f1 1103-pipe roof singapore sun -all ,38 pg

38
1305-TT –Myanmar – Pipe Roof Construction in Singapore Trisha Sun Trenchless Technology Seminar -Myanmar 5 to 7 June 2013 Pipe Roof Construction in Singapore Trisha Sun Principal W& M Consutlants [email protected] 1 of 38. 1 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Post on 21-Oct-2014

1.132 views

Category:

Design


4 download

DESCRIPTION

Construction of Pipe Roof and Support System in Proposed Outlet Drain Undercrossing North Buona Vista Road, Singapore T Sun, W& M Consultants, Singapore. [email protected] Land Transport Authority, Singapore , Public Utilities Board, Singapore, Or Kim Peow Contractors (Pte) Ltd, Singapore Abstract: The project in the paper included design and construction of a permanent 120m long RC box culvert and sewer diversion at North Buona Vista Road (NBV) Singapore. The pipe roof method was selected by the design and build contractor in fulfilment of the contract requirement for the 53 m box section undercrossing NBV Road. The adopted methodology comprised the installation by pipe jacking of numbers of interlocking steel pipes followed by traverse series of steel frames for safe mining of the tunnel. This served to maintain uninterrupted service conditions for the road, subways tunnel and other services. There are many challenges in the construction of pipe roof and mined tunnel. This paper deals with the consideration in the design and construction of such works. It also highlighted the problems encountered during the construction, subsequent solution adopted and protection of existing utilities as well as monitoring of settlement of the surrounding areas of the project.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

1305-TT –Myanmar –

Pipe Roof Construction in Singapore

Trisha Sun

Trenchless Technology Seminar

-Myanmar 5 to 7 June 2013

Pipe Roof Construction

in Singapore

Trisha Sun

Principal W& M Consutlants

[email protected]

1 of 38.

1 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 2: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

2 of 38.

2 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 3: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

3 of 38.

3 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 4: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

4 of 38.

4 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 5: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

5 of 38.

5 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 6: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

6 of 38.

6 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 7: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

7 of 38.

7 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 8: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

8 of 38.

8 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 9: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

9 of 38.

9 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 10: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

1

PIPE Roof

• Exepereince in Singapore –

Pipe roof costruction

•Sun , email: [email protected]

1Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

Topics 1-2

•Introduction

•Pipe roof concept

•Design issues

•Machine and problems

•Problems of jacking

•Constrction process2Pipe Roof Singapore- Sun

10 of 38.

10 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 11: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

2

Tpoics-2-2

• Jacking and receiving shafts

•Jacking ,mining

•Monitoring

•Risk

•Tender- design

•and documentationsPipe Roof Singapore- Sun 3

Introduction•Trenchless Methods for providing “No dig “

solution to installation of large culverts/pipes

•Alternatives:

•Pipe ramming / pipe roof by ramming/auger

machine

•Pipe roof by microtunnelling

•Pipe pushing/box culvert direct jacking

•Open cut

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 4

11 of 38.

11 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 12: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

3

Various shapes

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 5

Construction Sequence1. Execution of sheet piles2. Execution of the pipe arch microtunnelling3. Mined excavation of tunnel with steel ribs with reinforced shotcrete & fibre glass elements4. Casting of permanent concrete lining

Pipe Arch Tunnel – Concept

Site picture of project by Metropolitan Atlanta Rapid Transit Authority in USA

6IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKPIEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKPIEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKPIEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

12 of 38.

12 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 13: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

4

pipe roof Plan view (1-2)

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 7

Pipe roof -Plan view(2-2)

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP8

13 of 38.

13 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 14: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

5

Pipe roof

SG ,Pipe roof Tunnel•Long section view

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 9

• Design Issues

10IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

14 of 38.

14 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 15: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

6

Design Issues- 1

•Physical site constraints

Close to MRT CCL-central

circular Line

Close to Viaduct foundation E

west line ,Sewer line ,services

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 11

Design Issues -2 Physical site constraints-mining below

joint bay cables

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 12

15 of 38.

15 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 16: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

7

Design Issues- 3

critical issues

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun,

OKP

13

Design Issues -4-

geological profile

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 14

16 of 38.

16 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 17: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

8

Design 5-during break out-soil treatment, steel

portal frame

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 15

Design 6-

during break through at exit -soil treatment( soft alluvial), steel portal

frame

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 16

17 of 38.

17 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 18: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

9

Design 7 -stage excavation

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 17

Design 8 -Face Stability

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 18

18 of 38.

