experiences of primary school in-service teachers undertaking on-line professional learning sessions...

15
Experiences of primary school in-service teachers undertaking on-line professional learning sessions in Kenyan coastal county. Gioko Maina Ph. D. - [email protected] Aga Khan Academy, Mombasa Rosemary Waga B Ed. -[email protected] Aga Khan Primary, Mombasa Experiences of primary school in-service teachers undertaking on-line professional learning sessions in Kenyan coastal county. ABSTRACT Online professional Learning (OPL) has become an option to access profession learning (PL) due to limited opportunities in the developing world. With the Ministry of Education Science and Technology and the in-service teachers service commission demanding for PL for learner to maintain their teaching licenses in Kenya the demand for PL is high against the limited seats and offering as well as lack of time or study leave for the PL. This paper explores the experience of the in-service teachers undertaking OPL to understand their experiences so as to offer information to what the learner goes through. The research was undertaken to learners who had been given opportunities for OPL in a professional development centre. Data collection was through mobile based interviews through the WhatsApp platform. 80 in-service teachers were involved with responses received from 55 in-service teachers. The platform allowed follow-up question through voice, text and video response. The responses were analysed, coded and emerging themes identified and discussed against literature. The finding bought out the following as challenges attitude, competency, connectivity, electrical power, resources, support and time. The learner comes out with innovative ways of addressing the challenges so as to access OPL. The finding confirms the challenges of OPL in developing world according to literature. The innovative approaches to manage the challenges provide an insight to OPL

Upload: giokomaina

Post on 13-Sep-2015

11 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

profession learning (PL) due to limited opportunities in the developing world. With the Ministry of Education Science and Technology and the in-service teachers service commission demanding for PL for learner to maintain their teaching licenses in Kenya the demand for PL is high against the limited seats and offering as well as lack of time or study leave for the PL. This paper explores the experience of the in-service teachers undertaking OPL to understand their experiences so as to offer information to what the learner goes through. The research was undertaken to learners who had been given opportunities for OPL in a professional development centre. Data collection was through mobile based interviews through the WhatsApp platform. 80 in-service teachers were involved with responses received from 55 in-service teachers. The platform allowed follow-up question through voice, text and video response. The responses were analysed, coded and emerging themes identified and discussed against literature. The finding bought out the following as challenges attitude, competency, connectivity, electrical power, resources, support and time. The learner comes out with innovative ways of addressing the challenges so as to access OPL. The finding confirms the challenges of OPL in developing world according to literature. The innovative approaches to manage the challenges provide an insight to OPL providers, educators and designers on the experiences of the in-service teachers. The learner will derive maximum benefits of they are supported to overcome the challenges.

TRANSCRIPT

Experiences of primary school in-service teachers undertaking on-line professional learning sessions in Kenyan coastal county. Gioko Maina Ph. D. - [email protected] Khan Academy, MombasaRosemary Waga B Ed. [email protected] Khan Primary, Mombasa

Experiences of primary school in-service teachers undertaking on-line professional learning sessions in Kenyan coastal county.

ABSTRACTOnline professional Learning (OPL) has become an option to access profession learning (PL) due to limited opportunities in the developing world. With the Ministry of Education Science and Technology and the in-service teachers service commission demanding for PL for learner to maintain their teaching licenses in Kenya the demand for PL is high against the limited seats and offering as well as lack of time or study leave for the PL. This paper explores the experience of the in-service teachers undertaking OPL to understand their experiences so as to offer information to what the learner goes through. The research was undertaken to learners who had been given opportunities for OPL in a professional development centre. Data collection was through mobile based interviews through the WhatsApp platform. 80 in-service teachers were involved with responses received from 55 in-service teachers. The platform allowed follow-up question through voice, text and video response. The responses were analysed, coded and emerging themes identified and discussed against literature. The finding bought out the following as challenges attitude, competency, connectivity, electrical power, resources, support and time. The learner comes out with innovative ways of addressing the challenges so as to access OPL. The finding confirms the challenges of OPL in developing world according to literature. The innovative approaches to manage the challenges provide an insight to OPL providers, educators and designers on the experiences of the in-service teachers. The learner will derive maximum benefits of they are supported to overcome the challenges.

