eng draft proposal idd-final

Upload: kotopa-bobii

Post on 06-Apr-2018

231 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    1/33

    Iodine Deficiency Disorders among Children in

    Different Agroecological Zones: Study on FoodAvailability, Food Consumption, Socio-cultural

    Aspects, and Academic Achievement

    PROPOSAL

    Researchers:

    Leily Amalia, STP, MSiHadi Riyadi, Ph.D.

    Tin Herawati, SP, MSi

    Reisi Nurdiani, SP, M.Si

    Faculty of Human Ecology

    Bogor Agricultural University

    Darmaga, Bogor 16680, IndonesiaEmail: [email protected]

    June 2011

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    2/33

    DESCRIPTION

    Title : Iodine Deficiency Disorders among Children in Different

    Agroecological Zones: Study on Food Availability, FoodConsumption, Socio-cultural Aspects, and AcademicAchievement

    Researchers : Leily Amalia, STP, M.SiHadi Riyadi, Ph.D

    Tin Herawati, M.SiReisi Nurdiani, SP, M.Si

    Bank Account Number : 0174760723 (Leily Amalia, BNI Syariah,Bogor).

    Bank Swift Code : BNINIDJA

    Institution Address: Faculty of Human EcologyBogor Agricultural UniversityDarmaga, Bogor 16680West Java, Indonesia

    Phone : 62-8129265531

    Email : [email protected]

    Proposed Budget :

    Bogor, May 2011Principal Investigator,

    Leily Amalia, STP, MSi

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    3/33

    LIST OF CONTENTS

    Pag

    e

    SUMMARY ............................................................................................ 4

    INTRODUCTION.................................................................................... 6

    OBJECTIVES..........................................................................................

    10

    CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK..................................................................

    11

    METHODS.............................................................................................

    14

    Design...........................................................................................

    14

    Sampling.......................................................................................

    14

    Data Collection..............................................................................

    15

    RESEARCH AREA..................................................................................

    17

    DATA ANALYSIS AND MANAGEMENT....................................................

    17

    Data Limitation.............................................................................

    18

    RELEVANCE OF RESEARCH...................................................................

    18

    DISSEMINATION AND UTILIZATION OF THE RESEARCH .......................

    19

    TIME SCHEDULE...................................................................................20

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    4/33

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    5/33

    SUMMARY

    Iodine Deficiency Disorders (IDD) is one of four main nutritional

    problems besides energy protein malnutrition (EPM), iron deficiencyanemia (IDA), and vitamin A deficiency (VAD). The consequences of

    iodine deficiency include goiter, reduced mental function, delayed

    motor development, growth failure and stunting, neuromuscular

    disorders, and speech and hearing defects (ACC/SCN, 1992). Iodine

    deficiency exists in most regions in the world, resulting from a low

    intake of iodine in the diet, and commonly come from mountainous

    areas with the soil, water and plants which contain less iodine. Theproblem arises when people live in an environment with soil lack of

    iodine, either due to the flood of river valleys or by high rainfall or

    glaciations in hilly mountainous areas. The deficiency in the soil leads

    to deficiency in all forms of plant life including cereals, vegetables,

    and fruits grown in the soil (Hetzel, 1989). According to Harahap

    (2004), the other cause of iodine deficiency is due to several kinds of

    foods consumed in the developing countries which contain agoitrogenic substance which inhibits the iodine absorption by thyroid.

    The goitrogenic substance can be found in some kinds of foods, such

    as cassava, vegetables belonging to various kinds of cabbages.

    In regard to that consequences, it is necessary to conduct a

    study to identify IDD among the people and the school children. This

    study is aimed 1) to analyze incidence of IDD among the school

    children, 2) to identify food availability in different agro ecological

    zones, 3) to analyze food consumption of the children suffered from

    IDD, 4) to identify iodine-rich foods and goitrogenic food consumption

    among the children with IDD, 5) to analyze the iodine content of salt

    consumed by the households in study areas. 6) to analyze coverage

    of iodized salt consumption, 7) to analyze impacts of IDD on academic

    achievement among school children, and 8) to identify socio-cultural

    aspects as determinant factors of IDD.

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    6/33

    Attention to school children needs emphasizing as school

    children are still in a growth phase and badly need a good

    intelligence, and who are easily affected by the iodine status in their

    body. The problem of IDD is primarily caused by the low iodine

    consumption and/or the high goitrogenik food consumption. The

    results of riskesdas-- a basic health research (Kemenkes, 2008)

    showed that there was only 62.3% of the households consuming

    iodized salt. Because of that, the iodized salt consumption is one of

    the main channels which is able tobe utilized to overcome the IDD

    problem. In connection with the iodized salt, the living location also

    has a relatively significant influence. Many of the people who live in

    coastal areas do not consume iodized salt due to the spread of the

    people non-iodized salt. On the other hand, the people who live in

    mountainous areas generally only rely on the salt that comes to the

    local areas. The salt that is distributed in the mountainous areas

    commonly contains iodine, however the peoples access to the salt

    often becomes the obstacle.

