exhibit 7 part 1 of 9 - kcc class actionclassaction.kccllc.net/documents/nwd0001/576-7 -...

EXHIBIT 7 Part 1 of 9

Case 1:13-cv-06802-WHP Document 576-7 Filed 07/13/16 of 17

KELLOGG, HUBER, HANSEN, TQDD, EVANS 8< FIGEL, P.L.L.C.SUMNER SQUARE

161 5 M STREET. N.WSu|TE 4OO

WAsH|NGToN. D.C. 20036-321 5

(202)326-7900FACSIMILE

(202)326-7999

September 22, 2014

Christopher SignorelloSC JohnsonHenkel CorporationOne Henkel WayRocky Hill, CT 06067

Re: Henkel/Dial, et al. V. News America (Matter #: 12137)

Dear Christopher:

Enclosed is the bill for our work regarding the above referencedmatter for the month ended June 30, 2013. The total bill comes to$514,829.07, including $507,973.75 for lawyer and paralegal time and$6,855.32 for disbursements.

Please give me a call if you have any questions.

Sincerely,

Enclosure

Steven F. Benz


KELLOGG, HUBER, HANSEN, TODD, EVANS 8< FIGEL, P.L.L.c

Christopher SignorelloSC JohnsonHenkel CorporationOne Henkel WayRocky Hill, CT 06067

Re: Henkel/Dial, et al. v. News America (12137)

For Professional Services rendered through June 30, 2013

John ThorneSteven F. BenzSteven F. BenzAaron M. PannerDerek T. HoSteven F. BenzWilliam J. ConynghamJustin M. PresantBeverly C. MooreDrew A. NavikasJustin M. PresantJames H. MoranMelanie L. BostwickRobert A. RoeThomas B. SamuelsBernadette M. MurphyBernadette M. MurphyJonathan A. RabkinMax D. BrandyDavid K. HausmanJ. Tyler FirmageKyle W. ChowRipton A. MariniAndrew J. Clarke

Total Professional Services

DisbursementsAirfareBusiness MealsCar RentalConsultantCourt FeesDeliveryHotel

Page 2

2

75.1861.5.

202.4

1351.

203.5817.5

7.2.1.0

23.9.0.21.8

6.24.

.0025.25505050.25.250000.7500.25005075.7550257575

.000075

945.800.760.685.665.660.525.360.350.350.350.330.330.330.330.245.240190.190.185.115.100.85.75.

00000000000000000000000000000000.0000000000000000

August 1, 2014Invoice # 2008217379

EIN 52-1811709

Amount1,60,141,

1,3,

133,2,

48,

71,20,

5,1,2,

4,1,2,

1,507,

1,

1,

890.200.550.027.657.650231.690.350.050.562.610.732310.825.428.180465.757.138.501.800.510.856.

973.

044.267.35.634.18.88.151.

0000005050.00250000005000.50000075.0000507525000025

75

00252150002345

Timekeeper Hours Rate


Long DistanceOnline ResearchOut of Town Travel ExpensesPhotocopiesTaxi CabTrainfare

Total Disbursements

Net Amount Due

Page 3

2,

6/

514,

13.881.

38315.134.233.

855.

829.

5263

.00609300

32

07

SC JohnsonHenkel/Dial, et al. V. News America

August 1, 2014Invoice # 2008217379


Professional Services

02/08/10

02/17/10

SFB

SFB

02/17/10 RAR

02/18/10

02/19/10

02/22/10

02/23/10

02/23/10

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

Edit News Corporation litigationanalysis memorandum to s.Levensen.

Conferences with counsel atWalgreens, CVS, and Rite Aidregarding News case; meet with R.Roe; conferences with partners.

Meet with S. Benz regarding NewsCorporation litigation; reviewpleadings in competitor suits andoutline f actual basis for causesof action; search for potentialdirect purchasers who would beconsidered middle men or couponbrokers vis a vis the CPGcompanies; identify potential CPGplaintiffs; review news articlesregarding competitor suits anddraft KHHTEF letter to potentialclass representatives.

