february 25, 2011 demand side working group eils update mark patterson ercot, manager demand...
TRANSCRIPT
February 25, 2011
Demand Side Working Group
EILS Update
Mark PattersonERCOT, Manager Demand Integration
Demand Side Working Group February 25, 2011
February through May 2011 Procurement
February 2011
262
310
271
164
276.4
361 350
410.7
251.7
467.7
8
11 9095.7
55 89
106.5
183.6
9.8
0
75
150
225
300
375
450
525
FebMay08 JunSept08 Oct08Jan09 FebMay09 JunSept09 Oct09Jan10 FebMay10 JunSept10 Oct10Jan11 FebMay11
MW Offered, Not Procured
MW Procured
Business Hours 1
February 2011
262
219
287.6
168155
353 346 355.8
306.8
470.7
8
12
86.7
0
74.3
58.489.3
13133.2
9.8
0
75
150
225
300
375
450
525
FebMay08 JunSept08 Oct08Jan09 FebMay09 JunSept09 Oct09Jan10 FebMay10 JunSept10 Oct10Jan11 FebMay11
MW Offered, Not Procured
MW Procured
Business Hours 2
February 2011
262
216
290
163
237268
322335.5
270.1
472.4
8
11
86.7
0
0
137.3
89.3
15.8 152.7
1.2
0
75
150
225
300
375
450
525
FebMay08 JunSept08 Oct08Jan09 FebMay09 JunSept09 Oct09Jan10 FebMay10 JunSept10 Oct10Jan11 FebMay11
MW Offered, Not Procured
MW Procured
Business Hours 3
February 2011
185216
272
138
256
335
283
333.2
295.7
384.2
104
110
86.7
72.9
39.9
89.3
93.7
52
2.1
0
75
150
225
300
375
450
525
FebMay08 JunSept08 Oct08Jan09 FebMay09 JunSept09 Oct09Jan10 FebMay10 JunSept10 Oct10Jan11 FebMay11
MW Offered, Not Procured
MW Procured
Non-Business Hours
26
15
8
45
5
4 4
3
4
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
FebMay08 JunSept08 Oct08Jan09 FebMay09 JunSept09 Oct09Jan10 FebMay10 JunSept10 Oct10Jan11 FebMay11
Ave
rag
e S
ize
of P
rocu
red
Site
s(M
W)
Nu
mb
er o
f P
rocu
red
Lo
ad
s
BH1 BH2 BH3 NBH Average Size (MW)
Procurement Trends (no. & avg. size of EILS Loads)
EILS Loads include individual Loads and aggregations
February 2011
Individual Site ParticipationCumulative number of unique sites in EILS ID process
February 2011
Demand Side Working Group February 25, 2011
February 2, 2011 Event
3:00am 5:08am 5:17am
5:43am9:05am
ERCOT experienced communications challenges due to the rapidly-unfolding events
JAN 31 FEB 1 FEB 2
Issued OCN and Advisory•Severe Weather•Reserves below 3000 MW •PUCT Report @ 3:21am
Issued Watch•Reserves Below 2500 MW•Sent to Grid Alert List
Issued OCN•Winter Storm Warning•PUCT Report @2:45 a.m.
Issued EEA Level 2A•Reserves Below 1750 MW•Sent to Grid Emergency List
Issued EEA Level 3•Rotating Outages•Sent to Grid Emergency List•PUCT Report @ 6:05am
2:45am
Issued Advisory•Freezing Temperatures•PUCT Report
3:05p.m.
Issued OCN•Operating Condition Notice•Expected Freezing Temperatures•PUCT Report @3:05pm
OCN and Watch also include:•Qualified Scheduling Entity Hotline Call•Transmission Owner Hotline Call•Postings on the Market Information System and ERCOT website
5:20am5:08am
7:15pm
1,804 MW Non-Spin deployed Restored 500 MW
Restoration Complete
A timeline of the emergency steps that were taken leading to rotating outages in ERCOT
FEB 2 FEB 3, 10 AM EEA 2A ENDS & EILS RECALLED
Issued WatchReserves below 2,500 MW
Issued EEA 2A•Reserves below 1,750 MW •Load Resources deployed
Issued EEA 3•EILS deployed•Firm Load Shed 1,000 MW
7:57amRestored 500 MW (3,500 MW out)8:22amRestored 500 MW (3,000 MW out)9:25amRestored 500 MW (2,500 MW out)5:43am
6:04amFirm load shed 1,000 MW (2,000 MW total)
6:05amFrequency 59.576Hz
6:23amFirm Load Shed 2,000 MW
(4,000 MW total)
6:59amMedia Appeal issued
Move to EEA 2BFrom EEA 3
New winter Peak Record 56,480 MW
2:01pm
11:39amRestored 500 MW (2,000 MW out)12:04pmRestored 500 MW (1,500 MW out)12:25pmRestored 500 MW (1,000 MW out)12:49pmRestored 500 MW (500 MW out)
Load Resources Recalled
Move to EEA 2AFrom EEA 2B
3:14pm
4:30am 1:07pm
1:57pm
The ERCOT System responded as expected
59.45
59.50
59.55
59.60
59.65
59.70
59.75
59.80
59.85
59.90
59.95
60.00
60.05
60.10
HZ
Frequency vs. Load Shed
Frequency
Load Resources Shed @ 5:20
1,000 MW Firm Load Shed and Emergency Interruptible Load @ 5:44
1,000 MW Firm Load Shed @ 6:04
2,000 MW Firm Load Shed @ 6:23
Demand Side Working Group February 25, 2011
New EILS Contract Period(RFP)
Demand Side Working Group February 25, 2011
New EILS RFP
• Today ERCOT will be filing a Petition for Emergency Rulemaking with the Public Utility Commission
• Subst. R. 25.507 (a)(2):– (2) Notwithstanding the foregoing, ERCOT may
restructure the contract periods to facilitate additional load participation in EILS. ERCOT must publicly announce any changes to the contract period schedule described above at least 90 days prior to the next contract period start date.