    To achieve the objectives, a cross-sectional design will be

    applied in this study. The location of this study will be selected

    purposively based on the households which consume iodized salt at a

    relatively low level, namely District of Karawang (33.9%) and Cianjur

    (47.2%), as compared to national level which was 62.3% (Riskesdas

    2007). District of Karawang represents coastal areas and Cianjur

    represents high land areas. The study will be conducted in 2011-

    2012.

    The population and sample in this study are mothers and school

    children, especially grade 4-5. The samples are selected based on

    their vulnerability on the effect of IDD. The total number of children

    who become the samples of this study is 300, 150 children coming

    from three sub-districts in Karawang District and the other 150

    coming from three sub-districts of Cianjur District.

    The collected data are comprised of secondary data and

    primary data. The secondary data consist of data of the areas, while

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    7/33

    the primary data consist of characteristics of the sampled households,

    anthropometry and the iodine status of the samples as well as the

    food consumption, iodine-source foods and goitrogenic foods.

    An interview will be performed towards the mothers to obtain

    data on the households socio-economy including parents education,

    households income, and mothers KAP (knowledge, attitude,

    practice). Whereas, the children will be measured to get

    anthropometric data, and they will also be interviewed to find out

    their consumption of iodine-source foods and goitrogenic foods.

    Besides that, an analysis of iodine levels of the salt, soil and water in

    the research site will be carried out.

    Data collection will be conducted by enumerators. The criteria

    of the enumerators in this research are graduates having background

    in nutrition or public health. Before collecting data, they are informed

    on the purpose and scope of this research, length of survey, sampling

    technique, methods of data collection, and load of works. The

    enumerators will be trained how to complete fill-in forms and

    questionnaire, how to use a guideline for data collection, and

    interview technique.

    To ensure the success of the data collection process,

    supervision is conducted by the research team, so that any possible

    problems can be solved immediately during the process of data

    collection by enumerators. Besides, to ensure the data quality in the

    study , some steps of data management will be taken, consists of data

    cleaning, data processing, and data analysis.

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    8/33

    INTRODUCTION

    The national development which is being carried out by theIndonesian government is actually an attempt to increase the

    peoples prosperity in order to achieve the national goal, that is,

    prosperity for the entire nation. Likewise, in other developing

    countries, in Indonesia malnutrition is still the main problem that

    affects the health status of the people. The low nutritional status

    influences the quality of the human resources, either growth,

    intelligence, invulnerability to diseases, infant mortality, mothermortality, or working productivity.

    For the time being in Indonesia there are four main nutritional

    problems, namely, energy protein malnutrition (EPM), iron anemia

    (IA),vitamin A deficiency, and some disorders due to Iodine Deficiency

    (IDD-- Iodine Deficiency Disorders). Of the 20 millions of the total

    Indonesian people who suffer from IDD, it is estimated that the

    potential of IQ loss is equal to140 millions IQ pints (RAN KPP GAKY,2004). If these nutritional problems are not promptly overcome, the

    Indonesian people will suffer from the decrease of capability

    (academic matters as well as the working productivity).

    Iodine deficiency exists in most regions in the world, resulting

    from a low intake of iodine in the diet. The consequences of iodine

    deficiency include goiter, reduced mental function, increased rates of

    still births and abortions, and infant death. Severe mental andneurological impairment known as cretinism occurs in babies with

    severely iodine deficient mothers. Deficiency in iodine later in infancy

    and childhood causes mental retardation, delayed motor

    development, growth failure and stunting, neuromuscular disorders,

    and speech and hearing defects. Mild deficiency can cause lethargy,

    and this is reversible when iodine status improves, as is goiter

    (ACC/SCN, 1992).

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    9/33

    The sufferers of IDD commonly come from mountainous areas

    with the soil, water and plants which contain less iodine. The problem

    arises when people live in an environment whose soil has been lack of

    iodine, either due to the flood of river valleys or by high rainfall or

    glaciations in hilly mountainous areas. The deficiency in the soil leads

    to deficiency in all forms of plant life including cereals, vegetables,

    and fruits grown in the soil (Hetzel, 1989). The iodine content in the

    nature, which has been eliminated, cannot be replaced anymore. As a

    result, the people who live in the area will suffer from iodine

    deficiency.

