expanding your problem gambling prevention toolkit
DESCRIPTION
Presented at the Western Regional Conference on Problem Gambling, April 27, 2012. For more information, visit: http://problemgamblingprevention.orgTRANSCRIPT
Expanding Your Problem Gambling Prevention Toolkit
Agenda
• Introductions• Toolkit:
– Workplace: Lisa Miller– Retailers: Shawn Martinez– Middle and High School: Wendy Hausotter– Schools in general: Isabelle Barbour– Awareness Game: Julie Hynes
• Where to find these tools• Wrap up: questions/comments/concerns
• Give you some “tried and true” prevention tools so you can use them where you work
• Save you from reinventing the wheel• Encourage you to use our problem gambling
prevention coordinator’s website• Encourage you to share whatever you come
up with as well!
How We Plan to Meet those Goals
• Briefly introduce you to some problem gambling prevention tools that we have developed
• Give you a chance to talk to the person who developed the activity or strategy
• Show you where and how to find these tools• Offer support and advice if you use them
Introductions - please tell us:
• your name• where you work• what your role is • any particular question you want to be sure
we cover?
Isabelle Barbour, Team LeadHKLB Program, Oregon Public Health
Division
The intersection of grades and health risk factors
Schools have a role in student health
“Health and success in schools are interrelated.
Schools cannot achieve their primary mission of education if students and staff are not healthy and fit physically, mentally and socially.”
National Association of State Boards of Education
High School Graduation is Now a National and State Health Priority
http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/
State level
School district level
School level PrincipalPrincipal
School boardSchool board
SuperintendentSuperintendent
School improvement council
Central office staffCentral office staff
Chief state school officerChief state school officer
State education agency staffState education agency staff
Local government
State board of educationState board of educationLegislatureLegislatureGovernorGovernor
School staffSchool staff
A Complex Cast of Thousands
Adapted from NASBE’s How Schools Work and How to Work with Schools
How tough is school funding getting?
• McCleary v. State (Washington) 2012
• Pendleton v. Oregon 2009
Key Education Tools for Health/Prevention Professionals
• National Association of State Boards of Education (http://nasbe.org)
• How Schools Work and How to Work with Schools• School Health Policy Database
• CDC- Adolescent and School Health (http://www.cdc.gov/HealthyYouth/index.htm)
• Health and Academic Achievement• Coordinated School Health• National Health Education Standards
• Isabelle Barbour, Team Lead, Healthy Kids Learn Better Program, Oregon Public Health Division [email protected] 971-673-0376
The Business Community
Toolkits, resources, and helpful hints for working with this (often overlooked) population
PROBLEM GAMBLING AND THE WORKPLACE
Employee SurveyGAMBLING IN THE WORKPLACE SURVEY
1. Organization Staff Size:___Small (1-10 employees) ___Medium (11-50) employees ___Large (50-100 or more employees)
2. Does your organization have a written or unwritten policy addressing gambling in the workplace?___Yes, we have a written gambling policy.___Yes, we have an unwritten (understood) gambling policy.___No, we do not feel the need to implement any type of gambling policy.___No, but we have thought about implementing one in the future.___I don’t know
3. Have you been concerned in the past or are you currently concerned with someone’s gambling habits (in the workplace or in your personal life)?___Yes ___No
4. Would you like more information for your workplace?___Yes please. My contact information is listed below
___I would like to set up a free on-site training workshop. ___I would like a free problem gambling in the workplace toolkit.
___Other ______________________________________________ ___Not right now, but maybe in the future___No thank you.
75% of employees polled in Marion County
GAMBLING AWAY YOUR BOTTOM LINE… What’s a business to do?
Lisa Miller, CPS Health Educator Problem Gambling and Substance Abuse PreventionMarion County Health Department
Remember: The main
purpose of a business is to
MAKE MONEY.
