environmental cleanup of the idaho national laboratory
TRANSCRIPT
E102
0030
20BD
S
2
Panelists
Introductions Jeff Bradford, Session Chair Overview Allen SchubertTank Farm Closure Keith QuigleyBuried Waste Brandt MeagherRemote-handled Transuranic Waste Scott AndersonFacility Demolition/Disposition Jim Floerke
E102
0030
20BD
S
3
About the Idaho National Laboratory Site
890 square milesOriginally established in 1949 as a national reactor testing stationCleanup focuses on 5 majorgeographic areas• Idaho Nuclear Technology
and Engineering Center (INTEC)• Radioactive Waste Management Complex
(RWMC)• Test Area North (TAN)• Reactor Technology Center (RTC)• Power Burst Facility (PBF)
E102
0030
20BD
S
6
Safety Performance
Total Recordable Case Rate (TRCR)Day Away Case Rate (DACR)Day Away, Restricted, or Transfer Rate (DART)
0.00
0.30
0.60
0.90
1.20
1.50
1.80
TRCR 1.68 1.66 1.60 1.55 1.56 1.36 1.31 1.32 1.29 1.31 1.26 1.31
DACR 0.47 0.43 0.42 0.33 0.34 0.29 0.29 0.24 0.20 0.20 0.16 0.16
DART 0.56 0.51 0.51 0.42 0.42 0.37 0.37 0.28 0.20 0.20 0.16 0.16
Jan-07 Feb-07 Mar-07 Apr-07 May-07 Jun-07 Jul-07 Aug-07 Sep-07 Oct-07 Nov-07 Dec-07
2008 TRCR Goal <1.33
2008 DART Goal <0.50
2008 DACR Goal <0.30
E102
0030
20BD
S
7
Cost and Schedule Performance
Cost variance is $57,851K; CPI: 1.05 Schedule variance is $64,845K; SPI: 1.06
Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
CPI 1.01 1.01 1.02 1.04 1.04 1.04 1.05 1.05 1.06 1.06 1.05 1.05 SPI 1.01 1.01 1.01 1.01 1.01 1.01 1.02 1.01 1.03 1.05 1.04 1.06
Cumulative
Idaho Completion Project Performance Measurement Graph(Jan 2007 - Dec 2007)
0.900.920.940.960.981.001.021.041.061.081.10
Jan
Feb Mar Apr
May
June Ju
ly
Aug
Sept
Oct
Nov Dec
Cost Performance Index (CPI) Schedule Performance Index (SPI)
E102
0030
20BD
S
8
Nuclear Material Disposition
ScopeDispose of all legacy, Environmental Management (EM)-owned, unirradiated special nuclear materials by September 30, 2009
490 items*
652 itemsDisposition nuclear material items
*Accomplishments through December 31, 2007
Unirradiated Light Water Breeder Reactor
(ULWBR) canister being lowered into Super Tiger Cask
E102
0030
20BD
S
9
Spent Nuclear Fuel
ScopeTransfer legacy, EM-owned spent nuclear fuel (SNF) from wet storage in the CPP-666 storage pool to appropriate dry storage by September 2009Receive and store SNF from the Advanced Test ReactorProvide safe, regulatory-compliant, routine operations for INTEC SNF handling and storage facilities until transition to another entity Fort St. Vrain (B.5)
• Perform surveillance and maintenance of facility• Provide security force for security of spent nuclear fuel
at facilityReturn all navy-owned fuel to Naval Reactors Facility for long-term dry storage (B.5)
1,801 units
3,178 unitsTransfer SNF from wet to dry
Texas A&M fuel is unloaded at INTEC
E102
0030
20BD
S
10
Tank Farm Closure
ScopeClose tanks in tank farm (including those storing sodium-bearing waste) by groutingProvide remedy indicated by Record of Decision for tank farm
Dome pours
E102
0030
20BD
S
11
Tank Farm Closure (continued)
Sodium-bearing Waste Treatment ScopeDesign Integrated Waste Treatment Unit (IWTU)Construct IWTUProcess sodium-bearing wasteShip to Waste Isolation Pilot Plant (WIPP)
E102
0030
20BD
S
12
Waste Management Services
ScopeTransuranic waste
• Retrieve remote-handled (RH) and contact-handled (CH) transuranic waste• Characterize RH and CH transuranic waste• Ship transuranic waste to the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant (WIPP)
Low-level and low-level mixed waste• Provide waste management, packaging, and transportation services to Idaho National Lab and Idaho
Cleanup Project• Dispose of low-level waste at the RWMC (until 2008)• Provide offsite disposal
of low-level and mixed low-level waste
• Operate the Idaho CERCLA Disposal Facility (ICDF)
• Repack, treat, and/or dispose of the backlog mixed low-level waste
RH TRU waste leaving Idaho
E102
0030
20BD
S
13
Environmental Restoration
ScopeRetrieve targeted waste from approximately 2.8 acres (47,600 cubic yards) of the Subsurface Disposal Area Remediate 118 contaminated environmental sitesClose 68 hazardous waste tank systemsClose 550 unnecessary monitoring wellsConduct sitewide groundwater monitoring
Waste exhumation at Accelerated Retrieval Project
E102
0030
20BD
S
14
Facility D&D
ScopeDemolish or otherwise disposition facilities and structures• 73 industrial• 22 radiological (moderately
contaminated)• 25 nuclear facilities (reactor
vessels, spent nuclear fuel basins, fuel reprocessing and handling facilities)
• 115 other structures
Crews prepare PBF reactor heat exchanger for loading and transportation to the Idaho CERCLA Disposal Facility