    According to Harahap (2004), the other cause of iodine

    deficiency is due to several kinds of foods consumed in the

    developing countries which contain a goitrogenic substance which

    inhibits the iodine absorption by thyroid. The goitrogenic substance

    can be found in some kinds of foods, such as cassava, vegetables

    belonging to various kinds of cabbages. In Sarawak (Malaysia), the

    consumption of cassava was found to be correlated with goiter and

    cretin prevalence.

    Iodine is required for the synthesis of thyroid hormones which in

    turn are needed for the regulation of metabolic activities of all cells

    throughout the life cycle. They are also required to ensure normal

    growth, especially of the brain, which occurs from fetal life to the end

    of the third postnatal year (Delange, 1994).

    The prevalence of IDD was approximately 30% in 1980, and

    nationally it decreased to be 9.8% in 1998. However, the prevalence

    in some provinces was still high, for instance, in NTT 38.1%, Maluku

    33.3%, Sulawesi Tenggara 24.9%, and Sumatra Barat 20.5%.

    Provinces of NTT and Maluku were categorized to have a moderate

    IDD problem, while the other provinces belonged to have slight IDD or

    not to have any problem of IDD (Direktorat Gizi Masyarakat, 2003).

    As a whole the result report of a mapping survey of goiter in

    1998 which was published by WHO in 2000 showed that 18.8% of the

    Indonesian people lived in slightly endemic areas, 4.2% of the people

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    10/33

    lived in moderately endemic areas, and 4.5% of the people lived in

    severely endemic areas. It was also estimated that about 18.2

    millions of the people lived in moderately and severely endemic

    areas; and 39.2 millions of the people lived in slightly endemic areas.

    The IDD prevalence among the school-age children was 27.7%

    in 1980. This prevalence decreased to be 9.8% in 1998. Although

    there was a significant drop, IDD was still considered as the societys

    health problem, because in general the prevalence was still above

    5%. The prevalence varied from one sub-district to another sub-

    district, and it was still encountered sub-districts with the IDD

    prevalence of over 30% (severly endemic areas). From the results of

    a national survey conducted in 2003, it was known that in general the

    TGR (Total Goiter Rate) of the school children was still around 11.1%.

    The national survey showed that 35.8% of the districts in Indonesia

    was slightly endemic, 13.1% of the districts was moderately endemic,

    and 8,2% of the districts was severly endemic (RAN KPP GAKY, 2004).

    Rencana Aksi Nasional (RAN) Kesinambungan Program

    Penanggulangan GAKY 2005-2010 (a national plan to cope with IDD)

    states that the indicators used to monitor and evaluate IDD are the

    household consumption of iodized salt and the median of the people

    EIU as much as 100-299 g/L, whereas TGR is not applied anymore

    due to its low sensitiveness and specivity as well as the change of

    TGR occurance requiring a long time.

    In 2005, the nutritional program which was implemented by the

    government has several objectives. Firstly, it is to reduce the

    prevalence of poor nutrition among children under five, that is, to be

    20%. Secondly, it is to reduce the prevalence of iodine deficiency

    disorders (IDD) among children to be 5%. Thirdly, it is to reduce iron

    anemia among the pregnant women to be 40%. Fourthly, there is no

    more vitamin A clinical deficiency found among children under five

    and pregnant women. Fifthly, it is to increase the number of

    households consuming iodized salt to be 90 %. Finally, it is to achieve

    the balanced-nutrittion consumption with the average energy

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    11/33

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    12/33

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    13/33

    CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK

    Indonesia is an archipelago country with physical conditions of

    the territory which is greatly varied, either its climate, rainfall,humidity, slope, or height from the surface of the sea. The diversity

    makes Indonesia possess various types of soil with different fertility

    levels as well as different physical characteristics of the soil.

    According to Pusat Penelitian Tanah dan Agroklimat Bogor (a reseach

    centre of soil and agroclimate) in Bogor in Resosoedarmo et al.

    (1993), the different physical conditions will yield a diversity of

    agroecological zones in every area. Slamet (1989) stated that thedifferent agroecological zone among areas may affect the patterns of

    land use, the system of farm operation implemented, ans the farmers

    preference towards the kind of plant that will be cultivated. This will

    influence the number and and types of foods available in the area.

    Suhardjo (1989) also stated that the different geography and

    topography can give a specific characteristics to the food product

    yielded. Therefore, the food consumption patterns in an area usually

    developed from the local foods or from foods which have been in the

    area for a long time.

