european parliament 2009 - 2014...pv\814231en.doc pe441.002v03-00 en united in diversity en european...

$: EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT 2009 - 2014...PV\814231EN.doc PE441.002v03-00 EN United in diversity EN EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT 2009 - 2014 Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety$
PV\814231EN.doc PE441.002v03-00

EN United in diversity EN

EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT 2009 - 2014

Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety

ENVI_PV(2010)0315_1

MINUTES Meeting of 15 March 2010, from 15.00 to 18.30,

16 March 2010, from 09.00 to 12.30 and from 15.00 to 18.30, and 17 March 2010, from 09.00 to 12.30

BRUSSELS

The meeting opened at 15.13 on Monday 15 March 2010, with Jo Leinen (Chairman) in the chair.

1. Adoption of agenda

The agenda was adopted as shown in these minutes: Item 9, STOA Activities related to ENVI was withdrawn from the agenda and postponed to a later committee meeting; Items 19 and 20 Pharmacovigilance (McAvan report) were withdrawn from the agenda and postponed to a later committee meeting.

2. Chairman's announcements

2.1 Interpretation status

All languages were available, with the exception of Estonian, Latvian and Maltese on Tuesday morning. 2.2 IAC Review

The chairman advised the committee that the UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon had commissioned the Inter Academy Council (IAC) to conduct an independent review of the processes and the procedures of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. 2.3 Other announcements

Several TV crews (Europarl, Watch TV and VRT nieuws) were filming during the

PE441.002v03-00 2/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

meeting. Dagmar Roth-Behrendt submitted apologies for her absence during the whole meeting due to illness.

3. The obligations of operators who place timber and timber products on the market

ENVI/7/02292 ***II 2008/0198(COD) 05885/4/2010 – C7-0053/2010 T6-0225/2009

Rapporteur: Caroline Lucas (Verts/ALE) Responsible: ENVI Announcement of new Common Position

4. The European Union Strategy for the Baltic Sea Region and the role of macro-regions in the future cohesion policy

ENVI/7/01788 2009/2230(INI)

Draftswoman: Anna Rosbach (EFD) PA – PE438.455v01-00 Responsible: REGI - Wojciech Michał Olejniczak (S&D) PR – PE439.338v02-00 DT – PE431.006v01-00

• Consideration of draft opinion

Speakers: Anna Rosbach, Jo Leinen, Richard Seeber, Marita Ulvskog, Vittorio Prodi, Tadeusz Cymański, Anders Lindholm (DG REGIO) Timetable:

• Deadline for tabling amendments : 16 March 2010, 12.00 • Vote in committee: 7 April 2010

* Dan Jørgensen, (Vice-Chairman) took the chair at 15.42.

*

5. Oral question n° 2010/01 by Chris Davies on the implementation of directive 2000/53/EC on end-of- life vehicles for the period 2005-2008

ENVI/7/01694

• Exchange of views with Commission representatives Speakers: Chris Davies, Soledad Blanco (DG ENV), Vittorio Prodi, Richard Seeber, Jolanta Emilia Hibner

PV\814231EN.doc 3/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

6. Oral question No. 2010/04 jointly by Bas Eickhout, Corinne Lepage, Kriton Arsenis, Esther de Lange and Jan-Gerben Gerbrandy on sustainability criteria for biofuels and biomass

ENVI/7/02312

• Exchange of views with Commission representatives Speakers: Bas Eickhout, Vittorio Prodi, Michail Tremopoulos, Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy, Linda McAvan, Linda McAvan, Fabrizio Barbaso (DG ENER), Hans Van Steen (DG ENER), Philip Owen (DG CLIM)

7. Human rights, social and environmental standards in International Trade agreements

ENVI/7/01742 2009/2219(INI)

Draftsman: Thomas Ulmer (EPP) PA – PE439.249v01-00 Responsible: INTA – Tokia Saïfi (EPP) Opinions: AFET, DEVE, EMPL, ENVI

• Consideration of draft opinion Speakers: Thomas Ulmer, Vittorio Prodi, Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy (on behalf of Antonyia Parvanova), Luis Manuel Portero Sanchez (DG TRADE) Timetable: Deadline for tabling amendments : 18 March 2010, 12.00 Vote in Committee: 27 April 2010

*

Jo Leinen, (Chairman) took back the chair at 17.00.

*

8. Food information to consumers

ENVI/7/00099 ***I 2008/0028(COD) COM(2008)0040 – C6-0052/2008 Draftswoman: Renate Sommer (PPE) PR – PE430.616v01-00

AM – PE431.137v01-00 AM – PE431.051v01-00 AM – PE431.151v01-00

Responsible: ENVI – Opinions: IMCO – Christel Schaldemose (S&D) AD – PE430.628v02-00

AM – PE438.135v03-00

PE441.002v03-00 4/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

AGRI – Marc Tarabella (S&D) AD – PE430.537v02-00 AM – PE430.884v01-00

• Consideration of draft report

Speakers: Renate Sommer, Glenis Willmott, Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Peter Liese, Christa Klaß, Horst Schnellhardt, Pilar Ayuso, Anja Weisgerber, Alojz Peterle, Eric Poudelet (DG SANCO) Timetable: Vote in ENVI: 16 March 2010 Vote in Plenary: May II 2010

The meeting adjourned at 17.53 and resumed on Tuesday 16 March 2010 at 9.16 with Jo Leinen, (Chair) in the chair.

9. Power of legislative delegation

ENVI/7/02287 2010/2021(INI) COM(2009)0673

Draftsman: Jo Leinen (S&D) PA – PE439.162v01-00 AM – PE439.269v01-00

Responsible: JURI József Szájer (PPE) PR – PE439.171v02-00

• Adoption of draft opinion

Decision: Amendments adopted: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14 The draft opinion, as amended, was adopted: in favour: 62; against: 0, abstentions: 0 All other amendments were either withdrawn, fell or were rejected. Timetable: Vote in Plenary: April 2010

10. Food information to consumers

ENVI/7/00099 ***I 2008/0028(COD) COM(2008)0040 – C6-0052/2008

Draftswoman: Renate Sommer (EPP) PR – PE430.616v01-00

AM – PE431.137v01-00 AM – PE431.051v01-00 AM – PE431.151v01-00

Responsible: ENVI

• Adoption of draft report

PV\814231EN.doc 5/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

A procedural motion tabled by the draftswoman to postpone the vote was rejected with 29/30/1 votes. The chairman ruled Amendment 526 inadmissible. Amendments 162, 525, 224, 361 and 511 were ruled admissible. Decision: See attached voting results (Annex I) Timetable: Vote in Plenary: May II 2010

*

The meeting adjourned at 12.20 and resumed at 15.07 with Jo Leinen, (Chairman) in the chair.

* * *

11. Standards of quality and safety of human organs intended for transplantation

ENVI/7/00139 ***I 2008/0238(COD) COM(2008)0818 – C6-0480/2008 Draftsman: Miroslav Mikolášik (PPE) PR – PE430.898v01-00

AM – PE439.155v03-00 Responsible: ENVI Opinions: JURI - Cecilia Wilström (ALDE) AD – PE430.861v02-00 AM – PE438.152v01-00

LIBE – Decision: no opinion • Adoption of draft report

Decision: Amendments adopted: 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 14, 15, 16, 19, 21, 23, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 40, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46/1st part, 46/2nd part, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 59, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 70, 72, 74, 76/1st part, 80, 81, 82, 84, 89, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 101, 102, 103, 104, 106, 107, 108, 110, 118,120, 121, 122, 126, 128, 129, 130, 131, 134, 135, 136, 138, 142, 145, 146, 147, 148, 150, 156, 157, 158, 162, 169, 170, 180, 182, 183, 184, 185, 186, 187, 188, 189, 192, 193, 196, 197, 199, 200, 201, 202, 203, JURI 1, JURI 2, JURI 3, JURI 4, JURI 5, JURI 7, JURI 8, JURI 9, JURI 10, JURI 11, COMP 1, COMP 2, COMP 3, COMP 5, CONS 4 The draft report, as amended, was adopted: in favour: 53; against: 0, abstention: 1 All other amendments were either withdrawn, fell or were rejected.

PE441.002v03-00 6/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

12. Action plan on Organ Donation and Transplantation (2009-2015): Strengthened Cooperation between Member States

ENVI/7/00827 2009/2104(INI) COM(2008)0819 Draftsman: Andres Perello Rodriguez (S&D) PR – PE430.960v02-00

AM – PE439.156v01-00 Responsible: ENVI Opinions: JURI - Eva Lichtenberger (Greens/ALE) AD – PE430.860v02-00

AM – PE438.151v01-00 LIBE – Decision: no opinion

• Adoption of draft report Decision: Amendments adopted: 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 31, 32, 33, COMP 1, JURI 5, JURI 7, JURI A, JURI B, CONS 2, CONS 3 The draft report, as amended, was adopted: in favour: 58; against: 0, abstention: 1 All other amendments were either withdrawn, fell, or were rejected.

13. Joint Baltic Sea Research and Development Programme (BONUS-169)

ENVI/7/01486 ***I 2009/0169(COD) COM(2009)0610 – C7-0263/2009 Draftswoman: Anna Rosbach (EFD) PA – PE438.436v01-00

AM – PE439.291v01-00 Responsible:ITRE – Lena Ek (ALDE) PR – PE438.278v01-00

AM – PE439.384v01-00


Decision: Amendments adopted: 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 18, 19, 20, 21/22, 23/25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 31, 32/33, 34, 36, 39, 41. The draft report, as amended, was adopted: in favour: 54; against: 0, abstention: 1 All other amendments we either withdrawn, fell, or were rejected.

14. Mobilising Information and Communication Technologies to facilitate the transition to an energy-efficient, low-carbon economy

ENVI/7/01778 2009/2228(INI) COM(2009)0111 Draftswoman: Daciana Octavia Sârbu (S&D) PA – PE439.100v01-00

AM – PE439.186v01-00

PV\814231EN.doc 7/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

Responsible: ITRE – Patrizia Toia (S&D) PR – PE438.144v03-00 AM – PE439.383v01-00


Decision: Amendments adopted: 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27 The draft report, as amended, was adopted: in favour: 51; against: 1, abstention: 0 All other amendments we either withdrawn, fell, or were rejected.

15. White Paper: Adapting to climate change: Towards a European framework for action

ENVI/7/00825 2009/2152(INI) COM(2009)0147 Draftman: Vittorio Prodi (S&D) PR – PE430.965v01-00

AM – PE439.124v01-00 AM – PE439.169v01-00

Responsible: ENVI

• Adoption of draft report Decision: Amendments adopted: 1, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 24, 25, 27, 29, 30/first, 30/second, 31, 32, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38/first, 39, 40, 42, 44, 47, 49, 50, 51, 52, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 67, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 93, 94, 95, 97, 98, 100, 101, 104 , 106, 107, 108, 111, 112, 114, 116, 117/first, 119, 121, 122, 123, 124/2nd part, 125, 128, 129, 130, 135, 136, 137, 138/first, 138/second, 139, 140, 141, 143, 144, 147, 148, 151, 157, 158, 159, 161, 162, 164, 165, 166, 167, 170, 171, COMP 1, COMP 2, COMP 3, JURI B, JURI C, JURI 2, JURI 6, JURI 7, REGI 6, REGI 7, REGI 12, REGI 14, REGI 15, REGI 17, REGI 22, ORAL AM (EPP) The draft report, as amended, was adopted: in favour: 49; against: 3, abstentions: 2 All other amendments were either withdrawn, fell, or were rejected.

16. Information on medicinal products subject to medical prescription (amendment of Regulation (EC) No 726/2004)

ENVI/7/00156 ***I 2008/0255(COD) COM(2008)0662 – C6-517/2008 Draftsman: Christofer Fjellner (PPE) Responsible: ENVI Opinions: ITRE – Jorgo Chatzimarkakis (ALDE) PA – PE430.863v01-00

AM – PE438.482v01-00 IMCO – António Fernando Correia De Campos(S&D) PA – PE439.345v01-00

PE441.002v03-00 8/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

• Exchange of views

Speakers: Christofer Fjellner, Jorgo Chatzimarkakis, Andres Perello Rodriguez, Satu Hassi, Peter Liese, Anja Weisgerber, Martin Terberger (DG SANCO).

Timetable: Deadline for tabling amendments: 20 April 2010, 12:00 Consideration of amendments: 2-3 June 2010 Vote in ENVI: 21 - 23 June 2010 Vote in Plenary: September I 2010

17. Information on medicinal products subject to medical prescription (amendment of Directive 2001/83/EC)

ENVI/7/00159 ***I 2008/0256(COD) COM(2008)0663 – C6-0516/2008 Draftsman: Christofer Fjellner (PPE) Responsible: ENVI Opinions: ITRE – Jorgo Chatzimarkakis (ALDE) PA – PE430.857v01-00

AM – PE439.168v01-00 IMCO – Cristian Silviu Buşoi (ALDE) PA – PE439.346v01-00

DT – PE423.713v01-00 • Exchange of views

Speakers: Christofer Fjellner, Jorgo Chatzimarkakis, Andres Perello Rodriguez, Satu Hassi, Peter Liese, Anja Weisgerber, Martin Terberger (DG SANCO).

Timetable: Deadline for tabling amendments: 20 April 2010, 12:00 Consideration of amendments: 2-3 June 2010 Vote in ENVI: 21 - 23 June 2010 Vote in Plenary: September I 2010

*

Corinne Lepage, (Vice-Chairwoman) took the chair at 16.41

*

18. Report on the Commission communication : A community approach on the prevention of natural and man made disasters

ENVI/7/00824 2009/2151(INI) COM(2009)0082 Draftsman: João Ferreira (GUE/NGL) PR – PE439.259v01-00

PV\814231EN.doc 9/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

Responsible:ENVI Opinions:REGI –Viktor Uspaskich (ALDE) PA – PE431.009v01-00

AM – PE439.323v01-00 AGRI – Maria Do Céu Patrão Neves (EPP) PA – PE438.486v01-00

AM – PE439.136v01-00 LIBE – Antigoni Papadopoulou (S&D)

• Consideration of draft report

Speakers: João Ferreira, Esther Herranz García, Edite Estrela, Giommaria Uggias, Michail Tremopoulos, Marina Yannakoudakis (on behalf of Peter van Dalen), Thomas de Lannoy (DG ECHO) Timetable: Deadline for tabling amendments: 22 March 2010, 12:00 Vote in ENVI: 3 - 4 May 2010 Vote in Plenary: June 2010

*

The meeting adjourned at 18.20 and resumed on Wednesday 17 March 2010 at 09.05 with Jo Leinen, (Chairman) in the chair.

