Contact us :  PMR Project Management Unit (PMU) Wisma BSG  Jl. Abdul Muis No. 40 , 3A fl.  Jakarta 10160 P. +62 21 38900994 F. +62 21 21201769 www.pmr-indonesia.org

This meeting was opened by Mr. Dida Gardera, Deputy Assistant of

Environmental Conservation, CMEA - which then proceed with the

direction from Mr. Teddy C. Sianturi, Head of Green Industry

Research Center, MoF, as Coordinator of Industrial Working Group.

October 31, 2017 - In line with

the election of TUV Nord and

AMC as the implementing

consultant for the study of GHG

Emission Profile for industry

sectors, the Working Group for

Industry held an FGD to prepare

the workplan for 8 industry sub-

sectors involving members of the

Working Group and a team of

experts.

Kick-off Meeting – for Development of

GHG Emission Profile for Power

Generation and Energy Intensive

Industry 

Consolidation Meetings – for Development

of GHG Emission Profile for Power

Generation 

Preparation of GHG Emission on

Profiling  Activity for Energy-Intensive

Industry sector

Internal Coordination Meeting – for

Development of GHG Emission Profile

for Industry sector 

In This Edition : 

The 17th PMR Partnership Assembly

(PA) Meeting 

Focus Group Discussion –Working Plan

for Development of GHG Emission

Profile for Industry sector 

In their remarks, the two officials emphasized the importance of

setting appropriate strategies and approaches for the study –

knowing that collecting and processing of data from 8 different

sectors would not be an easy task.

Focus Group Discussion –Working Plan for

Development of GHG Emission Profile for

Industry sector 

2

The FGD was facilitated by experts and in-depth discuss

technical matters related:

• Industry distribution (type and location of industry)

• Identification of industrial scope in activities (> 6000 TOE)

• Identification of sources and emission uptake in industry

(based on emissions sources)

• Scope of emissions profile (direct and indirect)

• Identification of data availability and determination

of calculation methods

• Preparation of the workplan (Activities, Time and Location)

The one-day meeting was intended to: 1) Opening the engagement room of the members of the

Working Group on the preparation of the consultant's work plan; 2) Identify government and industry

needs in the implementation of GHG emission profile formulation; 3) Create a common understanding of

plans and workflow of GHG emission profile development activities in 8 industry sub-sectors;

4) Compile and agree on accelerated strategies and synchronize emission profile setting activities in

the consultant's workplan.

As a result of the meeting, it was agreed that the scope of activit ies for the development of

GHG emission profi le, emission basel ine and abatement cost-curve study would cover 8

industry sub-sectors: cement, fert i l izer, pulp and paper, food and beverages, steel,

petrochemical, and ceramics, by looking at al l sources of industrial GHG emissions (energy,

IPPU and waste). The eight industrial sub-sectors wil l use the same approach and start ing

point. Basel ine development wil l be conducted in each sub-sector with 2010 to 2016 data,

and using 2010 data as the base-year.

Development of Industrial Sector Emission Profile

The Working Group for Industry has held a series of meetings since Apri l 2017 which invited

the relevant technical directorates (from the Ministry of Industry) and industry associations.

The meeting began with presentation on

the preparation of the workplan by

consultants, followed by discussions in

groups of 8 industry sub-sectors, namely:

cement, ceramics and glass, steels,

fertilizers, chemicals, textiles, pulp and

paper, food and beverages.

At the end of the meeting, there were three decisions made by PA:

1. Allocation of Additional Implementation Phase Funding to Turkey

2. Third Allocation of Funding for Targeted Technical Support to Kazakhstan

3. Approve British Columbia, New Zealand, Cote d’Ivoire, Panama, and the Philippines as Technical

Partners of the PMR, with the understanding that British Columbia and New Zealand will not request

funding under Section 4.10 of the (amended) PMR Governance Framework

3

The 17th PMR Partnership Assembly (PA) Meeting

October 24, 2017 - The 17th Meeting of the Partnership

Assembly (PA17) was held in Tokyo, Japan, and was

accompanied by a technical workshop on Tuesday, October

24, followed by the three-day Partnership Assembly meeting,

and concluded with a public event on Friday, October 27, 2017.