    Food consumption is not a problem which stands alone but it is

    a part of a system which is determined by several intertwined factors.

    Sanjur (1982) states that in addition to the local food availability and

    the socio-culture, food consumption is also related with the

    households socio-economic characteristics, such as, the education

    level, income, and the number of the household members. The low

    income is another barrier which makes people unable to purchase

    food in an appropriate amount. Accordingly, income is the

    indispensable determinant correlated with the quality of food

    consumption.

    The formal education level of housewives is positively

    correlated with the improvement of the households food

    consumption pattern and the pattern of feeding their children.The

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    14/33

    education level will influence the consumption through food choice.

    People who are more educated tend to select better foods in terms of

    number and quality compared to those who have a lower education

    level (Moehdji, 1986).

    The number of the household members will affect food

    consumption. A variety of research results show that there is a very

    significant correlation between the size of households and the

    prevalence of malnutrition. The increasingly-greater number of the

    household members without any adequate income for them will lead

    to an increasingly imbalanced food distribution.

    Kinds and amount of the food consumed will affect the required

    nutrition adequacy. If the kinds and amount of food consumption are

    not sufficient, the nutrition need will not be fulfilled so this will trigger

    a health problem. IDD (Iodine Deficiency Disorders) is still a health

    problem in Indonesia which requires a serious attention and handling.

    According to Adriani (2002) Iodine Deficiency Disorders (IDD) is

    caused by a lack of iodine intake, the excessive goitrogenic food

    consumption, and a food consumption pattern which is of low protein.

    The lack of protein intake and the existence of goitrogenic in a food

    will cause a disorder of taking iodine by thyroid glands. Protein

    (albumin, globulin and prealbumin) is a means of transportation of

    thyroid hormones.

    Hetzel (1989) states that the low iodine intake of an individual

    or a group of people in a population is affected by the geographic

    condition. The IDD sufferers are found more in the upland than in the

    lowland. Water and soil in the upland contain lower iodine compared

    to that in the lowland.

    A study conducted by Prihartini (2001) towards the elementary

    school children in an endemic area of IDD found that the average

    iodine level of the childrens urine with a good nutritional status was

    higher or there was a significant difference compared to those with a

    low nutritional status. According to Djokomoeljantio (1997) people

    with a low or poor nutritional status will be at risk in the biosynthesis

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    15/33

    of thyroid hormones due to the lack of thyroxin binding protein (TBP)

    so the synthesis of thyroid hormones will be less. This is in line with

    Oenzils opinion (1996) that the number of iodine stores in every

    individual body will be different in accordance with his/her nutritional

    status condition.

    The effect of IDD is not only the enlargement of thyroid gland

    but it can result in a severer condition, that is, the decrease of ones

    IQ level which is started since one is still a fetus untill an adult. The

    younger one suffers from IDD, the severer the result will be,

    especially on the structure of the central nerve. The damage of the

    brain nerve will lead to the low IQ (intelligent quotient) score of the

    IDD sufferers. Every goiter sufferer experienced a five-point deficit of

    IQ, every cretin sufferer experienced a 50-point deficit of IQ, every

    IDD sufferer of non-goiter and non cretin experienced a 10-point

    deficit of IQ, and babies born in an area with an IDD risk would

    experience a ten-point deficit of IQ (Syahbudin, 2002).

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    16/33

    Figure 1. Conceptual Framework

    1

    FoodProductio

    n

    Food Availability Plants Animal Fish

    Socio-economic Characteristics of Household

    - Parents Education- Parents Occupation- Households income- Household Size- Mothers Nutritional Knowledge,

    Agro-ecologicalZone:

    Highland andLowland/ Coastal

    - Climate- Rain- Humidity-

    Food Consumption Dietary recall Food

    Cultural Aspects- Food Taboo- Food Priority- Food Preference- Iodine rich food

    Iodine DeficiencyDisorders (IDD)among schoolchildren

    Low academic

    - Low Iodine rich-foods- High goitrogenic rich-

    foods- Low iodized salt

    content- Low Iodized salt

    Iodine content Soil Water

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    17/33

    METHOD

    Design To achieve the objectives, a cross-sectional design will be applied in

    this study. The location of this study will be selected purposively based onthe households which consume iodized salt at a relatively low level, namely

    District of Karawang (33.9%) and Cianjur (47.2%), as compared to national

    level which was 62.3% (Riskesdas 2007). District of Karawang represents

    coastal areas and Cianjur represents high land areas. The study will be

    conducted in 2011-2012.

    Sampling

    The population and sample in this study are mothers and school

    children, especially grade 4-5. The samples are selected based on their

    vulnerability on the effect of IDD.

