ethics and/or trust: how do we solve the crisis? presentation for the center for ethics education at...
TRANSCRIPT
ETHICS A
ND/OR T
RUST:
HOW D
O WE S
OLVE T
HE
CRISIS
?
PR
ES
EN
TA
TI O
N F
OR
TH
E C
EN
TE
R F
OR
ET
HI C
S
ED
UC
AT
I ON
AT
FO
RD
HA
M U
NI V
ER
SI T
Y
OC
TO
BE
R 1
7, 2
01
2
IN HONOR OF A TRUSTWORTHY MOTHER
Patricia Duffy Hurley
August 17, 1924 to October 16, 201232,233 days of a life that inspired trust.
CFTO VISION
To expand the number of organizations that can legitimately be called trustworthy because they consistently demonstrate the values, practices and processes that warrant stakeholder trust.
CFTO ACTIVITIES
Annual Summit
Speaker Series
Best Practice Groups
Cutting-Edge Research
Trust Measurement Diagnostics and Metrics
Executive Education
Confident reliance on a person, group, or organization when there is uncertainty and risk
What Is Trust?
" Is insider trading part of the fabric?"
"Jury Says Vivendi Defrauded Liberty Media"
"Financier Is Sentenced To 110 Years For Fraud"
"Fraud accusations threaten Burgundy's reputation "
NEW YORK TIMES HEADLINES THIS SUMMER
"A Calculated Deal In a Rate-Rigging Inquiry "
"Regulators Charge a Futures BrokerageFirm and Its Chief with Fraud"
"Olympus Says It Might Have Violated an Anti-Bribery Law "
Copyright 2012 Dr. Hurley
A FIVE PART SOLUTION
• Better regulation to reduce signals of distrust• Change the conversation from ethics to trust• Educate trustors to make better trust decisions• Develop more trustworthy leaders• Trustworthy leaders embed trustworthiness into the
DNA of their organizations
ETHICS AND TRUST
• How many of you think about the degree to which you have ethical and unethical relationships in your life?
• How many of you think about the degree to which you have high or low trust relationship son your life?
• Ethics – First principles• Integrity and honesty• Fairness• Benevolence and concern for others• Virtue and moral precepts
• Is it possible to be ethical and untrustworthy?
Low HighRisk Tolerance
SituationalFactors
TrustorFactorsLow High
Low HighPower
Adjustment
Low HighSituational Security
Not Apparent Apparent
Conflicting AlignedInterests
Similarities
Not Demonstrated DemonstratedBenevolent Concern
Low High
Low HighPredictability/Integrity
Capability
Poor GoodCommunication
DistrustingChoice
TrustingChoice
The Decision To Trust Model
A MODEL OF THE TRUST/DISTRUST CHOICE
Similarities
Interests
Benevolent Concern
Capability
Predictability/Integrity
Communication
Distrusting Choice Trusting Choice
Not apparent
Conflicting
Not demonstrated
Low
Low
Poor
Apparent
Aligned
Demonstrated
High
High
Good
A MODEL OF THE TRUST/DISTRUST CHOICE
Similarities
Interests
Benevolent Concern
Capability
Predictability/Integrity
Communication
Distrusting Choice Trusting Choice
Not apparent
Conflicting
Not demonstrated
Low
Low
Poor
Apparent
Aligned
Demonstrated
High
High
Good
A MODEL OF THE TRUST/DISTRUST CHOICE
Similarities
Interests
Benevolent Concern
Capability
Predictability/Integrity
Communication
Distrusting Choice Trusting Choice
Not apparent
Conflicting
Not demonstrated
Low
Low
Poor
Apparent
Aligned
Demonstrated
High
High
Good
A MODEL OF THE TRUST/DISTRUST CHOICE
Similarities
Interests
Benevolent Concern
Capability
Predictability/Integrity
Communication
Distrusting Choice Trusting Choice
Not apparent
Conflicting
Not demonstrated
Low
Low
Poor
Apparent
Aligned
Demonstrated
High
High
Good
A MODEL OF THE TRUST/DISTRUST CHOICE
Similarities
Interests
Benevolent Concern
Capability
Predictability/Integrity
Communication
Distrusting Choice Trusting Choice
Not apparent
Conflicting
Not demonstrated
Low
Low
Poor
Apparent
Aligned
Demonstrated
High
High
Good
A MODEL OF THE TRUST/DISTRUST CHOICE
Similarities
Interests
Benevolent Concern
Capability
Predictability/Integrity
Communication
Distrusting Choice Trusting Choice
Not apparent
Conflicting
Not demonstrated
Low
Low
Poor
Apparent
Aligned
Demonstrated
High
High
Good
QUOTETRUSTWORTHINESS
FAILUREWHERE
IN ORGANIZATION
“Overwhelming volume” CapabilityCompetencies
StructureCore Processes
“Lost culture of accuracy”
“Focus on market share”
“Removed analysts”
“Waved procedures”
Benevolent Concern
Communication
Alignment of interests
Integrity
Leadership
Mission/strategyCommunication Systems
HR Systems
Core Processes
“IBG-YBG”
Similarities Culture
ORGANIZATION
Similarities
Interests
Benevolent Concern
Capability
Predictability/Integrity
Communication
Stakeholders’Decision to Trust
ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE AND TRUST MODEL
Th
e De
cision to T
RU
ST: H
ow LE
AD
ER
S C
reate
High
-Trust O
rgan
izatio
ns, Ro
bert F. H
urle
y,C
opyrigh
t © 2
012 by R
obert F. H
urley. All righ
ts rese
rved.
Copyright 2012 Dr. Hurley
Leadership
Systems (Planning,Reporting, Budgeting,Compliance, Reward)
Selection andManagement of People
Other(Natural
Environment, Investors,
Government, Technology,
etc.
Values and Competencies
Cooperativeness of Relationship
1 6
2
3
5
4
7
1. Trustworthy Leaders: What’s Required for the Next Generation2. Effective Trust Repair3. Measuring Organizational Trust and Trustworthiness4. HR and L&D in Trustworthy Organizations
5. The Regulation of Distrust and Building High Trust Firms6. Moving from Compliance to Deep Embedding of Ethical Cultures7. A Multi-stakeholder Communications Approach to Building Trust