emotions, media discourse and the mobilization of citizens. conceptual considerations and a...

Upload: transformeurope

Post on 08-Aug-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    1/33

    E, M D M CConceptual Consideraons and a Plausibility Probe

    M v S

    No. 16 | October 2010

    Working Paper

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    2/33

    2 | KFGWorking Paper No. 16 | October 2010

    KFG Working Paper Series

    Edited by the Kolleg-Forschergruppe T Tv Pw E

    T KFG W P S v Kolleg-Forschergruppe y

    v . I x w x

    x E E U.

    A KFG W P v KFG w www.. v

    -@-..

    Cy : M v S

    E : C B, J S

    v S, M 2010: E, M D M C: C C

    Py P, KFG W P S, N. 16, O 2010, K-F (KFG) T T-

    v Pw E, F Uv B.

    ISSN 1868-6834 (P)

    ISSN 1868-7601 (I)

    T y G R F (DFG).

    F Uv B

    K-F

    T Tv Pw E:

    T E U D I

    I. 26

    14195 B

    Gy

    P: +49 (0)30- 838 57033

    Fx: +49 (0)30- 838 57096-@-.

    www..

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    3/33

    Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens | 3

    Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of

    Citizens

    Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    M v Sg

    F Uv B

    Abstract

    T E U . Nwy, EU

    E , -w

    . C E y EU v

    EU vy w .

    S v v x w EU , y y

    . Sv v v w y v y y

    v E . Ay, EU

    - -

    . By w EU w v v

    E - w

    , v x w

    vy y v EU .

    I x y w y

    , ,

    E -. I v

    y- . M

    v y y

    y j y E , v EU .

    T Ar

    M v Sg - w R C T

    Tv Pw E.D KFG, e

    y EU. S

    E y . S PD

    E E Uvy I 2005. A

    w A P U Uvy E

    C y. C: .v@-.

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    4/33

    4 | KFGWorking Paper No. 16 | October 2010

    Contents

    1. T P E P 5

    2. T W Hw P: Dv A y PE 6

    3. A M D Iy I L

    P A 84. R D 13

    5. I V: M A Iy D 20

    6. T D V: P Bv C 25

    7. D M D w E C P Bv? 27

    8. C 28

    L 30

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    5/33

    Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of citizens | 5

    1. T P E P1

    T - C Ty B v

    E y . I v y

    E y w

    E . T y , wv, y . Oy

    C Ty, x, y D

    E T v w, D C. Mv, y

    B v2 E

    E , y v v, v

    w y R Ty. T v

    w EU vy w . T, E

    x v EU . T (

    , , v y v j) w E U w E -

    y . T -w - w

    v - EU -v v, j

    x. T w v w y

    wy v v v v. A

    w y

    .

    T y C Ty B v w y

    E , w

    w E . Ay, EU

    w E 1990. T EU w

    x E y w ( F/

    Hx 2006: 536 y). A Mv,

    w y EU, y x y v y (Mv 2002:

    615). M q

    1 T K-F (KFG) T Tv Pw E, F Uv B-

    , v y v w . T KFG y G R F (DFG)

    EU x . F , www...

    Ey, I w KFG J Fx v w

    . I v

    w , I w S A, Ev H, J

    D M, J H My, T Nj, Swj R, T R, Vv S,

    Medien und internaonale Beziehungen M 11-13 Fy 2010, , ,

    v y y vw.

    2 C B v w w E v . By -

    , w y v w y EU

    . C v W E w v y

    P w W E w y P F G .

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    6/33

    6 | KFGWorking Paper No. 16 | October 2010

    - w EU y v v E

    . My EU q w

    y y v v v.

    D jv , y wy: v EU

    -.

    T w C Ty

    B v y y w

    E EU . I v

    x w EU y v,

    w w y y w

    vv. C v y w

    , y y

    , , E - .

    T w w. F,

    vv E ( ) , , ,

    EU - . T

    . I v y

    . I w w w ,

    w v y . M y . T

    x w y y v

    v. Ey x y

    . W w y y

    v y . I , y

    , y w EU . T , E

    A v w H FP,

    y E 2000. T , C E E

    (CEEC) EU, w E ,

    y vv. T x

    E .

    2. T W Hw P: Dv A P

    E

    T E y w (H/

    M 2005; H 2007; M/W 2003). I M Ty v

    (H/M 2008). I y y

    y EU q (Hx 2005; M/W 2003). A

    w EU - (B 2005; F/Hx

    2006; M 2005; Mv 2006). P E y v y , y w E . B,

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    7/33

    Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of citizens | 7

    w E y -EU

    . V Ej F (2004) : v w

    . T w w. Ev M v EU v

    w y w -

    -.