KeywordsProfessional Learning, Online, Training

INTRODUCTION The education landscape is changing in Kenya with Registration of Examination candidates, checking of National Examination results and access of pays slips and salary statement for in-service teachers is all done online. This exemplifies the embracing of technology by the education sector. On the other hand the Ministry of education science and technology (MoEST) and Teacher Service commission (TSC) has offered a directive for in-service teachers to undertake professional learning (PL). This directive has taken a serious angle with a threat to deregister in-service teachers or to demote headteachers who have not attended PL in two years. This has made in-service teachers and school leaders to seek and undertake PL. Over the last few decades there has been increased use of computing devices in educational institutions in developing countries (Trucano, Hawkins & Iglesias, 2012). The use of the web, computer, and mobile-based technologies has drawn a lot of interest among in-service teachers, who use them for educational purposes as well as for social networking. This at least implies a degree of familiarity with these technologies and the skills for using those (Trucano et al., 2012).One challenge has been the availability of PL sessions as the few that are available can only accommodate a small percentage of the in-service teachers. Out of a population of 40 Million people Kenya has 171301 in-service teachers at primary schools and 48.087 at secondary schools. OPL also has the potential to offer access to professional learning to a large number of in-service teachers (Karim & Hashim, 2004). Economic challenges have pronounced the difficulty of paying for PL sessions. OPL has started to emerge in many developing countries where it has the potential to help meet an increasing demand for education and address the growing decline of trained in-service teachers (UNESCO, 2006). This has led to in-service teachers who have access to internet to explore online professional learning (OPL) opportunities. The exploration of OPL is an opportunity to offer PL to in-service teachers who are able to access. OPL offers great flexibility in learning (Kocur & Kosc, 2009). This flexibility provided by the various forms in which the learning material can be presented, allows the in-service teachers a variety of options to learn from at their own pace and time. However this opportunity comes with its challenges. Knowing the challenges the in-service teachers are undergoing will offer insights to professional leaning providers, trainers and other stakeholders on how best to support and facilitate the in-service teachers in OPL. This has led to the question What are the experiences of educators undertaking online professional learning session in a Kenyan county? The focus was in-service teachers undertaking OPL facilitated by professional development centre.

