evaluation of zot!portalkobsa/courses/inf231/15f/group1-pre... · 2015. 12. 4. · mockups survey...
TRANSCRIPT
Zot!Portal - Mission StatementTo provide UCI students, faculty, staff, and the community a single campus resource for efficient, unified, and customized access to the information and tools they need.
Project Requirements
● Understand the main reasons behind the low adoption rate of Zot!Portal among students.
● Collect feedback regarding the existing portal features using various methodologies.
● Suggest required changes and enhancements to the portal based on the user requirements.
● Gain user feedback regarding the newly implemented and enhanced feature mockups for the portal.
User Groups
Users
Staff
Undergraduates Graduates
Students
Project Methodology ● Interviews
To gather information on what users like and don’t like about the portal and new features they would like to find in it.
● Survey Reach a larger audience to collect feedback on existing features and comments on planned new features.
● Card Sorting Capture user rationales and priorities to determine hierarchy of portlets and organization of tabs.
● Usability Test Session Capture ease of portal usage and reveal usability problems.
Interviews
Methodology:
● Identified user groups for students.
● Interviewed 3-4 users from each group with varied background.
● Interviewed staff from different departments.
● Open ended questions were asked to get a holistic view.
● Encouraged users to access the portal and provide their feedback on the go.
● Carried over questions and observations from previous interviews to find overlapping likes and
dislikes.
Student interviews
Demographics:
● Interviewed 17 students ( Grads and Undergrads )
● 5 - heard of ZotPortal, 12 - not heard of ZotPortal
Comments and Observations:
● Low familiarity of layout - Students frequently use search box.
● Navigation not intuitive.
● Announcement tab is good, need notification functionality.
● Home page is cluttered with lot of information.
Student interviews (contd.) List of new portlets planned based on the Interviews:
● Zotlink for career/jobs related information.
● ZotAccount for billing/account information.
● Centralized appointment scheduling for counseling, health center and international center.
● Centralized booking facility for study rooms.
● Housing information.
● Notifications that can be imported into personal calendar easily.
● Sortable and Easily categorizable announcements.
● Degree/graduation requirement and progress.
Staff interviewsDemographics:
● Total of 7 interviews from distinct departments in UCI.
Like:
● Ease of customization offered by the portlets.● Bookmark portlet.
Wishlist:
● Directory lookup from within ZotPortal.● Automated site tutorial whenever necessary.● Categorized search results.● More graphical, less textual information.● More multimedia content.● More visual adjustments in layout (background color for portlets).
SurveysMethodology:
● After the interviews,
○ The problem scope was relatively clear.
○ Interview results were available for brainstorming questions.
● Hence, Surveys were conducted in order to get statistical data.
● We focused on:
○ Gauging usefulness of existing and proposed new features by user rating.
○ Navigation and Search features.
● We conducted two surveys based on user groups:
○ One for students
○ One for Staff
● Surveys consisted a mix of open and close-ended questions.
Student Survey Results
● 144 responses
● Most important features○ Notifications○ ZotLink Integration○ Degree requirements○ Appointments
● Less important features○ Social Media○ Housing Information
Survey Results
Students Choices
Staff Survey Results
● 59 responses
● Most important features○ Improve Search Feature○ Website Tutorial○ Reorganize Menu Tabs
● Less important features○ Social Media○ Different Colors for each portlet
● Survey Results
Staff Choices
Usability Test Session
● Aimed at capturing usability problems within the existing Zot!Portal.● Used Morae software tool to capture sessions.
● 15 participants belonging to different user groups.● Duration: 20-30 mins
The test included 5 tasks which captured various aspects like,
● Presentation of Information● Navigation● Usability● Organization of tabs● Search capability
Usability Test Session - Comments
Overall● Great job bringing useful information together.
Presentation● Overwhelming information in a congested 3-column layout.● Would like to have personalized information.
Organization of Tabs● More tabs can be added and regrouped to improve navigation.
Search Capability● Lacks provision for finding portlets and ability to filter results.
Card Sorting
● Participants sorted the portlets into groups to be organized as tabs.
● Selected portlets to be added to home as default.
● Prioritized the new portlets to be added to portal.
● 8 participants
● Duration: ~10 mins
Mockups
● Survey and Card Sorting results are considered to build the initial mockups.
● Mockups of new features, improved features and default layout designs are developed using balsamiq.
● Previous participants were asked to compare above mockups against the existing ZotPortal design & features.
Mockups for StudentsNew Features: Notifications, Appointments, ZotLink info, Degree Requirements ...
Improved Features: Search Results, My Courses, ZotAccount Summary, Study Space Locator ...
View
Mockups for StaffNew Features: Onboarding tutorial, Notifications, Suggested Bookmarks
Improved Features: Search with Autocomplete & Filters, Reorganized Menu
View
Task Name Timeline Persons responsible Status
Initial discussion and ramping up on project details
Week 2 SG 1, SG 2, SG 3 ✅
Student interviews (Phase 1) Week 3 - Week 4 SG 1, SG 2 ✅
Staff interviews (Phase 1) Week 4 SG 3 ✅
Usability test sessions Week 4 SG 1, SG 2(Students) SG 3 (Staff) ✅
Survey Week 5 SG 1, SG 2(Students) SG 3 (Staff) ✅
Mockups/ Wireframes Week 6 SG 1, SG 2, SG 3 ✅
Student/ Staff interviews (Phase 2) Week 7 SG 1, SG 2(Students) SG 3 (Staff)
Final Mockups/ Wireframes Week 8 SG 1, SG 2, SG 3
Presentation and Report Week 9 SG 1, SG 2, SG 3
Project Timeline SG 1 (Jwala Mohith, Vijaykumar), SG 2 (Yugandhar, Rajani, Anjana), SG 3 (Prateek, Swanand, Rathan)
Revised Project Timeline
Task Name Deadline Persons responsible
Staff interviews (Phase 2) Finals Week (Dec. 7) SG 3 (Staff)
Final Mockups Finals Week (Dec. 7) SG 1, SG 2, SG 3
Final Report Finals Week (Dec. 10) SG 1, SG 2, SG 3
Questions?