evaluation of led-outlined backplates at intersections...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections With Light Rail Lines
In Houston, Texas
ITS Texas Annual Meeting, November 2014 Jonathan Tydlacka, P.E. (TTI)
![Page 2: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Why Are We Here Today? • Great forum to present results of
evaluations of innovative traffic control devices
• Seek feedback and comments on the operational concepts
![Page 3: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
METRORail History
• METRORail Red Line opened in Houston, Texas - January 2004
• Extended North - January 2014 • Completely at-grade with shared
left turn lanes in some areas • Line operates from North Loop,
CBD, down to Texas Medical Center, and Reliant Park
• Currently carries about 42,000 passengers per day
![Page 4: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Initial Operational Issues
• High Frequency of Accidents (15) in 6 weeks of testing & 1st month of revenue operation
• All with motor vehicles
• All were low speed collisions at intersections
• Collisions were sudden from LRV perspective
• All attributed to motorist error
![Page 5: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
TCD Experimentation
• Stop bar location & visibility – Lighted Stop Bar
• Increase visibility of red signal indications – LED-outlined Backplates
![Page 6: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Evaluation Methodology
• TCD Experimentation Request • Driver Surveys • Operational Evaluations
– Before / After – Measures of Effectiveness (violations)
• Long Term Crash Monitoring – Crashes by type/causation
• Semi-annual reports
![Page 7: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Lighted Stop Bar Pilot Installation
• EB Jefferson Street at Main Street • FHWA Approved Experiment 4-295-EX • Stop Bar activated March 25, 2006 • Operational Aspects as Initially Evaluated:
– Markers operated in a steady red mode during every red signal indication of the traffic signal
– Markers off at all other times – Markers located prior to painted stop line
![Page 8: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Pilot Installation
![Page 9: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Replacement System & Additional Locations • Several failures at pilot installation • Pilot site & additional sites outfitted to 3G & 4G system
• FHWA granted request to expand experimentation
![Page 10: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Lighted Stop Bar Problems
• Newer 3G and 4G systems had durability issues
• Failures of the individual markers and the systems
• High traffic volumes, moisture, debris penetration – all factors leading to failure.
• Systems had IP addressable markers, so failures were reported BUT…
• The costs for repairs and replacements were too great in terms of dollars and manpower – A change was necessary.
![Page 11: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
LED-Outlined Traffic Signal Backplates
• Around the same time that the first pilot lighted stop bar was being tested, METRO was also testing a pilot location of LED-outlined traffic signal backplates
• The backplates were part of the same FHWA Experimentation Request.
![Page 12: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
LED-Outlined Backplates Pilot Installation
• WB Gray at Main Street • FHWA Approved Experiment 4-295-EX • Backplates activated October 13, 2006 • Operational Aspects:
– Red LEDs create a red border around the standard black traffic signal backplate for each signal head on the approach.
– Operate in a steady red mode during every red signal indication of the traffic signal & Off at all other times (including red or yellow flash).
![Page 13: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
LED-Outlined Backplates
![Page 14: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
• Mounted to signal mast arm
• Two signal faces
• No backplates before LED-outlined backplates added
LED-Outlined Backplates
![Page 15: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
LED-Outlined Backplates Results Motorist Violation Data – Pilot Site
Evaluation Period
24-hour Totals of WB Vehicles
WB Violations per Day
WB Violations per Day per
10,000 Vehicles
Left Turn Thru Right
Turn RLR* RTOR* RLR RTOR
Before (3 Day Average) 401 8089 381 19 68 22 76
After (3 Day Average) 273 6870 351 8 53 11 71
*RLR = Red Light Running *RTOR = Right Turn on Red Note: RTOR prohibited on all cross street approaches to the Red Line
![Page 16: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
LED Backplate - Vehicle Crash Statistics
• Crash statistics compiled for 24 months before and after the installation of the LED Backplates.
Period Total Crashes Ran Red Light (WB)
Before 24 Months 3 2
After 24 Months 1 0
![Page 17: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Maintenance & Durability Comparisons
Issue LED-Outlined Backplates Lighted Stop Bar
Installation
•Attach to signal pole or mast arm •No Experience with Span Wire
•Saw Cut, Run Cables •Anchor Markers •Time-consuming
Maintenance •None •Replace markers if full or partial failure
Durability
•Works fine for years (8+ years and counting) •Only failure - over-height truck
•Marker failure due to wheel impacts (very common) •System/wiring failures (less common)
Replacement •Purchase new LED strip •Assemble & Install
•Vendor/contractor remove old marker & drop in new one
![Page 18: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Monetary Cost Comparisons
Issue LED-Outlined Backplates Lighted Stop Bar
Initial Capital Cost (One Typical Approach)
•$2,500 - $3,000 each •$5,000 - $6,000 per 2 signal intersection
•$70,000 (about 30 markers)
Ongoing Maintenance Costs •None
•If no warranty (likely), then $20,000 per approach per year
![Page 19: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Observational Study of Additional Sites • Three LED-outlined backplate treatment
sites for Before & After Study – Westbound Pease at Main – Westbound Bell at Main – Westbound Franklin at Main
• Pease & Bell are five-lane, one-way approaches to the Red Line, Franklin is a three-lane approach.
