Upload File

evidence-based practice aupha annual meeting, june 20, 2013, monterey if doctors can do it managers...

  • Home
  • Documents
  • Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?
34
Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Upload: claud-harvey

Post on 26-Dec-2015

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

Report

Tags:

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Evidence-Based Practice

AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey

If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Page 2: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Evidence?

outcome of scientific research,

organizational facts & data,

benchmarking, best practices,

collective experience, personal

experience, intuition

Page 3: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

All managers base their

decisions on ‘evidence’

Page 4: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

However ...

Page 5: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Many managers pay little

or no attention to the

quality of the evidence they

base their decisions on

Page 6: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Trust me, 20 years of management experience

Page 7: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Teach managers how to

critically evaluate the validity,

and generalizability of the

evidence and help them find

‘the best available’ evidence

Page 8: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Evidence-based decision

Page 9: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

What is the added value of evidence- based

practice for managers within the field of

hospital care?

Proof of concept

Page 10: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Teaching Hospital

- 6 managers

University Hospital

- 4 managers

Evidence based pilot

Page 11: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Phase 1: Training managers in the principles of EBP

Phase 2: Examination of the current decision making

processes that managers are using

Phase 3: Evaluation of 4 completed projects from an

EB perspective (retrospective)

Phase 4: Making EB recommendations for 4 new

projects (prospective)

Phase 5: Evaluation

Evidence based pilot

Page 12: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Some preliminary results

Page 13: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Decision making process

Page 14: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Decision making process

Focus on procedures instead of evidence

Internal politics and power struggles

No critical appraisal of the evidence at hand

Relying on anecdotal evidence (workshops,

best practices, popular management books,

consultants)

One option (sometimes two)

Bias: Outcome, Halo, Confirmation, etc.

Page 15: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Post mortem analysis

Page 16: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Evidence-based perspective

NOT: Did we made the right decision?

BUT: Is there evidence from scientific research to

support (or call into question) the approach

taken?

Best available evidence?

Page 17: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Post mortem: leadership training

Page 18: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

leadership training: dm process

No problem definition

No organizational evidence consulted

Selection of training companies based on

experience, recommendation or reputation

No explicit selection criteria / procedure

‘Best’ presentation has won: one size fits all

Page 19: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

leadership training: scientific evidence

15 meta analyses, 5 relevant

37 (‘systematic’) reviews, 2 relevant

Lots of relevant primary studies

Page 20: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

leadership training: scientific evidence

Long history (30 yrs): moderate effect sizes

Senior & middle managers tend to benefit more

than managers at the supervisory level

Effect on ‘poor’ leaders is limited.

Leadership trainings that focus on

interpersonal / social skills show higher effect

sizes than those based on a specific leadership

‘model’

Page 21: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Reactions

Who knew?

Denial

Anger

Bargaining

Acceptance

Page 22: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Prospective /

EB recommendations

Page 23: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Questions / projects

360 degree feedback

Financial incentives

Lean Six Sigma

Hand Hygiene

Goal setting

Value Based Health Care

Downsizing

Page 24: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Evidence-based perspective

NOT: What works?

BUT: What are, given the target group, the problem and

the context involved, the main factors determining the

success or failure of the project that need to be taken into

account?Best available scientific

evidence?

Page 25: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Prospective: Multi Source Feedback

Page 26: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Multi Source Feedback: background

IFMS: based on multi source feedback

Regulating bodies and insurance companies

(KPI’s – prices/ revenue)

Based on CANMEDS, no standard method

New market: consulting firms

Page 27: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Process

Scoping session: inventory of the aspects

relevant to the question

Session with leading academic

Search in relevant databases

Critical Appraisal

Summary / research synthesis

Recommendations / guidelines

Page 28: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Multi Source Feedback: scientific evidence

223 primary studies on MSF, 42 relevant

6 meta analyses or systematic reviews on

MSF, 3 relevant

18 meta analyses or systematic reviews on

‘feedback’ or ‘performance appraisal’,

5 relevant

Page 29: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Content of the feedback (neg vs pos)

Way of the delivery of the feedback

Interpretation of the feedbackPersonality of the

rateeFeedback orientation

of the ratee

Type and number of ratersSelection of

raters

Rater reliablity (patients, nurses,

colleagues)Type of

response scale

Development vs perfomance appraisal

Organizational culture

Perceived procedural justice

Multi Source Feedback: main factors

Page 30: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Reactions

Who knew?

