(

#G.B*(3.<(*.(G"($."%&A(3.<(*.(G"(#+"1*&(,-(;.B(4.="(.1(.%(+.(#<#;>(/.(4"A(*3#*(3#&(#7<#;&(

G""1(*3"(4"#&B%"(.-(7"#$"%&3,6>((X1&4)!O1&51&bI!!

N"4,1,&*(7"#$"%&3,6(9,&:(.%,"1*"$(*.(#($,--"%"1*(#%%#1+"4"1*(.-(*3"(3B4#1(.%$"%'(%"P

$,&*%,GB*,.1(.-(6.<"%(#1$(%"P$,&*%,GB*,.1(.-(%"&6.1&,G,7,*,"&>(N,+3*,1+(&.5,"*#7(,1"OB#7,*,"&>(

23#1+,1+("5.1.4,5(#1$(&.5,#7(&*%B5*B%"&A(G"+,11,1+(<,*3(*%#1&-.%4#*,.1(.-(6&;53,5(

&*%B5*B%"&>(R%,$+,1+(6"%&.1#7(-%""$.4(<,*3(5.77"5*,="(-%""$.4>(@,4,1+(#*(5..6"%#*,.1(,1&*"#$(

.-(5.46"*,*,.1>(M>(T1(-"4,1,&*(7"#$"%&3,6("OB#7,*;A(4B*B#7,*;(#1$(#G&"15"(.-(&"C(%.7"(G"3#=,.%(

&3.B7$(G"(=,&,G7">(N"4,1,&*(7"#$"%&3,6(&3.B7$(6%.4.*"(_.%("="1(%"3#G,7,*#*"`("4.*,.1#7,*;(#1$(

*3"(=#7B"&(.-(%"7#*,.1&3,6&>(N"4,1,&*(7"#$"%&3,6(%"1.B15"&("C*"%1#7(6#%#63"%1#7,#(.-(6.<"%(

#1$(*3",%(,1-7B"15">a(/48'&)!Q..(M'*bb((

).4"(6".67"(57#,4(*3#*(-"4,1,&*(7"#$"%&3,6(#1$(+..$(7"#$"%&3,6(#%"(&;1.1;4&>(T1(#(&"1&"(,*(

,&A(#&(7.1+(#&(*3"(G"3.7$"%(#7&.(57#,4&(*3#*(-"4,1,&4A(5.1&,$"%"$(#&(#(&"*(.-(=#7B"&A(,&(/Fc(

+..$(&"*(.-(=#7B"&>(M>(d*3"%&(*3,10(*3#*(-"4,1,&*(7"#$"%&3,6(,&(#(0,1$(.-(5.1*%#$,5*,.1(,1(

*"%4&A(-"4,1,&4(G",1+(5.1*%#%;(*.(6.<"%(#1$(-"4,1,&*("OB#7,*;(5.1*%#%;(*.(7"#$"%&3,6(,*&"7->(

M>(d1(G"3#7-(.-(*3"(&BGL"5*(<"(%"1.B15"(G.*3(6.&,*,.1&A(#1$($"-,1"(-"4,1,&*(7"#$"%&3,6(#&(

7"#$"%&3,6(5.1+%B"1*(<,*3(-"4,1,&*(6%,15,67"&>(_"463#&,&(4,1"`(>a(/48'&)!Q..(M'*(be((

!

/54!FCG/]0!.,5!41A'5'*'.5U!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!IS!?1:)M'![)'52!"iik2!N=+$!=.815e!>0!Q+1&1!)!%D1-')(!p3)('*$!'5!=.815]0!O1)41&0+'DeP2!35D3L('0+14!D)D1&!

):)'()L(1!)*!*+1!F15*1&!A.&!=.815]0!X(.L)(!(1)41&0+'D2!C3*61&0!_5':1&0'*$T!Ii!9)+5)<!/AM+)8'2!/55!G'015L1&6!)54!Y)(1+!`)<'&'2!IJJ"2!NO1)4'56!*.!F+.'-10U!/!O1)41&0+'D!Q&)'5'56!Y)54L..M!

A.&!=.815P2!=.815]0!O1)&5'56!\)&*51&0+'D!A.&!C'6+*02!?1:1(.D815*!)54!\1)-1!@=O\E2!#1*+104)!9?T!!bJ!X1&4)!O1&51&2!"iik2!NO1)41&0+'DU!718'5'0*2!%D'&'*3)(2!\.('*'-)(P2!'5!=.8)5!.A!\.,1&2!Ig!@ggET!

31 ?):'4!9T!#.V12!\.0*8.41&5!O1)41&0+'D!Q+1.&$2!?1-18L1&!IJJJ2!)*!

-L)1T5803T143ms4L.V1m*1)-+'56mbbSmD.0*8.41&5t(1)41&0+'Dt*+1.&$!!

bI!X1&4)!O1&51&2!"iik2!NO1)41&0+'DU!718'5'0*2!%D'&'*3)(2!\.('*'-)(P2!'5!=.8)5!.A!\.,1&2!Ig!@ggE!

bb!+**DUmm,,,T<150M)W8&1<)T+&mD&'&3-5'Mm15m15t&1)4t8)5)61815*t(1)41&0+'DtST+*8!!2!)--10014!;-*.L1&!"J2!

IJJS!34 /48'&)2!5.!4)*12!%1-*'.5!S2!9)5)61815*!h!O1)41&0+'DU!718'5'0*!O1)41&0+'D2!):)'()L(1!)*!+**DUmm,,,T<150M)W

8&1<)T+&mD&'&3-5'Mm15m15t&1)4t8)5)61815*t(1)41&0+'DtST+*8!!

nataliae
Highlight
Page 13: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! "b!

f2Ic@(=,&B#7,Q"&(7"#$"%&3,6(#&(#($;1#4,5(OB#7,*;(*3#*(,&(6%"&"1*(#1$(5#1(G"("13#15"$(,1(4.&*(

,1$,=,$B#7&M(9#1$:(*3#*("1#G7"&(6".67"(*.(7,="(*3",%(7,="&(#&(*3";(53..&"A(<,*3($,+1,*;(#1$(<,*3(

&"1&,*,=,*;(*.(.*3"%(6".67"J&(53.,5"&(#1$($"5,&,.1&>(92Ic@J&:(7"#$"%&3,6(6%.+%#44"(<.%0&(.1(

*3"(#&&B46*,.1(*3#*(7"#$"%&3,6(,&(1.*(#(-,C"$(&*#*"(.-(G",1+(GB*(#(6%.5"&&(*3%.B+3(<3,53(

<.4"1(#&&"%*(*3",%(%,+3*&(G;(5.1*,1B#77;("=#7B#*,1+(%"7"=#1*("C6"%,"15"&A(OB"&*,.1,1+(*3",%(

%.7"&(,1(&.5,"*;A(53#77"1+,1+(6.<"%(&*%B5*B%"&(#1$("--"5*,="7;(5#*#7;Q,1+(&.5,#7(53#1+">a(

(

%1:1&)(!'8D.&*)5*!A)-*.&0!830*!L1!L.&51!'5!8'54!,+15!,1!1K)8'51!*+101!u)54!.*+1&v!

41A'5'*'.50!.A!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'DU!!

" Q+1!)L.:1!41A'5'*'.50!)&1!L$!5.!81)50!)!-.8D&1+150':1!.&!&1D&1015*)*':1!0)8D(1!.A!*+1!

A3((!4':1&0'*$!.A!A18'5'0*!*+'5M'56T!!=1!-)55.*!+.8.615'<1!*+1!A18'5'0*!4'0-.3&01!H!)54!

+15-1!41A'5'*'.50!W!.A!(1)41&0+'D2!)0!*+.36+!*+1&1!,)0!.51!0'56(1!6(.L)(!-.5:1&0)*'.5!

)L.3*!'*T!!>5!A)-*2!*+1&1!,1&1!41L)*10!)54!1KD1&'815*0!)((!.:1&!*+1!,.&(42!.5!1:1&$!

-.5*'515*2!,'*+!51,!A.&80!.A!.&6)5'<)*'.502!8.:1815*02!)54!(1)41&0+'D!0*&3-*3&10!)54!

D&)-*'-102!,'*+!8)&M14!4'AA1&15-10!'5!-.5-1&50!)54!A&)81,.&M0T!!>5!*+1!%.3*+!/0')5!

-.5*1K*2!A.&!'50*)5-12!*+1!SJ0!)54!1)&($!iJ0!0),!)!83-+!0*&.561&!A.-30!.5!*&)50A.&8'56!

61541&!D.,1&!&1()*'.50!*+&.36+!L3'(4'56!-.((1-*':1!D.,1&2!)54!A)&!(100!.5!(1)41&0+'D2!

,+'-+!L1-)81!1'*+1&!)!6':152!.&!)5!'5:'0'L(1!1(1815*!*+)*!4'4!5.*!&1-1':1!83-+!

18D+)0'0bk2blT!Y):'56!L115!:1&$!83-+!'5:.(:14!'5!*+101!41L)*10!)54!)-*':'082!>!-)55.*!

&1-)((2!A.&!'50*)5-12!)5$!N(1)41&0+'D!L3'(4'56P!-.3&010!A.&!>54')5!,.815!'5!*+1!SJ0!.&!iJ0!

H!L3*!D(15*$!.A!N),)&15100!L3'(4'56P!)54!N18D.,1&815*P!D&.6&)80!)54!'5*1&:15*'.50T!

/54!'A!)*!)((2!*+1&1!,)0!6&1)*1&!-.5-1&5!,'*+!-&1)*'56!5.77"5*,="(7"#$"%&3,6!8.41(02!&)*+1&!

*+)5!'54':'43)(!N+1&.'510Pbj!,+.!,.3(4!'51:'*)L($!03--38L!*.!*+1!D.('*'-0!.A!4.8'5)*'.5!

)54!-.5*&.(T!

" Q+1&1!,1&1!)(0.!-.5*10*)*'.50!)54!&10'0*)5-1!A&.8!6&)00&..*02!L()-M2!'54'615.302!

%.3*+1&52!)54!.*+1&,'01!8)&6'5)('<14!:.'-102!*.!*+1!41A'5'*'.50!)54!)DD&.)-+10!.A!,+)*!

*+1$!-.50'41&14!8)'50*&1)82!D&':'(16142!1('*1!A18'5'0*0T!!/(L'5.!)54!F)(4,1((WF.(L1&*!)&1!

)8.56!*+1!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!0-+.()&0!,+.!)44&100!*+1!'0031!.A!+.,!,.815]0!0.-')(!

4':1&0'*$!'5A(315-14!*+1!A18'5'0*!-.50*&3-*'.5!.A!(1)41&0+'DU!X/3"($,&*%,GB*,.1(.-(6.<"%(

#1$(&""0,1+("+#7,*#%,#1(%"7#*,.1&3,6&(#%"(5.467"C(+.#7&(.-(-"4,1,&4(*3#*(1"5"&&,*#*"(*3#*(

<"(#**"1$(1.*(.17;(*.(+"1$"%A(GB*(#7&.(*.(.*3"%(&;&*"4,5(-.%4&(.-(.66%"&&,.1(#1$(

6%,=,7"+">(/3"(,157B&,.1(.-(=#%,"$(7,-"("C6"%,"15"&(#1$(7,*"%#*B%"(%"-7"5*,1+(*3"(,46#5*(.-(

"*31,5,*;A(%#5"A(57#&&(#1$(+"1$"%(#%"("&6"5,#77;(,46.%*#1*(,1(.B%(5.1&*%B5*,1+(-"4,1,&*(

7"#$"%&3,6(#1$(5.1&,$"%,1+(,*&(6%#5*,5#7("1#5*4"1*>abg!

" 93-+!.A!*+'0!&'-+!4':1&0'*$!.A!41L)*1!)54!'55.:)*'.5!&18)'50!+'4415!.&!'5)--100'L(1!*.!)!

,.&M!('M1!*+'0!4.-3815*2!L1-)301!.A!()563)61!L)&&'1&0bi!W!L('54'56!30!*.!*+1!D.,1&A3(!

-&'*'d310!)54!-.5-1D*3)('<)*'.5!.A!O)*'5!/81&'-)5!A18'5'0*02!A.&!'50*)5-1!W!.&!L1-)301!0.!

83-+!.A!'*!,)0!5.*!&1-.&414!m!4.-3815*142!.&!'A!'*!,)02!L1-)301!'*]0!5.*!):)'()L(1!.5('51!

.&!'5!0.81!01*!.A!'415*'A')L(1!'50*'*3*'.50!.&!)&-+':10T!!Q+101!A)-*.&0!+):1!'51:'*)L($!

L')014!*+1!4'0-300'.5!'5!A):.&!.A!*+1!&1-.&414!+'0*.&$!.A!A18'5'0*!*+.36+*!.5!(1)41&0+'D!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!bk!%11!A.&!'50*)5-12!R)54'*)!%+)+!h!R)54'*)!X)54+'2!"iiJ2!NQ+1!>00310!)*!%*)M1U!Q+1.&$!)54!\&)-*'-1!'5!*+1!

F.5*18D.&)&$!>54')5!=.815]0!9.:1815*P2!R1,!?1(+'2!Z)('!A.&!=.8152!.&!!bl!C)4+)!Z38)&2!"iib2!NQ+1!Y'0*.&$!.A!?.'56!H!/5!>((30*&)*14!/--.35*!.A!9.:1815*0!A.&!=.815]0!C'6+*0!)54!

718'5'08!'5!>54')2!"SJJW"iiJP2!R1,!?1(+'2!Z)('!A.&!=.815!bj!/5!'&.5'-!*1&8!3014!L$!8)5$!.A!30!'5!>54')!'5!*+1!SJ0!*.!0'65)(!.3&!-&'*'-'08!.A!*+1!0'56(1W(1)41&!8.41(!.A!

(1)41&0+'DT!!bS![34'*+!/(L'5.!)54!Q.$!F)(4,1((WF.(L1&*2!N=.815!)0!/-)418'-!O1)41&0U!O':'56!*+1!GKD1&'15-1!'5!Q,.!

\1&0D1-*':10P2!'5!F+'5!1*!)(2!IJJj2!.6>5,*T2!DTliWSj!bi!GT6T2!*+1!+361!L.4$!.A!O)*'5!/81&'-)5!4'0-.3&01!.5!*+1!03LV1-*2!,+'-+!'0!'5!%D)5'0+!.&!\.&*3631012!.&!*+1!

*+'5M'56!.A!5.5W/56(.D+.51!G3&.D1)5!A18'5'0*02!,+'-+!'0!):)'()L(1!.5($!'5!X1&8)52!7&15-+2!.&!%D)5'0+T!

nataliae
Highlight
Page 14: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! "g!

'5!G56('0+2!)54!-.501d315*($2!*.,)&40!*+1!,.&M!.A!=10*1&5!m!R.&*+1&5!A18'5'0*0!)54!

A18'5'0*!M5.,(1461!-15*1&0!*+)*!,.&M14!'5!*+1!G56('0+!()563)61gJT!

#1)&'56!*+101!d3)('A'-)*'.50!'5!8'542!(1*!30!A.-30!.5!01:1&)(!'8D.&*)5*!A1)*3&10!.A!*+1!

41A'5'*'.50U!!

" >*!'0!0*&'M'56!*+)*!8)5$!.A!*+18!)&1!410-&'D*'.50!.A!+"($)"1#"+))-&47)$(?4$.+6&1-(3"

6+*7$(3"+',"/-+2)&2$(T!Q+1$!)&1!.A*15!-.50*'*3*14!L$!)4V1-*':10!)54!:1&L0!('M1!

'5-(30':12!D)&*'-'D)*.&$2!-.(()L.&)*':12!53&*3&'562!18D.,1&'562!-.5015030!L3'(4'562!

:)(3'56!)54!&10D1-*'56!.*+1&02!)54!:)(3'56!6&.,*+!)54!41:1(.D815*T!!

" #3*!8.&1!'8D.&*)5*($2!,1!011!*+)*!*+1!41A'5'*'.50!41)(!,'*+!/19$-"+',"/1*&)&2(3!

4'8150'.50!*+)*!)&1!)(8.0*!'5:'0'L(1!'5!*+1!8)'50*&1)8!41A'5'*'.50!.A!(1)41&0+'D2!

1:15!.A!A18'5'51!(1)41&0+'DT!!!

" %.81!.A!*+1!41A'5'*'.50!)(0.!+'5*!)*!*+1!-&'*'-)(!'0031!.A!#$%&'&()(@"19'"7($"+',"

/-+2)&2$"1#"/19$-"9.$'").$5"1227/5"*$+,$-(.&/"/1(&)&1'(T!!Q+'0!'0!)!:1&$!0*'-M$!)54!

35-.8A.&*)L(1!D.'5*2!L3*!.51!*+)*!+)0!L1-.81!'5-&1)0'56($!-15*&)(!*.!*+1!-+)((15610!

*+)*!A18'5'0*!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)&1!41)('56!,'*+!*.4)$2!10D1-')(($!'5!*+1!-.5*1K*!.A!

030*)'5'56!*+1'&!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!8.:1815*02!)54!'5!8)M'56!,)$!A.&!$.356!

,.815]0!:.'-10!)54!(1)41&0+'DT!!!

?&),'56!3D.5!*+101!&'-+($!()$1&14!'5*1&D&1*)*'.502!)!-.8D.0'*1!41A'5'*'.5!.A!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'D!,.3(4!L1!0.81*+'56!('M1!*+'0U!

S.4"1(<,*3(#(-"4,1,&*(6"%&6"5*,="(#1$(=,&,.1(.-(&.5,#7(LB&*,5"A(,1$,=,$B#77;(#1$(5.77"5*,="7;(

*%#1&-.%4,1+(*3"4&"7="&(*.(B&"(*3",%(6.<"%A(%"&.B%5"&(#1$(&0,77&(,1(1.1P.66%"&&,="A(,157B&,="(

&*%B5*B%"&(#1$(6%.5"&&"&(*.(4.G,7,Q"(.*3"%&(H("&6"5,#77;(.*3"%(<.4"1(P(#%.B1$(#(&3#%"$(

#+"1$#(.-(&.5,#7A(5B7*B%#7A("5.1.4,5(#1$(6.7,*,5#7(*%#1&-.%4#*,.1(-.%("OB#7,*;(#1$(*3"(

%"#7,Q#*,.1(.-(3B4#1(%,+3*&(-.%(#77>!

!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!gJ!93-+!.A!,+)*!'0!D&1015*14!L1(.,!'0!*+1!&103(*!.A!FCG/]0!&101)&-+

gJ!)*!*+1!F15*1&!A.&!=.815]0!X(.L)(!

O1)41&0+'D!)*!C3*61&0!_5':1&0'*$2!*+1!A'&0*!'5*1&5)*'.5)(!A18'5'0*!-15*1&!*.!A.-30!.5!*+1!*+1.&$!)54!D&)-*'-1!.A!

A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D2!)54!*.!414'-)*1!'*01(A!*.!*+1!41:1(.D815*!.A!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!'5!*+1!,.815]0!8.:1815*0!

,.&(4,'41T!!

Page 15: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! "k!

HHQ! 'B43O9!85!83K!S5R4<P85L!M2J85893!724I2:9B8R!

_5D)-M'56!*+1!-.5*15*!.A!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!,.3(4!5.*!L1!D.00'L(1!,'*+.3*!*+1!D'.511&'56!

)54!'55.:)*':1!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!,.&M!.A!A18'5'0*!,.815]0!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!

-)D)-'*$!L3'(41&0!)&.354!*+1!,.&(4T!!=1!)&1!'541L*14!*.!*&)'(L()<1&0!03-+!)0!F15*1&!A.&!

=.815]0!X(.L)(!O1)41&0+'D!@F=XOE2!?1:1(.D815*!/(*1&5)*':10!A.&!=.815!'5!)!R1,!G&)!

@?/=RE2!=.815]0!O1)&5'56!\)&*51&0+'D!@=O\E2!X1541&!)*!=.&M2![30*!/00.-')*102!

>5*1&5)*'.5)(!=.815]0!C'6+*0!/-*'.5!=)*-+!@/0')!\)-'A'-E2!XC;;Q%!>5*1&5)*'.5)(2!9/?CG2!

/?9>C/2!?'0/L(14!=.815]0!R1*,.&M!;5*)&'.2!*+1!7.&38!.A!=.815]0!RX;0!'5!F15*&)(!/0')2!

)54!FCG/!'*01(AT!!>5!)44'*'.52!*+1!)DD&.)-+!*.!L&.)415'562!411D15'56!)54!418.-&)*'<'56!

*+1'&!(1)41&0+'D!L)01!.A!0.81!M1$!,.815]0!8.:1815*0!)&.354!*+1!,.&(4!+)0!6&1)*($!

'5A.&814!)54!15&'-+14!*+1!)5)($0'0!'5!*+'0!01-*'.5!H!1T6T2!8.:1815*0!03-+!)0!*+1!?.810*'-!

=.&M1&0!/((')5-1!.A!*+1!_%/2!*+1!9.*+1&0!F15*1&0!.A!=10*1&5!)54!G)0*1&5!G3&.D12!*+1!

'54'615.30!,.815]0!8.:1815*0!.A!O)*'5!)54!910.!/81&'-)2!*+1!;51!'5!R'51!F)8D)'652!*+1!

4'0)L(14!,.815]0!8.:1815*02!)54!.*+1&!3&L)5!)54!&3&)(!,.815]0!8.:1815*0!)&.354!*+1!

,.&(4Tg"!!#)014!.5!.3&!)5)($0'0!.A!*+101!)54!.*+1&!A18'5'0*!41A'5'*'.50!)54!*+'5M'56!.5!

(1)41&0+'D2!)54!*+1'&!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!-)D)-'*$!L3'(4'56!D&.6&)80!)54!0*&)*16'102!,1!A'54!

*+)*!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!A.&!0.-')(!*&)50A.&8)*'.5!-.5*)'50!A.3&!10015*')(!-.8D.515*02!,+'-+!

8'6+*!L1!*1&814!*+1!N7.3&!\0P2!:'<TU!

1. T?A2:!

2. T:85<8R729!U!>47=29!

3. T?7838<9!U!R=:R?92!

4. T:4<38<29!

Q+101!A.3&!1(1815*0!-)5!L1!&1D&1015*14!'5!*+1!A.&8!.A!)!4')8.54!H!,+)*!,1!8'6+*!*1&8!*+1!

A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!4')8.54U!

08LQE!V!-B2!02J85893!(24I2:9B8R!W*84J?5IX!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!g"!!7.&!8.&1!'5A.&8)*'.5!.5!*+1!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!)DD&.)-+10!.A!*+101!8.:1815*02!D(1)01!011!%&'()*+)!

#)*(',)()2!IJJS2!NF+)5'56!Q+1'&!=.&(4U!F.5-1D*0!)54!\&)-*'-10!.A!=.815]0!9.:1815*0P2!/=>?2!):)'()L(1!'5!

G56('0+2!7&15-+!)54!%D)5'0+!)*!,,,T),'4T.&6m156m914')m7'(10mGRXWF+)56'56WQ+1'&W=.&(4!!

\;=GC!\;O>Q>F%!h!

\_C\;%G!

\C>RF>\OG%!

h!`/O_G%!\C/FQ>FG%!

Page 16: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! "l!

>*!'0!301A3(!*.!1KD()'5!)54!1K)8'51!*+1!-.5*15*!.A!1)-+!.A!*+101!-.8D.515*02!D)&*'-3()&($!'5!

&1()*'.5!*.!*+1!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!8.43(10!)54!)DD&.)-+10!*+)*!)&1!,'41($!'5!301!

*.4)$T!!!

GQ T?A2:!

O1)41&0+'D!'0!A'&0*!)54!A.&18.0*!)L.3*!D.,1&!H!'*!'0!)L.3*!+.(4'56!D.,1&2!1K1&-'0'56!D.,1&2!

)54!-+)56'56!*+1!4'0*&'L3*'.5!)54!&1()*'.50!.A!D.,1&2!'5!83(*'D(1!A.&80!)54!01**'560T!

718'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!81)50!A35-*'.5'56!,'*+!)!6&1)*1&!-.50-'.305100!5.*!.5($!.A!.*+1&0]!L3*!

.51]0!.,5!D.,1&2!L3*!'5*15*'.5)(($!8.:'56!),)$!A&.8!+.,!(1)41&0+'D!)54!D.,1&!+):1!

'5*1&01-*14!'5!8)'50*&1)8!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!0*&3-*3&102!)54!A&.8!A18'5'0*0]!)8L':)(15*!

+'0*.&'-)(!&1()*'.50+'D!,'*+!D.,1&T!Q+1!?/=R!;5*)&'.!A&)81,.&M!.5!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!

)5)($<10!*+1!-+)((1561!*+30U!