• Petition will seek to remove the 90-day advance notice requirement
Demand Side Working Group February 25, 2011
This EILS RFP is provisional and this procurement may be cancelled by ERCOT at any step in the process prior to notification of awards. A decision by ERCOT to proceed with the procurement will be contingent on factors including but not limited to the following:
– Approval by the Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUCT) of a change to PUCT Substantive Rule §25.507 (a)(2),
– May require Approval by the ERCOT Board of Directors of a waiver of Nodal Protocols Section 3.14.3 (2),
– EILS MW capacity offers that are determined by ERCOT to be both sufficient to provide a viable operational tool for ERCOT to deploy in an Energy Emergency Alert and priced consistent with the reasonableness criteria
Demand Side Working Group February 25, 2011
Term of Service This RFP is for EILS services for a Contract Period beginning at Hour Ending 01:00 (12:00 a.m.) on April 1, 2011, through Hour Ending 24:00 (midnight) on May 31, 2011. Offers may be submitted to provide EILS for one or more of the following Time Periods in this Contract Period:
Time Period Name Time Period Hours (Central Prevailing Time)
Business Hours 1 Hours Ending 0900 through 1300 (8:00:00 a.m. to 1:00:00 p.m.), Monday through Friday except ERCOT Holidays.* (210 total hours)
Business Hours 2 Hours Ending 1400 through 1600 (1:00:00 p.m. to 4:00:00 p.m.), Monday through Friday except ERCOT Holidays. (126 total hours)
Business Hours 3 Hours Ending 1700 through 2000 (4:00:00 p.m. to 8:00:00 p.m.), Monday through Friday except ERCOT Holidays. (168 total hours)
Non-Business Hours All other hours (960 total hours)
* The ERCOT Holiday in this Contract Period is Monday, May 30, 2011.
Demand Side Working Group February 25, 2011
• The Change Control process for the Technical Requirements and Scope of Work for the new Contract Period will be modified as follows: – the Market Participant review period for changes to the
document will be less than 14 days. Otherwise the Change Control process will not change.
GUIDELINES FOR New EILS PROCUREMENT
Demand Side Working Group February 25, 2011
• QSEs may submit new EILS Loads or reconfigured aggregated EILS Loads to ERCOT for consideration using the EILS Load Identification (ELID) process as defined and adhering to the ELID deadlines set forth in the procurement schedule.
GUIDELINES FOR New EILS PROCUREMENT (Cont’)
Demand Side Working Group February 25, 2011
• QSEs may submit offers for the following:– EILS Loads assigned an ELID number through the
process described in No. 2, above.– EILS Loads with valid, numbered ELIDs and baseline
assignments from the original Feb.-May 2011 Contract Period procurement cycle.
– EILS Loads with valid Reinstatement ELIDs that have successfully completed their reinstatement test and for which the suspension period has expired or will expire prior to April 1, 2011. Standard parameters relating to reinstatement offers apply.
– Substituting EILS Loads that were providing EILS at the time of the Feb. 2-3 EILS deployment event.
GUIDELINES FOR New EILS PROCUREMENT (Cont’)
Demand Side Working Group February 25, 2011
GUIDELINES FOR New EILS PROCUREMENT (Cont’)
• Availability and event performance will be evaluated independently of the original Feb.-May Contract Period.
February 25, 2011 Demand Side Working Group
Draft2
PROCUREMENT SCHEDULE Contract Period: April 1, 2011 through May 31, 2011
All deadlines are close of business U.S. Central Prevailing Time.Date Action
Fri., Feb. 25, 2011
RFP ISSUED: ERCOT issues EILS Request for Proposal. Draft Technical Requirements & Scope of Work posted to EILS web page.EILS Load ID process begins — submittal of Resources for baseline assignment & capacity pre-screening
Fri., Mar. 4, 2011 ELID process closes (last day to submit ELIDs for new Loads.
Mon., March 7, 2011 Online meeting review of Technical Requirements comments (if requested).
Fri., March 11, 2011ERCOT communicates to QSEs completed baseline assignment and capacity pre-screening information for prospective EILS Loads.
Mon., March 14, 2011QSEs opting for EILS Self-Provision submit the EILS Notification of Self-Provision Form to ERCOT.
Fri., March 18, 2011 OFFERS DUE: QSEs submit EILS Submission Forms with completed competitive Offers and/or Self-Provision Offers. ERCOT notifies Self-Providing QSEs of options for adjusted commitment levels.
Tue., March 22, 2011 Self-Providing QSEs provide ERCOT with final Self-Provision commitment (this must occur within two Business Days of the communication to the QSE from ERCOT).
Wed., March 24, 2011ERCOT notifies awarded QSEs of EILS awards. ERCOT issues Market Notice with summary of EILS awards. Standard Form Supplements to QSE Agreements distributed to awarded QSEs.
Wed., March 30, 2011 Deadline for signed contracts to be returned to ERCOT. Fri., April 1, 2011 First day of operation in the Contract Period. Tue., May 31, 2011 Last day of Contract PeriodTue., July 5, 2011 Deadline for submitting NOIE or non-TDSP interval meter data to ERCOTFri., July 15, 2011 ERCOT provides unofficial availability and event performance data to QSEs
Mon., July 25, 2011 Deadline for QSEs to identify any discrepancies with ERCOT’s unofficial data
Tue., Aug. 9, 2011 Approximate Settlement statement posting date for this Contract Period