Conference with S. Berry and J.Netz regarding News directpurchasers; prepare packet for D.Murphy of CVS; conference with J.Mackie-Mason (Valassis exper t).

Review Valassis trial transcriptfor News Corporation directpurchasers; draft memorandum andletter to D. Shaw from Heinz.

Conference with J. Comitale (RiteAid); prepare packet regardingNews Corporation.

Conference with J. Comitale (RiteAid), conference with V. Bomar(Sara Lee); conference with S.Levensen (Walgreens).

Conference with J. Comitale (RiteAid) , conference with V. Bomar(Sara Lee), conference with S.Levensen (Walgreens).

Page 4

Hours0.50

1.50

7.00

2.00

1.00

1.00

1.00

1.00

SC JohnsonHenkel/Dial, et al. v. News America

August 1, 2014Invoice # 2008217379


02/24/10

02/25/10

02/26/10

03/01/10

03/02/10

03/03/10

03/05/10

03/07/10

03/08/10

03/09/10

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

Conference with V. Bomar; preparepacket for Sara Lee and Rite Aid.

Prepare News Corporation analysismemoranda for J. Comitale and V.Bomar; conference with D. Murphyfrom CVS regarding damages.

Conference with D. Shaw regardingNews case; draft News PowerPointfor CVS; conference with D. Murphyregarding presentation to CVSmanagement.

Conference with J. Finocharo andJ. Cavanagh; prepare and send NewsCorporation packets to theforegoing.

Prepare potential case clientContact list.

Edit News Corporation Powerpointfor cvs; telephone calls tocounsel at Procter & Gamble,Heinz, Sara Lee, and PepsiCo; editContact list.

Telephone calls to counsel atClorox, Abbott Labs, Coca Cola,and Alberto Coloer; review CVScontacts; edit CVS Powerpoint;prepare and send memorandumpackages to R. Barack and M.McQueeney of Clorox and Coca Cola.

Travel from Washington, D.C. toWoonsocket, Rhode Island formeeting with CVS legal counsel.

Meet with D. Murphy and H. Devlinat CVS Caremark headquarters inWoonsocket, Rhode Island; reviewCVS contracts with NewsCorporation; travel fromWoonsocket, Rhode Island toWashington, D.C.

Telephone call with S. Levensen ofWalgreens; send memorandum packageto Abbott Labs; prepare package

Page 5

1.

4.

1.

0.

0.

2.

1

2.

5.

00

00

00

50

50

00

50

50

00

.00


August 1, 2014Invoice # 2008217379


03/10/10

03/11/10

03/17/10

03/23/10

03/24/10

03/25/10

04/14/10

04/19/10

04/27/10

05/05/10

05/06/10

05/07/10

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

for Frito Lay.

Telephone calls to counsel atWalgreens, Sara Lee, PepsiCo, RiteAid, and Coca Cola.

Send News memorandum packets toconference call with R.Frito Lay;

Barack of Clorox; review ThemePromotions, Inc. competition case.

Telephone call with S. Berry andG. Baruch regarding News forumselection clause and CVS venuememorandum; telephone call to J.Suarez of Procter & Gamble.

Conference call with R. Barack atClorox regarding News case.

Review News forum selectionmemorandum; telephone calls toCoca Cola, Abbott Labs, Rite Aid,and Sara Lee.

Conference call with D. Beckregarding News case.

Prepare and send News casememorandum for J. Espindi, G.Schmidt, and Alber to-Culver(General Counsel)

Conference with M. McQueeney (CocaCola assistant General Counsel)regarding News case;

Edit draft complaint; conferencewith S. Berry.

Conference with D. Steel (HomeDepot Senior Counsel forlitigation) regarding News case.

Conference with D. Davis (officeDepot General Counsel) regardingNews case; update News contactswith potential clients.

Conference with F. Greenfield(Campbell'S antitrust Counsel) and

Page 6

2

0

0

0

1

0.

0.

0

1

0

0.

