feeling the gap: why goals matter for employers and brands

24
Feeling the Gap: Why goals matter to employers and brands Neil Gains, TapestryWorks for Asia Research Seminar, Jakarta, 1 September 2016

Upload: tapestryworks

Post on 16-Apr-2017

121 views

Category:

Marketing


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

FeelingtheGap:Whygoalsmattertoemployersandbrands

NeilGains,TapestryWorksforAsiaResearchSeminar,Jakarta,1September2016

Howcloseisrealitytodesire?

•Thebeautygap•Themarketresearchgap•TheIndonesiangap

HowclosearebrandstothebeautyIndonesianwomen

desire?

Whatisthebeautythatyoudesire&thebeautyyouhavenow?

Indonesianwomenarealready90%ofthewaytohavingthebeautytheydesire.Whatdoesthatmeanforbeautybrands?

5

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%COURAGE(WARRIOR)

CREATIVITY(ARTIST)

DISCOVERY(EXPLORER)

FREEDOM(REBEL)

FUN(JOKER)

LOVE(SEDUCER)

BELONGING(EVERYMAN)

CARE(CAREGIVER)

INNOCENCE(IDEALIST)

CONTROL(RULER)

KNOWLEDGE(GURU)

CONFIDENCE(CATALYST)Idealbeauty

Beautytoday

TypicalinternationalbrandsarestrongonConfidence,butshowagapinBelonging

6

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%COURAGE(WARRIOR)

CREATIVITY(ARTIST)

DISCOVERY(EXPLORER)

FREEDOM(REBEL)

FUN(JOKER)

LOVE(SEDUCER)

BELONGING(EVERYMAN)

CARE(CAREGIVER)

INNOCENCE(IDEALIST)

CONTROL(RULER)

KNOWLEDGE(GURU)

CONFIDENCE(CATALYST)Idealbeauty

Internationalbeautybrand

LocalbrandsfeelcloserandarestrongerincommunicatingasenseofBelonging,CareandFun

7

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%COURAGE(WARRIOR)

CREATIVITY(ARTIST)

DISCOVERY(EXPLORER)

FREEDOM(REBEL)

FUN(JOKER)

LOVE(SEDUCER)

BELONGING(EVERYMAN)

CARE(CAREGIVER)

INNOCENCE(IDEALIST)

CONTROL(RULER)

KNOWLEDGE(GURU)

CONFIDENCE(CATALYST)Idealbeauty

Localbeautybrand

Howclosearemarketresearcherstotheemployer

theydesire?

Howdoesitfeeltoworkinmarketresearch?

• TapestryWorks andAsiaResearchcollectedfeedbackonthecurrentandidealfeelingsof270AsianmarketresearchersusingStoryWorks®visualcardsorts.Thequestionstook2minutestocomplete.

• Thegapbetweencurrentandidealjobfeelingscorrelatedhighlywithmeasuresoffutureintentionsandjobsatisfaction.

PositivefeelingsfocusedonKnowledge,Control,BelongingandalittleDiscovery

10

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%COURAGE(WARRIOR)

CREATIVITY(ARTIST)

DISCOVERY(EXPLORER)

FREEDOM(REBEL)

FUN(JOKER)

LOVE(SEDUCER)

BELONGING(EVERYMAN)

NURTURE(CAREGIVER)

INNOCENCE(IDEALIST)

CONTROL(RULER)

KNOWLEDGE(GURU)

MASTERY(CATALYST)

Positivefeelings

Q3Whichofthefollowingimagessumsupyourfeelingsaboutyourcurrentemployer?Selectasfeworasmanyasyoulike.

NegativefeelingsfocusedonChaosandIgnorance

11

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%WEAK(WARRIOR)

MEDIOCRE(ARTIST)

TRAPPED(EXPLORER)

TRIVIAL(REBEL)

BORED(JOKER)

ALONE(SEDUCER)

ISOLATED(EVERYMAN)

SELFISH(CAREGIVER)

BADLYBEHAVED(IDEALIST)

CHAOTIC(RULER)

IGNORANT(GURU)

SURPRISED(CATALYST)

Negativefeelings

Q3Whichofthefollowingimagessumsupyourfeelingsaboutyourcurrentemployer?Selectasfeworasmanyasyoulike.

KeygoalsareControl,Knowledge,BelongingandDiscovery

12

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%COURAGE(WARRIOR)

CREATIVITY(ARTIST)

DISCOVERY(EXPLORER)

FREEDOM(REBEL)

FUN(JOKER)

LOVE(SEDUCER)

BELONGING(EVERYMAN)

NURTURE(CAREGIVER)

INNOCENCE(IDEALIST)

CONTROL(RULER)

KNOWLEDGE(GURU)

MASTERY(CATALYST)

Currentfeelings

Q3Whichofthefollowingimagessumsupyourfeelingsaboutyourcurrentemployer?Selectasfeworasmanyasyoulike.

KeygoalsareControl,Knowledge,BelongingandDiscovery

13

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%COURAGE(WARRIOR)

CREATIVITY(ARTIST)

DISCOVERY(EXPLORER)

FREEDOM(REBEL)

FUN(JOKER)

LOVE(SEDUCER)

BELONGING(EVERYMAN)

NURTURE(CAREGIVER)

INNOCENCE(IDEALIST)

CONTROL(RULER)

KNOWLEDGE(GURU)

MASTERY(CATALYST)

Currentfeelings

Q3Whichofthefollowingimagessumsupyourfeelingsaboutyourcurrentemployer?Selectasfeworasmanyasyoulike.