!='*+'5!A18'5'0*!.&6)5'<)*'.502!(1)41&0!,.&M!A&.8!)!:'0'.5!.A!0+)&14!D.,1&2!

D&.:'4'56!.DD.&*35'*'10!A.&!)((!818L1&0!*.!41:1(.D!)54!301!*+1'&!(1)41&0+'D!0M'((0T!

Q+'0!'41)!8)$!A11(!35A)8'(')&!)*!A'&0*2!)0!,1!.A*15!*+'5M!.A!(1)41&0!'5!*+1!*&)4'*'.5)(!

01501U!)!+)54A3(!.A!D1.D(1!,'*+!+'6+W&)5M'56!D.0'*'.50!,+.!+):1!-()'814!*+1!8.0*!

D.,1&!,'*+'5!*+1'&!.&6)5'<)*'.5T!\.,1&!'0!5.*!0+)&14!'5!*+101!0*&3-*3&102!L1-)301!

L1'56!03--100A3(!81)50!)(,)$0!-.8D1*'56!*.!L1!N538L1&!.51TP!

>*!'0!5.*!03&D&'0'562!*+1&1A.&12!*+)*!)!538L1&!.A!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!D&.6&)80!

D&'.&'*'<1!D.,1&!)5)($0'0!'5!*+1'&!-3&&'-3()2!15)L('56!D)&*'-'D)5*0!*.!41-.50*&3-*!)54!1K)8'51!

*+1!4'AA1&15*!A.&80!)54!,)$0!'5!,+'-+!D.,1&!.D1&)*10!'5!*+1!0.-')(!-.5*1K*T!!_5A.&*35)*1($2!

8.0*!.A!*+1!.*+1&!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!D&.6&)80!)'814!)*!0.-')(!-+)561!)-*':'0*0!H!

'5-(34'56!,.815!)-*':'0*0!H!*154!*.!*)M1!)!8.&1!'50*&3815*)(!)54!8)5)61&')(!)DD&.)-+2!

6':'56!6&1)*1&!18D+)0'0!*.!81-+)5'-)(!8)5)61815*!)54!&10.3&-1!8.L'('<)*'.5!0M'((02!L3*!

L)&1($!*.3-+'56!3D.5!*+1!A354)815*)(!-.5-1D*0!)54!4$5)8'-0!.A!D.,1&T!!#3*!1:15!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'D!D&.6&)80!&)&1($!)44&100!*+1!'5*1&5)(!D.,1&!4$5)8'-0!.A!,.815]0!.&6)5'<)*'.50!

)54!8.:1815*0T!Q+101!)&1!01&'.30!.8'00'.502!0'5-1!*+1!8.0*!.:1&&'4'56!6.)(!.A!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'D!'0!5.*!-&1)*'56!,1((W8)5)614!.&6)5'<)*'.50!*+)*!8)'5*)'5!*+1!0.-')(!0*)*30!d3.2!

L3*!,.&M'56!*.!*&)50A.&8!*+1!&1()*'.50!.A!D.,1&!'5!0.-'1*$2!)54!*.!-&1)*1!)(*1&5)*1!8.41(0!.A!

D.,1&!,'*+'5!*+1'&!.,5!0*&3-*3&10T!!F.501d315*($2!'*!'0!301A3(!*.!A.-30!*+'0!01-*'.5!.5!

0*&156*+15'56!.3&!.,5!3541&0*)54'56!.A!D.,1&!)54!*+1!4'AA1&15*!,)$0!'*!.D1&)*10!,'*+'5!

)54!L1*,115!'54':'43)(02!6&.3D02!)54!0$0*180T!!!

*8J2598?59!?M!T?A2:!85!(24I2:9B8R/!

`151M()015!)54!9'((1&!W!*,.!D&)-*'*'.51&W0-+.()&0!,+.!+):1!6&1)*($!)4:)5-14!.3&!

3541&0*)54'56!.A!D.,1&!A&.8!)!A18'5'0*!D1&0D1-*':1!H!D&.:'41!)5!15.&8.30($!+1(DA3(!

0*)&*'56!D.'5*!L$!'415*'A$'56!*+1!*+&11!&1)(80!'5!,+'-+!D.,1&!.D1&)*10gIU!).$"/74*&2!@,+1&1!'*!

'0!:'0'L(12!03-+!)0!*+1!D.,1&!.A!*+1!6.:1&5815*2!8'('*)&$2!D.('-12!V34'-')&$2!-.&D.&)*'.502!1*-TE2!

).$"/-&6+)$!@,'*+'5!'50*'*3*'.50!('M1!*+1!A)8'($2!-()52!1*+5'-!6&.3D2!.&!'5!8)&&')612!A&'1540+'D02!

)54!.*+1&!&1()*'.50+'D0E2!)54!).$"&')&%+)$!@*+1!D.,1&!H!.&!D.,1&(1005100!H!*+)*!,1!A11(!

,'*+'5!.3&01(:102!1KD&10014!303)(($!'5!*1&80!.A!01(AW-.5A'415-12!01(AW10*1182!-.5*&.(!.:1&!.3&!

L.4'102!1*-TET!!Q+'0!*)M10!*+1!A'&0*!A18'5'0*!0*1D!.A!)-M5.,(146'562!5)8'562!)54!)5)($<'56!*,.!

'8D.&*)5*!0D+1&10!.A!D.,1&!*+)*!)AA1-*!,.815]0!(':10!411D($U!*+1!D&':)*1!)54!*+1!'5*'8)*1T!!

G:15!8.&1!'8D.&*)5*($2!*+'0!A&)81,.&M!+1(D0!30!&1-.65'<1!*+1!:'*)(!'0031!.A!*+1!D.,1&!

,'*+'5!302!0.!4&),'56!3D.5!A18'5'0*!5.*'.50!.A!*+1!#+"15;!*+)*!1:15!*+1!8.0*!0118'56($!

D.,1&(100!)54!8)&6'5)('<14!,.815!+):1T!!C1-.65'<'56!*+1!'5*'8)*1!&1)(8!.A!D.,1&!81)50!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!gI!O'0)!`151Z()015!,'*+!`)(1&'1!9'((1&[email protected]'*.&02!?1LL'1!#34(1541&!)54!F'54$!F()&ME2!IJJI2!/!R1,!=1):1!.A!

\.,1&!)54!\.('*'-0!H!/5!/-*'.5!X3'41!A.&!/4:.-)-$!)54!F'*'<15!\)&*'-'D)*'.52!;M()+.8)!F'*$2!=.&(4!R1'6+L.&02!

\Tk"!

Page 17: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! "j!

,1!)&1!5.*!18D*$!:1001(0!*.0014!)&.354!L$!*+1!A.&-10!.A!D.,1&!.D1&)*'56!B6.1!302!L3*!*+)*!

,1!D.00100!D.,1&!*..2!*+.36+!,1!.A*15!4.5]*!&1-.65'<1!*+'02!.&!301!'*!516)*':1($!.&!

&1)-*':1($2!*.!&10'0*!.&!03L:1&*!*+1!A.&-10!)-*'56!.5!30T!!Q+'0!'0!)5!'8D.&*)5*!'41)!*.!+)56!.5!

*.!)0!,1!L16'5!*.!*)-M(1!*+1!4'8150'.5!.A!D.,1&!'5!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'DT!

`151M()015!)54!9'((1&!)(0.!*)(M!)L.3*!*+1!N*+&11!A)-10!.A!D.,1&P2!,+'-+!*+1$!'415*'A$!)0!

6&(&4*$3".&,,$'!)54!&'6&(&4*$AB!W!*+101!-(.01($!'5*1&01-*!,'*+!.*+1&!D.,1&!A&)81,.&M0!*+)*!

'415*'A$!,&-$2)3"&',&-$2)2!)54!+:$',+C($))&':"/19$-!gg2!gk2!glT!!%'5-1!*+101!A.&80!.A!D.,1&!D()$!

)!-&'*'-)(!&.(1!'5!030*)'5'56!D)*&')&-+)(!D&':'(161!)54!03L.&4'5)*'56!,.8152!'*!'0!:'*)(!*.!

35D)-M!)54!3541&0*)54!*+18!-(1)&($gjU!

D&(&4*$"/19$-!'0!*+1!.51!,1!)&1!8.0*!A)8'(')&!,'*+2!)54!+):1!)((!1KD1&'15-14T!!>*!41*1&8'510!

,+.!D)&*'-'D)*10!H!)54!,+.!'0!1K-(3414!A&.8!H!41-'0'.5!8)M'56!'5!*+1!D3L('-!&1)(8T!!

?1-'0'.502!A.&!'50*)5-12!)L.3*!,+)*!)!-.35*&$]0!41:1(.D815*!D&'.&'*'10!0+.3(4!L12!.&!+.,!*+1!

:'(()61!-.35-'(]0!L3461*!,'((!L1!0D15*T!!`'0'L(1!D.,1&!'0!+1(4!L$!D.('*'-)(!(1)41&0!@1(1-*14!.&!

5.*aE2!D.('-12!8'('*)&$2!)54!*+1!V34'-')&$f!'*!'0!)(0.!+1(4!L$!*+1!+1)40!.A!83(*'5)*'.5)(!

-.&D.&)*'.502!.A!-()50!)54!*&'L102!.A!0.-')(!8.:1815*!.&6)5'<)*'.50!('M1!*&)41!35'.502!.&!'5!

*+1!(1)41&0+'D!.A!RX;0!)54!,.815]0!.&6)5'<)*'.50T!E&-$2)"/19$-!'0!0'8'()&2!*+.36+!'*!

.D1&)*10!'5!L.*+!*+1!D&':)*1!)54!D3L('-!&1)(802!)54!41*1&8'510!+.,!D.,1&2!D&':'(161!)54!

.DD.&*35'*$!)&1!)((.-)*142!)54!,+.!'0!6':15!)3*+.&'*$!*.!-.5*&.(!&10.3&-102!.*+1&!D1.D(12!.&!

)--100!*.!M5.,(1461!)54!'5A.&8)*'.5T!/!6..4!1K)8D(1!.A!*+'0!A.&!,.815!'0!*+1!4'&1-*!D.,1&!

+1(4!L$!8)(1!+1)40!.A!+.301+.(402!)54!*+1!61541&!4':'0'.5!.A!()L.&!)54!41-'0'.5W8)M'56!

D.,1&2!,+'-+!4'-*)*10!*+)*!,.815!,'((!D1&A.&8!-1&*)'5!+.301+.(4!)54!D&.43-*'.5!*)0M0!*+)*!

)&1!-&'*'-)(!A.&!+.301+.(4!03&:':)(2!L3*!*+1$!,'((!5.*!+):1!*+1!&'6+*!*.!1d3)(!,)6102!-.5*&.(!

.:1&!*+1'&!'5-.812!'5+1&'*)5-1!&'6+*02!.&!1:15!-.5*&.(!.:1&!*+1'&!L.4'10!'5!*1&80!.A!*+1'&!

8.L'('*$2!&1()*'.50+'D02!01K3)(!1KD&100'.52!.&!&1D&.43-*'.5T!!`'0'L(1!.&!4'&1-*!D.,1&!)(0.!

1KD()'50!D+15.815)!('M1!0.5WD&1A1&15-12!.&!+.,!*+1!'5*1&10*0!.A!D.,1&A3(!1-.5.8'-!)54!

0.-')(!6&.3D0!@L$!:'&*31!.A!*+1'&!)001*0!m!,1)(*+2!D.0'*'.52!61541&2!&)-12!-()002!1*+5'-'*$2!.&!

-)0*12!A.&!'50*)5-1E!)&1!)L(1!*.!4.8'5)*1!D.('*'-)(!0$0*180!)*!*+1!-.0*!.A!D..&1&!D1.D(1T!!!

F&,,$'"/19$-!H!0.81*'810!-)((14!+:$',+C($))&':"/19$-!W!'0!)L.3*!,+.!'5A(315-10!.&!01*0!

*+1!)6154)!L1+'54!*+1!0-15102!)54!*+1!L)&&'1&0!)54!L')010!,+'-+!41*1&8'51!,+'-+!'00310!-)5!

L1!)44&100142!,+.01!:.'-10!)&1!+1)&4!.&!,+.!'0!-.503(*14!.5!)!D)&*'-3()&!'0031T!!/6)'52!

+'4415!.&!)6154)W01**'56!D.,1&!.D1&)*10!'5!L.*+!*+1!D&':)*1!)54!D3L('-!&1)(80T!!>5!*+1!

D3L('-!&1)(82!A.&!'50*)5-12!,1!011!+'4415!D.,1&!.D1&)*1!,+15!:'.(15-1!)6)'50*!,.815!'5!

-.5A('-*!'0!5.*!-.50'41&14!)0!-&'*'-)(!)0!*+1!(.00!.A!*1&&'*.&$!.&!8'('*)&$!(.0010T!!Y'4415!D.,1&!

'0!)(0.!1:'415*!'5!*+1!51K30!L1*,115!D.('*'-)(!(1)41&0!)54!A354)815*)('0*!(.LL'10!,'*+!,+.8!

*+1$!+):1!-(.012!L3*!-.:1&*2!('5M02!0.!*+1!()**1&!)&1!)L(1!*.!'5A(315-1!D.('*'-)(!41-'0'.50!)54!

D.('-'10!,'*+.3*!)5$!:'0'L(1!D.,1&!.&!(16'*'8)-$T!!='*+'5!A)8'('102!,1!)(0.!011!+.,!N6..4!

,.815P!H!*+.01!43*'A3(($!-)&&$'56!.3*!*+1!D)*&')&-+)(!)6154)!)54!D&.*1-*'56!8)(1!D&':'(161!H!

.A*15!15V.$!L1+'54W*+1W0-1510!D.,1&!*.!'5A(315-1!8)(1!41-'0'.5W8)M1&02!,'*+.3*!)5$!A.&8)(!

)3*+.&'*$T!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!gb!`151M()015!,'*+!9'((1&2!IJJI2!.6>5,*T2!\Tgl!W!gS!

44 %*1:15!O3M102!K.<"%'(@(I#$,5#7(h,"<2!O.54.52!9)-9'(()52!"ijg2!)54!01-.54!14'*'.52!\)(6&):12!IJJk!!45 9'-+1(!7.3-)3(*2!/3"(F,&*.%;(.-()"CB#7,*;A(K#%*(T2!O.54.52!/((15!O)51T 46 [.+5!X):15*)!)54!/54&1)!F.&5,)((!@IJJ"E!N\.,1&!)54!Z5.,(14612P!'5!\1*1&!C1)0.5!)54!Y'()&$!#&)4L3&$!

@IJJ"E!@G40E2!\1*1&!C1)0.5!)54!Y'()&$!#&)4L3&$!@G40E!F#1$G..0(.-(@5*,.1(I"&"#%53(H(K#%*,5,6#*,="(T1OB,%;(#1$(

K%#5*,5"2!O.54.52!F)('A.&5')!)54!R1,!?1(+'2!%)61!\3L('-)*'.502!IJJ"!)L.:12!DDTjJWSJT!!

gj!>!,.3(4!('M1!*.!*+)5M![1*+&.!\1**'*!.A!*+1!X.:1&5)5-1!)54!\)&*'-'D)*'.5!_5'*2!>50*'*3*1!A.&!?1:1(.D815*!%*34'102!

%3001K2!_Z2!)54![30*!/00.-')*10!N\.,1&!.A!9.:1815*0P!,.&M0+.D!'5!?1-18L1&!IJJi2!A.&!-.5*&'L3*'56!6&1)*($!*.!

8$!.,5!-()&'*$!.5!D.,1&aW!!

Page 18: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! "S!

G'6&(&4*$"/19$-!H!.&!85I8:2<3!R?A2:!W!'0!'5!8)5$!,)$0!*+1!8.0*!'50'4'.30!)54!D&.L(18)*'-!.A!

)((!*.!-+)((1561!)54!-.5A&.5*2!L1-)301!'*!'0!*+1!-)D)-'*$!*.!0+)D1!D1.D(1]0!01(AW'8)612!01(AW

10*1182!0.-')(!)**'*3410!)54!L')0102!,'*+.3*!)5$!)DD)&15*!&.(1!'5!4.'56!0.T!!Q+1!814')!)54!

8)&M1*'56!m!)4:1&*'0'56!'5430*&'10!)&1!-()00'-!D3&:1$.&0!.A!03-+!'5:'0'L(1!D.,1&T!!Q+1!814')!

1K1&-'010!'5:'0'L(1!D.,1&!L$!-.50*)5*($!8)M'56!-+.'-10!)L.3*!,+)*!'00310!*.!+'6+('6+*!)54!

,+)*!*.!'65.&12!)54!L$!-.50*&3-*'56!'8)610!)54!0+)D'56!81)5'56!'5!()0*'56!,)$0T!!G:1&$!

4)$]0!*1(1:'0'.5!51,02!A.&!'50*)5-12!'0!'50*'(('56!'5!30!)!01501!.A!,+)*!)&1!*+1!8.0*!'8D.&*)5*!

'00310!.A!*+1!4)$!H!L3*!,+)*!*+1$!'65.&1!)54!4.5]*!-.:1&!'5!*+1!51,0!'0!)(0.!'8D.&*)5*2!L3*!

L$!8)M'56!*+.01!'00310!'5:'0'L(12!*+1$!)&1!0+)D'56!.3&!01501!.A!0.-')(2!1-.5.8'-!)54!D.('*'-)(!

D&'.&'*'10!'5!D&.A.354!,)$0!*+)*!,1!)&1!L)&1($!),)&1!.Aa!!Q.!3541&0*)54!*+1!D.,1&!.A!*+1!

814')2!,1!+):1!.5($!*.!-.50'41&!*+1!,'41($!+1(4!'8)61!.A!*+1!8)5W+)*'562!A)8'($WL&1)M'562!

+)&4W)0W5)'(02!D&.8'0-3.30!A18'5'0*T!!9.0*!D1.D(1!+):1!51:1&!81*!*+'0!-&1)*3&1!'5!&1)(!('A1!

L1-)301!0+1!4.105]*!1K'0*!H!0+1!'0!)!814')!-&1)*'.52!L3*!.51!*+)*!+)0!*)M15!03-+!D.,1&A3(!

+.(4!.A!D1.D(1]0!'8)6'5)*'.50!1:1&$,+1&12!*+)*!A1,!,.815!,+.!L1('1:1!'5!61541&!1d3)('*$!

)54!,.815]0!&'6+*0!)&1!,'(('56!*.!-)((!*+1801(:10!A18'5'0*0a!!%'8'()&($2!*+1!)4:1&*'0'56!

'5430*&$!1K1&-'010!'5:'0'L(1!D.,1&!L$!0+)D'56!81)5'56!)54!-&1)*'56!51,!5.&80!)L.3*!,+)*!

'0!6..42!410'&)L(12!D.0'*':12!.&!L)42!&16&100':12!516)*':1!H!*+1!)(8.0*!35':1&0)(!410'&1!A.&!

A)'&1&!0M'5!)54!*+'5!L.4'10!)8.56!%.3*+1&5!,.8152!A.&!'50*)5-12!,+'-+!'5!*3&5!)AA1-*0!*+1'&!

01501!.A!01(AW,.&*+2!'0!*10*'8.5$!*.!*+1!'5:'0'L(1!D.,1&!.A!*+101!A.&-10T!!!

Q+101!A)-1*0!.A!D.,1&!&18'54!30!*+)*!,+'(1!(1)41&0+'D!'0!D&'8)&'($!)00.-')*14!,'*+!41-'0'.5W

8)M'56!D.,1&2!'*!'0!)L.3*!83-+!8.&1!*+)5!*+)*T!/0!?1:)M'![)'5!)&6314!.:1&!)!41-)41!)6.2!!

f!"#$"%&3,6(#&(#(5.15"6*(,&(4B53(&*%.1+"%(*3#1(#1$($,--"%"1*(-%.4(*3"(5.15"6*(.-($"5,&,.1P(

4#0,1+>(K#%*,5,6#*,.1(,1($"5,&,.1P4#0,1+($."&(1.*(1"5"&&#%,7;(,157B$"A(.%(#$$%"&&A(*3"(

6.<"%(3,"%#%53;>(d1"(5.B7$(G"(6#%*(.-(#($"5,&,.1P4#0,1+(6%.5"&&(#1$(1.*(G"(6.<"%-B7(

"1.B+3(*.(,1-7B"15"(*3#*($"5,&,.1>(!"#$"%&3,6A(.1(*3"(.*3"%(3#1$A(3#&(#(3,"%#%53,5#7(

&,+1,-,5#15">(/3"($"4#1$(-%.4("="%;<3"%"A(<3"*3"%(-%.4(<.4"1A(*3"(K7#*-.%4(-.%(@5*,.1(

,1(R",L,1+A(.%(*3"(8FB4#1(^"="7.64"1*(I"6.%*(ijj?8A(,&(-.%(6#%*,5,6#*,.1A(-.%(-,C"$(&3#%"&(

,1($"5,&,.1P4#0,1+>(/3#*(,&(1.*("1.B+3>(/.(4#0"("--"5*,="($"4#1$&(-.%(53#1+"A(*3"%"(,&(#(

5#&"(-.%(*3"(-"4,1,&*(4.="4"1*(*.(57#,4(7"#$"%&3,6(#1$(57#,4(,*(G"5#B&"(.-(,*&("*3,5&(#1$(

1.*(.17;(,*&(+"1$"%>aeg!

!

/*!*+1!+'6+10*!(1:1(2!*+1&1A.&12!*+1!6.)(!.A!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!'0!*,.WA.(4U!!

"T Q.!-+)((1561!:'0'L(12!+'4415!)54!'5:'0'L(1!D.,1&!,+1&1:1&!'*!.D1&)*102!)54!10D1-')(($!

,+1&1!'*!-.50*&3-*0!)54!&1'5A.&-10!,.815]0!03L.&4'5)*'.5!'5!L.*+!6&.00!)54!03L*(1!

,)$02!.&!A3&*+1&0!4'0-&'8'5)*'.5!)6)'50*!,.815f!)54!

H! Q.!-.50*&3-*!)(*1&5)*':1!8.41(0!.A!D.,1&!*+)*!)8D('A$!*+1!:'0'L(1!A.&8!*.!*+1!

8)K'838!1K*15*!D.00'L(12!)54!6&)43)(($!1('8'5)*1!'5:'0'L(1!)54!+'4415!D.,1&T!!>5!

.*+1&!,.&402!#$%&'&()"*$+,$-(.&/"9&**"()-&6$")1"%+8$").$"/-+2)&2$"1#"/19$-"6&(&4*$3"

,$%12-+)&23"*$:&)&%+)$"+',"+2217')+4*$3"+)"+**"*$6$*(3"+',"&'"41)."/-&6+)$"+',"

/74*&2"-$+*%(!"

O1*!30!5.,!(..M!8.&1!-(.01($!)*!D.,1&!,'*+'5!(1)41&0+'D!&.(10T!Y1&12!'*!'0!301A3(!*.!A'&0*!8)M1!

)!4'0*'5-*'.5!L1*,115!*+1!&')-&'(&2!)54!$I)-&'(&2!D.,1&!.A!(1)41&0+'D2!8'&&.&'56!A18'5'08]0!

(.56W0*)54'56!0(.6)5!.A!*+1!D1&0.5)(!'0!*+1!D.('*'-)(T!!!

" G'()-&'(&2"/19$-"J"1-"&')&%+)$"/19$-"C!'0!*+1!A.&-1!.A!*+1!D1&0.5)('*$!*&)'*02!

-+)&'08)2!*)(15*02!-)D)L'('*'102!M5.,(14612!)54!1KD1&'15-1!*+)*!*+1!'54':'43)(!(1)41&!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!gS!?1:)M'![)'52!N=.815!)54!G*+'-)(!O1)41&0+'DP2!'5!#1(()!/L<36!)54!?1:)M'![)'52!=.815]0!O1)41&0+'D!)54!*+1!

G*+'-0!.A!?1:1(.D815*P2!X1541&!'5!?1:1(.D815*!9.5.6&)D+!%1&'10!wg2!_R?\2!/3630*!"iil2!\Tj!

nataliae
Highlight
Page 19: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! "i!

+)02!*+)*!+):1!L115!)-d3'&14!*+&.36+!*+1!-'&-380*)5-10!.A!+1&!('A12!)54!)&1!+15-1!

35'd31!*.!+1&T!!Q+'0!-.3(4!)(0.!L1!*1&814!*+1!&.(1!.A!*+1!%GO72!.A!.3&!D0$-+'-!

0*&3-*3&102!1KD1&'15-102!)54!)**&'L3*10!'5!)!(1)41&0+'D!&.(1T!!C1-.65'<'56!*+)*!,1!

