· example of the endeavour to promote buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such...

56

Upload: others

Post on 25-Apr-2020

9 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge
Page 2:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge
Page 3:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge
Page 4:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Title

Year

Author

Copyright

Disclaimer

Contact

Inclusive Tourism: Empowering Communities to

March 2014

Public and Social Policies Management (PSPM),

No part of this publication may be reproduced in any form by photo, photo-print, microfilm or any other means without the written permission of YES BANK Ltd. & ASSOCHAM.

This report is the publication of YES BANK Limited (“YES BANK”) & ASSOCHAM and so YES BANK & ASSOCHAM has editorial control over the content, including opinions, advice, statements, services, offers etc. that is represented in this report. However, YES BANK & ASSOCHAM will not be liable for any loss or damage caused by the reader’s reliance on information obtained through this report. This report may contain third party contents and third-party resources. YES BANK & ASSOCHAM takes no responsibility for third party content, advertisements or third party applications that are printed on or through this report, nor does it take any responsibility for the goods or services provided by its advertisers or for any error, omission, deletion, defect, theft or destruction or unauthorized access to, or alteration of, any user communication. Further, YES BANK & ASSOCHAM does not assume any responsibility or liability for any loss or damage, including personal injury or death, resulting from use of this report or from any content for communications or materials available on this report. The contents are provided for your reference only.

The reader/ buyer understands that except for the information, products and services clearly identified as being supplied by YES BANK & ASSOCHAM, it does not operate, control or endorse any information, products, or services appearing in the report in any way. All other information, products and services offered through the report are offered by third parties, which are not affiliated in any manner to YES BANK & ASSOCHAM.

The reader/ buyer hereby disclaims and waives any right and/ or claim, they may have against YES BANK & ASSOCHAM with respect to third party products and services.

All materials provided in the report is provided on “As is” basis and YES BANK & ASSOCHAM makes no representation or warranty, express or implied, including, but not limited to, warranties of merchantability, fitness for a particular purpose, title or non – infringement. As to documents, content, graphics published in the report, YES BANK & ASSOCHAM makes no representation or warranty that the contents of such documents, articles are free from error or suitable for any purpose; nor that the implementation of such contents will not infringe any third party patents, copyrights, trademarks or other rights. In no event shall YES BANK & ASSOCHAM or its content providers be liable for any damages whatsoever, whether direct, indirect, special, consequential and/or incidental, including without limitation, damages arising from loss of data or information, loss of profits, business interruption, or arising from the access and/or use or inability to access and/or use content and/or any service available in this report, even if YES BANK & ASSOCHAM is advised of the possibility of such loss.

Maps depicted in the report are graphical representation for general representation only.

YES BANK Ltd.Registered and Head Office9th Floor, Nehru CentreDr. Annie Besant RoadWorli, Mumbai - 400 018Tel : +91 22 6669 9000Fax : +91 22 2497 4088

Northern Regional Office48, Nyaya Marg, Chanakyapuri New Delhi – 110 021 Tel : +91 11 6656 9000 Fax : +91 11 4168 0144 Email : [email protected] Website : www.yesbank.in

The Associated Chambers of Commerce and Industry of IndiaD. S. RawatSecretary GeneralASSOCHAM Corporate Office5, S. P. Marg, New Delhi – 110021Tel : +91 11 4655 0555Fax : +91 11 2301 7008/9Email : [email protected] : www.assocham.org

Page 5:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

Page 6:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge
Page 7:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

ForewordThe Travel and Tourism industry has emerged as a key sunrise sector and potential game changer for India. The sector has been able to drive equitable growth through large scale employment for specialized as well as unskilled workforces, develop several remote locations, encourage entrepreneurial ventures at the micro level and promote environment issues and sustainability. Tourism also has significant potential in poverty alleviation - this is reflected in discussions around the Millennium Development Goals, notably in the context of the 2002 Johannesburg Summit on Sustainable Development.

According to the World Travel & Tourism Council, Tourism generated INR 6.4 trillion i.e. 6.6% of India’s GDP in 2012. The sector supported 39.5 million jobs i.e. 7.7% of India’s total employment. The Tourism sector is predicted to grow at an average annual rate of 7.9% from 2013 to 2023. This will make India the third fastest growing tourism destination over the next decade.

The total market size of India’s tourism and hospitality sector is US$117.7 billion – this is expected to grow four-fold to US$ 418.9 billion by 2022. The Central Government has allocated INR 3.5 billion (US$56.41 million) in FY2013-14 for Domestic as well as Overseas Promotion and Publicity to enhance India’s competitiveness as an attractive tourist destination. Further, India has signed 48 agreements with other countries and international organisations to strengthen mutual promotion of tourism. The number of tourists availing the Visa on Arrival (VOA) scheme during January to October, 2013 has recorded a growth of 28.5 percent with a total number of 15,770 VOAs issued, compared to 12,273 VOAs during the same period in 2012.

Tourism in India is insulated against economic fluctuations and it is important to leverage its potential through a sustainable policy framework, encouraging community participation and collaborative community models, offering a holistic platform to promote inclusive growth and strengthening the backward linkages of the industry. Tourism is a sector in which developing countries like India can have a comparative advantage due to our heritage, cultural diversity and natural beauty which are being successfully promoted in various ways. For instance, India occupies 73 per cent of the Himalayan Region and a special campaign - 777 days of the Incredible Indian Himalayas, has been launched by the Ministry of Tourism. The new and revamped Incredible India campaign has also resulted in an exemplary shift in the way Indian destinations are being promoted abroad as well as in India. The Government is also making concerted efforts to promote new forms of tourism such as rural, cruise, medical and eco-tourism, all of which have phenomenal growth potential.

India, by virtue of its ancient civilization, has been home to most major religions of the world – this is a significant enabler for Religious Tourism whose core motive is the experiencing of different religious sites and monuments, along with art, culture, traditions and architecture from different eras of Indian history. The Buddhist Circuit, for instance, is a shining example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar.

ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge interventions and representations to the Government, has been championing the cause of Tourism development in India. I am pleased to present the YES BANK - ASSOCHAM knowledge report, ‘Inclusive Tourism: Empowering Communities to create Sustainable Livelihoods’ which highlights key challenges and opportunities and suggests a holistic strategy for development of Tourism in India.

I am confident that the contents of the knowledge report will provide important insights to policy makers, industry leaders and stakeholders to conceptualize and execute sustainable development models for boosting growth of the tourism sector in India and providing economic and livelihood security to all sections of our society.

Thank you. Sincerely,

Rana Kapoor President Managing Director & CEO

Page 8:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge
Page 9:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

MESSAGE

Tourism has long been identified as one of the sunrise sectors for India which can serve the dual purpose of not only earning foreign exchange but also boosting inclusion by increasing disposable domestic income. With its backward and forward linkages and local connect; tourism becomes an important driver of equitable growth and prosperity, offering an alternative source of livelihood, development & growth in remote locations, preservation of local skills, enterprise development at the micro level, and sustainable environment management.

At this backdrop, ASSOCHAM has organized the Annual Summit on Inclusive Tourism: Think Tourism – Think India, on March 19, 2014 in New Delhi. The Summit addressed, the importance of Inclusive Tourism which is emerging as a Socio-Economic Enabler, challenges & issues faced in Domestic & International Tourism and the Emerging Needs and Challenges of the Tourism Sector from an industry perspective.

I am glad to share the release of ASSOCHAM-YES BANK Knowledge Report titled, Inclusive Tourism: Empowering Communities to Create Sustainable Livelihoods and congratulate the YES BANK and ASSOCHAM team for preparing this report, which will certainly help the Government and other important stakeholders in preparing future roadmap.

I also convey my heartfelt gratitude and congratulate ASSOCHAM, YES BANK and thank all stakeholders for their immense support and guidance to organize a highly successful Tourism Summit.