    M v E

    . T B v w F N

    C Ty . O , v y y

    v EU, H Fy 2000. I w,

    v y x w E ,

    H x y. I w y y

    y -EU , v - y EU

    y . Uy y E , y y y v E w

    E . P v vy v

    (S 2010). Ev E w EU

    , w . W

    , w y

    (H/M 2008: 18). Hwv, H M y y. Ty

    (w y v y) w y

    y . T w. W

    w. W ? W w y w

    EU ?

    T y x . T y w w

    y , S (2008) . T w

    v y , y w w

    . B , ,

    v w w . Cv

    y (G 1992, K 2002) j, y y:

    w . I ,

    w (.. v ) v (.. ).W w EU y

    v vv w EU

    w w.

    M v . F,

    . W y , y

    (G 1992). T y (

    ) y y v

    - y, j y. I y y

    y / . M

    v

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    8/33

    8 | KFGWorking Paper No. 16 | October 2010

    v y. T,

    v v y . T w

    EU w y v y

    v y v (

    y ).

    S, y v. T

    v y , , . O ,

    v y y w . T

    w w v . D ,

    y y

    v . F

    v, y , v xy x w v

    . A w v v EU w

    . I ( y

    ) y

    y wy x. V x, y v

    ( w y

    ) v x . Mw,

    y y ( j y) w

    v x v (

    vv) , vy,

    w v .

    3. Ag M D I I Lk P A

    P y EU v . S

    E w EU

    EU , y (..

    Dj . 2003; E/K 2000; K/E 2004; V S/R2010; T/M

    2003; V S 2006, 2010). P EU , y v y v y y x w

    EU (H/M 2004, 2005; Z 1992,

    Z 1978).

    T y

    G y (1992) w US w (w v w v ,

    w ) w . H w w

    v w w y x.

    L , w y A-I . T w w y

    y y x, y y w w xy

    y w w w y w y w

    jvy x . T w y EU EU .

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    9/33

    Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of citizens | 9

    B x, w y

    . I , xy EU .

    Ry, y v EU

    y. W w w v x EU v v (D V/B 2003, 2006; M/

    R 2008; S/D V 2006) w EU (B 2003). T

    EU vy vy . Hwv, w

    v vv y

    v w.

    I y w EU , ,

    v, x

    . F , v ,

    , v, y v. F ,

    y y , (

    ) . S, v

    v E , y y

    E , y

    .

    T y y

    , y

    y (.. w ). E w w . Dw v y, w

    w y j y.

    F w, w

    v .

    F w w j v , y j,

    y y: w (G 1992; K/G 1996;

    P/J 2001). I , y y w-. I w-

    w v y-. C y

    w, w v . K G (1996)

    w, x, D w y, D

    w y w v

    Dy I A (WAO D) v . I w D

    y w y w- w w y y

    v ( y) y. P q w

    j w

    ( w- y v ) y, y

    w , w . R y

    w, w j y v . T y

    y, EU y, w v

    y (C 2002; E/G 1995; H 1995; K 2004; V S/

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    10/33

    10 | KFGWorking Paper No. 16 | October 2010

    R 2010; V S 2010). G (1992: 171) v y

    xy . T x y w

    y j y v EU

    .

    A y ( v w y),

    j, y v v

    (K/G 1996). M y v , y

    y y v (G 1992). W ,

    ,

    v w v , x

    w w v

    (K/G 1996; S 2002). F v ,

    y . Hwv, y y

    w (K/G 1996). T,

    v, y w y v

    v .

    B .. w y w wy . A

    y v y

    w v. A ( ,

    ) w ( ). A

    w , . Oy

    y y

    jy w

    y q (MG 2001). A wy,

    , y j v . A v

    , v

    w . T y

    jy w

    q v w , v

    y .

    Evy q, v v

    y , v y (B 2009;

    C 2006; G 1988; S 2002; Z 1996). M y

    .. y , v w,

    w . O , w y

    , y v . A , w

    y w (Z 1988). T,

    q w q v v .

    Fw v (B 2003; D V/B 2003, 2006; M/

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    11/33

    Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of citizens | 11

    R 2008; S/D V 2006), x

    v v EU

    (y y ) . S v

    , y , y w

    . P w w w

    :

    Model 1: How emoonally loaded media discourse may lead to polical acon

    T y y v x

    v. Hwv, w

    y

    v v (.. y w , vv,

    w ,

    v v ), x w w

    y v . Iv x

    v, w w y

    . Fy, v y v .

    P v, v v w ,

    v . Mv, v

    vy vv w

    / y

    v (K/G 1996).