SIGNIFICANCE Positive learning climate and performance expectations affect learner satisfaction, and performance expectations provide the greatest contribution (total effect) to learning satisfaction. Educators will hold positive attitudes towards OPL if they recognize that it would help them improve their learning and teaching effectiveness and efficiency (Rahamat, Shah, Din, Puteh, Aziz, Norman, 2012). Chen and Huang stated that understanding learner attitudes can help expand OPL system functions and meet learner needs, which should further increase the impact of learning and enhance satisfaction with the learning process. Aixia and Wang (2011) found that the vast majority of in-service teachers who were satisfied with an OPL environment held positive believes and attitudes towards it; perceived satisfaction was identified as one of four factors that helped explain 83.8% of the variance of learner attitude. According to Rhema and Miliszewska (2014) OPL and its potential benefits for developing countries have been discussed in the literature, research on user perspectives of OPL in those countries is limited. Given this background to the current situation in Kenyas educational system, its imperative to explore the challenges posed to a successful implementation. LITERATURE REVIEW As indicated by the UNESCO report, the gains from the adoption and implementation of OPL are many and varied among which are the flexibility in learning (Kocur & Kosc, 2009), lower cost compared to on-campus presence, ability to absorb the increasing number of learner, availability of re-usable content, more avenues for human development, increased educational opportunities, among others. Moreover the application of OPL in developing countries has gradually advanced in recent years with an improved availability of Internet connections, local area networks, and IT support (Omidinia, Masrom, & Selamat, 2011). These advantages are however faced with some challenges that are fundamental and critical to a successful implementation in a developing country. It must be noted however that these challenges are not alien to developed economies (Andersson & Grnlund, 2009). Notable among these challenges are infrastructural, technological, financial and institutional support.Bhuasiri, Xaymoungkhoun, Zo, Rho, and Ciganek (2012) found that in developing countries the most significant factors were related to increasing technology awareness and improving attitude toward OPL, enhancing basic technology knowledge and skills, improving learning content, requiring computer training, motivating users to utilize OPL systems, and requiring a high level of support. Moreover in-service teachers characteristics are regarded as a critical success factor in OPL in developing countries (Bhuasiri et al., 2012). These characteristics include computer self-efficacy, Internet self-efficacy, computer experience, Internet experience, computer anxiety, and attitudes toward OPL (Chu & Chu, 2010). In-service teachers attitudes towards OPL have been identified as critical to the success of OPL (Zhang & Bhattacharyya, 2008). Attitudes are influenced by the quality and perceived ease of use of OPL courses, functionality of OPL platforms, and the level of computer skills (Aixia & Wang, 2011). Omidinia, Masrom, & Selamat (2011) identified learner attitudes as a factor that determined how OPL was adopted. In-service teachers computer experience including perceived self-efficacy, enjoyment, and usefulness of using OPL also played a role (Liaw & Huang, 2011). According to Selim (2007) the development of positive attitude is realise by the use of the devices by people who are familiar with web technologies and the skills needed to use computer and mobile devices. In turn, positive in-service teachers attitudes and behaviours towards OPL are critical to their OPL readiness and acceptance (Lim, Hong, & Tan, 2008). In-service teachers attitudes and beliefs towards OPL, as well as their satisfaction with technology and past OPL experiences are regarded as success determinants of future OPL initiatives. In-service teacher levels of access to technologies represent an initial factor that would shape their attitudes towards OPL, and their willingness to use it; the availability of reliable ICTs and the convenience of accessing these technologies reflect learner attitudes toward OPL (Rhema & Miliszewska, 2014). Having access to technology in OPL is evidently an enabling or disabling factor. Access here implies the physical access to a computer, an internet connection, the reliability of the connection and bandwidth, as may be needed to access the full range of the content needed (Burn & Thongprasert, 2005). Sweeney and Geer (2010) found that limited access to ICT constrains learner capabilities, attitudes and experiences. According to Hussain (2007), In-service teachers selected for a study on OPL indicated that they faced many difficulties in accessing ICT facilities and this limited their ability to use technologies. Accessibility of technology tends to affect learner and instructor attitudes and competencies and correlates positively with the level of technology use (Agyei & Voogt, 2011). The in-service teachers ability to use ICTs was significantly hindered by the low level of technology access (Hussain 2007). Many research studies identified correlations between positive computer experience and positive attitudes, competence and comfort with computers (Papaioannou & Charalambous, 2011, Paris, 2004) and an inverse relationship between computer experience and computer anxiety (Olatoye, 2011). Other studies disagreed with these findings and claimed that computer experience did not play a significant role in reducing computer anxiety or developing positive computer attitudes (Felton, 2006).The amount of time in-service teachers have to and want to commit plays an important role in the success of OPL implementation (Agyei & Voogt, 2011). When several activities compete for the attention of the learner, without prioritization and discipline, very little can be realized from an OPL programme. Furthermore, Agyei and Voogt conclude that without making time for studies reading materials, answering test questions, engaging in group assignments among others due to other equally important activities like job and home requirements, the expected impact will not be felt. This would create dissatisfaction, high dropout rates, and a rippling effect of discouraging potential in-service teachers.The academic confidence of a learner can predict the success or failure of a learner in an OPL (Simpson, 2004). Andersson (2008) describe that previous academic experience and qualifications can best describe in-service teachers performance. Where a learners self-efficacy, which is the learners confidence in his or her ability to successfully complete a course, is high, the potential for impacting positively on the success of an OPL implementation can be positive. Where the self-efficacy is low, it can result in difficulties in the implementation. In-service teachers also need to have the necessary computer skills and feel confident in the use of computers (Agyei & Voogt, 2011). The lack of these skills can be a hindrance to learning, especially for in-service teachers who are entirely new to computers as computer confidence accounts for much of the predictive power of good achievements. Many in-service teachers in Kenya have either not been introduced to computers or have a difficult time grasping the concepts and skills due to many factors like no access to computers, little time spent using computers due to the number of in-service teachers wanting to access them. Where this is the case, implementing OPL systems become a challenging task both for the implementers and the users. A stable and supportive study environment affect OPL to a very large extent and some research suggest that this is perhaps the most important factor influencing drop out and retention (Andersson & Grnlund, 2009). Social support can be about the time, and help in-service teachers get from family and friends, and employers for those working. The very nature of OPL that suggests self-study, either in part or whole shows that a conducive environment devoid of distractions and full of support from the home and work place is required. Where there is little understanding of OPL and its contributions to personal, organizational and national development, the denial of this support can negatively affect its implementation. There are claims that contact or intervention from the institution and support from the tutor or other staff improve learning and pass rates (Andersson, 2008). A low level support provision would discourage many people from using an OPL system.