L&'56!L.*+!516)*':1!)54!D.0'*':1!d3)('*'102!)54!)!,'(('565100!*.!1K)8'51!)54!)44&100!

.3&!516)*':1!*&)'*02!'0!)!:'*)(!-.8D.515*!'5!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D2!0'5-1!L$!*)-M('56!*+1!

D1&0.5)(!1AA1-*':1($2!,1!)&1!)(0.!15)L('56!.3&01(:10!*.!*)-M(1!*+1!D.('*'-)(!6.)(0!.A!

1d3)('*$2!+38)5!&'6+*0!)54!V30*'-1T!!!

" KI)-&'(&2"/19$-!H!.&!*+1!)3*+.&'*$!*+)*!-.810!*.!)!A18'5'0*!(1)41&!A&.8!.3*0'41!

+1&01(A2!,+'-+!'5-(3410!!

)T *+1!+((&:'$,"+7).1-&)5!0+1!'0!6':15!L$!.*+1&0!@1T6T!)!L.)&4!.A!4'&1-*.&0!.&!

*&30*1102!*+1!D1.D(1!,+.!1(1-*14!+1&!*+1!(1)41&2!1*-TEf!

LT *+1!/1(&)&1'+*"+7).1-&)5!*+)*!+1&!(1)41&0+'D!&.(1!6':10!+1&!@+'&'562!A'&'562!

8)5)6'56!D1.D(1!)54!A'5)5-102!&1D&1015*'562!&)'0'56!&10.3&-102!8)M'56!0*&)*16'-!

41-'0'.502!1*-TEf!

-T *+1!$+-'$,"+7).1-&)5!*+)*!0+1!6)'50!L$!30'56!+1&!)00'6514!)54!D.0'*'.5)(!

)3*+.&'*$!-)&1A3(($!)54!A)'&($2!L$!0+)&'56!+1&!D.,1&!,'*+!.*+1&02!L$!)-*'56!

'5-(30':1($2!)54!L1-)301!.A!*+1!D1&0.5)(!)**&'L3*102!1KD1&'15-12!)54!0M'((0!H!.&!

&')-&'(&2"/19$-!H!*+)*!0+1!L&'560!*.!+1&!&.(1T!!Q+1&1!'0!)!(.*!.A!1:'415-1!*+)*!*+1!

L10*!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0!)&1!*+.01!,+.!-.5:1&*!*+1'&!)00'6514!)3*+.&'*$!'5*.!1)&514!

)3*+.&'*$!'5!)!0+.&*!0D)-1!.A!*'812!0.!*+)*!*+1'&!(1)41&0+'D!'0!03DD.&*14!L$!)((!

*+.01!156)614!'5!*+1!15*1&D&'01!,'*+!*+182!)54!5.*!V30*!)!01*!.A!1K*1&5)(!)-*.&0a!

/*!*+1!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!.&!8.:1815*!L3'(4'56!(1:1(2!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!830*!)(0.!,&10*(1!,'*+!

A':1!M1$!$I/-$((&1'("1#"/19$-!*+)*!)&1!)**154)5*!'5!03-+!D&.-10010gi2kJU!!

!

>19$-")1!H!&1A1&0!*.!*+1!)615-$!)54!-)D)-'*$!*.!)-*!*+)*!(1)41&0+'D!830*!(1:1&)612!,'*+'5!

'*01(A!)54!'5!.*+1&02!*.!-&1)*1!-+)561f!'*!'0!)L.3*!*+1!0*&)*16'-!0M'((02!1KD1&'15-12!'50'6+*2!1*-T2!

*+)*!-)5!L1!8)&0+)(14!)54!8.L'('<14!*.,)&40!*+1!*&)50A.&8)*':1!)6154)!*+)*!+)0!L115!

)4.D*14f!6.<"%(*.!'0!*+1!&1-.65'*'.5!.A!,+)*!,12!*+1!-+)561!8)M1&02!L&'56!*.!*+1!*)L(1!H!*+1!!

'5*&'50'-!D.,1&!410-&'L14!)L.:1f!

>19$-"16$-!H!41&':10!A&.8!4'&1-*!D.,1&!)54!D.0'*'.5)(!m!)00'6514!)3*+.&'*$2!*+1!-.5*&.(!

@4'&1-*!.&!'54'&1-*E!.:1&!*+1!+38)5!)54!.*+1&!&10.3&-10!,'*+'5!*+1!D&.-1002!)54!*+1!,)$!

03-+!-.5*&.(!-)5!:1&$!d3'-M($!0('D!'5*.!4.8'5)*'.5f!)(0.!-.5*&.(!.:1&!*+1!301!)54!41D(.$815*!

.A!&10.3&-102!41-'0'.5W8)M'562!1*-Tf!!

>19$-"9&).!H!*+1!1AA1-*':1!18D.,1&815*!)54!15)L('56!.A!)((!*+.01!156)614!'5!*+1!

*&)50A.&8)*':1!D&.-100!*.!-&1)*1!0.('4)&'*$2!83*3)(!03DD.&*!0$0*1802!0)A1*$!51*02!1*-T!uQ+'0!'0!

*+1!D.,1&!*+)*!*10*0!,+1*+1&!(1)41&0!)&1!)-*'56!)0!'54':'43)(!+1&.10!m!+1&.'510!,'*+!

A.((.,1&02!.&!)0!'5'*')*.&0!)54!030*)'51&0!.A!-.((1-*':1!D&.-10010!.A!-+)561!,'*+!)!538L1&!.A!

A1((.,W*&):1((1&0av!f!!

>19$-"9&).&'!H!*+'0!'0!.A*15!*+1!0.3&-1!.A!*+1!030*)'5)L'('*$!.A!A18'5'0*!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!

8.:1815*02!0'5-1!*+'0!&1()*10!*.!*+1!'5*&'50'-!D.,1&!815*'.514!1)&('1&2!L3*!)(0.!*.!*+1!

-)D)-'*$!*.!&16151&)*1!.5101(A!)54!.51]0!0*&)*16'10!'5!&10D.501!*.!*+1!-+)((15610!)54!

&1:1&0)(0!*+)*!A18'5'0*!-+)561!D&.-10010!'51:'*)L($!35(1)0+T!!Q+1!D.,1&!,'*+'5!)(0.!'5-(34102!

'5!R)'()!Z)L11&]0!-()00'-!*1&82!*+.01!N'5*)56'L(1!&10.3&-10Pk"!H!03-+!)0!M5.,(14612!)--100!*.!

'5A.&8)*'.52!'5A(315-12!-.5*)-*02!1*-T!W!*+)*!-)5!L1!(1:1&)614!A.&!*+1!-)301!.&!.&6)5'<)*'.52!

)54!8)M1!3D!)!4'0*'5-*!-+)&)-*1&'0*'-!.A!(1)41&0+'Df!)54!

>19$-"7',$-!W!!'5!8)5$!,)$0!*+'0!'0!*+1!8.0*!-.8D(1K!L3*!D1&:)0':1!1KD&100'.5!.A!D.,1&!'5!

,.815]0!.&6)5'<)*'.502!)54!+1(D0!30!3541&0*)54!,+$!D1.D(1!,+.!+):1!1KD1&'15-14!)L3012!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!gi![.!C.,()5402!"iijU!p310*'.5'56!G8D.,1&815*!H!=.&M'56!,'*+!=.815!'5!Y.543&)02!;KA.&42!;KA)8T!

kJ!`151M()015!,'*+!9'((1&2!IJJI2!.6>5,*T!

k"!!R)'()!Z)L11&2!"iig2!NC1:1&014!C1)('*'10U!X1541&!+'1&)&-+'10!'5!41:1(.D815*!*+.36+*P2!O.54.52!`1&0.!\&100!

Page 20: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! IJ!

.DD&100'.5!)54!*&)38)2!,+15!*+1$!6)'5!D.,1&!@10D1-')(($!D.,1&!*.!)54!D.,1&!.:1&E2!.A*15!

L1-.81!)L30':12!)3*+.&'*)&')52!)54!.DD&100':1!*+1801(:10T!!%*1:15!='518)52!,+.!+)0!

41:1(.D14!*+'0!-.5-1D*!*+&.36+!+'0!,.&M!.5!03&:':.&0!.A!-.5A('-*2!*&)38)!)54!:'.(15-12!D.0'*0!

*+)*!6.<"%(B1$"%!181&610!A&.8!6.<"%7"&&(%#+"2!,+'-+!35(1)0+10!L.*+!*+1!410*&3-*':1!

D.,1&!.A!0)L.*)61!)54!03L:1&0'.5!*+)*!'0!.A*15!35-.50-'.30($!41D(.$14!L$!*+.01!,+.!+):1!

1KD1&'15-14!01:1&1!.DD&100'.5!.&!*&)38)2!)0!,1((!)0!*+1!-.50*&3-*':1!D.,1&!A.&!L3'(4'56!

8.:1815*0!*.!-.5A&.5*!)54!.:1&-.81!'5V30*'-1kIT!!>5*1&5)(($2!03&:':.&0!.A!*&)38)!)54!

:'.(15-1!A'54!'*!4'AA'-3(*!*.!*&)50'*!A&.8!L1'56!.LV1-*0!m!:'-*'80!.A!.DD&100'.5!*.!03LV1-*0!)54!

)615*0!.A!-+)561f!*+1$!)&1!35)L(1!*.!+.(4!)54!1K1&-'01!D.,1&!5.5W.DD&100':1($T!!%'5-1!

A18'5'0*!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)&1!.A*15!-&1)*142!(142!)54!0*)AA14!L$!,.8152!8)5$!.A!,+.8!)&1!

03&:':.&0!.A!:)&'.30!*&)38)*'-!.&!.DD&100':1!1KD1&'15-102!*+1!6.7,*,5&(.-(6.<"%7"&&1"&&!

-&1)*10!L1+):'.&)(!D)**1&50!*+)*!)AA1-*!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!A35-*'.5'56!'5!D&.A.354!)54!4'0*3&L'56!

,)$0U!!!

!

S"(3#="(01.<1(-.%(#(7.1+(*,4"(*3#*(*"1$"15,"&(*.<#%$($.4,1#*,.1(#1$(*.6P$.<1(6%#5*,5"&(

$.1J*(LB&*("C,&*(,1(4#,1&*%"#4(&.5,"*;A(GB*(#7&.(<,*3,1(6%.+%"&&,="M(4.="4"1*&(#1$(

.%+#1,Q#*,.1&(H(*3#*(<"(,1*"%1#7,Q"(*3"&"(*"1$"15,"&(#1$(5#%%;(*3"4(<,*3(B&A(1.(4#**"%(3.<(

3.1"&*7;(#1$($""67;(<"(G"7,"="(,1("+#7,*#%,#1(6%,15,67"&(#1$(=#7B"&>((@&(6%.$B5*&(.-(#((

&.5,"*;(.%+#1,Q"$(#%.B1$($.4,1#*,.1A(*3"(&*%B++7"(*.(5%"#*"("OB#7(6.<"%(%"7#*,.1&(,&(#7<#;&(

,1*"%1#7(#&(<"77(#&("C*"%1#7>((T(#4(&B++"&*,1+(*3#*(*3"(&#4"(,&(*%B"(%"+#%$,1+(6.<"%7"&&1"&&A(

#1$(*3#*(<"(1""$(*.(6#;(*3"(&#4"(0,1$(.-(&5%B6B7.B&(#**"1*,.1(*.(6.<"%PB1$"%(<,*3,1(&.5,#7(

53#1+"(4.="4"1*&(*3#*(,&(1""$"$(*.(&*%B++7"(#+#,1&*(*"1$"15,"&(*.<#%$(6.<"%P.="%>((T1(-#5*(

$.4,1#*,.1(#1$(6.<"%7"&&1"&&(#%"(*<.(&,$"&(.-(*3"(&#4"(5.,1A(#1$(#%"(,1*"%%"7#*"$(1.*(.17;(

G"*<""1(,1$,=,$B#7&(GB*(#7&.(<,*3,1(,1$,=,$B#7&(,1(<#;&(*3#*(#%"(5%,*,5#7(*.("C#4,1"(#1$(

B1$"%&*#1$>?b((

!

/5!1K-1((15*!1K)8D(1!.A!*+1!410*&3-*':1!)54!-.50*&3-*':1!-)D)-'*$!.A!6.<"%(B1$"%!'0!,+)*!

8)5$!01)0.514!/A&'-)5!A18'5'0*0!-)((!*+1!N!Q+1!o)5<'L)&!GKD1&'15-1P!W!)!D&.8'0'56!811*'56!

*+)*!*3&514!'5*.!)!5'6+*8)&1!.A!D)'52!)561&2!)54!&1-&'8'5)*'.50T!>5!IJJb2!)!6&.3D!.A!A18'5'0*0!

81*!'5!o)5<'L)&!*.!D()5!*+1!/A&'-)5!718'5'0*!F.56&100T!Q+'&*$WA':1!.A!*+18!81*!.5!)!9.54)$2!

)54!0..5!4'0-.:1&14!*+)*!)0038D*'.50!1)-+!,.8)5!+)4!8)41!)L.3*!*+1!.*+1&0]!

35)&*'-3()*14!'54':'43)(!)54!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!D.('*'-0!,1&15]*!+.(4'56!3D!H!'5!.*+1&!,.&402!

*+1&1!,)0!)!(.*!.A!6.<"%7"&&(%#+"!D()$'56!'*01(A!.3*!'5!*+1!D&.-100T!#$!Q+3&04)$2!L)-MWL'*'562!

+.0*'('*$2!*1)&02!L'**1&5100!)54!-+).0!&1'6514T!Q+1!F.56&100!4'45]*!+)DD152!)54!*+1!

D)&*'-'D)5*0!(1)&514!*+1!4'AA'-3(*!(100.5!*+)*!*+1.&$!)54!D&)-*'-1!4.5]*!)(,)$0!6.!*.61*+1&T!!

;5!*+1!D.0'*':1!0'412!*+1!o)5<'L)&!1KD1&'15-1!(14!/A&'-)5!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0!*.!&1)('<1!*+)*!.51!

.A!*+1!A'&0*!0*1D0!*.!1AA1-*':1!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!'0!*.!)-M5.,(1461!*+)*!,1!-.81!'5*.!*+1!

8.:1815*!,'*+!4'AA1&15*!+'0*.&'10!)54!1KD1&'15-102!)54!-.501d315*($2!,1!5114!*.!-&1)*1!

L)0'-!&3(10!.A!156)61815*!*.!6.:1&5!+.,!,1!*&1)*!1)-+!.*+1&2!)54!+.,!*.!+)54(1!.3&!.,5!

410*&3-*':1!*15415-'10T!Q+1!/A&'-)5!718'5'0*!F+)&*1&kg2!*+1!A'&0*!03-+!-.41!.A!-.543-*!'5!*+1!

A18'5'0*!,.&(42!,)0!*+1!D.,1&A3(!6'A*!.A!*+1!o)5<'L)&!41L)-(1T!!

!

T?A2:!85!?:L458Y438?59/!!

!

O1)41&0+'D!'0!D&)-*'-142!A.&!*+1!8.0*!D)&*2!'5!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!01**'560T!Y):'56!35D)-M14!)!

,+.(1!&)561!.A!-.5-1D*0!)L.3*!D.,1&2!'*!'0!5.,!51-100)&$!*.!3541&0*)54!*+1!4$5)8'-!.A!

D.,1&!,'*+'5!.&6)5'<)*'.502!'5!.&41&!*.!)44&100!+.,!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!-)5!-&1)*1!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!kI!!%*1:15!='518)52!IJJb2!N\.,1&W_541&U!Q&)38)!)54!R.5:'.(15*!%.-')(!F+)561P2!F)8L&'4612!9/T2!

4.,5(.)4)L(1!A&.8!,,,TQ&)38))54R.5:'.(15-1T-.8!2!\Tgj!W!""S!kb!%*1:15!='518)52!IJJb2!,G,$>A(\TgS!

kg!?.,5(.)4)L(1!A&.8!,,,T)A&'-)5A18'5'0*A.&38T.&6mF+)&*1&!!

Page 21: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! I"!

6153'51($!4'AA1&15*!0*&3-*3&10!A.&!*+1!)-+'1:1815*!.A!*+1'&!6.)(0T!%.!'*!'0!'8D.&*)5*!*.!

3541&0*)54!.&6)5'<)*'.50!8.&1!-(1)&($T!!/5!.&6)5'<)*'.5!'0!41A'514!)0!L+"(12&+*"+--+':$%$')"

9.&2."/7-(7$("21**$2)&6$":1+*(3"21')-1*("&)("19'"/$-#1-%+'2$3"+',".+("+"417',+-5"

($/+-+)&':"&)"#-1%"&)("$'6&-1'%$')!M!kk!!;&6)5'<)*'.50!-)5!L1!1'*+1&!#1-%+*"@(16)(($!

-.50*'*3*14!)54!&1-.65'<14!15*'*'10!('M1!-..D1&)*':102!*&)41!35'.502!-.8D)5'102!A.354)*'.50!

.&!RX;0E!.&!&'#1-%+*"!@5.*!(16)(($!-.50*'*3*142!L3*!0*&3-*3&10!-&1)*14!A.&!*+1!A3(A'((815*!.A!

0.81!D3&D.01!.&!6.)(!H!03-+!)0!)!A)&81&]0!6&.3D2!,.815]0!0):'560!)54!-&14'*!6&.3D02!

-.((1-*':102!1*-TET!!

!

;&6)5'<)*'.50!H!,+1*+1&!A.&8)(!.&!'5A.&8)(!W!)&1!8'-&.-.080!.A!*+1!0.-')(!15:'&.5815*!A&.8!

,+'-+!*+1$!181&61T!!#3*!8.0*!.A!30!)00381!*+)*!35('M1!0.-')(!0*&3-*3&10!('M1!*+1!A)8'($!.&!

-()52!,+'-+!)&1!&1D(1*1!,'*+!61541&!)54!.*+1&!L')010!)54!+'1&)&-+'102!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)&1!

&)*'.5)(2!(.6'-)(!15*'*'10!,+1&1!0*)*14!:)(3102!6.)(0!)54!D.('-'10!,'((!L1!.D1&)*'.5)('<14!'5!)((!

'*0!D&.-10010T!!_5A.&*35)*1($2!&101)&-+!'5!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!L1+):'.&!+)0!0+.,5!*+)*!*+'0!'0!

0'8D($!5.*!*&31!H!.&6)5'<)*'.502!)A*1&!)((2!)&1!-&1)*14!)54!&35!L$!+38)5!L1'5602!)54!+38)5!

L1'560!)&1!5.*!15*'&1($!&)*'.5)(a!!=+)*!'0!8.&12!.&6)5'<)*'.50!181&61!A&.8!0.-')(!'50*'*3*'.50!

'5!,+'-+!)!,'41!&)561!.A!D.,1&!'8L)()5-10!)54!'51d3)('*'10!)&1!18L14414T!!C).!)54!

Z1((1+1&!5.*12!A.&!'50*)5-12!*+)*!

!

N;&6)5'<)*'.50!0,'8!'5!)!01)!.A!0.-'1*)(!5.&802!,+'-+!5.*!.5($!'5A(315-1!

.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!L1+):'.&!L3*!.A*15!.D1&)*1!L1(.,!*+1!(1:1(!.A!-.50-'.305100cT!Q+1$!

-.50*&)'5!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!1AA.&*0!*.!-+)((1561!61541&WL')014!5.&80!L.*+!'5!*+1!

0.-'1*$!)54!'5!*+1!.&6)5'<)*'.5cT!uL3*v!Q+1!L3'(4'56!L(.-M0!.A!8)5$!.A!.3&!

.&6)5'<)*'.50!)&1!61541&!L')014!'5!,)$0!*+)*!)&1!d3'*1!'5:'0'L(1TP!kl!

F.501d315*($2!)5.*+1&!0.-')(!0-'15*'0*2!X1.AA&1$!=..42!)&6310!*+)*!410D'*1!*+1!A.&8)(!

5.&80!)54!:)(310!*+)*!,1!8)$!-&1)*1!A.&!.3&!.&6)5'<)*'.502!,1!)&1!5.*!)(,)$0!)L(1!*.!(1):1!

L1+'54!.3&!A)8'(')(!)54!0.-')(!-.54'*'.5'56!,+15!,1!15*1&!.3&!.AA'-10kjT!!='518)5!,.3(4!

D&.L)L($!)44!*+)*!,1!)&1!)(0.!35)L(1!*.!(1):1!L1+'54!*+1!1)&($!1KD1&'15-10!.A!

D.,1&(1005100!*+)*!4)8)61!.3&!01(A!10*118!)54!4'0)L(1!30!A&.8!30'56!.3&!6.<"%(<,*3,1!

-.50*&3-*':1($T!!Q.!8)M1!*+1!D.'5*2!=..4!)0M0U!N=+)*!0.-')(!)54!-3(*3&)(!4'0*)5-1!4.10!)5!

.AA'-')(!+):1!*.!*&):1(!A&.8!+.81!*.!,.&M!1:1&$!4)$ePkS2!)54!*+'0!d310*'.5!)DD('10!1d3)(($!*.!

)5$!.A!30!'5!.3&!4':1&01!1541):.&0T!=1!-(1)&($!L&'56!*.!.&6)5'<)*'.50!H!,+1*+1&!)*!(1)41&0+'D!

(1:1(!.&!.*+1&,'01!H!*+1!L')0102!-.54'*'.5'562!1KD1&'15-10!,'*+!D.,1&2!)54!.*+1&!D0$-+'-!

L)66)612!)0!,1((!)0!.3&!)0D'&)*'.502!+'6+W8'5414!6.)(02!)54!6..4!'5*15*'.50T!!!

Q+'0!'0!1d3)(($!*&31!A.&!A18'5'0*02!L3*!+)&41&!*.!)44&100!0'5-1!,1!011!.3&01(:10!)0!*+1!)615*0!

.A!*&)50A.&8)*'.5!.A!*+1!'51d3)('*'10!-&1)*14!L$!.*+1&02!L$!8)'50*&1)8!'41.(.6'10!)54!

'50*'*3*'.50T!!>541142!*+1&1!'0!5.,!83-+!8.&1!.D15!4'0-300'.52!'5!0D)-10!('M1!*+1!/=>?!

7.&38!'5*1&5)*'.5)(($2!)0!,1((!)0!'5!4.810*'-!0D)-102!*+)*!A18'5'0*!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0!+):1!5.*!)(,)$0!03--11414!'5!-&1)*'56!15:'&.5815*0!&18)&M)L($!4'AA1&15*!A&.8!

*+.01!.A!*+1'&!8)(1!0.-')(!V30*'-1!)-*':'0*0T!!/!&)561!.A!'00310!H!N*+1!A.3541&!0$54&.81P2!

8'0301!.&!)L301!.A!D.,1&2!()-M!.A!0D)-1!A.&!$.3561&!,.815]0!)6154)0!)54!(1)41&0+'D2!)54!

0.!A.&*+!H!+):1!181&614!83-+!8.&1!.D15($!'5!&1-15*!*'810T!!\1&+)D0!83-+!.A!*+'0!'0!

L1-)301!.A!.3&!A)'(3&1!*.!N,)(M!*+1!4'0*)5-1P2!.&!&1-.65'<1!.3&!.,5!'5*1&5)('<14!1KD1&'15-10!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!kk!!%11!+**DUmm15T,'M'D14')T.&6m,'M'm;&6)5'<)*'.50!!

kl!!/&35)!C).!)54!?):'4!Z1((1+1&2!IJJS2!N_5&):1(('56!>50*'*3*'.5)('<14!X1541&!>51d3)('*$P2!X1541&!)*!=.&M!

;--)0'.5)(!\)D1&2!,,,T61541&)*,.&MT.&6m(1)&5'56!2!\T!kWl!kj!X1.AA&1$!?T!=..42!"iig2!N#)56()410+U!=+.01!>41)0e!=+.01!>5*1&10*0eP2!O.54.5U!>5*1&814')*1!Q1-+5.(.6$!

\3L('-)*'.502!)54!N%.-')(!?'8150'.50!.A!X.:1&5)5-1P2!=.&(4!#)5M!m!#)56()410+!R)*'.5)(!>50*'*3*'.5)(!C1:'1,2!

-'*14!'5!C).!h!Z1((1+1&2!IJJS2!.6>5,*T!kS!X1.AA&1$!?T!=..42!N%.-')(!?'8150'.50!.A!X.:1&5)5-1P2!=.&(4!#)5M!m!#)56()410+!R)*'.5)(!>50*'*3*'.5)(!C1:'1,2!

-'*14!'5!C).!h!Z1((1+1&2!IJJS2!.6>5,*T!

Page 22: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! II!

,'*+!D.,1&T!718'5'0*!(1)41&0!)&1!303)(($!8.&1!-.50-'.30!)54!0150'*':1!*.!*+1'&!:'0'L(1!D.,1&!