    Where :

    Z (1-/2) = Significance level at 95% (=0.05) = 1,96

    P = prevalece of low iodized salt consumption in the area, namely33.9% in Karawang and 47.2% in Cianjur (Riskesdas 2007).

    d = desired absolut precision (0,08)

    With significance level at 95% (=0.05), prevalence of iodized salt

    consumption in Karawang of 33.9%, and desired absolute precision of 0.08,

    the minimum sample required is 134; whereas with prevalence of iodized

    salt consumption in Cianjur of 47%, the minimum sample required is 149.5.

    Based on the formula and calculation above, the number of children

    who become samples of this study is each area (Karawang and Cianjur

    Districts) is rounded to be 150, so that the total sample is 300. From each of

    17

    n = Z 2 (1-/2) P(1-P)

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    18/33

    the sub-districts will be taken two elementary schools, and from each school,

    25 children will be drawn randomly (See the chart below).

    ES = Elementary School

    Figure 2. Sampling Technique

    Data Collection The collected data are comprised of secondary data and primary data.

    The secondary data consist of data of the areas, while the primary data

    consist of characteristics of the sampled households, anthropometry and the

    iodine status of the samples as well as the food consumption, iodine-source

    foods and goitrogenic foods. Kinds and methods of data collections are

    displayed in Table 1.

    Table 1. Samples, types of variables and methods of collection

    Samples Variables Method of CollectionMothers

    Socio-economic Characteristics Parents education Parents occupation

    Interview

    18

    Agroecological Zones

    Coastal Area

    Karawang District

    Sub-district 4 Sub-district5

    Sub-district6

    ES 7 ES 8 ES 9 ES 12ES 11

    @25 children, total 150 children

    High land Area

    Cianjur District

    Sub-district1 Sub-district 2 Sub-district3

    ES 1 ES 5ES 4ES 3ES 2

    @25 children, total 150 children

    ES 6 ES10

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    19/33

    Samples Variables Method of Collection Households income Household size Nutrition knowledge, attitude and

    practice (KAP) of motherCultural characteristics Food Taboo Food Priority Food Preference Iodine rich food perception

    Interview

    Elementary Schoolchildren

    Anthropometric Age Sex Weight Height

    Interview measuremen

    t

    Iodine status UIE (Urinary Iodine Excretion) Urine sampleFood consumption Nutrient Intake Consumption of iodine rich foods Consumption of goitrogenic rich

    foods

    Interview byrecall & foodfrequencyquestionnaireSalt consumption

    Iodized salt Non-iodized salt

    Salt Iodine content (qualitative andquantitatively) from households Iodized salt coverage

    Iodine testtitration

    Environment Iodine level of local soil Iodine level of local water

    Iodine analysis

    Food Production/Availability Cereals Horticulture Animal Fish

    Secondary data

    Agro-ecologycharacteristics

    Climate Altitude

    Rain Humidity

    Secondary data

    An interview will be performed towards the sampled mothers to obtain

    data on the households socio-economy including parents education,

    19

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    20/33

    households income, and mothers KAP (knowledge, attitude, practice) ibu.

    Whereas, the sampled children will be measured to get anthropometric data,

    and they will also be interviewed to find out their consumption of iodine-

    source foods and goitrogenic foods. Besides that, An analysis of iodine levels

    of the salt, soil and water in the research site will be carried out.

    Data collection will be conducted by enumerators. The criteria of the

    enumerators in this research are graduates having background in nutrition or

    public health. Before collecting data, they are informed on the purpose and

    scope of this research, length of survey, sampling technique, methods of

    data collection, and load of works. The enumerators will be trained how to

    complete fill-in forms and questionnaire, how to use a guideline for data

    collection, and interview technique.

    To ensure the quality of the data, supervision is conducted by the

    research team at the time of data collection in the fields, so that any possible

    problems can be solved immediately during the process of data collection by

    enumerators.

    Research Area

    This research will be conducted in two different types of agroecology,namely, Karawang District (representing the coastal areas) and Cianjur

    District (representing the upland/mountainous areas). The two different

    types of areas are necessary to be selected as the research sites considering

    that IDD prevalence may be highly correlated with the difference of

    agroecology. It is known that the iodine contents in food and water depend

    very much on the location of an area (coastal or moutainous). This will

    impact on the risk difference of the people to suffer from IDD. In addition,

    Karawang and Cianjur still have a problem concerning with the low caverage

    of iodized-salt consumption. The Indonesian government has socialized the

    use of iodized salt since a long time ago but the coverages among the areas

    are still varied enough.