Training Objectives
Understand connection between gambling related issues and workplace fraud/embezzlement
Be able to recognize signs of problem gambling
Develop policies and procedures to prevent and address problem gambling at the workplace
Identify resources and assistance for coworkers and employees who showing sign of problem gambling
Action Plan
Problem Gambling in Oregon
Over 64% of Oregonians gamble in some way, shape, or form….most without any negative consequences.
Unfortunately, 2.7% may have a problem…
Set the Stage
Problem Gambling in the Workplace
Why should businesses care?
They are thinking it…
why not bring it out in the
open?
A Few Facts on EMBEZZLEMENT
Highest percentage of embezzlers were women
Men embezzled much larger amounts
Embezzlers most likely to hold financial positions with in organization
(from 2010 Marquet report)http://www.marquetinternational.com/
Interesting applicable tidbits…
A Few Facts on EMBEZZLEMENT
Only 5% of embezzlers have a criminal record
Gambling is a clear motivating factor in driving some major embezzlements (22% of all cases involve perpetrators who reportedly had gambling problems)
(from 2010 Marquet report)
…tie into gambling
& workplace
The Problem Gambling and Crime Connection
Moore (2009). More than one in three (35%) clients enrolled in
treatment reported committing illegal acts to finance their gambling.
Smith, Wynne, & Hartnagel (2003) Gambling related crime was responsible for 2.7%
of Edmonton police records in 2001. National Gambling Impact Study Commission
(1999). A third of problem and pathological gamblers had
been arrested, compared to 10% of low-risk gamblers and 4% of non-gamblers
Government/Education/Non-ProfitIn Oregon (2006-present): Bend: Postal Service, $156,000 (lead sales associate) Central Point: Court Clerk, $73,000, (Central Point Municipal Court) Hubbard: Postal Service, Undisclosed amount, case pending (Rural Postal Carrier), Pendleton: US Forest Service, $642,000 (firefighter) West Linn: City of West Linn, $1.4 million (finance director)
Throughout US (2008-present): California: Business Manager, $422,000 (Orange County School District)* Connecticut: Athletic Department official, $1.4 million (US Coast Guard)* Connecticut: Secretary, $200,000 (Connecticut Department of Developmental Services) Illinois: Assistant Controller, $580,000 (American Inter-Continental University)* Illinois: Library Clerk, $135,000 (Posen Public Library District) Nevada: Court Clerk, $202,000 (Washoe County District Court) Oklahoma: Accountant, $425,000 (Hinton Economic Development Authority) Oklahoma: $450,000 (Oklahoma Secondary School Activities Association)* Pennsylvania: Municipal Secretary, $389,000 (Springfield Township) Pennsylvania: Tax Collector, $224,000 (Lower Swatara Township) Washington: Cashier, $800,000 (Clallam County Treasurers Office) Washington: Assistant Finance Director, $1.3 million (City of Arlington)
“That only happens in
small businesses”
To keep current on news stories, try GOOGLE ALERTS. Sign up at http://www.google.com/alerts/create?hl=en
Financial InstitutionsIn OREGON (2005-present): Aloha: Bank Teller, $939,000 (US Bank) Portland: Assistant Manager, $800,000 (First American Title
Insurance)
Throughout US (2008-11): California: Bank Manager, $679,000 (Citizens Business Bank) California: Branch Manager, $178,000 (BBVA Compass Bank) California: Business Relationship Officer, $236,000 (United
Commercial Bank)* Georgia: Head Teller, $625,000 (MidSouth Federal Credit Union) Kansas: Chief Financial Officer, $800,000 (Summit America
Insurance Services, Inc) Michigan: Bank Teller, $600,000 (Huntington National Bank) Missouri: Teller/Loan Secretary, $414,000 (Bank Northwest) Nevada: Vice President, $3.7 million (National Bank of Ely) * North Carolina: Bank Manager, $270,000 (Piedmont Bank) South Dakota: Bank Teller, $166,000 (American Bank and Trust)