    A , x w y,

    y w q: W EU w

    y v y ? A w

    EU x

    Individual dispositions

    Emotionally loaded

    media discourse:

    Arousal generatingcharacteristics & Triad

    or collective action

    raming (we and/or

    they, agency, injustice)

    Cultural context

    Interpersonal interaction

    Political behaviour

    (conversations, letters/

    emails, petitions, etc.)

    Attitude

    confrmation

    or change

    Processes

    related to

    memorisation

    Attention &

    Interest

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    12/33

    12 | KFGWorking Paper No. 16 | October 2010

    ? Fy, w v y

    ? I y y

    x w - - q

    v v (.. v , x

    ).

    My y v v y y v

    / W . T

    w w w v

    x w w y v E -

    v -. T x y (..

    y v w / y w y j)

    y v, w v vv.

    Iy w v EU . I w , w y :

    y w EU ,

    y . T

    EU y. T w w ( , vv)

    .

    T x w w :

    1. I w y v

    v y y .2. A, y, w y v

    v y w; v w

    w x.

    T x , w w xy , y w v

    y w vv v

    v y w y y vv. I

    w w vv w y

    w, y

    y v, , . Ay

    w v v v

    .

    I w , w w w

    ( H w vv CEEC

    EU H y y vv). I

    j . T y qy

    y w w y w

    v. Nv, x w y

    w

    w E y .

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    13/33

    Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of citizens | 13

    4. R Dg

    Issue selecon: the Haider aair and CEEC enlargement

    T H A VP-FP v w EU w vv. O , w

    E . T H EU w

    J H -w FP A v Fy 2000. T EU

    A v

    y - x N - v. Bw

    Jy 2000 S 2000, E-w w

    y EU .

    T EU C E E w x

    EU w w . S 1989,

    v E C S. A 1990

    y F P M C P D, w EU

    w CEEC w y q y

    EU 2004. T w v w w H

    .

    Country & Newspaper Selecon

    F , w w y

    E ( V S 2005, 2006; V S/R 2010). F

    H , vy w y w qy w ( -w,

    -w) v EU (A, B, F, Gy Iy)

    w US qy w. T w w w y: P, S, N

    K (NKZ), S, S, F, M, P, F A Z

    (FAZ), S Z (SZ), C, R, N, W P, Nw Y

    T (NYT). F CEEC , v qy w v M Av

    F Uv B w w H : G FA Z (FAZ) S Z (SZ), F F M, I

    R. T w H w v 1998 1999,

    j H . T w qy y.

    O , v y 1989 1998 w w qy w

    Gy, S, UK, N Sw qy w y

    y w w w . J H , vy

    EU w y v qy w.

    T w y H

    w y y EU . Wv ,y v w w w .

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    14/33

    14 | KFGWorking Paper No. 16 | October 2010

    Operaonalizaon of the Dependent Variable

    T v v y y

    w x v: ,

    , y - y vv, y.

    R , w y. S w

    v, w w w y

    v . Hwv,

    y v v y . I , x,

    w B F w. I

    , .

    H w v w

    ( , w

    w w ):

    D v: P v

    . L [CEEC 4; H 44]

    . D, , [CEEC 0; H 90]

    . C (y - -) [CEEC 0; H 32]

    A [y v H 21]

    N A [y v H 11]. E y, y, y [CEEC 0; H 75]

    . O [CEEC 0; H 1]

    Operaonalizaon of the two Independent Variables

    T v y w y

    j y. Hw w y vy y

    w y w? T

    w y y , w x. I w, y j

    E v y y v y-w. I

    H E v y, v w : y-w

    y-y. Oy y ( v

    w y) w j y y

    v. T y. I w, y

    x, w y. I j x

    w x y , v w.

    Hwv, y w .

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    15/33

    Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of citizens | 15

    T w x v y : w y,

    y, j y:

    [B F M M:] This man is dangerous, insists the Foreign Minister. [] I hope

    that nobody falls into the classic trap of the extreme right: they try to make themselves acceptable by

    making believe that they will obey to democrac pracces. I hope that nobody forgets the tone, the

    method, the dishonesty and the lies that those people transmit. So, it does not suce when they say

    they repent their acts. In cases like this, any kind of forgiving is unjused

    [Ivw:] Should Belgium and the European Union consider calling the ambassador in Vienna

    home?

    [B F M M:] I am actually posing myself this queson, answers Louis Michel,

    who has had intense contacts with his fellow European ministers and with the Portuguese Presidency of

    the Union. At a certain moment, we have to consider an extremely resolute acon. If not, tomorrow, in

    the name of what could we sll convey the European message of democracy, openness and tolerance?

    (L S, 31 Jy 2000, ).