The 17th Meeting of the Partnership Assembly was co-chaired

by Ms. Zeren Erik (Turkey) and Mr. Kazuhisa Koakutsu

(Japan). The meeting was attended also by Hon. Masaharu

Nakagawa, Minister of Environment of Japan, who also gave

his opening remarks, followed by Mr. Masato Miyazaki,

Representative from World Bank Office in Tokyo.

On the first session, Mr. Venkata Putti, from PMR Secretariat deliver PMR update and progress report.

Which then followed by a sharing session by PMR participants and observers on relevant policy

developments in their jurisdictions or areas of work. Mr. Juan Pedro Searle (Chile); Dr. Akio Takemoto

(Japan), and Mr. Darryl Chua (Singapore) were present in this day.

The 2nd day of the meeting, Sri Lanka submitted a draft Market Readiness Proposal (MRP), which was

presented in order to seek feedback from the PA. Representatives from the PMR Expert Group who

carried out the Expert Feedback Process also presented observations and suggestions. Based on

feedback received, Sri Lanka will revise its MRP and submit it for funding consideration at PA18.

British Columbia, New Zealand, Cote d’Ivore, Panama and the Philippines expressed interest to join the

PMR as Technical Partners. In this session, each country provided an update on recent experience with

market-based instruments as well as a proposal for engaging with the PMR for the PA’s feedback.

In this PA Meeting, Implementing Country Participants

also presented their Implementation Status Report (ISR)

to detail the progress made toward the implementation of

their MRPs, and shared their ISRs with the PA during the

“PMR Exchange Forum”. Brazil, Indonesia, Kazakhstan,

Mexico, Peru, South Africa, Thailand, and Ukraine were

presented in the forum.

4

Consolidation Meetings – for Development

of GHG Emission Profile for Power Generation

October 18, 2017 - Profiles of Indonesia’s GHG emission from energy sector,

including power sector, have been reported in several documents.

National and international institutions have actively supported the energy audits and related field works in

power sector, where important information regarding the energy saving measures, potential energy

saving and emission reductions, and abatement cost of mitigation action have been gathered.

For these reasons, and as a follow-up to the election of TUV Nord and AMC as consultants, the Working

Group for Power (under the coordination of the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources) held a technical

meeting as consolidation measures for the preparation of the study, by inviting all members of working group,

ministry/related institutions, PLN, and independent power producer associations and other related parties.

The meeting meeting was intended as a venue for introduction between the implementing consultants and the

Working Group of Power and other related stakeholders. In particular, the meeting also aims to:

• Identification of activity and time frames for the development of GHG

emission profiles in the power generation sector;

• Identification of the availability of activity data and emission factors used

in GHG emission profile activities in the power generation sector;

• Gap analysis between the current available data and the required data

• Preliminary discussions regarding the scope, limitations and methodologies

to be used in the calculation of GHG emissions in the power generation

sector.

• Development of workplan.

The meeting was led by Mr. Benhur L. Tobing, representing the Director of Engineering and Environment,

MEMR, and continued with a brief direction from Mr. Dida Gardera, Deputy Assistant for Environmental

Protection of CMEA.

Several resource persons were invited to from MEMR (Directorate General of Electricity, Data and

Information Center, and Research Center), to present on:

• an overview of emissions in Indonesia's power generation sector

• the status of GHG emissions at the national level in the power sector

• country and site-specific emission factors calculations for oil and coal

• GHG emission baseline calculation methodology in the power generation sector

Industry players (PT PLN, PT Indonesia Power, and PT PJB) were also invited to present and sharing their

experiences on:

• Identification emission factor and projecting the calculation of emission in RUPTL (Power Generation

Business Plan)

• Calculation of activity data and emission factors currently used by the plant and calculation of GHG

emission baseline in Suralaya and Muara Karang power plant units

5

In the last session, speakers from BPPT, DG EBTKE, and PT PLN, presented and discussed the potential of GHG

emission reduction from the power generation sector in Indonesia.