Who is your audience? Be
ready with specific examples when
possible…
Private BusinessIn Oregon (2006-present): Beaverton: Financial Planner, $563,000 (Financial Planning) Eugene: Bookkeeper, $1.5 million (Transition Management Inc) Hillsboro: Bookkeeper, $500,000 (Tigard Furniture Store) Klamath Falls: Cashier, $160,000 (Walmart Cash Office) Newberg: Bookkeeper, $130,000 (Newberg Furniture Store) Newport: Business Manager, $122,000 (Nursing Home) Roseburg: Secretary, $140,000 (Days Creek) Salem: Lead Bookkeeper, $742,000 (Superior Tire Company) Springfield: Accounts Payable Clerk, $1.5 million (IP/KOKE Printing) Washington County: Bookkeeper, $275,000 (Easy Street Online IT Services)
Throughout US (2008-present): Arkansas: Executive Director, $756,000 (Upper Southwest Solid Waste
District)* Illinois: Bookkeeper, $1.5 million (ENR General Machining Co.) Kentucky: Used Car Manager, $1 million (Toyota Car Dealership) Louisiana: Office Manager $206,000 (Ark La Tex Farms, Inc) Nebraska: Manager, $154,000 (Joe Tess Place, Seafood Restaurant) New York: Bookkeeper, $617,000 (Eastern Star Home & Campus) Washington: Billing Clerk, $263,000 (Maersk, Inc)
$10,000 loss for a small
business might compare to
$1million loss for large.
Sandy4th grade teacher
PamFormer Credit Union VP(incarcerated for embezzlement)
WarrenCornell University
Economics Degree
THE HIDDEN ADDICTIONWhat does a Problem Gambler look like?
• Often high functioning and bright
• Usually employed
• Often not the typical user of social services
•No obvious physical signs of addiction (i.e. a person can’t
OD from too much gambling )
Jane Grandmastole 250K to gamble
Source: National Council on Problem Gambling voices of recovery http://www.ncpgambling.org/
Humanize the issue….everyday people working in variety of fields
I was going to pay it back after the big
win…
STORIES FROM THE FIELD
Employee accused of embezzling $140,000
Roseburg, OR - Douglas County authorities arrested a Days Creek secretary accused of embezzling almost $140,000 from her employer to support a gambling habit.
~ The Statesman Journal, Jan 9, 2010
Local furniture stores takes a loss
Hillsboro, OR - Bookkeeper for Tigard furniture store pleaded guilty to aggravated theft for stealing over $500,000 to support a gambling habit at casinos.
~The Oregonian, Oct 15, 2009
Newberg, OR – The owner of a Newberg furniture store said he was shocked when he learned his bookkeeper was suspected of embezzling nearly $130,000. She told investigators she spent all the money gambling in bars and casinos.
~KPTV.com, February 9, 2010
What Causes Problem Gambling?
Public Health ModelVs. Fraud/Embezzlement
Triangle
The Fraud/Embezzlement Triangle
FRAUDEmbezzlement
Rationalization
Motivation
Opportunity
Workplace policies and procedures: is the business fostering an
environment that fraud thrives in?
Negative Effects of Problem Gambling
48% indicate suicidal thoughts
34% indicate alcohol-related problems
13% indicate drug-related problems
57% indicate they jeopardized or lost significant relationship or job because of gambling
38% committed illegal acts to obtain gambling money
As reported by the 1,861 gamblers who received publicly funded treatment in Oregon 2008-09
Workplace
Wellness? Caring
about employees health...
Is Your Business Safe?
Theft/Fraud happening all around Occurs in Small and Large Businesses Extreme cases highlighted in the news Prevention is key
Only 19% of businesses have formal policy on workplace gambling(Society for Human Resource Management
http://www.shrm.org/Pages/Default.aspx )
Recognizing Signs of Problem Gambling
How will you know?
Indicators
Increase in gambling time and places Increase in size of bets Working up special occasions for gambling Intensity of interest in gambling Boasting wins; evading loses Exaggerated display of money
and other possessions
Indicators (cont.)