D.S. RawatSecretary General

Page 10:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge
Page 11:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

Table of Content:

1. Introduction 1

2. Understanding the Growth Dimensions of Tourism 5 2.1. Developmental Impacts of Tourism: A Global Overview 2.2. Economic Case for achieving Sustainability through Community Partnership 2.3. Policy Perspective as an Enabler 2.4. Policy Landscape in India – Working Towards a Convergent Platform

3. Collaborative Community Models: Leveraging Tourism Potential 19 3.1. Institutional Innovation: Redefining Livelihood Ecosystems 3.2. Cooperative Approach and Community Entrepreneurship: Impacts and Potential 3.3. Case Studies: Successful Community led Ventures around the world 3.4. Edge of India: Inclusive Tourism Development through Collaborative Community Approach

4. YES BANK - ASSOCHAM Roadmap: Achieving Social Equity through Tourism 41

Page 12:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge
Page 13:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Introduction

Chapter : 1

Page 14:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

2

1. Introduction

Tourism is a ‘livelihood oriented’ sector, inducing employment through ‘multiplier effect’ and creating a strong contributer for accelerating a country’s economic growth turn facilitating cultural exchange. Coupled with the sector’s ability towards building backward and forward linkages and establishing seamless local connect, tourism plays an instrumental role in stimulating equitable growth and prosperity.

The sector offers alternative sources of livelihood development and growth in remote locations, preserves local skills, enterprises development at the micro level, and helps encourage a pragmatic approach towards environment conservation. The Travel and Tourism Industry is one of the leading job creators in the world with more than 98 million people employed directly and nearly one in every eleven jobs offered is tours the tourist industry worldwide. According to United Nations World Tourism

Organization (UNWTO), tourism provides 6 - 7% of the world’s total jobs directly and millions indirectly through the multiplier effect. The industry is expected to grow at a rate of 1.9% per year over the next decade in comparison to an annual growth rate of 1.2% for all jobs in the global economy.

The tourism industry in India grew rapidly in the last two decades with international tourist arrivals exceeding the 1 billion mark in 2012. Tourism has been identified to have strong linkages with the socio-economic progress of a country. The high revenue-

capital and employment-investment ratio encourages more inclusive approach towards income generation and growth in an economy. Given the high growth expectation of this industry, developing countries have vast opportunity to tap the benefits.

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1995

1996

1997

1998

1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

International Tourist Arrivals (millions)

Figure 1: International Tourists Arrivals (mn)

Source: UNWTO

Page 15:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

3

In addition to employment, Travel & Tourism provides other valuable spinoffs through its contribution towards infrastructure that benefit the entire community and boost skill development and trade. Capacity Building of local stakeholder organizations and to devising and executing effective action plans by individuals and developing strategies enlightens local communities towards the value of their cultural heritage.

Another critical aspect of promoting tourism is its implications on gender equality through women empowerment with a focus on identifying and redressing power imbalances and giving women more autonomy to manage their own lives. Tourism as a tool empowers women in various aspects.

It assists women in securing their rightful power and control over natural resources; and gaining economic, educational and political empowerment. Some initiatives taken worldwide include the ‘Three Sisters Adventure

Quick Facts

Global Travel & Tourism contribution to direct 3World GDP in 2013 is expected to report a growth by 3.1%, compared to 3.2% in 2012.

Travel & Tourism is again forecast to outpace 3growth of the total global economy at 2.4% in 2013. Total Travel & Tourism employment is projected to expand by 4.4 million jobs in 2013.

In India, every one million invested in tourism 3creates 47.5 jobs directly and around 85-90 jobs indirectly.

Source: YES BANK Analysis

Figure 2: Visitor Spending Multiplier Effect

Transportation

Entertainment

Recreation

Retail

Food & Beverage

Accommdations

Impact

Direct InducedIndirectVisitorSpending

Production

Jobs

Wages

Taxes

Page 16:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

4

Trekking’ in Nepal that helped disadvantaged women to move out of their traditional roles in Nepal and improve their skills, knowledge of nutrition, environment and history through the trekking guide training programmes. These programmes employ mothers, who in turn, generate education and income in their villages.

The income infused in the economy through tourism industry has diverse implications on the overall economy. Direct multipliers arise from the visitors actual spending, whereas indirect multipliers arise from the industry expenditure. Induced multipliers arise from the routine spending by the non-tourism industry suppliers of both their indirect tourist and direct tourist industry proceeds. The tourism multiplier can be significantly high if most of the shake holders in the value chain consist of host-country’s businesses and travel services offered by local communities.

With the global emphasis on sustainability, it has become imperative for policy makers to focus on building capacity of local communities such that majority of socio-economic benefits of tourism is plougned back. There is need to implement institutional frameworks that lead to synergistic development by coordinated participation from multiple authorities with focus on tourism-related development.

The concept of ‘Inclusive Tourism’ aims to incorporate a Collaborative Community approach towards developing tourism. These models not only control the structure and volume of tourist activity to make it more sustainable,

but also ensure that the entire destination is promoted in its entirety.

India as a tourism destination is characterized by the myriad cultural and natural experiences it offers. It is therefore critical to identify and focus on India’s competitive advantage and differentiate its tourism products through active community participation. It has also become increasingly important to analyze shifting trends in international tourist profiles. Creative Tourism Destination/ product creation and innovative promotion is the need of the hour, and key to sustain in a volatile macroeconomic environment.

Figure 3: Tourism Multiplier Effect

Source: YES BANK Analysis

New hotel set up

Local businessessupply services

Private Sector

Create jobsdirectly in the

hotels

Other companies are

attracted to the area

Workers spend theirincome in the localareas; tax revenues

increase

Government

The area becomes amore popular tourist

destination, increasingpro�tability and revenue

for re-investment

Taxes spent onimproving

infrastructure, imagesand tourist services

More jobs areindirectly created

Page 17:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Understanding the Growth Dimensions of Tourism

Chapter : 2

Page 18:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

6

2. Understanding the Growth Dimensions of Tourism2.1 Developmental Impacts of Tourism: A Global Overview

Tourism is one of the most dynamic sectors with high development rates leading to inflows of substantial volumes of foreign currency, infrastructural augmentation and educational exposure, which positively influence various facets of socio-economic development of the country. It helps raise the standards of living of the communities involved.

From a global standpoint, tourism industry has contributed significantly to growth and development. A number of countries like Switzerland, Austria and France have accrued high degree of socio-economic security from tourism industry.

The tourism industry contributed nearly 9% of the World’s GDP as per Tourism Highlights 2013. Nearly US$ 1.3 trillion (6% of world exports) of Tourism exports were reported in 2012 with new destinations in

Figure 4: International Tourists Arrival (mn)

Source: UNWTO Tourism Highlights 2013

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

2010 2011 2012

America

Asia Paci�c

Europe

Middle East

Africa

Page 19:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

7

emerging markets gaining popularity. The highest growth in the number of international tourist arrivals was recorded in Asia Pacific at 7%, followed by Africa at 6%.

At the current growth rate of 3.3% per annum, the number of international tourist arrivals is likely to reach 1.4 billion by 2020 and 1.8 billion by 2030. Approximately 43 million additional international tourists are expected to travel each year. Established markets like Europe and America are expected to grow at a moduate rate of 2.5% and 2.2% by 2030, in comparison to those of Asia Pacific (5.7%) and Africa (5.0%).

Some emerging trends in the travel and tourism industry from a global perspective include:

Rise in international travel implying burgeoning air travel 3

Rise in travel for leisure, health and religion among others in comparison to those for business 3purposes.