* * *

In camera

19. Coordinators meeting from 9:00-10:00

See Annex II

20. Industrial emissions (integrated pollution prevention and control) (recast version)

ENVI/7/00351 ***II 2007/0286(COD) 11962/3/2009 – C7-0034/2010

T6-0093/2009

Draftsman: Holger Krahmer (ALDE) PR – PE430.626v01-00 Responsible: ENVI

• Consideration of draft recommendation for second reading Speakers: Holger Krahmer, Elisabetta Gardini, Åsa Westlund, Bas Eickhout, Martin Callanan, João Ferreira, Karl-Heinz Florenz, Miroslav Ouzký, Richard Seeber, Corinne Lepage, Bogusław Sonik, Chris Davies, Christa Klaß, Theodoros Skylakakis, Peter Liese, Satu Hassi, Anja Weisgerber, Sirpa Pietikäinen, Marianne Wenning (DG ENV)

PE441.002v03-00 10/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

Timetable: Vote in ENVI: 27 - 28 April 2010 Vote in Plenary: July 2010

21. Emission performance standards for new light commercial vehicles

ENVI/7/01506 ***I 2009/0173(COD) COM(2009)0593 – C7-0271/2009 Draftsman: Martin Callanan (ECR) Responsible: ENVI committee Opinions: ITRE – Werner Langen (PPE)

TRAN – Oldřich Vlasák (ECR)

• Exchange of views

Speakers: Martin Callanan, Anja Weisgerber, Matthias Groote, Holger Krahmer, Sabine Wils, Bas Eickhout, Judith A. Merkies, Chris Davies, Richard Seeber, Satu Hassi, Karl-Heinz Florenz, Philip Owen (DG ENV) Timetable: Vote in ENVI: September Vote in Plenary: October-November

22. Any other business

23. Date of next meeting (Brussels)

• 6 April 2010, 15.00-18.30 • 7 April 2010, 9.00-12.30

*

The meeting closed at 12.30.

* * *

PV\814231EN.doc 11/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PE441.002v03-00 12/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

Annex 1 15. March 2010

RESULTS OF VOTE

Draft Report on Proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council

on the provision of food information to consumers (2008/0028 (COD))

F = fell + = adopted - = rejected

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL

AM N° TABLED BY COMMENTS RESULT

VOTE

34 Renate Sommer

Deletion +

33/26/1 Article 1 – paragraph 1

247 Åsa Westlund Falls if AM 34 adopted -

Article 1 – paragraph 2

35 Renate Sommer

Deletion -

29/32/0

36 Renate Sommer

+

249 Glenis

Willmott Compatible with AM 36 +


IMCO 15 -

Article 1 – paragraph 3 a

(new) 248 János Áder

AGRI 17 Identical +

Article 1– paragraph 4

37 Renate Sommer

+

Article 1 – paragraph 4 – subparagraph 1

a (new)

IMCO 16 Partly compatible with AM 37 +

Article 2 – paragraph 2 –

point a 38

Renate Sommer

+


point b 39

Renate Sommer

Deletion +


point c 40

Renate Sommer

Deletion +

PV\814231EN.doc 13/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE Article 2 –

paragraph 2 – point d

41 Renate Sommer

Deletion +


point e 42

Renate Sommer

+

IMCO 17 +

32/29/0

250 Esther de Lange

Compatible with IMCO 17 +

43 Renate Sommer

251 Holger

Krahmer

(Almost) Identical

Compatible with IMCO 17 and AM 250

+

252 Frédérique

Ries

Article 2 – paragraph 2 – point e a (new)

253 Pilar Ayuso

Identical

Fall if IMCO 17, AM 250 or AM 43/ AM 251 is adopted

F


point f 44

Renate Sommer

+

AGRI 18 + Article 2 – paragraph 2 –

point g 254 Elisabetta Gardini

Falls if AGRI 18 is adopted F

AGRI 19 -

24/35/0

255 Elisabetta Gardini

Falls if AGRI 19 is adopted or if AM 254 is not adopted

F Article 2 –

paragraph 2 – point g a (new)

256 Åsa Westlund Falls if AM 254, AM 255 or AGRI

19 is adopted F

Article 2 – paragraph 2 – point g b (new)


-


point j 45

Renate Sommer

+


point k 46

Renate Sommer

+

Article 2 – paragraph 2 – point k a (new)

47 Renate Sommer

+

PE441.002v03-00 14/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE Article 2 –

paragraph 2 – point l

48 Renate Sommer

Deletion +

32/27/0


point m 49

Renate Sommer

+


point o 50

Renate Sommer

Deletion +

51 Renate Sommer Article 2 –

paragraph 2 – point p

AGRI 20

Identical

Deletion

+


points q 52

Renate Sommer

Deletion +


point r 53

Renate Sommer

+

32/29/0

54 Renate Sommer

+ Article 2 – paragraph 2 –

point s IMCO 18 Compatible with AM 54 +

258 Anja

Weisgerber

+ Article 2 – paragraph 2 – point s a (new) 55

Renate Sommer

Falls if AM 258 is adopted F

56 Renate Sommer

+

IMCO 20 Article 2 – paragraph 2 – point s b (new)

259

Dan Jørgensen, Christel

Schaldemose

Identical

Fall if AM 56 is adopted

F


point t 57

Renate Sommer

Deletion -

260 Struan

Stevenson Falls if AM 257is adopted -

IMCO 19 + Article 2 –

paragraph 2 – point t a (new)

261 Anja

Weisgerber Falls if IMCO 19 is adopted F

PV\814231EN.doc 15/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE Article 2 – paragraph 3

262 Carl Schlyter +


(new)

263 Carl Schlyter +

58 Renate Sommer

+


264 Åsa Westlund Falls if AM 58 is adopted F


(new) 59

Renate Sommer

+


60 Renate Sommer

+

265 Holger

Krahmer +

AGRI 21 Compatible with AM 265 +

266 Struan

Stevenson


IMCO 21

Identical

Fall if AGRI 21 is adopted Compatible with AM 265

F

Article 3 – paragraph 3 – point 1 a (new)

AGRI 22 Falls if AM 265 is adopted F

Article 4 – paragraph 1 – introductory

phrase

61 Renate Sommer

+


point a AGRI 23 +


point b – subpoint ii

267 Andres Perello

Rodriguez

+

Article 4 – paragraph 1 – 62

Renate Sommer

+

32/27/0

PE441.002v03-00 16/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE point b –

subpoint iii AGRI 24

Identical

Deletion


point c 63

Renate Sommer

NO VOTE (Linguistic)

NV

268

Mairead McGuinness,

Struan Stevenson

AGRI 25

(Almost) Identical

Split vote requested by rapporteur: 1st part: "When considering the need....of providing certain information." 2nd part: "to which they attach informed choices." Falls if AM 268/AGRI 25 (1st part split vote) is not adopted

1.+

2.-


64 Renate Sommer

2nd part compatible with AM 268 and AGRI 25

-


phrase

65 Renate Sommer

+

COMPROMISE AM If COMPROMISE AM is adopted, AMs 66, 67, 270, 271, 273, 274 and IMCO 23 fall

+ Article 7 – paragraph 1 –

point a 66

Renate Sommer

Falls if CompAM is adopted F

PV\814231EN.doc 17/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

271 Anja

Weisgerber Falls if CompAM is adopted F

270 Carl Schlyter Falls if CompAM is adopted

Falls if AM 271 is adopted

F

IMCO 23

Falls if CompAM is adopted


Partly compatible with AM 270

F

Article 7 – paragraph 1 – point aa (new)

67 Renate Sommer

Falls if CompAM is adopted

Falls if AM 270, AM 271 or IMCO 23 is adopted

F

IMCO 22 +

32/27/1

68 Renate Sommer

Article 7 – paragraph 1 – point a b (new)

269 Christa Klaß

Identical

Falls if IMCO 22 is adopted

F


point c 69

Renate Sommer

+

70 Renate Sommer

+

276 Elena Oana Antonescu


272 Karl-Heinz

Florenz Falls if AM 70 or AM 276 is

adopted F

Article 7 – paragraph 1 – point c a (new)

273 Carl Schlyter, Satu Hassi


71 Renate Sommer

+ Article 7 –

paragraph 1 – point c b (new) 274

Carl Schlyter, Satu Hassi


Article 7 – paragraph 1 – point c c (new)

275 Carl Schlyter

Oral AM by MEP Carl Schlyter (to be inserted in Annex V, Part B, 1 a

(new)):

"1 a. Milk which use-by-date is more than seven days after the date on which the milk packaging is filled

cannot be denoted as 'fresh'."

1. - 30/30/0

2.- 29/31/0

PE441.002v03-00 18/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

72 Renate Sommer

Deletion -

277 Struan

Stevenson Falls if Am 72 is adopted - Article 7 –

paragraph 2

278 Åsa Westlund Falls if Am 72 or AM 59 is adopted

Compatible with AM 277

F


(new) AGRI 26

-


AGRI 27 +

Article 7 – paragraph 4 – introduction

73 Renate Sommer

+

279 Holger

Krahmer +


74 Renate Sommer

Falls if AM 279 is adopted W

75 Renate Sommer

Deletion -

280 Kartika Tamara Liotard


IMCO 24

(Almost) Identical


+

281 Holger

Krahmer Falls if AM 75 is adopted

+ 39/20/0 Article 8 –

paragraph 3 IMCO 25 Falls if AM 281 is adopted F

76 Renate Sommer

+

282 Christa Klaß Falls if AM 76 is adopted F

IMCO 26 Falls if AM 76 or AM 282 is

adopted F


283 Holger

Krahmer Falls if AM 76, AM 282 or IMCO

26 is adopted F

285 Carl Schlyter,

Jill Evans

- 19/39/0


77 Renate Sommer

Falls if AM 285 is adopted +

PV\814231EN.doc 19/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE


287 Glenis

Willmott

Identical


- 28/30/1

286 Åsa Westlund Falls if AM 285, AM 77 or AM 284 /

287 are adopted F

AGRI 28 Partly compatible with AM 285, AM 77 and AM 284 / 287 and AM 286

+


(new) 288

Andres Perello

Rodriguez Falls if AM 281 is adopted F


part

289 Åsa Westlund -

29/32/0

290 Carl Schlyter

+ Article 8 – paragraph 6 – subparagraph 2 78

Renate Sommer


Article 9 – title 79 Renate Sommer

NO VOTE (linguistic) NV


IMCO 27 +

80 Renate Sommer

IMCO 28 Identical + Article 9 –

paragraph 1 – point a

291 Oreste Rossi Falls if AM 80 / IMCO 28 is

adopted F

IMCO 29 + Article 9 – paragraph 1 –

point c 81 Renate Sommer

Compatible with IMCO 29 +


point d 82

Renate Sommer

+

PE441.002v03-00 20/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

AGRI 29 Article 9 – paragraph 1 –

point e 292 Esther de Lange

Identical

+


point f IMCO 30 +

83 Renate Sommer

+

IMCO 31 Article 9 – paragraph 1 – point f a (new)

294

Dan Jorgensen, Christel

Schaldemose

Identical


F

CONSOLIDATED AM 1

If ConsAM 1 is adopted, AMs 84, 293, 315 and 377 fall

+

84 Renate Sommer

Falls if ConsAM 1 is adopted F Article 9 –

paragraph 1 – point g

293 Andres Perello

Rodriguez

Falls if ConsAM 1 is adopted

Compatible with AM 84 F

Article 9 – paragraph 1 – point g a (new)

85 Renate Sommer

+

IMCO 32 +

32/30/0

295

Sergio Berlato,

Giancarlo Scotta', Oreste

Rossi, Elisabetta Gardini,

Vittorio Prodi

297 Oreste Rossi

AGRI 30

(Almost) Identical

Compatible with IMCO 32

+

+Article 9 – paragraph 1 –

point h

296 Carl Schlyter Falls if IMCO 32, AM 295 / 297 /

AGRI 30 is adopted

F

PV\814231EN.doc 21/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

86 Renate Sommer

Falls if IMCO 32 or 295 / 297 / AGRI 30 is adopted

Compatible with AM 296 F

CONSOLIDATED AM 2

If ConsAM 2 is adopted, AMs 309, 300, 307, 304, 303, 306, IMCO 33, 301, 302, 308, AGRI 31, 298, 299, 305, 87, 310, 311, 312, 313, 314 and

317 fall

Split vote requested by MEP Oreste Rossi: 1st part: The whole text except the words "Where there are reasons...unspecified origin" 2nd part: Those words.

1.+ 32/29/1

2.+ 33/29/0

309 Karin

Kadenbach Falls if ConsAM 2 is adopted F

300 Dagmar Roth-

Behrendt



F

307 Åsa Westlund


Falls if AM 309 orAM 300 is adopted

F



Falls if AM 309, AM 300, or AM

307 is adopted

F

303 Struan

Stevenson


Falls if AM 309, AM 300, AM 307 or AM 304 is adopted

F


point i

306 Carl Schlyter



Compatible with AM 300, AM 307, AM 304 and AM 303

F

PE441.002v03-00 22/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

IMCO 33


Falls if AM 309, AM 300, AM 307, AM 304 or AM 303 is adopted

Compatible with AM 306 Wording needs to be adapted in a uniform manner throughout the

Regulation, if adopted ("unprocessed" instead of "non-processed")

F

301 Jill Evans

302 Glenis

Willmott

Identical


Fall if AM 309, AM 300, AM 307, AM 304, AM 303, AM 306 or

IMCO 33 is adopted

F

308 Pilar Ayuso


Falls if AM 309,AM 300 or AM 301/302 is adopted

Partly compatible with AM 307, AM 304, AM 303 amd IMCO 33


F

AGRI 31


Falls if AM 309, AM 300, AM 308, AM 307, AM 304, AM 303, AM 306,

IMCO 33 is adopted

F



Falls if AM 309, AM 300, AM308, AM 307, AM 304, AM 303, AM 306, IMCO 33, AM 301 / 302 or AGRI

31 is adopted

F

299

Françoise Grossetête, Catherine Soullie


Falls if AM 309, AM 300, AM 308, AM 307, AM 304, AM 303, IMCO 33, AM 301 / 302, AGRI 31 or AM

298 is adopted

F

PV\814231EN.doc 23/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

305 Holger

Krahmer


Falls if AM 309, AM 300, AM 308, AM 307, AM 304, AM 303, IMCO 33, AM 301 / 302, AGRI 31, AM

298 or AM 299 is adopted

F

87 Renate Sommer



310 János Áder Falls if ConsAM 2 is adopted F

311 Carl Schlyter


Falls if AM 303, AM 301 / 302 or AGRI 31 is adopted

Compatible with AM 307 and AM 304

F

312 Richard Seeber


Falls if AM 307, AM 304, AM 303, 301 / 302, AGRI 31 or AM 311 is

adopted

F

313 Oreste Rossi


Falls if AM 306, AM 298 or AM 301 / 302 is adopted

F

314 George Lyon Falls if ConsAM 2 is adopted F

Article 9 – paragraph 1 – point i a (new)

317 Richard Seeber


Falls if AGRI 31, IMCO 34, AM 307, AM 303 or AM 304 is adopted

F

88 Renate Sommer

Deletion Falls if AM 85 is adopted

F

AGRI 32 Falls if AM 85or AM 88 is adopted F Article 9 – paragraph 1 –

point j

315 Karin

Kadenbach


Falls if AM 85, AM 88 or AGRI 32 is adopted

F


(new) 316 Carl Schlyter -

PE441.002v03-00 24/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE


89 Renate Sommer

+

90 Renate Sommer

AGRI 33 Article 9 – paragraph 3

IMCO 34

Identical

Deletion

+

Article 9 a (new)

318 Carl Schlyter, Bas Eickhout

+

319 Oreste Rossi Article 10 – paragraph 2

IMCO 35

Identical

Deletion

-

Article 11 91 Renate Sommer

Deletion +


(new) AGRI 34

- 10/51/0

Article 11 a (new)