*+)5!*.!*+1'&!+'4415!)54!)6154)W01**'56!D.,1&f!'T1T2!*.!*+1'&!D.,1&!-.%!)54!*.2!5.*!*+1'&!

D.,1&!.="%T!!#3*!35(100!,1!61*!D)0*!*+'02!*+1&1!'0!('**(1!-+)5-1!*+)*!.3&!(1)41&0+'D!,'((!L1!

*&)50A.&8)*':12!.&!1:15!D)&*'-3()&($!A18'5'0*T!!!!

>5!.&41&!*.!8.:1!*.,)&40!8.&1!1AA1-*':1!)54!*&)50A.&8)*':1!156)61815*0!,'*+!.3&!D.,1&2!

)54!-&1)*1!8.&1!1AA1-*':1!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!8.:1815*02!'*!'0!301A3(!*.!1K)8'51!*+1!-.5-1D*!

.A!*+1!L,$$/"()-72)7-$M"1#"1-:+'&N+)&1'("+',"%16$%$')(ki2lJ2!,+1&1!8.0*!.A!*+1!'54'&1-*!

)54!+'4415!D.,1&!)54!6.<"%(B1$"%!'0!(.-)*142!)54!A&.8!,+1&1!4'&1-*!)54!:'0'L(1!D.,1&!'0!

&10'0*142!0)L.*)6142!.&!03L:1&*14T!!

!

08LQG!V!.?J2!04<239!?M!3B2!W*22R!.3:=<3=:2X!?M!&:L458Y438?59!!

!

?11D!0*&3-*3&1!'0!)!:'*)(!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!-.5-1D*2!)54!&1A1&0!*.!*+1!+'4415!0'*10!)54!D&.-10010!

.A!D.,1&!)54!'5A(315-12!*+1!'8D('-'*!-3(*3&12!*+1!'5A.&8)(!:)(310!)54!0$0*180!.A!&1,)&4!)54!

&1-.65'*'.52!)((!.A!,+'-+!+):1!15.&8.30!'8D)-*!.5!+.,!D1.D(1!)54!*+1!.&6)5'<)*'.5!)-*3)(($!

A35-*'.5T!?11D!0*&3-*3&10!)&12!'5!)!015012!('M1!*+1!1(1D+)5*!'5!*+1!&..8!H!,1!)((!M5.,!*+1$]&1!

*+1&12!L3*!,1!4.5]*!M5.,!+.,!*.!5)81!*+18!)54!*)-M(1!*+18!)5)($*'-)(($!.&!D&)-*'-)(($T!Q.!

'((30*&)*1!*+1!D.'5*2!0.81!-.88.5!4'8150'.50!.A!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!411D!0*&3-*3&10!'0!

D&1015*14!'5!7'6T!"!@51K*!D)61ET!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!59 /&35)!C).2!C'1M$!%*3)&*!)54!?):'4!Z1((1+1&2!X1541&!)*!=.&MU!;&6)5'<)*'.5)(!F+)561!A.&!Gd3)('*$2!#(..8A'1(4!

FQ2!Z38)&')5!\&1002!"iii

60 /&35)!C).!)54!?):'4!Z1((1+1&2!NO1)41&0+'D!A.&!0.-')(!*&)50A.&8)*'.5U!0.81!'41)0!)54!d310*'.50!.5!'50*'*3*'.50!

)54!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'DP2!X1541&!)54!?1:1(.D815*2!`.(T!S2!R.T!b2!R.:18L1&!IJJJ2!DDTjg!H!ji2!\Tjk!

Page 23: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! Ib!

718'5'0*!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!41:1(.D815*!D&)-*'*'.51&0!+):1!A.354!*+)*!411DW01)*14!&10'0*)5-1!

*.!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!-+)5612!10D1-')(($!*.,)&40!8.&1!61541&!1d3)(!)54!V30*!D&)-*'-102!)&'010!

A&.8!*+1!411D!0*&3-*3&12!)54!,'*+.3*!0D1-'A'-!*..(0!*.!351)&*+!)54!*&)50A.&8!'*2!.5($!

03D1&A'-')(!-+)5610!,'((!.--3&T!!='*+'5!A18'5'0*!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!8.:1815*02!411D!

0*&3-*3&10!)&1!1:15!8.&1!-.8D(1K2!10D1-')(($!,+1&1!*+1&1!+):1!L115!)**18D*0!*.!-&1)*1!

NA()*P!.&!N-'&-3()&P!.&!N5.5W+'1&)&-+'-)(P!0*&3-*3&10T!!Y'1&)&-+'10!)54!D.,1&!0*&3-*3&10!+):1!

)&'015!'5!*+101!&16)&4(1002!L3*!.D1&)*1!)*!*+1!(1:1(!.A!411D!0*&3-*3&12!8)M'56!*+18!1:15!

8.&1!4'AA'-3(*!*.!0112!)44&1002!.&!*&)50A.&8T!!/0!1)&($!)0!"ijJ2![.!7&118)5!,&.*1!)L.3*!NQ+1!

Q$&)55$!.A!%*&3-*3&1(1005100P!)54!*+1!+'4415!D.,1&!+'1&)&-+'10!*+)*!+)4!181&614!'5!*+1!

.&6)5'<)*'.50!.A!*+1!/81&'-)5!,.815]0!('L1&)*'.5!8.:1815*!.A!*+1!*'81l"2!)54!)L.3*!*+1!

301!.A!N*&)0+'56P!*.!4'0-&14'*!m!.0*&)-'01!m!418.&)('<1!m!4'018D.,1&!0.81.51lIT!!/*!(1)0*!

0.81!D)&*!.A!*+1!N*&)0+'56P!D+15.815.5!'0!)!8)5'A10*)*'.5!.A!6.<"%(B1$"%2!)54!'0!)!-()00'-!

411D!0*&3-*3&1!D+15.815.5!*+)*!-.5*'5310!*'((!*.4)$T!

?11D!0*&3-*3&10!)&1!)(0.!'8D.&*)5*!L1-)301!*+'0!'0!,+1&1!*+1!-3(*3&1!.A!*+1!.&6)5'<)*'.5!'0!

18L14414!)54!&1D&.43-14!H!5.!8)**1&!,+)*!*+1!A.&8)(2!0*)*142!.&!)0D'&14WA.&!-3(*3&1!8)$!

L1T!!>*!'0!)(0.!,+1&1!D1.D(1]0!'5*1&5)('<14!)**'*3410!)54!L1+):'.&0!)&1!8)5'A10*142!

-.5*&'L3*'56!*.!*+1!-.50*&3-*'.5!.A!*+)*!-3(*3&1T!!/54!*+1!(100!*+1!.&6)5'<)*'.5]0!:'0'L(1!

0*&3-*3&1!15)L(10!.D15!D&.-100'56!.A!'*0!818L1&0]!-.5A('-*02!)0D'&)*'.502!'41)02!)54!

D&.L(1802!*+1!8.&1!*+101!)&1!4&':15!'5*.!*+1!411D!0*&3-*3&12!8)M'56!'*!)!0'*1!.A!*150'.52!

&10'0*)5-12!03L:1&0'.52!)54!0)L.*)61T!!>5!.*+1&!,.&402!*+1!8.&1!.D152!*&)50D)&15*2!)54!

)--.35*)L(1!)5!.&6)5'<)*'.5!'02!*+1!0+)((.,1&!)54!(100!410*&3-*':1!,'((!*+1!411D!0*&3-*3&1!L1T!!

T?R=74:!,D3B9!"N?=3!U!'83B85!02J85893!&:L458Y438?59!

" =.815!,'((!(1)4!4'AA1&15*($!L1-)301!*+1$!)&1!,.815!

" !=.815!,'((!0+)&1!D.,1&!8.&1!&1)4'($2!8.&1!1d3)(($!

" #1-)301!,1]&1!)((!,.8152!,1!4.5]*!+):1!*.!,.&&$!)L.3*!D.,1&!,'*+'5!*+1!

.&6)5'<)*'.5m8.:1815*!!

" #1-)301!,1!)&1!A18'5'0*!,.8152!,1!m!.3&!.&6)5'<)*'.50!-)55.*!L1!.DD&100':12!

1K-(30'.5)&$2!.&!35418.-&)*'-!

" !;3&!.&6)5'<)*'.5!'0!NA()*P!W!,1!4.5]*!L1('1:1!'5!+'1&)&-+$2!,1!)&1!)((!1d3)(!+1&12!)54!

+):1!1d3)(!0)$!'5!)((!*+1!41-'0'.50!

" Y):'56!A.&8)(!(1)41&0!)54!(1)41&0+'D!&.(10!,'((!&1D&.43-1!D)*&')&-+)(!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!

A.&80!

" !7.&8)('<'56!41-'0'.5W8)M'56!D.,1&!)54!)--.35*)L'('*$!0$0*180!'0!D)*&')&-+)(!)54!

L3&1)3-&)*'-!!

" =1!)&1!)--.35*)L(1!*.!N*+1!8.:1815*P!@=+'-+!.51e!=+1&1e!Y.,eE2!0.!,1!4.5]*!

+):1!*.!L1!-.5-1&514!)L.3*!)--.35*)L'('*$!

!

?10D'*1!*+1!1KD1&'15-1!)54!-+)((15610!A18'5'0*!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!8.:1815*0!+):1!A)-142!

)54!*+1!&1-.65'*'.52!'A!5.*!5)8'562!.A!*+1!D&.L(180!*+)*!)&1!(3&M'56!'5!*+1'&!411D!0*&3-*3&12!

*+1&1!)&1!)!03&D&'0'56!538L1&!.A!8$*+0!*+)*!03&:':1!)L.3*!*+18!W!'41)('<14!5.*'.50!)L.3*!

*+1'&!03D1&'.&!+)54('56!.A!'00310!.A!D.,1&2!A)-'('*)*14!L$!*+1!411D!0*&3-*3&10!*+)*!03L81&61!

)54!+'41!*+1!D&.L(180T!/(*+.36+!0.81!8)$!0118!-('-+x02!*+1!8.&1!,'410D&1)4!.510!)&1!

,.&*+!5.*'56!@011!L.KEU!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!l"![.!7&118)52!"ijJ2!NQ+1!Q$&)55$!.A!%*&3-*3&1(1005100P2!4.,5(.)4)L(1!A&.8!,,,T0*&366(1T,0!!

lI![.!7&118)52!"ijl2!NQ&)0+'56U!Q+1!?)&M!%'41!.A!%'0*1&+..4P!Y&>(Y#+#Q,1"!@/D&'(EU!IiWk"2!iIWiST!

Page 24: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! Ig!

/!M1$!*)0M!.A!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!D&.6&)80!'0!*+1&1A.&1!*.!)&&':1!)*!)!83-+!

-(1)&1&!3541&0*)54'56!.A!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!*+1'&!411D!0*&3-*3&102!)54!*.!1K)8'51!)54!

03&A)-1!411D!0*&3-*3&1!4$5)8'-02!'5!.&41&!*.!L3'(4!8.&1!*&)50D)&15*2!)--.35*)L(12!)54!

418.-&)*'-!,)$0!.A!41)('56!,'*+!D.,1&!'5!.3&!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!)54!8.:1815*!0*&3-*3&10T!!

O1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!D&.6&)80!830*!0*&156*+15!'5D3*0!.5!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!L1+):'.&2!

-3(*3&12!)54!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!D.,1&!4$5)8'-02!'5-(34'56!H!.&!10D1-')(($!H!*+1!411D!0*&3-*3&1!

4'8150'.52!)54!1d3'D!D)&*'-'D)5*0!,'*+!*..(0!*.!)44&100!*+101T!!Q+1$!)(0.!+):1!*.!+1(D!

D)&*'-'D)5*0!-.81!*.!+.510*!*1&80!,'*+!5.*'.50!.A!'5*1&5)(!1d3)('*$!H!,+)*!*+)*!(..M0!('M1!

)54!+.,!'*!,.&M0!'5!D&)-*'-12!)54!D1&+)D0!)(0.!61*!D)0*!A1)&0!.A!*)-M('56!D.,1&!

)&&)561815*0!8.&1!.D15($T!!!

EQ! T:85<8R729!45I!Z47=29!

>*!'0!)!8..*!D.'5*!,+1*+1&!D&'5-'D(10!)54!:)(310!0+.3(4!+):1!D&1-1414!D.('*'-0!)54!D3&D.01!

'5!)!4.-3815*!.5!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'DT!!C16)&4(1002!*+1$!)&1!-&'*'-)(!*.!.3&!4'0-300'.5!L1-)301!

(1)41&0+'D!4.10!5.*!.--3&!'5!)!8.&)(!.&!0.-')(!:)-338!H!'*!'0!)(,)$0!'5A.&814!L$!:)(3102!

,+1*+1&!*+101!)&1!1KD('-'*!.&!5.*f!)54!:)(310!)&1!5.*!+1(4!.5($!L$!D&.6&100':1!(1)41&02!0'5-1!

1:15!)3*.-&)*02!,)&(.&402!*1&&.&'0*0!)54!4'-*)*.&0!-&1)*1!)!8.&)(!V30*'A'-)*'.5!A.&!*+1'&!

*$&)55$!)54!:'.(15-1T!Q+302!(1)41&0+'D!18L&)-10!*+1!:)(310!)54!D&'5-'D(10!*+)*!)&1!

-.50.5)5*!,'*+!'*0!8'00'.5!)54!D3&D.012!.&!,+'-+!+):1!A&)814!.&!-)*)($<14!*+)*!D3&D.01T!

>*!'0!301A3(!*.!L16'5!L$!4'0*'563'0+'56!L1*,115!:)(310!)54!D&'5-'D(102!)54!*+)*!,1!5114!*.!

4'0-300!:)(310!L1A.&1!D&'5-'D(10T!!D+*7$("+-$").$"$).&2+*"'1-%(").+)":7&,$"4$.+6&1-O"

/-&'2&/*$("+-$"'1-%(").+)":7&,$"+2)&1'T!!;L:'.30($2!*+1$!)&1!5.*!83*3)(($!1K-(30':1!H!*+1&1!'0!

5.*!.5($!)!6..4!41)(!.A!.:1&()D!L1*,115!*+182!L3*!8)5$!D&'5-'D(10!41&':1!A&.8!:)(310T!!7.&!

'50*)5-12!1d3)('*$!)54!1d3'*$!)&1!:)(310!)0!,1((!)0!D&'5-'D(10f!L3*!A35-*'.5'56!'5!418.-&)*'-2!

*&)50D)&15*!)54!)--.35*)L(1!,)$0!)&1!D&'5-'D(10!41&':14!A&.8!*+1!:)(31!.A!1d3)('*$T!

%'8'()&($2!*+1!:)(31!.A!61541&!1d3)('*$!63'410!*+1!)-*'.50!A.&!18D.,1&'56!,.815T!!

\&'5-'D(10!)54!:)(310!)&1!D)&*'-3()&($!'8D.&*)5*!'5!-.5A('-*!0'*3)*'.502!,+1*+1&!*+1!-.5A('-*!'0!

,'*+'5!)5!.&6)5'<)*'.52!.&!*+1!.&6)5'<)*'.5!'0!41)('56!,'*+!*+1!1AA1-*0!.A!-.5A('-*!'5!*+1!

1K*1&5)(!15:'&.5815*!W!03-+!)0!)!D.('*'-)(!-&'0'0!.&!,)&T!Q+'0!'0!D&1-'01($!,+15!'*!'0!*18D*'56!

*.!V1**'0.5!D&'5-'D(10!)54!:)(310!'5!.&41&!*.!41)(!,'*+!*+1!0+.&*W*1&8!-&'0'0f!,+'-+!'0!,+$!

A18'5'0*!(1)41&0!830*!1503&1!*+)*!*+1'&!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!8.:1815*0!41:1(.D!0.354!)54!

1KD('-'*($W)&*'-3()*14!D&'5-'D(10!*+)*!-)5!'5A.&8!0*&)*16'-!-+.'-10!43&'56!D&1-)&'.30!*'810T!!

#3*!L3'(4'56!-.5015030!)L.3*!:)(310!)54!D&'5-'D(10!'0!'*01(A!)!-+)((156'56!*)0MT!%.81!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0!0*)54!:1+1815*($!A.&!1d3)(!(16)(!&'6+*0!A.&!,.815!.&!,.815]0!&'6+*!*.!-+.'-12!L3*!

)&1!411D($!35-.8A.&*)L(1!03DD.&*'56!6)$!&'6+*0!8.:1815*0f!.*+1&0!,'((!6()4($!8)&-+!,'*+!

)(('10!'5!418)54'56!418.-&)*'-!6.:1&5)5-12!L3*!):.'4!'50*'*3*'56!*+1!0)81!D&'5-'D(10!'5!*+1'&!

.,5!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!0*&3-*3&10T!!Q+1!:)(31!4'8150'.5!'0!*+1&1A.&1!8.&1!*+)5!&+1*.&'-!A.&!

-&1)*'56!)!8.&)(!+'6+!6&.3542!L3*!)5!)-*':12!)(':1!'50*&3815*!.A!A18'5'0*!D.('*'-0T!

Q+1&1!)&1!01:1&)(!-.&1!:)(310!)54!D&'5-'D(10!*+)*!A18'5'08!+)0!18L&)-14!*+&.36+.3*!

+'0*.&$2!,'*+!0.81!:)&')*'.5!L)014!.5!-3(*3&1!)54!-.5*1K*T!!Q+1!A.((.,'56!*)L(1!)**18D*0!*.!

-)D*3&1!0.81!.A!*+101!'5!)!0'8D(1!A.&8!*.!)4:)5-1!.3&!4'0-300'.52!*+.36+!'*!'0!5.*!'5*15414!

*.!L1!)5!1K+)30*':1!('0*U!!

02J85893!Z47=29!45I!T:85<8R729[\!

!

Z47=29! T:85<8R729!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!63 Q+101!4&),!+1):'($!.5!%&'()*+)!#)*(',)()2!NQ+1!\.,1&!.A!9.:1815*0U!F()&'A$'56!;3&!F.5-1D*02P!'5!23#1+,1+(

/3",%(S.%7$'(2.15"6*&(#1$(K%#5*,5"&(.-(S.4"1J&(Y.="4"1*&2!/=>?2!IJJS2!DT""W"IT!

Page 25: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! Ik!

!

)]=4783D@!2]=83D@!45I!85<7=98?5!A.&!)((!

&16)&4(100!.A!61541&2!&)-12!&1('6'.52!)612!

)L'('*$2!1*+5'-'*$2!-()002!-)0*12!5)*'.5)('*$2!

(.-)*'.52!.&!01K3)(!.&'15*)*'.5!

Gd3)('*$!3541&!(),f!

Gd3'*$!)54!1d3)('*$!'5!D.('-'10f!

Q&)50A.&8!)((!0.-')(!&1()*'.50!.A!D.,1&!*+)*!

.DD&1002!1KD(.'*2!.&!8)&6'5)('<1!,.815!)54!

8152!.5!*+1!L)0'0!.A!*+1'&!61541&2!&)-12!&1('6'.52!

)612!)L'('*$2!1*+5'-'*$2!-()002!-)0*12!5)*'.5)('*$2!

(.-)*'.52!.&!01K3)(!.&'15*)*'.5!

-B2!B=J45!:8LB39!?M!477!R2?R729!*.!

)-+'1:1!*+1'&!A3((!D.*15*')(2!)0!(.56!)0!'*!

4.10!5.*!'8D141!.&!-.50*&)'5!*+1!&'6+*0!

.A!.*+1&0!

G5A.&-1815*!.A!*+1!A3((!L.4$!.A!+38)5!&'6+*0!

*+&.36+!1K'0*'56!)54!51,!'5*1&5)*'.5)(!

'50*&3815*0f!

/6)'50*!A354)815*)('080!.A!)((!M'540!

-B2!N498<!:8LB3!45I!2538372J253!?M!477!

R2?R72!3?!M??I@!9B2732:@!B2473B@!

2I=<438?5@!45I!78>278B??I2!!

G-.5.8'-!V30*'-12!'5-(34'56!1d3'*)L(1!!)--100!*.!

D&.43-*':1!&10.3&-102!18D(.$815*2!)54!L)0'-!

01&:'-10!A.&!)((!

TBD98<47!92<=:83D!45I!8532L:83D@!M:22I?J!

M:?J!>8?725<2!?:!<?2:<8?5!'5!)5$!A.&82!

)54!*+1!:8LB3!3?!<B?8<2!'5!&1D&.43-*':1!

)54!01K3)(!('A1!

o1&.!*.(1&)5-1!A.&!61541&WL)014!)54!.*+1&!

A.&80!.A!:'.(15-1f!

7&114.8!.A!-+.'-1!'5!01K3)(!)54!&1D&.43-*':1!

('A1!

T24<2!! R.5:'.(15-1f!0*)54!)6)'50*!)((!A.&80!.A!,)&2!

-.5A('-*2!8'('*)&'<)*'.52!!

"!B2473BD!R74523! %30*)'5)L(1!41:1(.D815*f!!

G-.(.6'-)(($!0.354!D&)-*'-10!'5!D1&0.5)(2!

.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!('A1f!A.&!D3L('-!D.('-$!*+)*!

D&.8.*10!030*)'5)L'('*$!

^?5?:!I8>2:983D!45I!I8MM2:25<2!! /6)'50*!&1('6'.302!1*+5'-2!&)-')(2!)54!.*+1&!

A354)815*)('080!

*2J?<:4<D@!3:459R4:25<D@!

4<<?=534N8783D!

`.'-1!)54!:.*1!A.&!)((!D1.D(1f!

\)&*'-'D)*.&$2!*&)50D)&15*!)54!)--.35*)L(1!

6.:1&5)5-1!)*!)((!(1:1(0!)54!'5!)((!'50*'*3*'.502!

D&':)*1!)54!D3L('-f!

C'6+*!*.!D3L('-!'5A.&8)*'.5f!

/00.-')*'.5)(!A&114.8!)54!&'6+*!*.!A&114.8!.A!

1KD&100'.5!

#B45L85L!3B2!=92!45I!R:4<38<2!?M!R?A2:! %+)&'56!D.,1&2!-.503(*)*':12!-.((1-*':12!

*&)50D)&15*!)54!)--.35*)L(1!41-'0'.5W8)M'56!

!

/5.*+1&!,)$!.A!)&*'-3()*'56!-.&1!:)(310!)54!D&'5-'D(10!'0!*+&.36+!5)8'56!*+1!N5.5W

516.*')L(10P!*+)*!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0!)54!*+1'&!.&6)5'<)*'.50!,'((!D&.*1-*!)54!)4:)5-1T!!/5!

1K)8D(1!.A!03-+!5.5W516.*')L(102!('0*14!L$!M1$!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0!)54!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!

41:1(.D815*!1KD1&*0!)*!)!&1-15*!,.&M0+.Dlg!)&1!D&1015*14!L1(.,U!

02J85893!(24I2:9B8R!V!9?J2!W%?5_%2L?384N729X!

718'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!4B&*!'5-(341!)5!)-*':1!D)&*'-'D)*.&$!)**'*3412!)54!'5-(30'.52!)*!)((!(1:1(0!

.A!*+1!.&6)5'<)*'.5T!Q+'0!)DD('10!D)&*'-3()&($!*.!'5*16&)*'.5!.A!D1.D(1!m!,.815!A&.8!

8)&6'5)('<14!6&.3D0T!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!lg!#$!D)&*'-'D)5*0!.A!*+1!FCG/!=.&M0+.D!N#3'(4'56!718'5'0*!O1)41&0+'DU!O..M'56!7.&,)&42!O..M'56!#)-MP2!

R.:18L1&!"I!h!"b2!IJJS2!F)D1!Q.,52!%.3*+!/A&'-)!

Page 26: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! Il!

718'5'0*!(1)41&0!830*!+):1!1K*150':1!M5.,(1461!.A!*+1!'00310!,'*+!,+'-+!*+1!.&6)5'<)*'.5!

156)610T!

718'5'0*!O1)41&0+'D!'0!030*)'5)L(1!.5($!,+15!,.815!)&1!)L(1!*.!L)()5-1!)((!)0D1-*0!.A!*+1'&!

(':10T!

?1-'0'.5W8)M'56!830*!L1!*&)50D)&15*!A.&!)!:')L(1!)54!:'L&)5*!(1)41&0+'D!*.!A(.3&'0+T!Q+'0!

'5:.(:10!)!-(1)&2!0+)&14!41-'0'.5W8)M'56!D&.-100!*+)*!D..(0!0*&156*+0!.A!D)&*'-'D)5*02!)54!

)((.,0!1:1&$.51!*.!+):1!0.81!D.,1&2!)54!)5!)*8.0D+1&1!*+)*!A)-'('*)*10!1:1&$!D1&0.5]0!