    I w , B F M jx E w y

    y, y H (w )

    x- w , j . I

    w, y, w w , y H y y

    A v, x- w EU, B. T v

    w y H w w y j v

    w y. F, M y w y y , y

    v j. Sqy, q, w w vy

    w w v w , w w ? I vw

    j, w y , x y V

    . M vw EU

    : y w w y

    . S . T w v

    w y y v A, B, w.

    T y y w y y w xy

    . Mv, x wy v w y y. B y , y

    w w y y . T

    v y CEEC H w

    w q :

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    16/33

    16 | KFGWorking Paper No. 16 | October 2010

    I v: Iy

    . N y [CEEC 9; H 292]

    . Iy

    1. Iy w [CEEC 1; H 200]

    2. Iy y [CEEC 0; H 264]

    3. Ij [CEEC 0; H 78]

    4. Ay [CEEC 0; H 126]

    5. O [CEEC 0; H 0]

    T v y y v

    w y v

    . T . I w

    v , v y. Mv,

    y ,

    , , v w v

    w . F w w w

    w . I v y

    w TV , w w

    . A , w w w

    v y v v y (G 1992; G 1988; Py/

    C 1986; S 2002):

    C ( x, v w - I w - w

    x- E);

    C (x ; w ; w w,

    );

    P v: . Hwv, w I

    y [] (D S, 27 Jy 2000); v

    w- w-E B w v, w w

    v , w H. ( L R, 1 Fy 2000);

    Ay ( P M P, C P,

    A P, B F A M w -H

    , Jw w H A VP P

    M y , y w y q);

    E [] F M v

    jv (D P, 29 Jy 2000);

    P: , , ,

    w ;

    R q.

    T w v y w

    q CEEC H

    vy :

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    17/33

    Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of citizens | 17

    I v: M

    . H

    1. S [CEEC 0; H 42]

    2. P [CEEC 0; H 75]

    3. H [CEEC 10; H 10]

    . P 1 ( M ) [CEEC 1; H 131]

    . O , w [CEEC 0; H 21]

    . C [2; 172]

    . P v: y [CEEC 0; H 9]

    . P v: w- w-E

    [CEEC 0; H 23]

    . Ay [CEEC 3; H 100]

    . E [CEEC 0; H 19]

    . R q [CEEC 0; H 46]

    j. C [CEEC 0; H 3]

    . A N, w [CEEC 0; H 177]

    . A , w [CEEC 0; H 79]

    .A H T R, w [CEEC 0; H 168]

    . A H S, w [CEEC 0; H 98]

    . A S H C [CEEC 0; H 37]

    . O [CEEC 0; H 0]

    F w EU, .. US, v w y

    w y y y

    vy US y. T

    E x US. I E ,

    y v EU w w w

    (V S 2005, 2006; V S/R 2010). I w, w

    v EU y w , EU

    . I, US, w . T US w

    q y E , w

    EU H, E . Hwv,

    US y v w;

    w w y EU ,

    y q . J w x

    US y v w w F w

    F, w x y

    y EU . Hy y , w

    y. I w, y

    w w .

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    18/33

    18 | KFGWorking Paper No. 16 | October 2010

    Sample Period

    T j EU

    y vv. E v w

    v. W EU

    ? A w

    y w

    . A y

    . T xy w EU . I

    w ,

    y y v. I

    , , w, w, . T

    . F , y =0.

    T w w v

    E . A, . T H

    vy O 1999 S 2000. I w v

    v w , y

    . A G 1 2 ,

    H 2 Fy 2000. T w v w

    y

    . Ty, 2 Fy 2000 =0 H .

    T CEEC

    H . T =0 =0 H .

    A x =0 H , .. Fy 2000, EU

    H EU

    q H : A w EU

    vv? F CEEC , v w

    M Av, I w vy w

    y w w H 1989

    1998. I M Av, w S 1999

    D 1999 j v w H w

    , EU w CEEC w

    1989 1997 w w EU - . A

    , 1998 v

    y w Jy 1999 Fy 2000 v w: 18 J 1998

    SZ w y FAZ. Sqy, 18 J 1998 =0 CEEC

    . I , EU w w w

    , =0

    v v v . A

    ; x w y x,

    v v.

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    19/33

    Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of citizens | 19

    Graphs 1 and 2: Leers to the editor in the sample of the Haider case: rst, each month in the sample,

    then, each day for the month with most leers to the editor

    F v, , w w =0

    y. T 18 J 1 Jy 1998 CEEC 2 15 Fy 2000

    H . T x ,

    .