AGRI 35 Falls if AM 318 is adopted F

Article 12 IMCO 36 +


(new) AGRI 36 -


92 Renate Sommer

+

93 Renate Sommer

IMCO 37

Identical

Deletion

+ Article 13 – paragraph 3

AGRI 37 Falls if AM 93 / IMCO 37 is

adopted F


320 Andres Perello

Rodriguez Deletion +

PV\814231EN.doc 25/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

94 / 108

Renate Sommer

To be voted together


F

322 Glenis

Willmott

IMCO 38

(Almost) Identical

Falls if AM 320 or AM 94 / 108 is

adopted

F

321 Horst

Schnellhardt Falls if AM 320, AM 94 / 108 or AM

322 / IMCO 38 is adopted F

AGRI 38 Falls if AM 320, AM 94 / 108, AM

322 / IMCO 38 or AM 321 is adopted

F

CONSOLIDATED AM 4

If ConsAM 4 is adopted, AMs 330, 326, 328, IMCO 39, 327, 323, AGRI 39, 95, 325, 324 (1st and 2nd part),

329, IMCO 40 and 331 fall

+

CONSOLIDATED AM 3


If ConsAM 3 is adopted, AMs 330, 326, 328, IMCO 39, 327, 323, AGRI 39, 95, 325, 324 (1st and 2nd part),

329, IMCO 40 and 331 fall

F

330 Glenis

Willmott

326 Jill Evans

Identical

Falls if ConsAM 4 or 3 is adopted

F



Falls if AM 326 / 330 are adopted F

IMCO 39


Falls if AM 330 / 326 or AM 328 is

adopted

F


327 Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy,

George Lyon


Falls if AM 326 / 330, AM 328 or

IMCO 39 is adopted

F

PE441.002v03-00 26/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

323 Bernadette Vergnaud


Falls if AM 326 / 330, AM 328, IMCO 39 or AM 327 is adopted

F

AGRI 39


Falls if AM 326 / 330, AM 328, IMCO 39, AM 327 or AM 323 is

adopted

F

95 Renate Sommer


Falls if AM 326 / 330, AM 328, IMCO 39 , AM 327, AM 323 or

AGRI 39 is adopted

F

325 Jan Březina,

Miroslav Ouzký


Falls if AM 326 / 330, AM 328, IMCO 39, AM 327, AM 323, AGRI


F

324 (1st part)

Holger Krahmer


Falls if AM 326 / 330, AM 328,

IMCO 39, AM 327, AM 323, AGRI 39, AM 95 or AM 325 is adopted

F

329 Dagmar Roth-

Behrendt


Falls if AM 326 / 330, AM 328,

IMCO 39, AM 327, AM 323, AGRI 39, AM 95, AM 325 or AM 324 (1st

part) is adopted

F

CONSOLIDATED AM 5

If ConsAM5 is adopted, AMs AGRI 45, 96, 332, 339, 340 and 469 fall

+

AGRI 45 Falls if ConsAM 5 is adopted F

96 Renate Sommer



332 Glenis

Willmott Falls if ConsAM 5 is adopted

F


(new)

IMCO 40



F

PV\814231EN.doc 27/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE




F

AGRI 40 Falls if AM 326 / 330, AM 328 or

AM 331 is adopted F

324 (2nd part)

Holger Krahmer


Falls if AM 326 / 330, AM 328 or

AM 327 is adopted

F

333 Bernadette Vergnaud Article 14 –

paragraph 2 IMCO 41

(Almost) Identical -

97 Renate Sommer


IMCO 42

Identical

Deletion

+

98 Renate Sommer

AGRI 42


335 George Lyon

Identical

Deletion

+

PE441.002v03-00 28/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE


Falls if AM 98 / 335 / AGRI 42, AM 326 / 330, AM 328, AM 327 or AM 324 (2nd part) is adopted

F


338 Glenis

Willmott

(Almost) Identical

Fall if AM 98 / 335 / AGRI 42, AM 334, AM 328, AM 327, AM 323, AGRI 39, AM 95, AM 325 or AM

324 (1st part) is adopted

Split vote requested by MEP Carl Schlyter: 1st part: 1st sentence ("The minimum....25 cm2".") 2nd part: 2nd sentence ("Specific....official language") 2nd part split vote falls if 1st part split vote is not adopted

F

336 Andres Perello

Rodriguez Falls if AM 98 / 335 / AGRI 42 is

adopted F

PV\814231EN.doc 29/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

IMCO 43 Falls if AM 98 / 335 / AGRI 42 is

adopted Compatible with AM 336

F


a (new)

339





b (new)

340


Falls if ConsAM 5 is adopted F


IMCO 44 +


(new) AGRI 43

+ 31/30/1

341 Christofer Fjellner

-

99 Renate Sommer Article 14 –

paragraph 6

AGRI 44

Identical


+

342 János Áder + Article 14 –

paragraph 6 a (new) 343

Karin Kadenbach

Falls if AM 94 / 108, AM 322 / IMCO 38, AM 321, AGRI 38 is

adopted or AM 320 is not adopted -

AGRI 46 +

344 János Áder Article 14 –

paragraph 6 b (new)

AGRI 47

Identical -


- Article 15 – paragraph 1 –

point a 345

Holger Krahmer

+


point b 348

Kartika Tamara Liotard

Deletion -

PE441.002v03-00 30/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

347 Carl Schlyter Falls if AM 348 is adopted +

35/25/0

100 Renate Sommer


+

101 Renate Sommer

+

35/26/0

349 Oreste Rossi Compatible with AM 101 - Article 16 – paragraph 1

IMCO 45 Falls if AM 349 is adopted


-

102 Renate Sommer

Deletion -

NV identical

with COM

proposal

350 Struan

Stevenson

Oral AM by rapporteur: 1st part: 1st sentence ("Within their territory....of the Union") Falls if AM 102 is adopted 2nd part: 2nd sentence ("This requirement....in question") Falls if AM 102 is adopted

+


AGRI 48 Falls if AM 102 or AM 350 is

adopted F


(new) 103

Renate Sommer

+

Article 17 – title

104 Renate Sommer

+

AGRI 49 Deletion -


Falls if AGRI 49 is adopted - Article 17 – paragraph 1

105 Renate Sommer

Falls if AGRI 49 is adopted

+

PV\814231EN.doc 31/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

353 Carl Schlyter

To be adapted in the light of the vote on Article 29 – paragraph 1 a

- 24/36/1

AGRI 50

352 Holger

Krahmer

Identical

Fall if AM 323 or AGRI 39 is

adopted To be adapted in the light of the vote

on Article 29 – paragraph 1 a

+

106 Renate Sommer

356 (1st part)

Dagmar Roth-Behrendt

Identical

Fall if AM 352 / AGRI 50 is adopted

Split vote requested by MEP Carl Schlyter: 1st part: The whole AM without the words "printable" and "80 cm2" 2nd part: Those words To be adapted in the light of the vote

on Article 29 – paragraph 1 a

F


Falls if AM 352/AGRI 50, AM 353 or AM 106 / 356 (1st part) is

adopted F

354 Horst

Schnellhardt

Falls if AM 352 / AGRI 50, AM 106 / 356 (1st part), AM 355, AM 323 or

AGRI 39 is adopted

F


IMCO 46

Falls if AM 352 / AGRI 50, AM 106 / 356 (1st part), AM 355, AM 354, AM 323 or AGRI 39 is adopted

F

PE441.002v03-00 32/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE Article 17 –

paragraph 2 a (new)

357 Carl Schlyter -

107 Renate Sommer

Article 17 – paragraph 3 356

(2nd part)


Identical

+

359 Renate Sommer

+

IMCO 47 Falls if AM 359 is adopted F


a (new) 358

Carl Schlyter on behalf of Greens/EFA,

Kartika Tamara

Liotard on behalf of

GUE/NGL

Falls if AM 359 or IMCO 47 is adopted

F


b (new)

360

Carl Schlyter on behalf of Greens/EFA,

Kartika Tamara

Liotard on behalf of

GUE/NGL

+

35/26/0

109 Renate Sommer



110 Renate Sommer

+

37/22/1

AGRI 51 - Article 19 –

paragraph 1 a (new)

361 Carl Schlyter -

Article 19 – paragraph 1 b

(new) 362 Carl Schlyter

Oral AM by MEP Carl Schlyter:

"For foods where eggs or egg

products are among the five first

ingredients, the terms referred to ....Council Regulation (EC) No 834/2007, Article 23 (4) (b)."

+ 31/29/1

PV\814231EN.doc 33/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE Article 20 –

title 111

Renate Sommer

+


point d 363

Horst Schnellhardt

-

365

Glenis Willmott,

Nessa Childers

Deletion -

112 Renate Sommer

Falls if AM 365 is adopted -


Falls if AM 365 or AM 112 is adopted

-

AGRI 52 Falls if AM 365, AM 112 or AM 368

is adopted -

364 Struan

Stevenson Falls if AM 365, AM 112, AM 368

or AGRI 52 is adopted -

366

Pilar Ayuso, Esther

Herranz García

Falls if AM 365, AM 112, AM 368, AGRI 52 or AM 364 is adopted

-


point e


Falls if AM 365, AM 112, AM 368, AGRI 52, AM 364 or AM 366 is

adopted

- 20/39/1

Article 21 – title and

introductory phrase

113 Renate Sommer

+

Article 21 – point c

114 Renate Sommer

+

369 Dagmar Roth-

Behrendt +



IMCO 49

Identical


F

373 Renate Sommer

+

115 Renate Sommer

WITHDRAWN

W

Article 22 – paragraph 1 – point b a (new)


PE441.002v03-00 34/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

371 Edite Estrela, José Manuel Fernandes

372 Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy

Identical

Fall if AM 373or IMCO 50 is

adopted

F

AGRI 53 Article 22 – paragraph 2 a (new)

374

Pilar Ayuso, Esther

Herranz García

(Almost) Identical


point a 116

Renate Sommer

+


point b AGRI 54 -


117 Renate Sommer

Deletion +

118 Renate Sommer


IMCO 51

Identical

+


119 Renate Sommer

+

120 Renate Sommer

+

376 Esther de Lange

-

375 Hans-Peter

Mayer Falls if AM 120 / 376 are adopted F


IMCO 52 Falls if AM 120 / 376 or AM 375 is

adopted F

121 Renate Sommer


377 Hans-Peter

Mayer



PV\814231EN.doc 35/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

AGRI 55 Falls if AM 121 or AM 377 is

adopted F

Article 27 a (new)

AGRI 56 -

Section 3 – title 122 Renate Sommer

+

36/26/0

CONSOLIDATED AM 6 + 7

To be voted together

If ConsAM 6/7 is adopted, AMs 384, 379 (1st part), 378, IMCO 53, 123, 124, 383, IMCO 54, 382, 381, 388, AGRI 57, 125, 390, IMCO 55, 386, 385, 387, 380, 389, IMCO 56, 407 (3rd and 5th part), AM 402 (3rd

part), 127 (4th part), 403 (4th part), 404 (2nd part), 405 (4th part), 406 (3rd part), AGRI 63, IMCO 58 (2nd

part), 409, 410 as well as

AMs 127 (part 1-4), 407 (part 1-5), 403 (part 1- 4), 402, 404, 405 (part 1- 4), 406, AGRI 59, 401 (part 1- 3), AGRI 60, AGRI 61, IMCO 59, 408, AGRI 62, IMCO 58, AGRI 63, 409,

410, 129 and IMCO 60 fall

+

384

Corinne Lepage, Glenis

Willmott, Antonyia Parvanova

Falls if ConsAM 6/7 is adopted F

379 (1st part)


Falls if ConsAM 6/7 is adopted


F

378


Schaldemose


IMCO 53

Identical


Fall if AM 384 or AM 379 (1st part)

is adopted

F F

PE441.002v03-00 36/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

123 Renate Sommer


NO VOTE (linguistic)

124 Renate Sommer


F

383 (1st part)

Bernadette Vergnaud

IMCO 54

Identical


Falls if AM 384, AM 379 (1st part)

or AM 124 is adopted

F


point a

382 (1st part)

Christa Klaß


Falls if AM 384, AM 379 (1st part)or AM 383 (1st part) / IMCO

54 is adopted


F

381 Carl Schlyter,

Jill Evans


Falls if AM 384 or AM 379 (1st part) is adopted

F

388 Andres Perello

Rodriguez


Falls if AM 384, AM 379 (1st part) or AM 381 is adopted

F


point b

AGRI 57



Partly compatible with AM 381 and

AM 388

F

PV\814231EN.doc 37/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

125 Renate Sommer



F

390 Holger

Krahmer


Falls if AM 384, AM 379 (1st part), AM 381, AM 388, AGRI 57 or AM

125 is adopted

F

IMCO 55



Partly compatible with AM 381, AM 390, AM 388, AGRI 57 and AM 125

F

386 Esther de Lange



Partly compatible with AM 125, AM 380, AM 382, AM 386, AM 390 and

IMCO 55

F

385 János Áder

387


Schaldemose

Identical


Falls if AM 384, AM 379 (1st part), AM 381, AM 388, AM 125, IMCO


F

PE441.002v03-00 38/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

380 Dagmar Roth-

Behrendt


Falls if AM 384, AM 379 (1st part), IMCO 55 or AM 386 is adopted

Partly compatible with AM 381, AM 388, AGRI 57, AM 125, AM 390 and

AM 385 / 387

F

383 (2nd part)

Bernadette Vergnaud


Falls if AM 384, AM 379 (1st part), AM 381, AM 388, AGRI 57, AM 125, AM 390, IMCO 55, AM 386, AM 385 / 387 or AM 380 is adopted

F

389

Anja Weisgerber,

Thomas Ulmer


Falls if AM 384, AM 379 (1st part), AM 381, AM 388, AGRI 57, AM 125, AM 390, IMCO 55, AM 386, AM 385 / 387, AM 380 or AM 383

(2nd part) is adopted

F

382 (2nd part)

Christa Klaß

Falls if AM 384, AM 379 (1st part), AM 381, AM 388, AM 125, IMCO 55, AM 386, AM 385 / 387 or AM

380 is adopted

Partly compatible with AGRI 57, AM 390, AM 383 (2nd part) and AM 389

F

Article 29 – paragraph 1 –point b a (new)

383 (3rd part)

Bernadette Vergnaud


Falls if AM 384, AM 379 (1st part) is adopted

Partly compatible with AM 381, AM 388, AGRI 57, AM 125, AM 390, IMCO 55, AM 386, AM 385 / 387,

AM 380, AM 383 (2nd part), AM 389 and AM 382 (2nd part)

F

PV\814231EN.doc 39/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

IMCO 56



Partly compatible with AM 381, AM 388, AGRI 57, AM 125, AM 390, IMCO 55, AM 386, AM 385 / 387, AM 380, AM 383 (2nd part), AM

389, AM 382 (2nd part) and AM 383 (3rd part)

F

392 Åsa Westlund

394 Carl Schlyter

Identical

Deletion

-

396 Horst

Schnellhardt Falls if AM 392/394 is adopted +

126 Renate Sommer

Falls if AM 392/394 or AM 396 is adopted

F

399 Struan

Stevenson Falls if AM 392/394, AM 396 or AM

126 is adopted F

398 Esther

Herranz García

Falls if AM 392/394, AM 396, AM 126 or AM 399 is adopted

F

IMCO 57 Falls if AM 392/394, AM 396, AM 126 AM 399 or AM 398 is adopted

F


Falls if AM 392/394, AM 396, AM 126 AM 399, AM 398 or IMCO 57

is adopted F

395 Holger

Krahmer

Falls if AM 392/394, AM 396, AM 126 AM 399, AM 398, IMCO 57 or

AM 397 is adopted F

AGRI 58

Falls if AM 392 / 394, AM 396, AM 126, AM 399, AM 398, IMCO 57, AM 397 or AM 395 is adopted