Wow!

Great!

Good stuff!

Relevant!

Page 31: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?
Page 32: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Lessons learned I

New approach

Recalibrates the power dynamics (accountability!)

The profit is in the process

Different (better?) decisions were made

Doctors love it!

Page 33: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

Lessons learned II

Hard for individual managers

It starts with the senior management team

It’s all about accountability

Support system

EBP > Planning & Control

Page 34: Evidence-Based Practice AUPHA Annual Meeting, June 20, 2013, Monterey If doctors can do it managers can do it?

One day, maybe …

Chief Evidence Officer


“Alone we can do so little. Together we can do so much.” Touch-July-August... · “Alone we can do so little. Together we can do so much.” Helen Keller, lecturer What have

Anything you can do - I can do uniquer!...Anything you can do - I can do uniquer! Author Frank Dahle Created Date 5/31/2018 10:48:02 AM

Can Do Descriptors - wida.wisc.edu · The WIDA Can Do Descriptors, Key Uses Edition, Grades K–12 The WIDA Can Do Descriptors provide examples of what language learners can do at

TOEIC Can-Do Guide: Linking TOEIC Scores to Activities ...dl.ueb.vnu.edu.vn/bitstream/1247/2978/1/TOEIC_CAN_DO.pdf · TOEIC Can –Do Guide 1 TOEIC Can-Do Guide This TOEIC Can-Do

Can Do Descriptors - Utah Education NetworkThe WIDA Can Do Descriptors, Key Uses Edition, Grades K–12 The WIDA Can Do Descriptors provide examples of what language learners can do

Can Do Descriptors...The WIDA Can Do Descriptors, Key Uses Edition, Grades K–12 The Can Do Descriptors provide examples of what language learners can do at various stages of English

Alone we can do so little; together we can do so much

ANYTHING YOU CAN DO, I CAN DO BETTER - parma.com · ANYTHING YOU CAN DO, I CAN DO BETTER . Presented to: ©2017 . Scynthia Syfrett, ESIS . Sheila Allameh, Pacific Neurobehavioral

Can do. Will do. Still do

Anything You Can Do, I Can Do Better: Study of Females

Anything You Can Do, I Can Do Better: Finding Expert Teams

Anything You Can Do, I Can Do Better: Finding Expert Teams ...ranger.uta.edu/~cli/pubs/2014/crewscout-cikm14demo-hassan.pdf · Anything You Can Do, I Can Do Better: Finding Expert

CAN DO SHOULD DO MUST DO

Evidence-Based Practice: If Doctors Can Do It, Managers Can Do It?

CAN-DO spirit!

‘CAN DO’ OBJECTIVE

Can do! - Multitech

UNDERSTANDING THE U.S. HEALTH SERVICES SYSTEM Fourth Edition · U.S. HEALTH SERVICES SYSTEM Fourth Edition Phoebe Lindsey Barton AUPHA. BRIEF CONTENTS ... Aids to Understanding the

Anything You Can Do, I Can Do Better: Finding Expert Teams ...naeemul/file/crewscout-cikm14demo-hassan.pdf · Anything You Can Do, I Can Do Better: Finding Expert Teams by CrewScout∗

RULES INSTRUCTIONS WE CAN ’ T DO AND WE CAN DO

Www.KARNA.org. Nobody can do everything, however everyone can do something

What can you do when there is nothing you can do!

What Can Now-Do Do For You

CAHME Update at AUPHA Annual Meeting 2017

YOU CAN DO

Yes Can Do

“Anything you can do we can do better” · 2017. 9. 22. · 2 “Anything you can do we can do better” An exploration using the method of grounded theory into whether successful

Microsoft 365 What it can do & What can we do with it?

CAN Do 2012

Anything You Can Do, I Can Do Better: Finding Expert Teams by …ranger.uta.edu/.../crewscout-cikm14demo-hassan-poster.pdf · 2018. 7. 5. · Anything You Can Do, I Can Do Better:

ALL ABOUT GYMNASTICS. YOU CAN LEARN DIFFERENT MOVES. You can do the splits. You can do a summer salt. you can do a flip

Should Do, Can Do, Can Knoweli.informatics.indiana.edu/indexfull_files/limits19-final14.pdfShould Do, Can Do, Can Know . Sustainability and Other Reflections on One Hundred and One

Anything They Can Do We Can Do Better: Examining Major

Can Do Houston

Revised AUPHA presentation June25, 2009