0*&156*+0T!G)-+!D1&0.5!'5!)5!.&6)5'<)*'.5!830*!+):1!0.81!)3*+.&'*$2!)0!,1((!)0!*..(02!

'5A.&8)*'.52!&10D.50'L'('*$!)54!)--.35*)L'('*$T!

Q+1!.&6)5'<)*'.5]0!818L1&0+'D!)*!()&61!830*!3541&0*)54!*+1'&!&.(10!)54!L1!'5:.(:14!'5!

-1&*)'5!41-'0'.502!)54!'5!*+1!1:.(3*'.5!.A!*+1!.&6)5'<)*'.5]0!0*&3-*3&1T!

718'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!830*!1503&1!*+)*!*+1!0)81!&'6+*0!)DD($!*.!)((2!)54!*+)*!*+101!&'6+*0!)&1!

'54':'0'L(1T!;&6)5'<)*'.5!818L1&0!830*!+):1!A3((!M5.,(1461!.A!*+1!.&6)5'<)*'.5]0!

D+'(.0.D+$!)54!)6154)2!)54!0+.3(4!L1!)L(1!*.!-+..012!)0!83-+!)0!D.00'L(12!+.,!*+1$!,.&M!

,'*+'5!*+1!.&6)5'<)*'.52!)54!+.,!83-+!'5A(315-1!*+1$!+):1!'5!41-'0'.5W8)M'56T!

718'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!830*!L1!3014!*.!'5*1&:151!'5!0*&3-*3&10!.A!D.,1&!*+)*!M11D!*+1!,.&(4!

35V30*f!'*!830*!-+)((1561!83(*'D(1!.DD&100'.502!L3*!61541&!V30*'-1!830*!L1!)!D&'.&'*$T!

O1)41&0+'D!'0!)!D&.-1002!)!6.)(2!)!D&)-*'-1!)54!)!81)50T!

/!A18'5'0*!.&6)5'<)*'.5!51140!)5!)AA'&8)*':1!:'0'.5!.A!-+)561!*+)*!*)M10!'*!A.&,)&42!&)*+1&!

*+)5!A.-30'56!.5($!.5!.DD&100'.5T!

718'5'0*!(1)41&0!5114!*.!-.50*)5*($!-+)((1561!)54!&1*+'5M!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!0*&3-*3&1T!

Q+1&1!830*!L1!0D)-1!A.&!(1)41&0!.A!)((!6151&)*'.502!)54!,1!830*!18L&)-1!4':1&0'*$2!

'5-(30':15100!)54!83*3)(!&10D1-*T!

=1!830*!)-*!)0!A18'5'0*!*&)50A.&8)*'.5)(!)615*02!)54!3541&0*)54!*+)*!D1.D(1!,+.!+.(4!

uA.&8)(v!D.,1&!)&15]*!51-100)&'($!*+1!L10*!(1)41&0T!

%'5-1!.3&!D.('*'-0!'0!4&':15!L$!*+101!:)(3102!D&'5-'D(102!)54!5.5W516.*')L(102!.3&!D&)-*'-1!.A!

D.,1&!+)0!*.!L1!*&)50A.&814!L$!*+18T!718'5'0*!(1)41&0!)54!.&6)5'<)*'.50!-)5!301!*+'0!

5.&8)*':1!A&)81,.&M!'5!01:1&)(!,)$02!1T6TU!

" *.!4:38<=7432!3B28:!>47=29!45I!R:85<8R729!85!J?:2!9R2<8M8<@!<?532;3=478Y2I!A4D9!*.!&1A(1-*!

*+1!-3(*3&1!)54!0.-'.WD.('*'-)(!15:'&.5815*!'5!,+'-+!'*!.D1&)*10f!

" *.!3:4597432!3B2J!853?!/1*&2&$(@!45I!J?:2!8JR?:34537D@!/-+2)&2$(2!,'*+'5!*+1'&!

.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!8.:1815*0f!

" *.!:29?7>2!R:?N72J9!45I!<?5M78<39!'5!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!('A1f!

" N=87I!J?:2!8532:_92<38?547!45I!7299_M:4LJ2532I!93:432L829!'5!.&41&!*.!)44&100!83(*'D(1!

01*0!.A!D&'5-'D(10f!)54!

" N=87I!839!4I>?<4<D!4L25I4!45I!477845<29!)--.&4'56!*.!*+101!:)(310!)54!D&'5-'D(10T!

Q+101!)&1!-&'*'-)(!D&'.&'*'10!*+)*!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!D&.6&)80!0+.3(4!)44&100T!!>!

18D+)0'<1!*+'0!L1-)301!:1&$!.A*152!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0!,'((!0*)54!:1+1815*($!A.&!1d3)(!(16)(!

&'6+*0!A.&!,.815!.&!,.815]0!&'6+*!*.!-+.'-12!L3*!*+1'&!-.5-1D*!.A!-+.'-1!8)$!L1!('8'*14!*.!

-1&*)'5!0.-')(($!)--1D*)L(1!-+.'-102!)54!,.3(4!L1!411D($!35-.8A.&*)L(1!.&!)5*)6.5'0*'-!*.!

Page 27: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! Ij!

03DD.&*'56!O#Q>lk!&'6+*0f!.&!*+1$!,'((!6()4($!8)&-+!,'*+!)(('10!'5!418)54'56!418.-&)*'-!

6.:1&5)5-12!L3*!):.'4!'50*'*3*'56!*+1!0)81!D&'5-'D(10!'5!*+1'&!.,5!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!0*&3-*3&10T!!

Q+1!:)(31!4'8150'.5!'0!*+1&1A.&1!M1$!*.!0.354!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!W!5.*!)0!&+1*.&'-!A.&!

01'<'56!*+1!8.&)(!+'6+!6&.3542!L3*!)0!)5!)-*':12!)(':1!'50*&3815*!.A!A18'5'0*!D.('*'-0T!

\Q T?7838<9!45I!T=:R?92!

/!M1$!-.8D.515*!.A!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!'0!'*0!/1*&)&2("+',").$"'+)7-$"1#").$"%&((&1'!@'T1T!

D3&D.01E!*+)*!63'410!'*T!!#$!/1*&)&2(!'0!81)5*!*+1!)5)($0'0!.A!0.-'.W1-.5.8'-!&1)('*'102!)54!*+1!

'41.(.6'-)(!(150!*+)*!'5A.&80!*+)*!)5)($0'0!@1T6T2!D&.A'*!)54!A&11!15*1&D&'012!D3L('-!6..42!

61541&!1d3)('*$2!0.-')(!V30*'-12!1*-TET!!/54!/7-/1($!&1A1&0!*.!*+1!(.561&W*1&8!:'0'.5!)54!

8'00'.5!A.&!-+)561!*+)*!181&610!A&.8!*+)*!D.('*'-0T!!

718'5'0*!D.('*'-02!L)014!.5!-.5*1K*3)(($!41A'514!)54!0'*3)*14!A18'5'0*!'41.(.6$!@5.*!0.81!

35':1&0)(!A.&8!.A!A18'5'08E2!830*!'5A.&8!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D2!)54!*+1!D.('*'-)(!)6154)!'*!

D3&0310T!!>5!.*+1&!,.&402!)-+'(#1-%+)&6$"#$%&'&()"*$+,$-(.&/!,'((!301!*+1!)5)($0'0!.A!61541&!

)54!0.-')(!4'0-&'8'5)*'.5!'5!)!D)&*'-3()&!0.-'1*$2!-.8835'*$2!.&!01**'56!)0!'*0!0*)&*'56!D.'5*2!

)54!,'((!)**18D*!*.!*&)50A.&8!*+1!0*&3-*3&10!.&!'50*'*3*'.50!'*!156)610!*.,)&40!)!8.&1!

61541&!)54!0.-')(($!1d3'*)L(1!)&-+'*1-*3&1!'5!L.*+!A.&8)(!)54!'5A.&8)(!*1&80T!!/54!.A!-.3&012!

*+'0!D.('*'-0!830*!L16'5!)*!+.812!A&.8!,'*+'5!*+1!.&6)5'<)*'.52!8.:1815*2!.&!.*+1&!(.-)*'.5!

A&.8!,+'-+!'*!'0!)**18D*'56!*.!-+)561!*+1!()&61&!&1)('*$T!!!

Q+'0!.A!-.3&01!L160!*+1!d310*'.5!H!-)5!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!.--3&!,'*+.3*!)!*&)50A.&8)*':1!

6.)(e!!F)5!'*2!A.&!'50*)5-12!L1!)DD('14!.&!3014!,'*+'5!)!8.&1!&1D&.43-*':1!-.5*1K*!H!03-+!)0!

&355'56!)!L30'51002!8)5)6'56!)!01&:'-1!RX;2!.&!)48'5'0*1&'56!)!830138e!!>541142!1:15!

,'*+'5!*+101!0118'56($!(100!&1:.(3*'.5)&$!)54!8.&1!0*)*'-!01**'5602!*+1!A18'5'0*!(1)41&!'0!0*'((!

*&)50A.&8'56!&.4"*3,1+!H!D1&+)D0!*+1!ND0$-+'-!0*&3-*3&1P!.A!0*)AA2!)0!*+1!/48'&)!*..(M'*!D3*0!

'*2!.&!*+1!,)$!0*)AA!D&.L(180!)&1!41)(*!,'*+2!.&!,+)*!'0!)5!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!'0031!)54!,+)*!'0!

5.*T!!#3*!A.&!8.0*!.A!30!'5!,.815]0!8.:1815*02!.3&!-.5-1&5!,'*+!L3'(4'56!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'D!'0!A.&!L&.)41&!0.-')(!*&)50A.&8)*'.5!*+)*!D3*0!61541&!)54!0.-')(!1d3)('*$!)*!*+1!

-15*1&!.A!*+1!8'00'.5T!!!

%'5-1!,1!0)'4!)*!*+1!.3*01*!*+)*!(1)41&0+'D!'0!)!81)502!5.*!)5!1542!D.('*'-0!)54!D3&D.01!'0!)!

-&'*'-)(!-.8D.515*T!!P$+,$-(.&/",$6$*1/%$')"%7()").$-$#1-$"4-&':")1").$"(7-#+2$"+',"$Q7&/"

/$1/*$")1"+-)&27*+)$").$&-"/1*&)&2("+',"/7-/1($"&'"2*$+-3"21'(2&17("9+5(!!!Q+'0!'0!,+1&1!

'5D3*0!.A!'5A.&8)*'.52!)5)($*'-)(!*..(02!-.5-1D*02!)54!'41)0!D()$!)!L'6!D)&*!H!,.815!

35A)8'(')&!,'*+!*+1!+38)5!&'6+*0!A&)81,.&M2!.&!,'*+!A18'5'0*!-.5-1D*0!('M1!D)*&')&-+$2!8)$!

)&*'-3()*1!*+1'&!D.('*'-0!:1&$!4'AA1&15*($!A&.8!*+.01!),)&1!.A!*+101!*&)50A.&8)*':1!'41)0llT!

KI/+',&':").$"-$/$-)1&-$"1#"/1((&4&*&)5"+',"&')$**$2)7+*".1-&N1'(3"$I/1(&':"/+-)&2&/+')(")1"

'$9"+'+*5)&2+*"#-+%$91-8(3"&'#1-%+)&1'"+',"8'19*$,:$")1"9.&2.").$5"%+5"'1)".+6$".+,"

+22$((3"&(").7("+'"$(($')&+*"21%/1'$')"1#"47&*,&':"%1-$")-+'(#1-%+)&6$"/1*&)&2("+',"

/7-/1($").-17:."*$+,$-(.&/",$6$*1/%$')!""=.$($")11*("+',"#-+%$91-8("2+'"+*(1"4$21%$"

)172.()1'$("#1-"()-+)$:&2",$2&(&1'C%+8&':"9.$'").$5"#+2$",&*$%%+("+',"2-&($(!!!!

\.('*'-0!)54!D3&D.01!)(0.!4'0*'563'0+10!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!A&.8!)((!.*+1&!A.&80!H!'5-(34'56!

A18'5'51!(1)41&0+'D2!,.815]0!(1)41&0+'D2!1*-T!H!,+1&1!*+1!(1)41&m0!8)$!L1!A18)(1!@.&!

8)(1E2!L3*!4.10!5.*!)4.D*!)!A18'5'0*!D.('*'-)(!)6154)U!'T1T2!)5!)6154)!*+)*!-(1)&($!D&':'(1610!

)54!-15*1&0!,.815]0!18D.,1&815*!)54!61541&!1d3)('*$!,'*+'5!'*0!0.-')(!*&)50A.&8)*'.5!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!lk!!O10L')52!L'01K3)(2!*&)5001K3)(!)54!'5*1&01K!!

ll!=+'-+!'0!,+$!*+101!'5D3*0!A.&8!)!-&'*'-)(!D)&*!.A!*+1!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!)DD&.)-+10!.A!.&6)5'<)*'.50!('M1!

F15*1&!A.&!=.815]0!X(.L)(!O1)41&0+'D2!FCG/2![30*!/00.-')*102!*+1!?.810*'-!=.&M1&0!/((')5-1!.A!*+1!_%/2!*+1!

7.&38!.A!=.815]0!RX;0!'5!F15*&)(!/0')2!XC;;Q%!>5*1&5)*'.5)(2!>5*1&5)*'.5)(!=.815]0!C'6+*0!/-*'.5!=)*-+!

@/0')!\)-'A'-E2!9/?CG2!=.815]0!O1)&5'56!\)&*51&0+'D2!)54!.*+1&!):.,14($!A18'5'0*!.&6)5'<)*'.50T!

Page 28: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! IS!

6.)(02!'5*1&5)(($!)54!1K*1&5)(($T!718'5'0*!D.('*'-0!H!,+1*+1&!'*!'0!5)814!.&!5.*!H!,'((!)5)($<1!

L.*+!*+1!0.-')(!.&41&!)54!*+1!D)&*'-3()&!-+)5610!'*!011M0!*+&.36+!)!61541&!)54!0.-')(!V30*'-1!

(1502!)54!,'((!)00381!*+)*!0.-')(!V30*'-1!@03-+!)0!()L.&!.&!()54!&'6+*0E!-)55.*!L1!)-+'1:14!

,'*+.3*!-15*1&'56!61541&!V30*'-1!,'*+'5!*+1!D&.-100T!

`Q! T:4<38<2!

/54!A'5)(($2!,1!-.81!*.!*+1!()&610*!4.8)'5!.A!(1)41&0+'D!H!*+1!*&)50)-*'.5)(2!(':142!d3.*'4')5!

&1)(8!.A!D&)-*'-1T!!Q+'0!'0!*+1!-.8D.515*!*+)*!-.50*'*3*10!*+1!()&610*!-+35M!.A!8.0*!

(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!)54!*&)'5'56!D&.6&)80T! !!/*!*+1!8.0*!D&'8)&$!(1:1(2!*&)50A.&8)*':1!

A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!'0!)L.3*!,)$0!.A!4.'56!)54!15)L('56!)!8$&')4!*+'5602!,+'-+!)&1!

-)*16.&'<14!)0!*+1!4'AA1&15*!*$D10!.A!N,.&MP!*+101!D&)-*'-10!A)((!'5*.U!!!

" Z898?585L!A?:PU!41:1(.D'56!)54!)&*'-3()*'56!)!*+1.&$!.A!-+)5612!-()&'A$'56!:'0'.5!)54!

.LV1-*':102!41*1&8'5'56!A.-30!@'0031!.&!01-*.&E!)54!)DD&.)-+2!1*-Tf!

" T?7838<47!A?:PU!)00100'56!D.('*'-)(!15:'&.5815*!)54!.DD.&*35'*'102!0.-')(!D.,1&!)5)($0'0!

.A!*+1!-.5*1K*!)54!'5*1&:15*'.5!)&1)2!)5*'-'D)*'56!D.('*'-)(!&1)-*'.502!L3'(4'56!)((')5-102!

1*-Tf!

" .3:432L8<!A?:PU!41:1(.D'56!)54!63'4'56!0*&)*16'102!8.5'*.&'56!'8D(1815*)*'.52!

1:)(3)*'56!'8D)-*2!)5)($<'56!6)'50!)54!01*L)-M02!&1:'0'56!4'&1-*'.5!)54!)DD&.)-+2!1*-Tf!

" 127438?59B8R!A?:PU!*+'0!'0!)!-&'*'-)(!-.8D.515*!.A!(1)41&0+'D!D&)-*'-12!)54!'5-(3410!

'543-*'56!)54!*&)'5'56!.*+1&02!8.L'('<'56!-.50*'*315*0!m!N*)&61*!6&.3D0P!m0*)M1+.(41&02!

8.*':)*'56!)54!030*)'5'56!151&6$!)54!8.&)(12!'8D)&*'56!)54!'8L'L'56!D)00'.5!)54!

-.88'*815*2!L3'(4'56!)((')5-10!)54!6..4,'((2!&10.(:'56!-.5A('-*0!)54!*150'.502!1*-Tf!!!

" #?JJ=58<438?5!A?:PU!,+'-+!'5-(3410!'5*1&5)(!)54!1K*1&5)(!-.8835'-)*'.5!0$0*1802!

-&1)*'56!-.8835'-)*'.5!0*&)*16'102!1503&'56!d3)('*$!-.5*15*2!0*&)*16'-!-.8835'-)*'.5!

,+15!&1d3'&14!@1T6T!301!.A!814')E2!301!.A!51,!*1-+5.(.6'10!*.!-&1)*1!1AA1-*':1!)54!

0*&)*16'-!1K*1&5)(!-.8835'-)*'.52!301!.A!*&)4'*'.5)(!*1-+5.(.6'10!@A.(M!*+1)*&12!0.562!

1*-TE!,+1&1!8.&1!)DD&.D&')*12!1*-T!

" 129?=:<85L!A?:PU!A'54'56!)54!030*)'5'56!A'5)5-')(!)54!.*+1&!&10.3&-10!@1KD1&*'012!

8)*1&')(02!'5A.&8)*'.52!'41)02!1*-TE!*+)*!)&1!-&'*'-)(!*.!*+1!*&)50A.&8)*'.5!D&.-100f!*+'0!

8)$!'5-(341!0.81!&1()*'.50+'D!L3'(4'56!,.&M!,'*+!4.5.&0!)54!03DD.&*1&02!)54!0M'((0!03-+!

)0!D&.D.0)(W,&'*'56!)54!L3'(4'56!51*,.&M0!.A!-.5*)-*0!*.!)--100!1KD1&*'012!'5A.&8)*'.52!

8)*1&')(02!*&)'51&02!1*-Tf!)54!

" ,454L2:847!A?:PU!0118'56($!+384&382!L3*!)!:1&$!-&'*'-)(!-.8D.515*!.A!(1)41&0+'D!

D&)-*'-12!'5-(34'56!418.-&)*'-2!*&)50D)&15*!)54!)--.35*)L(1!D.('-'10!)54!81-+)5'080!

A.&!'5*1&5)(!A35-*'.5'562!8)5)6'56!A'5)5-')(!)54!(16)(!.L('6)*'.50!)54!&1d3'&1815*02!

)((.-)*'56!+38)5!)54!A'5)5-')(!&10.3&-102!)34'*'56!-.&&1-*!3*'('<)*'.52!&1D.&*'56!*.!

1K*1&5)(!-.50*'*315-'10!)54!0*)M1+.(41&02!1*-T!1*-T!

>5!1K)8'5'56!-3&&15*!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!)DD&.)-+102!,1!+):1!*.!)00100!*+1!

&1()*':1!18D+)0'0!6':15!*.!&%/+-)&':"(8&**(!'5!*+1!)L.:1!)&1)02!:0T!).$"'1-%+)&6$"#-+%$91-8!

H!'T1T2!*&)50A.&8)*':1!D.,1&2!D.('*'-02!)54!D&'5-'D(10!H!*+)*!830*!3541&('1!*+.01!0M'((0T!!>5!

.*+1&!,.&402!,1!-)55.*!)DD&.)-+!0M'((WL3'(4'56!'5!)5!'50*&3815*)(!,)$2!.&!01D)&)*1!*+18!

A&.8!.3&!'41.(.6'-)(!D.0'*'.5T!!%M'((0!)&1!5.*!513*&)(2!D.&*)L(1!)L'('*'10!H!*+1$!)&1!0+)D14!L$!

:)(310!)54!D.('*'-0!H!)0!A.&!1K)8D(1!'5!*+1!,)$!&1()*'.50+'D0!)&1!8)5)6142!-.5A('-*0!)&1!

&10.(:142!.&!0)()&$!0-)(10!)54!V.L!410-&'D*'.50!)&1!A&)814T!R7-"*$+,$-(.&/",$6$*1/%$')"

%1,7*$("%7()").$-$#1-$"+,6+'2$"+'"+//-1+2.").+)",1$("'1)",&(21''$2)"/-+2)&2$("#-1%"

/19$-3"/1*&)&2(3"+',"6+*7$(!""

=+)*!'0!8.&12!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!*&)'5'56!830*!15)L(1!D&)-*'*'.51&0!*.!-.5:1&61!*+1!A.3&!

4'8150'.50!.A!(1)41&0+'D!'5!)5$!01**'56T!!Q.4)$2!83-+!.A!(1)41&0+'D!*&)'5'56!'0!A.-3014!.5!

*+1!D&)-*'-1!D'1-12!,'*+!('**(1!)**15*'.5!*.!1d3'DD'56!D&)-*'*'.51&0!,'*+!-.5-&1*1!,)$0!.A!

Page 29: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! Ii!

)&*'-3()*'56!)54!D&)-*'-'56!*+1!.*+1&!*+&11!4'8150'.50T!!Q+'0!(1)40!*.!A3&*+1&!'5*150'A$'56!

411D!0*&3-*3&102!)0!,1!+):1!0115T!;51!4'8150'.5!.A!*+'0!'0!*+1!A)'(3&12!'5!8)5$!(.-)*'.502!.A!

A18'5'0*!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!8.:1815*0!*.!01-3&1!*+1'&!A3*3&1!*+&.36+!03DD.&*'56!*+1!6&.,*+!

)54!)4:)5-1815*!.A!$.356!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0T!!

9)5$!(.56W10*)L('0+14!A18'5'0*!,.815]0!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!8.:1815*0!)&1!L16'55'56!*.!

N)61!.3*P!1'*+1&!L1-)301!*+1'&!(1)41&0+'D!+)0!A)'(14!*.!'5:10*!'5!41:1(.D'56!$.3561&!(1)41&02!

.&!L1-)301!*+1'&!-3(*3&1!)54!15:'&.5815*!)&1!35,'**'56($!35,1(-.8'56!*.!$.3561&!,.815T!

S&).17)"21'(2&17("+))$')&1'")1").$"9+5"/-+2)&2$("21'6$-:$"9&)."/19$-3"/1*&)&2("+',"

/-&'2&/*$(3"517':$-"#$%&'&()(")$',")1"4$"%+-:&'+*&N$,"1-"$6$'"17()$,"#-1%"/-12$(($("

4$2+7($").$5"2.+**$':$"$()+4*&(.$,"/-&1-&)&$(3"+'+*5($(3"+',"9+5("1#",1&':!!!%.81!

(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!'5'*')*':10!)&1!5.,!0D1-'A'-)(($!)44&100'56!*+'0!'0031lj2!L3*!830*!5.*!

&1D&.43-1!*+1!6)D0!*+)*!.(41&!(1)41&0+'D!D&.6&)80!-.5*)'514T!%1:1&)(!$.356!A18'5'0*!

'5'*')*':10!)&1!'5!)-*':1!4'0-300'.5!)L.3*!*+101!'003102!)54!+):1!)**18D*14!*.!-&1)*1!

63'41('510!A.&!8.&1!83(*'W6151&)*'.5)(!)DD&.)-+10!*+)*!)&1!,1((!,.&*+!'5*16&)*'56!,'*+'5!

.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!01**'560TlS!

%.81*'8102!*+'0!81)50!8.:'56!.3*!.A!.3&!.,5!0D)-10!)54!-.8A.&*!<.5102!6.'56!'5*.!*+1!

0D)-10!.A!*+1!,.815!,1!,'0+!*.!&1)-+!&)*+1&!*+)5!'5:'*'56!*+18!'5*.!.3&0T!!%)530+M)!

934)(')&!.A!/=>?!0D1)M0!.A!+1&!1KD1&'15-1!.A!,.&M'56!,'*+!$.356!%.3*+1)0*!/0')5!,.815!

'5!*+1!6)&815*!'5430*&$!'5!F)8L.4')T!=+15!)-*':'0*0!,15*!'5*.!*+1!A)-*.&'102!)54!'5*&.43-14!

