fast radio burst progenitor models - aspen 2017 winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/piro.pdf• neutron...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models
Tony Piro Carnegie Observatories
Fast Radio Bursts: New Probes of Fundamental Physics and Cosmology, February 13, 2017
![Page 2: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
What could FRBs be? • Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla ‘14; Zhang ’14) • Merger of charged black holes (Zhang ‘16; Liu et al. ’16; Liebling & Panenzuela ‘16) • Magnetospheric activity during neutron star mergers (Totani ‘13) • Unipolar inductor in neutron star mergers (Hansen & Lyutikov ‘01; Piro ‘12; Wang et al. ‘16) • White dwarf mergers (Kashiyama et al. ‘13) • Pulses from young neutron stars (Cordes & Wasserman ’15; Connor et al. ‘15; Lyutikov et al. ’16; Popov & Pshirkov ’16; Kashiyama & Murase ‘17) • Magnetars (Popov et al. ’07; Kulkarni et al. ‘14; Lyubarsky ‘14; Katz ’15; Pen & Connor ‘15) • Sparks from cosmic strings (Vachaspati ‘08; Yu et al. ‘14) • Evaporating primordial black holes (Rees ’77; Keane et al. ‘12) • White holes (Barrau et al. ’14) • Flaring stars (Loeb et al. ‘13; Maoz et al. ‘15) • Axion stars (Tkachev ‘15; Iwazaki ‘15) • Asteroids/comets falling onto neutron stars (Geng & Huang ‘15) • Quark novae (Chand et al. ‘15) • Dark matter-induced collapse of neutron stars (Fuller & Ott ‘15) • Higgs portals to pulsar collapse (Bramante & Elahi ’15) • Planets interacting with a pulsar wind (Mottez & Zarka ’15) • Black hole superradiance (Conlon & Herdeiro ‘17) • Extragalactic light sails (Lingam & Loeb ‘17) • Schwinger instability in young magnetars (Lieu ‘17) • Neutron star-white dwarf binaries (Gu et al. ’16)
![Page 3: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Repeating FRB 121102
• Spitler et al. (2016)
• Proves in at least one case FRBs are not cataclysmic events
![Page 4: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Non-Cataclysmic FRB Progenitors 1. Radio emission accompanying magnetar giant flares (Lyutikov ‘02; Popov & Postnov ‘10; Keane et al. ‘12; Pen & Connor ’15; Kulkarni et al. ‘14; Lyubarsky ‘14; Katz ’15)
2. Giant pulse analogues emitted by young pulsars (Cordes & Wasserman ‘16; Connor et al. ‘16; Lyutikov et al. ’16; Popov & Pshirkov ’16; Kashiyama & Murase ‘17)
(Apologies if there are any missing references!)
![Page 5: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Comparison to the SN rate Connor, Sievers, and Pen (2016)
![Page 6: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Can DM be from the source? • Nearly quadratic dispersion implies plasma cannot be too dense (Katz 2016)
• Thus dispersing region must be sufficiently large
• Dispersing material must also be optically thin (Luan & Goldreich 2014; Katz 2016)
• Potentially stricter, but depends on temperature
• Consistent with supernova remnant? (Connor et al. ’16; Lyutikov et al. 16)
ne <2
3|� ↵� 2|me!2
4⇡e2⇡ 5⇥ 107cm�3
RDM = DM/ne > 1013 � 1014cm
ne < 104(T/104K)3/2(DM/103pc cm�3)�1cm�3
![Page 7: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Localization of FRB 121102 (Chatterjee et al. ‘17; Tendulkar et al. ‘17)
![Page 8: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
106 107 108 109 1010 1011
Stellar mass (MO • )
10-3
10-2
10-1
100
101
Star
-form
atio
n ra
te (M
O • yr-1
)
sSFR =
10-8 yr
-1
10-9 yr
-1
10-10 yr
-1
10-11 yr
-1
10uhf
Type I/RType IILVL(area ~ SFR)
Host of FRB 121102: SFR (Tendulkar et al. ’17; Metzger, Berger & Margalit ‘17; Perley et al. ‘16)
![Page 9: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Host of FRB 121102: Metallicity
106 107 108 109 1010 1011
Stellar mass (MO • )
7.5
8.0
8.5
9.0
9.5
12+l
og10
[O/H
]
10uhf
Type I/RType II
(pale if from M-Z)
LVL(area ~ SFR)
(Tendulkar et al. ’17; Metzger, Berger & Margalit ‘17; Perley et al. ‘16)
![Page 10: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Supernova remnant
![Page 11: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Supernova Remnant Evolution Piro (2016)
![Page 12: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Total DM including SNR • Assuming we can subtract out the MW component, the remaining DM is
DMtotal(t) = DMSNR(t) + DMHost +DMIGM
�DMtotal
⇡ dDMSNR
dt�t ⇡ 2⇥ 105
✓M
M�
◆f�t
yr
v29
t3yr
pc cm�3
• How do we eliminate these pesky unknown constants?