    20

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    21/33

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    22/33

    Some data will be collected by a recalling technique, which could be a

    weakness of this study because ones remembering ability is relatively

    limited to recall all things. However, this method is the most practical to be

    operated in an on-field survey.

    22

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    23/33

    RELEVANCE OF RESEARCH

    Iodine Deficiency Disorders (IDD) is of public health concern

    throughout the world, including in Indonesia. WHO estimated that therewere in excess of 2.2 billion people from 130 countries at risk of IDD in the

    mid 90s. These countries include the most populous Bangladesh, Brazil,

    China, India, Indonesia and Nigeria (ICCIDD/WHO/UNICEF 1999). WHO,

    UNICEF and International Coordinating Committee on Iodine Deficiency

    Disorders (ICCIDD) also classified 191 countries into 68.1% having IDD

    problems, 10.5% having been able to cope with IDD problems, and the rest

    were not known their big problems of IDD. (Allen & Gillespie, 2001). In

    Indonesia, it was estimated 62.3 % of households using iodized salt

    (Kemenkes, 2008). There were variations in the prevalence among districts

    and provinces.

    Iodine deficiency in pregnancy and early life causes mental

    retardation, stunted growth, and other developmental abnormalities, which

    are largely irreversible. In later life it reduces intellectual performance,

    educational achievement and productivity, which can be improved with

    increased iodine intakes (SCN, 2011). Based on the evidence and lessons

    learned within the last decade, it appears that the most susceptible groups -

    pregnant and lactating women, and children less than two years of age -

    might not be adequately covered by iodized salt. This situation may

    jeopardize the optimal brain development of the fetus and young child

    (WHO, 2007).

    This research is indispensable to be conducted since it is able to reveal

    the IDD phenomena among children in different agro-ecologies. By focusingon the aspects of food availability, food consumption, coverage of iodized-

    salt consumption, as well as academic achievement of the children sufferers

    of IDD, this research will answer the IDD problems which at present still

    become one of the nutritional problems in Indonesia.

    23

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    24/33

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    25/33

    TIME OF SCHEDULE

    No. ActivitiesMonth

    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

    1. Survey of Study Sites x2. Survey Permit x3. Ethical Clearance x

    4. DevelopingQuestionnaires x

    5. Questionnaires Try Out x6. Revising Questionnaires x

    7. Training of the

    Interviewersx

    8. Data Collection x x x9. Writing Progress Report x

    10.

    Data Processing &Analysis:a. Data Entry and

    Cleaning x x x

    b. Data Analysis x x x13.

    Writing Draft of FinalReport x x

    14

    .Seminar x

    15. Final Report x X

    25

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    26/33

    PROPOSED BUDGET

    No Activities Unit Cost perunit (IDR)

    TotalCost(IDR)

    1 Preparation a. Survey of Study Sites

    * Karawang District- Meeting acommodation 2 days 500,000 1,000,000

    - Transport 2 packages 1,000,000 2,000,000 - Perdiem, 4 persons x 2 days 8 man-days 450,000 3,600,000 * Cianjur District

    - Meeting acommodation 2 days 500,000 1,000,000 - Transport 2 packages 1,000,000 2,000,000 - Perdiem, 4 persons x 2 days 8 man-days 450,000 3,600,000

    b. Survey Permit * Karawang District

    - Meeting acommodation 2 days 500,000 1,000,000 - Transport 2 packages 1,000,000 2,000,000 - Perdiem, 4 persons x 2 days 8 man-days 450,000 3,600,000 * Cianjur District

    - Meeting acommodation 2 days 500,000 1,000,000 - Transport 2 packages 1,000,000 2,000,000 - Perdiem, 4 persons x 2 days 8 man-days 450,000 3,600,000

    c. Ethical Clearance 1 package 2,500,000 2,500,000d. Developing Questionaires

    - Perdiem, 4 persons x 5 days 20 man-days 450,000 9,000,000

    e. Questioner Try Out (byenumerators)

    - Transport 1 package 500,000 500,000 - Perdiem 4 man-days 200,000 800,000

    f. Training of the interviewers* Researcher

    - Perdiem, 4 persons x 1 day 4 man-days 450,000 1,800,000 * Interviewers

    - Perdiem, 4 persons x 1 day 4 man-days 200,000 800,000

    Sub Total 141,800,0

    002 Data Collection, 300 samples

    - Meeting acommodation 2 days 500,000 1,000,000

    * Field Survey (by 4enumerators)

    - Local transport (20 days x 4enums) 80 man-days 50,000 4,000,000

    - Perdiem (20 days x 4enumerators) 80 man-days 450,00036,000,00

    0

    26

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    27/33

    No Activities Unit Cost perunit (IDR)

