establishing a risk appetite in asset management

19
Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management “If it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck, it might just be a duck” (Merk, 2012).* Christopher B Grix Asset Management Forum 12 th March 2013

Upload: chris-grix

Post on 08-Jan-2017

202 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

“If it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck, it might just be a duck”(Merk, 2012).*

Christopher B GrixAsset Management Forum12th March 2013

Page 2: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

2

Contents1. Aim/ Scope of Review2. Method

• Overview or Research• Portfolio Risk descriptions• Business Risk descriptions• Operational Risk descriptions

3. Results• Governance• Portfolio Risk• Business Risk• Operational Risk

4. Conclusions

Page 3: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

3

Aim/ Scope of Review• Aim:– “To understand if there is a benchmark risk

appetite or holistic control limit framework for Asset Managers, that has been agreed by firms’ senior management, separate to any mandatory regulatory, legal or client driven requirements.”

• Scope: – UK based Asset Management Companies, via Risk

Management Departments.

Page 4: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

4

Questionnaire – An online questionnaire was sent to members of the following Risk Professionals:

• IMA Risk Working Group.• Asset Management Risk Forum.

The questionnaire was broken into the following sections:

• Governance – focusing on how Risk Appetite is defined and reviewed.

The research then reviewed how the relevant risk types are enforced/ embedded within asset managers:

• Portfolio Risk – risk in the portfolios managed on behalf of clients.• Business Risk – risk in the Asset Manager itself that may affect its capital or

financial position.• Operational Risk – risk in the Asset Manager itself as a result of people, processes,

systems or external events.

Method – Overview of Research

Page 5: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

5

Method – Risk Descriptions

Portfolio Risk Types Description

Market Market volatility impacting performance.

Investment Performance

Performance of investments against a benchmark, usually on a 1, 3 or 5 year basis.

Liquidity Ability to turn portfolio assets to cash.

Counterparty/ Credit

Portfolios’ exposure to counterparties and risk of their default.

Investment Guideline Breaches

Failure to meet client, legal or regulatory restrictions on portfolio investments.

Portfolio Risk

Page 6: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

6

Business Risk Types Description

Profitability Profitability of overall business or sub units.

Product Concentration Profit, Revenue or AUM dependence on one or a few product types/ strategies.

Client or Intermediary Concentration(s)

Profit, Revenue or AUM dependence on one or a few client(s) or intermediaries.

Counterparty Risk Asset managers’ exposure to counterparties and risk of their default.

Liquidity of Own Assets Ability to turn own company assets to cash.

Business Risk

Method – Risk Descriptions

Page 7: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

7

Operational Risk

Operational Risk Types Description

Legal/ Tax/ Regulatory Failure to adhere to legal, tax or regulatory requirements.

Compliance/ Fraud/ Corruption

Ethical breaches resulting in fraud or corruption.

Information Security Adequacy of IT security standards.Business Continuity Preparedness to continue business

through a range of disaster events.Outsourcing Degree of reliance and quality of

outsourced services.Personnel Key person risk, attrition levels.Manual Models Reliance on non-standard or manual IT

tools.Errors/ Losses Volume and size of errors or

operational losses.

Portfolio Risk

Business Risk

Method – Risk Descriptions

Page 8: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

8

Results - Governance1.1. Does your firm have an explicit Risk Appetite Statement? Total of 46

Responses 

Total of 46 Responses

 

1.2. If you do have a Risk Appetite statement, how frequently is this reviewed (firms could select multiple answers for this question e.g. quarterly and annually)?

Page 9: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

9

1.3. How is your firm’s Risk Appetite defined or reviewed?

Results - GovernanceTotal of 46 Responses

 

1.4. Do you feel the organisation’s risk appetite acts as a practical tool to help steer or limit the organisation’s business plan within agreed risk tolerances?

Total of 46 Responses

 

Page 10: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

10

Results – Portfolio Risk2.1 Does your firm include Portfolio Risk for third party/ clients’ assets in its Board/ Executive approved Risk Appetite statement?

Total of 41 Responses

 

Page 11: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

11

Results – Portfolio Risk2.2 Please select which areas of Portfolio Risk have a Hard Limit applied to them across your organisation - these are defined by the Company separate to any regulatory minimums or client guidelines and must not be breached (firms could select multiple answers for this question). Total of 41

Responses 

Page 12: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

12

2.3 Please select which areas of Portfolio Risk have a Soft Limit applied to them across your organisation - where key risk indicators or other measures are in place, but no absolute limits are enforced (firms could select multiple answers for this question).

Results – Portfolio Risk

Total of 41 Responses

 

Page 13: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

13

Results – Business Risk3.1 Does your firm include Business Risk in its Board/ Executive approved Risk Appetite statement?

Total of 39 Responses

 

Page 14: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

14

3.2 Please select which areas of Business Risk have a Hard Limit applied to them across your organisation - these are defined by the Company separate to any regulatory minimums or client guidelines and must not be breached.

Results – Business Risk

Total of 39 Responses

 

Page 15: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

15

Results – Business Risk3.3 Please select which areas of Business Risk have a Soft Limit applied to them across your organisation - where key risk indicators or other measures are in place, but no absolute limits are enforced. Total of 39

Responses 

Page 16: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

16

Results – Operational Risk4.1 Does your firm include Operational Risk in its Board/ Executive approved Risk Appetite statement?

Total of 38 Responses

 

Page 17: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

17

Results – Operational Risk4.2 Please select which areas of Operational Risk have a Hard Limit applied to them across your organisation - these are defined by the Company separate to any regulatory minimums or client guidelines and must not be breached.Total of

38 Response

Page 18: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

18

Results – Operational Risk4.3 Please select which areas of Operational Risk have a Soft Limit applied to them across your organisation - where key risk indicators or other measures are in place, but no absolute limits are enforced. Total of 38

Responses 

Page 19: Establishing a Risk Appetite in Asset Management

19

Conclusions• Disconnect remains between strategic planning and formation of Risk

Appetite.

• Larger firms more “visibly” able to evidence documented risk appetites than smaller firms.

• The key trend that appears to have been the driver for the most prevalent risk limits identified in the survey are likely to be:

• Regulatory pressure, via rules or enforcement actions;• Client pressure, through increased requests for information or client

led due diligence;• Changes in market practice, where control improvements quickly

become expected industry standard.