E102
0030
20BD
S
15
Tank Farm ClosureBackground
Located at the Idaho Nuclear Technology and Engineering Center (INTEC)15 tanks used to store radioactive liquid waste generated during the reprocessing of spent nuclear fuel and plant decommissioning workOnly four 300,000-gallon tanks currently being used for waste storage (awaiting treatment)
Tank Farm construction
(interior)
E102
0030
20BD
S
16
Layout
11 underground, 300,000-gallon stainless steel tanks• Eight tanks constructed with cooling coils inside to remove radioactive decay heat
from highly radioactive wastes• Three tanks without cooling coils• Tanks are 50 feet in diameter
and ~ 25 feet tall• Each tank has ~ three riser
locations available to deploy cleaning equipment –12 inches in diameter
• Each 300,000-gallon tank is surrounded by a concrete vault for secondary containment
Four smaller, 30,000-gallon stainless steel tanks also used for storage (taken out of service in the early 1980s)
VES-WM-103
VES-WM-104 VES-WM-105
VES-WM-106
182 183185 186
187 189190
188
184181
180
Tank Farm Facility
E102
0030
20BD
S
19
WM-103 - 106
WM-182
WM-180 WM-181
WM-183 WM-185 WM-186
WM-184
WM-187
WM-188 WM-190
WM-189
Operational Tanks (not yet cleaned)
2,394 Ci 1,363 Ci 1,391 Ci
1,047 Ci 475 Ci 1,077 Ci
646 Ci
144 Ci
*Cs-137/Ba-137 accounts for ~95% of total activity
Residual Inventory in Cleaned Tank Farm Facility Tanks (curies*)
E102
0030
20BD
S
20
Engineered Pour
Tank and Vault
Domes
Ris
ers
Ris
ers
Ris
ers
Piping
Ris
ers
Tank and Vault Layers
E102
0030
20BD
S
22
Closure Status
Seven large (300,000 gallon) tanks and four small (30,000 gallon) tanks cleaned/sampled 2002-2005“Authorization Basis” documents (3116, Record of Decision, DOE Closure Plans) approved November 2006Three small tanks grouted in November 2006 prior to winter shutdownFourth small tank and seven large tanks and vaults grouted (> 24,000 cubic yards)
Grouting of WM-184 (August 2007)
E102
0030
20BD
S
23
Treatment Status
Integrated Waste Treatment Unit solidifies waste using steam reforming processRobust design confirmed to be bounding for all reasonable seismic assumptionsConstructed weather enclosure – enabling work to continue through winterCompleted concrete pour for the Process and Packaging Cells base slabCompleted fabrication of the Waste Feed Tank skid and Denitration Mineralization Reformer process gas filter vessel heads
IWTU construction
E102
0030
20BD
S
24
Challenges
Defining cleaning/closure criteriaChanges in project approval processLimited tank access Operational closureWeather
E102
0030
20BD
S
25
Buried WasteRadioactive Waste Management Complex
Radioactive Waste Management Complex
E102
0030
20BD
S
26
Buried WasteBackground
Disposal site established in 1952; now occupies 97 acres within the fence boundary with waste occupying ~35 acresAccepted waste from Rocky Flats, INL operations, and other generatorsDisposal of transuranic waste discontinued in 1970 in favor of retrievable storage Federal Facility Agreement and Consent Order established in 1991Demonstration of waste retrieval in Pit 9 February 2004 Accelerated Retrieval Project began waste exhumation in Pit 4 January 2005Proposed Plan for remediation of the site issued October 2007
E102
0030
20BD
S
30
Proposed Plan – Preferred Alternative
Retrieving targeted waste from pit areas totaling 4.8 acres – including the 0.8 acres currently underwayIn situ grouting soil vaults and trench areas totaling 0.2 acres to reduce mobility of technetium-99 and iodine-129Vadose zone vapor vacuum extraction and treatment to remove and destroy solvent vaporsEvapotranspiration surface barrierLong-term institutional controlsEstimated cost is approximately $1,072 M (FY06 dollars)18 years to complete
E102
0030
20BD
S
31
Remote-handled Transuranic WasteBackground
Site began providing interim storage of RH TRU waste in 1976 Waste originally stored in underground storage vaults located at the Intermediate Level Transuranic Storage Facility within the facility boundary of the RWMC • Constructed in 1976 for the purpose of providing a location for intermediate storage
prior to ultimate dispositionConsists of 256 below-grade steel vaults that can store between 5 and 11 drums each
RH TRU drum retrieval from Intermediate Level Transuranic Storage Facility
E102
0030
20BD
S
32
Inventory
Characteristics
Generating Source Storage Configuration
Quantity (drums)
Form
Argonne National Lab – East 30 gallon drum 617 Debris
Naval Reactors Facility 30 gallon drum 27 Debris
Idaho Nuclear Technology and Engineering Center
30 gallon drum 2 Debris
Materials and Fuels Complex (formerly ANL - West)
55 gallon drum 4 Debris