    TotalCost(IDR)

    - Reward 300 respondents 40,000 12,000,00 0 - Transport Bogor-Karawang 2 packages 1,000,000 2,000,000 - Transport Bogor-Cianjur 2 packages 1,000,000 2,000,000

    * Iodine Analysis- Urine Iodine Excretion (UIE)

    analysis 300 respondent 40,00012,000,00

    0 - Test of iodine content in salt 300 samples 20,000 6,000,000 - Test of iodine content in water 30 samples 20,000 600,000 - Test of iodine content in soil 30 samples 20,000 600,000

    SubTotal 276,200,0

    003 Supervision a. * Karawang

    - Meeting acommodation 2 days 500,000 1,000,000

    - Transport 4 packages 1,000,000 4,000,000 - Perdiem, 4 persons x 4 days 16 man-days 450,000 7,200,000b. * Cianjur

    - Meeting acommodation 2 days 500,000 1,000,000 - Transport 4 packages 1,000,000 4,000,000 - Perdiem, 4 persons x 4 days 16 man-days 450,000 7,200,000

    SubTotal 324,400,0

    004 Data Analysis

    - Data Entry dan Data Cleaning 300 questionnaire 50,00015,000,00

    0

    - Data analysis 8 packages 4,500,000 36,000,00

    0 Sub Total4

    51,000,000

    5 Report WritingProgress report- Perdiem, 4 persons x 4 days 16 man-days 450,000 7,200,000

    Final report

    - Perdiem, 4 persons x 12 days 48 man-days 450,000 21,600,00 0

    Sub Total528,800,0

    00

    6 Seminar (participant : 25

    policy makers)

    * Karawang District- Meeting acommodation 2 days 500,000 1,000,000

    - Transport 2 packages 1,000,000 2,000,000 - Perdiem, 4 persons x 2 days 8 man-days 450,000 3,600,000

    - Accommodation forparticipants 25 man-days 200,000 5,000,000

    * Cianjur District- Meeting acommodation 2 days 500,000 1,000,000

    27

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    28/33

    No Activities Unit Cost perunit (IDR)

    TotalCost(IDR)

    - Transport 2 packages 1,000,000 2,000,000 - Perdiem, 4 persons x 2 days 8 man-days 450,000 3,600,000

    - Accommodation for

    participants 25 man-days 200,000 5,000,000 Sub Total6

    23,200,000

    7 Research Assistants, 1 x 12months 12 months 1,500,00018,000,00

    0

    Sub Total718,000,0

    00

    8 Research Consultant, 1 x 3months 3 months 7,000,00021,000,00

    0

    Sub Total821,000,0

    009 Administration

    - Stationery 1 package 9,000,000 9,000,000 - Institutional Fee 1 package 6,000,000 6,000,000

    Sub Total915,000,0

    00

    Total in IDR 299,400,000

    1 Euro = IDR 12,422, Total in Euro 24,102.4 0

    28

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    29/33

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    30/33

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    31/33

    necessary to have two times meetings to prepare all of the necessitiesrequired in the field.

    4. Data Analysis This stage includes data entry and cleaning as well as data analyses. Thecost of data entry and cleaning is Rp 50.000,-/questionnaire, whereas, forthe data analyses the costs are determined by the research objectives,and each of the research objectives requires Rp. 4.500.000,-.

    5. Report Writing The report writing for the progress report takes about four days, while forthe final report takes twelve days.

    6. Seminar

    A seminar will be held in each of the two districts as the researchlocations, and each seminar will be attended by 25 policy makers. Prior tothe seminars, the researchers need to have a two-day meeting for each of the seminars to prepare all of the necessities needed for the seminar. Theresearchers need two days to reach each of the locations and to hold theseminars. For the seminars, it is needed accommodations for theresearchers, banners, refreshments and meals, reimbursement of theparticipants transport expenses, and to rent seminar rooms. The total costis estimated to reach Rp.200.000/participants.

    7. Research assistantA research assistant is needed for administration work and helping theresearch operation. The researcher assistant will be hired for one year.

    8. Research ConsultantFor this research we need a consultant on food and nutrition to be hiredfor 3 months.

    9. Administration

    For the secretarial and administrative work, office equipment andstationery are required. As the members of the institution, the researchershave to allocate an institutional fee for the department and faculty.

    31

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    32/33

    BIBLIOGRAPHY

    ACC/SCN. 1992. Second Report on the World Nutrition Situation. Chapter 3:Micronutrients. Volume I. Global and Regional Results. Geneva.