Figure 5: Factors influencing Travel and Tourism

Source: YES BANK Analysis

Natural

Disasters

Regional

demand shifts

In�ation/

Exchange rates

Aging

population

Political

instability

Digitization

Economic

Downturn

Terrorism

A� nity for Travel and Tourism

Price Competitiveness

in the Travel and Tourism

Industry

Tourism Infrastructure

Natural Resources

Policy Rules and

Regulations

Safety and Security

Cultural Resources

ICT Infrastructure

Prioritization of

Travel

and Tourism

Human resources

Air Transport Infrastructure

Health and hygiene

Ground Transport Infrastructure

Environmental Sustainability

Travel and

Tourism

Factors

Page 20:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

8

2.2 Economic Case for achieving Sustainability through Community Partnership

Partnerships at the community level enable speedy delivery of social and economic benefits to greater number of people in a more sustainable approach in comparison to the benefits achieved through traditional contractual or consultative relationships. Inventive partnerships between the tourism industry and local communities can play an instrumental role in promoting equitable growth with benefits reaching to the grassroot level.

Community Partnerships in tourism have multiple advantages:

Local partnerships help the tourism industry gain 3access to new sites owned by the local communities. The Government has also granted various concessions through competitive bidding with the aim to benefit the local community. This is more so in the case of PPP partnerships involving state properties, and agreements that facilitate exclusivity of use.

Community partnerships help to generate jobs for 3the local population, alleviate poverty, build local support, decline crime rates, and increase credibility through community involvement.

Such partnerships also encourage the creation of unique tourism products that give an exclusive 3characteristic to each destination, this augments product offering for guests and attracts tourists looking for unique holiday experience.

Community partnerships tend to increase staff morale (in case of tourist institutions like hotels etc.) 3and in turn lead to better customer experience and satisfaction. High staff morale directly translates to positive attitudes and improved services to the customers.

These partnerships facilitate brand enhancement through awards won, which further attract tourists 3and bring in more bookings.

Productive use of community resources attractive capital investments and technical know-how 3that further uplift a community’s capabilities; This faciliting greater exposure, and is turn boots the destination potentialities.

A number of initiatives have been made towards promoting community based sustainable tourism. One such initiative is the JICA (Japan International Cooperation Agency) Partnership Program- “Community-Based Sustainable Tourism Development” in Phobjikha. The Phobjikha valley was identified as critical for conservation.

Page 21:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

9

The local community was not benefiting despite rising footfall of tourists, as they capacity to provide adequate services to the visitors was lacking.

The JPP project aims to promote sustainable tourism by building the capacity of the local community in the tourism industry by augmenting tourist facilities and marketing the services provided and strengthening coordination among operators and communities.

2.3 Policy Perspective as an Enabler

Despite the high growth in the tourism industry, India has not reached its potential of becoming a preferred tourist destination. Although the sector is targeted to grow at a rate of 12% during the period 2011-2016, tourism infrastructure and skilled manpower are the major areas of concern. As per current

estimates, nearly 2.8 million employees are required for restaurants, 0.3 million for the travel and trade segment and 4.1 million employees for hotels, creating a shortfall of 2.7 million employees in the tourism sector.

As per the Travel and Tourism Competitiveness Report 2013, India ranked 74 out of 140 countries on the safety and security parameters, and a lot of improvement is needed in this aspect. The industry needs more infrastructure to support the projected growth for the current Five Year Plan.

The Government has taken several initiatives through the introduction of various schemes, a few notable ones mentioned as under:

Scheme for product/infrastructure and destination development; 3

Scheme for Integrated Development of Tourist Circuits; 3

Scheme for Assistance for Large Revenue Generating Projects; 3

Figure 6: Community-Based Sustainable Tourism Development Project

Source: JICA Partnership Program- Community-Based Sustainable Tourism Development

Local GuideTraining Development

of Souvenirand

handicrafts

Establishmentof

Homestay

Bird hidedevelopment

Improvementof wetlandboardwalk

Improvesawareness on

natureconservation

Community-Based

SustainableTourism

DevelopmentProject

Page 22:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

10

Scheme of capacity building for Rural 3Tourism;

Scheme for Support to Public 3Private Partnership in Infrastructure Development (Viability Gap Funding);

Market Development Assistance 3(MDA) scheme for promotion of domestic tourism.

Despite rigorous efforts, the tourism in India is yet to achieve its full potential, and given the fact that business in the sector is driven largely by the private sector, there is a need to analyze policy mechanisms and identify the ‘unique’ perspectives that need to be adopted to come up with a practical and sustainable growth framework. Few unique initiatives taken by smaller nations stand out as a unique and ‘authentic’ tourist destination.

Bahamas: One-stop Online Booking and Immigration Card

In promoting tourism, Bahamas focused on two areas that have mostly been overlooked by other developing countries – Collecting market information from visiting tourists and identifying how tourists select and book destinations.

The website allows tourists to make 3their own accounts which allow them to alter bookings conveniently

Figure 7: Focus of Tourism Policy in India

Source: YES BANK Analysis

TourismPolicyFocus

Cleanliness

Infrastructure

Information

FacilitationSecurity

Welcome

Cooperation

Page 23:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

11

To collect market information, the Bahamas Ministry of tourism hired Indusa Ltd. for designing the 3new Bahamas Immigration Card that helps immigration improve national security and makes visitor information readily available. The Immigration Card also helps the Ministry of Tourism to collect concise marketing data and conduct exit surveys that help in target marketing, reducing advertising costs and promoting tourism.

Gambia: Redistribution of Resources (Pro-Poor and Responsible Tourism)

Despite being a popular winter sun destination, local people weren’t benefiting from the investment inflow into the economy. Moreover, the Government initially marketed Gambia to local tour operators in Britain which resulted in most of the revenues generated staying within Britain itself. A crisis situation was reached when British tourists were discouraged to travel to Gambia by the British Foreign Office after the 1994 violent coup. The following initiatives were taken to address the sudden exisis:

The Gambia Tourism Concern (GTC) was established which led to the promotion of fair trade in tourism 3and eradication of poverty through linkages with a Gambian organization in Britain.

The Association of Small Scale Enterprises in Tourism (ASSET) was set up to encourage a collaborative 3approach between small scale enterprises and mainstream tourism.

The Tourism Challenge Fund (TCF) funded by UK Department for International Development aimed at 3improving linkages between the formal and informal sector and helped identify major road blocks in increasing revenues in the tourism industry.

The main goal of the Tourism industry was to develop a collaborative approach of work where 3partnerships between the private sector, Government and the informal sector would flourish.

Trinidad and Tobago: Trinidad and Tobago Tourism Industry Certification Programme

The Trinidad and Tobago Tourism Industry Certification (TTTIC) programme was established in 2001 with the aim to improve tourism products and services. This certification is based on the tourism standards established

Page 24:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

12

by the Trinidad & Tobago Bureau of Standards (TTBS) to facilitate quality delivery of products and services. The characteristic features of the programme are:

The industry was secured with all tourism operators 3agreeing on the need to match operational standards and linking the programme to several marketing initiatives.

Public workshops were conducted to present and 3explain the entire TTTIC process that involves a self-assessment, scheduled audit exercise and a report from TTBS evaluating the joint audit exercise. If TTBS verifies that the tourism operator meets the requisite standards, a certificate is issued.

To ensure the integrity of this process, stakeholders were involved while developing the standard but 3not in developing the certification programme.

2.4 Policy Landscape in India – Working Towards a Convergent Platform

Human Resource Development

The 12th five year plan recognizes tourism as a catalyst for inclusive growth. Tourism can provide a catharsis for social and economic development and can significantly contribute to poverty reduction. The Prime Minister’s National Skill Development Council (NSDC) has identified Tourism/ Hospitality Industry along with Health and IT as mass employment generators, making it imperative to initiate programs for mass basing and skill training. A study undertaken by the Ministry of Tourism estimates that the hospitality sector will generate almost 36 lakh jobs during the 12th plan period.

Bridging Skilled Manpower Requirement

In line with NSDC’s vision, the following programs are the cornerstone of the Ministry of Tourism’s (MoT) initiatives to ensure equitable growth.