Gambling when there is a crisis Drop off in other activities/interests Frequent absences from school,
work and home Excessive phone use Withdrawal from family Personality changes (irritability/hostility) Diversion of funds earmarked for other
purposes
Workplace signs of a gambling problem
Work performance deteriorates(pre-occupied, trouble concentrating, absent
or late for meetings, misses assignment deadlines)
Frequent unexplained absences or disappearances from work.
Eager to organize and participate in betting opportunities.
Workplace signs of a gambling problem
Frequently borrows money, argues with co-workers about money that is owed to them.
Complains about mounting debts.
Excessive use of the telephone for personal calls.
Experiences mood swings, often related to winning and losing streaks.
Credit card or loan bills are mailed to work rather than home.
Workplace signs of a gambling problem
Increasing time spent gambling during lunch hour and coffee breaks .
Requesting pay in lieu of vacation time.
Making false claims against expense accounts.
Theft of property.
Effects on the workplace
A problem gambler primarily affects the workplace through
Lost Time
Lost Productivity
Theft, Fraud and Embezzlement
Workplace Interventions
OK, so we can recognize signs…now what are we suppose
to do?
First Line of Defense is often Co-Workers
The challenge is to identify the problem gambler before they become desperate.
What can supervisors do?
Use work-related observations
Explain how the problem affects you
Provide information,
not advice
Documentation…treat as a performance issue rather than personal issue.
What can organizations do?
Create/update policy statements Provide employee awareness training Make financial counseling available Monitor the money stream
What do you want them to do? Small
easy action steps…
Sample Policy Language
Employees shall not participate, while on (business name) owned or leased property or while on duty, in any gambling activity (that is not an approved charitable fund-raiser).
Gambling activities approved by the Director’s office must be accompanied by reference to, or information on, where employees may go to seek help for a gambling problem.
Employees shall be informed that free, confidential treatment for gambling problems is available throughout the State via the Oregon Problem Gambling Helpline (1-877-MY LIMIT).
Local partner, Cascade Employers Association, helped create this sample policy. Do you have a partner to collaborate with?
Education and Awareness
Posters in Break Room
Annual in-service training
Email / Newsletter
Offer EAP services
Find out what will work best for individual businesses you are working with…they are
not One Size Fits All
Breakroom Posters
Envelope
stuffers
Problem Gambling Help Line:Statewide, 24hr, free and confidential hotline staffed by
professional counselors
Phone: 1-877-MY-LIMIT Online: http://1877mylimit.org/ (chat, IM, email)
Marion County Problem Gambling Treatment Provider:
Bridgeway Recovery Services, Salem, OR, provides in/out patient treatment for problem gamblers in recovery.
Phone: 503.362.2021Online: http://www.bridgewayrecovery.com/index.html
Need more?
Lisa Miller, CPSPrevention Services, Marion County Health Department976 N. Pacific Hwy Woodburn, OR 97071Phone: 503-981-2461 Email: [email protected]: http://www.co.marion.or.us/HLT/ad/gambling/
Keep in touch. You never know when they may need to refer back
to what you just told them.
Reward and RemindersLottery Scratch Tickets
Reward and Reminder
Evidence Based Strategy effectively used for Alcohol and Tobacco retailers, many of whom are lottery retailers as well.
Focus Teen Council
Working to make a positive impact in our community and in the lives of other youth by supporting a healthy, Drug
Free lifestyle
Lottery Scratch Tickets
Clerk SaleVending Machine Sales
CONDUCTING REWARD AND REMINDER VISITS
Student/ Parent training
Parent and Student consent form signed and returned
Practice
Clerk Sales
Students only have one dollar in cash with them and ID
Two students enter store with adult advisor following behind
One student picks up an item that is $1 of less At counter student ask for scratch ticket. At no
time does the student pick up the ticket If the clerk gets the ticket, totals the sale and
asks for money student say they don’t have enough money, pays for item and the second student reminds them that lottery tickets cannot be purchased by anyone under the age of 18
If the clerk asks for ID, show it If the clerk does not sell, give them their reward
and thank the clerk for not selling
Clerk Sales
Never lie If they are in a tough situation leave
the store If student is uncomfortable for any
reason – leave The students fill out the data form
with information from the visit
JUST A REMINDER!One in every 25 Oregon teens (13-17 year olds) is a problem or at
risk gambler– that’s more than 10,000 Oregon teens. REMEMBERORS 461.600 Sales to minors. (1) Tickets or shares in lottery
games, including tickets or shares sold from vending machines or other devices, may not be sold to a person under 18 years of age.
