expert review of post-mortem photographs obtained by the syrian opposition

8/13/2019 Expert Review of Post-Mortem Photographs Obtained by the Syrian Opposition

1/31

!"#$%&'#(%)*

!"#$%&'#(%)*"

! #$%&'(!"#$ #&' ()'*!+!,!#- $. (')#/!" '0!*'"(' 1!#& )'2/)* #$ 3$)#4)'/"* 56'(4#!$" $. 7')8$"8 9"(/)(')/#'* +- #&' (4))'"# :-)!/"

)'2!;'/?;3


5/31

!"#$%&'#(%)*

!"#$%&'#(%)*]

,%'G 67 7',67)6%( ,B', B% C'H% '2 B*2%7, '00*/2, *) B67 %O&%$6%20%73N) B% ;67B%( ,* %O'CC%$',% B67 %H6(%20% 6, ;*/5( B'H% E%%2 H%$J %'7J)*$ B6G ,* 7'J ,B', B% B'( '0,/'55J ;6,2%77%( %O%0/,6*273 N2 )'0,< B%

G'(% 6, Y/6,% &5'62 ,B', B% 2%H%$ ;6,2%77%( ' 762C5% %O%0/,6*23AB%$% ;%$% G'2J *,B%$ $%'7*27 ;B60B ($*H% ,B% 62Y/6$J ,%'G ,* 6,70*205/76*2 ,B', B67 %H6(%20% ;'7 $%56'E5% '2( 0*/5( 7')%5J E% '0,%(/&*2 62 '2J 7/E7%Y/%2, b/(606'5 &$*0%%(62C73


6/31

!"#$%&'#(%)*

!"#$%&'#(%)*9

%%%5 %2390B;?33

F/$62C ,B% 0*/$7% *) B67 '00*/2, ,* ,B% 62Y/6$J ,%'G ,B% ;6,2%77(%'5, ;6,B B67 %G&5*JG%2, 62 ,B% G656,'$J &*560% '2( 62)*$G%( ,B%G%GE%$7 *) ,B% ,%'G ,B', 6, )%55 ,* ,B', 7%0,6*2 ,* ,'1% &B*,*C$'&B7*) &%$7*27 ;B* ;%$% 62b/$%( *$ (%'(3 D*;%H%$ '),%$ ,B% /&$6762C'C'627, ,B% :77'( $%C6G% 6, E%0'G% $*/,62% ,* ,'1% &B*,*C$'&B7 *)&%*&5% 62 (%,%2,6*2 ;B* B'( E%%2 ,*$,/$%( '2( 1655%( (/$62C


7/31

!"#$%&'#(%)*

!"#$%&'#(%)*d

(%,%2,6*23 AB% $%'7*2 )*$ &B*,*C$'&B62C %O%0/,%( &%$7*27 ;'7,;*)*5(e V6$7, ,* &%$G6, ' (%',B 0%$,6)60',% ,* E% &$*(/0%( ;6,B*/,)'G656%7 $%Y/6$62C ,* 7%% ,B% E*(J ,B%$%EJ 'H*6(62C ,B% '/,B*$6,6%7

B'H62C ,* C6H% ' ,$/,B)/5 '00*/2, *) ,B%6$ (%',B7a 7%0*2( ,* 0*2)6$G,B', *$(%$7 ,* %O%0/,% 62(6H6(/'57 B'( E%%2 0'$$6%( */,3 :, 2* 7,'C%(6( [+'%7'$\ 62(60',% ,* G%GE%$7 *) ,B% 62Y/6$J ,%'G ,B', B% B'(E%%2 &$%7%2, ;B%2 '2J ,*$,/$% *$ '2J %O%0/,6*2 B'( ,'1%2 &5'0%3


8/31

!"#$%&'#(%)*

!"#$%&'#(%)*c

%C5 7/360B0.0D= 01 %2:;


9/31

!"#$%&'#(%)*

!"#$%&'#(%)*f

)%',/$%73 N, ;'7 $%0*C26g%( ,B', ,B% 6G'C%7 ;%$% 7'6( ,* B'H% E%%2&$*(/0%( (/$62C ' ,6G% *) '$G%( 0*2)560, 62 4J$6' '2( ,B% %O&%$,7;%$% ,B%$%)*$% G62()/5 *) ,B% &*776E656,J *) '&&'$%2, 62b/$6%7 E%62C