MoT established the National Council for Hotel Management and Catering Technology (NCHMCT) in 31982 to advice the government on development of hotel management and catering education, shore up human resource development through international cooperation.

Page 25:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

13

29 Institutes of Hotel Management (IHMs), comprising 21 Central IHMs and 8 State IHMs, and 5 Food 3Craft Institutes (FCIs), which have been set-up with the support of the Ministry.

To provide thrust to the skilling initiatives 3 Hunar Se Rozgar Tak (HSRT) Yojna was initiated.

Salient features of the program:

Furnish Skill

Relevant skills have to be furnished to all the stakeholders

Sectors covered

The program should identify and broad base training sectors to impart skills pertaining to medical tourism (yoga, meditation etc.), rural tourism – imparting language skills to tourist guides etc.

Implementation

Implementing Skill Development under Hunar Se Rozgar initiative through the following institutions:

a. Existing Institutes of Hotel Management (IHMs)/ Food Craft Institutes (FCI)s controlled by MoT/NCHMCT

b. Other IHMs/FCIs recommended through the State Govt.

c. Classified Hotels

Features of the training programmes:

a. Short duration courses extending from 4 to 8 weeks

b. Training cost is borne by MoT

c. The implementing institutes are entitled to receive a payment of 5/10% of the respective programme costs to cover their administrative expenses.

Food Productionand Food and

Beverage

House keeping

Bakery andPatisserie

DrivingSkills

Heritageconservation

and StoneMasonry

Golf Caddy

Figure 8: HSRT Activities

Source: Ministry of Tourism, Govt. of India

Page 26:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

14

d. Stipend of INR 1,500 for six week course and INR 2,000 for eight week course would be provided to the trainees who have a minimum attendance of 90%, thereby encouraging the students to attend classes regularly.

Partnership with Hotel Association of India and Federation of Hotel Restaurants Association of India for training in classified hotels would also bolster HRST program. It is mandatory for 1 to 5 Star Deluxe hotels and Heritage properties to augment skilled labor through training which would further support the ministry’s initiative. Along with this, it is also crucial that an ’on-site’ assessment procedure be devised to correctly gauge the effectiveness of training programmes.

Tourism Infrastructure Development

To sustain growth in the tourism sector and ensure its competitiveness, it is imperative to ascertain adequacy of local services and tourism Infrastructure. Development of Tourism infrastructure at key destinations would encourage investments by the private sector in facilitates such as accommodation, restaurants, tours and transport. It is therefore crucial to identify and prioritize key areas of government intervention. The Ministry’s infrastructure development scheme is expected to provide the necessary impetus to drive growth in this sector:

Under the Centrally Sponsored Scheme of Product/ Infrastructure Development for Destinations and 3Circuits, 100% Central Assistance is given for development of destinations/ circuits including mega projects to world standard and also for rural tourism infrastructure development.

The Ministry of Tourism provides financial assistance up to Rs. 5.00 crore for the development of 3Destinations and Rs. 8.00 crore for Circuits. The upper limit of financial assistance has been increased to Rs. 25 crore and Rs. 50 crore for development of identified mega destinations and circuits respectively.

Under the schemes to promote rural tourism in the country, the thrust is for development of tourism 3infrastructure at the identified rural tourism sites so that socio-economic benefits percolate down to the rural community. A maximum of Rs. 50.00 lakh is sanctioned for each project under this scheme for development of tourism related infrastructure.

The objective is to ensure that the infrastructure of these mega destinations / circuits is developed to 3the extent that it can cater to the future tourist inflows so that visitors get a satisfying and memorable experience. The Ministry has identified 29 mega projects for development.

(Source: Ministry of Tourism, Government of India)

Page 27:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

15

The Need for a Convergent Platform

Tourism as a sector has an ‘aggregator’ nature, combining products and services from various other manufacturing as well as service industries. While the Ministry of Tourism is the Nodal Agency for tourism development and promotion in the country, there is a need to increase the involvement of other relevant ministries and institutions like Culture, Education & Skill Development, HRD, Handicrafts & Cottage Industries and Agriculture & Food Processing.It is also pertinent to increase the involvement of higher education institutions which have immense knowledge repository and trainer manpower, as well as the local connect to effectively engage with the community towards skill development, ICT led development and even market linkages in case of proactive institutions.

� SHGs/Cooperatives� Local AdministrationBodies

� D evelop Administrationand ManagementCapabilities

� D evelop and deliver capacitybuilding - communitycapability to use these tools

� M arket Outreach� Distribution Channels� Client Engagement

� E ducational Institutions� C orporate / Industry

� M inistry of Tourism,State Tourism Depts.

� I nter ministerialcommittee: Ministry ofCulture, Rural Development,HRD, Agriculture and otherrelevant miniseries representedon the panel

Market LinkageICT

HRD, CapacityBuilding

PolicyIntegration,Convergent

platforms

Institutionalizationof on-ground

structures

Figure 9: Convergent Platform for Inclusive Tourism

Source: YES BANK Analysis

Page 28:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

16

Marketing and Promotion

Incredible India is the flagship promotional campaign under the Ministry of Tourism. The Ministry has recently launched two new campaigns under this umbrella –‘Find What You Seek’ for the international tourism market and ‘Go Beyond’, focused on taking the domestic tourist beyond the ‘honeypot’ destinations. The Incredible India portal provides a glimpse of India’s vibrant cultural heritage, festivals and cuisines and information on tour packages.

Both these campaigns have marked a paradigm shift in the strategy adopted to promote tourism in India with its focus shifting from the destination and products to consumers or tourists. The new Incredible India Campaign aims to increasing foreign tourists’ arrivals from 0.65% of total world tourists to 1%.

“Find What You Seek”Focused on the concept that tourists from all over the world can find all destinations and tourism 3products of their interest in India, be it adventure, religion, culture, festivals, medical or wildlife

This campaign has been a big success globally and won the first prize at the 11th Golden City Gate 3tourism Media Awards Ceremony held in Berlin.

“Go Beyond”This campaign aimed to promote India Domestically. 3

Focused on promoting less known destinations within the country. 3

Another initiative made by India’s Tourism Ministry was the “777 days of the India Himalayas” launched in September 2013, with a twofold objective - to attract greater number of international tourists to travel to India during the lean summer period and secondly, to create awareness among tourists that 73% of the Himalayan region lies within India.

Page 29:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

17

The Ministry of Tourism has decided to meet 50% of the Peak fee charged by the Indian Mountaineering 3Foundation from climbing expeditions conducted during the campaign.

The focus is directed towards not only promoting the Northern and North Eastern Himalayan states, 3but also the gateway cities that have well developed international and domestic airports, and railway connections. This would encourage tourists to visit these cities and further attract foreign exchange inflows and boost development.

This Campaign also aims to change enhance India’s image as a ‘Himalayan’ or ‘mountainous’ destination, 3generally ascribed to countries like Nepal and Bhutan.

Promoting India as a summer destination rather than only a winter destination by offering tourism right 3from hard to soft adventure.

Adventure Tour Operators’ Association of India, in association with the Ministry of Tourism has designed 3special adventure programmes, offered through a dedicated website (http://www.indianhimalayas.atoai.org) spanning across the 777 days of this Campaign.

Market Development Assistance (MDA)

The Market Development Assistance Scheme (MDA) aims to provide financial support to approved tourism service providers approved by the Ministry of Tourism for promoting several tourism activities:

Sales-cum-study tours 3

Participation in fairs/exhibitions 3

Publicity through printed material 3

Page 30:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge
Page 31:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Collaborative Community Models: Leveraging Tourism Potential

Chapter : 3

Page 32:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

20

3. Collaborative Community Models: Leveraging Tourism Potential3.1 Institutional Innovation: Redefining Livelihood Ecosystems

The tourism industry and policies in India have altered drastically over last few decades. During the early days of independence, the tourism industry wasn’t given much importance due to the small numbers of international tourists. The first policy initiatives were made in the 1980’s with the prospects of hosting the Asian Games of 1982. This was the first time the government initiated development in the tourism industry which was strengthened by the fact that tourism attracted maximum foreign currency. Subsequently, Tourism Policy followed in 1982 which focused on developing tourism circuits.