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    Total

    WP

    NYT

    Soir

    Standaard (B)

    Parisien

    Figaro

    Monde

    Repubblica

    Nazione

    Corriere

    SZ

    FAZ

    NKZ

    Standard (A)

    Presse

    Sep

    00

    Aug

    00

    Jul

    00

    Jun

    00

    May

    00

    Apr

    00

    Mar

    00

    Feb

    00

    Jan

    00

    Dez

    99

    Nov

    99

    Oct

    99

    0

    4

    10

    16

    20

    18

    14

    12

    8

    6

    2

    Total

    WP

    NYT

    Soir

    Standaard (B)

    Parisien

    Figaro

    Monde

    Repubblica

    Nazione

    Corriere

    SZ

    FAZ

    NKZ

    Standard (A)

    Presse

    2928272625242322212019181716151413121110987654321

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    20/33

    20 | KFGWorking Paper No. 16 | October 2010

    F v y , , w w

    w w =0 . T 4 17 J 1998 CEEC

    19 Jy 2 Fy 2000 H . T y

    w , .

    5. I V: M A I D

    A w x, w vy w y w y

    EU , CEEC . A

    v CEEC y , y ,

    H (57 w CEEC ; 127 w w

    ). Mv, CEEC y EU

    w . T y w EU v y. T CEEC y EU ,

    vy . F ,

    , w

    .

    T H w y -

    CEEC - x v w w. Nv,

    H w y EU : w,

    H x- E w . T

    v. T E H w 27

    28 Jy 2000, H Sw, v

    w v E. I w,

    H w EU w -w , EU .

    T w -w -w

    , , . T H qy.

    Sqy, E y w .

    Mv, y, vvy v

    VP-FP v, x . U CEEC , w EU w w . T

    v

    - ,

    .. w . T w H EU w

    w w w w

    v y y . I v v

    y , y w

    vy vv, w x y v w

    vv.

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    21/33

    Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of citizens | 21

    Table 1: Overview for both cases scored on the independent variable media arousal

    CEEC g H

    Mx S y y -

    w

    CEEC :

    FAZ15 J 1998.

    S , y -

    y , q 1 w

    H ,

    y :

    A -

    y B F M M -

    vw le Soir31 Jy 2000. T vw

    v w

    : w , y

    ; , y q;

    , y

    w .

    M

    high

    I

    w

    w

    CEEC .

    T

    -

    :

    N.

    I w

    w -

    H . T

    :

    53 28 10 w: die Presse,

    der Standard, de Standaard, le Soir, FAZ, SZ, il Corriere, la

    Repubblica, le Figaro, le Monde.

    D

    high

    N . Die Presse 27 Jy 2000; der Standard: 27 Jy; de

    Standaard: 28 Jy; le Soir: 26 Jy; FAZ: 27 J-

    y; SZ: 27 Jy; il Corriere: 1 Fy; la Repubblica:

    30 Jy; le Figaro 1 Fy; le Monde: 1 Fy.

    Nw

    w w

    A w. NKZ, la Nazione, le Parisien, Washington Post, NYT.

    Mx

    w

    w w

    Sv -

    v CEEC

    .

    FAZ: y -

    y .

    SZ:

    .

    La Repubblica:

    .

    Le Figaro: w y

    y

    .

    Le Monde: w w

    y

    y

    I w

    w

    H :

    La Nazione: 1 .

    Le Parisien: 1 .

    I NKZ w y w

    w v ,

    y y . T x -

    NKZ:

    , w w

    q.

    P 1 w : 2 Washing-

    ton Post, 4 NYT.

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    22/33

    22 | KFGWorking Paper No. 16 | October 2010

    F, w T 1 v . A

    x v y w

    w :

    1. I x ;2. I w ( );

    3. I w ;

    v

    w, .

    M . Evy

    w . W CEEC

    x v , H y

    , T 1, v. I EU , w w w H v . T w

    w vw B F M M

    y S 31 Jy 2000. T vw y

    y , B M L M, w

    w E. A , vw

    v w w w v

    . B S, EU w

    . I A, B, Gy,

    H y 26 27 Jy, y

    Sw H C w y E w . T I

    F w w w y w . By 1

    Fy, EU w w y v

    w E.

    I w v y, y w

    w xy : y j w

    , w v y . I

    w, y j, y

    w y y v. A x

    H v y ,

    y y w y y xy w y

    j.

    T v, y, w

    v . W H w EU

    y w y , y w

    w CEEC, T 2. O , le Monde (6

    J 1998) w-y w L F, Py

    N Ay: [By ,] E q w , w y, w

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    23/33

    Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of citizens | 23

    y y. T w v w w w y y.

    Mv, v y y j y

    . I 1998 w 1989 2004 E -

    w y v CEEC . P

    w v w

    . F , vv

    E w E . T,

    x y EU , w y .