-.5-1D*0!4'&1-*($!&1()*14!*.!*+1'&!,.&M2!*+1!,.815!,1&1!6)(:)5'<14T!>5!%)530+M)]0!,.&402!

N=+15!$.3!0+.,!*+18!,+1&1!$.3!,)5*!*.!6.2!5.*!V30*!,+)*!$.3&!:)(310!)&12!A18'5'08!'0!

1(1-*&'A$'56aPli!

7'6TI!-)D*3&10!*+1!'5*1&W-.551-*145100!.A!*+101!A.3&!1(1815*0!'5!)!N4')8.54P!*+)*!-)5!)(0.!

L1!*+1!L)0'0!.A!)5!)00100815*!A&)81,.&M!A.&!.3&!*&)'5'56!)DD&.)-+10T!!

-B2!1?72!?M!3B2!.27M!85!(24I2:9B8R!

=+15!1K)8'5'56!*+1!(1)41&0+'D!4')8.542!'*!'0!'8814')*1($!.L:'.30!*+)*!'*!0+.3(4!5.*!H!)54!

4.10!5.*!H!A(.)*!'5!*+1!)'&!('M1!)!M'*1!,'*+.3*!)!0*&'56T!!O1)41&0+'D!'0!D&)-*'-14!L$!D1.D(12!0.!

*+1!4')8.54!'0!)5-+.&14!,'*+'5!'54':'43)(02!,+1*+1&!*+1$!)&1!(1)4'56!)(.51!.&!*.61*+1&!,'*+!

.*+1&0T!!Q+1!4')8.542!*+1&1A.&12!'0!0+)D14!)54!*&)50A.&8142!'5!D&)-*'-12!L$!*+1!%GO7!H!*+1!

D)&*'-3()&!)**&'L3*102!*)(15*02!+'0*.&'102!1KD1&'15-102!)54!D0$-+'-!0*&3-*3&1!*+)*!1)-+!

'54':'43)(!L&'560!*.!*+1!(1)41&0+'D!&.(1T!!/54!,1!+):1!0115!*+)*!-1&*)'5!M'540!.A!('A1!

1KD1&'15-10!-)5!4)8)61!*+1!01(A!)*!411D!D0$-+'-!(1:1(0!*+)*!*+15!8)5'A10*!*+1801(:10!

516)*':1($!,+15!,1!6)'5!D.0'*'.50!.A!)3*+.&'*$!)54!D.,1&T!Q+1!8.&1!)--3&)*1!41D'-*'.5!.A!

*+1!4')8.542!*+1&1A.&12!'0!D&1015*14!'5!7'6Tb2!,+1&1!*+1!01(A!03&&.3540!.3&!'8D(1815*)*'.5!

.A!D.,1&2!D.('*'-02!D&'5-'D(102!)54!D&)-*'-10T!!

>&.5'-)(($2!'*!'0!A18'5'08!*+)*!A'&0*!)&*'-3()*14!*+1!'8D.&*)5-1!.A!*+1!01(A!'5!0.-')(!-+)5612!,'*+!

*+1!-.'5'56!.A!*+1!0(.6)5!NQ+1!D1&0.5)(!'0!D.('*'-)(PT!!/!6..4!41)(!.A!1)&('1&!&101)&-+!)54!

)5)($0'0!A.-3014!.5!*+1!N,.&MWA)8'($P!4':'412!)54!*+1!'8D.&*)5-1!.A!01(AW-)&12!01(A!

)AA'&8)*'.52!+1)('562!)54!(100!A&)6815*14!)DD&.)-+10!*.!.3&!-+)561!8'00'.5T!!#3*!.:1&!*+1!

41-)4102!*+)5M0!*.!)!+.0*!.A!D&1003&10!*+)*!-)55.*!L1!15381&)*14!+1&12!1:15!A18'5'0*0!+):1!

A.&6.**15!*+101!A354)815*)(0!)0!*+1$!0*&366(1!A.&!*+1!03&:':)(!.A!*+1'&!8.:1815*0!)54!

.&6)5'<)*'.50!'5!)5!'5-&1)0'56($!+.0*'(1!0.-')(2!D.('*'-)(!)54!A354'56!15:'&.5815*T!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!67 %112!A.&!'50*)5-12!*+1!FCG/!%.3*+!/0')!9.:1815*!#3'(4'56!)54!C'6+*0!>50*'*3*12!.&!*+1!FCG/W!/M'5)!9)8)!,)!

/A&'M)!718'5'0*!9.:1815*!#3'(4'56!)54!/4:.-)-$!>50*'*3*12!,,,T-&1),.&(4T.&6!!lS!%11!A.&!'50*)5-12!*+1!93(*'6151&)*'.5)(!Q..(M'*!D&.43-14!L$!*+1!^.356!718'5'0*!/-*':'08!'5'*')*':1!.A!/=>?!

@/00.-')*'.5!A.&!=.815B0!C'6+*0!'5!?1:1(.D815*E!D&'.&!*.!*+1!IJJS!/=>?!7.&38!'5!F)D1!Q.,5T!li!!GKD1&'15-1!0+)&14!L$!%)530+M)!)*!*+1!!

Page 30: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! bJ!

#3*!&1-15*!&101)&-+2!L$!A18'5'0*!-)D)-'*$!L3'(41&0!)54!.*+1&!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!41:1(.D815*!

1KD1&*02!+)0!&1W18D+)0'<14!*+1!-&'*'-)(!&.(1!.A!*+1!01(A!'5!L.*+!-.50*&3-*'56!)54!410*&.$'56!

*+1!L10*!1541):.&02!)54!*+1!'8D.&*)5-12!*+1&1A.&12!.A!)44&100'56!*+1!01(A!'5!(1)41&0+'D!

41:1(.D815*!,.&MjJ2j"T!!/54!)0!,1!+):1!0115!'5!1K)8'5'56!ND.,1&!3541&P2!*+1&1!'0!)(0.!)!

6&.,'56!),)&15100!*+)*!0.-')(!*&)50A.&8)*'.5!830*!'5-(3412!'A!5.*!L16'5!,'*+2!

*&)50A.&8)*'.5!)*!*+1!'54':'43)(!(1:1(TjI!Q+1!4)8)61!-)3014!L$!*+1!516(1-*!.A!*+'0!

4'8150'.52!)54!*+1!'8D.&*)5-1!.A!01(AW-)&1!)54!L)()5-12!,)0!)(0.!)!M1$!*+181!.A!4'0-300'.5!

)8.56!A18'5'0*!8.:1815*!)-*.&0!)*!*+1!IJJS!/=>?!7.&38!'5!F)D1!Q.,52!%.3*+!/A&'-)jbT!

08LQ!\/!-B2!.27M!45I!3B2!02J85893!(24I2:9B8R!*84J?5I!

!

=+'(1!*+1!01(A!-.8D&'010!)!,'41!&)561!.A!A)-*.&0!H!)54!0.81!*+)*!)&1!$1*!*.!L1!5)814!.&!

)5)($<14a!H!*+1!8.0*!'8D.&*)5*!A&.8!)!(1)41&0+'D!D1&0D1-*':1!)&1U!

" T2:9?54783D!45I!927M_29322J!H!D1.D(1!,'*+!(.,!01(AW10*118!*154!*.!L1!'501-3&12!)54!)&1!

8.&1!('M1($!*.!L1-.81!)3*+.&'*)&')5!'5!D.0'*'.50!.A!)3*+.&'*$2!*+&1)*1514!L$!*+1!

-.8D1*15-'10!.A!*+1'&!-.((1)6310!.&!03L.&4'5)*102!)54!(100!,'(('56!*.!0+)&1!D.,1&T!!Q+'0!

'0!.A*15!5.*!'5*15*'.5)(2!L3*!*+1!D()$'56!.3*!.A!03L-.50-'.30!0-&'D*02!L3*!-&1)*1!

15.&8.30!D&.L(180!'5!.&6)5'<)*'.50T!!Q+101!)&1!:1&$!411D!4'8150'.50!.A!*+1!01(A!*+)*!

5114!*.!L1!)44&10014!)54!*)-M(14!,'*+!0*&3-*3&14!03DD.&*T!!!

" ^893?:D!45I!2;R2:825<2!W!10D1-')(($!1KD1&'15-10!,'*+!D.,1&!@L.*+!D.0'*':1!)54!516)*':1E!

,+'-+!0+)D1!.3&!)**'*341!*.,)&40!'*2!)54!.A*15!.:1&&'41!.3&!'5*1((1-*3)(!3541&0*)54'56!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!jJ!!Z&'0*15!o'881&8)52!R11()8!\)*+'M.54)2!#&154)!%)(6)4.!)54!Q)V![)8102!IJ"J2!N;3*!.A!*+1!%D'&'*3)(!F(.01*!H!

;&6)5'<1&0!Q&)50A.&8'56!*+1!\&)-*'-1!.A!%.-')(![30*'-1P2!;)M()54!F/2!Q+1!9.:1815*!%*&)*16$!F15*1&!j"!9'-+1(!7&'148)5!)54!%+)8'8!911&!@G40E2!IJJj2!F+)561!'0!)!%(.,!?)5-12!,,,T61541&)*,.&MT.&6m(1)&5'56W

-15*1&!!jI!!9'-+)1(!FT!G4,)&40!)54!X'*)!%152!IJJJ2!NRX;02!%.-')(!F+)561!)54!*+1!Q&)50A.&8)*'.5!.A!Y38)5!

C1()*'.50+'D0U!/!I"0*!F15*3&$!F':'-!/6154)P2!/3,%$(S.%7$(\B#%*"%7;2!I"!@gEUlJkWl"l!

jb!%&'()*+)!#)*(',)()2!IJJi2!N718'5'08]0!F.8'56!.A!/61U!F1(1L&)*'56!?':1&0'*$!)54!\.,1&P2!'5!^"="7.64"1*2!kI!@IE!

Page 31: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! b"!

.A!'*f!+'0*.&$!)(0.!'5-(3410!*+1!,)$!.3&!1KD1&'15-10!'5!83(*'D(1!-.5*1K*0!6151&)*1!'50'6+*2!

D.('*'-)(!0)::$2!)54!0*&)*16'-!0M'((0f!!

" T2:9?547!9?<847!<4R8347!V!.3&!'54':'43)(!+'0*.&'10!)54!1KD1&'15-10!)(0.!6151&)*1!0.-')(!

-)D'*)(!W!D1&0.5)(!-.5*)-*02!-.551-*'.502!03DD.&*!0$0*1802!51*,.&M0!H!*+)*!)&1!D)&*!.A!

*+1!35'd31!&10.3&-10!,1!L&'56!*.!.3&!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!&.(12!)54!*+101!L1-.81!D)&*'-3()&($!

'8D.&*)5*!)001*0!'5!(1)41&0+'D!D.0'*'.50f!

" -472539@!4N8783829@!85<785438?59!V!*+101!)&1!D)&*!.A!*+1!35'd31!D)-M)61!*+)*!1:1&$!

'54':'43)(!L&'560!*.!(1)41&0+'D2!)54!*+1!0D1-')(!6'A*0!*+)*!*+1$!-)5!(1:1&)61!'5!(1)41&0+'D!

&.(10!@)!6..4!01501!.A!+38.&2!A.&!'50*)5-12!.&!0M'((14!)&*'-3()*'.5!H!*+1!N6'A*!.A!*+1!6)LP!H!

.&!)&*'0*'-!.&!830'-)(!0M'((Ef!)54!A'5)(($2!!

" HI25383829!V!*+1!83(*'()$1&14!'415*'*'10!L)014!.5!.3&!-()002!&)-12!61541&2!1*+5'-'*$2!-)0*12!

)L'('*$2!&1('6'.52!(.-)*'.52!01K3)(!.&'15*)*'.5!W!*+)*!'5!*3&5!0+)D14!.3&!+'0*.&'10!)54!

1KD1&'15-10!'5!D)&*'-3()&!,)$02!10D1-')(($!.A!D.,1&!W!03-+!)0!L1'56!)!&3&)(!?)('*!,.8)52!)!

01K!,.&M1&2!)!930('8!,.8)5!03&:':.&!.A!-.8835)(!-.5A('-*2!)!,.8)5!,'*+!)!4'0)L'('*$2!

1*-T!%'8'()&($2!-.8'56!A&.8!)!D.,1&A3(!0.-')(!-()00!.&!6&.3D!)(0.!0+)D10!.3&!01501!.A!

D&':'(161!)54!*+1!D.,1&!,1!'5:'0'L($!,'1(4!'5!)5!.&6)5'<)*'.52!&16)&4(100!.A!A.&8)(!

D.0'*'.5!'5!*+1!+'1&)&-+$T!=1!L&'56!*+101!'415*'*'10!'5*.!(1)41&0+'D!&.(10!'5!L.*+!03L*(1!

)54!.:1&*!,)$02!)54!*+1$!0.81*'810!41*1&8'51!+.,!,1!&10D.54!*.!4'AA1&15*!M'540!.A!

(1)41&0+'D!-+)((15610T!

C1-.65'<'56!*+1!D.,1&A3(!&.(1!.A!*+1!01(A!'0!-&'*'-)(!'5!*+1!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!-.5*1K*!L1-)301!

,.815]0!D0$-+'-!0*&3-*3&10!+):1!L115!-.50*&3-*14!5.*!.5($!*+&.36+!*+1!303)(!'50*'*3*'.502!

0.-')('<)*'.5!D&.-10010!)54!1KD1&'15-10!@('M1!A)8'($2!0-+..(2!D11&02!1*-TE2!L3*!*+&.36+!*+1!

D)&*'-3()&!5)*3&1!.A!*+1!D)*&')&-+)(!0*&3-*3&10!'5!,+'-+!*+1$!+):1!(':14!)54!*+1!.DD&100'.50!

*+1$!+):1!-.501d315*($!516.*')*14T!!%.!A.&!'50*)5-12!,.815!)&1!.A*15!(100!-.8A.&*)L(1!,'*+!

+.(4'56!.:1&*!D.,1&2!)54!8.&1!-.8A.&*)L(1!1K1&-'0'56!'*!'54'&1-*($2!.&!,'*+!-+)((156'56!.&!

03L:1&*'56!'*!@D.,1&!3541&E!)0!*+1$!+):1!4.51!'5!8.0*!.*+1&!(.-)*'.50!@03-+!)0!,'*+'5!*+1!

A)8'($!.&!8)&&')61ET!!Q+'0!(1)40!*.!:1&$!0D1-'A'-!4'0*.&*'.50!*+)*!5114!*.!L1!03&A)-142!)54!

,.815!.A*15!5114!)44'*'.5)(!*..(0!*.!)44&100!*+1'&!'5*1&5)('<14!H!)54!.A*15!35&1-.65'<14!H!

4'(188)0!,'*+!*+1!M'54!.A!.:1&*!)3*+.&'*$2!&10D.50'L'('*$!)54!)--.35*)L'('*$!*+)*!(1)41&0+'D!

&.(10!L&'56T!!!

;5!*+1!.*+1&!+)542!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!A&.8!)!A18'5'0*!D1&0D1-*':1!+)0!)(0.!L115!

1K*&181($!*&)50A.&8)*':1!A.&!'54':'43)(02!15)L('56!411DW01)*14!-+)5610!'5!*+1!01(A!*+)*!+):1!

&103(*14!5.*!.5($!'5!)!01501!.A!01(AW),)&151002!18D.,1&815*!)54!('L1&)*'.52!L3*!'5!51,!

,)$0!.A!)-*'56!A.&!-+)561!'5!*+1!1K*1&5)(!,.&(4T!!>5!FCG/]0!.,5!1KD1&'15-12!A.&!'50*)5-12!

,.815!3541&6.'56!*+101!D1&0.5)(!*&)50A.&8)*'.50!43&'56!*&)'5'56!,.&M0+.D0!+):1!6.51!.5!

*.!-+)((1561!:'.(15-12!A134)(!.DD&100'.52!)54!&1('6'.30!A354)815*)('08!'5!*+1'&!.,5!A)8'('102!

-.8835'*'10!)54!:'(()610T!!718'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!D&.6&)80!830*!*+1&1A.&1!

'5*16&)*1!81-+)5'080!A.&!15)L('56!D)&*'-'D)5*0!*.!)5)($<1!*+1'&!D0$-+'-!0*&3-*3&1!H!*+1!%GO7!

H!'5!)!0)A1!0D)-12!,'*+!1KD1&*!03DD.&*2!)54!D&.:'41!(.561&W*1&8!03DD.&*!0$0*180!*.!5.*!.5($!

41)(!,'*+!)54!.:1&-.81!*+1!516)*':1!L)66)61!,'*+'5!*+1!01(A2!L3*!)(0.!*.!35(1)0+!*+1!

D&.A.354($!*&)50A.&8)*':1!D.*15*')(!*+)*!('10!,'*+'5!'*T!!

Q+'0!L&'560!30!*.!*+1!154!.A!*+1!4'0-300'.5!.A!N=+)*!'0!'*eP2!)54!(1)40!30!*.!)44&100!*+1!

&18)'5'56!*,.!A)-1*0!.A!41-.50*&3-*'56!)L0*&)-*!-.5-1D*0!('M1!(1)41&0+'DT!

Page 32: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! bI!

>>>T! 'B2:2!89!83K!.8329!?M!02J85893!(24I2:9B8R!

9)5$!)8.&D+.302!+)&4W*.WD'5W4.,5!-.5-1D*0!-)5!L1!6&)0D14!D)&*($!L$!(.-)*'56!*+18!,'*+'5!

0D1-'A'-!0'*10!'5!,+'-+!*+1$!.--3&T!!>5!*+1!-)01!.A!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D2!*+1&1!)&1!)0!8)5$!

(.-)*'.50!)0!*+1&1!)&1!D.,1&!0*&3-*3&10!)54!'50*'*3*'.50!*+)*!03L.&4'5)*1!,.815U!

! -B2!M4J87D@!<745@!<4932@!3:8N2!?:!<?JJ=583D!H!*+101!)&1!D&'8)&$!0'*10!,+1&1!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'D!A.&!*&)50A.&8)*'.5!'0!D&)-*'-142!10D1-')(($!L$!A18'5'0*0!)54!*+1'&!

6&)00&..*0!8.:1815*02!011M'56!1d3)('*$!)54!*&)50A.&8)*'.5!'5!*+101!-&'*'-)(!

'50*'*3*'.50!,+1&1!*+1!8)V.&'*$!.A!,.815!830*!516.*')*1!*+1'&!(':10!)54!*+1'&!&'6+*0T!!!

!

! -B2!93432!)54!'*0!:)&'.30!)&80!H!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!)54!8.:1815*0!+):1!

*&)4'*'.5)(($!*)&61*14!*+1!0*)*12!&16'8102!)54!D3L('-!D.('-'10!)0!M1$!0'*10!*+)*!-)5!

1'*+1&!15)L(1!.&!4'0)L(1!*+1'&!18D.,1&815*T!!O16)(!0$0*180!+):1!L115!D)&*'-3()&!

*)&61*02!0'5-1!*+1$!150+&'51!*+1!0.-')(($!D&1:)(15*!0$0*180!.A!61541&!'51d3)('*$!)54!

4'0-&'8'5)*'.5T!!#3*!6.:1&5815*!D.('-'102!)54!*+1!-&1)*'.5!.A!15)L('56!81-+)5'080!

('M1!61541&!L3461*0!)54!5)*'.5)(!,.815]0!-.88'00'.502!+):1!)(0.!L115!*+1!*)&61*0!

.A!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!)54!)-*':'08T!!!

!

! -B2!J4:P23!45I!R:8>432!92<3?:!V!*+'0!'0!)!0'*1!,+1&1!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!+)0!6)'514!)!

0'65'A'-)5*!A..*+.(42!*+.36+!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!D&'5-'D(10!)54!D&)-*'-10!+):1!)(0.!

L115!'50*&3815*)('<14!*.!)4:)5-1!-.&D.&)*1!)54!8)&M1*!6.)(0jgT!F.&D.&)*'.50!)54!

8)5)61815*!0-+..(0!+):1!1)61&($!-.W.D*14!8)5$!(1)41&0+'D!D&)-*'-10!.A!,.8152!

A18'5'0*!)54!.*+1&2!)54!)DD('14!*+18!*.!15+)5-1!D&.43-*':'*$!)54!8.*':)*'.5T!!!

!

! #8>87!9?<823D@!A?J25O9!J?>2J2539!45I!?3B2:!9?<847!J?>2J2539!V!*+'0!'0!)!8.&1!

A)8'(')&!0'*1!,+1&1!,1!+):1!0115!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!*&)50)-*14T!=+'(1!8)5$!-':'(!

0.-'1*$!.&6)5'<)*'.50!H!10D1-')(($!*+.01!(14!L$!815!)54!5.5WA18'5'0*!,.815!H!+):1!

)**18D*14!*.!'5-.&D.&)*1!1(1815*0!.A!*+1!A18'5'51!(1)41&0+'D!N0*$(1P2!!*+101!)&1!

.A*15!-.081*'-!.&!03D1&A'-')(!'5!5)*3&1T!;5!*+1!.*+1&!+)542!61541&W0150'*':1!8)(1!

(1)41&0!-)5!0.81*'810!D&)-*'-1!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!D&'5-'D(10!8.&1!)3*+15*'-)(($!

)54!1AA1-*':1($!*+)5!5.5WA18'5'0*!,.815!(1)41&02!.&!1:15!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0!,+.!+):1!

5.*!L115!)L(1!*.!41)(!+.510*($!,'*+!*+1'&!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!411D!0*&3-*3&10!.&!D&.L(180!

,'*+!+)54('56!D.,1&!'5!8.&1!*&)50D)&15*!)54!)--.35*)L(1!,)$0T!!Q+1!8.0*!

'5*1&10*'56!-':'(!0.-'1*$!0'*102!+.,1:1&2!)&1!*+.01!,+1&1!-.50-'.30($!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0!

1KD1&'815*!,'*+!-&1)*'56!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!0*&3-*3&10!)54!0$0*180!*+)*!!'5*15*'.5)(($!

L&'56!)!*&)50A.&8)*':1!-+)&)-*1&!*.!*+1'&!D.,1&2!D.('*'-02!D&'5-'D(10!)54!D&)-*'-1T!!!

!

! #=73=:47!45I!:278L8?=9!859383=38?59/!A.&!8)5$!A18'5'0*!(1)41&02!*+101!)&1!-&'*'-)(!0'*10!

.A!156)61815*!)54!*&)50A.&8)*'.5T!!>54'615.30!,.815!'5!O)*'5!/81&'-)2!C.8)!

,.815!'5!G)0*!G3&.D12!A18'5'0*!F+&'0*')5!,.8152!)54!1:15!Y>`m/>?%!)-*':'0*0!'5!

/A&'-)2!+):1!-.5A&.5*14!*+1!61541&!4'0-&'8'5)*'.5!18L14414!'5!-3(*3&)(!)54!

&1('6'.30!5.&802!)54!-+)((15614!*+1!&1W-.50*&3-*'.5!.A!*&)4'*'.5!)54!&1('6'.30!5.&80!

*.!15A.&-1!8)(1!D&':'(161T!!91K'-)5!'54'615.30!,.8152!A.&!'50*)5-12!+):1!'50'0*14!

*+)*!.DD&100':1!1(1815*0!.A!D&1W-.(.5')(!'54'615.30!-3(*3&1!L1!)-M5.,(14614!)54!

4'0-)&414!'5!*+1!()&61&!@)54!8)(1W(14E!'54'615.30!D1.D(1]0!8.:1815*0jkf!0'8'()&($2!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!74 ^:.551!?31!#'(('56!h!9)*0!/(:100.52!Np310*'.5'56!*+1!R.*'.5!.A!718'5'51!O1)41&0+'DU!/!F&'*'-)(!\1&0D1-*':1!.5!

*+1!X1541&!O)L1(('56!.A!O1)41&0+'DP2!'5!X1541&2!=.&M!h!;&6)5'<)*'.52!`.(381!j!>0031!b2!\)610!"gg!H!"kjT!?1-!

IJJIT!

75 9)&30')!O.D1<2!NO)0!83V1&10!15!1(!8.:'8'15*.!'54'615)!41!91K'-.U!R31:)0!C3*)0!D)&)!Q&)50A.&8)&!1(!\.41&P!

@=.815!'5!*+1!>54'615.30!\1.D(1]0!9.:1815*0!.A!91K'-.U!R1,!\)*+0!A.&!Q&)50A.&8'56!\.,1&E2!-)01!0*34$!

Page 33: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! bb!

C.8)!,.815!)&1!418)54'56!*+)*!.DD&100'.50!)&'0'56!A&.8!D)*&')&-+$!L1!01D)&)*14!