F


379 (2nd part)


Falls if AM 392 / 394, AM 396, AM 126, AM 399, AM 398, IMCO 57, AM 397, AM 395 or AGRI 58 is

adopted

F

PE441.002v03-00 40/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

393 Asa Westlund

Falls if AM 392 / 394, AM 396, AM 126, AM 399, AM 398, IMCO 57, AM 397, AM 395, AGRI 58 or AM

379 (2nd part) is adopted

F

413 Dagmar Roth-

Behrendt

Falls if AM 392 / 394, AM 396, AM 126, AM 399, AM 398, IMCO 57, AM 397, AM 395, AGRI 58, AM 379 (2nd part) or AM 393 is

adopted

F

412 Antonyia Parvanova

Falls if AM 392 / 394, AM 396, AM 126, AM 399, AM 398, IMCO 57, AM 397, AM 395, AGRI 58, AM 379 (2nd part), AM 393 or AM 413

is adopted

F

391

Glenis Willmott,

Nessa Childers

Falls if AM 392 / 394, AM 396, AM 126, AM 399, AM 398, IMCO 57, AM 397, AM 395, AGRI 58, AM

379 (2nd part), AM 393, AM 413 or AM 412 is adopted

F

400 Åsa Westlund -

127 (1st part)

Renate Sommer

Falls if ConsAM 6/7 is adopted W

407 (1st part)

Renate Sommer


Falls if AM 127 (1st part) is adopted

F Article 29 –

paragraph 1 a (new)

403 (1st part)



Falls if AM 127 (1st part) or AM 407 (1st part) is adopted

F

402 (1st part)


404 (1st part)

Carl Schlyter, Jill Evans


point a

405 (1st part)

Bernadette Vergnaud

Identical


F

PV\814231EN.doc 41/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

406 (1st part)

Glenis Willmott, Antonyia

Parvanova, Corinne Lepage

Deletion

Deemed to be deleted if AM 388 or

AGRI 57 is adopted

AGRI 59 Falls if ConsAM 6/7 is adopted F Article 29 –

paragraph 2 – point b 401 (1st

part) Elena Oana Antonescu



AGRI 60 Falls if ConsAM 6/7 is adopted F Article 29 –

paragraph 2 – point c

401 (2nd part)

Elena Oana Antonescu



AGRI 61

IMCO 59

127 (3rd part)

Renate Sommer

403 (2nd part)


405 (2nd part)

Bernadette Vergnaud

407 (4th part)

Renate Sommer

Identical


F

Article 29 – paragraph 2 – point c a (new)

401 (3rd part)



Compatible with AGRI 61 / 127 (3rd part) / 403 (2nd part) / 405 (2nd part) /

407 (4th part)

F


point d 408

Horst Schnellhardt



F

AGRI 62 Article 29 –

paragraph 2 – point f

IMCO 58 (1st part)

F

PE441.002v03-00 42/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE 402 (2nd part)


403 (4th part)


405 (3rd part)

Bernadette Vergnaud

406 (2nd part)



Identical


Deletion

Deemed to be deleted if AM 380, AM 386, AGRI 57 or IMCO 55 is

adopted

127 (2nd part)

Renate Sommer

F

Article 29 – paragraph 2 – point f a (new) 407

(2nd part)

Renate Sommer

Identical


Compatible with AGRI 57 and AM

390

F

Article 29 – paragraph 2 – point f b (new)

407 (3rd part)

Renate Sommer


Deemed to fall if AM 380, AM 381, AM 383 (2nd part), AM 385, AM 387, AM 388, AM 389, AM 390, AGRI 57 or IMCO 55 is adopted

F

402 (3rd part)



point g 127 (4th part)

Renate Sommer

F

1 page 25-27

PV\814231EN.doc 43/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE 407 (5th part)

Renate Sommer

403 (4th part)


404 (2nd part)

Carl Schlyter, Jill Evans

405 (4th part)

Bernadette Vergnaud

406 (3rd part)



AGRI 63

IMCO 58 (2nd part)

409


Schaldemose

410 János Áder

Identical


Deletion

Deemed to be deleted if AM 380, AM 381, AM 382 (2nd part), AM

385, AM 386, AM 387, AM 388, AM 125 or IMCO 551 is adopted

127 (5th part)

Renate Sommer Article 29 –

paragraph 2 – point h 407

(6th part)

Renate Sommer

Identical

+

403 (5th part)


+

401 (4th part)


Article 29 – paragraph 2 – point h a (new)

AGRI 64

(Almost) Identical

Fall if AM 403 (5th part) is adopted

F

Article 29 – paragraph 2 – point h b (new)

127 (6th part)

Renate Sommer

+

PE441.002v03-00 44/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE 407 (7th part)

Renate Sommer

405 (5th part)

Bernadette Vergnaud

Identical


a (new)

AGRI 65 Falls if AM 403 (5th part) is

adopted F

128 Renate Sommer



411 Esther de Lange

+

129 Renate Sommer


IMCO 60

Identical


Deletion

F


130 Renate Sommer

+

131 Renate Sommer


IMCO 61 Second part compatible with AM 131 +


414 Carl Schlyter Compatible with AM 131 and IMCO

61 +

38/25/0

CONSOLIDATED AM 8

If ConsAM 8 is adopted, AM 132, 133, 417, 424, 425, 423, 416, IMCO 62, 421, 422, 419, 418, AGRI 66, 415, 420, 426, AGRI 67, 134, 432, 439, 431, 430, 428, IMCO 63, 436, 433, 435, 427, 434, 429 and 438 fall Oral AM by MEPGlenis Willmott:

(Art. 31, paragraph 2 a new, subparagraph 2, 5th indent

" soft drinks except fruit juices..."

1.- 29/32/1 (OA)

2. -

30/32/0


132 Renate Sommer

Falls if ConsAM 8 is adopted +

133 Renate Sommer

Falls if ConsAM 8 is adopted + Article 31 – paragraph 2




PV\814231EN.doc 45/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE


425 Åsa Westlund

Identical


Fall if AM 133 or AM 417 is adopted

F

423 Carl Schlyter


Falls if AM 133, AM 417 or AM 424 / 425 is adopted

F

416 Esther de Lange


Falls if AM 133, AM 417 , AM 424 / 425 or AM 423 is adopted

F

IMCO 62


Falls if AM 133, AM 417, AM 424 / 425,AM 423 or AM 416 is adopted

F

421 Anna Rosbach


Falls if AM 133, AM 417, AM 424 / 425, AM 423, AM 416 or IMCO 62

is adopted

F

422 Dagmar Roth-

Behrendt


Falls if AM 133, AM 417, AM 424/ 425, AM 423, AM 416, IMCO 62 or

AM 421 is adopted

F



Falls if AM 133, AM 417, AM 424 / 425, AM 423, AM 416, IMCO 62, AM 421 or AM 422 is adopted

F

418 Karin

Kadenbach


Falls if AM 133, AM 417, AM 424 / 425, AM 423, AM 416, IMCO 62, AM 421, AM 422 or AM 419 is

adopted

F

AGRI 66


Falls if AM 133, AM 417, AM 424 / 425, AM 423, AM 416, IMCO 62, AM 421, AM 422, AM 419 or AM

418 is adopted

F

PE441.002v03-00 46/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

415


Schaldemose


Falls if IMCO 62 is adopted Compatible with AM 133, AM 417, 424 / 425, AM 423, AM 416, AM

418, AM 419, AM 422, AM 421 and AGRI 66

-

420 George Lyon WITHDRAWN W


(new) 426

Bernadette Vergnaud


Falls if AM 133, AM 417, AM 423, AM 416, IMCO 62, AM 421, AM 422, AM 419, AM 418, AGRI 66 or

AM 415 is adopted

F

437 Oreste Rossi


Deletion

-

AGRI 67

134 Renate Sommer

432 George Lyon

(Almost) Identical



- 29/32/1

439

Glenis Willmott, Corinne Lepage, Antonyia Parvanova


Falls if AM 437 or AM 134/432/AGRI 67 is adopted

- 30/30/2



Falls if AM 437, AM 134 / 432 / AGRI 67 or AM 439 is adopted

-

430


Schaldemose


Falls if AM 437, AM 134 / 432 / AGRI 67, AM 439 or AM 431 is

adopted

-




Falls if AM 437, AM 134 / 432 / AGRI 67, AM 439 or AM 431 is

adopted

-

PV\814231EN.doc 47/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

IMCO 63


Falls if AM 437, AM 134 / 432 / AGRI 67, AM 439, AM 431, AM


-

436

Anja Weisgerber,

Thomas Ulmer


Falls if AM 437, AM 134 / 432 / AGRI 67, AM 439, AM 431, AM 430, AM 428 or IMCO 63 is

adopted

-

433 Anna Rosbach


Falls if AM 437, AM 134 / 432 / AGRI 67, AM 439, AM 431, AM 430, AM 428, IMCO 63 or 436 is

adopted

-

435 Jan Březina,

Miroslav Ouzký

427 Esther de Lange

Identical


Fall if AM 437, AM 439, AM 134 / 432 / AGRI 67, AM 431, AM 430, AM 428 or AM 433 is adopted

Partly compatible with IMCO 63 and

AM 436

-

434 Carl Schlyter,

Jill Evans


Falls if AM 437, AM 439, AM 431, AM 430 or AM 433 is adopted

Partly compatible with AM 428,

IMCO 63, AM 436, AM 435 and AM 427

-

PE441.002v03-00 48/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

429 Françoise Grossetête


Falls if AM 437, AM 439, AM 431, AM 430, AM 433, AM 435 or AM

427 is adopted

Partly compatible with AM 428, IMCO 63, AM 436 and AM 434

-

438 Åsa Westlund


Falls if AM 437, AM 134 / 432 / AGRI 67, AM 439, AM 431, AM 430, AM 428, IMCO 63, AM 436, AM 433, AM 435, AM 427 or AM

434 is adopted


- 17/44/0

135 Renate Sommer

+ Article 31 – paragraph 3 a

(new) 440 Carl Schlyter -

136 Renate Sommer

+


442 Carl Schlyter,

Jill Evans


IMCO 64

Identical


+

CONSOLIDATED AM 9

If ConsAM 9 is adopted, AMs 137, 443, 446, IMCO 65, 444, 445, 448, 447, IMCO 66, AGRI 68, 449, 450

and IMCO 67 fall

- 25/36/1

137 Renate Sommer


443 Åsa Westlund

Identical

PV\814231EN.doc 49/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

446 Anna Rosbach


Deletion Split vote requested by MEP Oreste Rossi: 1st part: Deletion of para 1 and 3 2nd part: Deletion of para 2

1.+ 2.+

IMCO 65


Falls if AM 137 / 443 / 446 (1st part of split vote) is adopted

F

444 Oreste Rossi


Falls if AM 137 / AM 443 / AM 446 or IMCO 65 is adopted

F



Falls if AM 137 / AM 443 / AM 446 (1st part of split vote), or IMCO 65

is adopted


F

448 (1st part)



Falls if AM 137 / AM 443 / AM 446(1st part of split vote), IMCO 65

or AM 445 is adopted


F

447 Anna Rosbach


Falls if AM 137 / 443 (2nd part of split vote) is adopted

Deletion

F Article 32 – paragraph 2

448 (2nd part)



Falls if AM 137 / 443 (2nd part of split vote) or AM 447 is adopted

F

PE441.002v03-00 50/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

IMCO 66


Falls if AM 137 / 443 (2nd part of split vote), AM 447 or AM 448 (2nd

part) is adopted

F

AGRI 68


Falls if AM 137 / 443 (2nd part of split vote), AM 447, AM 448 (2nd

part) IMCO 66 is adopted

F


(new) 449

Jorgo Chatzimarkaki

s


Falls if AM 137 / 443 (2nd part of split vote), AM 448 (2nd part), IMCO 66 or AGRI 68 is adopted

F

450 Anna Rosbach


Falls if AM 137 / AM 443 (1st part of split vote)is adopted

F


IMCO 67


Falls if AM 137 / 443 (1st part of split vote) or AM 450 is adopted

F


Deletion -

138 (1st part)

Renate Sommer


452 (1st part)

Jill Evans Falls if AM 453 orAM 138 (1st part)

is adopted

+

454 (1st part)

Anja Weisgerber,

Thomas Ulmer

IMCO 68 (1st part)

Identical

Falls if AM 453 or AM 138 (1st

part) is adopted

Compatible with AM 452 (1st part)

+ 31/29/2


451 (1st part)

Esther De Lange

Falls if AM 453, AM 138 (1st part) or AM 454(1st part)/IMCO 68 (1st

part) is adopted Compatible with AM 452 (1st part)

F

Article 33 paragraph 1 -

point (-a)

452 (2nd part)

Jill Evans Falls if AM 453 is adopted -

PV\814231EN.doc 51/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE Article 33

paragraph 1 - point a

138 (2nd part)

Renate Sommer


138 (3rd part)

Renate Sommer


31/31/0

454 (2nd part)

Anja Weisgerber,

Thomas Ulmer


point b

IMCO 68 (2nd part)

Identical

Falls if AM 453 or AM 138 (3rd

part) is adopted

- 28/34/0

138 (4th part)

Renate Sommer


30/31/0 Article 33 – paragraph 1 –

point c 452 (3rd part)

Jill Evans Falls if AM 453 or AM 138 (4th

part) is adopted +

138 (5th part)

Renate Sommer


Deletion

- 30/32/0

AGRI 69 Falls if AM 138 (5th part) or AM

453 is adopted -

451 (2nd part)

Esther de Lange

Falls if AM 138 (5th part), AM 453 or AGRI 69 is adopted

-

455 Horst

Schnellhardt

Falls if AM 138 (5th part), AM 453, AGRI 69 or AM 451 (2nd part) is

adopted -

452 (4th part)

Jill Evans Falls if AM 138 (5th part), AM 453, AGRI 69, AM 451 (2nd part) or AM

455 is adopted -

454 (3rd part)

Anja Weisgerber,

Thomas Ulmer

Falls if AM 138 (5th part), AM 453, AGRI 69, AM 451 (2nd part), AM 455 or AM 452 (4th part) is adopted

-


IMCO 68 (3rd part)

Falls if AM 138 (5th part), AM 453, AGRI 69, AM 451 (2nd part), AM 455, AM 452 (4th part) or AM 454

(3rd part) is adopted

-

PE441.002v03-00 52/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

CONSOLIDATED AM 10

Falls if ConsAM 9 is not adopted

If ConsAM 10 is adopted, AMs 459, AGRI 70, 139, 464, 461, IMCO 69, 458, 463, 460, 462, 457 (part 1 - 5), 140, 465, AGRI 71, 466, 468, 467, 469, 141, 470/575, 142, 473, 475, 142, 456 (1st part), IMCO 70 and