0

.00

75

75

.50

00

25

50

25

00

.25

50

.25


August 1 2014Invoice # 2008217379


05/12/10

05/13/10

05/14/10

05/19/10

05/24/10

05/27/10

05/28/10

06/07/10

06/08/10

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

Chung Bak (Campbell's CorporateCounsel) regarding News case.

Conference with D. Shaw (Heinzcounsel) regarding News case;conference with M. McQueeney (CocaCola); telephone calls with J.Espinili (Alberto Culver), S.Pendushi (Abott Labs), v. Bomas(Sara Lee); J. Savez (Proctor &Gamble).

Conference with H. Suarez (Procter& Gamble); conference with D. Shaw(Heinz), M. McQueeney (Coca Cola)regarding News caseconfidentiality.

Conference with D. Murphy (CVSassistant General Counsel)regarding News caseconfidentiality.

Conference with M. McQueeney(Coca-Cola) regarding News case;send memorandum to W. Barnette(Home Depot).

News case development call with D.Murphy (CVS), D. Shaw (Heinz), andF. Greenfield (Campbells Soup).

Conference call with D. Lof ty (SCJohnson) regarding News Case.

Conference with D. Lofty (SCJohnson), F. Greenfield(Campbells), D Murphy (CVS), andD. Shaw (Heinz) regarding Newscase; prepare Campbell's Soupconfidentiality agreement.

Prepare damages analysis for F.Greenfield (Campbells' Soup),conference with C. Carlson, S.Schoal (Tysons Foods) regardingNews case; prepare confidentialityagreement for General Mills (A.Gulavi), review of News case.

Telephone call with M. McQueeney

Page 7

1.00

1.00

0.25

0.25

1.00

0.50

1.00

1.00

0.50


August 1, 2014Invoice # 2008217379


06/15/10

06/18/10

06/22/10

06/24/10

06/25/10

06/28/10

07/08/10

07/09/10

07/13/10

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

(Coca Cola) regarding distributorsfor News Case; prepareconfidentiality agreement forTysons' Foods.

Edit and send News Case powerpointto S. Schaal at Tysons Foods.

Edit News case PowerPoint for S.Schaal (Tysons Foods).

Conference with D. Lofty, GeneralCounsel, and SC Johnson regardingNews Case.

Conference with D. Lofty (SCJohnson) regarding News case.

Prepare and send News case damagesestimates for D. Loft and SCJohnson.

Meet with Campbell General CounselEllen Kagan, Senior LitigationCounsel B. Subcow, assistantGeneral Counsel F. Greenfieldregarding News case; travel fromWashington D.C., to Camden, NewJersey.

Telephone calls with J. Tennenburg(Toys R. Us), C. Flippen (JCPenney), and D. Garrett (SportsAuthority) regarding News case;prepare News case memorandum forToys R US.

Finalize News Case memoranda andpackets for J. Tennenburg (Toys RUs) and C. Flippin (JC Penney),conference with D. Davis (PetcoGeneral Counsel) regarding theforegoing; prepare and send Newsmemorandum and packet to D. Davis.

Conference with H. Bak regardingCampbells in store promotionservices; prepare News casepackage for D. Garrett (SportsAuthority), conference with E.Bunzel (Kohls)

Page 8

0.50

0.75

0.25

0.25

0.50

7.25

1.75

2.00

1.00


August 1 2014Invoice =H= 2008217379


07/14/10

10/12/10

10/14/10

10/15/10

10/18/10

10/19/10

10/20/10

10/21/10

10/22/10

10/25/10

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

Conference with H. Bak (Campbells)regarding News memorandum edits.

Prepare and finalize News casePowerPoint for E. Sagehorn andTysons management.

Travel roundtrip from Washington,D.C. to Minneapolis, MN; meet withA. Gulati, S. Ruble, J. O'Donnell(General Mills), and M. Gustaferroregarding regarding News case.

Prepare News case memoranda andcompile Contact information forKelloggs, Danone, Kimberly-CorkCorporation, and Unilever;conference with S. Berry.