Use the change in the DM!
DMSNR(t) =3Mf
4⇡(vt)2= 9.5⇥ 104
✓M
M�
◆f
v29t2yr
pc cm�3
![Page 13: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Comparing to FRB 121102 • Over the ~4 years these bursts have repeated, the DM is the same within a few pc/cm3
• So not crazy. Can we keep checking the DM? How accurately can DM be measured?
• We also know that the total DM < 225 pc/cm3 (once MW and IGM is subtracted, Tendulkar et al. ‘17), which limits the mass to
t & 60
✓M
M�
◆1/3 ✓ f
v29
�tyr4
◆1/3
yrs
M . 8v29f
✓tyr60
◆2
M�
![Page 14: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Is there sufficient rotational energy?
• For a spinning down dipole, the spindown time and available energy (in ~1 ms) are
• If the neutron star spins down too fast, there won’t be enough rotational energy when remnant becomes optically thin
Katz (2016)
�E =(BR3)2⌦4
c3�t ⇡ 1040B2
12P�4ms erg
tsd ⇡ Ic3
2(BR3)2⌦2⇡ 10B�2
12 P 2msyrs
![Page 15: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Is there sufficient rotational energy?
• Favors quickly spinning (<2 ms) neutron stars with moderate B-field (<5x1011 G)
Piro (2016)
![Page 16: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
What about FRBs 110220 &140514? • Very different DMs:
FRB 110220, DM = 944.4 pc/cm3
FRB 140514, DM = 562.7 pc/cm3
• Similar positions within 9 arcmin:
FRB 110220, RA=22h34m38s, DEC= -12°24’
FRB 140514, RA=22h34m06s, DEC= -12°18’
• Could these be the same source? Maoz et al. (2016) conclude with 99% confidence that this is from the same repeating source based on location, FRB rate, and sky coverage
![Page 17: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Assuming FRB 110220 &140514 are the same source
• Over the 3.2 years, DM has changed by 381.7 pc/cm3
t ⇡ 12
✓M
M�
◆1/3 ✓ f
v29
◆1/3
yrs
DMSNR(t+3.2)2 +DMstu↵
DMSNRt2 +DMstu↵
=562.7
944.4= 0.596
t2
(t+ 3.2)2< 0.596
t < 10.8 yrs M < 1.2(v29/f)M�
• But we can even get a more model independent constraint!
![Page 18: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
−20 0 20 40 60 80 100Phase from peak [days]
−21
−20
−19
−18
−17
−16
−15
−14
−13
Abso
lute
mag
nit
ude
1993J
1994I
1996cb
1998bw
1999dn
1999ex
2002ap
2003bg
2003jd
2004aw
2004dk
2004dn
2004fe
2004ff
2004gq
2005az
2005bf
2005hg
2005kz
2005mf
2006T
2006aj
2006el
2006ep
2007C
2007Y
2007gr
2007ru
2007uy
2008D
2008ax
2009bb
2009jf
2010bh
2011bm
2011dh
2011hs
iPTF13bvn
41.0
41.5
42.0
42.5
43.0
43.5
log 1
0Lum
inos
ity
[erg
/s]
Stripped Envelope SN Light Curves Lyman et al. (2016)
tp ⇠ (M/vc)1/2
v ⇠ (2E/M)1/2
![Page 19: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Stripped Envelope SN Ejecta Masses
1 10EK [1051 ergs]
1
10
Mej[M
⊙]
IIb (9)Ib (13)Ic (8)Ic-BL (8)
Lyman et al. (2016)
M < 1.1(E51/f)1/2M�Type IIP SNe
Pejcha & Prieto (2015)
f = 0.1
![Page 20: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Neutron Stars
FRBs were 39 arcmin away :(
(Hakobyan et al. ‘08)
December 4, 2001
![Page 21: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Persistent radio source! Chatterjee et al. (2017)
![Page 22: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Young Magnetar FRB Model Metzger, Berger & Margalit ’17
Synchrotron from either SN shock or pulsar nebula
Argues for long term monitoring of persistent radio source.