476 fall

F

459 Holger

Krahmer


Deletion

-

AGRI 70



To be adapted in the light of the vote on Article 29 para 1, if adopted

-

139 Renate Sommer


Falls if AM 459 or AGRI 70 is adopted


-

464 Dagmar Roth-

Behrendt


Falls if AM 459, AGRI 70 or AM 139 is adopted


- 30/31/1

461 Anja

Weisgerber


Falls if AM 459, AGRI 70, AM 139 or AM 464 is adopted


-


IMCO 69


Falls if AM 459, AGRI 70, AM 139, AM 464 or AM 461 is adopted


-

PV\814231EN.doc 53/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

458 Jan Březina,

Miroslav Ouzký


Falls if AM 459, AGRI 70, AM 139, AM 464, AM 461 or IMCO 69 is

adopted To be adapted in the light of the vote

on Article 29 para 1, if adopted

-

463 Carl Schlyter


Falls if AM 459, AGRI 70, AM 139, AM 464, AM 461, IMCO 69 or AM

458 is adopted To be adapted in the light of the vote


- 30/32/0

460 Kartika Liotard


Falls if AM 459, AGRI 70, AM 139, AM 464, AM 461, IMCO 69, AM

458 or AM 463 is adopted To be adapted in the light of the vote


-

462 Glenis

Willmott


Falls if AM 459, AGRI 70, AM 139, AM 464, AM 461, IMCO 69, AM 458, AM 463 or AM 460 is adopted To be adapted in the light of the vote


+ 34/27/1

457(1st part)

Bernadette Vergnaud


Falls if AM 459, AGRI 70, AM 139, AM 464, AM 461, IMCO 69, AM 458, AM 463, AM 460 or AM 462 is

adopted

Falls if AM 426 is not adopted


F

140 Renate Sommer


+ 44/16/1


(new)

465 Hans-Peter

Mayer



F

PE441.002v03-00 54/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

AGRI 71



F

466 Dagmar Roth-

Behrendt



F

457 (2nd part)

Bernadette Vergnaud


Falls if AM 140, AM 465, AM 466 or AGRI 71 is adopted

F

468 Anja

Weisgerber


Falls if AM 140, AM 465, AM 466, AGRI 71 or AM 457 (2nd part) is

adopted

F

467 Carl Schlyter


Falls if AM 458, IMCO 69, AGRI 70, AM 457 (1st part), AM 139 or

AM 464 is adopted

-

469

Mairead McGuinness,

Struan Stevenson


F

141 Renate Sommer


Falls if AM 140 is not adopted +


(new) 470/ 575

Carl Schlyter


TO BE VOTED TOGETHER Falls if AM 431 or AM 439 is

adopted

-

142 (1st part)

Renate Sommer


+

457 (3rd part)

Bernadette Vergnaud


Falls if AM 142 (1st part) is adopted F

Article 34 – paragraph 2 -

subparagraph 1

473(1st part)



Falls if AM 142 (1st part) is adopted Compatible with AM 457 (3rd part)

F

PV\814231EN.doc 55/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

475 Glenis

Willmott


Falls if AM 473 (1st part) is adopted

Compatible with AM 457 (3rd part)

and AM 142 (1st part)

- 29/32/0

142 (2nd part)

Renate Sommer

456 (1st part)

Jill Evans

IMCO 70

Identical


+

457 (4th part)

Bernadette Vergnaud

Article 34 - paragraph 2 -

subparagraph 2

473 (2nd part)

Kartika Liotard

Identical


Fall if AM 142 (2nd part)/ 456 (1st part)/ IMCO 70 is adopted

F

471/474 Ulmer

472 Holger

Krahmer

Article 34 - paragraph 2 -

subparagraph 2 a (new)

AGRI 72

Identical

+


(new) AGRI 73

+

457 (5th part)

Bernadette Vergnaud


476 Glenis

Willmott

Identical


Deletion

-


IMCO 71 Falls if AGRI 73 is adopted F

PE441.002v03-00 56/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

143 Renate Sommer

Compatible with IMCO 71 and AGRI 73

+


Falls if IMCO 71 is adopted Compatible with AM 143

-

457 (6th part)

Bernadette Vergnaud

IMCO 72

Identical Compatible with IMCO 71, AM 143

and AM 477

+

144 Renate Sommer

457 (7th part)

Bernadette Vergnaud

Identical

Deletion

- 29/32/0

456 (2nd part)

Jill Evans Falls if AM 144/457(7th part) is

adopted

-


AGRI 74 Falls if AM 144/457(7th part) or AM 456 (2nd part) is adopted

- 27/33/1

145 Renate Sommer

+ Article 34 – paragraph 6 457

(8th part)

Bernadette Vergnaud


478 Carl Schlyter To be adapted if AM 459, AM 457 (5th part), AM 476 or AM 144/AM

457 (7th part) is adopted +


(new) 456 (3rd part)

Jill Evans Falls if AM 144/457(7th part) is

adopted +

35/24/2

146 Renate Sommer

+

Chapter V – title



PV\814231EN.doc 57/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE


CONSOLIDATED AM 11

If ConsAM 11 is adopted, AMs 147, 148, 481, 480, AGRI 75, 482, AGRI 76, 483, 484, 485, 486, 149, AGRI 77, 490, 489, 487, 488, IMCO 73, AGRI 78, IMCO 74, 150, 491, IMCO 75, AGRI 79, 492, AGRI 80, AGRI 81, IMCO 76, AGRI 82 and AM 495 fall

- 30/31/0

147 Renate Sommer


+

148 Renate Sommer


Deletion +

481 (1st part)

Frédérique Ries



F

480

Mairead McGuinness,

Struan Stevenson

AGRI 75

Identical


Falls if AM 148 or AM 481 (1st

part) is adopted

F

Article 35 - paragraph 1

482 Carl Schlyter

Falls if ConsAM 11 is adopted Falls if AM 148, AM 481 (1st part) or AM 480/AGRI 75 is adopted

F

AGRI 76

483 Holger

Krahmer

Identical



(new) 481

(2nd part)

Frédérique Ries


PE441.002v03-00 58/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

484 Glenis

Willmott

Falls if ConsAM 11 is adopted Falls if AM 481 (2nd part) is adopted

F

485 Carl Schlyter Falls if ConsAM 11 is adopted

+

486 Esther de Lange


149 Renate Sommer



AGRI 77



F

490 Oreste Rossi



Falls if AM 313 is not adopted

F



Falls if AM 486, AM 149, AGRI 77 or AM 490 is adopted

F



Falls if AM 486, AM 149, AGRI 77, AM 490 or AM 489 is adopted

F

488 Richard Seeber


Falls if AM 486, AM 149 or AM 490 is adopted

F

Article 35 - – paragraph 2

IMCO 73


Compatible with AM 486, AM 149, AGRI 77, AM 490, AM 489, AM 487

and AM 488

-

AGRI 78 Falls if ConsAM 11 is adopted

- Article 35 – paragraph 2 a

(new) IMCO 74 Falls if ConsAM 11 is adopted

-


150/1st part

Renate Sommer


Deletion

+ 32/28/0

PV\814231EN.doc 59/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

491 (1st part)

Frédérique Ries

Falls if ConsAM 11 is adopted Falls if AM 150 (1st part) is adopted

F

IMCO 75


Falls if AM 150 (1st part) or AM 491 (1st part) is adopted

F

491 (2nd part)

Frédérique Ries


492 Glenis

Willmott

Identical

Falls if ConsAM 11 is adopted AM 492 is WITHDRAWN Deletion

-

150 (2nd part)

Renate Sommer


AGRI 80

Identical

Falls if ConsAM 11 is adopted Deletion

+ 32/28/0

AGRI 81

IMCO 76

493

Mairead McGuinness,

Struan Stevenson


(new)

494 George Lyon

Identical

AM 493/AM 494 withdrawn


-


150 (3rd part)

Renate Sommer


Deletion +

PE441.002v03-00 60/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

AGRI 82

Falls if ConsAM 11 is adopted Falls if AM 150 (3rd part) is adopted

F

495 Carl Schlyter


Falls if AM 150 (3rd part), AM 148, AM 150 (1st part), AM 491 (2nd part)/AM 492/AGRI 79 or AM

150(2nd part)/AGRI 80 is adopted Compatible with AGRI 82

F



+



-

498


Schaldemose

-



Article 35 a (new)

499 Esther De

Lange


- 25/33/2

151 Renate Sommer

Article 36 501

Frédérique Ries

Identical Deletion

+

Chapter VI (Article 37-43)

AGRI 83 +

PV\814231EN.doc 61/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

IMCO 77

Identical Deletion Split vote requested by MEP Oreste Rossi: 1st part: Deletion of Article 37 2nd part: Deletion of Article 38 para 1 To be adapted in the light of the vote on Chapter VI split votes, if necessary 3rd part: Deletion of Article 38 para 2 4th part: Deletion of Article 39 5th part: Deletion of Article 40 6th part: Deletion of Article 41 para 1 and 3 7th part: Deletion of Article 41 para 2 8th part: Deletion of Article 42 para 1, 3 and 5 To be adapted in the light of the vote on Chapter VI split votes, if necessary 9th part: Deletion of Article 42 para 2 and 4 10 part: Deletion of Article 43

1.- 2.- 3.+

31/28/1 4.- 5.- 6.- 7.-

28/33/0 8.- 9.- 10.-


part


Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (2nd part split vote) is adopted

-

Article 38 – paragraph 1 – points a, b and

c

152 Renate Sommer

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (2nd part split vote) is adopted Deletion

- 30/31/0


point d 503

Renate Sommer

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (2nd part split vote) is adopted

+ 38/22/1

PE441.002v03-00 62/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE


a (new)

504 Struan

Stevenson

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77(2nd part split vote) is adopted

+

153 Renate Sommer

505 Carl Schlyter



Identical Deletion Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (3rd part split vote) is adopted

F

507 Carl Schlyter

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (1st-10th part split vote) is adopted

-

Article 38 a (new)

508 Kartika Liotard

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77(1st-10th part split vote) or AM 507 is

adopted

+ 31/27/2



Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (4th part split vote) is adopted

-

154 Renate Sommer

Article 40 510

Glenis Willmott

Identical Deletion AM 510 is WITHDRAWN Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (5th part split vote) is adopted

+

Article 40 a (new)

511 Carl Schlyter Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (1st-10th part split vote) is adopted -

Article 41– paragraph 1

155 Renate Sommer


Deletion

- 25/36/0

PV\814231EN.doc 63/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE 514 (1st

part) Glenis

Willmott Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (6th part split vote) or AM 155 is adopted +

515


Schaldemose

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (6th part split vote), AM 155 or AM 514(1st

part) is adopted F

513 (1st part)

Frédérique Ries

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (6th part split vote), AM 155, AM 514 (1st part) or AM 515 is adopted

F

512 (1st part)

Edite Estrela, José Manuel Fernandes

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (6th part split vote), AM 155, AM 514 (1st

part), AM 515 or AM 513 (1st part) is adopted

F

512 (2nd part)

Edite Estrela, José Manuel Fernandes

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (7th part split vote) or AM 155 is adopted

Deletion

-

516


Schaldemose

513 (2nd part)

Frédérique Ries

Identical

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (7th part split vote), AM 155 or AM 512 (2nd

part) is adopted

-

517 Dagmar Roth-

Behrendt

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77(7th part split vote), AM 155, AM 512 (2nd part)or AM 516/AM 513(2nd part)

is adopted

-

514 (2nd part)

Glenis Willmott

Falls if AGRI 83/ IMCO 77(7th part split vote), AM 155, AM 512(2nd

part), AM 513(2nd part)/516 or AM 517 is adopted

+ 33/27/1


518 Carl Schlyter

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77(7th part split vote), AM 155, AM 512(2nd part), AM 513(2nd part)/516, AM

517 or AM 514 (2nd part) is adopted

F


(new)

514 (3rd part)

Glenis Willmott

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77(7th part split vote), AM 155, AM 512(2nd part), AM 513(2nd part)/516 is

adopted or AM 514 (2nd part) is not adopted

+

PE441.002v03-00 64/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

519


Schaldemose

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (6th part split vote), AM 155, AM 512(1st part) or AM 514(1st part) is

adopted

Falls if AM 513 (2nd part) or AM 515 is not adopted

F


513 (3rd part)

Frédérique Ries

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (6th part split vote), AM 155, AM 512(1st part) or AM 514(1st part) is

adopted

Falls if AM 513 (2nd part) or AM 515 is not adopted

F


156 Renate Sommer


Deletion -


520

Mairead McGuinness,

Struan Stevenson

Falls if AGRI 83/ IMCO 77 (9th part split vote) or AM 156 is adopted

+


157 Renate Sommer

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (8th part split vote) Deletion

-

521 Struan

Stevenson

Falls if AGRI 83/ IMCO 77 (8th part split vote)

Deletion

+


158 Renate Sommer

Falls if AGRI 83/IMCO 77 (8th part split vote) or AM 521 is adopted

F



Deletion +

PV\814231EN.doc 65/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

522 Carl Schlyter

Falls if AGRI 83IMCO 77 (10th part split vote) or AM 159 is

adopted

F

AGRI 84

IMCO 78

Chapter VII (Article 44-47)

160 Renate Sommer

Identical

Deletion Split vote requested by MEP Oreste Rossi: 1st part: Deletion of Article 44 (except para 2) 2nd part: Deletion of Article 44 para 2 2nd part split vote falls if 1st part split vote is adopted 3rd part: Deletion of Article 45 3rd part split vote falls if 1st or 2nd part split vote is adopted 4th part: Deletion of Article 46 and 47 4th part split vote falls if 1st or 2nd part split vote is adopted

1. -

2. -

3. -

4. -


part

523 Karin

Kadenbach

Falls if AGRI 84/IMCO 78/AM 160 (1st part split vote) is adopted

-


524 Carl Schlyter Falls if AGRI 84/IMCO 78/AM160 (1st part split vote) is adopted

+ 47/14/0


Deletion + 32/29/0

Article 50 – paragraph -1

(new) 162

Renate Sommer

+

32/28/0

PE441.002v03-00 66/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE


-

AGRI 85

+

525 Renate Sommer

+

Article 51 a (new)

526 Carl Schlyter The chairman ruled this amendment inadmissible

Article 53 -subpara 2 a

(new) IMCO 79

-

528/1st part

Anja Weisgerber

+

527/1st part

Françoise Grossetête, Catherine Soullie,

Michel Dantin

AGRI 86/1st part

Identical

Fall if AM 528/1st part is adopted

F

529/1st part

Peter Liese, Horst

Schnellhardt

Article 53 - subparagraph 3

164/1st part

Renate Sommer

Identical

Falls if AM 528/1st part or AM 527/1st part/AGRI 86/1st part is

adopted

F

529/2nd part

Peter Liese, Horst

Schnellhardt

- 24/37/0

530 George Lyon +

32/27/1

164/2nd part

Renate Sommer

528/2nd part

Anja Weisgerber

Article 53 - subparagraph 3

a (new)

IMCO 80/

(Almost) Identical


F

PV\814231EN.doc 67/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

527/2nd part


Michel Dantin

AGRI 86/2nd part

Identical

Fall if AM 530 or AM 164/2nd part/ AM 528/2nd part/IMCO 80/83 is

adopted

F

Annex I – point 1 (intro)

531 (1st part)

Chris Davies German version needs to be corrected, if adopted ("bedeutet Informationen,

die....angeben") -

Annex I – point 1 – point a

165 Renate Sommer

+

531 (2nd part)