METHODOLOGY An analysis of relationships between learner attitudes towards OPL and their demographic characteristics, access to technology, use of technology for learning, skill in technology, and satisfaction with technology were included. The target group was in-service teachers who were facilitated to access resources and undertake OPL. OPL is a blended model of offering Professional Learning Session where concepts are taught face to face and complimented with online learning, For example teaching comprehension to early years was complimented by an online course from NovoEd which was offered after the session was taught. The whole certificate course was 378 hours over the year and 60 hours out of that was allocated for online learning. The approach was 20% offered by the facilitators to supplement, 30% offered by the facilitators as self-study and 50 % options selected by the course participants. Mobile qualitative researchused to collect data. This was easy and comfortable for the participants as it involved video, audio and text responses. This technique was used to reach in-service teachers who were in a nationwide strike and it had the possibility of follower up.The study aimed to explore the experiences of learner on online professional learning sessions. The study probed deeply and analysed intensively the multifarious phenomenon that constituted OPL (Cohen & Manion, 2000). OPL was approached from a dialectical perspective meaning both the person and the environment were taken into consideration (Valsiner & Van de Veer, 2000). Data is strong in reality; hence the study examined an instant action within a bounded system (Cohen & Manion, 2000). This involved OPL. The study was done to in-service teachers who have been facilitated to undertake OPL either by the course design or facilities support because it afforded an excellent opportunity to discover phenomena within the real world settings in which they occurred (Merriam, 1998). The study was also explorative in nature, the first goal sought to seek information from the learners experiences on OPL, benefits and constraints to develop a holistic understanding of the case. A set of open ended questions were used at the beginning. An evolving working hypothesis emerged (Merriam, 1998); new questions were asked based on the responses and inferences suggested. In the open interviews, relevant themes, descriptors and categories were identified through interpretation of raw data (Jansen, 2010).The open ended questions were posted on the in-service teachers WhatsApp page. The teachers were sent a prompted question in text, audio and video. The teacher would respond in the mode favourable to them. Semi structured, open-ended questions were used; (Wellington, 2000) asserts that in semi structured questions, the interviewer was flexible to ask questions in any order. The in-service teachers responded and the researcher asked follow-up question or clarification to get a deeper response to the questions. According to Hammersley-Fletcher, 2002 repeat interviews allows for refocusing and development of new questions based on the responses offered. The questions adopted a positive stance, with the main prompt to explore the experiences in OPL. The prompting was directed to derive the challenges educators were experiencing and how they were managing them. The series of questioning was uploaded or transcribed depending on data capture until the researchers were satisfied of the depth of the responses. As naturalistic research continued, it was uncommon to change direction and ask new questions (Merriam, 1998). The study was an enquiry, in real life context, where deep investigation involved interdependence of parts and the patterns that emerged (Yin, 2009). In this study, the researcher explored a single phenomenon, which is contemporary with real-life context (Yin , 2009). Therefore, the study was a qualitative, instrumental, exploratory and interpretive case study. The responses were transferred from WhatsApp to email. This allowed the extraction from email to a word processor. The video and audio responses were transcribed and all the text data were organized per aspect and tabulated. The tabulated data were posted on a spread sheet for coding. The codes began with two categories of challenges and approach to overcome the challenges. The second level of coding was based on the description of the response. The final coding was on the nature if the description. The responses were then sorted based on code 2 followed by code 1 and code 3. This allowed a deeper analysis of the responses base on the emerging codes.