ORS 461.300 Selection of retailers; rules; contracts (4) The director may terminate a contract with a lottery game retailer based on the grounds for termination included in the contract or commission rules governing the contract. The grounds for termination must include, but are not limited to, the knowing sale of lottery tickets or shares to any person under the age of 18 years or knowingly permitting a person under the age of 21 years to operate a video lottery game terminal.
REMINDER SLIP
REWARD
GIFT CARD (coffee, pizza, subway) T-shirt Coffee Mug Keychain Pencil / Pen
Vending Machine
Students only have one dollar in cash with them and ID
Two students enter store with adult advisor following behind
One student locates the vending machine One of the students put $1 in machine Students may not lie if asked age or date of
birth Second student is just observing employees or
others in store If the machine sells a ticket to student it is
handed to the adult
Vending Machine
Never lie If they are in a tough situation
leave the store If student is uncomfortable for any
reason – leave The students fill out the data form
with information from the visit
FOLLOW UP AFTER VISITS
Letter to store owner manager Congratulation Regretfully Information to share with employees
Any scratch tickets purchased are sent to State Lottery Commission
REWARD AND REMINDER
In 2007 Southern Oregon Drug Awareness conducted 100 reward and reminder visits of lottery scratch ticket retailers in Medford, Phoenix, Talent, Ashland, Central Point, White City, Eagle Point, Jacksonville, Rogue River, Trail, Prospect and Butte Falls.
100% SELLS FROM MACHINES
REWARD AND REMINDER
FOCUS TEEN COUNCIL MEMBERS AGE 13-17
25 visits – 5 clerk, 20 vending machines
NO SALES!
Observations
Youth felt some of the vending machine were in hidden areas or not in sight of any employees to monitor.
Youth felt if someone wanted a ticket they could push the button that says they are over 18.
Some of the machines were by customer service and when they put money into the machine or was looking at the machine with employees or other adults close by no one said anything to the youth.
Lottery ticket machine (RIGHT) is out of sight of cashier, whereas movie machine (LEFT) is in sight
Placement of Lottery machine next to movie machine draws kids’ interest
Contact Information
Shawn Martinez, CPSJosephine County Prevention
541-951-9399 cell
• 1 in 175• 1 in 175,000
• 1 in 175 million• 1 in 175 billion
1 in 175 Million(174,233,510)
Odds of getting struck by lightning:
1 in 280,000
Name at least 2 consequences that
someone may experience due to his/her gambling
problem
• Debt• Crime• Depression/Suicide• Relationship problems• Employment problems• Alcohol and/or drug problems
• Sports bets• Lottery tickets• Video & online• Bingo & raffles
Video lottery
& online gambling
Electronic Gambling
89% Cards6%
Other5%
Gambling Treatment ClientsGamblers' Preferences
• 18• 25
• 21• 65
At what age is the
brain considered
fully developed?
Source: Brain Briefings (2007, October), Society for Neuroscience, Washington, DC
Gambling & The “Doped” Brain
Decisions that will likely cause us to lose money vs. win money
Where can I find these materials?
www.problemgamblingprevention.org
Wrap up
Questions?Comments?Concerns?
Check out the websiteContact us for help or adviceShare what you come up with
Onward we go!
• Check out the website• Contact us for help or advice• Share what you come up with
Thanks for your time and attention!