![Page 23: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Don’t forget cataclysmic scenarios! • Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla ‘13; Zhang ’14)
• Merger of charged black holes (Zhang ‘16; Liu et al. ’16; Liebling & Panenzuela ‘16)
• Magnetospheric activity during neutron star mergers (Totani ‘13)
• Unipolar inductor in neutron star mergers (Piro ‘12; Wang et al. ‘16)
• White dwarf mergers (Kashiyama et al. ’13)
Probably cannot produce the majority of FRBs, but we should keep them in mind
![Page 24: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
“Blitzar” NS collapsing to BH Falcke & Rezzolla (2014); Zhang (2014)
• NS accretes and spun up above usual maximum mass
• When spun down (magnetic braking?) NS collapses to BH, expelling B-field, producing FRB
• Lots of potential scenarios (NS mergers, fast spinning SNe, HMXBs, AIC)
Many potential E&M and GW counterparts, but how will we uniquely know it’s a blitzar?
![Page 25: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Unipolar inductor during NS mergers Goldreich & Lynden-Bell ‘69; Hansen & Lyutikov ’01;
Lai ’12; Wang et al. ‘16
Piro (2012)
![Page 26: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Unipolar inductor emission • Take ~1% of dissipation and put into radio as curvature radiation (Mingarelli, Levan, & Lazio ‘15)
• Large currents expected to repeatedly break circuit (Lai ‘12)
• Treating as an LR circuit (Piro, unpublished) flaring timescale is
• Is the pair plasma surrounding the merger too dense for radio propagation? (Metzger & Zivancev 2016)
tLR
⇠ a
c
✓R
tot
4⇡/c
◆�1
![Page 27: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
E&M counterparts to NS mergers Metzger & Berger (2012) • GRB and afterglow
• Shattering of the NS crusts (Tsang et al. ‘12)
• Kilonova (~1041 erg/s infrared to optical transient)
• Pulsar wind nebulae in radio (Piro & Kulkarni ‘13)
• Radio from ejecta-ISM shock (Nakar & Piran ‘11)
Relative timing of counterparts to FRB also important
![Page 28: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Summary and Conclusion • Repeating FRB argues for non-cataclysmic scenario unless strong evidence for multiple FRB progenitors
• Young neutron stars are attractive for producing rate and DM
• Rotational powering requires modest B-fields (<1012 G) short P
• Host galaxy, DM constraints, suggest connection with stripped envelope supernovae
• Are FRBs 110220 and 140514 the same source? A 3rd burst from this location would provide amazing constraints
• Cataclysmic scenarios are likely to have E&M and/or GW counterparts but probably cannot produce all FRBs
![Page 29: Fast Radio Burst Progenitor Models - Aspen 2017 Winter ...aspen17.phys.wvu.edu/Piro.pdf• Neutron stars collapsing to black holes, ejecting “magnetic hair” (Falcke & Rezzolla](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022041009/5eb6270bad7de620b631a3a1/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Questions • How well can DMs be measured to look for changes? What are the limiting factors?
• How long do we have to stare at the location of FRBs 110220 and 140514 to rule out repeated bursts?
• What is the best strategy (cadence, targets, etc) for finding repeating bursts?
• When looking for E&M counterparts, are we searching parameter space to actually rule out models?
• Many of the counterparts (E&M, GW, etc) require nearby FRBs to be seen. Are we able to recover low DM FRBs?