Tourism Circuits were conceptualized to act as a tool for development in rural areas through the establishments of ‘Contels’ (condominium hotels) in undeveloped and backward villages. These Contels were managed as a cooperative venture giving community involvement highest importance. Local resources were utilized while offering the right balance of rural charm and basic comfort.

In the 1980’s, Tourism was recognized as an export industry and a special Public Tourism Finance Corporation (1987) was created. In 1997, the department of tourism declared new National Tourism Action Plan that focused on achieving an overall growth through improved marketing, infrastructural and human resource development. Moreover, the opening up of the Indian market in the 1990s encouraged states to compete for attracting investors in the tourism industry. For instance, the Kerala government played a major role in bolstering and promoting a number of tourist activities in the state. States started actively promoting tourism through publicity campaigns and supporting the private sector through incentives; identifying the potential of tourism in terms of job creation and income earning; and entrusting the responsibility of tourist services to private entrepreneurs.

The 1990’s marked the rise in modern forms of domestic tourism. This was associated with the booming Indian Economy and the growing exposure of the Indian middle and higher class to western ideas of tourism.

Page 33:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

21

In 2002, the Tourism Action Plan was transformed into a Tourism Policy which attempted to establish tourism’s contribution to national economic development and growth. The policy introduced the idea of tourism acting as a developmental tool that has the potential to generate high quality mass employment and prosperity amongst less fortunate groups in backward areas.

As a result of these policies, the livelihood framework has also evolved. Tourism is no longer viewed as an ‘alternative’ or ‘part-time’ activity, but a steady source of employment. As elucidated in the figure below, the

livelihood ecosystem is a subset of the stakeholder interests and policy direction, and there needs to be a uniformity in how the three are polarized to create a sustainable employment model.

3.2 Cooperative Approach and Community Entrepreneurship: Impacts and Potential

Authorities have continuously encouraged infrastructure upgradation for tourism development, but human resource has often proved to be the Achilles’ heel, with supply demand gaps in both the skilled and unskilled space.

Hunar seRozgar

Scheme:Rural

Tourism

Marketing &Promotion

TourismAwareness

CapacityBuilding

EnvironmentalConservation

Gender Equity

Source: Source: Ministry of Tourism, Govt. of India

Figure 11: Hunar Se Rozgar Scheme for Rural Tourism

Source: Primary Research, YES BANK

Policy Alignment

Stakeholder Aggregation

DevelopingConsensus on theRole of tourism inthe Development

Agenda

Remove Barriers togrowth to Leverage

Private SectorInvestment

Augment CapacityBuilding

Involve Rural Sector inTourism and start

mobile training units forservice providers in

rural areas

Mobilize support ofprimary players and

provide legislative andregulatory support

Livelihoods

Culture Nature Culinary,Transport

AncillaryServices

Figure 10: Evolving Livelihood Ecosystem

Page 34:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

22

The recent years have seen increasing impetus being provided to strengthen the training infrastructure in synchrony with the development of core tourism and hospitality infrastructure so that the two complement each other to bring out a consolidated tourism product, a strategy that many leading tourism economies are actively complying.

The Ministry of Tourism has instituted the Hunar Se Rozgar Tak Scheme to cover the varied aspects of tourism and hospitality skill development and training. The rural tourism focuses on the conservation ethics and providing

a business viewpoint to tourism activities for the rural populace.

HSRT scheme was envisaged to converge with the Ministry’s broader Rural Tourism scheme, which focused upon the infrastructural aspects of the niche (or the ‘hardware’), by providing the necessary human resource development to complement (or the ‘software’).

The unskilled sector forms a major chunk of the tourism work force in rural areas, and this is where the inclusion objectives should emphasize upon. The challenge is two pronged, whilst awareness is necessary to elaborate the need of behavioural ethics, the economic benefits need wider

dissemination and the working environment needs to improve. The problem presents itself as a tricky cycle, where the achievement of one objective would automatically lead to the fulfillment of the others.

Another problem lies in the training methodology. Most of the tourism training in the country is devised around existing institutional models. While these institutions run around a set theoretical framework, there

is disconnect from the actual working conditions of the unorganized sector, where

the extrinsic factors play a huge role in determining livelihoods.

Access and awareness to training programmes is a problematic area, as a large portion of the segment is either illiterate or partly educated, making accessibility and comprehension an issue.Source: Primary Research, YES BANK

Present private ownership / local enterpreneurs

Education and training infrastructure

Estimation of local and migratory population involved in tourism activities

Nature of Employment : Seasonal/ Full time; Duration of Seasonality

Source: Primary Research, YES BANK

Improved TouristInteraction

EconomicInclusion

Better workingConditions

Figure 12: Unskilled Workforce – Need and Objective Cycle

Figure 13: Human Resource: Need Assessment & Training Landscape

Page 35:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

23

This is where on ground institutions have a crucial role to play as an awareness and delivery platform.

The Cooperative Approach envisages that the collaborative community groups are empowered with the technical knowledge to deliver the capacity building modules. The ‘Train-the-Trainer’ model, wherein selected individuals from the local community are handpicked and trained intensively to be able to further disseminate the knowledge down to other members.

As highlighted in the figure below, the cooperative model has immense potential in the rural landscape as it gels well with the social dynamics of these areas. It is imperative that the policies and guidelines are designed are not only cognizant of these needs, but are also in sync with the market forces of demand and supply, as well as focus upon developing the base level skills (communication, etiquettes etc.) across all segments. An active industry-academia alliance is one way to ensure this, while constant interaction between the industry and the government can help the policy formulation process.

3.3 Case Studies: Successful Community Led Ventures in India

Sustainable tourism attempts at making a low impact on the environment and local culture, while catalyzing employment opportunities for the local populace. Incorporating cooperative model in tourism can ensure equitable socio-economic growth. The following case studies echo the success of community based tourism (CBT) initiatives:

LOCATION SUSTAINABLE TOURISMCommunity Led Ventures

Enablers

Community-Based Tourism in the Caribbean

Caribbean Key Features:

Collaborative approach to tourism 3

Community members actively 3participate in appraisals, development, management and/or ownership (whole or in part) of enterprises

Enterprises operating under the CBT 3model help deliver socio-economic benefits to the community, conserve natural and cultural resources to fulfill aspiration of local and foreign visitors.

Enabling national 3policy framework

Destination 3positioning and branding as environmentally & socially responsible

Technical & financial 3assistance

Local 3entrepreneurship and/or leadership

in communities 3

Page 36:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

24

CASE STUDY - Anse La Raye Seafood Friday, Saint Lucia (Launched in July 2000)

With the objective of diversifying tourism product and equitably spreading the economic benefits of tourism, the Anse La Raye Seafood Friday was conceived. Tourists & locals congregate on the waterfront on Friday evenings to purchase cooked seafood, beverages & craft and listen to music.

Key highlights of the project:

Pro-active Governance: Local government pushed the case for developing the area, which was facilitated by the St. Lucia Heritage Tourism Programme (SLHTP). Village council and community members developed a vision for tourism.

Strategic Location: Anse La Raye is rich in cultural and natural assets and is inhabited by relatively poor community. Developing tourism in such an area would ensure socio-economic development at the last mile.

Inputs: Skill training was provided to harness tourism potential of the village. The project reflects strong community leadership for management of the weekly event: Anse La Raye Seafood Friday Committee comprising of the village council, vendors association and local representatives oversees lighting, solid waste management and security.

Impact:

Socio-economic: The project has helped establish local economic linkages between seafood vendors and other local micro-entrepreneurs. The event provides business to fisher folk, farmers, shop owners, craft vendors and taxi drivers.