FINDINGS AND DISCUSSIONOne of the challenges was on attitude. The challenge on attitude focused on perspective and support (Zhang & Bhattacharyya, 2008). The in-service teachers felt that they did not have the required skills or were not supported adequately by their peers and facilitators (Selim, 2007). Furthermore some of the in-service teachers had thought that virtual environment was not effective in learning (Aixia & Wang, 2011). To overcome the attitude in-service teachers had to change their perspective by reflecting on the possible benefits of OPL.The other challenge was on competency which brought out access, content, knowledge, skills and techniques. According to one respondent Insufficient skills to navigate the net, faulty machines that leads to inefficiency, lack training and resources, uncooperative skilful colleagues /facilitators who are never willing to assist .... 6 January 2015. In-service teachers had difficulties in connecting, navigating and handling the computer while others felt that the online programs were difficult to comprehend (Burn & Thongprasert, 2005,Sweeney & Geer, 2010). The in-service teachers felt that they needed further training on how to operate the computer. To overcome this challenge the in-service teachers sought extra help from their peers and facilitators necessary skills and techniques (Andersson, 2008).The lack of competency influenced the learners confidence (Simpson, 2004.). The learner could not open the laptops or press the keys as they thought they would tamper with the laptops (Rhema & Miliszewska, 2014). The attitude of them being analogue impacted negatively on their confidence (Agyei & Voogt, 2011). To overcome the challenge in-service teachers gained courage and confidence by using the computer for an extended period (Hussain, 2007).Connectivity was a big challenge. Connectivity was seen through lack of access, lack of connectivity, cost, reliability, resources, instability and slow speed (Burn & Thongprasert, 2005). In-service teachers lacked internet at their homes and places of work so they had to travel all the way to the Academy to access OPL. Some went to the internet cafes so as to do the course, internet was also unreliable and slow so the in-service teachers could not be consistent with their work and most of the deadlines were not met. I only manage to finish 1 course...because of network problem...thigh I can assess a laptop network was the biggest challenge.....to overcome that challenge I had to get a modem which had to use airtime...noted a respondent, 6 Jan 2015. Some in-service teachers had no access to modems so doing the course outside the Academy was challenging. To overcome these challenge the in-service teachers decided to access the Academy where internet access was paid for and laptops are availed. At the Academy there were peers who assisted. The in-service teachers managed challenges by maximally utilizing the net when it was strong, and used other connections for example guest Wi-Fi. Other in-service teachers used a modem or visited cybercaf to overcome this challenge.Although OPL was free there were costs involved in travelling to the Academy. This made it expensive, limiting and costly. In-service teachers had some materials to download and found it costly because they used modems which needed airtime and also use airtime on their phones to enable them complete assignments on the course, sometimes the bundles got exhausted before the in-service teachers were through with the assignments or when downloading videos or documents, to overcome this the in-service teachers opted to come to the Academy to gain free access to the net incurring the travelling cost.Some courses were not offering certificates so in-service teachers felt that there was no need of doing such courses. The learner considered the certificate as a credibility indicator for their professional learning (Andersson & Grnlund, 2009). In some cases it was more of the certificate than the skills that they gained. This is because during promotion the certificates would be considered an indicator of professional growth. To manage the certificate issues the organiser only bookmarked OPLs offering certificates.The other challenge was power fluctuation, blackouts, disruptions or poor connections (Hussain, 2007). This interrupted their pacing during the course. To overcome these challenges some in-service teachers ensured that their laptops were fully charged at all times, others used stabilizers or visited the Academy which had a standby generator.Resources played a major part in such as access, availability, cost, reliability and support. Some in-service teachers had no laptops of their own, nor smart phones and the ones that were at the Academy were not enough for everyone, they were on first come first serve basis. Every time the in-service teachers came they were given different laptops this made it impossible to gain access to the work that was saved earlier (Papaioannou & Charalambous, 2011). Some in-service teachers had to purchase smart phones to enable them complete the course. To overcome this challenge some in-service teachers had to take loans to buy laptops or smart phones or saved work on the clouds, others saved to buy PCs. Support was cited as a major challenge in terms of access, competency, delay, lack, quality, accommodation, availability, collaboration, differentiation and motivation. In-service teachers lacked support in terms of online facilitators not responding in good time when asked questions regarding the course, they also felt that it was hard to interact with the online facilitators. Some in-service teachers did not have transport to the Academy Its only that I sometime had to miss for some days due sometimes lack fare Respondent, 6 Jan 2015. In-service teachers also felt that they were at different skill level hence needed a differentiated approach to the course. To overcome these challenges they asked the facilitators to differentiate the course. They also sought help from their peers. The learner demanded support that responded to their needs. The in-service teachers compared the benefits of OPL against the costs involved and sought for funds.Time presented a challenge to the in-service teachers due to alignment, deadlines, management, and quantity (Agyei & Voogt, 2011). The timings of the programmes were sometime not in line with in-service teachers schedules. This made the in-service teachers to miss deadlines. Most in-service teachers had issues with time management. They felt the time was short, limited, and inadequate or time consuming. This could have been a time management issue or it could have been due to the fact that they were also doing a full time job. The in-service teachers tried to manage this challenge by improving on their time management, aligned their schedule and being creative to access more time. This was done by creating time, being disciplined, scheduling work and requesting for more time. A summary of the unique challenges brought a distribution as shown in figure 1. Connectivity, time and competency took prominence. Support and Resources had a mild presence. Cost, attitude, power and credibility was mentioned sparsely as a challenge.