Reactor Technology Complex (formerly Test Reactor Area)
55 gallon drum 25 10 Homogeneous Solid, 15 Debris
E102
0030
20BD
S
33
Strategy
Use of integrated project team and earned value management system processEliminate plans for a site specific certification program by using the certification authority of the Central Characterization Project (CCP)Perform drum venting operations using a vendor developed systemComplete retrieval and transfer of stored RH TRU waste from vaults at the RWMC to storage areas at INTEC using shielded overpacks specifically fabricated for ICP useModify an existing shielded facility to accommodate a real-time radiography system and dose-to-curie measurement equipmentModify an existing shielded facility to provide RH 72B cask loading capability including canister loading and lag storage rack; cask loading platform; and cask/trailer loading capability
E102
0030
20BD
S
34
Status
On January 18, 2007, shipped first RH-TRU shipment to WIPPOn January 3, 2008, shipped 100th RH-TRU shipment to WIPP
First RH shipment leaves Idaho
100th RH shipment leaves Idaho
E102
0030
20BD
S
35
Challenges
Collection of acceptable knowledge for remaining waste streamsCompetition for CCP resources now needed at other DOE sitesRetaining trained and qualified staff in “project” environmentUnvented containers
Container side venting system
E102
0030
20BD
S
36
Demolition/DispositionBackground
Demolish or otherwise disposition facilities and structures• 235 facilities/structures• 79 highly contaminated/nuclear facilities• 3 nuclear reactors• 34 hot cells (Test Area North and INTEC)• 60,000 square foot hot shop• 1,827,581 total square feet of facilities/
structuresHistorically significant propertiesDetermine end states for high risk facilitiesSequence D&D around other mission activities (cleanup vs. closure)Negotiating decommissioning end states that balance environmental protection with worker safety
Engineering Test Reactor vessel installation (1956)
E102
0030
20BD
S
37
Accomplishments
Regulatory strategy• Partnered with DOE and regulatory agencies to determine end states and accelerate
regulatory documents
1
TAN-607 Hot Shop
EE/CA and Action Memo
PBFEE/CA and
Action Memo
LOFTEE/CA and
Action Memo
TAN-607AEE/CA and Action
Memo
General D&D
EE/CA and Action Memo
ETREE/CA and Action Memo
FY06 FY07 FY08
CPP-601/640EE/CA and Action Memo
CPP-603A BasinEE/CA and Action Memo
MTREE/CA and Action Memo
E102
0030
20BD
S
38
Accomplishments
Demolished 78 facilities and structuresNear completion of Engineering Test Reactor complex and Test Area NorthSubmitted Engineering Evaluation/Cost Analysis (EE/CA) for CPP-601 and CPP-640; public comment period ended February 15, 2008
Loss of Fluid Test Reactor
Before After
E102
0030
20BD
S
39
Engineering Test Reactor
Before
Building structure demolished
Reactor vessel removed Vessel en route to disposal facility
E102
0030
20BD
S
41
Challenges
Maintaining resources in cleanup/closure environmentDemolition of Materials Test Reactor adjacent to operating facility (Advanced Test Reactor)Maintaining stable and predictable funding levelsPerforming D&D operations in high rad environments (hot cells and reactors)
E102
0030
20BD
S
42
Project Look Ahead
Nuclear material• Identify disposition paths for all contract-
identified special nuclear material at Reactor Technology Complex by March 31
• Continue ULWBR shipments to Nevada Test Site
Spent nuclear fuel• Continue wet to dry fuel transfers• Unload Advanced Test Reactor fuels• Prepare Navy fuel for shipment
Sodium-bearing waste• Continue construction• Fabricate process vessel and skids
Tank farm• Complete grout work by end of July (excluding
sodium-bearing waste tanks) • Remove tents and turn over west side of the
tank farm to D&D by the end of FY08• Finalize documentation for RCRA closure
of tanks
Waste management• Complete remote-handled transuranic
shipments by December 2008• Continue contact-handled transuranic
shipments • Complete Class B/C Legacy Waste disposal
activitiesEnvironmental restoration
• Complete draft Record of Decision for buried waste
• Remove SFE-106 tank and transport to waste repository for grouting and disposal
Facility D&D• Complete closure of Test Area North and
transfer resources to INTEC• Complete Engineering Test Reactor complex• Complete Power Burst Reactor isolation,
removal, and disposal
E102
0030
20BD
S
43
Summary
ICP performance in• Safety• Risk reduction/protection of the Snake River Plain Aquifer• Delivering what we promised (and more)• Partnering with stakeholders from special interest groups to regulators• Corporate citizenship
will enable our success and support INL’s goal for nuclear energy leadership