Environment: Sensitization and training to implement mitigation measures addressing the adverse environmental impacts of tourism have been undertaken. Concerns regarding sustainability of harvesting marine species to supply the ALRSF, food safety and waste disposal have also been addressed.

Page 37:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

25

LOCATION SUSTAINABLE TOURISMCommunity Led Ventures

Enablers

Responsible Ecological Social Tours Projects (REST )

Thailand Key Features

Key role of REST is to assist rural 3Thai communities to plan, develop and manage CBT activities.

Local partners have harnessed CBT 3as a tool to facilitate development at the grassroots, support local lifestyles and bring in cultural pride, engender cross-cultural respect, and create environmental awareness.

REST has enabled 3community members to meaningfully engage and negotiate with government and the private sector to ensure tourism provides benefits to local people, while ensuring protection of cultural traditions and conservation of natural resources.

CASE STUDY – Koh Yao Noi, Phang Nga, Southern Thailand

Koh Yao Noi is a small island, located in Phang Nga bay, southern Thailand. Traditional, small scale fishing is the mainstay of locals of the island. However, degradation of the marine ecosystem due to intrusion of industrial fishers using illegal equipment depleted the fish stock as well as affected the food security of the local communities.

Key highlights of the project:

NGO - Thailand Volunteers Service (TVS-REST) facilitated development of Community-based Tourism (CBT)

Page 38:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

26

Member of the fishers’ group established ‘Koh Yoa Noi Community-based Ecotourism Club’ with the aim of developing a model sensitive to the culture of the island, supporting local conservation work and providing employment to the local community.

Impact:

Socio-economic: CBT has led to an increase in average income of participating families. The group has also created rules and regulations for visiting tourist such as abstinence from alcohol etc. to preserve local culture.

Environment: The group has created a community and environment fund which is charged from tourists. The club also has also undertaken conservation activities including improvement of the local environment through mangrove planting; sea-grass protection and waste collection have been undertaken by the CBT club.

LOCATION SUSTAINABLE TOURISMEnabler

CBT in Vietnam Vietnam ITC, the joint agency of the United Nations and the WTO, is dedicated to the development of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs).

Nine key international organizations including ITC have joined hands to form the United Nations Steering Committee on Tourism for Development with the objective of strengthening the developmental impact of international tourism.

The organization helped establish community tourism for the following case study.

CASE STUDY - Kim Bong Village, Vietnam Strategic Location: Kim Bong Village is located close to Hoi An which is a successful tourist destination in Vietnam. The village has rich cultural heritage and natural resources and tourists visit the village to experience traditional carpentry workshops and scenic landscapes

Page 39:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

27

Key highlights of the project:Initiatives by ITC in partnership with the local government: The local government financed the construction of a tourism information centre and showroom in Kim Bong. International Trade Centre (ITC) on the other hand provided training to locals, to imparted relevant skills for boosting tourism.

Inputs: Skill training was provided to the community for tourism product development and marketing, office administration and as effective tour guides. The village was included in the Quang Nam Tourism Festival of Vietnam to increase tourist inflows. Market linkages have been also established with tour operators and hotels in Hoi An.

Impact:

Socio-economic: Sale of local craft and products and new avenues for employment as tour guides and hospitality service providers in the village have increased revenues from tourism.

LOCATION SUSTAINABLE TOURISMCommunity Led Ventures

Enablers

Culture Aangan India Key features: 3

The projects aims at fostering rural 3development through tourism

It essentially focuses on utilizing 3cultural tourism to create sustainable livelihoods for rural communities.

Local residents invest to convert a 3part of their own home into rooms with modern amenities.

The community also engages in cultural activities as well as provides local produce and materials e.g. food supplies, construction materials for resorts etc.

Government: Village authorities to transform old buildings into restaurants or activity areas

Facilitator: Culture Aangan oversees the management and maintenance of homes as well as ensures services are provided as per the visitor’s expectations.

It also supports self help groups and works towards preservation of local craft through provision of art galleries where tourist can interact with the local artisans.

Page 40:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

28

Merging Religion and Tourism with Community Development

The Bahá’í Lotus Temple in New Delhi is not only a prime tourist attraction known for its unique architecture, but also a good example of how tourism and devotion can be sustainably managed in tandem. The architect Fariburz Sabha chose the lotus as a symbol common to Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, Zoroastrianism and Islam. Adherents of all Faiths are free to visit the temple and pray or meditate.

The temple scores both in terms of well maintained physical infrastructure as well as astute management. The Bahá’í community is also very active in social transformation. Through a unique process of cooperation, study, and worship, individual Baha’is and Baha’i communities are exploring the application of Baha’u’llah’s teachings on a more effective and far-reaching basis, involved in areas like education, healthcare, women empowerment and rural development.

This is an excellent example of how institution led community partnerships can bring about positive transformation while promoting tourism and cultural exchange.

Dr. A. K. Merchant is a Trustee, Lotus Temple & National Spiritual Assembly of the Baha’is of India; General Secretary, The Temple of Understanding, India; Chairperson, Sarvodaya International Trust - Delhi Chapter. He can be contacted at [email protected].

Edge of India: Inclusive Tourism Development through Collaborative Community Approach

Tourism is one of the key employment progenitors, creating 78 jobs for every Rs 10 lakh of investment — and is expected to create 37 million additional jobs

in the next 10 years (Source: Planning Commission Research). However, there is a need to create a convergent platform where the development objectives can be bridged with the business aspects of the industry through dynamic and flexible policy mechanisms.

The concept of Cooperative Tourism aims to deliver sustainable economic development by building the capacity of local communities to realize the potential value of their natural and cultural heritage to create tourism enterprise opportunities through a co-operative destination management organization model.

Edge of India is a pilot initiative in India towards establishing such models, supported by the Scottish Government through its South Asia Development Programme. This innovative partnership combines Scottish academic and project expertise with an innovative Indian Financial institution bringing in implementation focus with effective policy integration.

Page 41:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

29

Project Area: Region Overview

Kumaun Region – Uttarakhand

Kumaun is one of the two regions and administrative divisions of Uttarakhand, bounded on the north by Tibet, on the east by Nepal, on the south by the state of Uttar Pradesh, and on the west by the Garhwal region. The local language of this region is Kumaoni and some of its prominent towns include Nainital, Almora, Haldwani, Mukteshwar, Pithoragarh, Kashipur, Rudrapur and Ranikhet. The nearest airbase to Kumaon is the airport situated in Pantnagar, while Kathgodam is the nearest railway station.

A network of co-operative destination management

organizations (cDMOs) to be established, led by a team of local coordinators across the destination clusters, enabling rural communities to realize the economic value of their

tourism assets

A comprehensive training programme to be delivered

with an emphasis on ‘train the trainers’ and relevant

practical skills

A world class distribution system with a network of destination

portals, promoting fairly-traded products and delivering

market access

Figure 15: Kumaun Region – Uttarakhand

Figure 14: Edge of India - Key Objectives

Source: Primary Research, YES BANK

Source: Primary Research, YES BANK

Page 42:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

30

i) Ranikhet Cluster, District Almora

The town of Ranikhet, at an altitude of 1,900m (6233ft) within sight of the snow clad western Himalayas, is the perfect quaint little hill town. According to local legend, King Raja Sudhardev won the heart of his queen, Rani Padmini, here. She subsequently chose the area for her residence, giving it the name Ranikhet which means Queen’s Meadow. It was the British, though, who lent the town its colonial undertones and set the headquarters for the Kumaun Regiment here, using the hill station as a retreat from the heat of the Indian summer.