    Table 2: Overview for both cases scored on the independent variable identy discourse

    CEEC g H

    Mx O -

    y :

    I w y:

    le Monde 6

    J 1998.

    A y :

    I w y, y, j

    y:

    27 20 8 w.

    I -

    g

    A . I w / y w

    j y:

    37 25 10 w: der Stan-

    dard, de Standaard, le Soir, FAZ, SZ, I l Corriere, la Repub-

    blica, le Monde, le Parisien, Washington Post.

    I -

    g

    D

    g

    N . Der Standard: 29 Jy 2000; de Standaard: 28 Jy;

    le Soir: 26 Jy; FAZ: 27 Jy; SZ: 26 Jy; il

    Corriere: 26 Jy; la Repubblica: 30 Jy; le Monde:

    28 Jy; le Parisien: 29 Jy; Washington Post: 30

    Jy.

    Nw

    w

    w -

    w

    A w . Die Presse, NKZ, la Nazione, le Figaro, NYT.

    Mx

    ww -

    w

    O w y

    le Monde 6 J 1998.

    I w / y w

    j y:die Presse 9 5 ; la Nazione 1 -

    ; le Figaro 4 1 .

    O y NKZ NYT 1 Fy.

    Sy y E ,

    H w y . E w

    v x y y :

    w y j y. F

    y, w v w y

    j y. I y ,

    v y . I

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    24/33

    24 | KFGWorking Paper No. 16 | October 2010

    B, G I w y

    H C. T w w A F w w y . I

    w, w y y

    H . Ev FAZ, w H w

    x v EU,

    y . T FAZ, j w, y

    w w E H C E w

    E v y .

    Table 3: Overview for both cases when the two independent variables are combined

    CEEC g H

    Mx

    &

    A w x w

    w

    y w -

    y .

    Le Soir31 Jy 2000: & y .

    M

    g &

    g

    N. T

    v:

    Der Standard4 3 ; le Soir4 -

    2 .

    A w

    w y :

    De Standaard1 ; le Soir2 ; FAZ1 ; SZ1; la Repubblica 1 ; le Monde 1 .

    D

    g &

    g

    N . Der Standard: 29 Jy 2000; de Standaard: 28 Jy;

    le Soir: 26 Jy; FAZ: 27 Jy; SZ: 28 Jy; la

    Repubblica: 30 Jy; le Monde: 1 Fy.

    Nw

    w

    w

    w -

    &

    g,

    w g

    & w

    .

    N. A w w & :

    il Corriere, le Parisien, Washington Post.

    A w & w y

    :

    Die Presse; il Corriere; le Figaro.

    Nw

    w -

    w w

    & w

    .

    A w. NKZ; la Nazione; NYT.

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    25/33

    Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of citizens | 25

    W v , w w x w

    y , v

    v y w y v wy.

    S y w EU , w

    x . I, T 3, w

    x q H .

    T y T . T A -

    w w der Standard B F -w w le Soir

    w w v y . T w

    G qy w, B w, I F -w w

    w w w w y

    . T x v . Hwv,

    w y v , w v . I , x der Standard( y VP FP)

    le Soir( y P C VP ), H

    w y v A

    VP w FP. I vw , w x

    A W v B. O , y

    x EU, w v EU v

    . I, w x US.

    6. T D V: P Bv C

    I y CEEC T 4, v y

    x, w H

    w . I wy j ,

    , CEEC w j w EU w,

    , . I , j ,

    w , w w EU .

    I , y H w y . S w w v , y

    w w w w y w E

    w w A w jy . I I la Nazione,

    w v v w w

    H : v MSI (Movimento Sociale Italiano, y M

    y).

    A , qy y H w:

    y H, vy y H,

    A ( v H), y

    q, y y , w , y A

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    26/33

    26 | KFGWorking Paper No. 17 | October 2010

    . I A B w

    y FP v. Tw, le Soir

    -H v W . A le Soir, w

    , y y w SZ, der Standard,

    x de Standaard,FAZ,la Repubblica, la Nazione.

    Table 4: Overview for the two cases with the scores on the dependent variable

    CEEC g H

    L

    editor top 4

    A y

    w ,

    CEEC

    y.

    SZ(3; EU

    Vertriebenen, S G-

    ); FAZ(1;

    Vertriebenen).

    A H .

    Die Presse (12; ); NKZ(11;

    ); la Nazione (7; ); SZ(6; 3

    H; 3 ).

    F

    the editor

    N :

    N

    CEEC .

    B =0:

    NKZ24 Jy 2000;

    A =0, w -

    :

    Die Presse la Nazione 2 Fy.