Finalize and send News casepackets to General Counsels ofKelloggs, Danone, Unilever, andKimberly-Clark Corporation.

Finalize and send News caseanalysis to Brian Chevlin, R.Soeifer, and T. Lovell atUnilever.

Conference with Ari Gulati(General Molls) regarding Newscase and Unilever interest;conference with B. Chevlin(Unilever) regarding News case.

Conference with T. Monroe atKellogg regarding News case;conference and send Valassistranscripts to B. Chevlin atUnilever; send Valassis transcriptto Sagehorn at Tysons.

Review Valassis state News caseargument transcript; conferencewith E. Sagehorn (Tysons' GeneralCounsel), conference with S.Berry; edit Tyson's NDA for Newscase

Sign Tysons NDA for News case;

Page 9

0.

0.

10

1.

1.

1.

0.

1.

1.

3.

25

50

.00

00

00

00

50

00

00

00


August 1 2014Invoice # 2008217379


10/26/10 SFB

10/27/10 SFB

10/28/10 WJC

10/29/10 SFB

11/01/10 SFB

11/02/10 WJC

send to E. Sagehorn (Tysons);conference with D. Everson(Stinson, Morrison and Hecker)regarding Unilever News claim;conference with B . Conyngham andS. Berry regarding News CaseValassis database;send powerpointGeneral Counsel

Finalize Tysonsconference with(Tysons General

prepare andto Don Lofty,for SC Johnson.

Foods NDA;E. SagehornCounsel) regarding

NDA and powerpoint; Conferencewith T. Monroe (Kellogg) regardingNews case; finalize supplementalpresentation for SC Johnson andDon Lofty (General Counsel);finalize supplementalpresentations for D. Shaw andHeinz.

Prepare powerpoint regarding Newscase and send to T. Monroe and D.Ball at Kellogg; update News casetracking chart spreadsheet; sendupdated powerpoint to FaithGreenfield (Campbells).

Review NewsCorp Evaluationmemoranda; arrange login andassignment to download Vassallistrial transcript, exhibits, andvideos.

Lunch with H. Callums regardingNews case; provide Proctor &Gamble information to S. Berry forNews case; review Henkels Newstrade spend; update News potentialclient contacts chart; checkbilling rates for retentionletters.

Prepare News powerpoint for C.Signorello and Hankel; prepare forTysons and E. Sagehorn News casemeeting.

News begin training of AndrewClarke to assist in Vallassis

Page 10

3.00

1.75

0.75

1.50

1.00

1.50


August 1 2014Invoice # 2008217379


SC JohnsonHenkel/Dial,

11/03/10 SFB

11/04/10 SFB

11/04/10 MLB

11/05/10 SFB

11/05/10 MLB

11/08/10 SFB

11/09/10 SFB

11/09/10 MLB

August 1, 2014

trial review.

Prepare for and meet with E.Sagehorn, S. Berry, R. George, H.Johnson, K. Baker, M. Bond, B.Welcsh, and Tysons Foods GeneralCounsel regarding News case;conference with E. Sagehorn andothers regarding News contractfrom selection clause.

Meet with L. Taylor regardingconflicts check for News case

conference(Kelloggs, Tysons);with A. Gulati, and R. Allendorf(General Mills) regarding Newscase

Meet with S. Benz regardingresearch on forum selectionclauses (News Matter)

Related case and venue researchfor News case; conference with M.Bostwick regarding the same.

Research enforcement of forumselection clauses for cer tainplaintiffs in related orconsolidated cases (News Matter)

Conference with S. Elwoodregarding Frito Lay participationin News case; conference with L.Fauchald regarding General MillsNews case meeting; conference withJ. Min (Kellogg) regarding Newsclaim meeting; prepare Kelloggconfidentiality agreement for Newscase

Edit venue analysis for relatedcases and forum selection for Newscase; conference with s. Berry andM. Bostwick regarding the same;prepare supplemental Newspresentation for General Millsboard and antitrust counsel.