Chris Davies - Annex I – point 1 – point b

(intro) 166 (1st part)

Renate Sommer

Falls if AM 531 (2nd part) is adopted

- 30/30/0

Annex I – point 1 – point b –

indent 2

166 (3rd part)

Renate Sommer

-

Annex I – point 1 – point b – indent 2 a

AGRI 87 -

Annex I – point 1 – point b – indent 2 b

AGRI 88 -

Annex I – point 1 – point b – indent 2 c

AGRI 89 -

Annex I – point 1 – point b – indent 2 d

AGRI 90 -

AGRI 91 Deletion - Annex I – point 1 – point b –

indent 3 166 (4th part)

Renate Sommer

Falls if AGRI 91 is adopted -

AGRI 92 Deletion - Annex I – point 1 – point b –

indent 4 166 (2nd part)

Renate Sommer

Falls if AGRI 92 is adopted -

PE441.002v03-00 68/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE Annex I – point 1 – point b –

indent 5

166 (5th part)

Renate Sommer

-

167 Renate Sommer

WITHDRAWN W

AGRI 93 - Annex I - point

4

532 Renate Sommer


NV

Annex I – point 8

168 Renate Sommer

+

31/30/0

Annex I – point 8 a (new)

AGRI 94 -

Annex I – point 8 b (new)

AGRI 95 -

Annex I – point 9

533 Horst

Schnellhardt -

AGRI 96 Annex I – point

10 169

Renate Sommer

Identical

+

Annex I – point 11 a (new)

170 Renate Sommer

+

AGRI 97

535


Michel Dantin

Identical

Deletion

-

534 Esther de Lange

-

Annex I – point 13

171 Renate Sommer


Annex II – title 172 Renate Sommer

+

Annex II – point 1 – point 173

Renate Sommer +

PV\814231EN.doc 69/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE d

AGRI 98 Identical

174 Renate Sommer Annex II –

point 7 – point a AGRI 99

Identical

+

175 Renate Sommer Annex II –

point 8 – point a AGRI 100

Identical

-30/31/0

Annex II – point 12

176 Renate Sommer

+

Annex III – table- row 5 a

(new)

AGRI 101

-

Annex III – table – row 1 a

(new) 177

Renate Sommer

+

30/22/9

Annex III – row 1 - point 1.1 a (new)

536 Carl Schlyter -

178 Renate Sommer

Deletion - Annex III – row 2 - point

2.1 537 Carl Schlyter Falls if AM 178 is adopted -

Annex III – row 2 - point

2.2 538 Carl Schlyter

-

IMCO 82

+ Annex III – row 2 - point

2.3 539 Carl Schlyter Falls if IMCO 82 is adopted

F

Annex III – row 3 a (new)

540 Carl Schlyter

-

Annex III – row 3 b (new)

541 Carl Schlyter\

-

Annex III – row 3 c (new)

542 Carl Schlyter

-

Annex III – point 5 a (new)

543


Schaldemose

-

PE441.002v03-00 70/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

IMCO 83 Identical

Annex III - point 5 a (new)

IMCO 84

+

Annex IV – title

179 Renate Sommer

Falls if AM 122 is not adopted +

Annex IV – indent 1

180 Renate Sommer

+

AGRI 102

-

Annex IV – -indent 2

544


Michel Dantin


+

Annex IV – indent 2 a

(new) 545

Hans-Peter Mayer

Oral AM by MEP Hans-Peter Mayer: "non-processed fresh meat, which is seasoned"

1. - (OA)

25/35/0 2. -

Annex IV –

indent 3 IMCO 85 (1st part)

+

IMCO 85 (2nd part)

+ Annex IV –

indent 4 AGRI 103

Compatible with IMCO 85 (2nd part) +

181 Renate Sommer

+ Annex IV –

indent 5 a (new) IMCO 85 (3rd part)


Annex IV – indent 5 b

(new) 182

Renate Sommer

+


(new) 183

Renate Sommer

+


(new) 184

Renate Sommer

+

185 Renate Sommer


(new) AGRI 105

(Almost) Identical

+

PV\814231EN.doc 71/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

IMCO 87

551 Struan

Stevenson

+

188 Renate Sommer

Compatible with AM 551 +

546 Holger

Krahmer Compatible with AM 551 and AM188

+

547 Holger

Krahmer Compatible with AM 551, AM 546

and AM 188 +


(new)

548 Holger

Krahmer

Falls if AM 551 or AM 188 adopted Compatible with AM 546 and AM

547 F

549 Carl Schlyter Deletion -

550 Glenis

Willmott Falls if AM 549 is adopted

+ 36/25/0

186 Renate Sommer

Falls if AM 549 is adopted. Compatible with 550

-

Annex IV – indent16

IMCO 86 Falls if AM 549 or AM 186 is

adopted Compatible with 550

+ 38/23/0


(new) 187

Renate Sommer

IMCO 88

Identical

+

Annex IV – indent 18

AGRI 104 +


(new) AGRI 106 +

Annex IV – indent 19 c

(new) AGRI 107 +

Annex V – part A – paragraph

1 – subparagraph 2

553 Jill Evans +

552 János Áder Annex V – part B – paragraph

1 AGRI 108

Identical

+

PE441.002v03-00 72/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

189 Renate Sommer

Compatible with AM 552 and AGRI 108

+

Annex V – part B – paragraph

2 a (new)

190 Renate Sommer

WITHDRAWN

W

554 Glenis

Willmott

+

555 Carl Schlyter Compatible with AM 554

+ Annex V – part B – paragraph

2 b (new

556 Carl Schlyter Compatible with AM 554 and AM

555

+

AGRI 109 -

29/31/0 Annex V – part

C a (new) 191

Renate Sommer

Various language versions need to be adapted to the German original version, if adopted.

+

AGRI 110

Oral AM by Anja Weisgerber: "Official designation of foods which give the impression of being different food (the following list contains examples)".

+

557 Anja

Weisgerber

Annex V – part C b (new)

IMCO 89

Identical


F

Annex VI – Part A – point 5

left-hand column

IMCO 90

+

AGRI 111 Annex VI – part B – point 1

right-hand column

subparagraph 2 IMCO 91 (1st part)

Identical

+

Annex VI – part B – point 2

right-hand column

subpara 2

IMCO 91 (2nd part)

+

PV\814231EN.doc 73/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE Annex VI –

part B – point 2 right-hand column

subpara 2

AGRI 112

Identical +

Annex VI – part B – point 4

left-hand column

IMCO 92

+

Annex VI – part B – row 15

a (new) 192

Renate Sommer

+

558 Carl Schlyter -

AGRI 113 + Annex VI –

part B – row 17 - subpara 1 -

559 Hans-Peter

Mayer Falls if AGRI 113 is adopted

F

Annex VI – part B – row 17 - subpara 1 a

(new)

193 Renate Sommer

Oral AM by rapporteur: "With the exception of beef, this definition also covers meat which is obtained mechanically from meat bearing bones after boning and which is not covered...No 853/2004."

Falls if AGRI 113 or AM 559 is

adopted

F

Annex VI – part B – row 17

– left hand column – table

– last row

560 Hans-Peter

Mayer


-

Annex VI – part B – row 18 – left column

561 Hans-Peter

Mayer

-

Annex VI – part B – row 18 – right column

562 Carl Schlyter

- 27/33/0

Annex VI – part C – listing row 9 a (new)

563 Esther de Lange

+

33/26/1

Annex VI – part C – listing row 16 a (new)

564 Horst

Schnellhardt

-

PE441.002v03-00 74/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE 565 (1st

part) Esther de Lange

+ Annex VIII –

paragraph 1 - point a 566

Renate Sommer

Falls if 565 (1st part) is adopted. F

194 Renate Sommer

Annex VIII – paragraph 1 b 565

(2nd part)

Esther de Lange

Identical

+

567 Horst

Schnellhardt Compatible with AM 565 (1st and 2nd

part) and AM 194 -

195 Renate Sommer

W

AGRI 114

IMCO 93

Identical

+

32/27/2 Annex VIII – paragraph 5

568 Carl Schlyter Compatible with AM 195/AGRI 114/IMCO 93 -

Annex IX 196 Renate Sommer

Deletion Deemed to be adopted if AM 120,

AM 375 or 376 is adopted.

+

Annex X 197 Renate Sommer

Deletion -

Annex XI – part A – title

198 Renate Sommer

+

AGRI 115 Annex XI – part A –

paragraph 1 – table IMCO 94

Identical

+

569

Esther de Lange

+ Annex XI –

part A – paragraph 2 AGRI 116


PV\814231EN.doc 75/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

CONSOLIDATED AM 12

Falls if Consolidated AM 9 is not

adopted

If ConsAM 12 is adopted, AMs 573, 570, 571, 572, AGRI 117, AGRI 118, AGRI 119; AGRI 120 and AGRI

121 fall

F

573 Carl Schlyter Falls if ConsAM 12 is adopted

-



+

Annex XI – part B - title

570 (1st part)/ 199 (1st part)

Renate Sommer

Falls if ConsAM 12 is adopted AM 199(1st part) withdrawn

Compatible with AM 573 and AGRI

117

+

Annex XI – part B – table –

row 1

570 (2nd part)/ 199 (2nd part)

Renate Sommer


AM 199(2nd part) withdrawn


+

570 (3rd part)

Renate Sommer



Annex XI – part B – table – row 1 a (new) 199

(3rd part)

Renate Sommer

WITHDRAWN W



- Annex XI –

part B – table – row 3 a (new) 572 (1st

part) Elena Oana Antonescu



-



-

Annex XI – part B – table – row 3 b (new) 572

(2nd part)



Falls if AM 573 or AGRI 119 is

adopted

-

PE441.002v03-00 76/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

AGRI 120

Annex XI – part B – table – row 3 c (new)

572 (3rd part)


Identical



-

AGRI 121



- Annex XI –

part B – table – row 3 d (new)

572 (4th part)




-

Annex XI – part B – table –

row 6

570 (4th part)/ 199 (4th part)

Renate Sommer



AM 199 (4th part) is withdrawn

-

Annex XI – part B – table – row 6 a (new)

571 Anna Rosbach



-

200 Renate Sommer

Annex XII – table

IMCO 95

Identical

+

PV\814231EN.doc 77/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

201 Renate Sommer

+ 39/27/0

IMCO 96 Annex XIII- Part A - table-

First row

AGRI 122

Identical


F

574

Anja Weisgerber,

Thomas Ulmer Annex XIII –

part C a (new)

IMCO 97

Identical

Fall if AM 454 (3rd part) is not

adopted

F

Annex XIII a (new)

575 Carl Schlyter Falls if AM 470 is not adopted

F

Recital 2 1 Renate Sommer

+


+


-


+

5 Renate Sommer

+

AGRI 1 First part compatible with AM 5 + Recital 10

IMCO 1 Falls if AM 5 or AGRI 1 is adopted F

Recital 14 AGRI 2

+


PE441.002v03-00 78/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

AGRI 3

(Almost) Identical Split vote by MEP Carl Schlyter: 1st part: 1st sentence ("Community rules....this regulation.") 2nd part: 2nd sentence ("In order....requirements")

1.+ 2.+

IMCO 2 Falls if AM 6/AGRI 3 is adopted F

Recital 15 a (new)

7 Renate Sommer

+

AGRI 4 + Recital 16

8 Renate Sommer



+


+

11 Renate Sommer

+

AGRI 5 Recital 19

IMCO 3

Identical


F

12 Renate Sommer

Recital 20

AGRI 6 (Almost) Identical +

Recital 20 a (new)


+

203 Holger

Krahmer +

13 Renate Sommer

Compatible with AM 203 + Recital 21

IMCO 4 Compatible with AM 203 and AM 13

as an addition +

Recital 22 AGRI 7 +

Recital 22 a AGRI 8 +

PV\814231EN.doc 79/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

14 Renate Sommer

Deletion +

204

Mairead McGuinness,

Struan Stevenson

AGRI 9

Recital 23

IMCO 5

Identical


F


+

15 Renate Sommer

Compatible with AM 206 + Recital 24


Compatible with AM 206 and AM 15 +

AGRI 10 +

208

Mairead McGuinness,

Struan Stevenson

IMCO 6

Identical


F

16 Renate Sommer

Falls if AGRI 10 or AM 208/IMCO 6 is adopted

F

Recital 25

207 Holger

Krahmer

Falls if AGRI 10 or AM 16 is adopted

Compatible with AM 208/IMCO 6

F


+

18 Renate Sommer

Deletion -

25/33/2 Recital 27

211

Glenis Willmott,

Nessa Childers


-

PE441.002v03-00 80/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

209 Carl Schlyter

210 Åsa Westlund

Identical

Fall if AM 18 or AM 211 is adopted

-

Recital 27 a (new)

IMCO 7

+

213 Carl Schlyter

216 Åsa Westlund

217

Glenis Willmott,

Nessa Childers

Deletion

Identical - 22/39/1

AGRI 11

Falls if AMs 213 / 216 / 217 adopted

Possibly would need to be adapted in the light of the vote on Article 29 paragraph 1 subpara 2

+

Recital 28

19/214 Renate Sommer

F

PV\814231EN.doc 81/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

IMCO 8

(Almost) Identical

Fall if AMs 213 / 216 / 217 or AGRI 11 is adopted

AM 19 is withdrawn

Possibly would need to be adapted in

the light of the vote on Article 29 paragraph 1 subpara 2


Falls if Am 213 / 216 / 217 adopted

Partly compatible with AMs 19 / 214/IMCO 8 and AGRI 11



-

212 Dagmar Roth-

Behrendt

Falls if AMs 213 / 216 / 217 adopted

Compatible with AGRI 11, AMs 19 / 214/ IMCO 8 and AM 215



-

220 Dagmar Roth-

Behrendt

-



222 Åsa Westlund


- 24/37/1

Recital 29

219 Oreste Rossi First part compatible with AM 220,

AM 218 and AM 222 +

PE441.002v03-00 82/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

20 Renate Sommer

Split vote requested by MEP Oreste Rossi: 1st part: The whole AM without the words "As a matter of principle" 2nd part: Those words



First part compatible with AM 220

F

221 Carl Schlyter

Falls if AM 220 or AM 218 or AM 222 is adopted


-

AGRI 12

Falls if AM 220, AM 218, AM 222 AM 219 or 221 is adopted


F

IMCO 9

Falls if AM 218, AM 222, AM 219, AM 20, AM 221 or AGRI 12 is

adopted


F


+

Recital 31 223 Carl Schlyter

+

Recital 31 a (new)

224 Frédérique

Ries

-


+

Recital 32

22 Renate Sommer

Compatible with AM 225 +

Recital 33 226 Antonyia Parvanova

+

PV\814231EN.doc 83/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

AGRI 13

228 Horst

Schnellhardt

Identical -

23 Renate Sommer

Falls if AGRI 13 / AM 228 is adopted

+

229

Glenis Willmott,

Nessa Childers

Falls if AGRI 13 / AM 228 or AM 23 is adopted

F

Recital 34

227 Carl Schlyter Falls if AGRI 13 / AM 228, AM 23

or AM 229 is adopted F


+

230 Esther de Lange

IMCO 10

Identical

+ Recital 36

25 Renate Sommer

Falls if AM 230/IMCO 10 is adopted F

26 Renate Sommer

+



(Almost) Identical

Falls if Am 26 is adopted

F

233 Dagmar Roth-

Behrendt Falls if AM 26 or AM 231/232 is

adopted F

AGRI 14 Falls if AM 26 or AM 231/232 or

AM 233 is adopted F

Recital 37

IMCO 11 Falls if AM 26, AM 231/232, AM

233 or AGRI 14 is adopted F

236 Carl Schlyter -



Recital 38



-

PE441.002v03-00 84/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

27 Renate Sommer

Compatible with AM 236, AM 235 and AM 234 is adopted

+ 40/21/0

IMCO 12


Compatible with AM 236, AM 235 or AM 234

F


- 29/32/0 Recital 38 a

(new) 238

Glenis Willmott

+ 29/28/3

28 Renate Sommer

Deletion - Recital 39



241 Andres Perello

Rodriguez Deletion -

29 Renate Sommer


Split vote requested by MEP Oreste Rossi: 1st part: 1st sentence ("Information....catering services")

2nd part: 2nd sentence ("Therefore....to the consumer"

2nd part split vote falls, if 1st part split vote is not adopted

1.+ 2.+

240 Edite Estrela, José Manuel Fernandes

Falls if AM 241 or AM 29 (1st part split vote) is adopted

F

243 Oreste Rossi Falls if AM 241, AM 29 (1st part split vote) or AM 240 is adopted

F

242 Dagmar Roth-

Behrendt

Falls if AM 241, AM 29 (1st part split vote) or AM 240 is adopted


F

Recital 41


Falls if AM 241, AM 250, AM 251, AM 252 / 253 or AM 240 is adopted

Compatible with AM 29 (1st and 2nd part split vote), AM 243 and AM 242

F

PV\814231EN.doc 85/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

PARAGRAPH / RECITAL


VOTE

IMCO 13

Falls if AM 241, AM 29 (1st part split vote), AM 240 or AM 243 is

adopted

Partly compatible with AM 242 and AM 244

F

Recital 42 AGRI 15 +


-

31 Renate Sommer

- Recital 45




- 27/34/0

Recital 46 a (new)

246 Åsa Westlund

-

Recital 49 AGRI 16 +

33 Renate Sommer

+

Recital 49 a (new)

IMCO 14 Compatible with AM 33

+

IN FAVOUR

AGAINST ABST.