AsianmarketresearchersdesiremoreDiscoveryandCreativityandalittlemoreCare

14

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%COURAGE(WARRIOR)

CREATIVITY(ARTIST)

DISCOVERY(EXPLORER)

FREEDOM(REBEL)

FUN(JOKER)

LOVE(SEDUCER)

BELONGING(EVERYMAN)

NURTURE(CAREGIVER)

INNOCENCE(IDEALIST)

CONTROL(RULER)

KNOWLEDGE(GURU)

MASTERY(CATALYST)

Currentfeelings(total)

Idealemployer(total)

A3Whichofthefollowingimagessumsupyourfeelingsaboutyourcurrentemployer?A4Whichimageswouldsuitthatofyourideal employer?

Gapbetweenrealityandidealpredictsfutureintentions

-40

-20

0

20

40

60

80

100

TOTAL Will not stay

Not sure Quite likely to stay

Very likely to stay

Similaritybetweencurrent&

ideal(%)

A3Whichofthefollowingimagessumsupyourfeelingsaboutyourcurrentemployer?A4Whichimageswouldsuitthatofyouridealemployer?C6Howlikelyareyoutobewithyourcurrentemployer(witherinyourcurrentmarketoroverseas)inayear’stime?

Thosewhoplantoleaveshowalargegap,especiallyinareasofKnowledge(orIgnorance)

16

0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%

COURAGE(WARRIOR)

CREATIVITY(ARTIST)

DISCOVERY(EXPLORER)

FREEDOM(REBEL)

FUN(JOKER)

LOVE(SEDUCER)

BELONGING(EVERYMAN)

NURTURE(CAREGIVER)

INNOCENCE(IDEALIST)

CONTROL(RULER)

KNOWLEDGE(GURU)

MASTERY(CATALYST)

Currentfeelings(willnotstay)

Idealemployer(willnotstay)

A3Whichofthefollowingimagessumsupyourfeelingsaboutyourcurrentemployer?A4Whichimageswouldsuitthatofyourideal employer?

Thosewhoplantostayhaveasmallgapbetweenrealityanddesire

0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%

COURAGE(WARRIOR)

CREATIVITY(ARTIST)

DISCOVERY(EXPLORER)

FREEDOM(REBEL)

FUN(JOKER)

LOVE(SEDUCER)

BELONGING(EVERYMAN)

NURTURE(CAREGIVER)

INNOCENCE(IDEALIST)

CONTROL(RULER)

KNOWLEDGE(GURU)

MASTERY(CATALYST)Currentfeelings(willstay)

Idealemployer(willstay)

A3Whichofthefollowingimagessumsupyourfeelingsaboutyourcurrentemployer?A4Whichimageswouldsuitthatofyourideal employer?

Thedifferenceisnotinwhatthosewhowanttostayorleavedesire…

18

0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%

COURAGE(WARRIOR)

CREATIVITY(ARTIST)

DISCOVERY(EXPLORER)

FREEDOM(REBEL)

FUN(JOKER)

LOVE(SEDUCER)

BELONGING(EVERYMAN)

NURTURE(CAREGIVER)

INNOCENCE(IDEALIST)

CONTROL(RULER)

KNOWLEDGE(GURU)

MASTERY(CATALYST)

Idealemployer(willnotstay)

Idealemployer(willstay)

A3Whichofthefollowingimagessumsupyourfeelingsaboutyourcurrentemployer?A4Whichimageswouldsuitthatofyourideal employer?

…butratherinhowdifferentlytheyperceivetheircurrentsituation

0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%

COURAGE(WARRIOR)

CREATIVITY(ARTIST)

DISCOVERY(EXPLORER)

FREEDOM(REBEL)

FUN(JOKER)

LOVE(SEDUCER)

BELONGING(EVERYMAN)

NURTURE(CAREGIVER)

INNOCENCE(IDEALIST)

CONTROL(RULER)

KNOWLEDGE(GURU)

MASTERY(CATALYST)Currentfeelings(willstay)

Currentfeelings(willnotstay)

A3Whichofthefollowingimagessumsupyourfeelingsaboutyourcurrentemployer?A4Whichimageswouldsuitthatofyourideal employer?

HowcloseareIndonesianmarketresearcherstotheemployertheydesire?

IndonesianmarketresearchersaremorepositivethanthosefromChinaandSingapore

21

Currentfeelingsaboutemployer

Correlation betweencurrentandidealemployer

GreaterChina 37%India 82%

Indonesia 62%Singapore 56%60.7

47.6

70.756.7 55.1

39.352.4

29.343.3 44.9

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

TOTAL China India Indonesia Singapore

Positive Negative

A3Whichofthefollowingimagessumsupyourfeelingsaboutyourcurrentemployer?A4Whichimageswouldsuitthatofyourideal employer?

IndonesianmarketresearcherswantmoreConfidence,Courage,DiscoveryandBelonging

22

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%COURAGE(WARRIOR)

CREATIVITY(ARTIST)

DISCOVERY(EXPLORER)

FREEDOM(REBEL)

FUN(JOKER)

LOVE(SEDUCER)

BELONGING(EVERYMAN)

CARE(CAREGIVER)

INNOCENCE(IDEALIST)

CONTROL(RULER)

KNOWLEDGE(GURU)

CONFIDENCE(CATALYST)Currentemployer

Idealemployer

Howcloseisrealitytowhatyourcustomersandemployeesdesire?

•Understandgoals

•Createtherightfeeling

•Closethegap

Terima kasih

WeavingsenseintobrandsFormoreinformationcontact:

[email protected]@neilgains (Twitter)