A&.8!.*+1&!-3(*3&)(!1KD&100'.50!'5!)&*'-3()*'.50!.A!NC.8)!F3(*3&1TPjl!

/((!*+101!)&1!M1$!0'*10!.A!(1)&5'56!A.&!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!D&.6&)80T!

%D1-'A'-)(($2!*+1$!-+)((1561!30!*.!+1(D!D&)-*'*'.51&0!35&):1(!*+1!D)&*'-3()&!,)$0!'5!,+'-+!1)-+!

0'*1!&1)-*0!*.!A18'5'0*!D.,1&2!D.('*'-02!D&'5-'D(10!)54!D&)-*'-12!)54!1d3'D!*+18!,'*+!)5)($*'-)(!

)54!D&)-*'-)(!*..(0!A.&!)3*+15*'-!)54!*&)50A.&8)*':1!156)61815*0!'5!1)-+!(.-)*'.5T!

!

!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

D&1D)&14!A.&!/=>?!@/00.-')*'.5!A.&!=.815B0!C'6+*0!'5!?1:1(.D815*E2!?1-18L1&!IJJj2!):)'()L(1!0..5!)*!

,,,T),'4T.&6!T!76 C'*)!><0)M2!NQ+1!G3&.D1)5!C.8)5'!=.815]0!9.:1815*U!>5*1&5)*'.5)(!C.8)!=.815]0!R1*,.&MP2!-)01!0*34$!

D&1D)&14!A.&!/=>?2!;-*.L1&!IJJj2!):)'()L(1!0..5!)*!,,,T),'4T.&6!!

Page 34: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! bg!

HZQ! 'B43!I?29!83!7??P!78P2K!02J85893!'4D9!?M!(24I85L!

Q+1&1!)&1!01:1&)(!'((30*&)*'.50!.A!,+)*!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!(..M0!('M1!'5!D&)-*'-12!)54!*+101!

)&1!,.&*+!1K)8'5'56!*.!6&.354!.3&!4'0-300'.5T!!;51!01*!.A!D&'5-'D(10W'5W)-*'.5!)54!

(1)41&0+'D!D&)-*'-10!181&614!.3*!.A!)!0*34$!.A!*,15*$!,.815!(1)41&0!A&.8!)&.354!*+1!

,.&(42!0.81!.D15($!A18'5'0*2!0.81!5.*2!L3*!)((!)-*'56!A.&!61541&!1d3)('*$2!)54!D&)-*'-'56!

,+)*!,1!,.3(4!410-&'L12!'5!*1&80!.A!*+1!41A'5'*'.50!.AA1&14!1)&('1&!'5!*+'0!D)D1&2!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'DjjT!/A*1&!'5W41D*+!'5*1&:'1,02!*+1!0*34$!(.-)*14!*+1!A.((.,'56!-.88.5!1(1815*0!'5!

*+1!,)$!*+101!,.815!*&)50)-*14!*+1'&!(1)41&0+'DU!

! Q+1$!-&1)*1!)54!030*)'5!0.-')(!-+)561!0*&)*16'10!*+)*!D()-1!2.+':$("&'":$',$-"/19$-"

-$*+)&1'("+)").$"2$')$-"H(Q+1$!011!61541&!V30*'-1!)54!0.-')(!V30*'-1!)0!'5*1&-.551-*14!

-+)56102!)54!A1(*!*+)*!8)(1!0.-')(!V30*'-1!(1)41&0!4.!5.*!)(,)$0!011!61541&!V30*'-1!)0!

'5*16&)(!*.!*+1'&!)6154)T!

!

! Q+1$!)&1!5.*!4'AA1&15*!V30*!L1-)301!*+1$!)&1!,.815!(1)41&02!L3*!L1-)301!*+1$!)&1!

,.815!(1)4'56!,'*+!)!)-+'(#1-%+)&6$"+:$',+!*+)*!-.551-*0!61541&!D.,1&!*.!0.-')(!

-+)561T!!

!

! 718'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!&1d3'&10!'5-&14'L(1!+:&*&)5"+',"-$(&*&$'2$!L1-)301!1)-+!0*1D!

A.&,)&4!-&1)*10!51,!)54!0.81*'810!6&):1&!-+)((15610!.&!L)-M()0+T!Q+'0!8)M10!

A18'5'0*!(1)41&0!0*&.561&!)54!08)&*1&!0*&)*16'0*0!)54!516.*')*.&0T!

!

! Q+1!8'00'.5!.A!61541&!1d3)('*$!)54!0.-')(!V30*'-1!'0!'5A3014!'5*.!$6$-5"T143"$6$-5"

+2)&6&)5"+',"$6$-5"*12+)&1'!@&355'56!)!V.3&5)(2!)5!RX;2!)5!)-)418'-!*1)-+'56!

D&.6&)82!)!6&)00&..*0!D&.6&)8ET!!

!

! Q+1!8)'50*&1)8!4.10!5.*!&1,)&4!)54!8)$!1:15!/$'+*&N$"#$%&'&()"*$+,$-(.&/!H!

D&1003&10!-.81!A&.8!A)8'($2!-.8835'*$2!-+3&-+2!D)&*$2!6.:1&5815*2!.&!.51]0!.,5!

.&6)5'<)*'.5T!%.!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!&1d3'&10!&'0MW*)M'56T!

!

! 718'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!81)50!*+1!+4&*&)5")1"&'#*7$'2$"+:$',+("$6$'"9&).17)").$""

#1-%+*"/19$-"1-"+7).1-&)5")1",1"(12!)54!*+1!!-)D)-'*$!*.!(1:1&)61!()&61&W0-)(1!

-+)5610!@'5!D.('-$2!(16)(!&'6+*02!0.-')(!)**'*34102!)54!D.,1&!&1()*'.50E!,'*+!:1&$!

8)&6'5)(!&10.3&-10T!!!

!

! 9)5$!.A!*+1!(1)41&0!'5!*+1!0*34$!4'4!5.*!011!*+1801(:10!)0!(1)41&0!'5!)5!

'54':'43)('0*'-!015012!L3*!)0!/$1/*$"+)").$"6+':7+-,".A!L&.)41&!D&.-10010!.A!-+)561T!

!

! U$%&'&()"*$+,$-("+-$"1#)$'"7'21%#1-)+4*$"9&).").$&-"/19$-T!!O1)41&0+'D!+)4!)!

516)*':1!-.55.*)*'.5!A.&!8)5$!.A!*+182!)54!,1&1!35-.8A.&*)L(1!L1'56!

-+)&)-*1&'<14!)0!(1)41&0T!/0!.51!(1)41&!0)'42!NO1)41&0+'D!'0!)!-.54'*'.5!*+)*!.*+1&0!

)**&'L3*1!*.!$.32!5.*!$.3!*.!$.3&01(ATP!!

!

! 718'5'0*!(1)41&0!18D+)0'<1!*+1!6+*7$"1#"21**$2)&6$"+',"%7*)&C*+5$-$,"*$+,$-(.&/2!

*+1!0+)&'56!.A!D.,1&!)54!&10D.50'L'('*$2!)54!6151&)(($!&1V1-*!*+1!8)(1!)54!

N=10*1&5P!N(.51!&)561&P!8.41(!.A!'54':'43)(!(1)41&0+'DT!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!77 %&'()*+)!#)*(',)()!)54!/&35)!C).2!=.8152!O1)41&0+'D!)54!%.-')(!F+)561!H!C1D.&*!.A!)!%.354'56!%*34$!

-.543-*14!A.&!*+1!7.&4!7.354)*'.5!@35D3L('0+14E2![3($2!IJJI2!DT""!W!"S!

Page 35: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! bk!

! F.501d315*($2!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!'0!'1)"+"1'$C9+5"1-")1/C,19'"/-12$((2!L3*!(1)40!

*+&.36+!-.503(*)*'.52!D)&*'-'D)*'.5!)54!-.5015030WL3'(4'56T!!Q+101!(1)41&0!4.!5.*!

D&1)-+!D)&*'-'D)*'.5!)54!&10D.50':15100!*.!*+1'&!-.50*'*315-'10!)0!83-+!)0!*+1$!

D&)-*'-1!'*T!Q+'0!)DD&.)-+2!*+1$!A1(*2!'0!L.*+!)!,1)M5100!)54!)!0*&156*+T!>*!'0!0(.,1&!H!

(1)4'56!*.!0+.&*1&W*1&8!(.0010!W!L3*!411D1&2!(1)4'56!*.!(.561&W*1&8!6)'50T!

!

! 7.&!A18'5'0*!(1)41&02!6..4!(1)41&0+'D!'0!)L.3*!-$*+)&1'(.&/C47&*,&':!W!,'*+'5!*+1'&!

.&6)5'<)*'.502!,'*+!*+1'&!-.50*'*315-'102!)54!,'*+!L.*+!)(('10!)54!.DD.515*0T!!Q+1$!

'5:10*!*'81!)54!151&6$!'5!L3'(4'56!)!L&.)4!&)561!.A!&1()*'.50+'D02!)54!011!5.!0+.&*W

-3*!*.!*+'0T!!

!

! Q+1$!L&'56!L).$"#$%&'&'$"7'&6$-($M!'5*.!*+1'&!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!D&)-*'-1!H!)!&10.3&-1!

*+)*!8)(1!(1)41&0!()-M!.&!)&1!)A&)'4!*.!301!'5!*+1'&!,.&MD()-1T!!Q+1$!301!,.815]0!

*&)4'*'.5)(!53&*3&'56!&.(10!)54!&1()*'.50+'D!0M'((0!'5!*+1'&!(1)41&0+'D!D&)-*'-1T!

!

! Q+1$!)&1!-.5-1&514!,'*+!*+1!$%/19$-%$')"+',")-+'(#1-%+)&1'"1#"%$'!H!

D)&*'-3()&($!A&.8!.DD&10014!)54!1K-(3414!6&.3D0!H!)0!,1((!)0!,.815T!!Q+1$!,.&M!A.&!

61541&!)54!0.-')(!1d3)('*$2!5.*!V30*!,.815]0!18D.,1&815*!T!

!

! 718'5'0*0!)&1!&')-1(/$2)&6$"+',"2-&)&2+*"+417)").$&-"19'"*$+,$-(.&/!)54!*+1!A)'('560!

.&!0+.&*-.8'560!.A!*+1'&!.,5!8.:1815*0!)54!.&6)5'<)*'.50T!718'5'0*!(1)41&0!

18D+)0'<1!*+1!'8D.&*)5-1!.A!-.50*)5*!01(AW1K)8'5)*'.5!,'*+!&16)&4!*.!D.,1&!)54!'*0!

1AA1-*0T!!Q+1$!)-M5.,(1461!*+1!-.&&3D*'56!D.00'L'('*'10!.A!D.,1&2!10D1-')(($!A.&8)(!

D.,1&!H!16.*'082!)&&.6)5-12!)3*+.&'*)&')5'082!01(A'0+5100!W!)54!-&1)*1!81-+)5'080!

*.!-+1-M!*+1'&!.,5!301!)54!)L301!.A!D.,1&T!!

!

! Q+1$!-&1)*1!&''16+)&6$"1-:+'&N+)&1'+*"()-72)7-$("+',":16$-'+'2$"/-+2)&2$(!*.!L&'56!

*+1'&!*&)50A.&8)*':1!)6154)0!'5*.!*+1'&!.,5!.&6)5'<)*'.50T!!7.&!'50*)5-12!Q+1$!-&1)*1!

0D)-10!)54!.DD.&*35'*'10!A.&!.*+1&!(1)41&0!*.!181&61!H!1T6T!6':'56!!$.3561&!0*)AA!&1)(!

.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!D.,1&!H!L1-)301!*+1$!L1('1:1!!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!830*!15)L(1!*+1!

181&615-1!)54!6&.,*+!.A!.*+1&!(1)41&02!&)*+1&!*+)5!+.(4'56!.5!*.!D.,1&!)54!

-.5*&.(T!!

?/=R!;5*)&'.!.AA1&0!*+101!'50'6+*0!)L.3*!*+1!0*&366(10!'5!*+1!D&)-*'-1!.A!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!

D&'5-'D(102!*.!D&.:'41!)5!'8)61!.A!+.,!*+'560!-)5!(..M!,+15!*+101!0*&366(10!)&1!03--100A3(2!

)54!51)*($!0388'56!3D!*+1!'8D(1815*)*'.5!.A!*+1!A18'5'0*!:)(310!)54!D&'5-'D(10!,1!

.3*('514!1)&('1&U!

=1!8)$!1KD1-*!*+)*!A18'5'0*!6&.3D0!,'((!L1!D&.L(18WA&112!.&!*+)*!,1!,'((!-&1)*1!

'5-(30':1!15:'&.5815*0!L$!:'&*31!.A!.3&!-.((1-*':1!,.&MT!/0!,.8152!,1!830*!

)-M5.,(1461!*+)*!,1!-.81!A&.8!4'AA1&15*!1KD1&'15-10!.A!(1)41&0+'D2!)54!*+)*!.3&!

D&)-*'-10!)&1!'5A.&814!L$!*&)4'*'.5)(2!+'1&)&-+'-)(!0*&3-*3&10T!%.81*'810!,1!&1D1)*!

*+1!:1&$!D&)-*'-10!,1!4'0('M12!1:15!,+15!,1!)&1!*&$'56!*.!4.!*+'560!4'AA1&15*($T!=1!

8)$!15-.35*1&!.*+1&!-+)((156102!'5-(34'56!,.815!,+.!L&'56!410*&3-*':1!L1+):'.&0!

0*188'56!A&.8!'00310!.&!)!()-M!.A!D.,1&!,'*+'5!.3&!D1&0.5)(!(':10!'5*.!.3&!

.&6)5'<)*'.50T!/0!A18'5'0*02!cT!=1!5114!*.!1K)8'51!*+1!0*&3-*3&10!,1!+):1!-.81!

A&.82!)54!-.50'41&!+.,!.3&!1KD1&'15-1!'5A.&80!.3&!-3&&15*!D&)-*'-10T!

='*+'5!1d3)('*$W011M'56!.&6)5'<)*'.502!,1!8)$!1KD1-*!*+)*!.3&!A18'5'0*!818L1&0!

,'((!5.*!0*&366(1!,'*+!'00310!.A!D.,1&T!O1)41&0!5114!*.!L1!),)&1!*+)*!D.,1&!

4$5)8'-0!+)DD15!'5!)5$!.&6)5'<)*'.52!)54!*+)*!0.81!,.815!)&1!03DD.&*':1!,+'(1!

.*+1&0!)&1!8.&1!-.8A.&*)L(1!,'*+!-.5A('-*T!7.&!1K)8D(12!)!,.8)5!8)$!6)'5!D.,1&!

Page 36: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! bl!

*+&.36+!8)5'D3()*'.52!-()'8'56!4'018D.,1&815*!,+15!0+1!-)55.*!+):1!*+'560!+1&!

,)$T!=1!8)$!L1-.81!0.!)A&)'4!.A!-.5A('-*!*+)*!,1!0*.D!-+)((156'562!)((.,'56!

'54':'43)(!,.815!*.!*)M1!D.,1&!),)$!A&.8!.3&!.&6)5'<)*'.5T!Q+'0!4.10!5.*!01&:1!

.3&!-.((1-*':1!'5*1&10*2!)0!.3&!,.&M!*.,)&4!1d3)('*$!)54!'5-(30'.5!L1-.810!(.0*!

,'*+'5!.3&!.,5!D&)-*'-10T!=1!8)$!A11(!35-.8A.&*)L(1!,'*+!D.,1&!0*&366(102!L3*!,1!

)&1!8.&1!)*!&'0M!,+15!,1!4.!5.*!-+)((1561!1K-(30'.5)&$!.&!410*&3-*':1!L1+):'.&0T!

718'5'0*!(1)41&0!-+)((1561!410*&3-*':1!D)**1&50!*+)*!181&612!,+'(1!-.5*'53.30($!

4&),'56!.5!*+1!0M'((0!)54!*)(15*0!.A!,.815!'5!.3&!6&.3DT!

O1)41&0!.A!A18'5'0*!1d3)('*$W011M'56!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)&1!)--.35*)L(1!5.*!.5($!*.!.3&!

818L1&0!)54!01&:'-1!301&02!L3*!*.!*+1!6(.L)(!8.:1815*!A.&!D1)-12!1d3)('*$!)54!

V30*'-1T!=1!*$D'-)(($!1KD1-*!.3&!(1)41&0!*.!1503&1!*+)*!.3&!.&6)5'<)*'.5]0!A'5)5-10!

)&1!'5!6..4!.&41&2!D&.V1-*0!)&1!.5!*&)-M2!)54!D3L('-!&1()*'.50!)&1!1AA1-*':1T!718'5'0*!

(1)41&0!)&1!)(0.!&10D.50'L(1!A.&!1503&'56!*+)*!*+1!D1&0D1-*':1!)54!)5)($0'0!.A!.3&!

1d3)('*$W011M'56!.&6)5'<)*'.5!'0!L&.36+*!*.!*+1!()&61&!A18'5'0*!-.8835'*$T!=.815!

'5!(1)41&0+'D!&.(10!5114!*.!*)M1!1:1&$!.DD.&*35'*$!*.!L3'(4!('5M0!,'*+!.*+1&!,.815!

)54!,.815]0!.&6)5'<)*'.50!*+)*!0+)&1!.3&!)6154)!A.&!1d3)('*$!)54!'5-(30'.5T!=1!

5114!*.!-.50'41&!+.,!,1!)&1!)--.35*)L(1!*.!.3&!6&.3D!)54!-.8835'*$2!)54!'A!.3&!

01&:'-1!)54!)4:.-)-$!,.&M!'0!1AA1-*':1!.&!)DD&.D&')*1!*.!*+1!51140!.A!,.815T!/0!

A18'5'0*02!,1!830*!)(,)$0!&18'54!.3&01(:10!.A!*+1!()&61&!&1)0.50!,+$!,1!)&1!4&),5!

*.!1d3)('*$W011M'56!,.&M2!)54!.A!.3&!410'&1!*.!*&)50A.&8!.3&!.&6)5'<)*'.50!)54!

-.8835'*'10!'5*.!0)A12!1d3'*)L(12!)54!'5-(30':1!D()-10!A.&!)((!,.815T!

cTT!='*+'5!*+1!A18'5'0*!D&)-*'-1!.A!(1)41&0+'D2!(1)41&0!)&1!818L1&0!.A!)!*1)8!.A!

,.815!,.&M'56!*.,)&4!)!-.88.5!6.)(!.A!1d3)('*$!)54!'5-(30'.5T!G)-+!,.8)5!.5!

*+1!*1)8!+)0!)!35'd31!0M'((!.&!)L'('*$!*+)*!'0!:)(3)L(1!*.!.3&!-.88.5!1AA.&*0T!Q+'0!

4.10!5.*!81)5!*+)*!.3&!&.(10!)54!&10D.50'L'('*'10!)&1!'415*'-)(2!L3*!*+)*!.3&!

-.5*&'L3*'.50!)54!D)&*'-'D)*'.5!)&1!1d3)(($!:)(314T!=+1*+1&!)!,.8)5!-+)'&0!)!

811*'562!.&!D&1D)&10!*+1!A..4!A.&!)!811*'562!+1&!-.5*&'L3*'.5!'0!'8D.&*)5*!'5!

)4:)5-'56!.3&!1d3)('*$W011M'56!,.&MT!cTT!

!918L1&0!.A!1d3)('*$W011M'56!.&6)5'<)*'.50!-+..01!.3&!(1)41&0T!/0!,'(('56!A.((.,1&0!

)54!03DD.&*1&02!,1!'5:10*!D.,1&!'5!.3&!(1)41&0T!=1!15*&30*!*+1$!,'((!0+)&1!*+1'&!

0M'((0!)54!)L'('*'10!,'*+!.3&!6&.3D!)54!D&.:'41!.DD.&*35'*'10!*.!41:1(.D!.*+1&!

,.815]0!(1)41&0+'D!D.*15*')(T!7.&!1K)8D(12!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0!-&1)*1!.DD.&*35'*'10!

A.&!81)5'56A3(!4'0-300'.50!,+1&1!1:1&$!,.8)5]0!D)&*'-'D)*'.5!'0!15-.3&)614T!=1!

1KD1-*!.3&!(1)41&0!*.!815*.&!.*+1&02!4&),'56!.3*!*+1!'41)0!)54!)5)($0'0!.A!1:1&$!

,.8)5!'5!8)M'56!41-'0'.50!)54!-&1)*'56!0*&)*16'10!A.&!.3&!.&6)5'<)*'.50T!718'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'D!'0!)!:1+'-(1!A.&!,.815!)54!.&6)5'<)*'.50!*.!A'54!D.,1&!*.!41)(!,'*+!

'003102!-+)561!D.('-'102!)54!*&)50A.&8!-.8835'*'10TjS!

!

Q+1!/48'&)!Q..(M'*!.5!718'5'0*!O1)41&0+'D!F.8D.515*0ji!@,+'-+!1-+.10!0.81!1(1815*0!.A!

.3&!(1)41&0+'D!4')8.54E2!41:1(.D14!L$!1K)8'5'56!L.*+!*+1!('*1&)*3&1!.5!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!

)54!6..4!D&)-*'-102!0388)&'<10!*+1!*+&11!4.8'5)5*!-.8D.515*0!.A!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!*+)*!

181&614!A&.8!*+1'&!0*34$U!0M'((02!5.&80!)54!:)(3102!)54!D1&0.5)(!-+)&)-*1&'0*'-0!@*+1!N01(APET!!

Q+1!41*)'(14!)**&'L3*10!)54!4'8150'.50!.A!1)-+!)&1!('0*14!)0U!

.P8779/!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!78 ?/=R!;5*)&'.2!Q+1!718'5'0*!\&'5-'D(1!.A!O1)41&0+'D2!.6>5,*T ji!/48'&)2!5.!4)*12!%1-*'.5!S2!9)5)61815*!h!O1)41&0+'DU!718'5'0*!O1)41&0+'D2!+**DUmm,,,T<150M)W

8&1<)T+&mD&'&3-5'Mm15m15t&1)4t8)5)61815*t(1)41&0+'DtST+*8!

Page 37: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! bj!

" O1)&5'56!)L'('*$2!41)('56!D.0'*':1($!,'*+!-&'*'-'082!-3&'.0'*$2!&1-1D*':15100!.&!030-1D*'L'('*$!

" G8D.,1&815*2!&1-&3'*'56!-.8D1*15*!D1.D(12!8)M'56!301!.A!4':1&0'*$2!-&1)*'56!

-.54'*'.50!A.&!18D.,1&815*2!!41(16)*'56!

" F..D1&)*'562!51*,.&M'562!.&'15*14!)*!0*)M1+.(41&02!-.551-*'56!)54!)**35'562!5.*!L1'56!

41A150':12!.&'15*14!)*!'5*1&5)(!-..D1&)*'.5!!

%?:J9!45I!>47=29!

" X3'4'56!:'0'.52!)!A.&-1A3(!.,5!:'0'.52!L1'56!'50D'&'562!-)D)-'*$!*.!-.5-1D*3)('<12!

*&)50A.&8'56!'41)0!'5*.!)-*'.5!

" ;D15!156)61815*2!:'0'L(1!18.*'.5)(!'5:.(:1815*2!D)00'.5!)54!-.8D)00'.52!

-.88'*815*!,'*+!D1.D(12!0.-'1*)(!'5:.(:1815*!

" #1'56!)!8.&)(!)3*+.&'*$2!)-*':1($!uD&)-*'-'56v!8.&)('*$2!L1'56!&1-.65'<14!)0!)!8.&)(!

)3*+.&'*$2!)DD($'56!8.&)(!0*)54)&40!!

T2:9?547!<B4:4<32:8938<9!

" O.-30!.A!-.5*&.(2!'5*1&5)(!(.-30!.A!-.5*&.(2!01(AWM5.,(14612!01(A!-.50-'.3051002!

)3*.5.8$!

" F&14'L'('*$2!-.56&3'*$2!L1'56!*&30*,.&*+$2!)3*+15*'-'*$!

" G8.*'.5)(!'5*1(('615-12!)L(1!*.!+)54(1!.,5!18.*'.502!'5*&.0D1-*'.52!.D*'8'082!

18D)*+$!!

Q+1&1!)&1!01:1&)(!-.88.5!*+&1)40!&355'56!*+&.36+!*+101!410-&'D*'.50!.A!,+)*!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'D!(..M0!('M1U!A'&0*2!*+1$!&10.5)*1!*+1!A.3&!4'8150'.50!.A!*+1!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!

N4')8.54P!H!D.,1&2!D.('*'-0!)54!!D3&D.012!D&'5-'D(10!)54!:)(3102!)54!D&)-*'-1T!!Q+1$!)(0.!