Figure 1 Distribution of Unique challengesThe teachers despite the challenges explore ways of overcoming the challenges. Table 2 presents the distribution of the unique solution implemented by the teachers.

Figure 2 Distribution of Unique SolutionsSupport took prominence as an aspect that the teachers sought to overcome the challenges. Time, connectivity and resources were solutions which we mentioned more after the support. Competency, attitude, cost and power were solutions that were least varied in the solutions that the teachers sought for help.The challenges identified are very similar to the theoretical findings. The difference in the composition of the challenges is due to the contextual realities. The innovative responses to the challenges were driven by the need to access and complete OPL. The igniting aspects was the benefits offered by OPL and the weighting of the certificate earned. The innovative approaches were self-driven by the in-service teachers themselves. It is important to note the importance of intrinsic motivation as most in-service teachers try to find extrinsic motivation. More impactful approaches are contextually designed solutions to the challenges.

CONCLUSIONThe findings in the Kenyan context are very similar to the literature findings. The approaches to overcome the challenges provide insights of what the in-service teachers undergo as they try to get the best out of OPL. Attitude, electrical power competency, connectivity, resources, support and time are critical aspects in OPL. OPL educators, designers and providers need to address these challenges if the OPL is to be beneficial to in-service teachers. The innovative approaches devised by the in-service teachers to address the challenge provide insights on how the OPL educators, designers and providers can support the in-service teachers using contextual solutions. The challenges and the innovative solutions the in-service teachers go through can be used during the design and implementation of the OPL learning environment to enhance access and utility effectively.