• Replaced standard backplates with LED-outlined backplates
![Page 20: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Observational Study of Additional Sites
• Before & After Study using recorded video
– 3 days (three 24-hour periods) of video before – 3 days of video after backplates installed and
activated • Approx 5-8 weeks after activation
– Manually reduced video
• Study still ongoing – Data is complete for Pease at Main treatment location
![Page 21: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Observational Study of Additional Sites
• Several differences from pilot location
• Mounted to signal poles (one on each side)
• Two signal faces
• Pease site had backplates before LED-outlined backplates added
![Page 22: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Observational Study of Additional Sites • Data included traffic volumes and violations
– Red Light Running (RLR) – Right Turn On Red (RTOR)
• RTOR prohibited on all cross street approaches to the Red Line
• Some deliberate RLR violations in both
before and after periods – Violations occuring after more than 90 seconds
of red time were removed
![Page 23: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Three Day Average Violation Frequency
24-hour Totals of WB
Vehicles WB Violations
per Day
WB Violations per Day Day*
(Daylight) Night
(No Daylight) Left Turn Thru Right
Turn RLR RTOR RLR RTOR RLR RTOR
Before (3 Day
Average) 106 10794 223 10.33 24.33 7.67 20.33 2.67 3.67
After (3 Day
Average) 84 10115 176 8.67 19.33 7.00 15.33 1.67 4.00
% Change -21% -6% -21% -16% -21% -9% -25% -37% +9%
*Note: Day includes daylight and twilight periods of the day.
Westbound Pease at Main – Treatment Site
![Page 24: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Notes on Violation Frequency • Reduction of RLR and RTOR at each
treatment site – Similar reductions for both day and night, except for
RTOR at night, which essentially stayed the same
• Normalized data to account for different approach traffic volumes – Violations per 10,000 cross street approach vehicles – Pooled t-Test used to determine significant
differences in Before vs. After data
![Page 25: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Normalized Violation Data
Study Site Study Period
3-Day Average Number of Violations per Day per
10,000 Vehicles
Statistically Significant Reduction in Violations per Day per 10,000 Vehicles?
RLR RTOR RLR RTOR
Pease at Main
Before 9.3 21.9
NO
YES
90% Confidence
Level After 8.4 18.6
![Page 26: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Additional Observational Study Data • Time of violation after onset of red signal
(> 2) Signal red more than 2 seconds (≤ 2) Signal red less than or equal to 2 seconds
– RLR
• More RLR in ≤ 2 data • Reduction of 20% for > 2 • Reduction of 15% for ≤ 2
![Page 27: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Crash Monitoring
• Long-term crash analysis still ongoing for these and all LED-outlined backplate locations
• Being done to provide additional data points at FHWA & TxDOT request
![Page 28: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
In Summary • LED-outlined backplates show potential to supplement the
effectiveness of standard TCD’s along the LRT – Reduction in red light running – Reduction in illegal right turn on red movements
• Helped to reduce RLR and RTOR violations at the treatment site.
![Page 29: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Discussion • Results slightly different for this recent treatment due to
some changes in installation characteristics as well as other factors.
• Previously saw greater reduction of RLR when comparing LED backplates to no backplates. Now, our “before” data had “regular” backplates.
• Previously, LED backplates were mounted on a signal mast arm, visible over the lanes. That seems to have made a greater positive impact than mounting them on signal poles.
• Two other sites currently being analyzed – these will add even more understanding and confidence to the evaluation.
![Page 30: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
METRO’s View On Experimental TCD’s • Working with its local, state and federal
partners, METRO plans to continue developing and deploying innovative TCD’s where in the best interest of its passengers and the traveling public.
• METRO plans to use the LED-outlined backplates on new light rail lines currently under design and initial stages of construction.
![Page 31: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
METRO’s View On Experimental TCD’s • METRO is seeking to garner support for interim
approval to use these devices within its jurisdiction.
• NCUTCD (National Committee) will be making decisions soon about what is included in next MUTCD
• METRO has demonstrated these TCDs to visiting agencies, and conveyed the success of the devices among peers (i.e., APTA Conference in Houston this year)
![Page 32: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
For More Information • TTI
– Jonathan Tydlacka, P.E. • [email protected]
– 713-686-2971
• Houston METRO – Walter Langford, III
• [email protected] – 713-652-4377
![Page 33: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
![Page 34: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Driver Survey Results • LED Backplate
– The focus group tested a flashing LED-outlined backplate concept with both yellow and red indications
– This operation was later changed to steady red only in the field.
– 95% recognized the LED-outlined backplates – 75% responded that the purpose was to draw attention
to the yellow and red signals.
– There was no indication from observation of video of field deployment that drivers are misinterpreting the steady red LED backplate.
![Page 35: Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections ...itstexas.org/sites/itstexas.org/files/presentations/4-LED_Back... · Evaluation of LED-Outlined Backplates at Intersections](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051800/5ac591067f8b9aae1b8e1e52/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)