,B% $%7/5, *) 5';)/5 G656,'$J '0,6*23

AB6$,J-)6H% 6G'C%7 ;%$% /&5*'(%( (6$%0,5J ,* ' 7%0/$% 7%$H%$ ',:0/G% V*$%27607 62 ,B% L26,%( W62C(*G )*$ '77%77G%2, EJ 4,%&B%2+*5%< '2 %O&%$, 62 (6C6,'5 6G'C62C3 N, ;'7 0*2)6$G%( ,* ,B% 62Y/6$J,%'G ,B', ,B%7% 6G'C%7 ;%$% 2*, (6C6,'55J '5,%$%(3

X) ,B% )6),J-)6H% ,B*/7'2( T]]


10/31

!"#$%&'#(%)*

!"#$%&'#(%)*"^

!02@


11/31

!"#$%&'#(%)*

!"#$%&'#(%)*""

AB% 6G'C%7 ;%$% 2*, &$*(/0%( 62 ,B% G'22%$ *) %H6(%2,6'$J&B*,*C$'&B7 '7 ;*/5( E% ,'1%2 EJ 0$6G% 70%2% 62H%7,6C',*$7 62 0'7%7

*) (*G%7,60 B*G606(% E/, ;%$% 7'6( ,* B'H% E%%2 &$*(/0%( '7 '$%0*$( *) ,B% (%0%'7%( 62(6H6(/'573 AB%$%)*$% ,B% 6G'C%7 (6( 2*,E%'$ ' 70'5% '2( ,B%$% ;%$% 2* 05*7%-/& 6G'C%7 *) 62(6H6(/'5 62b/$6%73AB% G'b*$6,J *) ,B% 6G'C%7 (6( 2*, 7B*; ,B% E'01 *) ,B% E*(J *) ,B%(%0%'7%( '2( ,B%$%)*$% '2J 62b/$6%7 ,B', G'J B'H% E%%2 &$%7%2, ',,B% E'01 *) ,B% E*(J 0*/5( 2*, E% '77%77%(3

AB% 6G'C%7 ;%$% *25J *) ,B% %O,%$2'5 '7&%0, *) ,B% E*(6%7 '2( 7*

62,%$2'5 62b/$6%7 *$ 62,%$2'5 2',/$'5 (67%'7% 0*/5( 2*, E% 6(%2,6)6%(3

K6H%2 ,B% ,6G% 0*27,$'62,7 /&*2 ,B% 62Y/6$J ,%'G '2( ,B% 5'$C%2/GE%$ *) 6G'C%7 'H'65'E5% 6, ;'7 2*, &*776E5% ,* &$*(/0% ' (%,'65%($%&*$, $%C'$(62C ,B% %O'0, 62b/$6%7 &$%7%2, 62 %'0B 6G'C% )*$ %'0B62(6H6(/'53 AB%$%)*$% ,B% 'E*H% 0',%C*$6g',6*2 ;'7 '(*&,%(3


12/31

!"#$%&'#(%)*

!"#$%&'#(%)*"@

C5 (6/ '@!"2

?!(#4)'8 $. >!,,'* *'#/!"''8 \3 AB% 62Y/6$J ,%'G ;'7 62)*$G%( EJ[+'%7'$\ ,B', )*$ ,B% 5'7, ,B$%% J%'$7 B67 *25J b*E ,*C%,B%$ ;6,B*,B%$7 62 B67 7%0,6*2< ;'7 ,* &B*,*C$'&B '2( (*0/G%2, E*(6%7 *)(%,'62%%7 ;B* B'( E%%2 1655%(3 +'%7'$ ;%2, *2 ,* ,%55 ,B% 62Y/6$J,%'G ,B', B67 b*E ;'7 (6))60/5, '2( 0'/7%( B67 0*55%'C/%7 '2( B6G7%5)[ ?8-(&$,$2!(/, 84..')!"2 \3

AB% &$*0%(/$% ;'7 ,B', ;B%2 (%,'62%%7 ;%$% 1655%( ', ,B%6$ &5'0%7 *)(%,%2,6*2 ,B%6$ E*(6%7 ;*/5( E% ,'1%2 ,* ' G656,'$J B*7&6,'5 ,* ;B60BB% ;*/5( E% 7%2, ;6,B ' (*0,*$ '2( ' G%GE%$ *) ,B% b/(606'$J!,,')8 ($4,* +' ?)$8'(4#'* #$/(&!'0' =48#!(' \3