REFERENCES Agyei, D. D., & Voogt, J. M. (2011). Exploring the potential of the will, skill, tool model in Ghana: Predicting prospective and practicing in-service teachers use of technology. Computers & Education, 56, 91-100.Aixia, D., & Wang, D. (2011). Factors influencing learner attitudes toward e-learning and development of e-learning environment based on the integrated e-learning platform. International Journal of e-Education, e-Business, e-Management and e-Learning, 1(3), 264-268.Andersson, A. (2008). Seven Major Challenges for e-learning in Developing Countries: Case Study eBIT, Sri Lanka. International Journal of Education and Development using ICT, 4(3).Andersson, A., & Grnlund, A. (2009). A Conceptual Framework in Developing Countries: A Critical Review of Research Challenges,. EJISDC, 38(8), 1-16.Bhuasiri, W., Xaymoungkhoun, O., Zo, H., Rho, J. J., & Ciganek, A. P. (2012). Critical success factors for e-learning in developing countries: A comparative analysis between ICT experts and faculty. Com-puters & Education, 58 (2012),. 58(2012), 843-855.Burn, J., & Thongprasert, N. (2005). A Culture-based model for strategic implementation of virtual education delivery. International Journal of Education and Development using ICT, 1(1).Chu, R. J., & Chu, A. Z. ( 2010). Multi-level analysis of peer support, internet self-efficacy and e-learning outcomes the contextual effects of collectivism and group potency. . Computers & Education, 55 (1), 145-154.Cohen, L., & Manion, L. (2000). Research methods in education. London: Routledge Falmer.Felton, F. S. (2006). The use of computers by primary school principals . PhD Thesis, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia.Hammersley-Fletcher, L. (2002). Becoming a subject leader: Whats in a name? Subject leadership in english primary schools. . School Leadership and Management, 22(4), 407420.Hussain, I. (2007). A study of students attitude towards virtual education in Pakistan. Turkish Journal of Distance Learning, 8 (2), 69-79.Jansen, H. (2010). The Logic of Qualitative Survey Research and its Position in the Field of Social Research Methods . Forum: Qualitative Social Research, 11(2).Karim, M., & Hashim, Y. (2004). The Experience of e-learning Implementation at the Universiti Pendidikan Sultan Idris, Malaysia. Malaysian Online Journal of Instructional Technology, 1(1), 50-59.Kocur, D., & Kosc, P. (2009). E-learning Implementation in Higher Education. Acta_Electrotechnica et Informatica, 9(1), 20-26.Liaw, S. S., & Huang, H. M. (2011). A study of investigating in-service teachers attitudes toward e-learning. 2011 5th International Conference on Distance Learning and Education. 12, pp. 28-32. Singapore: IACSIT Press.Merriam, B. S. (1998). Case study research in education. A qualitative approach. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.Olatoye, R. (2011). Levels of participation in ICT training programmes, computer anxiety and ICT utilization among selected professionals. International Journal of Education and Development using Information and Communication Technology, 7(2), 15-26.Omidinia, S., Masrom, M., & Selamat, H. (2011). Review of e-learning and ICT infrastructure in developing countries (Case study of Iran). American Journal of Economics and Business Administration, 3(1), 120-125.Pagram, P., & Pagram, J. (2006). Issues in e-learning: A Thai Case Study. The Electronic Journal of Information Systems in Developing Countries, 26(6), 1-8.Papaioannou, P., & Charalambous, K. ( 2011). Principals attitudes towards ICT and their perceptions about the factors that facilitate or inhibit ICT integration in primary schools of Cyprus. . Journal of Information Technology Education, 10, 349-369.Paris, P. G. (2004). E-learning: A study on secondary students attitudes towards online web assisted learn-ing. International Education Journal, 5(1), 98-112.Rahamat, R., Shah, P. M., Din, R., Puteh, S. N., Aziz, J. A., Norman, H., et al. (2012). Measuring in-service teachers perceived satisfaction towards e-learning material and environment. WSEAS Transactions on Advances in Engineering Education, 3(9), 72-83.Rhema, A., & Miliszewska, I. .. (2014). Analysis of student attitudes towards e-learning: The case of engineering students in Libya. . Issues in Informing Science and Information Technology, 11, 169-190.Selim, H. M. (2007). Critical success factors for e-learning acceptance: Confirmatory factor models. Computers and Education, 49 (2007), 396413.Simpson, O. (2004.). The impact on retention of interventions to support distance learning students. Open Learning, 19(1).Sweeney, T., & Geer, R. (2010). Student capabilities and attitudes towards ICT in the early years. . Australian Educational Computing,, 25(2010), 18-24.Trucano, M., Hawkins, R., & Iglesias, C. J. (2012). Ten trends in technology use in education in developing countries that you may not have heard about. A World Bank Blog on ICT use in Education. Retrieved 2014 29, December, from Edutech: http://blogs.worldbank.org/edutech/some-more-trends UNESCO. (2006). in-service teachers amd Educational Quality: Monitoring Global Needs for 2015. UNESCO.Valsiner, J., & Van de Veer, R. (2000). The social mind. Construction of the idea. . Cambridge UK: Cambridge university Press.Wellington, J. (2000). Educational research: Contemporary issues and practical approaches. London: Continuum.Yin, Y. K. (2009). Case Study Research: Design and Methods. Thousands Oaks, CA: Sage.Zhang, P., & Bhattacharyya, S. (2008). Students views of a learning management system: A longitudinal qualitative study. The Communications of the Association for Information Systems, 23(2008), 351-374. Biography Gioko Maina is Vice Principal Aga Khan Academy Mombasa. And Project Manage with SESEA programs. Gioko is the Head of the Professional Development Centre which provide professional learning to in-service teachers within the academy and through outreach. The programmes under the centre are Professional Learning for Educators Series, Educating Girls in Science, Teacher Preparation Programme and Learning Tool Kit

**This table has a row height of EXACTLY 3.5cm. The first column (for the photo) is 3cm wide and the second column (for the text) is 11.5 cm wide. The photo is x pixels high and y pie.

Rosemary Waga is SESEA Literacy and Numeracy Coach Aga Khan Education Service, Mombasa. Rosemary supports practicum in-service teachers and mentor in-service teachers as they work together. She also evaluates the learning environments to explore how best it supports teaching, learning and assessment. She is a member of English in-service teachers Language association and a Master trainer and Ambassador with the Learning Tool Kit

CopyrightThis work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/