The Ranikhet cluster comprises of three villages centered around village Kothiyan, 8 kms from Ranikhet town. Kothiyan, the first stop, is located at an altitude of 1600 mts, about 15 km before Ranikhet, on a hillock surrounded by lush terrace fields. Agriculture is the major occupation, and the village has the essential infrastructure in terms of electricity and communication systems (internet is still a distance way, though, and cell phone networks are sporadic at times. Lore has it that an Englishman one fine day decided to slip into the little river flowing next to the village for a dip, and left his coat perched on some comfortable nook in the village, hence the name ‘Kothiyan’. ii) Bageshwar Cluster, District Bageshwar

The town of Bageshwar is situated at the confluence of the rivers Saryu & Gomati and nestles under the shadow of twin hills of Bhileshwar & Nileshwar, and is so named because of the temple of Bagnath, an epithet of Shiv that overlooks the town. The valley of Bageshwar is extremely fertile and is renowned for its high quality rice, pulses, fresh vegetables and fruits.

The Bageshwar cluster comprises four villages, namely Karmi, Tani, Dhur and Sorag. The valley encompassing the

Figure 16: A homestay in village Kothiyan. Tourism provides the owners with sufficient income to afford the relatively expensive upkeep of traditional

architectural structures such as these

Figure 17: Maa Chiltha Temple, near Village Dhur, Bageshwar Ecotourism Cooperative Society, District Bageshwar, Uttarakhand.; religious sites like these not only sensitize the tourist about the deep bond between man, religion and nature in the hills, but also helps in generating revenue for

maintaining these structures

Page 43:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

31

villages of Karmi and Tani, lying at altitudes ranging from 1800-2000 mts, is one of the most fertile regions of the lower Himalayas. With a population of around 6, 000, agriculture is the primary occupation. Difficult accessibility has turned out to be a boon for the region in this aspect, as the traditional farming practices have managed to remain organic. However, the region is getting an extensive road network necessary for prepping up the infrastructure in sectors like health and education.

Village Dhur lies at a height of about 2500 mts, surrounded by lush green meadows and an exhilarating view of the Nanda Devi and the three glaciers, viz. Pindari, Kafni and Sunderdhunga. A tiny little settlement of about 50 families as compared to its bigger counterparts down the valley, the village has a rich and organic agrarian spread owing to a variety of support programmes that are run by both the government and NGOs. Located 8 kms ahead, the village of Sorag shares its geographical trails with Dhur, and is accessible only by foot.

iii) Berinag Cluster, District Pithoragarh

Located in the Siwalik range of the lower Himalaya on the western edge of Pithoragarh (the easternmost district of Uttarakhand), Berinag is a typical quaint Himalayan township, nestled at an altitude of 1,700m (5,577ft), amidst pine and oak forests. Previously known as ‘Bedinag’, the name comes from the Nagveni King Benimadhavahas, and makes reference to the numerous temples dedicated to snakes in the region. Berinag was a major worship centre under the Chand rulers, and consequently abounds in religious folklore and culture, with numerous temples dotting the landscape. The cluster around Berinag comprises of the following villages.

Garaun: Located about 3km from Berinag, the village of Garaun has a population of around 450 people. Steeped in religious folklore, the village and its surroundings find mention in many ancient scriptures, and a lot of Hindu deities are associated with the region. A picturesque, 250 metre high seasonal waterfall attracts a lot of visitors.

Devinagar: Located 3km away from Berinag with a population of around 500, the village of Devinagar is defined by a large British era building. Agriculture is the primary occupation of the community, and the village is surrounded by beautiful conifer

forests whilst also offering good views of the

Himalayas.

Figure 18: Watermill near Village Garaun, Berinag Ecotourism Cooperative Society, District Pithoragarh, Uttarakhand; the flour derived from these mills is more wholesome and tastier than traditional flour mills; such traditional technologies are not only being revived as

emerging solutions towards a sustainable lifestyle, but also find favour among tourists

Page 44:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

32

Chalori: Located about 2km from Berinag, Chalori is a relatively small village consitsting of about 20 families. Again, agriculture is the primary occupation and the village is located in a lush green and pristine valley, surrounded by hills with many famous temples, promising complete solitude from the rush of urban life.

Budera: Located 9km from Berinag, the majority of the 200 or so residents of Budera are farmers and shepherds. The village is home to the famous Punkershwar Mahadev temple, dedicated to Lord Shiva, which hosts a popular fair procession during the Dusshera festival. An old British bungalow takes centre stage in the village landscape.

Kamdina: One of the largest villages in the region in terms of population (approximately 700), Kamdina is located about 8km from Berinag. Agriculture and rearing livestock are the major occupations, and the surroundings offer a cool, relaxed atmosphere.

Action Strategy/ Execution Plan

The model establishment and mobilization is carried out in a three stage process defined as under.

Stage 1: Socio-economic feasibility study

• InfrastructureAssessment

Current number of homestays/ huts/ tents/ accommodation units 3

Accessibility, peripheral infrastructure like roads, transport options (road, rail, air) 3

LocalCoordinatorUttarakhand

LocalCoordinatorBageshwar

BageshwarEcotourism

Coop Society

Edge of Indiaprotal

RanikhetEcotourism

Coop Society

BerinagEcotourism

Coop Society

LocalCoordinator

Berinag

LocalCoordinator

Ranikhet

Project Map:Edge of India

Project Map

Figure 19: Action Strategy/ Execution Plan

Source: YES BANK Analysis

Page 45:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

33

Details of accommodation units 3

Occupancy figures 3

Market Demand/ Trends 3

Compliance with environmental norms 3

Ancillary infrastructure (Banks, Money Changers, 3ATMs, Restaurants etc.)

Entertainment/ Recreational facilities: Breadth 3and Depth

Safety & Security 3

• HumanResourceDevelopment

Estimation of local and migratory population 3

Stage 1:

Socio-economic

feasibility

study

� Infrastructure assessment

� Human Resource assessment

� Tourism centric EIA

� Carrying Capacity Assessment

Stage 2:cDMO

mobilizationand creation;

CapacityBuilding

� Identifying training needs

� Training programmes/workshops

� Evaluation and certi�cation

Stage 3:

Market

Linkage

� Identify counterparts/ other cooperatives

� Stakeholder mapping

� Portal Development

� Participation in tourism fairs / expositions

Source: YES BANK Analysis

� Energy� FoodLocal

Resources

� Q uality� U sage

� C onstruction� S oil, Forests

� A ir and Noise� Waste Disposal� A rchitectural

Water

Land Use

Pollution

Source: YES BANK Analysis

Figure 21: Tourism Centric EIA

Figure 20: Cooperative Tourism Model - Establishment & Mobilization

Page 46:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

34

involved in tourism activities

Nature of employment (perennial/ seasonal) 3

Duration of seasonality, average income levels 3

Present private ownership/ local entrepreneurs 3

Education infrastructure 3

Sectoral training infrastructure 3

Training needs 3

Training sources 3

• CarryingCapacityAssessment

Natural Environment 3

Built Environment 3

Socio-Cultural Ecosystem 3

Stage 2: cDMO mobilization and creation; Capacity Building Training Areas:• Hospitality• Accommodation• FoodandCatering• Activities• NatureandEnvironment• RecreationandTourism• Transport

The capacity building process runs on two broad themes – one, raising tourism awareness, developing the community’s cognition towards looking at tourism as a source of income, and second, training the communities toward establishing tourism products, and their operation and maintenance.