From this meeting, it was expected that the relevant

partners can understand the purpose of the GHG

emission profile, including understanding the

opportunities and costs of emission reduction in the

power plant sector.

Internal Coordination Meeting – for Development of GHG

Emission Profile for Industry sector 

October 19, 2017 - As a follow-up to the election of TUV Nord

and AMC as consultants, the Working Group for Industry (under

the coordination of the Ministry of Industry) held a technical

meeting as consolidation measures for the preparation of the

study, by inviting all members of working group, ministry/related

institutions, companies, and industry associations.

• Identification of activity and time frames for the development of GHG emission profiles in the industry sector;

• Identification of the availability of activity data and emission factors used in GHG emission profile activities

in the industry sector;

• Gap analysis between the current available data and the required data

• Preliminary discussions regarding the scope, limitations and methodologies to be used in the calculation of

GHG emissions in the industry sector.

• Development of workplan.

The meeting was opened by Mr. Teddy C. Sianturi, Head of IHLH - Ministry of Industry, as Coordinator of

Industrial Working Group, which emphasizes the importance of all parties' support for this study, so that the

quality of data and reports will have credibility for future reference for policy makers in the energy sector.

At the end of the meeting, it was also agreed on the need for a follow-up meeting with all representatives of 8

industry sub-sectors to obtain an overview of the status of each sub-sector, including the importance of

regular meetings in each industry sub-sector to monitor the progress. A follow-up meeting was agreed to be

held on October 31, 2017.

The meeting meeting was intended as a venue for introduction between the implementing consultants and the

Working Group of Industry and other related stakeholders. In particular, the meeting also aims to:

Overall, the discussions were successful in agreeing

on the following matters:

• Activity plan and a time frame for the development

of GHG emission profile for the power sector;

• Scope and methodologies to be used in the

calculation of GHG emissions in the power

generation sector;

• The consultant's workplan, and follow-up steps.

6

October 9, 2019 - A kick-off meeting was held in UNDP

Office, Jakarta on October 9, 2017, to begin the

implementation of the study on the development of GHG

emission profile in the power generation and energy

intensive industries.

Kick-off Meeting – for Development of GHG Emission Profile for Power

Generation and Energy Intensive Industry

The meeting was opened by Mr. Dida Gardera, Assistant Deputy of Environmental Conservation of (CMEA).

He presented a short summary of the project and stressed on the goals and timeline of delivery. In his closing

remarks, he expressed his high expectation on the quality and credibility of the study and hoped that it could

be implemented and completed on time.

The final deliverables of this assignment are:

1. Reports relating to GHG emission profiles from power generating sector and industrious energy sector with

scope of emission source originating from energy, IPPU and waste;

2. Reports related to the preparation of GHG emission baseline in each sub-sector;

3. Review the estimated potential GHG emission reduction and reduction costs of mitigation actions, including

a comprehensive marginal cost reduction curve. This study includes detailed and separate analysis for the

power sector and each of the eight energy sub sector industries.

In the meeting, the consulting firms introduced all the members of the consultant’s team and presented each

role in the study implementation. The consultant also presented their draft workplan, approach of the study,

the team arrangement, proposed modes of interaction and other issues.

He was aware that the collection and processing of data from 9 different sectors would not be an easy task.

Nevertheless, he said that the government, in this case the CMEA, MoI, and MEMR are fully supports and

committed to this activity. With the full support of the government and all actors in the power and industry

sectors, it is hoped that the implementation of the study can produce a credible and accountable report that

can be used as a reference for the government in the policy development later on.