Research enforcement of forumSelection clauses in certain

Page ll

5.25

1.00

0.25

1.75

1.00

2.00

2.00

1.00

et al. v. News America Invoice # 2008217379


11/10/10 SFB

11/11/10 SFB

11/11/10 MLB

11/12/10 SFB

11/12/10 MLB

11/14/10 SFB

potential class members' contracts(News matter)

Prepare for General Mills Newscase meeting; conference with J.Min (Kellogg) regarding News casemeeting; review transcripts in ATTMobility v. Conception oralargument regarding class actionwaiver in arbitration agreement;meet with M. Bostwick; editmemorandum on forum selection andrelated case doctrine; conferencewith E. Sagehorn (Tysons); checkTyson's News contract limitationof liability and forum selectionclauses.

Edit forum selection and relatedcase memorandum for News clients;conference with E. Sagehorn(Tysons) regarding News contractforum selection provision;conference with D. Lofty (SCJohnson) regarding budget anddocument review for News case;prepare for Kelloggs News meeting;review and circulate Nestlesupplemental production from 1999to 2000.

NEWS Research and draft memorandumanalyzing effect of forumselection clauses on ability tokeep all cases in Michigan federalcourt.

Finalize edits to News case formselection and related casememorandum; circulate to S. Berry;conference with E. Sagehorn(Tysons) regarding enforceabilityof tremble damages waivers.

NEWS Draft memorandum analyzingeffect of forum selection clauseson ability to keep all cases inMichigan federal court.

Finalize and send News Forumselection change memorandum to D.

Page 12

2.60

2.00

2.00

1.00

1.00

1.00


August 1 2014Invoice # 2008217379


case with Steve


11/15/10 SFB

11/15/10 WJC

11/16/10 SFB

11/16/10 RAM

11/17/10 SFB

11/17/10 RAM

11/18/10 SFB

11/23/10 SFB

August 1, 2014

Murphy (CVS General counsel), sendNews Forum selection clausememorandum to E. Sagehorn(TysonS);sent to E.

review News memorandumSagehorn (Tysons)

regarding table damage waiver .

Follow-up meeting regarding NewsBerry, Ari Gulati ,

and Janice McBride (Deputy Generalcounsel) (General Mills);conference with E. Sagehorn (TysonFoods) regarding News NY Forumselection clause.

Supervise and assist A. Colarkewith download of Valassis trialmaterials.

Prepare powerpoint for Newsmeeting with Kellogg Co.,conference with J. min (Kellogg)regarding News meeting; SearchDepartment of Justice and FFCdatabases for News investigations.

Print News Corporation exhibits.

News meeting at Kellogg with TomMoore (Head of litigation), BethBremer (Procurement), John Min(Assistant General Counsel), KimStaib and Tom Simon (Marketing);travel; prepareconference callconference with(General Mills)case meeting of

for meeting; post-with J. Min;Ari Gulatiregarding NewsCounsel.

Print News Corporation exhibits.

Circulate News Chicago meetinginvitation to CVS, Kraft, andothers.

Conference with C. Signorello(Henkel) regarding News Americameeting; send email to News casepotential clients regardingattendance by SC Johnson, GeneralMills, Heinz Unilever, and

Page 13

1.00

2.00

2.00

2.00

8.00

4.00

0.25

1.00



11/24/10 SFB

11/29/10 AJC

11/30/10 SFB

12/06/10 SFB

12/06/10 AJC

12/09/10 SFB

12/09/10 AJC

12/16/10 SFB

12/20/10 SFB

Alberto-Culver.

Conference with J. Mackie Masanregarding News case experttestimony; review Valassis experttestimony; update News clienttable; conference with E. Sagehornregarding News case; conferencewith J. Min (Kellogg) regardingNews case.

Complete plaintiff exhibit binderson News Corp. project.

Conference with Mackie-Masonpotential damages expert re: Newscase

Expert research for News case (D.Meyer Navigant); conference withJ. Mackie-Mason.

Locate, convert, and sendtranscript files for "NewsCorp"case to B. Conyngham; verify thatall video files, exhibits, andtranscripts have been downloadedfrom the iBinder on Huron'swebsite.