Figure 22: Rhododendrons with Nanda Kot in backdrop, Village Dhur, Bageshwar Ecotourism Cooperative Society, District Bageshwar, Uttarakhand.; Rhododendron

squash is a popular commodity among tourists to this region and such cottage industries benefit through tourism activities

Page 47:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

35

Recreation and Tourism- The meaning of recreation and tourism- Basics of tourism- Rural tourism: definition/ structure- Trends in rural tourism on national and international level

Hospitality- Understanding what hospitality is- Guest expectations- Interpersonal skills- Importance of communication (first impressions; on the phone; mail e.g. personal identity)- Integration: family – primary occupation – tourism

Accommodation- Quality standards- Types of accommodation- Location of the accommodation

Food & Catering- Food service opportunities (e.g. Breakfast/ lunch/ dinner/self-service)- Using local foods and recipes - Regional products- Importance of hygiene in food preparation

Activities- General recreational activities in Rural Tourism: Indoor & Outdoor- Opportunities for special groups e.g. Children, people with disabilities

Nature and Environment- Environmental awareness of use of resources e.g. sea, forest- Environmentally aware activities

Page 48:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

36

Marketing and Promotion Activities: Details

Apart from the portal, Edge of India, which is a key element to directly link the cooperatives with the market, both domestic and international, efforts have also been undertaken to integrate the tourism models into the business ecosystem, forging linkages with various stakeholders in tourism and other business value chain as shown in the figure below.

Stakeholder Mapping focuses upon the following aspects.

Identify:• Transporters• GrocerySuppliers• ActivityManagers/Suppliers• TravelAgents/TourOperators

Devise:• Tie-upterms/commissionstructures• Businessethics/ResponsibleTourismcodeofconduct

Identify cooperatives

working in tourism

or allied �elds

(agriculture, �sheries,

health, education etc.)

Look for possible

lines of collaboration

(human resource,

activities / product

o�erings, backend

supplies)

Identify existing

sustainable tourism

initiatives in the

region

Look for branding /

co-branding

opportunites

Source: YES BANK Analysis

Figure 23: Market Linkage Snapshot

Page 49:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

37

Unique Features of the Project

While there are many projects running across the length and breadth of the entire country to promote rural tourism as a sustainable growth model for rural areas, given below are a few characteristics that render the project unique.

• ThisistheoneofthefirstprojectsinthecountrytryingtodevelopruraltourismmodelsthroughcooperativeDestination Management Organizations (cDMOs), based upon cooperative principles.

• Theprojectgivesequalemphasistocapacitybuildingmeasures,whileutilizingtheexistinginfrastructure(homestays) to offer an authentic ethnic experience.

• Thisisoneofthefewprojectswherethecommunityisbeingimpartedtechnicalskillslikedevelopingandmanaging web content.

There is no credit/ microfinance involved in the initial stages and the project utilizes the current assets of the region to build up resources. The focus is upon institutional innovation by creating a sustainable financing environment before credit can be injected into the rural economies

The network is being developed through a programme funded by the Scottish Government and implemented by partners in India and Scotland, including Public & Social Policies Management (PSPM) division of YES BANK , Queen Margaret University and Dunira Strategy.

Potential for Replication: The Buddhist Pilgrimage

One of the major unifying characteristics of South, South-East and East Asia, the Buddhist heritage spans a long and rich history dating back to almost 2, 500 years. India holds the unique distinction of being the source of origination for the Buddhist philosophy, holding within its boundaries a number of significant destinations that Lord Buddha traversed on his path of enlightenment.

The Buddhist circuit is also one of the most popular tourism product offerings, drawing in huge numbers from South and South East Asia, as well as from the western religion economies Europe and America. The importance of this niche is also highlighted in the government’s efforts to develop the circuit, both in terms of core and peripheral infrastructure near key destinations, as well as extending services like Visa on Arrival for tourists from Buddhist countries, and focusing the Clean India Campaign on these destinations.

Page 50:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

38

An important fact to note here is that the Buddist Pilgrimage not only attains importance in terms of attracting the leisure traveller, but also scholars and practitioners of the Buddhist faith interested in the meditative practices and deeper research into Buddha’s life and philosophy, who do not mind the ‘long-haul’ nature of some of these destinations and imply a higher number of tourist nights - in line with the Ministry of Tourism’s objectives to strengthen this positive aspect of tourist propensity towards longer stay in the country.

Ensuring ‘Inclusiveness’ in the Development of Buddhist Pilgrimage

The infrastructure around Buddhist Circuit is rapidly undergoing upgradation, and it is important to ensure that human resource development is synergized with these transformations, and the local community is not only cognizant of the development, but also plays an active role in the administration and managerial aspects of development projects, which can ensure that the models envisaged remain sustainable.

UPSarnath,

Kushinagar,Kapilavastu,Kaushambi,

Sankisa, Sravasti

BiharBodhgaya, Nalanda, Rajgir,

Vaishali

OdishaKalinga, Ratnagiri, Udayagiri,Lalitgiri, Puphagiri, Marichi,

Madhya PradeshSanchi

HP J&K(Spiti),(Ladakh), (Arunachal Pradesh)North East

NepalLumbiniBhutan

Monastries and monuments (like Takstang)

Sri Lanka : Anuradhapura, PolonnaruwaOther Regions (Tibet, Thailand, Cambodia,

Indonesia, Vietnam, China, Japan)

Source: YES BANK Analysis

Figure 24: Buddhist Pilgrimage: An Integrated Tourism Circuit in Asia

Page 51:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

39

Action Strategy & Approach

The initial focus is upon the community coming up with their own action plan for problem resolution, forging partnerships with key developmental organizations working in the region, and establishing market linkages.

� Preliminary assessment of the cluster to identify existing programmes/projects� M arket Research & Value Chain Analysis� H uman Resource assessment of the Catchment Area including preliminary

analysis of local Focus Groups w.r.t. women participation, communityleadership

� Identity training needs to bridge the skill gaps� S kill development training programmes /workshops on entrepreneurship,

Marketing and Promotional Strategies� P latform/Forums for Knowledge Sharing� I nstitutions like co-operatives to give a focused push towards enterprise

development and management

� Focussed Training for Institutions including Self-Help Groups, Cooperativesetc., on Business opportunities in Tourism Space.

� C reate Promotional Products including Website, Promotional Materials aimed atcreating awareness and access to Tourism in the catchment area

1. Catchment Area Analysis

2. Capacity Building Exercises & Institutionalization

3. Entrepreneurship Development andPromotional Activities

Source: YES BANK Analysis

Figure 25: Cooperative Approach in Buddhist Pilgrimage: Action Strategy

Page 52:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge
Page 53:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

YES BANK - ASSOCHAM Roadmap: Achieving Social Equity through Tourism

Chapter : 4

Page 54:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge

Tourismin India

42

1. Reinforce Policy with Action Measures: The Government is cognizant of the fact that tourism is changing the rural economies and has allotted sufficient funds for the purpose. However, the policy framework is very basic and theoretical in nature, which alienates them from on ground scenarios, making execution strategies difficult to implement. Now that there are successful models running in the country, it might prove to be beneficial to revisit these frameworks in their light and address the lacunae.

2. Capacity Building: Lack of skilled human resource has been a hindrance towards realizing the full potential of the Tourism sector. Capacity building programmes are conducted across various aspects of the tourism and hospitality sector. The quality of training resources and infrastructure needs to improve to churn out a competitive workforce.

3. Train Entrepreneurs: While the training infrastructure for the sector is evolving, the focus is still upon the operations and logistical aspects rather than establishing businesses. Rural entrepreneurs, in recent times, have proved to be the success story of the emerging Indian economy, and given suitable guidance, they can very well champion the cause of sustainable tourism models.

4. Community Trust: Lack of active participation of the local community in strategizing and decision making process have led to breeding antagonism and violence in extreme cases. Rather than forcing business options on communities, it would be wiser to involve them in the process from the beginning itself.

5. ‘Real’ Ownership: A major part of community antagonism arises from the fact that apart from basic operations, the other business aspects lie externally, leading to economic leakages and improper tourist behaviour at times. Ensuring self-managed models is one of the surest and safest ways to put faith back in the system.

4. YES BANK - ASSOCHAM Roadmap: Achieving Social Equity through Tourism

Page 55:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge
Page 56:  · example of the endeavour to promote Buddhist pilgrimage, covering primary pilgrimage sites such as Lumbini, Bodhgaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar. ASSOCHAM, through strategic knowledge