During the meeting, representatives of the MEMER

and MoI also provided input and recommendations

for the implementation of activities by consultants,

including the proposed capacity building activities

for industry actors and associations in enhancing

their knowledge and understanding related to MRV

(monitoring-reporting and verification).

This was the first meeting held between selected firm (PT.

TUV NORD-AMC) with the project team and the

government stakeholders from the Coordinating Ministry

for Economic Affairs (CMEA), Ministry of Industry (MoI),

Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (MEMR).

October 03, 2017 - For the preparation of the study for GHG

inventory in the chemical industry, the Working Group for

Industry, together with the related units at the Ministry of

Industry held a Coordination meeting on 3-4 October 2017 at the

Ministry of Industry office, Jakarta.

The preparation meeting for the chemical industry discussed several agendas which include:

• Description of GHG inventory and mitigation actions in the chemical industry;

• Integration of online monitoring system of GHG emissions inventory to National Industry

Information System (SII-Nas);

• The workplan for GHG inventory program activity in the chemical industry.

Preparation Meeting – for Development

of GHG Emission Profile for Industry sector

The scope for the GHG emission profile and baseline development related to the chemical industry are

covering sources of emissions from energy and IPPU (industrial processes and product use), where the

national emission reduction target set for from IPPU is 1%.

7

• GHG emission profi les from the energy-savvy industrial sector with coverage of sources

of emissions originating from energy, IPPU and waste;

• Basel ine GHG emissions in each sub-sector;

• Assess the potential for GHG emission reduction and reduction costs from mit igation

actions, including a comprehensive marginal cost reduction curve.

• This review includes detai led and separate analyzes for the power sector and each of the

eight energy-hungry industry sub-sectors.

The expected output from the study on GHG emission profile for

power generation and industry sector will be implemented from

October until June 2018 (8 months), which includes:

Representatives from the Ministry of Environment and Forestry (MoEF), Coordinating Ministry of Economy

Affairs (CMEA), Ministry of Industry (Data and Information Center, Green Industry Research Center, and

Directorate of Chemical-Textile-and-Upstream-Chemical Industry), industry representatives and its

associations – were present and actively participate in the meeting.

The meeting was opened by Mr. Dida Gardera, Deputy Assistant for Environmental Conservation of

CMEA, who delivered a presentation on the scope of works of PMR which was then followed by technical

discussions.

The meeting continued on the second day, focusing on the Upstream Chemical Industry,

which specifically focused to the fertilizer and ammonia industry.

Partners

8

It was emerged from the discussion that most of

the player in the chemical industry do not have

sufficient capacity and knowledge related to

GHG inventory calculation and reporting. Hence

the development of emission profile and baseline

needs to be accompanied by capacity building

related to the calculation of GHG emission

(especially from energy use).

The activities will be carried-out by regional approach. Companies to be targeted are companies with the

character of energy consumption of more than 6000 TOE (tones of oil equivalent).

During the discussion, it is known that baseline data for upstream chemical industry is still lagging behind

and need updating for baseline determination. For this reason, data updating needs to be done to

complement the requirements for determining the fertilizer industry's emission baseline (which will be

splitted between IPPU and energy), and the development of MRV system for emissions.

This second day meeting was opened and moderated by Mr. Muhammad Khayam, Director of Upstream

Chemical Industry, Ministry of Industry, with Dr. Retno Gumilang Dewi as the expert facilitator.

Both activities will be conducted simultaneously and are planned to begin in November 2017. The

preparation of the workplan will be organized jointly by Directorate of Upstream Chemical Industry and

Green Industry Research Center in October 2017.

The study on the development of GHG emission profiles in the power generation and energy intensive

industries, was tendered and by end of September 2017, the tender committee announced PT. TUV NORD

in association with AMC (Asian Management Consulting) as selected firms that will carry out the work of

this study for 8 months duration (from October 2017 to June 2018).