Prepare template litigation holdnotice for News case clients; sendsame to S. Berry.

Correct labels for Valassisexhibits for "NewsCorp" case;verify all files have beencorrectly downloaded and saved on"M" drive; correspond with B.Conyngham and A. Woehler (of S.Berry'S office) by email; deliverseven 5" binders to S. Berry'soffice on 17th Street andPennsylvania Avenue.

Prepare News joint prosecutionagreement.

Prepare joint representation andcost sharing agreement for Newsclients.

Page 14

3.00

3.00

0.50

1.00

2.00

1.00

4.00

0.75

0.50


August 1, 2014Invoice # 2008217379



12/22/10 SFB

12/26/10 SFB

01/03/11 SFB

01/03/11 BCM

01/04/11 SFB

01/05/11 SFB

01/05/11 JHM

01/06/11 SFB

August 1, 2014

Revise News retention letter;conference with S. Berry.

Review News case Valassis,Floorgraphics and Insigniacomplaints.

Prepare News engagement agreement;update client Contact list;finalize agenda; finalize Newscase joint representation andadministration agreement;conference with Mark Gustaferro(General Mills); conference withMark Sinonett and Dale Bockregarding Schwanns claim.

Research damages waiver issue forclient meeting in Chicago for NewsAmerica.

Research enforceability of tabledamages waivers for Newsmemorandum; conference with B.Moore regarding same.

Prepare for News meeting withpotential clients; prepare fee andcosts estimates; researcharbitration collateral estoppel;travel to Chicago; meet with S.Berry.

Legal research for S. Benzregarding News Corp.

Meet with D. Murphy (CVS), AniGulati (General Mills), ChrisSignorallo (Henkel), Dan Shaw(Heinz), T. Monroe and John Min(Kellogg Co.), D. Cherry (Kraft),D. Lofty (SC Johnson), R. George(Tyson Foods) and B. Chevlin(Unilever) regarding NewsAntitrust case; travel Chicago toOffice; circulate Mars amended30(b)(6), send forum selectionanalysis to E. Sagehorn (Tysons)

Page 15

1.25

2.75

2.00

1.00

1.00

4.00

2.50

8.75



01/07/11 SFB

01/10/11 SFB

01/11/11 SFB

01/13/11 SFB

01/14/11 SFB

01/15/11 SFB

01/17/11 SFB

01/18/11 SFB

Meet with L. Taylor regarding Newsbudget and litigation holds; editretention letter.

Review competitor complaints fordraft CPG News complaint;conference with C. Signorelloregarding representation of Henkelcorporation; edit retentionagreement; conference with D.Murphy (CVS) regarding News case;call to P&G colgate business inhouse counsel; conflicts checkregarding News case with Lexecon(Hal Sid€I)

Prepare News case budget percomparable cases; conferences withD. Shaw (Heinz) regarding Newscase; complete and send Newsdamage estimates to D. Lofty (SCJohnson); review Heinz-News tradespend figures; conflicts checkcall with H. Sider at Lexecon.

Conference with C. Signorello(Herkel Corporation) regardingNews case.

Conference call regarding Newscase with C. Signorello (HenkelCorporation), conference with D.Eveerson and B. O'blenessregarding Unilever, and AlbertoCulver damages.

Compile Reckitt trade Spend forNews case; client fee and expenseallocation; review SC Johnson-Newscontracts; conference with D.Lofty (SC Johnson assistantGeneral counsel) regarding thesame

Review SC Johnson News contracts;conference with D. Lofty (SCJohnson) regarding News case andoutreach to Kimberly Clark.

Call to D. Shaw (Heinz) regardingNews case; Conference with M.

Page 16

1.25

2.00

2.75

0.25

0.75

1.25

1.00

3.00


August 1 2014Invoice # 2008217379


exhibit 7 part 1 of 9 - kcc class actionclassaction.kccllc.net/documents/nwd0001/576-7 -...

Documents