    D

    & protest top4

    N. Le Soir(16 ; 15 H, 1

    ); SZ(10 ; 9 H, 1 ); FAZ(8 ; H); la

    Repubblica (7 ; 5 H, 2

    ).

    First demonst-

    N . B =0:

    31 Jy 2000 B;

    A =0, w -

    :

    Dy V 2 Fy.

    Economic or

    & statements by

    top 4

    N. Der Standard(14; H); SZ(10;

    H); de Standaard(9; H); a Nazione (7;

    H).

    F

    N . B =0:

    27 Jy 2000 M By

    vy

    v;

    A =0, w -

    :

    2 Fy: VP y A

    C C v .

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    27/33

    Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of citizens | 27

    7. D M D g w E C P

    Bv?

    Ev , v , w y

    , w w q .

    A T 5, w y w ,

    w, , y

    y y w / , ,

    , v v y w y w . A x,

    w w w w y

    , v y w : A W v B.

    Hwv, v y v w EU .

    Mv, E A

    w w w v: NKZ la

    Nazione. T w A w jy y

    E die Presse. T w , w

    y . T v y

    j w w

    w A v y A, , A ,

    E , A P, . B ,

    w w v q y

    v.

    T y F. Le Monde w w

    v. Mv, F P w w H

    E-w w y A j H

    C. Nv, F w y

    y y . N w

    y F, y w . T y vy

    F y der Standard NYT y x

    (M, F N) A y P.

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    28/33

    28 | KFGWorking Paper No. 16 | October 2010

    Table 5: Theorecal expectaons and an il lustraon of empirical reality

    CEEC g H

    T x I & v-

    : w.

    I & v-

    : .

    I v: M

    &

    Lw. H w EU

    :

    Der Standard; le Soir; de Standaard;

    FAZ; SZ; la Repubblica; le Monde.

    D v: P

    v

    A, .. w. P w EU

    F:

    Der Standard, die Presse, le Soir, SZ,

    de Standaard, FAZ, la Repubblica,

    la Nazione.

    M , y, w

    w . W CEEC v w v

    x EU , H , w v -.

    S , y w w EU.

    Mv, v w w y H , N, , H

    H, v y v y y qy. T w w

    400 H . I x . Py

    w E y . T w y v y

    w . I EU

    v w x- w y w

    . T E ,

    y . O ,

    x y.

    A v. A y

    ( ) y w y v? I

    y , w y

    ? W y w w w v

    vv y w EU .

    8. C

    E w . C w w w

    E v w E

    v. R w, y E U yy y,

    , y, E. T E x v EU .

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    29/33

    Emotions, media discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens | 29

    T w E U

    w E - y . P

    v y - v

    E -. Nv, y

    y E - against E

    U. I Fy 2000, w y H FP A v, B,

    P, V w v y w y

    theirE U. T y

    w y x v

    v E . W v EU w

    v w E ,

    y . I w w

    E U, E w w?

    T EU E y

    . I w ,

    v . T

    v x w w y v EU

    EU w-y, EU y. T v

    y y v

    . Hwv, w y

    E v w v w

    y . T y w

    v w E w .

    I, y v w

    v j - EU -v v

    x. I y , EU -v v y .

    Hwv, w y v

    w EU

    . I w w , , w w w w E

    , EU v v qy. Oy , w

    EU , x y y, , y . T y H ,

    C Ty B v y v qy, y

    y y vv . T

    w w E

    w y y v,

    E w .

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    30/33

    30 | KFGWorking Paper No. 16 | October 2010

    L

    Bandura, Albert2009: S v y, : By, J/Ov, My B (E.): M .Av y , Nw Y: R, 94-124.

    Bartolini, Stefano 2005: R E. C , y , w E U, Ox: Ox Uvy P.

    Bruter, Michael2003: W E: T w y v E y, : Cv 36: 10, 1148-79.

    Calhoun, Craig 2002: I Sy: C, C P, PS, : P 14: 1, 147-171.

    Christ, William G. 2006: T , : H CR 11: 4, 575-92.

    Dereje, Cornelia/Kantner, Cathleen/Hans-Jrg Trenz 2003: T qy E ,: W B S (WZB) E w , I C, J 2003, B, Gy.

    De Vreese, Claes H./Boomgaarden, Hajo 2003: V w EU, :C 28, 361-81.

    De Vreese, Claes H./Boomgaarden, Hajo 2006: M E U, : J C M S 44:2, 419-36.

    Eisenstadt, Shmuel N./Giesen, Bernhard1995: T C Cv Iy, : E J Sy 36, 72-102.

    Follesdal, Anfreas/Hix, Simon 2006: Wy EU: A Mj Mv, : J C M S 44: 3, 533-62.

