Evidenced Based Behavioral

Treatment (EBT) of AD/HD in

Children Kimberly Sirl, PhDOctober 12, 2013

• Behavior Therapy• Behavioral parent training• Behavioral Classroom management• Intensive Behavioral Treatment

Current EBT’s for AD/HD

Parent-training• Contingency management strategies

– Immediate Feedback– Frequent Feedback– Consistent Feedback– Positive / Novel Reinforcement

School interventions

• Daily Behavior Report Card– Russell Barkley, PhD.

• Classroom accommodations– 504 Plan– Individual Education Plan (IEP) under

educational dx of Other Health Impairment (OHI)

Summer Treatment Program

William Pelham, PhD

8 weeks 9 hours /day–Explicit behavioral instruction 2 hrs

Recreational group activities 2 hrs

Behavior modification

Parent training & involvement in B-mod

Behavior Therapy Obstacles

• Recent longitudinal research indicates that When kids start stimulant meds first, families are less likely to try behavior therapy (Pelham)

Behavior Therapy Obstacles

• Lack of consumer education about EBTs

• Efforts to inform consumers about EBTshttp://effectivechildtherapy.com

http://helpyourkeiki.com

Behavior Therapy ObstaclesDifficulties accessing EBT

• Demand outweighs the supply• Insurance issues• Competing demands on family

Neuropsychological Perspective on AD/HD• Neuropsycholgoical tests can measure

and describe deficits in specific neurocognitive processes

• Executive Functioning skills are often less well-developed in children with AD/HD compared to same-aged peers

• Higher order cognitive skills that allow for controlled, intentional, goal directed behavior

• Processes that guide, direct and manage cognitive, emotional and behavioral functions, especially during novel problem solving

• Organization – Cognitive flexibility

• Working Memory – Self-monitoring

• Task Initiation – Inhibition

• Task Persistence – Emotion Modulation

• Planning – Fluency

What Are Executive Functions?

Will my child outgrow ADHD?

• Neuroanatomical structures and executive functioning skills continue to develop until young adulthood

Specific Executive Functions

– Organization – Cognitive flexibility– Working Memory – Self-monitoring– Task Initiation – Inhibition– Task Persistence – Planning– Emotion Modulation – Fluency

Working Memory

The ability to mentally manipulate information

held in immediate attention– Online” processing– Flexible problem solving– Rehearsal

Children with AD/HD have moderate to marked Working Memory Deficits

Promising Interventions to Improve Specific Executive

Functioning Skills

Working Memory Training

• Cogmed– Computer based daily training

• 25 training sessions, 30-40 min. each for 5 weeks• separate programs for preschoolers,

children/adolescents, and adults• Progress monitored by a qualified coach weekly• Not covered by insurance

Working Memory Training

• Cogmed: Promising empirical evidence– Improvements in parent & teacher ratings of attention,

inhibition, academic performance, & daily functioning• Metanalysis 769 kids, 82% improved inattention sx• Baseline to post tx improvement average of 36%

– Improvement generalizes to other measures of WM– Improvement in visual spatial & verbal WM– Improvements maintained at 3-6 mos. f/u

Green el al (2012)

Working Memory TrainingDiscriminant validity

does not improve IQ, LTM, reading decoding

Impacts symptoms of inattention primarily

Not clearly better than current EBTs

Neurofeedback Treatments

Uses EEG to modify cortical arousal Theta/Beta Protocols (US)

• Initial QEEG mapping• 20-40 30-60 min. sessions, initially 2-3x/wk • Uses operant conditioning to maintain EEG within

target range (i.e., video dims /brightens)

Neurofeedback Treatments

• Research methodology improving– Improved attention compared to WLC– Not clearly better than placebo/sham tx– Current EBT’s much easier & cheaper

(Loo & Makeig, 2012)

Pediatric Cognitive Remediation Programs

– Focused on systematic training of attention and executive functioning skills

– Uses aspects of cognitive-behavior therapy(e.g., self-talk, reinforcement)

– Butler & Copeland (2002)

20 2 hour sessions

Pediatric Cognitive Remediation Programs

– Promising evidence from clinical trials– Multicenter study of pediatric cancer survivors

sign. improvements post-intervention in parent ratings of attention & academic functioning (Butler et al 2008)

Pilot fMRI Studydifferences in brain activation between survivors & controls at baseline, but survivors showed increased activation post remediation and at 6 month follow-up (Zou et al 2012)

Abbreviated Ped. Cognitive Remediation Program

- 6 1-hour individual sessions

- included variety of neurological dx (e.g, ADHD, TS, NF epilepsy)

- improved on 4 types of attentionselective, sustained, shifting & divided attention

using auditory & visual measures

(O’Toole et al @ CHOA)

Brain Balance System

• Limited empirical evidence– Uses sensory integration, nutrition and

cognitive exercises to improve balance between left and right brain functioning

Acknowledgements

Special thanks for assistance in the preparation of this presentation goes to :

– Stephanie Powell, Ph.D.– Shera Kafka & Lisa Hadley of 454-TEEN– SLCH Family Resource Center