D.'5*!*.!*+1!18L14414!4'-+.*.8$!.A!)0D'&)*'.5!:0!&1)('*$U!*+1!,)$!*+'560!&3.B7$(G"($.1"!L$!

A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D2!)54!*+1!&1)('*'10!*+)*!41&)'(!*+1!)0D'&)*'.5!L1-)301!.A!*+1!L)66)61!.A!

+'0*.&$2!-3(*3&12!1KD1&'15-10!.A!D.,1&2!)54!D)'5!*+)*!,1!L&'56!*.!*+1!D&.-100T!!#3*!8.0*!

'8D.&*)5*($2!*+1$!0*&100!*+1!5114!A.&!-.5-&1*1!*..(0!)54!81-+)5'080!*.!1503&1!*+)*!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'D!'0!D&)-*'-14!'5!*+1!L10*!D.00'L(1!,)$2!&1-.65'<'56!*+)*!8)5$!.A!30!5114!*+101!*.!

.:1&-.81!.3&!.,5!A1)&!.A!D.,1&2!'5*1&5)('<14!,)$0!.A!30'56!H!)54!8'030'56!H!D.,1&2!)54!

*+)*!-&1)*'56!)DD&.D&')*1($!418.-&)*'-!)54!*&)50D)&15*!0*&3-*3&10!-)5!+1(D!30!)-+'1:1!.3&!

)0D'&)*'.50!A.&!*&3($!A18'5'0*!15*1&D&'010T!!

Q+1!8100'5100!)54!18L144145100!.A!.3&!.,5!1KD1&'15-10!.A!D.,1&!)54!D.,1&(1005100!'0!

L1)3*'A3(($!41-.50*&3-*14!'5!X1541&!)*!=.&M]0!1K-1((15*!4.-3815*)*'.5!.A!*+1'&!)-*'.5W

(1)&5'56!D&.6&)8!,'*+!*+&11!%.3*+!/A&'-)5!0.-')(!-+)561!)54!+38)5!&'6+*0!.&6)5'<)*'.502!

15*'*(14!NF+)561!'0!)!%(.,!?)5-1PT!X1541&!)*!=.&M!A)-'('*)*.&0!,.&M14!*.!+1(D!0*)AA!)54!

(1)41&0+'D!.A!*+101!.&6)5'<)*'.50!*.!411D15!*+1'&!-)D)-'*$!A.&!'8D&.:'56!61541&!

&1()*'.50+'D0!)54!D.,1&!'51d3)('*'10!L.*+!,'*+'5!*+1!.&6)5'<)*'.5!)54!'5!*+1'&!D&.6&)80T!>5!

.51!-)012!.A!)5!.&6)5'<)*'.5!A.35414!L$!,.815!03&:':.&0!.A!:'.(15-1!'5!\'1*1&8)&'*<L3&62!

*+1&1!,)0!)!-&'*'-)(!8.815*!,+15!*+1!(1)41&0+'D!*1)8!&1-.65'<14!+.,!*+1'&!.,5!5114!A.&!

:'-*'8+..4!H!)54!*+1'&!15*&)D815*!'5!*+1!D.('*'-0!.A!D.,1&(1005100!W!,)0!4)8)6'56!*+1'&!

(1)41&0+'D!D&)-*'-10!)54!L(.-M'56!*+1!.&6)5'<)*'.5]0!6&.,*+T!!?3&'56!.51!,.&M0+.D!,'*+!*+1!

X1541&!)*!=.&M!*1)8!'5!F)D1!Q.,52!,+15!*+'0!&1)('<)*'.5!0*&3-M!*+182!*+1$!3541&*..M!)!

D.,1&A3(!0$8L.('-!)-*!.A!('L1&)*'.5!A&.8!*+'0!516)*':1!A.&-1U!*+1$!,15*!*.!*+1!*.D!.A!

Q)L(1*.D!9.35*)'5!)54!*+&1,!*+1'&!:'-*'8+..4!.:1&!*+1!0'41TSJ!!Q+1!'41)!.A!*+1!NA18'5'51!

35':1&01P2!,+'-+!1-+.10!Z5'6+*]0!D.'5*!.5!-1(1L&)*'.52!&'*3)(2!V.$!)54!0)451002!'0!)(0.!)!:1&$!

'5*1&10*'56!4'8150'.52!)54!D.'5*0!*.!*+1!&.(1!.A!*&)50A.&8)*':1!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!'5!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!80 [155$!#1((!)54!7)<'()!X)5$2![30*'-1!)54!=.815!@[/=E2!'5!9'-+1(!7&'148)5!)54!%+)8'8!911&!@G40E2!F+)561!'0!)!

%(.,!?)5-12!X1541&!)*!=.&M2!;-*.L1&!IJJj2!\Tkb!

Page 38: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! bS!

L&1)M'56!*+1!ND&':)*1WD3L('-P!)54!,.&MWA)8'($!4':'410!*+)*!+):1!-+)&)-*1&'<14!8.41&5!

.&6)5'<)*'.50TS"!!!

Q+101!(':1!1K)8D(10!)54!'50'6+*0!(1)4!30!*.!*+'5M!)L.3*!*.!,+)*!1K*15*!.3&!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!D&.6&)80!+1(D!D&)-*'*'.51&0!41:1(.D!6&1)*1&!-()&'*$2!)54!)--100!

-.5-&1*1!*..(0!)54!81-+)5'0802!A.&!*+1'&!.,5!(1)41&0+'D!D&)-*'-12!)54!L1!D)&*'-3()&($!

)**15*':1!*.!*+1!)&-+'*1-*3&1!)54!4$5)8'-0!.A!D.,1&!'5!*+1'&!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!.&!8.:1815*!

-.5*1K*0T!!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!81 C).!)54!Z1((1+1&2!IJJJ2!.6>5,*T

Page 39: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! bi!

#?5<7=98?59!

Q+'0!D)D1&!+)0!)**18D*14!*.!D&.:'41!)!A&)81,.&M!A.&!35&):1('56!*+1!-.8D(1K!)54!6151&)(($!

)8.&D+.30!-.5-1D*!.A!(1)41&0+'D2!)54!*.!'((38'5)*1!*+1!-.5-1D*!)54!D&)-*'-1!.A!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'DT!Q+1!6.)(!.A!*+1!D)D1&2!+.,1:1&2!,)0!5.*!*.!D&.:'41!0.(3*'.50!)54!&1-'D102!L3*!

A..4!A.&!*+.36+*!A.&!*+.01!.A!30!156)614!'5!L3'(4'562!0*&156*+15'56!)54!)4:)5-'56!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'D!A.&!0.-')(!*&)50A.&8)*'.5T!!>*!+)0!0.36+*!*.!41-.50*&3-*!*+1!-.5-1D*!'5*.!0.81!

+.D1A3(($!301A3(!-.8D.515*02!L)014!.5!)5!1K*150':1!&1:'1,!.A!('*1&)*3&1!H!0-+.()&($!)54!

D.D3()&!H!.5!(1)41&0+'D2!.&6)5'<)*'.5)(!L1+):'.&!*+1.&$2!D.,1&!)5)($0'02!)0!,1((!)0!.5!)54!

A18'5'08!)54!A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'DT!

=+'(1!*+'0!A&)81,.&M!+)0!+.D1A3(($!5)'(14!*+1!V1(($!*.!*+1!,)((!8.&1!A'&8($!*+)5!L1A.&12!'*!'0!

0*'((!*15*)*':12!)54!'5*15414!.5($!*.!)4:)5-1!.3&!41L)*1T!!Q+1&1!8)$!L1!8)5$!A(),0!)54!6)D0!

*+)*!5114!*.!L1!A'((142!.&!4'8150'.50!.A!(1)41&0+'D!*+)*!+):1!5.*!L115!'5-.&D.&)*14T!!

=1!)(0.!+.D1!*+)*!*+'0!A&)81,.&M!,'((!'5A.&82!-+)((1561!)54!03DD.&*!*+.01!.A!30!156)614!'5!

A18'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!*&)'5'56!)54!41:1(.D815*!*.!(..M!8.&1!-&'*'-)(($!)*!.3&!)DD&.)-+102!)54!

'415*'A$!-.8D.515*0!*+)*!)&1!-3&&15*($!8'00'562!,1)M2!.&!'5!5114!.A!&1:'*)('<)*'.5!'5!.3&!

-3&&'-3()1!)54!D14)6.6$T!!!

>*!'0!)(0.!)!L16'55'56!'5!-&1)*'56!)!0*&3-*3&1!)54!8.&1!0150'*':1!'54'-)*.&0!*.!*&)-M!)54!)00100!

*+1!'8D)-*!)54!301A3(5100!.A!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!D&.6&)80!H!)!:1&$!'8D.&*)5*!6.)(!)*!)!

*'81!,+15!4.5.&0!)&1!'5-&1)0'56($!&1(3-*)5*!*.!A354!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!L1-)301!.A!*+1!

4'AA'-3(*$!'5!10*)L('0+'56!*+)*!'*!4.102!'541142!8)M1!)!4'AA1&15-1T!

\1&+)D0!'*!'0!8.0*!)DD&.D&')*1!*.!-.5-(341!*+'0!D)D1&!,'*+!)!-&3-')(!&18'541&U!*+)*!A18'5'0*!

(1)41&0+'D]0!A354)815*)(!)**&'L3*1!0+.3(4!L12!)0!*+1!/48'&)!*..(M'*!'50'0*02!*.!N8)M1!,):10TP!

>5!.*+1&!,.&402!*+1&1!'0!('**(1!D.'5*!'5!(1)41&0+'D!41:1(.D815*!D&.6&)802!'A!*+1$!4.!5.*!1d3'D!

,.815!*.!41)(!,'*+!*+1!8100$2!A&'6+*15'562!4)561&.30!L3*!1K+'()&)*'56!L30'5100!.A!A18'5'0*!

0.-')(!*&)50A.&8)*'.5T!!7.&!1:1&$!6&1)*!A18'5'0*!(1)41&!,1!-)5!*+'5M!.A!A&.8!)5$,+1&1!'5!*+1!

,.&(42!D)0*!)54!D&1015*!+)0!.51!*+'56!'5!-.88.5U!0+1!(14!L$!-+)((156'56!)54!4'0*3&L'56!*+1!

0*)*30!d3.T!!

718'5'0*!(1)41&0+'D!830*!8)M1!,):10T!

!

!

!

nataliae
Highlight
Page 40: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! gJ!

*2M85838?59!?M!724I2:9/!

!

@&(-.%(*3"(G"&*(7"#$"%&A(*3"(6".67"($.(1.*(1.*,5"(*3",%("C,&*"15">(/3"(1"C*(G"&*A(*3"(6".67"(

3.1.%(#1$(6%#,&">(/3"(1"C*A(*3"(6".67"(-"#%W(*3"(1"C*A(*3"(6".67"(3#*">(

(

/3"(&B6"%,.%(7"#$"%(+"*&(*3,1+&($.1"(<,*3(="%;(7,**7"(4.*,.1>(F"(,46#%*&(,1&*%B5*,.1(1.*(

*3%.B+3(4#1;(<.%$&(GB*(*3%.B+3(#(-"<($""$&>(F"(0""6&(,1-.%4"$(#G.B*("="%;*3,1+(GB*(

,1*"%-"%"&(3#%$7;(#*(#77>(F"(,&(#(5#*#7;&*A(#1$(*3.B+3(*3,1+&(<.B7$(1.*(+"*($.1"(<"77(,-(3"(

<"%"1k*J(*3"%"A(<3"1(*3";(&B55""$(3"(*#0"&(1.(5%"$,*>(@1$(G"5#B&"(3"(*#0"&(1.(5%"$,*A(5%"$,*(

1"="%(7"#="&(3,4>!

#.*+2!O).!Q012!lJgWkb"!#T!FT2!'5!/#.(/"(23,1+!

(

/3"(-,%&*(L.G(.-(#(7"#$"%(,&(*.($"-,1"(#(=,&,.1(-.%(*3"(.%+#1,Q#*,.1>>>>(!"#$"%&3,6(,&(*3"(5#6#5,*;(

*.(*%#1&7#*"(=,&,.1(,1*.(%"#7,*;>!=)&&15!#155'0!

(

R"(<,77,1+(*.(4#0"($"5,&,.1&>(/3#*k&(*3"(4.&*(,46.%*#1*(OB#7,*;(,1(#(+..$(7"#$"%>!X151&)(!

X1.&61!%T!\)**.5![&T!

(

Y#1#+"%&(3#="(&BG.%$,1#*"&l7"#$"%&(3#="(-.77.<"%&>(93&&)$![.+)55015!

(

T-(;.B%(#5*,.1&(,1&6,%"(.*3"%&(*.($%"#4(4.%"A(7"#%1(4.%"A($.(4.%"(#1$(G"5.4"(4.%"A(;.B(#%"(

#(7"#$"%>([.+5!p3'5-$!/4)80!

(

@(7"#$"%(*#0"&(6".67"(<3"%"(*3";(<#1*(*.(+.>(@(+%"#*(7"#$"%(*#0"&(6".67"(<3"%"(*3";($.1k*(

1"5"&&#%,7;(<#1*(*.(+.A(GB*(.B+3*(*.(G">(C.0)($55!F)&*1&!

(

T(#4(7..0,1+(-.%(#(7.*(.-(4"1(<3.(3#="(#1(,1-,1,*"(5#6#5,*;(*.(1.*(01.<(<3#*(5#1k*(G"($.1">(((

Y15&$!7.&4!

!

*2M85838?59!?M!724I2:9B8R/!

"

!"#$"%&3,6(,&(#1(,1*#1+,G7"(OB#7,*;(<,*3(1.(57"#%($"-,1,*,.1>(/3#*k&(6%.G#G7;(#(+..$(*3,1+A(

G"5#B&"(,-(*3"(6".67"(<3.(<"%"(G",1+(7"$(01"<(*3"($"-,1,*,.1A(*3";(<.B7$(3B1*($.<1(*3",%(

7"#$"%&(#1$(0,77(*3"4>(%-.**!/4)802!Q+1!?'(L1&*!\&'5-'D(1(

(

!"#$"%&3,6(%"=.7="&(#%.B1$(=,&,.1A(,$"#&A($,%"5*,.1A(#1$(3#&(4.%"(*.($.(<,*3(,1&6,%,1+(6".67"(

#&(*.($,%"5*,.1(#1$(+.#7&(*3#1(<,*3($#;P*.P$#;(,467"4"1*#*,.1>(@(7"#$"%(4B&*(G"(#G7"(*.(

7"="%#+"(4.%"(*3#1(3,&(.<1(5#6#G,7,*,"&>(F"(4B&*(G"(5#6#G7"(.-(,1&6,%,1+(.*3"%(6".67"(*.($.(

*3,1+&(<,*3.B*(#5*B#77;(&,**,1+(.1(*.6(.-(*3"4(<,*3(#(53"507,&*>!cT!

!"#$"%&3,6(,&(#(-B15*,.1(.-(01.<,1+(;.B%&"7-A(3#=,1+(#(=,&,.1(*3#*(,&(<"77(5.44B1,5#*"$A(

GB,7$,1+(*%B&*(#4.1+(5.77"#+B"&A(#1$(*#0,1+("--"5*,="(#5*,.1(*.(%"#7,Q"(;.B%(.<1(7"#$"%&3,6(

6.*"1*,#7>(=)&&15!#155'0!

(

!"#$"%&3,6(,&(#(5.4G,1#*,.1(.-(&*%#*"+;(#1$(53#%#5*"%>(T-(;.B(4B&*(G"(<,*3.B*(.1"A(G"(

<,*3.B*(*3"(&*%#*"+;>(X15T!YT!R.&8)5!%-+,)&<M.DA!

(

!"#$"%&3,6(,&(1.*(#(6"%&.1(.%(#(6.&,*,.1>(T*(,&(#(5.467"C(4.%#7(%"7#*,.1&3,6(G"*<""1(6".67"A(

G#&"$(.1(*%B&*A(.G7,+#*,.1A(5.44,*4"1*A("4.*,.1A(#1$(#(&3#%"$(=,&,.1(.-(*3"(+..$>![.)551!

F'3(()!!

Page 41: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! g"!

(

!"#$"%&3,6(,&(#(6%.5"&&(.-(+,=,1+(6B%6.&"(_4"#1,1+-B7($,%"5*,.1`(*.(5.77"5*,="("--.%*A(#1$(

5#B&,1+(<,77,1+("--.%*(*.(G"("C6"1$"$(*.(#53,"="(9*3#*:(6B%6.&">([)-.L0!h![)d310!

!

!"#$"%&3,6(,&(,1-7B"15"(P(1.*3,1+(4.%"A(1.*3,1+(7"&&>![.+5!9)K,1((!

(

!"#$"%&3,6(,&(#G.B*(#%*,5B7#*,1+(=,&,.1&A("4G.$;,1+(=#7B"&A(#1$(5%"#*,1+(*3"("1=,%.14"1*(

<,*3,1(<3,53(*3,1+&(5#1(G"(#55.467,&3"$>(!C'-+)&40!)54!G56(1!

!

d1"(.-(*3"(3#%$"&*(*#&0&(.-(7"#$"%&3,6(,&(B1$"%&*#1$,1+(*3#*(;.B(#%"(1.*(<3#*(;.B(#%"A(GB*(

<3#*(;.Bk%"(6"%5",="$(*.(G"(G;(.*3"%&>(!G4,)&4!OT!7(.8!

!

T-(;.B(<#1*(*.(GB,7$(#(&3,6A($.1k*($%B4(B6(*3"(4"1(*.(+#*3"%(<..$A($,=,$"(*3"(<.%0(#1$(+,="(

.%$"%&>(T1&*"#$A(*"#53(*3"4(*.(;"#%1(-.%(*3"(=#&*(#1$("1$7"&&(&"#>((/5*.'51!41!%*T!GK3D1&$!

!

!

*2M85838?59!?M!WM2J85852X!724I2:9B8R/!

!

M>-"4,1,1"(7"#$"%&3,6(,&(*3"(0";(*.(*%#1&-.%4,1+(.%+#1,Q#*,.1&A(5.44B1,*,"&(#1$(B&>(!.1+P

*"%4(53#1+"(3#&(*.(3#66"1(,1(#(1"<(4.$"7(<3"%"(=#7B"&(&B53(#&(,1*"+%,*;A(5.46#&&,.1A(

7,&*"1,1+A(%"5",=,1+(#1$(#(<,1P<,1(#66%.#53(*.(1"+.*,#*,.1(67#;(0";(%.7"&>(N"4,1,1"(

!"#$"%&3,6(,1&6,%"&(#B*3"1*,5,*;A(5#%,1+(#1$(&3#%,1+A(#(1"<(7"#$"%&3,6(&*;7"(#1$(-"4,1,1"(

<#;&(.-($.,1+(GB&,1"&&>(,,,TA18'5'51W(1)41&0+'DT-.8!

!

/3"(-"4,1,1"(7"#$"%&3,6(&*;7"("463#&,Q"&(5..6"%#*,.1(.="%(5.46"*,*,.1W(,1*B,*,.1(#&(<"77(#&(

%#*,.1#7(*3,10,1+(,1(6%.G7"4(&.7=,1+A(*"#4(&*%B5*B%"&(<3"%"(6.<"%(#1$(,1-7B"15"(#%"(&3#%"$(

<,*3,1(*3"(+%.B6(>(>(>(,1*"%6"%&.1#7(5.46"*"15"W(#1$(6#%*,5,6#*,="($"5,&,.1(4#0,1+>(9)&'($5!

O.415SI!

!

N"4,1,1"(7"#$"%&3,6(,&(#(&.5,#7($"4#1$(5.4,1+(-%.4(*3"("5.1.4,5(<.%7$>(/3"(Y5m,1&";(

\B#%*"%7;(%"6.%*(57#,4&(*3#*(-"4,1,1"(*#7"1*(,1(.%+#1,Q#*,.1&(3#&(5.46"*,*,="(=#7B"A(,*J&(1.*(

#G.B*(8G"&*(6%#5*,5"8>(/3"(&*#*,&*,5&(.-(*3"(%"6.%*(&3.<(*3"(1"5"&&,*;(.-(,15.%6.%#*,1+(

-"4,1,1"(=#7B"&(#1$(*#7"1*&(-.%(*3"(5.46#1,"&(*.(G"(4.%"(5.46"*,*,="(#1$(,11.=#*,=">(Y#1;(

cB%.6"#1(-"4#7"(^,%"5*.%&(#%"(&"**,1+(&*#1$#%$&(*.(,15.%6.%#*"(-"4,1,1"(*#7"1*(*3#*(

.*3"%<,&"(<.B7$(G"(7.&*(*.(&.5,"*;(#1$(*.(*3"("5.1.4,"&(.-(*3",%(5.B1*%,"&>(/3"("+#7,*#%,#1(

6%"&"15"(.-(<.4"1J&(6.&,*,.1&(,1(*3"(.%+#1,Q#*,.1&(,&(#1(,1$,5#*.%(.-(6%.+%"&&(#1$(*3"(

.66.&,*"(,&(6"%5",="$(#&(#1(,1$,5#*.%(.-(&.5,#7($"7#;>(((G3&.D1)5!_5'.52!G3&.D1)5!?'&1-*':1!

IJJgm""bmGF2!IJJg!

(

M(N"4,1,1"(!"#$"%&3,6(,&(#(1"<(&.5,#7(6#%#$,+4(*3#*(#77.<&(*3"("4"%+"15"(.-(*3"(-"4,1,1"(

*#7"1*M(N"4,1,1"(7"#$"%&3,6(,&(#(&.5,#7(5.44,*4"1*A(1.*(#(*"1$"15;(-.%(<.4"1(.17;>(T*(

%"6%"&"1*&(#(1"<(6#%#$,+4A(#1&<"%,1+(4#1;(.-(*3"(OB"&*,.1&(*3#*(#%"(G",1+(6.&"$(,1(*3,&(

3,&*.%,5(4.4"1*>(,,,T('*1&)6.A1815'5.T-.82!_5':1&0'*)*!\.8D13!7)L&)2!#)&-1(.5)!!

!

/3"(f-"4,1,1"(7"#$"%&3,6a(&*;7"A(53#%#5*"%,Q"$(G;(5..6"%#*,.1A(6#%*,5,6#*,.1A(&3#%,1+(.-(

6.<"%(#1$(,1-.%4#*,.1A(*"#4<.%0A("1"%+,Q,1+(.*3"%&A("13#15,1+(&"7-P<.%*3(.-(.*3"%&A("*5>A(,&(

#(7"#$"%&3,6(&*;7"(.-(*3"(-B*B%">(R'5)!\.(.0M'!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!SI!718'5'51!O1)41&0+'D!.&!Y.,!*.!%3--114!'5!#30'5100!='*+.3*!#1'56!;51!.A!*+1!#.$0!@Q'810!#..M02!"iSkE!(

Page 42: Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation · Feminist Leadership for Social Transformation: Clearing the Conceptual Cloud ! I! "#$%&’()*+),)%-./!!

! gI!

)#5%"$(-"4,1,1"(7"#$"%&3,6(,&(1.*(#G.B*(<.4"1(*#0,1+(.="%(5.1*%.7(-%.4(4"1>((T*(,&(1.*(#G.B*(

%"67#5,1+(6#*%,#%53#7(3,"%#%53;(<,*3(4#*%,#%53#7(3,"%#%53;>((T*J&(1.*(#G.B*(6#&&,=,*;>((I#*3"%A(

,*(,&(#G.B*(5.1*%,GB*,1+(&#5%"$(-"4,1,1"(#**%,GB*"&(9B15.1$,*,.1#7(7.="A(G",1+A(3.7$,1+(&6#5"A(

&"%=,1+A(-#5,7,*#*,1+A(#77.<,1+:(*.(*3"(3B4#1(6&;53"A(&.(*3#*(*3"($.,1+(#1$(*3"(G",1+A(*3"(

.B*"%(#1$(*3"(,11"%A(#%"(G#7#15"$>((@1$A(<3,7"(,*(4#;(G"(+"1"%#77;("#&,"%(-.%(<.4"1(*.(

5.1*%,GB*"(&#5%"$(-"4,1,1,*;(#1$(4"1(*.(5.1*%,GB*"(&#5%"$(4#&5B7,1,*;(9$.,1+A(#53,"=,1+A(

#1#7;Q,1+:A(#($;1#4,5(G#7#15"(<,*3,1("#53(6"%&.1(,&(<3#*(,&(#5*B#77;(%"OB,%"$>(F)&.(!Y'(*51&Sb!

!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Sb!N/5!>5:'*)*'.5!*.!%)-&14!718'5'51!O1)41&0+'DP2!D&1015*14!)*!*+1!IJJj!X(.L)(!O1)41&0+'D!7.&382!R.:.0'L'&0M2!

C300')!