    Gamson, William A. 1992: T , C: C Uvy P.

    Graber, Doris A. 1988: M A , W (DC): CQP.Habermas, Jrgen 1995: C y D G: D E ?, :

    E Lw J 1: 3, 303-307.

    Hix, Simon 2005: T y E U, H.

    Hix, Simon 2008: W w w EU w x , C: Py P.

    Hooghe, Liesbet2007: W v E? Py- , y y,: E U P 8: 1, 5-12.

    Hooghe, Liesbet/Marks, Gary2004: D y y v E?, : PSO Jy 2004 (www..).

    Hooghe, Liesbet/Marks, Gary 2005: C, y : P E, : E U P 6: 4, 419-43.

    Hooghe, Liesbet/Marks, Gary2008: A y E : F v , : B J P S 39, 1-23.

    Kantner, Cathleen 2004: K B. Kv V ,W: VS V Sw.

    Klandermans, Bert2002: Hw v v , :A Bv S 45: 5, 887-900.

    Klandermans, Bert/Goslinga, Sjoerd1996: M , v y, v : x , : MA,D/MCy, J D./Z, My N. (E.): Cv v v.

    P , , , C: C UvyP, 312-37.

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    31/33

    Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens | 31

    Koopmans, Ruud/Erbe, Jessica 2004: Tw E ? V E , : Iv 17:2: 97-118.

    Maier, Jrgen/Riberger, Berthold2008: S E : M , EU, : E U P 9: 2, 243-67.

    Mair, Peter2005: P y E U y, EUROGOV 2005: 3, : ://www.x-w./v//-x-C-05-03. ( A 2010).

    McGuire, William J. 2001: I v y v, : R, R E./A, C K. (E.): P ,3 , T O (CA): S, 22-47.

    Miag, Jrgen/Wessels, Wolfgang 2003: T O F? T w v, : W/W, M, A/M, J (E.): F ? T E U , M:M Uvy P, 413-57.

    Moravcsik, Andrew2002: R Ly E U, : J C MS 40, 603-24.

    Moravscik, Andrew2006: W w E j?P Vj 47: 2, 219-41.

    Pey, Richard E./Cacioppo John T. 1986: T , : Av x yy 19, 123-205.

    Pollea, Francesca/Jasper, James M. 2001: Cv y v, : A vw y 27(A 2001), 283-305.

    Schenk, Michael2002: Mw, T: M S.

    Schmidt, Vivien A. 2008: T xy w , : A Rvw PS 11, 303-26.

    Schmidt, Vivien A. 2010: T y y E U: I w?, : L, S/C, F/S, Vv A. (E.): T E: TE U y y, L: R ().

    Schuck, Andreas, R.T./De Vreese, Claes H. 2006: Bw y: Nw EU , : E J C 21: 1, 5-32.

    Trenz, Hans-Jrg/Mnzing, Christoph 2003: Q v E? Qy w Ey, : W B S (WZB), E ? P , , E U, IC, J 2003, B, Gy.

    Van der Eijk, Cees/Franklin, Mark N. 2004: P E E, : M, Gy/S, M R. (E.): E

    , C: C Uvy P, 32-50.Van de Steeg, Marianne 2005: T E U. A y

    EU H , PD Jy 2005 E Uvy I.

    Van de Steeg, Marianne 2006: D x E U? A y H , : E J P R 45: 4, 609634.

    Van de Steeg, Marianne 2010: T E U: Aw y?, : B, C/B, E(E.): M E : , v y, F: AP.

    Van de Steeg, Marianne/Risse, Thomas 2010: T E y :I E , : KFG W P(), F Uv B.

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    32/33

    32 | KFGWorking Paper No. 16 | October 2010

    Zaller, John R. 1992: T , C: C Uvy P.

    Zillmann, Dolf 1988: M : U v, : Dw, Lw/Sy, Hw E./H, E. Ty (E.): C, , Mw(NJ): Lw E A, 147-71.

    Zillmann, Dolf1996: Sq x v, : Kv, RD./Z, By/F, Sv (E.): E: Iy v, Mw (NJ):Lw E A, 243-72.

    Zucker, Harold G. 1978: T v w , : C Y 2, NwBw, 225-40.

  • 8/22/2019 Emotions, Media Discourse and the Mobilization of Citizens. Conceptual Considerations and a Plausibility Probe

    33/33

    T Kg-Fg - Egg A Exg

    Iv R

    T K-F (KFG) w - y G R F 2008. I -

    KFG v y v w vv w y w j .

    T K-F T Tv Pw E E B-B- w v- . I x EU , y - x :

    Iy P S

    C, Cy By Cv R E Ex R