    Adriani M. 2002. Pengaruh Suplementasi Yodium dan Yodium Selenium Terhadap Kadar T3, T4 dan Yodium Urin Pada Anak Sekolah DasarPujon Kidul, Kecamatan Pujon, Kabupaten Malang (Jawa Timur).Prosiding Kongres Nasional Persagi dan Temu Ilmiah XII tanggal 8-10

    Juli 2002. PERSAGI. Jakarta. Hal: 388.

    Allen LH and Gillespie SR. 2001. What works? A Review of the Efficacy andEffectiveness of Nutrition Intervention. United Nation AdministrativeCommittee on Coordination, Sub-Committee on Nutrition (ACC/SCN).Philippines. P43-54

    Arisman. 2002. Gizi Dalam Daur Kehidupan. Ilmu Gizi-Fakultas KedokteranUniversitas Sriwijaya. Palembang.

    Delange F. 1994. The Disorders Induced by Iodine Deficiency. Thyroid4(1):107-128.

    Direktorat Gizi Mayarakat. 2003. Gizi dalam Angka. Dirjen Binkesmas.Depkes RI. Jakarta.

    Djokomoeljanto R. 1997. Gangguan Akibat Defisiensi Yodium dan GondokEndemik. Ilmu Penyakit Dalam. FKUI. Jakarta.

    Harahap H. 2004. Masalah Gizi Mikro Utama dan Tumbuh Kembang Anak DiIndonesia. Makalah Pribadi Falsafah Sains. Sekolah Pasca Sarjana.Institut Pertanian Bogor.

    Hetzel BS. 1983. Iodine Deficiency Disorders (IDD) and their Eradication. Thelancet 2:1126-1129.

    Hetzel BS. 1989. The Story of Iodine Deficiency: an International Challenge inNutrition. Oxford University Press. Oxford and New Delhi.

    ICCIDD/WHO/UNICEF. 1999. Progress towards Elimination of IodineDeficiency Disorders. WHO/NHD/99.4.

    32

  • 8/3/2019 Eng Draft Proposal IDD-Final

    33/33

    Kodyat BA. 1992. Masalah yang Dihadapi dalam Penyelenggaran IntervensiGaram Fortifikasi dan Upaya Mengatasinya. PAU Pangan Dan Gizi IPB.

    Prihartini, dkk. 2001. Pengaruh Status Gizi terhadap kadar yodium urinsetelah pemberian kapsul minyak beryodium pada anak sekolah dasardi daerah gondok endemik. Laporan penelitian Litbang Depkes.(http:www.litbang.depkes.go.id).

    RAN KPP GAKY. 2004. Rencana Aksi Nasional Kesinambungan ProgramPenanggulangan Gaky. Sumber: http://www.gizi.net/gaky/exit%20gaky.pdf . [Diunduh: 20 des 2010].

    Resosoedarmo R, Kartawinata SK, dan Soegiarto A. 1993. Buku PengantarEkologi. PT. Remaja Rosdakarya. Bandung.

    Sanjur D. 1982. Social and Cultural Perspective in Nutrition. Prentice-Hall Inc.Englewood Cliffs. NJ

    SCN. 2011. Sixth report on the world nutrition situation : Progress inNutrition. United Nations System, Standing Committee on Nutrition.

    Slamet S.K. 1989. Dampak Perbedaan Zono Agroekosistem di Daerah SemiArid terhadap Pemilikan Aset Produksi Pertanian. Laporan Penelitian.Undana. Kupang

    Suhardjo. 1989. Sosio Budaya Gizi. PAU Pangan dan Gizi IPB. Bogor.Syahbudin S. 2002. GAKY dan Usia. Jurnal GAKY Indonesia. Vol I (1). hal 13

    Tim Penanggulangan GAKY Pusat. Rencana Aksi Nasional KesinambunganProgram Penanggulangan Gangguan Akibat Kekurangan Yodium.

    Jakarta. 2005.

    WHO. 1998. Physical Status : The Use and Interpretation of Antrophomentry.Report of a WHO Expert Committee. WHO Technical Report Series 854.WHO, Geneva.

    WHO/UNICEF. 2007. Reaching Optimal Iodine Nutrition in Pregnant andLactating Women and Young Children. Joint Statement by the WorldHealth Organization and the United Nations Childrens Fund.

    http://www.gizi.net/gaky/exit%20gaky.pdfhttp://www.gizi.net/gaky/exit%20gaky.pdfhttp://www.gizi.net/gaky/exit%20gaky.pdfhttp://www.gizi.net/gaky/exit%20gaky.pdf