environmental, social & governance factors and credit ratings
TRANSCRIPT
Environmental, Social & Governance
Factors and Credit Ratings
October 22, 2019
Eversource is the Largest New England Utility
and 1 of the 15 Largest in the United States
Eversource
Electric Customers 3.2 million
Natural Gas Customers 535,000
Water Customers 230,000
Employees 8,000
Assets $39 billion
2018 Net Income $1.04 billion
We Serve New England’s Most Populous States:
All Have Aggressive Renewable and GHG Targets
Regional Greenhouse Gas Emission TargetsMMTCO2e
2019 2020 2025
CT 27.5% 29.0% 38.0%
MA 24.9% 27.7% 38.96%
NH 19.7% 20.7% 25.2%
Renewable Portfolio Standards in Place
(Percentage of electricity that must come from
qualifying renewable facilities)
Eversource Addressing Largest Sources of New
England Carbon Emissions: Transportation, Space
Heating & Power Generation
48.4%
36.7%
29.0%
10.3%
16.7%
34.8%
5.9%
18.2%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
New England U.S.
2016 Energy Carbon Emissions by SourceNew England vs. U.S.
Transportation
Space heating
Power generation
Industrial
Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration
Most Effective Method of Reducing Emissions:
Improve Energy Efficiency
14
4 21
1
5
3
Retail Customer Count Up 3% Since 2013, While KWH Sales Down 3.5%
Eversource MA, #1 Most Energy Efficient Utility in the United StatesAccording to ACEEE, in their second edition of the Utility Energy Efficiency Scorecard
#1 Energy Efficiency Provider in the NationAccording to Ceres most recent benchmarking report
Source: American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy 2018 Scorecard
Note: The lower the number…the more effective the Energy Efficiency Programs
Another Critical Effort to Reduce Emissions:
Low-Carbon Energy Solutions
MA Grid Modernization:
• Approved $133 million in grid facing investments in visibility and automation
• New 2021-2023 plan due to DPU by mid-2020
• CT and NH considering grid mod initiatives as well
Battery Storage:
• Constructing $55 million of projects on
Cape Cod and Martha’s Vineyard -
Completion expected in late 2020
• Two projects proposed in New
Hampshire
EV Infrastructure:
• Building infrastructure to support
3,500 charge ports in MA by the
end of 2020
• Similar rapid expansion likely in CT
to support 150K EVs by 2025
Generation:
• Eversource divested last of its fossil plants in January 2018
• Ørsted-Eversource JV largest developer of offshore wind in N. America
• Completed construction of 70 MW of solar in Massachusetts
Typical Topics of ESG Reviews:
Eversource Generally Scores Well
Environmental
• GHG & energy use
• Air quality
• Coal ash
• Water stewardship
• Energy efficiency
Social
• Community engagement
• Human resource and
compensation policies
• Health & Safety
• Grid reliability
• Lobbying
Governance
• Board diversity
• Board experience
• Independence
• Incentives & compensation
• Tax strategy
Source: PwC U.S. Power & Utilities team
And Here Are the Results
Number of SRI Funds Holding Eversource Shares
72
86
95
108
143
0
25
50
75
100
125
150
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
1. CMS ENERGY CORP
2. EVERSOURCE ENERGY3. XCEL ENERGY INC
4. EXELON CORP
5. DTE ENERGY CO
6. PINNACLE WEST CAPITAL
7. PUBLIC SERVICE ENTERPRISE
8. NISOURCE INC
9. PG&E CORP
10. NATIONAL GRID
11. AMERICAN ELECTRIC POWER
12. NEXTERA ENERGY
13. WEC ENERGY GROUP
14. PPL CORP
15. ENTERGY CORP
16. CONSOLIDATED EDISON
17. EDISON INTERNATIONAL
18. AES CORP
19. DUKE ENERGY CORP
20. ALLIANT ENERGY CORP
21. CENTERPOINT ENERGY
22. AMEREN CORP
23. OGE ENERGY CORP
24. DOMINION ENERGY, INC25. FIRSTENERGY
26. SOUTHERN CO
27. MDU RESOURCES
2019 Sustainalytics Ratings For Electric Utilities
R
a
n
k
Eversource Has Also Co-Chaired Electric Industry
Efforts to Standardize ESG Reporting
• In 2017, EEI members became the first industry in the US to offer investors standardized
qualitative and quantitative ESG disclosure
• In 2018, AGA members began offering comparable disclosure
• In 2019, we merged the two templates into one
• All posted on website with links
• Very positive reaction from equity, fixed-income, buy-side, sell-side analysts
• Has helped reduce error rate in third party reporting
• Has highlighted very significant progress made in recent years to reduce GHG emissions
Fitch Ratings Ltd -
ESG & Credit Ratings, Making The Connection
October 2019
Andrew Steel
Global Head of Sustainable Finance
We Measure Which ESG Risks Appear in Our Ratings
Credit Risk
• Which specific ESG risks are
potentially relevant for each
issuer’s credit profile.
• Which ESG risks are relevant
for different sectors, and even
countries or regions.
• Which ESG risks have risen to
a level where they are an
active factor in the rating
decision, on an issuer-by-
issuer basis.
• Which ESG risks actually led
to a rating change.
How Are We defining Relevance - Issuer Scale
4 5
Irrelevant to the
entity rating and
irrelevant to the
sector
Conceptually
inapplicable
from a credit
perspectivefor the sector
Irrelevant to the
entity rating, but
relevant to the
sector
Conceptually
applicable from
a credit
perspectivefor the sector, but
unlikely to impact a
rating.
Minimally
relevant to
rating, either
very low impact
or actively
managed in a
way that results
in no impact on
the entity rating.
Relevant to
rating, but not a
key rating driver,
but has an
impact on the
entity rating in
combination
with other
factors.
Highly relevant,
a key rating
driver that has a
significant
impact on the
entity rating on
an individual
basis.
Baseline neutral valueLowest relevance Credit-relevant to issuer
Source: Fitch Ratings
Introducing the ESG Relevance Navigator
Analyst Commentary Extract 4’s & 5’s Report
Source: Fitch Ratings, Introducing ESG Relevance Scores for Corporates
ESG.RS Output Summary For 1,534 Corporate Issuers
No Impact78%
Some Impact22%
Relevance to Issuer Portfolio
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Environmental Social Governance
(No.)
ESG Elements Driving Issuer Credit Impact(ESG Score of 4 or 5)
ESG.RS Output Summary for 345 Utility Issuers
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Environmental Social Governance
(No.)
ESG Elements Driving Issuer Credit Impact (ESG Score of 4 or 5)
Some Impact16%
No Impact84%
Relevance to Issuer Portfolio
ESG.RS for 159 Oil & Gas Issuers
Some Impact41%
No Impact59%
Relevance to Issuer Portfolio
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Environmental Social Governance
(No.)
ESG Elements Driving Issuer Credit Impact(ESG Score of 4 or 5)