V%'$62C )*$ B67 56)% '2( ,B', *) B67 6GG%(6',% )'G65J [+'%7'$\

62)*$G%( ,B% 62Y/6$J ,%'G ,B', B% %70'&%( )$*G 4J$6' '2( B%(%70$6E%( B67 %70'&% $*/,%3


15/31

!"#$%&'#(%)*

!"#$%&'#(%)*"]

C%5 (6/ '@ .$) ?'$?,' 1$)>!"2 1!#& #&' )'2!;'!#8',. 1&$ /)' 8-;?/#&'#!( #$ $4) (/48'A \ ] 3

AB% ;6,2%77 62)*$G%( ,B% 62Y/6$J ,%'G ,B', ;B%2 [+'%7'$\ 7,'$,%(,* E% 0*20%$2%( 'E*/, B67 7')%,J< '),%$ B% B'( 7%2, */, ,%27 *),B*/7'2(7 *) 6G'C%7 ,B', ,B67 ;6,2%77 '2( *,B%$7 62 B67 C$*/& E%C'2,* &5'2 )*$ +'%7'$`7 7/00%77)/5 (%)%0,6*23 AB% ;6,2%77 (%70$6E%( B*;+'%7'$ ;'7 %O)65,$',%( )$*G 4J$6' '2( B*; B67 )'G65J )*55*;%( B6G ';B65% 5',%$3 AB% ;6,2%77 (%'5, ;6,B ,B% )'0, ,B', ,B% (%)%0,6*2&$*0%77 ,**1 7*G% )*/$ G*2,B73

> : G%GE%$ *) ,B% 4J$6'2 M',6*2'5 P*H%G%2,3] I/*,%7 )$*G ,B% 0*2,'0, '$% 62 6,'56073


16/31


17/31

!"#$%&'#(%)*

!"#$%&'#(%)*"d

EJ %5%0,$*0/,6*2 *2 7*G% *) ,B% E*(6%73 Z% '00%&, ,B', ,B67 67 '7&%0/5',6H% 0*205/76*23 D*;%H%$< 5**162C ', ,B67 0',%C*$J *) 6G'C%762 56CB, *) '55 ,B% *,B%$ )'0,7< 6205/(62C ,B% )'0, ,B', ,B*7% E*(6%7

;%$% ,*C%,B%$ ;6,B ,B% *,B%$7 ;B* B'( 05%'$5J E%%2 G/$(%$%(< 5%2(77/&&*$, ,* ,B% 0*205/76*2 ,B', ,B%J G%, ,B%6$ %2( ', ,B% B'2(7 *),B%6$ 0'&,*$73

$09/24


18/31

!"#$%&'#(%)*

!"#$%&'#(%)*"c

,B67 162( 67 '57* 0*2767,%2, ;6,B 7,$'2C/5',6*2 E%62C /7%( '7 'G%,B*( *) ,*$,/$%3 AB%$% ;%$% 6G'C%7 *) (%0%'7%( &%$7*2;B%$% 56C',/$% G'$17 ;%$% &$%7%2, *2 ,B% ;$67,7 '2( '215%73 N2

*2% 0'7% ' &5'7,60 0'E5% ,6% ;'7 '$*/2( ,B% '215%7< E%62C /7%('7 ' 56C',/$%3 AB% G'b*$6,J *) ,B% ,$'G562% E$/67%7 ;%$% *2 ,B% ,*$7* fhM*2-7&%06)60 f 9h86C',/$% ] ?h

j%$*62b/$6%7 c ]h=G'06',%( f? 9@h

3/+,' B< :4;;/)- $. !"=4)- #-?'8 )'($)*'* .)$; / *!? 8/;?,' $. BCD !"*!0!*4/,8


29/31


30/31

!"#$%&'#(%)*

!"#$%&'#(%)*?^

)II/2B !5 S.044,9= 01 $09/24


31/31

!"#$%&'#(%)*

'),%$ ,B67 &$*0%77 ,B% E5**( ;655 7B6), ;6,B ,B% 2%; &*76,6*2< E/, '),%$' &%$6*( *) ,6G% ,B% BJ&*7,'767 &%$G'2%2,5J 7,'627 ,B% 7162 T$%)%$$%(,* '7 ,B% BJ&*7,'767 E%0*G62C [)6O%(\U3

&/?08I04

expert review of post-mortem photographs obtained by the syrian opposition

Documents