18 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 19: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

10

Design 9 -Design Model

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 19

Adopted Solution 1-3 The pipe jacking method adopted

-jacking from one end (jacking Shaft)

to the other end(receiving shaft)

using steel pipes to form a horizontal

and vertical temporary structure (

around the proposed reinforced box

culvert.)

20IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

19 of 38.

19 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 20: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

11

Adopted Solution 2-3

The pipe roof (see below Sketch

)comprises rows of 780mm dia Steel pipes

(10 on top and bottom and 6 rows on each

sides to form the vertical wall.

Each row of the steel pipes -interlock

together using steel T- clutches prefabricated

together with the pipes.

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP -22

Adopted Solution 2-3

Each row of the pipe which is

approximately 54m is formed

by welding together 9 to 10 number (

6 m long ) of steel pipe using the full

butt penetration welds

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 22

20 of 38.

20 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 21: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

12

SKETCH – CONFIGURATION OF THE PIPE

ROOF -drilling sequence

23IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

•Machine and

problems

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 24

21 of 38.

21 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 22: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

13

Machine 2-2 -Layout

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

25

PIPE JAKCING PROCESS -

Problems- jacking

•Obstruction

•Alignment

•Clutch

•Soil information

•SettlementIEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 26

22 of 38.

22 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 23: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

14

•Construction process

27IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

Construction process 1-

Jacking shaft –typical

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 28

23 of 38.

23 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 24: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

15

Construction process 2

Construction of Jacking & Receiving Shaft

29IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

Construction 7

Setting of Jacks

30IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

24 of 38.

24 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 25: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

16

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 31

Construction process 8

Steel pipes

Construction process 9

Sample clutch details

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 32

25 of 38.

25 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 26: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

17

Construction process 14

Pipe Jacking in Progress

33-

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun,

OKP

Construction process 16

Ultrasonic Test to welded joint

34-IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun,

OKP

26 of 38.

26 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 27: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

18

Construction process 19

TBM Through at Receiving Shaft

35IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

Construction process 21

Completed Horizontal Row of Pipe

Roof

36IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

27 of 38.

27 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 28: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

19

Construction process 22

Completed pipe roof

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun,

OKP37

•Mining of Tunnel

India No Dig-Dec 9,2010 -

Pipe Roof , cheng

38

28 of 38.

28 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 29: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

20

Construction –Mining of tunnel 3 -

Installing portal frame at jacking shaft

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 39

Construction –Mining of tunnel 4

Installing portal frame at jacking shaft

India No Dig-Dec 9,2010 -

Pipe Roof , cheng

40

29 of 38.

29 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 30: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

21

Construction –Mining of tunnel 6

install entrance frame before

mining

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP41

Construction –Mining of tunnel 8A

EXCAVATON

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, 42

30 of 38.

30 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 31: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

22

•Monitoring

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, 43

Monitoring 1-

Services –need for monitoring

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP44

31 of 38.

31 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 32: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

23

Monitoring 3 A

Sample-installations of

instrumentations

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 45

Monitoring 3 B

Installations of instrumentations –Joint

Bay

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 46

32 of 38.

32 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 33: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

24

Instrumentation – Monitoring 4

INSTALL PRISM INSIDE THE STEEL PIPE –for

monitoring settlements

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP47

Monitoring 5 A

MRT Line below project

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 48

33 of 38.

33 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 34: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

25

Monitoring 5B

MRT-FIXING PRISMS

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 49

Monitoring 6

- Predictions

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

50

34 of 38.

34 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 35: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

26

Monitoring 7

Readings

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

51

• Completion

52IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

35 of 38.

35 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 36: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

27

Completion

Final stage

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun,

OKP cheng53

• Risk Assessment

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP54

36 of 38.

36 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 37: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

28

Risk Assessment

Risk factors (1)•Risk from Soil information, services

•Settlement control and damages

•Insurance cover on adjacent structures

•Pre con survey

•Sharing of risks

•Design and build contract

•Allowance of claimIEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof

Singapore-Sun, OKP55

Risk Assessment

Risk factors (2)•Client risks

•Contractors

•Stakeholders

•3rd party client ( Authorities)

•Selection- method, main contractor ,specialist ( soil

treatment , shaft, pipe jacking , structures )

•Selecting –machine & skilled operators

•Luck /planningIEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 56

37 of 38.

37 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun

Page 38: F1 1103-pipe  roof  singapore sun -all ,38 pg

25/10/2012

29

Preparing for contract

•Contract documentation

•Design/drawings

•Specifications

•Bills /Lump sum/VO

IEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP 57

Thank you ,

58IIEM Conf Mar 2011- Pipe Roof Singapore-Sun, OKP

38 of 38.

38 of 38. -Pipe Roof In Singapore-Sun