DRAFT REPORT AS A WHOLE 51 4 5

DRAFT LEGISLATIVE RESOLUTION 52 2 5

PE441.002v03-00 86/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

PV\814231EN.doc 87/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

Annex 2

Coordinators`results 17 March 2010

17.3.2010

A. APPOINTMENT OF RAPPORTEURS AND DRAFTSPERSONS

DECISION ON PROCEDURES

REPORTS

A.1. Conclusion of the Protocol on Integrated Coastal Zone

Management to the Convention for the Protection of the Marine Environment and the Coastal Region of the Mediterranean

ENVI/7/02324

2010/0016(NLE) COM (2010) 0030

Responsible: Opinions:

ENVI TRAN, REGI, PECH

Decision: The chairman was appointed rapporteur

A.2. Appointment of seven members of the Management Board of the

European Food Safety Authority ENVI/7/02440

2010/0815(NLE) 06896/2010 – C7-0065/2010

Responsible: ENVI

No legislative procedure - see item C.1.

OPINIONS

A.3. Integrated Maritime Policy (IMP) - Evaluation of progress made

and new challenges ENVI/7/02396

2010/2040(INI) COM(2009)0540

Responsible:

TRAN

PE441.002v03-00 88/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

Decision: No opinion

A.4. Conclusion of the Statute of the International Renewable Energy

Agency (IRENA) ENVI/7/02342

***I 2009/0085(COD) COM(2009)0326 – C7-0092/2009

Responsible:

ITRE

Decision: The chairman was appointed draftsman

Documents received for information

5. Green Paper on forest protection and information in the EU: preparing forests for climate change (SEC(2010)163 final)

COM(2010)0066 Responsible: ENVI – Opinions: ITRE, REGI, AGRI

Decision: The coordinators decided that the committee should seek

authorisation to draw up an own-initiative report on this paper.

Decision on rapporteur to be taken once the authorisation has been

granted.

6. Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions: Options for an EU vision and target for biodiversity beyond 2010

COM(2010)0004

Responsible: ENVI – Opinions: DEVE, ITRE, AGRI, PECH

Decision The coordinators decided that the issues raised in this paper should be addressed expeditiously within the current INI -report on the application of biodiversity legislation within the EU (rapporteur: Ms De Lange). The coordinators also agreed that other options, such as tabling an Oral Question plus a draft resolution, might be considered at a later stage with a view to addressing specific problems such as the preparation of the Nagoya Conference on biodiversity.

PV\814231EN.doc 89/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

*

* * B. DECISIONS ON ADDITIONAL REPORTS/OPINIONS/RESOLUTIONS B.1. Appointment of a standing rapporteur for legislative planning

The papers for the meeting included an extract (Part B, Chapter 2) from the Second Interim Report of the Working Party on parliamentary reform. Decision The coordinators noted that Ms Haug was the committee's standing rapporteur on the budget and decided to nominate Mr Seeber, co-coordinator of the EPP Group, rapporteur for legislative planning.

* * *

B.2. Short-list of possible candidates for own-initiative reports

Authorised ongoing own-initiative reports (no more than 6 at any given time): Action plan on Organ Donation and Transplantation (2009-2015): Strengthened cooperation between Member States (PERELLO - was adopted on 16 March) White Paper: Adapting to climate change: Towards a European framework for action (PRODI - was adopted on 16 March)

• Action against Cancer: European Partnership (PETELE - adoption on 7 April) • A Community approach on the prevention of natural and man made disasters"

(FERREIRA - adoption on 4 May) • Management of bio-waste in the European Union (FERNANDES - adoption on 3 June) • GDP and beyond (requested, but not yet authorised) • Green Paper on forest protection and information in the EU: preparing forests for climate

change (request for authorisation to be launched) Implementation report (only one per year) • Implementation of EU legislation aiming at the conservation of biodiversity (DE LANGE

- adoption on 2-3 June)

Short-list of candidates for own-initiative reports:

PE441.002v03-00 90/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

- p.m. Commission communication on 'Safe, Innovative and Accessible Medicines: a Renewed Vision for the Pharmaceutical Sector' (COM(2008)666 - see coordinators' decision of 12 January 2009(1))

- p.m. Commission communication on ' on implementing European Community Environmental Law' (COM(2008)773) - see coordinators' decision of 12 January 2009(2)

- p.m. Report from the Commission to the Council and the European Parliament on the implementation of Council Regulation (EEC) No 259/93 of 1 February 1993 on the supervision and control of shipments of waste within, into and out of the European Community . Generation, treatment and transboundary shipment of hazardous waste and other waste in the Member States of the European Union, 2001-2006 (COM(2009)0282) - On 21 July and on 2 September 2009, the coordinators decided to return to this document for further consideration. - Background: This Commission report is a 10-page paper on the operation of the former Waste Shipment Regulation. There are similar problems arising from the application of its successor which entered into force in mid-2007.

- p.m. At their meeting of 30 September, the coordinators short-listed a Commission communication on 'a European initiative on Alzheimer's disease and other dementias' (COM(2009)0380) as a possible future own-initiative report

- p.m. Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions solidarity in health: Reducing health inequalities in the EU (COM(2009)0567), see coordinators' decision of 5 November 2009: This communication was put on the short-list for possible future own-initiative reports.

- p.m. "GDP and beyond" (document COM(2009)0433), coordinators' decision of 2 December 2009, a prerequisite for authorisation being a common understanding with the ECON committee as to how Rule 50 should be applied..

B.3. Outlook: Future non-legislative Commission papers in the pipeline

Outlook (major non-legislative texts in the pipeline as listed in the Commission's rolling

programme):

- Climate Change: [adopted on 9 March 2010 - published as COM(2010)86, SEC(2010)261] International climate policy post-Copenhagen: Acting now to reinvigorate global action on climate change - official referral to ENVI for information expected soon (in time for the next coordinators' meeting)

The coordinators came to the conclusion that since the matter had been debated in plenary on 9 March 2010, there was no need to draw up a report on this paper.

*

* *

1 The coordinators agreed that the (then) PES Group should have the right to take up the matter after the elections in the procedurally most appropriate form. 2 The coordinators agreed that the committee should continue to deal with the matter after the elections in the procedurally most appropriate form.

PV\814231EN.doc 91/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

C. DECISIONS ON OTHER ISSUES

C.1. EFSA Management Board - EP opinion on the appointment of 7 new members

The papers for the meeting included: - a transmission letter of 5 March 2010 from Mr Piris to President Buzek - a letter of 5 March 2010 from Mr Piris to President Buzek on the procedure and the deadline - a summary on the selection process, together with a short-list (Council document 6896/10) - a full list of candidates and their c.v.s (Council document 6896/10 ADD - 210 pages!) Proposed action The coordinators

• heard MEP Liotard, the committee's contact person for relations with the EFSA

• agreed that a special evaluation meeting should be convened on 7 April 2010 (date and time to be confirmed subject to the availability of a suitable meeting room).

[Note on the procedure: The President of the European Parliament should inform the Council of Parliament's position within three months, that is before 8 June 2010 (the Council letter was officially received by Parliament on 8 March 2010).] C.2. Application of Rule 50 to the 'CO2 emissions from light commercial vehicles (LCV)

file

The papers for the meeting included a letter of 4 February 2010 from Mr Leinen to Mr Lehne. Decision The coordinators • heard Mr Callanan, rapporteur; • invited Mr Callanan to proceed in close cooperation with the shadow rapporteurs; • invited Mr Callanan and the Chair to negotiate (as foreseen by Rule 50) with their

counterparts a list of those provisions of the draft regulation which should be considered as falling under the joint competence of both committees.

PE441.002v03-00 92/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

C.3. Re-establishment of HealthWorking Group

Decision The coordinators re-enacted the traditional mandate(1) of the Health Working Group and agreed that the EPP and the S&D groups should nominate the two co-chairs (Mr Peterle and Ms Willmott respectively).

C.4. Use of ENVI expertise budget - request by Ms De Lange to authorise a workshop in

the context of the report on the implementation of biodiversity legislation

Decision The coordinators took the decision of principle to authorise the organisation of a workshop in the last week of April, to be financed form ENVI's expertise budget. Detailed specifications (on the basis of a concrete proposal from the rapporteur) would be refined in a written procedure with group staff, whereas indications as to the likely costs involved and the overall usage of the ENVI expertise budget in 2010 should be provided by Policy Department A. C.5. Use of ENVI expertise budget - request by Ms Klaß to authorise a workshop on

biocidal products

[Note: The proposed date for the workshop is the 15th of April 2010, from 9h until 12h30.] Decision The coordinators took a decision of principle to authorise the organisation of a workshop in mid-April, to be financed form ENVI's expertise budget. The workshop would involve a participation of the IMCO committee, which is associated to the procedure under Rule 50. Detailed specifications (on the basis of a concrete proposal from the rapporteur) would be refined in a written procedure with group staff, whereas indications as to the likely costs involved and the overall usage of the ENVI expertise budget in 2010 should be provided by Policy Department A.

1 The remit of the Health Working Group is to follow the implementation of the Health Action Programme and to discuss any healthissues that could not be discussed in the full committee due time constraints and bring, if necessary, those issues to the attention of the full committee.

PV\814231EN.doc 93/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

C.6. Delegation to Iceland on 25-28 May

C.6.1. Use of ENVI expertise budget - briefings for delegation to Iceland on 25-28 May

Decision The coordinators authorised the commissioning of briefing papers providing Members with background information in view of the delegation to Iceland. These briefings would address topical environmental, public health and food safety issues in Iceland, e.g. • an analysis of the acquis communautaire, especially in the fields of the environment,

public health and food safety, which Iceland is required to apply under the EEA agreement

• the state of play of accession negotiations • climate change and Iceland's role in developing alternative sources of energy, in

particular geothermal energy • biodiversity issues, in particular fisheries and whaling

C.6.2. Delegation to Iceland (25-28 May 2010) - information on composition of the

delegation

Decision The coordinators noted that currently only the EPP and the S&D group had put forward names of possible participants. C.7. Letter from Mr Rübig on STOA projects for ENVI

- Letter of 11 February from Mr RÜBIG to Mr LEINEN on the new STOA project proposals Decision The coordinators decided to return to the matter at their next meeting.

PE441.002v03-00 94/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

C.8. Comitology - RPS - objection pursuant to Rule 88 against the Draft Commission

Decision laying down criteria and measures for the financing of commercial demonstration

projects that aim at the environmentally safe capture and geological storage of CO2 as well

as demonstration projects of innovative renewable energy technologies under the ETS

Decision 1. The coordinators decide not to appoint a rapporteur in the meaning of Rule 88. Consequently the objectors are invited to present a draft resolution. 2. The timetable shall be as follows: (Note: The overall deadline for Parliament to react ends on 25 May.)

Draft resolution should be ready by 25 March 2010 (only English) A discussion might held in committee on 6/7 April 2010 (subject to the

availability of sufficient time) Deadline for amendments (only in English) 8 April 18.00 Vote in committee: 26-28 April 2010 Plenary vote: 17-20 May 2010

C.9. Amflora - request to invite Commissioner Dalli to the committee

The papers for the meeting include the two Amflora decisions adopted by the Commission on 2 March 2010. Decision The coordinators

• heard Ms Liotard • noted that the Commissioner had presented his decision to the coordinators

on 1 March, before the formal adoption of the decision by the Commission on 2 March and

• noted that Commissioner Dalli was expected to address the committee in the context of the 'structured dialogue' exercise in the course of April/May.

C.10 - Comitology - RoS - objection against three genetically modified maizes"

Awaiting the appearance of Commissioner Dalli in the committee, the decision on the

procedure was postponed.

C.11. Functioning of REACH and ECHA - request to send a letter to Commissioners

Potočnik and Tajani

Decision

PV\814231EN.doc 95/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

The coordinators agreed to Ms Hassi's proposal that a letter on topical issues related to the functioning of REACH and the European Chemicals Agency be sent to the two Commissioners before their visit to the Agency on 25 March 2010. The wording of that letter would be circulated to the coordinators by email before its being signed by the chairman.

* * *

p.m.: Upcoming issues:

• Delegation to EFSA on 23/24 June (tbc)

• Timetable of the Fjellner report (possible application of Rule 53)

• Involvement in possible post-Bonn ministerial conference/preparations for

COP16

D. DOCUMENTS FOR INFORMATION 1) Letter of 9 February 2010 from Mr Madelin to Mr Leinen: Invitation to participate in the evaluation in the Pandemic (H1N1) 2009 2) Letter of 11 February 2010 from Commissioner Potočnik to Mr Leinen on priorities of ENVI portfolio 3) Letter of 11 March 2010 from Mr Lehne to President Buzek on deadlines for the consultation of the Committee of the Regions and of the European Economic and Social Committee 4) Letter of 8 (?) March 2010 from Mr Bastarreche, Chairman of Coreper II, informing Mr Leinen that it would not be possible for EP observers to attend EU coordination meetings at CITES COP-15 in Doha. 5) Letter of 4 March 2010 from Mr Bastarreche, Chairman of Coreper II, informing President Buzek inter alia that it would not be possible for EP observers to attend EU coordination meetings at CITES COP-15 in Doha.

PE441.002v03-00 96/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

ПРИСЪСТВЕН ЛИСТ/LISTA DE ASISTENCIA/PREZENČNÍ LISTINA/DELTAGERLISTE/ ANWESENHEITSLISTE/KOHALOLIJATE NIMEKIRI/ΚΑΤΑΣΤΑΣΗ ΠΑΡΟΝΤΩΝ/RECORD OF ATTENDANCE/

LISTE DE PRÉSENCE/ELENCO DI PRESENZA/APMEKLĒJUMU REĂISTRS/DALYVIŲ SĄRAŠAS/JELENLÉTI ÍV/ REĀISTRU TA' ATTENDENZA/PRESENTIELIJST/LISTA OBECNOŚCI/LISTA DE PRESENÇAS/LISTĂ DE PREZENłĂ/

PREZENČNÁ LISTINA/SEZNAM NAVZOČIH/LÄSNÄOLOLISTA/DELTAGARLISTA

Бюро/Mesa/Předsednictvo/Formandskabet/Vorstand/Juhatus/Προεδρείο/Bureau/Ufficio di presidenza/Prezidijs/Biuras/Elnökség/ Prezydium/Birou/Predsedníctvo/Predsedstvo/Puheenjohtajisto/Presidiet (*)

Jo Leinen (Chairman),Dan Jørgensen (Vice-Chairman) (1,2), Corinne Lepage (Vice-Chairman), Carl Schlyter (Vice-Chairman) (2), Bogusław Sonik (Vice-Chairman) (2,3)

Членове/Diputados/Poslanci/Medlemmer/Mitglieder/Parlamendiliikmed/Μέλη/Members/Députés/Deputati/Deputāti/Nariai/Képviselõk/ Membri/Leden/Posłowie/Deputados/DeputaŃi/Jäsenet/Ledamöter

János Áder (2,3),Elena Oana Antonescu (2), Kriton Arsenis (2),Pilar Ayuso, Paolo Bartolozzi (1,2), Sergio Berlato (2,3), Milan Cabrnoch, (2), Martin Callanan, Chris Davies, Anne Delvaux (1,2),Bas Eickhout, Edite Estrela (2),Jill Evans (1,2), Karl-Heinz Florenz, Elisabetta Gardini (2), Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy, Julie Girling, Nick Griffin (2,3), Satu Hassi (2,3), Jolanta Emilia Hibner (1,2), Karin Kadenbach, (2,3),Christa Klaß, Holger Krahmer, Esther de Lange (2),Peter Liese, Kartika Tamara Liotard (2,3), Linda McAvan, Radvil÷ Morkūnait÷-Mikul÷nien÷, Miroslav Ouzký (1,2), Vladko Todorov Panayotov (2,3), Gilles Pargneaux, (2,3),Antonyia Parvanova, (2),Sirpa Pietikäinen (3), Frédérique Ries (2), Andres Perello Rodriguez, Pavel Poc, Vittorio Prodi, Anna Rosbach, Oreste Rossi (2), Daciana Octavia Sârbu, (2,3), Horst Schnellhardt, Richard Seeber, Theodoros Skylakakis,Claudiu Ciprian Tănăsescu (2), Anja Weisgerber, Åsa Westlund, Glenis Willmott, Sabine Wils, Marina Yannakoudakis (1,2)

Заместници/Suplentes/Náhradníci/Stedfortrædere/Stellvertreter/Asendusliikmed/Αναπληρωτές/Substitutes/Suppléants/Supplenti/ Aizstājēji/Pavaduojantys nariai/Póttagok/Sostituti/Plaatsvervangers/Zastępcy/Membros suplentes/SupleanŃi/Náhradníci/Namestniki/ Varajäsenet/Suppleanter

Pablo Arias Echeverría (2), Cristian Silviu Buşoi (2), Jorgo Chatzimarkakis (2),Tadeusz Cymański (1), João Ferreira (2,3), Christofer Fjellner (1,2), Jacqueline Foster (3), Matthias Groote, Esther Herranz García (2), Romana Jordan Cizelj (2),ElŜbieta Katarzyna Łukacijewska (2), Jiří Maštálka (2), Judith A. Merkies, Miroslav Mikolášik (2,3), Bill Newton Dunn (1,2), Justas Vincas Paleckis (2), Jaroslav Paška (1,2), Alojz Peterle (1,2) Michèle Rivasi (3), Giancarlo Scottà (2), Renate Sommer (1,2), Bart Staes (1,2), Csaba Sándor Tabajdi (1), Marianne Thyssen (2),Michail Tremopoulos, Giommaria Uggias (2),Thomas Ulmer, Marita Ulvskog (1), Kathleen Van Brempt (1,2), Peter van Dalen (1,2), Anna Záborská (1,2)

187 (2)

Dieter-Lebrecht Koch (2),Markus Pieper (2), Barbara Matera (1,2), Véronique Mathieu (2), Mario Mauro (2), Potito Salatto (2), Gianluca Susta (2), Joachim Zeller (1)

193 (3)

Josefa Andrés Barea (2), Guido Milana (2), Pablo Zalba Bidegain (2)

46 (6) (Точка от дневния ред/Punto del orden del día/Bod pořadu jednání (OJ)/Punkt på dagsordenen/Tagesordnungspunkt/Päevakorra punkt/Ηµερήσια ∆ιάταξη Σηµείο/Agenda item/Point OJ/Punto all'ordine del giorno/Darba kārtības punkts/Darbotvark÷s punktas/ Napirendi pont/Punt Aāenda/Agendapunt/Punkt porządku dziennego/Ponto OD/Punct de pe ordinea de zi/Bod programu schôdze/ Točka UL/Esityslistan kohta/Föredragningslista punkt)

Наблюдатели/Observadores/Pozorovatelé/Observatører/Beobachter/Vaatlejad/Παρατηρητές/Observers/Observateurs/Osservatori/ Novērotāji/Steb÷tojai/Megfigyelık/Osservaturi/Waarnemers/Obserwatorzy/Observadores/Observatori/Pozorovatelia/Opazovalci/ Tarkkailijat/Observatörer

Присъствал на/Presente el/Přítomný dne/Til stede den/Anwesend am/Viibis(id) kohal/Παρών στις/Present on/Présent le/Presente il/Piedalījās/ Dalyvauja/Jelen volt/PreŜenti fi/Aanwezig op/Obecny dnia/Presente em/Prezent/Prítomný dňa/Navzoči dne/Läsnä/Närvarande den: (1) 15.3.2010 (2) 16.3.2010 (3) 17.3.2010

PV\814231EN.doc 97/98 PE441.002v03-00

EN

По покана на председателя/Por invitación del presidente/Na pozvání předsedy/Efter indbydelse fra formanden/Auf Einladung des Vorsitzenden/Esimehe kutsel/Με πρόσκληση του Προέδρου/At the invitation of the Chair(wo)man/Sur l'invitation du président/ Su invito del presidente/Pēc priekšsēdētāja uzaicinājuma/Pirmininkui pakvietus/Az elnök meghívására/Fuq stedina taë-'Chairman'/ Op uitnodiging van de voorzitter/Na zaproszenie Przewodniczącego/A convite do Presidente/La invitaŃia preşedintelui/Na pozvanie predsedu/Na povabilo predsednika/Puheenjohtajan kutsusta/På ordförandens inbjudan

Съвет/Consejo/Rada/Rådet/Rat/Nõukogu/Συµβούλιο/Council/Conseil/Consiglio/Padome/Taryba/Tanács/Kunsill/Raad/Conselho/ Consiliu/Svet/Neuvosto/Rådet (*)

Комисия/Comisión/Komise/Kommissionen/Kommission/Euroopa Komisjon/Επιτροπή/Commission/Commissione/Komisija/Bizottság/ Kummissjoni/Commissie/Komisja/Comissão/Comisie/Komisia/Komissio/Kommissionen (*)

Fabrizio Barbaso (DG ENER), Soledad Blanco (DG ENV), Anders Lindholm (DG REGIO), Luis Manuel Portero Sanchez (DG TRADE), Eric Poudelet (DG SANCO), Hans Van Steen (DG ENER)

Други институции/Otras instituciones/Ostatní orgány a instituce/Andre institutioner/Andere Organe/Muud institutsioonid/ Άλλα θεσµικά όργανα/Other institutions/Autres institutions/Altre istituzioni/Citas iestādes/Kitos institucijos/Más intézmények/ Istituzzjonijiet ohra/Andere instellingen/Inne instytucje/Outras Instituições/Alte instituŃii/Iné inštitúcie/Druge institucije/Muut toimielimet/Andra institutioner/organ

Други участници/Otros participantes/Ostatní účastníci/Endvidere deltog/Andere Teilnehmer/Muud osalejad/Επίσης Παρόντες/Other participants/Autres participants/Altri partecipanti/Citi klātesošie/Kiti dalyviai/Más résztvevık/Parteëipanti ohra/Andere aanwezigen/ Inni uczestnicy/Outros participantes/AlŃi participanŃi/Iní účastníci/Drugi udeleženci/Muut osallistujat/Övriga deltagare

Секретариат на политическите групи/Secretaría de los Grupos políticos/Sekretariát politických skupin/Gruppernes sekretariat/ Sekretariat der Fraktionen/Fraktsioonide sekretariaat/Γραµµατεία των Πολιτικών Οµάδων/Secretariats of political groups/Secrétariat des groupes politiques/Segreteria gruppi politici/Politisko grupu sekretariāts/Frakcijų sekretoriai/Képviselıcsoportok titkársága/Segretarjat gruppi politiëi/Fractiesecretariaten/Sekretariat Grup Politycznych/Secr. dos grupos políticos/Secretariate grupuri politice/Sekretariát politických skupín/Sekretariat političnih skupin/Poliittisten ryhmien sihteeristöt/Gruppernas sekretariat

PPE

S&D

ALDE

ECR

Verts/ALE

GUE/NGL

EFD

NI

Gersony, Philibert, Lejko, Golz

Schoner, Guerra, Wood, Lamb -Borkowska, Pohlen

Bargum, Rogin,

Meehan, Milackova

Singhofen, Lehtonen, Zerger

Pantazidou, Lopriore

Van Luik, Berners

PE441.002v03-00 98/98 PV\814231EN.doc

EN

Кабинет на председателя/Gabinete del Presidente/Kancelář předsedy/Formandens Kabinet/Kabinett des Präsidenten/Presidendi kantselei/Γραφείο Προέδρου/President's Office/Cabinet du Président/Gabinetto del Presidente/Priekšsēdētāja kabinets/Pirmininko kabinetas/Elnöki hivatal/Kabinett tal-President/Kabinet van de Voorzitter/Gabinet Przewodniczącego/Gabinete do Presidente/ Cabinet Preşedinte/Kancelária predsedu/Urad predsednika/Puhemiehen kabinetti/Talmannens kansli

Кабинет на генералния секретар/Gabinete del Secretario General/Kancelář generálního tajemníka/Generalsekretærens Kabinet/ Kabinett des Generalsekretärs/Peasekretäri büroo/Γραφείο Γενικού Γραµµατέα/Secretary-General's Office/Cabinet du Secrétaire général/Gabinetto del Segretario generale/Ăenerālsekretāra kabinets/Generalinio sekretoriaus kabinetas/Fıtitkári hivatal/Kabinett tas-Segretarju Āenerali/Kabinet van de secretaris-generaal/Gabinet Sekretarza Generalnego/Gabinete do Secretário-Geral/Cabinet Secretar General/Kancelária generálneho tajomníka/Urad generalnega sekretarja/Pääsihteerin kabinetti/Generalsekreterarens kansli

Генерална дирекция/Dirección General/Generální ředitelství/Generaldirektorat/Generaldirektion/Peadirektoraat/Γενική ∆ιεύθυνση/ Directorate-General/Direction générale/Direzione generale/Ăenerāldirektorāts/Generalinis direktoratas/Fıigazgatóság/Direttorat Āenerali/Directoraten-generaal/Dyrekcja Generalna/Direcção-Geral/DirecŃii Generale/Generálne riaditeľstvo/Generalni direktorat/ Pääosasto/Generaldirektorat

DG PRES

DG IPOL

DG EXPO

DG COMM

DG PERS

DG INLO

DG TRAD

DG INTE

DG FINS

DG ITEC

Krugel, Toszegi, Beamisa

Meneghini

Правна служба/Servicio Jurídico/Právní služba/Juridisk Tjeneste/Juristischer Dienst/Õigusteenistus/Νοµική Υπηρεσία/Legal Service/ Service juridique/Servizio giuridico/Juridiskais dienests/Teis÷s tarnyba/Jogi szolgálat/Servizz legali/Juridische Dienst/Wydział prawny/ Serviço Jurídico/Serviciu Juridic/Právny servis/Pravna služba/Oikeudellinen yksikkö/Rättstjänsten

Anagnostopoulou

Секретариат на комисията/Secretaría de la comisión/Sekretariát výboru/Udvalgssekretariatet/Ausschusssekretariat/Komisjoni sekretariaat/Γραµµατεία επιτροπής/Committee secretariat/Secrétariat de la commission/Segreteria della commissione/Komitejas sekretariāts/Komiteto sekretoriatas/A bizottság titkársága/Segretarjat tal-kumitat/Commissiesecretariaat/Sekretariat komisji/ Secretariado da comissão/Secretariat comisie/Sekretariat odbora/Valiokunnan sihteeristö/Utskottssekretariatet

A.Huber, Amanatidis, Basin, Breier, Findlay, Koekkoek, Laky, Ohliger, Romano, Vervloet

Сътрудник/Asistente/Asistent/Assistent/Assistenz/Βοηθός/Assistant/Assistente/Palīgs/Pad÷j÷jas/Asszisztens/Asystent/Pomočnik/ Avustaja/Assistenter

Vigneron, Priborska

* (P) = Председател/Presidente/Předseda/Formand/Vorsitzender/Esimees/Πρόεδρος/Chair(wo)man/Président/Priekšsēdētājs/Pirmininkas/

Elnök/'Chairman'/Voorzitter/Przewodniczący/Preşedinte/Predseda/Predsednik/Puheenjohtaja/Ordförande (VP) = Заместник-председател/Vicepresidente/Místopředseda/Næstformand/Stellvertretender Vorsitzender/Aseesimees/Αντιπρόεδρος/

Vice-Chair(wo)man/Vice-Président/Priekšsēdētāja vietnieks/Pirmininko pavaduotojas/Alelnök/Viëi 'Chairman'/Ondervoorzitter/ Wiceprzewodniczący/Vice-Presidente/Vicepreşedinte/Podpredseda/Podpredsednik/Varapuheenjohtaja/Vice ordförande

(M) = Член/Miembro/Člen/Medlem./Mitglied/Parlamendiliige/Μέλος/Member/Membre/Membro/Deputāts/Narys/Képviselı/ Membru/Lid/Członek/Membro/Membru/Člen/Poslanec/Jäsen/Ledamot

(F) = Длъжностно лице/Funcionario/Úředník/Tjenestemand/Beamter/Ametnik/Υπάλληλος/Official/Fonctionnaire/Funzionario/ Ierēdnis/Pareigūnas/Tisztviselı/Uffiëjal/Ambtenaar/Urzędnik/Funcionário/FuncŃionar/Úradník/Uradnik/Virkamies/Tjänsteman